""" Model extensions for Claim 5 (Sec. 7.1-7.2): (1) softmax variant -> reuses capacity.train_run(softmax=True) (2) value-channel / message-retrieval variant (Sec. 7.2): frozen random value map W_V, mix messages with raw max-over-heads scores, train MSE to neighbor message. Both keep the key-query path identical (max-over-heads, no 1/sqrt(d_k)) and test whether the multi-head advantage persists. """ import math, argparse, json import numpy as np import torch import torch.nn.functional as F from capacity import (make_embeddings, make_permutation, sample_contexts, MaxHeadAttention) def value_retrieval_run(m, d_model, D_K, h, seed, device, d_msg=None, ell=16, rho=0.5, lr=1e-3, max_steps=20000, batch=64, check_every=500, patience=8, pool=20000, verbose=False): """Sec. 7.2: value-routing message retrieval. Reports test MSE (lower=better).""" torch.manual_seed(seed) d_msg = d_msg or d_model X = make_embeddings(m, d_model, seed, device) pi = make_permutation(m, seed) pi_t = torch.as_tensor(pi) WV = (torch.randn(d_model, d_msg, generator=torch.Generator().manual_seed(seed + 5)) / math.sqrt(d_model)).to(device) # frozen random value map Y_all = X @ WV # per-node messages (m, d_msg) def batch_tensors(ctx): ctx_t = torch.as_tensor(ctx) Xc = X[ctx_t.to(device)] # (n, ell, d_model) tgt = pi_t[ctx_t] # (n, ell) neighbor id # valid position: neighbor in-context inctx = (tgt.unsqueeze(2) == ctx_t.unsqueeze(1)) # (n, ell, ell) valid = inctx.any(dim=2) # (n, ell) ymsg = Y_all[tgt.to(device)] # (n, ell, d_msg) true neighbor msg Vc = X[ctx_t.to(device)] @ WV # (n, ell, d_msg) in-context messages return Xc, Vc, ymsg, valid.to(device) model = MaxHeadAttention(d_model, D_K, h, agg="max").to(device) opt = torch.optim.AdamW(model.parameters(), lr=lr, weight_decay=0.0) train_ctx = sample_contexts(pi, m, ell, rho, pool, seed + 3) val_ctx = sample_contexts(pi, m, ell, rho, 500, seed + 1) test_ctx = sample_contexts(pi, m, ell, rho, 2000, seed + 2) Xtr, Vtr, Ytr, valtr = batch_tensors(train_ctx) Xv, Vv, Yv, valv = batch_tensors(val_ctx) Xte, Vte, Yte, valte = batch_tensors(test_ctx) def mse(Xc, Vc, ymsg, valid): S = model.scores(Xc) # (n, ell, ell) raw max-over-heads yhat = torch.einsum("nij,njd->nid", S, Vc) # (n, ell, d_msg) err = ((yhat - ymsg) ** 2).sum(-1) # (n, ell) return err[valid].mean() g = torch.Generator().manual_seed(seed + 7) order = torch.randperm(pool, generator=g); ptr = 0 best_val = float("inf"); bad = 0 for step in range(1, max_steps + 1): if ptr + batch > pool: order = torch.randperm(pool, generator=g); ptr = 0 idx = order[ptr:ptr + batch]; ptr += batch loss = mse(Xtr[idx], Vtr[idx], Ytr[idx], valtr[idx]) opt.zero_grad(); loss.backward(); opt.step() if step % check_every == 0: with torch.no_grad(): v = mse(Xv, Vv, Yv, valv).item() if verbose: print(f" step {step} valMSE {v:.4f}", flush=True) if v < best_val - 1e-4: best_val = v; bad = 0 else: bad += 1 if bad >= patience: break with torch.no_grad(): test_mse = mse(Xte, Vte, Yte, valte).item() return {"m": m, "d_model": d_model, "D_K": D_K, "h": h, "d_k": D_K // h, "seed": seed, "test_mse": test_mse, "steps": step} if __name__ == "__main__": dev = "cuda" if torch.cuda.is_available() else ("mps" if torch.backends.mps.is_available() else "cpu") print("device", dev) # Value retrieval: m=64, compressed d_model=16 -> multi-head advantage (Fig 6 top) for dm in [16, 32]: print(f"\n=== Value retrieval m=64 d_model={dm} (Sec 7.2, Fig 6) ===") for h in [1, 2, 4, 8]: for DK in [16, 32]: if DK % h or DK // h < 2: continue r = value_retrieval_run(64, dm, DK, h, seed=0, device=dev, max_steps=8000, batch=64) print(f" d_model={dm} h={h} D_K={DK} test_MSE={r['test_mse']:.4f}")