{ "retrieval": { "HotpotQA-CLIP": { "Oracle": { "mean": 1.0, "std": 0.0, "n": 1000 }, "Cosine": { "mean": 0.5059999999596, "std": 0.3145854414785986, "n": 1000 }, "Diagonal": { "mean": 0.5524999999578999, "std": 0.3201464508490927, "n": 1000 }, "LowRank": { "mean": 0.6329999999549, "std": 0.3127475019785076, "n": 1000 }, "Skew": { "mean": 0.6459999999547499, "std": 0.31493491390105194, "n": 1000 } }, "ScienceQA": { "Oracle": { "mean": 1.0, "std": 0.0, "n": 800 }, "Cosine": { "mean": 0.32249999996775003, "std": 0.23925666132534587, "n": 800 }, "Diagonal": { "mean": 0.9806249999501873, "std": 0.10576913242828584, "n": 800 }, "LowRank": { "mean": 0.9999999999499997, "std": 3.3306690738754696e-16, "n": 800 }, "Skew": { "mean": 0.9999999999499997, "std": 3.3306690738754696e-16, "n": 800 } }, "MMStar": { "Oracle": { "mean": 1.0, "std": 0.0, "n": 150 }, "Cosine": { "mean": 0.25666666664099996, "std": 0.2499110952780297, "n": 150 }, "Diagonal": { "mean": 0.9999999999500001, "std": 1.1102230246251565e-16, "n": 150 }, "LowRank": { "mean": 0.9999999999500001, "std": 1.1102230246251565e-16, "n": 150 }, "Skew": { "mean": 0.9999999999500001, "std": 1.1102230246251565e-16, "n": 150 } }, "SLAKE": { "Oracle": { "mean": 1.0, "std": 0.0, "n": 400 }, "Cosine": { "mean": 0.066249999993375, "std": 0.16951677643894958, "n": 400 }, "Diagonal": { "mean": 0.9999999999499997, "std": 3.3306690738754696e-16, "n": 400 }, "LowRank": { "mean": 0.9999999999499997, "std": 3.3306690738754696e-16, "n": 400 }, "Skew": { "mean": 0.9999999999499997, "std": 3.3306690738754696e-16, "n": 400 } }, "OK-VQA": { "Oracle": { "mean": 1.0, "std": 0.0, "n": 500 }, "Cosine": { "mean": 0.4059999999594, "std": 0.19535608511732416, "n": 500 }, "Diagonal": { "mean": 0.9999999999499998, "std": 2.220446049250313e-16, "n": 500 }, "LowRank": { "mean": 0.9999999999499998, "std": 2.220446049250313e-16, "n": 500 }, "Skew": { "mean": 0.9999999999499998, "std": 2.220446049250313e-16, "n": 500 } } }, "xmodal_recall": { "ScienceQA": { "Cosine": 0.0, "Diagonal": 0.98125, "LowRank": 1.0, "Skew": 1.0 }, "MMStar": { "Cosine": 0.0, "Diagonal": 1.0, "LowRank": 1.0, "Skew": 1.0 }, "SLAKE": { "Cosine": 0.0, "Diagonal": 1.0, "LowRank": 1.0, "Skew": 1.0 }, "OK-VQA": { "Cosine": 0.0, "Diagonal": 1.0, "LowRank": 1.0, "Skew": 1.0 } }, "recall_at_k": { "HotpotQA-CLIP": { "Cosine": { "1": 0.4399999999706667, "2": 0.5059999999596, "3": 0.48679999995771195, "5": 0.43257142853257136, "10": 0.3333333333055556 }, "Diagonal": { "1": 0.4799999999680001, "2": 0.5529999999579, "3": 0.5263999999565119, "5": 0.45771428567473466, "10": 0.3333333333055556 }, "LowRank": { "1": 0.5293333332980444, "2": 0.6324999999547499, "3": 0.6123999999539681, "5": 0.5051428571025306, "10": 0.3333333333055556 }, "Skew": { "1": 0.5266666666315556, "2": 0.6424999999547999, "3": 0.6155999999540639, "5": 0.5019999999597551, "10": 0.3333333333055556 } }, "ScienceQA": { "Cosine": { "1": 0.4233333333051111, "2": 0.32249999996775003, "3": 0.26799999996784, "5": 0.20999999997, "10": 0.3333333333055557 }, "Diagonal": { "1": 0.6649999999556667, "2": 0.9812499999501247, "3": 0.78599999995206, "5": 0.5671428571020407, "10": 0.3333333333055557 }, "LowRank": { "1": 0.6666666666222223, "2": 0.9999999999499997, "3": 0.799999999952, "5": 0.5714285713877549, "10": 0.3333333333055557 }, "Skew": { "1": 0.6666666666222223, "2": 0.9999999999499997, "3": 0.799999999952, "5": 0.5714285713877549, "10": 0.3333333333055557 } }, "MMStar": { "Cosine": { "1": 0.3422222221994074, "2": 0.25666666664099996, "3": 0.20533333330869336, "5": 0.1466666666457143, "10": 0.3333333333055557 }, "Diagonal": { "1": 0.6666666666222221, "2": 0.9999999999500001, "3": 0.799999999952, "5": 0.571428571387755, "10": 0.3333333333055557 }, "LowRank": { "1": 0.6666666666222221, "2": 0.9999999999500001, "3": 0.799999999952, "5": 0.571428571387755, "10": 0.3333333333055557 }, "Skew": { "1": 0.6666666666222221, "2": 0.9999999999500001, "3": 0.799999999952, "5": 0.571428571387755, "10": 0.3333333333055557 } }, "SLAKE": { "Cosine": { "1": 0.03166666666455555, "2": 0.066249999993375, "3": 0.05299999999364, "5": 0.25714285710612245, "10": 0.3333333333055557 }, "Diagonal": { "1": 0.6666666666222223, "2": 0.9999999999499997, "3": 0.799999999952, "5": 0.5714285713877549, "10": 0.3333333333055557 }, "LowRank": { "1": 0.6666666666222223, "2": 0.9999999999499997, "3": 0.799999999952, "5": 0.5714285713877549, "10": 0.3333333333055557 }, "Skew": { "1": 0.6666666666222223, "2": 0.9999999999499997, "3": 0.799999999952, "5": 0.5714285713877549, "10": 0.3333333333055557 } }, "OK-VQA": { "Cosine": { "1": 0.5413333332972445, "2": 0.4059999999594, "3": 0.324799999961024, "5": 0.23199999996685716, "10": 0.3333333333055556 }, "Diagonal": { "1": 0.6666666666222221, "2": 0.9999999999499998, "3": 0.7999999999520001, "5": 0.571428571387755, "10": 0.3333333333055556 }, "LowRank": { "1": 0.6666666666222221, "2": 0.9999999999499998, "3": 0.7999999999520001, "5": 0.571428571387755, "10": 0.3333333333055556 }, "Skew": { "1": 0.6666666666222221, "2": 0.9999999999499998, "3": 0.7999999999520001, "5": 0.571428571387755, "10": 0.3333333333055556 } } }, "img_recall_at_k": { "HotpotQA-CLIP": { "Cosine": { "1": NaN, "2": NaN, "3": NaN, "5": NaN, "10": NaN }, "Diagonal": { "1": NaN, "2": NaN, "3": NaN, "5": NaN, "10": NaN }, "LowRank": { "1": NaN, "2": NaN, "3": NaN, "5": NaN, "10": NaN }, "Skew": { "1": NaN, "2": NaN, "3": NaN, "5": NaN, "10": NaN } }, "ScienceQA": { "Cosine": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "10": 1.0 }, "Diagonal": { "1": 0.32125, "2": 0.9825, "3": 0.98375, "5": 0.99125, "10": 1.0 }, "LowRank": { "1": 0.99, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 }, "Skew": { "1": 1.0, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 } }, "MMStar": { "Cosine": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "10": 1.0 }, "Diagonal": { "1": 0.47333333333333333, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 }, "LowRank": { "1": 1.0, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 }, "Skew": { "1": 1.0, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 } }, "SLAKE": { "Cosine": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "10": 1.0 }, "Diagonal": { "1": 0.955, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 }, "LowRank": { "1": 0.0675, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 }, "Skew": { "1": 0.9775, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 } }, "OK-VQA": { "Cosine": { "1": 0.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "5": 0.0, "10": 1.0 }, "Diagonal": { "1": 0.182, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 }, "LowRank": { "1": 1.0, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 }, "Skew": { "1": 1.0, "2": 1.0, "3": 1.0, "5": 1.0, "10": 1.0 } } }, "enc_ablation": { "SigLIP-L": { "ScienceQA": { "Cosine": 0.32249999996775003, "Diagonal": 0.9806249999501873, "LowRank": 0.9999999999499997, "Skew": 0.9999999999499997 }, "SLAKE": { "Cosine": 0.066249999993375, "Diagonal": 0.9999999999499997, "LowRank": 0.9999999999499997, "Skew": 0.9999999999499997 } }, "CLIP-L": { "ScienceQA": { "Cosine": 0.32874999996712495, "Diagonal": 0.9012499999512498, "LowRank": 0.9993749999499997, "Skew": 0.9999999999499997 }, "SLAKE": { "Cosine": 0.10249999998975, "Diagonal": 0.9987499999499997, "LowRank": 0.9999999999499997, "Skew": 0.9999999999499997 } } }, "generation": { "ScienceQA": { "Oracle": { "RL": 0.5464184325395869, "n": 300 }, "Cosine": { "RL": 0.4227723694529199, "n": 300 }, "Skew": { "RL": 0.5464184325395869, "n": 300 } }, "SLAKE": { "Oracle": { "RL": 0.14245104974531245, "n": 300 }, "Cosine": { "RL": 0.06689952186449186, "n": 300 }, "Skew": { "RL": 0.14245104974531245, "n": 300 } } }, "alpha_analysis": { "ScienceQA": { "alpha_norm_mean": 4.279110431671143, "alpha_mod_sim_mean": 0.4472242738008499, "alpha_mod_sim_std": 6.108695219996097e-05, "n_samples": 500, "modality_gap_size": 1.085861086845398 }, "MMStar": { "alpha_norm_mean": 2.7181665897369385, "alpha_mod_sim_mean": 0.5411634361743927, "alpha_mod_sim_std": 2.8985091818691015e-05, "n_samples": 150, "modality_gap_size": 1.1763067245483398 }, "SLAKE": { "alpha_norm_mean": 3.195904016494751, "alpha_mod_sim_mean": 0.36432429909706116, "alpha_mod_sim_std": 4.656341142927801e-05, "n_samples": 400, "modality_gap_size": 0.8340014815330505 }, "OK-VQA": { "alpha_norm_mean": 3.0929431915283203, "alpha_mod_sim_mean": 0.5773968752622605, "alpha_mod_sim_std": 5.261573760594549e-05, "n_samples": 500, "modality_gap_size": 1.2074462175369263 } }, "modality_gap": { "ScienceQA": { "within": 0.7921797445363232, "cross": 0.053419092516123784, "gap": 0.7387606520201995, "n_tt": 8400, "n_ii": 0, "n_ti": 2400 }, "MMStar": { "within": 0.8898574270520891, "cross": -0.013365559010943842, "gap": 0.903222986063033, "n_tt": 3150, "n_ii": 0, "n_ti": 1050 }, "SLAKE": { "within": 0.6578754385974672, "cross": 0.0, "gap": 0.6578754385974672, "n_tt": 6300, "n_ii": 0, "n_ti": 2100 }, "OK-VQA": { "within": 0.8912451232898803, "cross": -0.03354347423960765, "gap": 0.9247885975294879, "n_tt": 6300, "n_ii": 0, "n_ti": 2100 } }, "config": { "primary_encoder": "SigLIP-L", "ablation_encoder": "CLIP-L", "seed": 42, "datasets": { "HotpotQA-CLIP": { "n_train": 5000, "n_val": 500, "n_test": 1000, "k": 2, "type": "text_only", "has_images": false }, "ScienceQA": { "n_train": 2361, "n_val": 200, "n_test": 800, "k": 2, "type": "text_image", "has_images": true }, "MMStar": { "n_train": 1200, "n_val": 150, "n_test": 150, "k": 2, "type": "text_image", "has_images": true }, "SLAKE": { "n_train": 2000, "n_val": 200, "n_test": 400, "k": 2, "type": "text_image", "has_images": true }, "OK-VQA": { "n_train": 2000, "n_val": 200, "n_test": 500, "k": 2, "type": "text_image", "has_images": true } } } }