the possibility is considered that turbulence is described by differential equations for which uniqueness fails maximally , at least in some limit . the inviscid burgers equation , in the context of onsager s suggestion that turbulence should be described by a negative absolute temperature , is such a limit . </S>","<S> in this picture , the onset of turbulence coincides with the proliferation of singularities which characterizes the failure of uniqueness . </S>","<S> epsf 2 </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> the possibility is considered that turbulence is described by differential equations for which uniqueness fails maximally , at least in some limit . the inviscid burgers equation , in the context of onsager s suggestion that turbulence should be described by a negative absolute temperature , is such a limit . </S>\",\n \"<S> in this picture , the onset of turbulence coincides with the proliferation of singularities which characterizes the failure of uniqueness . </S>\",\n \"<S> epsf 2 </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["nonuniqueness","inviscid burgers equation","negative temperature","interpretation"],"string":"[\n \"nonuniqueness\",\n \"inviscid burgers equation\",\n \"negative temperature\",\n \"interpretation\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["the existence and uniqueness of solutions to the differential equations of physics is seldom an issue .","the very fact that these equations describe physical reality seems to argue that their solutions must exist and be unique .","textbook examples of nonuniqueness , for example clairaut s equation ( ref .","@xcite , p. 94 ) , seem like exceptional cases , which would not arise in physics in any case . there is , however , a system of differential equations , arising as a limiting case of a much studied physical problem , in which uniqueness fails for _ every _ solution at _ every _ time .","the system is singular laplacian growth @xcite , @xcite .","one might call this behavior `` maximally nonunique . ''","it is so different from the usual behavior of differential equations that it hardly seems like a differential system at all .","the way it occurs is the following : the theory of singular laplacian growth describes the motions of certain singularities of a conformal map , which are all located on the unit circle in the complex plane .","they move on the circle , but they can also `` split , '' introducing new singularities , at any time .","this behavior , which does not sound very remarkable , essentially implies the maximal nonuniqueness property . in ref .","@xcite the term `` fragile '' was suggested for such a system , because its distinguishing feature is that its singularities can break apart .","it is natural to ask if other physical systems might reduce to a fragile system in some limit , and if the fragile property manifests itself in the behavior of the system .","turbulence is certainly a candidate to be a fragile system : like laplacian growth , turbulence is a phenomenon in which a differential equation has unexpectedly complex solutions . in this paper","i argue that turbulence is a system that has a fragile ( maximally nonunique ) limiting case .","the limiting case is the burgers equation .","( on rather different grounds a resemblance between the problems of turbulence and laplacian growth has been noted by hastings and levitov @xcite ) ."],["the burgers equation @xcite , @xcite @xmath0 has played a shifting role in the problem of turbulence .","it was first introduced as a one - dimensional zero pressure version of the navier - stokes equation ( with @xmath1 the viscosity ) in the hope that it might exhibit in its solutions some of the complexity of turbulence . by the hopf - cole trick ,","though , it was found to be equivalent to a linear diffusion equation , so that the initial value problem could be solved explicitly : one can write a formula for the solution ! that is surely too simple to be turbulent .","attention was thus focussed on the only case which still seemed promising , the @xmath2 limit , the inviscid burgers equation , which is a conservation law for @xmath3 . in this limit","the solution may develop discontinuities ( `` shocks '' ) .","the distribution of shocks , and their development in time , for random initial data , is a problem called burgers turbulence .","the reason that one should think of this as a @xmath2 limit , and not simply as a @xmath4 version of the equation , is that for @xmath4 the solution is ambiguous . to be sure , the solution of the inviscid equation is immediate by the method of characteristics : @xmath3 is constant along lines @xmath5 ( hence straight lines in the x - t plane ) .","but if the characteristics cross , which they certainly will do in the case of random initial data @xmath6 , then one has multiple determinations of @xmath7 , as in fig .","1 . the resolution of this difficulty is to take the formula for @xmath7 in case @xmath8 , which is unambiguous , and let @xmath1 approach zero .","the result is as shown in fig .","2 : a discontinuity forms at a definite location , separating one determination of @xmath3 from another .","the same procedure shows that shocks interact in a definite manner , coalescing as shown in fig .","3 when one overtakes or collides with another .","the rules for how these discontinuities form and interact were known long ago in the theory of compressible gas dynamics , where they are called the rankine - hugoniot jump conditions ( see ref .","@xcite , pp .","488 - 90 , ref .","@xcite , p. 596 ) .","they are justified by appeal to the second law of thermodynamics : while @xmath3 is conserved , entropy must increase in the shock .","that is what the argument with @xmath8 also does : we resolve the ambiguity in the inviscid burgers equation by putting in a dissipative term with the right sign .","the second law of thermodynamics says mechanical energy should be dissipated in the shock , and not created .","it is this condition which leads to the interaction rule illustrated in fig ."],["now recall the suggestion of onsager , as emphasized by alexandre chorin , among others , that a statistical theory of the turbulent steady state should be characterized by a negative temperature ( see ref .","@xcite , chapter 4 ) .","what is meant is that there is a maxwell - boltzmann probability distribution @xmath9 which , instead of giving more weight to the low energy microstates in the ensemble description of the macrostate , as is usual , gives more weight to high energy microstates .","( this statistical `` temperature '' of turbulence has nothing to do with usual thermodynamic temperature , which is only weakly coupled to the mechanical degrees of freedom of interest . )","let us accept this idea for the moment .","the second law says that entropy should increase , or perhaps better , in this more general situation , that information should be lost , in irreversible processes",". stated in terms of the free energy @xmath10 ( and remembering @xmath11 ) this says that free energy should _ increase _ in the approach to the steady state .","this is opposite to what is usual . putting onsager s idea together with the ideas of burgers turbulence","thus requires that mechanical energy should be created in the shock rather than dissipated .","we see that the limit in the inviscid burgers equation should be @xmath12 , i.e. , we should imagine the viscosity approaching zero through _ negative _ values , from _","below_. the inviscid burger s equation does not contain temperature or @xmath1 explicitly , of course , but the rules for how the shocks form and interact are now different .","the following argument gives the simple idea which is at the heart of this paper .","we do not try to give it an elaborate justification , since , like many simple ideas , it may contain some truth even if the arguments are wrong .","the argument is that there is a symmetry of the ( general ) burgers equation , @xmath13 we can convert the @xmath14 inviscid burgers equation into the familiar @xmath8 inviscid burgers equation by reversing the signs of @xmath15 and @xmath16 , i.e. , reflecting graphs like fig .","3 through the origin . the result is fig .","4 , in which a single shock has spontaneously split into two , with no reference to initial conditions .","this is the fragile property .","if shocks can split at any time , as indicated , then the solutions to the differential equation are maximally nonunique ."],["our aim in the previous section was to show that the equations which describe fluid flow , the navier - stokes equations , become maximally nonunique , or `` fragile , '' in some limit .","this limit is rather far removed from physical reality , however .","one naturally wonders how , if at all , the nonuniqueness property might manifest itself in a real system .","the example of laplacian growth encourages one to think that real processes would not completely obscure the underlying `` fragile '' processes @xcite .","the system we have imagined is characterized by two temperatures : a `` superhot '' negative temperature , which describes the ensemble of microscopic entities which make up the turbulent state , and the usual temperature , which describes the ensemble at the molecular level .","these two ensembles interact only weakly , it has been argued , but , again by the second law of thermodynamics , to the extent that they interact , there must be a flow of energy from the first to the second , from the turbulent ensemble to the molecular ensemble .","this picture is reminiscent of the kolmogorov cascade idea ( ref .","@xcite , chapter 3 ) , and suggests identifying the turbulent ensemble with the `` energy range , '' ( a hypothetical range in @xmath17 space containing most of the energy ) , and the molecular ensemble with the `` dissipation range , '' ( a range in @xmath17 space , disjoint from the energy range , in which dissipation is important ) , i.e. , assigning a temperature gradient to the kolmogorov picture , with negative temperature at small @xmath17 and positive temperature at large @xmath17 .","it is in the energy range , then , at small @xmath17 , that the fragile processes of nonuniqueness would occur .","these processes extract mechanical energy from the negative temperature `` bath , '' and this energy must ultimately derive from the forces maintaining the turbulence .","thus the onset of fragile processes would appear , on the macroscopic scale , as an increase in resistance to these applied forces . at a more microscopic level","it would be the onset of nonuniqueness , allowing splitting and proliferation of microscopic entities as in fig .","4 . at a still more microscopic level , corresponding to the dissipation range , the usual picture would apply , and one would have dissipative processes like fig .","3 . in this view turbulence _ is _ the visible manifestation of nonuniqueness on the intermediate scale of the energy range , and the work done by external forces goes directly into the proliferation of singularities at that scale , and only indirectly into dissipation . in terms of modelling turbulence",", it suggests that the proliferative processes of the energy range , which are still hypothetical , may be like the dissipative processes of the dissipation range , but time reversed ( and on a larger length scale ) . in this way","the abstract picture suggested here might persist in a more realistic dynamics .","the issue of nonuniqueness may also be relevant to cfd modelling of turbulence .","the algorithms of differential equation solvers are not set up for equations which do not have unique solutions .","experience with laplacian growth confirms that proximity to a nonunique model may indicate trouble for conventional numerical solutions . 99 r. courant and d. hilbert , _ methods of mathematical physics _ , vol 2 ( interscience publishers , 1962 ) .","peterson , * phys","62 * , 284 ( 1989 ) .","peterson , cond - mat/9710046 .","hastings and l.s .","levitov , cond - mat/9607021 .","burgers , _ the nonlinear diffusion equation _ , ( riedel , dordrecht , 1974 ) . g. strang , _ introduction to applied mathematics _ , ( wellesley - cambridge press , wellesley ma , 1986 ) .","chorin , _ vorticity and turbulence _ , ( springer , 1994 ) ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"the existence and uniqueness of solutions to the differential equations of physics is seldom an issue .\",\n \"the very fact that these equations describe physical reality seems to argue that their solutions must exist and be unique .\",\n \"textbook examples of nonuniqueness , for example clairaut s equation ( ref .\",\n \"@xcite , p. 94 ) , seem like exceptional cases , which would not arise in physics in any case . there is , however , a system of differential equations , arising as a limiting case of a much studied physical problem , in which uniqueness fails for _ every _ solution at _ every _ time .\",\n \"the system is singular laplacian growth @xcite , @xcite .\",\n \"one might call this behavior `` maximally nonunique . ''\",\n \"it is so different from the usual behavior of differential equations that it hardly seems like a differential system at all .\",\n \"the way it occurs is the following : the theory of singular laplacian growth describes the motions of certain singularities of a conformal map , which are all located on the unit circle in the complex plane .\",\n \"they move on the circle , but they can also `` split , '' introducing new singularities , at any time .\",\n \"this behavior , which does not sound very remarkable , essentially implies the maximal nonuniqueness property . in ref .\",\n \"@xcite the term `` fragile '' was suggested for such a system , because its distinguishing feature is that its singularities can break apart .\",\n \"it is natural to ask if other physical systems might reduce to a fragile system in some limit , and if the fragile property manifests itself in the behavior of the system .\",\n \"turbulence is certainly a candidate to be a fragile system : like laplacian growth , turbulence is a phenomenon in which a differential equation has unexpectedly complex solutions . in this paper\",\n \"i argue that turbulence is a system that has a fragile ( maximally nonunique ) limiting case .\",\n \"the limiting case is the burgers equation .\",\n \"( on rather different grounds a resemblance between the problems of turbulence and laplacian growth has been noted by hastings and levitov @xcite ) .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the burgers equation @xcite , @xcite @xmath0 has played a shifting role in the problem of turbulence .\",\n \"it was first introduced as a one - dimensional zero pressure version of the navier - stokes equation ( with @xmath1 the viscosity ) in the hope that it might exhibit in its solutions some of the complexity of turbulence . by the hopf - cole trick ,\",\n \"though , it was found to be equivalent to a linear diffusion equation , so that the initial value problem could be solved explicitly : one can write a formula for the solution ! that is surely too simple to be turbulent .\",\n \"attention was thus focussed on the only case which still seemed promising , the @xmath2 limit , the inviscid burgers equation , which is a conservation law for @xmath3 . in this limit\",\n \"the solution may develop discontinuities ( `` shocks '' ) .\",\n \"the distribution of shocks , and their development in time , for random initial data , is a problem called burgers turbulence .\",\n \"the reason that one should think of this as a @xmath2 limit , and not simply as a @xmath4 version of the equation , is that for @xmath4 the solution is ambiguous . to be sure , the solution of the inviscid equation is immediate by the method of characteristics : @xmath3 is constant along lines @xmath5 ( hence straight lines in the x - t plane ) .\",\n \"but if the characteristics cross , which they certainly will do in the case of random initial data @xmath6 , then one has multiple determinations of @xmath7 , as in fig .\",\n \"1 . the resolution of this difficulty is to take the formula for @xmath7 in case @xmath8 , which is unambiguous , and let @xmath1 approach zero .\",\n \"the result is as shown in fig .\",\n \"2 : a discontinuity forms at a definite location , separating one determination of @xmath3 from another .\",\n \"the same procedure shows that shocks interact in a definite manner , coalescing as shown in fig .\",\n \"3 when one overtakes or collides with another .\",\n \"the rules for how these discontinuities form and interact were known long ago in the theory of compressible gas dynamics , where they are called the rankine - hugoniot jump conditions ( see ref .\",\n \"@xcite , pp .\",\n \"488 - 90 , ref .\",\n \"@xcite , p. 596 ) .\",\n \"they are justified by appeal to the second law of thermodynamics : while @xmath3 is conserved , entropy must increase in the shock .\",\n \"that is what the argument with @xmath8 also does : we resolve the ambiguity in the inviscid burgers equation by putting in a dissipative term with the right sign .\",\n \"the second law of thermodynamics says mechanical energy should be dissipated in the shock , and not created .\",\n \"it is this condition which leads to the interaction rule illustrated in fig .\"\n ],\n [\n \"now recall the suggestion of onsager , as emphasized by alexandre chorin , among others , that a statistical theory of the turbulent steady state should be characterized by a negative temperature ( see ref .\",\n \"@xcite , chapter 4 ) .\",\n \"what is meant is that there is a maxwell - boltzmann probability distribution @xmath9 which , instead of giving more weight to the low energy microstates in the ensemble description of the macrostate , as is usual , gives more weight to high energy microstates .\",\n \"( this statistical `` temperature '' of turbulence has nothing to do with usual thermodynamic temperature , which is only weakly coupled to the mechanical degrees of freedom of interest . )\",\n \"let us accept this idea for the moment .\",\n \"the second law says that entropy should increase , or perhaps better , in this more general situation , that information should be lost , in irreversible processes\",\n \". stated in terms of the free energy @xmath10 ( and remembering @xmath11 ) this says that free energy should _ increase _ in the approach to the steady state .\",\n \"this is opposite to what is usual . putting onsager s idea together with the ideas of burgers turbulence\",\n \"thus requires that mechanical energy should be created in the shock rather than dissipated .\",\n \"we see that the limit in the inviscid burgers equation should be @xmath12 , i.e. , we should imagine the viscosity approaching zero through _ negative _ values , from _\",\n \"below_. the inviscid burger s equation does not contain temperature or @xmath1 explicitly , of course , but the rules for how the shocks form and interact are now different .\",\n \"the following argument gives the simple idea which is at the heart of this paper .\",\n \"we do not try to give it an elaborate justification , since , like many simple ideas , it may contain some truth even if the arguments are wrong .\",\n \"the argument is that there is a symmetry of the ( general ) burgers equation , @xmath13 we can convert the @xmath14 inviscid burgers equation into the familiar @xmath8 inviscid burgers equation by reversing the signs of @xmath15 and @xmath16 , i.e. , reflecting graphs like fig .\",\n \"3 through the origin . the result is fig .\",\n \"4 , in which a single shock has spontaneously split into two , with no reference to initial conditions .\",\n \"this is the fragile property .\",\n \"if shocks can split at any time , as indicated , then the solutions to the differential equation are maximally nonunique .\"\n ],\n [\n \"our aim in the previous section was to show that the equations which describe fluid flow , the navier - stokes equations , become maximally nonunique , or `` fragile , '' in some limit .\",\n \"this limit is rather far removed from physical reality , however .\",\n \"one naturally wonders how , if at all , the nonuniqueness property might manifest itself in a real system .\",\n \"the example of laplacian growth encourages one to think that real processes would not completely obscure the underlying `` fragile '' processes @xcite .\",\n \"the system we have imagined is characterized by two temperatures : a `` superhot '' negative temperature , which describes the ensemble of microscopic entities which make up the turbulent state , and the usual temperature , which describes the ensemble at the molecular level .\",\n \"these two ensembles interact only weakly , it has been argued , but , again by the second law of thermodynamics , to the extent that they interact , there must be a flow of energy from the first to the second , from the turbulent ensemble to the molecular ensemble .\",\n \"this picture is reminiscent of the kolmogorov cascade idea ( ref .\",\n \"@xcite , chapter 3 ) , and suggests identifying the turbulent ensemble with the `` energy range , '' ( a hypothetical range in @xmath17 space containing most of the energy ) , and the molecular ensemble with the `` dissipation range , '' ( a range in @xmath17 space , disjoint from the energy range , in which dissipation is important ) , i.e. , assigning a temperature gradient to the kolmogorov picture , with negative temperature at small @xmath17 and positive temperature at large @xmath17 .\",\n \"it is in the energy range , then , at small @xmath17 , that the fragile processes of nonuniqueness would occur .\",\n \"these processes extract mechanical energy from the negative temperature `` bath , '' and this energy must ultimately derive from the forces maintaining the turbulence .\",\n \"thus the onset of fragile processes would appear , on the macroscopic scale , as an increase in resistance to these applied forces . at a more microscopic level\",\n \"it would be the onset of nonuniqueness , allowing splitting and proliferation of microscopic entities as in fig .\",\n \"4 . at a still more microscopic level , corresponding to the dissipation range , the usual picture would apply , and one would have dissipative processes like fig .\",\n \"3 . in this view turbulence _ is _ the visible manifestation of nonuniqueness on the intermediate scale of the energy range , and the work done by external forces goes directly into the proliferation of singularities at that scale , and only indirectly into dissipation . in terms of modelling turbulence\",\n \", it suggests that the proliferative processes of the energy range , which are still hypothetical , may be like the dissipative processes of the dissipation range , but time reversed ( and on a larger length scale ) . in this way\",\n \"the abstract picture suggested here might persist in a more realistic dynamics .\",\n \"the issue of nonuniqueness may also be relevant to cfd modelling of turbulence .\",\n \"the algorithms of differential equation solvers are not set up for equations which do not have unique solutions .\",\n \"experience with laplacian growth confirms that proximity to a nonunique model may indicate trouble for conventional numerical solutions . 99 r. courant and d. hilbert , _ methods of mathematical physics _ , vol 2 ( interscience publishers , 1962 ) .\",\n \"peterson , * phys\",\n \"62 * , 284 ( 1989 ) .\",\n \"peterson , cond - mat/9710046 .\",\n \"hastings and l.s .\",\n \"levitov , cond - mat/9607021 .\",\n \"burgers , _ the nonlinear diffusion equation _ , ( riedel , dordrecht , 1974 ) . g. strang , _ introduction to applied mathematics _ , ( wellesley - cambridge press , wellesley ma , 1986 ) .\",\n \"chorin , _ vorticity and turbulence _ , ( springer , 1994 ) .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":79,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"astro-ph0404366"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["over the past decade , the search for sources of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) has begun to focus upon small scale anisotropy in event arrival directions .","this refers to statistically significant excesses occurring at the scale of @xmath1 .","the interest in this sort of anisotropy has largely been fueled by the observations of the akeno giant air shower array ( agasa ) . in 1999","@xcite and again in 2001 @xcite , the agasa collaboration reported observing what eventually became seven clusters ( six `` doublets '' and one `` triplet '' ) with estimated energies above @xmath2 ev .","several attempts that have been made to ascertain the significance of these clusters returned chance probabilities of @xmath3 @xcite to 0.08 @xcite .","by contrast , the monocular ( and stereo ) analyses that have been presented by the high resolution fly s eye ( hires ) demonstrate that the level of autocorrelation observed in our sample is completely consistent with that expected from background coincidences @xcite .","any analysis of hires monocular data needs to take into account that the angular resolution in monocular mode is highly asymmetric .","it is very difficult to compare the results of the hires monocular and agasa analyses .","they are very different in the way that they measure autocorrelation .","differences in the published energy spectra of the two experiments suggest an energy scale difference of 30% @xcite . additionally , the two experiments observe uhecrs in very different ways .","the hires experiment has an energy - dependent aperture and an exposure with a seasonal variability @xcite .","these differences make it very difficult get an intuitive grasp of what hires should see if the agasa claim of autocorrelation is justified . in order to develop this sort of intuition",", we apply the same analysis to both agasa and hires data .","the data set that we consider consists of events that were included in the hires - i monocular spectrum measurement @xcite .","this set contains 52 events observed between may 1997 and february 2003 with measured energies greater than @xmath0 ev . the data set represents a cumulative exposure of @xmath4 km@xmath5sr@xmath6yr at @xmath7 ev .","this data was subject to a number of quality cuts that are detailed in the above - mentioned papers @xcite .","we previously verified that this data set was consistent with monte carlo predictions in many ways including impact parameter ( @xmath8 ) distributions @xcite and zenith angle distributions @xcite . for this study , we presumed an average atmospheric clarity @xcite . in order to calculate the autocorrelation function for this subset of data , we must first parameterize the hires - i monocular angular resolution . for a monocular air fluorescence detector ,","angular resolution consists of two components , the plane of reconstruction , that is the plane in which the shower is observed , and the angle @xmath9 within the plane of reconstruction ( see figure [ figure : picture ] ) . [ cols=\"^ \" , ]","we can see the result of these simulations .","the observed hires - i signal corresponds to the 90% confidence upper limit with the inclusion of only 3.5 doublets beyond random background coincidence .","if we repeat this analysis with first , a 7.5% reduction in the estimated angular resolution values and second , a 7.5% increase in the estimated angular resolution values , we obtain a range for the 90% confidence upper limit of @xmath10 $ ] doublets and a range for the 95% confidence upper limit of @xmath11 $ ] doublets .","a final area of concern is the systematic uncertainty in the determination of atmospheric clarity .","because hourly atmospheric observations are not available for the entire hires - i monocular data set , we have relied upon the use of an average atmospheric profile for the reconstruction of our data @xcite . while different atmospheric conditions have negligible impact on the determination of the arrival direction for events with measured energies this high , differing conditions can have an impact on energy estimation and thus the number of events that are included in our data set . over the @xmath12 error space for our estimation of atmospheric conditions , the total number of events in our data set fluctuates on the interval @xmath13 $ ] .","the value of the observable , @xmath14}$ ] , has a fluctuation on the interval @xmath15 $ ] owing to addition and subtraction of events from the data set .","note that in neither case does the value of @xmath14}$ ] exceed the mean value ( 0.99250 ) expected for a background set .","we conclude that the hires - i monocular detector sees no evidence of clustering in its highest energy events . furthermore , the hires - i monocular data has an intrinsic sensitivity to global autocorrelation such that we can claim at the 90% confidence level that there can be no more than 3.5 doublets above that which would be expected by background coincidence in the hires - i monocular data set above @xmath0 ev . from this result",", we can then derive , with a 90% confidence level , that no more than 13% of the observed hires - i events could be sharing common arrival directions .","this data set is comparable to the sensitivity of the reported agasa data set if one assumes that there is indeed a 30% energy scale difference between the two experiments .","it should be emphasized that this conclusion pertains only to point sources of the sort claimed by the agasa collaboration .","furthermore , because a measure of autocorrelation makes no assumption of the underlying astrophysical mechanism that results in clustering phenomena , we can not claim that the hires monocular analysis and the agasa analysis are inconsistent beyond a specified confidence level .","this work is supported by us nsf grants phy 9322298 , phy 9321949 , phy 9974537 , phy 0071069 , phy 0098826 , phy 0140688 , phy 0245428 , phy 0307098 by the doe grant fg03 - 92er40732 , and by the australian research council .","we gratefully acknowledge the contributions from the technical staffs of our home institutions .","we gratefully acknowledge the contributions from the university of utah center for high performance computing .","the cooperation of colonels e. fisher and g. harter , the us army and the dugway proving ground staff is appreciated .","p. g. tinyakov and i. i. tkachev , jetp lett .","* 74 * , 1 ( 2001 ) [ pisma zh .","* 74 * , 3 ( 2001 ) ] [ arxiv : astro - ph/0102101 ] . c. b. finley and s. westerhoff , accepted for publication in _ astroparticle physics _ [ arxiv : astro - ph/0309159 ] .","r. u. abbasi _ et al . _","[ high resolution fly s eye collaboration ] , phys .","lett . * 92 * , 151101 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0208243 ] .","m. takeda _ et al .","_ , phys .","lett . * 81 * , 1163 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9807193 ] . t. abu - zayyad _ et al . _","[ high resolution fly s eye collaboration ] , submitted for publication in _ astroparticle physics _ [ arxiv : astro - ph/0208301 ] .","y. uchihori , m. nagano , m. takeda , m. teshima , j. lloyd - evans and a. a. watson , astropart .","* 13 * , 151 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9908193 ] .","n. w. evans , f. ferrer and s. sarkar , astropart .","* 17 * , 319 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0103085 ] ."],"string":"[\n \"over the past decade , the search for sources of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) has begun to focus upon small scale anisotropy in event arrival directions .\",\n \"this refers to statistically significant excesses occurring at the scale of @xmath1 .\",\n \"the interest in this sort of anisotropy has largely been fueled by the observations of the akeno giant air shower array ( agasa ) . in 1999\",\n \"@xcite and again in 2001 @xcite , the agasa collaboration reported observing what eventually became seven clusters ( six `` doublets '' and one `` triplet '' ) with estimated energies above @xmath2 ev .\",\n \"several attempts that have been made to ascertain the significance of these clusters returned chance probabilities of @xmath3 @xcite to 0.08 @xcite .\",\n \"by contrast , the monocular ( and stereo ) analyses that have been presented by the high resolution fly s eye ( hires ) demonstrate that the level of autocorrelation observed in our sample is completely consistent with that expected from background coincidences @xcite .\",\n \"any analysis of hires monocular data needs to take into account that the angular resolution in monocular mode is highly asymmetric .\",\n \"it is very difficult to compare the results of the hires monocular and agasa analyses .\",\n \"they are very different in the way that they measure autocorrelation .\",\n \"differences in the published energy spectra of the two experiments suggest an energy scale difference of 30% @xcite . additionally , the two experiments observe uhecrs in very different ways .\",\n \"the hires experiment has an energy - dependent aperture and an exposure with a seasonal variability @xcite .\",\n \"these differences make it very difficult get an intuitive grasp of what hires should see if the agasa claim of autocorrelation is justified . in order to develop this sort of intuition\",\n \", we apply the same analysis to both agasa and hires data .\",\n \"the data set that we consider consists of events that were included in the hires - i monocular spectrum measurement @xcite .\",\n \"this set contains 52 events observed between may 1997 and february 2003 with measured energies greater than @xmath0 ev . the data set represents a cumulative exposure of @xmath4 km@xmath5sr@xmath6yr at @xmath7 ev .\",\n \"this data was subject to a number of quality cuts that are detailed in the above - mentioned papers @xcite .\",\n \"we previously verified that this data set was consistent with monte carlo predictions in many ways including impact parameter ( @xmath8 ) distributions @xcite and zenith angle distributions @xcite . for this study , we presumed an average atmospheric clarity @xcite . in order to calculate the autocorrelation function for this subset of data , we must first parameterize the hires - i monocular angular resolution . for a monocular air fluorescence detector ,\",\n \"angular resolution consists of two components , the plane of reconstruction , that is the plane in which the shower is observed , and the angle @xmath9 within the plane of reconstruction ( see figure [ figure : picture ] ) . [ cols=\\\"^ \\\" , ]\",\n \"we can see the result of these simulations .\",\n \"the observed hires - i signal corresponds to the 90% confidence upper limit with the inclusion of only 3.5 doublets beyond random background coincidence .\",\n \"if we repeat this analysis with first , a 7.5% reduction in the estimated angular resolution values and second , a 7.5% increase in the estimated angular resolution values , we obtain a range for the 90% confidence upper limit of @xmath10 $ ] doublets and a range for the 95% confidence upper limit of @xmath11 $ ] doublets .\",\n \"a final area of concern is the systematic uncertainty in the determination of atmospheric clarity .\",\n \"because hourly atmospheric observations are not available for the entire hires - i monocular data set , we have relied upon the use of an average atmospheric profile for the reconstruction of our data @xcite . while different atmospheric conditions have negligible impact on the determination of the arrival direction for events with measured energies this high , differing conditions can have an impact on energy estimation and thus the number of events that are included in our data set . over the @xmath12 error space for our estimation of atmospheric conditions , the total number of events in our data set fluctuates on the interval @xmath13 $ ] .\",\n \"the value of the observable , @xmath14}$ ] , has a fluctuation on the interval @xmath15 $ ] owing to addition and subtraction of events from the data set .\",\n \"note that in neither case does the value of @xmath14}$ ] exceed the mean value ( 0.99250 ) expected for a background set .\",\n \"we conclude that the hires - i monocular detector sees no evidence of clustering in its highest energy events . furthermore , the hires - i monocular data has an intrinsic sensitivity to global autocorrelation such that we can claim at the 90% confidence level that there can be no more than 3.5 doublets above that which would be expected by background coincidence in the hires - i monocular data set above @xmath0 ev . from this result\",\n \", we can then derive , with a 90% confidence level , that no more than 13% of the observed hires - i events could be sharing common arrival directions .\",\n \"this data set is comparable to the sensitivity of the reported agasa data set if one assumes that there is indeed a 30% energy scale difference between the two experiments .\",\n \"it should be emphasized that this conclusion pertains only to point sources of the sort claimed by the agasa collaboration .\",\n \"furthermore , because a measure of autocorrelation makes no assumption of the underlying astrophysical mechanism that results in clustering phenomena , we can not claim that the hires monocular analysis and the agasa analysis are inconsistent beyond a specified confidence level .\",\n \"this work is supported by us nsf grants phy 9322298 , phy 9321949 , phy 9974537 , phy 0071069 , phy 0098826 , phy 0140688 , phy 0245428 , phy 0307098 by the doe grant fg03 - 92er40732 , and by the australian research council .\",\n \"we gratefully acknowledge the contributions from the technical staffs of our home institutions .\",\n \"we gratefully acknowledge the contributions from the university of utah center for high performance computing .\",\n \"the cooperation of colonels e. fisher and g. harter , the us army and the dugway proving ground staff is appreciated .\",\n \"p. g. tinyakov and i. i. tkachev , jetp lett .\",\n \"* 74 * , 1 ( 2001 ) [ pisma zh .\",\n \"* 74 * , 3 ( 2001 ) ] [ arxiv : astro - ph/0102101 ] . c. b. finley and s. westerhoff , accepted for publication in _ astroparticle physics _ [ arxiv : astro - ph/0309159 ] .\",\n \"r. u. abbasi _ et al . _\",\n \"[ high resolution fly s eye collaboration ] , phys .\",\n \"lett . * 92 * , 151101 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0208243 ] .\",\n \"m. takeda _ et al .\",\n \"_ , phys .\",\n \"lett . * 81 * , 1163 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9807193 ] . t. abu - zayyad _ et al . _\",\n \"[ high resolution fly s eye collaboration ] , submitted for publication in _ astroparticle physics _ [ arxiv : astro - ph/0208301 ] .\",\n \"y. uchihori , m. nagano , m. takeda , m. teshima , j. lloyd - evans and a. a. watson , astropart .\",\n \"* 13 * , 151 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9908193 ] .\",\n \"n. w. evans , f. ferrer and s. sarkar , astropart .\",\n \"* 17 * , 319 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0103085 ] .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> in the past few years , small scale anisotropy has become a primary focus in the search for source of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) . the akeno giant air shower array ( agasa ) </S>","<S> has reported the presence of clusters of event arrival directions in their highest energy data set . </S>","<S> the high resolution fly s eye ( hires ) has accumulated an exposure in one of its monocular eyes at energies above @xmath0 ev comparable to that of agasa . however , monocular events observed with an air fluorescence detector are characterized by highly asymmetric angular resolution . </S>","<S> a method is developed for measuring autocorrelation with asymmetric angular resolution . </S>","<S> it is concluded that hires - i observations are consistent with no autocorrelation and that the sensitivity to clustering of the hires - i detector is comparable to that of the reported agasa data set . </S>","<S> furthermore , we state with a 90% confidence level that no more than 13% of the observed hires - i events above @xmath0 ev could be sharing common arrival directions . however , because a measure of autocorrelation makes no assumption of the underlying astrophysical mechanism that results in clustering phenomena , we can not claim that the hires monocular analysis and the agasa analysis are inconsistent beyond a specified confidence level . cosmic rays , anisotropy , clustering , autocorrelation , hires , agasa 98.70.sa , 95.55.vj , 96.40.pq , 13.85.tp </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> in the past few years , small scale anisotropy has become a primary focus in the search for source of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) . the akeno giant air shower array ( agasa ) </S>\",\n \"<S> has reported the presence of clusters of event arrival directions in their highest energy data set . </S>\",\n \"<S> the high resolution fly s eye ( hires ) has accumulated an exposure in one of its monocular eyes at energies above @xmath0 ev comparable to that of agasa . however , monocular events observed with an air fluorescence detector are characterized by highly asymmetric angular resolution . </S>\",\n \"<S> a method is developed for measuring autocorrelation with asymmetric angular resolution . </S>\",\n \"<S> it is concluded that hires - i observations are consistent with no autocorrelation and that the sensitivity to clustering of the hires - i detector is comparable to that of the reported agasa data set . </S>\",\n \"<S> furthermore , we state with a 90% confidence level that no more than 13% of the observed hires - i events above @xmath0 ev could be sharing common arrival directions . however , because a measure of autocorrelation makes no assumption of the underlying astrophysical mechanism that results in clustering phenomena , we can not claim that the hires monocular analysis and the agasa analysis are inconsistent beyond a specified confidence level . cosmic rays , anisotropy , clustering , autocorrelation , hires , agasa 98.70.sa , 95.55.vj , 96.40.pq , 13.85.tp </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","the hires-i monocular data","conclusion","acknowledgments"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"the hires-i monocular data\",\n \"conclusion\",\n \"acknowledgments\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["over the past decade , the search for sources of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) has begun to focus upon small scale anisotropy in event arrival directions .","this refers to statistically significant excesses occurring at the scale of @xmath1 .","the interest in this sort of anisotropy has largely been fueled by the observations of the akeno giant air shower array ( agasa ) . in 1999","@xcite and again in 2001 @xcite , the agasa collaboration reported observing what eventually became seven clusters ( six `` doublets '' and one `` triplet '' ) with estimated energies above @xmath2 ev .","several attempts that have been made to ascertain the significance of these clusters returned chance probabilities of @xmath3 @xcite to 0.08 @xcite .","by contrast , the monocular ( and stereo ) analyses that have been presented by the high resolution fly s eye ( hires ) demonstrate that the level of autocorrelation observed in our sample is completely consistent with that expected from background coincidences @xcite .","any analysis of hires monocular data needs to take into account that the angular resolution in monocular mode is highly asymmetric .","it is very difficult to compare the results of the hires monocular and agasa analyses .","they are very different in the way that they measure autocorrelation .","differences in the published energy spectra of the two experiments suggest an energy scale difference of 30% @xcite . additionally , the two experiments observe uhecrs in very different ways .","the hires experiment has an energy - dependent aperture and an exposure with a seasonal variability @xcite .","these differences make it very difficult get an intuitive grasp of what hires should see if the agasa claim of autocorrelation is justified . in order to develop this sort of intuition",", we apply the same analysis to both agasa and hires data ."],["the data set that we consider consists of events that were included in the hires - i monocular spectrum measurement @xcite .","this set contains 52 events observed between may 1997 and february 2003 with measured energies greater than @xmath0 ev . the data set represents a cumulative exposure of @xmath4 km@xmath5sr@xmath6yr at @xmath7 ev .","this data was subject to a number of quality cuts that are detailed in the above - mentioned papers @xcite .","we previously verified that this data set was consistent with monte carlo predictions in many ways including impact parameter ( @xmath8 ) distributions @xcite and zenith angle distributions @xcite . for this study , we presumed an average atmospheric clarity @xcite . in order to calculate the autocorrelation function for this subset of data , we must first parameterize the hires - i monocular angular resolution . for a monocular air fluorescence detector ,","angular resolution consists of two components , the plane of reconstruction , that is the plane in which the shower is observed , and the angle @xmath9 within the plane of reconstruction ( see figure [ figure : picture ] ) . [ cols=\"^ \" , ]","we can see the result of these simulations .","the observed hires - i signal corresponds to the 90% confidence upper limit with the inclusion of only 3.5 doublets beyond random background coincidence .","if we repeat this analysis with first , a 7.5% reduction in the estimated angular resolution values and second , a 7.5% increase in the estimated angular resolution values , we obtain a range for the 90% confidence upper limit of @xmath10 $ ] doublets and a range for the 95% confidence upper limit of @xmath11 $ ] doublets .","a final area of concern is the systematic uncertainty in the determination of atmospheric clarity .","because hourly atmospheric observations are not available for the entire hires - i monocular data set , we have relied upon the use of an average atmospheric profile for the reconstruction of our data @xcite . while different atmospheric conditions have negligible impact on the determination of the arrival direction for events with measured energies this high , differing conditions can have an impact on energy estimation and thus the number of events that are included in our data set . over the @xmath12 error space for our estimation of atmospheric conditions , the total number of events in our data set fluctuates on the interval @xmath13 $ ] .","the value of the observable , @xmath14}$ ] , has a fluctuation on the interval @xmath15 $ ] owing to addition and subtraction of events from the data set .","note that in neither case does the value of @xmath14}$ ] exceed the mean value ( 0.99250 ) expected for a background set ."],["we conclude that the hires - i monocular detector sees no evidence of clustering in its highest energy events . furthermore , the hires - i monocular data has an intrinsic sensitivity to global autocorrelation such that we can claim at the 90% confidence level that there can be no more than 3.5 doublets above that which would be expected by background coincidence in the hires - i monocular data set above @xmath0 ev . from this result",", we can then derive , with a 90% confidence level , that no more than 13% of the observed hires - i events could be sharing common arrival directions .","this data set is comparable to the sensitivity of the reported agasa data set if one assumes that there is indeed a 30% energy scale difference between the two experiments .","it should be emphasized that this conclusion pertains only to point sources of the sort claimed by the agasa collaboration .","furthermore , because a measure of autocorrelation makes no assumption of the underlying astrophysical mechanism that results in clustering phenomena , we can not claim that the hires monocular analysis and the agasa analysis are inconsistent beyond a specified confidence level ."],["this work is supported by us nsf grants phy 9322298 , phy 9321949 , phy 9974537 , phy 0071069 , phy 0098826 , phy 0140688 , phy 0245428 , phy 0307098 by the doe grant fg03 - 92er40732 , and by the australian research council .","we gratefully acknowledge the contributions from the technical staffs of our home institutions .","we gratefully acknowledge the contributions from the university of utah center for high performance computing .","the cooperation of colonels e. fisher and g. harter , the us army and the dugway proving ground staff is appreciated .","p. g. tinyakov and i. i. tkachev , jetp lett .","* 74 * , 1 ( 2001 ) [ pisma zh .","* 74 * , 3 ( 2001 ) ] [ arxiv : astro - ph/0102101 ] . c. b. finley and s. westerhoff , accepted for publication in _ astroparticle physics _ [ arxiv : astro - ph/0309159 ] .","r. u. abbasi _ et al . _","[ high resolution fly s eye collaboration ] , phys .","lett . * 92 * , 151101 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0208243 ] .","m. takeda _ et al .","_ , phys .","lett . * 81 * , 1163 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9807193 ] . t. abu - zayyad _ et al . _","[ high resolution fly s eye collaboration ] , submitted for publication in _ astroparticle physics _ [ arxiv : astro - ph/0208301 ] .","y. uchihori , m. nagano , m. takeda , m. teshima , j. lloyd - evans and a. a. watson , astropart .","* 13 * , 151 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9908193 ] .","n. w. evans , f. ferrer and s. sarkar , astropart .","* 17 * , 319 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0103085 ] ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"over the past decade , the search for sources of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) has begun to focus upon small scale anisotropy in event arrival directions .\",\n \"this refers to statistically significant excesses occurring at the scale of @xmath1 .\",\n \"the interest in this sort of anisotropy has largely been fueled by the observations of the akeno giant air shower array ( agasa ) . in 1999\",\n \"@xcite and again in 2001 @xcite , the agasa collaboration reported observing what eventually became seven clusters ( six `` doublets '' and one `` triplet '' ) with estimated energies above @xmath2 ev .\",\n \"several attempts that have been made to ascertain the significance of these clusters returned chance probabilities of @xmath3 @xcite to 0.08 @xcite .\",\n \"by contrast , the monocular ( and stereo ) analyses that have been presented by the high resolution fly s eye ( hires ) demonstrate that the level of autocorrelation observed in our sample is completely consistent with that expected from background coincidences @xcite .\",\n \"any analysis of hires monocular data needs to take into account that the angular resolution in monocular mode is highly asymmetric .\",\n \"it is very difficult to compare the results of the hires monocular and agasa analyses .\",\n \"they are very different in the way that they measure autocorrelation .\",\n \"differences in the published energy spectra of the two experiments suggest an energy scale difference of 30% @xcite . additionally , the two experiments observe uhecrs in very different ways .\",\n \"the hires experiment has an energy - dependent aperture and an exposure with a seasonal variability @xcite .\",\n \"these differences make it very difficult get an intuitive grasp of what hires should see if the agasa claim of autocorrelation is justified . in order to develop this sort of intuition\",\n \", we apply the same analysis to both agasa and hires data .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the data set that we consider consists of events that were included in the hires - i monocular spectrum measurement @xcite .\",\n \"this set contains 52 events observed between may 1997 and february 2003 with measured energies greater than @xmath0 ev . the data set represents a cumulative exposure of @xmath4 km@xmath5sr@xmath6yr at @xmath7 ev .\",\n \"this data was subject to a number of quality cuts that are detailed in the above - mentioned papers @xcite .\",\n \"we previously verified that this data set was consistent with monte carlo predictions in many ways including impact parameter ( @xmath8 ) distributions @xcite and zenith angle distributions @xcite . for this study , we presumed an average atmospheric clarity @xcite . in order to calculate the autocorrelation function for this subset of data , we must first parameterize the hires - i monocular angular resolution . for a monocular air fluorescence detector ,\",\n \"angular resolution consists of two components , the plane of reconstruction , that is the plane in which the shower is observed , and the angle @xmath9 within the plane of reconstruction ( see figure [ figure : picture ] ) . [ cols=\\\"^ \\\" , ]\",\n \"we can see the result of these simulations .\",\n \"the observed hires - i signal corresponds to the 90% confidence upper limit with the inclusion of only 3.5 doublets beyond random background coincidence .\",\n \"if we repeat this analysis with first , a 7.5% reduction in the estimated angular resolution values and second , a 7.5% increase in the estimated angular resolution values , we obtain a range for the 90% confidence upper limit of @xmath10 $ ] doublets and a range for the 95% confidence upper limit of @xmath11 $ ] doublets .\",\n \"a final area of concern is the systematic uncertainty in the determination of atmospheric clarity .\",\n \"because hourly atmospheric observations are not available for the entire hires - i monocular data set , we have relied upon the use of an average atmospheric profile for the reconstruction of our data @xcite . while different atmospheric conditions have negligible impact on the determination of the arrival direction for events with measured energies this high , differing conditions can have an impact on energy estimation and thus the number of events that are included in our data set . over the @xmath12 error space for our estimation of atmospheric conditions , the total number of events in our data set fluctuates on the interval @xmath13 $ ] .\",\n \"the value of the observable , @xmath14}$ ] , has a fluctuation on the interval @xmath15 $ ] owing to addition and subtraction of events from the data set .\",\n \"note that in neither case does the value of @xmath14}$ ] exceed the mean value ( 0.99250 ) expected for a background set .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we conclude that the hires - i monocular detector sees no evidence of clustering in its highest energy events . furthermore , the hires - i monocular data has an intrinsic sensitivity to global autocorrelation such that we can claim at the 90% confidence level that there can be no more than 3.5 doublets above that which would be expected by background coincidence in the hires - i monocular data set above @xmath0 ev . from this result\",\n \", we can then derive , with a 90% confidence level , that no more than 13% of the observed hires - i events could be sharing common arrival directions .\",\n \"this data set is comparable to the sensitivity of the reported agasa data set if one assumes that there is indeed a 30% energy scale difference between the two experiments .\",\n \"it should be emphasized that this conclusion pertains only to point sources of the sort claimed by the agasa collaboration .\",\n \"furthermore , because a measure of autocorrelation makes no assumption of the underlying astrophysical mechanism that results in clustering phenomena , we can not claim that the hires monocular analysis and the agasa analysis are inconsistent beyond a specified confidence level .\"\n ],\n [\n \"this work is supported by us nsf grants phy 9322298 , phy 9321949 , phy 9974537 , phy 0071069 , phy 0098826 , phy 0140688 , phy 0245428 , phy 0307098 by the doe grant fg03 - 92er40732 , and by the australian research council .\",\n \"we gratefully acknowledge the contributions from the technical staffs of our home institutions .\",\n \"we gratefully acknowledge the contributions from the university of utah center for high performance computing .\",\n \"the cooperation of colonels e. fisher and g. harter , the us army and the dugway proving ground staff is appreciated .\",\n \"p. g. tinyakov and i. i. tkachev , jetp lett .\",\n \"* 74 * , 1 ( 2001 ) [ pisma zh .\",\n \"* 74 * , 3 ( 2001 ) ] [ arxiv : astro - ph/0102101 ] . c. b. finley and s. westerhoff , accepted for publication in _ astroparticle physics _ [ arxiv : astro - ph/0309159 ] .\",\n \"r. u. abbasi _ et al . _\",\n \"[ high resolution fly s eye collaboration ] , phys .\",\n \"lett . * 92 * , 151101 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0208243 ] .\",\n \"m. takeda _ et al .\",\n \"_ , phys .\",\n \"lett . * 81 * , 1163 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9807193 ] . t. abu - zayyad _ et al . _\",\n \"[ high resolution fly s eye collaboration ] , submitted for publication in _ astroparticle physics _ [ arxiv : astro - ph/0208301 ] .\",\n \"y. uchihori , m. nagano , m. takeda , m. teshima , j. lloyd - evans and a. a. watson , astropart .\",\n \"* 13 * , 151 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9908193 ] .\",\n \"n. w. evans , f. ferrer and s. sarkar , astropart .\",\n \"* 17 * , 319 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0103085 ] .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":80,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"astro-ph9906217"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["interstellar gas in the solar neighborhood has a variety of thermal and chemical phases , including cold atomic gas inside or mixed with cold molecular clouds ( e.g. , sato & fukui 1978 ) , cool and warm atomic gas on the envelopes of molecular clouds ( chromey et al .","1989 ; andersson & wannier 1993 ; wannier et al .","1993 ) and in the diffuse , low density medium ( kulkarni & heiles 1987 ) , cold molecules in dark and dense clouds ( combes 1991 ) and in translucent clouds ( magnani , blitz & mundy 1985 ) , warm molecules in dense clouds near embedded luminous stars ( e.g. , cesaroni et al . 1994 ) , dense photo - ionized gas in the neighborhoods of o and b - type stars , low - density ionized gas between these stars ( walterbos & braun 1994 ; reynolds 1995 ; ferguson et al . 1996 ) , and hot , shock - heated gas near supernovae and windy stars ( ostriker & mckee 1988 ) .","there is also considerable variety in the types of molecules that are present inside dark clouds , ranging from primarily h@xmath0 in translucent clouds ( spitzer & jenkins 1975 ; magnani et al .","1998 ) , with a possible trace of pah or long - chain molecules ( leger & puget 1984 ; tulej et al . 1998 ) , to a mixture of complex molecules in dense clouds ( e.g. , langer et al . 1997","; see reviews by van dishoeck and thaddeus , this conference ) .","the thermal and chemical states of the cold and cool gas have such a great variety because the clouds shield themselves to different levels from photodissociative radiation and radiant heating .","this makes the molecular abundance and temperature depend on density , column density , metallicity , age , and local radiation field , all of which vary from cloud to cloud and with radius in the galaxy .","the nature of cloud _ structure _ does not change this much , because it is largely the result of turbulence , self - gravity , and local explosions , which seem to act the same way everywhere .","here we discuss the dominant processes that affect the molecular and thermal states of the gas , and we review the some of the aspects of cloud structure that are likely to arise from turbulence .","interstellar clouds shield themselves from photo - dissociative radiation when the molecular formation rate ( in @xmath1 ) integrated over the cloud radius exceeds the molecular dissociation flux ( in @xmath2 ) from incident starlight ( jura 1975 ; federman , glassgold , & kwan 1979 ; van dishoeck & black 1988 ; sternberg 1989 ; hollenbach & tielens 1997 ) .","this means that clouds determine their own molecular abundances for any particular radiation field , depending on their density , column density , and metallicity .","dense clouds with only moderate column densities can have the same h@xmath0/h ratio as lower density clouds with larger column densities . as a result ,","_ regions with larger pressures tend to be more molecular _",", i.e. , higher pressures lead to higher densities and greater self - shielding at all cloud masses .","one implication of this result is that most galaxies have a radial gradient in the molecular fraction outside the nuclear or barred region because the pressure is lower at larger radii ( elmegreen 1993 ; honma , sofue , & arimoto 1995 ) .","the total ( turbulent+magnetic+thermal ) interstellar medium pressure varies approximately as @xmath3 for gas column density @xmath4 and total gas+star column density in the gas layer , @xmath5 .","typically , @xmath6 , so @xmath7 .","this means that as @xmath4 decreases exponentially with radius in a typical spiral galaxy , the total pressure decreases with radius too , and it has half the scale length .","this corresponds to a rather rapid decrease of interstellar pressure with galactocentric radius .","radial pressure gradients lead to the appearance of `` molecular rings '' in galaxies that have inner disk cutoffs from a bar or bulge .","molecular rings are not true rings , like galactic resonance rings , but only molecular emission concentrations that result from smooth exponential disks with inner cutoffs .","the rapid decrease of molecular fraction with increasing radius beyond the `` ring '' results primarily from large - scale pressure changes .","high latitude clouds , shells , spiral - arm dust lanes , and other pressurized fronts should also have large molecular fractions compared to other clouds with the same column density .","a good example of the influence of pressure on molecule formation is shown by the nearby l1457 cloud , which has h@xmath0 primarily in the southern part , where it was recently compressed ( moriarty - schieven , andersson & wannier 1997 ) .","the _ thermal _ state in clouds is generally related to the _ molecular _ state , at least in the solar neighborhood , because once a cloud begins to shield itself in the h@xmath0 lines , it also becomes optically thick from dust .","then it removes its principle quiescent heat source , which is the photoejection of electrons off grains ( de jong 1977 ; draine 1978 ; bakes & tielens 1994 ) .","molecular clouds need not always be cold , though .","different photons are involved with photodissocation , which is limited to spectral lines , and photoejection , which is a continuum process . besides",", density and column density can vary separately .","consequently , there are warm molecular clouds in the diffuse phase , i.e. , high density , low column - density clouds ( spitzer & cochran 1973 ) .","these clouds tend to dominate the diffuse cloud population in the inner ( high pressure ) regions of bright galaxies ( polk et al .","1988 ; honma , sofue , & arimoto 1995 ) .","there are also diffuse or dense molecular clouds in the high pressure regions of _ dim _ galaxies that are so cold they do not emit much co radiation ( allen et al .","such temperature variations for molecular gas inversely affect the conversion factor from integrated co linewidth to molecular hydrogen .","high temperature molecular clouds have proportionally less molecular matter per unit co emission than low temperature molecular clouds .","figure [ fig : nn ] shows a schematic diagram of the cold and cool interstellar cloud phases in the parameter space that is defined by density and column density .","the rising line that separates diffuse from self - gravitating gas comes from the relation @xmath8 for velocity dispersion @xmath9 .","this is the threshold for strong self - gravity in a cloud .","the falling line that separates molecular from atomic gas comes from the equation @xmath10 for metallicity @xmath11 and radiation field @xmath12 , normalized to solar neighborhood values .","this relation is based on the balance between the h@xmath0 formation rate ( on dust , hence the @xmath11 dependence ) along a column of gas , @xmath13 , and the photodissociation rate per unit area , which is proportional to the absorbed photon flux , @xmath14 .","the column density dependence in @xmath15 accounts for extra absorption in the line wings as @xmath16 increases ( federman , glassgold , & kwan 1979 ) .","equation [ eq : mole ] was considered in more detail by sternberg ( 1989 ) , who included a temperature dependence for the molecule formation rate and dust extinction .","sternberg also approximated the column density dependence of @xmath15 as @xmath17 for pure linewing absorption . according to sternberg ,","dust dominates molecules for the absorption of light in the shielding layer when @xmath18 , which translates to @xmath19\\left[z / z_0\\right]\\right)^{1/2}}}>>1 .","\\label{eq : sternberg}\\ ] ] ( this assumes sternberg s molecule formation rate , @xmath20 , and dust cross section , @xmath21 , both scale with metallicity , @xmath11 . ) if we scale the federman , glassgold & kwan ( 1979 ) result with @xmath22 instead of @xmath23 and add a @xmath24 dependence to the molecule formation rate ( from the thermal speed at which h atoms impact grains ) , then the equation of detailed balance implied by equation [ eq : mole ] , @xmath25 , gives a molecular column density for self - shielding of @xmath26 , and a corresponding dust opacity @xmath27 .","the square root of this opacity is essentially the quantity @xmath28 in sternberg ( 1989 ) , to within a factor of 2 .","the column density at this opacity limit is approximately @xmath29 @xmath30 for standard interstellar extinction , which means that points to the right of @xmath31 @xmath30 at high density @xmath32 in figure [ fig : nn ] are primarily shielded by dust , and points to the left are _ self_-shielded by molecules . in both cases , the clouds are molecular , as indicated .","low density clouds are generally atomic except at very high column density , at which point they may turn molecular if the conditions are right .","however , real clouds with very low densities are not likely to turn molecular at high column density if their spatial extent is so large that they include many field stars inside them . in that case",", there is no proper boundary for self - shielding .","such clouds will still make a transition from diffuse to self - gravitating at moderate column densities , however .","this explains why the largest hi clouds in spiral galaxies can be self - gravitating , and conversely , why the largest self - gravitating clouds are often atomic ( elmegreen & elmegreen 1983 ; 1987 ; rand 1995 ) .","figure [ fig : nn ] also suggests that high density clouds are generally molecular , except at very low column density . when the density is high because of a high pressure , molecular clouds can be diffuse .","the internal density can also be high in a region with a low ambient pressure provided the cloud is self - gravitating ; this makes the cloud molecular again . in the solar neighborhood ,","most clouds make a transition from atomic and diffuse at low column density to molecular and self - gravitating at high column density , with relatively little total cloud mass in the form of molecular diffuse gas or atomic self - gravitating gas .","however , in the spiral arms of our galaxy , atomic self - gravitating gas is prevalent in the form of giant hi cloud complexes ( @xmath33 m@xmath34 ) , which have relatively small molecular cores ( @xmath35 m@xmath34 ) that are also self - gravitating .","such clouds are often regularly spaced along the spiral arms . in other galaxies such as m51",", these @xmath33 m@xmath34 spiral arm clouds are mostly molecular ( rand 1993 ) .","this is a sensible result for m51 because it has a relatively high total gas column density , and therefore a high pressure ( @xmath36 ) .","figure [ fig : nm ] makes these same points in a different way , showing the densities of diffuse and self - gravitating gas as functions of cloud mass .","the larson ( 1981 ) relation between density and mass is used for the self - gravitating clouds .","it comes from the two equations @xmath37 and @xmath38 . at low mass , both diffuse and self - gravitating states are possible , as in the usual two - fold solution to the virial equation with external pressure : @xmath39 in this equation , for masses less than @xmath40 , there are stable states with low density and negligible self - gravity , bounded by external pressure , and there are stable states with high density and strong self - gravity , bounded by gravity , all at the same mass .","similarly , in the interstellar medium , there are low mass diffuse clouds as well as low mass self - gravitating clouds , such as bok globules . at high mass ,","equation [ eq : virial ] has only one stable solution and that is with self - gravity dominant .","similarly in the interstellar medium , most massive clouds are strongly self - gravitating .","this mass limit changes when a magnetic field is present , but only slightly if the field has the equipartition energy density ( mouschovias & spitzer 1976 ) . also shown in figure [ fig : nm ] are short lines that indicate transitions from atomic to molecular phase as the mass increases ( @xmath41 ) , from a mixture of non - self - gravitating and self - gravitating clouds to pure self - gravitating clouds ( @xmath42 ) , and from molecular back to atomic gas ( @xmath43 . the origin of this latter transition , which occurs at around @xmath33 m@xmath34 for normal pressure , is that the density of a massive cloud is so low as a result of the high velocity dispersion and the requirement of pressure equilibrium , that the cloud can no longer shield itself from photodissociative radiation .","the fact that the cloud is strongly self - gravitating does not matter .","examples of such clouds are again the giant hi complexes in spiral arms . at higher pressures ,","this transition from molecular to atomic self - gravitating clouds occurs at higher masses .","two thermal phases of atomic gas , cool and warm , can co - exist in the solar neighborhood at the _ same _ pressure and radiation field because of inflections in the thermal cooling rate as a function of temperature ( field , goldsmith & habing 1969 ) . at temperatures of around 100 k , ionized","carbon and neutral oxygen cool the gas by collisions with neutral h , electrons , and , for oi , ionized h ( wolfire et al . 1995 ) .","these collisions are very strong coolants at temperatures near the energy levels of cii and oi , which are 94 k and 228 k , easily balancing the photoelectric heating rate that scales primarily with density .","thus the gas is thermally stable around 100 k. at lower temperatures , the cii and oi cooling transitions are barely excited , but the cooling rate does not drop much because the ci fine structure lines , which have lower excitation temperatures , become important coolants . thus the gas remains stable below 100 k too . at higher temperatures and lower densities with the same pressure , the collision rates and cooling rates decrease , leading to an unstable region until @xmath44k , at which point rapid cooling from ly@xmath45 emission and electron recombination onto grains","makes the gas stable again ( wolfire et al .","1995 ) .","figure [ fig : wolf ] shows the thermal pressure , heating and cooling rates , ionization fraction , temperature , and ionization parameter ( @xmath46 for radiation field @xmath47 scaled to the value in the solar neighborhood , temperature @xmath48 , and electron density @xmath49 ) for the `` standard '' model in wolfire et al .","( 1995 ) .","the local coexistence of two stable thermal states should not apply everywhere in a disk galaxy . in the inner parts , where the pressure is very high and the ambient radiation field is only moderately high",", there may not be a warm atomic phase at all , and a high fraction of the atomic gas can be cool .","conversely , at large galactocentric radii , the pressure drops precipitously but the radiation field only a small amount , so there comes a point , at about 4 exponential scale lengths , where most of the hi becomes warm ( elmegreen & parravano 1994 ; braun 1997 ) .","local variations in the atomic state can arise because of variations in the radiation field and pressure .","these variations often follow a spiral density wave .","for example , most of the gas between the spiral arms is at low pressure , so it should be highly atomic , mostly diffuse , and warm .","a population of low - mass , self - gravitating molecular clouds typically remains as well , from the previous arm .","when this gas shocks to form a dust lane in the arm , the density and opacity to starlight go up in the atomic gas , the temperature drops , and the gas should turn molecular , even ultra - cold molecular .","but if massive star formation occurs inside or near this shocked gas , the enhanced radiation can warm it up again and dissociate it , forming a concentration of cool or warm hi near the resulting ob association , as observed in m83 ( allen , atherton & tilanus 1985 ; tilanus & allen 1993 ) , m51 ( tilanus & allen 1989 ) , m100 ( rand 1995 ) , and m81 ( allen et al . 1997 ) .","cold dense molecular material can coexist with this warm atomic gas if the molecules are in strongly self - gravitating clouds ; the gravity preserves their high density and self - shielding even in the presence of strong radiation fields .","the pressure , radiation field , and metallicity vary both systematically and randomly from place to place and time to time in any one galaxy , and from galaxy to galaxy along the hubble sequence .","what applies to the solar neighborhood will not generally apply elsewhere , and what typifies the milky way can be relatively rare in galaxies with different hubble types .","nevertheless , most of the variations that have been observed in other galaxies can be explained as a consequence of the simple rules given above .","the hotter phases of interstellar gas require local excess energy sources such as hot stars and supernovae .","these sources are relatively rare in a typical galactic disk ( not in a nuclear starburst disk , though ) , but each commands such a wide domain of influence that the locally heated regions can sometimes overlap with each other , making the hot gas pervasive ( cox & smith 1974 ; salpeter 1976 ; mckee & ostriker 1977 ) .","the domain of influence increases at lower density , so a single massive star at a large distance off the galactic plane can ionize a large volume in the halo .","for example , an o5 star in a gas with a halo - type density of 0.03 @xmath50 can ionize out to 3 kpc distance .","the origin of structure in interstellar gas is far less tangible than the origin of thermal and chemical states , because some of the structure is caused by supersonic turbulence , and no one understands yet how this works .","other structures , such as shells ( tenorio - tagle & bodenheimer 1988 ) and spiral shocks ( roberts 1969 ) , are somewhat easier to understand because they are regular and well defined .","turbulent structures , on the other hand , are irregular , boundary - free , and extremely intricate . for example , a single molecular cloud , such as the orion cloud , probably contains a total number of dense tiny clumps and cloud pieces ( each with masses of @xmath51 m@xmath34 in the @xmath52 m@xmath34 orion cloud ) that exceeds the total number of all other orion - type clouds in all of the galaxies out to and including the virgo cluster ( considering @xmath53 orion - type clouds per spiral galaxy the size of the milky way ) .","obviously there are far too many pieces of structure in a typical molecular cloud to catalog or map at the present time , and far too many to simulate on a computer .","yet these tiny pieces are very important : they probably contain most of the mass in the cloud , as demonstrated by the generally high excitation densities for many molecular transitions ( e.g. , falgarone , phillips , & walker 1991 ; lada , evans & falgarone 1997 ) , and therefore control most of the chemistry , and ultimately , star formation",". how should we proceed to understand interstellar matter in the face of such complexity ( scalo 1990 ) ?","one of the most fundamental properties of turbulent clouds seems to be the arrangement of gas into hierarchical structures that are fractal or multi - fractal , with increasing density and local volume filling factor on smaller scales .","scale - free structures like this make a certain amount of sense for turbulent gas because the velocities that continuously form them have a scale - free nature as well , reminiscent of the kolmogorov velocity law in incompressible laboratory turbulence .","scale - free velocities should make scale - free structures , as long as thermal pressure and gravity are not important structuring agents as well . when gravity is important , the gas becomes centrally condensed and builds up a pressure gradient .","most star - forming clouds are centrally condensed already .","we would like to know whether non - linear gas motions ( i.e. `` turbulence '' ) with a magnetic field can produce structures and velocities similar to what is observed in space .","figure [ fig : sim ] shows one time step in a computer simulation of a supersonically turbulent , magnetic gas . the density is plotted as a grayscale , with two cycles of gray representing the span of density in the central `` cloudy '' region of a two - dimensional mhd simulation .","the initial conditions are a uniform density ( value 1 ) , and pressure ( value 1 , giving a sound speed of 5/3 ) , with a uniform magnetic field oriented vertically in the figure .","the initial alfven speed for this field is 10 in these units , which is supersonic .","there is no self - gravity .","the full grid measures 800 cells in the vertical direction , and 640 cells horizontally ( only the central 480 cells in the vertical direction are shown here ) .","after this initial setup , the magnetic field lines at the top and bottom of the grid are accelerated back and forth , horizontally , with random accelerations for random durations at random times , taking big swaths of field lines all at once .","the distribution of swath size is the same as we measured for the distribution of interstellar cloud sizes , namely a power law with @xmath54 ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) .","what this result simulates is the non - linear excitation of field lines by moving neighboring clouds .","the gas in the simulation has two stable thermal states , one at a temperature corresponding to a sound speed of 1 , and another at a temperature corresponding to a sound speed of @xmath55 ( i.e. , 10 times hotter ) .","the magnetic field - line excitations at the top and bottom of the grid heat up the gas there to the high temperature state , and also drive the motion of gas toward the grid center .","this forms a dense `` cloud '' at the vertical center of the grid , and this cloud takes the cool thermal state .","the simulation was run for @xmath52 timesteps , with each time step equal to one - tenth of the time it takes an initial alfven wave to travel over a distance of one cell .","the figure shows the dense central part of the grid , measuring 640 cells horizontally and 480 cells vertically .","substructure inside the dense part is apparently hierarchical , with some `` clumps '' containing 4 levels of substructure .","the larger pieces move with a mildly supersonic speed , and last for about one sound crossing time ; during this time , they are `` bound '' by ram pressure from their constant motion .","that is , the @xmath56 term in the equation of motion acts like a binding pressure .","the thermal pressure is actually lower between the clumps than inside the clumps , so they are not bound by thermal pressure ; i.e. , there is no warm interclump medium .","simulations like these suggest that hierarchical structure is a natural consequence of non - linear magnetic wave interactions .","this gives an indication that perhaps turbulence is causing some of the structures seen in interstellar clouds .","we have a long way to go before the picture is complete .","optical images of galaxies like ours show such dominance by spiral arms that we should always question whether any local interstellar structures might have been caused by density waves . obviously , the string of giant molecular clouds along the sagittarius - carina arm , including the m17 and m16 clouds in the first quadrant , the eta carina cloud in the third quadrant , and many others ( e.g. , cohen et al . 1985 ) , should look like pieces in a giant spiral arm _ dust lane _ if viewed from outside the galaxy . there are probably streaming motions along this dustlane too .","spiral arm streaming motions ( roberts 1969 ) are well documented for other galaxies ( e.g. , kuno & nakai 1997 ) and for some regions in our galaxy , particularly along the tangent points of the inner spiral arms ( burton 1992 ) .","these streaming motions affect our estimates for the kinematic distances to molecular clouds .","for example ,","the longitude and velocity of the m17 cloud , @xmath57 and @xmath58 km s@xmath59 , give it a kinematic distance of 2.5 kpc in the standard galactic rotation model .","but hanson , howarth & conti ( 1997 ) found a spectroscopic distance in the range of 1.1 to 1.7 kpc . at the preferred distance of 1.3 kpc",", its radial velocity should be only 10 km s@xmath59 .","this implies that the m17 molecular cloud has a streaming motion in the radial direction of @xmath60 km s@xmath59 , moving away from the sun .","this is consistent with the expected sense of spiral wave streaming , i.e. , directed radially inward along the arm inside corotation , or it corresponds to a purely azimuthal streaming of @xmath61 km s@xmath59 .","thus , the true streaming speed is somewhere between 10 and 30 km s@xmath59 . in any case",", the observed radial speed gives it a kinematic distance that is wrong by nearly a factor of 2 !","such an error affects the mass estimate for m17 and other clouds as well as our perception of galactic spiral structure .","if turbulence makes some clouds and cloud clumps , then it also makes some of the low density regions between these clouds and clumps .","these are the spaces cleared out by the turbulent motions when the gas is moved into denser regions . for a fractal cloud population ,","the intercloud medium has certain regular properties that also come from fractal geometry .","one of these properties is the size distribution of holes . in a hierarchical model with clumps inside other clumps ,","each level in the hierarchy has a constant proportion of the number of empty regions of a particular size to the number of clumps of that size .","this means that the hole size distribution is the same as the clump size distribution , which is @xmath62 for size @xmath63 and fractal dimension @xmath64 ( mandelbrot 1982 ) .","the dimension for this type of fractal is defined by the relation @xmath65 for number of subclumps in a clump , @xmath16 , and for size ratio of clump to subclump @xmath66 .","it may also be defined from the scaling of mass with size @xmath67 . if @xmath68 from the cloud size distribution and mass - size relation ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) , then the hole size distribution should be @xmath69 too .","the fractal brownian motion model proposed by stutzki et al .","( 1998 ) also has a size distribution for clouds equal to the size distribution for holes .","this model begins with a white noise spectrum , and then convolves this with a power law that has decreasing power at high frequencies .","the result is a noise model with the large scale features emphasized .","these features , like the original noise , are equally likely to have positive or negative excursions around the mean density .","if we identify the positive excursions with clouds and cloud clumps and the negative excursions with holes between the clouds , then the size distribution for holes will be the same as the size distribution for clumps .","these predicted size distributions are steeper than the shell size distribution found by oey & clarke ( 1997 ) , who got a power law with a slope of @xmath70 ( instead of @xmath71 ) on a @xmath72 plot .","oey & clarke s objects are real shells , however , not just random regions with locally low densities .","there are no studies yet of the distribution of hole sizes , but consideration of this might prove fruitful .","the volume filling factor of low density gas is another important consideration for comparisons with observations . for the hierarchical fractal model discussed above",", the low density volume filling factor equals @xmath73 for density contrast @xmath74 between the highest and lowest levels ( elmegreen 1997 ) . to evaluate this , we used @xmath75 considering densities from 0.1 cm @xmath76 to 100 @xmath50 in the diffuse medium , or from 100 @xmath50 to @xmath52 @xmath50 in molecular clouds .","the large value of this filling factor indicates that _ a turbulent interstellar medium should be mostly empty , with most of the mass in the form of clouds that occupy only a small fraction of the volume_. this result challenges the usual interpretation of the open frothy structure of the interstellar medium as an indication of stellar winds and supernovae ( brand & zealey 1975 ; hunter & gallagher 1990 ) .","more likely , the frothy structure is from a combination of these direct stellar processes plus pervasive turbulent motions . for the turbulent motions",", the energy can be put into the gas in non - explosive forms ( e.g. , shear , magnetic wave interactions , etc . ) , although some of it may ultimately come from explosions around stars too . a recent fractal interpretation of the frothy structure in hi maps of the smc","was made by stanimirovic et al .","( 1998 ) .","equation [ eq : ficm ] gives the total filling factor of low density gas from all levels in the hierarchy .","there is another filling factor for a hierarchical cloud distribution and that is the filling factor of regions with a certain average gas density , @xmath77 , @xmath78\\right ) d\\log s \\propto { { 1}\\over{<\\rho>}}d\\log < \\rho>. \\label{eq : fave}\\ ] ] this result","is easily derived using the intermediate step shown , along with the size distribution function @xmath79 and the density - size relation @xmath80 , which comes from the mass - size relation that defines the fractal dimension @xmath64 in this model , @xmath67 .","equation [ eq : fave ] indicates that the summed volume of regions with a certain average density occupies a smaller and smaller fraction of the total volume as that density increases .","equation [ eq : ficm ] above suggests further that as this average density increases ( and @xmath81 ) , the gas inside each dense piece becomes more and more uniform .","thus we recover the standard model of _ interstellar clouds composed of numerous , tiny , near - uniform clumps , arranged in a fractal pattern with the average gas density varying inversely with size _ ( for @xmath64 near 2 ) .","we also get an explanation for the common perception that clumps in emission line surveys generally occupy 110% of the volume ( e.g. , blitz 1993 ) . evidently , this is a selection effect caused by the limitations of molecular emission maps which are typically sensitive to only a factor of @xmath82 range in density for any one survey .","berkhuijsen ( 1998 ) has obtained a remarkable result recently in plotting the volume filling factor of ionized interstellar gas as a function of its local average density .","the result , shown in figure [ fig : berk ] , is a @xmath83 distribution , as expected for a turbulent fluid with any fractal dimension .","this does not mean that the ionized fluid itself is turbulent in this way ; in most regions , the ionization structure is probably just a reflection of the neutral structure of the gas before it was ionized .","hierarchical or fractal structure in the intestellar medium implies that clouds are highly clumped , i.e. , that any one cloud is likely to have another cloud nearby , and , conversely , any empty region is not particularly likely to have a cloud nearby .","such clumping makes the mean free path for intersecting a cloud on the line of sight different for regions near clouds than for regions between clouds .","thus the _ intercloud _ mean free path can be larger than the _ average _ mean free , which has always been obtained in the past by assuming a uniform density .","this result has important implications for the distance ionizing photons can travel once they leave a molecular cloud / ob association complex .","the mean free path is generally defined as @xmath84 for number density of clouds @xmath32 and cross sectional area @xmath85 .","when @xmath32 is not uniform , but clumped instead , this expression has a different value on lines of sight near cloud complexes than it does on lines of sight between cloud complexes .","the hierarchical cloud model discussed above ( elmegreen 1997 ) can be used to show that the number of sub - clouds on a line of sight through a fractal cloud is @xmath86 if there are 8 interstellar absorption lines kpc@xmath59 on _ average _ ( blaauw 1952 ) , then these correspond to @xmath87 fractal cloud complexes per kiloparsec .","indeed , most of the local gas is not randomly distributed with a constant space density of clouds everywhere .","it is highly clumped into cloud complexes associated with the ob associations in orion , sco - cen , and perseus , and with the taurus clouds .","these are the types of clouds that occur with the rate of 3 kpc@xmath59 .","the average mean free path on lines of sight _ between _ the fractal cloud complexes should be @xmath88 pc .","this may be defined as the pure intercloud mean free path .","it exceeds the galactic scale height , which means that once photons get into the disk intercloud medium , they are likely to reach the halo . for this reason , the ionization of the halo , giving the `` reynolds '' layer ( reynolds 1995 ) , may be much easier than previously thought ( compare this result to the uniform cloud model by miller & cox 1993 ) .","hii regions expand away from giant molecular clouds into the intercloud medium . for fractal clouds ,","the neutral density varies inversely with distance @xmath20 as @xmath89 for @xmath68 .","when the ionization front reaches this neutral density , it heats and ionizes the gas , causing the smallest pieces to expand and mix with each other .","this makes the local density more uniform on a timescale equal to the sound crossing time for the small pieces , but it does not affect the overall density gradient much because the sound crossing time is large on a large scale . thus a young hii region should have a radial density gradient reflecting the @xmath90 gradient in the initial neutral cloud . as a result",", there should be an extended component of _ diffuse ionized gas _ surrounding most hii regions .","the fraction of the ionization outside the conventional strmgren sphere can be large , perhaps 50% ( elmegreen 1997 ) .","such extended ionization around hii regions presumably corresponds to the observations of diffuse ionized gas in our galaxy ( reynolds 1995 ) and other galaxies ( walterbos & braun 1994 ; ferguson et al .","this diffuse ionized gas is clearly associated with the outlying parts of individual hii regions in many cases ( walterbos & braun 1994 ) .","the mass distribution of purely hierarchical structures should scale as @xmath91 constant , or ( fleck 1996 ) : @xmath92 actually , @xmath93 from clump surveys ( stutzki et al .","1998 ; heithausen et al .","1998 ) .","elmegreen & falgarone ( 1997 ) got @xmath94 with @xmath95 from a model of hierarchical cloud structure using the observed @xmath96 for size @xmath63 with @xmath97 , and the observed @xmath98 with @xmath99 , and then combining these relations with the standard conversion @xmath100 , which gives @xmath101 .","stutzki et al .","( 1998 ) got @xmath102 with a cloud model based on fractal brownian motion , using @xmath103 and the same @xmath64 and @xmath104 .","the physical difference between these two models is that hierarchical clouds have all their small clumps inside larger clumps , whereas fractal brownian motion clouds have small structure with equal probability everywhere , although it is weaker outside the larger clumps . in theory",", the brownian motion model makes more sense for turbulence , which should have some density structure everywhere , but in practice , the low density regions outside of the main hierarchy in an interstellar cloud may be ionized or invisible in co , in which case only the dense hierarchical core , which is common to both models , will be seen .","the @xmath105 function also applies to the probability of choosing part of a hierarchical cloud from any level .","if stars form at all levels in a hierarchy because all levels have dense gas in tiny clumps , then the resulting stars will be hierarchically clumped too .","such a distribution for stars is in fact commonly observed ( elmegreen & efremov 1997 , 1998 ) . if , in addition , bound clusters form with some high and nearly constant efficiency , so @xmath106 , then the mass distribution for star","_ clusters _ will be about the same as the mass distribution for cloud structure ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) . battinelli et al .","( 1994 ) found cluster mass functions from two samples that had power law slopes equal to @xmath107 and @xmath108 .","elmegreen & efremov ( 1997 ) similarly found @xmath109 for three different age groups in the lmc .","these cluster mass functions are very similar to the expectations from hierarchical clouds , given by equation [ eq : fleck ] .","berkhuijsen , e. m. 1998 , `` the volume filling factor of the wim , '' in _ the local bubble and beyond _ , iau colloquium no .","166 , d. breitschwerdt , m. j. freyberg , and j. truemper ( eds . ) , berlin : springer - verlag , p. 301304","elmegreen , b.g .","1995 , `` large scale star formation , '' in _ the 7th gou shoujing summer school on astrophysics : molecular clouds and star formation _ , c. yuan and hunhan you ( eds . ) , singapore : world press , p. 149205","elmegreen , b.g . , & efremov , y.n .","1998 , `` hierarchy of interstellar and stellar structures and the case of the orion star - forming region , '' in _ the orion complex revisited _ , mccaughrean , m.j .","& burkert , a. ( eds . )","san francisco : asp conference series , in press heithausen , a. , bensch , f. , stutzki , j. , falgarone , e. , & panis , j.f .","1998 , `` the iram key project : small scale structure of pre - star forming cores .","combined mass spectra and scaling laws , '' _","a&a _ * 331 *","6568 langer , w. d. , velusamy , t. , kuiper , t.b.h . , peng , r. , mccarthy , m.c . ,","travers , m.j . , kovacs , a. , gottleib , c.a .",", thaddeus , p. 1997 , `` first astronomical detection of the cumulene carbon chain molecule h2c6 in tmc-1 , '' _ apj _ * 480 * , l63l66 reynolds , r.j .","1995 , `` diffuse optical emission lines as probes of the interstellar and intergalactic ionizing radiation , '' in the physics of the interstellar medium and intergalactic medium , asp conf .","series 80 , ed .","a. ferrara , c.f .","mckee , c. heiles , and p.r .","shapiro , san francisco , astron.soc.pacific , p. 388397 scalo , j. 1990 in physical processes in fragmentation and star formation , `` perception of interstellar structure : facing complexity , '' r. capuzzo - dolcetta , c. chiosi , & a. di fazio ( eds . ) dordrecht : kluwer , p. 151178","stanimirovic , s. , staveley - smith , l. , sault , r. j. , dickey , j. , & snowden , s. 1998 , `` fractal structure in the interstellar medium of the smc ? '' _ iau symposium 190 , new views of the magellanic clouds _ ,","cu , yuo - hua , et al .","( eds . ) , asp conference series , in press wannier , p.g . , andersson , b .-","g . , federman , s. r. , lewis , b. m. , viala , y. p. , & shaya , e. 1993 , `` warm neutral halos around molecular clouds .","v - oh ( 1665 and 1667 mhz ) observations , '' _ apj _ * 407 * , 163174"],"string":"[\n \"interstellar gas in the solar neighborhood has a variety of thermal and chemical phases , including cold atomic gas inside or mixed with cold molecular clouds ( e.g. , sato & fukui 1978 ) , cool and warm atomic gas on the envelopes of molecular clouds ( chromey et al .\",\n \"1989 ; andersson & wannier 1993 ; wannier et al .\",\n \"1993 ) and in the diffuse , low density medium ( kulkarni & heiles 1987 ) , cold molecules in dark and dense clouds ( combes 1991 ) and in translucent clouds ( magnani , blitz & mundy 1985 ) , warm molecules in dense clouds near embedded luminous stars ( e.g. , cesaroni et al . 1994 ) , dense photo - ionized gas in the neighborhoods of o and b - type stars , low - density ionized gas between these stars ( walterbos & braun 1994 ; reynolds 1995 ; ferguson et al . 1996 ) , and hot , shock - heated gas near supernovae and windy stars ( ostriker & mckee 1988 ) .\",\n \"there is also considerable variety in the types of molecules that are present inside dark clouds , ranging from primarily h@xmath0 in translucent clouds ( spitzer & jenkins 1975 ; magnani et al .\",\n \"1998 ) , with a possible trace of pah or long - chain molecules ( leger & puget 1984 ; tulej et al . 1998 ) , to a mixture of complex molecules in dense clouds ( e.g. , langer et al . 1997\",\n \"; see reviews by van dishoeck and thaddeus , this conference ) .\",\n \"the thermal and chemical states of the cold and cool gas have such a great variety because the clouds shield themselves to different levels from photodissociative radiation and radiant heating .\",\n \"this makes the molecular abundance and temperature depend on density , column density , metallicity , age , and local radiation field , all of which vary from cloud to cloud and with radius in the galaxy .\",\n \"the nature of cloud _ structure _ does not change this much , because it is largely the result of turbulence , self - gravity , and local explosions , which seem to act the same way everywhere .\",\n \"here we discuss the dominant processes that affect the molecular and thermal states of the gas , and we review the some of the aspects of cloud structure that are likely to arise from turbulence .\",\n \"interstellar clouds shield themselves from photo - dissociative radiation when the molecular formation rate ( in @xmath1 ) integrated over the cloud radius exceeds the molecular dissociation flux ( in @xmath2 ) from incident starlight ( jura 1975 ; federman , glassgold , & kwan 1979 ; van dishoeck & black 1988 ; sternberg 1989 ; hollenbach & tielens 1997 ) .\",\n \"this means that clouds determine their own molecular abundances for any particular radiation field , depending on their density , column density , and metallicity .\",\n \"dense clouds with only moderate column densities can have the same h@xmath0/h ratio as lower density clouds with larger column densities . as a result ,\",\n \"_ regions with larger pressures tend to be more molecular _\",\n \", i.e. , higher pressures lead to higher densities and greater self - shielding at all cloud masses .\",\n \"one implication of this result is that most galaxies have a radial gradient in the molecular fraction outside the nuclear or barred region because the pressure is lower at larger radii ( elmegreen 1993 ; honma , sofue , & arimoto 1995 ) .\",\n \"the total ( turbulent+magnetic+thermal ) interstellar medium pressure varies approximately as @xmath3 for gas column density @xmath4 and total gas+star column density in the gas layer , @xmath5 .\",\n \"typically , @xmath6 , so @xmath7 .\",\n \"this means that as @xmath4 decreases exponentially with radius in a typical spiral galaxy , the total pressure decreases with radius too , and it has half the scale length .\",\n \"this corresponds to a rather rapid decrease of interstellar pressure with galactocentric radius .\",\n \"radial pressure gradients lead to the appearance of `` molecular rings '' in galaxies that have inner disk cutoffs from a bar or bulge .\",\n \"molecular rings are not true rings , like galactic resonance rings , but only molecular emission concentrations that result from smooth exponential disks with inner cutoffs .\",\n \"the rapid decrease of molecular fraction with increasing radius beyond the `` ring '' results primarily from large - scale pressure changes .\",\n \"high latitude clouds , shells , spiral - arm dust lanes , and other pressurized fronts should also have large molecular fractions compared to other clouds with the same column density .\",\n \"a good example of the influence of pressure on molecule formation is shown by the nearby l1457 cloud , which has h@xmath0 primarily in the southern part , where it was recently compressed ( moriarty - schieven , andersson & wannier 1997 ) .\",\n \"the _ thermal _ state in clouds is generally related to the _ molecular _ state , at least in the solar neighborhood , because once a cloud begins to shield itself in the h@xmath0 lines , it also becomes optically thick from dust .\",\n \"then it removes its principle quiescent heat source , which is the photoejection of electrons off grains ( de jong 1977 ; draine 1978 ; bakes & tielens 1994 ) .\",\n \"molecular clouds need not always be cold , though .\",\n \"different photons are involved with photodissocation , which is limited to spectral lines , and photoejection , which is a continuum process . besides\",\n \", density and column density can vary separately .\",\n \"consequently , there are warm molecular clouds in the diffuse phase , i.e. , high density , low column - density clouds ( spitzer & cochran 1973 ) .\",\n \"these clouds tend to dominate the diffuse cloud population in the inner ( high pressure ) regions of bright galaxies ( polk et al .\",\n \"1988 ; honma , sofue , & arimoto 1995 ) .\",\n \"there are also diffuse or dense molecular clouds in the high pressure regions of _ dim _ galaxies that are so cold they do not emit much co radiation ( allen et al .\",\n \"such temperature variations for molecular gas inversely affect the conversion factor from integrated co linewidth to molecular hydrogen .\",\n \"high temperature molecular clouds have proportionally less molecular matter per unit co emission than low temperature molecular clouds .\",\n \"figure [ fig : nn ] shows a schematic diagram of the cold and cool interstellar cloud phases in the parameter space that is defined by density and column density .\",\n \"the rising line that separates diffuse from self - gravitating gas comes from the relation @xmath8 for velocity dispersion @xmath9 .\",\n \"this is the threshold for strong self - gravity in a cloud .\",\n \"the falling line that separates molecular from atomic gas comes from the equation @xmath10 for metallicity @xmath11 and radiation field @xmath12 , normalized to solar neighborhood values .\",\n \"this relation is based on the balance between the h@xmath0 formation rate ( on dust , hence the @xmath11 dependence ) along a column of gas , @xmath13 , and the photodissociation rate per unit area , which is proportional to the absorbed photon flux , @xmath14 .\",\n \"the column density dependence in @xmath15 accounts for extra absorption in the line wings as @xmath16 increases ( federman , glassgold , & kwan 1979 ) .\",\n \"equation [ eq : mole ] was considered in more detail by sternberg ( 1989 ) , who included a temperature dependence for the molecule formation rate and dust extinction .\",\n \"sternberg also approximated the column density dependence of @xmath15 as @xmath17 for pure linewing absorption . according to sternberg ,\",\n \"dust dominates molecules for the absorption of light in the shielding layer when @xmath18 , which translates to @xmath19\\\\left[z / z_0\\\\right]\\\\right)^{1/2}}}>>1 .\",\n \"\\\\label{eq : sternberg}\\\\ ] ] ( this assumes sternberg s molecule formation rate , @xmath20 , and dust cross section , @xmath21 , both scale with metallicity , @xmath11 . ) if we scale the federman , glassgold & kwan ( 1979 ) result with @xmath22 instead of @xmath23 and add a @xmath24 dependence to the molecule formation rate ( from the thermal speed at which h atoms impact grains ) , then the equation of detailed balance implied by equation [ eq : mole ] , @xmath25 , gives a molecular column density for self - shielding of @xmath26 , and a corresponding dust opacity @xmath27 .\",\n \"the square root of this opacity is essentially the quantity @xmath28 in sternberg ( 1989 ) , to within a factor of 2 .\",\n \"the column density at this opacity limit is approximately @xmath29 @xmath30 for standard interstellar extinction , which means that points to the right of @xmath31 @xmath30 at high density @xmath32 in figure [ fig : nn ] are primarily shielded by dust , and points to the left are _ self_-shielded by molecules . in both cases , the clouds are molecular , as indicated .\",\n \"low density clouds are generally atomic except at very high column density , at which point they may turn molecular if the conditions are right .\",\n \"however , real clouds with very low densities are not likely to turn molecular at high column density if their spatial extent is so large that they include many field stars inside them . in that case\",\n \", there is no proper boundary for self - shielding .\",\n \"such clouds will still make a transition from diffuse to self - gravitating at moderate column densities , however .\",\n \"this explains why the largest hi clouds in spiral galaxies can be self - gravitating , and conversely , why the largest self - gravitating clouds are often atomic ( elmegreen & elmegreen 1983 ; 1987 ; rand 1995 ) .\",\n \"figure [ fig : nn ] also suggests that high density clouds are generally molecular , except at very low column density . when the density is high because of a high pressure , molecular clouds can be diffuse .\",\n \"the internal density can also be high in a region with a low ambient pressure provided the cloud is self - gravitating ; this makes the cloud molecular again . in the solar neighborhood ,\",\n \"most clouds make a transition from atomic and diffuse at low column density to molecular and self - gravitating at high column density , with relatively little total cloud mass in the form of molecular diffuse gas or atomic self - gravitating gas .\",\n \"however , in the spiral arms of our galaxy , atomic self - gravitating gas is prevalent in the form of giant hi cloud complexes ( @xmath33 m@xmath34 ) , which have relatively small molecular cores ( @xmath35 m@xmath34 ) that are also self - gravitating .\",\n \"such clouds are often regularly spaced along the spiral arms . in other galaxies such as m51\",\n \", these @xmath33 m@xmath34 spiral arm clouds are mostly molecular ( rand 1993 ) .\",\n \"this is a sensible result for m51 because it has a relatively high total gas column density , and therefore a high pressure ( @xmath36 ) .\",\n \"figure [ fig : nm ] makes these same points in a different way , showing the densities of diffuse and self - gravitating gas as functions of cloud mass .\",\n \"the larson ( 1981 ) relation between density and mass is used for the self - gravitating clouds .\",\n \"it comes from the two equations @xmath37 and @xmath38 . at low mass , both diffuse and self - gravitating states are possible , as in the usual two - fold solution to the virial equation with external pressure : @xmath39 in this equation , for masses less than @xmath40 , there are stable states with low density and negligible self - gravity , bounded by external pressure , and there are stable states with high density and strong self - gravity , bounded by gravity , all at the same mass .\",\n \"similarly , in the interstellar medium , there are low mass diffuse clouds as well as low mass self - gravitating clouds , such as bok globules . at high mass ,\",\n \"equation [ eq : virial ] has only one stable solution and that is with self - gravity dominant .\",\n \"similarly in the interstellar medium , most massive clouds are strongly self - gravitating .\",\n \"this mass limit changes when a magnetic field is present , but only slightly if the field has the equipartition energy density ( mouschovias & spitzer 1976 ) . also shown in figure [ fig : nm ] are short lines that indicate transitions from atomic to molecular phase as the mass increases ( @xmath41 ) , from a mixture of non - self - gravitating and self - gravitating clouds to pure self - gravitating clouds ( @xmath42 ) , and from molecular back to atomic gas ( @xmath43 . the origin of this latter transition , which occurs at around @xmath33 m@xmath34 for normal pressure , is that the density of a massive cloud is so low as a result of the high velocity dispersion and the requirement of pressure equilibrium , that the cloud can no longer shield itself from photodissociative radiation .\",\n \"the fact that the cloud is strongly self - gravitating does not matter .\",\n \"examples of such clouds are again the giant hi complexes in spiral arms . at higher pressures ,\",\n \"this transition from molecular to atomic self - gravitating clouds occurs at higher masses .\",\n \"two thermal phases of atomic gas , cool and warm , can co - exist in the solar neighborhood at the _ same _ pressure and radiation field because of inflections in the thermal cooling rate as a function of temperature ( field , goldsmith & habing 1969 ) . at temperatures of around 100 k , ionized\",\n \"carbon and neutral oxygen cool the gas by collisions with neutral h , electrons , and , for oi , ionized h ( wolfire et al . 1995 ) .\",\n \"these collisions are very strong coolants at temperatures near the energy levels of cii and oi , which are 94 k and 228 k , easily balancing the photoelectric heating rate that scales primarily with density .\",\n \"thus the gas is thermally stable around 100 k. at lower temperatures , the cii and oi cooling transitions are barely excited , but the cooling rate does not drop much because the ci fine structure lines , which have lower excitation temperatures , become important coolants . thus the gas remains stable below 100 k too . at higher temperatures and lower densities with the same pressure , the collision rates and cooling rates decrease , leading to an unstable region until @xmath44k , at which point rapid cooling from ly@xmath45 emission and electron recombination onto grains\",\n \"makes the gas stable again ( wolfire et al .\",\n \"1995 ) .\",\n \"figure [ fig : wolf ] shows the thermal pressure , heating and cooling rates , ionization fraction , temperature , and ionization parameter ( @xmath46 for radiation field @xmath47 scaled to the value in the solar neighborhood , temperature @xmath48 , and electron density @xmath49 ) for the `` standard '' model in wolfire et al .\",\n \"( 1995 ) .\",\n \"the local coexistence of two stable thermal states should not apply everywhere in a disk galaxy . in the inner parts , where the pressure is very high and the ambient radiation field is only moderately high\",\n \", there may not be a warm atomic phase at all , and a high fraction of the atomic gas can be cool .\",\n \"conversely , at large galactocentric radii , the pressure drops precipitously but the radiation field only a small amount , so there comes a point , at about 4 exponential scale lengths , where most of the hi becomes warm ( elmegreen & parravano 1994 ; braun 1997 ) .\",\n \"local variations in the atomic state can arise because of variations in the radiation field and pressure .\",\n \"these variations often follow a spiral density wave .\",\n \"for example , most of the gas between the spiral arms is at low pressure , so it should be highly atomic , mostly diffuse , and warm .\",\n \"a population of low - mass , self - gravitating molecular clouds typically remains as well , from the previous arm .\",\n \"when this gas shocks to form a dust lane in the arm , the density and opacity to starlight go up in the atomic gas , the temperature drops , and the gas should turn molecular , even ultra - cold molecular .\",\n \"but if massive star formation occurs inside or near this shocked gas , the enhanced radiation can warm it up again and dissociate it , forming a concentration of cool or warm hi near the resulting ob association , as observed in m83 ( allen , atherton & tilanus 1985 ; tilanus & allen 1993 ) , m51 ( tilanus & allen 1989 ) , m100 ( rand 1995 ) , and m81 ( allen et al . 1997 ) .\",\n \"cold dense molecular material can coexist with this warm atomic gas if the molecules are in strongly self - gravitating clouds ; the gravity preserves their high density and self - shielding even in the presence of strong radiation fields .\",\n \"the pressure , radiation field , and metallicity vary both systematically and randomly from place to place and time to time in any one galaxy , and from galaxy to galaxy along the hubble sequence .\",\n \"what applies to the solar neighborhood will not generally apply elsewhere , and what typifies the milky way can be relatively rare in galaxies with different hubble types .\",\n \"nevertheless , most of the variations that have been observed in other galaxies can be explained as a consequence of the simple rules given above .\",\n \"the hotter phases of interstellar gas require local excess energy sources such as hot stars and supernovae .\",\n \"these sources are relatively rare in a typical galactic disk ( not in a nuclear starburst disk , though ) , but each commands such a wide domain of influence that the locally heated regions can sometimes overlap with each other , making the hot gas pervasive ( cox & smith 1974 ; salpeter 1976 ; mckee & ostriker 1977 ) .\",\n \"the domain of influence increases at lower density , so a single massive star at a large distance off the galactic plane can ionize a large volume in the halo .\",\n \"for example , an o5 star in a gas with a halo - type density of 0.03 @xmath50 can ionize out to 3 kpc distance .\",\n \"the origin of structure in interstellar gas is far less tangible than the origin of thermal and chemical states , because some of the structure is caused by supersonic turbulence , and no one understands yet how this works .\",\n \"other structures , such as shells ( tenorio - tagle & bodenheimer 1988 ) and spiral shocks ( roberts 1969 ) , are somewhat easier to understand because they are regular and well defined .\",\n \"turbulent structures , on the other hand , are irregular , boundary - free , and extremely intricate . for example , a single molecular cloud , such as the orion cloud , probably contains a total number of dense tiny clumps and cloud pieces ( each with masses of @xmath51 m@xmath34 in the @xmath52 m@xmath34 orion cloud ) that exceeds the total number of all other orion - type clouds in all of the galaxies out to and including the virgo cluster ( considering @xmath53 orion - type clouds per spiral galaxy the size of the milky way ) .\",\n \"obviously there are far too many pieces of structure in a typical molecular cloud to catalog or map at the present time , and far too many to simulate on a computer .\",\n \"yet these tiny pieces are very important : they probably contain most of the mass in the cloud , as demonstrated by the generally high excitation densities for many molecular transitions ( e.g. , falgarone , phillips , & walker 1991 ; lada , evans & falgarone 1997 ) , and therefore control most of the chemistry , and ultimately , star formation\",\n \". how should we proceed to understand interstellar matter in the face of such complexity ( scalo 1990 ) ?\",\n \"one of the most fundamental properties of turbulent clouds seems to be the arrangement of gas into hierarchical structures that are fractal or multi - fractal , with increasing density and local volume filling factor on smaller scales .\",\n \"scale - free structures like this make a certain amount of sense for turbulent gas because the velocities that continuously form them have a scale - free nature as well , reminiscent of the kolmogorov velocity law in incompressible laboratory turbulence .\",\n \"scale - free velocities should make scale - free structures , as long as thermal pressure and gravity are not important structuring agents as well . when gravity is important , the gas becomes centrally condensed and builds up a pressure gradient .\",\n \"most star - forming clouds are centrally condensed already .\",\n \"we would like to know whether non - linear gas motions ( i.e. `` turbulence '' ) with a magnetic field can produce structures and velocities similar to what is observed in space .\",\n \"figure [ fig : sim ] shows one time step in a computer simulation of a supersonically turbulent , magnetic gas . the density is plotted as a grayscale , with two cycles of gray representing the span of density in the central `` cloudy '' region of a two - dimensional mhd simulation .\",\n \"the initial conditions are a uniform density ( value 1 ) , and pressure ( value 1 , giving a sound speed of 5/3 ) , with a uniform magnetic field oriented vertically in the figure .\",\n \"the initial alfven speed for this field is 10 in these units , which is supersonic .\",\n \"there is no self - gravity .\",\n \"the full grid measures 800 cells in the vertical direction , and 640 cells horizontally ( only the central 480 cells in the vertical direction are shown here ) .\",\n \"after this initial setup , the magnetic field lines at the top and bottom of the grid are accelerated back and forth , horizontally , with random accelerations for random durations at random times , taking big swaths of field lines all at once .\",\n \"the distribution of swath size is the same as we measured for the distribution of interstellar cloud sizes , namely a power law with @xmath54 ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) .\",\n \"what this result simulates is the non - linear excitation of field lines by moving neighboring clouds .\",\n \"the gas in the simulation has two stable thermal states , one at a temperature corresponding to a sound speed of 1 , and another at a temperature corresponding to a sound speed of @xmath55 ( i.e. , 10 times hotter ) .\",\n \"the magnetic field - line excitations at the top and bottom of the grid heat up the gas there to the high temperature state , and also drive the motion of gas toward the grid center .\",\n \"this forms a dense `` cloud '' at the vertical center of the grid , and this cloud takes the cool thermal state .\",\n \"the simulation was run for @xmath52 timesteps , with each time step equal to one - tenth of the time it takes an initial alfven wave to travel over a distance of one cell .\",\n \"the figure shows the dense central part of the grid , measuring 640 cells horizontally and 480 cells vertically .\",\n \"substructure inside the dense part is apparently hierarchical , with some `` clumps '' containing 4 levels of substructure .\",\n \"the larger pieces move with a mildly supersonic speed , and last for about one sound crossing time ; during this time , they are `` bound '' by ram pressure from their constant motion .\",\n \"that is , the @xmath56 term in the equation of motion acts like a binding pressure .\",\n \"the thermal pressure is actually lower between the clumps than inside the clumps , so they are not bound by thermal pressure ; i.e. , there is no warm interclump medium .\",\n \"simulations like these suggest that hierarchical structure is a natural consequence of non - linear magnetic wave interactions .\",\n \"this gives an indication that perhaps turbulence is causing some of the structures seen in interstellar clouds .\",\n \"we have a long way to go before the picture is complete .\",\n \"optical images of galaxies like ours show such dominance by spiral arms that we should always question whether any local interstellar structures might have been caused by density waves . obviously , the string of giant molecular clouds along the sagittarius - carina arm , including the m17 and m16 clouds in the first quadrant , the eta carina cloud in the third quadrant , and many others ( e.g. , cohen et al . 1985 ) , should look like pieces in a giant spiral arm _ dust lane _ if viewed from outside the galaxy . there are probably streaming motions along this dustlane too .\",\n \"spiral arm streaming motions ( roberts 1969 ) are well documented for other galaxies ( e.g. , kuno & nakai 1997 ) and for some regions in our galaxy , particularly along the tangent points of the inner spiral arms ( burton 1992 ) .\",\n \"these streaming motions affect our estimates for the kinematic distances to molecular clouds .\",\n \"for example ,\",\n \"the longitude and velocity of the m17 cloud , @xmath57 and @xmath58 km s@xmath59 , give it a kinematic distance of 2.5 kpc in the standard galactic rotation model .\",\n \"but hanson , howarth & conti ( 1997 ) found a spectroscopic distance in the range of 1.1 to 1.7 kpc . at the preferred distance of 1.3 kpc\",\n \", its radial velocity should be only 10 km s@xmath59 .\",\n \"this implies that the m17 molecular cloud has a streaming motion in the radial direction of @xmath60 km s@xmath59 , moving away from the sun .\",\n \"this is consistent with the expected sense of spiral wave streaming , i.e. , directed radially inward along the arm inside corotation , or it corresponds to a purely azimuthal streaming of @xmath61 km s@xmath59 .\",\n \"thus , the true streaming speed is somewhere between 10 and 30 km s@xmath59 . in any case\",\n \", the observed radial speed gives it a kinematic distance that is wrong by nearly a factor of 2 !\",\n \"such an error affects the mass estimate for m17 and other clouds as well as our perception of galactic spiral structure .\",\n \"if turbulence makes some clouds and cloud clumps , then it also makes some of the low density regions between these clouds and clumps .\",\n \"these are the spaces cleared out by the turbulent motions when the gas is moved into denser regions . for a fractal cloud population ,\",\n \"the intercloud medium has certain regular properties that also come from fractal geometry .\",\n \"one of these properties is the size distribution of holes . in a hierarchical model with clumps inside other clumps ,\",\n \"each level in the hierarchy has a constant proportion of the number of empty regions of a particular size to the number of clumps of that size .\",\n \"this means that the hole size distribution is the same as the clump size distribution , which is @xmath62 for size @xmath63 and fractal dimension @xmath64 ( mandelbrot 1982 ) .\",\n \"the dimension for this type of fractal is defined by the relation @xmath65 for number of subclumps in a clump , @xmath16 , and for size ratio of clump to subclump @xmath66 .\",\n \"it may also be defined from the scaling of mass with size @xmath67 . if @xmath68 from the cloud size distribution and mass - size relation ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) , then the hole size distribution should be @xmath69 too .\",\n \"the fractal brownian motion model proposed by stutzki et al .\",\n \"( 1998 ) also has a size distribution for clouds equal to the size distribution for holes .\",\n \"this model begins with a white noise spectrum , and then convolves this with a power law that has decreasing power at high frequencies .\",\n \"the result is a noise model with the large scale features emphasized .\",\n \"these features , like the original noise , are equally likely to have positive or negative excursions around the mean density .\",\n \"if we identify the positive excursions with clouds and cloud clumps and the negative excursions with holes between the clouds , then the size distribution for holes will be the same as the size distribution for clumps .\",\n \"these predicted size distributions are steeper than the shell size distribution found by oey & clarke ( 1997 ) , who got a power law with a slope of @xmath70 ( instead of @xmath71 ) on a @xmath72 plot .\",\n \"oey & clarke s objects are real shells , however , not just random regions with locally low densities .\",\n \"there are no studies yet of the distribution of hole sizes , but consideration of this might prove fruitful .\",\n \"the volume filling factor of low density gas is another important consideration for comparisons with observations . for the hierarchical fractal model discussed above\",\n \", the low density volume filling factor equals @xmath73 for density contrast @xmath74 between the highest and lowest levels ( elmegreen 1997 ) . to evaluate this , we used @xmath75 considering densities from 0.1 cm @xmath76 to 100 @xmath50 in the diffuse medium , or from 100 @xmath50 to @xmath52 @xmath50 in molecular clouds .\",\n \"the large value of this filling factor indicates that _ a turbulent interstellar medium should be mostly empty , with most of the mass in the form of clouds that occupy only a small fraction of the volume_. this result challenges the usual interpretation of the open frothy structure of the interstellar medium as an indication of stellar winds and supernovae ( brand & zealey 1975 ; hunter & gallagher 1990 ) .\",\n \"more likely , the frothy structure is from a combination of these direct stellar processes plus pervasive turbulent motions . for the turbulent motions\",\n \", the energy can be put into the gas in non - explosive forms ( e.g. , shear , magnetic wave interactions , etc . ) , although some of it may ultimately come from explosions around stars too . a recent fractal interpretation of the frothy structure in hi maps of the smc\",\n \"was made by stanimirovic et al .\",\n \"( 1998 ) .\",\n \"equation [ eq : ficm ] gives the total filling factor of low density gas from all levels in the hierarchy .\",\n \"there is another filling factor for a hierarchical cloud distribution and that is the filling factor of regions with a certain average gas density , @xmath77 , @xmath78\\\\right ) d\\\\log s \\\\propto { { 1}\\\\over{<\\\\rho>}}d\\\\log < \\\\rho>. \\\\label{eq : fave}\\\\ ] ] this result\",\n \"is easily derived using the intermediate step shown , along with the size distribution function @xmath79 and the density - size relation @xmath80 , which comes from the mass - size relation that defines the fractal dimension @xmath64 in this model , @xmath67 .\",\n \"equation [ eq : fave ] indicates that the summed volume of regions with a certain average density occupies a smaller and smaller fraction of the total volume as that density increases .\",\n \"equation [ eq : ficm ] above suggests further that as this average density increases ( and @xmath81 ) , the gas inside each dense piece becomes more and more uniform .\",\n \"thus we recover the standard model of _ interstellar clouds composed of numerous , tiny , near - uniform clumps , arranged in a fractal pattern with the average gas density varying inversely with size _ ( for @xmath64 near 2 ) .\",\n \"we also get an explanation for the common perception that clumps in emission line surveys generally occupy 110% of the volume ( e.g. , blitz 1993 ) . evidently , this is a selection effect caused by the limitations of molecular emission maps which are typically sensitive to only a factor of @xmath82 range in density for any one survey .\",\n \"berkhuijsen ( 1998 ) has obtained a remarkable result recently in plotting the volume filling factor of ionized interstellar gas as a function of its local average density .\",\n \"the result , shown in figure [ fig : berk ] , is a @xmath83 distribution , as expected for a turbulent fluid with any fractal dimension .\",\n \"this does not mean that the ionized fluid itself is turbulent in this way ; in most regions , the ionization structure is probably just a reflection of the neutral structure of the gas before it was ionized .\",\n \"hierarchical or fractal structure in the intestellar medium implies that clouds are highly clumped , i.e. , that any one cloud is likely to have another cloud nearby , and , conversely , any empty region is not particularly likely to have a cloud nearby .\",\n \"such clumping makes the mean free path for intersecting a cloud on the line of sight different for regions near clouds than for regions between clouds .\",\n \"thus the _ intercloud _ mean free path can be larger than the _ average _ mean free , which has always been obtained in the past by assuming a uniform density .\",\n \"this result has important implications for the distance ionizing photons can travel once they leave a molecular cloud / ob association complex .\",\n \"the mean free path is generally defined as @xmath84 for number density of clouds @xmath32 and cross sectional area @xmath85 .\",\n \"when @xmath32 is not uniform , but clumped instead , this expression has a different value on lines of sight near cloud complexes than it does on lines of sight between cloud complexes .\",\n \"the hierarchical cloud model discussed above ( elmegreen 1997 ) can be used to show that the number of sub - clouds on a line of sight through a fractal cloud is @xmath86 if there are 8 interstellar absorption lines kpc@xmath59 on _ average _ ( blaauw 1952 ) , then these correspond to @xmath87 fractal cloud complexes per kiloparsec .\",\n \"indeed , most of the local gas is not randomly distributed with a constant space density of clouds everywhere .\",\n \"it is highly clumped into cloud complexes associated with the ob associations in orion , sco - cen , and perseus , and with the taurus clouds .\",\n \"these are the types of clouds that occur with the rate of 3 kpc@xmath59 .\",\n \"the average mean free path on lines of sight _ between _ the fractal cloud complexes should be @xmath88 pc .\",\n \"this may be defined as the pure intercloud mean free path .\",\n \"it exceeds the galactic scale height , which means that once photons get into the disk intercloud medium , they are likely to reach the halo . for this reason , the ionization of the halo , giving the `` reynolds '' layer ( reynolds 1995 ) , may be much easier than previously thought ( compare this result to the uniform cloud model by miller & cox 1993 ) .\",\n \"hii regions expand away from giant molecular clouds into the intercloud medium . for fractal clouds ,\",\n \"the neutral density varies inversely with distance @xmath20 as @xmath89 for @xmath68 .\",\n \"when the ionization front reaches this neutral density , it heats and ionizes the gas , causing the smallest pieces to expand and mix with each other .\",\n \"this makes the local density more uniform on a timescale equal to the sound crossing time for the small pieces , but it does not affect the overall density gradient much because the sound crossing time is large on a large scale . thus a young hii region should have a radial density gradient reflecting the @xmath90 gradient in the initial neutral cloud . as a result\",\n \", there should be an extended component of _ diffuse ionized gas _ surrounding most hii regions .\",\n \"the fraction of the ionization outside the conventional strmgren sphere can be large , perhaps 50% ( elmegreen 1997 ) .\",\n \"such extended ionization around hii regions presumably corresponds to the observations of diffuse ionized gas in our galaxy ( reynolds 1995 ) and other galaxies ( walterbos & braun 1994 ; ferguson et al .\",\n \"this diffuse ionized gas is clearly associated with the outlying parts of individual hii regions in many cases ( walterbos & braun 1994 ) .\",\n \"the mass distribution of purely hierarchical structures should scale as @xmath91 constant , or ( fleck 1996 ) : @xmath92 actually , @xmath93 from clump surveys ( stutzki et al .\",\n \"1998 ; heithausen et al .\",\n \"1998 ) .\",\n \"elmegreen & falgarone ( 1997 ) got @xmath94 with @xmath95 from a model of hierarchical cloud structure using the observed @xmath96 for size @xmath63 with @xmath97 , and the observed @xmath98 with @xmath99 , and then combining these relations with the standard conversion @xmath100 , which gives @xmath101 .\",\n \"stutzki et al .\",\n \"( 1998 ) got @xmath102 with a cloud model based on fractal brownian motion , using @xmath103 and the same @xmath64 and @xmath104 .\",\n \"the physical difference between these two models is that hierarchical clouds have all their small clumps inside larger clumps , whereas fractal brownian motion clouds have small structure with equal probability everywhere , although it is weaker outside the larger clumps . in theory\",\n \", the brownian motion model makes more sense for turbulence , which should have some density structure everywhere , but in practice , the low density regions outside of the main hierarchy in an interstellar cloud may be ionized or invisible in co , in which case only the dense hierarchical core , which is common to both models , will be seen .\",\n \"the @xmath105 function also applies to the probability of choosing part of a hierarchical cloud from any level .\",\n \"if stars form at all levels in a hierarchy because all levels have dense gas in tiny clumps , then the resulting stars will be hierarchically clumped too .\",\n \"such a distribution for stars is in fact commonly observed ( elmegreen & efremov 1997 , 1998 ) . if , in addition , bound clusters form with some high and nearly constant efficiency , so @xmath106 , then the mass distribution for star\",\n \"_ clusters _ will be about the same as the mass distribution for cloud structure ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) . battinelli et al .\",\n \"( 1994 ) found cluster mass functions from two samples that had power law slopes equal to @xmath107 and @xmath108 .\",\n \"elmegreen & efremov ( 1997 ) similarly found @xmath109 for three different age groups in the lmc .\",\n \"these cluster mass functions are very similar to the expectations from hierarchical clouds , given by equation [ eq : fleck ] .\",\n \"berkhuijsen , e. m. 1998 , `` the volume filling factor of the wim , '' in _ the local bubble and beyond _ , iau colloquium no .\",\n \"166 , d. breitschwerdt , m. j. freyberg , and j. truemper ( eds . ) , berlin : springer - verlag , p. 301304\",\n \"elmegreen , b.g .\",\n \"1995 , `` large scale star formation , '' in _ the 7th gou shoujing summer school on astrophysics : molecular clouds and star formation _ , c. yuan and hunhan you ( eds . ) , singapore : world press , p. 149205\",\n \"elmegreen , b.g . , & efremov , y.n .\",\n \"1998 , `` hierarchy of interstellar and stellar structures and the case of the orion star - forming region , '' in _ the orion complex revisited _ , mccaughrean , m.j .\",\n \"& burkert , a. ( eds . )\",\n \"san francisco : asp conference series , in press heithausen , a. , bensch , f. , stutzki , j. , falgarone , e. , & panis , j.f .\",\n \"1998 , `` the iram key project : small scale structure of pre - star forming cores .\",\n \"combined mass spectra and scaling laws , '' _\",\n \"a&a _ * 331 *\",\n \"6568 langer , w. d. , velusamy , t. , kuiper , t.b.h . , peng , r. , mccarthy , m.c . ,\",\n \"travers , m.j . , kovacs , a. , gottleib , c.a .\",\n \", thaddeus , p. 1997 , `` first astronomical detection of the cumulene carbon chain molecule h2c6 in tmc-1 , '' _ apj _ * 480 * , l63l66 reynolds , r.j .\",\n \"1995 , `` diffuse optical emission lines as probes of the interstellar and intergalactic ionizing radiation , '' in the physics of the interstellar medium and intergalactic medium , asp conf .\",\n \"series 80 , ed .\",\n \"a. ferrara , c.f .\",\n \"mckee , c. heiles , and p.r .\",\n \"shapiro , san francisco , astron.soc.pacific , p. 388397 scalo , j. 1990 in physical processes in fragmentation and star formation , `` perception of interstellar structure : facing complexity , '' r. capuzzo - dolcetta , c. chiosi , & a. di fazio ( eds . ) dordrecht : kluwer , p. 151178\",\n \"stanimirovic , s. , staveley - smith , l. , sault , r. j. , dickey , j. , & snowden , s. 1998 , `` fractal structure in the interstellar medium of the smc ? '' _ iau symposium 190 , new views of the magellanic clouds _ ,\",\n \"cu , yuo - hua , et al .\",\n \"( eds . ) , asp conference series , in press wannier , p.g . , andersson , b .-\",\n \"g . , federman , s. r. , lewis , b. m. , viala , y. p. , & shaya , e. 1993 , `` warm neutral halos around molecular clouds .\",\n \"v - oh ( 1665 and 1667 mhz ) observations , '' _ apj _ * 407 * , 163174\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> the thermal and chemical phases of the cool component of interstellar gas are discussed . variations with galactocentric radius and from galaxy to galaxy are mostly the result of changes in the ambient interstellar pressure and radiation field . </S>","<S> interstellar structure that is hierarchical or fractal in the cloudy parts and has large and connected empty regions between these clouds is probably the result of turbulence . </S>","<S> such structure opens up the disk to the transmission of ob star light into the halo , and it provides for a diffuse ionized component that tapers away gradually from each dense hii region . </S>","<S> fractal cloud structure may also produce the cloud and clump mass functions , and perhaps even the star cluster mass function . to be published in `` the physics and chemistry of the interstellar medium , '' 3rd cologne - zermatt symposium , ed . </S>","<S> g. winnewisser , j. sttzki , and v. ossenkopf , aachen : shaker - verlag , 1999 , in press </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> the thermal and chemical phases of the cool component of interstellar gas are discussed . variations with galactocentric radius and from galaxy to galaxy are mostly the result of changes in the ambient interstellar pressure and radiation field . </S>\",\n \"<S> interstellar structure that is hierarchical or fractal in the cloudy parts and has large and connected empty regions between these clouds is probably the result of turbulence . </S>\",\n \"<S> such structure opens up the disk to the transmission of ob star light into the halo , and it provides for a diffuse ionized component that tapers away gradually from each dense hii region . </S>\",\n \"<S> fractal cloud structure may also produce the cloud and clump mass functions , and perhaps even the star cluster mass function . to be published in `` the physics and chemistry of the interstellar medium , '' 3rd cologne - zermatt symposium , ed . </S>\",\n \"<S> g. winnewisser , j. sttzki , and v. ossenkopf , aachen : shaker - verlag , 1999 , in press </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["phases of interstellar gas","structure of interstellar gas","further implications of hierarchical/fractal structure"],"string":"[\n \"phases of interstellar gas\",\n \"structure of interstellar gas\",\n \"further implications of hierarchical/fractal structure\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["interstellar gas in the solar neighborhood has a variety of thermal and chemical phases , including cold atomic gas inside or mixed with cold molecular clouds ( e.g. , sato & fukui 1978 ) , cool and warm atomic gas on the envelopes of molecular clouds ( chromey et al .","1989 ; andersson & wannier 1993 ; wannier et al .","1993 ) and in the diffuse , low density medium ( kulkarni & heiles 1987 ) , cold molecules in dark and dense clouds ( combes 1991 ) and in translucent clouds ( magnani , blitz & mundy 1985 ) , warm molecules in dense clouds near embedded luminous stars ( e.g. , cesaroni et al . 1994 ) , dense photo - ionized gas in the neighborhoods of o and b - type stars , low - density ionized gas between these stars ( walterbos & braun 1994 ; reynolds 1995 ; ferguson et al . 1996 ) , and hot , shock - heated gas near supernovae and windy stars ( ostriker & mckee 1988 ) .","there is also considerable variety in the types of molecules that are present inside dark clouds , ranging from primarily h@xmath0 in translucent clouds ( spitzer & jenkins 1975 ; magnani et al .","1998 ) , with a possible trace of pah or long - chain molecules ( leger & puget 1984 ; tulej et al . 1998 ) , to a mixture of complex molecules in dense clouds ( e.g. , langer et al . 1997","; see reviews by van dishoeck and thaddeus , this conference ) .","the thermal and chemical states of the cold and cool gas have such a great variety because the clouds shield themselves to different levels from photodissociative radiation and radiant heating .","this makes the molecular abundance and temperature depend on density , column density , metallicity , age , and local radiation field , all of which vary from cloud to cloud and with radius in the galaxy .","the nature of cloud _ structure _ does not change this much , because it is largely the result of turbulence , self - gravity , and local explosions , which seem to act the same way everywhere .","here we discuss the dominant processes that affect the molecular and thermal states of the gas , and we review the some of the aspects of cloud structure that are likely to arise from turbulence .","interstellar clouds shield themselves from photo - dissociative radiation when the molecular formation rate ( in @xmath1 ) integrated over the cloud radius exceeds the molecular dissociation flux ( in @xmath2 ) from incident starlight ( jura 1975 ; federman , glassgold , & kwan 1979 ; van dishoeck & black 1988 ; sternberg 1989 ; hollenbach & tielens 1997 ) .","this means that clouds determine their own molecular abundances for any particular radiation field , depending on their density , column density , and metallicity .","dense clouds with only moderate column densities can have the same h@xmath0/h ratio as lower density clouds with larger column densities . as a result ,","_ regions with larger pressures tend to be more molecular _",", i.e. , higher pressures lead to higher densities and greater self - shielding at all cloud masses .","one implication of this result is that most galaxies have a radial gradient in the molecular fraction outside the nuclear or barred region because the pressure is lower at larger radii ( elmegreen 1993 ; honma , sofue , & arimoto 1995 ) .","the total ( turbulent+magnetic+thermal ) interstellar medium pressure varies approximately as @xmath3 for gas column density @xmath4 and total gas+star column density in the gas layer , @xmath5 .","typically , @xmath6 , so @xmath7 .","this means that as @xmath4 decreases exponentially with radius in a typical spiral galaxy , the total pressure decreases with radius too , and it has half the scale length .","this corresponds to a rather rapid decrease of interstellar pressure with galactocentric radius .","radial pressure gradients lead to the appearance of `` molecular rings '' in galaxies that have inner disk cutoffs from a bar or bulge .","molecular rings are not true rings , like galactic resonance rings , but only molecular emission concentrations that result from smooth exponential disks with inner cutoffs .","the rapid decrease of molecular fraction with increasing radius beyond the `` ring '' results primarily from large - scale pressure changes .","high latitude clouds , shells , spiral - arm dust lanes , and other pressurized fronts should also have large molecular fractions compared to other clouds with the same column density .","a good example of the influence of pressure on molecule formation is shown by the nearby l1457 cloud , which has h@xmath0 primarily in the southern part , where it was recently compressed ( moriarty - schieven , andersson & wannier 1997 ) .","the _ thermal _ state in clouds is generally related to the _ molecular _ state , at least in the solar neighborhood , because once a cloud begins to shield itself in the h@xmath0 lines , it also becomes optically thick from dust .","then it removes its principle quiescent heat source , which is the photoejection of electrons off grains ( de jong 1977 ; draine 1978 ; bakes & tielens 1994 ) .","molecular clouds need not always be cold , though .","different photons are involved with photodissocation , which is limited to spectral lines , and photoejection , which is a continuum process . besides",", density and column density can vary separately .","consequently , there are warm molecular clouds in the diffuse phase , i.e. , high density , low column - density clouds ( spitzer & cochran 1973 ) .","these clouds tend to dominate the diffuse cloud population in the inner ( high pressure ) regions of bright galaxies ( polk et al .","1988 ; honma , sofue , & arimoto 1995 ) .","there are also diffuse or dense molecular clouds in the high pressure regions of _ dim _ galaxies that are so cold they do not emit much co radiation ( allen et al .","such temperature variations for molecular gas inversely affect the conversion factor from integrated co linewidth to molecular hydrogen .","high temperature molecular clouds have proportionally less molecular matter per unit co emission than low temperature molecular clouds .","figure [ fig : nn ] shows a schematic diagram of the cold and cool interstellar cloud phases in the parameter space that is defined by density and column density .","the rising line that separates diffuse from self - gravitating gas comes from the relation @xmath8 for velocity dispersion @xmath9 .","this is the threshold for strong self - gravity in a cloud .","the falling line that separates molecular from atomic gas comes from the equation @xmath10 for metallicity @xmath11 and radiation field @xmath12 , normalized to solar neighborhood values .","this relation is based on the balance between the h@xmath0 formation rate ( on dust , hence the @xmath11 dependence ) along a column of gas , @xmath13 , and the photodissociation rate per unit area , which is proportional to the absorbed photon flux , @xmath14 .","the column density dependence in @xmath15 accounts for extra absorption in the line wings as @xmath16 increases ( federman , glassgold , & kwan 1979 ) .","equation [ eq : mole ] was considered in more detail by sternberg ( 1989 ) , who included a temperature dependence for the molecule formation rate and dust extinction .","sternberg also approximated the column density dependence of @xmath15 as @xmath17 for pure linewing absorption . according to sternberg ,","dust dominates molecules for the absorption of light in the shielding layer when @xmath18 , which translates to @xmath19\\left[z / z_0\\right]\\right)^{1/2}}}>>1 .","\\label{eq : sternberg}\\ ] ] ( this assumes sternberg s molecule formation rate , @xmath20 , and dust cross section , @xmath21 , both scale with metallicity , @xmath11 . ) if we scale the federman , glassgold & kwan ( 1979 ) result with @xmath22 instead of @xmath23 and add a @xmath24 dependence to the molecule formation rate ( from the thermal speed at which h atoms impact grains ) , then the equation of detailed balance implied by equation [ eq : mole ] , @xmath25 , gives a molecular column density for self - shielding of @xmath26 , and a corresponding dust opacity @xmath27 .","the square root of this opacity is essentially the quantity @xmath28 in sternberg ( 1989 ) , to within a factor of 2 .","the column density at this opacity limit is approximately @xmath29 @xmath30 for standard interstellar extinction , which means that points to the right of @xmath31 @xmath30 at high density @xmath32 in figure [ fig : nn ] are primarily shielded by dust , and points to the left are _ self_-shielded by molecules . in both cases , the clouds are molecular , as indicated .","low density clouds are generally atomic except at very high column density , at which point they may turn molecular if the conditions are right .","however , real clouds with very low densities are not likely to turn molecular at high column density if their spatial extent is so large that they include many field stars inside them . in that case",", there is no proper boundary for self - shielding .","such clouds will still make a transition from diffuse to self - gravitating at moderate column densities , however .","this explains why the largest hi clouds in spiral galaxies can be self - gravitating , and conversely , why the largest self - gravitating clouds are often atomic ( elmegreen & elmegreen 1983 ; 1987 ; rand 1995 ) .","figure [ fig : nn ] also suggests that high density clouds are generally molecular , except at very low column density . when the density is high because of a high pressure , molecular clouds can be diffuse .","the internal density can also be high in a region with a low ambient pressure provided the cloud is self - gravitating ; this makes the cloud molecular again . in the solar neighborhood ,","most clouds make a transition from atomic and diffuse at low column density to molecular and self - gravitating at high column density , with relatively little total cloud mass in the form of molecular diffuse gas or atomic self - gravitating gas .","however , in the spiral arms of our galaxy , atomic self - gravitating gas is prevalent in the form of giant hi cloud complexes ( @xmath33 m@xmath34 ) , which have relatively small molecular cores ( @xmath35 m@xmath34 ) that are also self - gravitating .","such clouds are often regularly spaced along the spiral arms . in other galaxies such as m51",", these @xmath33 m@xmath34 spiral arm clouds are mostly molecular ( rand 1993 ) .","this is a sensible result for m51 because it has a relatively high total gas column density , and therefore a high pressure ( @xmath36 ) .","figure [ fig : nm ] makes these same points in a different way , showing the densities of diffuse and self - gravitating gas as functions of cloud mass .","the larson ( 1981 ) relation between density and mass is used for the self - gravitating clouds .","it comes from the two equations @xmath37 and @xmath38 . at low mass , both diffuse and self - gravitating states are possible , as in the usual two - fold solution to the virial equation with external pressure : @xmath39 in this equation , for masses less than @xmath40 , there are stable states with low density and negligible self - gravity , bounded by external pressure , and there are stable states with high density and strong self - gravity , bounded by gravity , all at the same mass .","similarly , in the interstellar medium , there are low mass diffuse clouds as well as low mass self - gravitating clouds , such as bok globules . at high mass ,","equation [ eq : virial ] has only one stable solution and that is with self - gravity dominant .","similarly in the interstellar medium , most massive clouds are strongly self - gravitating .","this mass limit changes when a magnetic field is present , but only slightly if the field has the equipartition energy density ( mouschovias & spitzer 1976 ) . also shown in figure [ fig : nm ] are short lines that indicate transitions from atomic to molecular phase as the mass increases ( @xmath41 ) , from a mixture of non - self - gravitating and self - gravitating clouds to pure self - gravitating clouds ( @xmath42 ) , and from molecular back to atomic gas ( @xmath43 . the origin of this latter transition , which occurs at around @xmath33 m@xmath34 for normal pressure , is that the density of a massive cloud is so low as a result of the high velocity dispersion and the requirement of pressure equilibrium , that the cloud can no longer shield itself from photodissociative radiation .","the fact that the cloud is strongly self - gravitating does not matter .","examples of such clouds are again the giant hi complexes in spiral arms . at higher pressures ,","this transition from molecular to atomic self - gravitating clouds occurs at higher masses .","two thermal phases of atomic gas , cool and warm , can co - exist in the solar neighborhood at the _ same _ pressure and radiation field because of inflections in the thermal cooling rate as a function of temperature ( field , goldsmith & habing 1969 ) . at temperatures of around 100 k , ionized","carbon and neutral oxygen cool the gas by collisions with neutral h , electrons , and , for oi , ionized h ( wolfire et al . 1995 ) .","these collisions are very strong coolants at temperatures near the energy levels of cii and oi , which are 94 k and 228 k , easily balancing the photoelectric heating rate that scales primarily with density .","thus the gas is thermally stable around 100 k. at lower temperatures , the cii and oi cooling transitions are barely excited , but the cooling rate does not drop much because the ci fine structure lines , which have lower excitation temperatures , become important coolants . thus the gas remains stable below 100 k too . at higher temperatures and lower densities with the same pressure , the collision rates and cooling rates decrease , leading to an unstable region until @xmath44k , at which point rapid cooling from ly@xmath45 emission and electron recombination onto grains","makes the gas stable again ( wolfire et al .","1995 ) .","figure [ fig : wolf ] shows the thermal pressure , heating and cooling rates , ionization fraction , temperature , and ionization parameter ( @xmath46 for radiation field @xmath47 scaled to the value in the solar neighborhood , temperature @xmath48 , and electron density @xmath49 ) for the `` standard '' model in wolfire et al .","( 1995 ) .","the local coexistence of two stable thermal states should not apply everywhere in a disk galaxy . in the inner parts , where the pressure is very high and the ambient radiation field is only moderately high",", there may not be a warm atomic phase at all , and a high fraction of the atomic gas can be cool .","conversely , at large galactocentric radii , the pressure drops precipitously but the radiation field only a small amount , so there comes a point , at about 4 exponential scale lengths , where most of the hi becomes warm ( elmegreen & parravano 1994 ; braun 1997 ) .","local variations in the atomic state can arise because of variations in the radiation field and pressure .","these variations often follow a spiral density wave .","for example , most of the gas between the spiral arms is at low pressure , so it should be highly atomic , mostly diffuse , and warm .","a population of low - mass , self - gravitating molecular clouds typically remains as well , from the previous arm .","when this gas shocks to form a dust lane in the arm , the density and opacity to starlight go up in the atomic gas , the temperature drops , and the gas should turn molecular , even ultra - cold molecular .","but if massive star formation occurs inside or near this shocked gas , the enhanced radiation can warm it up again and dissociate it , forming a concentration of cool or warm hi near the resulting ob association , as observed in m83 ( allen , atherton & tilanus 1985 ; tilanus & allen 1993 ) , m51 ( tilanus & allen 1989 ) , m100 ( rand 1995 ) , and m81 ( allen et al . 1997 ) .","cold dense molecular material can coexist with this warm atomic gas if the molecules are in strongly self - gravitating clouds ; the gravity preserves their high density and self - shielding even in the presence of strong radiation fields .","the pressure , radiation field , and metallicity vary both systematically and randomly from place to place and time to time in any one galaxy , and from galaxy to galaxy along the hubble sequence .","what applies to the solar neighborhood will not generally apply elsewhere , and what typifies the milky way can be relatively rare in galaxies with different hubble types .","nevertheless , most of the variations that have been observed in other galaxies can be explained as a consequence of the simple rules given above .","the hotter phases of interstellar gas require local excess energy sources such as hot stars and supernovae .","these sources are relatively rare in a typical galactic disk ( not in a nuclear starburst disk , though ) , but each commands such a wide domain of influence that the locally heated regions can sometimes overlap with each other , making the hot gas pervasive ( cox & smith 1974 ; salpeter 1976 ; mckee & ostriker 1977 ) .","the domain of influence increases at lower density , so a single massive star at a large distance off the galactic plane can ionize a large volume in the halo .","for example , an o5 star in a gas with a halo - type density of 0.03 @xmath50 can ionize out to 3 kpc distance ."],["the origin of structure in interstellar gas is far less tangible than the origin of thermal and chemical states , because some of the structure is caused by supersonic turbulence , and no one understands yet how this works .","other structures , such as shells ( tenorio - tagle & bodenheimer 1988 ) and spiral shocks ( roberts 1969 ) , are somewhat easier to understand because they are regular and well defined .","turbulent structures , on the other hand , are irregular , boundary - free , and extremely intricate . for example , a single molecular cloud , such as the orion cloud , probably contains a total number of dense tiny clumps and cloud pieces ( each with masses of @xmath51 m@xmath34 in the @xmath52 m@xmath34 orion cloud ) that exceeds the total number of all other orion - type clouds in all of the galaxies out to and including the virgo cluster ( considering @xmath53 orion - type clouds per spiral galaxy the size of the milky way ) .","obviously there are far too many pieces of structure in a typical molecular cloud to catalog or map at the present time , and far too many to simulate on a computer .","yet these tiny pieces are very important : they probably contain most of the mass in the cloud , as demonstrated by the generally high excitation densities for many molecular transitions ( e.g. , falgarone , phillips , & walker 1991 ; lada , evans & falgarone 1997 ) , and therefore control most of the chemistry , and ultimately , star formation",". how should we proceed to understand interstellar matter in the face of such complexity ( scalo 1990 ) ?","one of the most fundamental properties of turbulent clouds seems to be the arrangement of gas into hierarchical structures that are fractal or multi - fractal , with increasing density and local volume filling factor on smaller scales .","scale - free structures like this make a certain amount of sense for turbulent gas because the velocities that continuously form them have a scale - free nature as well , reminiscent of the kolmogorov velocity law in incompressible laboratory turbulence .","scale - free velocities should make scale - free structures , as long as thermal pressure and gravity are not important structuring agents as well . when gravity is important , the gas becomes centrally condensed and builds up a pressure gradient .","most star - forming clouds are centrally condensed already .","we would like to know whether non - linear gas motions ( i.e. `` turbulence '' ) with a magnetic field can produce structures and velocities similar to what is observed in space .","figure [ fig : sim ] shows one time step in a computer simulation of a supersonically turbulent , magnetic gas . the density is plotted as a grayscale , with two cycles of gray representing the span of density in the central `` cloudy '' region of a two - dimensional mhd simulation .","the initial conditions are a uniform density ( value 1 ) , and pressure ( value 1 , giving a sound speed of 5/3 ) , with a uniform magnetic field oriented vertically in the figure .","the initial alfven speed for this field is 10 in these units , which is supersonic .","there is no self - gravity .","the full grid measures 800 cells in the vertical direction , and 640 cells horizontally ( only the central 480 cells in the vertical direction are shown here ) .","after this initial setup , the magnetic field lines at the top and bottom of the grid are accelerated back and forth , horizontally , with random accelerations for random durations at random times , taking big swaths of field lines all at once .","the distribution of swath size is the same as we measured for the distribution of interstellar cloud sizes , namely a power law with @xmath54 ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) .","what this result simulates is the non - linear excitation of field lines by moving neighboring clouds .","the gas in the simulation has two stable thermal states , one at a temperature corresponding to a sound speed of 1 , and another at a temperature corresponding to a sound speed of @xmath55 ( i.e. , 10 times hotter ) .","the magnetic field - line excitations at the top and bottom of the grid heat up the gas there to the high temperature state , and also drive the motion of gas toward the grid center .","this forms a dense `` cloud '' at the vertical center of the grid , and this cloud takes the cool thermal state .","the simulation was run for @xmath52 timesteps , with each time step equal to one - tenth of the time it takes an initial alfven wave to travel over a distance of one cell .","the figure shows the dense central part of the grid , measuring 640 cells horizontally and 480 cells vertically .","substructure inside the dense part is apparently hierarchical , with some `` clumps '' containing 4 levels of substructure .","the larger pieces move with a mildly supersonic speed , and last for about one sound crossing time ; during this time , they are `` bound '' by ram pressure from their constant motion .","that is , the @xmath56 term in the equation of motion acts like a binding pressure .","the thermal pressure is actually lower between the clumps than inside the clumps , so they are not bound by thermal pressure ; i.e. , there is no warm interclump medium .","simulations like these suggest that hierarchical structure is a natural consequence of non - linear magnetic wave interactions .","this gives an indication that perhaps turbulence is causing some of the structures seen in interstellar clouds .","we have a long way to go before the picture is complete .","optical images of galaxies like ours show such dominance by spiral arms that we should always question whether any local interstellar structures might have been caused by density waves . obviously , the string of giant molecular clouds along the sagittarius - carina arm , including the m17 and m16 clouds in the first quadrant , the eta carina cloud in the third quadrant , and many others ( e.g. , cohen et al . 1985 ) , should look like pieces in a giant spiral arm _ dust lane _ if viewed from outside the galaxy . there are probably streaming motions along this dustlane too .","spiral arm streaming motions ( roberts 1969 ) are well documented for other galaxies ( e.g. , kuno & nakai 1997 ) and for some regions in our galaxy , particularly along the tangent points of the inner spiral arms ( burton 1992 ) .","these streaming motions affect our estimates for the kinematic distances to molecular clouds .","for example ,","the longitude and velocity of the m17 cloud , @xmath57 and @xmath58 km s@xmath59 , give it a kinematic distance of 2.5 kpc in the standard galactic rotation model .","but hanson , howarth & conti ( 1997 ) found a spectroscopic distance in the range of 1.1 to 1.7 kpc . at the preferred distance of 1.3 kpc",", its radial velocity should be only 10 km s@xmath59 .","this implies that the m17 molecular cloud has a streaming motion in the radial direction of @xmath60 km s@xmath59 , moving away from the sun .","this is consistent with the expected sense of spiral wave streaming , i.e. , directed radially inward along the arm inside corotation , or it corresponds to a purely azimuthal streaming of @xmath61 km s@xmath59 .","thus , the true streaming speed is somewhere between 10 and 30 km s@xmath59 . in any case",", the observed radial speed gives it a kinematic distance that is wrong by nearly a factor of 2 !","such an error affects the mass estimate for m17 and other clouds as well as our perception of galactic spiral structure ."],["if turbulence makes some clouds and cloud clumps , then it also makes some of the low density regions between these clouds and clumps .","these are the spaces cleared out by the turbulent motions when the gas is moved into denser regions . for a fractal cloud population ,","the intercloud medium has certain regular properties that also come from fractal geometry .","one of these properties is the size distribution of holes . in a hierarchical model with clumps inside other clumps ,","each level in the hierarchy has a constant proportion of the number of empty regions of a particular size to the number of clumps of that size .","this means that the hole size distribution is the same as the clump size distribution , which is @xmath62 for size @xmath63 and fractal dimension @xmath64 ( mandelbrot 1982 ) .","the dimension for this type of fractal is defined by the relation @xmath65 for number of subclumps in a clump , @xmath16 , and for size ratio of clump to subclump @xmath66 .","it may also be defined from the scaling of mass with size @xmath67 . if @xmath68 from the cloud size distribution and mass - size relation ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) , then the hole size distribution should be @xmath69 too .","the fractal brownian motion model proposed by stutzki et al .","( 1998 ) also has a size distribution for clouds equal to the size distribution for holes .","this model begins with a white noise spectrum , and then convolves this with a power law that has decreasing power at high frequencies .","the result is a noise model with the large scale features emphasized .","these features , like the original noise , are equally likely to have positive or negative excursions around the mean density .","if we identify the positive excursions with clouds and cloud clumps and the negative excursions with holes between the clouds , then the size distribution for holes will be the same as the size distribution for clumps .","these predicted size distributions are steeper than the shell size distribution found by oey & clarke ( 1997 ) , who got a power law with a slope of @xmath70 ( instead of @xmath71 ) on a @xmath72 plot .","oey & clarke s objects are real shells , however , not just random regions with locally low densities .","there are no studies yet of the distribution of hole sizes , but consideration of this might prove fruitful .","the volume filling factor of low density gas is another important consideration for comparisons with observations . for the hierarchical fractal model discussed above",", the low density volume filling factor equals @xmath73 for density contrast @xmath74 between the highest and lowest levels ( elmegreen 1997 ) . to evaluate this , we used @xmath75 considering densities from 0.1 cm @xmath76 to 100 @xmath50 in the diffuse medium , or from 100 @xmath50 to @xmath52 @xmath50 in molecular clouds .","the large value of this filling factor indicates that _ a turbulent interstellar medium should be mostly empty , with most of the mass in the form of clouds that occupy only a small fraction of the volume_. this result challenges the usual interpretation of the open frothy structure of the interstellar medium as an indication of stellar winds and supernovae ( brand & zealey 1975 ; hunter & gallagher 1990 ) .","more likely , the frothy structure is from a combination of these direct stellar processes plus pervasive turbulent motions . for the turbulent motions",", the energy can be put into the gas in non - explosive forms ( e.g. , shear , magnetic wave interactions , etc . ) , although some of it may ultimately come from explosions around stars too . a recent fractal interpretation of the frothy structure in hi maps of the smc","was made by stanimirovic et al .","( 1998 ) .","equation [ eq : ficm ] gives the total filling factor of low density gas from all levels in the hierarchy .","there is another filling factor for a hierarchical cloud distribution and that is the filling factor of regions with a certain average gas density , @xmath77 , @xmath78\\right ) d\\log s \\propto { { 1}\\over{<\\rho>}}d\\log < \\rho>. \\label{eq : fave}\\ ] ] this result","is easily derived using the intermediate step shown , along with the size distribution function @xmath79 and the density - size relation @xmath80 , which comes from the mass - size relation that defines the fractal dimension @xmath64 in this model , @xmath67 .","equation [ eq : fave ] indicates that the summed volume of regions with a certain average density occupies a smaller and smaller fraction of the total volume as that density increases .","equation [ eq : ficm ] above suggests further that as this average density increases ( and @xmath81 ) , the gas inside each dense piece becomes more and more uniform .","thus we recover the standard model of _ interstellar clouds composed of numerous , tiny , near - uniform clumps , arranged in a fractal pattern with the average gas density varying inversely with size _ ( for @xmath64 near 2 ) .","we also get an explanation for the common perception that clumps in emission line surveys generally occupy 110% of the volume ( e.g. , blitz 1993 ) . evidently , this is a selection effect caused by the limitations of molecular emission maps which are typically sensitive to only a factor of @xmath82 range in density for any one survey .","berkhuijsen ( 1998 ) has obtained a remarkable result recently in plotting the volume filling factor of ionized interstellar gas as a function of its local average density .","the result , shown in figure [ fig : berk ] , is a @xmath83 distribution , as expected for a turbulent fluid with any fractal dimension .","this does not mean that the ionized fluid itself is turbulent in this way ; in most regions , the ionization structure is probably just a reflection of the neutral structure of the gas before it was ionized .","hierarchical or fractal structure in the intestellar medium implies that clouds are highly clumped , i.e. , that any one cloud is likely to have another cloud nearby , and , conversely , any empty region is not particularly likely to have a cloud nearby .","such clumping makes the mean free path for intersecting a cloud on the line of sight different for regions near clouds than for regions between clouds .","thus the _ intercloud _ mean free path can be larger than the _ average _ mean free , which has always been obtained in the past by assuming a uniform density .","this result has important implications for the distance ionizing photons can travel once they leave a molecular cloud / ob association complex .","the mean free path is generally defined as @xmath84 for number density of clouds @xmath32 and cross sectional area @xmath85 .","when @xmath32 is not uniform , but clumped instead , this expression has a different value on lines of sight near cloud complexes than it does on lines of sight between cloud complexes .","the hierarchical cloud model discussed above ( elmegreen 1997 ) can be used to show that the number of sub - clouds on a line of sight through a fractal cloud is @xmath86 if there are 8 interstellar absorption lines kpc@xmath59 on _ average _ ( blaauw 1952 ) , then these correspond to @xmath87 fractal cloud complexes per kiloparsec .","indeed , most of the local gas is not randomly distributed with a constant space density of clouds everywhere .","it is highly clumped into cloud complexes associated with the ob associations in orion , sco - cen , and perseus , and with the taurus clouds .","these are the types of clouds that occur with the rate of 3 kpc@xmath59 .","the average mean free path on lines of sight _ between _ the fractal cloud complexes should be @xmath88 pc .","this may be defined as the pure intercloud mean free path .","it exceeds the galactic scale height , which means that once photons get into the disk intercloud medium , they are likely to reach the halo . for this reason , the ionization of the halo , giving the `` reynolds '' layer ( reynolds 1995 ) , may be much easier than previously thought ( compare this result to the uniform cloud model by miller & cox 1993 ) .","hii regions expand away from giant molecular clouds into the intercloud medium . for fractal clouds ,","the neutral density varies inversely with distance @xmath20 as @xmath89 for @xmath68 .","when the ionization front reaches this neutral density , it heats and ionizes the gas , causing the smallest pieces to expand and mix with each other .","this makes the local density more uniform on a timescale equal to the sound crossing time for the small pieces , but it does not affect the overall density gradient much because the sound crossing time is large on a large scale . thus a young hii region should have a radial density gradient reflecting the @xmath90 gradient in the initial neutral cloud . as a result",", there should be an extended component of _ diffuse ionized gas _ surrounding most hii regions .","the fraction of the ionization outside the conventional strmgren sphere can be large , perhaps 50% ( elmegreen 1997 ) .","such extended ionization around hii regions presumably corresponds to the observations of diffuse ionized gas in our galaxy ( reynolds 1995 ) and other galaxies ( walterbos & braun 1994 ; ferguson et al .","this diffuse ionized gas is clearly associated with the outlying parts of individual hii regions in many cases ( walterbos & braun 1994 ) .","the mass distribution of purely hierarchical structures should scale as @xmath91 constant , or ( fleck 1996 ) : @xmath92 actually , @xmath93 from clump surveys ( stutzki et al .","1998 ; heithausen et al .","1998 ) .","elmegreen & falgarone ( 1997 ) got @xmath94 with @xmath95 from a model of hierarchical cloud structure using the observed @xmath96 for size @xmath63 with @xmath97 , and the observed @xmath98 with @xmath99 , and then combining these relations with the standard conversion @xmath100 , which gives @xmath101 .","stutzki et al .","( 1998 ) got @xmath102 with a cloud model based on fractal brownian motion , using @xmath103 and the same @xmath64 and @xmath104 .","the physical difference between these two models is that hierarchical clouds have all their small clumps inside larger clumps , whereas fractal brownian motion clouds have small structure with equal probability everywhere , although it is weaker outside the larger clumps . in theory",", the brownian motion model makes more sense for turbulence , which should have some density structure everywhere , but in practice , the low density regions outside of the main hierarchy in an interstellar cloud may be ionized or invisible in co , in which case only the dense hierarchical core , which is common to both models , will be seen .","the @xmath105 function also applies to the probability of choosing part of a hierarchical cloud from any level .","if stars form at all levels in a hierarchy because all levels have dense gas in tiny clumps , then the resulting stars will be hierarchically clumped too .","such a distribution for stars is in fact commonly observed ( elmegreen & efremov 1997 , 1998 ) . if , in addition , bound clusters form with some high and nearly constant efficiency , so @xmath106 , then the mass distribution for star","_ clusters _ will be about the same as the mass distribution for cloud structure ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) . battinelli et al .","( 1994 ) found cluster mass functions from two samples that had power law slopes equal to @xmath107 and @xmath108 .","elmegreen & efremov ( 1997 ) similarly found @xmath109 for three different age groups in the lmc .","these cluster mass functions are very similar to the expectations from hierarchical clouds , given by equation [ eq : fleck ] .","berkhuijsen , e. m. 1998 , `` the volume filling factor of the wim , '' in _ the local bubble and beyond _ , iau colloquium no .","166 , d. breitschwerdt , m. j. freyberg , and j. truemper ( eds . ) , berlin : springer - verlag , p. 301304","elmegreen , b.g .","1995 , `` large scale star formation , '' in _ the 7th gou shoujing summer school on astrophysics : molecular clouds and star formation _ , c. yuan and hunhan you ( eds . ) , singapore : world press , p. 149205","elmegreen , b.g . , & efremov , y.n .","1998 , `` hierarchy of interstellar and stellar structures and the case of the orion star - forming region , '' in _ the orion complex revisited _ , mccaughrean , m.j .","& burkert , a. ( eds . )","san francisco : asp conference series , in press heithausen , a. , bensch , f. , stutzki , j. , falgarone , e. , & panis , j.f .","1998 , `` the iram key project : small scale structure of pre - star forming cores .","combined mass spectra and scaling laws , '' _","a&a _ * 331 *","6568 langer , w. d. , velusamy , t. , kuiper , t.b.h . , peng , r. , mccarthy , m.c . ,","travers , m.j . , kovacs , a. , gottleib , c.a .",", thaddeus , p. 1997 , `` first astronomical detection of the cumulene carbon chain molecule h2c6 in tmc-1 , '' _ apj _ * 480 * , l63l66 reynolds , r.j .","1995 , `` diffuse optical emission lines as probes of the interstellar and intergalactic ionizing radiation , '' in the physics of the interstellar medium and intergalactic medium , asp conf .","series 80 , ed .","a. ferrara , c.f .","mckee , c. heiles , and p.r .","shapiro , san francisco , astron.soc.pacific , p. 388397 scalo , j. 1990 in physical processes in fragmentation and star formation , `` perception of interstellar structure : facing complexity , '' r. capuzzo - dolcetta , c. chiosi , & a. di fazio ( eds . ) dordrecht : kluwer , p. 151178","stanimirovic , s. , staveley - smith , l. , sault , r. j. , dickey , j. , & snowden , s. 1998 , `` fractal structure in the interstellar medium of the smc ? '' _ iau symposium 190 , new views of the magellanic clouds _ ,","cu , yuo - hua , et al .","( eds . ) , asp conference series , in press wannier , p.g . , andersson , b .-","g . , federman , s. r. , lewis , b. m. , viala , y. p. , & shaya , e. 1993 , `` warm neutral halos around molecular clouds .","v - oh ( 1665 and 1667 mhz ) observations , '' _ apj _ * 407 * , 163174"]],"string":"[\n [\n \"interstellar gas in the solar neighborhood has a variety of thermal and chemical phases , including cold atomic gas inside or mixed with cold molecular clouds ( e.g. , sato & fukui 1978 ) , cool and warm atomic gas on the envelopes of molecular clouds ( chromey et al .\",\n \"1989 ; andersson & wannier 1993 ; wannier et al .\",\n \"1993 ) and in the diffuse , low density medium ( kulkarni & heiles 1987 ) , cold molecules in dark and dense clouds ( combes 1991 ) and in translucent clouds ( magnani , blitz & mundy 1985 ) , warm molecules in dense clouds near embedded luminous stars ( e.g. , cesaroni et al . 1994 ) , dense photo - ionized gas in the neighborhoods of o and b - type stars , low - density ionized gas between these stars ( walterbos & braun 1994 ; reynolds 1995 ; ferguson et al . 1996 ) , and hot , shock - heated gas near supernovae and windy stars ( ostriker & mckee 1988 ) .\",\n \"there is also considerable variety in the types of molecules that are present inside dark clouds , ranging from primarily h@xmath0 in translucent clouds ( spitzer & jenkins 1975 ; magnani et al .\",\n \"1998 ) , with a possible trace of pah or long - chain molecules ( leger & puget 1984 ; tulej et al . 1998 ) , to a mixture of complex molecules in dense clouds ( e.g. , langer et al . 1997\",\n \"; see reviews by van dishoeck and thaddeus , this conference ) .\",\n \"the thermal and chemical states of the cold and cool gas have such a great variety because the clouds shield themselves to different levels from photodissociative radiation and radiant heating .\",\n \"this makes the molecular abundance and temperature depend on density , column density , metallicity , age , and local radiation field , all of which vary from cloud to cloud and with radius in the galaxy .\",\n \"the nature of cloud _ structure _ does not change this much , because it is largely the result of turbulence , self - gravity , and local explosions , which seem to act the same way everywhere .\",\n \"here we discuss the dominant processes that affect the molecular and thermal states of the gas , and we review the some of the aspects of cloud structure that are likely to arise from turbulence .\",\n \"interstellar clouds shield themselves from photo - dissociative radiation when the molecular formation rate ( in @xmath1 ) integrated over the cloud radius exceeds the molecular dissociation flux ( in @xmath2 ) from incident starlight ( jura 1975 ; federman , glassgold , & kwan 1979 ; van dishoeck & black 1988 ; sternberg 1989 ; hollenbach & tielens 1997 ) .\",\n \"this means that clouds determine their own molecular abundances for any particular radiation field , depending on their density , column density , and metallicity .\",\n \"dense clouds with only moderate column densities can have the same h@xmath0/h ratio as lower density clouds with larger column densities . as a result ,\",\n \"_ regions with larger pressures tend to be more molecular _\",\n \", i.e. , higher pressures lead to higher densities and greater self - shielding at all cloud masses .\",\n \"one implication of this result is that most galaxies have a radial gradient in the molecular fraction outside the nuclear or barred region because the pressure is lower at larger radii ( elmegreen 1993 ; honma , sofue , & arimoto 1995 ) .\",\n \"the total ( turbulent+magnetic+thermal ) interstellar medium pressure varies approximately as @xmath3 for gas column density @xmath4 and total gas+star column density in the gas layer , @xmath5 .\",\n \"typically , @xmath6 , so @xmath7 .\",\n \"this means that as @xmath4 decreases exponentially with radius in a typical spiral galaxy , the total pressure decreases with radius too , and it has half the scale length .\",\n \"this corresponds to a rather rapid decrease of interstellar pressure with galactocentric radius .\",\n \"radial pressure gradients lead to the appearance of `` molecular rings '' in galaxies that have inner disk cutoffs from a bar or bulge .\",\n \"molecular rings are not true rings , like galactic resonance rings , but only molecular emission concentrations that result from smooth exponential disks with inner cutoffs .\",\n \"the rapid decrease of molecular fraction with increasing radius beyond the `` ring '' results primarily from large - scale pressure changes .\",\n \"high latitude clouds , shells , spiral - arm dust lanes , and other pressurized fronts should also have large molecular fractions compared to other clouds with the same column density .\",\n \"a good example of the influence of pressure on molecule formation is shown by the nearby l1457 cloud , which has h@xmath0 primarily in the southern part , where it was recently compressed ( moriarty - schieven , andersson & wannier 1997 ) .\",\n \"the _ thermal _ state in clouds is generally related to the _ molecular _ state , at least in the solar neighborhood , because once a cloud begins to shield itself in the h@xmath0 lines , it also becomes optically thick from dust .\",\n \"then it removes its principle quiescent heat source , which is the photoejection of electrons off grains ( de jong 1977 ; draine 1978 ; bakes & tielens 1994 ) .\",\n \"molecular clouds need not always be cold , though .\",\n \"different photons are involved with photodissocation , which is limited to spectral lines , and photoejection , which is a continuum process . besides\",\n \", density and column density can vary separately .\",\n \"consequently , there are warm molecular clouds in the diffuse phase , i.e. , high density , low column - density clouds ( spitzer & cochran 1973 ) .\",\n \"these clouds tend to dominate the diffuse cloud population in the inner ( high pressure ) regions of bright galaxies ( polk et al .\",\n \"1988 ; honma , sofue , & arimoto 1995 ) .\",\n \"there are also diffuse or dense molecular clouds in the high pressure regions of _ dim _ galaxies that are so cold they do not emit much co radiation ( allen et al .\",\n \"such temperature variations for molecular gas inversely affect the conversion factor from integrated co linewidth to molecular hydrogen .\",\n \"high temperature molecular clouds have proportionally less molecular matter per unit co emission than low temperature molecular clouds .\",\n \"figure [ fig : nn ] shows a schematic diagram of the cold and cool interstellar cloud phases in the parameter space that is defined by density and column density .\",\n \"the rising line that separates diffuse from self - gravitating gas comes from the relation @xmath8 for velocity dispersion @xmath9 .\",\n \"this is the threshold for strong self - gravity in a cloud .\",\n \"the falling line that separates molecular from atomic gas comes from the equation @xmath10 for metallicity @xmath11 and radiation field @xmath12 , normalized to solar neighborhood values .\",\n \"this relation is based on the balance between the h@xmath0 formation rate ( on dust , hence the @xmath11 dependence ) along a column of gas , @xmath13 , and the photodissociation rate per unit area , which is proportional to the absorbed photon flux , @xmath14 .\",\n \"the column density dependence in @xmath15 accounts for extra absorption in the line wings as @xmath16 increases ( federman , glassgold , & kwan 1979 ) .\",\n \"equation [ eq : mole ] was considered in more detail by sternberg ( 1989 ) , who included a temperature dependence for the molecule formation rate and dust extinction .\",\n \"sternberg also approximated the column density dependence of @xmath15 as @xmath17 for pure linewing absorption . according to sternberg ,\",\n \"dust dominates molecules for the absorption of light in the shielding layer when @xmath18 , which translates to @xmath19\\\\left[z / z_0\\\\right]\\\\right)^{1/2}}}>>1 .\",\n \"\\\\label{eq : sternberg}\\\\ ] ] ( this assumes sternberg s molecule formation rate , @xmath20 , and dust cross section , @xmath21 , both scale with metallicity , @xmath11 . ) if we scale the federman , glassgold & kwan ( 1979 ) result with @xmath22 instead of @xmath23 and add a @xmath24 dependence to the molecule formation rate ( from the thermal speed at which h atoms impact grains ) , then the equation of detailed balance implied by equation [ eq : mole ] , @xmath25 , gives a molecular column density for self - shielding of @xmath26 , and a corresponding dust opacity @xmath27 .\",\n \"the square root of this opacity is essentially the quantity @xmath28 in sternberg ( 1989 ) , to within a factor of 2 .\",\n \"the column density at this opacity limit is approximately @xmath29 @xmath30 for standard interstellar extinction , which means that points to the right of @xmath31 @xmath30 at high density @xmath32 in figure [ fig : nn ] are primarily shielded by dust , and points to the left are _ self_-shielded by molecules . in both cases , the clouds are molecular , as indicated .\",\n \"low density clouds are generally atomic except at very high column density , at which point they may turn molecular if the conditions are right .\",\n \"however , real clouds with very low densities are not likely to turn molecular at high column density if their spatial extent is so large that they include many field stars inside them . in that case\",\n \", there is no proper boundary for self - shielding .\",\n \"such clouds will still make a transition from diffuse to self - gravitating at moderate column densities , however .\",\n \"this explains why the largest hi clouds in spiral galaxies can be self - gravitating , and conversely , why the largest self - gravitating clouds are often atomic ( elmegreen & elmegreen 1983 ; 1987 ; rand 1995 ) .\",\n \"figure [ fig : nn ] also suggests that high density clouds are generally molecular , except at very low column density . when the density is high because of a high pressure , molecular clouds can be diffuse .\",\n \"the internal density can also be high in a region with a low ambient pressure provided the cloud is self - gravitating ; this makes the cloud molecular again . in the solar neighborhood ,\",\n \"most clouds make a transition from atomic and diffuse at low column density to molecular and self - gravitating at high column density , with relatively little total cloud mass in the form of molecular diffuse gas or atomic self - gravitating gas .\",\n \"however , in the spiral arms of our galaxy , atomic self - gravitating gas is prevalent in the form of giant hi cloud complexes ( @xmath33 m@xmath34 ) , which have relatively small molecular cores ( @xmath35 m@xmath34 ) that are also self - gravitating .\",\n \"such clouds are often regularly spaced along the spiral arms . in other galaxies such as m51\",\n \", these @xmath33 m@xmath34 spiral arm clouds are mostly molecular ( rand 1993 ) .\",\n \"this is a sensible result for m51 because it has a relatively high total gas column density , and therefore a high pressure ( @xmath36 ) .\",\n \"figure [ fig : nm ] makes these same points in a different way , showing the densities of diffuse and self - gravitating gas as functions of cloud mass .\",\n \"the larson ( 1981 ) relation between density and mass is used for the self - gravitating clouds .\",\n \"it comes from the two equations @xmath37 and @xmath38 . at low mass , both diffuse and self - gravitating states are possible , as in the usual two - fold solution to the virial equation with external pressure : @xmath39 in this equation , for masses less than @xmath40 , there are stable states with low density and negligible self - gravity , bounded by external pressure , and there are stable states with high density and strong self - gravity , bounded by gravity , all at the same mass .\",\n \"similarly , in the interstellar medium , there are low mass diffuse clouds as well as low mass self - gravitating clouds , such as bok globules . at high mass ,\",\n \"equation [ eq : virial ] has only one stable solution and that is with self - gravity dominant .\",\n \"similarly in the interstellar medium , most massive clouds are strongly self - gravitating .\",\n \"this mass limit changes when a magnetic field is present , but only slightly if the field has the equipartition energy density ( mouschovias & spitzer 1976 ) . also shown in figure [ fig : nm ] are short lines that indicate transitions from atomic to molecular phase as the mass increases ( @xmath41 ) , from a mixture of non - self - gravitating and self - gravitating clouds to pure self - gravitating clouds ( @xmath42 ) , and from molecular back to atomic gas ( @xmath43 . the origin of this latter transition , which occurs at around @xmath33 m@xmath34 for normal pressure , is that the density of a massive cloud is so low as a result of the high velocity dispersion and the requirement of pressure equilibrium , that the cloud can no longer shield itself from photodissociative radiation .\",\n \"the fact that the cloud is strongly self - gravitating does not matter .\",\n \"examples of such clouds are again the giant hi complexes in spiral arms . at higher pressures ,\",\n \"this transition from molecular to atomic self - gravitating clouds occurs at higher masses .\",\n \"two thermal phases of atomic gas , cool and warm , can co - exist in the solar neighborhood at the _ same _ pressure and radiation field because of inflections in the thermal cooling rate as a function of temperature ( field , goldsmith & habing 1969 ) . at temperatures of around 100 k , ionized\",\n \"carbon and neutral oxygen cool the gas by collisions with neutral h , electrons , and , for oi , ionized h ( wolfire et al . 1995 ) .\",\n \"these collisions are very strong coolants at temperatures near the energy levels of cii and oi , which are 94 k and 228 k , easily balancing the photoelectric heating rate that scales primarily with density .\",\n \"thus the gas is thermally stable around 100 k. at lower temperatures , the cii and oi cooling transitions are barely excited , but the cooling rate does not drop much because the ci fine structure lines , which have lower excitation temperatures , become important coolants . thus the gas remains stable below 100 k too . at higher temperatures and lower densities with the same pressure , the collision rates and cooling rates decrease , leading to an unstable region until @xmath44k , at which point rapid cooling from ly@xmath45 emission and electron recombination onto grains\",\n \"makes the gas stable again ( wolfire et al .\",\n \"1995 ) .\",\n \"figure [ fig : wolf ] shows the thermal pressure , heating and cooling rates , ionization fraction , temperature , and ionization parameter ( @xmath46 for radiation field @xmath47 scaled to the value in the solar neighborhood , temperature @xmath48 , and electron density @xmath49 ) for the `` standard '' model in wolfire et al .\",\n \"( 1995 ) .\",\n \"the local coexistence of two stable thermal states should not apply everywhere in a disk galaxy . in the inner parts , where the pressure is very high and the ambient radiation field is only moderately high\",\n \", there may not be a warm atomic phase at all , and a high fraction of the atomic gas can be cool .\",\n \"conversely , at large galactocentric radii , the pressure drops precipitously but the radiation field only a small amount , so there comes a point , at about 4 exponential scale lengths , where most of the hi becomes warm ( elmegreen & parravano 1994 ; braun 1997 ) .\",\n \"local variations in the atomic state can arise because of variations in the radiation field and pressure .\",\n \"these variations often follow a spiral density wave .\",\n \"for example , most of the gas between the spiral arms is at low pressure , so it should be highly atomic , mostly diffuse , and warm .\",\n \"a population of low - mass , self - gravitating molecular clouds typically remains as well , from the previous arm .\",\n \"when this gas shocks to form a dust lane in the arm , the density and opacity to starlight go up in the atomic gas , the temperature drops , and the gas should turn molecular , even ultra - cold molecular .\",\n \"but if massive star formation occurs inside or near this shocked gas , the enhanced radiation can warm it up again and dissociate it , forming a concentration of cool or warm hi near the resulting ob association , as observed in m83 ( allen , atherton & tilanus 1985 ; tilanus & allen 1993 ) , m51 ( tilanus & allen 1989 ) , m100 ( rand 1995 ) , and m81 ( allen et al . 1997 ) .\",\n \"cold dense molecular material can coexist with this warm atomic gas if the molecules are in strongly self - gravitating clouds ; the gravity preserves their high density and self - shielding even in the presence of strong radiation fields .\",\n \"the pressure , radiation field , and metallicity vary both systematically and randomly from place to place and time to time in any one galaxy , and from galaxy to galaxy along the hubble sequence .\",\n \"what applies to the solar neighborhood will not generally apply elsewhere , and what typifies the milky way can be relatively rare in galaxies with different hubble types .\",\n \"nevertheless , most of the variations that have been observed in other galaxies can be explained as a consequence of the simple rules given above .\",\n \"the hotter phases of interstellar gas require local excess energy sources such as hot stars and supernovae .\",\n \"these sources are relatively rare in a typical galactic disk ( not in a nuclear starburst disk , though ) , but each commands such a wide domain of influence that the locally heated regions can sometimes overlap with each other , making the hot gas pervasive ( cox & smith 1974 ; salpeter 1976 ; mckee & ostriker 1977 ) .\",\n \"the domain of influence increases at lower density , so a single massive star at a large distance off the galactic plane can ionize a large volume in the halo .\",\n \"for example , an o5 star in a gas with a halo - type density of 0.03 @xmath50 can ionize out to 3 kpc distance .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the origin of structure in interstellar gas is far less tangible than the origin of thermal and chemical states , because some of the structure is caused by supersonic turbulence , and no one understands yet how this works .\",\n \"other structures , such as shells ( tenorio - tagle & bodenheimer 1988 ) and spiral shocks ( roberts 1969 ) , are somewhat easier to understand because they are regular and well defined .\",\n \"turbulent structures , on the other hand , are irregular , boundary - free , and extremely intricate . for example , a single molecular cloud , such as the orion cloud , probably contains a total number of dense tiny clumps and cloud pieces ( each with masses of @xmath51 m@xmath34 in the @xmath52 m@xmath34 orion cloud ) that exceeds the total number of all other orion - type clouds in all of the galaxies out to and including the virgo cluster ( considering @xmath53 orion - type clouds per spiral galaxy the size of the milky way ) .\",\n \"obviously there are far too many pieces of structure in a typical molecular cloud to catalog or map at the present time , and far too many to simulate on a computer .\",\n \"yet these tiny pieces are very important : they probably contain most of the mass in the cloud , as demonstrated by the generally high excitation densities for many molecular transitions ( e.g. , falgarone , phillips , & walker 1991 ; lada , evans & falgarone 1997 ) , and therefore control most of the chemistry , and ultimately , star formation\",\n \". how should we proceed to understand interstellar matter in the face of such complexity ( scalo 1990 ) ?\",\n \"one of the most fundamental properties of turbulent clouds seems to be the arrangement of gas into hierarchical structures that are fractal or multi - fractal , with increasing density and local volume filling factor on smaller scales .\",\n \"scale - free structures like this make a certain amount of sense for turbulent gas because the velocities that continuously form them have a scale - free nature as well , reminiscent of the kolmogorov velocity law in incompressible laboratory turbulence .\",\n \"scale - free velocities should make scale - free structures , as long as thermal pressure and gravity are not important structuring agents as well . when gravity is important , the gas becomes centrally condensed and builds up a pressure gradient .\",\n \"most star - forming clouds are centrally condensed already .\",\n \"we would like to know whether non - linear gas motions ( i.e. `` turbulence '' ) with a magnetic field can produce structures and velocities similar to what is observed in space .\",\n \"figure [ fig : sim ] shows one time step in a computer simulation of a supersonically turbulent , magnetic gas . the density is plotted as a grayscale , with two cycles of gray representing the span of density in the central `` cloudy '' region of a two - dimensional mhd simulation .\",\n \"the initial conditions are a uniform density ( value 1 ) , and pressure ( value 1 , giving a sound speed of 5/3 ) , with a uniform magnetic field oriented vertically in the figure .\",\n \"the initial alfven speed for this field is 10 in these units , which is supersonic .\",\n \"there is no self - gravity .\",\n \"the full grid measures 800 cells in the vertical direction , and 640 cells horizontally ( only the central 480 cells in the vertical direction are shown here ) .\",\n \"after this initial setup , the magnetic field lines at the top and bottom of the grid are accelerated back and forth , horizontally , with random accelerations for random durations at random times , taking big swaths of field lines all at once .\",\n \"the distribution of swath size is the same as we measured for the distribution of interstellar cloud sizes , namely a power law with @xmath54 ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) .\",\n \"what this result simulates is the non - linear excitation of field lines by moving neighboring clouds .\",\n \"the gas in the simulation has two stable thermal states , one at a temperature corresponding to a sound speed of 1 , and another at a temperature corresponding to a sound speed of @xmath55 ( i.e. , 10 times hotter ) .\",\n \"the magnetic field - line excitations at the top and bottom of the grid heat up the gas there to the high temperature state , and also drive the motion of gas toward the grid center .\",\n \"this forms a dense `` cloud '' at the vertical center of the grid , and this cloud takes the cool thermal state .\",\n \"the simulation was run for @xmath52 timesteps , with each time step equal to one - tenth of the time it takes an initial alfven wave to travel over a distance of one cell .\",\n \"the figure shows the dense central part of the grid , measuring 640 cells horizontally and 480 cells vertically .\",\n \"substructure inside the dense part is apparently hierarchical , with some `` clumps '' containing 4 levels of substructure .\",\n \"the larger pieces move with a mildly supersonic speed , and last for about one sound crossing time ; during this time , they are `` bound '' by ram pressure from their constant motion .\",\n \"that is , the @xmath56 term in the equation of motion acts like a binding pressure .\",\n \"the thermal pressure is actually lower between the clumps than inside the clumps , so they are not bound by thermal pressure ; i.e. , there is no warm interclump medium .\",\n \"simulations like these suggest that hierarchical structure is a natural consequence of non - linear magnetic wave interactions .\",\n \"this gives an indication that perhaps turbulence is causing some of the structures seen in interstellar clouds .\",\n \"we have a long way to go before the picture is complete .\",\n \"optical images of galaxies like ours show such dominance by spiral arms that we should always question whether any local interstellar structures might have been caused by density waves . obviously , the string of giant molecular clouds along the sagittarius - carina arm , including the m17 and m16 clouds in the first quadrant , the eta carina cloud in the third quadrant , and many others ( e.g. , cohen et al . 1985 ) , should look like pieces in a giant spiral arm _ dust lane _ if viewed from outside the galaxy . there are probably streaming motions along this dustlane too .\",\n \"spiral arm streaming motions ( roberts 1969 ) are well documented for other galaxies ( e.g. , kuno & nakai 1997 ) and for some regions in our galaxy , particularly along the tangent points of the inner spiral arms ( burton 1992 ) .\",\n \"these streaming motions affect our estimates for the kinematic distances to molecular clouds .\",\n \"for example ,\",\n \"the longitude and velocity of the m17 cloud , @xmath57 and @xmath58 km s@xmath59 , give it a kinematic distance of 2.5 kpc in the standard galactic rotation model .\",\n \"but hanson , howarth & conti ( 1997 ) found a spectroscopic distance in the range of 1.1 to 1.7 kpc . at the preferred distance of 1.3 kpc\",\n \", its radial velocity should be only 10 km s@xmath59 .\",\n \"this implies that the m17 molecular cloud has a streaming motion in the radial direction of @xmath60 km s@xmath59 , moving away from the sun .\",\n \"this is consistent with the expected sense of spiral wave streaming , i.e. , directed radially inward along the arm inside corotation , or it corresponds to a purely azimuthal streaming of @xmath61 km s@xmath59 .\",\n \"thus , the true streaming speed is somewhere between 10 and 30 km s@xmath59 . in any case\",\n \", the observed radial speed gives it a kinematic distance that is wrong by nearly a factor of 2 !\",\n \"such an error affects the mass estimate for m17 and other clouds as well as our perception of galactic spiral structure .\"\n ],\n [\n \"if turbulence makes some clouds and cloud clumps , then it also makes some of the low density regions between these clouds and clumps .\",\n \"these are the spaces cleared out by the turbulent motions when the gas is moved into denser regions . for a fractal cloud population ,\",\n \"the intercloud medium has certain regular properties that also come from fractal geometry .\",\n \"one of these properties is the size distribution of holes . in a hierarchical model with clumps inside other clumps ,\",\n \"each level in the hierarchy has a constant proportion of the number of empty regions of a particular size to the number of clumps of that size .\",\n \"this means that the hole size distribution is the same as the clump size distribution , which is @xmath62 for size @xmath63 and fractal dimension @xmath64 ( mandelbrot 1982 ) .\",\n \"the dimension for this type of fractal is defined by the relation @xmath65 for number of subclumps in a clump , @xmath16 , and for size ratio of clump to subclump @xmath66 .\",\n \"it may also be defined from the scaling of mass with size @xmath67 . if @xmath68 from the cloud size distribution and mass - size relation ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) , then the hole size distribution should be @xmath69 too .\",\n \"the fractal brownian motion model proposed by stutzki et al .\",\n \"( 1998 ) also has a size distribution for clouds equal to the size distribution for holes .\",\n \"this model begins with a white noise spectrum , and then convolves this with a power law that has decreasing power at high frequencies .\",\n \"the result is a noise model with the large scale features emphasized .\",\n \"these features , like the original noise , are equally likely to have positive or negative excursions around the mean density .\",\n \"if we identify the positive excursions with clouds and cloud clumps and the negative excursions with holes between the clouds , then the size distribution for holes will be the same as the size distribution for clumps .\",\n \"these predicted size distributions are steeper than the shell size distribution found by oey & clarke ( 1997 ) , who got a power law with a slope of @xmath70 ( instead of @xmath71 ) on a @xmath72 plot .\",\n \"oey & clarke s objects are real shells , however , not just random regions with locally low densities .\",\n \"there are no studies yet of the distribution of hole sizes , but consideration of this might prove fruitful .\",\n \"the volume filling factor of low density gas is another important consideration for comparisons with observations . for the hierarchical fractal model discussed above\",\n \", the low density volume filling factor equals @xmath73 for density contrast @xmath74 between the highest and lowest levels ( elmegreen 1997 ) . to evaluate this , we used @xmath75 considering densities from 0.1 cm @xmath76 to 100 @xmath50 in the diffuse medium , or from 100 @xmath50 to @xmath52 @xmath50 in molecular clouds .\",\n \"the large value of this filling factor indicates that _ a turbulent interstellar medium should be mostly empty , with most of the mass in the form of clouds that occupy only a small fraction of the volume_. this result challenges the usual interpretation of the open frothy structure of the interstellar medium as an indication of stellar winds and supernovae ( brand & zealey 1975 ; hunter & gallagher 1990 ) .\",\n \"more likely , the frothy structure is from a combination of these direct stellar processes plus pervasive turbulent motions . for the turbulent motions\",\n \", the energy can be put into the gas in non - explosive forms ( e.g. , shear , magnetic wave interactions , etc . ) , although some of it may ultimately come from explosions around stars too . a recent fractal interpretation of the frothy structure in hi maps of the smc\",\n \"was made by stanimirovic et al .\",\n \"( 1998 ) .\",\n \"equation [ eq : ficm ] gives the total filling factor of low density gas from all levels in the hierarchy .\",\n \"there is another filling factor for a hierarchical cloud distribution and that is the filling factor of regions with a certain average gas density , @xmath77 , @xmath78\\\\right ) d\\\\log s \\\\propto { { 1}\\\\over{<\\\\rho>}}d\\\\log < \\\\rho>. \\\\label{eq : fave}\\\\ ] ] this result\",\n \"is easily derived using the intermediate step shown , along with the size distribution function @xmath79 and the density - size relation @xmath80 , which comes from the mass - size relation that defines the fractal dimension @xmath64 in this model , @xmath67 .\",\n \"equation [ eq : fave ] indicates that the summed volume of regions with a certain average density occupies a smaller and smaller fraction of the total volume as that density increases .\",\n \"equation [ eq : ficm ] above suggests further that as this average density increases ( and @xmath81 ) , the gas inside each dense piece becomes more and more uniform .\",\n \"thus we recover the standard model of _ interstellar clouds composed of numerous , tiny , near - uniform clumps , arranged in a fractal pattern with the average gas density varying inversely with size _ ( for @xmath64 near 2 ) .\",\n \"we also get an explanation for the common perception that clumps in emission line surveys generally occupy 110% of the volume ( e.g. , blitz 1993 ) . evidently , this is a selection effect caused by the limitations of molecular emission maps which are typically sensitive to only a factor of @xmath82 range in density for any one survey .\",\n \"berkhuijsen ( 1998 ) has obtained a remarkable result recently in plotting the volume filling factor of ionized interstellar gas as a function of its local average density .\",\n \"the result , shown in figure [ fig : berk ] , is a @xmath83 distribution , as expected for a turbulent fluid with any fractal dimension .\",\n \"this does not mean that the ionized fluid itself is turbulent in this way ; in most regions , the ionization structure is probably just a reflection of the neutral structure of the gas before it was ionized .\",\n \"hierarchical or fractal structure in the intestellar medium implies that clouds are highly clumped , i.e. , that any one cloud is likely to have another cloud nearby , and , conversely , any empty region is not particularly likely to have a cloud nearby .\",\n \"such clumping makes the mean free path for intersecting a cloud on the line of sight different for regions near clouds than for regions between clouds .\",\n \"thus the _ intercloud _ mean free path can be larger than the _ average _ mean free , which has always been obtained in the past by assuming a uniform density .\",\n \"this result has important implications for the distance ionizing photons can travel once they leave a molecular cloud / ob association complex .\",\n \"the mean free path is generally defined as @xmath84 for number density of clouds @xmath32 and cross sectional area @xmath85 .\",\n \"when @xmath32 is not uniform , but clumped instead , this expression has a different value on lines of sight near cloud complexes than it does on lines of sight between cloud complexes .\",\n \"the hierarchical cloud model discussed above ( elmegreen 1997 ) can be used to show that the number of sub - clouds on a line of sight through a fractal cloud is @xmath86 if there are 8 interstellar absorption lines kpc@xmath59 on _ average _ ( blaauw 1952 ) , then these correspond to @xmath87 fractal cloud complexes per kiloparsec .\",\n \"indeed , most of the local gas is not randomly distributed with a constant space density of clouds everywhere .\",\n \"it is highly clumped into cloud complexes associated with the ob associations in orion , sco - cen , and perseus , and with the taurus clouds .\",\n \"these are the types of clouds that occur with the rate of 3 kpc@xmath59 .\",\n \"the average mean free path on lines of sight _ between _ the fractal cloud complexes should be @xmath88 pc .\",\n \"this may be defined as the pure intercloud mean free path .\",\n \"it exceeds the galactic scale height , which means that once photons get into the disk intercloud medium , they are likely to reach the halo . for this reason , the ionization of the halo , giving the `` reynolds '' layer ( reynolds 1995 ) , may be much easier than previously thought ( compare this result to the uniform cloud model by miller & cox 1993 ) .\",\n \"hii regions expand away from giant molecular clouds into the intercloud medium . for fractal clouds ,\",\n \"the neutral density varies inversely with distance @xmath20 as @xmath89 for @xmath68 .\",\n \"when the ionization front reaches this neutral density , it heats and ionizes the gas , causing the smallest pieces to expand and mix with each other .\",\n \"this makes the local density more uniform on a timescale equal to the sound crossing time for the small pieces , but it does not affect the overall density gradient much because the sound crossing time is large on a large scale . thus a young hii region should have a radial density gradient reflecting the @xmath90 gradient in the initial neutral cloud . as a result\",\n \", there should be an extended component of _ diffuse ionized gas _ surrounding most hii regions .\",\n \"the fraction of the ionization outside the conventional strmgren sphere can be large , perhaps 50% ( elmegreen 1997 ) .\",\n \"such extended ionization around hii regions presumably corresponds to the observations of diffuse ionized gas in our galaxy ( reynolds 1995 ) and other galaxies ( walterbos & braun 1994 ; ferguson et al .\",\n \"this diffuse ionized gas is clearly associated with the outlying parts of individual hii regions in many cases ( walterbos & braun 1994 ) .\",\n \"the mass distribution of purely hierarchical structures should scale as @xmath91 constant , or ( fleck 1996 ) : @xmath92 actually , @xmath93 from clump surveys ( stutzki et al .\",\n \"1998 ; heithausen et al .\",\n \"1998 ) .\",\n \"elmegreen & falgarone ( 1997 ) got @xmath94 with @xmath95 from a model of hierarchical cloud structure using the observed @xmath96 for size @xmath63 with @xmath97 , and the observed @xmath98 with @xmath99 , and then combining these relations with the standard conversion @xmath100 , which gives @xmath101 .\",\n \"stutzki et al .\",\n \"( 1998 ) got @xmath102 with a cloud model based on fractal brownian motion , using @xmath103 and the same @xmath64 and @xmath104 .\",\n \"the physical difference between these two models is that hierarchical clouds have all their small clumps inside larger clumps , whereas fractal brownian motion clouds have small structure with equal probability everywhere , although it is weaker outside the larger clumps . in theory\",\n \", the brownian motion model makes more sense for turbulence , which should have some density structure everywhere , but in practice , the low density regions outside of the main hierarchy in an interstellar cloud may be ionized or invisible in co , in which case only the dense hierarchical core , which is common to both models , will be seen .\",\n \"the @xmath105 function also applies to the probability of choosing part of a hierarchical cloud from any level .\",\n \"if stars form at all levels in a hierarchy because all levels have dense gas in tiny clumps , then the resulting stars will be hierarchically clumped too .\",\n \"such a distribution for stars is in fact commonly observed ( elmegreen & efremov 1997 , 1998 ) . if , in addition , bound clusters form with some high and nearly constant efficiency , so @xmath106 , then the mass distribution for star\",\n \"_ clusters _ will be about the same as the mass distribution for cloud structure ( elmegreen & falgarone 1996 ) . battinelli et al .\",\n \"( 1994 ) found cluster mass functions from two samples that had power law slopes equal to @xmath107 and @xmath108 .\",\n \"elmegreen & efremov ( 1997 ) similarly found @xmath109 for three different age groups in the lmc .\",\n \"these cluster mass functions are very similar to the expectations from hierarchical clouds , given by equation [ eq : fleck ] .\",\n \"berkhuijsen , e. m. 1998 , `` the volume filling factor of the wim , '' in _ the local bubble and beyond _ , iau colloquium no .\",\n \"166 , d. breitschwerdt , m. j. freyberg , and j. truemper ( eds . ) , berlin : springer - verlag , p. 301304\",\n \"elmegreen , b.g .\",\n \"1995 , `` large scale star formation , '' in _ the 7th gou shoujing summer school on astrophysics : molecular clouds and star formation _ , c. yuan and hunhan you ( eds . ) , singapore : world press , p. 149205\",\n \"elmegreen , b.g . , & efremov , y.n .\",\n \"1998 , `` hierarchy of interstellar and stellar structures and the case of the orion star - forming region , '' in _ the orion complex revisited _ , mccaughrean , m.j .\",\n \"& burkert , a. ( eds . )\",\n \"san francisco : asp conference series , in press heithausen , a. , bensch , f. , stutzki , j. , falgarone , e. , & panis , j.f .\",\n \"1998 , `` the iram key project : small scale structure of pre - star forming cores .\",\n \"combined mass spectra and scaling laws , '' _\",\n \"a&a _ * 331 *\",\n \"6568 langer , w. d. , velusamy , t. , kuiper , t.b.h . , peng , r. , mccarthy , m.c . ,\",\n \"travers , m.j . , kovacs , a. , gottleib , c.a .\",\n \", thaddeus , p. 1997 , `` first astronomical detection of the cumulene carbon chain molecule h2c6 in tmc-1 , '' _ apj _ * 480 * , l63l66 reynolds , r.j .\",\n \"1995 , `` diffuse optical emission lines as probes of the interstellar and intergalactic ionizing radiation , '' in the physics of the interstellar medium and intergalactic medium , asp conf .\",\n \"series 80 , ed .\",\n \"a. ferrara , c.f .\",\n \"mckee , c. heiles , and p.r .\",\n \"shapiro , san francisco , astron.soc.pacific , p. 388397 scalo , j. 1990 in physical processes in fragmentation and star formation , `` perception of interstellar structure : facing complexity , '' r. capuzzo - dolcetta , c. chiosi , & a. di fazio ( eds . ) dordrecht : kluwer , p. 151178\",\n \"stanimirovic , s. , staveley - smith , l. , sault , r. j. , dickey , j. , & snowden , s. 1998 , `` fractal structure in the interstellar medium of the smc ? '' _ iau symposium 190 , new views of the magellanic clouds _ ,\",\n \"cu , yuo - hua , et al .\",\n \"( eds . ) , asp conference series , in press wannier , p.g . , andersson , b .-\",\n \"g . , federman , s. r. , lewis , b. m. , viala , y. p. , & shaya , e. 1993 , `` warm neutral halos around molecular clouds .\",\n \"v - oh ( 1665 and 1667 mhz ) observations , '' _ apj _ * 407 * , 163174\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":81,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"hep-th9609016"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["it has long been known that there is an @xmath0 supermultiplet which , with respect to @xmath1 supersymmetry , appears as a combination of one vector and one chiral multiplet @xcite .","this supermultiplet is irreducible under @xmath0 supersymmetry and carries vanishing central charge .","it is usually referred to as the vector supermultiplet .","not long after its introduction , it was realized that there exists a variant , the vector - tensor multiplet , which , under @xmath1 supersymmetry , appears as a combination of one vector and one linear multiplet @xcite .","this variant is irreducible under @xmath0 and , in contrast , carries non - vanishing central charge off - shell . on shell","it is equivalent to the vector multiplet .","this multiplet was originally constructed using component field techniques @xcite , and it and its properties have received little attention . recently , however , within the context of trying to understand the consequences of @xmath0 duality in superstrings , the vector - tensor multiplet has re - emerged . specifically , when heterotic string theory is reduced to an @xmath0 theory in four dimensions the dilaton and the antisymmetric tensor field lie in a vector - tensor multiplet @xcite .","it is clear from this work that the vector - tensor supermultiplet is fundamental in heterotic theories and that elucidation of its properties , such as its behavior under duality transformations , is of importance .","the coupling of the vector - tensor multiplet to supergravity has also recently been considered @xcite .","it was shown that this requires the gauging of the central charge , leading to a chern - simons coupling between the vector - tensor multiplet and a vector multiplet .","if one wants to fully understand the complete , off - shell structure of the tensor - vector multiplet , one powerful approach is to construct the appropriate @xmath0 superfield .","it is the purpose of this paper to provide such a formulation .","much of the interesting structure of the vector - tensor multiplet appears in its couplings to other multiplets @xcite . here , however , we will restrict ourselves to a superfield formulation of the free abelian case , leaving interacting generalization to future publications .","since the vector - tensor supermultiplet has non - zero central charge , it is necessary to expand the usual superspace .","the maximal central extension of the @xmath0 superalgebra has two central charges .","consequently the corresponding superspace has two extra bosonic coordinates @xcite .","working in this superspace , one can introduce superfields and covariant constraints .","following the geometrical formulation of supergauge fields , we introduce a super - connection and the associated curvature .","we then introduce the appropriate constraints , solve the bianchi identities and show how the component fields of the tensor - vector multiplet emerge . using superspace techniques we rederive the supersymmetry and central charge transformations and , after showing that there exist a lagrangian superfield in central charge superspace , the higher components of which are all total derivatives",", we give the superfield and component actions .","the existence of a superfield lagrangian is an example of a central - charge generalization of the superactions described in @xcite .","it suggests that there is an even - dimensional submanifold of the central charge superspace naturally associated with the vector - tensor multiplet .","central charge superspace has recently also been considered in @xcite and used to rederive the usual gauge supermultiplet .","also , we want to point out that there is a strong relationship between the theory of @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions and four - dimensional , @xmath0 central charge superspace . indeed , the superfield equations of motion in the six - dimensional theory motivated the choice of one important constraint equation in four - dimensional central charge superspace .","in this sense , our constraint can be understood as a superfield realization of the dimensional reduction by legendre transformation discussed in @xcite .","we start by briefly recapitulating the relevant formulae of @xmath0 superspace . throughout the paper","we will use the conventions of @xcite .","the @xmath0 supersymmetry algebra is obtained from the poincar algebra by adding four fermionic operators @xmath2 ( @xmath3 and @xmath4 ) and their anti - hermitian conjugates @xmath5 .","moreover the algebra admits one complex `` central charge '' @xmath6 where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are hermitian .","these operators satisfy the following anticommutation relations : @xmath9 where @xmath10 are the four - momenta and @xmath11 .","the automorphism group of algebra is @xmath12 where the @xmath13 acts on the @xmath14 index in @xmath2 .","the antisymmetric tensor @xmath15 with @xmath16 provides an invariant metric for raising and lowering the @xmath13 indices by @xmath17 and @xmath18 .","@xmath0 superspace is a space with coordinates @xmath19 where @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 are commuting bosonic coordinates while @xmath23 and @xmath24 are anticommuting fermionic coordinates .","a superfield @xmath25 is a function of the superspace coordinates , @xmath26 .","taylor - series expansion of a general superfield @xmath25 in the @xmath27 coordinates terminates after a finite number of terms due to the anticommuting nature of @xmath27 . on the other hand",", the expansion in @xmath21 and @xmath28 never ends .","this means there are an infinite number of component fields ( functions of the spacetime coordinates @xmath20 ) in a general superfield .","this infinite number of component fields can be reduced to a finite number either off - shell , by applying appropriate constraints , or on - shell , by choosing equations of motion which propagate only a finite number of component fields .","translations in the superspace are generated by the supercovariant differential operators @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 where @xmath33 .","it is straightforward to compute the anticommutation relations for these operators .","they are @xmath34 by construction @xmath35 and @xmath36 anticommute with @xmath37 and @xmath38 and so can be used to impose supersymmetric covariant conditions on superfields .","the supervielbein @xmath39 of the @xmath0 superspace is defined as the matrix that relates the supercovariant derivatives @xmath40 and the ordinary partial derivatives @xmath41 the matrix @xmath42 is the inverse of @xmath39 .","these two matrices define the geometry of the @xmath0 superspace .","the torsion @xmath43 is defined as the exterior derivative of the supervielbein one - form @xmath44 , @xmath45 the non - vanishing components of the torsion are found to be @xmath46","in this section we give a geometrical superfield formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet .","we begin by considering the usual geometrical form of super - gauge theory , though in superspace with central charge .","we then find a suitable set of constraints on the superfield strength to reproduce the field content of the vector - tensor multiplet .","restricting our attention to abelian gauge theories , let us introduce a hermitian connection @xmath47 .","the hermiticity of the connection implies @xmath48 where @xmath49 is real , @xmath50 , and @xmath51 .","the curvature two - form is defined as @xmath52 the coefficient functions @xmath53 comprise thirteen lorentz - covariant types .","the ones that contain torsion terms are given by @xmath54 the curvature tensor @xmath55 is subject to the bianchi identities @xmath56 or equivalently @xmath57 each tensor component of the curvature tensor is an @xmath0 superfield which , in turn , has an infinite number of component fields .","all but a finite number of these component fields must be eliminated by virtue of appropriate constraints .","these constraints must be lorentz , gauge , and supersymmetric covariant .","it is natural to adopt a set of constraints which set the pure spinorial part of the curvature tensor to zero . that is @xmath58 before imposing further conditions","we would like to explore the consequences of . to do so we must solve the bianchi identities subject to these constraints .","the result is that all the components of the curvature tensor @xmath59 are determined in terms of a single superfield @xmath60 and its hermitian conjugate @xmath61 .","henceforth , we denote these superfields by @xmath62 and @xmath63 . in particular @xmath64 and @xmath65 furthermore , @xmath62 is constrained to satisfy @xmath66 } = - \\epsilon^{\\dot\\alpha\\dot\\beta } \\bar d_{\\dot\\alpha}^{[i } \\bar w_{\\dot\\beta}^{j ] } , \\label{3 } \\\\ & \\epsilon^{\\alpha\\beta } d_\\alpha^{(i } w_\\beta^{j ) } = \\epsilon^{\\dot\\alpha\\dot\\beta } \\bar d_{\\dot\\alpha}^{(i } \\bar w_{\\dot\\beta}^{j)}. \\label{4}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] let us explore the consequences of on the field content of @xmath62 .","the expansion of @xmath62 in the anti - commuting coordinates has the general form @xmath67 it is obvious that conditions will not impose any restriction on @xmath68 .","first we consider the implications of the lowest component of superfield constraints . condition implies that @xmath69 where @xmath70 and @xmath71 .","conditions and further implies the reality condition @xmath72 and @xmath73 where @xmath74 .","condition yields @xmath75 higher components of the superfield constraint ","imply further conditions on the fields @xmath76 , @xmath77 , and @xmath78 . one way to realize these conditions is to note that , from equations , , and , @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath81 .","the equations are the general solution of the bianchi identities subject to our constraints .","three of the bianchi identities they satisfy are @xmath82 taking the lowest component of equation gives rise to @xmath83 so that @xmath84 is the field strength of a gauge field @xmath85 .","that is @xmath86 the lowest components of and give @xmath87 } & = - \\tfrac12 ( \\partial_z + \\partial_{\\bar z } ) \\mathscript f_{ab } , \\\\ \\partial_{[a } h^i_{b ] } & = - \\tfrac12 i ( \\partial_z-\\partial_{\\bar z } ) \\mathscript f_{ab } , \\label{h1 } \\\\","\\partial_a d & = - \\tfrac14 i \\left\\ { ( \\partial_z-\\partial_{\\bar z } ) h_a^r + i ( \\partial_z + \\partial_{\\bar z } ) h_a^i \\right\\ } , \\label{temp11}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] where @xmath88 .","this is as far as we can go using solely the constraints .","so far we have the following component fields : an @xmath13 doublet of spinors @xmath89 , a real gauge field @xmath85 , a complex vector field @xmath90 , a real scalar @xmath78 and a real @xmath13 triplet of scalars @xmath91 .","we would like to impose further constraints to reduce the number of fields to an irreducible multiplet .","as we will show very shortly , it is possible to impose further constraints to ensure that the real and imaginary parts of @xmath90 are each field strengths , one of an anti - symmetric tensor and the other of a scalar .","what about the fields @xmath78 and @xmath91 ?","we will find that @xmath78 and @xmath91 play the role of auxiliary fields .","note that the usual @xmath0 gauge multiplet has a triplet of auxiliary fields .","hence , if we want to derive the usual gauge multiplet we are led to set @xmath78 to zero by promoting the constraint to the stronger one @xmath92 } = 0 , \\qquad \\epsilon^{\\dot\\alpha\\dot\\beta } \\bar d_{\\dot\\alpha}^{[i } \\bar w_{\\dot\\beta}^{j ] } = 0.\\ ] ] on the other hand , if we want to derive the vector - tensor multiplet , which has a single auxiliary field , we must eliminate @xmath91 .","this can be achieved by promoting condition to the stronger condition @xmath93 henceforth , we add condition as a further constraint on the theory .","now let us proceed using conditions as well as the stronger version of , constraint .","apart from eliminating @xmath91 , it can be shown that the consequences of imposing are @xmath94 we note that the conditions obtained so far on @xmath90 given in and are not sufficient to render the real and imaginary components of @xmath90 as field strengths .","we would like , therefore , to impose yet another , and final , constraint that will achieve this goal .","we take a reality condition on the central charge @xmath95 this means that superfield @xmath62 , and hence all the curvature tensor components , depend on the two central charges @xmath21 and @xmath96 only through the combination @xmath97 with no dependence on @xmath98 .","substituting from constraint into and immediately gives the following constraints on the real and imaginary components of @xmath90 @xmath99}^i = 0 . \\label{t5}\\ ] ] these equations achieve just the goal we were aiming for .","they assert that @xmath100 and @xmath101 are field strengths of an anti - symmetric tensor and a scalar field respectively .","that is @xmath102 in conclusion , we find that the component fields in @xmath62 are exactly those of the vector - tensor multiplet , namely @xmath103 . it will not have escaped the readers notice that these fields are actually functions of the central charge coordinates as well as the spacetime coordinates . however , by virtue of constraint , they depend on the central charge coordinates only via @xmath104 .","let us introduce a real central charge coordinate @xmath105 .","moreover , the dependence of these fields on @xmath106 is highly restricted by the conditions we derived so far .","in fact , as we now show , these conditions completely determine their dependence on @xmath106 in terms of their lowest component in their central charge expansion . to see this","let us summarize the relevant conditions in , , and derived on the bosonic fields .","they are @xmath107}^r . \\end{split } \\label{t4}\\ ] ] equations constitute a system of first - order `` differential equations '' for the @xmath108 dependence of the bosonic fields .","the general solution is completely determined in terms of the `` initial conditions '' ; that is , the values of the fields at @xmath109 , say , @xmath110 , @xmath111 , and @xmath112 .","thus in a taylor series expansion in @xmath106 each term in the series gets related to lower - order terms , so that for instance , @xmath113 with similar formulas for @xmath100 , @xmath101 , and @xmath84 .","furthermore , in the next section , we will derive the corresponding equation for the fermionic field @xmath68 .","in this section , we would like to derive the supersymmetry and central charge transformations of the component fields . in order to exhibit these transformations","it is necessary to compute the part of @xmath62 quadratic in the fermionic coordinates .","moreover , since all the component fields are present in the lowest and first order terms of @xmath62 , the quadratic term is sufficient for computing the supersymmetry transformations .","we have @xmath114 let us first consider the constraint equations , , and .","demanding that the linear term in @xmath27 in these equations vanish completely determines @xmath115 , @xmath116 , and @xmath117 .","we find @xmath118 we note that these terms do not involve any new fields .","they are completely given in terms of the lowest component of @xmath62 , namely @xmath68 .","we are still left with equation which is a reality condition . evaluating the linear term in , and making use of , yields the following constraint on the fermionic field @xmath68 @xmath119 where @xmath120 .","equation is the relation for the fermionic field @xmath121 corresponding to equations for the bosonic fields .","it fixes the expansion of @xmath68 in the central charge @xmath106 , leaving only the lowest component @xmath122 arbitrary .","we are now in a position to compute the supersymmetry transformation of the different component fields .","to do this we have to act on @xmath62 with @xmath123 we find @xmath124 } + 2 \\xi_\\alpha^i d + \\tfrac{i}{3 } \\bar\\xi^{\\dot\\alpha i } { { \\smash{{\\sigma}^{a}}_{\\alpha\\dot\\alpha } } } \\epsilon_{abcd } \\partial^b b^{cd } - 2 { { \\smash{{\\sigma}^{a}}_{\\alpha\\dot\\alpha } } } \\bar\\xi^{\\dot\\alpha } \\partial_a \\phi . \\end{split } \\label{susy}\\ ] ] note that the fields in these supersymmetry transformations are formally functions of both @xmath20 and @xmath106 .","we have already shown that the only independent components of these fields are the lowest order terms in @xmath106 .","further , transformations do not mix component fields from different orders in @xmath106 .","thus equations also express the variations of the lowest - order independent fields , which are functions of @xmath20 only . to get the central charge transformations we have to act with @xmath125 on @xmath62 .","it is straightforward to get the following set of transformations @xmath126 expressions and reproduce the supersymmetry and central charge transformations of the vector - tensor multiplet given in the component field calculations of @xcite .","they are a realization of the @xmath0 supersymmetry algebra with central charge .","note that as a result of our constraints , in particular , only one of the two central charges is represented nontrivially .","we now discuss how to write a superfield action for the vector - tensor multiplet .","we start by noting that the relevant field strengths of the different bosonic fields occur at the linear level in @xmath62 . to get a quadratic expression in these field strengths",", we have to consider expressions quadratic in @xmath62 .","these expressions can contain both @xmath35 and @xmath36 .","contracting the indices to get a proper lorentz invariant lagrangian implies that there must be an even number of @xmath78 s .","in such an expression , the relevant terms will occur at @xmath127 level if it involves no derivatives or the lowest component if it involves two derivatives . in the former case we will have to integrate over two @xmath27 s only .","but in contrast to the chiral space for @xmath1 supersymmetry , there is no two - dimensional subspace of the @xmath0 superspace over which supersymmetry is represented .","hence , we are forced to consider expressions quadratic in @xmath62 with two supersymmetric covariant derivatives , and to integrate over spacetime only .","in fact , we find that the free lagrangian for all the component fields is contained in the lowest component of @xmath128 to be precise , we have @xmath129 it is straightforward to verify that lagrangian is invariant under supersymmetry transformations up to a total divergence .","although this implies that it must be invariant under central charge transformation as well , since the latter is equivalent to two successive supersymmetry transformations , one can check directly that it is indeed invariant under up to a total divergence .","this invariance of the lowest component of the lagrangian under central charge and supersymmetry transformations , in fact , implies that the higher components are spacetime total divergences . to show this","let us consider first the invariance under central charge transformation . since the lagrangian transforms by a total divergence under a single central charge transformation , it must does so under @xmath130 such transformations .","that is @xmath131 put another way , all the coefficients in the @xmath106 expansion of @xmath132 but the lowest one are , in fact , spacetime total divergences .","therefore we have @xmath133 although a little involved we can extend this proof to the expansion in @xmath27 as well .","that is , it can be shown that @xmath134 we would like to stress that this is completely general .","if the lowest component of a superfield is supersymmetric invariant up to a spacetime total divergence , all the higher components in @xmath106 as well as @xmath27 are spacetime total divergences .","this has the immediate consequence that a spacetime integral of this superfield will single out the lowest component . in other words","we can write down the following superfield expression for the invariant action @xmath135 this represents a central charge generalization of the type of superactions considered in @xcite .","this completes our study of the superfield formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet .","we conclude by briefly mentioning the connection between the superspace formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet and @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions . the presence of central charge led us to augment @xmath0 superspace by two new bosonic coordinates , @xmath21 and @xmath96 .","the resulting space , with six bosonic coordinates , is actually none - other than the superspace of @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions ( though with the fermionic coordinates treated slightly unconventionally , being formulated as a pair of @xmath13 majorana - weyl spinors @xcite ) .","the introduction of a connection @xmath136 in the central charge superspace then mirrors the formulation of supersymmetric gauge theory in six dimensions .","in fact our first set of constraints are precisely those used for the six - dimensional vector multiplet @xcite . to obtain the vector - tensor multiplet we imposed two further constraints .","the first condition still has a six - dimensional interpretation : it corresponds to the on - shell condition for the six- dimensional vector multiplet .","it is important to note that this does not imply that the multiplet is on - shell in four - dimensions .","instead it implies a relationship between the derivatives of the component fields in the internal @xmath21@xmath137 directions and in the four - dimensional @xmath138 directions , as shown in equation .","the second condition breaks the six - dimensional lorentz symmetry .","it forces the superfield to be independent of one of the internal @xmath21@xmath137 directions .","as we have shown , together these conditions are sufficient to completely determine the dependence of the multiplet on the central charge coordinates .","the connection to the component formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet given by sohnius _","@xcite now also becomes clear .","the second condition is a conventional dimensional reduction of the six- dimensional vector multiplet down to five - dimensions .","the first condition , corresponding to an on - shell condition in six- dimensions , reproduces the `` dimensional reduction by legendre transform '' from five to four dimensions .","a superspace formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet allows a number of further issues to be addressed .","first is the question of duality . on shell , the usual vector multiplet and the vector - tensor multiplet","describe the same degrees of freedom . from the @xmath1 point of view , one is the dual of the other since the chiral multiplet in the usual vector multiplet is dual to the tensor multiplet in the vector - tensor multiplet .","central charge superspace should provide a realization of this duality in a manifestly @xmath0 supersymmetric way .","a related question is to find an unconstrained @xmath0 prepotential for the vector - tensor multiplet .","we also note that the form of the multiplet described here has been explicitly non - interacting .","however , the superspace formalism also allows the description of non - abelian multiplets as well as multiplets with gauged central charge and chern - simons terms as have been discussed in components in @xcite .","it is also pertinent to the discussion of the most general form of the action for the vector - tensor multiplet .","finally the central charge superspace can be used to give a superfield description of other exotic @xmath0 multiplets , in particular the tensor and double - tensor multiplets mentioned in @xcite .","we leave the discussion of these issues to future publications .","this work was supported in part by doe grant no . de - fg02 - 95er40893 and nato grand no",". crg-940784 ."],"string":"[\n \"it has long been known that there is an @xmath0 supermultiplet which , with respect to @xmath1 supersymmetry , appears as a combination of one vector and one chiral multiplet @xcite .\",\n \"this supermultiplet is irreducible under @xmath0 supersymmetry and carries vanishing central charge .\",\n \"it is usually referred to as the vector supermultiplet .\",\n \"not long after its introduction , it was realized that there exists a variant , the vector - tensor multiplet , which , under @xmath1 supersymmetry , appears as a combination of one vector and one linear multiplet @xcite .\",\n \"this variant is irreducible under @xmath0 and , in contrast , carries non - vanishing central charge off - shell . on shell\",\n \"it is equivalent to the vector multiplet .\",\n \"this multiplet was originally constructed using component field techniques @xcite , and it and its properties have received little attention . recently , however , within the context of trying to understand the consequences of @xmath0 duality in superstrings , the vector - tensor multiplet has re - emerged . specifically , when heterotic string theory is reduced to an @xmath0 theory in four dimensions the dilaton and the antisymmetric tensor field lie in a vector - tensor multiplet @xcite .\",\n \"it is clear from this work that the vector - tensor supermultiplet is fundamental in heterotic theories and that elucidation of its properties , such as its behavior under duality transformations , is of importance .\",\n \"the coupling of the vector - tensor multiplet to supergravity has also recently been considered @xcite .\",\n \"it was shown that this requires the gauging of the central charge , leading to a chern - simons coupling between the vector - tensor multiplet and a vector multiplet .\",\n \"if one wants to fully understand the complete , off - shell structure of the tensor - vector multiplet , one powerful approach is to construct the appropriate @xmath0 superfield .\",\n \"it is the purpose of this paper to provide such a formulation .\",\n \"much of the interesting structure of the vector - tensor multiplet appears in its couplings to other multiplets @xcite . here , however , we will restrict ourselves to a superfield formulation of the free abelian case , leaving interacting generalization to future publications .\",\n \"since the vector - tensor supermultiplet has non - zero central charge , it is necessary to expand the usual superspace .\",\n \"the maximal central extension of the @xmath0 superalgebra has two central charges .\",\n \"consequently the corresponding superspace has two extra bosonic coordinates @xcite .\",\n \"working in this superspace , one can introduce superfields and covariant constraints .\",\n \"following the geometrical formulation of supergauge fields , we introduce a super - connection and the associated curvature .\",\n \"we then introduce the appropriate constraints , solve the bianchi identities and show how the component fields of the tensor - vector multiplet emerge . using superspace techniques we rederive the supersymmetry and central charge transformations and , after showing that there exist a lagrangian superfield in central charge superspace , the higher components of which are all total derivatives\",\n \", we give the superfield and component actions .\",\n \"the existence of a superfield lagrangian is an example of a central - charge generalization of the superactions described in @xcite .\",\n \"it suggests that there is an even - dimensional submanifold of the central charge superspace naturally associated with the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"central charge superspace has recently also been considered in @xcite and used to rederive the usual gauge supermultiplet .\",\n \"also , we want to point out that there is a strong relationship between the theory of @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions and four - dimensional , @xmath0 central charge superspace . indeed , the superfield equations of motion in the six - dimensional theory motivated the choice of one important constraint equation in four - dimensional central charge superspace .\",\n \"in this sense , our constraint can be understood as a superfield realization of the dimensional reduction by legendre transformation discussed in @xcite .\",\n \"we start by briefly recapitulating the relevant formulae of @xmath0 superspace . throughout the paper\",\n \"we will use the conventions of @xcite .\",\n \"the @xmath0 supersymmetry algebra is obtained from the poincar algebra by adding four fermionic operators @xmath2 ( @xmath3 and @xmath4 ) and their anti - hermitian conjugates @xmath5 .\",\n \"moreover the algebra admits one complex `` central charge '' @xmath6 where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are hermitian .\",\n \"these operators satisfy the following anticommutation relations : @xmath9 where @xmath10 are the four - momenta and @xmath11 .\",\n \"the automorphism group of algebra is @xmath12 where the @xmath13 acts on the @xmath14 index in @xmath2 .\",\n \"the antisymmetric tensor @xmath15 with @xmath16 provides an invariant metric for raising and lowering the @xmath13 indices by @xmath17 and @xmath18 .\",\n \"@xmath0 superspace is a space with coordinates @xmath19 where @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 are commuting bosonic coordinates while @xmath23 and @xmath24 are anticommuting fermionic coordinates .\",\n \"a superfield @xmath25 is a function of the superspace coordinates , @xmath26 .\",\n \"taylor - series expansion of a general superfield @xmath25 in the @xmath27 coordinates terminates after a finite number of terms due to the anticommuting nature of @xmath27 . on the other hand\",\n \", the expansion in @xmath21 and @xmath28 never ends .\",\n \"this means there are an infinite number of component fields ( functions of the spacetime coordinates @xmath20 ) in a general superfield .\",\n \"this infinite number of component fields can be reduced to a finite number either off - shell , by applying appropriate constraints , or on - shell , by choosing equations of motion which propagate only a finite number of component fields .\",\n \"translations in the superspace are generated by the supercovariant differential operators @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 where @xmath33 .\",\n \"it is straightforward to compute the anticommutation relations for these operators .\",\n \"they are @xmath34 by construction @xmath35 and @xmath36 anticommute with @xmath37 and @xmath38 and so can be used to impose supersymmetric covariant conditions on superfields .\",\n \"the supervielbein @xmath39 of the @xmath0 superspace is defined as the matrix that relates the supercovariant derivatives @xmath40 and the ordinary partial derivatives @xmath41 the matrix @xmath42 is the inverse of @xmath39 .\",\n \"these two matrices define the geometry of the @xmath0 superspace .\",\n \"the torsion @xmath43 is defined as the exterior derivative of the supervielbein one - form @xmath44 , @xmath45 the non - vanishing components of the torsion are found to be @xmath46\",\n \"in this section we give a geometrical superfield formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"we begin by considering the usual geometrical form of super - gauge theory , though in superspace with central charge .\",\n \"we then find a suitable set of constraints on the superfield strength to reproduce the field content of the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"restricting our attention to abelian gauge theories , let us introduce a hermitian connection @xmath47 .\",\n \"the hermiticity of the connection implies @xmath48 where @xmath49 is real , @xmath50 , and @xmath51 .\",\n \"the curvature two - form is defined as @xmath52 the coefficient functions @xmath53 comprise thirteen lorentz - covariant types .\",\n \"the ones that contain torsion terms are given by @xmath54 the curvature tensor @xmath55 is subject to the bianchi identities @xmath56 or equivalently @xmath57 each tensor component of the curvature tensor is an @xmath0 superfield which , in turn , has an infinite number of component fields .\",\n \"all but a finite number of these component fields must be eliminated by virtue of appropriate constraints .\",\n \"these constraints must be lorentz , gauge , and supersymmetric covariant .\",\n \"it is natural to adopt a set of constraints which set the pure spinorial part of the curvature tensor to zero . that is @xmath58 before imposing further conditions\",\n \"we would like to explore the consequences of . to do so we must solve the bianchi identities subject to these constraints .\",\n \"the result is that all the components of the curvature tensor @xmath59 are determined in terms of a single superfield @xmath60 and its hermitian conjugate @xmath61 .\",\n \"henceforth , we denote these superfields by @xmath62 and @xmath63 . in particular @xmath64 and @xmath65 furthermore , @xmath62 is constrained to satisfy @xmath66 } = - \\\\epsilon^{\\\\dot\\\\alpha\\\\dot\\\\beta } \\\\bar d_{\\\\dot\\\\alpha}^{[i } \\\\bar w_{\\\\dot\\\\beta}^{j ] } , \\\\label{3 } \\\\\\\\ & \\\\epsilon^{\\\\alpha\\\\beta } d_\\\\alpha^{(i } w_\\\\beta^{j ) } = \\\\epsilon^{\\\\dot\\\\alpha\\\\dot\\\\beta } \\\\bar d_{\\\\dot\\\\alpha}^{(i } \\\\bar w_{\\\\dot\\\\beta}^{j)}. \\\\label{4}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] let us explore the consequences of on the field content of @xmath62 .\",\n \"the expansion of @xmath62 in the anti - commuting coordinates has the general form @xmath67 it is obvious that conditions will not impose any restriction on @xmath68 .\",\n \"first we consider the implications of the lowest component of superfield constraints . condition implies that @xmath69 where @xmath70 and @xmath71 .\",\n \"conditions and further implies the reality condition @xmath72 and @xmath73 where @xmath74 .\",\n \"condition yields @xmath75 higher components of the superfield constraint \",\n \"imply further conditions on the fields @xmath76 , @xmath77 , and @xmath78 . one way to realize these conditions is to note that , from equations , , and , @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath81 .\",\n \"the equations are the general solution of the bianchi identities subject to our constraints .\",\n \"three of the bianchi identities they satisfy are @xmath82 taking the lowest component of equation gives rise to @xmath83 so that @xmath84 is the field strength of a gauge field @xmath85 .\",\n \"that is @xmath86 the lowest components of and give @xmath87 } & = - \\\\tfrac12 ( \\\\partial_z + \\\\partial_{\\\\bar z } ) \\\\mathscript f_{ab } , \\\\\\\\ \\\\partial_{[a } h^i_{b ] } & = - \\\\tfrac12 i ( \\\\partial_z-\\\\partial_{\\\\bar z } ) \\\\mathscript f_{ab } , \\\\label{h1 } \\\\\\\\\",\n \"\\\\partial_a d & = - \\\\tfrac14 i \\\\left\\\\ { ( \\\\partial_z-\\\\partial_{\\\\bar z } ) h_a^r + i ( \\\\partial_z + \\\\partial_{\\\\bar z } ) h_a^i \\\\right\\\\ } , \\\\label{temp11}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath88 .\",\n \"this is as far as we can go using solely the constraints .\",\n \"so far we have the following component fields : an @xmath13 doublet of spinors @xmath89 , a real gauge field @xmath85 , a complex vector field @xmath90 , a real scalar @xmath78 and a real @xmath13 triplet of scalars @xmath91 .\",\n \"we would like to impose further constraints to reduce the number of fields to an irreducible multiplet .\",\n \"as we will show very shortly , it is possible to impose further constraints to ensure that the real and imaginary parts of @xmath90 are each field strengths , one of an anti - symmetric tensor and the other of a scalar .\",\n \"what about the fields @xmath78 and @xmath91 ?\",\n \"we will find that @xmath78 and @xmath91 play the role of auxiliary fields .\",\n \"note that the usual @xmath0 gauge multiplet has a triplet of auxiliary fields .\",\n \"hence , if we want to derive the usual gauge multiplet we are led to set @xmath78 to zero by promoting the constraint to the stronger one @xmath92 } = 0 , \\\\qquad \\\\epsilon^{\\\\dot\\\\alpha\\\\dot\\\\beta } \\\\bar d_{\\\\dot\\\\alpha}^{[i } \\\\bar w_{\\\\dot\\\\beta}^{j ] } = 0.\\\\ ] ] on the other hand , if we want to derive the vector - tensor multiplet , which has a single auxiliary field , we must eliminate @xmath91 .\",\n \"this can be achieved by promoting condition to the stronger condition @xmath93 henceforth , we add condition as a further constraint on the theory .\",\n \"now let us proceed using conditions as well as the stronger version of , constraint .\",\n \"apart from eliminating @xmath91 , it can be shown that the consequences of imposing are @xmath94 we note that the conditions obtained so far on @xmath90 given in and are not sufficient to render the real and imaginary components of @xmath90 as field strengths .\",\n \"we would like , therefore , to impose yet another , and final , constraint that will achieve this goal .\",\n \"we take a reality condition on the central charge @xmath95 this means that superfield @xmath62 , and hence all the curvature tensor components , depend on the two central charges @xmath21 and @xmath96 only through the combination @xmath97 with no dependence on @xmath98 .\",\n \"substituting from constraint into and immediately gives the following constraints on the real and imaginary components of @xmath90 @xmath99}^i = 0 . \\\\label{t5}\\\\ ] ] these equations achieve just the goal we were aiming for .\",\n \"they assert that @xmath100 and @xmath101 are field strengths of an anti - symmetric tensor and a scalar field respectively .\",\n \"that is @xmath102 in conclusion , we find that the component fields in @xmath62 are exactly those of the vector - tensor multiplet , namely @xmath103 . it will not have escaped the readers notice that these fields are actually functions of the central charge coordinates as well as the spacetime coordinates . however , by virtue of constraint , they depend on the central charge coordinates only via @xmath104 .\",\n \"let us introduce a real central charge coordinate @xmath105 .\",\n \"moreover , the dependence of these fields on @xmath106 is highly restricted by the conditions we derived so far .\",\n \"in fact , as we now show , these conditions completely determine their dependence on @xmath106 in terms of their lowest component in their central charge expansion . to see this\",\n \"let us summarize the relevant conditions in , , and derived on the bosonic fields .\",\n \"they are @xmath107}^r . \\\\end{split } \\\\label{t4}\\\\ ] ] equations constitute a system of first - order `` differential equations '' for the @xmath108 dependence of the bosonic fields .\",\n \"the general solution is completely determined in terms of the `` initial conditions '' ; that is , the values of the fields at @xmath109 , say , @xmath110 , @xmath111 , and @xmath112 .\",\n \"thus in a taylor series expansion in @xmath106 each term in the series gets related to lower - order terms , so that for instance , @xmath113 with similar formulas for @xmath100 , @xmath101 , and @xmath84 .\",\n \"furthermore , in the next section , we will derive the corresponding equation for the fermionic field @xmath68 .\",\n \"in this section , we would like to derive the supersymmetry and central charge transformations of the component fields . in order to exhibit these transformations\",\n \"it is necessary to compute the part of @xmath62 quadratic in the fermionic coordinates .\",\n \"moreover , since all the component fields are present in the lowest and first order terms of @xmath62 , the quadratic term is sufficient for computing the supersymmetry transformations .\",\n \"we have @xmath114 let us first consider the constraint equations , , and .\",\n \"demanding that the linear term in @xmath27 in these equations vanish completely determines @xmath115 , @xmath116 , and @xmath117 .\",\n \"we find @xmath118 we note that these terms do not involve any new fields .\",\n \"they are completely given in terms of the lowest component of @xmath62 , namely @xmath68 .\",\n \"we are still left with equation which is a reality condition . evaluating the linear term in , and making use of , yields the following constraint on the fermionic field @xmath68 @xmath119 where @xmath120 .\",\n \"equation is the relation for the fermionic field @xmath121 corresponding to equations for the bosonic fields .\",\n \"it fixes the expansion of @xmath68 in the central charge @xmath106 , leaving only the lowest component @xmath122 arbitrary .\",\n \"we are now in a position to compute the supersymmetry transformation of the different component fields .\",\n \"to do this we have to act on @xmath62 with @xmath123 we find @xmath124 } + 2 \\\\xi_\\\\alpha^i d + \\\\tfrac{i}{3 } \\\\bar\\\\xi^{\\\\dot\\\\alpha i } { { \\\\smash{{\\\\sigma}^{a}}_{\\\\alpha\\\\dot\\\\alpha } } } \\\\epsilon_{abcd } \\\\partial^b b^{cd } - 2 { { \\\\smash{{\\\\sigma}^{a}}_{\\\\alpha\\\\dot\\\\alpha } } } \\\\bar\\\\xi^{\\\\dot\\\\alpha } \\\\partial_a \\\\phi . \\\\end{split } \\\\label{susy}\\\\ ] ] note that the fields in these supersymmetry transformations are formally functions of both @xmath20 and @xmath106 .\",\n \"we have already shown that the only independent components of these fields are the lowest order terms in @xmath106 .\",\n \"further , transformations do not mix component fields from different orders in @xmath106 .\",\n \"thus equations also express the variations of the lowest - order independent fields , which are functions of @xmath20 only . to get the central charge transformations we have to act with @xmath125 on @xmath62 .\",\n \"it is straightforward to get the following set of transformations @xmath126 expressions and reproduce the supersymmetry and central charge transformations of the vector - tensor multiplet given in the component field calculations of @xcite .\",\n \"they are a realization of the @xmath0 supersymmetry algebra with central charge .\",\n \"note that as a result of our constraints , in particular , only one of the two central charges is represented nontrivially .\",\n \"we now discuss how to write a superfield action for the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"we start by noting that the relevant field strengths of the different bosonic fields occur at the linear level in @xmath62 . to get a quadratic expression in these field strengths\",\n \", we have to consider expressions quadratic in @xmath62 .\",\n \"these expressions can contain both @xmath35 and @xmath36 .\",\n \"contracting the indices to get a proper lorentz invariant lagrangian implies that there must be an even number of @xmath78 s .\",\n \"in such an expression , the relevant terms will occur at @xmath127 level if it involves no derivatives or the lowest component if it involves two derivatives . in the former case we will have to integrate over two @xmath27 s only .\",\n \"but in contrast to the chiral space for @xmath1 supersymmetry , there is no two - dimensional subspace of the @xmath0 superspace over which supersymmetry is represented .\",\n \"hence , we are forced to consider expressions quadratic in @xmath62 with two supersymmetric covariant derivatives , and to integrate over spacetime only .\",\n \"in fact , we find that the free lagrangian for all the component fields is contained in the lowest component of @xmath128 to be precise , we have @xmath129 it is straightforward to verify that lagrangian is invariant under supersymmetry transformations up to a total divergence .\",\n \"although this implies that it must be invariant under central charge transformation as well , since the latter is equivalent to two successive supersymmetry transformations , one can check directly that it is indeed invariant under up to a total divergence .\",\n \"this invariance of the lowest component of the lagrangian under central charge and supersymmetry transformations , in fact , implies that the higher components are spacetime total divergences . to show this\",\n \"let us consider first the invariance under central charge transformation . since the lagrangian transforms by a total divergence under a single central charge transformation , it must does so under @xmath130 such transformations .\",\n \"that is @xmath131 put another way , all the coefficients in the @xmath106 expansion of @xmath132 but the lowest one are , in fact , spacetime total divergences .\",\n \"therefore we have @xmath133 although a little involved we can extend this proof to the expansion in @xmath27 as well .\",\n \"that is , it can be shown that @xmath134 we would like to stress that this is completely general .\",\n \"if the lowest component of a superfield is supersymmetric invariant up to a spacetime total divergence , all the higher components in @xmath106 as well as @xmath27 are spacetime total divergences .\",\n \"this has the immediate consequence that a spacetime integral of this superfield will single out the lowest component . in other words\",\n \"we can write down the following superfield expression for the invariant action @xmath135 this represents a central charge generalization of the type of superactions considered in @xcite .\",\n \"this completes our study of the superfield formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"we conclude by briefly mentioning the connection between the superspace formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet and @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions . the presence of central charge led us to augment @xmath0 superspace by two new bosonic coordinates , @xmath21 and @xmath96 .\",\n \"the resulting space , with six bosonic coordinates , is actually none - other than the superspace of @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions ( though with the fermionic coordinates treated slightly unconventionally , being formulated as a pair of @xmath13 majorana - weyl spinors @xcite ) .\",\n \"the introduction of a connection @xmath136 in the central charge superspace then mirrors the formulation of supersymmetric gauge theory in six dimensions .\",\n \"in fact our first set of constraints are precisely those used for the six - dimensional vector multiplet @xcite . to obtain the vector - tensor multiplet we imposed two further constraints .\",\n \"the first condition still has a six - dimensional interpretation : it corresponds to the on - shell condition for the six- dimensional vector multiplet .\",\n \"it is important to note that this does not imply that the multiplet is on - shell in four - dimensions .\",\n \"instead it implies a relationship between the derivatives of the component fields in the internal @xmath21@xmath137 directions and in the four - dimensional @xmath138 directions , as shown in equation .\",\n \"the second condition breaks the six - dimensional lorentz symmetry .\",\n \"it forces the superfield to be independent of one of the internal @xmath21@xmath137 directions .\",\n \"as we have shown , together these conditions are sufficient to completely determine the dependence of the multiplet on the central charge coordinates .\",\n \"the connection to the component formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet given by sohnius _\",\n \"@xcite now also becomes clear .\",\n \"the second condition is a conventional dimensional reduction of the six- dimensional vector multiplet down to five - dimensions .\",\n \"the first condition , corresponding to an on - shell condition in six- dimensions , reproduces the `` dimensional reduction by legendre transform '' from five to four dimensions .\",\n \"a superspace formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet allows a number of further issues to be addressed .\",\n \"first is the question of duality . on shell , the usual vector multiplet and the vector - tensor multiplet\",\n \"describe the same degrees of freedom . from the @xmath1 point of view , one is the dual of the other since the chiral multiplet in the usual vector multiplet is dual to the tensor multiplet in the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"central charge superspace should provide a realization of this duality in a manifestly @xmath0 supersymmetric way .\",\n \"a related question is to find an unconstrained @xmath0 prepotential for the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"we also note that the form of the multiplet described here has been explicitly non - interacting .\",\n \"however , the superspace formalism also allows the description of non - abelian multiplets as well as multiplets with gauged central charge and chern - simons terms as have been discussed in components in @xcite .\",\n \"it is also pertinent to the discussion of the most general form of the action for the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"finally the central charge superspace can be used to give a superfield description of other exotic @xmath0 multiplets , in particular the tensor and double - tensor multiplets mentioned in @xcite .\",\n \"we leave the discussion of these issues to future publications .\",\n \"this work was supported in part by doe grant no . de - fg02 - 95er40893 and nato grand no\",\n \". crg-940784 .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> we use the four - dimensional @xmath0 central charge superspace to give a geometrical construction of the abelian vector - tensor multiplet consisting , under @xmath1 supersymmetry , of one vector and one linear multiplet . </S>","<S> we derive the component field supersymmetry and central charge transformations , and show that there is a super - lagrangian , the higher components of which are all total derivatives , allowing us to construct superfield and component actions . </S>","<S> pacs numbers : 11.30.pb , 11.15.-q + </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> we use the four - dimensional @xmath0 central charge superspace to give a geometrical construction of the abelian vector - tensor multiplet consisting , under @xmath1 supersymmetry , of one vector and one linear multiplet . </S>\",\n \"<S> we derive the component field supersymmetry and central charge transformations , and show that there is a super - lagrangian , the higher components of which are all total derivatives , allowing us to construct superfield and component actions . </S>\",\n \"<S> pacs numbers : 11.30.pb , 11.15.-q + </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","@xmath0 superspace","vector-tensor multiplet in @xmath0 superspace","supersymmetry and central charge transformations","concluding remarks","acknowledgments"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"@xmath0 superspace\",\n \"vector-tensor multiplet in @xmath0 superspace\",\n \"supersymmetry and central charge transformations\",\n \"concluding remarks\",\n \"acknowledgments\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["it has long been known that there is an @xmath0 supermultiplet which , with respect to @xmath1 supersymmetry , appears as a combination of one vector and one chiral multiplet @xcite .","this supermultiplet is irreducible under @xmath0 supersymmetry and carries vanishing central charge .","it is usually referred to as the vector supermultiplet .","not long after its introduction , it was realized that there exists a variant , the vector - tensor multiplet , which , under @xmath1 supersymmetry , appears as a combination of one vector and one linear multiplet @xcite .","this variant is irreducible under @xmath0 and , in contrast , carries non - vanishing central charge off - shell . on shell","it is equivalent to the vector multiplet .","this multiplet was originally constructed using component field techniques @xcite , and it and its properties have received little attention . recently , however , within the context of trying to understand the consequences of @xmath0 duality in superstrings , the vector - tensor multiplet has re - emerged . specifically , when heterotic string theory is reduced to an @xmath0 theory in four dimensions the dilaton and the antisymmetric tensor field lie in a vector - tensor multiplet @xcite .","it is clear from this work that the vector - tensor supermultiplet is fundamental in heterotic theories and that elucidation of its properties , such as its behavior under duality transformations , is of importance .","the coupling of the vector - tensor multiplet to supergravity has also recently been considered @xcite .","it was shown that this requires the gauging of the central charge , leading to a chern - simons coupling between the vector - tensor multiplet and a vector multiplet .","if one wants to fully understand the complete , off - shell structure of the tensor - vector multiplet , one powerful approach is to construct the appropriate @xmath0 superfield .","it is the purpose of this paper to provide such a formulation .","much of the interesting structure of the vector - tensor multiplet appears in its couplings to other multiplets @xcite . here , however , we will restrict ourselves to a superfield formulation of the free abelian case , leaving interacting generalization to future publications .","since the vector - tensor supermultiplet has non - zero central charge , it is necessary to expand the usual superspace .","the maximal central extension of the @xmath0 superalgebra has two central charges .","consequently the corresponding superspace has two extra bosonic coordinates @xcite .","working in this superspace , one can introduce superfields and covariant constraints .","following the geometrical formulation of supergauge fields , we introduce a super - connection and the associated curvature .","we then introduce the appropriate constraints , solve the bianchi identities and show how the component fields of the tensor - vector multiplet emerge . using superspace techniques we rederive the supersymmetry and central charge transformations and , after showing that there exist a lagrangian superfield in central charge superspace , the higher components of which are all total derivatives",", we give the superfield and component actions .","the existence of a superfield lagrangian is an example of a central - charge generalization of the superactions described in @xcite .","it suggests that there is an even - dimensional submanifold of the central charge superspace naturally associated with the vector - tensor multiplet .","central charge superspace has recently also been considered in @xcite and used to rederive the usual gauge supermultiplet .","also , we want to point out that there is a strong relationship between the theory of @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions and four - dimensional , @xmath0 central charge superspace . indeed , the superfield equations of motion in the six - dimensional theory motivated the choice of one important constraint equation in four - dimensional central charge superspace .","in this sense , our constraint can be understood as a superfield realization of the dimensional reduction by legendre transformation discussed in @xcite ."],["we start by briefly recapitulating the relevant formulae of @xmath0 superspace . throughout the paper","we will use the conventions of @xcite .","the @xmath0 supersymmetry algebra is obtained from the poincar algebra by adding four fermionic operators @xmath2 ( @xmath3 and @xmath4 ) and their anti - hermitian conjugates @xmath5 .","moreover the algebra admits one complex `` central charge '' @xmath6 where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are hermitian .","these operators satisfy the following anticommutation relations : @xmath9 where @xmath10 are the four - momenta and @xmath11 .","the automorphism group of algebra is @xmath12 where the @xmath13 acts on the @xmath14 index in @xmath2 .","the antisymmetric tensor @xmath15 with @xmath16 provides an invariant metric for raising and lowering the @xmath13 indices by @xmath17 and @xmath18 .","@xmath0 superspace is a space with coordinates @xmath19 where @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 are commuting bosonic coordinates while @xmath23 and @xmath24 are anticommuting fermionic coordinates .","a superfield @xmath25 is a function of the superspace coordinates , @xmath26 .","taylor - series expansion of a general superfield @xmath25 in the @xmath27 coordinates terminates after a finite number of terms due to the anticommuting nature of @xmath27 . on the other hand",", the expansion in @xmath21 and @xmath28 never ends .","this means there are an infinite number of component fields ( functions of the spacetime coordinates @xmath20 ) in a general superfield .","this infinite number of component fields can be reduced to a finite number either off - shell , by applying appropriate constraints , or on - shell , by choosing equations of motion which propagate only a finite number of component fields .","translations in the superspace are generated by the supercovariant differential operators @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 where @xmath33 .","it is straightforward to compute the anticommutation relations for these operators .","they are @xmath34 by construction @xmath35 and @xmath36 anticommute with @xmath37 and @xmath38 and so can be used to impose supersymmetric covariant conditions on superfields .","the supervielbein @xmath39 of the @xmath0 superspace is defined as the matrix that relates the supercovariant derivatives @xmath40 and the ordinary partial derivatives @xmath41 the matrix @xmath42 is the inverse of @xmath39 .","these two matrices define the geometry of the @xmath0 superspace .","the torsion @xmath43 is defined as the exterior derivative of the supervielbein one - form @xmath44 , @xmath45 the non - vanishing components of the torsion are found to be @xmath46"],["in this section we give a geometrical superfield formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet .","we begin by considering the usual geometrical form of super - gauge theory , though in superspace with central charge .","we then find a suitable set of constraints on the superfield strength to reproduce the field content of the vector - tensor multiplet .","restricting our attention to abelian gauge theories , let us introduce a hermitian connection @xmath47 .","the hermiticity of the connection implies @xmath48 where @xmath49 is real , @xmath50 , and @xmath51 .","the curvature two - form is defined as @xmath52 the coefficient functions @xmath53 comprise thirteen lorentz - covariant types .","the ones that contain torsion terms are given by @xmath54 the curvature tensor @xmath55 is subject to the bianchi identities @xmath56 or equivalently @xmath57 each tensor component of the curvature tensor is an @xmath0 superfield which , in turn , has an infinite number of component fields .","all but a finite number of these component fields must be eliminated by virtue of appropriate constraints .","these constraints must be lorentz , gauge , and supersymmetric covariant .","it is natural to adopt a set of constraints which set the pure spinorial part of the curvature tensor to zero . that is @xmath58 before imposing further conditions","we would like to explore the consequences of . to do so we must solve the bianchi identities subject to these constraints .","the result is that all the components of the curvature tensor @xmath59 are determined in terms of a single superfield @xmath60 and its hermitian conjugate @xmath61 .","henceforth , we denote these superfields by @xmath62 and @xmath63 . in particular @xmath64 and @xmath65 furthermore , @xmath62 is constrained to satisfy @xmath66 } = - \\epsilon^{\\dot\\alpha\\dot\\beta } \\bar d_{\\dot\\alpha}^{[i } \\bar w_{\\dot\\beta}^{j ] } , \\label{3 } \\\\ & \\epsilon^{\\alpha\\beta } d_\\alpha^{(i } w_\\beta^{j ) } = \\epsilon^{\\dot\\alpha\\dot\\beta } \\bar d_{\\dot\\alpha}^{(i } \\bar w_{\\dot\\beta}^{j)}. \\label{4}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] let us explore the consequences of on the field content of @xmath62 .","the expansion of @xmath62 in the anti - commuting coordinates has the general form @xmath67 it is obvious that conditions will not impose any restriction on @xmath68 .","first we consider the implications of the lowest component of superfield constraints . condition implies that @xmath69 where @xmath70 and @xmath71 .","conditions and further implies the reality condition @xmath72 and @xmath73 where @xmath74 .","condition yields @xmath75 higher components of the superfield constraint ","imply further conditions on the fields @xmath76 , @xmath77 , and @xmath78 . one way to realize these conditions is to note that , from equations , , and , @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath81 .","the equations are the general solution of the bianchi identities subject to our constraints .","three of the bianchi identities they satisfy are @xmath82 taking the lowest component of equation gives rise to @xmath83 so that @xmath84 is the field strength of a gauge field @xmath85 .","that is @xmath86 the lowest components of and give @xmath87 } & = - \\tfrac12 ( \\partial_z + \\partial_{\\bar z } ) \\mathscript f_{ab } , \\\\ \\partial_{[a } h^i_{b ] } & = - \\tfrac12 i ( \\partial_z-\\partial_{\\bar z } ) \\mathscript f_{ab } , \\label{h1 } \\\\","\\partial_a d & = - \\tfrac14 i \\left\\ { ( \\partial_z-\\partial_{\\bar z } ) h_a^r + i ( \\partial_z + \\partial_{\\bar z } ) h_a^i \\right\\ } , \\label{temp11}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] where @xmath88 .","this is as far as we can go using solely the constraints .","so far we have the following component fields : an @xmath13 doublet of spinors @xmath89 , a real gauge field @xmath85 , a complex vector field @xmath90 , a real scalar @xmath78 and a real @xmath13 triplet of scalars @xmath91 .","we would like to impose further constraints to reduce the number of fields to an irreducible multiplet .","as we will show very shortly , it is possible to impose further constraints to ensure that the real and imaginary parts of @xmath90 are each field strengths , one of an anti - symmetric tensor and the other of a scalar .","what about the fields @xmath78 and @xmath91 ?","we will find that @xmath78 and @xmath91 play the role of auxiliary fields .","note that the usual @xmath0 gauge multiplet has a triplet of auxiliary fields .","hence , if we want to derive the usual gauge multiplet we are led to set @xmath78 to zero by promoting the constraint to the stronger one @xmath92 } = 0 , \\qquad \\epsilon^{\\dot\\alpha\\dot\\beta } \\bar d_{\\dot\\alpha}^{[i } \\bar w_{\\dot\\beta}^{j ] } = 0.\\ ] ] on the other hand , if we want to derive the vector - tensor multiplet , which has a single auxiliary field , we must eliminate @xmath91 .","this can be achieved by promoting condition to the stronger condition @xmath93 henceforth , we add condition as a further constraint on the theory .","now let us proceed using conditions as well as the stronger version of , constraint .","apart from eliminating @xmath91 , it can be shown that the consequences of imposing are @xmath94 we note that the conditions obtained so far on @xmath90 given in and are not sufficient to render the real and imaginary components of @xmath90 as field strengths .","we would like , therefore , to impose yet another , and final , constraint that will achieve this goal .","we take a reality condition on the central charge @xmath95 this means that superfield @xmath62 , and hence all the curvature tensor components , depend on the two central charges @xmath21 and @xmath96 only through the combination @xmath97 with no dependence on @xmath98 .","substituting from constraint into and immediately gives the following constraints on the real and imaginary components of @xmath90 @xmath99}^i = 0 . \\label{t5}\\ ] ] these equations achieve just the goal we were aiming for .","they assert that @xmath100 and @xmath101 are field strengths of an anti - symmetric tensor and a scalar field respectively .","that is @xmath102 in conclusion , we find that the component fields in @xmath62 are exactly those of the vector - tensor multiplet , namely @xmath103 . it will not have escaped the readers notice that these fields are actually functions of the central charge coordinates as well as the spacetime coordinates . however , by virtue of constraint , they depend on the central charge coordinates only via @xmath104 .","let us introduce a real central charge coordinate @xmath105 .","moreover , the dependence of these fields on @xmath106 is highly restricted by the conditions we derived so far .","in fact , as we now show , these conditions completely determine their dependence on @xmath106 in terms of their lowest component in their central charge expansion . to see this","let us summarize the relevant conditions in , , and derived on the bosonic fields .","they are @xmath107}^r . \\end{split } \\label{t4}\\ ] ] equations constitute a system of first - order `` differential equations '' for the @xmath108 dependence of the bosonic fields .","the general solution is completely determined in terms of the `` initial conditions '' ; that is , the values of the fields at @xmath109 , say , @xmath110 , @xmath111 , and @xmath112 .","thus in a taylor series expansion in @xmath106 each term in the series gets related to lower - order terms , so that for instance , @xmath113 with similar formulas for @xmath100 , @xmath101 , and @xmath84 .","furthermore , in the next section , we will derive the corresponding equation for the fermionic field @xmath68 ."],["in this section , we would like to derive the supersymmetry and central charge transformations of the component fields . in order to exhibit these transformations","it is necessary to compute the part of @xmath62 quadratic in the fermionic coordinates .","moreover , since all the component fields are present in the lowest and first order terms of @xmath62 , the quadratic term is sufficient for computing the supersymmetry transformations .","we have @xmath114 let us first consider the constraint equations , , and .","demanding that the linear term in @xmath27 in these equations vanish completely determines @xmath115 , @xmath116 , and @xmath117 .","we find @xmath118 we note that these terms do not involve any new fields .","they are completely given in terms of the lowest component of @xmath62 , namely @xmath68 .","we are still left with equation which is a reality condition . evaluating the linear term in , and making use of , yields the following constraint on the fermionic field @xmath68 @xmath119 where @xmath120 .","equation is the relation for the fermionic field @xmath121 corresponding to equations for the bosonic fields .","it fixes the expansion of @xmath68 in the central charge @xmath106 , leaving only the lowest component @xmath122 arbitrary .","we are now in a position to compute the supersymmetry transformation of the different component fields .","to do this we have to act on @xmath62 with @xmath123 we find @xmath124 } + 2 \\xi_\\alpha^i d + \\tfrac{i}{3 } \\bar\\xi^{\\dot\\alpha i } { { \\smash{{\\sigma}^{a}}_{\\alpha\\dot\\alpha } } } \\epsilon_{abcd } \\partial^b b^{cd } - 2 { { \\smash{{\\sigma}^{a}}_{\\alpha\\dot\\alpha } } } \\bar\\xi^{\\dot\\alpha } \\partial_a \\phi . \\end{split } \\label{susy}\\ ] ] note that the fields in these supersymmetry transformations are formally functions of both @xmath20 and @xmath106 .","we have already shown that the only independent components of these fields are the lowest order terms in @xmath106 .","further , transformations do not mix component fields from different orders in @xmath106 .","thus equations also express the variations of the lowest - order independent fields , which are functions of @xmath20 only . to get the central charge transformations we have to act with @xmath125 on @xmath62 .","it is straightforward to get the following set of transformations @xmath126 expressions and reproduce the supersymmetry and central charge transformations of the vector - tensor multiplet given in the component field calculations of @xcite .","they are a realization of the @xmath0 supersymmetry algebra with central charge .","note that as a result of our constraints , in particular , only one of the two central charges is represented nontrivially .","we now discuss how to write a superfield action for the vector - tensor multiplet .","we start by noting that the relevant field strengths of the different bosonic fields occur at the linear level in @xmath62 . to get a quadratic expression in these field strengths",", we have to consider expressions quadratic in @xmath62 .","these expressions can contain both @xmath35 and @xmath36 .","contracting the indices to get a proper lorentz invariant lagrangian implies that there must be an even number of @xmath78 s .","in such an expression , the relevant terms will occur at @xmath127 level if it involves no derivatives or the lowest component if it involves two derivatives . in the former case we will have to integrate over two @xmath27 s only .","but in contrast to the chiral space for @xmath1 supersymmetry , there is no two - dimensional subspace of the @xmath0 superspace over which supersymmetry is represented .","hence , we are forced to consider expressions quadratic in @xmath62 with two supersymmetric covariant derivatives , and to integrate over spacetime only .","in fact , we find that the free lagrangian for all the component fields is contained in the lowest component of @xmath128 to be precise , we have @xmath129 it is straightforward to verify that lagrangian is invariant under supersymmetry transformations up to a total divergence .","although this implies that it must be invariant under central charge transformation as well , since the latter is equivalent to two successive supersymmetry transformations , one can check directly that it is indeed invariant under up to a total divergence .","this invariance of the lowest component of the lagrangian under central charge and supersymmetry transformations , in fact , implies that the higher components are spacetime total divergences . to show this","let us consider first the invariance under central charge transformation . since the lagrangian transforms by a total divergence under a single central charge transformation , it must does so under @xmath130 such transformations .","that is @xmath131 put another way , all the coefficients in the @xmath106 expansion of @xmath132 but the lowest one are , in fact , spacetime total divergences .","therefore we have @xmath133 although a little involved we can extend this proof to the expansion in @xmath27 as well .","that is , it can be shown that @xmath134 we would like to stress that this is completely general .","if the lowest component of a superfield is supersymmetric invariant up to a spacetime total divergence , all the higher components in @xmath106 as well as @xmath27 are spacetime total divergences .","this has the immediate consequence that a spacetime integral of this superfield will single out the lowest component . in other words","we can write down the following superfield expression for the invariant action @xmath135 this represents a central charge generalization of the type of superactions considered in @xcite .","this completes our study of the superfield formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet ."],["we conclude by briefly mentioning the connection between the superspace formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet and @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions . the presence of central charge led us to augment @xmath0 superspace by two new bosonic coordinates , @xmath21 and @xmath96 .","the resulting space , with six bosonic coordinates , is actually none - other than the superspace of @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions ( though with the fermionic coordinates treated slightly unconventionally , being formulated as a pair of @xmath13 majorana - weyl spinors @xcite ) .","the introduction of a connection @xmath136 in the central charge superspace then mirrors the formulation of supersymmetric gauge theory in six dimensions .","in fact our first set of constraints are precisely those used for the six - dimensional vector multiplet @xcite . to obtain the vector - tensor multiplet we imposed two further constraints .","the first condition still has a six - dimensional interpretation : it corresponds to the on - shell condition for the six- dimensional vector multiplet .","it is important to note that this does not imply that the multiplet is on - shell in four - dimensions .","instead it implies a relationship between the derivatives of the component fields in the internal @xmath21@xmath137 directions and in the four - dimensional @xmath138 directions , as shown in equation .","the second condition breaks the six - dimensional lorentz symmetry .","it forces the superfield to be independent of one of the internal @xmath21@xmath137 directions .","as we have shown , together these conditions are sufficient to completely determine the dependence of the multiplet on the central charge coordinates .","the connection to the component formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet given by sohnius _","@xcite now also becomes clear .","the second condition is a conventional dimensional reduction of the six- dimensional vector multiplet down to five - dimensions .","the first condition , corresponding to an on - shell condition in six- dimensions , reproduces the `` dimensional reduction by legendre transform '' from five to four dimensions .","a superspace formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet allows a number of further issues to be addressed .","first is the question of duality . on shell , the usual vector multiplet and the vector - tensor multiplet","describe the same degrees of freedom . from the @xmath1 point of view , one is the dual of the other since the chiral multiplet in the usual vector multiplet is dual to the tensor multiplet in the vector - tensor multiplet .","central charge superspace should provide a realization of this duality in a manifestly @xmath0 supersymmetric way .","a related question is to find an unconstrained @xmath0 prepotential for the vector - tensor multiplet .","we also note that the form of the multiplet described here has been explicitly non - interacting .","however , the superspace formalism also allows the description of non - abelian multiplets as well as multiplets with gauged central charge and chern - simons terms as have been discussed in components in @xcite .","it is also pertinent to the discussion of the most general form of the action for the vector - tensor multiplet .","finally the central charge superspace can be used to give a superfield description of other exotic @xmath0 multiplets , in particular the tensor and double - tensor multiplets mentioned in @xcite .","we leave the discussion of these issues to future publications ."],["this work was supported in part by doe grant no . de - fg02 - 95er40893 and nato grand no",". crg-940784 ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"it has long been known that there is an @xmath0 supermultiplet which , with respect to @xmath1 supersymmetry , appears as a combination of one vector and one chiral multiplet @xcite .\",\n \"this supermultiplet is irreducible under @xmath0 supersymmetry and carries vanishing central charge .\",\n \"it is usually referred to as the vector supermultiplet .\",\n \"not long after its introduction , it was realized that there exists a variant , the vector - tensor multiplet , which , under @xmath1 supersymmetry , appears as a combination of one vector and one linear multiplet @xcite .\",\n \"this variant is irreducible under @xmath0 and , in contrast , carries non - vanishing central charge off - shell . on shell\",\n \"it is equivalent to the vector multiplet .\",\n \"this multiplet was originally constructed using component field techniques @xcite , and it and its properties have received little attention . recently , however , within the context of trying to understand the consequences of @xmath0 duality in superstrings , the vector - tensor multiplet has re - emerged . specifically , when heterotic string theory is reduced to an @xmath0 theory in four dimensions the dilaton and the antisymmetric tensor field lie in a vector - tensor multiplet @xcite .\",\n \"it is clear from this work that the vector - tensor supermultiplet is fundamental in heterotic theories and that elucidation of its properties , such as its behavior under duality transformations , is of importance .\",\n \"the coupling of the vector - tensor multiplet to supergravity has also recently been considered @xcite .\",\n \"it was shown that this requires the gauging of the central charge , leading to a chern - simons coupling between the vector - tensor multiplet and a vector multiplet .\",\n \"if one wants to fully understand the complete , off - shell structure of the tensor - vector multiplet , one powerful approach is to construct the appropriate @xmath0 superfield .\",\n \"it is the purpose of this paper to provide such a formulation .\",\n \"much of the interesting structure of the vector - tensor multiplet appears in its couplings to other multiplets @xcite . here , however , we will restrict ourselves to a superfield formulation of the free abelian case , leaving interacting generalization to future publications .\",\n \"since the vector - tensor supermultiplet has non - zero central charge , it is necessary to expand the usual superspace .\",\n \"the maximal central extension of the @xmath0 superalgebra has two central charges .\",\n \"consequently the corresponding superspace has two extra bosonic coordinates @xcite .\",\n \"working in this superspace , one can introduce superfields and covariant constraints .\",\n \"following the geometrical formulation of supergauge fields , we introduce a super - connection and the associated curvature .\",\n \"we then introduce the appropriate constraints , solve the bianchi identities and show how the component fields of the tensor - vector multiplet emerge . using superspace techniques we rederive the supersymmetry and central charge transformations and , after showing that there exist a lagrangian superfield in central charge superspace , the higher components of which are all total derivatives\",\n \", we give the superfield and component actions .\",\n \"the existence of a superfield lagrangian is an example of a central - charge generalization of the superactions described in @xcite .\",\n \"it suggests that there is an even - dimensional submanifold of the central charge superspace naturally associated with the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"central charge superspace has recently also been considered in @xcite and used to rederive the usual gauge supermultiplet .\",\n \"also , we want to point out that there is a strong relationship between the theory of @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions and four - dimensional , @xmath0 central charge superspace . indeed , the superfield equations of motion in the six - dimensional theory motivated the choice of one important constraint equation in four - dimensional central charge superspace .\",\n \"in this sense , our constraint can be understood as a superfield realization of the dimensional reduction by legendre transformation discussed in @xcite .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we start by briefly recapitulating the relevant formulae of @xmath0 superspace . throughout the paper\",\n \"we will use the conventions of @xcite .\",\n \"the @xmath0 supersymmetry algebra is obtained from the poincar algebra by adding four fermionic operators @xmath2 ( @xmath3 and @xmath4 ) and their anti - hermitian conjugates @xmath5 .\",\n \"moreover the algebra admits one complex `` central charge '' @xmath6 where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are hermitian .\",\n \"these operators satisfy the following anticommutation relations : @xmath9 where @xmath10 are the four - momenta and @xmath11 .\",\n \"the automorphism group of algebra is @xmath12 where the @xmath13 acts on the @xmath14 index in @xmath2 .\",\n \"the antisymmetric tensor @xmath15 with @xmath16 provides an invariant metric for raising and lowering the @xmath13 indices by @xmath17 and @xmath18 .\",\n \"@xmath0 superspace is a space with coordinates @xmath19 where @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 are commuting bosonic coordinates while @xmath23 and @xmath24 are anticommuting fermionic coordinates .\",\n \"a superfield @xmath25 is a function of the superspace coordinates , @xmath26 .\",\n \"taylor - series expansion of a general superfield @xmath25 in the @xmath27 coordinates terminates after a finite number of terms due to the anticommuting nature of @xmath27 . on the other hand\",\n \", the expansion in @xmath21 and @xmath28 never ends .\",\n \"this means there are an infinite number of component fields ( functions of the spacetime coordinates @xmath20 ) in a general superfield .\",\n \"this infinite number of component fields can be reduced to a finite number either off - shell , by applying appropriate constraints , or on - shell , by choosing equations of motion which propagate only a finite number of component fields .\",\n \"translations in the superspace are generated by the supercovariant differential operators @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 where @xmath33 .\",\n \"it is straightforward to compute the anticommutation relations for these operators .\",\n \"they are @xmath34 by construction @xmath35 and @xmath36 anticommute with @xmath37 and @xmath38 and so can be used to impose supersymmetric covariant conditions on superfields .\",\n \"the supervielbein @xmath39 of the @xmath0 superspace is defined as the matrix that relates the supercovariant derivatives @xmath40 and the ordinary partial derivatives @xmath41 the matrix @xmath42 is the inverse of @xmath39 .\",\n \"these two matrices define the geometry of the @xmath0 superspace .\",\n \"the torsion @xmath43 is defined as the exterior derivative of the supervielbein one - form @xmath44 , @xmath45 the non - vanishing components of the torsion are found to be @xmath46\"\n ],\n [\n \"in this section we give a geometrical superfield formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"we begin by considering the usual geometrical form of super - gauge theory , though in superspace with central charge .\",\n \"we then find a suitable set of constraints on the superfield strength to reproduce the field content of the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"restricting our attention to abelian gauge theories , let us introduce a hermitian connection @xmath47 .\",\n \"the hermiticity of the connection implies @xmath48 where @xmath49 is real , @xmath50 , and @xmath51 .\",\n \"the curvature two - form is defined as @xmath52 the coefficient functions @xmath53 comprise thirteen lorentz - covariant types .\",\n \"the ones that contain torsion terms are given by @xmath54 the curvature tensor @xmath55 is subject to the bianchi identities @xmath56 or equivalently @xmath57 each tensor component of the curvature tensor is an @xmath0 superfield which , in turn , has an infinite number of component fields .\",\n \"all but a finite number of these component fields must be eliminated by virtue of appropriate constraints .\",\n \"these constraints must be lorentz , gauge , and supersymmetric covariant .\",\n \"it is natural to adopt a set of constraints which set the pure spinorial part of the curvature tensor to zero . that is @xmath58 before imposing further conditions\",\n \"we would like to explore the consequences of . to do so we must solve the bianchi identities subject to these constraints .\",\n \"the result is that all the components of the curvature tensor @xmath59 are determined in terms of a single superfield @xmath60 and its hermitian conjugate @xmath61 .\",\n \"henceforth , we denote these superfields by @xmath62 and @xmath63 . in particular @xmath64 and @xmath65 furthermore , @xmath62 is constrained to satisfy @xmath66 } = - \\\\epsilon^{\\\\dot\\\\alpha\\\\dot\\\\beta } \\\\bar d_{\\\\dot\\\\alpha}^{[i } \\\\bar w_{\\\\dot\\\\beta}^{j ] } , \\\\label{3 } \\\\\\\\ & \\\\epsilon^{\\\\alpha\\\\beta } d_\\\\alpha^{(i } w_\\\\beta^{j ) } = \\\\epsilon^{\\\\dot\\\\alpha\\\\dot\\\\beta } \\\\bar d_{\\\\dot\\\\alpha}^{(i } \\\\bar w_{\\\\dot\\\\beta}^{j)}. \\\\label{4}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] let us explore the consequences of on the field content of @xmath62 .\",\n \"the expansion of @xmath62 in the anti - commuting coordinates has the general form @xmath67 it is obvious that conditions will not impose any restriction on @xmath68 .\",\n \"first we consider the implications of the lowest component of superfield constraints . condition implies that @xmath69 where @xmath70 and @xmath71 .\",\n \"conditions and further implies the reality condition @xmath72 and @xmath73 where @xmath74 .\",\n \"condition yields @xmath75 higher components of the superfield constraint \",\n \"imply further conditions on the fields @xmath76 , @xmath77 , and @xmath78 . one way to realize these conditions is to note that , from equations , , and , @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath81 .\",\n \"the equations are the general solution of the bianchi identities subject to our constraints .\",\n \"three of the bianchi identities they satisfy are @xmath82 taking the lowest component of equation gives rise to @xmath83 so that @xmath84 is the field strength of a gauge field @xmath85 .\",\n \"that is @xmath86 the lowest components of and give @xmath87 } & = - \\\\tfrac12 ( \\\\partial_z + \\\\partial_{\\\\bar z } ) \\\\mathscript f_{ab } , \\\\\\\\ \\\\partial_{[a } h^i_{b ] } & = - \\\\tfrac12 i ( \\\\partial_z-\\\\partial_{\\\\bar z } ) \\\\mathscript f_{ab } , \\\\label{h1 } \\\\\\\\\",\n \"\\\\partial_a d & = - \\\\tfrac14 i \\\\left\\\\ { ( \\\\partial_z-\\\\partial_{\\\\bar z } ) h_a^r + i ( \\\\partial_z + \\\\partial_{\\\\bar z } ) h_a^i \\\\right\\\\ } , \\\\label{temp11}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath88 .\",\n \"this is as far as we can go using solely the constraints .\",\n \"so far we have the following component fields : an @xmath13 doublet of spinors @xmath89 , a real gauge field @xmath85 , a complex vector field @xmath90 , a real scalar @xmath78 and a real @xmath13 triplet of scalars @xmath91 .\",\n \"we would like to impose further constraints to reduce the number of fields to an irreducible multiplet .\",\n \"as we will show very shortly , it is possible to impose further constraints to ensure that the real and imaginary parts of @xmath90 are each field strengths , one of an anti - symmetric tensor and the other of a scalar .\",\n \"what about the fields @xmath78 and @xmath91 ?\",\n \"we will find that @xmath78 and @xmath91 play the role of auxiliary fields .\",\n \"note that the usual @xmath0 gauge multiplet has a triplet of auxiliary fields .\",\n \"hence , if we want to derive the usual gauge multiplet we are led to set @xmath78 to zero by promoting the constraint to the stronger one @xmath92 } = 0 , \\\\qquad \\\\epsilon^{\\\\dot\\\\alpha\\\\dot\\\\beta } \\\\bar d_{\\\\dot\\\\alpha}^{[i } \\\\bar w_{\\\\dot\\\\beta}^{j ] } = 0.\\\\ ] ] on the other hand , if we want to derive the vector - tensor multiplet , which has a single auxiliary field , we must eliminate @xmath91 .\",\n \"this can be achieved by promoting condition to the stronger condition @xmath93 henceforth , we add condition as a further constraint on the theory .\",\n \"now let us proceed using conditions as well as the stronger version of , constraint .\",\n \"apart from eliminating @xmath91 , it can be shown that the consequences of imposing are @xmath94 we note that the conditions obtained so far on @xmath90 given in and are not sufficient to render the real and imaginary components of @xmath90 as field strengths .\",\n \"we would like , therefore , to impose yet another , and final , constraint that will achieve this goal .\",\n \"we take a reality condition on the central charge @xmath95 this means that superfield @xmath62 , and hence all the curvature tensor components , depend on the two central charges @xmath21 and @xmath96 only through the combination @xmath97 with no dependence on @xmath98 .\",\n \"substituting from constraint into and immediately gives the following constraints on the real and imaginary components of @xmath90 @xmath99}^i = 0 . \\\\label{t5}\\\\ ] ] these equations achieve just the goal we were aiming for .\",\n \"they assert that @xmath100 and @xmath101 are field strengths of an anti - symmetric tensor and a scalar field respectively .\",\n \"that is @xmath102 in conclusion , we find that the component fields in @xmath62 are exactly those of the vector - tensor multiplet , namely @xmath103 . it will not have escaped the readers notice that these fields are actually functions of the central charge coordinates as well as the spacetime coordinates . however , by virtue of constraint , they depend on the central charge coordinates only via @xmath104 .\",\n \"let us introduce a real central charge coordinate @xmath105 .\",\n \"moreover , the dependence of these fields on @xmath106 is highly restricted by the conditions we derived so far .\",\n \"in fact , as we now show , these conditions completely determine their dependence on @xmath106 in terms of their lowest component in their central charge expansion . to see this\",\n \"let us summarize the relevant conditions in , , and derived on the bosonic fields .\",\n \"they are @xmath107}^r . \\\\end{split } \\\\label{t4}\\\\ ] ] equations constitute a system of first - order `` differential equations '' for the @xmath108 dependence of the bosonic fields .\",\n \"the general solution is completely determined in terms of the `` initial conditions '' ; that is , the values of the fields at @xmath109 , say , @xmath110 , @xmath111 , and @xmath112 .\",\n \"thus in a taylor series expansion in @xmath106 each term in the series gets related to lower - order terms , so that for instance , @xmath113 with similar formulas for @xmath100 , @xmath101 , and @xmath84 .\",\n \"furthermore , in the next section , we will derive the corresponding equation for the fermionic field @xmath68 .\"\n ],\n [\n \"in this section , we would like to derive the supersymmetry and central charge transformations of the component fields . in order to exhibit these transformations\",\n \"it is necessary to compute the part of @xmath62 quadratic in the fermionic coordinates .\",\n \"moreover , since all the component fields are present in the lowest and first order terms of @xmath62 , the quadratic term is sufficient for computing the supersymmetry transformations .\",\n \"we have @xmath114 let us first consider the constraint equations , , and .\",\n \"demanding that the linear term in @xmath27 in these equations vanish completely determines @xmath115 , @xmath116 , and @xmath117 .\",\n \"we find @xmath118 we note that these terms do not involve any new fields .\",\n \"they are completely given in terms of the lowest component of @xmath62 , namely @xmath68 .\",\n \"we are still left with equation which is a reality condition . evaluating the linear term in , and making use of , yields the following constraint on the fermionic field @xmath68 @xmath119 where @xmath120 .\",\n \"equation is the relation for the fermionic field @xmath121 corresponding to equations for the bosonic fields .\",\n \"it fixes the expansion of @xmath68 in the central charge @xmath106 , leaving only the lowest component @xmath122 arbitrary .\",\n \"we are now in a position to compute the supersymmetry transformation of the different component fields .\",\n \"to do this we have to act on @xmath62 with @xmath123 we find @xmath124 } + 2 \\\\xi_\\\\alpha^i d + \\\\tfrac{i}{3 } \\\\bar\\\\xi^{\\\\dot\\\\alpha i } { { \\\\smash{{\\\\sigma}^{a}}_{\\\\alpha\\\\dot\\\\alpha } } } \\\\epsilon_{abcd } \\\\partial^b b^{cd } - 2 { { \\\\smash{{\\\\sigma}^{a}}_{\\\\alpha\\\\dot\\\\alpha } } } \\\\bar\\\\xi^{\\\\dot\\\\alpha } \\\\partial_a \\\\phi . \\\\end{split } \\\\label{susy}\\\\ ] ] note that the fields in these supersymmetry transformations are formally functions of both @xmath20 and @xmath106 .\",\n \"we have already shown that the only independent components of these fields are the lowest order terms in @xmath106 .\",\n \"further , transformations do not mix component fields from different orders in @xmath106 .\",\n \"thus equations also express the variations of the lowest - order independent fields , which are functions of @xmath20 only . to get the central charge transformations we have to act with @xmath125 on @xmath62 .\",\n \"it is straightforward to get the following set of transformations @xmath126 expressions and reproduce the supersymmetry and central charge transformations of the vector - tensor multiplet given in the component field calculations of @xcite .\",\n \"they are a realization of the @xmath0 supersymmetry algebra with central charge .\",\n \"note that as a result of our constraints , in particular , only one of the two central charges is represented nontrivially .\",\n \"we now discuss how to write a superfield action for the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"we start by noting that the relevant field strengths of the different bosonic fields occur at the linear level in @xmath62 . to get a quadratic expression in these field strengths\",\n \", we have to consider expressions quadratic in @xmath62 .\",\n \"these expressions can contain both @xmath35 and @xmath36 .\",\n \"contracting the indices to get a proper lorentz invariant lagrangian implies that there must be an even number of @xmath78 s .\",\n \"in such an expression , the relevant terms will occur at @xmath127 level if it involves no derivatives or the lowest component if it involves two derivatives . in the former case we will have to integrate over two @xmath27 s only .\",\n \"but in contrast to the chiral space for @xmath1 supersymmetry , there is no two - dimensional subspace of the @xmath0 superspace over which supersymmetry is represented .\",\n \"hence , we are forced to consider expressions quadratic in @xmath62 with two supersymmetric covariant derivatives , and to integrate over spacetime only .\",\n \"in fact , we find that the free lagrangian for all the component fields is contained in the lowest component of @xmath128 to be precise , we have @xmath129 it is straightforward to verify that lagrangian is invariant under supersymmetry transformations up to a total divergence .\",\n \"although this implies that it must be invariant under central charge transformation as well , since the latter is equivalent to two successive supersymmetry transformations , one can check directly that it is indeed invariant under up to a total divergence .\",\n \"this invariance of the lowest component of the lagrangian under central charge and supersymmetry transformations , in fact , implies that the higher components are spacetime total divergences . to show this\",\n \"let us consider first the invariance under central charge transformation . since the lagrangian transforms by a total divergence under a single central charge transformation , it must does so under @xmath130 such transformations .\",\n \"that is @xmath131 put another way , all the coefficients in the @xmath106 expansion of @xmath132 but the lowest one are , in fact , spacetime total divergences .\",\n \"therefore we have @xmath133 although a little involved we can extend this proof to the expansion in @xmath27 as well .\",\n \"that is , it can be shown that @xmath134 we would like to stress that this is completely general .\",\n \"if the lowest component of a superfield is supersymmetric invariant up to a spacetime total divergence , all the higher components in @xmath106 as well as @xmath27 are spacetime total divergences .\",\n \"this has the immediate consequence that a spacetime integral of this superfield will single out the lowest component . in other words\",\n \"we can write down the following superfield expression for the invariant action @xmath135 this represents a central charge generalization of the type of superactions considered in @xcite .\",\n \"this completes our study of the superfield formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we conclude by briefly mentioning the connection between the superspace formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet and @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions . the presence of central charge led us to augment @xmath0 superspace by two new bosonic coordinates , @xmath21 and @xmath96 .\",\n \"the resulting space , with six bosonic coordinates , is actually none - other than the superspace of @xmath1 supersymmetry in six dimensions ( though with the fermionic coordinates treated slightly unconventionally , being formulated as a pair of @xmath13 majorana - weyl spinors @xcite ) .\",\n \"the introduction of a connection @xmath136 in the central charge superspace then mirrors the formulation of supersymmetric gauge theory in six dimensions .\",\n \"in fact our first set of constraints are precisely those used for the six - dimensional vector multiplet @xcite . to obtain the vector - tensor multiplet we imposed two further constraints .\",\n \"the first condition still has a six - dimensional interpretation : it corresponds to the on - shell condition for the six- dimensional vector multiplet .\",\n \"it is important to note that this does not imply that the multiplet is on - shell in four - dimensions .\",\n \"instead it implies a relationship between the derivatives of the component fields in the internal @xmath21@xmath137 directions and in the four - dimensional @xmath138 directions , as shown in equation .\",\n \"the second condition breaks the six - dimensional lorentz symmetry .\",\n \"it forces the superfield to be independent of one of the internal @xmath21@xmath137 directions .\",\n \"as we have shown , together these conditions are sufficient to completely determine the dependence of the multiplet on the central charge coordinates .\",\n \"the connection to the component formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet given by sohnius _\",\n \"@xcite now also becomes clear .\",\n \"the second condition is a conventional dimensional reduction of the six- dimensional vector multiplet down to five - dimensions .\",\n \"the first condition , corresponding to an on - shell condition in six- dimensions , reproduces the `` dimensional reduction by legendre transform '' from five to four dimensions .\",\n \"a superspace formulation of the vector - tensor multiplet allows a number of further issues to be addressed .\",\n \"first is the question of duality . on shell , the usual vector multiplet and the vector - tensor multiplet\",\n \"describe the same degrees of freedom . from the @xmath1 point of view , one is the dual of the other since the chiral multiplet in the usual vector multiplet is dual to the tensor multiplet in the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"central charge superspace should provide a realization of this duality in a manifestly @xmath0 supersymmetric way .\",\n \"a related question is to find an unconstrained @xmath0 prepotential for the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"we also note that the form of the multiplet described here has been explicitly non - interacting .\",\n \"however , the superspace formalism also allows the description of non - abelian multiplets as well as multiplets with gauged central charge and chern - simons terms as have been discussed in components in @xcite .\",\n \"it is also pertinent to the discussion of the most general form of the action for the vector - tensor multiplet .\",\n \"finally the central charge superspace can be used to give a superfield description of other exotic @xmath0 multiplets , in particular the tensor and double - tensor multiplets mentioned in @xcite .\",\n \"we leave the discussion of these issues to future publications .\"\n ],\n [\n \"this work was supported in part by doe grant no . de - fg02 - 95er40893 and nato grand no\",\n \". crg-940784 .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":82,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"1209.5999"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["the statistical toolkit @xcite was originally conceived as a statistical data analysis toolkit for the problem of comparing data distributions .","its development follows the unified software development process @xcite . according to this approach , the life - cycle of the software is iterative - incremental , every iteration representing an evolution , an improvement , an extension in comparison with the previous one .","iterations in the statistical toolkit development process are driven by the needs of its experimental applications ; practical use cases steer the implementations of new tests .","the first development cycles of the statistical toolkit implemented a set of goodness - of - fit ( gof ) tests for the two - sample problem , i.e. for the comparison of two distributions .","these developments were motivated by experimental requirements for regression testing , validation of simulation with respect to experimental data , comparison of expected versus reconstructed distributions , and more in general for the comparison of data from different sources .","new requirements have been identified , based on the experience of using the statistical toolkit in several analyses for the validation of geant4 physics models .","these projects highlighted the need for complementary functionality , beyond the problem of assessing the compatibility of two distributions .","one of the problems faced in simulation validation ( and , more in general , in the comparison of experimental distributions ) , consists in the identification of possible systematic effects : tests of randomness address this requirement .","another problem encountered in the experience with the simulation validation consists of the comparison not only of individual data distributions , but also of categories ( e.g. the evaluation of differences in the behaviour of two geant4 physics models with respect to a set of experimental test cases ) .","goodness - of - fit tests quantify the compatibility of the agreement between a set of sample observations and the the corresponding values predicted from some model of interest , or between two ( or more ) sets of observations .","the result of a goodness - of - fit test is expressed through a @xmath0-value , which represents the probability that the test statistic has a value at least as extreme as that observed , assuming the null hypothesis is true .","the collection of tests implemented in the current version of the statistical toolkit is given in table [ old_tests ] ; extensive details can be found in @xcite .","lll gof test & distribution type & ` < comparisonalgorithm > ` class + & & ` andersondarlingbinned ` + & & ` andersondarlingbinnedapproximated ` + & & ` andersondarlingunbinned ` + & & ` andersondarlingunbinnedapproximated ` + & & ` chi2 ` + & & ` chi2approximated ` + & & ` chi2integrating ` + & ` binned ` & ` cramervonmisesbinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` cramervonmisesunbinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` weightedcramervonmisesbuningunbinned ` + girone & ` unbinned ` & ` girone ` + goodman & ` unbinned ` & ` kolmogorovsmirnovapproximated ` + & & ` kolmogorovsmirnov ` + & & ` weightedadkolmogorovsmirnov ` + & & ` weightedbuningkolmogorovsmirnov ` + kuiper & ` unbinned ` & ` kuiper ` + & ` binned ` & ` tikubinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` tikuunbinned ` + watson & ` unbinned ` & ` watson ` +","an effort has been invested to provide an effective software development environment , which exploits more modern tools and facilitates the use of the statistical toolkit in a variety of computing environments . for the new development cycle subversion ( svn )","@xcite has been selected as a tool in support of the configuration and change management discipline .","the statistical toolkit code was moved to a svn repository . in order to facilitate using the statistical toolkit on a wide variety of operating systems ,","the build system has been moved to the cross platform make ( cmake ) @xcite system .","the ` ctest ` testing tool , distributed as a part of cmake , is used for unit testing . to be as self - consistent as possible ,","the number of dependencies on external software systems has been minimized .","the only essential external dependency is on the gnu scientific library @xcite .","an additional user layer was implemented to facilitate the use of the statistical toolkit in analysis environment that are concerned neither with aida @xcite nor with root @xcite analysis objects , which are supported by the two user layers available in the current version .","the new user layer allows the analyst to supply input data to the statistical toolkit in the form of comma - separated lists of values ( csv ascii files ) .","if no external dependencies are specified , this user layer is built by default .","otherwise , in properly set - up environments aida or root ( or both ) are found by ` cmake`and the corresponding user layer is built automatically .","the statistical toolkit comes with an extensive set of ` unittests ` , which are meant to test the correct implementation of the statistical tests for each new version of the statistical toolkit .","the new development cycle extends the functionality of the statistical toolkit with tests for randomness , one sample goodness - of - fit tests , i.e. comparing data to reference functions , and tests for categorical data .","table [ new_tests ] lists the new tests .","lll test & input data & class name + wald - wolfowitz & sequence of & ` waldwolfowitztwosamplesrunstest ` + runs test & signs ( -1/1 ) & ` waldwolfowitzonesamplerunstest ` + wald - wolfowitz & 1-dimensional & ` waldwolfowitzonesamplerandomnesstest ` + test of randomness & distribution & + mann - whitney @xmath1 test & 1-dimensional & ` mannwhitneytwosamplestest ` + & distribution & + fisher s exact test & @xmath2 matrix & ` fishersexact2x2test ` + @xmath3 contingency test & @xmath4 matrix & ` chi2contingencytabletest ` + @xmath3 paired test & paired values & `","chi2curvescomparisonalgorithm ` + randomness tests provide complementary information to the existing goodness of fit tests ( table [ old_tests ] ) : for instance , tests for randomness can highlight the presence of systematic effects in the distributions subject to comparison , which goodness of fit tests can not detect .","a use case is illustrated in @xcite : goodness of fit tests confirm the compatibility of various geant4 proton elastic scattering models respect to reference data , nevertheless asymmetries in the distribution of differences between the results of the simulation and reference data hint to the presence of systematic effects associated with some of the geant4 physics models .","the runs tests are statistical tests , used to test the hypothesis that the elements of the sequence are mutually independent or whether the data have some pattern .","a run is defined as a series of values of the same type ( e.g. series of increasing / decreasing values , series of true / false values , etc ) , the number of consequent values of the same type being the length of the run . as an example consider tossing a coin and noting the outcome , which is either head ( @xmath5 ) or tail ( @xmath6 ) .","a run in this example is each sequence of the same type of outcome .","both too many runs ( as in case of cyclic pattern @xmath7 , which has the maximum possible number of runs for given number of observations ) and too few runs ( where heads and tails are clustered together @xmath8 ) exhibit evidence of a non - random relationship between the order of the experiments and the outcome .","the wald - wolfowitz test from @xcite is the best known test that is based on the number of runs .","it has been proposed as a test of whether two samples are from the same population , but as such has poor power @xcite and the mann - whitney test is preferable .","the new version of the statistical toolkit ( to be released ) encompasses implementations of the the wald - wolfowitz runs test for one or two samples . when the test is used with two samples , the algorithm in @xcite is used to construct one ( binary ) sample , and results from the test for one sample are returned . to calculate the @xmath0-values , either the exact or an approximated formula","can be used .","the exact calculation of the two - tailed probability of the test statistics implemented in the statistical toolkit follows the description from @xcite , while the approximated formula takes into account that for large samples the distribution of the number of runs approaches a normal distribution .","wilcoxon @xcite published a test for comparison of two samples , based on comparison of the general size of the two samples , ranking of the ( combined ) samples and then comparing the average ranks of separate ranks .","the developments of the test followed fast and the first to publish it were mann and whitney @xcite .","the new version of the statistical toolkit implements the mann - whitney @xmath1 test and an approximated formula for the @xmath0-value calculation , again assuming that the samples are large , hence the distribution of the ranks can be described with a normal distribution .","categorical data analysis involves testing the significance of the association ( contingency ) between the groups . in practice","the number of categories is usually small ( below 20 ) , although in principle the tests for categorical data could be used for any number of groups .","the difference between the observed and the expected data , considering the given marginal and the assumptions of the model of independence , can be calculated using the @xmath3 test ( already available in the statistical toolkit ) ; however , the @xmath3 test gives only an estimate of the true probability value .","the estimate might be inaccurate in case the marginal is very uneven or if there is a small value ( less than five ) in one of the cells of the contingency table .","fisher s exact test for contingency tables @xcite is most widely known exact test for categorical data analysis .","it is calculated by generating all tables that are more extreme than the table given by the user . to get the two - tailed @xmath0-value",", the @xmath0-values of the tables that have @xmath0-values of the same size or smaller than the data table probability are added up to form the cumulative @xmath0-value , including the @xmath0-value of the data table itself .","this method becomes computationally intensive already for moderately sized tables , since the number of table probabilities to be enumerated can easily reach billions .","fisher s exact test for @xmath2 contingency tables is available in the new development version of the statistical toolkit .","an algorithm to calculate the @xmath3 test with yates continuity correction has also been implemented as part of the new development cycle .","the @xmath3 tests can be applied to general ( @xmath4 ) contingency tables , while due to computational reasons fisher s exact test is only implemented for @xmath9 tables .","the new development cycle of the statistical toolkit comes with a more versatile build system and provides the user significant extensions in testing capabilities .","the new tests extend the statistical toolkit capabilities with tests for randomness and tests for categorical data analysis .","the new user layer component makes it possible to use the toolkit with many spreadsheet applications that allow exporting data directly to comma separated list of values .","new tests , together with the new user layer , make the statistical toolkit a powerful data analysis tool for experimental physics problems concerned with data comparisons .","this paper is dedicated to the memory of the late paolo viarengo , who contributed to the previous development cycles of the statistical toolkit .","10 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 cirrone g a p , donadio s , guatelli s , mantero a , mascialino b , parlati s , pia m g , pfeiffer a , ribon a and viarengo p 2004 _ ieee trans .","sci . _ * 51 * 2056 barrand g , binko p , dnszelmann m , johnson a and pfeiffer a 2001 abstract interfaces for data analysis : component architecture for data analysis tools .","oai : cds.cern.ch:519004 tech . rep .","cern - it-2001 - 013 cern geneva"],"string":"[\n \"the statistical toolkit @xcite was originally conceived as a statistical data analysis toolkit for the problem of comparing data distributions .\",\n \"its development follows the unified software development process @xcite . according to this approach , the life - cycle of the software is iterative - incremental , every iteration representing an evolution , an improvement , an extension in comparison with the previous one .\",\n \"iterations in the statistical toolkit development process are driven by the needs of its experimental applications ; practical use cases steer the implementations of new tests .\",\n \"the first development cycles of the statistical toolkit implemented a set of goodness - of - fit ( gof ) tests for the two - sample problem , i.e. for the comparison of two distributions .\",\n \"these developments were motivated by experimental requirements for regression testing , validation of simulation with respect to experimental data , comparison of expected versus reconstructed distributions , and more in general for the comparison of data from different sources .\",\n \"new requirements have been identified , based on the experience of using the statistical toolkit in several analyses for the validation of geant4 physics models .\",\n \"these projects highlighted the need for complementary functionality , beyond the problem of assessing the compatibility of two distributions .\",\n \"one of the problems faced in simulation validation ( and , more in general , in the comparison of experimental distributions ) , consists in the identification of possible systematic effects : tests of randomness address this requirement .\",\n \"another problem encountered in the experience with the simulation validation consists of the comparison not only of individual data distributions , but also of categories ( e.g. the evaluation of differences in the behaviour of two geant4 physics models with respect to a set of experimental test cases ) .\",\n \"goodness - of - fit tests quantify the compatibility of the agreement between a set of sample observations and the the corresponding values predicted from some model of interest , or between two ( or more ) sets of observations .\",\n \"the result of a goodness - of - fit test is expressed through a @xmath0-value , which represents the probability that the test statistic has a value at least as extreme as that observed , assuming the null hypothesis is true .\",\n \"the collection of tests implemented in the current version of the statistical toolkit is given in table [ old_tests ] ; extensive details can be found in @xcite .\",\n \"lll gof test & distribution type & ` < comparisonalgorithm > ` class + & & ` andersondarlingbinned ` + & & ` andersondarlingbinnedapproximated ` + & & ` andersondarlingunbinned ` + & & ` andersondarlingunbinnedapproximated ` + & & ` chi2 ` + & & ` chi2approximated ` + & & ` chi2integrating ` + & ` binned ` & ` cramervonmisesbinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` cramervonmisesunbinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` weightedcramervonmisesbuningunbinned ` + girone & ` unbinned ` & ` girone ` + goodman & ` unbinned ` & ` kolmogorovsmirnovapproximated ` + & & ` kolmogorovsmirnov ` + & & ` weightedadkolmogorovsmirnov ` + & & ` weightedbuningkolmogorovsmirnov ` + kuiper & ` unbinned ` & ` kuiper ` + & ` binned ` & ` tikubinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` tikuunbinned ` + watson & ` unbinned ` & ` watson ` +\",\n \"an effort has been invested to provide an effective software development environment , which exploits more modern tools and facilitates the use of the statistical toolkit in a variety of computing environments . for the new development cycle subversion ( svn )\",\n \"@xcite has been selected as a tool in support of the configuration and change management discipline .\",\n \"the statistical toolkit code was moved to a svn repository . in order to facilitate using the statistical toolkit on a wide variety of operating systems ,\",\n \"the build system has been moved to the cross platform make ( cmake ) @xcite system .\",\n \"the ` ctest ` testing tool , distributed as a part of cmake , is used for unit testing . to be as self - consistent as possible ,\",\n \"the number of dependencies on external software systems has been minimized .\",\n \"the only essential external dependency is on the gnu scientific library @xcite .\",\n \"an additional user layer was implemented to facilitate the use of the statistical toolkit in analysis environment that are concerned neither with aida @xcite nor with root @xcite analysis objects , which are supported by the two user layers available in the current version .\",\n \"the new user layer allows the analyst to supply input data to the statistical toolkit in the form of comma - separated lists of values ( csv ascii files ) .\",\n \"if no external dependencies are specified , this user layer is built by default .\",\n \"otherwise , in properly set - up environments aida or root ( or both ) are found by ` cmake`and the corresponding user layer is built automatically .\",\n \"the statistical toolkit comes with an extensive set of ` unittests ` , which are meant to test the correct implementation of the statistical tests for each new version of the statistical toolkit .\",\n \"the new development cycle extends the functionality of the statistical toolkit with tests for randomness , one sample goodness - of - fit tests , i.e. comparing data to reference functions , and tests for categorical data .\",\n \"table [ new_tests ] lists the new tests .\",\n \"lll test & input data & class name + wald - wolfowitz & sequence of & ` waldwolfowitztwosamplesrunstest ` + runs test & signs ( -1/1 ) & ` waldwolfowitzonesamplerunstest ` + wald - wolfowitz & 1-dimensional & ` waldwolfowitzonesamplerandomnesstest ` + test of randomness & distribution & + mann - whitney @xmath1 test & 1-dimensional & ` mannwhitneytwosamplestest ` + & distribution & + fisher s exact test & @xmath2 matrix & ` fishersexact2x2test ` + @xmath3 contingency test & @xmath4 matrix & ` chi2contingencytabletest ` + @xmath3 paired test & paired values & `\",\n \"chi2curvescomparisonalgorithm ` + randomness tests provide complementary information to the existing goodness of fit tests ( table [ old_tests ] ) : for instance , tests for randomness can highlight the presence of systematic effects in the distributions subject to comparison , which goodness of fit tests can not detect .\",\n \"a use case is illustrated in @xcite : goodness of fit tests confirm the compatibility of various geant4 proton elastic scattering models respect to reference data , nevertheless asymmetries in the distribution of differences between the results of the simulation and reference data hint to the presence of systematic effects associated with some of the geant4 physics models .\",\n \"the runs tests are statistical tests , used to test the hypothesis that the elements of the sequence are mutually independent or whether the data have some pattern .\",\n \"a run is defined as a series of values of the same type ( e.g. series of increasing / decreasing values , series of true / false values , etc ) , the number of consequent values of the same type being the length of the run . as an example consider tossing a coin and noting the outcome , which is either head ( @xmath5 ) or tail ( @xmath6 ) .\",\n \"a run in this example is each sequence of the same type of outcome .\",\n \"both too many runs ( as in case of cyclic pattern @xmath7 , which has the maximum possible number of runs for given number of observations ) and too few runs ( where heads and tails are clustered together @xmath8 ) exhibit evidence of a non - random relationship between the order of the experiments and the outcome .\",\n \"the wald - wolfowitz test from @xcite is the best known test that is based on the number of runs .\",\n \"it has been proposed as a test of whether two samples are from the same population , but as such has poor power @xcite and the mann - whitney test is preferable .\",\n \"the new version of the statistical toolkit ( to be released ) encompasses implementations of the the wald - wolfowitz runs test for one or two samples . when the test is used with two samples , the algorithm in @xcite is used to construct one ( binary ) sample , and results from the test for one sample are returned . to calculate the @xmath0-values , either the exact or an approximated formula\",\n \"can be used .\",\n \"the exact calculation of the two - tailed probability of the test statistics implemented in the statistical toolkit follows the description from @xcite , while the approximated formula takes into account that for large samples the distribution of the number of runs approaches a normal distribution .\",\n \"wilcoxon @xcite published a test for comparison of two samples , based on comparison of the general size of the two samples , ranking of the ( combined ) samples and then comparing the average ranks of separate ranks .\",\n \"the developments of the test followed fast and the first to publish it were mann and whitney @xcite .\",\n \"the new version of the statistical toolkit implements the mann - whitney @xmath1 test and an approximated formula for the @xmath0-value calculation , again assuming that the samples are large , hence the distribution of the ranks can be described with a normal distribution .\",\n \"categorical data analysis involves testing the significance of the association ( contingency ) between the groups . in practice\",\n \"the number of categories is usually small ( below 20 ) , although in principle the tests for categorical data could be used for any number of groups .\",\n \"the difference between the observed and the expected data , considering the given marginal and the assumptions of the model of independence , can be calculated using the @xmath3 test ( already available in the statistical toolkit ) ; however , the @xmath3 test gives only an estimate of the true probability value .\",\n \"the estimate might be inaccurate in case the marginal is very uneven or if there is a small value ( less than five ) in one of the cells of the contingency table .\",\n \"fisher s exact test for contingency tables @xcite is most widely known exact test for categorical data analysis .\",\n \"it is calculated by generating all tables that are more extreme than the table given by the user . to get the two - tailed @xmath0-value\",\n \", the @xmath0-values of the tables that have @xmath0-values of the same size or smaller than the data table probability are added up to form the cumulative @xmath0-value , including the @xmath0-value of the data table itself .\",\n \"this method becomes computationally intensive already for moderately sized tables , since the number of table probabilities to be enumerated can easily reach billions .\",\n \"fisher s exact test for @xmath2 contingency tables is available in the new development version of the statistical toolkit .\",\n \"an algorithm to calculate the @xmath3 test with yates continuity correction has also been implemented as part of the new development cycle .\",\n \"the @xmath3 tests can be applied to general ( @xmath4 ) contingency tables , while due to computational reasons fisher s exact test is only implemented for @xmath9 tables .\",\n \"the new development cycle of the statistical toolkit comes with a more versatile build system and provides the user significant extensions in testing capabilities .\",\n \"the new tests extend the statistical toolkit capabilities with tests for randomness and tests for categorical data analysis .\",\n \"the new user layer component makes it possible to use the toolkit with many spreadsheet applications that allow exporting data directly to comma separated list of values .\",\n \"new tests , together with the new user layer , make the statistical toolkit a powerful data analysis tool for experimental physics problems concerned with data comparisons .\",\n \"this paper is dedicated to the memory of the late paolo viarengo , who contributed to the previous development cycles of the statistical toolkit .\",\n \"10 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 cirrone g a p , donadio s , guatelli s , mantero a , mascialino b , parlati s , pia m g , pfeiffer a , ribon a and viarengo p 2004 _ ieee trans .\",\n \"sci . _ * 51 * 2056 barrand g , binko p , dnszelmann m , johnson a and pfeiffer a 2001 abstract interfaces for data analysis : component architecture for data analysis tools .\",\n \"oai : cds.cern.ch:519004 tech . rep .\",\n \"cern - it-2001 - 013 cern geneva\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> the statistical toolkit is an open source system specialized in the statistical comparison of distributions . </S>","<S> it addresses requirements common to different experimental domains , such as simulation validation ( e.g. comparison of experimental and simulated distributions ) , regression testing in the course of the software development process , and detector performance monitoring . </S>","<S> various sets of statistical tests have been added to the existing collection to deal with the one sample problem ( i.e. the comparison of a data distribution to a function , including tests for normality , categorical analysis and the estimate of randomness ) . improved algorithms and software design </S>","<S> contribute to the robustness of the results . </S>","<S> a simple user layer dealing with primitive data types facilitates the use of the toolkit both in standalone analyses and in large scale experiments . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> the statistical toolkit is an open source system specialized in the statistical comparison of distributions . </S>\",\n \"<S> it addresses requirements common to different experimental domains , such as simulation validation ( e.g. comparison of experimental and simulated distributions ) , regression testing in the course of the software development process , and detector performance monitoring . </S>\",\n \"<S> various sets of statistical tests have been added to the existing collection to deal with the one sample problem ( i.e. the comparison of a data distribution to a function , including tests for normality , categorical analysis and the estimate of randomness ) . improved algorithms and software design </S>\",\n \"<S> contribute to the robustness of the results . </S>\",\n \"<S> a simple user layer dealing with primitive data types facilitates the use of the toolkit both in standalone analyses and in large scale experiments . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","overview of the current functionality of the statistical toolkit","software improvements","extension of functionality","conclusions","acknowledgment","references"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"overview of the current functionality of the statistical toolkit\",\n \"software improvements\",\n \"extension of functionality\",\n \"conclusions\",\n \"acknowledgment\",\n \"references\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["the statistical toolkit @xcite was originally conceived as a statistical data analysis toolkit for the problem of comparing data distributions .","its development follows the unified software development process @xcite . according to this approach , the life - cycle of the software is iterative - incremental , every iteration representing an evolution , an improvement , an extension in comparison with the previous one .","iterations in the statistical toolkit development process are driven by the needs of its experimental applications ; practical use cases steer the implementations of new tests .","the first development cycles of the statistical toolkit implemented a set of goodness - of - fit ( gof ) tests for the two - sample problem , i.e. for the comparison of two distributions .","these developments were motivated by experimental requirements for regression testing , validation of simulation with respect to experimental data , comparison of expected versus reconstructed distributions , and more in general for the comparison of data from different sources .","new requirements have been identified , based on the experience of using the statistical toolkit in several analyses for the validation of geant4 physics models .","these projects highlighted the need for complementary functionality , beyond the problem of assessing the compatibility of two distributions .","one of the problems faced in simulation validation ( and , more in general , in the comparison of experimental distributions ) , consists in the identification of possible systematic effects : tests of randomness address this requirement .","another problem encountered in the experience with the simulation validation consists of the comparison not only of individual data distributions , but also of categories ( e.g. the evaluation of differences in the behaviour of two geant4 physics models with respect to a set of experimental test cases ) ."],["goodness - of - fit tests quantify the compatibility of the agreement between a set of sample observations and the the corresponding values predicted from some model of interest , or between two ( or more ) sets of observations .","the result of a goodness - of - fit test is expressed through a @xmath0-value , which represents the probability that the test statistic has a value at least as extreme as that observed , assuming the null hypothesis is true .","the collection of tests implemented in the current version of the statistical toolkit is given in table [ old_tests ] ; extensive details can be found in @xcite .","lll gof test & distribution type & ` < comparisonalgorithm > ` class + & & ` andersondarlingbinned ` + & & ` andersondarlingbinnedapproximated ` + & & ` andersondarlingunbinned ` + & & ` andersondarlingunbinnedapproximated ` + & & ` chi2 ` + & & ` chi2approximated ` + & & ` chi2integrating ` + & ` binned ` & ` cramervonmisesbinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` cramervonmisesunbinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` weightedcramervonmisesbuningunbinned ` + girone & ` unbinned ` & ` girone ` + goodman & ` unbinned ` & ` kolmogorovsmirnovapproximated ` + & & ` kolmogorovsmirnov ` + & & ` weightedadkolmogorovsmirnov ` + & & ` weightedbuningkolmogorovsmirnov ` + kuiper & ` unbinned ` & ` kuiper ` + & ` binned ` & ` tikubinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` tikuunbinned ` + watson & ` unbinned ` & ` watson ` +"],["an effort has been invested to provide an effective software development environment , which exploits more modern tools and facilitates the use of the statistical toolkit in a variety of computing environments . for the new development cycle subversion ( svn )","@xcite has been selected as a tool in support of the configuration and change management discipline .","the statistical toolkit code was moved to a svn repository . in order to facilitate using the statistical toolkit on a wide variety of operating systems ,","the build system has been moved to the cross platform make ( cmake ) @xcite system .","the ` ctest ` testing tool , distributed as a part of cmake , is used for unit testing . to be as self - consistent as possible ,","the number of dependencies on external software systems has been minimized .","the only essential external dependency is on the gnu scientific library @xcite .","an additional user layer was implemented to facilitate the use of the statistical toolkit in analysis environment that are concerned neither with aida @xcite nor with root @xcite analysis objects , which are supported by the two user layers available in the current version .","the new user layer allows the analyst to supply input data to the statistical toolkit in the form of comma - separated lists of values ( csv ascii files ) .","if no external dependencies are specified , this user layer is built by default .","otherwise , in properly set - up environments aida or root ( or both ) are found by ` cmake`and the corresponding user layer is built automatically .","the statistical toolkit comes with an extensive set of ` unittests ` , which are meant to test the correct implementation of the statistical tests for each new version of the statistical toolkit ."],["the new development cycle extends the functionality of the statistical toolkit with tests for randomness , one sample goodness - of - fit tests , i.e. comparing data to reference functions , and tests for categorical data .","table [ new_tests ] lists the new tests .","lll test & input data & class name + wald - wolfowitz & sequence of & ` waldwolfowitztwosamplesrunstest ` + runs test & signs ( -1/1 ) & ` waldwolfowitzonesamplerunstest ` + wald - wolfowitz & 1-dimensional & ` waldwolfowitzonesamplerandomnesstest ` + test of randomness & distribution & + mann - whitney @xmath1 test & 1-dimensional & ` mannwhitneytwosamplestest ` + & distribution & + fisher s exact test & @xmath2 matrix & ` fishersexact2x2test ` + @xmath3 contingency test & @xmath4 matrix & ` chi2contingencytabletest ` + @xmath3 paired test & paired values & `","chi2curvescomparisonalgorithm ` + randomness tests provide complementary information to the existing goodness of fit tests ( table [ old_tests ] ) : for instance , tests for randomness can highlight the presence of systematic effects in the distributions subject to comparison , which goodness of fit tests can not detect .","a use case is illustrated in @xcite : goodness of fit tests confirm the compatibility of various geant4 proton elastic scattering models respect to reference data , nevertheless asymmetries in the distribution of differences between the results of the simulation and reference data hint to the presence of systematic effects associated with some of the geant4 physics models .","the runs tests are statistical tests , used to test the hypothesis that the elements of the sequence are mutually independent or whether the data have some pattern .","a run is defined as a series of values of the same type ( e.g. series of increasing / decreasing values , series of true / false values , etc ) , the number of consequent values of the same type being the length of the run . as an example consider tossing a coin and noting the outcome , which is either head ( @xmath5 ) or tail ( @xmath6 ) .","a run in this example is each sequence of the same type of outcome .","both too many runs ( as in case of cyclic pattern @xmath7 , which has the maximum possible number of runs for given number of observations ) and too few runs ( where heads and tails are clustered together @xmath8 ) exhibit evidence of a non - random relationship between the order of the experiments and the outcome .","the wald - wolfowitz test from @xcite is the best known test that is based on the number of runs .","it has been proposed as a test of whether two samples are from the same population , but as such has poor power @xcite and the mann - whitney test is preferable .","the new version of the statistical toolkit ( to be released ) encompasses implementations of the the wald - wolfowitz runs test for one or two samples . when the test is used with two samples , the algorithm in @xcite is used to construct one ( binary ) sample , and results from the test for one sample are returned . to calculate the @xmath0-values , either the exact or an approximated formula","can be used .","the exact calculation of the two - tailed probability of the test statistics implemented in the statistical toolkit follows the description from @xcite , while the approximated formula takes into account that for large samples the distribution of the number of runs approaches a normal distribution .","wilcoxon @xcite published a test for comparison of two samples , based on comparison of the general size of the two samples , ranking of the ( combined ) samples and then comparing the average ranks of separate ranks .","the developments of the test followed fast and the first to publish it were mann and whitney @xcite .","the new version of the statistical toolkit implements the mann - whitney @xmath1 test and an approximated formula for the @xmath0-value calculation , again assuming that the samples are large , hence the distribution of the ranks can be described with a normal distribution .","categorical data analysis involves testing the significance of the association ( contingency ) between the groups . in practice","the number of categories is usually small ( below 20 ) , although in principle the tests for categorical data could be used for any number of groups .","the difference between the observed and the expected data , considering the given marginal and the assumptions of the model of independence , can be calculated using the @xmath3 test ( already available in the statistical toolkit ) ; however , the @xmath3 test gives only an estimate of the true probability value .","the estimate might be inaccurate in case the marginal is very uneven or if there is a small value ( less than five ) in one of the cells of the contingency table .","fisher s exact test for contingency tables @xcite is most widely known exact test for categorical data analysis .","it is calculated by generating all tables that are more extreme than the table given by the user . to get the two - tailed @xmath0-value",", the @xmath0-values of the tables that have @xmath0-values of the same size or smaller than the data table probability are added up to form the cumulative @xmath0-value , including the @xmath0-value of the data table itself .","this method becomes computationally intensive already for moderately sized tables , since the number of table probabilities to be enumerated can easily reach billions .","fisher s exact test for @xmath2 contingency tables is available in the new development version of the statistical toolkit .","an algorithm to calculate the @xmath3 test with yates continuity correction has also been implemented as part of the new development cycle .","the @xmath3 tests can be applied to general ( @xmath4 ) contingency tables , while due to computational reasons fisher s exact test is only implemented for @xmath9 tables ."],["the new development cycle of the statistical toolkit comes with a more versatile build system and provides the user significant extensions in testing capabilities .","the new tests extend the statistical toolkit capabilities with tests for randomness and tests for categorical data analysis .","the new user layer component makes it possible to use the toolkit with many spreadsheet applications that allow exporting data directly to comma separated list of values .","new tests , together with the new user layer , make the statistical toolkit a powerful data analysis tool for experimental physics problems concerned with data comparisons ."],["this paper is dedicated to the memory of the late paolo viarengo , who contributed to the previous development cycles of the statistical toolkit ."],["10 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 cirrone g a p , donadio s , guatelli s , mantero a , mascialino b , parlati s , pia m g , pfeiffer a , ribon a and viarengo p 2004 _ ieee trans .","sci . _ * 51 * 2056 barrand g , binko p , dnszelmann m , johnson a and pfeiffer a 2001 abstract interfaces for data analysis : component architecture for data analysis tools .","oai : cds.cern.ch:519004 tech . rep .","cern - it-2001 - 013 cern geneva"]],"string":"[\n [\n \"the statistical toolkit @xcite was originally conceived as a statistical data analysis toolkit for the problem of comparing data distributions .\",\n \"its development follows the unified software development process @xcite . according to this approach , the life - cycle of the software is iterative - incremental , every iteration representing an evolution , an improvement , an extension in comparison with the previous one .\",\n \"iterations in the statistical toolkit development process are driven by the needs of its experimental applications ; practical use cases steer the implementations of new tests .\",\n \"the first development cycles of the statistical toolkit implemented a set of goodness - of - fit ( gof ) tests for the two - sample problem , i.e. for the comparison of two distributions .\",\n \"these developments were motivated by experimental requirements for regression testing , validation of simulation with respect to experimental data , comparison of expected versus reconstructed distributions , and more in general for the comparison of data from different sources .\",\n \"new requirements have been identified , based on the experience of using the statistical toolkit in several analyses for the validation of geant4 physics models .\",\n \"these projects highlighted the need for complementary functionality , beyond the problem of assessing the compatibility of two distributions .\",\n \"one of the problems faced in simulation validation ( and , more in general , in the comparison of experimental distributions ) , consists in the identification of possible systematic effects : tests of randomness address this requirement .\",\n \"another problem encountered in the experience with the simulation validation consists of the comparison not only of individual data distributions , but also of categories ( e.g. the evaluation of differences in the behaviour of two geant4 physics models with respect to a set of experimental test cases ) .\"\n ],\n [\n \"goodness - of - fit tests quantify the compatibility of the agreement between a set of sample observations and the the corresponding values predicted from some model of interest , or between two ( or more ) sets of observations .\",\n \"the result of a goodness - of - fit test is expressed through a @xmath0-value , which represents the probability that the test statistic has a value at least as extreme as that observed , assuming the null hypothesis is true .\",\n \"the collection of tests implemented in the current version of the statistical toolkit is given in table [ old_tests ] ; extensive details can be found in @xcite .\",\n \"lll gof test & distribution type & ` < comparisonalgorithm > ` class + & & ` andersondarlingbinned ` + & & ` andersondarlingbinnedapproximated ` + & & ` andersondarlingunbinned ` + & & ` andersondarlingunbinnedapproximated ` + & & ` chi2 ` + & & ` chi2approximated ` + & & ` chi2integrating ` + & ` binned ` & ` cramervonmisesbinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` cramervonmisesunbinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` weightedcramervonmisesbuningunbinned ` + girone & ` unbinned ` & ` girone ` + goodman & ` unbinned ` & ` kolmogorovsmirnovapproximated ` + & & ` kolmogorovsmirnov ` + & & ` weightedadkolmogorovsmirnov ` + & & ` weightedbuningkolmogorovsmirnov ` + kuiper & ` unbinned ` & ` kuiper ` + & ` binned ` & ` tikubinned ` + & ` unbinned ` & ` tikuunbinned ` + watson & ` unbinned ` & ` watson ` +\"\n ],\n [\n \"an effort has been invested to provide an effective software development environment , which exploits more modern tools and facilitates the use of the statistical toolkit in a variety of computing environments . for the new development cycle subversion ( svn )\",\n \"@xcite has been selected as a tool in support of the configuration and change management discipline .\",\n \"the statistical toolkit code was moved to a svn repository . in order to facilitate using the statistical toolkit on a wide variety of operating systems ,\",\n \"the build system has been moved to the cross platform make ( cmake ) @xcite system .\",\n \"the ` ctest ` testing tool , distributed as a part of cmake , is used for unit testing . to be as self - consistent as possible ,\",\n \"the number of dependencies on external software systems has been minimized .\",\n \"the only essential external dependency is on the gnu scientific library @xcite .\",\n \"an additional user layer was implemented to facilitate the use of the statistical toolkit in analysis environment that are concerned neither with aida @xcite nor with root @xcite analysis objects , which are supported by the two user layers available in the current version .\",\n \"the new user layer allows the analyst to supply input data to the statistical toolkit in the form of comma - separated lists of values ( csv ascii files ) .\",\n \"if no external dependencies are specified , this user layer is built by default .\",\n \"otherwise , in properly set - up environments aida or root ( or both ) are found by ` cmake`and the corresponding user layer is built automatically .\",\n \"the statistical toolkit comes with an extensive set of ` unittests ` , which are meant to test the correct implementation of the statistical tests for each new version of the statistical toolkit .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the new development cycle extends the functionality of the statistical toolkit with tests for randomness , one sample goodness - of - fit tests , i.e. comparing data to reference functions , and tests for categorical data .\",\n \"table [ new_tests ] lists the new tests .\",\n \"lll test & input data & class name + wald - wolfowitz & sequence of & ` waldwolfowitztwosamplesrunstest ` + runs test & signs ( -1/1 ) & ` waldwolfowitzonesamplerunstest ` + wald - wolfowitz & 1-dimensional & ` waldwolfowitzonesamplerandomnesstest ` + test of randomness & distribution & + mann - whitney @xmath1 test & 1-dimensional & ` mannwhitneytwosamplestest ` + & distribution & + fisher s exact test & @xmath2 matrix & ` fishersexact2x2test ` + @xmath3 contingency test & @xmath4 matrix & ` chi2contingencytabletest ` + @xmath3 paired test & paired values & `\",\n \"chi2curvescomparisonalgorithm ` + randomness tests provide complementary information to the existing goodness of fit tests ( table [ old_tests ] ) : for instance , tests for randomness can highlight the presence of systematic effects in the distributions subject to comparison , which goodness of fit tests can not detect .\",\n \"a use case is illustrated in @xcite : goodness of fit tests confirm the compatibility of various geant4 proton elastic scattering models respect to reference data , nevertheless asymmetries in the distribution of differences between the results of the simulation and reference data hint to the presence of systematic effects associated with some of the geant4 physics models .\",\n \"the runs tests are statistical tests , used to test the hypothesis that the elements of the sequence are mutually independent or whether the data have some pattern .\",\n \"a run is defined as a series of values of the same type ( e.g. series of increasing / decreasing values , series of true / false values , etc ) , the number of consequent values of the same type being the length of the run . as an example consider tossing a coin and noting the outcome , which is either head ( @xmath5 ) or tail ( @xmath6 ) .\",\n \"a run in this example is each sequence of the same type of outcome .\",\n \"both too many runs ( as in case of cyclic pattern @xmath7 , which has the maximum possible number of runs for given number of observations ) and too few runs ( where heads and tails are clustered together @xmath8 ) exhibit evidence of a non - random relationship between the order of the experiments and the outcome .\",\n \"the wald - wolfowitz test from @xcite is the best known test that is based on the number of runs .\",\n \"it has been proposed as a test of whether two samples are from the same population , but as such has poor power @xcite and the mann - whitney test is preferable .\",\n \"the new version of the statistical toolkit ( to be released ) encompasses implementations of the the wald - wolfowitz runs test for one or two samples . when the test is used with two samples , the algorithm in @xcite is used to construct one ( binary ) sample , and results from the test for one sample are returned . to calculate the @xmath0-values , either the exact or an approximated formula\",\n \"can be used .\",\n \"the exact calculation of the two - tailed probability of the test statistics implemented in the statistical toolkit follows the description from @xcite , while the approximated formula takes into account that for large samples the distribution of the number of runs approaches a normal distribution .\",\n \"wilcoxon @xcite published a test for comparison of two samples , based on comparison of the general size of the two samples , ranking of the ( combined ) samples and then comparing the average ranks of separate ranks .\",\n \"the developments of the test followed fast and the first to publish it were mann and whitney @xcite .\",\n \"the new version of the statistical toolkit implements the mann - whitney @xmath1 test and an approximated formula for the @xmath0-value calculation , again assuming that the samples are large , hence the distribution of the ranks can be described with a normal distribution .\",\n \"categorical data analysis involves testing the significance of the association ( contingency ) between the groups . in practice\",\n \"the number of categories is usually small ( below 20 ) , although in principle the tests for categorical data could be used for any number of groups .\",\n \"the difference between the observed and the expected data , considering the given marginal and the assumptions of the model of independence , can be calculated using the @xmath3 test ( already available in the statistical toolkit ) ; however , the @xmath3 test gives only an estimate of the true probability value .\",\n \"the estimate might be inaccurate in case the marginal is very uneven or if there is a small value ( less than five ) in one of the cells of the contingency table .\",\n \"fisher s exact test for contingency tables @xcite is most widely known exact test for categorical data analysis .\",\n \"it is calculated by generating all tables that are more extreme than the table given by the user . to get the two - tailed @xmath0-value\",\n \", the @xmath0-values of the tables that have @xmath0-values of the same size or smaller than the data table probability are added up to form the cumulative @xmath0-value , including the @xmath0-value of the data table itself .\",\n \"this method becomes computationally intensive already for moderately sized tables , since the number of table probabilities to be enumerated can easily reach billions .\",\n \"fisher s exact test for @xmath2 contingency tables is available in the new development version of the statistical toolkit .\",\n \"an algorithm to calculate the @xmath3 test with yates continuity correction has also been implemented as part of the new development cycle .\",\n \"the @xmath3 tests can be applied to general ( @xmath4 ) contingency tables , while due to computational reasons fisher s exact test is only implemented for @xmath9 tables .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the new development cycle of the statistical toolkit comes with a more versatile build system and provides the user significant extensions in testing capabilities .\",\n \"the new tests extend the statistical toolkit capabilities with tests for randomness and tests for categorical data analysis .\",\n \"the new user layer component makes it possible to use the toolkit with many spreadsheet applications that allow exporting data directly to comma separated list of values .\",\n \"new tests , together with the new user layer , make the statistical toolkit a powerful data analysis tool for experimental physics problems concerned with data comparisons .\"\n ],\n [\n \"this paper is dedicated to the memory of the late paolo viarengo , who contributed to the previous development cycles of the statistical toolkit .\"\n ],\n [\n \"10 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 cirrone g a p , donadio s , guatelli s , mantero a , mascialino b , parlati s , pia m g , pfeiffer a , ribon a and viarengo p 2004 _ ieee trans .\",\n \"sci . _ * 51 * 2056 barrand g , binko p , dnszelmann m , johnson a and pfeiffer a 2001 abstract interfaces for data analysis : component architecture for data analysis tools .\",\n \"oai : cds.cern.ch:519004 tech . rep .\",\n \"cern - it-2001 - 013 cern geneva\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":83,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"1510.00798"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["cognitive radio ( cr ) has been an important research area for its superiority in spectrum efficiency .","generally , there are two categories in cr transmissions : underlay and overlay . in the underlay mode",", the primary users ( pus ) and the secondary users ( sus ) can transmit in the same spectrum simultaneously with the guarantee that the sus transmissions should not affect the pus to a certain extent ( e.g. , the interference - signal - ratio at the pus should not exceed some constant ) . in the overlay mode , the sus sense the spectrum holes that the pus do not utilize periodically , and then transmit through these holes .","recently , green ( i.e. , energy - saving and co2 emission reduction ) transmission becomes a vital consideration in communications system design due to severe energy shortage and environmental problems . under this circumstances , renewable energy , e.g. , solar ,","has been introduced into wireless communications .","renewable energy or energy harvestingaided wireless communications becomes a hot research topic@xcite-@xcite .","especially , the renewable energy aided cr network gains much interest because of its assemblage of spectrum efficiency and green energy advantages ( e.g. , eco - efficiency and potential energy - efficiency)@xcite . in @xcite ,","an upper bound on the theoretical achievable throughput of energy harvesting su has been obtained under overlay mode . in @xcite ,","the harvesting - sensing - throughput tradeoff is investigated for energy harvesting cr .","an optimal single - slot spectrum sensing strategy for throughput optimization has been proposed . in @xcite , a hybrid underlay - overlay cognitive radio with energy harvesting","is considered , and an access strategy for maximizing the long - term throughput of the system is derived by applying the partially observable markov decision process framework . in @xcite ,","a renewable energy aided cooperative cr system , where su receives unsuccessful packets transmitted by pu and relays them to pu rx , is considered .","the stable throughput region is analyzed . in @xcite ,","the robust optimization is performed for energy harvesting cr with the channel and energy harvesting uncertainties . in the paper",", we investigate a renewable energy powered cr , where a pu shares spectrum with an su .","the pu transmits with constant power .","the su transmitter ( tx ) is equipped with an energy harvester ( e.g. , a photovoltaic ) , and the harvested renewable energy is stored in a battery before usage .","the generated data from application layer of the su tx is stored in a first - in - first - out ( fifo ) data buffer . in each transmission slot , the su tx allocates the stored renewable energy for transmitting some data to the su rx . to guarantee the pu s transmission qos ,","the isr at the pu rx should be less than a threshold ( i.e. , the su tx s transmitting power is constrained in each slot ) . as delay is an important qos merit ( delay - sensitive traffic such as the video increases sharply in wide - spectrum wireless networks , e.g. , lte networks ) , we focus on the average buffer delay minimization by scheduling the allocated renewable energy in each slot .","accordingly , a constrained stochastic optimization problem is formulated .","next , we analyze the constraints : in each slot , the allocated power , the transmitted data , and the pu s isr should not extend the corresponding battery power , the corresponding buffer data , and the isr threshold , respectively . based on activity of the constraints , we propose two algorithms .","when the renewable energy constraint is inactive ( the data constraint or the isr constraint is active ) in all slots , we propose the optimal greedy algorithm .","when the renewable energy constraint is active in all slots , we propose an optimal power re - allocation algorithm .","generally , the two algorithms give the upper bound and lower bound , respectively .","additionally , we explore the case that the pu s private information ( e.g. , the pu s channel gain ) is not accessible by the su .","consider a cr network , where a pu co - exits with an su .","slotted - time model is utilized in the paper , and each slot is with length @xmath0 .","the channel power gains for pu tx @xmath1 pu rx , pu tx @xmath1 su rx , su tx @xmath1 su rx , and su tx @xmath1 pu rx during the @xmath2-th slot are denoted as @xmath3 $ ] , @xmath4 $ ] , @xmath5 $ ] , and @xmath6 $ ] , respectively .","the pu transmits with a fixed power @xmath7 .","the su tx is connected with a renewable energy harvester .","the harvested renewable energy is stored in a battery before usage .","the data are generated randomly in the application layer of the su tx , and wait in an fifo data buffer . in each slot , some data in the buffer are transmitted to the su rx .","denote the transmitting power of su in the @xmath2-th slot as @xmath8 $ ] . to guarantee the pu s transmission , the interference - signal - ratio ( isr ) at the pu","rx should be less than a given constant , @xmath9 , i.e. , @xmath10g_{21}[n]}{p_0 g_{11}[n]}\\le \\rho , \\forall n.\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] let @xmath11 $ ] be the arrived renewable energy at the end of the @xmath2-th slot ( harvested renewable energy during the @xmath2-th slot ) .","denote @xmath12 $ ] as the stored energy in the battery at the beginning of the @xmath2-th slot .","assume that the battery capacity is large enough , we have @xmath13=e[n]-p[n]\\tau+e_a[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] assume that the additive white gaussian noise at the pu rx is with zero mean and variance @xmath14 .","denote the transmitted data number ( in bit ) during the @xmath2-th slot as @xmath15 $ ] , then @xmath16=\\log \\big[\\frac{p[n]g_{22}[n]}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}+1\\big]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] denote the data buffer length at the beginning of @xmath2-th slot as @xmath17 $ ] , the arrived data at the end of the @xmath2-th slot ( generated data from application layer during the @xmath2-th slot ) as @xmath18 $ ] .","we have @xmath19=q[n]-r[n]+d_a[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] the objective is to minimize the average buffer delay over @xmath20 slots under the isr constraint by scheduling the renewable allocation in each slot @xmath21\\right\\}_{i=1}^{n}$ ] .","accordingly , we have the following problem .","@xmath22\\right\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\frac{1}{n}\\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1 } q[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] ( [ isr constraint]),[isr constraint inproblem ] + 0p[n]e[n ] , n,[renewable constraint ] + 0r[n]q[n ] , n[rate constraint ] where ( [ isr constraint inproblem ] ) is the isr constraint , ( [ renewable constraint ] ) denotes the renewable energy constraint , and ( [ rate constraint ] ) is the rate constraint in each slot .","in this section , the constraints in the formulated problem are analyzed . and","two optimal algorithms ( referred to as the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm ) for special scenarios are proposed thereafter . moreover , the two algorithms give the upper bound and lower bound respectively .","although the bounds are not the exact solution , they give an important insight into the performance gap .","the three constraints in ( [ optimization problem ] ) can be merged as$ ] is the function of the optimizing variable @xmath8 $ ] . ]","@xmath23}\\nonumber\\\\ & \\le & \\min\\bigg\\{\\frac{e[n]}{\\tau},\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\bigg\\ } \\nonumber\\\\ \\\\ & : = & \\mathcal{c}[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] _ remark : ( [ merged constraint ] ) reveals that the renewable energy constraint , the isr constraint , and the rate constraint can be equivalently transformed to three value - constraints on the allocated power in a slot .","thus , in a slot , only one constraint among the three constraints is active . _","consequently , the su solves the following optimization problem to get the optimal renewable allocation . @xmath24\\right\\}_{i=1}^{n } } \\frac{1}{n}\\sum\\limits_{i = 1}^{n+1 } q[i]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] @xmath25\\le \\mathcal{c}[n ] , \\forall n.\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] intuitively , we try to transmit as much data as possible , in one slot , so as to minimize the data queue length in data buffer .","more data transmission corresponds to more renewable allocation .","that is to say , allocate renewable as much as possible in each slot ( referred to as greedy renewable allocation ) is optimal for minimizing instant data queue length in a slot .","formally , the greedy renewable allocation can be expressed as @xmath26=\\mathcal{c}[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] for @xmath27 then there is a natural question__is the greedy renewable allocation optimal over several slots in average sense?is the greedy renewable allocation optimal for the formulated problem ? _ _ with respect to the optimality of the greedy allocation , we have the following lemma . generally , the greedy renewable allocation is not optimal . when the renewable generation process , the data arrival process , and channel state variation are markov processes , the formulated problem ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) corresponds to @xmath28 of lemma 10 in @xcite . thus , the greedy renewable allocation is not optimal in this case .","thereafter , we arrive at the lemma . _","remark : although not optimal , the greedy renewable allocation is practically useful since its on - line feature and low - complexity .","in addition , as the greedy allocation is a feasible solution of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) , it gives an upper bound of the optimal data queue length .","_ the greedy renewable allocation is optimal in special circumstances .","the following lemma characterizes the scenarios that greedy allocation is optimal .","if @xmath29}{\\tau}\\ge \\min\\big\\{\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\big\\}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] for @xmath30 , the greedy renewable allocation is optimal for ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) .","when ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) holds , the constraint ( [ merged constraint ] ) can be reduced as @xmath31\\le \\min\\big\\{\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\big\\}.\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] define @xmath32:=\\log \\big[\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]}\\frac{g_{22}[n]}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}+1\\big].\\ ] ] ( [ 1 ] ) is equivalent to @xmath15\\le \\min\\big\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\big\\}$ ] .","( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) becomes @xmath33\\right\\}_{i=1}^{n } } \\frac{1}{n}\\sum\\limits_{i = 1}^{n+1 } q[i]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] @xmath34\\le \\min\\big\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\big\\}.\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] the optimal solution is @xmath35=\\min\\big\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\big\\};\\ ] ] on the other hand , if ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) is satisfied , the greedy renewable allocation becomes @xmath8=\\min\\big\\{\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\big\\}$ ] or @xmath15= \\min\\big\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\big\\}$ ] equivalently .","hence we reach the lemma .","_ remark : ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) gives a sufficient condition for the optimality of the greedy renewable allocation .","it is a strong condition since ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) should be satisfied for arbitrary @xmath36 $ ] . _ _ remark : @xmath37}{\\tau}\\ge \\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}$ ] means that the renewable energy is enough for emptying the data buffer in each slot . @xmath37}{\\tau}\\ge","\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]}$ ] demonstrates that the available renewable energy is more than the isr upper bound on the su s transmitting power in each slot .","alternatively , ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) means that the renewable energy constraint is inactive in all slots . in either case , the greedy policy that transmits as much data as possible in each slot is optimal in average sense over slots . _ since @xmath17=q[1]+\\sum\\limits_{j=1}^{n-1}\\big(d_a[j]-r[j]\\big)$ ] , we have @xmath38=nq[1]+\\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1}\\sum\\limits_{j = 1}^{n-1}d_a[j]-\\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1}\\sum\\limits_{j = 1}^{n-1}r[j].\\ ] ] then ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) is equivalent to the following problem . @xmath39\\right\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n } \\beta_n\\log \\big[\\alpha_np[n]+1\\big]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] @xmath40\\le \\mathcal{c}[n],\\forall n\\ ] ] where @xmath41}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}$ ] , @xmath42 . if @xmath43}{\\tau}\\le \\min\\bigg\\{\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\bigg\\}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] for @xmath30 , @xmath44=e[n]$ ] . then ( [ equivalent optimization problem when private available ] ) becomes @xmath45\\right\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n } \\beta_n\\log \\big[\\alpha_np[n]+1\\big]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ]","0p[n],n + _","n=1^l p[n]_n=0^l-1 e_a[n ] , l _ remark : ( [ renewable active ] ) denotes that the renewable energy constraint is active in all slots . _","let @xmath46 , and assume @xmath47 being increasing order ( the indexes can be arbitrarily renumbered to comply with this condition ) .","the optimal solution of ( [ optimization problem with renewable constraint ] ) can be given by a re - allocation algorithm ( i.e. , pa algorithm ) in table [ alloc ] .","steps 2.1 - 2.3 are the water - filling procedures that give the optimal power allocation for @xmath48\\right\\}_{n = r}^{k } } \\sum\\limits_{n = r}^{k } \\beta_n\\log \\big[\\alpha_np[n]+1\\big]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] 0p[n],n + _ n = r^k p[n]=p .","lcl * power re - allocation ( pa ) algorithm : @xmath49 * + input : @xmath20 , @xmath50\\}_{n=1}^n$ ] , @xmath51 + step 1 : @xmath52=e_a[0]$ ] .","+ step 2 : + for @xmath53 + @xmath54\\big\\}_{i=1}^{k-1}=alloc(k-1)$ ] + for @xmath55 + @xmath56+e_a[k-1]$ ] + step 2 - 1 : @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 ; + step 2 - 2 : @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 ; + step 2 - 3 : if @xmath63 and @xmath64 , @xmath65 , repeat step 2 - 2 ; + else @xmath66 , @xmath67=\\frac{\\beta_{q^*}}{\\delta}p_m$ ] .","+ end if + p^*[q]= _ q , rqq^ * + 0,q^ *","< q k. + if @xmath68 , @xmath69>0,1\\le q\\le r-1\\big\\}$ ] + else @xmath70 . + end if + if @xmath71}{\\beta_{q^*}}\\ge \\frac{1}{\\alpha_{q_e}\\beta_{q_e}}+\\frac{p^{'}[q_e]}{\\beta_{q_e}}$ ] + @xmath72,\\cdots , p^{'}[r-1],p^{*}[r],\\cdots , p^{*}[k]\\big\\}$ ] , break .","+ end if + end for + end for + output : @xmath73\\}_{n=1}^n = alloc(n)$ ] + _ remark : the pa algorithm gives the optimal solution for a relaxed version of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) .","the constraint @xmath74\\le \\mathcal{c}[n],\\forall n$ ] is relaxed to be @xmath74\\le \\frac{e[n]}{\\tau},\\forall n$ ] . although not optimal generally , it incurs a lower bound of the optimal data queue length .","_ _ remark : the pa algorithm derives the optimal power allocation of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) in special scenarios .","_ _ remark : the pa algorithm is an off - line algorithm .","_ in the following , we give two numerical examples to illustrate the pa algorithm s executing process .","_ numerical examples : _ let @xmath75 , @xmath76 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath77=e[0]=1 $ ] . fig .","[ example1 ] demonstrates the power allocation of the pa algorithm for @xmath78 $ ] ( numerical example 1 ) , @xmath79 , @xmath80 $ ] , @xmath81 $ ] . for slot 1 ,","the renewable at slot 1 is the initial renewable energy @xmath82=1 $ ] , all renewable energy is allocated , @xmath83=1 $ ] . for slot 1 & slot 2 ,","the maximal renewable energy at slot 2 is @xmath82+ea[1]=1 + 1=2 $ ] .","as the channel condition for slot 2 ( @xmath84 $ ] ) is better enough than slot 1 ( @xmath85 $ ] ) , then the power allocation is adjusted and the re - allocation occurs .","more power is allocated at slot 2 , @xmath83=0.4 $ ] , @xmath86=1.6 $ ] . for slot 1 & slot 2 & slot 3 ,","the maximal available renewable energy is @xmath82+ea[1]+ea[2]=1 + 1 + 2=4 $ ] .","since the channel condition for slot 3 ( @xmath87 $ ] ) is better enough than slot 1 and slot 2 , the power is re - allocated once again , more power is utilized for data transmission at slot 3 , @xmath83=0.5000 $ ] , @xmath86=1.3333 $ ] , @xmath88=2.1667]$ ] .","[ example2 ] shows the power allocation of the pa algorithm for @xmath89 $ ] ( numerical example 2 ) , @xmath79 , @xmath90 $ ] , @xmath91 $ ] .","the explanations for slot 1 and slot 1 & slot 2 are same as former example . for slot 1 & slot 2 & slot 3 , as the channel condition for slot 3 ( @xmath87 $ ] ) is not better enough than slot 1 and slot 2 , then no re - allocation occurs .","power allocation of slot 1 and slot 2 remains static as that for slot 1 & slot 2 , and the newly arrived power at slot 3 ( @xmath92=2 $ ] ) is totally allocated for slot 3 .","the su s renewable allocation constraint is related to @xmath7 , @xmath93 , etc .","hence there are two scenarios : * the private information of the pu , e.g. , @xmath7 , @xmath93 , can be obtained by the su . *","the private information of the pu is unavailable at the su .","we have studied the scenario that the pu s private information is available at the su in section [ section private information available ] . in this section ,","we investigate the problem _ how can we do when the private information is unavailable ? _ when the private information of the pu ( e.g. , @xmath7 , @xmath93 ) is unavailable , the su can not compute the second item @xmath94}{g_{21}[n]}$ ] in ( [ merged constraint ] ) .","in contrast , @xmath95+n_0 $ ] can be obtained at the su rx and can be fed back to the su tx .","the third one @xmath96}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}$ ] can be obtained .","consider the following relaxed problem @xmath97\\right\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\frac{1}{n}\\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1 } q[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] @xmath98&\\le & \\min\\bigg\\{\\frac{e[n]}{\\tau},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\bigg\\ } \\nonumber\\\\ & : = & \\mathcal{f}[n].\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] since @xmath99\\ge \\mathcal{c}[n]$ ] for arbitrary @xmath2 , ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) is a relaxed version of ( [ optimization problem ] ) .","that is to say , the optimal data queue length of ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) gives a lower bound for that of ( [ optimization problem ] ) .","that is to say , even without the pu s private information , the su can derive a lower bound on the average buffer length by solving a relaxed problem .","furthermore , regarding the relaxed problem ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) , we have the following results . for problem ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) , when @xmath100}{\\tau}\\ge \\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\ ] ] for @xmath101 , the greedy allocation is optimal ; if @xmath100}{\\tau } < \\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\ ] ] for @xmath101 , the pa algorithm gives the optimal allocation .","the lemma can be verified by derives in section [ section private information available ] .","the detailed proofs are omitted for brevity .","in this section , simulations are carried out to illustrate the average data buffer length performance of the pa algorithm and the greedy algorithm .","unless otherwise specified , @xmath75 , @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 $ ] .","[ fig_sim1 ] plots the average buffer length performance v.s .","the channel condition @xmath87 $ ] for the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm , respectively . we have set","@xmath105 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath82=e_a[0]=12 $ ] , @xmath106 $ ] , the initial data @xmath107=1 $ ] , @xmath108 $ ] .","it can be observed that the average buffer length decreases with the channel condition improvement ( increase of @xmath87 $ ] ) for the pa algorithm .","in contrast , for the greedy algorithm , the buffer length decreases sharply in small value region of @xmath87 $ ] and remains almost constant when @xmath87>0.5 $ ] .","in addition , for bad channel conditions ( small value region of @xmath87 $ ] ) the gap between the pa algorithm and the greedy is apparently smaller than that for the good channel conditions ( the lager value region ) .","generally , the channel state improvement results in more data transmission given renewable energy arrival . for the pa algorithm , larger value of @xmath87 $ ] incurs the re - allocation of the renewables at slot 3 . specifically , when @xmath109 , the pa algorithm produces @xmath110 $ ] , i.e. , the renewable re - allocation happens at slot 2 only .","when @xmath87\\ge 0.3 $ ] , the re - allocation happens at both slot 2 and slot 3 .","furthermore , with the increase of @xmath111 , more power is allocated to slot 3 ( e.g. , the power allocations are @xmath112 $ ] and @xmath113 $ ] for @xmath87=0.3 $ ] and @xmath87=0.9 $ ] , respectively ) . since the channel condition of slot 3 is the best among the there slots , more data can be transmitted .","thus , the average buffer length decreases with the increase of @xmath87 $ ] . for the greedy algorithm , when @xmath87 $ ] is small , the isr constraint ( [ isr constraint inproblem ] ) and the renewable constraint ( [ renewable constraint ] ) are active constraints for all the three slots ( especially for slot 3 ) .","consequently , the average buffer length decreases with the increase of @xmath87 $ ] .","once @xmath87 $ ] is larger enough , the active constraint becomes the rate constraint ( [ rate constraint ] ) .","that is to say , the transmitted data is determined by the buffer queue length at the beginning of the 3-th slot and it is irrelevant to @xmath87 $ ] . then the average buffer length remains static ( in the greedy algorithm , @xmath87 $ ] does not affect the data transmissions of slot 1 and slot 2 ) .","when @xmath87>0.5 $ ] , the average buffer length for the pa algorithm decreases and remains static for the greedy algorithm .","hence the gap between the two algorithms becomes apparently larger .","[ fig_sim2 ] draws the average buffer length performance regarding the mean renewable energy arrival , @xmath114 , for the pa algorithm and greedy algorithm , respectively . in the simulation ,","@xmath115 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath82=e_a[0]=1/4*\\bar{e}_a$ ] , @xmath116 $ ] , the initial data @xmath107=2 $ ] , and @xmath117 $ ] . from the figure , we can find that with the increase of @xmath114 , the mean buffer length decreases for both algorithms , and the performance gap becomes indistinct ( almost zero finally ) . for the pa algorithm",", since the channel conditions of slot 1 and slot 2 are similar , no power reallocation happens between slot 1 and slot 2 .","the power re - allocation occurs between slot 2 and slot 3 , and the re - allocation becomes weaker with the increase of @xmath114 .","for example , the power allocation is @xmath118 $ ] for @xmath119 , i.e. , the stored renewable energy for slot 2 is totally re - allocated to slot 3 , @xmath86=0 $ ] & @xmath88=e[3]=e_a[1]+e_a[2]$ ] . in contrast , for @xmath120 , the power allocation is @xmath121 $ ] .","@xmath86=87.5\\%*e_a[1]$ ] & @xmath88=12.5\\%*e_a[1]+e_a[2]$ ] and only @xmath122 is re - allocated .","regarding the greedy algorithm , renewable energy constraint ( i.e. , ( [ renewable constraint ] ) ) is the active constraint .","then , the stored renewable energy is totally utilized in each slot , @xmath8=e[n]=e_a[n-1]$ ] .","when @xmath114 increases , for both algorithms , the allocated power in each slot increases , more data is transmitted . then the average buffer length decreases .","meanwhile , with the increase , the pa allocation approaches the greedy allocation .","thus , the average buffer length gap becomes minor .","[ fig_sim3 ] illustrates the average buffer length performance of the pa algorithm and the greedy algorithm regarding the mean data arrival , @xmath123 . in the simulation ,","@xmath124 $ ] , @xmath82=e_a[0]=8 $ ] , @xmath125 $ ] , @xmath107=0 $ ] , and @xmath126 $ ] .","it can be seen that the average buffer length increase with the increase of @xmath123 according to linear relationship for the pa algorithm . concerning the greedy algorithm ,","the increase is slow first and fast then .","the average buffer length gap between the two algorithms becomes smaller in small value region of @xmath123 and remains constant in large value region .","it can be explained as follows : the pa algorithm is irrelevant to the mean data arrival , and forasmuch , the produced power allocation remains as @xmath127 $ ] , and the transmitted data @xmath128+r[2]+r[3]$ ] is constant with respected to @xmath123 .","the average buffer length @xmath129 .","hence the average buffer length varies linearly with @xmath123 . with regard to the greedy algorithm ,","since the initial data is zero , the rate constraint is active and the power allocation in slot 1 is zero .","when @xmath123 is small ( @xmath130 ) , for slot 2 and slot 3 , the rate constraint is active .","hence the increment is slow . when @xmath131 , @xmath132 , renewable energy constraint is active for slot 2 and rate constraint is active for slot 3 .","the increase is moderate . when @xmath133 , the renewable constraint is active for slot 2 and slot 3 .","then the increase becomes linear .","combing above analysis of the two algorithms , we can explain why the gap becomes smaller first and remains static then .","delay - optimal data transmission of cr networks in the presence of renewable energy is studied in the paper . considering the data generation , renewable energy arrival , and wireless channel state , the su s renewable energy allocation in each slot","is scheduled to minimize the average data buffer length with isr constraint . by formulating a constrained stochastic optimization problem and corresponding theoretical analysis",", we propose two practical algorithms : the on - line greedy algorithm and the off - line pa algorithm .","the two algorithms are respectively optimal in certain special conditions .","meanwhile , the greedy algorithm gives an upper bound on the average data buffer length , and the pa algorithm derives a lower bound .","additionally , the case that su can not get the pu s private information is also discussed .","numerical results demonstrate that the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm can produce effective upper & lower bounds on the average buffer length and give important insights into the performance thereafter .","1 t. zhang , w. chen , z. han , and z. cao , a cross - layer perspective on energy harvesting aided green communications over fading channels , _ ieee trans . veh .","1519 - 1534 , apr . 2015 .","r. d. yates and h. m .-","doost , energy harvesting receivers : packet sampling and decoding policies , _ ieee j. sel . area comm .","558 - 570 , mar .","he , l. zhao , s. zhou , and z. niu , recursive waterfilling for wireless links with energy harvesting transmitters , _ ieee trans .",". 1232 - 1241 , mar .","x. huang , t. han , and n. ansari , on green energy powered cognitive radio networks , _ ieee commun .","surv . & tut .","827 - 842 , 2nd - quar . 2015 .","m. usman and i. koo , access strategy for hybrid underlay - overlay cognitive radios with energy harvesting , _ ieee sens .","j. _ , vol .","9 , pp . 3164 - 3173 , sept .","2014 k. kulkarni and a. banerjee , stable throughput tradeoffs in cognitive radio networks with cooperating rechargeable nodes , _ proc .","ieee wcnc15 _ ,","new orleans , la , mar . 2015 ."],"string":"[\n \"cognitive radio ( cr ) has been an important research area for its superiority in spectrum efficiency .\",\n \"generally , there are two categories in cr transmissions : underlay and overlay . in the underlay mode\",\n \", the primary users ( pus ) and the secondary users ( sus ) can transmit in the same spectrum simultaneously with the guarantee that the sus transmissions should not affect the pus to a certain extent ( e.g. , the interference - signal - ratio at the pus should not exceed some constant ) . in the overlay mode , the sus sense the spectrum holes that the pus do not utilize periodically , and then transmit through these holes .\",\n \"recently , green ( i.e. , energy - saving and co2 emission reduction ) transmission becomes a vital consideration in communications system design due to severe energy shortage and environmental problems . under this circumstances , renewable energy , e.g. , solar ,\",\n \"has been introduced into wireless communications .\",\n \"renewable energy or energy harvestingaided wireless communications becomes a hot research topic@xcite-@xcite .\",\n \"especially , the renewable energy aided cr network gains much interest because of its assemblage of spectrum efficiency and green energy advantages ( e.g. , eco - efficiency and potential energy - efficiency)@xcite . in @xcite ,\",\n \"an upper bound on the theoretical achievable throughput of energy harvesting su has been obtained under overlay mode . in @xcite ,\",\n \"the harvesting - sensing - throughput tradeoff is investigated for energy harvesting cr .\",\n \"an optimal single - slot spectrum sensing strategy for throughput optimization has been proposed . in @xcite , a hybrid underlay - overlay cognitive radio with energy harvesting\",\n \"is considered , and an access strategy for maximizing the long - term throughput of the system is derived by applying the partially observable markov decision process framework . in @xcite ,\",\n \"a renewable energy aided cooperative cr system , where su receives unsuccessful packets transmitted by pu and relays them to pu rx , is considered .\",\n \"the stable throughput region is analyzed . in @xcite ,\",\n \"the robust optimization is performed for energy harvesting cr with the channel and energy harvesting uncertainties . in the paper\",\n \", we investigate a renewable energy powered cr , where a pu shares spectrum with an su .\",\n \"the pu transmits with constant power .\",\n \"the su transmitter ( tx ) is equipped with an energy harvester ( e.g. , a photovoltaic ) , and the harvested renewable energy is stored in a battery before usage .\",\n \"the generated data from application layer of the su tx is stored in a first - in - first - out ( fifo ) data buffer . in each transmission slot , the su tx allocates the stored renewable energy for transmitting some data to the su rx . to guarantee the pu s transmission qos ,\",\n \"the isr at the pu rx should be less than a threshold ( i.e. , the su tx s transmitting power is constrained in each slot ) . as delay is an important qos merit ( delay - sensitive traffic such as the video increases sharply in wide - spectrum wireless networks , e.g. , lte networks ) , we focus on the average buffer delay minimization by scheduling the allocated renewable energy in each slot .\",\n \"accordingly , a constrained stochastic optimization problem is formulated .\",\n \"next , we analyze the constraints : in each slot , the allocated power , the transmitted data , and the pu s isr should not extend the corresponding battery power , the corresponding buffer data , and the isr threshold , respectively . based on activity of the constraints , we propose two algorithms .\",\n \"when the renewable energy constraint is inactive ( the data constraint or the isr constraint is active ) in all slots , we propose the optimal greedy algorithm .\",\n \"when the renewable energy constraint is active in all slots , we propose an optimal power re - allocation algorithm .\",\n \"generally , the two algorithms give the upper bound and lower bound , respectively .\",\n \"additionally , we explore the case that the pu s private information ( e.g. , the pu s channel gain ) is not accessible by the su .\",\n \"consider a cr network , where a pu co - exits with an su .\",\n \"slotted - time model is utilized in the paper , and each slot is with length @xmath0 .\",\n \"the channel power gains for pu tx @xmath1 pu rx , pu tx @xmath1 su rx , su tx @xmath1 su rx , and su tx @xmath1 pu rx during the @xmath2-th slot are denoted as @xmath3 $ ] , @xmath4 $ ] , @xmath5 $ ] , and @xmath6 $ ] , respectively .\",\n \"the pu transmits with a fixed power @xmath7 .\",\n \"the su tx is connected with a renewable energy harvester .\",\n \"the harvested renewable energy is stored in a battery before usage .\",\n \"the data are generated randomly in the application layer of the su tx , and wait in an fifo data buffer . in each slot , some data in the buffer are transmitted to the su rx .\",\n \"denote the transmitting power of su in the @xmath2-th slot as @xmath8 $ ] . to guarantee the pu s transmission , the interference - signal - ratio ( isr ) at the pu\",\n \"rx should be less than a given constant , @xmath9 , i.e. , @xmath10g_{21}[n]}{p_0 g_{11}[n]}\\\\le \\\\rho , \\\\forall n.\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] let @xmath11 $ ] be the arrived renewable energy at the end of the @xmath2-th slot ( harvested renewable energy during the @xmath2-th slot ) .\",\n \"denote @xmath12 $ ] as the stored energy in the battery at the beginning of the @xmath2-th slot .\",\n \"assume that the battery capacity is large enough , we have @xmath13=e[n]-p[n]\\\\tau+e_a[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] assume that the additive white gaussian noise at the pu rx is with zero mean and variance @xmath14 .\",\n \"denote the transmitted data number ( in bit ) during the @xmath2-th slot as @xmath15 $ ] , then @xmath16=\\\\log \\\\big[\\\\frac{p[n]g_{22}[n]}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}+1\\\\big]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] denote the data buffer length at the beginning of @xmath2-th slot as @xmath17 $ ] , the arrived data at the end of the @xmath2-th slot ( generated data from application layer during the @xmath2-th slot ) as @xmath18 $ ] .\",\n \"we have @xmath19=q[n]-r[n]+d_a[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] the objective is to minimize the average buffer delay over @xmath20 slots under the isr constraint by scheduling the renewable allocation in each slot @xmath21\\\\right\\\\}_{i=1}^{n}$ ] .\",\n \"accordingly , we have the following problem .\",\n \"@xmath22\\\\right\\\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\\\frac{1}{n}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1 } q[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] ( [ isr constraint]),[isr constraint inproblem ] + 0p[n]e[n ] , n,[renewable constraint ] + 0r[n]q[n ] , n[rate constraint ] where ( [ isr constraint inproblem ] ) is the isr constraint , ( [ renewable constraint ] ) denotes the renewable energy constraint , and ( [ rate constraint ] ) is the rate constraint in each slot .\",\n \"in this section , the constraints in the formulated problem are analyzed . and\",\n \"two optimal algorithms ( referred to as the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm ) for special scenarios are proposed thereafter . moreover , the two algorithms give the upper bound and lower bound respectively .\",\n \"although the bounds are not the exact solution , they give an important insight into the performance gap .\",\n \"the three constraints in ( [ optimization problem ] ) can be merged as$ ] is the function of the optimizing variable @xmath8 $ ] . ]\",\n \"@xmath23}\\\\nonumber\\\\\\\\ & \\\\le & \\\\min\\\\bigg\\\\{\\\\frac{e[n]}{\\\\tau},\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\bigg\\\\ } \\\\nonumber\\\\\\\\ \\\\\\\\ & : = & \\\\mathcal{c}[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] _ remark : ( [ merged constraint ] ) reveals that the renewable energy constraint , the isr constraint , and the rate constraint can be equivalently transformed to three value - constraints on the allocated power in a slot .\",\n \"thus , in a slot , only one constraint among the three constraints is active . _\",\n \"consequently , the su solves the following optimization problem to get the optimal renewable allocation . @xmath24\\\\right\\\\}_{i=1}^{n } } \\\\frac{1}{n}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{i = 1}^{n+1 } q[i]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] @xmath25\\\\le \\\\mathcal{c}[n ] , \\\\forall n.\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] intuitively , we try to transmit as much data as possible , in one slot , so as to minimize the data queue length in data buffer .\",\n \"more data transmission corresponds to more renewable allocation .\",\n \"that is to say , allocate renewable as much as possible in each slot ( referred to as greedy renewable allocation ) is optimal for minimizing instant data queue length in a slot .\",\n \"formally , the greedy renewable allocation can be expressed as @xmath26=\\\\mathcal{c}[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] for @xmath27 then there is a natural question__is the greedy renewable allocation optimal over several slots in average sense?is the greedy renewable allocation optimal for the formulated problem ? _ _ with respect to the optimality of the greedy allocation , we have the following lemma . generally , the greedy renewable allocation is not optimal . when the renewable generation process , the data arrival process , and channel state variation are markov processes , the formulated problem ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) corresponds to @xmath28 of lemma 10 in @xcite . thus , the greedy renewable allocation is not optimal in this case .\",\n \"thereafter , we arrive at the lemma . _\",\n \"remark : although not optimal , the greedy renewable allocation is practically useful since its on - line feature and low - complexity .\",\n \"in addition , as the greedy allocation is a feasible solution of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) , it gives an upper bound of the optimal data queue length .\",\n \"_ the greedy renewable allocation is optimal in special circumstances .\",\n \"the following lemma characterizes the scenarios that greedy allocation is optimal .\",\n \"if @xmath29}{\\\\tau}\\\\ge \\\\min\\\\big\\\\{\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\big\\\\}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] for @xmath30 , the greedy renewable allocation is optimal for ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) .\",\n \"when ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) holds , the constraint ( [ merged constraint ] ) can be reduced as @xmath31\\\\le \\\\min\\\\big\\\\{\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\big\\\\}.\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] define @xmath32:=\\\\log \\\\big[\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]}\\\\frac{g_{22}[n]}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}+1\\\\big].\\\\ ] ] ( [ 1 ] ) is equivalent to @xmath15\\\\le \\\\min\\\\big\\\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\\\big\\\\}$ ] .\",\n \"( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) becomes @xmath33\\\\right\\\\}_{i=1}^{n } } \\\\frac{1}{n}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{i = 1}^{n+1 } q[i]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] @xmath34\\\\le \\\\min\\\\big\\\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\\\big\\\\}.\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] the optimal solution is @xmath35=\\\\min\\\\big\\\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\\\big\\\\};\\\\ ] ] on the other hand , if ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) is satisfied , the greedy renewable allocation becomes @xmath8=\\\\min\\\\big\\\\{\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\big\\\\}$ ] or @xmath15= \\\\min\\\\big\\\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\\\big\\\\}$ ] equivalently .\",\n \"hence we reach the lemma .\",\n \"_ remark : ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) gives a sufficient condition for the optimality of the greedy renewable allocation .\",\n \"it is a strong condition since ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) should be satisfied for arbitrary @xmath36 $ ] . _ _ remark : @xmath37}{\\\\tau}\\\\ge \\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}$ ] means that the renewable energy is enough for emptying the data buffer in each slot . @xmath37}{\\\\tau}\\\\ge\",\n \"\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]}$ ] demonstrates that the available renewable energy is more than the isr upper bound on the su s transmitting power in each slot .\",\n \"alternatively , ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) means that the renewable energy constraint is inactive in all slots . in either case , the greedy policy that transmits as much data as possible in each slot is optimal in average sense over slots . _ since @xmath17=q[1]+\\\\sum\\\\limits_{j=1}^{n-1}\\\\big(d_a[j]-r[j]\\\\big)$ ] , we have @xmath38=nq[1]+\\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{j = 1}^{n-1}d_a[j]-\\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{j = 1}^{n-1}r[j].\\\\ ] ] then ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) is equivalent to the following problem . @xmath39\\\\right\\\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n } \\\\beta_n\\\\log \\\\big[\\\\alpha_np[n]+1\\\\big]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] @xmath40\\\\le \\\\mathcal{c}[n],\\\\forall n\\\\ ] ] where @xmath41}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}$ ] , @xmath42 . if @xmath43}{\\\\tau}\\\\le \\\\min\\\\bigg\\\\{\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\bigg\\\\}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] for @xmath30 , @xmath44=e[n]$ ] . then ( [ equivalent optimization problem when private available ] ) becomes @xmath45\\\\right\\\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n } \\\\beta_n\\\\log \\\\big[\\\\alpha_np[n]+1\\\\big]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ]\",\n \"0p[n],n + _\",\n \"n=1^l p[n]_n=0^l-1 e_a[n ] , l _ remark : ( [ renewable active ] ) denotes that the renewable energy constraint is active in all slots . _\",\n \"let @xmath46 , and assume @xmath47 being increasing order ( the indexes can be arbitrarily renumbered to comply with this condition ) .\",\n \"the optimal solution of ( [ optimization problem with renewable constraint ] ) can be given by a re - allocation algorithm ( i.e. , pa algorithm ) in table [ alloc ] .\",\n \"steps 2.1 - 2.3 are the water - filling procedures that give the optimal power allocation for @xmath48\\\\right\\\\}_{n = r}^{k } } \\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = r}^{k } \\\\beta_n\\\\log \\\\big[\\\\alpha_np[n]+1\\\\big]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] 0p[n],n + _ n = r^k p[n]=p .\",\n \"lcl * power re - allocation ( pa ) algorithm : @xmath49 * + input : @xmath20 , @xmath50\\\\}_{n=1}^n$ ] , @xmath51 + step 1 : @xmath52=e_a[0]$ ] .\",\n \"+ step 2 : + for @xmath53 + @xmath54\\\\big\\\\}_{i=1}^{k-1}=alloc(k-1)$ ] + for @xmath55 + @xmath56+e_a[k-1]$ ] + step 2 - 1 : @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 ; + step 2 - 2 : @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 ; + step 2 - 3 : if @xmath63 and @xmath64 , @xmath65 , repeat step 2 - 2 ; + else @xmath66 , @xmath67=\\\\frac{\\\\beta_{q^*}}{\\\\delta}p_m$ ] .\",\n \"+ end if + p^*[q]= _ q , rqq^ * + 0,q^ *\",\n \"< q k. + if @xmath68 , @xmath69>0,1\\\\le q\\\\le r-1\\\\big\\\\}$ ] + else @xmath70 . + end if + if @xmath71}{\\\\beta_{q^*}}\\\\ge \\\\frac{1}{\\\\alpha_{q_e}\\\\beta_{q_e}}+\\\\frac{p^{'}[q_e]}{\\\\beta_{q_e}}$ ] + @xmath72,\\\\cdots , p^{'}[r-1],p^{*}[r],\\\\cdots , p^{*}[k]\\\\big\\\\}$ ] , break .\",\n \"+ end if + end for + end for + output : @xmath73\\\\}_{n=1}^n = alloc(n)$ ] + _ remark : the pa algorithm gives the optimal solution for a relaxed version of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) .\",\n \"the constraint @xmath74\\\\le \\\\mathcal{c}[n],\\\\forall n$ ] is relaxed to be @xmath74\\\\le \\\\frac{e[n]}{\\\\tau},\\\\forall n$ ] . although not optimal generally , it incurs a lower bound of the optimal data queue length .\",\n \"_ _ remark : the pa algorithm derives the optimal power allocation of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) in special scenarios .\",\n \"_ _ remark : the pa algorithm is an off - line algorithm .\",\n \"_ in the following , we give two numerical examples to illustrate the pa algorithm s executing process .\",\n \"_ numerical examples : _ let @xmath75 , @xmath76 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath77=e[0]=1 $ ] . fig .\",\n \"[ example1 ] demonstrates the power allocation of the pa algorithm for @xmath78 $ ] ( numerical example 1 ) , @xmath79 , @xmath80 $ ] , @xmath81 $ ] . for slot 1 ,\",\n \"the renewable at slot 1 is the initial renewable energy @xmath82=1 $ ] , all renewable energy is allocated , @xmath83=1 $ ] . for slot 1 & slot 2 ,\",\n \"the maximal renewable energy at slot 2 is @xmath82+ea[1]=1 + 1=2 $ ] .\",\n \"as the channel condition for slot 2 ( @xmath84 $ ] ) is better enough than slot 1 ( @xmath85 $ ] ) , then the power allocation is adjusted and the re - allocation occurs .\",\n \"more power is allocated at slot 2 , @xmath83=0.4 $ ] , @xmath86=1.6 $ ] . for slot 1 & slot 2 & slot 3 ,\",\n \"the maximal available renewable energy is @xmath82+ea[1]+ea[2]=1 + 1 + 2=4 $ ] .\",\n \"since the channel condition for slot 3 ( @xmath87 $ ] ) is better enough than slot 1 and slot 2 , the power is re - allocated once again , more power is utilized for data transmission at slot 3 , @xmath83=0.5000 $ ] , @xmath86=1.3333 $ ] , @xmath88=2.1667]$ ] .\",\n \"[ example2 ] shows the power allocation of the pa algorithm for @xmath89 $ ] ( numerical example 2 ) , @xmath79 , @xmath90 $ ] , @xmath91 $ ] .\",\n \"the explanations for slot 1 and slot 1 & slot 2 are same as former example . for slot 1 & slot 2 & slot 3 , as the channel condition for slot 3 ( @xmath87 $ ] ) is not better enough than slot 1 and slot 2 , then no re - allocation occurs .\",\n \"power allocation of slot 1 and slot 2 remains static as that for slot 1 & slot 2 , and the newly arrived power at slot 3 ( @xmath92=2 $ ] ) is totally allocated for slot 3 .\",\n \"the su s renewable allocation constraint is related to @xmath7 , @xmath93 , etc .\",\n \"hence there are two scenarios : * the private information of the pu , e.g. , @xmath7 , @xmath93 , can be obtained by the su . *\",\n \"the private information of the pu is unavailable at the su .\",\n \"we have studied the scenario that the pu s private information is available at the su in section [ section private information available ] . in this section ,\",\n \"we investigate the problem _ how can we do when the private information is unavailable ? _ when the private information of the pu ( e.g. , @xmath7 , @xmath93 ) is unavailable , the su can not compute the second item @xmath94}{g_{21}[n]}$ ] in ( [ merged constraint ] ) .\",\n \"in contrast , @xmath95+n_0 $ ] can be obtained at the su rx and can be fed back to the su tx .\",\n \"the third one @xmath96}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}$ ] can be obtained .\",\n \"consider the following relaxed problem @xmath97\\\\right\\\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\\\frac{1}{n}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1 } q[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] @xmath98&\\\\le & \\\\min\\\\bigg\\\\{\\\\frac{e[n]}{\\\\tau},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\bigg\\\\ } \\\\nonumber\\\\\\\\ & : = & \\\\mathcal{f}[n].\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] since @xmath99\\\\ge \\\\mathcal{c}[n]$ ] for arbitrary @xmath2 , ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) is a relaxed version of ( [ optimization problem ] ) .\",\n \"that is to say , the optimal data queue length of ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) gives a lower bound for that of ( [ optimization problem ] ) .\",\n \"that is to say , even without the pu s private information , the su can derive a lower bound on the average buffer length by solving a relaxed problem .\",\n \"furthermore , regarding the relaxed problem ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) , we have the following results . for problem ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) , when @xmath100}{\\\\tau}\\\\ge \\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\ ] ] for @xmath101 , the greedy allocation is optimal ; if @xmath100}{\\\\tau } < \\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\ ] ] for @xmath101 , the pa algorithm gives the optimal allocation .\",\n \"the lemma can be verified by derives in section [ section private information available ] .\",\n \"the detailed proofs are omitted for brevity .\",\n \"in this section , simulations are carried out to illustrate the average data buffer length performance of the pa algorithm and the greedy algorithm .\",\n \"unless otherwise specified , @xmath75 , @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 $ ] .\",\n \"[ fig_sim1 ] plots the average buffer length performance v.s .\",\n \"the channel condition @xmath87 $ ] for the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm , respectively . we have set\",\n \"@xmath105 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath82=e_a[0]=12 $ ] , @xmath106 $ ] , the initial data @xmath107=1 $ ] , @xmath108 $ ] .\",\n \"it can be observed that the average buffer length decreases with the channel condition improvement ( increase of @xmath87 $ ] ) for the pa algorithm .\",\n \"in contrast , for the greedy algorithm , the buffer length decreases sharply in small value region of @xmath87 $ ] and remains almost constant when @xmath87>0.5 $ ] .\",\n \"in addition , for bad channel conditions ( small value region of @xmath87 $ ] ) the gap between the pa algorithm and the greedy is apparently smaller than that for the good channel conditions ( the lager value region ) .\",\n \"generally , the channel state improvement results in more data transmission given renewable energy arrival . for the pa algorithm , larger value of @xmath87 $ ] incurs the re - allocation of the renewables at slot 3 . specifically , when @xmath109 , the pa algorithm produces @xmath110 $ ] , i.e. , the renewable re - allocation happens at slot 2 only .\",\n \"when @xmath87\\\\ge 0.3 $ ] , the re - allocation happens at both slot 2 and slot 3 .\",\n \"furthermore , with the increase of @xmath111 , more power is allocated to slot 3 ( e.g. , the power allocations are @xmath112 $ ] and @xmath113 $ ] for @xmath87=0.3 $ ] and @xmath87=0.9 $ ] , respectively ) . since the channel condition of slot 3 is the best among the there slots , more data can be transmitted .\",\n \"thus , the average buffer length decreases with the increase of @xmath87 $ ] . for the greedy algorithm , when @xmath87 $ ] is small , the isr constraint ( [ isr constraint inproblem ] ) and the renewable constraint ( [ renewable constraint ] ) are active constraints for all the three slots ( especially for slot 3 ) .\",\n \"consequently , the average buffer length decreases with the increase of @xmath87 $ ] .\",\n \"once @xmath87 $ ] is larger enough , the active constraint becomes the rate constraint ( [ rate constraint ] ) .\",\n \"that is to say , the transmitted data is determined by the buffer queue length at the beginning of the 3-th slot and it is irrelevant to @xmath87 $ ] . then the average buffer length remains static ( in the greedy algorithm , @xmath87 $ ] does not affect the data transmissions of slot 1 and slot 2 ) .\",\n \"when @xmath87>0.5 $ ] , the average buffer length for the pa algorithm decreases and remains static for the greedy algorithm .\",\n \"hence the gap between the two algorithms becomes apparently larger .\",\n \"[ fig_sim2 ] draws the average buffer length performance regarding the mean renewable energy arrival , @xmath114 , for the pa algorithm and greedy algorithm , respectively . in the simulation ,\",\n \"@xmath115 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath82=e_a[0]=1/4*\\\\bar{e}_a$ ] , @xmath116 $ ] , the initial data @xmath107=2 $ ] , and @xmath117 $ ] . from the figure , we can find that with the increase of @xmath114 , the mean buffer length decreases for both algorithms , and the performance gap becomes indistinct ( almost zero finally ) . for the pa algorithm\",\n \", since the channel conditions of slot 1 and slot 2 are similar , no power reallocation happens between slot 1 and slot 2 .\",\n \"the power re - allocation occurs between slot 2 and slot 3 , and the re - allocation becomes weaker with the increase of @xmath114 .\",\n \"for example , the power allocation is @xmath118 $ ] for @xmath119 , i.e. , the stored renewable energy for slot 2 is totally re - allocated to slot 3 , @xmath86=0 $ ] & @xmath88=e[3]=e_a[1]+e_a[2]$ ] . in contrast , for @xmath120 , the power allocation is @xmath121 $ ] .\",\n \"@xmath86=87.5\\\\%*e_a[1]$ ] & @xmath88=12.5\\\\%*e_a[1]+e_a[2]$ ] and only @xmath122 is re - allocated .\",\n \"regarding the greedy algorithm , renewable energy constraint ( i.e. , ( [ renewable constraint ] ) ) is the active constraint .\",\n \"then , the stored renewable energy is totally utilized in each slot , @xmath8=e[n]=e_a[n-1]$ ] .\",\n \"when @xmath114 increases , for both algorithms , the allocated power in each slot increases , more data is transmitted . then the average buffer length decreases .\",\n \"meanwhile , with the increase , the pa allocation approaches the greedy allocation .\",\n \"thus , the average buffer length gap becomes minor .\",\n \"[ fig_sim3 ] illustrates the average buffer length performance of the pa algorithm and the greedy algorithm regarding the mean data arrival , @xmath123 . in the simulation ,\",\n \"@xmath124 $ ] , @xmath82=e_a[0]=8 $ ] , @xmath125 $ ] , @xmath107=0 $ ] , and @xmath126 $ ] .\",\n \"it can be seen that the average buffer length increase with the increase of @xmath123 according to linear relationship for the pa algorithm . concerning the greedy algorithm ,\",\n \"the increase is slow first and fast then .\",\n \"the average buffer length gap between the two algorithms becomes smaller in small value region of @xmath123 and remains constant in large value region .\",\n \"it can be explained as follows : the pa algorithm is irrelevant to the mean data arrival , and forasmuch , the produced power allocation remains as @xmath127 $ ] , and the transmitted data @xmath128+r[2]+r[3]$ ] is constant with respected to @xmath123 .\",\n \"the average buffer length @xmath129 .\",\n \"hence the average buffer length varies linearly with @xmath123 . with regard to the greedy algorithm ,\",\n \"since the initial data is zero , the rate constraint is active and the power allocation in slot 1 is zero .\",\n \"when @xmath123 is small ( @xmath130 ) , for slot 2 and slot 3 , the rate constraint is active .\",\n \"hence the increment is slow . when @xmath131 , @xmath132 , renewable energy constraint is active for slot 2 and rate constraint is active for slot 3 .\",\n \"the increase is moderate . when @xmath133 , the renewable constraint is active for slot 2 and slot 3 .\",\n \"then the increase becomes linear .\",\n \"combing above analysis of the two algorithms , we can explain why the gap becomes smaller first and remains static then .\",\n \"delay - optimal data transmission of cr networks in the presence of renewable energy is studied in the paper . considering the data generation , renewable energy arrival , and wireless channel state , the su s renewable energy allocation in each slot\",\n \"is scheduled to minimize the average data buffer length with isr constraint . by formulating a constrained stochastic optimization problem and corresponding theoretical analysis\",\n \", we propose two practical algorithms : the on - line greedy algorithm and the off - line pa algorithm .\",\n \"the two algorithms are respectively optimal in certain special conditions .\",\n \"meanwhile , the greedy algorithm gives an upper bound on the average data buffer length , and the pa algorithm derives a lower bound .\",\n \"additionally , the case that su can not get the pu s private information is also discussed .\",\n \"numerical results demonstrate that the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm can produce effective upper & lower bounds on the average buffer length and give important insights into the performance thereafter .\",\n \"1 t. zhang , w. chen , z. han , and z. cao , a cross - layer perspective on energy harvesting aided green communications over fading channels , _ ieee trans . veh .\",\n \"1519 - 1534 , apr . 2015 .\",\n \"r. d. yates and h. m .-\",\n \"doost , energy harvesting receivers : packet sampling and decoding policies , _ ieee j. sel . area comm .\",\n \"558 - 570 , mar .\",\n \"he , l. zhao , s. zhou , and z. niu , recursive waterfilling for wireless links with energy harvesting transmitters , _ ieee trans .\",\n \". 1232 - 1241 , mar .\",\n \"x. huang , t. han , and n. ansari , on green energy powered cognitive radio networks , _ ieee commun .\",\n \"surv . & tut .\",\n \"827 - 842 , 2nd - quar . 2015 .\",\n \"m. usman and i. koo , access strategy for hybrid underlay - overlay cognitive radios with energy harvesting , _ ieee sens .\",\n \"j. _ , vol .\",\n \"9 , pp . 3164 - 3173 , sept .\",\n \"2014 k. kulkarni and a. banerjee , stable throughput tradeoffs in cognitive radio networks with cooperating rechargeable nodes , _ proc .\",\n \"ieee wcnc15 _ ,\",\n \"new orleans , la , mar . 2015 .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> renewable energy powered cognitive radio ( cr ) network has gained much attention due to its combination of the cr s spectrum efficiency and the renewable energy s greennature . in the paper </S>","<S> , we investigate the delay - optimal data transmission in the renewable energy aided cr networks . </S>","<S> specifically , a primary user ( pu ) and a secondary user ( su ) share the same frequency in an area . </S>","<S> the su s interference to the pu is controlled by interference - signal - ratio ( isr ) constraint , which means that the isr at the pu receiver ( rx ) should be less than a threshold . under this constraint , </S>","<S> the renewable energy powered su aims to minimize the average data buffer delay by scheduling the renewable allocations in each slot . </S>","<S> a constrained stochastic optimization problem is formulated when the randomness of the renewable arrival , the uncertainty of the su s data generation , and the variability of the fading channel are taken into account . by analyzing the formulated problem , we propose two practical algorithms that is optimal for two special scenarios . and </S>","<S> the two algorithms respectively give an upper and a lower bound for the general scenario . </S>","<S> in addition , the availability of the pu s private information at the su is discussed . </S>","<S> finally , numerical simulations verify the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> renewable energy powered cognitive radio ( cr ) network has gained much attention due to its combination of the cr s spectrum efficiency and the renewable energy s greennature . in the paper </S>\",\n \"<S> , we investigate the delay - optimal data transmission in the renewable energy aided cr networks . </S>\",\n \"<S> specifically , a primary user ( pu ) and a secondary user ( su ) share the same frequency in an area . </S>\",\n \"<S> the su s interference to the pu is controlled by interference - signal - ratio ( isr ) constraint , which means that the isr at the pu receiver ( rx ) should be less than a threshold . under this constraint , </S>\",\n \"<S> the renewable energy powered su aims to minimize the average data buffer delay by scheduling the renewable allocations in each slot . </S>\",\n \"<S> a constrained stochastic optimization problem is formulated when the randomness of the renewable arrival , the uncertainty of the su s data generation , and the variability of the fading channel are taken into account . by analyzing the formulated problem , we propose two practical algorithms that is optimal for two special scenarios . and </S>\",\n \"<S> the two algorithms respectively give an upper and a lower bound for the general scenario . </S>\",\n \"<S> in addition , the availability of the pu s private information at the su is discussed . </S>\",\n \"<S> finally , numerical simulations verify the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","system model and problem formulation","problem analysis and algorithm design","discussion on the availability of the pus private information at the su","numerical results","conclusion"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"system model and problem formulation\",\n \"problem analysis and algorithm design\",\n \"discussion on the availability of the pus private information at the su\",\n \"numerical results\",\n \"conclusion\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["cognitive radio ( cr ) has been an important research area for its superiority in spectrum efficiency .","generally , there are two categories in cr transmissions : underlay and overlay . in the underlay mode",", the primary users ( pus ) and the secondary users ( sus ) can transmit in the same spectrum simultaneously with the guarantee that the sus transmissions should not affect the pus to a certain extent ( e.g. , the interference - signal - ratio at the pus should not exceed some constant ) . in the overlay mode , the sus sense the spectrum holes that the pus do not utilize periodically , and then transmit through these holes .","recently , green ( i.e. , energy - saving and co2 emission reduction ) transmission becomes a vital consideration in communications system design due to severe energy shortage and environmental problems . under this circumstances , renewable energy , e.g. , solar ,","has been introduced into wireless communications .","renewable energy or energy harvestingaided wireless communications becomes a hot research topic@xcite-@xcite .","especially , the renewable energy aided cr network gains much interest because of its assemblage of spectrum efficiency and green energy advantages ( e.g. , eco - efficiency and potential energy - efficiency)@xcite . in @xcite ,","an upper bound on the theoretical achievable throughput of energy harvesting su has been obtained under overlay mode . in @xcite ,","the harvesting - sensing - throughput tradeoff is investigated for energy harvesting cr .","an optimal single - slot spectrum sensing strategy for throughput optimization has been proposed . in @xcite , a hybrid underlay - overlay cognitive radio with energy harvesting","is considered , and an access strategy for maximizing the long - term throughput of the system is derived by applying the partially observable markov decision process framework . in @xcite ,","a renewable energy aided cooperative cr system , where su receives unsuccessful packets transmitted by pu and relays them to pu rx , is considered .","the stable throughput region is analyzed . in @xcite ,","the robust optimization is performed for energy harvesting cr with the channel and energy harvesting uncertainties . in the paper",", we investigate a renewable energy powered cr , where a pu shares spectrum with an su .","the pu transmits with constant power .","the su transmitter ( tx ) is equipped with an energy harvester ( e.g. , a photovoltaic ) , and the harvested renewable energy is stored in a battery before usage .","the generated data from application layer of the su tx is stored in a first - in - first - out ( fifo ) data buffer . in each transmission slot , the su tx allocates the stored renewable energy for transmitting some data to the su rx . to guarantee the pu s transmission qos ,","the isr at the pu rx should be less than a threshold ( i.e. , the su tx s transmitting power is constrained in each slot ) . as delay is an important qos merit ( delay - sensitive traffic such as the video increases sharply in wide - spectrum wireless networks , e.g. , lte networks ) , we focus on the average buffer delay minimization by scheduling the allocated renewable energy in each slot .","accordingly , a constrained stochastic optimization problem is formulated .","next , we analyze the constraints : in each slot , the allocated power , the transmitted data , and the pu s isr should not extend the corresponding battery power , the corresponding buffer data , and the isr threshold , respectively . based on activity of the constraints , we propose two algorithms .","when the renewable energy constraint is inactive ( the data constraint or the isr constraint is active ) in all slots , we propose the optimal greedy algorithm .","when the renewable energy constraint is active in all slots , we propose an optimal power re - allocation algorithm .","generally , the two algorithms give the upper bound and lower bound , respectively .","additionally , we explore the case that the pu s private information ( e.g. , the pu s channel gain ) is not accessible by the su ."],["consider a cr network , where a pu co - exits with an su .","slotted - time model is utilized in the paper , and each slot is with length @xmath0 .","the channel power gains for pu tx @xmath1 pu rx , pu tx @xmath1 su rx , su tx @xmath1 su rx , and su tx @xmath1 pu rx during the @xmath2-th slot are denoted as @xmath3 $ ] , @xmath4 $ ] , @xmath5 $ ] , and @xmath6 $ ] , respectively .","the pu transmits with a fixed power @xmath7 .","the su tx is connected with a renewable energy harvester .","the harvested renewable energy is stored in a battery before usage .","the data are generated randomly in the application layer of the su tx , and wait in an fifo data buffer . in each slot , some data in the buffer are transmitted to the su rx .","denote the transmitting power of su in the @xmath2-th slot as @xmath8 $ ] . to guarantee the pu s transmission , the interference - signal - ratio ( isr ) at the pu","rx should be less than a given constant , @xmath9 , i.e. , @xmath10g_{21}[n]}{p_0 g_{11}[n]}\\le \\rho , \\forall n.\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] let @xmath11 $ ] be the arrived renewable energy at the end of the @xmath2-th slot ( harvested renewable energy during the @xmath2-th slot ) .","denote @xmath12 $ ] as the stored energy in the battery at the beginning of the @xmath2-th slot .","assume that the battery capacity is large enough , we have @xmath13=e[n]-p[n]\\tau+e_a[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] assume that the additive white gaussian noise at the pu rx is with zero mean and variance @xmath14 .","denote the transmitted data number ( in bit ) during the @xmath2-th slot as @xmath15 $ ] , then @xmath16=\\log \\big[\\frac{p[n]g_{22}[n]}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}+1\\big]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] denote the data buffer length at the beginning of @xmath2-th slot as @xmath17 $ ] , the arrived data at the end of the @xmath2-th slot ( generated data from application layer during the @xmath2-th slot ) as @xmath18 $ ] .","we have @xmath19=q[n]-r[n]+d_a[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] the objective is to minimize the average buffer delay over @xmath20 slots under the isr constraint by scheduling the renewable allocation in each slot @xmath21\\right\\}_{i=1}^{n}$ ] .","accordingly , we have the following problem .","@xmath22\\right\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\frac{1}{n}\\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1 } q[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] ( [ isr constraint]),[isr constraint inproblem ] + 0p[n]e[n ] , n,[renewable constraint ] + 0r[n]q[n ] , n[rate constraint ] where ( [ isr constraint inproblem ] ) is the isr constraint , ( [ renewable constraint ] ) denotes the renewable energy constraint , and ( [ rate constraint ] ) is the rate constraint in each slot ."],["in this section , the constraints in the formulated problem are analyzed . and","two optimal algorithms ( referred to as the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm ) for special scenarios are proposed thereafter . moreover , the two algorithms give the upper bound and lower bound respectively .","although the bounds are not the exact solution , they give an important insight into the performance gap .","the three constraints in ( [ optimization problem ] ) can be merged as$ ] is the function of the optimizing variable @xmath8 $ ] . ]","@xmath23}\\nonumber\\\\ & \\le & \\min\\bigg\\{\\frac{e[n]}{\\tau},\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\bigg\\ } \\nonumber\\\\ \\\\ & : = & \\mathcal{c}[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] _ remark : ( [ merged constraint ] ) reveals that the renewable energy constraint , the isr constraint , and the rate constraint can be equivalently transformed to three value - constraints on the allocated power in a slot .","thus , in a slot , only one constraint among the three constraints is active . _","consequently , the su solves the following optimization problem to get the optimal renewable allocation . @xmath24\\right\\}_{i=1}^{n } } \\frac{1}{n}\\sum\\limits_{i = 1}^{n+1 } q[i]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] @xmath25\\le \\mathcal{c}[n ] , \\forall n.\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] intuitively , we try to transmit as much data as possible , in one slot , so as to minimize the data queue length in data buffer .","more data transmission corresponds to more renewable allocation .","that is to say , allocate renewable as much as possible in each slot ( referred to as greedy renewable allocation ) is optimal for minimizing instant data queue length in a slot .","formally , the greedy renewable allocation can be expressed as @xmath26=\\mathcal{c}[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] for @xmath27 then there is a natural question__is the greedy renewable allocation optimal over several slots in average sense?is the greedy renewable allocation optimal for the formulated problem ? _ _ with respect to the optimality of the greedy allocation , we have the following lemma . generally , the greedy renewable allocation is not optimal . when the renewable generation process , the data arrival process , and channel state variation are markov processes , the formulated problem ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) corresponds to @xmath28 of lemma 10 in @xcite . thus , the greedy renewable allocation is not optimal in this case .","thereafter , we arrive at the lemma . _","remark : although not optimal , the greedy renewable allocation is practically useful since its on - line feature and low - complexity .","in addition , as the greedy allocation is a feasible solution of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) , it gives an upper bound of the optimal data queue length .","_ the greedy renewable allocation is optimal in special circumstances .","the following lemma characterizes the scenarios that greedy allocation is optimal .","if @xmath29}{\\tau}\\ge \\min\\big\\{\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\big\\}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] for @xmath30 , the greedy renewable allocation is optimal for ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) .","when ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) holds , the constraint ( [ merged constraint ] ) can be reduced as @xmath31\\le \\min\\big\\{\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\big\\}.\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] define @xmath32:=\\log \\big[\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]}\\frac{g_{22}[n]}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}+1\\big].\\ ] ] ( [ 1 ] ) is equivalent to @xmath15\\le \\min\\big\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\big\\}$ ] .","( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) becomes @xmath33\\right\\}_{i=1}^{n } } \\frac{1}{n}\\sum\\limits_{i = 1}^{n+1 } q[i]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] @xmath34\\le \\min\\big\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\big\\}.\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] the optimal solution is @xmath35=\\min\\big\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\big\\};\\ ] ] on the other hand , if ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) is satisfied , the greedy renewable allocation becomes @xmath8=\\min\\big\\{\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\big\\}$ ] or @xmath15= \\min\\big\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\big\\}$ ] equivalently .","hence we reach the lemma .","_ remark : ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) gives a sufficient condition for the optimality of the greedy renewable allocation .","it is a strong condition since ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) should be satisfied for arbitrary @xmath36 $ ] . _ _ remark : @xmath37}{\\tau}\\ge \\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}$ ] means that the renewable energy is enough for emptying the data buffer in each slot . @xmath37}{\\tau}\\ge","\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]}$ ] demonstrates that the available renewable energy is more than the isr upper bound on the su s transmitting power in each slot .","alternatively , ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) means that the renewable energy constraint is inactive in all slots . in either case , the greedy policy that transmits as much data as possible in each slot is optimal in average sense over slots . _ since @xmath17=q[1]+\\sum\\limits_{j=1}^{n-1}\\big(d_a[j]-r[j]\\big)$ ] , we have @xmath38=nq[1]+\\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1}\\sum\\limits_{j = 1}^{n-1}d_a[j]-\\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1}\\sum\\limits_{j = 1}^{n-1}r[j].\\ ] ] then ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) is equivalent to the following problem . @xmath39\\right\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n } \\beta_n\\log \\big[\\alpha_np[n]+1\\big]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] @xmath40\\le \\mathcal{c}[n],\\forall n\\ ] ] where @xmath41}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}$ ] , @xmath42 . if @xmath43}{\\tau}\\le \\min\\bigg\\{\\frac{\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\bigg\\}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] for @xmath30 , @xmath44=e[n]$ ] . then ( [ equivalent optimization problem when private available ] ) becomes @xmath45\\right\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n } \\beta_n\\log \\big[\\alpha_np[n]+1\\big]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ]","0p[n],n + _","n=1^l p[n]_n=0^l-1 e_a[n ] , l _ remark : ( [ renewable active ] ) denotes that the renewable energy constraint is active in all slots . _","let @xmath46 , and assume @xmath47 being increasing order ( the indexes can be arbitrarily renumbered to comply with this condition ) .","the optimal solution of ( [ optimization problem with renewable constraint ] ) can be given by a re - allocation algorithm ( i.e. , pa algorithm ) in table [ alloc ] .","steps 2.1 - 2.3 are the water - filling procedures that give the optimal power allocation for @xmath48\\right\\}_{n = r}^{k } } \\sum\\limits_{n = r}^{k } \\beta_n\\log \\big[\\alpha_np[n]+1\\big]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] 0p[n],n + _ n = r^k p[n]=p .","lcl * power re - allocation ( pa ) algorithm : @xmath49 * + input : @xmath20 , @xmath50\\}_{n=1}^n$ ] , @xmath51 + step 1 : @xmath52=e_a[0]$ ] .","+ step 2 : + for @xmath53 + @xmath54\\big\\}_{i=1}^{k-1}=alloc(k-1)$ ] + for @xmath55 + @xmath56+e_a[k-1]$ ] + step 2 - 1 : @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 ; + step 2 - 2 : @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 ; + step 2 - 3 : if @xmath63 and @xmath64 , @xmath65 , repeat step 2 - 2 ; + else @xmath66 , @xmath67=\\frac{\\beta_{q^*}}{\\delta}p_m$ ] .","+ end if + p^*[q]= _ q , rqq^ * + 0,q^ *","< q k. + if @xmath68 , @xmath69>0,1\\le q\\le r-1\\big\\}$ ] + else @xmath70 . + end if + if @xmath71}{\\beta_{q^*}}\\ge \\frac{1}{\\alpha_{q_e}\\beta_{q_e}}+\\frac{p^{'}[q_e]}{\\beta_{q_e}}$ ] + @xmath72,\\cdots , p^{'}[r-1],p^{*}[r],\\cdots , p^{*}[k]\\big\\}$ ] , break .","+ end if + end for + end for + output : @xmath73\\}_{n=1}^n = alloc(n)$ ] + _ remark : the pa algorithm gives the optimal solution for a relaxed version of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) .","the constraint @xmath74\\le \\mathcal{c}[n],\\forall n$ ] is relaxed to be @xmath74\\le \\frac{e[n]}{\\tau},\\forall n$ ] . although not optimal generally , it incurs a lower bound of the optimal data queue length .","_ _ remark : the pa algorithm derives the optimal power allocation of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) in special scenarios .","_ _ remark : the pa algorithm is an off - line algorithm .","_ in the following , we give two numerical examples to illustrate the pa algorithm s executing process .","_ numerical examples : _ let @xmath75 , @xmath76 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath77=e[0]=1 $ ] . fig .","[ example1 ] demonstrates the power allocation of the pa algorithm for @xmath78 $ ] ( numerical example 1 ) , @xmath79 , @xmath80 $ ] , @xmath81 $ ] . for slot 1 ,","the renewable at slot 1 is the initial renewable energy @xmath82=1 $ ] , all renewable energy is allocated , @xmath83=1 $ ] . for slot 1 & slot 2 ,","the maximal renewable energy at slot 2 is @xmath82+ea[1]=1 + 1=2 $ ] .","as the channel condition for slot 2 ( @xmath84 $ ] ) is better enough than slot 1 ( @xmath85 $ ] ) , then the power allocation is adjusted and the re - allocation occurs .","more power is allocated at slot 2 , @xmath83=0.4 $ ] , @xmath86=1.6 $ ] . for slot 1 & slot 2 & slot 3 ,","the maximal available renewable energy is @xmath82+ea[1]+ea[2]=1 + 1 + 2=4 $ ] .","since the channel condition for slot 3 ( @xmath87 $ ] ) is better enough than slot 1 and slot 2 , the power is re - allocated once again , more power is utilized for data transmission at slot 3 , @xmath83=0.5000 $ ] , @xmath86=1.3333 $ ] , @xmath88=2.1667]$ ] .","[ example2 ] shows the power allocation of the pa algorithm for @xmath89 $ ] ( numerical example 2 ) , @xmath79 , @xmath90 $ ] , @xmath91 $ ] .","the explanations for slot 1 and slot 1 & slot 2 are same as former example . for slot 1 & slot 2 & slot 3 , as the channel condition for slot 3 ( @xmath87 $ ] ) is not better enough than slot 1 and slot 2 , then no re - allocation occurs .","power allocation of slot 1 and slot 2 remains static as that for slot 1 & slot 2 , and the newly arrived power at slot 3 ( @xmath92=2 $ ] ) is totally allocated for slot 3 ."],["the su s renewable allocation constraint is related to @xmath7 , @xmath93 , etc .","hence there are two scenarios : * the private information of the pu , e.g. , @xmath7 , @xmath93 , can be obtained by the su . *","the private information of the pu is unavailable at the su .","we have studied the scenario that the pu s private information is available at the su in section [ section private information available ] . in this section ,","we investigate the problem _ how can we do when the private information is unavailable ? _ when the private information of the pu ( e.g. , @xmath7 , @xmath93 ) is unavailable , the su can not compute the second item @xmath94}{g_{21}[n]}$ ] in ( [ merged constraint ] ) .","in contrast , @xmath95+n_0 $ ] can be obtained at the su rx and can be fed back to the su tx .","the third one @xmath96}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}$ ] can be obtained .","consider the following relaxed problem @xmath97\\right\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\frac{1}{n}\\sum\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1 } q[n]\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] @xmath98&\\le & \\min\\bigg\\{\\frac{e[n]}{\\tau},\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\bigg\\ } \\nonumber\\\\ & : = & \\mathcal{f}[n].\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] since @xmath99\\ge \\mathcal{c}[n]$ ] for arbitrary @xmath2 , ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) is a relaxed version of ( [ optimization problem ] ) .","that is to say , the optimal data queue length of ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) gives a lower bound for that of ( [ optimization problem ] ) .","that is to say , even without the pu s private information , the su can derive a lower bound on the average buffer length by solving a relaxed problem .","furthermore , regarding the relaxed problem ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) , we have the following results . for problem ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) , when @xmath100}{\\tau}\\ge \\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\ ] ] for @xmath101 , the greedy allocation is optimal ; if @xmath100}{\\tau } < \\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\big)\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\ ] ] for @xmath101 , the pa algorithm gives the optimal allocation .","the lemma can be verified by derives in section [ section private information available ] .","the detailed proofs are omitted for brevity ."],["in this section , simulations are carried out to illustrate the average data buffer length performance of the pa algorithm and the greedy algorithm .","unless otherwise specified , @xmath75 , @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 $ ] .","[ fig_sim1 ] plots the average buffer length performance v.s .","the channel condition @xmath87 $ ] for the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm , respectively . we have set","@xmath105 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath82=e_a[0]=12 $ ] , @xmath106 $ ] , the initial data @xmath107=1 $ ] , @xmath108 $ ] .","it can be observed that the average buffer length decreases with the channel condition improvement ( increase of @xmath87 $ ] ) for the pa algorithm .","in contrast , for the greedy algorithm , the buffer length decreases sharply in small value region of @xmath87 $ ] and remains almost constant when @xmath87>0.5 $ ] .","in addition , for bad channel conditions ( small value region of @xmath87 $ ] ) the gap between the pa algorithm and the greedy is apparently smaller than that for the good channel conditions ( the lager value region ) .","generally , the channel state improvement results in more data transmission given renewable energy arrival . for the pa algorithm , larger value of @xmath87 $ ] incurs the re - allocation of the renewables at slot 3 . specifically , when @xmath109 , the pa algorithm produces @xmath110 $ ] , i.e. , the renewable re - allocation happens at slot 2 only .","when @xmath87\\ge 0.3 $ ] , the re - allocation happens at both slot 2 and slot 3 .","furthermore , with the increase of @xmath111 , more power is allocated to slot 3 ( e.g. , the power allocations are @xmath112 $ ] and @xmath113 $ ] for @xmath87=0.3 $ ] and @xmath87=0.9 $ ] , respectively ) . since the channel condition of slot 3 is the best among the there slots , more data can be transmitted .","thus , the average buffer length decreases with the increase of @xmath87 $ ] . for the greedy algorithm , when @xmath87 $ ] is small , the isr constraint ( [ isr constraint inproblem ] ) and the renewable constraint ( [ renewable constraint ] ) are active constraints for all the three slots ( especially for slot 3 ) .","consequently , the average buffer length decreases with the increase of @xmath87 $ ] .","once @xmath87 $ ] is larger enough , the active constraint becomes the rate constraint ( [ rate constraint ] ) .","that is to say , the transmitted data is determined by the buffer queue length at the beginning of the 3-th slot and it is irrelevant to @xmath87 $ ] . then the average buffer length remains static ( in the greedy algorithm , @xmath87 $ ] does not affect the data transmissions of slot 1 and slot 2 ) .","when @xmath87>0.5 $ ] , the average buffer length for the pa algorithm decreases and remains static for the greedy algorithm .","hence the gap between the two algorithms becomes apparently larger .","[ fig_sim2 ] draws the average buffer length performance regarding the mean renewable energy arrival , @xmath114 , for the pa algorithm and greedy algorithm , respectively . in the simulation ,","@xmath115 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath82=e_a[0]=1/4*\\bar{e}_a$ ] , @xmath116 $ ] , the initial data @xmath107=2 $ ] , and @xmath117 $ ] . from the figure , we can find that with the increase of @xmath114 , the mean buffer length decreases for both algorithms , and the performance gap becomes indistinct ( almost zero finally ) . for the pa algorithm",", since the channel conditions of slot 1 and slot 2 are similar , no power reallocation happens between slot 1 and slot 2 .","the power re - allocation occurs between slot 2 and slot 3 , and the re - allocation becomes weaker with the increase of @xmath114 .","for example , the power allocation is @xmath118 $ ] for @xmath119 , i.e. , the stored renewable energy for slot 2 is totally re - allocated to slot 3 , @xmath86=0 $ ] & @xmath88=e[3]=e_a[1]+e_a[2]$ ] . in contrast , for @xmath120 , the power allocation is @xmath121 $ ] .","@xmath86=87.5\\%*e_a[1]$ ] & @xmath88=12.5\\%*e_a[1]+e_a[2]$ ] and only @xmath122 is re - allocated .","regarding the greedy algorithm , renewable energy constraint ( i.e. , ( [ renewable constraint ] ) ) is the active constraint .","then , the stored renewable energy is totally utilized in each slot , @xmath8=e[n]=e_a[n-1]$ ] .","when @xmath114 increases , for both algorithms , the allocated power in each slot increases , more data is transmitted . then the average buffer length decreases .","meanwhile , with the increase , the pa allocation approaches the greedy allocation .","thus , the average buffer length gap becomes minor .","[ fig_sim3 ] illustrates the average buffer length performance of the pa algorithm and the greedy algorithm regarding the mean data arrival , @xmath123 . in the simulation ,","@xmath124 $ ] , @xmath82=e_a[0]=8 $ ] , @xmath125 $ ] , @xmath107=0 $ ] , and @xmath126 $ ] .","it can be seen that the average buffer length increase with the increase of @xmath123 according to linear relationship for the pa algorithm . concerning the greedy algorithm ,","the increase is slow first and fast then .","the average buffer length gap between the two algorithms becomes smaller in small value region of @xmath123 and remains constant in large value region .","it can be explained as follows : the pa algorithm is irrelevant to the mean data arrival , and forasmuch , the produced power allocation remains as @xmath127 $ ] , and the transmitted data @xmath128+r[2]+r[3]$ ] is constant with respected to @xmath123 .","the average buffer length @xmath129 .","hence the average buffer length varies linearly with @xmath123 . with regard to the greedy algorithm ,","since the initial data is zero , the rate constraint is active and the power allocation in slot 1 is zero .","when @xmath123 is small ( @xmath130 ) , for slot 2 and slot 3 , the rate constraint is active .","hence the increment is slow . when @xmath131 , @xmath132 , renewable energy constraint is active for slot 2 and rate constraint is active for slot 3 .","the increase is moderate . when @xmath133 , the renewable constraint is active for slot 2 and slot 3 .","then the increase becomes linear .","combing above analysis of the two algorithms , we can explain why the gap becomes smaller first and remains static then ."],["delay - optimal data transmission of cr networks in the presence of renewable energy is studied in the paper . considering the data generation , renewable energy arrival , and wireless channel state , the su s renewable energy allocation in each slot","is scheduled to minimize the average data buffer length with isr constraint . by formulating a constrained stochastic optimization problem and corresponding theoretical analysis",", we propose two practical algorithms : the on - line greedy algorithm and the off - line pa algorithm .","the two algorithms are respectively optimal in certain special conditions .","meanwhile , the greedy algorithm gives an upper bound on the average data buffer length , and the pa algorithm derives a lower bound .","additionally , the case that su can not get the pu s private information is also discussed .","numerical results demonstrate that the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm can produce effective upper & lower bounds on the average buffer length and give important insights into the performance thereafter .","1 t. zhang , w. chen , z. han , and z. cao , a cross - layer perspective on energy harvesting aided green communications over fading channels , _ ieee trans . veh .","1519 - 1534 , apr . 2015 .","r. d. yates and h. m .-","doost , energy harvesting receivers : packet sampling and decoding policies , _ ieee j. sel . area comm .","558 - 570 , mar .","he , l. zhao , s. zhou , and z. niu , recursive waterfilling for wireless links with energy harvesting transmitters , _ ieee trans .",". 1232 - 1241 , mar .","x. huang , t. han , and n. ansari , on green energy powered cognitive radio networks , _ ieee commun .","surv . & tut .","827 - 842 , 2nd - quar . 2015 .","m. usman and i. koo , access strategy for hybrid underlay - overlay cognitive radios with energy harvesting , _ ieee sens .","j. _ , vol .","9 , pp . 3164 - 3173 , sept .","2014 k. kulkarni and a. banerjee , stable throughput tradeoffs in cognitive radio networks with cooperating rechargeable nodes , _ proc .","ieee wcnc15 _ ,","new orleans , la , mar . 2015 ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"cognitive radio ( cr ) has been an important research area for its superiority in spectrum efficiency .\",\n \"generally , there are two categories in cr transmissions : underlay and overlay . in the underlay mode\",\n \", the primary users ( pus ) and the secondary users ( sus ) can transmit in the same spectrum simultaneously with the guarantee that the sus transmissions should not affect the pus to a certain extent ( e.g. , the interference - signal - ratio at the pus should not exceed some constant ) . in the overlay mode , the sus sense the spectrum holes that the pus do not utilize periodically , and then transmit through these holes .\",\n \"recently , green ( i.e. , energy - saving and co2 emission reduction ) transmission becomes a vital consideration in communications system design due to severe energy shortage and environmental problems . under this circumstances , renewable energy , e.g. , solar ,\",\n \"has been introduced into wireless communications .\",\n \"renewable energy or energy harvestingaided wireless communications becomes a hot research topic@xcite-@xcite .\",\n \"especially , the renewable energy aided cr network gains much interest because of its assemblage of spectrum efficiency and green energy advantages ( e.g. , eco - efficiency and potential energy - efficiency)@xcite . in @xcite ,\",\n \"an upper bound on the theoretical achievable throughput of energy harvesting su has been obtained under overlay mode . in @xcite ,\",\n \"the harvesting - sensing - throughput tradeoff is investigated for energy harvesting cr .\",\n \"an optimal single - slot spectrum sensing strategy for throughput optimization has been proposed . in @xcite , a hybrid underlay - overlay cognitive radio with energy harvesting\",\n \"is considered , and an access strategy for maximizing the long - term throughput of the system is derived by applying the partially observable markov decision process framework . in @xcite ,\",\n \"a renewable energy aided cooperative cr system , where su receives unsuccessful packets transmitted by pu and relays them to pu rx , is considered .\",\n \"the stable throughput region is analyzed . in @xcite ,\",\n \"the robust optimization is performed for energy harvesting cr with the channel and energy harvesting uncertainties . in the paper\",\n \", we investigate a renewable energy powered cr , where a pu shares spectrum with an su .\",\n \"the pu transmits with constant power .\",\n \"the su transmitter ( tx ) is equipped with an energy harvester ( e.g. , a photovoltaic ) , and the harvested renewable energy is stored in a battery before usage .\",\n \"the generated data from application layer of the su tx is stored in a first - in - first - out ( fifo ) data buffer . in each transmission slot , the su tx allocates the stored renewable energy for transmitting some data to the su rx . to guarantee the pu s transmission qos ,\",\n \"the isr at the pu rx should be less than a threshold ( i.e. , the su tx s transmitting power is constrained in each slot ) . as delay is an important qos merit ( delay - sensitive traffic such as the video increases sharply in wide - spectrum wireless networks , e.g. , lte networks ) , we focus on the average buffer delay minimization by scheduling the allocated renewable energy in each slot .\",\n \"accordingly , a constrained stochastic optimization problem is formulated .\",\n \"next , we analyze the constraints : in each slot , the allocated power , the transmitted data , and the pu s isr should not extend the corresponding battery power , the corresponding buffer data , and the isr threshold , respectively . based on activity of the constraints , we propose two algorithms .\",\n \"when the renewable energy constraint is inactive ( the data constraint or the isr constraint is active ) in all slots , we propose the optimal greedy algorithm .\",\n \"when the renewable energy constraint is active in all slots , we propose an optimal power re - allocation algorithm .\",\n \"generally , the two algorithms give the upper bound and lower bound , respectively .\",\n \"additionally , we explore the case that the pu s private information ( e.g. , the pu s channel gain ) is not accessible by the su .\"\n ],\n [\n \"consider a cr network , where a pu co - exits with an su .\",\n \"slotted - time model is utilized in the paper , and each slot is with length @xmath0 .\",\n \"the channel power gains for pu tx @xmath1 pu rx , pu tx @xmath1 su rx , su tx @xmath1 su rx , and su tx @xmath1 pu rx during the @xmath2-th slot are denoted as @xmath3 $ ] , @xmath4 $ ] , @xmath5 $ ] , and @xmath6 $ ] , respectively .\",\n \"the pu transmits with a fixed power @xmath7 .\",\n \"the su tx is connected with a renewable energy harvester .\",\n \"the harvested renewable energy is stored in a battery before usage .\",\n \"the data are generated randomly in the application layer of the su tx , and wait in an fifo data buffer . in each slot , some data in the buffer are transmitted to the su rx .\",\n \"denote the transmitting power of su in the @xmath2-th slot as @xmath8 $ ] . to guarantee the pu s transmission , the interference - signal - ratio ( isr ) at the pu\",\n \"rx should be less than a given constant , @xmath9 , i.e. , @xmath10g_{21}[n]}{p_0 g_{11}[n]}\\\\le \\\\rho , \\\\forall n.\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] let @xmath11 $ ] be the arrived renewable energy at the end of the @xmath2-th slot ( harvested renewable energy during the @xmath2-th slot ) .\",\n \"denote @xmath12 $ ] as the stored energy in the battery at the beginning of the @xmath2-th slot .\",\n \"assume that the battery capacity is large enough , we have @xmath13=e[n]-p[n]\\\\tau+e_a[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] assume that the additive white gaussian noise at the pu rx is with zero mean and variance @xmath14 .\",\n \"denote the transmitted data number ( in bit ) during the @xmath2-th slot as @xmath15 $ ] , then @xmath16=\\\\log \\\\big[\\\\frac{p[n]g_{22}[n]}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}+1\\\\big]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] denote the data buffer length at the beginning of @xmath2-th slot as @xmath17 $ ] , the arrived data at the end of the @xmath2-th slot ( generated data from application layer during the @xmath2-th slot ) as @xmath18 $ ] .\",\n \"we have @xmath19=q[n]-r[n]+d_a[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] the objective is to minimize the average buffer delay over @xmath20 slots under the isr constraint by scheduling the renewable allocation in each slot @xmath21\\\\right\\\\}_{i=1}^{n}$ ] .\",\n \"accordingly , we have the following problem .\",\n \"@xmath22\\\\right\\\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\\\frac{1}{n}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1 } q[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] ( [ isr constraint]),[isr constraint inproblem ] + 0p[n]e[n ] , n,[renewable constraint ] + 0r[n]q[n ] , n[rate constraint ] where ( [ isr constraint inproblem ] ) is the isr constraint , ( [ renewable constraint ] ) denotes the renewable energy constraint , and ( [ rate constraint ] ) is the rate constraint in each slot .\"\n ],\n [\n \"in this section , the constraints in the formulated problem are analyzed . and\",\n \"two optimal algorithms ( referred to as the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm ) for special scenarios are proposed thereafter . moreover , the two algorithms give the upper bound and lower bound respectively .\",\n \"although the bounds are not the exact solution , they give an important insight into the performance gap .\",\n \"the three constraints in ( [ optimization problem ] ) can be merged as$ ] is the function of the optimizing variable @xmath8 $ ] . ]\",\n \"@xmath23}\\\\nonumber\\\\\\\\ & \\\\le & \\\\min\\\\bigg\\\\{\\\\frac{e[n]}{\\\\tau},\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\bigg\\\\ } \\\\nonumber\\\\\\\\ \\\\\\\\ & : = & \\\\mathcal{c}[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] _ remark : ( [ merged constraint ] ) reveals that the renewable energy constraint , the isr constraint , and the rate constraint can be equivalently transformed to three value - constraints on the allocated power in a slot .\",\n \"thus , in a slot , only one constraint among the three constraints is active . _\",\n \"consequently , the su solves the following optimization problem to get the optimal renewable allocation . @xmath24\\\\right\\\\}_{i=1}^{n } } \\\\frac{1}{n}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{i = 1}^{n+1 } q[i]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] @xmath25\\\\le \\\\mathcal{c}[n ] , \\\\forall n.\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] intuitively , we try to transmit as much data as possible , in one slot , so as to minimize the data queue length in data buffer .\",\n \"more data transmission corresponds to more renewable allocation .\",\n \"that is to say , allocate renewable as much as possible in each slot ( referred to as greedy renewable allocation ) is optimal for minimizing instant data queue length in a slot .\",\n \"formally , the greedy renewable allocation can be expressed as @xmath26=\\\\mathcal{c}[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] for @xmath27 then there is a natural question__is the greedy renewable allocation optimal over several slots in average sense?is the greedy renewable allocation optimal for the formulated problem ? _ _ with respect to the optimality of the greedy allocation , we have the following lemma . generally , the greedy renewable allocation is not optimal . when the renewable generation process , the data arrival process , and channel state variation are markov processes , the formulated problem ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) corresponds to @xmath28 of lemma 10 in @xcite . thus , the greedy renewable allocation is not optimal in this case .\",\n \"thereafter , we arrive at the lemma . _\",\n \"remark : although not optimal , the greedy renewable allocation is practically useful since its on - line feature and low - complexity .\",\n \"in addition , as the greedy allocation is a feasible solution of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) , it gives an upper bound of the optimal data queue length .\",\n \"_ the greedy renewable allocation is optimal in special circumstances .\",\n \"the following lemma characterizes the scenarios that greedy allocation is optimal .\",\n \"if @xmath29}{\\\\tau}\\\\ge \\\\min\\\\big\\\\{\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\big\\\\}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] for @xmath30 , the greedy renewable allocation is optimal for ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) .\",\n \"when ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) holds , the constraint ( [ merged constraint ] ) can be reduced as @xmath31\\\\le \\\\min\\\\big\\\\{\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\big\\\\}.\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] define @xmath32:=\\\\log \\\\big[\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]}\\\\frac{g_{22}[n]}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}+1\\\\big].\\\\ ] ] ( [ 1 ] ) is equivalent to @xmath15\\\\le \\\\min\\\\big\\\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\\\big\\\\}$ ] .\",\n \"( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) becomes @xmath33\\\\right\\\\}_{i=1}^{n } } \\\\frac{1}{n}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{i = 1}^{n+1 } q[i]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] @xmath34\\\\le \\\\min\\\\big\\\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\\\big\\\\}.\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] the optimal solution is @xmath35=\\\\min\\\\big\\\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\\\big\\\\};\\\\ ] ] on the other hand , if ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) is satisfied , the greedy renewable allocation becomes @xmath8=\\\\min\\\\big\\\\{\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\big\\\\}$ ] or @xmath15= \\\\min\\\\big\\\\{q[n],r_s[n]\\\\big\\\\}$ ] equivalently .\",\n \"hence we reach the lemma .\",\n \"_ remark : ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) gives a sufficient condition for the optimality of the greedy renewable allocation .\",\n \"it is a strong condition since ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) should be satisfied for arbitrary @xmath36 $ ] . _ _ remark : @xmath37}{\\\\tau}\\\\ge \\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}$ ] means that the renewable energy is enough for emptying the data buffer in each slot . @xmath37}{\\\\tau}\\\\ge\",\n \"\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]}$ ] demonstrates that the available renewable energy is more than the isr upper bound on the su s transmitting power in each slot .\",\n \"alternatively , ( [ sufficient condition for optimality of greedy ] ) means that the renewable energy constraint is inactive in all slots . in either case , the greedy policy that transmits as much data as possible in each slot is optimal in average sense over slots . _ since @xmath17=q[1]+\\\\sum\\\\limits_{j=1}^{n-1}\\\\big(d_a[j]-r[j]\\\\big)$ ] , we have @xmath38=nq[1]+\\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{j = 1}^{n-1}d_a[j]-\\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{j = 1}^{n-1}r[j].\\\\ ] ] then ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) is equivalent to the following problem . @xmath39\\\\right\\\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n } \\\\beta_n\\\\log \\\\big[\\\\alpha_np[n]+1\\\\big]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] @xmath40\\\\le \\\\mathcal{c}[n],\\\\forall n\\\\ ] ] where @xmath41}{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}$ ] , @xmath42 . if @xmath43}{\\\\tau}\\\\le \\\\min\\\\bigg\\\\{\\\\frac{\\\\rho p_0 g_{11}[n]}{g_{21}[n]},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\bigg\\\\}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] for @xmath30 , @xmath44=e[n]$ ] . then ( [ equivalent optimization problem when private available ] ) becomes @xmath45\\\\right\\\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n } \\\\beta_n\\\\log \\\\big[\\\\alpha_np[n]+1\\\\big]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ]\",\n \"0p[n],n + _\",\n \"n=1^l p[n]_n=0^l-1 e_a[n ] , l _ remark : ( [ renewable active ] ) denotes that the renewable energy constraint is active in all slots . _\",\n \"let @xmath46 , and assume @xmath47 being increasing order ( the indexes can be arbitrarily renumbered to comply with this condition ) .\",\n \"the optimal solution of ( [ optimization problem with renewable constraint ] ) can be given by a re - allocation algorithm ( i.e. , pa algorithm ) in table [ alloc ] .\",\n \"steps 2.1 - 2.3 are the water - filling procedures that give the optimal power allocation for @xmath48\\\\right\\\\}_{n = r}^{k } } \\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = r}^{k } \\\\beta_n\\\\log \\\\big[\\\\alpha_np[n]+1\\\\big]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] 0p[n],n + _ n = r^k p[n]=p .\",\n \"lcl * power re - allocation ( pa ) algorithm : @xmath49 * + input : @xmath20 , @xmath50\\\\}_{n=1}^n$ ] , @xmath51 + step 1 : @xmath52=e_a[0]$ ] .\",\n \"+ step 2 : + for @xmath53 + @xmath54\\\\big\\\\}_{i=1}^{k-1}=alloc(k-1)$ ] + for @xmath55 + @xmath56+e_a[k-1]$ ] + step 2 - 1 : @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 ; + step 2 - 2 : @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 ; + step 2 - 3 : if @xmath63 and @xmath64 , @xmath65 , repeat step 2 - 2 ; + else @xmath66 , @xmath67=\\\\frac{\\\\beta_{q^*}}{\\\\delta}p_m$ ] .\",\n \"+ end if + p^*[q]= _ q , rqq^ * + 0,q^ *\",\n \"< q k. + if @xmath68 , @xmath69>0,1\\\\le q\\\\le r-1\\\\big\\\\}$ ] + else @xmath70 . + end if + if @xmath71}{\\\\beta_{q^*}}\\\\ge \\\\frac{1}{\\\\alpha_{q_e}\\\\beta_{q_e}}+\\\\frac{p^{'}[q_e]}{\\\\beta_{q_e}}$ ] + @xmath72,\\\\cdots , p^{'}[r-1],p^{*}[r],\\\\cdots , p^{*}[k]\\\\big\\\\}$ ] , break .\",\n \"+ end if + end for + end for + output : @xmath73\\\\}_{n=1}^n = alloc(n)$ ] + _ remark : the pa algorithm gives the optimal solution for a relaxed version of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) .\",\n \"the constraint @xmath74\\\\le \\\\mathcal{c}[n],\\\\forall n$ ] is relaxed to be @xmath74\\\\le \\\\frac{e[n]}{\\\\tau},\\\\forall n$ ] . although not optimal generally , it incurs a lower bound of the optimal data queue length .\",\n \"_ _ remark : the pa algorithm derives the optimal power allocation of ( [ optimization problem when private available ] ) in special scenarios .\",\n \"_ _ remark : the pa algorithm is an off - line algorithm .\",\n \"_ in the following , we give two numerical examples to illustrate the pa algorithm s executing process .\",\n \"_ numerical examples : _ let @xmath75 , @xmath76 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath77=e[0]=1 $ ] . fig .\",\n \"[ example1 ] demonstrates the power allocation of the pa algorithm for @xmath78 $ ] ( numerical example 1 ) , @xmath79 , @xmath80 $ ] , @xmath81 $ ] . for slot 1 ,\",\n \"the renewable at slot 1 is the initial renewable energy @xmath82=1 $ ] , all renewable energy is allocated , @xmath83=1 $ ] . for slot 1 & slot 2 ,\",\n \"the maximal renewable energy at slot 2 is @xmath82+ea[1]=1 + 1=2 $ ] .\",\n \"as the channel condition for slot 2 ( @xmath84 $ ] ) is better enough than slot 1 ( @xmath85 $ ] ) , then the power allocation is adjusted and the re - allocation occurs .\",\n \"more power is allocated at slot 2 , @xmath83=0.4 $ ] , @xmath86=1.6 $ ] . for slot 1 & slot 2 & slot 3 ,\",\n \"the maximal available renewable energy is @xmath82+ea[1]+ea[2]=1 + 1 + 2=4 $ ] .\",\n \"since the channel condition for slot 3 ( @xmath87 $ ] ) is better enough than slot 1 and slot 2 , the power is re - allocated once again , more power is utilized for data transmission at slot 3 , @xmath83=0.5000 $ ] , @xmath86=1.3333 $ ] , @xmath88=2.1667]$ ] .\",\n \"[ example2 ] shows the power allocation of the pa algorithm for @xmath89 $ ] ( numerical example 2 ) , @xmath79 , @xmath90 $ ] , @xmath91 $ ] .\",\n \"the explanations for slot 1 and slot 1 & slot 2 are same as former example . for slot 1 & slot 2 & slot 3 , as the channel condition for slot 3 ( @xmath87 $ ] ) is not better enough than slot 1 and slot 2 , then no re - allocation occurs .\",\n \"power allocation of slot 1 and slot 2 remains static as that for slot 1 & slot 2 , and the newly arrived power at slot 3 ( @xmath92=2 $ ] ) is totally allocated for slot 3 .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the su s renewable allocation constraint is related to @xmath7 , @xmath93 , etc .\",\n \"hence there are two scenarios : * the private information of the pu , e.g. , @xmath7 , @xmath93 , can be obtained by the su . *\",\n \"the private information of the pu is unavailable at the su .\",\n \"we have studied the scenario that the pu s private information is available at the su in section [ section private information available ] . in this section ,\",\n \"we investigate the problem _ how can we do when the private information is unavailable ? _ when the private information of the pu ( e.g. , @xmath7 , @xmath93 ) is unavailable , the su can not compute the second item @xmath94}{g_{21}[n]}$ ] in ( [ merged constraint ] ) .\",\n \"in contrast , @xmath95+n_0 $ ] can be obtained at the su rx and can be fed back to the su tx .\",\n \"the third one @xmath96}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}$ ] can be obtained .\",\n \"consider the following relaxed problem @xmath97\\\\right\\\\}_{n=1}^{n } } \\\\frac{1}{n}\\\\sum\\\\limits_{n = 1}^{n+1 } q[n]\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] @xmath98&\\\\le & \\\\min\\\\bigg\\\\{\\\\frac{e[n]}{\\\\tau},\\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\bigg\\\\ } \\\\nonumber\\\\\\\\ & : = & \\\\mathcal{f}[n].\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] since @xmath99\\\\ge \\\\mathcal{c}[n]$ ] for arbitrary @xmath2 , ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) is a relaxed version of ( [ optimization problem ] ) .\",\n \"that is to say , the optimal data queue length of ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) gives a lower bound for that of ( [ optimization problem ] ) .\",\n \"that is to say , even without the pu s private information , the su can derive a lower bound on the average buffer length by solving a relaxed problem .\",\n \"furthermore , regarding the relaxed problem ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) , we have the following results . for problem ( [ relaxed optimization problem when private unavailable ] ) , when @xmath100}{\\\\tau}\\\\ge \\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\ ] ] for @xmath101 , the greedy allocation is optimal ; if @xmath100}{\\\\tau } < \\\\big(e^{q[n]}-1\\\\big)\\\\frac{p_0g_{12}[n]+n_0}{g_{22}[n]}\\\\ ] ] for @xmath101 , the pa algorithm gives the optimal allocation .\",\n \"the lemma can be verified by derives in section [ section private information available ] .\",\n \"the detailed proofs are omitted for brevity .\"\n ],\n [\n \"in this section , simulations are carried out to illustrate the average data buffer length performance of the pa algorithm and the greedy algorithm .\",\n \"unless otherwise specified , @xmath75 , @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 $ ] .\",\n \"[ fig_sim1 ] plots the average buffer length performance v.s .\",\n \"the channel condition @xmath87 $ ] for the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm , respectively . we have set\",\n \"@xmath105 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath82=e_a[0]=12 $ ] , @xmath106 $ ] , the initial data @xmath107=1 $ ] , @xmath108 $ ] .\",\n \"it can be observed that the average buffer length decreases with the channel condition improvement ( increase of @xmath87 $ ] ) for the pa algorithm .\",\n \"in contrast , for the greedy algorithm , the buffer length decreases sharply in small value region of @xmath87 $ ] and remains almost constant when @xmath87>0.5 $ ] .\",\n \"in addition , for bad channel conditions ( small value region of @xmath87 $ ] ) the gap between the pa algorithm and the greedy is apparently smaller than that for the good channel conditions ( the lager value region ) .\",\n \"generally , the channel state improvement results in more data transmission given renewable energy arrival . for the pa algorithm , larger value of @xmath87 $ ] incurs the re - allocation of the renewables at slot 3 . specifically , when @xmath109 , the pa algorithm produces @xmath110 $ ] , i.e. , the renewable re - allocation happens at slot 2 only .\",\n \"when @xmath87\\\\ge 0.3 $ ] , the re - allocation happens at both slot 2 and slot 3 .\",\n \"furthermore , with the increase of @xmath111 , more power is allocated to slot 3 ( e.g. , the power allocations are @xmath112 $ ] and @xmath113 $ ] for @xmath87=0.3 $ ] and @xmath87=0.9 $ ] , respectively ) . since the channel condition of slot 3 is the best among the there slots , more data can be transmitted .\",\n \"thus , the average buffer length decreases with the increase of @xmath87 $ ] . for the greedy algorithm , when @xmath87 $ ] is small , the isr constraint ( [ isr constraint inproblem ] ) and the renewable constraint ( [ renewable constraint ] ) are active constraints for all the three slots ( especially for slot 3 ) .\",\n \"consequently , the average buffer length decreases with the increase of @xmath87 $ ] .\",\n \"once @xmath87 $ ] is larger enough , the active constraint becomes the rate constraint ( [ rate constraint ] ) .\",\n \"that is to say , the transmitted data is determined by the buffer queue length at the beginning of the 3-th slot and it is irrelevant to @xmath87 $ ] . then the average buffer length remains static ( in the greedy algorithm , @xmath87 $ ] does not affect the data transmissions of slot 1 and slot 2 ) .\",\n \"when @xmath87>0.5 $ ] , the average buffer length for the pa algorithm decreases and remains static for the greedy algorithm .\",\n \"hence the gap between the two algorithms becomes apparently larger .\",\n \"[ fig_sim2 ] draws the average buffer length performance regarding the mean renewable energy arrival , @xmath114 , for the pa algorithm and greedy algorithm , respectively . in the simulation ,\",\n \"@xmath115 $ ] , the initial renewable energy @xmath82=e_a[0]=1/4*\\\\bar{e}_a$ ] , @xmath116 $ ] , the initial data @xmath107=2 $ ] , and @xmath117 $ ] . from the figure , we can find that with the increase of @xmath114 , the mean buffer length decreases for both algorithms , and the performance gap becomes indistinct ( almost zero finally ) . for the pa algorithm\",\n \", since the channel conditions of slot 1 and slot 2 are similar , no power reallocation happens between slot 1 and slot 2 .\",\n \"the power re - allocation occurs between slot 2 and slot 3 , and the re - allocation becomes weaker with the increase of @xmath114 .\",\n \"for example , the power allocation is @xmath118 $ ] for @xmath119 , i.e. , the stored renewable energy for slot 2 is totally re - allocated to slot 3 , @xmath86=0 $ ] & @xmath88=e[3]=e_a[1]+e_a[2]$ ] . in contrast , for @xmath120 , the power allocation is @xmath121 $ ] .\",\n \"@xmath86=87.5\\\\%*e_a[1]$ ] & @xmath88=12.5\\\\%*e_a[1]+e_a[2]$ ] and only @xmath122 is re - allocated .\",\n \"regarding the greedy algorithm , renewable energy constraint ( i.e. , ( [ renewable constraint ] ) ) is the active constraint .\",\n \"then , the stored renewable energy is totally utilized in each slot , @xmath8=e[n]=e_a[n-1]$ ] .\",\n \"when @xmath114 increases , for both algorithms , the allocated power in each slot increases , more data is transmitted . then the average buffer length decreases .\",\n \"meanwhile , with the increase , the pa allocation approaches the greedy allocation .\",\n \"thus , the average buffer length gap becomes minor .\",\n \"[ fig_sim3 ] illustrates the average buffer length performance of the pa algorithm and the greedy algorithm regarding the mean data arrival , @xmath123 . in the simulation ,\",\n \"@xmath124 $ ] , @xmath82=e_a[0]=8 $ ] , @xmath125 $ ] , @xmath107=0 $ ] , and @xmath126 $ ] .\",\n \"it can be seen that the average buffer length increase with the increase of @xmath123 according to linear relationship for the pa algorithm . concerning the greedy algorithm ,\",\n \"the increase is slow first and fast then .\",\n \"the average buffer length gap between the two algorithms becomes smaller in small value region of @xmath123 and remains constant in large value region .\",\n \"it can be explained as follows : the pa algorithm is irrelevant to the mean data arrival , and forasmuch , the produced power allocation remains as @xmath127 $ ] , and the transmitted data @xmath128+r[2]+r[3]$ ] is constant with respected to @xmath123 .\",\n \"the average buffer length @xmath129 .\",\n \"hence the average buffer length varies linearly with @xmath123 . with regard to the greedy algorithm ,\",\n \"since the initial data is zero , the rate constraint is active and the power allocation in slot 1 is zero .\",\n \"when @xmath123 is small ( @xmath130 ) , for slot 2 and slot 3 , the rate constraint is active .\",\n \"hence the increment is slow . when @xmath131 , @xmath132 , renewable energy constraint is active for slot 2 and rate constraint is active for slot 3 .\",\n \"the increase is moderate . when @xmath133 , the renewable constraint is active for slot 2 and slot 3 .\",\n \"then the increase becomes linear .\",\n \"combing above analysis of the two algorithms , we can explain why the gap becomes smaller first and remains static then .\"\n ],\n [\n \"delay - optimal data transmission of cr networks in the presence of renewable energy is studied in the paper . considering the data generation , renewable energy arrival , and wireless channel state , the su s renewable energy allocation in each slot\",\n \"is scheduled to minimize the average data buffer length with isr constraint . by formulating a constrained stochastic optimization problem and corresponding theoretical analysis\",\n \", we propose two practical algorithms : the on - line greedy algorithm and the off - line pa algorithm .\",\n \"the two algorithms are respectively optimal in certain special conditions .\",\n \"meanwhile , the greedy algorithm gives an upper bound on the average data buffer length , and the pa algorithm derives a lower bound .\",\n \"additionally , the case that su can not get the pu s private information is also discussed .\",\n \"numerical results demonstrate that the greedy algorithm and the pa algorithm can produce effective upper & lower bounds on the average buffer length and give important insights into the performance thereafter .\",\n \"1 t. zhang , w. chen , z. han , and z. cao , a cross - layer perspective on energy harvesting aided green communications over fading channels , _ ieee trans . veh .\",\n \"1519 - 1534 , apr . 2015 .\",\n \"r. d. yates and h. m .-\",\n \"doost , energy harvesting receivers : packet sampling and decoding policies , _ ieee j. sel . area comm .\",\n \"558 - 570 , mar .\",\n \"he , l. zhao , s. zhou , and z. niu , recursive waterfilling for wireless links with energy harvesting transmitters , _ ieee trans .\",\n \". 1232 - 1241 , mar .\",\n \"x. huang , t. han , and n. ansari , on green energy powered cognitive radio networks , _ ieee commun .\",\n \"surv . & tut .\",\n \"827 - 842 , 2nd - quar . 2015 .\",\n \"m. usman and i. koo , access strategy for hybrid underlay - overlay cognitive radios with energy harvesting , _ ieee sens .\",\n \"j. _ , vol .\",\n \"9 , pp . 3164 - 3173 , sept .\",\n \"2014 k. kulkarni and a. banerjee , stable throughput tradeoffs in cognitive radio networks with cooperating rechargeable nodes , _ proc .\",\n \"ieee wcnc15 _ ,\",\n \"new orleans , la , mar . 2015 .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":84,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"1301.5274"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["the origin of cosmic rays is an unsolved problem since the discovery in 1912 .","the spectrum of cosmic rays has a break at the knee energy ( @xmath4 ev ) , and those below the knee energy are believed to have galactic origin .","recently , the high energy stereoscopic system ( h.e.s.s . ) found more than 50 sources on the galactic plane in the very high energy ( vhe ; @xmath5 gev ) gamma - ray band ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . because vhe gamma - rays are produced either through inverse compton scattering of low energy photons by relativistic electrons , or through the decay of pions produced by collisions of relativistic protons with interstellar medium , high energy particles are surely present in the vhe gamma - ray sources .","if relativistic electrons are present , they may be traced through the observations of synchrotron x - ray emission .","however , in spite of extensive x - ray followup observations , a non - negligible fraction of the galactic vhe gamma - ray sources do not have an x - ray counterpart , and they are referred to as unidentified ( unid ) sources ( e.g. , @xcite ) . among identified galactic vhe gamma - ray sources , pulsar wind nebulae ( pwne ) represent the largest population @xcite .","accordingly , one would expect that pwne are the first candidate of the origin of the unid vhe gamma - ray sources .","however , identifying the vhe gamma - ray sources as pwne is not straightforward .","the vhe gamma - ray emission region sometimes shows significant spatial offset from the x - ray emission region or a pulsar ( e.g. , @xcite ) .","furthermore , the life time of x - ray emitting electrons through synchrotron emission may be shorter than that of vhe gamma - ray emitting electrons through compton scattering .","this means that x - ray emission from the pwne can be much dimmer than the vhe gamma - rays if the pwne are old .","finally , a pulsar is not always found in the vicinity of ( candidate ) pwne .","hess j1427608 is one of the unid vhe gamma - ray sources located at @xmath6 @xcite , and is extended with @xmath7 .","the flux is @xmath8 in the 110 tev band with a photon index of @xmath9 @xcite .","no plausible counterpart is listed in the galactic supernova remnant ( snr ) catalog @xcite or in the simbad data base in the vicinity of hess j1427608 .","we also looked for a possible counterpart in the atnf pulsar catalog @xcite .","however , no energetic pulsar was found within from hess j1427608 . here",", the definition of the energetic pulsar is those with @xmath10 erg s@xmath11 kpc@xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the spin - down energy and @xmath14 is the distance to the source .","this search radius of is large enough compared to offsets of radio pulsars to vhe sources among known pwn systems , and virtually excludes the possibility of associating hess j1427608 with any known energetic radio pulsar .","thus , hess j1427608 seems to be one of the most `` unlikely '' pwne among the vhe gamma - ray sources . in order to search for an x - ray counterpart",", we observed hess j1427608 with suzaku , and also analyzed the xmm - newton archive data .","we observed the sky region including hess j1427608 with suzaku ( @xcite ) from 2010 january 13 through 16 .","the journal of the observation is listed in table [ tab : obslog ] .","suzaku is equipped with two types of detectors : four sets of x - ray imaging spectrometers ( xis0xis3 : @xcite ) and a non - imaging hard x - ray detector ( hxd : @xcite ; @xcite ) .","xis1 uses the back - illuminated ( bi ) ccd while the others the front - illuminated ( fi ) ccds . among the four sensors ,","xis2 is not operational and a part of xis0 ( corresponding to the off - source region in the latter analysis ) is not usable due to its anomaly . hereafter ,","unless otherwise mentioned , we used only xis1 and xis3 data for the current analysis .","xis was operated in normal clocking mode without any window options .","spaced - row charge injection ( @xcite ; @xcite ) was used to reduce the effects of radiation damage .","we used version 2.4.12.27 of the processed data for hess j1427608 .","the data was analyzed with the headas software version 6.10 and xspec version 12.6.0 .","we used the cleaned event file created by the suzaku team .","the resultant effective exposure was 104 ks .","figure 1 shows xis images in the soft ( 0.52 kev ) and the hard ( 28 kev ) bands .","the images were corrected for exposure using an exposure map generated by the ftool xisexpmapgen after subtracting non x - ray background ( nxb ) images generated by the ftool xisnxbgen @xcite .","finally , the xis1 and xis3 images were added , and the resulting image was binned to a pixel size of and smoothed with a gaussian of @xmath15 .","the position center and the extent of hess j1427608 are shown as a black cross and a yellow dashed circle , respectively .","a few faint , point - like sources are seen in the soft band , while an apparently extended source is detected in the hard band .","the position and apparent extension of the hard source match those of hess j1427608 . as will be shown in a later section , all the suzaku soft - band sources","may be explained by the point - like sources in the xmm - newton archive data while the suzaku hard - band source seems to be a truly new source .","we thus designate the central hard - band source suzaku j14276051 , and mainly focus on this source in the following analysis .","because hess j1427608 and suzaku j14276051 are both extended , we evaluate the x - ray size of the source .","for this purpose , careful estimation of the x - ray background is necessary since suzaku j14276051 is relatively faint . in particular",", this region contains significant contribution from the galactic ridge x - ray emission ( grxe ) as well as the cosmic x - ray background ( cxb ) , both of which are subject to mirror vignetting effect resulting in a centrally - peaked spatial distribution .","therefore , it is not appropriate to assume a flat background image defined at an off - source region within the field of view ( fov ) . instead , we estimated the grxe+cxb image in the source region through monte - carlo simulation .","we explain details of the x - ray background estimation below .","first , we estimated the surface brightness of the grxe and cxb assuming their uniform distribution in the sky . for this purpose",", we analyzed the x - ray spectrum in the off - source annulus region shown in figure [ fig : xisspecreg ] .","the region ( between and from the center of suzaku j14276051 ) was selected to minimize contamination from suzaku j14276051 . in other words ,","the off - source region contains only the grxe and the cxb after the subtraction of nxb .","figure [ fig : xisanuspec ] shows the spectra extracted from the off - source region .","the spectra were modeled by optically thin thermal three temperature plasma with neutral iron emission line plus the cxb following @xcite .","in the course of model fitting , the hydrogen column density was fixed to @xmath16 determined by hi observations ( @xcite ) , the photon index of the cxb to 1.4 , and the surface brightness of the cxb to @xmath17 in the 210 kev band ( @xcite ) .","we made the ancillary response file using the ftool xissimarfgen assuming a uniform emission in the sky .","the model could reproduce the observed spectrum well .","the best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : xisanuspec ] .","next , we simulated the grxe+cxb event data assuming uniform emission with the best - fit spectrum model determined above using the ftool xissim @xcite . in order to avoid an extra ambiguity due to poor statistics , the exposure time for the simulation","was set to 500 ks .","then we extracted the grxe+cxb spectrum in the source region and added it to the nxb in the source region to obtain the total background spectrum , following the instruction in section 5.5.2 of the suzaku technical description .","figure [ fig : xisspeccomp ] shows the simulated background spectra of the xis1 and xis3 respectively as well as the source and off - source spectra . as can be seen from the spectra , the source region contains significant emission above the grxe+cxb level .","figure [ fig : xisprof ] shows the radial profiles of the nxb - subtracted image and the simulated grxe+cxb image in the 28 kev band .","the difference is attributed to suzaku j14276051 . even if we consider the relatively broad half - power radius (;","@xcite ) of the point spread function of suzaku mirror , suzaku j14276051 is clearly extended . in order to estimate the source extent , we compared the observed radial profile with that of a model calculation for an extended source having a 2d - gaussian distribution . instead of performing the @xmath18 fitting , we calculated @xmath18 for a set of @xmath19 , i.e. , , , , and .","the simulated profiles were generated with xissim .","it turned out that none of them gave an acceptable fit ; the radial profile of suzaku j14276051 has a core and a tail in comparison with the best - fit simulation data .","we thus performed the @xmath18 test using only the core region ( @xmath20 ) .","we then could obtain an acceptable fit ( @xmath21 for 3 degrees of freedom ) .","the best - fit value obtained was @xmath0 with 90% confidence level .","although suzaku j14276051 is extended , we tried to search for pulsations in the xis light curve as point sources may be hidden in the image .","we extracted light curves of the source region in the 0.510 kev band and binned them to a time resolution of 16 sec .","we calculated fourier power spectra every 2048 bin ( @xmath22 9.1 hour ) using the ftool powspec to obtain the ensemble - averaged power spectrum density ( psd ) .","the psd of xis1 is dominated by the orbital period of the satellite and its higher harmonics , probably due to the contamination of earth albedo .","thus we used only the psd of xis3 in the subsequent analysis .","no significant peak was detected in the psd with an upper limit of @xmath23 ( poisson fluctuation level was normalized to 2.0 ) , which corresponds to an rms amplitude of 0.0064 count s@xmath11 .","because the net count rate of the source is 0.021 count s@xmath11 , this corresponds to a relative amplitude of 31% .","thus we conclude that no coherent pulsation is present in the light curves of suzaku j14276051 with an upper limit of 31 % between the pulse periods of 32 sec and 32768 sec .","figure [ fig : xisspec ] shows the background - subtracted energy spectra of suzaku j14276051 . here",", the background spectrum ( sum of grxe , cxb , and nxb ) was calculated with the method detailed in section [ subsec : xisimage ] .","it is found that the spectrum of suzaku j14276051 is featureless and heavily absorbed .","although a hint of feature is seen in the 67 kev band , which may be due to the spacial variation of the iron emission line in grxe , it is not statistically significant .","we calculated the ancillary response file using the ftool xissimarfgen for an extended source of a gaussian profile with @xmath24 .","the spectrum was well modeled by either an absorbed power - law or a thermal model , whose best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : xisparm ] . however ,","a thermal origin is unlikely because the abundance is unreasonably small , and the x - rays are thus considered to be produced by non - thermal processes .","the absorbed x - ray flux of the source is @xmath25 in the 210 kev band .","we also analyzed the spectrum of the hxd to search for emission of suzaku j14276051 above 10 kev .","we used the background spectrum called `` bgd_d '' provided by the suzaku team @xcite and added the cxb to it using the ftool hxdpinnxbpi .","we used the xis nominal - position response file categorized to epoch 6 , released as a caldb .","we made the background - subtracted spectrum and fitted it with a power - law , whose photon index was fixed to @xmath26 , as derived from the xis analysis .","the flux in the 1540 kev band is ( @xmath27 ) @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) if no systematic error is taken into account .","based on @xcite , who showed the reproducibility of nxb in the 1540 kev band is about 3% in the 90% confidence range , we constructed the nxb spectra with 3% higher count rates to include the systematic error of the nxb reproduction .","then , a significant signal is no longer detected .","we thus obtained the 90% upper limit of @xmath30 in the 1540 kev band .","in order to estimate the contribution of point sources , we analyzed the archival data of xmm - newton including the hess j1427608 field .","xmm - newton ( @xcite ) carries three x - ray telescopes each equipped with a european photon imaging camera ( epic ) at the foci .","epic consists of two mos ccd camera ( mos1 and mos2 : @xcite ) and a pn ccd camera ( pn : @xcite ) .","the observation was carried out on 2007 august 9 for 24 ks . during the observation , epic was operated in full - frame mode with medium filter .","the data were analyzed with the science analysis software ( sas ) version 10.0.0 , headas version 6.10 and xspec version 12.6.0 .","time intervals of enhanced background , which are caused by soft proton flares , were removed with thresholds of 0.20 count s@xmath11 for mos1 , 0.24 count s@xmath11 for mos2 , and 0.6 count s@xmath11 for pn , respectively , calculated for pattern=0 events above 10 kev .","we used x - ray events of pattern=012 ( for mos cameras ) and pattern=04 ( for pn camera ) for the image and spectral analyses .","the resultant effective exposures were 21 ks ( mos1 ) , 22 ks ( mos2 ) , and 15 ks ( pn ) , respectively .","the journal of the observation is listed in table [ tab : obslog ] .","figure [ fig : epicimage ] shows the summed images of mos1 and mos2 in the soft ( 0.32 kev ) and the hard ( 212 kev ) bands .","the xis images are also overlaid in green contours . using the sas tool edetect_chain ,","a total of 16 point sources were detected within from the center of suzaku j14276051 .","eleven and seven sources were found in the soft and the hard bands , respectively , and two sources were commonly detected in both bands .","names and count rates of the point sources are listed in table [ tab : xmmps ] .","summing up the count rates of the point sources located within the suzaku source region ( x1 through x7 ) , we obtained @xmath31 count s@xmath11 in the 0.52 kev band .","this may be converted to the xis bi count rate of @xmath32 count s@xmath11 assuming the power - law spectrum in table 2 . because this is comparable to the rate actually observed with suzaku ( @xmath33 count s@xmath11 ) ,","the xis data may be explained by the sum of the xmm - newton point sources in the soft band .","on the other hand , if we carry out a similar calculation for the hard band , the xmm - newton point sources would produce @xmath34 count s@xmath11 in xis .","because this corresponds to only @xmath35 % of the actual xis count rate , suzaku j14276051 is difficult to be explained by the sum of the sources and may be a truly diffuse source .","we calculated the energy spectra of only x1 and of the summed spectra of the central seven point sources ( x1 through x7 ) .","we made the response file and the ancillary response file using the sas tool rmfgen and arfgen , respectively .","we fitted these spectra with the model of an absorbed power - law .","because of the poor statistics , the photon index was fixed to 3.1 , which was determined by the spectral analysis of suzaku j14276051 .","the best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : epicparm ] .","figure [ fig : epicspec ] shows the summed spectra of the seven point sources .","the absorbed x - ray flux of the summed spectra was @xmath36 in the 210 kev band , which is about 5% of the flux derived with suzaku for suzaku j14276051 .","it is also found that the column density of the summed spectra is two orders of magnitude smaller than that derived for suzaku j14276051 .","these results confirm that suzaku j14276051 can not be explained by the xmm - newton point sources .","we discovered an apparently - diffuse hard x - ray source , suzaku j14276051 with suzaku , and several point sources with xmm - newton in spatial coincidence with hess j1427608 .","we found that suzaku j14276051 could not be explained by the sum of the point sources detected with xmm - newton , and concluded that it is a truly diffuse source . even if time variability of the detected point - like sources is considered , it is unlikely that suzaku j14276051 is explained by them because the hydrogen column densities are quite different .","the xmm - newton point sources are most likely foreground sources . to explain","suzaku j14276051 by the sum of several point sources would require that all those sources would be below detection threshold at the time of the xmm - newton observation , which appears very unlikely .","thus , we concluded that suzaku j14276051 is an intrinsically diffuse source and the x - ray counterpart of hess j1427608 .","we searched various catalogs and literature for the possible counterpart of hess j1427608 in other wavebands .","a gev gamma - ray source , 2fgl j1427.66048c , is listed in the 2-year catalog of fermi ( @xcite ) .","the gev source is located at @xmath37 , which is away from the center of hess j1427608 ( see figure [ fig : xisimage ] ) . since the error radius of the position is about ,","it may be associated with hess j1427608 @xcite . however ,","this is a `` c - designator - applied ''","fermi source whose position , emission characteristics , or even existence may not be reliable due to a potential confusion with interstellar emission @xcite .","we believe it is premature to discuss a possible association of the gev source to hess j1427608 ; future fermi data and analysis is necessary .","we also searched the akari point source catalogues ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .","no point source was found in the mid - infrared ( @xmath38 m ) and the far - infrared ( @xmath39 m ) bands within from the center of hess j1427608 .","although we mentioned hess j1427608 as one of the most `` unlikely '' pwne in the introduction , its center - filled morphology and featureless spectrum in the x - ray band suggest that the source could be a pwn .","thus we postulate here that the source is a pwn as a working hypothesis",". figure [ fig : wideband ] shows the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) from x - rays to vhe gamma - rays .","the estimated synchrotron spectra from the vhe gamma - ray spectrum @xcite , assuming that the same electron population would inverse - compton scatter cmb photons up to vhe gamma - rays and radiate synchrotron emission in x - rays , are also plotted with a local magnetic field @xmath40 of 1 , 3 , and 10@xmath41 .","this sed plot indicates that the simple one - zone leptonic model with @xmath40 of about 5@xmath42 g would roughly explain both the x - ray and vhe gamma - ray data . in this context",", the steep suzaku spectrum of @xmath43 could indicate that the suzaku energy band is higher than the cut - off energy .","the inferred magnetic field strength of @xmath225@xmath42 g is within the range of typical values on the galactic plane .","thus the sed is consistent with a one - zone leptonic model expected for pwne .","we next examine the flux ratio and luminosities . the x - ray to vhe gamma - ray ratio is useful to probe the nature of unid sources @xcite . in the case of hess","j1427608 , the unabsorbed x - ray flux @xmath44 of @xmath45 ( 210 kev ) and the vhe gamma - ray flux @xmath46 of @xmath47 ( 110 tev ) result in a flux ratio of @xmath48 .","if we assume a distance to hess j1427608 of @xmath49 kpc , the x - ray luminosity would be @xmath50 .","the estimated flux ratio and x - ray luminosity are within the values of known x - ray and vhe gamma - ray emitting pwne , given that both values show a large scatter : @xmath51 in @xmath52 and @xmath53 erg s@xmath11 in @xmath54 @xcite .","thus the flux ratio and luminosity are also consistent with sources of pwn origin . while there are observational evidences supporting the pwn origin as discussed above , others challenge such a view . with the assumption of @xmath49 kpc ,","the core size and whole radial extent would be 2 pc and 12 pc , respectively .","the core size of 2 pc is a little large , but not exceptional among other pwn @xcite .","the whole extent of 12 pc is not surprisingly large compared with the nebula of e.g. , psr j18261334 @xcite .","the largest drawback of the pwn hypothesis is lacking the detection of both a pulsar and radio pwn associated .","it is known that the pulsar luminosity and its nebula luminosity in the x - ray band are correlated over 7 orders of magnitude @xcite . according to the correlation",", the not - yet - detected pulsar should be brighter than @xmath55 in x - rays , one - tenth of the pwn luminosity . such a pulsar would have been easily detected with xmm - newton .","in addition , the x - ray photon index of the nebula ( @xmath56 ) is very steep among the known x - ray nebulae most of which have a @xmath57 between 1.22.2 @xcite . in terms of photon","index comparison , non - thermal snrs might present a more plausible scenario than pwne .","most of non - thermal snrs radiate synchrotron x - rays with a photon index of @xmath58 @xcite .","the x - ray luminosity and extent are also compatible to synchrotron snrs @xcite .","however , the facts that the source has a center - filled morphology in the x - ray band and no detection of the shell structure in the radio band hamper the interpretation as a non - thermal snr . in summary , we have not reached a firm conclusion on the nature of hess j1427608 .","pwn and/or non - thermal snr , which are not necessary exclusive to each other , are the prime candidates but a decisive observational evidence is lacking . increasing statistics in fermi data","may reveal a pulsation from 2fgl j1427.66048c",". a deep radio observation would also be helpful if it could detect pulsations or reveal the morphology of the source .","we observed hess j1427608 with suzaku , which is combined with the archival data analysis of xmm - newton , and obtained following results . *","we discovered an x - ray counterpart , suzaku j14276051 , of hess j1427608 .","it is intrinsically extended ( @xmath59 ) and has a spectral shape of an absorbed power - law with a photon index of @xmath2 .","* several faint point sources were found in spatial coincidence with hess j1427608 using xmm - newton archival data in the soft x - ray band . *","observational properties of suzaku j14276051 and hess j1427608 are compared with those of known pwne and non - thermal snrs .","some properties favor the pwn and/or snr origin , but the available data are insufficient to draw firm conclusions .","we thank kentaro someya , yoshitomo maeda and michito sakai for their useful comments .","t.f . acknowledges the financial support from the global center of excellence program by mext , japan through the `` nanoscience and quantum physics '' project of the tokyo institute of technology , and jsps young research fellowship , no .","23 - 9676 . the work of k.m .","is partially supported by the grant - in - aid for young scientists ( b ) of the mext ( no .","24740167 ) .","aharonian , f. , et al .","2005 , science , 307 , 1938 aharonian , f. , et al .","2006 , , 636 , 777 aharonian , f. , et al .","2008 , , 477 , 353 de jager , o. c. , & djannati - ata , a. 2009 , in neutron stars and pulsars , ed .","w. becker ( berlin : springer ) , 451 fukazawa , y. , et al .","2009 , , 61 , s17 fujinaga , t. , et al .","2011 , , 63 , s863 green , d. a. 2009 , bull .","india , 37 , 45 hinton , j. a. & hoffman , w. 2009 , araa , 47 , 523 ishihara , d. , et al .","2010 , , 514 , a1 ishisaki , y. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s113 jansen , f. , et al .","2001 , , 365 , l1 kalberla , m. , et al .","2005 , , 440 , 775 kargaltsev , o. , & pavlov , g. g. 2008 , in aip conf . proc . , 983 , 40 years of pulsars : millisecond pulsars , magnetars and more , ed .","bassa et al .","( new york : aip ) , 171 kokubun , m. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s53 koyama , k. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s23 kushino , a. , ishisaki , y. , morita , u. , yamasaki , n. y. , ishida , m. , ohashi , t. , & ueda , y. 2002 , , 54 , 327 manchester , r.n . , et al .","2005 , , 129 , 1993 mattana , f. , et al .","2010 , , 694 , 12 mitsuda , k. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s1 nakamura , r. , et al .","2009 , , 61 , s197 nakamura , r. , bamba , a. , dotani , t. , ishida , m. , yamazaki , r. , & kohri , k. 2012 , , 746 , 134 nolan , p. l. , et al .","2012 , , 199 , 31 prigozhin , g. , burke , b. , bautz , m. , kissel , s. , lamarr , b. 2008 , ieee transactions on electron devices , 55 , 2111 serlemitsos , p. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s9 strder , l. , et al .","2001 , , 365 , l18 takahashi , t. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s35 turner et al .","2001 , , 365 , l27 tawa , n. , et al .","2008 , , 60 , s11 uchiyama , h. , et al .","2009a , , 61 , s9 uchiyama , h. , et al .","2009b , , 61 , s189 yamauchi , c. , et al .","2011 , pasp , 123 , 852 yamazaki , r. , kohri , k. , bamba , a. , yoshida , t. , tsuribe , t. , & takahara , f. 2006 , , 371 , 1975 lccc & soft & medium & high + @xmath62 ( @xmath63 cm@xmath12 ) & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & @xmath67 + @xmath68 ( kev ) & @xmath69 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 + absorbed flux & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 + & + ne & + s & + ar & + others & + line @xmath75 ( kev ) & + line flux & + @xmath18/d.o.f & + + + lcc & power - law & apec + @xmath62 ( @xmath63 cm@xmath12 ) & @xmath76 & @xmath77 + @xmath57 & @xmath78 & + @xmath68 ( kev ) & & @xmath79 + abundance ( @xmath80 ) & & @xmath81 + unabsorbed flux & @xmath82 & @xmath83 + absorbed flux & 3.1 & 3.0 + @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 + + + i d & name & distance & + & & & 0.32 kev & 212 kev + x1 & xmmu j142755.4605112.9 & & 5.3 & 3.3 + x2 & xmmu j142746.5605011.4 & & & 1.9 + x3 & xmmu j142746.8605317.8 & & 2.3 & + x4 & xmmu j142800.7605356.4 & & 2.7 & + x5 & xmmu j142731.4605141.4 & & & 2.9 + x6 & xmmu j142810.3604752.0 & & 3.3 & 1.7 + x7 & xmmu j142736.9604712.8 & & 1.9 & + x8 & xmmu j142711.0605320.3 & & & 2.2 + x9 & xmmu j142742.7604436.9 & & 3.4 & + x10 & xmmu j142722.3604425.8 & & & 3.1 + x11 & xmmu j142856.1605027.9 & & 3.0 & + x12 & xmmu j142649.9604810.0 & & & 1.7 + x13 & xmmu j142810.0604337.9 & & 9.1 & + x14 & xmmu j142651.3605300.9 & & 4.9 & + x15 & xmmu j142654.9604556.1 & & 4.1 & + x16 & xmmu j142855.6604636.4 & & 3.1 & + + + lcc & x1 & sum of x1x7 + @xmath62 ( @xmath87 ) & @xmath88 & @xmath89 + @xmath57 & 3.1 ( fixed ) & 3.1 ( fixed ) + unabsorbed flux & @xmath90 & @xmath91 + absorbed flux & 0.7 & 1.7 + & 11.28 / 6 & 16.74 / 27 + + +"],"string":"[\n \"the origin of cosmic rays is an unsolved problem since the discovery in 1912 .\",\n \"the spectrum of cosmic rays has a break at the knee energy ( @xmath4 ev ) , and those below the knee energy are believed to have galactic origin .\",\n \"recently , the high energy stereoscopic system ( h.e.s.s . ) found more than 50 sources on the galactic plane in the very high energy ( vhe ; @xmath5 gev ) gamma - ray band ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . because vhe gamma - rays are produced either through inverse compton scattering of low energy photons by relativistic electrons , or through the decay of pions produced by collisions of relativistic protons with interstellar medium , high energy particles are surely present in the vhe gamma - ray sources .\",\n \"if relativistic electrons are present , they may be traced through the observations of synchrotron x - ray emission .\",\n \"however , in spite of extensive x - ray followup observations , a non - negligible fraction of the galactic vhe gamma - ray sources do not have an x - ray counterpart , and they are referred to as unidentified ( unid ) sources ( e.g. , @xcite ) . among identified galactic vhe gamma - ray sources , pulsar wind nebulae ( pwne ) represent the largest population @xcite .\",\n \"accordingly , one would expect that pwne are the first candidate of the origin of the unid vhe gamma - ray sources .\",\n \"however , identifying the vhe gamma - ray sources as pwne is not straightforward .\",\n \"the vhe gamma - ray emission region sometimes shows significant spatial offset from the x - ray emission region or a pulsar ( e.g. , @xcite ) .\",\n \"furthermore , the life time of x - ray emitting electrons through synchrotron emission may be shorter than that of vhe gamma - ray emitting electrons through compton scattering .\",\n \"this means that x - ray emission from the pwne can be much dimmer than the vhe gamma - rays if the pwne are old .\",\n \"finally , a pulsar is not always found in the vicinity of ( candidate ) pwne .\",\n \"hess j1427608 is one of the unid vhe gamma - ray sources located at @xmath6 @xcite , and is extended with @xmath7 .\",\n \"the flux is @xmath8 in the 110 tev band with a photon index of @xmath9 @xcite .\",\n \"no plausible counterpart is listed in the galactic supernova remnant ( snr ) catalog @xcite or in the simbad data base in the vicinity of hess j1427608 .\",\n \"we also looked for a possible counterpart in the atnf pulsar catalog @xcite .\",\n \"however , no energetic pulsar was found within from hess j1427608 . here\",\n \", the definition of the energetic pulsar is those with @xmath10 erg s@xmath11 kpc@xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the spin - down energy and @xmath14 is the distance to the source .\",\n \"this search radius of is large enough compared to offsets of radio pulsars to vhe sources among known pwn systems , and virtually excludes the possibility of associating hess j1427608 with any known energetic radio pulsar .\",\n \"thus , hess j1427608 seems to be one of the most `` unlikely '' pwne among the vhe gamma - ray sources . in order to search for an x - ray counterpart\",\n \", we observed hess j1427608 with suzaku , and also analyzed the xmm - newton archive data .\",\n \"we observed the sky region including hess j1427608 with suzaku ( @xcite ) from 2010 january 13 through 16 .\",\n \"the journal of the observation is listed in table [ tab : obslog ] .\",\n \"suzaku is equipped with two types of detectors : four sets of x - ray imaging spectrometers ( xis0xis3 : @xcite ) and a non - imaging hard x - ray detector ( hxd : @xcite ; @xcite ) .\",\n \"xis1 uses the back - illuminated ( bi ) ccd while the others the front - illuminated ( fi ) ccds . among the four sensors ,\",\n \"xis2 is not operational and a part of xis0 ( corresponding to the off - source region in the latter analysis ) is not usable due to its anomaly . hereafter ,\",\n \"unless otherwise mentioned , we used only xis1 and xis3 data for the current analysis .\",\n \"xis was operated in normal clocking mode without any window options .\",\n \"spaced - row charge injection ( @xcite ; @xcite ) was used to reduce the effects of radiation damage .\",\n \"we used version 2.4.12.27 of the processed data for hess j1427608 .\",\n \"the data was analyzed with the headas software version 6.10 and xspec version 12.6.0 .\",\n \"we used the cleaned event file created by the suzaku team .\",\n \"the resultant effective exposure was 104 ks .\",\n \"figure 1 shows xis images in the soft ( 0.52 kev ) and the hard ( 28 kev ) bands .\",\n \"the images were corrected for exposure using an exposure map generated by the ftool xisexpmapgen after subtracting non x - ray background ( nxb ) images generated by the ftool xisnxbgen @xcite .\",\n \"finally , the xis1 and xis3 images were added , and the resulting image was binned to a pixel size of and smoothed with a gaussian of @xmath15 .\",\n \"the position center and the extent of hess j1427608 are shown as a black cross and a yellow dashed circle , respectively .\",\n \"a few faint , point - like sources are seen in the soft band , while an apparently extended source is detected in the hard band .\",\n \"the position and apparent extension of the hard source match those of hess j1427608 . as will be shown in a later section , all the suzaku soft - band sources\",\n \"may be explained by the point - like sources in the xmm - newton archive data while the suzaku hard - band source seems to be a truly new source .\",\n \"we thus designate the central hard - band source suzaku j14276051 , and mainly focus on this source in the following analysis .\",\n \"because hess j1427608 and suzaku j14276051 are both extended , we evaluate the x - ray size of the source .\",\n \"for this purpose , careful estimation of the x - ray background is necessary since suzaku j14276051 is relatively faint . in particular\",\n \", this region contains significant contribution from the galactic ridge x - ray emission ( grxe ) as well as the cosmic x - ray background ( cxb ) , both of which are subject to mirror vignetting effect resulting in a centrally - peaked spatial distribution .\",\n \"therefore , it is not appropriate to assume a flat background image defined at an off - source region within the field of view ( fov ) . instead , we estimated the grxe+cxb image in the source region through monte - carlo simulation .\",\n \"we explain details of the x - ray background estimation below .\",\n \"first , we estimated the surface brightness of the grxe and cxb assuming their uniform distribution in the sky . for this purpose\",\n \", we analyzed the x - ray spectrum in the off - source annulus region shown in figure [ fig : xisspecreg ] .\",\n \"the region ( between and from the center of suzaku j14276051 ) was selected to minimize contamination from suzaku j14276051 . in other words ,\",\n \"the off - source region contains only the grxe and the cxb after the subtraction of nxb .\",\n \"figure [ fig : xisanuspec ] shows the spectra extracted from the off - source region .\",\n \"the spectra were modeled by optically thin thermal three temperature plasma with neutral iron emission line plus the cxb following @xcite .\",\n \"in the course of model fitting , the hydrogen column density was fixed to @xmath16 determined by hi observations ( @xcite ) , the photon index of the cxb to 1.4 , and the surface brightness of the cxb to @xmath17 in the 210 kev band ( @xcite ) .\",\n \"we made the ancillary response file using the ftool xissimarfgen assuming a uniform emission in the sky .\",\n \"the model could reproduce the observed spectrum well .\",\n \"the best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : xisanuspec ] .\",\n \"next , we simulated the grxe+cxb event data assuming uniform emission with the best - fit spectrum model determined above using the ftool xissim @xcite . in order to avoid an extra ambiguity due to poor statistics , the exposure time for the simulation\",\n \"was set to 500 ks .\",\n \"then we extracted the grxe+cxb spectrum in the source region and added it to the nxb in the source region to obtain the total background spectrum , following the instruction in section 5.5.2 of the suzaku technical description .\",\n \"figure [ fig : xisspeccomp ] shows the simulated background spectra of the xis1 and xis3 respectively as well as the source and off - source spectra . as can be seen from the spectra , the source region contains significant emission above the grxe+cxb level .\",\n \"figure [ fig : xisprof ] shows the radial profiles of the nxb - subtracted image and the simulated grxe+cxb image in the 28 kev band .\",\n \"the difference is attributed to suzaku j14276051 . even if we consider the relatively broad half - power radius (;\",\n \"@xcite ) of the point spread function of suzaku mirror , suzaku j14276051 is clearly extended . in order to estimate the source extent , we compared the observed radial profile with that of a model calculation for an extended source having a 2d - gaussian distribution . instead of performing the @xmath18 fitting , we calculated @xmath18 for a set of @xmath19 , i.e. , , , , and .\",\n \"the simulated profiles were generated with xissim .\",\n \"it turned out that none of them gave an acceptable fit ; the radial profile of suzaku j14276051 has a core and a tail in comparison with the best - fit simulation data .\",\n \"we thus performed the @xmath18 test using only the core region ( @xmath20 ) .\",\n \"we then could obtain an acceptable fit ( @xmath21 for 3 degrees of freedom ) .\",\n \"the best - fit value obtained was @xmath0 with 90% confidence level .\",\n \"although suzaku j14276051 is extended , we tried to search for pulsations in the xis light curve as point sources may be hidden in the image .\",\n \"we extracted light curves of the source region in the 0.510 kev band and binned them to a time resolution of 16 sec .\",\n \"we calculated fourier power spectra every 2048 bin ( @xmath22 9.1 hour ) using the ftool powspec to obtain the ensemble - averaged power spectrum density ( psd ) .\",\n \"the psd of xis1 is dominated by the orbital period of the satellite and its higher harmonics , probably due to the contamination of earth albedo .\",\n \"thus we used only the psd of xis3 in the subsequent analysis .\",\n \"no significant peak was detected in the psd with an upper limit of @xmath23 ( poisson fluctuation level was normalized to 2.0 ) , which corresponds to an rms amplitude of 0.0064 count s@xmath11 .\",\n \"because the net count rate of the source is 0.021 count s@xmath11 , this corresponds to a relative amplitude of 31% .\",\n \"thus we conclude that no coherent pulsation is present in the light curves of suzaku j14276051 with an upper limit of 31 % between the pulse periods of 32 sec and 32768 sec .\",\n \"figure [ fig : xisspec ] shows the background - subtracted energy spectra of suzaku j14276051 . here\",\n \", the background spectrum ( sum of grxe , cxb , and nxb ) was calculated with the method detailed in section [ subsec : xisimage ] .\",\n \"it is found that the spectrum of suzaku j14276051 is featureless and heavily absorbed .\",\n \"although a hint of feature is seen in the 67 kev band , which may be due to the spacial variation of the iron emission line in grxe , it is not statistically significant .\",\n \"we calculated the ancillary response file using the ftool xissimarfgen for an extended source of a gaussian profile with @xmath24 .\",\n \"the spectrum was well modeled by either an absorbed power - law or a thermal model , whose best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : xisparm ] . however ,\",\n \"a thermal origin is unlikely because the abundance is unreasonably small , and the x - rays are thus considered to be produced by non - thermal processes .\",\n \"the absorbed x - ray flux of the source is @xmath25 in the 210 kev band .\",\n \"we also analyzed the spectrum of the hxd to search for emission of suzaku j14276051 above 10 kev .\",\n \"we used the background spectrum called `` bgd_d '' provided by the suzaku team @xcite and added the cxb to it using the ftool hxdpinnxbpi .\",\n \"we used the xis nominal - position response file categorized to epoch 6 , released as a caldb .\",\n \"we made the background - subtracted spectrum and fitted it with a power - law , whose photon index was fixed to @xmath26 , as derived from the xis analysis .\",\n \"the flux in the 1540 kev band is ( @xmath27 ) @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) if no systematic error is taken into account .\",\n \"based on @xcite , who showed the reproducibility of nxb in the 1540 kev band is about 3% in the 90% confidence range , we constructed the nxb spectra with 3% higher count rates to include the systematic error of the nxb reproduction .\",\n \"then , a significant signal is no longer detected .\",\n \"we thus obtained the 90% upper limit of @xmath30 in the 1540 kev band .\",\n \"in order to estimate the contribution of point sources , we analyzed the archival data of xmm - newton including the hess j1427608 field .\",\n \"xmm - newton ( @xcite ) carries three x - ray telescopes each equipped with a european photon imaging camera ( epic ) at the foci .\",\n \"epic consists of two mos ccd camera ( mos1 and mos2 : @xcite ) and a pn ccd camera ( pn : @xcite ) .\",\n \"the observation was carried out on 2007 august 9 for 24 ks . during the observation , epic was operated in full - frame mode with medium filter .\",\n \"the data were analyzed with the science analysis software ( sas ) version 10.0.0 , headas version 6.10 and xspec version 12.6.0 .\",\n \"time intervals of enhanced background , which are caused by soft proton flares , were removed with thresholds of 0.20 count s@xmath11 for mos1 , 0.24 count s@xmath11 for mos2 , and 0.6 count s@xmath11 for pn , respectively , calculated for pattern=0 events above 10 kev .\",\n \"we used x - ray events of pattern=012 ( for mos cameras ) and pattern=04 ( for pn camera ) for the image and spectral analyses .\",\n \"the resultant effective exposures were 21 ks ( mos1 ) , 22 ks ( mos2 ) , and 15 ks ( pn ) , respectively .\",\n \"the journal of the observation is listed in table [ tab : obslog ] .\",\n \"figure [ fig : epicimage ] shows the summed images of mos1 and mos2 in the soft ( 0.32 kev ) and the hard ( 212 kev ) bands .\",\n \"the xis images are also overlaid in green contours . using the sas tool edetect_chain ,\",\n \"a total of 16 point sources were detected within from the center of suzaku j14276051 .\",\n \"eleven and seven sources were found in the soft and the hard bands , respectively , and two sources were commonly detected in both bands .\",\n \"names and count rates of the point sources are listed in table [ tab : xmmps ] .\",\n \"summing up the count rates of the point sources located within the suzaku source region ( x1 through x7 ) , we obtained @xmath31 count s@xmath11 in the 0.52 kev band .\",\n \"this may be converted to the xis bi count rate of @xmath32 count s@xmath11 assuming the power - law spectrum in table 2 . because this is comparable to the rate actually observed with suzaku ( @xmath33 count s@xmath11 ) ,\",\n \"the xis data may be explained by the sum of the xmm - newton point sources in the soft band .\",\n \"on the other hand , if we carry out a similar calculation for the hard band , the xmm - newton point sources would produce @xmath34 count s@xmath11 in xis .\",\n \"because this corresponds to only @xmath35 % of the actual xis count rate , suzaku j14276051 is difficult to be explained by the sum of the sources and may be a truly diffuse source .\",\n \"we calculated the energy spectra of only x1 and of the summed spectra of the central seven point sources ( x1 through x7 ) .\",\n \"we made the response file and the ancillary response file using the sas tool rmfgen and arfgen , respectively .\",\n \"we fitted these spectra with the model of an absorbed power - law .\",\n \"because of the poor statistics , the photon index was fixed to 3.1 , which was determined by the spectral analysis of suzaku j14276051 .\",\n \"the best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : epicparm ] .\",\n \"figure [ fig : epicspec ] shows the summed spectra of the seven point sources .\",\n \"the absorbed x - ray flux of the summed spectra was @xmath36 in the 210 kev band , which is about 5% of the flux derived with suzaku for suzaku j14276051 .\",\n \"it is also found that the column density of the summed spectra is two orders of magnitude smaller than that derived for suzaku j14276051 .\",\n \"these results confirm that suzaku j14276051 can not be explained by the xmm - newton point sources .\",\n \"we discovered an apparently - diffuse hard x - ray source , suzaku j14276051 with suzaku , and several point sources with xmm - newton in spatial coincidence with hess j1427608 .\",\n \"we found that suzaku j14276051 could not be explained by the sum of the point sources detected with xmm - newton , and concluded that it is a truly diffuse source . even if time variability of the detected point - like sources is considered , it is unlikely that suzaku j14276051 is explained by them because the hydrogen column densities are quite different .\",\n \"the xmm - newton point sources are most likely foreground sources . to explain\",\n \"suzaku j14276051 by the sum of several point sources would require that all those sources would be below detection threshold at the time of the xmm - newton observation , which appears very unlikely .\",\n \"thus , we concluded that suzaku j14276051 is an intrinsically diffuse source and the x - ray counterpart of hess j1427608 .\",\n \"we searched various catalogs and literature for the possible counterpart of hess j1427608 in other wavebands .\",\n \"a gev gamma - ray source , 2fgl j1427.66048c , is listed in the 2-year catalog of fermi ( @xcite ) .\",\n \"the gev source is located at @xmath37 , which is away from the center of hess j1427608 ( see figure [ fig : xisimage ] ) . since the error radius of the position is about ,\",\n \"it may be associated with hess j1427608 @xcite . however ,\",\n \"this is a `` c - designator - applied ''\",\n \"fermi source whose position , emission characteristics , or even existence may not be reliable due to a potential confusion with interstellar emission @xcite .\",\n \"we believe it is premature to discuss a possible association of the gev source to hess j1427608 ; future fermi data and analysis is necessary .\",\n \"we also searched the akari point source catalogues ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .\",\n \"no point source was found in the mid - infrared ( @xmath38 m ) and the far - infrared ( @xmath39 m ) bands within from the center of hess j1427608 .\",\n \"although we mentioned hess j1427608 as one of the most `` unlikely '' pwne in the introduction , its center - filled morphology and featureless spectrum in the x - ray band suggest that the source could be a pwn .\",\n \"thus we postulate here that the source is a pwn as a working hypothesis\",\n \". figure [ fig : wideband ] shows the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) from x - rays to vhe gamma - rays .\",\n \"the estimated synchrotron spectra from the vhe gamma - ray spectrum @xcite , assuming that the same electron population would inverse - compton scatter cmb photons up to vhe gamma - rays and radiate synchrotron emission in x - rays , are also plotted with a local magnetic field @xmath40 of 1 , 3 , and 10@xmath41 .\",\n \"this sed plot indicates that the simple one - zone leptonic model with @xmath40 of about 5@xmath42 g would roughly explain both the x - ray and vhe gamma - ray data . in this context\",\n \", the steep suzaku spectrum of @xmath43 could indicate that the suzaku energy band is higher than the cut - off energy .\",\n \"the inferred magnetic field strength of @xmath225@xmath42 g is within the range of typical values on the galactic plane .\",\n \"thus the sed is consistent with a one - zone leptonic model expected for pwne .\",\n \"we next examine the flux ratio and luminosities . the x - ray to vhe gamma - ray ratio is useful to probe the nature of unid sources @xcite . in the case of hess\",\n \"j1427608 , the unabsorbed x - ray flux @xmath44 of @xmath45 ( 210 kev ) and the vhe gamma - ray flux @xmath46 of @xmath47 ( 110 tev ) result in a flux ratio of @xmath48 .\",\n \"if we assume a distance to hess j1427608 of @xmath49 kpc , the x - ray luminosity would be @xmath50 .\",\n \"the estimated flux ratio and x - ray luminosity are within the values of known x - ray and vhe gamma - ray emitting pwne , given that both values show a large scatter : @xmath51 in @xmath52 and @xmath53 erg s@xmath11 in @xmath54 @xcite .\",\n \"thus the flux ratio and luminosity are also consistent with sources of pwn origin . while there are observational evidences supporting the pwn origin as discussed above , others challenge such a view . with the assumption of @xmath49 kpc ,\",\n \"the core size and whole radial extent would be 2 pc and 12 pc , respectively .\",\n \"the core size of 2 pc is a little large , but not exceptional among other pwn @xcite .\",\n \"the whole extent of 12 pc is not surprisingly large compared with the nebula of e.g. , psr j18261334 @xcite .\",\n \"the largest drawback of the pwn hypothesis is lacking the detection of both a pulsar and radio pwn associated .\",\n \"it is known that the pulsar luminosity and its nebula luminosity in the x - ray band are correlated over 7 orders of magnitude @xcite . according to the correlation\",\n \", the not - yet - detected pulsar should be brighter than @xmath55 in x - rays , one - tenth of the pwn luminosity . such a pulsar would have been easily detected with xmm - newton .\",\n \"in addition , the x - ray photon index of the nebula ( @xmath56 ) is very steep among the known x - ray nebulae most of which have a @xmath57 between 1.22.2 @xcite . in terms of photon\",\n \"index comparison , non - thermal snrs might present a more plausible scenario than pwne .\",\n \"most of non - thermal snrs radiate synchrotron x - rays with a photon index of @xmath58 @xcite .\",\n \"the x - ray luminosity and extent are also compatible to synchrotron snrs @xcite .\",\n \"however , the facts that the source has a center - filled morphology in the x - ray band and no detection of the shell structure in the radio band hamper the interpretation as a non - thermal snr . in summary , we have not reached a firm conclusion on the nature of hess j1427608 .\",\n \"pwn and/or non - thermal snr , which are not necessary exclusive to each other , are the prime candidates but a decisive observational evidence is lacking . increasing statistics in fermi data\",\n \"may reveal a pulsation from 2fgl j1427.66048c\",\n \". a deep radio observation would also be helpful if it could detect pulsations or reveal the morphology of the source .\",\n \"we observed hess j1427608 with suzaku , which is combined with the archival data analysis of xmm - newton , and obtained following results . *\",\n \"we discovered an x - ray counterpart , suzaku j14276051 , of hess j1427608 .\",\n \"it is intrinsically extended ( @xmath59 ) and has a spectral shape of an absorbed power - law with a photon index of @xmath2 .\",\n \"* several faint point sources were found in spatial coincidence with hess j1427608 using xmm - newton archival data in the soft x - ray band . *\",\n \"observational properties of suzaku j14276051 and hess j1427608 are compared with those of known pwne and non - thermal snrs .\",\n \"some properties favor the pwn and/or snr origin , but the available data are insufficient to draw firm conclusions .\",\n \"we thank kentaro someya , yoshitomo maeda and michito sakai for their useful comments .\",\n \"t.f . acknowledges the financial support from the global center of excellence program by mext , japan through the `` nanoscience and quantum physics '' project of the tokyo institute of technology , and jsps young research fellowship , no .\",\n \"23 - 9676 . the work of k.m .\",\n \"is partially supported by the grant - in - aid for young scientists ( b ) of the mext ( no .\",\n \"24740167 ) .\",\n \"aharonian , f. , et al .\",\n \"2005 , science , 307 , 1938 aharonian , f. , et al .\",\n \"2006 , , 636 , 777 aharonian , f. , et al .\",\n \"2008 , , 477 , 353 de jager , o. c. , & djannati - ata , a. 2009 , in neutron stars and pulsars , ed .\",\n \"w. becker ( berlin : springer ) , 451 fukazawa , y. , et al .\",\n \"2009 , , 61 , s17 fujinaga , t. , et al .\",\n \"2011 , , 63 , s863 green , d. a. 2009 , bull .\",\n \"india , 37 , 45 hinton , j. a. & hoffman , w. 2009 , araa , 47 , 523 ishihara , d. , et al .\",\n \"2010 , , 514 , a1 ishisaki , y. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s113 jansen , f. , et al .\",\n \"2001 , , 365 , l1 kalberla , m. , et al .\",\n \"2005 , , 440 , 775 kargaltsev , o. , & pavlov , g. g. 2008 , in aip conf . proc . , 983 , 40 years of pulsars : millisecond pulsars , magnetars and more , ed .\",\n \"bassa et al .\",\n \"( new york : aip ) , 171 kokubun , m. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s53 koyama , k. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s23 kushino , a. , ishisaki , y. , morita , u. , yamasaki , n. y. , ishida , m. , ohashi , t. , & ueda , y. 2002 , , 54 , 327 manchester , r.n . , et al .\",\n \"2005 , , 129 , 1993 mattana , f. , et al .\",\n \"2010 , , 694 , 12 mitsuda , k. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s1 nakamura , r. , et al .\",\n \"2009 , , 61 , s197 nakamura , r. , bamba , a. , dotani , t. , ishida , m. , yamazaki , r. , & kohri , k. 2012 , , 746 , 134 nolan , p. l. , et al .\",\n \"2012 , , 199 , 31 prigozhin , g. , burke , b. , bautz , m. , kissel , s. , lamarr , b. 2008 , ieee transactions on electron devices , 55 , 2111 serlemitsos , p. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s9 strder , l. , et al .\",\n \"2001 , , 365 , l18 takahashi , t. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s35 turner et al .\",\n \"2001 , , 365 , l27 tawa , n. , et al .\",\n \"2008 , , 60 , s11 uchiyama , h. , et al .\",\n \"2009a , , 61 , s9 uchiyama , h. , et al .\",\n \"2009b , , 61 , s189 yamauchi , c. , et al .\",\n \"2011 , pasp , 123 , 852 yamazaki , r. , kohri , k. , bamba , a. , yoshida , t. , tsuribe , t. , & takahara , f. 2006 , , 371 , 1975 lccc & soft & medium & high + @xmath62 ( @xmath63 cm@xmath12 ) & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & @xmath67 + @xmath68 ( kev ) & @xmath69 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 + absorbed flux & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 + & + ne & + s & + ar & + others & + line @xmath75 ( kev ) & + line flux & + @xmath18/d.o.f & + + + lcc & power - law & apec + @xmath62 ( @xmath63 cm@xmath12 ) & @xmath76 & @xmath77 + @xmath57 & @xmath78 & + @xmath68 ( kev ) & & @xmath79 + abundance ( @xmath80 ) & & @xmath81 + unabsorbed flux & @xmath82 & @xmath83 + absorbed flux & 3.1 & 3.0 + @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 + + + i d & name & distance & + & & & 0.32 kev & 212 kev + x1 & xmmu j142755.4605112.9 & & 5.3 & 3.3 + x2 & xmmu j142746.5605011.4 & & & 1.9 + x3 & xmmu j142746.8605317.8 & & 2.3 & + x4 & xmmu j142800.7605356.4 & & 2.7 & + x5 & xmmu j142731.4605141.4 & & & 2.9 + x6 & xmmu j142810.3604752.0 & & 3.3 & 1.7 + x7 & xmmu j142736.9604712.8 & & 1.9 & + x8 & xmmu j142711.0605320.3 & & & 2.2 + x9 & xmmu j142742.7604436.9 & & 3.4 & + x10 & xmmu j142722.3604425.8 & & & 3.1 + x11 & xmmu j142856.1605027.9 & & 3.0 & + x12 & xmmu j142649.9604810.0 & & & 1.7 + x13 & xmmu j142810.0604337.9 & & 9.1 & + x14 & xmmu j142651.3605300.9 & & 4.9 & + x15 & xmmu j142654.9604556.1 & & 4.1 & + x16 & xmmu j142855.6604636.4 & & 3.1 & + + + lcc & x1 & sum of x1x7 + @xmath62 ( @xmath87 ) & @xmath88 & @xmath89 + @xmath57 & 3.1 ( fixed ) & 3.1 ( fixed ) + unabsorbed flux & @xmath90 & @xmath91 + absorbed flux & 0.7 & 1.7 + & 11.28 / 6 & 16.74 / 27 + + +\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> we report the discovery of an x - ray counterpart of the unidentified very high energy gamma - ray source hess j1427608 . in the sky field </S>","<S> coincident with hess j1427608 , an extended source was found in the 28 kev band , and was designated as suzaku j14276051 . </S>","<S> its x - ray radial profile has an extension of @xmath0 if approximated by a gaussian . </S>","<S> the spectrum was well fitted by an absorbed power - law with @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and the unabsorbed flux @xmath3 in the 210 kev band . </S>","<S> using xmm - newton archive data , we found seven point sources in the suzaku source region . </S>","<S> however , because their total flux and absorbing column densities are more than an order of magnitude lower than those of suzaku j14276051 , we consider that they are unrelated to the suzaku source . </S>","<S> thus , suzaku j14276051 is considered to be a truly diffuse source and an x - ray counterpart of hess j1427608 . </S>","<S> the possible nature of hess j1427608 is discussed based on the observational properties . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> we report the discovery of an x - ray counterpart of the unidentified very high energy gamma - ray source hess j1427608 . in the sky field </S>\",\n \"<S> coincident with hess j1427608 , an extended source was found in the 28 kev band , and was designated as suzaku j14276051 . </S>\",\n \"<S> its x - ray radial profile has an extension of @xmath0 if approximated by a gaussian . </S>\",\n \"<S> the spectrum was well fitted by an absorbed power - law with @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and the unabsorbed flux @xmath3 in the 210 kev band . </S>\",\n \"<S> using xmm - newton archive data , we found seven point sources in the suzaku source region . </S>\",\n \"<S> however , because their total flux and absorbing column densities are more than an order of magnitude lower than those of suzaku j14276051 , we consider that they are unrelated to the suzaku source . </S>\",\n \"<S> thus , suzaku j14276051 is considered to be a truly diffuse source and an x - ray counterpart of hess j1427608 . </S>\",\n \"<S> the possible nature of hess j1427608 is discussed based on the observational properties . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","observation and data reduction","analysis","archival data of xmm-newton","discussion","conclusion"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"observation and data reduction\",\n \"analysis\",\n \"archival data of xmm-newton\",\n \"discussion\",\n \"conclusion\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["the origin of cosmic rays is an unsolved problem since the discovery in 1912 .","the spectrum of cosmic rays has a break at the knee energy ( @xmath4 ev ) , and those below the knee energy are believed to have galactic origin .","recently , the high energy stereoscopic system ( h.e.s.s . ) found more than 50 sources on the galactic plane in the very high energy ( vhe ; @xmath5 gev ) gamma - ray band ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . because vhe gamma - rays are produced either through inverse compton scattering of low energy photons by relativistic electrons , or through the decay of pions produced by collisions of relativistic protons with interstellar medium , high energy particles are surely present in the vhe gamma - ray sources .","if relativistic electrons are present , they may be traced through the observations of synchrotron x - ray emission .","however , in spite of extensive x - ray followup observations , a non - negligible fraction of the galactic vhe gamma - ray sources do not have an x - ray counterpart , and they are referred to as unidentified ( unid ) sources ( e.g. , @xcite ) . among identified galactic vhe gamma - ray sources , pulsar wind nebulae ( pwne ) represent the largest population @xcite .","accordingly , one would expect that pwne are the first candidate of the origin of the unid vhe gamma - ray sources .","however , identifying the vhe gamma - ray sources as pwne is not straightforward .","the vhe gamma - ray emission region sometimes shows significant spatial offset from the x - ray emission region or a pulsar ( e.g. , @xcite ) .","furthermore , the life time of x - ray emitting electrons through synchrotron emission may be shorter than that of vhe gamma - ray emitting electrons through compton scattering .","this means that x - ray emission from the pwne can be much dimmer than the vhe gamma - rays if the pwne are old .","finally , a pulsar is not always found in the vicinity of ( candidate ) pwne .","hess j1427608 is one of the unid vhe gamma - ray sources located at @xmath6 @xcite , and is extended with @xmath7 .","the flux is @xmath8 in the 110 tev band with a photon index of @xmath9 @xcite .","no plausible counterpart is listed in the galactic supernova remnant ( snr ) catalog @xcite or in the simbad data base in the vicinity of hess j1427608 .","we also looked for a possible counterpart in the atnf pulsar catalog @xcite .","however , no energetic pulsar was found within from hess j1427608 . here",", the definition of the energetic pulsar is those with @xmath10 erg s@xmath11 kpc@xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the spin - down energy and @xmath14 is the distance to the source .","this search radius of is large enough compared to offsets of radio pulsars to vhe sources among known pwn systems , and virtually excludes the possibility of associating hess j1427608 with any known energetic radio pulsar .","thus , hess j1427608 seems to be one of the most `` unlikely '' pwne among the vhe gamma - ray sources . in order to search for an x - ray counterpart",", we observed hess j1427608 with suzaku , and also analyzed the xmm - newton archive data ."],["we observed the sky region including hess j1427608 with suzaku ( @xcite ) from 2010 january 13 through 16 .","the journal of the observation is listed in table [ tab : obslog ] .","suzaku is equipped with two types of detectors : four sets of x - ray imaging spectrometers ( xis0xis3 : @xcite ) and a non - imaging hard x - ray detector ( hxd : @xcite ; @xcite ) .","xis1 uses the back - illuminated ( bi ) ccd while the others the front - illuminated ( fi ) ccds . among the four sensors ,","xis2 is not operational and a part of xis0 ( corresponding to the off - source region in the latter analysis ) is not usable due to its anomaly . hereafter ,","unless otherwise mentioned , we used only xis1 and xis3 data for the current analysis .","xis was operated in normal clocking mode without any window options .","spaced - row charge injection ( @xcite ; @xcite ) was used to reduce the effects of radiation damage .","we used version 2.4.12.27 of the processed data for hess j1427608 .","the data was analyzed with the headas software version 6.10 and xspec version 12.6.0 .","we used the cleaned event file created by the suzaku team .","the resultant effective exposure was 104 ks ."],["figure 1 shows xis images in the soft ( 0.52 kev ) and the hard ( 28 kev ) bands .","the images were corrected for exposure using an exposure map generated by the ftool xisexpmapgen after subtracting non x - ray background ( nxb ) images generated by the ftool xisnxbgen @xcite .","finally , the xis1 and xis3 images were added , and the resulting image was binned to a pixel size of and smoothed with a gaussian of @xmath15 .","the position center and the extent of hess j1427608 are shown as a black cross and a yellow dashed circle , respectively .","a few faint , point - like sources are seen in the soft band , while an apparently extended source is detected in the hard band .","the position and apparent extension of the hard source match those of hess j1427608 . as will be shown in a later section , all the suzaku soft - band sources","may be explained by the point - like sources in the xmm - newton archive data while the suzaku hard - band source seems to be a truly new source .","we thus designate the central hard - band source suzaku j14276051 , and mainly focus on this source in the following analysis .","because hess j1427608 and suzaku j14276051 are both extended , we evaluate the x - ray size of the source .","for this purpose , careful estimation of the x - ray background is necessary since suzaku j14276051 is relatively faint . in particular",", this region contains significant contribution from the galactic ridge x - ray emission ( grxe ) as well as the cosmic x - ray background ( cxb ) , both of which are subject to mirror vignetting effect resulting in a centrally - peaked spatial distribution .","therefore , it is not appropriate to assume a flat background image defined at an off - source region within the field of view ( fov ) . instead , we estimated the grxe+cxb image in the source region through monte - carlo simulation .","we explain details of the x - ray background estimation below .","first , we estimated the surface brightness of the grxe and cxb assuming their uniform distribution in the sky . for this purpose",", we analyzed the x - ray spectrum in the off - source annulus region shown in figure [ fig : xisspecreg ] .","the region ( between and from the center of suzaku j14276051 ) was selected to minimize contamination from suzaku j14276051 . in other words ,","the off - source region contains only the grxe and the cxb after the subtraction of nxb .","figure [ fig : xisanuspec ] shows the spectra extracted from the off - source region .","the spectra were modeled by optically thin thermal three temperature plasma with neutral iron emission line plus the cxb following @xcite .","in the course of model fitting , the hydrogen column density was fixed to @xmath16 determined by hi observations ( @xcite ) , the photon index of the cxb to 1.4 , and the surface brightness of the cxb to @xmath17 in the 210 kev band ( @xcite ) .","we made the ancillary response file using the ftool xissimarfgen assuming a uniform emission in the sky .","the model could reproduce the observed spectrum well .","the best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : xisanuspec ] .","next , we simulated the grxe+cxb event data assuming uniform emission with the best - fit spectrum model determined above using the ftool xissim @xcite . in order to avoid an extra ambiguity due to poor statistics , the exposure time for the simulation","was set to 500 ks .","then we extracted the grxe+cxb spectrum in the source region and added it to the nxb in the source region to obtain the total background spectrum , following the instruction in section 5.5.2 of the suzaku technical description .","figure [ fig : xisspeccomp ] shows the simulated background spectra of the xis1 and xis3 respectively as well as the source and off - source spectra . as can be seen from the spectra , the source region contains significant emission above the grxe+cxb level .","figure [ fig : xisprof ] shows the radial profiles of the nxb - subtracted image and the simulated grxe+cxb image in the 28 kev band .","the difference is attributed to suzaku j14276051 . even if we consider the relatively broad half - power radius (;","@xcite ) of the point spread function of suzaku mirror , suzaku j14276051 is clearly extended . in order to estimate the source extent , we compared the observed radial profile with that of a model calculation for an extended source having a 2d - gaussian distribution . instead of performing the @xmath18 fitting , we calculated @xmath18 for a set of @xmath19 , i.e. , , , , and .","the simulated profiles were generated with xissim .","it turned out that none of them gave an acceptable fit ; the radial profile of suzaku j14276051 has a core and a tail in comparison with the best - fit simulation data .","we thus performed the @xmath18 test using only the core region ( @xmath20 ) .","we then could obtain an acceptable fit ( @xmath21 for 3 degrees of freedom ) .","the best - fit value obtained was @xmath0 with 90% confidence level .","although suzaku j14276051 is extended , we tried to search for pulsations in the xis light curve as point sources may be hidden in the image .","we extracted light curves of the source region in the 0.510 kev band and binned them to a time resolution of 16 sec .","we calculated fourier power spectra every 2048 bin ( @xmath22 9.1 hour ) using the ftool powspec to obtain the ensemble - averaged power spectrum density ( psd ) .","the psd of xis1 is dominated by the orbital period of the satellite and its higher harmonics , probably due to the contamination of earth albedo .","thus we used only the psd of xis3 in the subsequent analysis .","no significant peak was detected in the psd with an upper limit of @xmath23 ( poisson fluctuation level was normalized to 2.0 ) , which corresponds to an rms amplitude of 0.0064 count s@xmath11 .","because the net count rate of the source is 0.021 count s@xmath11 , this corresponds to a relative amplitude of 31% .","thus we conclude that no coherent pulsation is present in the light curves of suzaku j14276051 with an upper limit of 31 % between the pulse periods of 32 sec and 32768 sec .","figure [ fig : xisspec ] shows the background - subtracted energy spectra of suzaku j14276051 . here",", the background spectrum ( sum of grxe , cxb , and nxb ) was calculated with the method detailed in section [ subsec : xisimage ] .","it is found that the spectrum of suzaku j14276051 is featureless and heavily absorbed .","although a hint of feature is seen in the 67 kev band , which may be due to the spacial variation of the iron emission line in grxe , it is not statistically significant .","we calculated the ancillary response file using the ftool xissimarfgen for an extended source of a gaussian profile with @xmath24 .","the spectrum was well modeled by either an absorbed power - law or a thermal model , whose best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : xisparm ] . however ,","a thermal origin is unlikely because the abundance is unreasonably small , and the x - rays are thus considered to be produced by non - thermal processes .","the absorbed x - ray flux of the source is @xmath25 in the 210 kev band .","we also analyzed the spectrum of the hxd to search for emission of suzaku j14276051 above 10 kev .","we used the background spectrum called `` bgd_d '' provided by the suzaku team @xcite and added the cxb to it using the ftool hxdpinnxbpi .","we used the xis nominal - position response file categorized to epoch 6 , released as a caldb .","we made the background - subtracted spectrum and fitted it with a power - law , whose photon index was fixed to @xmath26 , as derived from the xis analysis .","the flux in the 1540 kev band is ( @xmath27 ) @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) if no systematic error is taken into account .","based on @xcite , who showed the reproducibility of nxb in the 1540 kev band is about 3% in the 90% confidence range , we constructed the nxb spectra with 3% higher count rates to include the systematic error of the nxb reproduction .","then , a significant signal is no longer detected .","we thus obtained the 90% upper limit of @xmath30 in the 1540 kev band ."],["in order to estimate the contribution of point sources , we analyzed the archival data of xmm - newton including the hess j1427608 field .","xmm - newton ( @xcite ) carries three x - ray telescopes each equipped with a european photon imaging camera ( epic ) at the foci .","epic consists of two mos ccd camera ( mos1 and mos2 : @xcite ) and a pn ccd camera ( pn : @xcite ) .","the observation was carried out on 2007 august 9 for 24 ks . during the observation , epic was operated in full - frame mode with medium filter .","the data were analyzed with the science analysis software ( sas ) version 10.0.0 , headas version 6.10 and xspec version 12.6.0 .","time intervals of enhanced background , which are caused by soft proton flares , were removed with thresholds of 0.20 count s@xmath11 for mos1 , 0.24 count s@xmath11 for mos2 , and 0.6 count s@xmath11 for pn , respectively , calculated for pattern=0 events above 10 kev .","we used x - ray events of pattern=012 ( for mos cameras ) and pattern=04 ( for pn camera ) for the image and spectral analyses .","the resultant effective exposures were 21 ks ( mos1 ) , 22 ks ( mos2 ) , and 15 ks ( pn ) , respectively .","the journal of the observation is listed in table [ tab : obslog ] .","figure [ fig : epicimage ] shows the summed images of mos1 and mos2 in the soft ( 0.32 kev ) and the hard ( 212 kev ) bands .","the xis images are also overlaid in green contours . using the sas tool edetect_chain ,","a total of 16 point sources were detected within from the center of suzaku j14276051 .","eleven and seven sources were found in the soft and the hard bands , respectively , and two sources were commonly detected in both bands .","names and count rates of the point sources are listed in table [ tab : xmmps ] .","summing up the count rates of the point sources located within the suzaku source region ( x1 through x7 ) , we obtained @xmath31 count s@xmath11 in the 0.52 kev band .","this may be converted to the xis bi count rate of @xmath32 count s@xmath11 assuming the power - law spectrum in table 2 . because this is comparable to the rate actually observed with suzaku ( @xmath33 count s@xmath11 ) ,","the xis data may be explained by the sum of the xmm - newton point sources in the soft band .","on the other hand , if we carry out a similar calculation for the hard band , the xmm - newton point sources would produce @xmath34 count s@xmath11 in xis .","because this corresponds to only @xmath35 % of the actual xis count rate , suzaku j14276051 is difficult to be explained by the sum of the sources and may be a truly diffuse source .","we calculated the energy spectra of only x1 and of the summed spectra of the central seven point sources ( x1 through x7 ) .","we made the response file and the ancillary response file using the sas tool rmfgen and arfgen , respectively .","we fitted these spectra with the model of an absorbed power - law .","because of the poor statistics , the photon index was fixed to 3.1 , which was determined by the spectral analysis of suzaku j14276051 .","the best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : epicparm ] .","figure [ fig : epicspec ] shows the summed spectra of the seven point sources .","the absorbed x - ray flux of the summed spectra was @xmath36 in the 210 kev band , which is about 5% of the flux derived with suzaku for suzaku j14276051 .","it is also found that the column density of the summed spectra is two orders of magnitude smaller than that derived for suzaku j14276051 .","these results confirm that suzaku j14276051 can not be explained by the xmm - newton point sources ."],["we discovered an apparently - diffuse hard x - ray source , suzaku j14276051 with suzaku , and several point sources with xmm - newton in spatial coincidence with hess j1427608 .","we found that suzaku j14276051 could not be explained by the sum of the point sources detected with xmm - newton , and concluded that it is a truly diffuse source . even if time variability of the detected point - like sources is considered , it is unlikely that suzaku j14276051 is explained by them because the hydrogen column densities are quite different .","the xmm - newton point sources are most likely foreground sources . to explain","suzaku j14276051 by the sum of several point sources would require that all those sources would be below detection threshold at the time of the xmm - newton observation , which appears very unlikely .","thus , we concluded that suzaku j14276051 is an intrinsically diffuse source and the x - ray counterpart of hess j1427608 .","we searched various catalogs and literature for the possible counterpart of hess j1427608 in other wavebands .","a gev gamma - ray source , 2fgl j1427.66048c , is listed in the 2-year catalog of fermi ( @xcite ) .","the gev source is located at @xmath37 , which is away from the center of hess j1427608 ( see figure [ fig : xisimage ] ) . since the error radius of the position is about ,","it may be associated with hess j1427608 @xcite . however ,","this is a `` c - designator - applied ''","fermi source whose position , emission characteristics , or even existence may not be reliable due to a potential confusion with interstellar emission @xcite .","we believe it is premature to discuss a possible association of the gev source to hess j1427608 ; future fermi data and analysis is necessary .","we also searched the akari point source catalogues ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .","no point source was found in the mid - infrared ( @xmath38 m ) and the far - infrared ( @xmath39 m ) bands within from the center of hess j1427608 .","although we mentioned hess j1427608 as one of the most `` unlikely '' pwne in the introduction , its center - filled morphology and featureless spectrum in the x - ray band suggest that the source could be a pwn .","thus we postulate here that the source is a pwn as a working hypothesis",". figure [ fig : wideband ] shows the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) from x - rays to vhe gamma - rays .","the estimated synchrotron spectra from the vhe gamma - ray spectrum @xcite , assuming that the same electron population would inverse - compton scatter cmb photons up to vhe gamma - rays and radiate synchrotron emission in x - rays , are also plotted with a local magnetic field @xmath40 of 1 , 3 , and 10@xmath41 .","this sed plot indicates that the simple one - zone leptonic model with @xmath40 of about 5@xmath42 g would roughly explain both the x - ray and vhe gamma - ray data . in this context",", the steep suzaku spectrum of @xmath43 could indicate that the suzaku energy band is higher than the cut - off energy .","the inferred magnetic field strength of @xmath225@xmath42 g is within the range of typical values on the galactic plane .","thus the sed is consistent with a one - zone leptonic model expected for pwne .","we next examine the flux ratio and luminosities . the x - ray to vhe gamma - ray ratio is useful to probe the nature of unid sources @xcite . in the case of hess","j1427608 , the unabsorbed x - ray flux @xmath44 of @xmath45 ( 210 kev ) and the vhe gamma - ray flux @xmath46 of @xmath47 ( 110 tev ) result in a flux ratio of @xmath48 .","if we assume a distance to hess j1427608 of @xmath49 kpc , the x - ray luminosity would be @xmath50 .","the estimated flux ratio and x - ray luminosity are within the values of known x - ray and vhe gamma - ray emitting pwne , given that both values show a large scatter : @xmath51 in @xmath52 and @xmath53 erg s@xmath11 in @xmath54 @xcite .","thus the flux ratio and luminosity are also consistent with sources of pwn origin . while there are observational evidences supporting the pwn origin as discussed above , others challenge such a view . with the assumption of @xmath49 kpc ,","the core size and whole radial extent would be 2 pc and 12 pc , respectively .","the core size of 2 pc is a little large , but not exceptional among other pwn @xcite .","the whole extent of 12 pc is not surprisingly large compared with the nebula of e.g. , psr j18261334 @xcite .","the largest drawback of the pwn hypothesis is lacking the detection of both a pulsar and radio pwn associated .","it is known that the pulsar luminosity and its nebula luminosity in the x - ray band are correlated over 7 orders of magnitude @xcite . according to the correlation",", the not - yet - detected pulsar should be brighter than @xmath55 in x - rays , one - tenth of the pwn luminosity . such a pulsar would have been easily detected with xmm - newton .","in addition , the x - ray photon index of the nebula ( @xmath56 ) is very steep among the known x - ray nebulae most of which have a @xmath57 between 1.22.2 @xcite . in terms of photon","index comparison , non - thermal snrs might present a more plausible scenario than pwne .","most of non - thermal snrs radiate synchrotron x - rays with a photon index of @xmath58 @xcite .","the x - ray luminosity and extent are also compatible to synchrotron snrs @xcite .","however , the facts that the source has a center - filled morphology in the x - ray band and no detection of the shell structure in the radio band hamper the interpretation as a non - thermal snr . in summary , we have not reached a firm conclusion on the nature of hess j1427608 .","pwn and/or non - thermal snr , which are not necessary exclusive to each other , are the prime candidates but a decisive observational evidence is lacking . increasing statistics in fermi data","may reveal a pulsation from 2fgl j1427.66048c",". a deep radio observation would also be helpful if it could detect pulsations or reveal the morphology of the source ."],["we observed hess j1427608 with suzaku , which is combined with the archival data analysis of xmm - newton , and obtained following results . *","we discovered an x - ray counterpart , suzaku j14276051 , of hess j1427608 .","it is intrinsically extended ( @xmath59 ) and has a spectral shape of an absorbed power - law with a photon index of @xmath2 .","* several faint point sources were found in spatial coincidence with hess j1427608 using xmm - newton archival data in the soft x - ray band . *","observational properties of suzaku j14276051 and hess j1427608 are compared with those of known pwne and non - thermal snrs .","some properties favor the pwn and/or snr origin , but the available data are insufficient to draw firm conclusions .","we thank kentaro someya , yoshitomo maeda and michito sakai for their useful comments .","t.f . acknowledges the financial support from the global center of excellence program by mext , japan through the `` nanoscience and quantum physics '' project of the tokyo institute of technology , and jsps young research fellowship , no .","23 - 9676 . the work of k.m .","is partially supported by the grant - in - aid for young scientists ( b ) of the mext ( no .","24740167 ) .","aharonian , f. , et al .","2005 , science , 307 , 1938 aharonian , f. , et al .","2006 , , 636 , 777 aharonian , f. , et al .","2008 , , 477 , 353 de jager , o. c. , & djannati - ata , a. 2009 , in neutron stars and pulsars , ed .","w. becker ( berlin : springer ) , 451 fukazawa , y. , et al .","2009 , , 61 , s17 fujinaga , t. , et al .","2011 , , 63 , s863 green , d. a. 2009 , bull .","india , 37 , 45 hinton , j. a. & hoffman , w. 2009 , araa , 47 , 523 ishihara , d. , et al .","2010 , , 514 , a1 ishisaki , y. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s113 jansen , f. , et al .","2001 , , 365 , l1 kalberla , m. , et al .","2005 , , 440 , 775 kargaltsev , o. , & pavlov , g. g. 2008 , in aip conf . proc . , 983 , 40 years of pulsars : millisecond pulsars , magnetars and more , ed .","bassa et al .","( new york : aip ) , 171 kokubun , m. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s53 koyama , k. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s23 kushino , a. , ishisaki , y. , morita , u. , yamasaki , n. y. , ishida , m. , ohashi , t. , & ueda , y. 2002 , , 54 , 327 manchester , r.n . , et al .","2005 , , 129 , 1993 mattana , f. , et al .","2010 , , 694 , 12 mitsuda , k. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s1 nakamura , r. , et al .","2009 , , 61 , s197 nakamura , r. , bamba , a. , dotani , t. , ishida , m. , yamazaki , r. , & kohri , k. 2012 , , 746 , 134 nolan , p. l. , et al .","2012 , , 199 , 31 prigozhin , g. , burke , b. , bautz , m. , kissel , s. , lamarr , b. 2008 , ieee transactions on electron devices , 55 , 2111 serlemitsos , p. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s9 strder , l. , et al .","2001 , , 365 , l18 takahashi , t. , et al .","2007 , , 59 , s35 turner et al .","2001 , , 365 , l27 tawa , n. , et al .","2008 , , 60 , s11 uchiyama , h. , et al .","2009a , , 61 , s9 uchiyama , h. , et al .","2009b , , 61 , s189 yamauchi , c. , et al .","2011 , pasp , 123 , 852 yamazaki , r. , kohri , k. , bamba , a. , yoshida , t. , tsuribe , t. , & takahara , f. 2006 , , 371 , 1975 lccc & soft & medium & high + @xmath62 ( @xmath63 cm@xmath12 ) & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & @xmath67 + @xmath68 ( kev ) & @xmath69 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 + absorbed flux & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 + & + ne & + s & + ar & + others & + line @xmath75 ( kev ) & + line flux & + @xmath18/d.o.f & + + + lcc & power - law & apec + @xmath62 ( @xmath63 cm@xmath12 ) & @xmath76 & @xmath77 + @xmath57 & @xmath78 & + @xmath68 ( kev ) & & @xmath79 + abundance ( @xmath80 ) & & @xmath81 + unabsorbed flux & @xmath82 & @xmath83 + absorbed flux & 3.1 & 3.0 + @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 + + + i d & name & distance & + & & & 0.32 kev & 212 kev + x1 & xmmu j142755.4605112.9 & & 5.3 & 3.3 + x2 & xmmu j142746.5605011.4 & & & 1.9 + x3 & xmmu j142746.8605317.8 & & 2.3 & + x4 & xmmu j142800.7605356.4 & & 2.7 & + x5 & xmmu j142731.4605141.4 & & & 2.9 + x6 & xmmu j142810.3604752.0 & & 3.3 & 1.7 + x7 & xmmu j142736.9604712.8 & & 1.9 & + x8 & xmmu j142711.0605320.3 & & & 2.2 + x9 & xmmu j142742.7604436.9 & & 3.4 & + x10 & xmmu j142722.3604425.8 & & & 3.1 + x11 & xmmu j142856.1605027.9 & & 3.0 & + x12 & xmmu j142649.9604810.0 & & & 1.7 + x13 & xmmu j142810.0604337.9 & & 9.1 & + x14 & xmmu j142651.3605300.9 & & 4.9 & + x15 & xmmu j142654.9604556.1 & & 4.1 & + x16 & xmmu j142855.6604636.4 & & 3.1 & + + + lcc & x1 & sum of x1x7 + @xmath62 ( @xmath87 ) & @xmath88 & @xmath89 + @xmath57 & 3.1 ( fixed ) & 3.1 ( fixed ) + unabsorbed flux & @xmath90 & @xmath91 + absorbed flux & 0.7 & 1.7 + & 11.28 / 6 & 16.74 / 27 + + +"]],"string":"[\n [\n \"the origin of cosmic rays is an unsolved problem since the discovery in 1912 .\",\n \"the spectrum of cosmic rays has a break at the knee energy ( @xmath4 ev ) , and those below the knee energy are believed to have galactic origin .\",\n \"recently , the high energy stereoscopic system ( h.e.s.s . ) found more than 50 sources on the galactic plane in the very high energy ( vhe ; @xmath5 gev ) gamma - ray band ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . because vhe gamma - rays are produced either through inverse compton scattering of low energy photons by relativistic electrons , or through the decay of pions produced by collisions of relativistic protons with interstellar medium , high energy particles are surely present in the vhe gamma - ray sources .\",\n \"if relativistic electrons are present , they may be traced through the observations of synchrotron x - ray emission .\",\n \"however , in spite of extensive x - ray followup observations , a non - negligible fraction of the galactic vhe gamma - ray sources do not have an x - ray counterpart , and they are referred to as unidentified ( unid ) sources ( e.g. , @xcite ) . among identified galactic vhe gamma - ray sources , pulsar wind nebulae ( pwne ) represent the largest population @xcite .\",\n \"accordingly , one would expect that pwne are the first candidate of the origin of the unid vhe gamma - ray sources .\",\n \"however , identifying the vhe gamma - ray sources as pwne is not straightforward .\",\n \"the vhe gamma - ray emission region sometimes shows significant spatial offset from the x - ray emission region or a pulsar ( e.g. , @xcite ) .\",\n \"furthermore , the life time of x - ray emitting electrons through synchrotron emission may be shorter than that of vhe gamma - ray emitting electrons through compton scattering .\",\n \"this means that x - ray emission from the pwne can be much dimmer than the vhe gamma - rays if the pwne are old .\",\n \"finally , a pulsar is not always found in the vicinity of ( candidate ) pwne .\",\n \"hess j1427608 is one of the unid vhe gamma - ray sources located at @xmath6 @xcite , and is extended with @xmath7 .\",\n \"the flux is @xmath8 in the 110 tev band with a photon index of @xmath9 @xcite .\",\n \"no plausible counterpart is listed in the galactic supernova remnant ( snr ) catalog @xcite or in the simbad data base in the vicinity of hess j1427608 .\",\n \"we also looked for a possible counterpart in the atnf pulsar catalog @xcite .\",\n \"however , no energetic pulsar was found within from hess j1427608 . here\",\n \", the definition of the energetic pulsar is those with @xmath10 erg s@xmath11 kpc@xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the spin - down energy and @xmath14 is the distance to the source .\",\n \"this search radius of is large enough compared to offsets of radio pulsars to vhe sources among known pwn systems , and virtually excludes the possibility of associating hess j1427608 with any known energetic radio pulsar .\",\n \"thus , hess j1427608 seems to be one of the most `` unlikely '' pwne among the vhe gamma - ray sources . in order to search for an x - ray counterpart\",\n \", we observed hess j1427608 with suzaku , and also analyzed the xmm - newton archive data .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we observed the sky region including hess j1427608 with suzaku ( @xcite ) from 2010 january 13 through 16 .\",\n \"the journal of the observation is listed in table [ tab : obslog ] .\",\n \"suzaku is equipped with two types of detectors : four sets of x - ray imaging spectrometers ( xis0xis3 : @xcite ) and a non - imaging hard x - ray detector ( hxd : @xcite ; @xcite ) .\",\n \"xis1 uses the back - illuminated ( bi ) ccd while the others the front - illuminated ( fi ) ccds . among the four sensors ,\",\n \"xis2 is not operational and a part of xis0 ( corresponding to the off - source region in the latter analysis ) is not usable due to its anomaly . hereafter ,\",\n \"unless otherwise mentioned , we used only xis1 and xis3 data for the current analysis .\",\n \"xis was operated in normal clocking mode without any window options .\",\n \"spaced - row charge injection ( @xcite ; @xcite ) was used to reduce the effects of radiation damage .\",\n \"we used version 2.4.12.27 of the processed data for hess j1427608 .\",\n \"the data was analyzed with the headas software version 6.10 and xspec version 12.6.0 .\",\n \"we used the cleaned event file created by the suzaku team .\",\n \"the resultant effective exposure was 104 ks .\"\n ],\n [\n \"figure 1 shows xis images in the soft ( 0.52 kev ) and the hard ( 28 kev ) bands .\",\n \"the images were corrected for exposure using an exposure map generated by the ftool xisexpmapgen after subtracting non x - ray background ( nxb ) images generated by the ftool xisnxbgen @xcite .\",\n \"finally , the xis1 and xis3 images were added , and the resulting image was binned to a pixel size of and smoothed with a gaussian of @xmath15 .\",\n \"the position center and the extent of hess j1427608 are shown as a black cross and a yellow dashed circle , respectively .\",\n \"a few faint , point - like sources are seen in the soft band , while an apparently extended source is detected in the hard band .\",\n \"the position and apparent extension of the hard source match those of hess j1427608 . as will be shown in a later section , all the suzaku soft - band sources\",\n \"may be explained by the point - like sources in the xmm - newton archive data while the suzaku hard - band source seems to be a truly new source .\",\n \"we thus designate the central hard - band source suzaku j14276051 , and mainly focus on this source in the following analysis .\",\n \"because hess j1427608 and suzaku j14276051 are both extended , we evaluate the x - ray size of the source .\",\n \"for this purpose , careful estimation of the x - ray background is necessary since suzaku j14276051 is relatively faint . in particular\",\n \", this region contains significant contribution from the galactic ridge x - ray emission ( grxe ) as well as the cosmic x - ray background ( cxb ) , both of which are subject to mirror vignetting effect resulting in a centrally - peaked spatial distribution .\",\n \"therefore , it is not appropriate to assume a flat background image defined at an off - source region within the field of view ( fov ) . instead , we estimated the grxe+cxb image in the source region through monte - carlo simulation .\",\n \"we explain details of the x - ray background estimation below .\",\n \"first , we estimated the surface brightness of the grxe and cxb assuming their uniform distribution in the sky . for this purpose\",\n \", we analyzed the x - ray spectrum in the off - source annulus region shown in figure [ fig : xisspecreg ] .\",\n \"the region ( between and from the center of suzaku j14276051 ) was selected to minimize contamination from suzaku j14276051 . in other words ,\",\n \"the off - source region contains only the grxe and the cxb after the subtraction of nxb .\",\n \"figure [ fig : xisanuspec ] shows the spectra extracted from the off - source region .\",\n \"the spectra were modeled by optically thin thermal three temperature plasma with neutral iron emission line plus the cxb following @xcite .\",\n \"in the course of model fitting , the hydrogen column density was fixed to @xmath16 determined by hi observations ( @xcite ) , the photon index of the cxb to 1.4 , and the surface brightness of the cxb to @xmath17 in the 210 kev band ( @xcite ) .\",\n \"we made the ancillary response file using the ftool xissimarfgen assuming a uniform emission in the sky .\",\n \"the model could reproduce the observed spectrum well .\",\n \"the best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : xisanuspec ] .\",\n \"next , we simulated the grxe+cxb event data assuming uniform emission with the best - fit spectrum model determined above using the ftool xissim @xcite . in order to avoid an extra ambiguity due to poor statistics , the exposure time for the simulation\",\n \"was set to 500 ks .\",\n \"then we extracted the grxe+cxb spectrum in the source region and added it to the nxb in the source region to obtain the total background spectrum , following the instruction in section 5.5.2 of the suzaku technical description .\",\n \"figure [ fig : xisspeccomp ] shows the simulated background spectra of the xis1 and xis3 respectively as well as the source and off - source spectra . as can be seen from the spectra , the source region contains significant emission above the grxe+cxb level .\",\n \"figure [ fig : xisprof ] shows the radial profiles of the nxb - subtracted image and the simulated grxe+cxb image in the 28 kev band .\",\n \"the difference is attributed to suzaku j14276051 . even if we consider the relatively broad half - power radius (;\",\n \"@xcite ) of the point spread function of suzaku mirror , suzaku j14276051 is clearly extended . in order to estimate the source extent , we compared the observed radial profile with that of a model calculation for an extended source having a 2d - gaussian distribution . instead of performing the @xmath18 fitting , we calculated @xmath18 for a set of @xmath19 , i.e. , , , , and .\",\n \"the simulated profiles were generated with xissim .\",\n \"it turned out that none of them gave an acceptable fit ; the radial profile of suzaku j14276051 has a core and a tail in comparison with the best - fit simulation data .\",\n \"we thus performed the @xmath18 test using only the core region ( @xmath20 ) .\",\n \"we then could obtain an acceptable fit ( @xmath21 for 3 degrees of freedom ) .\",\n \"the best - fit value obtained was @xmath0 with 90% confidence level .\",\n \"although suzaku j14276051 is extended , we tried to search for pulsations in the xis light curve as point sources may be hidden in the image .\",\n \"we extracted light curves of the source region in the 0.510 kev band and binned them to a time resolution of 16 sec .\",\n \"we calculated fourier power spectra every 2048 bin ( @xmath22 9.1 hour ) using the ftool powspec to obtain the ensemble - averaged power spectrum density ( psd ) .\",\n \"the psd of xis1 is dominated by the orbital period of the satellite and its higher harmonics , probably due to the contamination of earth albedo .\",\n \"thus we used only the psd of xis3 in the subsequent analysis .\",\n \"no significant peak was detected in the psd with an upper limit of @xmath23 ( poisson fluctuation level was normalized to 2.0 ) , which corresponds to an rms amplitude of 0.0064 count s@xmath11 .\",\n \"because the net count rate of the source is 0.021 count s@xmath11 , this corresponds to a relative amplitude of 31% .\",\n \"thus we conclude that no coherent pulsation is present in the light curves of suzaku j14276051 with an upper limit of 31 % between the pulse periods of 32 sec and 32768 sec .\",\n \"figure [ fig : xisspec ] shows the background - subtracted energy spectra of suzaku j14276051 . here\",\n \", the background spectrum ( sum of grxe , cxb , and nxb ) was calculated with the method detailed in section [ subsec : xisimage ] .\",\n \"it is found that the spectrum of suzaku j14276051 is featureless and heavily absorbed .\",\n \"although a hint of feature is seen in the 67 kev band , which may be due to the spacial variation of the iron emission line in grxe , it is not statistically significant .\",\n \"we calculated the ancillary response file using the ftool xissimarfgen for an extended source of a gaussian profile with @xmath24 .\",\n \"the spectrum was well modeled by either an absorbed power - law or a thermal model , whose best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : xisparm ] . however ,\",\n \"a thermal origin is unlikely because the abundance is unreasonably small , and the x - rays are thus considered to be produced by non - thermal processes .\",\n \"the absorbed x - ray flux of the source is @xmath25 in the 210 kev band .\",\n \"we also analyzed the spectrum of the hxd to search for emission of suzaku j14276051 above 10 kev .\",\n \"we used the background spectrum called `` bgd_d '' provided by the suzaku team @xcite and added the cxb to it using the ftool hxdpinnxbpi .\",\n \"we used the xis nominal - position response file categorized to epoch 6 , released as a caldb .\",\n \"we made the background - subtracted spectrum and fitted it with a power - law , whose photon index was fixed to @xmath26 , as derived from the xis analysis .\",\n \"the flux in the 1540 kev band is ( @xmath27 ) @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) if no systematic error is taken into account .\",\n \"based on @xcite , who showed the reproducibility of nxb in the 1540 kev band is about 3% in the 90% confidence range , we constructed the nxb spectra with 3% higher count rates to include the systematic error of the nxb reproduction .\",\n \"then , a significant signal is no longer detected .\",\n \"we thus obtained the 90% upper limit of @xmath30 in the 1540 kev band .\"\n ],\n [\n \"in order to estimate the contribution of point sources , we analyzed the archival data of xmm - newton including the hess j1427608 field .\",\n \"xmm - newton ( @xcite ) carries three x - ray telescopes each equipped with a european photon imaging camera ( epic ) at the foci .\",\n \"epic consists of two mos ccd camera ( mos1 and mos2 : @xcite ) and a pn ccd camera ( pn : @xcite ) .\",\n \"the observation was carried out on 2007 august 9 for 24 ks . during the observation , epic was operated in full - frame mode with medium filter .\",\n \"the data were analyzed with the science analysis software ( sas ) version 10.0.0 , headas version 6.10 and xspec version 12.6.0 .\",\n \"time intervals of enhanced background , which are caused by soft proton flares , were removed with thresholds of 0.20 count s@xmath11 for mos1 , 0.24 count s@xmath11 for mos2 , and 0.6 count s@xmath11 for pn , respectively , calculated for pattern=0 events above 10 kev .\",\n \"we used x - ray events of pattern=012 ( for mos cameras ) and pattern=04 ( for pn camera ) for the image and spectral analyses .\",\n \"the resultant effective exposures were 21 ks ( mos1 ) , 22 ks ( mos2 ) , and 15 ks ( pn ) , respectively .\",\n \"the journal of the observation is listed in table [ tab : obslog ] .\",\n \"figure [ fig : epicimage ] shows the summed images of mos1 and mos2 in the soft ( 0.32 kev ) and the hard ( 212 kev ) bands .\",\n \"the xis images are also overlaid in green contours . using the sas tool edetect_chain ,\",\n \"a total of 16 point sources were detected within from the center of suzaku j14276051 .\",\n \"eleven and seven sources were found in the soft and the hard bands , respectively , and two sources were commonly detected in both bands .\",\n \"names and count rates of the point sources are listed in table [ tab : xmmps ] .\",\n \"summing up the count rates of the point sources located within the suzaku source region ( x1 through x7 ) , we obtained @xmath31 count s@xmath11 in the 0.52 kev band .\",\n \"this may be converted to the xis bi count rate of @xmath32 count s@xmath11 assuming the power - law spectrum in table 2 . because this is comparable to the rate actually observed with suzaku ( @xmath33 count s@xmath11 ) ,\",\n \"the xis data may be explained by the sum of the xmm - newton point sources in the soft band .\",\n \"on the other hand , if we carry out a similar calculation for the hard band , the xmm - newton point sources would produce @xmath34 count s@xmath11 in xis .\",\n \"because this corresponds to only @xmath35 % of the actual xis count rate , suzaku j14276051 is difficult to be explained by the sum of the sources and may be a truly diffuse source .\",\n \"we calculated the energy spectra of only x1 and of the summed spectra of the central seven point sources ( x1 through x7 ) .\",\n \"we made the response file and the ancillary response file using the sas tool rmfgen and arfgen , respectively .\",\n \"we fitted these spectra with the model of an absorbed power - law .\",\n \"because of the poor statistics , the photon index was fixed to 3.1 , which was determined by the spectral analysis of suzaku j14276051 .\",\n \"the best - fit parameters are listed in table [ tab : epicparm ] .\",\n \"figure [ fig : epicspec ] shows the summed spectra of the seven point sources .\",\n \"the absorbed x - ray flux of the summed spectra was @xmath36 in the 210 kev band , which is about 5% of the flux derived with suzaku for suzaku j14276051 .\",\n \"it is also found that the column density of the summed spectra is two orders of magnitude smaller than that derived for suzaku j14276051 .\",\n \"these results confirm that suzaku j14276051 can not be explained by the xmm - newton point sources .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we discovered an apparently - diffuse hard x - ray source , suzaku j14276051 with suzaku , and several point sources with xmm - newton in spatial coincidence with hess j1427608 .\",\n \"we found that suzaku j14276051 could not be explained by the sum of the point sources detected with xmm - newton , and concluded that it is a truly diffuse source . even if time variability of the detected point - like sources is considered , it is unlikely that suzaku j14276051 is explained by them because the hydrogen column densities are quite different .\",\n \"the xmm - newton point sources are most likely foreground sources . to explain\",\n \"suzaku j14276051 by the sum of several point sources would require that all those sources would be below detection threshold at the time of the xmm - newton observation , which appears very unlikely .\",\n \"thus , we concluded that suzaku j14276051 is an intrinsically diffuse source and the x - ray counterpart of hess j1427608 .\",\n \"we searched various catalogs and literature for the possible counterpart of hess j1427608 in other wavebands .\",\n \"a gev gamma - ray source , 2fgl j1427.66048c , is listed in the 2-year catalog of fermi ( @xcite ) .\",\n \"the gev source is located at @xmath37 , which is away from the center of hess j1427608 ( see figure [ fig : xisimage ] ) . since the error radius of the position is about ,\",\n \"it may be associated with hess j1427608 @xcite . however ,\",\n \"this is a `` c - designator - applied ''\",\n \"fermi source whose position , emission characteristics , or even existence may not be reliable due to a potential confusion with interstellar emission @xcite .\",\n \"we believe it is premature to discuss a possible association of the gev source to hess j1427608 ; future fermi data and analysis is necessary .\",\n \"we also searched the akari point source catalogues ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .\",\n \"no point source was found in the mid - infrared ( @xmath38 m ) and the far - infrared ( @xmath39 m ) bands within from the center of hess j1427608 .\",\n \"although we mentioned hess j1427608 as one of the most `` unlikely '' pwne in the introduction , its center - filled morphology and featureless spectrum in the x - ray band suggest that the source could be a pwn .\",\n \"thus we postulate here that the source is a pwn as a working hypothesis\",\n \". figure [ fig : wideband ] shows the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) from x - rays to vhe gamma - rays .\",\n \"the estimated synchrotron spectra from the vhe gamma - ray spectrum @xcite , assuming that the same electron population would inverse - compton scatter cmb photons up to vhe gamma - rays and radiate synchrotron emission in x - rays , are also plotted with a local magnetic field @xmath40 of 1 , 3 , and 10@xmath41 .\",\n \"this sed plot indicates that the simple one - zone leptonic model with @xmath40 of about 5@xmath42 g would roughly explain both the x - ray and vhe gamma - ray data . in this context\",\n \", the steep suzaku spectrum of @xmath43 could indicate that the suzaku energy band is higher than the cut - off energy .\",\n \"the inferred magnetic field strength of @xmath225@xmath42 g is within the range of typical values on the galactic plane .\",\n \"thus the sed is consistent with a one - zone leptonic model expected for pwne .\",\n \"we next examine the flux ratio and luminosities . the x - ray to vhe gamma - ray ratio is useful to probe the nature of unid sources @xcite . in the case of hess\",\n \"j1427608 , the unabsorbed x - ray flux @xmath44 of @xmath45 ( 210 kev ) and the vhe gamma - ray flux @xmath46 of @xmath47 ( 110 tev ) result in a flux ratio of @xmath48 .\",\n \"if we assume a distance to hess j1427608 of @xmath49 kpc , the x - ray luminosity would be @xmath50 .\",\n \"the estimated flux ratio and x - ray luminosity are within the values of known x - ray and vhe gamma - ray emitting pwne , given that both values show a large scatter : @xmath51 in @xmath52 and @xmath53 erg s@xmath11 in @xmath54 @xcite .\",\n \"thus the flux ratio and luminosity are also consistent with sources of pwn origin . while there are observational evidences supporting the pwn origin as discussed above , others challenge such a view . with the assumption of @xmath49 kpc ,\",\n \"the core size and whole radial extent would be 2 pc and 12 pc , respectively .\",\n \"the core size of 2 pc is a little large , but not exceptional among other pwn @xcite .\",\n \"the whole extent of 12 pc is not surprisingly large compared with the nebula of e.g. , psr j18261334 @xcite .\",\n \"the largest drawback of the pwn hypothesis is lacking the detection of both a pulsar and radio pwn associated .\",\n \"it is known that the pulsar luminosity and its nebula luminosity in the x - ray band are correlated over 7 orders of magnitude @xcite . according to the correlation\",\n \", the not - yet - detected pulsar should be brighter than @xmath55 in x - rays , one - tenth of the pwn luminosity . such a pulsar would have been easily detected with xmm - newton .\",\n \"in addition , the x - ray photon index of the nebula ( @xmath56 ) is very steep among the known x - ray nebulae most of which have a @xmath57 between 1.22.2 @xcite . in terms of photon\",\n \"index comparison , non - thermal snrs might present a more plausible scenario than pwne .\",\n \"most of non - thermal snrs radiate synchrotron x - rays with a photon index of @xmath58 @xcite .\",\n \"the x - ray luminosity and extent are also compatible to synchrotron snrs @xcite .\",\n \"however , the facts that the source has a center - filled morphology in the x - ray band and no detection of the shell structure in the radio band hamper the interpretation as a non - thermal snr . in summary , we have not reached a firm conclusion on the nature of hess j1427608 .\",\n \"pwn and/or non - thermal snr , which are not necessary exclusive to each other , are the prime candidates but a decisive observational evidence is lacking . increasing statistics in fermi data\",\n \"may reveal a pulsation from 2fgl j1427.66048c\",\n \". a deep radio observation would also be helpful if it could detect pulsations or reveal the morphology of the source .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we observed hess j1427608 with suzaku , which is combined with the archival data analysis of xmm - newton , and obtained following results . *\",\n \"we discovered an x - ray counterpart , suzaku j14276051 , of hess j1427608 .\",\n \"it is intrinsically extended ( @xmath59 ) and has a spectral shape of an absorbed power - law with a photon index of @xmath2 .\",\n \"* several faint point sources were found in spatial coincidence with hess j1427608 using xmm - newton archival data in the soft x - ray band . *\",\n \"observational properties of suzaku j14276051 and hess j1427608 are compared with those of known pwne and non - thermal snrs .\",\n \"some properties favor the pwn and/or snr origin , but the available data are insufficient to draw firm conclusions .\",\n \"we thank kentaro someya , yoshitomo maeda and michito sakai for their useful comments .\",\n \"t.f . acknowledges the financial support from the global center of excellence program by mext , japan through the `` nanoscience and quantum physics '' project of the tokyo institute of technology , and jsps young research fellowship , no .\",\n \"23 - 9676 . the work of k.m .\",\n \"is partially supported by the grant - in - aid for young scientists ( b ) of the mext ( no .\",\n \"24740167 ) .\",\n \"aharonian , f. , et al .\",\n \"2005 , science , 307 , 1938 aharonian , f. , et al .\",\n \"2006 , , 636 , 777 aharonian , f. , et al .\",\n \"2008 , , 477 , 353 de jager , o. c. , & djannati - ata , a. 2009 , in neutron stars and pulsars , ed .\",\n \"w. becker ( berlin : springer ) , 451 fukazawa , y. , et al .\",\n \"2009 , , 61 , s17 fujinaga , t. , et al .\",\n \"2011 , , 63 , s863 green , d. a. 2009 , bull .\",\n \"india , 37 , 45 hinton , j. a. & hoffman , w. 2009 , araa , 47 , 523 ishihara , d. , et al .\",\n \"2010 , , 514 , a1 ishisaki , y. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s113 jansen , f. , et al .\",\n \"2001 , , 365 , l1 kalberla , m. , et al .\",\n \"2005 , , 440 , 775 kargaltsev , o. , & pavlov , g. g. 2008 , in aip conf . proc . , 983 , 40 years of pulsars : millisecond pulsars , magnetars and more , ed .\",\n \"bassa et al .\",\n \"( new york : aip ) , 171 kokubun , m. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s53 koyama , k. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s23 kushino , a. , ishisaki , y. , morita , u. , yamasaki , n. y. , ishida , m. , ohashi , t. , & ueda , y. 2002 , , 54 , 327 manchester , r.n . , et al .\",\n \"2005 , , 129 , 1993 mattana , f. , et al .\",\n \"2010 , , 694 , 12 mitsuda , k. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s1 nakamura , r. , et al .\",\n \"2009 , , 61 , s197 nakamura , r. , bamba , a. , dotani , t. , ishida , m. , yamazaki , r. , & kohri , k. 2012 , , 746 , 134 nolan , p. l. , et al .\",\n \"2012 , , 199 , 31 prigozhin , g. , burke , b. , bautz , m. , kissel , s. , lamarr , b. 2008 , ieee transactions on electron devices , 55 , 2111 serlemitsos , p. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s9 strder , l. , et al .\",\n \"2001 , , 365 , l18 takahashi , t. , et al .\",\n \"2007 , , 59 , s35 turner et al .\",\n \"2001 , , 365 , l27 tawa , n. , et al .\",\n \"2008 , , 60 , s11 uchiyama , h. , et al .\",\n \"2009a , , 61 , s9 uchiyama , h. , et al .\",\n \"2009b , , 61 , s189 yamauchi , c. , et al .\",\n \"2011 , pasp , 123 , 852 yamazaki , r. , kohri , k. , bamba , a. , yoshida , t. , tsuribe , t. , & takahara , f. 2006 , , 371 , 1975 lccc & soft & medium & high + @xmath62 ( @xmath63 cm@xmath12 ) & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & @xmath67 + @xmath68 ( kev ) & @xmath69 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 + absorbed flux & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 + & + ne & + s & + ar & + others & + line @xmath75 ( kev ) & + line flux & + @xmath18/d.o.f & + + + lcc & power - law & apec + @xmath62 ( @xmath63 cm@xmath12 ) & @xmath76 & @xmath77 + @xmath57 & @xmath78 & + @xmath68 ( kev ) & & @xmath79 + abundance ( @xmath80 ) & & @xmath81 + unabsorbed flux & @xmath82 & @xmath83 + absorbed flux & 3.1 & 3.0 + @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 + + + i d & name & distance & + & & & 0.32 kev & 212 kev + x1 & xmmu j142755.4605112.9 & & 5.3 & 3.3 + x2 & xmmu j142746.5605011.4 & & & 1.9 + x3 & xmmu j142746.8605317.8 & & 2.3 & + x4 & xmmu j142800.7605356.4 & & 2.7 & + x5 & xmmu j142731.4605141.4 & & & 2.9 + x6 & xmmu j142810.3604752.0 & & 3.3 & 1.7 + x7 & xmmu j142736.9604712.8 & & 1.9 & + x8 & xmmu j142711.0605320.3 & & & 2.2 + x9 & xmmu j142742.7604436.9 & & 3.4 & + x10 & xmmu j142722.3604425.8 & & & 3.1 + x11 & xmmu j142856.1605027.9 & & 3.0 & + x12 & xmmu j142649.9604810.0 & & & 1.7 + x13 & xmmu j142810.0604337.9 & & 9.1 & + x14 & xmmu j142651.3605300.9 & & 4.9 & + x15 & xmmu j142654.9604556.1 & & 4.1 & + x16 & xmmu j142855.6604636.4 & & 3.1 & + + + lcc & x1 & sum of x1x7 + @xmath62 ( @xmath87 ) & @xmath88 & @xmath89 + @xmath57 & 3.1 ( fixed ) & 3.1 ( fixed ) + unabsorbed flux & @xmath90 & @xmath91 + absorbed flux & 0.7 & 1.7 + & 11.28 / 6 & 16.74 / 27 + + +\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":85,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"quant-ph0512038"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["a wealth of information about the motion of microscopic particles can be gathered by scattering a well - controlled probe , typically light in the case of atoms with optical resonances .","young s historic double slit experiment demonstrated that the probe light wave shows interference if it can propagate along more than a single path .","interference fringes therefore can give sensitive information about the scatterers , as was shown by eichmann and coworkers @xcite by realizing young s double slits with two trapped atoms .","on the other hand , the motional state of the probed particle gives information about the probe field , as recently discussed by eschner @xcite . as a commonly accepted rule",", one can have either full interference contrast or full which - way - information at the same time . between these two extremes ,","there are interesting intermediate situations that can be quantified using general quantum duality relations derived by englert @xcite that have been used for instance in atom interferometers @xcite . in mesoscopic samples of weakly disordered clouds of cold atoms ,","coherent multiple scattering of light leads to enhanced backscattering @xcite . in this letter ,","we investigate coherent backscattering ( cbs ) of light by two atoms that are trapped in harmonic oscillators .","this model system can describe how atomic motion destroys multiple scattering interference via recoil and doppler effects .","we calculate the cbs interference visibility both at zero and finite temperature in shallow traps that allow to treat the limiting case of freely moving atoms .","the cbs double scattering geometry realizes a two - way interferometer where the two mutually exclusive alternatives are the order in which the photon visits both atoms .","which - way information is then present if one knows which of both atoms has been visited first .","we calculate the which - way distinguishability proposed by englert and show how it is physically encoded .","consider two atoms trapped in identical harmonic oscillators at fixed positions well separated from each other by many wavelengths of the probe light .","a single incident photon with wave vector @xmath0 and polarization @xmath1 is then scattered by the atoms and detected in the backscattering direction @xmath2 with polarization analysis in the helicity - preserving channel @xmath3 .","a photon scattered in the backscattering direction by a single atom with a non - degenerate ground state has the same polarization , but opposite helicity , and does not contribute to the detected intensity .","since the atoms are far from each other , the probability for repeated scattering is very small .","the detector then receives a photon that has been scattered exactly once by each atom , either along way a or along way b , see fig . [ twoways.fig ] .","the total amplitude is the coherent superposition of both amplitudes .","such an interference of counter - propagating multiple scattering amplitudes in the backscattering direction is known as coherent backscattering ( cbs ) @xcite . without interaction , the free electromagnetic field and the internal and external ( motional ) atomic degrees of freedom","are described by the hamiltonian @xmath4 or @xmath5 the first term constitutes the standard hamiltonian for free photons @xcite .","@xmath6 is the projector onto the degenerate multiplet @xmath7 of excited states with transition frequency @xmath8 from the non - degenerate ground state @xmath9 of atoms @xmath10 .","the atomic motion is described by the number operators @xmath11 of excitations in the three - dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillators with frequency @xmath12 . the dipole interaction @xmath13 couples the photon field both to the electronic states and the motional degrees of freedom .","@xmath14 is the electronic dipole transition operator for atom @xmath15 .","the electric field operator @xmath16 is evaluated at the atomic center - of - mass position @xmath17 . the displacement operator @xmath18 from the trap s origin @xmath19 measures distance in units of the oscillator length @xmath20{\\hbar/(2 m { { \\omega_\\ab{ho } } } ) } } $ ] .","the vector joining the two atoms will be denoted @xmath21 , with a distance @xmath22 between the traps such that @xmath23 . of the first scatterer during the total scattering time @xmath24","is larger than the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 . , title=\"fig:\",width=188 ] of the first scatterer during the total scattering time @xmath24 is larger than the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 .",", title=\"fig:\",width=151 ] [ atomicoverlap.fig ]","since the atoms are well separated , the total double scattering process is described by the product of two individual scattering processes with free propagation inbetween . in the far - field photon propagator @xmath26",", we expand the absolute distance to linear order in the small relative displacement : @xmath27 . in the exponential",", the zeroth - order contribution @xmath28 drops out from all interference quantities , whereas the linear term generates a phase difference between the amplitudes of @xmath29 and @xmath30 and must be kept . to this leading order",", the denominator can be taken constant . the transition operator @xcite for way a takes a useful form in time representation and interaction picture where @xmath31 .","up to irrelevant prefactors , @xmath32 read from right to left , it describes how the photon is scattered first by atom 1 , then propagates with @xmath33 , and is finally scattered by atom 2 .","the transition operator @xmath34 of the reverse way b is obtained from @xmath35 by the substitution @xmath36 .","the complex detuning @xmath37 of the probe frequency @xmath38 from the transition frequency includes the spontaneous decay rate or inverse lifetime @xmath39 .","retardation times of order @xmath40 have been neglected in the time arguments of the operators .","indeed , the photon scattering by two atoms defines two distinct time scales for the atomic motion : first , the total inverse detuning @xmath41 which is simply @xmath42 at resonance .","second , the free propagation time @xmath40 from one atom to the other . for resonant atomic scatterers with @xmath43 of order @xmath44s or larger , and typical distances @xmath28 of 1@xmath45 mm or less ,","one has @xmath46 such that the scattering is resonance - dominated , and the free propagation time can be safely neglected . in all of the following ,","we have in mind the limit of quasi - free atoms and therefore consider the case of shallow traps @xmath47 in which the oscillation period of an atom is much larger than the time @xmath48 it takes to scatter a photon .","the incident photon can choose between two _ a priori _ indistinguishable paths , way @xmath49 or @xmath50 .","following englert s fashionable choice @xcite , we call this binary degree of freedom a qubit .","let @xmath51 and @xmath52 denote the choice of way @xmath49 and @xmath50 . scattering entangles the qubit with the motional degrees of freedom .","consequently , the atomic oscillator states can serve as a which - path detector . prior to scattering ,","the total initial state of qubit and detector is @xmath53 .","the qubit is in the pure state @xmath54 , the symmetric superposition of equally probable ways .","an external cooling laser field serves as a thermal bath for the trapped atoms .","the detector is thus in a thermal state @xmath55 at inverse temperature @xmath56 with partition function @xmath57 .","the total final state is then obtained by applying the transition operators associated with way @xmath49 and @xmath50 : @xmath58 in general , @xmath59 is not a unitary operator since it describes only the scattering amplitude around the backscattering direction .","the factor @xmath60 guarantees , however , that @xmath61 is properly normalized .","adapting englert s general definitions @xcite , we can express the _ visibility _ @xmath62 and the _ distinguishability _ @xmath63 obeying the fundamental _ duality relation _ @xmath64 as follows : @xmath65 the visibility is the ratio of interference contribution and background intensity @xmath66 and therefore equal to the cbs contrast .","the distinguishability @xmath63 describes the maximum which - way information available in principle , i.e. , that can be extracted by the additional measurement of an optimal detector observable ; @xmath67 denotes the trace - class norm of the operator @xmath68 .","another interesting quantity is the _ predictability _ @xmath69 the predictability measures the amount of which - way information available _ a priori _ , as for instance in unbalanced interferometers like young s double slits with different widths . for balanced interferometers @xmath70 ,","the predictability vanishes , @xmath71 . with the help of these quantities",", we can quantify the breakdown of coherent photon backscattering by mobile atoms , both at zero and finite temperature .","the distinguishability @xmath72 is difficult to evaluate in our case because it is defined via the trace - class norm of operators on the infinite - dimensional hilbert space of harmonic oscillators . on the contrary , visibility @xmath62 and predictability","@xmath73 involve a thermal harmonic average of products like @xmath74 or @xmath75 .","since the transition operator ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) contains only exponentials linear in the displacement , taking the trace amounts to gaussian integration .","at zero temperature , the atoms are initially in their respective harmonic oscillator ground states . in other words ,","the detectors are prepared in pure states . setting @xmath76 in ( [ d_and_v ] ) permits to show that in this case the duality relation is always saturated : @xmath77 .","thus , we can use the visibility @xmath62 , much easier to calculate than the distinguishability @xmath63 , in order to understand how much which - way information is present and how it is encoded . carrying out the thermal average , we find in the limit @xmath78 @xmath79 neglecting higher - order terms @xmath80 in the two relevant small parameters defined as","follows : the influence of atomic recoil without harmonic trapping is encoded in the factor @xmath81 with @xmath82 the recoil energy , @xmath83 the probe detuning from the atomic resonance , and @xmath84 as before .","the harmonic trap enters through the parameter @xmath85 it is worthwile to discuss the physical significance of both parameters .","let us first consider a very shallow trap @xmath86 where the free recoil effect described by @xmath87 dominates . at least to order @xmath88 , we find @xmath89 .","together with the general property @xmath90 ( read : the _ a priori _ information can not be larger than the total available information ) this implies that all which - way information is actually available _ a priori _ : @xmath91 . just as in the case of other asymmetric interferometers ,","this predictability is due to unbalanced scattering amplitudes . at perpendicular scattering @xmath92 ,","the situation is completely symmetric , and both paths are equally probable .","but for the extreme case @xmath93 of atoms in line with the probe , the atom in front scatters either the incident probe photon at the laser frequency or the already scattered photon on its way out again , now at laser frequency minus twice the recoil .","a different frequency generally implies a different scattering cross section such that the two paths have different probabilities . for a given position configuration ,","this information is known _ a priori _ without the necessity to perform any measurement .","more quantitatively , the relative change in the resonant cross section @xmath94^{-1}$ ] under a small frequency change @xmath95 then is @xmath96 , one finds exactly @xmath97 . to this order",", the predictability vanishes at exact detuning , since a small frequency change on the flat top of the resonance lorentzian has no effect .","let us now interpret the influence of harmonic trapping at zero temperature .","the predictability ( [ predzero ] ) contains no contribution in @xmath98 , which indicates that this parameter encodes which - path information that may only be revealed _ a posteriori _ by an appropriate measurement on the detector . in a temporal picture ( see fig .","[ atomicoverlap.fig](b ) ) , one can determine which way the photon has taken if one can measure which atom has scattered the photon first .","this is only possible if the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 is smaller than the distance @xmath99 travelled by the first scattering atom .","more quantitatively , the first scatterer takes up the recoil in the direction of @xmath100 and travels the distance @xmath101{2\\hbar { { \\omega_\\ab{rec } } } / m}}\\delta t $ ] during the whole time @xmath102 until the emission of the final photon by the second atom .","is simply twice the total contribution per atom that can be justified by a stationary - phase argument if both the wigner time delay of the phase and the amplitude change of the resonant scattering function @xmath103 are taken into account .","] at that moment , the second atom receives the same recoil in the direction @xmath100 , such that the final momentum states for both ways become indistinguishable ( note that the recoil in the direction joining the atoms is exchanged instantaneously , because we can neglect the propagation time ) .","the zero - temperature position uncertainty is the oscillator length @xmath104 , which finally shows that which - path information is indeed present on the scale @xmath105 .","on the steep slope of a resonance curve implies a large scattering cross section difference @xmath106 that can provide which - path information .","( b ) cbs visibility ( [ d_and_v ] ) as function of the thermal doppler shift ( [ xiclassical ] ) at resonance @xmath107 .",", title=\"fig:\",width=207 ] on the steep slope of a resonance curve implies a large scattering cross section difference @xmath106 that can provide which - path information .","( b ) cbs visibility ( [ d_and_v ] ) as function of the thermal doppler shift ( [ xiclassical ] ) at resonance @xmath107 .",", title=\"fig:\",width=283 ] if the atoms are coupled to a thermal bath , the detector is not prepared in a pure state , and one expects that the duality relation no longer saturates .","we thus have to calculate visibility and distinguishability separately .","after the gaussian thermal average , the visibility is given in terms of a product of amplitudes like ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) for way a and b. it can be evaluated numerically for all values of the detuning @xmath108 and of the thermal trap parameter @xmath109 this parameter corresponds to the zero - temperature trap parameter ( [ zeta ] ) at effective oscillator excitation @xmath110 { { \\omega_\\ab{ho } } } $ ] , with @xmath111^{-1}$ ] the bose - einstein distribution function . for highly excited atoms","@xmath112 the oscillator frequency drops out of the definition of the thermal trap parameter which becomes @xmath113 the classical thermal doppler shift ( @xmath114 ) in units of the linewidth .","figure [ visibility.fig](b ) shows a plot of the visibility at exact resonance @xmath107 as function of @xmath115 on a semi - logarithmic scale . here",", we concentrate on the effect of harmonic trapping at finite temperature and neglect the free recoil contribution , which is justified if @xmath116 . the visibility decreases monotonically with temperature . for @xmath117",", we can expand to lowest order and find analytically ( compare with eq .","( [ distzero ] ) ) : @xmath118 at this point , we recover the case of free thermal atoms .","our result ( [ visfinal ] ) agrees with the cbs contrast calculated in @xcite for the low - temperature case @xmath119 ( if the avarage medium effect included there is disregarded ) .","note that our calculation is also valid in the high - temperature regime @xmath120 where the visibility goes to zero as @xmath121 .","it is too difficult to evaluate analytically the trace - class norm for the distinguishability @xmath63 with the transition operators in the general form ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) .","therefore , we formally expand the exponentials in powers of the lamb - dicke parameter @xmath122 { { { \\omega_\\ab{rec } } } / { { \\omega_\\ab{ho } } } } } $ ] . the leading order expression for @xmath63 in the shallow - trap limit @xmath112","becomes @xmath123 here , @xmath124 $ ] is the momentum associated with @xmath125 , the antisymmetric oscillator mode projected onto the probe direction @xmath100 .","it is reasonable that only this mode should be relevant : symmetric motion can not encode differential information about the paths ( and could be disposed of by transformation into a co - moving frame ) , whereas the momentum along the only other available direction @xmath126 is exchanged instantaneously . to linear order in @xmath127 ,","the positive operator @xmath128 can be moved outside the absolute value ( using @xmath129 since @xmath130 and @xmath131 commute to zeroth order in @xmath132 ) .","this makes the distinguishability proportional to the thermal expectation value of the momentum modulus , which is easy to evaluate for a maxwell - boltzmann distribution : @xmath133 it can be read as the relative shift @xmath134 of the resonant cross section under the small doppler frequency change @xmath135 .","this suggests an interpretation in terms of the frequency - shift mechanism ( cf .","fig.[visibility.fig](a ) ) : by measuring the actual atomic velocities _ a posteriori _ , one can determine which way was more probable : if atom 1 is found to move towards a red - detuned probe and atom 2 to move away from it , way a was more probable than b because atom 1 had a larger absorption cross section this is simply the principle of doppler cooling .","contrary to the zero - temperature case , now the predictability @xmath136 is zero to the order considered because the interferometer symmetry is reestablished by the isotropic thermal average . naturally , as in the case of harmonic trapping at zero temperature , the distinguishability vanishes also at exact resonance @xmath107 because no differential information can be encoded on the flat top of the resonance lorentzian . in the high - temperature limit @xmath137 ,","i.e. , for very large frequence shifts @xmath138 with moderate detuning , one explores the flat wings of the lorentzian , and the distinguishability must then drop to zero . at finite temperature ,","the quantum duality is no longer saturated and reads to order @xmath115 : @xmath139 \\left(\\frac { 2 k_\\ab{in } { { v_\\ab{rms } } } } { |\\gamma| } \\right)^2 .\\ ] ] this value of @xmath63 assumes an optimal measurement within just the system of center - of - mass motion .","but the initial thermal distribution requires the presence of a thermal bath ( e.g. , cooling lasers ) .","the total system ( detector plus bath ) is described by a pure state for which the quantum duality saturates .","however , the which - path information could only be retrieved by an optimal measurement including all bath degrees of freedom that are not under our control .","measurements on just the detector necessarily correspond to a non - optimal measurement with respect to the whole system and therefore imply a reduced distinguishability .","we have studied the coherent backscattering effect from two trapped atoms , an interesting case study for quantitative quantum duality in a physically realistic setting . at zero temperature ,","inelastic scattering due to the recoil effect provides _ a priori _ which - path information .","further which - path information can be gained by measuring which atom has scattered the photon first , which is possible if the initial position uncertainty is small enough . at finite temperature , the atomic movement destroys the interference once the average doppler shift becomes of the order of the resonance width .","which - path information resides in the atomic velocities via resonance conditions , but the duality inequality no longer saturates because an initial thermal state corresponds to a non - optimal detector preparation .","we gratefully acknowledge a stimulating collaboration with d. delande and c. miniatura , who brought englert s work to our attention .","we further wish to thank g. morigi and j. eschner for helpful discussions and o. sigwarth and r. kuhn for numerous remarks and a critical reading of the manuscript .","this project was financially supported by the procope program of the daad ."],"string":"[\n \"a wealth of information about the motion of microscopic particles can be gathered by scattering a well - controlled probe , typically light in the case of atoms with optical resonances .\",\n \"young s historic double slit experiment demonstrated that the probe light wave shows interference if it can propagate along more than a single path .\",\n \"interference fringes therefore can give sensitive information about the scatterers , as was shown by eichmann and coworkers @xcite by realizing young s double slits with two trapped atoms .\",\n \"on the other hand , the motional state of the probed particle gives information about the probe field , as recently discussed by eschner @xcite . as a commonly accepted rule\",\n \", one can have either full interference contrast or full which - way - information at the same time . between these two extremes ,\",\n \"there are interesting intermediate situations that can be quantified using general quantum duality relations derived by englert @xcite that have been used for instance in atom interferometers @xcite . in mesoscopic samples of weakly disordered clouds of cold atoms ,\",\n \"coherent multiple scattering of light leads to enhanced backscattering @xcite . in this letter ,\",\n \"we investigate coherent backscattering ( cbs ) of light by two atoms that are trapped in harmonic oscillators .\",\n \"this model system can describe how atomic motion destroys multiple scattering interference via recoil and doppler effects .\",\n \"we calculate the cbs interference visibility both at zero and finite temperature in shallow traps that allow to treat the limiting case of freely moving atoms .\",\n \"the cbs double scattering geometry realizes a two - way interferometer where the two mutually exclusive alternatives are the order in which the photon visits both atoms .\",\n \"which - way information is then present if one knows which of both atoms has been visited first .\",\n \"we calculate the which - way distinguishability proposed by englert and show how it is physically encoded .\",\n \"consider two atoms trapped in identical harmonic oscillators at fixed positions well separated from each other by many wavelengths of the probe light .\",\n \"a single incident photon with wave vector @xmath0 and polarization @xmath1 is then scattered by the atoms and detected in the backscattering direction @xmath2 with polarization analysis in the helicity - preserving channel @xmath3 .\",\n \"a photon scattered in the backscattering direction by a single atom with a non - degenerate ground state has the same polarization , but opposite helicity , and does not contribute to the detected intensity .\",\n \"since the atoms are far from each other , the probability for repeated scattering is very small .\",\n \"the detector then receives a photon that has been scattered exactly once by each atom , either along way a or along way b , see fig . [ twoways.fig ] .\",\n \"the total amplitude is the coherent superposition of both amplitudes .\",\n \"such an interference of counter - propagating multiple scattering amplitudes in the backscattering direction is known as coherent backscattering ( cbs ) @xcite . without interaction , the free electromagnetic field and the internal and external ( motional ) atomic degrees of freedom\",\n \"are described by the hamiltonian @xmath4 or @xmath5 the first term constitutes the standard hamiltonian for free photons @xcite .\",\n \"@xmath6 is the projector onto the degenerate multiplet @xmath7 of excited states with transition frequency @xmath8 from the non - degenerate ground state @xmath9 of atoms @xmath10 .\",\n \"the atomic motion is described by the number operators @xmath11 of excitations in the three - dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillators with frequency @xmath12 . the dipole interaction @xmath13 couples the photon field both to the electronic states and the motional degrees of freedom .\",\n \"@xmath14 is the electronic dipole transition operator for atom @xmath15 .\",\n \"the electric field operator @xmath16 is evaluated at the atomic center - of - mass position @xmath17 . the displacement operator @xmath18 from the trap s origin @xmath19 measures distance in units of the oscillator length @xmath20{\\\\hbar/(2 m { { \\\\omega_\\\\ab{ho } } } ) } } $ ] .\",\n \"the vector joining the two atoms will be denoted @xmath21 , with a distance @xmath22 between the traps such that @xmath23 . of the first scatterer during the total scattering time @xmath24\",\n \"is larger than the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 . , title=\\\"fig:\\\",width=188 ] of the first scatterer during the total scattering time @xmath24 is larger than the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig:\\\",width=151 ] [ atomicoverlap.fig ]\",\n \"since the atoms are well separated , the total double scattering process is described by the product of two individual scattering processes with free propagation inbetween . in the far - field photon propagator @xmath26\",\n \", we expand the absolute distance to linear order in the small relative displacement : @xmath27 . in the exponential\",\n \", the zeroth - order contribution @xmath28 drops out from all interference quantities , whereas the linear term generates a phase difference between the amplitudes of @xmath29 and @xmath30 and must be kept . to this leading order\",\n \", the denominator can be taken constant . the transition operator @xcite for way a takes a useful form in time representation and interaction picture where @xmath31 .\",\n \"up to irrelevant prefactors , @xmath32 read from right to left , it describes how the photon is scattered first by atom 1 , then propagates with @xmath33 , and is finally scattered by atom 2 .\",\n \"the transition operator @xmath34 of the reverse way b is obtained from @xmath35 by the substitution @xmath36 .\",\n \"the complex detuning @xmath37 of the probe frequency @xmath38 from the transition frequency includes the spontaneous decay rate or inverse lifetime @xmath39 .\",\n \"retardation times of order @xmath40 have been neglected in the time arguments of the operators .\",\n \"indeed , the photon scattering by two atoms defines two distinct time scales for the atomic motion : first , the total inverse detuning @xmath41 which is simply @xmath42 at resonance .\",\n \"second , the free propagation time @xmath40 from one atom to the other . for resonant atomic scatterers with @xmath43 of order @xmath44s or larger , and typical distances @xmath28 of 1@xmath45 mm or less ,\",\n \"one has @xmath46 such that the scattering is resonance - dominated , and the free propagation time can be safely neglected . in all of the following ,\",\n \"we have in mind the limit of quasi - free atoms and therefore consider the case of shallow traps @xmath47 in which the oscillation period of an atom is much larger than the time @xmath48 it takes to scatter a photon .\",\n \"the incident photon can choose between two _ a priori _ indistinguishable paths , way @xmath49 or @xmath50 .\",\n \"following englert s fashionable choice @xcite , we call this binary degree of freedom a qubit .\",\n \"let @xmath51 and @xmath52 denote the choice of way @xmath49 and @xmath50 . scattering entangles the qubit with the motional degrees of freedom .\",\n \"consequently , the atomic oscillator states can serve as a which - path detector . prior to scattering ,\",\n \"the total initial state of qubit and detector is @xmath53 .\",\n \"the qubit is in the pure state @xmath54 , the symmetric superposition of equally probable ways .\",\n \"an external cooling laser field serves as a thermal bath for the trapped atoms .\",\n \"the detector is thus in a thermal state @xmath55 at inverse temperature @xmath56 with partition function @xmath57 .\",\n \"the total final state is then obtained by applying the transition operators associated with way @xmath49 and @xmath50 : @xmath58 in general , @xmath59 is not a unitary operator since it describes only the scattering amplitude around the backscattering direction .\",\n \"the factor @xmath60 guarantees , however , that @xmath61 is properly normalized .\",\n \"adapting englert s general definitions @xcite , we can express the _ visibility _ @xmath62 and the _ distinguishability _ @xmath63 obeying the fundamental _ duality relation _ @xmath64 as follows : @xmath65 the visibility is the ratio of interference contribution and background intensity @xmath66 and therefore equal to the cbs contrast .\",\n \"the distinguishability @xmath63 describes the maximum which - way information available in principle , i.e. , that can be extracted by the additional measurement of an optimal detector observable ; @xmath67 denotes the trace - class norm of the operator @xmath68 .\",\n \"another interesting quantity is the _ predictability _ @xmath69 the predictability measures the amount of which - way information available _ a priori _ , as for instance in unbalanced interferometers like young s double slits with different widths . for balanced interferometers @xmath70 ,\",\n \"the predictability vanishes , @xmath71 . with the help of these quantities\",\n \", we can quantify the breakdown of coherent photon backscattering by mobile atoms , both at zero and finite temperature .\",\n \"the distinguishability @xmath72 is difficult to evaluate in our case because it is defined via the trace - class norm of operators on the infinite - dimensional hilbert space of harmonic oscillators . on the contrary , visibility @xmath62 and predictability\",\n \"@xmath73 involve a thermal harmonic average of products like @xmath74 or @xmath75 .\",\n \"since the transition operator ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) contains only exponentials linear in the displacement , taking the trace amounts to gaussian integration .\",\n \"at zero temperature , the atoms are initially in their respective harmonic oscillator ground states . in other words ,\",\n \"the detectors are prepared in pure states . setting @xmath76 in ( [ d_and_v ] ) permits to show that in this case the duality relation is always saturated : @xmath77 .\",\n \"thus , we can use the visibility @xmath62 , much easier to calculate than the distinguishability @xmath63 , in order to understand how much which - way information is present and how it is encoded . carrying out the thermal average , we find in the limit @xmath78 @xmath79 neglecting higher - order terms @xmath80 in the two relevant small parameters defined as\",\n \"follows : the influence of atomic recoil without harmonic trapping is encoded in the factor @xmath81 with @xmath82 the recoil energy , @xmath83 the probe detuning from the atomic resonance , and @xmath84 as before .\",\n \"the harmonic trap enters through the parameter @xmath85 it is worthwile to discuss the physical significance of both parameters .\",\n \"let us first consider a very shallow trap @xmath86 where the free recoil effect described by @xmath87 dominates . at least to order @xmath88 , we find @xmath89 .\",\n \"together with the general property @xmath90 ( read : the _ a priori _ information can not be larger than the total available information ) this implies that all which - way information is actually available _ a priori _ : @xmath91 . just as in the case of other asymmetric interferometers ,\",\n \"this predictability is due to unbalanced scattering amplitudes . at perpendicular scattering @xmath92 ,\",\n \"the situation is completely symmetric , and both paths are equally probable .\",\n \"but for the extreme case @xmath93 of atoms in line with the probe , the atom in front scatters either the incident probe photon at the laser frequency or the already scattered photon on its way out again , now at laser frequency minus twice the recoil .\",\n \"a different frequency generally implies a different scattering cross section such that the two paths have different probabilities . for a given position configuration ,\",\n \"this information is known _ a priori _ without the necessity to perform any measurement .\",\n \"more quantitatively , the relative change in the resonant cross section @xmath94^{-1}$ ] under a small frequency change @xmath95 then is @xmath96 , one finds exactly @xmath97 . to this order\",\n \", the predictability vanishes at exact detuning , since a small frequency change on the flat top of the resonance lorentzian has no effect .\",\n \"let us now interpret the influence of harmonic trapping at zero temperature .\",\n \"the predictability ( [ predzero ] ) contains no contribution in @xmath98 , which indicates that this parameter encodes which - path information that may only be revealed _ a posteriori _ by an appropriate measurement on the detector . in a temporal picture ( see fig .\",\n \"[ atomicoverlap.fig](b ) ) , one can determine which way the photon has taken if one can measure which atom has scattered the photon first .\",\n \"this is only possible if the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 is smaller than the distance @xmath99 travelled by the first scattering atom .\",\n \"more quantitatively , the first scatterer takes up the recoil in the direction of @xmath100 and travels the distance @xmath101{2\\\\hbar { { \\\\omega_\\\\ab{rec } } } / m}}\\\\delta t $ ] during the whole time @xmath102 until the emission of the final photon by the second atom .\",\n \"is simply twice the total contribution per atom that can be justified by a stationary - phase argument if both the wigner time delay of the phase and the amplitude change of the resonant scattering function @xmath103 are taken into account .\",\n \"] at that moment , the second atom receives the same recoil in the direction @xmath100 , such that the final momentum states for both ways become indistinguishable ( note that the recoil in the direction joining the atoms is exchanged instantaneously , because we can neglect the propagation time ) .\",\n \"the zero - temperature position uncertainty is the oscillator length @xmath104 , which finally shows that which - path information is indeed present on the scale @xmath105 .\",\n \"on the steep slope of a resonance curve implies a large scattering cross section difference @xmath106 that can provide which - path information .\",\n \"( b ) cbs visibility ( [ d_and_v ] ) as function of the thermal doppler shift ( [ xiclassical ] ) at resonance @xmath107 .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig:\\\",width=207 ] on the steep slope of a resonance curve implies a large scattering cross section difference @xmath106 that can provide which - path information .\",\n \"( b ) cbs visibility ( [ d_and_v ] ) as function of the thermal doppler shift ( [ xiclassical ] ) at resonance @xmath107 .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig:\\\",width=283 ] if the atoms are coupled to a thermal bath , the detector is not prepared in a pure state , and one expects that the duality relation no longer saturates .\",\n \"we thus have to calculate visibility and distinguishability separately .\",\n \"after the gaussian thermal average , the visibility is given in terms of a product of amplitudes like ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) for way a and b. it can be evaluated numerically for all values of the detuning @xmath108 and of the thermal trap parameter @xmath109 this parameter corresponds to the zero - temperature trap parameter ( [ zeta ] ) at effective oscillator excitation @xmath110 { { \\\\omega_\\\\ab{ho } } } $ ] , with @xmath111^{-1}$ ] the bose - einstein distribution function . for highly excited atoms\",\n \"@xmath112 the oscillator frequency drops out of the definition of the thermal trap parameter which becomes @xmath113 the classical thermal doppler shift ( @xmath114 ) in units of the linewidth .\",\n \"figure [ visibility.fig](b ) shows a plot of the visibility at exact resonance @xmath107 as function of @xmath115 on a semi - logarithmic scale . here\",\n \", we concentrate on the effect of harmonic trapping at finite temperature and neglect the free recoil contribution , which is justified if @xmath116 . the visibility decreases monotonically with temperature . for @xmath117\",\n \", we can expand to lowest order and find analytically ( compare with eq .\",\n \"( [ distzero ] ) ) : @xmath118 at this point , we recover the case of free thermal atoms .\",\n \"our result ( [ visfinal ] ) agrees with the cbs contrast calculated in @xcite for the low - temperature case @xmath119 ( if the avarage medium effect included there is disregarded ) .\",\n \"note that our calculation is also valid in the high - temperature regime @xmath120 where the visibility goes to zero as @xmath121 .\",\n \"it is too difficult to evaluate analytically the trace - class norm for the distinguishability @xmath63 with the transition operators in the general form ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) .\",\n \"therefore , we formally expand the exponentials in powers of the lamb - dicke parameter @xmath122 { { { \\\\omega_\\\\ab{rec } } } / { { \\\\omega_\\\\ab{ho } } } } } $ ] . the leading order expression for @xmath63 in the shallow - trap limit @xmath112\",\n \"becomes @xmath123 here , @xmath124 $ ] is the momentum associated with @xmath125 , the antisymmetric oscillator mode projected onto the probe direction @xmath100 .\",\n \"it is reasonable that only this mode should be relevant : symmetric motion can not encode differential information about the paths ( and could be disposed of by transformation into a co - moving frame ) , whereas the momentum along the only other available direction @xmath126 is exchanged instantaneously . to linear order in @xmath127 ,\",\n \"the positive operator @xmath128 can be moved outside the absolute value ( using @xmath129 since @xmath130 and @xmath131 commute to zeroth order in @xmath132 ) .\",\n \"this makes the distinguishability proportional to the thermal expectation value of the momentum modulus , which is easy to evaluate for a maxwell - boltzmann distribution : @xmath133 it can be read as the relative shift @xmath134 of the resonant cross section under the small doppler frequency change @xmath135 .\",\n \"this suggests an interpretation in terms of the frequency - shift mechanism ( cf .\",\n \"fig.[visibility.fig](a ) ) : by measuring the actual atomic velocities _ a posteriori _ , one can determine which way was more probable : if atom 1 is found to move towards a red - detuned probe and atom 2 to move away from it , way a was more probable than b because atom 1 had a larger absorption cross section this is simply the principle of doppler cooling .\",\n \"contrary to the zero - temperature case , now the predictability @xmath136 is zero to the order considered because the interferometer symmetry is reestablished by the isotropic thermal average . naturally , as in the case of harmonic trapping at zero temperature , the distinguishability vanishes also at exact resonance @xmath107 because no differential information can be encoded on the flat top of the resonance lorentzian . in the high - temperature limit @xmath137 ,\",\n \"i.e. , for very large frequence shifts @xmath138 with moderate detuning , one explores the flat wings of the lorentzian , and the distinguishability must then drop to zero . at finite temperature ,\",\n \"the quantum duality is no longer saturated and reads to order @xmath115 : @xmath139 \\\\left(\\\\frac { 2 k_\\\\ab{in } { { v_\\\\ab{rms } } } } { |\\\\gamma| } \\\\right)^2 .\\\\ ] ] this value of @xmath63 assumes an optimal measurement within just the system of center - of - mass motion .\",\n \"but the initial thermal distribution requires the presence of a thermal bath ( e.g. , cooling lasers ) .\",\n \"the total system ( detector plus bath ) is described by a pure state for which the quantum duality saturates .\",\n \"however , the which - path information could only be retrieved by an optimal measurement including all bath degrees of freedom that are not under our control .\",\n \"measurements on just the detector necessarily correspond to a non - optimal measurement with respect to the whole system and therefore imply a reduced distinguishability .\",\n \"we have studied the coherent backscattering effect from two trapped atoms , an interesting case study for quantitative quantum duality in a physically realistic setting . at zero temperature ,\",\n \"inelastic scattering due to the recoil effect provides _ a priori _ which - path information .\",\n \"further which - path information can be gained by measuring which atom has scattered the photon first , which is possible if the initial position uncertainty is small enough . at finite temperature , the atomic movement destroys the interference once the average doppler shift becomes of the order of the resonance width .\",\n \"which - path information resides in the atomic velocities via resonance conditions , but the duality inequality no longer saturates because an initial thermal state corresponds to a non - optimal detector preparation .\",\n \"we gratefully acknowledge a stimulating collaboration with d. delande and c. miniatura , who brought englert s work to our attention .\",\n \"we further wish to thank g. morigi and j. eschner for helpful discussions and o. sigwarth and r. kuhn for numerous remarks and a critical reading of the manuscript .\",\n \"this project was financially supported by the procope program of the daad .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> we investigate coherent backscattering of light by two harmonically trapped atoms in the light of quantitative quantum duality . </S>","<S> including recoil and doppler shift close to an optical resonance , we calculate the interference visibility as well as the amount of which - path information , both for zero and finite temperature . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> we investigate coherent backscattering of light by two harmonically trapped atoms in the light of quantitative quantum duality . </S>\",\n \"<S> including recoil and doppler shift close to an optical resonance , we calculate the interference visibility as well as the amount of which - path information , both for zero and finite temperature . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","the setting","transition operator for photon double scattering","quantitative quantum duality","zero temperature","finite temperatures","summary"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"the setting\",\n \"transition operator for photon double scattering\",\n \"quantitative quantum duality\",\n \"zero temperature\",\n \"finite temperatures\",\n \"summary\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["a wealth of information about the motion of microscopic particles can be gathered by scattering a well - controlled probe , typically light in the case of atoms with optical resonances .","young s historic double slit experiment demonstrated that the probe light wave shows interference if it can propagate along more than a single path .","interference fringes therefore can give sensitive information about the scatterers , as was shown by eichmann and coworkers @xcite by realizing young s double slits with two trapped atoms .","on the other hand , the motional state of the probed particle gives information about the probe field , as recently discussed by eschner @xcite . as a commonly accepted rule",", one can have either full interference contrast or full which - way - information at the same time . between these two extremes ,","there are interesting intermediate situations that can be quantified using general quantum duality relations derived by englert @xcite that have been used for instance in atom interferometers @xcite . in mesoscopic samples of weakly disordered clouds of cold atoms ,","coherent multiple scattering of light leads to enhanced backscattering @xcite . in this letter ,","we investigate coherent backscattering ( cbs ) of light by two atoms that are trapped in harmonic oscillators .","this model system can describe how atomic motion destroys multiple scattering interference via recoil and doppler effects .","we calculate the cbs interference visibility both at zero and finite temperature in shallow traps that allow to treat the limiting case of freely moving atoms .","the cbs double scattering geometry realizes a two - way interferometer where the two mutually exclusive alternatives are the order in which the photon visits both atoms .","which - way information is then present if one knows which of both atoms has been visited first .","we calculate the which - way distinguishability proposed by englert and show how it is physically encoded ."],["consider two atoms trapped in identical harmonic oscillators at fixed positions well separated from each other by many wavelengths of the probe light .","a single incident photon with wave vector @xmath0 and polarization @xmath1 is then scattered by the atoms and detected in the backscattering direction @xmath2 with polarization analysis in the helicity - preserving channel @xmath3 .","a photon scattered in the backscattering direction by a single atom with a non - degenerate ground state has the same polarization , but opposite helicity , and does not contribute to the detected intensity .","since the atoms are far from each other , the probability for repeated scattering is very small .","the detector then receives a photon that has been scattered exactly once by each atom , either along way a or along way b , see fig . [ twoways.fig ] .","the total amplitude is the coherent superposition of both amplitudes .","such an interference of counter - propagating multiple scattering amplitudes in the backscattering direction is known as coherent backscattering ( cbs ) @xcite . without interaction , the free electromagnetic field and the internal and external ( motional ) atomic degrees of freedom","are described by the hamiltonian @xmath4 or @xmath5 the first term constitutes the standard hamiltonian for free photons @xcite .","@xmath6 is the projector onto the degenerate multiplet @xmath7 of excited states with transition frequency @xmath8 from the non - degenerate ground state @xmath9 of atoms @xmath10 .","the atomic motion is described by the number operators @xmath11 of excitations in the three - dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillators with frequency @xmath12 . the dipole interaction @xmath13 couples the photon field both to the electronic states and the motional degrees of freedom .","@xmath14 is the electronic dipole transition operator for atom @xmath15 .","the electric field operator @xmath16 is evaluated at the atomic center - of - mass position @xmath17 . the displacement operator @xmath18 from the trap s origin @xmath19 measures distance in units of the oscillator length @xmath20{\\hbar/(2 m { { \\omega_\\ab{ho } } } ) } } $ ] .","the vector joining the two atoms will be denoted @xmath21 , with a distance @xmath22 between the traps such that @xmath23 . of the first scatterer during the total scattering time @xmath24","is larger than the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 . , title=\"fig:\",width=188 ] of the first scatterer during the total scattering time @xmath24 is larger than the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 .",", title=\"fig:\",width=151 ] [ atomicoverlap.fig ]"],["since the atoms are well separated , the total double scattering process is described by the product of two individual scattering processes with free propagation inbetween . in the far - field photon propagator @xmath26",", we expand the absolute distance to linear order in the small relative displacement : @xmath27 . in the exponential",", the zeroth - order contribution @xmath28 drops out from all interference quantities , whereas the linear term generates a phase difference between the amplitudes of @xmath29 and @xmath30 and must be kept . to this leading order",", the denominator can be taken constant . the transition operator @xcite for way a takes a useful form in time representation and interaction picture where @xmath31 .","up to irrelevant prefactors , @xmath32 read from right to left , it describes how the photon is scattered first by atom 1 , then propagates with @xmath33 , and is finally scattered by atom 2 .","the transition operator @xmath34 of the reverse way b is obtained from @xmath35 by the substitution @xmath36 .","the complex detuning @xmath37 of the probe frequency @xmath38 from the transition frequency includes the spontaneous decay rate or inverse lifetime @xmath39 .","retardation times of order @xmath40 have been neglected in the time arguments of the operators .","indeed , the photon scattering by two atoms defines two distinct time scales for the atomic motion : first , the total inverse detuning @xmath41 which is simply @xmath42 at resonance .","second , the free propagation time @xmath40 from one atom to the other . for resonant atomic scatterers with @xmath43 of order @xmath44s or larger , and typical distances @xmath28 of 1@xmath45 mm or less ,","one has @xmath46 such that the scattering is resonance - dominated , and the free propagation time can be safely neglected . in all of the following ,","we have in mind the limit of quasi - free atoms and therefore consider the case of shallow traps @xmath47 in which the oscillation period of an atom is much larger than the time @xmath48 it takes to scatter a photon ."],["the incident photon can choose between two _ a priori _ indistinguishable paths , way @xmath49 or @xmath50 .","following englert s fashionable choice @xcite , we call this binary degree of freedom a qubit .","let @xmath51 and @xmath52 denote the choice of way @xmath49 and @xmath50 . scattering entangles the qubit with the motional degrees of freedom .","consequently , the atomic oscillator states can serve as a which - path detector . prior to scattering ,","the total initial state of qubit and detector is @xmath53 .","the qubit is in the pure state @xmath54 , the symmetric superposition of equally probable ways .","an external cooling laser field serves as a thermal bath for the trapped atoms .","the detector is thus in a thermal state @xmath55 at inverse temperature @xmath56 with partition function @xmath57 .","the total final state is then obtained by applying the transition operators associated with way @xmath49 and @xmath50 : @xmath58 in general , @xmath59 is not a unitary operator since it describes only the scattering amplitude around the backscattering direction .","the factor @xmath60 guarantees , however , that @xmath61 is properly normalized .","adapting englert s general definitions @xcite , we can express the _ visibility _ @xmath62 and the _ distinguishability _ @xmath63 obeying the fundamental _ duality relation _ @xmath64 as follows : @xmath65 the visibility is the ratio of interference contribution and background intensity @xmath66 and therefore equal to the cbs contrast .","the distinguishability @xmath63 describes the maximum which - way information available in principle , i.e. , that can be extracted by the additional measurement of an optimal detector observable ; @xmath67 denotes the trace - class norm of the operator @xmath68 .","another interesting quantity is the _ predictability _ @xmath69 the predictability measures the amount of which - way information available _ a priori _ , as for instance in unbalanced interferometers like young s double slits with different widths . for balanced interferometers @xmath70 ,","the predictability vanishes , @xmath71 . with the help of these quantities",", we can quantify the breakdown of coherent photon backscattering by mobile atoms , both at zero and finite temperature .","the distinguishability @xmath72 is difficult to evaluate in our case because it is defined via the trace - class norm of operators on the infinite - dimensional hilbert space of harmonic oscillators . on the contrary , visibility @xmath62 and predictability","@xmath73 involve a thermal harmonic average of products like @xmath74 or @xmath75 .","since the transition operator ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) contains only exponentials linear in the displacement , taking the trace amounts to gaussian integration ."],["at zero temperature , the atoms are initially in their respective harmonic oscillator ground states . in other words ,","the detectors are prepared in pure states . setting @xmath76 in ( [ d_and_v ] ) permits to show that in this case the duality relation is always saturated : @xmath77 .","thus , we can use the visibility @xmath62 , much easier to calculate than the distinguishability @xmath63 , in order to understand how much which - way information is present and how it is encoded . carrying out the thermal average , we find in the limit @xmath78 @xmath79 neglecting higher - order terms @xmath80 in the two relevant small parameters defined as","follows : the influence of atomic recoil without harmonic trapping is encoded in the factor @xmath81 with @xmath82 the recoil energy , @xmath83 the probe detuning from the atomic resonance , and @xmath84 as before .","the harmonic trap enters through the parameter @xmath85 it is worthwile to discuss the physical significance of both parameters .","let us first consider a very shallow trap @xmath86 where the free recoil effect described by @xmath87 dominates . at least to order @xmath88 , we find @xmath89 .","together with the general property @xmath90 ( read : the _ a priori _ information can not be larger than the total available information ) this implies that all which - way information is actually available _ a priori _ : @xmath91 . just as in the case of other asymmetric interferometers ,","this predictability is due to unbalanced scattering amplitudes . at perpendicular scattering @xmath92 ,","the situation is completely symmetric , and both paths are equally probable .","but for the extreme case @xmath93 of atoms in line with the probe , the atom in front scatters either the incident probe photon at the laser frequency or the already scattered photon on its way out again , now at laser frequency minus twice the recoil .","a different frequency generally implies a different scattering cross section such that the two paths have different probabilities . for a given position configuration ,","this information is known _ a priori _ without the necessity to perform any measurement .","more quantitatively , the relative change in the resonant cross section @xmath94^{-1}$ ] under a small frequency change @xmath95 then is @xmath96 , one finds exactly @xmath97 . to this order",", the predictability vanishes at exact detuning , since a small frequency change on the flat top of the resonance lorentzian has no effect .","let us now interpret the influence of harmonic trapping at zero temperature .","the predictability ( [ predzero ] ) contains no contribution in @xmath98 , which indicates that this parameter encodes which - path information that may only be revealed _ a posteriori _ by an appropriate measurement on the detector . in a temporal picture ( see fig .","[ atomicoverlap.fig](b ) ) , one can determine which way the photon has taken if one can measure which atom has scattered the photon first .","this is only possible if the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 is smaller than the distance @xmath99 travelled by the first scattering atom .","more quantitatively , the first scatterer takes up the recoil in the direction of @xmath100 and travels the distance @xmath101{2\\hbar { { \\omega_\\ab{rec } } } / m}}\\delta t $ ] during the whole time @xmath102 until the emission of the final photon by the second atom .","is simply twice the total contribution per atom that can be justified by a stationary - phase argument if both the wigner time delay of the phase and the amplitude change of the resonant scattering function @xmath103 are taken into account .","] at that moment , the second atom receives the same recoil in the direction @xmath100 , such that the final momentum states for both ways become indistinguishable ( note that the recoil in the direction joining the atoms is exchanged instantaneously , because we can neglect the propagation time ) .","the zero - temperature position uncertainty is the oscillator length @xmath104 , which finally shows that which - path information is indeed present on the scale @xmath105 ."],["on the steep slope of a resonance curve implies a large scattering cross section difference @xmath106 that can provide which - path information .","( b ) cbs visibility ( [ d_and_v ] ) as function of the thermal doppler shift ( [ xiclassical ] ) at resonance @xmath107 .",", title=\"fig:\",width=207 ] on the steep slope of a resonance curve implies a large scattering cross section difference @xmath106 that can provide which - path information .","( b ) cbs visibility ( [ d_and_v ] ) as function of the thermal doppler shift ( [ xiclassical ] ) at resonance @xmath107 .",", title=\"fig:\",width=283 ] if the atoms are coupled to a thermal bath , the detector is not prepared in a pure state , and one expects that the duality relation no longer saturates .","we thus have to calculate visibility and distinguishability separately .","after the gaussian thermal average , the visibility is given in terms of a product of amplitudes like ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) for way a and b. it can be evaluated numerically for all values of the detuning @xmath108 and of the thermal trap parameter @xmath109 this parameter corresponds to the zero - temperature trap parameter ( [ zeta ] ) at effective oscillator excitation @xmath110 { { \\omega_\\ab{ho } } } $ ] , with @xmath111^{-1}$ ] the bose - einstein distribution function . for highly excited atoms","@xmath112 the oscillator frequency drops out of the definition of the thermal trap parameter which becomes @xmath113 the classical thermal doppler shift ( @xmath114 ) in units of the linewidth .","figure [ visibility.fig](b ) shows a plot of the visibility at exact resonance @xmath107 as function of @xmath115 on a semi - logarithmic scale . here",", we concentrate on the effect of harmonic trapping at finite temperature and neglect the free recoil contribution , which is justified if @xmath116 . the visibility decreases monotonically with temperature . for @xmath117",", we can expand to lowest order and find analytically ( compare with eq .","( [ distzero ] ) ) : @xmath118 at this point , we recover the case of free thermal atoms .","our result ( [ visfinal ] ) agrees with the cbs contrast calculated in @xcite for the low - temperature case @xmath119 ( if the avarage medium effect included there is disregarded ) .","note that our calculation is also valid in the high - temperature regime @xmath120 where the visibility goes to zero as @xmath121 .","it is too difficult to evaluate analytically the trace - class norm for the distinguishability @xmath63 with the transition operators in the general form ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) .","therefore , we formally expand the exponentials in powers of the lamb - dicke parameter @xmath122 { { { \\omega_\\ab{rec } } } / { { \\omega_\\ab{ho } } } } } $ ] . the leading order expression for @xmath63 in the shallow - trap limit @xmath112","becomes @xmath123 here , @xmath124 $ ] is the momentum associated with @xmath125 , the antisymmetric oscillator mode projected onto the probe direction @xmath100 .","it is reasonable that only this mode should be relevant : symmetric motion can not encode differential information about the paths ( and could be disposed of by transformation into a co - moving frame ) , whereas the momentum along the only other available direction @xmath126 is exchanged instantaneously . to linear order in @xmath127 ,","the positive operator @xmath128 can be moved outside the absolute value ( using @xmath129 since @xmath130 and @xmath131 commute to zeroth order in @xmath132 ) .","this makes the distinguishability proportional to the thermal expectation value of the momentum modulus , which is easy to evaluate for a maxwell - boltzmann distribution : @xmath133 it can be read as the relative shift @xmath134 of the resonant cross section under the small doppler frequency change @xmath135 .","this suggests an interpretation in terms of the frequency - shift mechanism ( cf .","fig.[visibility.fig](a ) ) : by measuring the actual atomic velocities _ a posteriori _ , one can determine which way was more probable : if atom 1 is found to move towards a red - detuned probe and atom 2 to move away from it , way a was more probable than b because atom 1 had a larger absorption cross section this is simply the principle of doppler cooling .","contrary to the zero - temperature case , now the predictability @xmath136 is zero to the order considered because the interferometer symmetry is reestablished by the isotropic thermal average . naturally , as in the case of harmonic trapping at zero temperature , the distinguishability vanishes also at exact resonance @xmath107 because no differential information can be encoded on the flat top of the resonance lorentzian . in the high - temperature limit @xmath137 ,","i.e. , for very large frequence shifts @xmath138 with moderate detuning , one explores the flat wings of the lorentzian , and the distinguishability must then drop to zero . at finite temperature ,","the quantum duality is no longer saturated and reads to order @xmath115 : @xmath139 \\left(\\frac { 2 k_\\ab{in } { { v_\\ab{rms } } } } { |\\gamma| } \\right)^2 .\\ ] ] this value of @xmath63 assumes an optimal measurement within just the system of center - of - mass motion .","but the initial thermal distribution requires the presence of a thermal bath ( e.g. , cooling lasers ) .","the total system ( detector plus bath ) is described by a pure state for which the quantum duality saturates .","however , the which - path information could only be retrieved by an optimal measurement including all bath degrees of freedom that are not under our control .","measurements on just the detector necessarily correspond to a non - optimal measurement with respect to the whole system and therefore imply a reduced distinguishability ."],["we have studied the coherent backscattering effect from two trapped atoms , an interesting case study for quantitative quantum duality in a physically realistic setting . at zero temperature ,","inelastic scattering due to the recoil effect provides _ a priori _ which - path information .","further which - path information can be gained by measuring which atom has scattered the photon first , which is possible if the initial position uncertainty is small enough . at finite temperature , the atomic movement destroys the interference once the average doppler shift becomes of the order of the resonance width .","which - path information resides in the atomic velocities via resonance conditions , but the duality inequality no longer saturates because an initial thermal state corresponds to a non - optimal detector preparation .","we gratefully acknowledge a stimulating collaboration with d. delande and c. miniatura , who brought englert s work to our attention .","we further wish to thank g. morigi and j. eschner for helpful discussions and o. sigwarth and r. kuhn for numerous remarks and a critical reading of the manuscript .","this project was financially supported by the procope program of the daad ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"a wealth of information about the motion of microscopic particles can be gathered by scattering a well - controlled probe , typically light in the case of atoms with optical resonances .\",\n \"young s historic double slit experiment demonstrated that the probe light wave shows interference if it can propagate along more than a single path .\",\n \"interference fringes therefore can give sensitive information about the scatterers , as was shown by eichmann and coworkers @xcite by realizing young s double slits with two trapped atoms .\",\n \"on the other hand , the motional state of the probed particle gives information about the probe field , as recently discussed by eschner @xcite . as a commonly accepted rule\",\n \", one can have either full interference contrast or full which - way - information at the same time . between these two extremes ,\",\n \"there are interesting intermediate situations that can be quantified using general quantum duality relations derived by englert @xcite that have been used for instance in atom interferometers @xcite . in mesoscopic samples of weakly disordered clouds of cold atoms ,\",\n \"coherent multiple scattering of light leads to enhanced backscattering @xcite . in this letter ,\",\n \"we investigate coherent backscattering ( cbs ) of light by two atoms that are trapped in harmonic oscillators .\",\n \"this model system can describe how atomic motion destroys multiple scattering interference via recoil and doppler effects .\",\n \"we calculate the cbs interference visibility both at zero and finite temperature in shallow traps that allow to treat the limiting case of freely moving atoms .\",\n \"the cbs double scattering geometry realizes a two - way interferometer where the two mutually exclusive alternatives are the order in which the photon visits both atoms .\",\n \"which - way information is then present if one knows which of both atoms has been visited first .\",\n \"we calculate the which - way distinguishability proposed by englert and show how it is physically encoded .\"\n ],\n [\n \"consider two atoms trapped in identical harmonic oscillators at fixed positions well separated from each other by many wavelengths of the probe light .\",\n \"a single incident photon with wave vector @xmath0 and polarization @xmath1 is then scattered by the atoms and detected in the backscattering direction @xmath2 with polarization analysis in the helicity - preserving channel @xmath3 .\",\n \"a photon scattered in the backscattering direction by a single atom with a non - degenerate ground state has the same polarization , but opposite helicity , and does not contribute to the detected intensity .\",\n \"since the atoms are far from each other , the probability for repeated scattering is very small .\",\n \"the detector then receives a photon that has been scattered exactly once by each atom , either along way a or along way b , see fig . [ twoways.fig ] .\",\n \"the total amplitude is the coherent superposition of both amplitudes .\",\n \"such an interference of counter - propagating multiple scattering amplitudes in the backscattering direction is known as coherent backscattering ( cbs ) @xcite . without interaction , the free electromagnetic field and the internal and external ( motional ) atomic degrees of freedom\",\n \"are described by the hamiltonian @xmath4 or @xmath5 the first term constitutes the standard hamiltonian for free photons @xcite .\",\n \"@xmath6 is the projector onto the degenerate multiplet @xmath7 of excited states with transition frequency @xmath8 from the non - degenerate ground state @xmath9 of atoms @xmath10 .\",\n \"the atomic motion is described by the number operators @xmath11 of excitations in the three - dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillators with frequency @xmath12 . the dipole interaction @xmath13 couples the photon field both to the electronic states and the motional degrees of freedom .\",\n \"@xmath14 is the electronic dipole transition operator for atom @xmath15 .\",\n \"the electric field operator @xmath16 is evaluated at the atomic center - of - mass position @xmath17 . the displacement operator @xmath18 from the trap s origin @xmath19 measures distance in units of the oscillator length @xmath20{\\\\hbar/(2 m { { \\\\omega_\\\\ab{ho } } } ) } } $ ] .\",\n \"the vector joining the two atoms will be denoted @xmath21 , with a distance @xmath22 between the traps such that @xmath23 . of the first scatterer during the total scattering time @xmath24\",\n \"is larger than the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 . , title=\\\"fig:\\\",width=188 ] of the first scatterer during the total scattering time @xmath24 is larger than the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig:\\\",width=151 ] [ atomicoverlap.fig ]\"\n ],\n [\n \"since the atoms are well separated , the total double scattering process is described by the product of two individual scattering processes with free propagation inbetween . in the far - field photon propagator @xmath26\",\n \", we expand the absolute distance to linear order in the small relative displacement : @xmath27 . in the exponential\",\n \", the zeroth - order contribution @xmath28 drops out from all interference quantities , whereas the linear term generates a phase difference between the amplitudes of @xmath29 and @xmath30 and must be kept . to this leading order\",\n \", the denominator can be taken constant . the transition operator @xcite for way a takes a useful form in time representation and interaction picture where @xmath31 .\",\n \"up to irrelevant prefactors , @xmath32 read from right to left , it describes how the photon is scattered first by atom 1 , then propagates with @xmath33 , and is finally scattered by atom 2 .\",\n \"the transition operator @xmath34 of the reverse way b is obtained from @xmath35 by the substitution @xmath36 .\",\n \"the complex detuning @xmath37 of the probe frequency @xmath38 from the transition frequency includes the spontaneous decay rate or inverse lifetime @xmath39 .\",\n \"retardation times of order @xmath40 have been neglected in the time arguments of the operators .\",\n \"indeed , the photon scattering by two atoms defines two distinct time scales for the atomic motion : first , the total inverse detuning @xmath41 which is simply @xmath42 at resonance .\",\n \"second , the free propagation time @xmath40 from one atom to the other . for resonant atomic scatterers with @xmath43 of order @xmath44s or larger , and typical distances @xmath28 of 1@xmath45 mm or less ,\",\n \"one has @xmath46 such that the scattering is resonance - dominated , and the free propagation time can be safely neglected . in all of the following ,\",\n \"we have in mind the limit of quasi - free atoms and therefore consider the case of shallow traps @xmath47 in which the oscillation period of an atom is much larger than the time @xmath48 it takes to scatter a photon .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the incident photon can choose between two _ a priori _ indistinguishable paths , way @xmath49 or @xmath50 .\",\n \"following englert s fashionable choice @xcite , we call this binary degree of freedom a qubit .\",\n \"let @xmath51 and @xmath52 denote the choice of way @xmath49 and @xmath50 . scattering entangles the qubit with the motional degrees of freedom .\",\n \"consequently , the atomic oscillator states can serve as a which - path detector . prior to scattering ,\",\n \"the total initial state of qubit and detector is @xmath53 .\",\n \"the qubit is in the pure state @xmath54 , the symmetric superposition of equally probable ways .\",\n \"an external cooling laser field serves as a thermal bath for the trapped atoms .\",\n \"the detector is thus in a thermal state @xmath55 at inverse temperature @xmath56 with partition function @xmath57 .\",\n \"the total final state is then obtained by applying the transition operators associated with way @xmath49 and @xmath50 : @xmath58 in general , @xmath59 is not a unitary operator since it describes only the scattering amplitude around the backscattering direction .\",\n \"the factor @xmath60 guarantees , however , that @xmath61 is properly normalized .\",\n \"adapting englert s general definitions @xcite , we can express the _ visibility _ @xmath62 and the _ distinguishability _ @xmath63 obeying the fundamental _ duality relation _ @xmath64 as follows : @xmath65 the visibility is the ratio of interference contribution and background intensity @xmath66 and therefore equal to the cbs contrast .\",\n \"the distinguishability @xmath63 describes the maximum which - way information available in principle , i.e. , that can be extracted by the additional measurement of an optimal detector observable ; @xmath67 denotes the trace - class norm of the operator @xmath68 .\",\n \"another interesting quantity is the _ predictability _ @xmath69 the predictability measures the amount of which - way information available _ a priori _ , as for instance in unbalanced interferometers like young s double slits with different widths . for balanced interferometers @xmath70 ,\",\n \"the predictability vanishes , @xmath71 . with the help of these quantities\",\n \", we can quantify the breakdown of coherent photon backscattering by mobile atoms , both at zero and finite temperature .\",\n \"the distinguishability @xmath72 is difficult to evaluate in our case because it is defined via the trace - class norm of operators on the infinite - dimensional hilbert space of harmonic oscillators . on the contrary , visibility @xmath62 and predictability\",\n \"@xmath73 involve a thermal harmonic average of products like @xmath74 or @xmath75 .\",\n \"since the transition operator ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) contains only exponentials linear in the displacement , taking the trace amounts to gaussian integration .\"\n ],\n [\n \"at zero temperature , the atoms are initially in their respective harmonic oscillator ground states . in other words ,\",\n \"the detectors are prepared in pure states . setting @xmath76 in ( [ d_and_v ] ) permits to show that in this case the duality relation is always saturated : @xmath77 .\",\n \"thus , we can use the visibility @xmath62 , much easier to calculate than the distinguishability @xmath63 , in order to understand how much which - way information is present and how it is encoded . carrying out the thermal average , we find in the limit @xmath78 @xmath79 neglecting higher - order terms @xmath80 in the two relevant small parameters defined as\",\n \"follows : the influence of atomic recoil without harmonic trapping is encoded in the factor @xmath81 with @xmath82 the recoil energy , @xmath83 the probe detuning from the atomic resonance , and @xmath84 as before .\",\n \"the harmonic trap enters through the parameter @xmath85 it is worthwile to discuss the physical significance of both parameters .\",\n \"let us first consider a very shallow trap @xmath86 where the free recoil effect described by @xmath87 dominates . at least to order @xmath88 , we find @xmath89 .\",\n \"together with the general property @xmath90 ( read : the _ a priori _ information can not be larger than the total available information ) this implies that all which - way information is actually available _ a priori _ : @xmath91 . just as in the case of other asymmetric interferometers ,\",\n \"this predictability is due to unbalanced scattering amplitudes . at perpendicular scattering @xmath92 ,\",\n \"the situation is completely symmetric , and both paths are equally probable .\",\n \"but for the extreme case @xmath93 of atoms in line with the probe , the atom in front scatters either the incident probe photon at the laser frequency or the already scattered photon on its way out again , now at laser frequency minus twice the recoil .\",\n \"a different frequency generally implies a different scattering cross section such that the two paths have different probabilities . for a given position configuration ,\",\n \"this information is known _ a priori _ without the necessity to perform any measurement .\",\n \"more quantitatively , the relative change in the resonant cross section @xmath94^{-1}$ ] under a small frequency change @xmath95 then is @xmath96 , one finds exactly @xmath97 . to this order\",\n \", the predictability vanishes at exact detuning , since a small frequency change on the flat top of the resonance lorentzian has no effect .\",\n \"let us now interpret the influence of harmonic trapping at zero temperature .\",\n \"the predictability ( [ predzero ] ) contains no contribution in @xmath98 , which indicates that this parameter encodes which - path information that may only be revealed _ a posteriori _ by an appropriate measurement on the detector . in a temporal picture ( see fig .\",\n \"[ atomicoverlap.fig](b ) ) , one can determine which way the photon has taken if one can measure which atom has scattered the photon first .\",\n \"this is only possible if the initial position uncertainty @xmath25 is smaller than the distance @xmath99 travelled by the first scattering atom .\",\n \"more quantitatively , the first scatterer takes up the recoil in the direction of @xmath100 and travels the distance @xmath101{2\\\\hbar { { \\\\omega_\\\\ab{rec } } } / m}}\\\\delta t $ ] during the whole time @xmath102 until the emission of the final photon by the second atom .\",\n \"is simply twice the total contribution per atom that can be justified by a stationary - phase argument if both the wigner time delay of the phase and the amplitude change of the resonant scattering function @xmath103 are taken into account .\",\n \"] at that moment , the second atom receives the same recoil in the direction @xmath100 , such that the final momentum states for both ways become indistinguishable ( note that the recoil in the direction joining the atoms is exchanged instantaneously , because we can neglect the propagation time ) .\",\n \"the zero - temperature position uncertainty is the oscillator length @xmath104 , which finally shows that which - path information is indeed present on the scale @xmath105 .\"\n ],\n [\n \"on the steep slope of a resonance curve implies a large scattering cross section difference @xmath106 that can provide which - path information .\",\n \"( b ) cbs visibility ( [ d_and_v ] ) as function of the thermal doppler shift ( [ xiclassical ] ) at resonance @xmath107 .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig:\\\",width=207 ] on the steep slope of a resonance curve implies a large scattering cross section difference @xmath106 that can provide which - path information .\",\n \"( b ) cbs visibility ( [ d_and_v ] ) as function of the thermal doppler shift ( [ xiclassical ] ) at resonance @xmath107 .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig:\\\",width=283 ] if the atoms are coupled to a thermal bath , the detector is not prepared in a pure state , and one expects that the duality relation no longer saturates .\",\n \"we thus have to calculate visibility and distinguishability separately .\",\n \"after the gaussian thermal average , the visibility is given in terms of a product of amplitudes like ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) for way a and b. it can be evaluated numerically for all values of the detuning @xmath108 and of the thermal trap parameter @xmath109 this parameter corresponds to the zero - temperature trap parameter ( [ zeta ] ) at effective oscillator excitation @xmath110 { { \\\\omega_\\\\ab{ho } } } $ ] , with @xmath111^{-1}$ ] the bose - einstein distribution function . for highly excited atoms\",\n \"@xmath112 the oscillator frequency drops out of the definition of the thermal trap parameter which becomes @xmath113 the classical thermal doppler shift ( @xmath114 ) in units of the linewidth .\",\n \"figure [ visibility.fig](b ) shows a plot of the visibility at exact resonance @xmath107 as function of @xmath115 on a semi - logarithmic scale . here\",\n \", we concentrate on the effect of harmonic trapping at finite temperature and neglect the free recoil contribution , which is justified if @xmath116 . the visibility decreases monotonically with temperature . for @xmath117\",\n \", we can expand to lowest order and find analytically ( compare with eq .\",\n \"( [ distzero ] ) ) : @xmath118 at this point , we recover the case of free thermal atoms .\",\n \"our result ( [ visfinal ] ) agrees with the cbs contrast calculated in @xcite for the low - temperature case @xmath119 ( if the avarage medium effect included there is disregarded ) .\",\n \"note that our calculation is also valid in the high - temperature regime @xmath120 where the visibility goes to zero as @xmath121 .\",\n \"it is too difficult to evaluate analytically the trace - class norm for the distinguishability @xmath63 with the transition operators in the general form ( [ transitionoperatora ] ) .\",\n \"therefore , we formally expand the exponentials in powers of the lamb - dicke parameter @xmath122 { { { \\\\omega_\\\\ab{rec } } } / { { \\\\omega_\\\\ab{ho } } } } } $ ] . the leading order expression for @xmath63 in the shallow - trap limit @xmath112\",\n \"becomes @xmath123 here , @xmath124 $ ] is the momentum associated with @xmath125 , the antisymmetric oscillator mode projected onto the probe direction @xmath100 .\",\n \"it is reasonable that only this mode should be relevant : symmetric motion can not encode differential information about the paths ( and could be disposed of by transformation into a co - moving frame ) , whereas the momentum along the only other available direction @xmath126 is exchanged instantaneously . to linear order in @xmath127 ,\",\n \"the positive operator @xmath128 can be moved outside the absolute value ( using @xmath129 since @xmath130 and @xmath131 commute to zeroth order in @xmath132 ) .\",\n \"this makes the distinguishability proportional to the thermal expectation value of the momentum modulus , which is easy to evaluate for a maxwell - boltzmann distribution : @xmath133 it can be read as the relative shift @xmath134 of the resonant cross section under the small doppler frequency change @xmath135 .\",\n \"this suggests an interpretation in terms of the frequency - shift mechanism ( cf .\",\n \"fig.[visibility.fig](a ) ) : by measuring the actual atomic velocities _ a posteriori _ , one can determine which way was more probable : if atom 1 is found to move towards a red - detuned probe and atom 2 to move away from it , way a was more probable than b because atom 1 had a larger absorption cross section this is simply the principle of doppler cooling .\",\n \"contrary to the zero - temperature case , now the predictability @xmath136 is zero to the order considered because the interferometer symmetry is reestablished by the isotropic thermal average . naturally , as in the case of harmonic trapping at zero temperature , the distinguishability vanishes also at exact resonance @xmath107 because no differential information can be encoded on the flat top of the resonance lorentzian . in the high - temperature limit @xmath137 ,\",\n \"i.e. , for very large frequence shifts @xmath138 with moderate detuning , one explores the flat wings of the lorentzian , and the distinguishability must then drop to zero . at finite temperature ,\",\n \"the quantum duality is no longer saturated and reads to order @xmath115 : @xmath139 \\\\left(\\\\frac { 2 k_\\\\ab{in } { { v_\\\\ab{rms } } } } { |\\\\gamma| } \\\\right)^2 .\\\\ ] ] this value of @xmath63 assumes an optimal measurement within just the system of center - of - mass motion .\",\n \"but the initial thermal distribution requires the presence of a thermal bath ( e.g. , cooling lasers ) .\",\n \"the total system ( detector plus bath ) is described by a pure state for which the quantum duality saturates .\",\n \"however , the which - path information could only be retrieved by an optimal measurement including all bath degrees of freedom that are not under our control .\",\n \"measurements on just the detector necessarily correspond to a non - optimal measurement with respect to the whole system and therefore imply a reduced distinguishability .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we have studied the coherent backscattering effect from two trapped atoms , an interesting case study for quantitative quantum duality in a physically realistic setting . at zero temperature ,\",\n \"inelastic scattering due to the recoil effect provides _ a priori _ which - path information .\",\n \"further which - path information can be gained by measuring which atom has scattered the photon first , which is possible if the initial position uncertainty is small enough . at finite temperature , the atomic movement destroys the interference once the average doppler shift becomes of the order of the resonance width .\",\n \"which - path information resides in the atomic velocities via resonance conditions , but the duality inequality no longer saturates because an initial thermal state corresponds to a non - optimal detector preparation .\",\n \"we gratefully acknowledge a stimulating collaboration with d. delande and c. miniatura , who brought englert s work to our attention .\",\n \"we further wish to thank g. morigi and j. eschner for helpful discussions and o. sigwarth and r. kuhn for numerous remarks and a critical reading of the manuscript .\",\n \"this project was financially supported by the procope program of the daad .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":86,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"physics0702182"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["tracking and vertexing in a high multiplicity environment such as the lhc is a challenging task . in order to get a good secondary vertex resolution",", one needs measurements as close to the interaction point as possible .","to have acceptably low occupancies one needs a very fine segmented detector .","the cms experiment uses a hybrid pixel detector with @xmath1m@xmath2 pixel size .","the barrel part has three layers at mean radii of 4.4 , 7.3 and 10.2 cm . in the innermost layer the occupancy reaches @xmath3 at the full lhc luminosity of @xmath4s@xmath5@xmath6 .","+ the main purpose of the pixel detector is the reconstruction of secondary vertices ( mainly for b and @xmath7 physics ) and the generation of track seeds for the reconstruction in the full tracker .","also tracks reconstructed with the pixel detector alone is the only available tracking information at the first stage of the higher level trigger ( hlt ) . here","speed is more important than accuracy or efficiency .","as pointed out in @xcite , pixel - only tracks can be reconstructed in less than 20ms ( 110ms ) per event for regional ( global ) track finder .","the @xmath8 resolution is @xmath9[gev / c ] and the impact parameter can be measured with @xmath10 m for @xmath11gev / c rising to @xmath12 m for @xmath13 gev / c .","the component of the vertex position along the beam line is measured at the hlt .","the resolution depends on the physics channel ( number and momentum of tracks ) and is typically @xmath14 m with an efficiency of @xmath15 .","the smallest independent unit of the barrel support structure is a half - shell .","it is made out of 53 cm long and 0.25 mm thin carbon fiber ladders glued to aluminum cooling pipes with 0.3 mm wall thickness . to reach full spatial coverage ladders","are mounted with overlap on alternating sides of the cooling tubes .","this is shown in figure [ fig : mechanics ] on the left .","since the ladders are not tilted , charge sharing is enhanced between pixels due to lorentz drift in the 4 t magnetic field and hence the spatial resolution through analog signal interpolation is increased .","+ eight modules are screwed onto each ladder using thermal grease to improve the heat transfer from the electronics components to the cooling tubes .","this allows an easy removal of the mounted modules .","+ three half - shells are mounted together at the end flange building up half of the barrel detector .","the left and right half barrels are mechanically separated .","a six layer pcb is mounted on the end flange .","it distributes power and signals to the individual modules .","the pcb is equipped with lcds ( low current differential signal ) driver chips and is otherwise passive .","about 10 cm long cables and cooling tubes connect the barrel support structure to the service half - cylinders .","a sketch of the later is shown in figure [ fig : supply ] .","the barrel layers are made out of two types of sensor modules .","each layer has 32 half modules at the edges of the half - shells and 128 , 224 and 320 full modules for the three layers respectively .","a sketch of a module is shown in figure [ fig : module ] .","16 ( 8) readout chips ( rocs ) are bump bonded to the full ( half ) sensors .","a dedicated in bump bonding process has been developed at psi @xcite and the whole production is done in house . a three layer flexible high density interconnect ( hdi ) is glued on top of the sensor and wire bonded to the rocs and to the token bit manager chip ( tbm ) @xcite .","it is then glued to si - nitride base stripes which give mechanical stability and reduces stress to the bump bonds due to an excellent cte match to si .","details about the module assembly are described in these proceedings ( @xcite ) . the active area of a full ( half ) module sensor is 64.8@xmath1610.6 mm@xmath2 ( 64.8@xmath16 5.3mm@xmath2 ) . it is a double sided processed `` n+ on n '' design .","this is a pixelated high dose n implantation in a lightly n - doped bulk material .","the backside is p - doped forming the pn junction .","the inter - pixel isolation is done with a moderated p - spray technique .","there are mainly two reasons for this choice : ( i ) after irradiation , the bulk material will be type inverted .","depletion will then begin at the structured n - side , allowing the device to be operated in a partially depleted mode and thus at a lower bias voltage .","( ii ) a multiple guard ring structure on the p - side controls the voltage drop from the large negative bias voltage towards the sensor edge and allows to put all sensor edges to ground potential .","this enables a safe operation at very high bias voltages up to 600v .","the readout chip ( roc ) is fabricated in a commercial @xmath17 m 5 metal layer cmos process .","it s main purposes are * amplification and buffering of the charge signal from the sensor * zero suppression in the pixel unit cell .","only signals above a certain threshold will be read out .","this threshold can be adjusted individually for each pixel by means of four trim bits .","the trim bits have capacitive protection against single event upset ( seu ) , which have shown to reduce seu by 2 orders of magnitude @xcite .","a typical threshold dispersion after trimming at t=-10@xmath18c is 90 electron equivalents with a noise of 170 electrons .","* level 1 trigger verification . hit information without a corresponding l1 trigger are abandoned .","* sending hit information and configuration data out to the tbm chip * adjusting various voltage levels and offsets in order to compensate for chip - to - chip variations in the cmos device parameters the roc has 6 on chip voltage regulators .","this makes it possible to operate the detector without voltage regulator boards inside the cms tracker volume , improves ac power rejection and strongly reduces intermodule cross - talk .","more details about the roc can be found in @xcite .","the module is readout in a daisy chained scheme .","it is controlled by the token bit manager ( tbm ) chip . for each level 1 trigger","the tbm generates a token bit which controls 8 or 16 rocs .","one roc at a time sends its hit information through a lvds ( low voltage differential signal ) to the tbm chip where they are amplified and converted into a lcds ( low current differential signal ) .","the later has been chosen because of its low voltage swing , in order to reduce cross - talk on the kapton signal cable to the supply tube .","+ there is one analog readout link running at 40mhz for each half module and each full module in the outermost layer and 2 such links for each full module in the two inner layers . in order to reduce readout time",", the pixel address is sent in a digital coded analog signal , i.e. there exist 6 discrete address levels .","the amplified sensor signal is sent purely analog .","each hit pixel needs 6 clock cycles or 150ns to be read out .","the address level separation has been measured with the entire system and was found to be @xmath1930 times the rms of the level width .","thus , reliable address decoding is ensured .","figure [ fig : signal ] shows a simplified diagram of the signal flow for the barrel pixel detector .","the signal path in the middle shows the fast detector control link .","the pixel front end controller ( pfec ) sends a clock signal with encoded fast control signals ( l1 trigger , reset , internal calibration and resynchronization signal ) to the detector .","the pfec also downloads configuration data at run start and if necessary during runs via the industrial i@xmath2c protocol , modified to run at a higher clock rate of 40mhz .","all connections between service tube and counting room are optical links .","the doh ( digital opto hybrid ) does the conversion between optical and electrical signals .","a pll chip regenerates the fast signals and restores the clock .","a delay chip can adjust the phase for each signal separately .","the gatekeeper chip blocks idle signals needed for automatic gain adjustment of the optical links from being transmitted to the module .","finally there is a lvds to lcds level converter chip on the end flange print .","+ the path on the right shows the readout part .","the tbm drives the analog signal all the way to the service tube .","a level translator chip ( alt ) generates signal levels acceptable to the laser driver chips of the analog optical link .","driver and optical transmitter are located on the analog opto hybrid ( aoh ) .","the signal is received in the counting room by a vme front end driver unit ( pxfed ) @xcite .","it converts back to electrical signals , does a baseline correction , determines all pixel addresses and digitizes the analog pulse height .","it then passes this information to the cms daq system .","+ some of these components need to be programmed .","this happens through a dedicated digital link via a standard i@xmath2c protocol .","the boxes in gray show pixel specific full custom auxiliary asics developed at psi .","barrel modules have been tested in a high rate 300 mev / c pion beam at psi .","figure [ fig : effi ] shows the detection efficiency as a function of particle fluence for trigger rates of 10 and 100khz .","three different methods have been used . for low trigger rates efficiencies","are shown for tracks reconstructed with a beam telescope or using small scintillators only .","the third method measures the efficiency for internal calibration signals which are superimposed on top of the beam induced data traffic . for comparison ,","triangles show the efficiencies as expected from simulations . at high trigger rates","the data losses are dominated by readout related dead times .","the agreement between data and simulation is excellent here . for low trigger rates","the measurement shows @xmath20 higher inefficiency than expected from simulations .","this can be understood by radiation damage of the sensor under test .","+ resolution studies have been made in @xcite . using pion beam test data together with simulations",", one expects a resolution in @xmath21 between 10 and 20 @xmath22 m for sensors irradiated up to @xmath23n@xmath24cm@xmath2 , which corresponds to the first 4 years of operation in the innermost layer .","the z resolution depends on the azimuthal angle @xmath26 and only weakly on the irradiation dose .","for @xmath27 the resolution is @xmath28 m , increasing to 40 @xmath22 m at @xmath29 .","an overview of the cms barrel pixel detector has been given .","the design is finalized and all system components have been tested extensively . the device is still in the construction phase and will be delivered to cms in summer 2007 .","first proton collisions are expected by the end of 2007 at the injection energy of 450gev per beam and at the full energy of 7tev in spring 2008 . the cms collaboration , cms tracker technical design report , cern / lhcc 98 - 6 the cms collaboration , cms physics technical design report , vol i : detector performance and software , cern / lhcc 06 - 001 ch .","broennimann , development of an indium bump bond process for silicon pixel detectors at psi , nucl .","methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 303 s. knig , building cms pixel barrel detector modules , these proceedings h. c. kstli , design and performance of the cms pixel detector readout chip , nucl .","methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 188 d. kotlinski , the control and readout system of the cms pixel barrel detector , nucl .","methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 73 e. bartz , the 0.25@xmath22 m token bit manager chip for the cms pixel readout , proceedings of the 11@xmath30 workshop on electronics for lhc and future experiments , heidelberg , germany designed by m. pernicka , et al .",", hephy institute , vienna , austria a. dorokhov , performance of radiation hard pixel sensors for the cms experiment , ph.d .","thesis university of zrich , 2006"],"string":"[\n \"tracking and vertexing in a high multiplicity environment such as the lhc is a challenging task . in order to get a good secondary vertex resolution\",\n \", one needs measurements as close to the interaction point as possible .\",\n \"to have acceptably low occupancies one needs a very fine segmented detector .\",\n \"the cms experiment uses a hybrid pixel detector with @xmath1m@xmath2 pixel size .\",\n \"the barrel part has three layers at mean radii of 4.4 , 7.3 and 10.2 cm . in the innermost layer the occupancy reaches @xmath3 at the full lhc luminosity of @xmath4s@xmath5@xmath6 .\",\n \"+ the main purpose of the pixel detector is the reconstruction of secondary vertices ( mainly for b and @xmath7 physics ) and the generation of track seeds for the reconstruction in the full tracker .\",\n \"also tracks reconstructed with the pixel detector alone is the only available tracking information at the first stage of the higher level trigger ( hlt ) . here\",\n \"speed is more important than accuracy or efficiency .\",\n \"as pointed out in @xcite , pixel - only tracks can be reconstructed in less than 20ms ( 110ms ) per event for regional ( global ) track finder .\",\n \"the @xmath8 resolution is @xmath9[gev / c ] and the impact parameter can be measured with @xmath10 m for @xmath11gev / c rising to @xmath12 m for @xmath13 gev / c .\",\n \"the component of the vertex position along the beam line is measured at the hlt .\",\n \"the resolution depends on the physics channel ( number and momentum of tracks ) and is typically @xmath14 m with an efficiency of @xmath15 .\",\n \"the smallest independent unit of the barrel support structure is a half - shell .\",\n \"it is made out of 53 cm long and 0.25 mm thin carbon fiber ladders glued to aluminum cooling pipes with 0.3 mm wall thickness . to reach full spatial coverage ladders\",\n \"are mounted with overlap on alternating sides of the cooling tubes .\",\n \"this is shown in figure [ fig : mechanics ] on the left .\",\n \"since the ladders are not tilted , charge sharing is enhanced between pixels due to lorentz drift in the 4 t magnetic field and hence the spatial resolution through analog signal interpolation is increased .\",\n \"+ eight modules are screwed onto each ladder using thermal grease to improve the heat transfer from the electronics components to the cooling tubes .\",\n \"this allows an easy removal of the mounted modules .\",\n \"+ three half - shells are mounted together at the end flange building up half of the barrel detector .\",\n \"the left and right half barrels are mechanically separated .\",\n \"a six layer pcb is mounted on the end flange .\",\n \"it distributes power and signals to the individual modules .\",\n \"the pcb is equipped with lcds ( low current differential signal ) driver chips and is otherwise passive .\",\n \"about 10 cm long cables and cooling tubes connect the barrel support structure to the service half - cylinders .\",\n \"a sketch of the later is shown in figure [ fig : supply ] .\",\n \"the barrel layers are made out of two types of sensor modules .\",\n \"each layer has 32 half modules at the edges of the half - shells and 128 , 224 and 320 full modules for the three layers respectively .\",\n \"a sketch of a module is shown in figure [ fig : module ] .\",\n \"16 ( 8) readout chips ( rocs ) are bump bonded to the full ( half ) sensors .\",\n \"a dedicated in bump bonding process has been developed at psi @xcite and the whole production is done in house . a three layer flexible high density interconnect ( hdi ) is glued on top of the sensor and wire bonded to the rocs and to the token bit manager chip ( tbm ) @xcite .\",\n \"it is then glued to si - nitride base stripes which give mechanical stability and reduces stress to the bump bonds due to an excellent cte match to si .\",\n \"details about the module assembly are described in these proceedings ( @xcite ) . the active area of a full ( half ) module sensor is 64.8@xmath1610.6 mm@xmath2 ( 64.8@xmath16 5.3mm@xmath2 ) . it is a double sided processed `` n+ on n '' design .\",\n \"this is a pixelated high dose n implantation in a lightly n - doped bulk material .\",\n \"the backside is p - doped forming the pn junction .\",\n \"the inter - pixel isolation is done with a moderated p - spray technique .\",\n \"there are mainly two reasons for this choice : ( i ) after irradiation , the bulk material will be type inverted .\",\n \"depletion will then begin at the structured n - side , allowing the device to be operated in a partially depleted mode and thus at a lower bias voltage .\",\n \"( ii ) a multiple guard ring structure on the p - side controls the voltage drop from the large negative bias voltage towards the sensor edge and allows to put all sensor edges to ground potential .\",\n \"this enables a safe operation at very high bias voltages up to 600v .\",\n \"the readout chip ( roc ) is fabricated in a commercial @xmath17 m 5 metal layer cmos process .\",\n \"it s main purposes are * amplification and buffering of the charge signal from the sensor * zero suppression in the pixel unit cell .\",\n \"only signals above a certain threshold will be read out .\",\n \"this threshold can be adjusted individually for each pixel by means of four trim bits .\",\n \"the trim bits have capacitive protection against single event upset ( seu ) , which have shown to reduce seu by 2 orders of magnitude @xcite .\",\n \"a typical threshold dispersion after trimming at t=-10@xmath18c is 90 electron equivalents with a noise of 170 electrons .\",\n \"* level 1 trigger verification . hit information without a corresponding l1 trigger are abandoned .\",\n \"* sending hit information and configuration data out to the tbm chip * adjusting various voltage levels and offsets in order to compensate for chip - to - chip variations in the cmos device parameters the roc has 6 on chip voltage regulators .\",\n \"this makes it possible to operate the detector without voltage regulator boards inside the cms tracker volume , improves ac power rejection and strongly reduces intermodule cross - talk .\",\n \"more details about the roc can be found in @xcite .\",\n \"the module is readout in a daisy chained scheme .\",\n \"it is controlled by the token bit manager ( tbm ) chip . for each level 1 trigger\",\n \"the tbm generates a token bit which controls 8 or 16 rocs .\",\n \"one roc at a time sends its hit information through a lvds ( low voltage differential signal ) to the tbm chip where they are amplified and converted into a lcds ( low current differential signal ) .\",\n \"the later has been chosen because of its low voltage swing , in order to reduce cross - talk on the kapton signal cable to the supply tube .\",\n \"+ there is one analog readout link running at 40mhz for each half module and each full module in the outermost layer and 2 such links for each full module in the two inner layers . in order to reduce readout time\",\n \", the pixel address is sent in a digital coded analog signal , i.e. there exist 6 discrete address levels .\",\n \"the amplified sensor signal is sent purely analog .\",\n \"each hit pixel needs 6 clock cycles or 150ns to be read out .\",\n \"the address level separation has been measured with the entire system and was found to be @xmath1930 times the rms of the level width .\",\n \"thus , reliable address decoding is ensured .\",\n \"figure [ fig : signal ] shows a simplified diagram of the signal flow for the barrel pixel detector .\",\n \"the signal path in the middle shows the fast detector control link .\",\n \"the pixel front end controller ( pfec ) sends a clock signal with encoded fast control signals ( l1 trigger , reset , internal calibration and resynchronization signal ) to the detector .\",\n \"the pfec also downloads configuration data at run start and if necessary during runs via the industrial i@xmath2c protocol , modified to run at a higher clock rate of 40mhz .\",\n \"all connections between service tube and counting room are optical links .\",\n \"the doh ( digital opto hybrid ) does the conversion between optical and electrical signals .\",\n \"a pll chip regenerates the fast signals and restores the clock .\",\n \"a delay chip can adjust the phase for each signal separately .\",\n \"the gatekeeper chip blocks idle signals needed for automatic gain adjustment of the optical links from being transmitted to the module .\",\n \"finally there is a lvds to lcds level converter chip on the end flange print .\",\n \"+ the path on the right shows the readout part .\",\n \"the tbm drives the analog signal all the way to the service tube .\",\n \"a level translator chip ( alt ) generates signal levels acceptable to the laser driver chips of the analog optical link .\",\n \"driver and optical transmitter are located on the analog opto hybrid ( aoh ) .\",\n \"the signal is received in the counting room by a vme front end driver unit ( pxfed ) @xcite .\",\n \"it converts back to electrical signals , does a baseline correction , determines all pixel addresses and digitizes the analog pulse height .\",\n \"it then passes this information to the cms daq system .\",\n \"+ some of these components need to be programmed .\",\n \"this happens through a dedicated digital link via a standard i@xmath2c protocol .\",\n \"the boxes in gray show pixel specific full custom auxiliary asics developed at psi .\",\n \"barrel modules have been tested in a high rate 300 mev / c pion beam at psi .\",\n \"figure [ fig : effi ] shows the detection efficiency as a function of particle fluence for trigger rates of 10 and 100khz .\",\n \"three different methods have been used . for low trigger rates efficiencies\",\n \"are shown for tracks reconstructed with a beam telescope or using small scintillators only .\",\n \"the third method measures the efficiency for internal calibration signals which are superimposed on top of the beam induced data traffic . for comparison ,\",\n \"triangles show the efficiencies as expected from simulations . at high trigger rates\",\n \"the data losses are dominated by readout related dead times .\",\n \"the agreement between data and simulation is excellent here . for low trigger rates\",\n \"the measurement shows @xmath20 higher inefficiency than expected from simulations .\",\n \"this can be understood by radiation damage of the sensor under test .\",\n \"+ resolution studies have been made in @xcite . using pion beam test data together with simulations\",\n \", one expects a resolution in @xmath21 between 10 and 20 @xmath22 m for sensors irradiated up to @xmath23n@xmath24cm@xmath2 , which corresponds to the first 4 years of operation in the innermost layer .\",\n \"the z resolution depends on the azimuthal angle @xmath26 and only weakly on the irradiation dose .\",\n \"for @xmath27 the resolution is @xmath28 m , increasing to 40 @xmath22 m at @xmath29 .\",\n \"an overview of the cms barrel pixel detector has been given .\",\n \"the design is finalized and all system components have been tested extensively . the device is still in the construction phase and will be delivered to cms in summer 2007 .\",\n \"first proton collisions are expected by the end of 2007 at the injection energy of 450gev per beam and at the full energy of 7tev in spring 2008 . the cms collaboration , cms tracker technical design report , cern / lhcc 98 - 6 the cms collaboration , cms physics technical design report , vol i : detector performance and software , cern / lhcc 06 - 001 ch .\",\n \"broennimann , development of an indium bump bond process for silicon pixel detectors at psi , nucl .\",\n \"methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 303 s. knig , building cms pixel barrel detector modules , these proceedings h. c. kstli , design and performance of the cms pixel detector readout chip , nucl .\",\n \"methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 188 d. kotlinski , the control and readout system of the cms pixel barrel detector , nucl .\",\n \"methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 73 e. bartz , the 0.25@xmath22 m token bit manager chip for the cms pixel readout , proceedings of the 11@xmath30 workshop on electronics for lhc and future experiments , heidelberg , germany designed by m. pernicka , et al .\",\n \", hephy institute , vienna , austria a. dorokhov , performance of radiation hard pixel sensors for the cms experiment , ph.d .\",\n \"thesis university of zrich , 2006\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> the pixel detector is the innermost tracking device of the cms experiment at the lhc . </S>","<S> it is built from two independent sub devices , the pixel barrel and the end disks . </S>","<S> the barrel consists of three concentric layers around the beam pipe with mean radii of 4.4 , 7.3 and 10.2 cm . </S>","<S> there are two end disks on each side of the interaction point at @xmath034.5 cm and @xmath046.5 cm + this article gives an overview of the pixel barrel detector , its mechanical support structure , electronics components , services and its expected performance . </S>","<S> , , , , , , , , , , cms , pixel detector , lhc 29.40.wk , 29.40.gx </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> the pixel detector is the innermost tracking device of the cms experiment at the lhc . </S>\",\n \"<S> it is built from two independent sub devices , the pixel barrel and the end disks . </S>\",\n \"<S> the barrel consists of three concentric layers around the beam pipe with mean radii of 4.4 , 7.3 and 10.2 cm . </S>\",\n \"<S> there are two end disks on each side of the interaction point at @xmath034.5 cm and @xmath046.5 cm + this article gives an overview of the pixel barrel detector , its mechanical support structure , electronics components , services and its expected performance . </S>\",\n \"<S> , , , , , , , , , , cms , pixel detector , lhc 29.40.wk , 29.40.gx </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","mechanical structure","modules","detector control and readout","performance","conclusion and outlook"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"mechanical structure\",\n \"modules\",\n \"detector control and readout\",\n \"performance\",\n \"conclusion and outlook\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["tracking and vertexing in a high multiplicity environment such as the lhc is a challenging task . in order to get a good secondary vertex resolution",", one needs measurements as close to the interaction point as possible .","to have acceptably low occupancies one needs a very fine segmented detector .","the cms experiment uses a hybrid pixel detector with @xmath1m@xmath2 pixel size .","the barrel part has three layers at mean radii of 4.4 , 7.3 and 10.2 cm . in the innermost layer the occupancy reaches @xmath3 at the full lhc luminosity of @xmath4s@xmath5@xmath6 .","+ the main purpose of the pixel detector is the reconstruction of secondary vertices ( mainly for b and @xmath7 physics ) and the generation of track seeds for the reconstruction in the full tracker .","also tracks reconstructed with the pixel detector alone is the only available tracking information at the first stage of the higher level trigger ( hlt ) . here","speed is more important than accuracy or efficiency .","as pointed out in @xcite , pixel - only tracks can be reconstructed in less than 20ms ( 110ms ) per event for regional ( global ) track finder .","the @xmath8 resolution is @xmath9[gev / c ] and the impact parameter can be measured with @xmath10 m for @xmath11gev / c rising to @xmath12 m for @xmath13 gev / c .","the component of the vertex position along the beam line is measured at the hlt .","the resolution depends on the physics channel ( number and momentum of tracks ) and is typically @xmath14 m with an efficiency of @xmath15 ."],["the smallest independent unit of the barrel support structure is a half - shell .","it is made out of 53 cm long and 0.25 mm thin carbon fiber ladders glued to aluminum cooling pipes with 0.3 mm wall thickness . to reach full spatial coverage ladders","are mounted with overlap on alternating sides of the cooling tubes .","this is shown in figure [ fig : mechanics ] on the left .","since the ladders are not tilted , charge sharing is enhanced between pixels due to lorentz drift in the 4 t magnetic field and hence the spatial resolution through analog signal interpolation is increased .","+ eight modules are screwed onto each ladder using thermal grease to improve the heat transfer from the electronics components to the cooling tubes .","this allows an easy removal of the mounted modules .","+ three half - shells are mounted together at the end flange building up half of the barrel detector .","the left and right half barrels are mechanically separated .","a six layer pcb is mounted on the end flange .","it distributes power and signals to the individual modules .","the pcb is equipped with lcds ( low current differential signal ) driver chips and is otherwise passive .","about 10 cm long cables and cooling tubes connect the barrel support structure to the service half - cylinders .","a sketch of the later is shown in figure [ fig : supply ] ."],["the barrel layers are made out of two types of sensor modules .","each layer has 32 half modules at the edges of the half - shells and 128 , 224 and 320 full modules for the three layers respectively .","a sketch of a module is shown in figure [ fig : module ] .","16 ( 8) readout chips ( rocs ) are bump bonded to the full ( half ) sensors .","a dedicated in bump bonding process has been developed at psi @xcite and the whole production is done in house . a three layer flexible high density interconnect ( hdi ) is glued on top of the sensor and wire bonded to the rocs and to the token bit manager chip ( tbm ) @xcite .","it is then glued to si - nitride base stripes which give mechanical stability and reduces stress to the bump bonds due to an excellent cte match to si .","details about the module assembly are described in these proceedings ( @xcite ) . the active area of a full ( half ) module sensor is 64.8@xmath1610.6 mm@xmath2 ( 64.8@xmath16 5.3mm@xmath2 ) . it is a double sided processed `` n+ on n '' design .","this is a pixelated high dose n implantation in a lightly n - doped bulk material .","the backside is p - doped forming the pn junction .","the inter - pixel isolation is done with a moderated p - spray technique .","there are mainly two reasons for this choice : ( i ) after irradiation , the bulk material will be type inverted .","depletion will then begin at the structured n - side , allowing the device to be operated in a partially depleted mode and thus at a lower bias voltage .","( ii ) a multiple guard ring structure on the p - side controls the voltage drop from the large negative bias voltage towards the sensor edge and allows to put all sensor edges to ground potential .","this enables a safe operation at very high bias voltages up to 600v .","the readout chip ( roc ) is fabricated in a commercial @xmath17 m 5 metal layer cmos process .","it s main purposes are * amplification and buffering of the charge signal from the sensor * zero suppression in the pixel unit cell .","only signals above a certain threshold will be read out .","this threshold can be adjusted individually for each pixel by means of four trim bits .","the trim bits have capacitive protection against single event upset ( seu ) , which have shown to reduce seu by 2 orders of magnitude @xcite .","a typical threshold dispersion after trimming at t=-10@xmath18c is 90 electron equivalents with a noise of 170 electrons .","* level 1 trigger verification . hit information without a corresponding l1 trigger are abandoned .","* sending hit information and configuration data out to the tbm chip * adjusting various voltage levels and offsets in order to compensate for chip - to - chip variations in the cmos device parameters the roc has 6 on chip voltage regulators .","this makes it possible to operate the detector without voltage regulator boards inside the cms tracker volume , improves ac power rejection and strongly reduces intermodule cross - talk .","more details about the roc can be found in @xcite .","the module is readout in a daisy chained scheme .","it is controlled by the token bit manager ( tbm ) chip . for each level 1 trigger","the tbm generates a token bit which controls 8 or 16 rocs .","one roc at a time sends its hit information through a lvds ( low voltage differential signal ) to the tbm chip where they are amplified and converted into a lcds ( low current differential signal ) .","the later has been chosen because of its low voltage swing , in order to reduce cross - talk on the kapton signal cable to the supply tube .","+ there is one analog readout link running at 40mhz for each half module and each full module in the outermost layer and 2 such links for each full module in the two inner layers . in order to reduce readout time",", the pixel address is sent in a digital coded analog signal , i.e. there exist 6 discrete address levels .","the amplified sensor signal is sent purely analog .","each hit pixel needs 6 clock cycles or 150ns to be read out .","the address level separation has been measured with the entire system and was found to be @xmath1930 times the rms of the level width .","thus , reliable address decoding is ensured ."],["figure [ fig : signal ] shows a simplified diagram of the signal flow for the barrel pixel detector .","the signal path in the middle shows the fast detector control link .","the pixel front end controller ( pfec ) sends a clock signal with encoded fast control signals ( l1 trigger , reset , internal calibration and resynchronization signal ) to the detector .","the pfec also downloads configuration data at run start and if necessary during runs via the industrial i@xmath2c protocol , modified to run at a higher clock rate of 40mhz .","all connections between service tube and counting room are optical links .","the doh ( digital opto hybrid ) does the conversion between optical and electrical signals .","a pll chip regenerates the fast signals and restores the clock .","a delay chip can adjust the phase for each signal separately .","the gatekeeper chip blocks idle signals needed for automatic gain adjustment of the optical links from being transmitted to the module .","finally there is a lvds to lcds level converter chip on the end flange print .","+ the path on the right shows the readout part .","the tbm drives the analog signal all the way to the service tube .","a level translator chip ( alt ) generates signal levels acceptable to the laser driver chips of the analog optical link .","driver and optical transmitter are located on the analog opto hybrid ( aoh ) .","the signal is received in the counting room by a vme front end driver unit ( pxfed ) @xcite .","it converts back to electrical signals , does a baseline correction , determines all pixel addresses and digitizes the analog pulse height .","it then passes this information to the cms daq system .","+ some of these components need to be programmed .","this happens through a dedicated digital link via a standard i@xmath2c protocol .","the boxes in gray show pixel specific full custom auxiliary asics developed at psi ."],["barrel modules have been tested in a high rate 300 mev / c pion beam at psi .","figure [ fig : effi ] shows the detection efficiency as a function of particle fluence for trigger rates of 10 and 100khz .","three different methods have been used . for low trigger rates efficiencies","are shown for tracks reconstructed with a beam telescope or using small scintillators only .","the third method measures the efficiency for internal calibration signals which are superimposed on top of the beam induced data traffic . for comparison ,","triangles show the efficiencies as expected from simulations . at high trigger rates","the data losses are dominated by readout related dead times .","the agreement between data and simulation is excellent here . for low trigger rates","the measurement shows @xmath20 higher inefficiency than expected from simulations .","this can be understood by radiation damage of the sensor under test .","+ resolution studies have been made in @xcite . using pion beam test data together with simulations",", one expects a resolution in @xmath21 between 10 and 20 @xmath22 m for sensors irradiated up to @xmath23n@xmath24cm@xmath2 , which corresponds to the first 4 years of operation in the innermost layer .","the z resolution depends on the azimuthal angle @xmath26 and only weakly on the irradiation dose .","for @xmath27 the resolution is @xmath28 m , increasing to 40 @xmath22 m at @xmath29 ."],["an overview of the cms barrel pixel detector has been given .","the design is finalized and all system components have been tested extensively . the device is still in the construction phase and will be delivered to cms in summer 2007 .","first proton collisions are expected by the end of 2007 at the injection energy of 450gev per beam and at the full energy of 7tev in spring 2008 . the cms collaboration , cms tracker technical design report , cern / lhcc 98 - 6 the cms collaboration , cms physics technical design report , vol i : detector performance and software , cern / lhcc 06 - 001 ch .","broennimann , development of an indium bump bond process for silicon pixel detectors at psi , nucl .","methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 303 s. knig , building cms pixel barrel detector modules , these proceedings h. c. kstli , design and performance of the cms pixel detector readout chip , nucl .","methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 188 d. kotlinski , the control and readout system of the cms pixel barrel detector , nucl .","methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 73 e. bartz , the 0.25@xmath22 m token bit manager chip for the cms pixel readout , proceedings of the 11@xmath30 workshop on electronics for lhc and future experiments , heidelberg , germany designed by m. pernicka , et al .",", hephy institute , vienna , austria a. dorokhov , performance of radiation hard pixel sensors for the cms experiment , ph.d .","thesis university of zrich , 2006"]],"string":"[\n [\n \"tracking and vertexing in a high multiplicity environment such as the lhc is a challenging task . in order to get a good secondary vertex resolution\",\n \", one needs measurements as close to the interaction point as possible .\",\n \"to have acceptably low occupancies one needs a very fine segmented detector .\",\n \"the cms experiment uses a hybrid pixel detector with @xmath1m@xmath2 pixel size .\",\n \"the barrel part has three layers at mean radii of 4.4 , 7.3 and 10.2 cm . in the innermost layer the occupancy reaches @xmath3 at the full lhc luminosity of @xmath4s@xmath5@xmath6 .\",\n \"+ the main purpose of the pixel detector is the reconstruction of secondary vertices ( mainly for b and @xmath7 physics ) and the generation of track seeds for the reconstruction in the full tracker .\",\n \"also tracks reconstructed with the pixel detector alone is the only available tracking information at the first stage of the higher level trigger ( hlt ) . here\",\n \"speed is more important than accuracy or efficiency .\",\n \"as pointed out in @xcite , pixel - only tracks can be reconstructed in less than 20ms ( 110ms ) per event for regional ( global ) track finder .\",\n \"the @xmath8 resolution is @xmath9[gev / c ] and the impact parameter can be measured with @xmath10 m for @xmath11gev / c rising to @xmath12 m for @xmath13 gev / c .\",\n \"the component of the vertex position along the beam line is measured at the hlt .\",\n \"the resolution depends on the physics channel ( number and momentum of tracks ) and is typically @xmath14 m with an efficiency of @xmath15 .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the smallest independent unit of the barrel support structure is a half - shell .\",\n \"it is made out of 53 cm long and 0.25 mm thin carbon fiber ladders glued to aluminum cooling pipes with 0.3 mm wall thickness . to reach full spatial coverage ladders\",\n \"are mounted with overlap on alternating sides of the cooling tubes .\",\n \"this is shown in figure [ fig : mechanics ] on the left .\",\n \"since the ladders are not tilted , charge sharing is enhanced between pixels due to lorentz drift in the 4 t magnetic field and hence the spatial resolution through analog signal interpolation is increased .\",\n \"+ eight modules are screwed onto each ladder using thermal grease to improve the heat transfer from the electronics components to the cooling tubes .\",\n \"this allows an easy removal of the mounted modules .\",\n \"+ three half - shells are mounted together at the end flange building up half of the barrel detector .\",\n \"the left and right half barrels are mechanically separated .\",\n \"a six layer pcb is mounted on the end flange .\",\n \"it distributes power and signals to the individual modules .\",\n \"the pcb is equipped with lcds ( low current differential signal ) driver chips and is otherwise passive .\",\n \"about 10 cm long cables and cooling tubes connect the barrel support structure to the service half - cylinders .\",\n \"a sketch of the later is shown in figure [ fig : supply ] .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the barrel layers are made out of two types of sensor modules .\",\n \"each layer has 32 half modules at the edges of the half - shells and 128 , 224 and 320 full modules for the three layers respectively .\",\n \"a sketch of a module is shown in figure [ fig : module ] .\",\n \"16 ( 8) readout chips ( rocs ) are bump bonded to the full ( half ) sensors .\",\n \"a dedicated in bump bonding process has been developed at psi @xcite and the whole production is done in house . a three layer flexible high density interconnect ( hdi ) is glued on top of the sensor and wire bonded to the rocs and to the token bit manager chip ( tbm ) @xcite .\",\n \"it is then glued to si - nitride base stripes which give mechanical stability and reduces stress to the bump bonds due to an excellent cte match to si .\",\n \"details about the module assembly are described in these proceedings ( @xcite ) . the active area of a full ( half ) module sensor is 64.8@xmath1610.6 mm@xmath2 ( 64.8@xmath16 5.3mm@xmath2 ) . it is a double sided processed `` n+ on n '' design .\",\n \"this is a pixelated high dose n implantation in a lightly n - doped bulk material .\",\n \"the backside is p - doped forming the pn junction .\",\n \"the inter - pixel isolation is done with a moderated p - spray technique .\",\n \"there are mainly two reasons for this choice : ( i ) after irradiation , the bulk material will be type inverted .\",\n \"depletion will then begin at the structured n - side , allowing the device to be operated in a partially depleted mode and thus at a lower bias voltage .\",\n \"( ii ) a multiple guard ring structure on the p - side controls the voltage drop from the large negative bias voltage towards the sensor edge and allows to put all sensor edges to ground potential .\",\n \"this enables a safe operation at very high bias voltages up to 600v .\",\n \"the readout chip ( roc ) is fabricated in a commercial @xmath17 m 5 metal layer cmos process .\",\n \"it s main purposes are * amplification and buffering of the charge signal from the sensor * zero suppression in the pixel unit cell .\",\n \"only signals above a certain threshold will be read out .\",\n \"this threshold can be adjusted individually for each pixel by means of four trim bits .\",\n \"the trim bits have capacitive protection against single event upset ( seu ) , which have shown to reduce seu by 2 orders of magnitude @xcite .\",\n \"a typical threshold dispersion after trimming at t=-10@xmath18c is 90 electron equivalents with a noise of 170 electrons .\",\n \"* level 1 trigger verification . hit information without a corresponding l1 trigger are abandoned .\",\n \"* sending hit information and configuration data out to the tbm chip * adjusting various voltage levels and offsets in order to compensate for chip - to - chip variations in the cmos device parameters the roc has 6 on chip voltage regulators .\",\n \"this makes it possible to operate the detector without voltage regulator boards inside the cms tracker volume , improves ac power rejection and strongly reduces intermodule cross - talk .\",\n \"more details about the roc can be found in @xcite .\",\n \"the module is readout in a daisy chained scheme .\",\n \"it is controlled by the token bit manager ( tbm ) chip . for each level 1 trigger\",\n \"the tbm generates a token bit which controls 8 or 16 rocs .\",\n \"one roc at a time sends its hit information through a lvds ( low voltage differential signal ) to the tbm chip where they are amplified and converted into a lcds ( low current differential signal ) .\",\n \"the later has been chosen because of its low voltage swing , in order to reduce cross - talk on the kapton signal cable to the supply tube .\",\n \"+ there is one analog readout link running at 40mhz for each half module and each full module in the outermost layer and 2 such links for each full module in the two inner layers . in order to reduce readout time\",\n \", the pixel address is sent in a digital coded analog signal , i.e. there exist 6 discrete address levels .\",\n \"the amplified sensor signal is sent purely analog .\",\n \"each hit pixel needs 6 clock cycles or 150ns to be read out .\",\n \"the address level separation has been measured with the entire system and was found to be @xmath1930 times the rms of the level width .\",\n \"thus , reliable address decoding is ensured .\"\n ],\n [\n \"figure [ fig : signal ] shows a simplified diagram of the signal flow for the barrel pixel detector .\",\n \"the signal path in the middle shows the fast detector control link .\",\n \"the pixel front end controller ( pfec ) sends a clock signal with encoded fast control signals ( l1 trigger , reset , internal calibration and resynchronization signal ) to the detector .\",\n \"the pfec also downloads configuration data at run start and if necessary during runs via the industrial i@xmath2c protocol , modified to run at a higher clock rate of 40mhz .\",\n \"all connections between service tube and counting room are optical links .\",\n \"the doh ( digital opto hybrid ) does the conversion between optical and electrical signals .\",\n \"a pll chip regenerates the fast signals and restores the clock .\",\n \"a delay chip can adjust the phase for each signal separately .\",\n \"the gatekeeper chip blocks idle signals needed for automatic gain adjustment of the optical links from being transmitted to the module .\",\n \"finally there is a lvds to lcds level converter chip on the end flange print .\",\n \"+ the path on the right shows the readout part .\",\n \"the tbm drives the analog signal all the way to the service tube .\",\n \"a level translator chip ( alt ) generates signal levels acceptable to the laser driver chips of the analog optical link .\",\n \"driver and optical transmitter are located on the analog opto hybrid ( aoh ) .\",\n \"the signal is received in the counting room by a vme front end driver unit ( pxfed ) @xcite .\",\n \"it converts back to electrical signals , does a baseline correction , determines all pixel addresses and digitizes the analog pulse height .\",\n \"it then passes this information to the cms daq system .\",\n \"+ some of these components need to be programmed .\",\n \"this happens through a dedicated digital link via a standard i@xmath2c protocol .\",\n \"the boxes in gray show pixel specific full custom auxiliary asics developed at psi .\"\n ],\n [\n \"barrel modules have been tested in a high rate 300 mev / c pion beam at psi .\",\n \"figure [ fig : effi ] shows the detection efficiency as a function of particle fluence for trigger rates of 10 and 100khz .\",\n \"three different methods have been used . for low trigger rates efficiencies\",\n \"are shown for tracks reconstructed with a beam telescope or using small scintillators only .\",\n \"the third method measures the efficiency for internal calibration signals which are superimposed on top of the beam induced data traffic . for comparison ,\",\n \"triangles show the efficiencies as expected from simulations . at high trigger rates\",\n \"the data losses are dominated by readout related dead times .\",\n \"the agreement between data and simulation is excellent here . for low trigger rates\",\n \"the measurement shows @xmath20 higher inefficiency than expected from simulations .\",\n \"this can be understood by radiation damage of the sensor under test .\",\n \"+ resolution studies have been made in @xcite . using pion beam test data together with simulations\",\n \", one expects a resolution in @xmath21 between 10 and 20 @xmath22 m for sensors irradiated up to @xmath23n@xmath24cm@xmath2 , which corresponds to the first 4 years of operation in the innermost layer .\",\n \"the z resolution depends on the azimuthal angle @xmath26 and only weakly on the irradiation dose .\",\n \"for @xmath27 the resolution is @xmath28 m , increasing to 40 @xmath22 m at @xmath29 .\"\n ],\n [\n \"an overview of the cms barrel pixel detector has been given .\",\n \"the design is finalized and all system components have been tested extensively . the device is still in the construction phase and will be delivered to cms in summer 2007 .\",\n \"first proton collisions are expected by the end of 2007 at the injection energy of 450gev per beam and at the full energy of 7tev in spring 2008 . the cms collaboration , cms tracker technical design report , cern / lhcc 98 - 6 the cms collaboration , cms physics technical design report , vol i : detector performance and software , cern / lhcc 06 - 001 ch .\",\n \"broennimann , development of an indium bump bond process for silicon pixel detectors at psi , nucl .\",\n \"methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 303 s. knig , building cms pixel barrel detector modules , these proceedings h. c. kstli , design and performance of the cms pixel detector readout chip , nucl .\",\n \"methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 188 d. kotlinski , the control and readout system of the cms pixel barrel detector , nucl .\",\n \"methods a 565 ( 2006 ) 73 e. bartz , the 0.25@xmath22 m token bit manager chip for the cms pixel readout , proceedings of the 11@xmath30 workshop on electronics for lhc and future experiments , heidelberg , germany designed by m. pernicka , et al .\",\n \", hephy institute , vienna , austria a. dorokhov , performance of radiation hard pixel sensors for the cms experiment , ph.d .\",\n \"thesis university of zrich , 2006\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":87,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"cond-mat0610661"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["quantum phase transitions constitute a very active topic in theoretical physics @xcite , to which disorder and frustration of a quantum spin glass add considerable intricacies @xcite .","although quantum effects were usually considered to be negligible in spin glasses at finite temperatures , diverse experiments @xcite have proved them to be highly relevant , leading to the first experimental realization of _ quantum annealing _ @xcite .","one of the most widely employed theoretical approaches to the quantum spin - glass transition ( qsgt ) is the random couplings ising model in a transverse field ( ritf ) @xcite . within the analytical approach",", a griffiths phase was found in the 1d case via an elegant rg procedure @xcite , while such a structure was proved to be absent from the infinite range case within the replica formalism @xcite .","the 1d rg analysis was extended to study the presence of a certain number of long - distance links , proving the relevance of the perturbation @xcite .","regarding numerical approaches , quantum monte - carlo ( qmc ) remains as the most suitable tool at @xmath0 .","using it , a coherent picture was obtained in the 2d and 3d cases , showing that the griffiths phase is present in 2d but absent in 3d @xcite .","classical spin glasses have been thoroughly analysed on bethe lattices @xcite .","however , finite bethe lattices are dominated by boundary effects and present no frustration . a way out is to study random graphs with a fixed connectivity which , in the classical case , allow the application of the _ cavity approach _ @xcite .","these random graphs present genuine frustration , since they have _ loops _ , and have no boundaries . on the other hand",", the average size of the loops grows with the number of sites @xcite , thus making them resemble , _ locally _ , a bethe lattice ( see figure [ graph : fig ] ) .","the density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) @xcite is known to be a highly accurate method to analyze @xmath1 ground state properties of 1d or quasi-1d quantum many body systems , including tree structures @xcite .","we have extended the method in order to trace the behaviour of finite size samples of random graphs of fixed connectivity @xmath2 across the qsgt within the ritf model . given the high connectivity of these graphs ,","the applicability of the dmrg is highly non - trivial .","it is remarkable that in the case of non - random couplings , we have found the number of retained states needed to ensure a good accuracy to be very high , rendering the application of the dmrg unfeasible . the careful analysis of _","pseudo-_critical points of finite size samples constitutes a powerful tool to study a qsgt . as a recent example , the work of igli and coworkers @xcite studies the distributions of , e.g. , the average entanglement entropy and the surface magnetization of finite size 1d samples . in this work","we provide measurements of , among other observables , spin - glass susceptibilities , energy gaps , long distance spin - spin correlations and entanglement entropies , and use them to obtain insight on the mechanism of the transition .","a full characterization of the qsgt , nonetheless , is not attempted in this work , since it would require to obtain statistics on a large number of disorder realizations .","the rest of the paper is organized as follows : sec .","[ model : sec ] presents the model , and sec .","[ dmrg ] provides details on the application of dmrg .","[ results ] shows the numerical dmrg results obtained .","[ conclusions ] presents a discussion of the results and some concluding remarks .","let us consider the random ising model in a transverse field ( ritf ) on a generic graph @xcite : @xmath3 where @xmath4 denotes pairs of neighboring sites @xmath5 and @xmath6 on the graph .","the values of @xmath7 are uncorrelated random variables with a uniform probability density distribution in the interval @xmath8 $ ] .","we will focus our study on randomly generated graphs , with @xmath9 sites and a fixed connectivity @xmath2 @xcite , i.e. , each site @xmath5 is connected to @xmath2 other ( randomly chosen ) sites @xmath6 .","an example of such a graph , with @xmath10 sites , is shown in fig .","[ graph : fig ] .","it should be noticed that , locally and for large @xmath9 , such graphs resemble _ bethe lattices _ , as we have highlighted with thicker links in fig . [ graph : fig ] . nonetheless , the behaviour of finite bethe lattices is dominated by the boundary , unlike in our case , where there is none . moreover , trees have no loops and , therefore , present no _ frustration _ , while random graphs with fixed connectivity do contain loops and , therefore , have genuine frustration .","it has been proved , nonetheless , that short loops become rare as @xmath11 : more precisely , the probability of finding a loop of any fixed size @xmath12 falls to zero when @xmath11 @xcite .","the physics of classical spin glasses in these graphs has been studied using the cavity method by mzard and parisi @xcite .","let @xmath13 be the absolute value of the disorder - averaged energy per site of the classical ground state .","our numerical experiments show that it increases from @xmath14 at @xmath15 up to @xmath16 for larger @xmath9 , which is the theoretical limiting value for @xmath11 under the assumption that all links are satisfied .","we will take the product of eigenstates of @xmath17 , for all @xmath5 , as the _ canonical basis _ for our problem . in this basis",", we denote the state in which all spins point in the positive @xmath18-direction as @xmath19 .","let us assume , for the moment , that @xmath20 for all @xmath5 . for @xmath21 , all the non - diagonal terms in the hamiltonian vanish .","therefore , the ground state is given by the configurations with the classical minimum energy .","disregarding accidental degeneracies , there are two such configurations , related by a simultaneous flip of all spins , @xmath22 for all @xmath5 .","the transverse field @xmath23 may be considered as a _ kinetic energy _ coefficient , providing a hopping term among the classical configurations . in the @xmath24","limit the transverse field term dominates and the ground state tends to the state @xmath25 , with all the spins pointing in the positive @xmath18-direction , separated by a large gap @xmath26 from the first excited state .","let us remark that all the components of the canonical basis have the same amplitude in the state @xmath25 .","by decreasing @xmath23 there is a certain value @xmath27 for which the system undergoes a quantum spin - glass transition ( qsgt ) . for @xmath28 ,","the system is in a quantum paramagnetic phase , which presents no long - range order .","below @xmath29 , the system is in a quantum spin - glass phase , presenting a hidden long - range order which may be detected by a number of observables .","we will focus here on the divergence of the _ spin - glass susceptibility _ : @xmath30 i.e. , physically , a small longitudinal magnetic field @xmath31 , applied at site @xmath6 , generates a magnetization response on each site @xmath5 , which is measured ( and squared , so as to disregard its sign ) ; the results are summed over all sites @xmath5 and averaged over all sites @xmath6 . if the system is in a paramagnetic phase , the magnetization will be proportional to @xmath31 and short - ranged in space , so that the sum over @xmath5 and @xmath6 yields a finite value for @xmath32 . on the other hand , on approaching the spin - glass phase , an infinitesimally small longitudinal magnetic field @xmath31 , localized at a single site @xmath6 , will eventually induce a finite magnetization over a long - range of spins .","this effect is at the origin of the divergence of @xmath32 .","we shall now discuss the numerical approach we have used to study this system , and the results obtained .","the density - matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) has proved to be an accurate method to analyse the properties of 1d and quasi-1d systems @xcite .","the dmrg may be described as a variational method within the matrix - product states ( mps ) , which constitute a low - dimensional subspace of the full hilbert space @xcite .","a mps may be expressed as @xmath33 where each @xmath34 is a square matrix with dimension @xmath35 , which may be considered as the number of retained states per block when splitting the system into a left and right parts .","the total number of variational parameters is less than @xmath36 .","the success of the dmrg is related to the ability of these mps to reproduce faithfully the ground states of local 1d many - body problems for low values of @xmath35 @xcite . if @xmath37 , any state of the hilbert space may be exactly represented as a mps .","the minimum number of retained states @xmath35 is related to the exponential of the von neumann entanglement entropy of the dmrg block @xcite . in a non - critical 1d system , this entropy is bounded for all sizes , while it grows as @xmath38 for a 1d critical system of length @xmath12 .","it is believed that for a @xmath39-dimensional system out of criticality , the entanglement entropy scales as @xmath40 , where @xmath12 is the shortest spatial dimension of the system @xcite .","this estimate is known as the _ area law _ and is believed to have logarithmic corrections at critical points .","an important practical consequence is that , in order to study a 2d system , the number of retained states @xmath35 should grow as @xmath41 , thus making the dmrg very inefficient .","our system , on the other hand , is defined on a random graph of fixed connectivity , @xmath2 .","we will show that this poses no problem to the number of retained states @xmath35 , which appears to remain manageable even for @xmath42 as long as the couplings are random .","however , the implementation of the dmrg on such a model has required the following technical refinements of the original method : * ( a ) path selection . * : : in a non-1d system , dmrg proceeds by converting the system into an effective 1d problem with long - range couplings .","a path is chosen along the graph , which does not repeat sites , and is considered to be appropriate if the number of broken links between the left and the right blocks is kept low along a dmrg sweep .","normally , the selection of a suitable path in a quasi-1d system ( e.g. ladders ) is done by geometrical intuition . in our implementation","we have designed an automated procedure : a simulated annealing algorithm is employed in order to minimize the number of broken links .","the full problem of finding the optimal path is computationally very hard .","therefore , we do not aim at the exact optimum , but only to a reasonably good local minimum .","we have noticed that our quasi - optimal path performs much better than a random path . *","( b ) perron - frobenius criterion . * : : the hamiltonian of the ritf on any graph fulfills , on the canonical basis , the conditions of the perron - frobenius theorem , i.e. , all off - diagonal components are _ non - positive_. hence , all the ground state components must have the same sign . using the mps representation of the ground state","obtained within the dmrg , it is always possible to reconstruct the amplitude of any configuration @xmath43 .","the obtention of the full @xmath44 is unfeasible , since it would require reconstructing the amplitude of an exponentially large number of configurations .","nonetheless , it is possible to pick up a few random configurations @xmath45 , and check that all their amplitudes have the same sign .","whenever this criterion was not met a rather rare event , the calculation was repeated changing the random seed for the lanczos procedure on the first dmrg step . *","( c ) wavefunction annealing .","* : : for large @xmath23 the ground state @xmath25 is easily representable as a mps , requiring a single retained state .","the dmrg works extremely well in this regime and , therefore , our simulations are always started well within the paramagnetic ( large @xmath23 ) phase .","the qsgt is approached by repeatedly decreasing the value of @xmath23 by a small amount , always using the previous ground state as a seed for the new calculation , exploiting the wavefunction transformations suggested by white @xcite .","this type of _ annealing _ of the ground state provides a faster convergence and more accurate results for low @xmath23 . *","( d ) adaptive number of retained states . * : : the number of retained states @xmath35 , and the number of dmrg sweeps @xmath46 , are not fixed in our algorithm .","we set a maximum value for the sum of the neglected eigenvalues of the density matrix in the rg truncation ( @xmath47 ) , and select @xmath35 accordingly .","moreover , sometimes convergence takes more sweeps than usual ( @xmath48 ) in order to obtain machine precision in the convergence of the ground state energy . *","( e ) energy gap measurements . * : : when there is a symmetry in a problem , e.g. , under su(2 ) , it is usually possible to obtain the first excited state as the ground state of a different _ sector _ of the hilbert space . in our case , lacking this , the best option has proved to be the following one . for each dmrg step , after the ground state @xmath49 had been found , it was `` promoted '' to a higher energy by the following transformation of the hamiltonian : + @xmath50 + in such a way that the ground state of this new hamiltonian is the former first excited state , as long as we take @xmath51 , @xmath52 being the gap we are looking for . the density matrix used for truncation","was built as a linear combination of the density matrices for each state , with equal weights .","however , we should remember that only ground states of local hamiltonians are expected to be faithfully represented by mps @xcite , and eq .","( [ h.gap ] ) does not define a local hamiltonian .","therefore , the accuracy in the gap estimate is worse than that in the ground state energy and in other observables .","we have applied the modified dmrg technique to study a few samples of random graphs with fixed connectivity @xmath2 and sizes ranging from @xmath53 to @xmath42 .","a full characterization of the qsgt would require relevant statistics on the disorder .","unfortunately , in order to obtain a high accuracy for each sample , the required cpu - time is rather large .","therefore , we have decided to focus on a precise study of a few realizations , in order to gain insight on the mechanism of the transition for finite samples .","most of our findings will be illustrated in the figures of this section by showing in detail the results obtained for a sample with @xmath54 sites .","it should be remarked that the highlighted features are typical of all the ensemble .","the numerical simulations were done with the dmrg algorithm explained in section [ dmrg ] , with a neglected probability tolerance @xmath55 and a tolerance on the convergence of the energy of one part in @xmath56 , for ten samples of each size ( @xmath57 50 , 100 , 150 , 200 , 250 , 300 , 400 , 500 ) .","each sample is a different random graph , always with fixed connectivity @xmath2 , and the bonds @xmath7 are random and independent , uniformly distributed in the interval @xmath8 $ ] .","figure [ xsg : fig](a ) shows three observables calculated for a given instance of a @xmath54 graph , as a fuction of @xmath23 .","the most relevant quantity is the spin - glass susceptibility , defined in equation [ xsg ] .","a small magnetic field @xmath58 is applied at a single site @xmath59 , and the magnetic response is measured with the formula @xmath60 which is found to increase very fast as @xmath23 approaches @xmath61 from above , and thereupon saturating at a very high value .","figure [ xsg : fig](b ) proves the divergence of @xmath32 by showing its behavior at three different values of @xmath62 ( @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 ) : the saturation value is seen to scale as @xmath66 .","we estimate the _","pseudo-_critical value @xmath29 for the given sample as the value of @xmath23 at which the slope of the susceptibility attains its maximum . with this definition",", @xmath29 appears to be almost independent of the chosen site @xmath59 , at our level of precision @xmath67 .","figure [ xsg : fig](c ) , finally , shows @xmath32 for ten different samples with @xmath54 sites , differing in the graph structure and in the choice of the couplings @xmath7 , and diverging at different ( sample dependent ) values of @xmath29 .","figure [ xsg : fig](a ) also shows two other observables which point towards the same value for @xmath29 .","the first is the block entanglement entropy , defined as @xmath68 , where @xmath69 is the reduced density matrix for a part of the system .","it is measured for all the left - right decompositions along a dmrg sweep , and its maximum value is denoted by @xmath70 .","this value of @xmath70 is obviously dependent on the dmrg path .","nonetheless , since this path has been chosen so as to minimize the number of retained states , it is expected that it will also minimize the maximum value of the entropy .","it should be emphasized that this observable attains its maximum value , as a function of @xmath23 , at the same @xmath29 which is found by analyzing the spin - glass susceptibility .","the relevance of the entanglement entropy in order to characterize the critical point of a qsgt has already been remarked in the literature @xcite .","the dmrg , being based on the obtention and analysis of the density matrix of different parts of the system , is specially well suited for measuring this observable @xcite .","the other observable shown in figure [ xsg : fig](a ) is the energy gap @xmath52 , which extrapolates to zero at a value of @xmath23 which is close to @xmath29 .","the sign of the difference between these two pseudo - critical points is sample dependent .","this discrepancy is likely to be a finite size effect .","the next observable that we calculated for each sample is the average value of @xmath71 , see figure [ szzsx : fig ] . for high @xmath23 ,","the transverse field is dominant , the ground state is close to @xmath25 and the value of @xmath71 is close to 1 .","as we decrease @xmath23 , this value is reduced .","it is remarkable that , at the value of @xmath29 defined by @xmath32 , and confirmed by the maximum block entropy , @xmath71 is never lower than @xmath72 , at variance with the 1d ritf , where it is normal to have values below @xmath73 . also in figure [ szzsx : fig ]","we have plotted the behavior of the quantum equivalent of the @xmath74 order parameter , which measures the magnitude of the long - distance spatial correlations @xcite , @xmath75 our definition differs slightly from that used commonly in the literature on classical spin glasses . instead of the long - distance behavior",", we measure the global average behavior .","they are equivalent in a system with a bethe lattice topology because the number of neighbours of a given site at distance @xmath76 scales as @xmath77 . also note that these two observables , @xmath71 and @xmath74 have the advantage that they do not vanish trivially in the absence of external longitudinal magnetic field .","this quantity is close to zero within the paramagnetic phase , and takes a non - zero value inside the spin - glass phase .","figure [ szzsx : fig ] shows that the behaviours of @xmath74 and @xmath71 are highly correlated , both pointing to a pseudo - critical point which is , in many instances , sensibly lower than the one obtained with @xmath32 and @xmath70 .","this systematic discrepancy is not explainable in the framework of classical physics , since the fluctuation - dissipation theorem leads to the proportionality of @xmath74 and @xmath32 @xcite . in the quantum case , @xmath32 is not equivalent to @xmath74 , but to @xmath78 ^ 2\\ ] ] where the integral is performed on imaginary time , from @xmath79 to @xmath80 .","therefore , in quantum spin - glasses , @xmath32 contains a contribution from time - correlations , while @xmath74 only measures spatial ones .","their different divergence points might suggest that long - distance correlations develop at a higher value of @xmath23 in time than in space . at different sizes @xmath9 ,","the behavior of the various samples is qualitatively similar , the only difference being the sample - dependent value of @xmath81 .","it is possible to construct histograms showing , for different @xmath9 , the probability distribution of the various @xmath81 . as a preliminary result",", we mark in figure [ gammac_vs_n : fig ] by empty circles the @xmath29 values obtained for 10 samples of different sizes : @xmath9=50 , 100 , 150 , 200 , 250 , 300 , 400 , and 500 . the crosses mark , for each size @xmath9 , the average values of @xmath81 , which apparently saturate at some point around @xmath82 . a useful clue to the physics of this system across the transition is obtained by monitoring selected wavefunction components of the ground state as a function of @xmath23 , which can be easily done with the dmrg .","we illustrate this in figure [ wf : fig ] , for a sample with @xmath15 whose @xmath29 is marked by the arrow .","one of the monitored configurations is the classical ground state of the system .","( naturally , there are two of them , related by a global spin - flip , which we denote by @xmath83 and @xmath84 .","they are obtained by measuring the values of @xmath85 at each site for very low @xmath23 under the presence of a very small longitudinal field @xmath86 that splits the degeneracy between them .","we will consider its weight to be the sum of their probabilities . )","the weight of the classical ground state grows up to @xmath87 as @xmath23 is decreased .","a second monitored configuration is picked at random ( dashed lower line in figure [ wf : fig ] ) : the weight of such a random configuration is similar to that of all the others only for very large values @xmath23 , while it is definitely much smaller when @xmath23 approaches the pseudo - critical point .","the remaining monitored configurations in figure [ wf : fig ] are obtained by classical simulated annealing , i.e. , they are local minima of the classical energy .","these configurations maintain a high weight ( similar to that of the optimal configuration ) across the transition , up to a value of @xmath23 below which their weight decline markedly . therefore , the number of relevant classical configurations contributing to the ground state changes drastically across @xmath29 . deep into the paramagnetic phase ,","all of them have the same weight , coherently bound within the @xmath25 state .","this state retains a high weight at @xmath29 , as shown by the high values taken by @xmath71 at that moment . within the spin - glass phase",", the weight of the different configurations is gradually redistributed according to their classical energies , until eventually only the classical ground state remains .","it should be remarked that the dmrg was applicable in practice only in the case of random couplings . for random graphs with fixed values of @xmath88 ( either ferro or antiferromagnetic ) , the number of retained states needed for a similar accuracy increased in an order of magnitude , rendering impractical the calculations .","it should be remarked that a quantum phase transition may be observed exactly in the mps formalism with as few as two retained states per block @xcite .","the low values of @xmath70 measured in our system points to the fact that the number of states involved in the qsgt is reduced .","thus , in an attempt to explain the transition we might build a simple - minded ansatz consistent of a linear combination of only two states : the classical ground state @xmath89 and a _ background state _ containing the rest of classical configurations : neglecting matrix elements which are exponentially small for large @xmath9 , there is a very sharp crossover at @xmath91 , from state @xmath92 to state @xmath44 .","this last state clearly presents a divergent spin - glass susceptibility .","the physics of our model is actually more complicated than this simple ansatz , as shown by the numerical estimate , @xmath93 for large @xmath9 .","an interesting question is how our system differs from the 1d ritf analyzed by fisher and coworkers @xcite . in 1d",", duality arguments and a detailed rg analysis give a value of @xmath29 satisfying @xmath94_{av}$ ] , where @xmath95_{av}$ ] indicates a disorder average .","this equation leads to values of @xmath29 much lower than those measured in our random graph case ( e.g. , for our distribution of @xmath7 , fisher s model yields @xmath96 , while in our case it reaches @xmath97 for @xmath42 sites ) .","the higher connectivity seems to make a large difference in that respect .","moreover , in our case , the value of @xmath71 at the transition is fairly high , about @xmath72 , while it is almost always below @xmath73 for ritf chains with the same sizes .","this means that the state @xmath25 is still dominant in the paramagnetic phase at the moment of the divergence of the spin - glass susceptibility . in conclusion ,","we have extended the dmrg to make it suitable to study the qsgt on random graphs .","the main technical innovations are the path - selection , which reduces the maximum number of retained states , and the wavefunction annealing , which allows to use the ground state for a certain value of @xmath23 as a seed to obtain the ground state for a lower value .","this modified dmrg algorithm has been applied to the measurement of the energy gap @xmath52 , spin - glass susceptibility @xmath32 , entanglement entropy @xmath70 , long - distance spatial correlations @xmath74 and average @xmath18-magnetization @xmath71 to high precision on a few samples of different sizes , ranging from @xmath53 to @xmath42 sites .","remarkably , @xmath70 attains its maximum at the same value of @xmath27 at which @xmath32 diverges .","this led us to consider this value as our candidate for the pseudo - critical point .","the energy gap @xmath52 vanishes in the surroundings of that value for all realizations . in most disorder realizations , @xmath74 and","@xmath71 start their crossover at a value of @xmath23 which is inferior to @xmath29 .","this may suggest that long - range temporal correlations develop at a higher value of @xmath23 than purely spatial ones .","we would like to emphasize that our definition of @xmath70 constitutes an alternative approach to the entanglement entropy on random graphs .","its relation to the standard block entropy , defined as the entanglement entropy obtained by tracing out a site and its neighbours up to a certain distance , remains as an open question .","we have also monitored the ground state probabilities of several classical low - energy configurations , showing that , as @xmath23 is reduced below @xmath29 , these probabilities increase exponentially until they attain a maximum value and then fall to zero , leaving the classical minimum energy configuration as the only ground state component as @xmath98 .","the fact that the model on such disordered graph was amenable to analysis within the dmrg is non - trivial .","both @xmath70 and the maximum number of retained states per block increase slowly with the system size . in a restricted sense , the system behaves similarly to a 1d chain , despite the high connectivity of the underlying graph .","this is a rather remarkable effect due to the disorder , which perhaps leads to the selection of an effective 1d path of strong bonds .","if the couplings @xmath88 are not random , we have found that the number of retained states per block increases in a much more pronounced way , rendering the numerical dmrg approach impractical .","it will be interesting and is left to a future study to understand quantitatively how the entanglement entropy at the transition behaves as a function of the system size , both for random and non - random couplings @xcite ."],"string":"[\n \"quantum phase transitions constitute a very active topic in theoretical physics @xcite , to which disorder and frustration of a quantum spin glass add considerable intricacies @xcite .\",\n \"although quantum effects were usually considered to be negligible in spin glasses at finite temperatures , diverse experiments @xcite have proved them to be highly relevant , leading to the first experimental realization of _ quantum annealing _ @xcite .\",\n \"one of the most widely employed theoretical approaches to the quantum spin - glass transition ( qsgt ) is the random couplings ising model in a transverse field ( ritf ) @xcite . within the analytical approach\",\n \", a griffiths phase was found in the 1d case via an elegant rg procedure @xcite , while such a structure was proved to be absent from the infinite range case within the replica formalism @xcite .\",\n \"the 1d rg analysis was extended to study the presence of a certain number of long - distance links , proving the relevance of the perturbation @xcite .\",\n \"regarding numerical approaches , quantum monte - carlo ( qmc ) remains as the most suitable tool at @xmath0 .\",\n \"using it , a coherent picture was obtained in the 2d and 3d cases , showing that the griffiths phase is present in 2d but absent in 3d @xcite .\",\n \"classical spin glasses have been thoroughly analysed on bethe lattices @xcite .\",\n \"however , finite bethe lattices are dominated by boundary effects and present no frustration . a way out is to study random graphs with a fixed connectivity which , in the classical case , allow the application of the _ cavity approach _ @xcite .\",\n \"these random graphs present genuine frustration , since they have _ loops _ , and have no boundaries . on the other hand\",\n \", the average size of the loops grows with the number of sites @xcite , thus making them resemble , _ locally _ , a bethe lattice ( see figure [ graph : fig ] ) .\",\n \"the density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) @xcite is known to be a highly accurate method to analyze @xmath1 ground state properties of 1d or quasi-1d quantum many body systems , including tree structures @xcite .\",\n \"we have extended the method in order to trace the behaviour of finite size samples of random graphs of fixed connectivity @xmath2 across the qsgt within the ritf model . given the high connectivity of these graphs ,\",\n \"the applicability of the dmrg is highly non - trivial .\",\n \"it is remarkable that in the case of non - random couplings , we have found the number of retained states needed to ensure a good accuracy to be very high , rendering the application of the dmrg unfeasible . the careful analysis of _\",\n \"pseudo-_critical points of finite size samples constitutes a powerful tool to study a qsgt . as a recent example , the work of igli and coworkers @xcite studies the distributions of , e.g. , the average entanglement entropy and the surface magnetization of finite size 1d samples . in this work\",\n \"we provide measurements of , among other observables , spin - glass susceptibilities , energy gaps , long distance spin - spin correlations and entanglement entropies , and use them to obtain insight on the mechanism of the transition .\",\n \"a full characterization of the qsgt , nonetheless , is not attempted in this work , since it would require to obtain statistics on a large number of disorder realizations .\",\n \"the rest of the paper is organized as follows : sec .\",\n \"[ model : sec ] presents the model , and sec .\",\n \"[ dmrg ] provides details on the application of dmrg .\",\n \"[ results ] shows the numerical dmrg results obtained .\",\n \"[ conclusions ] presents a discussion of the results and some concluding remarks .\",\n \"let us consider the random ising model in a transverse field ( ritf ) on a generic graph @xcite : @xmath3 where @xmath4 denotes pairs of neighboring sites @xmath5 and @xmath6 on the graph .\",\n \"the values of @xmath7 are uncorrelated random variables with a uniform probability density distribution in the interval @xmath8 $ ] .\",\n \"we will focus our study on randomly generated graphs , with @xmath9 sites and a fixed connectivity @xmath2 @xcite , i.e. , each site @xmath5 is connected to @xmath2 other ( randomly chosen ) sites @xmath6 .\",\n \"an example of such a graph , with @xmath10 sites , is shown in fig .\",\n \"[ graph : fig ] .\",\n \"it should be noticed that , locally and for large @xmath9 , such graphs resemble _ bethe lattices _ , as we have highlighted with thicker links in fig . [ graph : fig ] . nonetheless , the behaviour of finite bethe lattices is dominated by the boundary , unlike in our case , where there is none . moreover , trees have no loops and , therefore , present no _ frustration _ , while random graphs with fixed connectivity do contain loops and , therefore , have genuine frustration .\",\n \"it has been proved , nonetheless , that short loops become rare as @xmath11 : more precisely , the probability of finding a loop of any fixed size @xmath12 falls to zero when @xmath11 @xcite .\",\n \"the physics of classical spin glasses in these graphs has been studied using the cavity method by mzard and parisi @xcite .\",\n \"let @xmath13 be the absolute value of the disorder - averaged energy per site of the classical ground state .\",\n \"our numerical experiments show that it increases from @xmath14 at @xmath15 up to @xmath16 for larger @xmath9 , which is the theoretical limiting value for @xmath11 under the assumption that all links are satisfied .\",\n \"we will take the product of eigenstates of @xmath17 , for all @xmath5 , as the _ canonical basis _ for our problem . in this basis\",\n \", we denote the state in which all spins point in the positive @xmath18-direction as @xmath19 .\",\n \"let us assume , for the moment , that @xmath20 for all @xmath5 . for @xmath21 , all the non - diagonal terms in the hamiltonian vanish .\",\n \"therefore , the ground state is given by the configurations with the classical minimum energy .\",\n \"disregarding accidental degeneracies , there are two such configurations , related by a simultaneous flip of all spins , @xmath22 for all @xmath5 .\",\n \"the transverse field @xmath23 may be considered as a _ kinetic energy _ coefficient , providing a hopping term among the classical configurations . in the @xmath24\",\n \"limit the transverse field term dominates and the ground state tends to the state @xmath25 , with all the spins pointing in the positive @xmath18-direction , separated by a large gap @xmath26 from the first excited state .\",\n \"let us remark that all the components of the canonical basis have the same amplitude in the state @xmath25 .\",\n \"by decreasing @xmath23 there is a certain value @xmath27 for which the system undergoes a quantum spin - glass transition ( qsgt ) . for @xmath28 ,\",\n \"the system is in a quantum paramagnetic phase , which presents no long - range order .\",\n \"below @xmath29 , the system is in a quantum spin - glass phase , presenting a hidden long - range order which may be detected by a number of observables .\",\n \"we will focus here on the divergence of the _ spin - glass susceptibility _ : @xmath30 i.e. , physically , a small longitudinal magnetic field @xmath31 , applied at site @xmath6 , generates a magnetization response on each site @xmath5 , which is measured ( and squared , so as to disregard its sign ) ; the results are summed over all sites @xmath5 and averaged over all sites @xmath6 . if the system is in a paramagnetic phase , the magnetization will be proportional to @xmath31 and short - ranged in space , so that the sum over @xmath5 and @xmath6 yields a finite value for @xmath32 . on the other hand , on approaching the spin - glass phase , an infinitesimally small longitudinal magnetic field @xmath31 , localized at a single site @xmath6 , will eventually induce a finite magnetization over a long - range of spins .\",\n \"this effect is at the origin of the divergence of @xmath32 .\",\n \"we shall now discuss the numerical approach we have used to study this system , and the results obtained .\",\n \"the density - matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) has proved to be an accurate method to analyse the properties of 1d and quasi-1d systems @xcite .\",\n \"the dmrg may be described as a variational method within the matrix - product states ( mps ) , which constitute a low - dimensional subspace of the full hilbert space @xcite .\",\n \"a mps may be expressed as @xmath33 where each @xmath34 is a square matrix with dimension @xmath35 , which may be considered as the number of retained states per block when splitting the system into a left and right parts .\",\n \"the total number of variational parameters is less than @xmath36 .\",\n \"the success of the dmrg is related to the ability of these mps to reproduce faithfully the ground states of local 1d many - body problems for low values of @xmath35 @xcite . if @xmath37 , any state of the hilbert space may be exactly represented as a mps .\",\n \"the minimum number of retained states @xmath35 is related to the exponential of the von neumann entanglement entropy of the dmrg block @xcite . in a non - critical 1d system , this entropy is bounded for all sizes , while it grows as @xmath38 for a 1d critical system of length @xmath12 .\",\n \"it is believed that for a @xmath39-dimensional system out of criticality , the entanglement entropy scales as @xmath40 , where @xmath12 is the shortest spatial dimension of the system @xcite .\",\n \"this estimate is known as the _ area law _ and is believed to have logarithmic corrections at critical points .\",\n \"an important practical consequence is that , in order to study a 2d system , the number of retained states @xmath35 should grow as @xmath41 , thus making the dmrg very inefficient .\",\n \"our system , on the other hand , is defined on a random graph of fixed connectivity , @xmath2 .\",\n \"we will show that this poses no problem to the number of retained states @xmath35 , which appears to remain manageable even for @xmath42 as long as the couplings are random .\",\n \"however , the implementation of the dmrg on such a model has required the following technical refinements of the original method : * ( a ) path selection . * : : in a non-1d system , dmrg proceeds by converting the system into an effective 1d problem with long - range couplings .\",\n \"a path is chosen along the graph , which does not repeat sites , and is considered to be appropriate if the number of broken links between the left and the right blocks is kept low along a dmrg sweep .\",\n \"normally , the selection of a suitable path in a quasi-1d system ( e.g. ladders ) is done by geometrical intuition . in our implementation\",\n \"we have designed an automated procedure : a simulated annealing algorithm is employed in order to minimize the number of broken links .\",\n \"the full problem of finding the optimal path is computationally very hard .\",\n \"therefore , we do not aim at the exact optimum , but only to a reasonably good local minimum .\",\n \"we have noticed that our quasi - optimal path performs much better than a random path . *\",\n \"( b ) perron - frobenius criterion . * : : the hamiltonian of the ritf on any graph fulfills , on the canonical basis , the conditions of the perron - frobenius theorem , i.e. , all off - diagonal components are _ non - positive_. hence , all the ground state components must have the same sign . using the mps representation of the ground state\",\n \"obtained within the dmrg , it is always possible to reconstruct the amplitude of any configuration @xmath43 .\",\n \"the obtention of the full @xmath44 is unfeasible , since it would require reconstructing the amplitude of an exponentially large number of configurations .\",\n \"nonetheless , it is possible to pick up a few random configurations @xmath45 , and check that all their amplitudes have the same sign .\",\n \"whenever this criterion was not met a rather rare event , the calculation was repeated changing the random seed for the lanczos procedure on the first dmrg step . *\",\n \"( c ) wavefunction annealing .\",\n \"* : : for large @xmath23 the ground state @xmath25 is easily representable as a mps , requiring a single retained state .\",\n \"the dmrg works extremely well in this regime and , therefore , our simulations are always started well within the paramagnetic ( large @xmath23 ) phase .\",\n \"the qsgt is approached by repeatedly decreasing the value of @xmath23 by a small amount , always using the previous ground state as a seed for the new calculation , exploiting the wavefunction transformations suggested by white @xcite .\",\n \"this type of _ annealing _ of the ground state provides a faster convergence and more accurate results for low @xmath23 . *\",\n \"( d ) adaptive number of retained states . * : : the number of retained states @xmath35 , and the number of dmrg sweeps @xmath46 , are not fixed in our algorithm .\",\n \"we set a maximum value for the sum of the neglected eigenvalues of the density matrix in the rg truncation ( @xmath47 ) , and select @xmath35 accordingly .\",\n \"moreover , sometimes convergence takes more sweeps than usual ( @xmath48 ) in order to obtain machine precision in the convergence of the ground state energy . *\",\n \"( e ) energy gap measurements . * : : when there is a symmetry in a problem , e.g. , under su(2 ) , it is usually possible to obtain the first excited state as the ground state of a different _ sector _ of the hilbert space . in our case , lacking this , the best option has proved to be the following one . for each dmrg step , after the ground state @xmath49 had been found , it was `` promoted '' to a higher energy by the following transformation of the hamiltonian : + @xmath50 + in such a way that the ground state of this new hamiltonian is the former first excited state , as long as we take @xmath51 , @xmath52 being the gap we are looking for . the density matrix used for truncation\",\n \"was built as a linear combination of the density matrices for each state , with equal weights .\",\n \"however , we should remember that only ground states of local hamiltonians are expected to be faithfully represented by mps @xcite , and eq .\",\n \"( [ h.gap ] ) does not define a local hamiltonian .\",\n \"therefore , the accuracy in the gap estimate is worse than that in the ground state energy and in other observables .\",\n \"we have applied the modified dmrg technique to study a few samples of random graphs with fixed connectivity @xmath2 and sizes ranging from @xmath53 to @xmath42 .\",\n \"a full characterization of the qsgt would require relevant statistics on the disorder .\",\n \"unfortunately , in order to obtain a high accuracy for each sample , the required cpu - time is rather large .\",\n \"therefore , we have decided to focus on a precise study of a few realizations , in order to gain insight on the mechanism of the transition for finite samples .\",\n \"most of our findings will be illustrated in the figures of this section by showing in detail the results obtained for a sample with @xmath54 sites .\",\n \"it should be remarked that the highlighted features are typical of all the ensemble .\",\n \"the numerical simulations were done with the dmrg algorithm explained in section [ dmrg ] , with a neglected probability tolerance @xmath55 and a tolerance on the convergence of the energy of one part in @xmath56 , for ten samples of each size ( @xmath57 50 , 100 , 150 , 200 , 250 , 300 , 400 , 500 ) .\",\n \"each sample is a different random graph , always with fixed connectivity @xmath2 , and the bonds @xmath7 are random and independent , uniformly distributed in the interval @xmath8 $ ] .\",\n \"figure [ xsg : fig](a ) shows three observables calculated for a given instance of a @xmath54 graph , as a fuction of @xmath23 .\",\n \"the most relevant quantity is the spin - glass susceptibility , defined in equation [ xsg ] .\",\n \"a small magnetic field @xmath58 is applied at a single site @xmath59 , and the magnetic response is measured with the formula @xmath60 which is found to increase very fast as @xmath23 approaches @xmath61 from above , and thereupon saturating at a very high value .\",\n \"figure [ xsg : fig](b ) proves the divergence of @xmath32 by showing its behavior at three different values of @xmath62 ( @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 ) : the saturation value is seen to scale as @xmath66 .\",\n \"we estimate the _\",\n \"pseudo-_critical value @xmath29 for the given sample as the value of @xmath23 at which the slope of the susceptibility attains its maximum . with this definition\",\n \", @xmath29 appears to be almost independent of the chosen site @xmath59 , at our level of precision @xmath67 .\",\n \"figure [ xsg : fig](c ) , finally , shows @xmath32 for ten different samples with @xmath54 sites , differing in the graph structure and in the choice of the couplings @xmath7 , and diverging at different ( sample dependent ) values of @xmath29 .\",\n \"figure [ xsg : fig](a ) also shows two other observables which point towards the same value for @xmath29 .\",\n \"the first is the block entanglement entropy , defined as @xmath68 , where @xmath69 is the reduced density matrix for a part of the system .\",\n \"it is measured for all the left - right decompositions along a dmrg sweep , and its maximum value is denoted by @xmath70 .\",\n \"this value of @xmath70 is obviously dependent on the dmrg path .\",\n \"nonetheless , since this path has been chosen so as to minimize the number of retained states , it is expected that it will also minimize the maximum value of the entropy .\",\n \"it should be emphasized that this observable attains its maximum value , as a function of @xmath23 , at the same @xmath29 which is found by analyzing the spin - glass susceptibility .\",\n \"the relevance of the entanglement entropy in order to characterize the critical point of a qsgt has already been remarked in the literature @xcite .\",\n \"the dmrg , being based on the obtention and analysis of the density matrix of different parts of the system , is specially well suited for measuring this observable @xcite .\",\n \"the other observable shown in figure [ xsg : fig](a ) is the energy gap @xmath52 , which extrapolates to zero at a value of @xmath23 which is close to @xmath29 .\",\n \"the sign of the difference between these two pseudo - critical points is sample dependent .\",\n \"this discrepancy is likely to be a finite size effect .\",\n \"the next observable that we calculated for each sample is the average value of @xmath71 , see figure [ szzsx : fig ] . for high @xmath23 ,\",\n \"the transverse field is dominant , the ground state is close to @xmath25 and the value of @xmath71 is close to 1 .\",\n \"as we decrease @xmath23 , this value is reduced .\",\n \"it is remarkable that , at the value of @xmath29 defined by @xmath32 , and confirmed by the maximum block entropy , @xmath71 is never lower than @xmath72 , at variance with the 1d ritf , where it is normal to have values below @xmath73 . also in figure [ szzsx : fig ]\",\n \"we have plotted the behavior of the quantum equivalent of the @xmath74 order parameter , which measures the magnitude of the long - distance spatial correlations @xcite , @xmath75 our definition differs slightly from that used commonly in the literature on classical spin glasses . instead of the long - distance behavior\",\n \", we measure the global average behavior .\",\n \"they are equivalent in a system with a bethe lattice topology because the number of neighbours of a given site at distance @xmath76 scales as @xmath77 . also note that these two observables , @xmath71 and @xmath74 have the advantage that they do not vanish trivially in the absence of external longitudinal magnetic field .\",\n \"this quantity is close to zero within the paramagnetic phase , and takes a non - zero value inside the spin - glass phase .\",\n \"figure [ szzsx : fig ] shows that the behaviours of @xmath74 and @xmath71 are highly correlated , both pointing to a pseudo - critical point which is , in many instances , sensibly lower than the one obtained with @xmath32 and @xmath70 .\",\n \"this systematic discrepancy is not explainable in the framework of classical physics , since the fluctuation - dissipation theorem leads to the proportionality of @xmath74 and @xmath32 @xcite . in the quantum case , @xmath32 is not equivalent to @xmath74 , but to @xmath78 ^ 2\\\\ ] ] where the integral is performed on imaginary time , from @xmath79 to @xmath80 .\",\n \"therefore , in quantum spin - glasses , @xmath32 contains a contribution from time - correlations , while @xmath74 only measures spatial ones .\",\n \"their different divergence points might suggest that long - distance correlations develop at a higher value of @xmath23 in time than in space . at different sizes @xmath9 ,\",\n \"the behavior of the various samples is qualitatively similar , the only difference being the sample - dependent value of @xmath81 .\",\n \"it is possible to construct histograms showing , for different @xmath9 , the probability distribution of the various @xmath81 . as a preliminary result\",\n \", we mark in figure [ gammac_vs_n : fig ] by empty circles the @xmath29 values obtained for 10 samples of different sizes : @xmath9=50 , 100 , 150 , 200 , 250 , 300 , 400 , and 500 . the crosses mark , for each size @xmath9 , the average values of @xmath81 , which apparently saturate at some point around @xmath82 . a useful clue to the physics of this system across the transition is obtained by monitoring selected wavefunction components of the ground state as a function of @xmath23 , which can be easily done with the dmrg .\",\n \"we illustrate this in figure [ wf : fig ] , for a sample with @xmath15 whose @xmath29 is marked by the arrow .\",\n \"one of the monitored configurations is the classical ground state of the system .\",\n \"( naturally , there are two of them , related by a global spin - flip , which we denote by @xmath83 and @xmath84 .\",\n \"they are obtained by measuring the values of @xmath85 at each site for very low @xmath23 under the presence of a very small longitudinal field @xmath86 that splits the degeneracy between them .\",\n \"we will consider its weight to be the sum of their probabilities . )\",\n \"the weight of the classical ground state grows up to @xmath87 as @xmath23 is decreased .\",\n \"a second monitored configuration is picked at random ( dashed lower line in figure [ wf : fig ] ) : the weight of such a random configuration is similar to that of all the others only for very large values @xmath23 , while it is definitely much smaller when @xmath23 approaches the pseudo - critical point .\",\n \"the remaining monitored configurations in figure [ wf : fig ] are obtained by classical simulated annealing , i.e. , they are local minima of the classical energy .\",\n \"these configurations maintain a high weight ( similar to that of the optimal configuration ) across the transition , up to a value of @xmath23 below which their weight decline markedly . therefore , the number of relevant classical configurations contributing to the ground state changes drastically across @xmath29 . deep into the paramagnetic phase ,\",\n \"all of them have the same weight , coherently bound within the @xmath25 state .\",\n \"this state retains a high weight at @xmath29 , as shown by the high values taken by @xmath71 at that moment . within the spin - glass phase\",\n \", the weight of the different configurations is gradually redistributed according to their classical energies , until eventually only the classical ground state remains .\",\n \"it should be remarked that the dmrg was applicable in practice only in the case of random couplings . for random graphs with fixed values of @xmath88 ( either ferro or antiferromagnetic ) , the number of retained states needed for a similar accuracy increased in an order of magnitude , rendering impractical the calculations .\",\n \"it should be remarked that a quantum phase transition may be observed exactly in the mps formalism with as few as two retained states per block @xcite .\",\n \"the low values of @xmath70 measured in our system points to the fact that the number of states involved in the qsgt is reduced .\",\n \"thus , in an attempt to explain the transition we might build a simple - minded ansatz consistent of a linear combination of only two states : the classical ground state @xmath89 and a _ background state _ containing the rest of classical configurations : neglecting matrix elements which are exponentially small for large @xmath9 , there is a very sharp crossover at @xmath91 , from state @xmath92 to state @xmath44 .\",\n \"this last state clearly presents a divergent spin - glass susceptibility .\",\n \"the physics of our model is actually more complicated than this simple ansatz , as shown by the numerical estimate , @xmath93 for large @xmath9 .\",\n \"an interesting question is how our system differs from the 1d ritf analyzed by fisher and coworkers @xcite . in 1d\",\n \", duality arguments and a detailed rg analysis give a value of @xmath29 satisfying @xmath94_{av}$ ] , where @xmath95_{av}$ ] indicates a disorder average .\",\n \"this equation leads to values of @xmath29 much lower than those measured in our random graph case ( e.g. , for our distribution of @xmath7 , fisher s model yields @xmath96 , while in our case it reaches @xmath97 for @xmath42 sites ) .\",\n \"the higher connectivity seems to make a large difference in that respect .\",\n \"moreover , in our case , the value of @xmath71 at the transition is fairly high , about @xmath72 , while it is almost always below @xmath73 for ritf chains with the same sizes .\",\n \"this means that the state @xmath25 is still dominant in the paramagnetic phase at the moment of the divergence of the spin - glass susceptibility . in conclusion ,\",\n \"we have extended the dmrg to make it suitable to study the qsgt on random graphs .\",\n \"the main technical innovations are the path - selection , which reduces the maximum number of retained states , and the wavefunction annealing , which allows to use the ground state for a certain value of @xmath23 as a seed to obtain the ground state for a lower value .\",\n \"this modified dmrg algorithm has been applied to the measurement of the energy gap @xmath52 , spin - glass susceptibility @xmath32 , entanglement entropy @xmath70 , long - distance spatial correlations @xmath74 and average @xmath18-magnetization @xmath71 to high precision on a few samples of different sizes , ranging from @xmath53 to @xmath42 sites .\",\n \"remarkably , @xmath70 attains its maximum at the same value of @xmath27 at which @xmath32 diverges .\",\n \"this led us to consider this value as our candidate for the pseudo - critical point .\",\n \"the energy gap @xmath52 vanishes in the surroundings of that value for all realizations . in most disorder realizations , @xmath74 and\",\n \"@xmath71 start their crossover at a value of @xmath23 which is inferior to @xmath29 .\",\n \"this may suggest that long - range temporal correlations develop at a higher value of @xmath23 than purely spatial ones .\",\n \"we would like to emphasize that our definition of @xmath70 constitutes an alternative approach to the entanglement entropy on random graphs .\",\n \"its relation to the standard block entropy , defined as the entanglement entropy obtained by tracing out a site and its neighbours up to a certain distance , remains as an open question .\",\n \"we have also monitored the ground state probabilities of several classical low - energy configurations , showing that , as @xmath23 is reduced below @xmath29 , these probabilities increase exponentially until they attain a maximum value and then fall to zero , leaving the classical minimum energy configuration as the only ground state component as @xmath98 .\",\n \"the fact that the model on such disordered graph was amenable to analysis within the dmrg is non - trivial .\",\n \"both @xmath70 and the maximum number of retained states per block increase slowly with the system size . in a restricted sense , the system behaves similarly to a 1d chain , despite the high connectivity of the underlying graph .\",\n \"this is a rather remarkable effect due to the disorder , which perhaps leads to the selection of an effective 1d path of strong bonds .\",\n \"if the couplings @xmath88 are not random , we have found that the number of retained states per block increases in a much more pronounced way , rendering the numerical dmrg approach impractical .\",\n \"it will be interesting and is left to a future study to understand quantitatively how the entanglement entropy at the transition behaves as a function of the system size , both for random and non - random couplings @xcite .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> the density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) has been extended to study quantum phase transitions on random graphs of fixed connectivity . as a relevant example </S>","<S> , we have analysed the random ising model in a transverse field . </S>","<S> if the couplings are random , the number of retained states remains reasonably low even for large sizes . </S>","<S> the resulting quantum spin - glass transition has been traced down for a few disorder realizations , through the careful measurement of selected observables : spatial correlations , entanglement entropy , energy gap and spin - glass susceptibility , among others . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> the density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) has been extended to study quantum phase transitions on random graphs of fixed connectivity . as a relevant example </S>\",\n \"<S> , we have analysed the random ising model in a transverse field . </S>\",\n \"<S> if the couplings are random , the number of retained states remains reasonably low even for large sizes . </S>\",\n \"<S> the resulting quantum spin - glass transition has been traced down for a few disorder realizations , through the careful measurement of selected observables : spatial correlations , entanglement entropy , energy gap and spin - glass susceptibility , among others . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","model","application of the dmrg","results","discussion and conclusions"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"model\",\n \"application of the dmrg\",\n \"results\",\n \"discussion and conclusions\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["quantum phase transitions constitute a very active topic in theoretical physics @xcite , to which disorder and frustration of a quantum spin glass add considerable intricacies @xcite .","although quantum effects were usually considered to be negligible in spin glasses at finite temperatures , diverse experiments @xcite have proved them to be highly relevant , leading to the first experimental realization of _ quantum annealing _ @xcite .","one of the most widely employed theoretical approaches to the quantum spin - glass transition ( qsgt ) is the random couplings ising model in a transverse field ( ritf ) @xcite . within the analytical approach",", a griffiths phase was found in the 1d case via an elegant rg procedure @xcite , while such a structure was proved to be absent from the infinite range case within the replica formalism @xcite .","the 1d rg analysis was extended to study the presence of a certain number of long - distance links , proving the relevance of the perturbation @xcite .","regarding numerical approaches , quantum monte - carlo ( qmc ) remains as the most suitable tool at @xmath0 .","using it , a coherent picture was obtained in the 2d and 3d cases , showing that the griffiths phase is present in 2d but absent in 3d @xcite .","classical spin glasses have been thoroughly analysed on bethe lattices @xcite .","however , finite bethe lattices are dominated by boundary effects and present no frustration . a way out is to study random graphs with a fixed connectivity which , in the classical case , allow the application of the _ cavity approach _ @xcite .","these random graphs present genuine frustration , since they have _ loops _ , and have no boundaries . on the other hand",", the average size of the loops grows with the number of sites @xcite , thus making them resemble , _ locally _ , a bethe lattice ( see figure [ graph : fig ] ) .","the density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) @xcite is known to be a highly accurate method to analyze @xmath1 ground state properties of 1d or quasi-1d quantum many body systems , including tree structures @xcite .","we have extended the method in order to trace the behaviour of finite size samples of random graphs of fixed connectivity @xmath2 across the qsgt within the ritf model . given the high connectivity of these graphs ,","the applicability of the dmrg is highly non - trivial .","it is remarkable that in the case of non - random couplings , we have found the number of retained states needed to ensure a good accuracy to be very high , rendering the application of the dmrg unfeasible . the careful analysis of _","pseudo-_critical points of finite size samples constitutes a powerful tool to study a qsgt . as a recent example , the work of igli and coworkers @xcite studies the distributions of , e.g. , the average entanglement entropy and the surface magnetization of finite size 1d samples . in this work","we provide measurements of , among other observables , spin - glass susceptibilities , energy gaps , long distance spin - spin correlations and entanglement entropies , and use them to obtain insight on the mechanism of the transition .","a full characterization of the qsgt , nonetheless , is not attempted in this work , since it would require to obtain statistics on a large number of disorder realizations .","the rest of the paper is organized as follows : sec .","[ model : sec ] presents the model , and sec .","[ dmrg ] provides details on the application of dmrg .","[ results ] shows the numerical dmrg results obtained .","[ conclusions ] presents a discussion of the results and some concluding remarks ."],["let us consider the random ising model in a transverse field ( ritf ) on a generic graph @xcite : @xmath3 where @xmath4 denotes pairs of neighboring sites @xmath5 and @xmath6 on the graph .","the values of @xmath7 are uncorrelated random variables with a uniform probability density distribution in the interval @xmath8 $ ] .","we will focus our study on randomly generated graphs , with @xmath9 sites and a fixed connectivity @xmath2 @xcite , i.e. , each site @xmath5 is connected to @xmath2 other ( randomly chosen ) sites @xmath6 .","an example of such a graph , with @xmath10 sites , is shown in fig .","[ graph : fig ] .","it should be noticed that , locally and for large @xmath9 , such graphs resemble _ bethe lattices _ , as we have highlighted with thicker links in fig . [ graph : fig ] . nonetheless , the behaviour of finite bethe lattices is dominated by the boundary , unlike in our case , where there is none . moreover , trees have no loops and , therefore , present no _ frustration _ , while random graphs with fixed connectivity do contain loops and , therefore , have genuine frustration .","it has been proved , nonetheless , that short loops become rare as @xmath11 : more precisely , the probability of finding a loop of any fixed size @xmath12 falls to zero when @xmath11 @xcite .","the physics of classical spin glasses in these graphs has been studied using the cavity method by mzard and parisi @xcite .","let @xmath13 be the absolute value of the disorder - averaged energy per site of the classical ground state .","our numerical experiments show that it increases from @xmath14 at @xmath15 up to @xmath16 for larger @xmath9 , which is the theoretical limiting value for @xmath11 under the assumption that all links are satisfied .","we will take the product of eigenstates of @xmath17 , for all @xmath5 , as the _ canonical basis _ for our problem . in this basis",", we denote the state in which all spins point in the positive @xmath18-direction as @xmath19 .","let us assume , for the moment , that @xmath20 for all @xmath5 . for @xmath21 , all the non - diagonal terms in the hamiltonian vanish .","therefore , the ground state is given by the configurations with the classical minimum energy .","disregarding accidental degeneracies , there are two such configurations , related by a simultaneous flip of all spins , @xmath22 for all @xmath5 .","the transverse field @xmath23 may be considered as a _ kinetic energy _ coefficient , providing a hopping term among the classical configurations . in the @xmath24","limit the transverse field term dominates and the ground state tends to the state @xmath25 , with all the spins pointing in the positive @xmath18-direction , separated by a large gap @xmath26 from the first excited state .","let us remark that all the components of the canonical basis have the same amplitude in the state @xmath25 .","by decreasing @xmath23 there is a certain value @xmath27 for which the system undergoes a quantum spin - glass transition ( qsgt ) . for @xmath28 ,","the system is in a quantum paramagnetic phase , which presents no long - range order .","below @xmath29 , the system is in a quantum spin - glass phase , presenting a hidden long - range order which may be detected by a number of observables .","we will focus here on the divergence of the _ spin - glass susceptibility _ : @xmath30 i.e. , physically , a small longitudinal magnetic field @xmath31 , applied at site @xmath6 , generates a magnetization response on each site @xmath5 , which is measured ( and squared , so as to disregard its sign ) ; the results are summed over all sites @xmath5 and averaged over all sites @xmath6 . if the system is in a paramagnetic phase , the magnetization will be proportional to @xmath31 and short - ranged in space , so that the sum over @xmath5 and @xmath6 yields a finite value for @xmath32 . on the other hand , on approaching the spin - glass phase , an infinitesimally small longitudinal magnetic field @xmath31 , localized at a single site @xmath6 , will eventually induce a finite magnetization over a long - range of spins .","this effect is at the origin of the divergence of @xmath32 .","we shall now discuss the numerical approach we have used to study this system , and the results obtained ."],["the density - matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) has proved to be an accurate method to analyse the properties of 1d and quasi-1d systems @xcite .","the dmrg may be described as a variational method within the matrix - product states ( mps ) , which constitute a low - dimensional subspace of the full hilbert space @xcite .","a mps may be expressed as @xmath33 where each @xmath34 is a square matrix with dimension @xmath35 , which may be considered as the number of retained states per block when splitting the system into a left and right parts .","the total number of variational parameters is less than @xmath36 .","the success of the dmrg is related to the ability of these mps to reproduce faithfully the ground states of local 1d many - body problems for low values of @xmath35 @xcite . if @xmath37 , any state of the hilbert space may be exactly represented as a mps .","the minimum number of retained states @xmath35 is related to the exponential of the von neumann entanglement entropy of the dmrg block @xcite . in a non - critical 1d system , this entropy is bounded for all sizes , while it grows as @xmath38 for a 1d critical system of length @xmath12 .","it is believed that for a @xmath39-dimensional system out of criticality , the entanglement entropy scales as @xmath40 , where @xmath12 is the shortest spatial dimension of the system @xcite .","this estimate is known as the _ area law _ and is believed to have logarithmic corrections at critical points .","an important practical consequence is that , in order to study a 2d system , the number of retained states @xmath35 should grow as @xmath41 , thus making the dmrg very inefficient .","our system , on the other hand , is defined on a random graph of fixed connectivity , @xmath2 .","we will show that this poses no problem to the number of retained states @xmath35 , which appears to remain manageable even for @xmath42 as long as the couplings are random .","however , the implementation of the dmrg on such a model has required the following technical refinements of the original method : * ( a ) path selection . * : : in a non-1d system , dmrg proceeds by converting the system into an effective 1d problem with long - range couplings .","a path is chosen along the graph , which does not repeat sites , and is considered to be appropriate if the number of broken links between the left and the right blocks is kept low along a dmrg sweep .","normally , the selection of a suitable path in a quasi-1d system ( e.g. ladders ) is done by geometrical intuition . in our implementation","we have designed an automated procedure : a simulated annealing algorithm is employed in order to minimize the number of broken links .","the full problem of finding the optimal path is computationally very hard .","therefore , we do not aim at the exact optimum , but only to a reasonably good local minimum .","we have noticed that our quasi - optimal path performs much better than a random path . *","( b ) perron - frobenius criterion . * : : the hamiltonian of the ritf on any graph fulfills , on the canonical basis , the conditions of the perron - frobenius theorem , i.e. , all off - diagonal components are _ non - positive_. hence , all the ground state components must have the same sign . using the mps representation of the ground state","obtained within the dmrg , it is always possible to reconstruct the amplitude of any configuration @xmath43 .","the obtention of the full @xmath44 is unfeasible , since it would require reconstructing the amplitude of an exponentially large number of configurations .","nonetheless , it is possible to pick up a few random configurations @xmath45 , and check that all their amplitudes have the same sign .","whenever this criterion was not met a rather rare event , the calculation was repeated changing the random seed for the lanczos procedure on the first dmrg step . *","( c ) wavefunction annealing .","* : : for large @xmath23 the ground state @xmath25 is easily representable as a mps , requiring a single retained state .","the dmrg works extremely well in this regime and , therefore , our simulations are always started well within the paramagnetic ( large @xmath23 ) phase .","the qsgt is approached by repeatedly decreasing the value of @xmath23 by a small amount , always using the previous ground state as a seed for the new calculation , exploiting the wavefunction transformations suggested by white @xcite .","this type of _ annealing _ of the ground state provides a faster convergence and more accurate results for low @xmath23 . *","( d ) adaptive number of retained states . * : : the number of retained states @xmath35 , and the number of dmrg sweeps @xmath46 , are not fixed in our algorithm .","we set a maximum value for the sum of the neglected eigenvalues of the density matrix in the rg truncation ( @xmath47 ) , and select @xmath35 accordingly .","moreover , sometimes convergence takes more sweeps than usual ( @xmath48 ) in order to obtain machine precision in the convergence of the ground state energy . *","( e ) energy gap measurements . * : : when there is a symmetry in a problem , e.g. , under su(2 ) , it is usually possible to obtain the first excited state as the ground state of a different _ sector _ of the hilbert space . in our case , lacking this , the best option has proved to be the following one . for each dmrg step , after the ground state @xmath49 had been found , it was `` promoted '' to a higher energy by the following transformation of the hamiltonian : + @xmath50 + in such a way that the ground state of this new hamiltonian is the former first excited state , as long as we take @xmath51 , @xmath52 being the gap we are looking for . the density matrix used for truncation","was built as a linear combination of the density matrices for each state , with equal weights .","however , we should remember that only ground states of local hamiltonians are expected to be faithfully represented by mps @xcite , and eq .","( [ h.gap ] ) does not define a local hamiltonian .","therefore , the accuracy in the gap estimate is worse than that in the ground state energy and in other observables ."],["we have applied the modified dmrg technique to study a few samples of random graphs with fixed connectivity @xmath2 and sizes ranging from @xmath53 to @xmath42 .","a full characterization of the qsgt would require relevant statistics on the disorder .","unfortunately , in order to obtain a high accuracy for each sample , the required cpu - time is rather large .","therefore , we have decided to focus on a precise study of a few realizations , in order to gain insight on the mechanism of the transition for finite samples .","most of our findings will be illustrated in the figures of this section by showing in detail the results obtained for a sample with @xmath54 sites .","it should be remarked that the highlighted features are typical of all the ensemble .","the numerical simulations were done with the dmrg algorithm explained in section [ dmrg ] , with a neglected probability tolerance @xmath55 and a tolerance on the convergence of the energy of one part in @xmath56 , for ten samples of each size ( @xmath57 50 , 100 , 150 , 200 , 250 , 300 , 400 , 500 ) .","each sample is a different random graph , always with fixed connectivity @xmath2 , and the bonds @xmath7 are random and independent , uniformly distributed in the interval @xmath8 $ ] .","figure [ xsg : fig](a ) shows three observables calculated for a given instance of a @xmath54 graph , as a fuction of @xmath23 .","the most relevant quantity is the spin - glass susceptibility , defined in equation [ xsg ] .","a small magnetic field @xmath58 is applied at a single site @xmath59 , and the magnetic response is measured with the formula @xmath60 which is found to increase very fast as @xmath23 approaches @xmath61 from above , and thereupon saturating at a very high value .","figure [ xsg : fig](b ) proves the divergence of @xmath32 by showing its behavior at three different values of @xmath62 ( @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 ) : the saturation value is seen to scale as @xmath66 .","we estimate the _","pseudo-_critical value @xmath29 for the given sample as the value of @xmath23 at which the slope of the susceptibility attains its maximum . with this definition",", @xmath29 appears to be almost independent of the chosen site @xmath59 , at our level of precision @xmath67 .","figure [ xsg : fig](c ) , finally , shows @xmath32 for ten different samples with @xmath54 sites , differing in the graph structure and in the choice of the couplings @xmath7 , and diverging at different ( sample dependent ) values of @xmath29 .","figure [ xsg : fig](a ) also shows two other observables which point towards the same value for @xmath29 .","the first is the block entanglement entropy , defined as @xmath68 , where @xmath69 is the reduced density matrix for a part of the system .","it is measured for all the left - right decompositions along a dmrg sweep , and its maximum value is denoted by @xmath70 .","this value of @xmath70 is obviously dependent on the dmrg path .","nonetheless , since this path has been chosen so as to minimize the number of retained states , it is expected that it will also minimize the maximum value of the entropy .","it should be emphasized that this observable attains its maximum value , as a function of @xmath23 , at the same @xmath29 which is found by analyzing the spin - glass susceptibility .","the relevance of the entanglement entropy in order to characterize the critical point of a qsgt has already been remarked in the literature @xcite .","the dmrg , being based on the obtention and analysis of the density matrix of different parts of the system , is specially well suited for measuring this observable @xcite .","the other observable shown in figure [ xsg : fig](a ) is the energy gap @xmath52 , which extrapolates to zero at a value of @xmath23 which is close to @xmath29 .","the sign of the difference between these two pseudo - critical points is sample dependent .","this discrepancy is likely to be a finite size effect .","the next observable that we calculated for each sample is the average value of @xmath71 , see figure [ szzsx : fig ] . for high @xmath23 ,","the transverse field is dominant , the ground state is close to @xmath25 and the value of @xmath71 is close to 1 .","as we decrease @xmath23 , this value is reduced .","it is remarkable that , at the value of @xmath29 defined by @xmath32 , and confirmed by the maximum block entropy , @xmath71 is never lower than @xmath72 , at variance with the 1d ritf , where it is normal to have values below @xmath73 . also in figure [ szzsx : fig ]","we have plotted the behavior of the quantum equivalent of the @xmath74 order parameter , which measures the magnitude of the long - distance spatial correlations @xcite , @xmath75 our definition differs slightly from that used commonly in the literature on classical spin glasses . instead of the long - distance behavior",", we measure the global average behavior .","they are equivalent in a system with a bethe lattice topology because the number of neighbours of a given site at distance @xmath76 scales as @xmath77 . also note that these two observables , @xmath71 and @xmath74 have the advantage that they do not vanish trivially in the absence of external longitudinal magnetic field .","this quantity is close to zero within the paramagnetic phase , and takes a non - zero value inside the spin - glass phase .","figure [ szzsx : fig ] shows that the behaviours of @xmath74 and @xmath71 are highly correlated , both pointing to a pseudo - critical point which is , in many instances , sensibly lower than the one obtained with @xmath32 and @xmath70 .","this systematic discrepancy is not explainable in the framework of classical physics , since the fluctuation - dissipation theorem leads to the proportionality of @xmath74 and @xmath32 @xcite . in the quantum case , @xmath32 is not equivalent to @xmath74 , but to @xmath78 ^ 2\\ ] ] where the integral is performed on imaginary time , from @xmath79 to @xmath80 .","therefore , in quantum spin - glasses , @xmath32 contains a contribution from time - correlations , while @xmath74 only measures spatial ones .","their different divergence points might suggest that long - distance correlations develop at a higher value of @xmath23 in time than in space . at different sizes @xmath9 ,","the behavior of the various samples is qualitatively similar , the only difference being the sample - dependent value of @xmath81 .","it is possible to construct histograms showing , for different @xmath9 , the probability distribution of the various @xmath81 . as a preliminary result",", we mark in figure [ gammac_vs_n : fig ] by empty circles the @xmath29 values obtained for 10 samples of different sizes : @xmath9=50 , 100 , 150 , 200 , 250 , 300 , 400 , and 500 . the crosses mark , for each size @xmath9 , the average values of @xmath81 , which apparently saturate at some point around @xmath82 . a useful clue to the physics of this system across the transition is obtained by monitoring selected wavefunction components of the ground state as a function of @xmath23 , which can be easily done with the dmrg .","we illustrate this in figure [ wf : fig ] , for a sample with @xmath15 whose @xmath29 is marked by the arrow .","one of the monitored configurations is the classical ground state of the system .","( naturally , there are two of them , related by a global spin - flip , which we denote by @xmath83 and @xmath84 .","they are obtained by measuring the values of @xmath85 at each site for very low @xmath23 under the presence of a very small longitudinal field @xmath86 that splits the degeneracy between them .","we will consider its weight to be the sum of their probabilities . )","the weight of the classical ground state grows up to @xmath87 as @xmath23 is decreased .","a second monitored configuration is picked at random ( dashed lower line in figure [ wf : fig ] ) : the weight of such a random configuration is similar to that of all the others only for very large values @xmath23 , while it is definitely much smaller when @xmath23 approaches the pseudo - critical point .","the remaining monitored configurations in figure [ wf : fig ] are obtained by classical simulated annealing , i.e. , they are local minima of the classical energy .","these configurations maintain a high weight ( similar to that of the optimal configuration ) across the transition , up to a value of @xmath23 below which their weight decline markedly . therefore , the number of relevant classical configurations contributing to the ground state changes drastically across @xmath29 . deep into the paramagnetic phase ,","all of them have the same weight , coherently bound within the @xmath25 state .","this state retains a high weight at @xmath29 , as shown by the high values taken by @xmath71 at that moment . within the spin - glass phase",", the weight of the different configurations is gradually redistributed according to their classical energies , until eventually only the classical ground state remains .","it should be remarked that the dmrg was applicable in practice only in the case of random couplings . for random graphs with fixed values of @xmath88 ( either ferro or antiferromagnetic ) , the number of retained states needed for a similar accuracy increased in an order of magnitude , rendering impractical the calculations ."],["it should be remarked that a quantum phase transition may be observed exactly in the mps formalism with as few as two retained states per block @xcite .","the low values of @xmath70 measured in our system points to the fact that the number of states involved in the qsgt is reduced .","thus , in an attempt to explain the transition we might build a simple - minded ansatz consistent of a linear combination of only two states : the classical ground state @xmath89 and a _ background state _ containing the rest of classical configurations : neglecting matrix elements which are exponentially small for large @xmath9 , there is a very sharp crossover at @xmath91 , from state @xmath92 to state @xmath44 .","this last state clearly presents a divergent spin - glass susceptibility .","the physics of our model is actually more complicated than this simple ansatz , as shown by the numerical estimate , @xmath93 for large @xmath9 .","an interesting question is how our system differs from the 1d ritf analyzed by fisher and coworkers @xcite . in 1d",", duality arguments and a detailed rg analysis give a value of @xmath29 satisfying @xmath94_{av}$ ] , where @xmath95_{av}$ ] indicates a disorder average .","this equation leads to values of @xmath29 much lower than those measured in our random graph case ( e.g. , for our distribution of @xmath7 , fisher s model yields @xmath96 , while in our case it reaches @xmath97 for @xmath42 sites ) .","the higher connectivity seems to make a large difference in that respect .","moreover , in our case , the value of @xmath71 at the transition is fairly high , about @xmath72 , while it is almost always below @xmath73 for ritf chains with the same sizes .","this means that the state @xmath25 is still dominant in the paramagnetic phase at the moment of the divergence of the spin - glass susceptibility . in conclusion ,","we have extended the dmrg to make it suitable to study the qsgt on random graphs .","the main technical innovations are the path - selection , which reduces the maximum number of retained states , and the wavefunction annealing , which allows to use the ground state for a certain value of @xmath23 as a seed to obtain the ground state for a lower value .","this modified dmrg algorithm has been applied to the measurement of the energy gap @xmath52 , spin - glass susceptibility @xmath32 , entanglement entropy @xmath70 , long - distance spatial correlations @xmath74 and average @xmath18-magnetization @xmath71 to high precision on a few samples of different sizes , ranging from @xmath53 to @xmath42 sites .","remarkably , @xmath70 attains its maximum at the same value of @xmath27 at which @xmath32 diverges .","this led us to consider this value as our candidate for the pseudo - critical point .","the energy gap @xmath52 vanishes in the surroundings of that value for all realizations . in most disorder realizations , @xmath74 and","@xmath71 start their crossover at a value of @xmath23 which is inferior to @xmath29 .","this may suggest that long - range temporal correlations develop at a higher value of @xmath23 than purely spatial ones .","we would like to emphasize that our definition of @xmath70 constitutes an alternative approach to the entanglement entropy on random graphs .","its relation to the standard block entropy , defined as the entanglement entropy obtained by tracing out a site and its neighbours up to a certain distance , remains as an open question .","we have also monitored the ground state probabilities of several classical low - energy configurations , showing that , as @xmath23 is reduced below @xmath29 , these probabilities increase exponentially until they attain a maximum value and then fall to zero , leaving the classical minimum energy configuration as the only ground state component as @xmath98 .","the fact that the model on such disordered graph was amenable to analysis within the dmrg is non - trivial .","both @xmath70 and the maximum number of retained states per block increase slowly with the system size . in a restricted sense , the system behaves similarly to a 1d chain , despite the high connectivity of the underlying graph .","this is a rather remarkable effect due to the disorder , which perhaps leads to the selection of an effective 1d path of strong bonds .","if the couplings @xmath88 are not random , we have found that the number of retained states per block increases in a much more pronounced way , rendering the numerical dmrg approach impractical .","it will be interesting and is left to a future study to understand quantitatively how the entanglement entropy at the transition behaves as a function of the system size , both for random and non - random couplings @xcite ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"quantum phase transitions constitute a very active topic in theoretical physics @xcite , to which disorder and frustration of a quantum spin glass add considerable intricacies @xcite .\",\n \"although quantum effects were usually considered to be negligible in spin glasses at finite temperatures , diverse experiments @xcite have proved them to be highly relevant , leading to the first experimental realization of _ quantum annealing _ @xcite .\",\n \"one of the most widely employed theoretical approaches to the quantum spin - glass transition ( qsgt ) is the random couplings ising model in a transverse field ( ritf ) @xcite . within the analytical approach\",\n \", a griffiths phase was found in the 1d case via an elegant rg procedure @xcite , while such a structure was proved to be absent from the infinite range case within the replica formalism @xcite .\",\n \"the 1d rg analysis was extended to study the presence of a certain number of long - distance links , proving the relevance of the perturbation @xcite .\",\n \"regarding numerical approaches , quantum monte - carlo ( qmc ) remains as the most suitable tool at @xmath0 .\",\n \"using it , a coherent picture was obtained in the 2d and 3d cases , showing that the griffiths phase is present in 2d but absent in 3d @xcite .\",\n \"classical spin glasses have been thoroughly analysed on bethe lattices @xcite .\",\n \"however , finite bethe lattices are dominated by boundary effects and present no frustration . a way out is to study random graphs with a fixed connectivity which , in the classical case , allow the application of the _ cavity approach _ @xcite .\",\n \"these random graphs present genuine frustration , since they have _ loops _ , and have no boundaries . on the other hand\",\n \", the average size of the loops grows with the number of sites @xcite , thus making them resemble , _ locally _ , a bethe lattice ( see figure [ graph : fig ] ) .\",\n \"the density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) @xcite is known to be a highly accurate method to analyze @xmath1 ground state properties of 1d or quasi-1d quantum many body systems , including tree structures @xcite .\",\n \"we have extended the method in order to trace the behaviour of finite size samples of random graphs of fixed connectivity @xmath2 across the qsgt within the ritf model . given the high connectivity of these graphs ,\",\n \"the applicability of the dmrg is highly non - trivial .\",\n \"it is remarkable that in the case of non - random couplings , we have found the number of retained states needed to ensure a good accuracy to be very high , rendering the application of the dmrg unfeasible . the careful analysis of _\",\n \"pseudo-_critical points of finite size samples constitutes a powerful tool to study a qsgt . as a recent example , the work of igli and coworkers @xcite studies the distributions of , e.g. , the average entanglement entropy and the surface magnetization of finite size 1d samples . in this work\",\n \"we provide measurements of , among other observables , spin - glass susceptibilities , energy gaps , long distance spin - spin correlations and entanglement entropies , and use them to obtain insight on the mechanism of the transition .\",\n \"a full characterization of the qsgt , nonetheless , is not attempted in this work , since it would require to obtain statistics on a large number of disorder realizations .\",\n \"the rest of the paper is organized as follows : sec .\",\n \"[ model : sec ] presents the model , and sec .\",\n \"[ dmrg ] provides details on the application of dmrg .\",\n \"[ results ] shows the numerical dmrg results obtained .\",\n \"[ conclusions ] presents a discussion of the results and some concluding remarks .\"\n ],\n [\n \"let us consider the random ising model in a transverse field ( ritf ) on a generic graph @xcite : @xmath3 where @xmath4 denotes pairs of neighboring sites @xmath5 and @xmath6 on the graph .\",\n \"the values of @xmath7 are uncorrelated random variables with a uniform probability density distribution in the interval @xmath8 $ ] .\",\n \"we will focus our study on randomly generated graphs , with @xmath9 sites and a fixed connectivity @xmath2 @xcite , i.e. , each site @xmath5 is connected to @xmath2 other ( randomly chosen ) sites @xmath6 .\",\n \"an example of such a graph , with @xmath10 sites , is shown in fig .\",\n \"[ graph : fig ] .\",\n \"it should be noticed that , locally and for large @xmath9 , such graphs resemble _ bethe lattices _ , as we have highlighted with thicker links in fig . [ graph : fig ] . nonetheless , the behaviour of finite bethe lattices is dominated by the boundary , unlike in our case , where there is none . moreover , trees have no loops and , therefore , present no _ frustration _ , while random graphs with fixed connectivity do contain loops and , therefore , have genuine frustration .\",\n \"it has been proved , nonetheless , that short loops become rare as @xmath11 : more precisely , the probability of finding a loop of any fixed size @xmath12 falls to zero when @xmath11 @xcite .\",\n \"the physics of classical spin glasses in these graphs has been studied using the cavity method by mzard and parisi @xcite .\",\n \"let @xmath13 be the absolute value of the disorder - averaged energy per site of the classical ground state .\",\n \"our numerical experiments show that it increases from @xmath14 at @xmath15 up to @xmath16 for larger @xmath9 , which is the theoretical limiting value for @xmath11 under the assumption that all links are satisfied .\",\n \"we will take the product of eigenstates of @xmath17 , for all @xmath5 , as the _ canonical basis _ for our problem . in this basis\",\n \", we denote the state in which all spins point in the positive @xmath18-direction as @xmath19 .\",\n \"let us assume , for the moment , that @xmath20 for all @xmath5 . for @xmath21 , all the non - diagonal terms in the hamiltonian vanish .\",\n \"therefore , the ground state is given by the configurations with the classical minimum energy .\",\n \"disregarding accidental degeneracies , there are two such configurations , related by a simultaneous flip of all spins , @xmath22 for all @xmath5 .\",\n \"the transverse field @xmath23 may be considered as a _ kinetic energy _ coefficient , providing a hopping term among the classical configurations . in the @xmath24\",\n \"limit the transverse field term dominates and the ground state tends to the state @xmath25 , with all the spins pointing in the positive @xmath18-direction , separated by a large gap @xmath26 from the first excited state .\",\n \"let us remark that all the components of the canonical basis have the same amplitude in the state @xmath25 .\",\n \"by decreasing @xmath23 there is a certain value @xmath27 for which the system undergoes a quantum spin - glass transition ( qsgt ) . for @xmath28 ,\",\n \"the system is in a quantum paramagnetic phase , which presents no long - range order .\",\n \"below @xmath29 , the system is in a quantum spin - glass phase , presenting a hidden long - range order which may be detected by a number of observables .\",\n \"we will focus here on the divergence of the _ spin - glass susceptibility _ : @xmath30 i.e. , physically , a small longitudinal magnetic field @xmath31 , applied at site @xmath6 , generates a magnetization response on each site @xmath5 , which is measured ( and squared , so as to disregard its sign ) ; the results are summed over all sites @xmath5 and averaged over all sites @xmath6 . if the system is in a paramagnetic phase , the magnetization will be proportional to @xmath31 and short - ranged in space , so that the sum over @xmath5 and @xmath6 yields a finite value for @xmath32 . on the other hand , on approaching the spin - glass phase , an infinitesimally small longitudinal magnetic field @xmath31 , localized at a single site @xmath6 , will eventually induce a finite magnetization over a long - range of spins .\",\n \"this effect is at the origin of the divergence of @xmath32 .\",\n \"we shall now discuss the numerical approach we have used to study this system , and the results obtained .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the density - matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) has proved to be an accurate method to analyse the properties of 1d and quasi-1d systems @xcite .\",\n \"the dmrg may be described as a variational method within the matrix - product states ( mps ) , which constitute a low - dimensional subspace of the full hilbert space @xcite .\",\n \"a mps may be expressed as @xmath33 where each @xmath34 is a square matrix with dimension @xmath35 , which may be considered as the number of retained states per block when splitting the system into a left and right parts .\",\n \"the total number of variational parameters is less than @xmath36 .\",\n \"the success of the dmrg is related to the ability of these mps to reproduce faithfully the ground states of local 1d many - body problems for low values of @xmath35 @xcite . if @xmath37 , any state of the hilbert space may be exactly represented as a mps .\",\n \"the minimum number of retained states @xmath35 is related to the exponential of the von neumann entanglement entropy of the dmrg block @xcite . in a non - critical 1d system , this entropy is bounded for all sizes , while it grows as @xmath38 for a 1d critical system of length @xmath12 .\",\n \"it is believed that for a @xmath39-dimensional system out of criticality , the entanglement entropy scales as @xmath40 , where @xmath12 is the shortest spatial dimension of the system @xcite .\",\n \"this estimate is known as the _ area law _ and is believed to have logarithmic corrections at critical points .\",\n \"an important practical consequence is that , in order to study a 2d system , the number of retained states @xmath35 should grow as @xmath41 , thus making the dmrg very inefficient .\",\n \"our system , on the other hand , is defined on a random graph of fixed connectivity , @xmath2 .\",\n \"we will show that this poses no problem to the number of retained states @xmath35 , which appears to remain manageable even for @xmath42 as long as the couplings are random .\",\n \"however , the implementation of the dmrg on such a model has required the following technical refinements of the original method : * ( a ) path selection . * : : in a non-1d system , dmrg proceeds by converting the system into an effective 1d problem with long - range couplings .\",\n \"a path is chosen along the graph , which does not repeat sites , and is considered to be appropriate if the number of broken links between the left and the right blocks is kept low along a dmrg sweep .\",\n \"normally , the selection of a suitable path in a quasi-1d system ( e.g. ladders ) is done by geometrical intuition . in our implementation\",\n \"we have designed an automated procedure : a simulated annealing algorithm is employed in order to minimize the number of broken links .\",\n \"the full problem of finding the optimal path is computationally very hard .\",\n \"therefore , we do not aim at the exact optimum , but only to a reasonably good local minimum .\",\n \"we have noticed that our quasi - optimal path performs much better than a random path . *\",\n \"( b ) perron - frobenius criterion . * : : the hamiltonian of the ritf on any graph fulfills , on the canonical basis , the conditions of the perron - frobenius theorem , i.e. , all off - diagonal components are _ non - positive_. hence , all the ground state components must have the same sign . using the mps representation of the ground state\",\n \"obtained within the dmrg , it is always possible to reconstruct the amplitude of any configuration @xmath43 .\",\n \"the obtention of the full @xmath44 is unfeasible , since it would require reconstructing the amplitude of an exponentially large number of configurations .\",\n \"nonetheless , it is possible to pick up a few random configurations @xmath45 , and check that all their amplitudes have the same sign .\",\n \"whenever this criterion was not met a rather rare event , the calculation was repeated changing the random seed for the lanczos procedure on the first dmrg step . *\",\n \"( c ) wavefunction annealing .\",\n \"* : : for large @xmath23 the ground state @xmath25 is easily representable as a mps , requiring a single retained state .\",\n \"the dmrg works extremely well in this regime and , therefore , our simulations are always started well within the paramagnetic ( large @xmath23 ) phase .\",\n \"the qsgt is approached by repeatedly decreasing the value of @xmath23 by a small amount , always using the previous ground state as a seed for the new calculation , exploiting the wavefunction transformations suggested by white @xcite .\",\n \"this type of _ annealing _ of the ground state provides a faster convergence and more accurate results for low @xmath23 . *\",\n \"( d ) adaptive number of retained states . * : : the number of retained states @xmath35 , and the number of dmrg sweeps @xmath46 , are not fixed in our algorithm .\",\n \"we set a maximum value for the sum of the neglected eigenvalues of the density matrix in the rg truncation ( @xmath47 ) , and select @xmath35 accordingly .\",\n \"moreover , sometimes convergence takes more sweeps than usual ( @xmath48 ) in order to obtain machine precision in the convergence of the ground state energy . *\",\n \"( e ) energy gap measurements . * : : when there is a symmetry in a problem , e.g. , under su(2 ) , it is usually possible to obtain the first excited state as the ground state of a different _ sector _ of the hilbert space . in our case , lacking this , the best option has proved to be the following one . for each dmrg step , after the ground state @xmath49 had been found , it was `` promoted '' to a higher energy by the following transformation of the hamiltonian : + @xmath50 + in such a way that the ground state of this new hamiltonian is the former first excited state , as long as we take @xmath51 , @xmath52 being the gap we are looking for . the density matrix used for truncation\",\n \"was built as a linear combination of the density matrices for each state , with equal weights .\",\n \"however , we should remember that only ground states of local hamiltonians are expected to be faithfully represented by mps @xcite , and eq .\",\n \"( [ h.gap ] ) does not define a local hamiltonian .\",\n \"therefore , the accuracy in the gap estimate is worse than that in the ground state energy and in other observables .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we have applied the modified dmrg technique to study a few samples of random graphs with fixed connectivity @xmath2 and sizes ranging from @xmath53 to @xmath42 .\",\n \"a full characterization of the qsgt would require relevant statistics on the disorder .\",\n \"unfortunately , in order to obtain a high accuracy for each sample , the required cpu - time is rather large .\",\n \"therefore , we have decided to focus on a precise study of a few realizations , in order to gain insight on the mechanism of the transition for finite samples .\",\n \"most of our findings will be illustrated in the figures of this section by showing in detail the results obtained for a sample with @xmath54 sites .\",\n \"it should be remarked that the highlighted features are typical of all the ensemble .\",\n \"the numerical simulations were done with the dmrg algorithm explained in section [ dmrg ] , with a neglected probability tolerance @xmath55 and a tolerance on the convergence of the energy of one part in @xmath56 , for ten samples of each size ( @xmath57 50 , 100 , 150 , 200 , 250 , 300 , 400 , 500 ) .\",\n \"each sample is a different random graph , always with fixed connectivity @xmath2 , and the bonds @xmath7 are random and independent , uniformly distributed in the interval @xmath8 $ ] .\",\n \"figure [ xsg : fig](a ) shows three observables calculated for a given instance of a @xmath54 graph , as a fuction of @xmath23 .\",\n \"the most relevant quantity is the spin - glass susceptibility , defined in equation [ xsg ] .\",\n \"a small magnetic field @xmath58 is applied at a single site @xmath59 , and the magnetic response is measured with the formula @xmath60 which is found to increase very fast as @xmath23 approaches @xmath61 from above , and thereupon saturating at a very high value .\",\n \"figure [ xsg : fig](b ) proves the divergence of @xmath32 by showing its behavior at three different values of @xmath62 ( @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 ) : the saturation value is seen to scale as @xmath66 .\",\n \"we estimate the _\",\n \"pseudo-_critical value @xmath29 for the given sample as the value of @xmath23 at which the slope of the susceptibility attains its maximum . with this definition\",\n \", @xmath29 appears to be almost independent of the chosen site @xmath59 , at our level of precision @xmath67 .\",\n \"figure [ xsg : fig](c ) , finally , shows @xmath32 for ten different samples with @xmath54 sites , differing in the graph structure and in the choice of the couplings @xmath7 , and diverging at different ( sample dependent ) values of @xmath29 .\",\n \"figure [ xsg : fig](a ) also shows two other observables which point towards the same value for @xmath29 .\",\n \"the first is the block entanglement entropy , defined as @xmath68 , where @xmath69 is the reduced density matrix for a part of the system .\",\n \"it is measured for all the left - right decompositions along a dmrg sweep , and its maximum value is denoted by @xmath70 .\",\n \"this value of @xmath70 is obviously dependent on the dmrg path .\",\n \"nonetheless , since this path has been chosen so as to minimize the number of retained states , it is expected that it will also minimize the maximum value of the entropy .\",\n \"it should be emphasized that this observable attains its maximum value , as a function of @xmath23 , at the same @xmath29 which is found by analyzing the spin - glass susceptibility .\",\n \"the relevance of the entanglement entropy in order to characterize the critical point of a qsgt has already been remarked in the literature @xcite .\",\n \"the dmrg , being based on the obtention and analysis of the density matrix of different parts of the system , is specially well suited for measuring this observable @xcite .\",\n \"the other observable shown in figure [ xsg : fig](a ) is the energy gap @xmath52 , which extrapolates to zero at a value of @xmath23 which is close to @xmath29 .\",\n \"the sign of the difference between these two pseudo - critical points is sample dependent .\",\n \"this discrepancy is likely to be a finite size effect .\",\n \"the next observable that we calculated for each sample is the average value of @xmath71 , see figure [ szzsx : fig ] . for high @xmath23 ,\",\n \"the transverse field is dominant , the ground state is close to @xmath25 and the value of @xmath71 is close to 1 .\",\n \"as we decrease @xmath23 , this value is reduced .\",\n \"it is remarkable that , at the value of @xmath29 defined by @xmath32 , and confirmed by the maximum block entropy , @xmath71 is never lower than @xmath72 , at variance with the 1d ritf , where it is normal to have values below @xmath73 . also in figure [ szzsx : fig ]\",\n \"we have plotted the behavior of the quantum equivalent of the @xmath74 order parameter , which measures the magnitude of the long - distance spatial correlations @xcite , @xmath75 our definition differs slightly from that used commonly in the literature on classical spin glasses . instead of the long - distance behavior\",\n \", we measure the global average behavior .\",\n \"they are equivalent in a system with a bethe lattice topology because the number of neighbours of a given site at distance @xmath76 scales as @xmath77 . also note that these two observables , @xmath71 and @xmath74 have the advantage that they do not vanish trivially in the absence of external longitudinal magnetic field .\",\n \"this quantity is close to zero within the paramagnetic phase , and takes a non - zero value inside the spin - glass phase .\",\n \"figure [ szzsx : fig ] shows that the behaviours of @xmath74 and @xmath71 are highly correlated , both pointing to a pseudo - critical point which is , in many instances , sensibly lower than the one obtained with @xmath32 and @xmath70 .\",\n \"this systematic discrepancy is not explainable in the framework of classical physics , since the fluctuation - dissipation theorem leads to the proportionality of @xmath74 and @xmath32 @xcite . in the quantum case , @xmath32 is not equivalent to @xmath74 , but to @xmath78 ^ 2\\\\ ] ] where the integral is performed on imaginary time , from @xmath79 to @xmath80 .\",\n \"therefore , in quantum spin - glasses , @xmath32 contains a contribution from time - correlations , while @xmath74 only measures spatial ones .\",\n \"their different divergence points might suggest that long - distance correlations develop at a higher value of @xmath23 in time than in space . at different sizes @xmath9 ,\",\n \"the behavior of the various samples is qualitatively similar , the only difference being the sample - dependent value of @xmath81 .\",\n \"it is possible to construct histograms showing , for different @xmath9 , the probability distribution of the various @xmath81 . as a preliminary result\",\n \", we mark in figure [ gammac_vs_n : fig ] by empty circles the @xmath29 values obtained for 10 samples of different sizes : @xmath9=50 , 100 , 150 , 200 , 250 , 300 , 400 , and 500 . the crosses mark , for each size @xmath9 , the average values of @xmath81 , which apparently saturate at some point around @xmath82 . a useful clue to the physics of this system across the transition is obtained by monitoring selected wavefunction components of the ground state as a function of @xmath23 , which can be easily done with the dmrg .\",\n \"we illustrate this in figure [ wf : fig ] , for a sample with @xmath15 whose @xmath29 is marked by the arrow .\",\n \"one of the monitored configurations is the classical ground state of the system .\",\n \"( naturally , there are two of them , related by a global spin - flip , which we denote by @xmath83 and @xmath84 .\",\n \"they are obtained by measuring the values of @xmath85 at each site for very low @xmath23 under the presence of a very small longitudinal field @xmath86 that splits the degeneracy between them .\",\n \"we will consider its weight to be the sum of their probabilities . )\",\n \"the weight of the classical ground state grows up to @xmath87 as @xmath23 is decreased .\",\n \"a second monitored configuration is picked at random ( dashed lower line in figure [ wf : fig ] ) : the weight of such a random configuration is similar to that of all the others only for very large values @xmath23 , while it is definitely much smaller when @xmath23 approaches the pseudo - critical point .\",\n \"the remaining monitored configurations in figure [ wf : fig ] are obtained by classical simulated annealing , i.e. , they are local minima of the classical energy .\",\n \"these configurations maintain a high weight ( similar to that of the optimal configuration ) across the transition , up to a value of @xmath23 below which their weight decline markedly . therefore , the number of relevant classical configurations contributing to the ground state changes drastically across @xmath29 . deep into the paramagnetic phase ,\",\n \"all of them have the same weight , coherently bound within the @xmath25 state .\",\n \"this state retains a high weight at @xmath29 , as shown by the high values taken by @xmath71 at that moment . within the spin - glass phase\",\n \", the weight of the different configurations is gradually redistributed according to their classical energies , until eventually only the classical ground state remains .\",\n \"it should be remarked that the dmrg was applicable in practice only in the case of random couplings . for random graphs with fixed values of @xmath88 ( either ferro or antiferromagnetic ) , the number of retained states needed for a similar accuracy increased in an order of magnitude , rendering impractical the calculations .\"\n ],\n [\n \"it should be remarked that a quantum phase transition may be observed exactly in the mps formalism with as few as two retained states per block @xcite .\",\n \"the low values of @xmath70 measured in our system points to the fact that the number of states involved in the qsgt is reduced .\",\n \"thus , in an attempt to explain the transition we might build a simple - minded ansatz consistent of a linear combination of only two states : the classical ground state @xmath89 and a _ background state _ containing the rest of classical configurations : neglecting matrix elements which are exponentially small for large @xmath9 , there is a very sharp crossover at @xmath91 , from state @xmath92 to state @xmath44 .\",\n \"this last state clearly presents a divergent spin - glass susceptibility .\",\n \"the physics of our model is actually more complicated than this simple ansatz , as shown by the numerical estimate , @xmath93 for large @xmath9 .\",\n \"an interesting question is how our system differs from the 1d ritf analyzed by fisher and coworkers @xcite . in 1d\",\n \", duality arguments and a detailed rg analysis give a value of @xmath29 satisfying @xmath94_{av}$ ] , where @xmath95_{av}$ ] indicates a disorder average .\",\n \"this equation leads to values of @xmath29 much lower than those measured in our random graph case ( e.g. , for our distribution of @xmath7 , fisher s model yields @xmath96 , while in our case it reaches @xmath97 for @xmath42 sites ) .\",\n \"the higher connectivity seems to make a large difference in that respect .\",\n \"moreover , in our case , the value of @xmath71 at the transition is fairly high , about @xmath72 , while it is almost always below @xmath73 for ritf chains with the same sizes .\",\n \"this means that the state @xmath25 is still dominant in the paramagnetic phase at the moment of the divergence of the spin - glass susceptibility . in conclusion ,\",\n \"we have extended the dmrg to make it suitable to study the qsgt on random graphs .\",\n \"the main technical innovations are the path - selection , which reduces the maximum number of retained states , and the wavefunction annealing , which allows to use the ground state for a certain value of @xmath23 as a seed to obtain the ground state for a lower value .\",\n \"this modified dmrg algorithm has been applied to the measurement of the energy gap @xmath52 , spin - glass susceptibility @xmath32 , entanglement entropy @xmath70 , long - distance spatial correlations @xmath74 and average @xmath18-magnetization @xmath71 to high precision on a few samples of different sizes , ranging from @xmath53 to @xmath42 sites .\",\n \"remarkably , @xmath70 attains its maximum at the same value of @xmath27 at which @xmath32 diverges .\",\n \"this led us to consider this value as our candidate for the pseudo - critical point .\",\n \"the energy gap @xmath52 vanishes in the surroundings of that value for all realizations . in most disorder realizations , @xmath74 and\",\n \"@xmath71 start their crossover at a value of @xmath23 which is inferior to @xmath29 .\",\n \"this may suggest that long - range temporal correlations develop at a higher value of @xmath23 than purely spatial ones .\",\n \"we would like to emphasize that our definition of @xmath70 constitutes an alternative approach to the entanglement entropy on random graphs .\",\n \"its relation to the standard block entropy , defined as the entanglement entropy obtained by tracing out a site and its neighbours up to a certain distance , remains as an open question .\",\n \"we have also monitored the ground state probabilities of several classical low - energy configurations , showing that , as @xmath23 is reduced below @xmath29 , these probabilities increase exponentially until they attain a maximum value and then fall to zero , leaving the classical minimum energy configuration as the only ground state component as @xmath98 .\",\n \"the fact that the model on such disordered graph was amenable to analysis within the dmrg is non - trivial .\",\n \"both @xmath70 and the maximum number of retained states per block increase slowly with the system size . in a restricted sense , the system behaves similarly to a 1d chain , despite the high connectivity of the underlying graph .\",\n \"this is a rather remarkable effect due to the disorder , which perhaps leads to the selection of an effective 1d path of strong bonds .\",\n \"if the couplings @xmath88 are not random , we have found that the number of retained states per block increases in a much more pronounced way , rendering the numerical dmrg approach impractical .\",\n \"it will be interesting and is left to a future study to understand quantitatively how the entanglement entropy at the transition behaves as a function of the system size , both for random and non - random couplings @xcite .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":88,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"hep-ph0010221"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["the idea of a statistical approach to hadron production in high energy collisions dates back to 50s @xcite and 60s @xcite and it has been recently revived by the observation that hadron multiplicities in collisions agree very well with a thermodynamical - like ansatz @xcite .","this finding has also been confirmed in hadronic collisions and it has been interpreted in terms of a pure statistical filling of multi - hadronic phase space of assumed pre - hadronic clusters ( or fireballs ) formed in high - energy collisions , at a critical value of energy density @xcite . in this framework , temperature and other thermodynamical quantities have a statistical meaning which does not entail the existence of a thermalised hadronic system on an event - by - event basis .","stated otherwise , statistical equilibrium shows up only when comparing many different events , whilst in each of them the gibbs law of equally likely multi - hadronic states applies .","so far , this proposed statistical cluster hadronisation model has been mainly tested against measured abundances of different hadron species for a twofold reason .","firstly , unlike momentum spectra , they are quantities which are not affected by hard ( perturbative ) qcd dynamical effects but are only determined by the hadronisation process ; indeed , in the framework of a multi - cluster model , they are lorentz - invariant quantities which are independent of the cluster s overall momentum .","secondly , they are quite easy to calculate and provide a very sensitive test of the model yielding an accurate determination of the temperature . however , in order to establish the validity of this approach , it is necessary to test further observables and to assess their consistency with the results obtained for multiplicities .","certainly , one of the best suited observables is the transverse momentum of identified hadrons , where transverse is meant to be with respect to beam line in high energy hadronic collision , and thrust or event axis in high energy collisions .","indeed , such projection of particle momentum is supposed to be the most sensitive to hadronisation or , conversely , the least sensitive to perturbative qcd dynamics .","+ actually , it has been known for a long time that transverse momentum distributions are boltzmann - like in hadronic collisions and this very observation was pointed out by hagedorn as a major indication in favour of his statistical model of hadron production @xcite .","it must be emphasized that the prediction of a thermal - like shape in principle only applies to particles directly emitted from the hadronising source , whereas measured spectra also include particles produced by decays of heavier hadrons .","however , most analyses do not take into account the distortion of primordial hadronisation spectrum due the to hadronic decay chain and try to fit the data straight through it .","this problem has been discussed in literature @xcite and an analytical calculation has been developed to take into account the effect of two and three body decays @xcite , which has then been used both for pp @xcite and heavy ion collision @xcite including most abundant resonances . in this paper","we introduce a method allowing to rigorously and exhaustively determine the contribution of all particle decays .","hence , by taking advantage of this technique , we have performed an analysis of many measured transverse momentum spectra of identified hadrons in a wide range of centre - of - mass energies for several kind of collisions .","the statistical hadronisation model @xcite assumes that in high energy collisions , as a consequence of strong interaction dynamics , a set of colourless clusters ( or fireballs ) is formed having certain values of mass , volume , internal quantum numbers and momentum , the latter being inherited from the hard stage of the process .","those clusters are assumed to give rise to hadrons according to a pure statistical law in the multi - hadronic phase space defined by their mass , volume and quantum numbers .","this approach differs from another popular cluster hadronisation model @xcite mainly because it gives clusters a volume so that hadron production is ruled by the properly understood phase space rather than relativistic momentum space . in this framework",", the use of statistical mechanics and thermodynamical quantities , such as temperature , which need spacial dimension besides momentum space in order to be meaningful , is allowed .","we emphasize once more that the introduction of such quantities does not entail any thermalisation process of hadrons after their formation , nor the existence of a thermalised system event by event . +","although many clusters with different momenta , volumes , masses and quantum numbers are formed , it can be shown that the average values of many observables , e. g. particle multiplicites , are the same as those relevant to one equivalent cluster having suitable values of volume ( namely the sum of all cluster volumes measured in the rest frame of the equivalent cluster itself ) , mass and quantum numbers ( namely the sum of all cluster quantum numbers ) .","the proof of this statement @xcite , a lengthy one , requires the assumption of special probabilities governing the fluctuations of cluster masses and quantum numbers for a given set of volumes .","if the volume ( or mass ) of the equivalent cluster is large enough , it is then reasonable to take a canonical approach ( i.e. introducing a temperature ) in order to calculate mean quantities , instead of carrying out an involved microcanonical calculation .","therefore , even though actual clusters are small sized and microcanonical calculations would be needed to determine mean quantities within each of them , the choice of suitable mass fluctuation probabilities for the clusters allows one to calculate overall means dealing with only one large global structure and with much fewer parameters . arguing the other way around , it is not difficult to be convinced that the fluctuation probabilities to be chosen in order to achieve such reduction of the problem are exactly the same as those of obtaining a given set of masses by splitting a large cluster into a given number of clusters with volumes @xmath2 .","this statement extends a reduction procedure to the microcanonical case which was proved in the canonical case @xcite , where , from the very beginning , clusters were given temperature and volume instead of mass and volume .","nevertheless , it is not obvious how large the equivalent cluster should be for the canonical approximation to apply . for the present",", we have adopted a simple - minded _ a posteriori _ method consisting in justifying the canonical framework by its capability of accordance with the data .","a simple argument to support the canonical approximation even at moderate values of volumes is the very large number of states ( @xmath3 ) , i.e. hadrons and resonances , which can be excited in a hadron gas . +","as far as single - particle transverse momentum spectra are concerned , a similar reduction theorem from many clusters to one equivalent cluster in the averaging procedure applies @xcite , though only approximately . in general",", it can be shown that the _ primary _ spectrum of @xmath4 hadron species depends on transverse four - velocities @xmath5 with vanishing longitudinal component . ] of the @xmath6 clusters : @xmath7 \\ ; f(u_{t1},\\ldots , u_{tn } ) \\nonumber \\\\ & & \\times \\ ; \\sum_{i=1}^n \\frac{\\d n_j}{\\d p_t}\\vl_{i}(\\ui ) \\ , .\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] where @xmath8 is the transverse four - velocities distribution function .","if one expands all single - cluster spectra @xmath9 in series of @xmath10 starting from a common value @xmath11 for all clusters , it can be proved that , at the zeroth order , the spectrum in eq .","( [ one ] ) becomes the same as that obtained for the aforementioned equivalent cluster , endowed with a tranverse four - velocity @xmath11 .","this reduction possibly allows taking the canonical approach in order to calculate the transverse momentum spectrum since the equivalent cluster size is much larger than single cluster s : @xmath12 where @xmath13 , @xmath14 is the temperature , and @xmath15 , @xmath16 are modified bessel functions .","( [ two ] ) is the boltzmann limit of quantum statistics and it is a very good approximation for all hadrons except pions @xcite . for the zeroth order approximation in the @xmath10 expansion to be sufficiently accurate , the involved transverse four - velocities should be small , i.e. @xmath17 already for @xmath18 . since it is possible to choose the starting point @xmath11 of the series expansion to make the first order term vanishing @xcite , the largest neglected term turns out to be @xmath19 which is very small provided that the aforementioned condition on @xmath20 is met .","the analysis presented in this paper assumes the validity of this approximation and primary spectra have been calculated according to eq .","( [ two ] ) . +","even though eq .","( [ two ] ) looks like the spectrum from a thermalised source with a superimposed flow , a popular formula in the heavy - ion community , it is well worth emphasizing that in fact this formula has nothing to do with flow .","indeed , the average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 is not meant to be the mean value of cluster velocity distribution in a single event ; rather , it is the average transverse four - velocity of all clusters over all collision events . in other words ,","@xmath11 may well arise from single clusters emitted at high @xmath21 in some events , e.g. following a hard parton scattering , and does not imply by any means a collective event - by - event expansion .","gev @xcite .","the measured @xmath22 spectra ( above ) have been normalised so as to have the same value at @xmath23 .","while slopes of @xmath22 spectra are different , those of @xmath24 ( below ) are approximately the same for all identified particles . ]","a peculiar prediction of a statistical picture in high energy collisions which is relevant to transverse momentum spectra is the so - called @xmath25 scaling : there should be an apparent common slope for @xmath26 spectra of identified hadrons at a given centre - of - mass energy . by looking at eq .","( [ two ] ) one can easily realize that this holds in the limit @xmath27 . in principle",", @xmath25 scaling applies only to primary hadrons , namely those directly emitted from the hadronising source . on the other hand , as stated in sect .","1 , most observed or reconstructed particles in experiments arise from decays of heavier hadrons .","those secondary decays may well distort the primary spectrum shape , thus spoling @xmath25 scaling .","nevertheless , it can be seen in fig .","( [ mtslope ] ) that @xmath25 scaling apparently also holds for measured final hadrons , at least in the examined collision , implying seemingly little distortion from primary to final spectrum . settling this and","other related issues demands a thorough analysis taking into account the effect of decays .","therefore , measured @xmath21 spectrum of the @xmath4 hadron species should be compared with the sum of its primary spectrum and the contribution arising from all heavier hadrons decaying into it : @xmath28 whilst @xmath29 is given by eq .","( [ two ] ) , the calculation of the second term in the right hand side of eq .","( [ three ] ) within a statistical - thermal framework is a very complicated problem as the number of contributing resonances and decay modes is huge and also owing the presence of cascade decays ( e.g. @xmath30 ) . in refs .","@xcite an analytical approach has been taken including two and three body decays of directly emitted resonances .","on the other hand , we have adopted @xcite a mixed numerical - analytical method which allows a very accurate and exhaustive calculation .","our method can be summarised as follows : for any couple of hadrons @xmath31 , where @xmath32 decays into @xmath33 , either directly or through a cascade process , we have determined the momentum spectrum @xmath34 in the equivalent cluster s rest frame via a monte - carlo method by randomly generating 200,000 @xmath32 s decays , according to phase space , by picking @xmath32 s three - momenta from a thermal distribution with a given temperature @xmath14 : @xmath35 then , we have boosted the obtained @xmath34 distributions in order to compute the @xmath36 for a given transverse four - velocity @xmath11 of the equivalent cluster , to be plugged into eq .","( [ three ] ) , with an integral formula derived by the authors @xcite : @xmath37 where f is the elliptic integral of the first kind and : @xmath38 [ cols=\"<,<,<,<,<,<\",options=\"header \" , ] + the main advantage of formula ( [ five ] ) is to allow a quick computation of transverse momentum spectra associated with particle decays for any tranverse four - velocity once the corresponding momentum spectra at zero velocity are known . to obtain it",", we took advantage of the isotropy of @xmath34 distributions , which holds as long as decay products distribution is isotropic , which is true for simple phase - space decays with no polarisation .","the integration in the variable @xmath39 in eq .","( [ five ] ) has been performed numerically .","the monte - carlo generation of @xmath34 spectra , depending on the temperature , has been performed for all unstable hadrons and resonances up to a mass of 1.8 gev and it has been repeated for temperature values between 140 and 190 mev in steps of 1 mev , so as to have a large enough range of temperatures where to search for minima in a fitting procedure .","for any other temperature value , the spectra have been calculated by means of a linear interpolation .","overall , for hadronic collisions , we have generated about 1200 spectra associated to 144 unstable hadrons for each @xmath14 value .","+ the abundances of all hadrons , which are needed to assess the contribution of secondaries in the spectra of eq .","( [ three ] ) , have been preliminarly set to the model values calculated by fitting the parameters @xmath14 , @xmath40 and or @xmath41 to the experimentally measured yields .","this procedure amounts to exclude the overall normalisation dependence of @xmath42 on @xmath14 in the fit so to keep only its shape dependence on @xmath14 .","+ whilst the @xmath41 parameter has already extensively been used in multiplicity fits @xcite , a new parameter is introduced here for the strangeness suppression .","the particle yields are computed by constraining the number of newly created pairs to fixed integers which fluctuate according to a poissonian distribution .","the mean value of the poissonian distribution , namely the mean value of newly created pairs , is the adjustable fit parameter . for the present , this new parametrisation has been used only for hadronic collisions ( see table 1 ) because collisions present difficulties related to the production of heavy flavoured quarks which makes calculations extremely slow .","the mathematical features of the parametrisation are described in detail in ref .","+ the fitted values , which update those in refs .","@xcite for hadronic and collisions are quoted in table 1 .","the fitted temperature in pp collision in the present analysis is somewhat lower compared with ref .","@xcite owing to an updated set of hadron parameters @xcite , an upgraded procedure of @xmath43 minimisation also taking into account correlations in the effective variance method @xcite , as well as the replacement of @xmath41 with .","the fitted temperature values show a very interesting trend consisting in a slight but significant increase as centre - of - mass energy diminishes ; this is in agreement with the observation pointed out in ref .","@xcite .","contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for @xmath45 @xmath46 spectrum in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev . ]","the collisions and relevant centre - of - mass energies to be analysed have been primarily chosen on the basis of a fairly large number of measured particle yields and spectra .","particle multiplicities are needed to establish with some accuracy the contribution of secondary decays while many identified hadron spectra allow performing a test of universality on the slopes governed by @xmath14 and @xmath11 .","this criterion led to singling out mainly four collision systems for hadronic collisions : k@xmath48p at @xmath49 @xcite and 21.7 gev @xcite , @xmath45p at @xmath50 gev @xcite and pp @xmath51 gev @xcite .","for each identified particle transverse momentum spectrum , three free parameters have been determined by fitting eq .","( [ three ] ) to the data : @xmath14 , @xmath11 and an overall normalisation parameter @xmath52 .","the fits have been performed in the variables @xmath21 or @xmath46 according to the available experimental spectrum ; henceforth , we will denote by @xmath53 both @xmath53 and @xmath54 . as we have mentioned before , overall multiplicities of hadrons in eq .","( [ three ] ) have been fixed to model values by using fit parameters in table 1 .","+ the fit is performed by minimising the following @xmath43 : @xmath55 ^ 2}{\\sigma_i^2}\\ ] ] the errors @xmath56 in the denominator of eq .","( [ chi2 ] ) have been taken as the sum in quadrature of experimental errors and errors arising from the uncertainty on masses , widths and branching ratios of hadrons decaying into the examined hadron , according to the effective variance method ( see ref .","@xcite for a detailed description ) .","plane of @xmath57 for @xmath45p collisions @xmath47 21.7 gev .","the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath60 , @xmath61 , k@xmath62 and @xmath63 .","the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .","the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]","plane of @xmath57 for k@xmath48p collisions @xmath47 21.7 gev .","the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath60 , @xmath61 , k@xmath64 and f@xmath65 .","the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .","the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]","plane of @xmath57 for pp collisions @xmath47 27.4 gev .","the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath45 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath48 , k@xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath61 , and f@xmath65 .","the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .","the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]","once the normalisation parameter @xmath52 is fitted , a study of @xmath43 contour lines is performed in the @xmath44 plane in order to look for possible local minima .","indeed , the presence of several local minima along a band is a quite general feature of the @xmath43 ( see fig .","( [ picont ] ) ) owing to the strong anticorrelation between @xmath14 and @xmath11 .","hence , different solutions are possible for the @xmath68 pair . in order to enforce universality of such parameters among different hadron species","we have chosen a solution for each particle according to the following procedure : 1 .","firstly , we have determined the contour lines of @xmath69 as a function of @xmath14 and @xmath11 by fixing all normalisation parameters to their fitted values , where @xmath6 is the number of different hadron species spectra for a given collision .","the minimisation of the sum of all @xmath43 s amounts to fit a common value of @xmath14 and @xmath11 for all measured hadrons .","secondly , among the different local minima we have chosen the one lying in or closest to the band defined by @xmath14 fitted with average multiplicities along with its error ( see figs .","( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) ) .","finally , all single particle spectrum fits have been repeated seeking a local minimum as close as possible to the previously determined @xmath69 minimum .","it must be noted that this procedure aims at achieving the best agreement between temperatures determined by using different observables , namely particle yields and transverse momentum spectra .","the @xmath69 contour plots are shown in figs .","( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) for the examined collisions .","there is a good agreement between the @xmath14 obtained from multiplicities and the location of minima in the @xmath44 plane . for k@xmath48p and @xmath45p at @xmath50","gev the absolute minimum lies nearly about the centre of the band demonstrating an intriguing correlation between the slope of transverse momentum distributions and the slope of average multiplicities as a function of mass .","moreover , the @xmath11 values turn out to be small , thus justifying the series expansion described in sect . 2 .","conversely , in k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath49 gev a clear disagreement emerges for k@xmath48p at @xmath49 gev between differently determined temperatures ( see fig .","( [ kpcontlow ] ) ) which can be explained with the inadequacy of our used parametrisation at low energy where exact @xmath21 conservation , neglected in the canonical framework , is expected to play a significant role .","contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for @xmath59 and k@xmath60 @xmath46 spectra in k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath47 11.5 gev .","the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .","local minima lie outside the 1-sigma temperature band . ]","measured and fitted spectrum in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev .","the lines lying below the top solid line represent the cumulative contributions to the fitted spectrum of secondary @xmath45 s arising from the decays of doubly and singly strange baryons , other baryons , strange , charged and neutral mesons .","below : residuals distribution . ]","p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . from top to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .","the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]","p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . from top to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .","the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]","27.4 gev . from top","to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .","the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]","the summary plots of the single particle fits are shown in figs .","( [ summagp ] , [ summakp],[summapp ] ) while an example of fitted spectrum in pp collisions is shown in fig .","( [ piplot ] ) .","in general , very good fits ( low @xmath43 s ) are obtained with good agreement between temperatures and average transverse boost velocities fitted for different identified hadrons , especially in pp collisions .","some discrepancies show up in k@xmath48p and @xmath45p collisions where k@xmath71 s seem to have slopes steeper than expected .","it must be noted that error estimates for @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough .","we have also performed a similar analysis for collisions at centre - of - mass energies between 14 and 44 gev . compared with hadronic collisions ,","the analysis of data presents several additional difficulties .","first of all , the production of heavy flavoured hadrons can not be neglected and the inclusion of many more decay channels is implied . a major issue is the fact that @xmath21 is defined with respect to the so - called thrust or event axis .","this direction is not known _ a priori _ , unlike in hadronic collisions where @xmath21 is defined with respect to the beam line , and must be determined on an event by event basis .","hence , whatever the algorithm being used , this very fact introduces a bias on transverse momentum spectra because momenta projection are used to determine the event or thrust axis itself ; often , this is done by just minimising the sum of particle @xmath21 s .","contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for charged tracks @xmath21 or @xmath46 spectra in collisions at four different centre - of - mass energies ranging from 14 to 44 gev .","the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities . for collisions at @xmath47 44 gev ,","local minima lie outside the considered @xmath11 upper bound and the minimum @xmath43 is poor . ] in spite of this problem , we have repeated the same analysis performed for hadronic collisions by using measured charged tracks transverse momentum spectra @xcite with respect to thrust axis .","the @xmath43 contour plots are shown in fig .","( [ eecont ] ) along with @xmath14 bands obtained from multiplicity fits and resulting @xmath43 s minima .","it can be seen that no minimum is found within the band for collisions at @xmath72 gev , a situation looking very similar that found in k@xmath48p collision at @xmath49 gev .","it is also found that fitted @xmath11 increases quite rapidly with centre - of - mass energy reflecting the rise of average @xmath21 of gluon radiation . since our parametrisation of transverse momentum spectra with an average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 requires @xmath11 to be @xmath73 ( see discussion in sect .","2 ) , it is quite natural that fit quality deteriorates as centre - of - mass energy increases .","this is indeed found already at 44 gev where @xmath74 can not longer be considered small .","as energy increases , particle @xmath21 spectra become sensitive to the shape of clusters @xmath75 distribution ( related in turn to radiated gluon @xmath21 spectrum ) and not only to its mean value .","further on , they become dominated by the shape of gluon radiation spectrum whilst hadronisation @xmath21 plays the role of a small superimposed noise .","the analysis of transverse momentum spectra of several identified hadrons , accurately taking into account the effect of hadron decays , indicates that they can be well reproduced within the statistical hadronisation model for several high energy hadronic collisions .","furthermore , a good agreement is found between the temperatures estimated by fits to average particles multiplicities and those extracted by fitting transverse momentum spectra . this can be seen especially by comparing figs .","( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) ; in fact , the location of the best @xmath14 value for transverse momentum spectra , determined by @xmath43 s lowest contour line , is apparently correlated to the best @xmath14 value defined by particle multiplicities as spotted by the vertical band .","indeed , those temperatures move toghether from @xmath76 mev in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev to @xmath77 mev in @xmath45p and k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . in our view",", this finding is a strong indication in favour of one of the key predictions of the statistical hadronisation model , namely the existence of a close relationship between the laws governing the production of particles as a function of their mass and , for each particle species , the production as a function of momentum ( measured in the rest frame of the cluster they belong to ) at the hadronisation .","+ besides this main conclusion , there are many remarks to be made .","first of all , our calculations assumed a canonical framework and so they are expected to have only a limited validity at low centre - of - mass energies where the effect of exact transverse momentum conservation must show up .","indeed , in collisions at a centre - of - mass energy of 14 gev and k@xmath48p collisions at 11.5 gev , a clear disagreement is found between the temperatures determined in the two fashions ( see fig .","( [ kpcontlow ] ) ) . secondly ,","whilst the results obtained in pp collisions for different particles are in very good agreement among them , there are some significant discrepancies between different particles in @xmath45p and k@xmath48p collisions , especially for k@xmath71 s , which are not understood at the present .","finally , it is evident in the analysis of moderately high energy collisions , at @xmath47 44 gev , that our parametrisation of transverse momentum spectra as a function of an average transverse four - velocity alone , is not accurate enough . as the average @xmath21 of radiated gluons and , as a consequence , of hadronising clusters , rises ,","particle spectra are influenced more by the shape of clusters transverse four - velocity spectrum than by primordial hadronisation @xmath21 spectrum so that more accurate calculations are needed involving perturbative qcd to perform such an analysis .","finally , in the very high energy regime , @xmath21 spectra become insensitive to hadronisation and , as a consequence , it is no longer interesting to study its properties . in summary , the presently used parametrisation of @xmath21 spectra is found to work well only in a limited centre - of - mass energy range ( roughly between 20 and 30 gev ) . at lower energies , the study of @xmath21 is still of great interest in probing the statistical features of hadronisation but complex microcanonical calculations are required . at higher energy ,","hadronisation is swamped by hard qcd dynamics in @xmath21 spectra and all it can do is to add a little smearing .","we would like to thank the organizers of the `` correlations and fluctuations '' conference in torino .","we are grateful to u. heinz and u. a. wiedemann for clarifying discussions .","many thanks to j. a. baldry for the careful revision of the manuscript .","this work would have not been possible without the great durham reaction data database ; we wish to express our gratitude to their editors and curators .","e. fermi , progr .","phys . 5 ( 1950 ) 570 .","r. hagedorn , nuovo cimento 15 ( 1960 ) 434 .","f. becattini , z. phys .","c 69 ( 1996 ) 485 .","f. becattini , proc . of xxxiii eloisatron workshop on `` universality features in multihadron production '' ( 1996 ) 74 .","f. becattini and u. heinz , z. phys .","c 76 ( 1997 ) 269 .","r. hagedorn , `` hot hadronic matter : theory and experiment '' ( 1994 ) 13 .","r. hagedorn , riv .","nuovo cimento 6 ( 1984 ) 1983 .","j. sollfrank , p. koch and u. heinz , phys .","b 252 ( 1990 ) 256 .","j. sollfrank , p. koch and u. heinz , z. phys .","c 52 ( 1991 ) 593 .","u. a. wiedemann and u. heinz , phys .","c 56 ( 1997 ) 3265 .","t. peitzmann , nucl .","phys . a 638 ( 1998 ) 415c . for","a description of the model in the canonical approximation see f. becattini , proc . of xi chris engelbrecht summer school `` hadrons in dense matter and hadrosynthesis '' ( 1998 ) 71 .","g. marchesini and b. webber , nucl .","b 238 ( 1984 ) 1 .","f. becattini , l. bellucci and g. passaleva , in preparation .","f. becattini , l. bellucci , g. passaleva , proc . of xxix international symposium on multiparticle dynamics ( 1999 ) 220 .","p. chliapnikov , private communication .","m. aguilar - benitez et al . , z. phys .","c 50 ( 1991 ) 405 .","the durham reaction data database , http://durpdg.dur.ac.uk/hepdata/reac .","particle data book , c. caso et al , eur .","j. c 3 ( 1998 ) 1 .","f. becattini , m. gazdzicki and j. sollfrank , eur .","j. c 5 ( 1998 ) 143",". m. i. gorenstein , m. gazdzicki and w. greiner , phys .","b 483 ( 2000 ) 60 . m. barth et al . , z. phys .","c 22 ( 1984 ) 23 + m. barth et al . , nucl .","b 191 ( 1981 ) 39 . m. adamus et al . , z. phys .","c 35 ( 1987 ) 7 + n.m .","agababyan et al . , z. phys .","c 41 ( 1989 ) 539 + m. adamus et al . , z. phys .","c 39 ( 1988 ) 311 + i.v .","azhinenko et al .",", z. phys .","c 46 ( 1990 ) 525 . m. adamus et al . , z. phys .","c 35 ( 1987 ) 7 + n.m .","agababyan et al . , z. phys .","c 46 ( 1990 ) 387 + m. adamus et al . , z. phys .","c 39 ( 1988 ) 311 + i.v .","azhinenko et al . , z. phys .","c 46 ( 1990 ) 525 .","m. aguilar - benitez et al . , z. phys .","c 50 ( 1991 ) 405 ; numerical values of @xmath21 spectra can be found in durham reaction data database @xcite + a. suzuki , lett .","nuovo cimento 24 ( 1979 ) 31 .","m. althoff et al . ,","tasso coll .",". c 22 ( 1984 ) 307 + d. bender et al . ,","d 31 ( 1985 ) 1 + w. braunschweig et al .",", tasso coll .",", z. phys .","c 47 ( 1990 ) 187 ."],"string":"[\n \"the idea of a statistical approach to hadron production in high energy collisions dates back to 50s @xcite and 60s @xcite and it has been recently revived by the observation that hadron multiplicities in collisions agree very well with a thermodynamical - like ansatz @xcite .\",\n \"this finding has also been confirmed in hadronic collisions and it has been interpreted in terms of a pure statistical filling of multi - hadronic phase space of assumed pre - hadronic clusters ( or fireballs ) formed in high - energy collisions , at a critical value of energy density @xcite . in this framework , temperature and other thermodynamical quantities have a statistical meaning which does not entail the existence of a thermalised hadronic system on an event - by - event basis .\",\n \"stated otherwise , statistical equilibrium shows up only when comparing many different events , whilst in each of them the gibbs law of equally likely multi - hadronic states applies .\",\n \"so far , this proposed statistical cluster hadronisation model has been mainly tested against measured abundances of different hadron species for a twofold reason .\",\n \"firstly , unlike momentum spectra , they are quantities which are not affected by hard ( perturbative ) qcd dynamical effects but are only determined by the hadronisation process ; indeed , in the framework of a multi - cluster model , they are lorentz - invariant quantities which are independent of the cluster s overall momentum .\",\n \"secondly , they are quite easy to calculate and provide a very sensitive test of the model yielding an accurate determination of the temperature . however , in order to establish the validity of this approach , it is necessary to test further observables and to assess their consistency with the results obtained for multiplicities .\",\n \"certainly , one of the best suited observables is the transverse momentum of identified hadrons , where transverse is meant to be with respect to beam line in high energy hadronic collision , and thrust or event axis in high energy collisions .\",\n \"indeed , such projection of particle momentum is supposed to be the most sensitive to hadronisation or , conversely , the least sensitive to perturbative qcd dynamics .\",\n \"+ actually , it has been known for a long time that transverse momentum distributions are boltzmann - like in hadronic collisions and this very observation was pointed out by hagedorn as a major indication in favour of his statistical model of hadron production @xcite .\",\n \"it must be emphasized that the prediction of a thermal - like shape in principle only applies to particles directly emitted from the hadronising source , whereas measured spectra also include particles produced by decays of heavier hadrons .\",\n \"however , most analyses do not take into account the distortion of primordial hadronisation spectrum due the to hadronic decay chain and try to fit the data straight through it .\",\n \"this problem has been discussed in literature @xcite and an analytical calculation has been developed to take into account the effect of two and three body decays @xcite , which has then been used both for pp @xcite and heavy ion collision @xcite including most abundant resonances . in this paper\",\n \"we introduce a method allowing to rigorously and exhaustively determine the contribution of all particle decays .\",\n \"hence , by taking advantage of this technique , we have performed an analysis of many measured transverse momentum spectra of identified hadrons in a wide range of centre - of - mass energies for several kind of collisions .\",\n \"the statistical hadronisation model @xcite assumes that in high energy collisions , as a consequence of strong interaction dynamics , a set of colourless clusters ( or fireballs ) is formed having certain values of mass , volume , internal quantum numbers and momentum , the latter being inherited from the hard stage of the process .\",\n \"those clusters are assumed to give rise to hadrons according to a pure statistical law in the multi - hadronic phase space defined by their mass , volume and quantum numbers .\",\n \"this approach differs from another popular cluster hadronisation model @xcite mainly because it gives clusters a volume so that hadron production is ruled by the properly understood phase space rather than relativistic momentum space . in this framework\",\n \", the use of statistical mechanics and thermodynamical quantities , such as temperature , which need spacial dimension besides momentum space in order to be meaningful , is allowed .\",\n \"we emphasize once more that the introduction of such quantities does not entail any thermalisation process of hadrons after their formation , nor the existence of a thermalised system event by event . +\",\n \"although many clusters with different momenta , volumes , masses and quantum numbers are formed , it can be shown that the average values of many observables , e. g. particle multiplicites , are the same as those relevant to one equivalent cluster having suitable values of volume ( namely the sum of all cluster volumes measured in the rest frame of the equivalent cluster itself ) , mass and quantum numbers ( namely the sum of all cluster quantum numbers ) .\",\n \"the proof of this statement @xcite , a lengthy one , requires the assumption of special probabilities governing the fluctuations of cluster masses and quantum numbers for a given set of volumes .\",\n \"if the volume ( or mass ) of the equivalent cluster is large enough , it is then reasonable to take a canonical approach ( i.e. introducing a temperature ) in order to calculate mean quantities , instead of carrying out an involved microcanonical calculation .\",\n \"therefore , even though actual clusters are small sized and microcanonical calculations would be needed to determine mean quantities within each of them , the choice of suitable mass fluctuation probabilities for the clusters allows one to calculate overall means dealing with only one large global structure and with much fewer parameters . arguing the other way around , it is not difficult to be convinced that the fluctuation probabilities to be chosen in order to achieve such reduction of the problem are exactly the same as those of obtaining a given set of masses by splitting a large cluster into a given number of clusters with volumes @xmath2 .\",\n \"this statement extends a reduction procedure to the microcanonical case which was proved in the canonical case @xcite , where , from the very beginning , clusters were given temperature and volume instead of mass and volume .\",\n \"nevertheless , it is not obvious how large the equivalent cluster should be for the canonical approximation to apply . for the present\",\n \", we have adopted a simple - minded _ a posteriori _ method consisting in justifying the canonical framework by its capability of accordance with the data .\",\n \"a simple argument to support the canonical approximation even at moderate values of volumes is the very large number of states ( @xmath3 ) , i.e. hadrons and resonances , which can be excited in a hadron gas . +\",\n \"as far as single - particle transverse momentum spectra are concerned , a similar reduction theorem from many clusters to one equivalent cluster in the averaging procedure applies @xcite , though only approximately . in general\",\n \", it can be shown that the _ primary _ spectrum of @xmath4 hadron species depends on transverse four - velocities @xmath5 with vanishing longitudinal component . ] of the @xmath6 clusters : @xmath7 \\\\ ; f(u_{t1},\\\\ldots , u_{tn } ) \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\times \\\\ ; \\\\sum_{i=1}^n \\\\frac{\\\\d n_j}{\\\\d p_t}\\\\vl_{i}(\\\\ui ) \\\\ , .\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath8 is the transverse four - velocities distribution function .\",\n \"if one expands all single - cluster spectra @xmath9 in series of @xmath10 starting from a common value @xmath11 for all clusters , it can be proved that , at the zeroth order , the spectrum in eq .\",\n \"( [ one ] ) becomes the same as that obtained for the aforementioned equivalent cluster , endowed with a tranverse four - velocity @xmath11 .\",\n \"this reduction possibly allows taking the canonical approach in order to calculate the transverse momentum spectrum since the equivalent cluster size is much larger than single cluster s : @xmath12 where @xmath13 , @xmath14 is the temperature , and @xmath15 , @xmath16 are modified bessel functions .\",\n \"( [ two ] ) is the boltzmann limit of quantum statistics and it is a very good approximation for all hadrons except pions @xcite . for the zeroth order approximation in the @xmath10 expansion to be sufficiently accurate , the involved transverse four - velocities should be small , i.e. @xmath17 already for @xmath18 . since it is possible to choose the starting point @xmath11 of the series expansion to make the first order term vanishing @xcite , the largest neglected term turns out to be @xmath19 which is very small provided that the aforementioned condition on @xmath20 is met .\",\n \"the analysis presented in this paper assumes the validity of this approximation and primary spectra have been calculated according to eq .\",\n \"( [ two ] ) . +\",\n \"even though eq .\",\n \"( [ two ] ) looks like the spectrum from a thermalised source with a superimposed flow , a popular formula in the heavy - ion community , it is well worth emphasizing that in fact this formula has nothing to do with flow .\",\n \"indeed , the average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 is not meant to be the mean value of cluster velocity distribution in a single event ; rather , it is the average transverse four - velocity of all clusters over all collision events . in other words ,\",\n \"@xmath11 may well arise from single clusters emitted at high @xmath21 in some events , e.g. following a hard parton scattering , and does not imply by any means a collective event - by - event expansion .\",\n \"gev @xcite .\",\n \"the measured @xmath22 spectra ( above ) have been normalised so as to have the same value at @xmath23 .\",\n \"while slopes of @xmath22 spectra are different , those of @xmath24 ( below ) are approximately the same for all identified particles . ]\",\n \"a peculiar prediction of a statistical picture in high energy collisions which is relevant to transverse momentum spectra is the so - called @xmath25 scaling : there should be an apparent common slope for @xmath26 spectra of identified hadrons at a given centre - of - mass energy . by looking at eq .\",\n \"( [ two ] ) one can easily realize that this holds in the limit @xmath27 . in principle\",\n \", @xmath25 scaling applies only to primary hadrons , namely those directly emitted from the hadronising source . on the other hand , as stated in sect .\",\n \"1 , most observed or reconstructed particles in experiments arise from decays of heavier hadrons .\",\n \"those secondary decays may well distort the primary spectrum shape , thus spoling @xmath25 scaling .\",\n \"nevertheless , it can be seen in fig .\",\n \"( [ mtslope ] ) that @xmath25 scaling apparently also holds for measured final hadrons , at least in the examined collision , implying seemingly little distortion from primary to final spectrum . settling this and\",\n \"other related issues demands a thorough analysis taking into account the effect of decays .\",\n \"therefore , measured @xmath21 spectrum of the @xmath4 hadron species should be compared with the sum of its primary spectrum and the contribution arising from all heavier hadrons decaying into it : @xmath28 whilst @xmath29 is given by eq .\",\n \"( [ two ] ) , the calculation of the second term in the right hand side of eq .\",\n \"( [ three ] ) within a statistical - thermal framework is a very complicated problem as the number of contributing resonances and decay modes is huge and also owing the presence of cascade decays ( e.g. @xmath30 ) . in refs .\",\n \"@xcite an analytical approach has been taken including two and three body decays of directly emitted resonances .\",\n \"on the other hand , we have adopted @xcite a mixed numerical - analytical method which allows a very accurate and exhaustive calculation .\",\n \"our method can be summarised as follows : for any couple of hadrons @xmath31 , where @xmath32 decays into @xmath33 , either directly or through a cascade process , we have determined the momentum spectrum @xmath34 in the equivalent cluster s rest frame via a monte - carlo method by randomly generating 200,000 @xmath32 s decays , according to phase space , by picking @xmath32 s three - momenta from a thermal distribution with a given temperature @xmath14 : @xmath35 then , we have boosted the obtained @xmath34 distributions in order to compute the @xmath36 for a given transverse four - velocity @xmath11 of the equivalent cluster , to be plugged into eq .\",\n \"( [ three ] ) , with an integral formula derived by the authors @xcite : @xmath37 where f is the elliptic integral of the first kind and : @xmath38 [ cols=\\\"<,<,<,<,<,<\\\",options=\\\"header \\\" , ] + the main advantage of formula ( [ five ] ) is to allow a quick computation of transverse momentum spectra associated with particle decays for any tranverse four - velocity once the corresponding momentum spectra at zero velocity are known . to obtain it\",\n \", we took advantage of the isotropy of @xmath34 distributions , which holds as long as decay products distribution is isotropic , which is true for simple phase - space decays with no polarisation .\",\n \"the integration in the variable @xmath39 in eq .\",\n \"( [ five ] ) has been performed numerically .\",\n \"the monte - carlo generation of @xmath34 spectra , depending on the temperature , has been performed for all unstable hadrons and resonances up to a mass of 1.8 gev and it has been repeated for temperature values between 140 and 190 mev in steps of 1 mev , so as to have a large enough range of temperatures where to search for minima in a fitting procedure .\",\n \"for any other temperature value , the spectra have been calculated by means of a linear interpolation .\",\n \"overall , for hadronic collisions , we have generated about 1200 spectra associated to 144 unstable hadrons for each @xmath14 value .\",\n \"+ the abundances of all hadrons , which are needed to assess the contribution of secondaries in the spectra of eq .\",\n \"( [ three ] ) , have been preliminarly set to the model values calculated by fitting the parameters @xmath14 , @xmath40 and or @xmath41 to the experimentally measured yields .\",\n \"this procedure amounts to exclude the overall normalisation dependence of @xmath42 on @xmath14 in the fit so to keep only its shape dependence on @xmath14 .\",\n \"+ whilst the @xmath41 parameter has already extensively been used in multiplicity fits @xcite , a new parameter is introduced here for the strangeness suppression .\",\n \"the particle yields are computed by constraining the number of newly created pairs to fixed integers which fluctuate according to a poissonian distribution .\",\n \"the mean value of the poissonian distribution , namely the mean value of newly created pairs , is the adjustable fit parameter . for the present , this new parametrisation has been used only for hadronic collisions ( see table 1 ) because collisions present difficulties related to the production of heavy flavoured quarks which makes calculations extremely slow .\",\n \"the mathematical features of the parametrisation are described in detail in ref .\",\n \"+ the fitted values , which update those in refs .\",\n \"@xcite for hadronic and collisions are quoted in table 1 .\",\n \"the fitted temperature in pp collision in the present analysis is somewhat lower compared with ref .\",\n \"@xcite owing to an updated set of hadron parameters @xcite , an upgraded procedure of @xmath43 minimisation also taking into account correlations in the effective variance method @xcite , as well as the replacement of @xmath41 with .\",\n \"the fitted temperature values show a very interesting trend consisting in a slight but significant increase as centre - of - mass energy diminishes ; this is in agreement with the observation pointed out in ref .\",\n \"@xcite .\",\n \"contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for @xmath45 @xmath46 spectrum in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev . ]\",\n \"the collisions and relevant centre - of - mass energies to be analysed have been primarily chosen on the basis of a fairly large number of measured particle yields and spectra .\",\n \"particle multiplicities are needed to establish with some accuracy the contribution of secondary decays while many identified hadron spectra allow performing a test of universality on the slopes governed by @xmath14 and @xmath11 .\",\n \"this criterion led to singling out mainly four collision systems for hadronic collisions : k@xmath48p at @xmath49 @xcite and 21.7 gev @xcite , @xmath45p at @xmath50 gev @xcite and pp @xmath51 gev @xcite .\",\n \"for each identified particle transverse momentum spectrum , three free parameters have been determined by fitting eq .\",\n \"( [ three ] ) to the data : @xmath14 , @xmath11 and an overall normalisation parameter @xmath52 .\",\n \"the fits have been performed in the variables @xmath21 or @xmath46 according to the available experimental spectrum ; henceforth , we will denote by @xmath53 both @xmath53 and @xmath54 . as we have mentioned before , overall multiplicities of hadrons in eq .\",\n \"( [ three ] ) have been fixed to model values by using fit parameters in table 1 .\",\n \"+ the fit is performed by minimising the following @xmath43 : @xmath55 ^ 2}{\\\\sigma_i^2}\\\\ ] ] the errors @xmath56 in the denominator of eq .\",\n \"( [ chi2 ] ) have been taken as the sum in quadrature of experimental errors and errors arising from the uncertainty on masses , widths and branching ratios of hadrons decaying into the examined hadron , according to the effective variance method ( see ref .\",\n \"@xcite for a detailed description ) .\",\n \"plane of @xmath57 for @xmath45p collisions @xmath47 21.7 gev .\",\n \"the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath60 , @xmath61 , k@xmath62 and @xmath63 .\",\n \"the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .\",\n \"the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]\",\n \"plane of @xmath57 for k@xmath48p collisions @xmath47 21.7 gev .\",\n \"the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath60 , @xmath61 , k@xmath64 and f@xmath65 .\",\n \"the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .\",\n \"the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]\",\n \"plane of @xmath57 for pp collisions @xmath47 27.4 gev .\",\n \"the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath45 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath48 , k@xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath61 , and f@xmath65 .\",\n \"the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .\",\n \"the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]\",\n \"once the normalisation parameter @xmath52 is fitted , a study of @xmath43 contour lines is performed in the @xmath44 plane in order to look for possible local minima .\",\n \"indeed , the presence of several local minima along a band is a quite general feature of the @xmath43 ( see fig .\",\n \"( [ picont ] ) ) owing to the strong anticorrelation between @xmath14 and @xmath11 .\",\n \"hence , different solutions are possible for the @xmath68 pair . in order to enforce universality of such parameters among different hadron species\",\n \"we have chosen a solution for each particle according to the following procedure : 1 .\",\n \"firstly , we have determined the contour lines of @xmath69 as a function of @xmath14 and @xmath11 by fixing all normalisation parameters to their fitted values , where @xmath6 is the number of different hadron species spectra for a given collision .\",\n \"the minimisation of the sum of all @xmath43 s amounts to fit a common value of @xmath14 and @xmath11 for all measured hadrons .\",\n \"secondly , among the different local minima we have chosen the one lying in or closest to the band defined by @xmath14 fitted with average multiplicities along with its error ( see figs .\",\n \"( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) ) .\",\n \"finally , all single particle spectrum fits have been repeated seeking a local minimum as close as possible to the previously determined @xmath69 minimum .\",\n \"it must be noted that this procedure aims at achieving the best agreement between temperatures determined by using different observables , namely particle yields and transverse momentum spectra .\",\n \"the @xmath69 contour plots are shown in figs .\",\n \"( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) for the examined collisions .\",\n \"there is a good agreement between the @xmath14 obtained from multiplicities and the location of minima in the @xmath44 plane . for k@xmath48p and @xmath45p at @xmath50\",\n \"gev the absolute minimum lies nearly about the centre of the band demonstrating an intriguing correlation between the slope of transverse momentum distributions and the slope of average multiplicities as a function of mass .\",\n \"moreover , the @xmath11 values turn out to be small , thus justifying the series expansion described in sect . 2 .\",\n \"conversely , in k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath49 gev a clear disagreement emerges for k@xmath48p at @xmath49 gev between differently determined temperatures ( see fig .\",\n \"( [ kpcontlow ] ) ) which can be explained with the inadequacy of our used parametrisation at low energy where exact @xmath21 conservation , neglected in the canonical framework , is expected to play a significant role .\",\n \"contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for @xmath59 and k@xmath60 @xmath46 spectra in k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath47 11.5 gev .\",\n \"the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .\",\n \"local minima lie outside the 1-sigma temperature band . ]\",\n \"measured and fitted spectrum in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev .\",\n \"the lines lying below the top solid line represent the cumulative contributions to the fitted spectrum of secondary @xmath45 s arising from the decays of doubly and singly strange baryons , other baryons , strange , charged and neutral mesons .\",\n \"below : residuals distribution . ]\",\n \"p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . from top to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .\",\n \"the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]\",\n \"p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . from top to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .\",\n \"the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]\",\n \"27.4 gev . from top\",\n \"to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .\",\n \"the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]\",\n \"the summary plots of the single particle fits are shown in figs .\",\n \"( [ summagp ] , [ summakp],[summapp ] ) while an example of fitted spectrum in pp collisions is shown in fig .\",\n \"( [ piplot ] ) .\",\n \"in general , very good fits ( low @xmath43 s ) are obtained with good agreement between temperatures and average transverse boost velocities fitted for different identified hadrons , especially in pp collisions .\",\n \"some discrepancies show up in k@xmath48p and @xmath45p collisions where k@xmath71 s seem to have slopes steeper than expected .\",\n \"it must be noted that error estimates for @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough .\",\n \"we have also performed a similar analysis for collisions at centre - of - mass energies between 14 and 44 gev . compared with hadronic collisions ,\",\n \"the analysis of data presents several additional difficulties .\",\n \"first of all , the production of heavy flavoured hadrons can not be neglected and the inclusion of many more decay channels is implied . a major issue is the fact that @xmath21 is defined with respect to the so - called thrust or event axis .\",\n \"this direction is not known _ a priori _ , unlike in hadronic collisions where @xmath21 is defined with respect to the beam line , and must be determined on an event by event basis .\",\n \"hence , whatever the algorithm being used , this very fact introduces a bias on transverse momentum spectra because momenta projection are used to determine the event or thrust axis itself ; often , this is done by just minimising the sum of particle @xmath21 s .\",\n \"contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for charged tracks @xmath21 or @xmath46 spectra in collisions at four different centre - of - mass energies ranging from 14 to 44 gev .\",\n \"the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities . for collisions at @xmath47 44 gev ,\",\n \"local minima lie outside the considered @xmath11 upper bound and the minimum @xmath43 is poor . ] in spite of this problem , we have repeated the same analysis performed for hadronic collisions by using measured charged tracks transverse momentum spectra @xcite with respect to thrust axis .\",\n \"the @xmath43 contour plots are shown in fig .\",\n \"( [ eecont ] ) along with @xmath14 bands obtained from multiplicity fits and resulting @xmath43 s minima .\",\n \"it can be seen that no minimum is found within the band for collisions at @xmath72 gev , a situation looking very similar that found in k@xmath48p collision at @xmath49 gev .\",\n \"it is also found that fitted @xmath11 increases quite rapidly with centre - of - mass energy reflecting the rise of average @xmath21 of gluon radiation . since our parametrisation of transverse momentum spectra with an average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 requires @xmath11 to be @xmath73 ( see discussion in sect .\",\n \"2 ) , it is quite natural that fit quality deteriorates as centre - of - mass energy increases .\",\n \"this is indeed found already at 44 gev where @xmath74 can not longer be considered small .\",\n \"as energy increases , particle @xmath21 spectra become sensitive to the shape of clusters @xmath75 distribution ( related in turn to radiated gluon @xmath21 spectrum ) and not only to its mean value .\",\n \"further on , they become dominated by the shape of gluon radiation spectrum whilst hadronisation @xmath21 plays the role of a small superimposed noise .\",\n \"the analysis of transverse momentum spectra of several identified hadrons , accurately taking into account the effect of hadron decays , indicates that they can be well reproduced within the statistical hadronisation model for several high energy hadronic collisions .\",\n \"furthermore , a good agreement is found between the temperatures estimated by fits to average particles multiplicities and those extracted by fitting transverse momentum spectra . this can be seen especially by comparing figs .\",\n \"( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) ; in fact , the location of the best @xmath14 value for transverse momentum spectra , determined by @xmath43 s lowest contour line , is apparently correlated to the best @xmath14 value defined by particle multiplicities as spotted by the vertical band .\",\n \"indeed , those temperatures move toghether from @xmath76 mev in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev to @xmath77 mev in @xmath45p and k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . in our view\",\n \", this finding is a strong indication in favour of one of the key predictions of the statistical hadronisation model , namely the existence of a close relationship between the laws governing the production of particles as a function of their mass and , for each particle species , the production as a function of momentum ( measured in the rest frame of the cluster they belong to ) at the hadronisation .\",\n \"+ besides this main conclusion , there are many remarks to be made .\",\n \"first of all , our calculations assumed a canonical framework and so they are expected to have only a limited validity at low centre - of - mass energies where the effect of exact transverse momentum conservation must show up .\",\n \"indeed , in collisions at a centre - of - mass energy of 14 gev and k@xmath48p collisions at 11.5 gev , a clear disagreement is found between the temperatures determined in the two fashions ( see fig .\",\n \"( [ kpcontlow ] ) ) . secondly ,\",\n \"whilst the results obtained in pp collisions for different particles are in very good agreement among them , there are some significant discrepancies between different particles in @xmath45p and k@xmath48p collisions , especially for k@xmath71 s , which are not understood at the present .\",\n \"finally , it is evident in the analysis of moderately high energy collisions , at @xmath47 44 gev , that our parametrisation of transverse momentum spectra as a function of an average transverse four - velocity alone , is not accurate enough . as the average @xmath21 of radiated gluons and , as a consequence , of hadronising clusters , rises ,\",\n \"particle spectra are influenced more by the shape of clusters transverse four - velocity spectrum than by primordial hadronisation @xmath21 spectrum so that more accurate calculations are needed involving perturbative qcd to perform such an analysis .\",\n \"finally , in the very high energy regime , @xmath21 spectra become insensitive to hadronisation and , as a consequence , it is no longer interesting to study its properties . in summary , the presently used parametrisation of @xmath21 spectra is found to work well only in a limited centre - of - mass energy range ( roughly between 20 and 30 gev ) . at lower energies , the study of @xmath21 is still of great interest in probing the statistical features of hadronisation but complex microcanonical calculations are required . at higher energy ,\",\n \"hadronisation is swamped by hard qcd dynamics in @xmath21 spectra and all it can do is to add a little smearing .\",\n \"we would like to thank the organizers of the `` correlations and fluctuations '' conference in torino .\",\n \"we are grateful to u. heinz and u. a. wiedemann for clarifying discussions .\",\n \"many thanks to j. a. baldry for the careful revision of the manuscript .\",\n \"this work would have not been possible without the great durham reaction data database ; we wish to express our gratitude to their editors and curators .\",\n \"e. fermi , progr .\",\n \"phys . 5 ( 1950 ) 570 .\",\n \"r. hagedorn , nuovo cimento 15 ( 1960 ) 434 .\",\n \"f. becattini , z. phys .\",\n \"c 69 ( 1996 ) 485 .\",\n \"f. becattini , proc . of xxxiii eloisatron workshop on `` universality features in multihadron production '' ( 1996 ) 74 .\",\n \"f. becattini and u. heinz , z. phys .\",\n \"c 76 ( 1997 ) 269 .\",\n \"r. hagedorn , `` hot hadronic matter : theory and experiment '' ( 1994 ) 13 .\",\n \"r. hagedorn , riv .\",\n \"nuovo cimento 6 ( 1984 ) 1983 .\",\n \"j. sollfrank , p. koch and u. heinz , phys .\",\n \"b 252 ( 1990 ) 256 .\",\n \"j. sollfrank , p. koch and u. heinz , z. phys .\",\n \"c 52 ( 1991 ) 593 .\",\n \"u. a. wiedemann and u. heinz , phys .\",\n \"c 56 ( 1997 ) 3265 .\",\n \"t. peitzmann , nucl .\",\n \"phys . a 638 ( 1998 ) 415c . for\",\n \"a description of the model in the canonical approximation see f. becattini , proc . of xi chris engelbrecht summer school `` hadrons in dense matter and hadrosynthesis '' ( 1998 ) 71 .\",\n \"g. marchesini and b. webber , nucl .\",\n \"b 238 ( 1984 ) 1 .\",\n \"f. becattini , l. bellucci and g. passaleva , in preparation .\",\n \"f. becattini , l. bellucci , g. passaleva , proc . of xxix international symposium on multiparticle dynamics ( 1999 ) 220 .\",\n \"p. chliapnikov , private communication .\",\n \"m. aguilar - benitez et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 50 ( 1991 ) 405 .\",\n \"the durham reaction data database , http://durpdg.dur.ac.uk/hepdata/reac .\",\n \"particle data book , c. caso et al , eur .\",\n \"j. c 3 ( 1998 ) 1 .\",\n \"f. becattini , m. gazdzicki and j. sollfrank , eur .\",\n \"j. c 5 ( 1998 ) 143\",\n \". m. i. gorenstein , m. gazdzicki and w. greiner , phys .\",\n \"b 483 ( 2000 ) 60 . m. barth et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 22 ( 1984 ) 23 + m. barth et al . , nucl .\",\n \"b 191 ( 1981 ) 39 . m. adamus et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 35 ( 1987 ) 7 + n.m .\",\n \"agababyan et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 41 ( 1989 ) 539 + m. adamus et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 39 ( 1988 ) 311 + i.v .\",\n \"azhinenko et al .\",\n \", z. phys .\",\n \"c 46 ( 1990 ) 525 . m. adamus et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 35 ( 1987 ) 7 + n.m .\",\n \"agababyan et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 46 ( 1990 ) 387 + m. adamus et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 39 ( 1988 ) 311 + i.v .\",\n \"azhinenko et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 46 ( 1990 ) 525 .\",\n \"m. aguilar - benitez et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 50 ( 1991 ) 405 ; numerical values of @xmath21 spectra can be found in durham reaction data database @xcite + a. suzuki , lett .\",\n \"nuovo cimento 24 ( 1979 ) 31 .\",\n \"m. althoff et al . ,\",\n \"tasso coll .\",\n \". c 22 ( 1984 ) 307 + d. bender et al . ,\",\n \"d 31 ( 1985 ) 1 + w. braunschweig et al .\",\n \", tasso coll .\",\n \", z. phys .\",\n \"c 47 ( 1990 ) 187 .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> a detailed analysis is performed of transverse momentum spectra of several identified hadrons in high energy collisions within the framework of the statistical model of hadronisation . </S>","<S> the effect of the decay chain following hadron generation is accurately taken into account . </S>","<S> the considered centre - of - mass energies range from @xmath0 10 to 30 gev in hadronic collisions ( @xmath1p , pp and kp ) and from @xmath0 15 to 45 gev in collisions . </S>","<S> a clear consistency is found between the temperature parameter extracted from the present analysis and that obtained from fits to average hadron multiplicities in the same collision systems . </S>","<S> this finding indicates that in the hadronisation , the production of different particle species and their momentum spectra are two closely related phenomenons governed by one parameter . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> a detailed analysis is performed of transverse momentum spectra of several identified hadrons in high energy collisions within the framework of the statistical model of hadronisation . </S>\",\n \"<S> the effect of the decay chain following hadron generation is accurately taken into account . </S>\",\n \"<S> the considered centre - of - mass energies range from @xmath0 10 to 30 gev in hadronic collisions ( @xmath1p , pp and kp ) and from @xmath0 15 to 45 gev in collisions . </S>\",\n \"<S> a clear consistency is found between the temperature parameter extracted from the present analysis and that obtained from fits to average hadron multiplicities in the same collision systems . </S>\",\n \"<S> this finding indicates that in the hadronisation , the production of different particle species and their momentum spectra are two closely related phenomenons governed by one parameter . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","statistical hadronisation and transverse momentum spectra","method of data analysis","data set and results for hadronic collisions","results for collisions","discussion and conclusions","acknowledgments"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"statistical hadronisation and transverse momentum spectra\",\n \"method of data analysis\",\n \"data set and results for hadronic collisions\",\n \"results for collisions\",\n \"discussion and conclusions\",\n \"acknowledgments\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["the idea of a statistical approach to hadron production in high energy collisions dates back to 50s @xcite and 60s @xcite and it has been recently revived by the observation that hadron multiplicities in collisions agree very well with a thermodynamical - like ansatz @xcite .","this finding has also been confirmed in hadronic collisions and it has been interpreted in terms of a pure statistical filling of multi - hadronic phase space of assumed pre - hadronic clusters ( or fireballs ) formed in high - energy collisions , at a critical value of energy density @xcite . in this framework , temperature and other thermodynamical quantities have a statistical meaning which does not entail the existence of a thermalised hadronic system on an event - by - event basis .","stated otherwise , statistical equilibrium shows up only when comparing many different events , whilst in each of them the gibbs law of equally likely multi - hadronic states applies .","so far , this proposed statistical cluster hadronisation model has been mainly tested against measured abundances of different hadron species for a twofold reason .","firstly , unlike momentum spectra , they are quantities which are not affected by hard ( perturbative ) qcd dynamical effects but are only determined by the hadronisation process ; indeed , in the framework of a multi - cluster model , they are lorentz - invariant quantities which are independent of the cluster s overall momentum .","secondly , they are quite easy to calculate and provide a very sensitive test of the model yielding an accurate determination of the temperature . however , in order to establish the validity of this approach , it is necessary to test further observables and to assess their consistency with the results obtained for multiplicities .","certainly , one of the best suited observables is the transverse momentum of identified hadrons , where transverse is meant to be with respect to beam line in high energy hadronic collision , and thrust or event axis in high energy collisions .","indeed , such projection of particle momentum is supposed to be the most sensitive to hadronisation or , conversely , the least sensitive to perturbative qcd dynamics .","+ actually , it has been known for a long time that transverse momentum distributions are boltzmann - like in hadronic collisions and this very observation was pointed out by hagedorn as a major indication in favour of his statistical model of hadron production @xcite .","it must be emphasized that the prediction of a thermal - like shape in principle only applies to particles directly emitted from the hadronising source , whereas measured spectra also include particles produced by decays of heavier hadrons .","however , most analyses do not take into account the distortion of primordial hadronisation spectrum due the to hadronic decay chain and try to fit the data straight through it .","this problem has been discussed in literature @xcite and an analytical calculation has been developed to take into account the effect of two and three body decays @xcite , which has then been used both for pp @xcite and heavy ion collision @xcite including most abundant resonances . in this paper","we introduce a method allowing to rigorously and exhaustively determine the contribution of all particle decays .","hence , by taking advantage of this technique , we have performed an analysis of many measured transverse momentum spectra of identified hadrons in a wide range of centre - of - mass energies for several kind of collisions ."],["the statistical hadronisation model @xcite assumes that in high energy collisions , as a consequence of strong interaction dynamics , a set of colourless clusters ( or fireballs ) is formed having certain values of mass , volume , internal quantum numbers and momentum , the latter being inherited from the hard stage of the process .","those clusters are assumed to give rise to hadrons according to a pure statistical law in the multi - hadronic phase space defined by their mass , volume and quantum numbers .","this approach differs from another popular cluster hadronisation model @xcite mainly because it gives clusters a volume so that hadron production is ruled by the properly understood phase space rather than relativistic momentum space . in this framework",", the use of statistical mechanics and thermodynamical quantities , such as temperature , which need spacial dimension besides momentum space in order to be meaningful , is allowed .","we emphasize once more that the introduction of such quantities does not entail any thermalisation process of hadrons after their formation , nor the existence of a thermalised system event by event . +","although many clusters with different momenta , volumes , masses and quantum numbers are formed , it can be shown that the average values of many observables , e. g. particle multiplicites , are the same as those relevant to one equivalent cluster having suitable values of volume ( namely the sum of all cluster volumes measured in the rest frame of the equivalent cluster itself ) , mass and quantum numbers ( namely the sum of all cluster quantum numbers ) .","the proof of this statement @xcite , a lengthy one , requires the assumption of special probabilities governing the fluctuations of cluster masses and quantum numbers for a given set of volumes .","if the volume ( or mass ) of the equivalent cluster is large enough , it is then reasonable to take a canonical approach ( i.e. introducing a temperature ) in order to calculate mean quantities , instead of carrying out an involved microcanonical calculation .","therefore , even though actual clusters are small sized and microcanonical calculations would be needed to determine mean quantities within each of them , the choice of suitable mass fluctuation probabilities for the clusters allows one to calculate overall means dealing with only one large global structure and with much fewer parameters . arguing the other way around , it is not difficult to be convinced that the fluctuation probabilities to be chosen in order to achieve such reduction of the problem are exactly the same as those of obtaining a given set of masses by splitting a large cluster into a given number of clusters with volumes @xmath2 .","this statement extends a reduction procedure to the microcanonical case which was proved in the canonical case @xcite , where , from the very beginning , clusters were given temperature and volume instead of mass and volume .","nevertheless , it is not obvious how large the equivalent cluster should be for the canonical approximation to apply . for the present",", we have adopted a simple - minded _ a posteriori _ method consisting in justifying the canonical framework by its capability of accordance with the data .","a simple argument to support the canonical approximation even at moderate values of volumes is the very large number of states ( @xmath3 ) , i.e. hadrons and resonances , which can be excited in a hadron gas . +","as far as single - particle transverse momentum spectra are concerned , a similar reduction theorem from many clusters to one equivalent cluster in the averaging procedure applies @xcite , though only approximately . in general",", it can be shown that the _ primary _ spectrum of @xmath4 hadron species depends on transverse four - velocities @xmath5 with vanishing longitudinal component . ] of the @xmath6 clusters : @xmath7 \\ ; f(u_{t1},\\ldots , u_{tn } ) \\nonumber \\\\ & & \\times \\ ; \\sum_{i=1}^n \\frac{\\d n_j}{\\d p_t}\\vl_{i}(\\ui ) \\ , .\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] where @xmath8 is the transverse four - velocities distribution function .","if one expands all single - cluster spectra @xmath9 in series of @xmath10 starting from a common value @xmath11 for all clusters , it can be proved that , at the zeroth order , the spectrum in eq .","( [ one ] ) becomes the same as that obtained for the aforementioned equivalent cluster , endowed with a tranverse four - velocity @xmath11 .","this reduction possibly allows taking the canonical approach in order to calculate the transverse momentum spectrum since the equivalent cluster size is much larger than single cluster s : @xmath12 where @xmath13 , @xmath14 is the temperature , and @xmath15 , @xmath16 are modified bessel functions .","( [ two ] ) is the boltzmann limit of quantum statistics and it is a very good approximation for all hadrons except pions @xcite . for the zeroth order approximation in the @xmath10 expansion to be sufficiently accurate , the involved transverse four - velocities should be small , i.e. @xmath17 already for @xmath18 . since it is possible to choose the starting point @xmath11 of the series expansion to make the first order term vanishing @xcite , the largest neglected term turns out to be @xmath19 which is very small provided that the aforementioned condition on @xmath20 is met .","the analysis presented in this paper assumes the validity of this approximation and primary spectra have been calculated according to eq .","( [ two ] ) . +","even though eq .","( [ two ] ) looks like the spectrum from a thermalised source with a superimposed flow , a popular formula in the heavy - ion community , it is well worth emphasizing that in fact this formula has nothing to do with flow .","indeed , the average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 is not meant to be the mean value of cluster velocity distribution in a single event ; rather , it is the average transverse four - velocity of all clusters over all collision events . in other words ,","@xmath11 may well arise from single clusters emitted at high @xmath21 in some events , e.g. following a hard parton scattering , and does not imply by any means a collective event - by - event expansion .","gev @xcite .","the measured @xmath22 spectra ( above ) have been normalised so as to have the same value at @xmath23 .","while slopes of @xmath22 spectra are different , those of @xmath24 ( below ) are approximately the same for all identified particles . ]"],["a peculiar prediction of a statistical picture in high energy collisions which is relevant to transverse momentum spectra is the so - called @xmath25 scaling : there should be an apparent common slope for @xmath26 spectra of identified hadrons at a given centre - of - mass energy . by looking at eq .","( [ two ] ) one can easily realize that this holds in the limit @xmath27 . in principle",", @xmath25 scaling applies only to primary hadrons , namely those directly emitted from the hadronising source . on the other hand , as stated in sect .","1 , most observed or reconstructed particles in experiments arise from decays of heavier hadrons .","those secondary decays may well distort the primary spectrum shape , thus spoling @xmath25 scaling .","nevertheless , it can be seen in fig .","( [ mtslope ] ) that @xmath25 scaling apparently also holds for measured final hadrons , at least in the examined collision , implying seemingly little distortion from primary to final spectrum . settling this and","other related issues demands a thorough analysis taking into account the effect of decays .","therefore , measured @xmath21 spectrum of the @xmath4 hadron species should be compared with the sum of its primary spectrum and the contribution arising from all heavier hadrons decaying into it : @xmath28 whilst @xmath29 is given by eq .","( [ two ] ) , the calculation of the second term in the right hand side of eq .","( [ three ] ) within a statistical - thermal framework is a very complicated problem as the number of contributing resonances and decay modes is huge and also owing the presence of cascade decays ( e.g. @xmath30 ) . in refs .","@xcite an analytical approach has been taken including two and three body decays of directly emitted resonances .","on the other hand , we have adopted @xcite a mixed numerical - analytical method which allows a very accurate and exhaustive calculation .","our method can be summarised as follows : for any couple of hadrons @xmath31 , where @xmath32 decays into @xmath33 , either directly or through a cascade process , we have determined the momentum spectrum @xmath34 in the equivalent cluster s rest frame via a monte - carlo method by randomly generating 200,000 @xmath32 s decays , according to phase space , by picking @xmath32 s three - momenta from a thermal distribution with a given temperature @xmath14 : @xmath35 then , we have boosted the obtained @xmath34 distributions in order to compute the @xmath36 for a given transverse four - velocity @xmath11 of the equivalent cluster , to be plugged into eq .","( [ three ] ) , with an integral formula derived by the authors @xcite : @xmath37 where f is the elliptic integral of the first kind and : @xmath38 [ cols=\"<,<,<,<,<,<\",options=\"header \" , ] + the main advantage of formula ( [ five ] ) is to allow a quick computation of transverse momentum spectra associated with particle decays for any tranverse four - velocity once the corresponding momentum spectra at zero velocity are known . to obtain it",", we took advantage of the isotropy of @xmath34 distributions , which holds as long as decay products distribution is isotropic , which is true for simple phase - space decays with no polarisation .","the integration in the variable @xmath39 in eq .","( [ five ] ) has been performed numerically .","the monte - carlo generation of @xmath34 spectra , depending on the temperature , has been performed for all unstable hadrons and resonances up to a mass of 1.8 gev and it has been repeated for temperature values between 140 and 190 mev in steps of 1 mev , so as to have a large enough range of temperatures where to search for minima in a fitting procedure .","for any other temperature value , the spectra have been calculated by means of a linear interpolation .","overall , for hadronic collisions , we have generated about 1200 spectra associated to 144 unstable hadrons for each @xmath14 value .","+ the abundances of all hadrons , which are needed to assess the contribution of secondaries in the spectra of eq .","( [ three ] ) , have been preliminarly set to the model values calculated by fitting the parameters @xmath14 , @xmath40 and or @xmath41 to the experimentally measured yields .","this procedure amounts to exclude the overall normalisation dependence of @xmath42 on @xmath14 in the fit so to keep only its shape dependence on @xmath14 .","+ whilst the @xmath41 parameter has already extensively been used in multiplicity fits @xcite , a new parameter is introduced here for the strangeness suppression .","the particle yields are computed by constraining the number of newly created pairs to fixed integers which fluctuate according to a poissonian distribution .","the mean value of the poissonian distribution , namely the mean value of newly created pairs , is the adjustable fit parameter . for the present , this new parametrisation has been used only for hadronic collisions ( see table 1 ) because collisions present difficulties related to the production of heavy flavoured quarks which makes calculations extremely slow .","the mathematical features of the parametrisation are described in detail in ref .","+ the fitted values , which update those in refs .","@xcite for hadronic and collisions are quoted in table 1 .","the fitted temperature in pp collision in the present analysis is somewhat lower compared with ref .","@xcite owing to an updated set of hadron parameters @xcite , an upgraded procedure of @xmath43 minimisation also taking into account correlations in the effective variance method @xcite , as well as the replacement of @xmath41 with .","the fitted temperature values show a very interesting trend consisting in a slight but significant increase as centre - of - mass energy diminishes ; this is in agreement with the observation pointed out in ref .","@xcite .","contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for @xmath45 @xmath46 spectrum in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev . ]"],["the collisions and relevant centre - of - mass energies to be analysed have been primarily chosen on the basis of a fairly large number of measured particle yields and spectra .","particle multiplicities are needed to establish with some accuracy the contribution of secondary decays while many identified hadron spectra allow performing a test of universality on the slopes governed by @xmath14 and @xmath11 .","this criterion led to singling out mainly four collision systems for hadronic collisions : k@xmath48p at @xmath49 @xcite and 21.7 gev @xcite , @xmath45p at @xmath50 gev @xcite and pp @xmath51 gev @xcite .","for each identified particle transverse momentum spectrum , three free parameters have been determined by fitting eq .","( [ three ] ) to the data : @xmath14 , @xmath11 and an overall normalisation parameter @xmath52 .","the fits have been performed in the variables @xmath21 or @xmath46 according to the available experimental spectrum ; henceforth , we will denote by @xmath53 both @xmath53 and @xmath54 . as we have mentioned before , overall multiplicities of hadrons in eq .","( [ three ] ) have been fixed to model values by using fit parameters in table 1 .","+ the fit is performed by minimising the following @xmath43 : @xmath55 ^ 2}{\\sigma_i^2}\\ ] ] the errors @xmath56 in the denominator of eq .","( [ chi2 ] ) have been taken as the sum in quadrature of experimental errors and errors arising from the uncertainty on masses , widths and branching ratios of hadrons decaying into the examined hadron , according to the effective variance method ( see ref .","@xcite for a detailed description ) .","plane of @xmath57 for @xmath45p collisions @xmath47 21.7 gev .","the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath60 , @xmath61 , k@xmath62 and @xmath63 .","the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .","the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]","plane of @xmath57 for k@xmath48p collisions @xmath47 21.7 gev .","the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath60 , @xmath61 , k@xmath64 and f@xmath65 .","the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .","the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]","plane of @xmath57 for pp collisions @xmath47 27.4 gev .","the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath45 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath48 , k@xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath61 , and f@xmath65 .","the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .","the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]","once the normalisation parameter @xmath52 is fitted , a study of @xmath43 contour lines is performed in the @xmath44 plane in order to look for possible local minima .","indeed , the presence of several local minima along a band is a quite general feature of the @xmath43 ( see fig .","( [ picont ] ) ) owing to the strong anticorrelation between @xmath14 and @xmath11 .","hence , different solutions are possible for the @xmath68 pair . in order to enforce universality of such parameters among different hadron species","we have chosen a solution for each particle according to the following procedure : 1 .","firstly , we have determined the contour lines of @xmath69 as a function of @xmath14 and @xmath11 by fixing all normalisation parameters to their fitted values , where @xmath6 is the number of different hadron species spectra for a given collision .","the minimisation of the sum of all @xmath43 s amounts to fit a common value of @xmath14 and @xmath11 for all measured hadrons .","secondly , among the different local minima we have chosen the one lying in or closest to the band defined by @xmath14 fitted with average multiplicities along with its error ( see figs .","( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) ) .","finally , all single particle spectrum fits have been repeated seeking a local minimum as close as possible to the previously determined @xmath69 minimum .","it must be noted that this procedure aims at achieving the best agreement between temperatures determined by using different observables , namely particle yields and transverse momentum spectra .","the @xmath69 contour plots are shown in figs .","( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) for the examined collisions .","there is a good agreement between the @xmath14 obtained from multiplicities and the location of minima in the @xmath44 plane . for k@xmath48p and @xmath45p at @xmath50","gev the absolute minimum lies nearly about the centre of the band demonstrating an intriguing correlation between the slope of transverse momentum distributions and the slope of average multiplicities as a function of mass .","moreover , the @xmath11 values turn out to be small , thus justifying the series expansion described in sect . 2 .","conversely , in k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath49 gev a clear disagreement emerges for k@xmath48p at @xmath49 gev between differently determined temperatures ( see fig .","( [ kpcontlow ] ) ) which can be explained with the inadequacy of our used parametrisation at low energy where exact @xmath21 conservation , neglected in the canonical framework , is expected to play a significant role .","contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for @xmath59 and k@xmath60 @xmath46 spectra in k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath47 11.5 gev .","the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .","local minima lie outside the 1-sigma temperature band . ]","measured and fitted spectrum in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev .","the lines lying below the top solid line represent the cumulative contributions to the fitted spectrum of secondary @xmath45 s arising from the decays of doubly and singly strange baryons , other baryons , strange , charged and neutral mesons .","below : residuals distribution . ]","p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . from top to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .","the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]","p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . from top to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .","the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]","27.4 gev . from top","to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .","the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]","the summary plots of the single particle fits are shown in figs .","( [ summagp ] , [ summakp],[summapp ] ) while an example of fitted spectrum in pp collisions is shown in fig .","( [ piplot ] ) .","in general , very good fits ( low @xmath43 s ) are obtained with good agreement between temperatures and average transverse boost velocities fitted for different identified hadrons , especially in pp collisions .","some discrepancies show up in k@xmath48p and @xmath45p collisions where k@xmath71 s seem to have slopes steeper than expected .","it must be noted that error estimates for @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough ."],["we have also performed a similar analysis for collisions at centre - of - mass energies between 14 and 44 gev . compared with hadronic collisions ,","the analysis of data presents several additional difficulties .","first of all , the production of heavy flavoured hadrons can not be neglected and the inclusion of many more decay channels is implied . a major issue is the fact that @xmath21 is defined with respect to the so - called thrust or event axis .","this direction is not known _ a priori _ , unlike in hadronic collisions where @xmath21 is defined with respect to the beam line , and must be determined on an event by event basis .","hence , whatever the algorithm being used , this very fact introduces a bias on transverse momentum spectra because momenta projection are used to determine the event or thrust axis itself ; often , this is done by just minimising the sum of particle @xmath21 s .","contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for charged tracks @xmath21 or @xmath46 spectra in collisions at four different centre - of - mass energies ranging from 14 to 44 gev .","the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities . for collisions at @xmath47 44 gev ,","local minima lie outside the considered @xmath11 upper bound and the minimum @xmath43 is poor . ] in spite of this problem , we have repeated the same analysis performed for hadronic collisions by using measured charged tracks transverse momentum spectra @xcite with respect to thrust axis .","the @xmath43 contour plots are shown in fig .","( [ eecont ] ) along with @xmath14 bands obtained from multiplicity fits and resulting @xmath43 s minima .","it can be seen that no minimum is found within the band for collisions at @xmath72 gev , a situation looking very similar that found in k@xmath48p collision at @xmath49 gev .","it is also found that fitted @xmath11 increases quite rapidly with centre - of - mass energy reflecting the rise of average @xmath21 of gluon radiation . since our parametrisation of transverse momentum spectra with an average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 requires @xmath11 to be @xmath73 ( see discussion in sect .","2 ) , it is quite natural that fit quality deteriorates as centre - of - mass energy increases .","this is indeed found already at 44 gev where @xmath74 can not longer be considered small .","as energy increases , particle @xmath21 spectra become sensitive to the shape of clusters @xmath75 distribution ( related in turn to radiated gluon @xmath21 spectrum ) and not only to its mean value .","further on , they become dominated by the shape of gluon radiation spectrum whilst hadronisation @xmath21 plays the role of a small superimposed noise ."],["the analysis of transverse momentum spectra of several identified hadrons , accurately taking into account the effect of hadron decays , indicates that they can be well reproduced within the statistical hadronisation model for several high energy hadronic collisions .","furthermore , a good agreement is found between the temperatures estimated by fits to average particles multiplicities and those extracted by fitting transverse momentum spectra . this can be seen especially by comparing figs .","( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) ; in fact , the location of the best @xmath14 value for transverse momentum spectra , determined by @xmath43 s lowest contour line , is apparently correlated to the best @xmath14 value defined by particle multiplicities as spotted by the vertical band .","indeed , those temperatures move toghether from @xmath76 mev in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev to @xmath77 mev in @xmath45p and k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . in our view",", this finding is a strong indication in favour of one of the key predictions of the statistical hadronisation model , namely the existence of a close relationship between the laws governing the production of particles as a function of their mass and , for each particle species , the production as a function of momentum ( measured in the rest frame of the cluster they belong to ) at the hadronisation .","+ besides this main conclusion , there are many remarks to be made .","first of all , our calculations assumed a canonical framework and so they are expected to have only a limited validity at low centre - of - mass energies where the effect of exact transverse momentum conservation must show up .","indeed , in collisions at a centre - of - mass energy of 14 gev and k@xmath48p collisions at 11.5 gev , a clear disagreement is found between the temperatures determined in the two fashions ( see fig .","( [ kpcontlow ] ) ) . secondly ,","whilst the results obtained in pp collisions for different particles are in very good agreement among them , there are some significant discrepancies between different particles in @xmath45p and k@xmath48p collisions , especially for k@xmath71 s , which are not understood at the present .","finally , it is evident in the analysis of moderately high energy collisions , at @xmath47 44 gev , that our parametrisation of transverse momentum spectra as a function of an average transverse four - velocity alone , is not accurate enough . as the average @xmath21 of radiated gluons and , as a consequence , of hadronising clusters , rises ,","particle spectra are influenced more by the shape of clusters transverse four - velocity spectrum than by primordial hadronisation @xmath21 spectrum so that more accurate calculations are needed involving perturbative qcd to perform such an analysis .","finally , in the very high energy regime , @xmath21 spectra become insensitive to hadronisation and , as a consequence , it is no longer interesting to study its properties . in summary , the presently used parametrisation of @xmath21 spectra is found to work well only in a limited centre - of - mass energy range ( roughly between 20 and 30 gev ) . at lower energies , the study of @xmath21 is still of great interest in probing the statistical features of hadronisation but complex microcanonical calculations are required . at higher energy ,","hadronisation is swamped by hard qcd dynamics in @xmath21 spectra and all it can do is to add a little smearing ."],["we would like to thank the organizers of the `` correlations and fluctuations '' conference in torino .","we are grateful to u. heinz and u. a. wiedemann for clarifying discussions .","many thanks to j. a. baldry for the careful revision of the manuscript .","this work would have not been possible without the great durham reaction data database ; we wish to express our gratitude to their editors and curators .","e. fermi , progr .","phys . 5 ( 1950 ) 570 .","r. hagedorn , nuovo cimento 15 ( 1960 ) 434 .","f. becattini , z. phys .","c 69 ( 1996 ) 485 .","f. becattini , proc . of xxxiii eloisatron workshop on `` universality features in multihadron production '' ( 1996 ) 74 .","f. becattini and u. heinz , z. phys .","c 76 ( 1997 ) 269 .","r. hagedorn , `` hot hadronic matter : theory and experiment '' ( 1994 ) 13 .","r. hagedorn , riv .","nuovo cimento 6 ( 1984 ) 1983 .","j. sollfrank , p. koch and u. heinz , phys .","b 252 ( 1990 ) 256 .","j. sollfrank , p. koch and u. heinz , z. phys .","c 52 ( 1991 ) 593 .","u. a. wiedemann and u. heinz , phys .","c 56 ( 1997 ) 3265 .","t. peitzmann , nucl .","phys . a 638 ( 1998 ) 415c . for","a description of the model in the canonical approximation see f. becattini , proc . of xi chris engelbrecht summer school `` hadrons in dense matter and hadrosynthesis '' ( 1998 ) 71 .","g. marchesini and b. webber , nucl .","b 238 ( 1984 ) 1 .","f. becattini , l. bellucci and g. passaleva , in preparation .","f. becattini , l. bellucci , g. passaleva , proc . of xxix international symposium on multiparticle dynamics ( 1999 ) 220 .","p. chliapnikov , private communication .","m. aguilar - benitez et al . , z. phys .","c 50 ( 1991 ) 405 .","the durham reaction data database , http://durpdg.dur.ac.uk/hepdata/reac .","particle data book , c. caso et al , eur .","j. c 3 ( 1998 ) 1 .","f. becattini , m. gazdzicki and j. sollfrank , eur .","j. c 5 ( 1998 ) 143",". m. i. gorenstein , m. gazdzicki and w. greiner , phys .","b 483 ( 2000 ) 60 . m. barth et al . , z. phys .","c 22 ( 1984 ) 23 + m. barth et al . , nucl .","b 191 ( 1981 ) 39 . m. adamus et al . , z. phys .","c 35 ( 1987 ) 7 + n.m .","agababyan et al . , z. phys .","c 41 ( 1989 ) 539 + m. adamus et al . , z. phys .","c 39 ( 1988 ) 311 + i.v .","azhinenko et al .",", z. phys .","c 46 ( 1990 ) 525 . m. adamus et al . , z. phys .","c 35 ( 1987 ) 7 + n.m .","agababyan et al . , z. phys .","c 46 ( 1990 ) 387 + m. adamus et al . , z. phys .","c 39 ( 1988 ) 311 + i.v .","azhinenko et al . , z. phys .","c 46 ( 1990 ) 525 .","m. aguilar - benitez et al . , z. phys .","c 50 ( 1991 ) 405 ; numerical values of @xmath21 spectra can be found in durham reaction data database @xcite + a. suzuki , lett .","nuovo cimento 24 ( 1979 ) 31 .","m. althoff et al . ,","tasso coll .",". c 22 ( 1984 ) 307 + d. bender et al . ,","d 31 ( 1985 ) 1 + w. braunschweig et al .",", tasso coll .",", z. phys .","c 47 ( 1990 ) 187 ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"the idea of a statistical approach to hadron production in high energy collisions dates back to 50s @xcite and 60s @xcite and it has been recently revived by the observation that hadron multiplicities in collisions agree very well with a thermodynamical - like ansatz @xcite .\",\n \"this finding has also been confirmed in hadronic collisions and it has been interpreted in terms of a pure statistical filling of multi - hadronic phase space of assumed pre - hadronic clusters ( or fireballs ) formed in high - energy collisions , at a critical value of energy density @xcite . in this framework , temperature and other thermodynamical quantities have a statistical meaning which does not entail the existence of a thermalised hadronic system on an event - by - event basis .\",\n \"stated otherwise , statistical equilibrium shows up only when comparing many different events , whilst in each of them the gibbs law of equally likely multi - hadronic states applies .\",\n \"so far , this proposed statistical cluster hadronisation model has been mainly tested against measured abundances of different hadron species for a twofold reason .\",\n \"firstly , unlike momentum spectra , they are quantities which are not affected by hard ( perturbative ) qcd dynamical effects but are only determined by the hadronisation process ; indeed , in the framework of a multi - cluster model , they are lorentz - invariant quantities which are independent of the cluster s overall momentum .\",\n \"secondly , they are quite easy to calculate and provide a very sensitive test of the model yielding an accurate determination of the temperature . however , in order to establish the validity of this approach , it is necessary to test further observables and to assess their consistency with the results obtained for multiplicities .\",\n \"certainly , one of the best suited observables is the transverse momentum of identified hadrons , where transverse is meant to be with respect to beam line in high energy hadronic collision , and thrust or event axis in high energy collisions .\",\n \"indeed , such projection of particle momentum is supposed to be the most sensitive to hadronisation or , conversely , the least sensitive to perturbative qcd dynamics .\",\n \"+ actually , it has been known for a long time that transverse momentum distributions are boltzmann - like in hadronic collisions and this very observation was pointed out by hagedorn as a major indication in favour of his statistical model of hadron production @xcite .\",\n \"it must be emphasized that the prediction of a thermal - like shape in principle only applies to particles directly emitted from the hadronising source , whereas measured spectra also include particles produced by decays of heavier hadrons .\",\n \"however , most analyses do not take into account the distortion of primordial hadronisation spectrum due the to hadronic decay chain and try to fit the data straight through it .\",\n \"this problem has been discussed in literature @xcite and an analytical calculation has been developed to take into account the effect of two and three body decays @xcite , which has then been used both for pp @xcite and heavy ion collision @xcite including most abundant resonances . in this paper\",\n \"we introduce a method allowing to rigorously and exhaustively determine the contribution of all particle decays .\",\n \"hence , by taking advantage of this technique , we have performed an analysis of many measured transverse momentum spectra of identified hadrons in a wide range of centre - of - mass energies for several kind of collisions .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the statistical hadronisation model @xcite assumes that in high energy collisions , as a consequence of strong interaction dynamics , a set of colourless clusters ( or fireballs ) is formed having certain values of mass , volume , internal quantum numbers and momentum , the latter being inherited from the hard stage of the process .\",\n \"those clusters are assumed to give rise to hadrons according to a pure statistical law in the multi - hadronic phase space defined by their mass , volume and quantum numbers .\",\n \"this approach differs from another popular cluster hadronisation model @xcite mainly because it gives clusters a volume so that hadron production is ruled by the properly understood phase space rather than relativistic momentum space . in this framework\",\n \", the use of statistical mechanics and thermodynamical quantities , such as temperature , which need spacial dimension besides momentum space in order to be meaningful , is allowed .\",\n \"we emphasize once more that the introduction of such quantities does not entail any thermalisation process of hadrons after their formation , nor the existence of a thermalised system event by event . +\",\n \"although many clusters with different momenta , volumes , masses and quantum numbers are formed , it can be shown that the average values of many observables , e. g. particle multiplicites , are the same as those relevant to one equivalent cluster having suitable values of volume ( namely the sum of all cluster volumes measured in the rest frame of the equivalent cluster itself ) , mass and quantum numbers ( namely the sum of all cluster quantum numbers ) .\",\n \"the proof of this statement @xcite , a lengthy one , requires the assumption of special probabilities governing the fluctuations of cluster masses and quantum numbers for a given set of volumes .\",\n \"if the volume ( or mass ) of the equivalent cluster is large enough , it is then reasonable to take a canonical approach ( i.e. introducing a temperature ) in order to calculate mean quantities , instead of carrying out an involved microcanonical calculation .\",\n \"therefore , even though actual clusters are small sized and microcanonical calculations would be needed to determine mean quantities within each of them , the choice of suitable mass fluctuation probabilities for the clusters allows one to calculate overall means dealing with only one large global structure and with much fewer parameters . arguing the other way around , it is not difficult to be convinced that the fluctuation probabilities to be chosen in order to achieve such reduction of the problem are exactly the same as those of obtaining a given set of masses by splitting a large cluster into a given number of clusters with volumes @xmath2 .\",\n \"this statement extends a reduction procedure to the microcanonical case which was proved in the canonical case @xcite , where , from the very beginning , clusters were given temperature and volume instead of mass and volume .\",\n \"nevertheless , it is not obvious how large the equivalent cluster should be for the canonical approximation to apply . for the present\",\n \", we have adopted a simple - minded _ a posteriori _ method consisting in justifying the canonical framework by its capability of accordance with the data .\",\n \"a simple argument to support the canonical approximation even at moderate values of volumes is the very large number of states ( @xmath3 ) , i.e. hadrons and resonances , which can be excited in a hadron gas . +\",\n \"as far as single - particle transverse momentum spectra are concerned , a similar reduction theorem from many clusters to one equivalent cluster in the averaging procedure applies @xcite , though only approximately . in general\",\n \", it can be shown that the _ primary _ spectrum of @xmath4 hadron species depends on transverse four - velocities @xmath5 with vanishing longitudinal component . ] of the @xmath6 clusters : @xmath7 \\\\ ; f(u_{t1},\\\\ldots , u_{tn } ) \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\times \\\\ ; \\\\sum_{i=1}^n \\\\frac{\\\\d n_j}{\\\\d p_t}\\\\vl_{i}(\\\\ui ) \\\\ , .\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath8 is the transverse four - velocities distribution function .\",\n \"if one expands all single - cluster spectra @xmath9 in series of @xmath10 starting from a common value @xmath11 for all clusters , it can be proved that , at the zeroth order , the spectrum in eq .\",\n \"( [ one ] ) becomes the same as that obtained for the aforementioned equivalent cluster , endowed with a tranverse four - velocity @xmath11 .\",\n \"this reduction possibly allows taking the canonical approach in order to calculate the transverse momentum spectrum since the equivalent cluster size is much larger than single cluster s : @xmath12 where @xmath13 , @xmath14 is the temperature , and @xmath15 , @xmath16 are modified bessel functions .\",\n \"( [ two ] ) is the boltzmann limit of quantum statistics and it is a very good approximation for all hadrons except pions @xcite . for the zeroth order approximation in the @xmath10 expansion to be sufficiently accurate , the involved transverse four - velocities should be small , i.e. @xmath17 already for @xmath18 . since it is possible to choose the starting point @xmath11 of the series expansion to make the first order term vanishing @xcite , the largest neglected term turns out to be @xmath19 which is very small provided that the aforementioned condition on @xmath20 is met .\",\n \"the analysis presented in this paper assumes the validity of this approximation and primary spectra have been calculated according to eq .\",\n \"( [ two ] ) . +\",\n \"even though eq .\",\n \"( [ two ] ) looks like the spectrum from a thermalised source with a superimposed flow , a popular formula in the heavy - ion community , it is well worth emphasizing that in fact this formula has nothing to do with flow .\",\n \"indeed , the average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 is not meant to be the mean value of cluster velocity distribution in a single event ; rather , it is the average transverse four - velocity of all clusters over all collision events . in other words ,\",\n \"@xmath11 may well arise from single clusters emitted at high @xmath21 in some events , e.g. following a hard parton scattering , and does not imply by any means a collective event - by - event expansion .\",\n \"gev @xcite .\",\n \"the measured @xmath22 spectra ( above ) have been normalised so as to have the same value at @xmath23 .\",\n \"while slopes of @xmath22 spectra are different , those of @xmath24 ( below ) are approximately the same for all identified particles . ]\"\n ],\n [\n \"a peculiar prediction of a statistical picture in high energy collisions which is relevant to transverse momentum spectra is the so - called @xmath25 scaling : there should be an apparent common slope for @xmath26 spectra of identified hadrons at a given centre - of - mass energy . by looking at eq .\",\n \"( [ two ] ) one can easily realize that this holds in the limit @xmath27 . in principle\",\n \", @xmath25 scaling applies only to primary hadrons , namely those directly emitted from the hadronising source . on the other hand , as stated in sect .\",\n \"1 , most observed or reconstructed particles in experiments arise from decays of heavier hadrons .\",\n \"those secondary decays may well distort the primary spectrum shape , thus spoling @xmath25 scaling .\",\n \"nevertheless , it can be seen in fig .\",\n \"( [ mtslope ] ) that @xmath25 scaling apparently also holds for measured final hadrons , at least in the examined collision , implying seemingly little distortion from primary to final spectrum . settling this and\",\n \"other related issues demands a thorough analysis taking into account the effect of decays .\",\n \"therefore , measured @xmath21 spectrum of the @xmath4 hadron species should be compared with the sum of its primary spectrum and the contribution arising from all heavier hadrons decaying into it : @xmath28 whilst @xmath29 is given by eq .\",\n \"( [ two ] ) , the calculation of the second term in the right hand side of eq .\",\n \"( [ three ] ) within a statistical - thermal framework is a very complicated problem as the number of contributing resonances and decay modes is huge and also owing the presence of cascade decays ( e.g. @xmath30 ) . in refs .\",\n \"@xcite an analytical approach has been taken including two and three body decays of directly emitted resonances .\",\n \"on the other hand , we have adopted @xcite a mixed numerical - analytical method which allows a very accurate and exhaustive calculation .\",\n \"our method can be summarised as follows : for any couple of hadrons @xmath31 , where @xmath32 decays into @xmath33 , either directly or through a cascade process , we have determined the momentum spectrum @xmath34 in the equivalent cluster s rest frame via a monte - carlo method by randomly generating 200,000 @xmath32 s decays , according to phase space , by picking @xmath32 s three - momenta from a thermal distribution with a given temperature @xmath14 : @xmath35 then , we have boosted the obtained @xmath34 distributions in order to compute the @xmath36 for a given transverse four - velocity @xmath11 of the equivalent cluster , to be plugged into eq .\",\n \"( [ three ] ) , with an integral formula derived by the authors @xcite : @xmath37 where f is the elliptic integral of the first kind and : @xmath38 [ cols=\\\"<,<,<,<,<,<\\\",options=\\\"header \\\" , ] + the main advantage of formula ( [ five ] ) is to allow a quick computation of transverse momentum spectra associated with particle decays for any tranverse four - velocity once the corresponding momentum spectra at zero velocity are known . to obtain it\",\n \", we took advantage of the isotropy of @xmath34 distributions , which holds as long as decay products distribution is isotropic , which is true for simple phase - space decays with no polarisation .\",\n \"the integration in the variable @xmath39 in eq .\",\n \"( [ five ] ) has been performed numerically .\",\n \"the monte - carlo generation of @xmath34 spectra , depending on the temperature , has been performed for all unstable hadrons and resonances up to a mass of 1.8 gev and it has been repeated for temperature values between 140 and 190 mev in steps of 1 mev , so as to have a large enough range of temperatures where to search for minima in a fitting procedure .\",\n \"for any other temperature value , the spectra have been calculated by means of a linear interpolation .\",\n \"overall , for hadronic collisions , we have generated about 1200 spectra associated to 144 unstable hadrons for each @xmath14 value .\",\n \"+ the abundances of all hadrons , which are needed to assess the contribution of secondaries in the spectra of eq .\",\n \"( [ three ] ) , have been preliminarly set to the model values calculated by fitting the parameters @xmath14 , @xmath40 and or @xmath41 to the experimentally measured yields .\",\n \"this procedure amounts to exclude the overall normalisation dependence of @xmath42 on @xmath14 in the fit so to keep only its shape dependence on @xmath14 .\",\n \"+ whilst the @xmath41 parameter has already extensively been used in multiplicity fits @xcite , a new parameter is introduced here for the strangeness suppression .\",\n \"the particle yields are computed by constraining the number of newly created pairs to fixed integers which fluctuate according to a poissonian distribution .\",\n \"the mean value of the poissonian distribution , namely the mean value of newly created pairs , is the adjustable fit parameter . for the present , this new parametrisation has been used only for hadronic collisions ( see table 1 ) because collisions present difficulties related to the production of heavy flavoured quarks which makes calculations extremely slow .\",\n \"the mathematical features of the parametrisation are described in detail in ref .\",\n \"+ the fitted values , which update those in refs .\",\n \"@xcite for hadronic and collisions are quoted in table 1 .\",\n \"the fitted temperature in pp collision in the present analysis is somewhat lower compared with ref .\",\n \"@xcite owing to an updated set of hadron parameters @xcite , an upgraded procedure of @xmath43 minimisation also taking into account correlations in the effective variance method @xcite , as well as the replacement of @xmath41 with .\",\n \"the fitted temperature values show a very interesting trend consisting in a slight but significant increase as centre - of - mass energy diminishes ; this is in agreement with the observation pointed out in ref .\",\n \"@xcite .\",\n \"contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for @xmath45 @xmath46 spectrum in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev . ]\"\n ],\n [\n \"the collisions and relevant centre - of - mass energies to be analysed have been primarily chosen on the basis of a fairly large number of measured particle yields and spectra .\",\n \"particle multiplicities are needed to establish with some accuracy the contribution of secondary decays while many identified hadron spectra allow performing a test of universality on the slopes governed by @xmath14 and @xmath11 .\",\n \"this criterion led to singling out mainly four collision systems for hadronic collisions : k@xmath48p at @xmath49 @xcite and 21.7 gev @xcite , @xmath45p at @xmath50 gev @xcite and pp @xmath51 gev @xcite .\",\n \"for each identified particle transverse momentum spectrum , three free parameters have been determined by fitting eq .\",\n \"( [ three ] ) to the data : @xmath14 , @xmath11 and an overall normalisation parameter @xmath52 .\",\n \"the fits have been performed in the variables @xmath21 or @xmath46 according to the available experimental spectrum ; henceforth , we will denote by @xmath53 both @xmath53 and @xmath54 . as we have mentioned before , overall multiplicities of hadrons in eq .\",\n \"( [ three ] ) have been fixed to model values by using fit parameters in table 1 .\",\n \"+ the fit is performed by minimising the following @xmath43 : @xmath55 ^ 2}{\\\\sigma_i^2}\\\\ ] ] the errors @xmath56 in the denominator of eq .\",\n \"( [ chi2 ] ) have been taken as the sum in quadrature of experimental errors and errors arising from the uncertainty on masses , widths and branching ratios of hadrons decaying into the examined hadron , according to the effective variance method ( see ref .\",\n \"@xcite for a detailed description ) .\",\n \"plane of @xmath57 for @xmath45p collisions @xmath47 21.7 gev .\",\n \"the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath60 , @xmath61 , k@xmath62 and @xmath63 .\",\n \"the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .\",\n \"the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]\",\n \"plane of @xmath57 for k@xmath48p collisions @xmath47 21.7 gev .\",\n \"the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath60 , @xmath61 , k@xmath64 and f@xmath65 .\",\n \"the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .\",\n \"the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]\",\n \"plane of @xmath57 for pp collisions @xmath47 27.4 gev .\",\n \"the identified particles involved in the sum are @xmath45 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , k@xmath48 , k@xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath61 , and f@xmath65 .\",\n \"the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .\",\n \"the @xmath57 quoted in the picture is its value in the local minimum pointed by the solid line . ]\",\n \"once the normalisation parameter @xmath52 is fitted , a study of @xmath43 contour lines is performed in the @xmath44 plane in order to look for possible local minima .\",\n \"indeed , the presence of several local minima along a band is a quite general feature of the @xmath43 ( see fig .\",\n \"( [ picont ] ) ) owing to the strong anticorrelation between @xmath14 and @xmath11 .\",\n \"hence , different solutions are possible for the @xmath68 pair . in order to enforce universality of such parameters among different hadron species\",\n \"we have chosen a solution for each particle according to the following procedure : 1 .\",\n \"firstly , we have determined the contour lines of @xmath69 as a function of @xmath14 and @xmath11 by fixing all normalisation parameters to their fitted values , where @xmath6 is the number of different hadron species spectra for a given collision .\",\n \"the minimisation of the sum of all @xmath43 s amounts to fit a common value of @xmath14 and @xmath11 for all measured hadrons .\",\n \"secondly , among the different local minima we have chosen the one lying in or closest to the band defined by @xmath14 fitted with average multiplicities along with its error ( see figs .\",\n \"( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) ) .\",\n \"finally , all single particle spectrum fits have been repeated seeking a local minimum as close as possible to the previously determined @xmath69 minimum .\",\n \"it must be noted that this procedure aims at achieving the best agreement between temperatures determined by using different observables , namely particle yields and transverse momentum spectra .\",\n \"the @xmath69 contour plots are shown in figs .\",\n \"( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) for the examined collisions .\",\n \"there is a good agreement between the @xmath14 obtained from multiplicities and the location of minima in the @xmath44 plane . for k@xmath48p and @xmath45p at @xmath50\",\n \"gev the absolute minimum lies nearly about the centre of the band demonstrating an intriguing correlation between the slope of transverse momentum distributions and the slope of average multiplicities as a function of mass .\",\n \"moreover , the @xmath11 values turn out to be small , thus justifying the series expansion described in sect . 2 .\",\n \"conversely , in k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath49 gev a clear disagreement emerges for k@xmath48p at @xmath49 gev between differently determined temperatures ( see fig .\",\n \"( [ kpcontlow ] ) ) which can be explained with the inadequacy of our used parametrisation at low energy where exact @xmath21 conservation , neglected in the canonical framework , is expected to play a significant role .\",\n \"contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for @xmath59 and k@xmath60 @xmath46 spectra in k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath47 11.5 gev .\",\n \"the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities .\",\n \"local minima lie outside the 1-sigma temperature band . ]\",\n \"measured and fitted spectrum in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev .\",\n \"the lines lying below the top solid line represent the cumulative contributions to the fitted spectrum of secondary @xmath45 s arising from the decays of doubly and singly strange baryons , other baryons , strange , charged and neutral mesons .\",\n \"below : residuals distribution . ]\",\n \"p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . from top to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .\",\n \"the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]\",\n \"p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . from top to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .\",\n \"the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]\",\n \"27.4 gev . from top\",\n \"to bottom : temperatures ( the dashed line is the value obtained by fitting multiplicities ) , average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 and minimum @xmath70 .\",\n \"the errors on @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough estimates . ]\",\n \"the summary plots of the single particle fits are shown in figs .\",\n \"( [ summagp ] , [ summakp],[summapp ] ) while an example of fitted spectrum in pp collisions is shown in fig .\",\n \"( [ piplot ] ) .\",\n \"in general , very good fits ( low @xmath43 s ) are obtained with good agreement between temperatures and average transverse boost velocities fitted for different identified hadrons , especially in pp collisions .\",\n \"some discrepancies show up in k@xmath48p and @xmath45p collisions where k@xmath71 s seem to have slopes steeper than expected .\",\n \"it must be noted that error estimates for @xmath14 and @xmath11 are still very rough .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we have also performed a similar analysis for collisions at centre - of - mass energies between 14 and 44 gev . compared with hadronic collisions ,\",\n \"the analysis of data presents several additional difficulties .\",\n \"first of all , the production of heavy flavoured hadrons can not be neglected and the inclusion of many more decay channels is implied . a major issue is the fact that @xmath21 is defined with respect to the so - called thrust or event axis .\",\n \"this direction is not known _ a priori _ , unlike in hadronic collisions where @xmath21 is defined with respect to the beam line , and must be determined on an event by event basis .\",\n \"hence , whatever the algorithm being used , this very fact introduces a bias on transverse momentum spectra because momenta projection are used to determine the event or thrust axis itself ; often , this is done by just minimising the sum of particle @xmath21 s .\",\n \"contour plot in the @xmath44 plane for charged tracks @xmath21 or @xmath46 spectra in collisions at four different centre - of - mass energies ranging from 14 to 44 gev .\",\n \"the two vertical lines define the 1-sigma band corresponding to the temperature fitted by using average particle multiplicities . for collisions at @xmath47 44 gev ,\",\n \"local minima lie outside the considered @xmath11 upper bound and the minimum @xmath43 is poor . ] in spite of this problem , we have repeated the same analysis performed for hadronic collisions by using measured charged tracks transverse momentum spectra @xcite with respect to thrust axis .\",\n \"the @xmath43 contour plots are shown in fig .\",\n \"( [ eecont ] ) along with @xmath14 bands obtained from multiplicity fits and resulting @xmath43 s minima .\",\n \"it can be seen that no minimum is found within the band for collisions at @xmath72 gev , a situation looking very similar that found in k@xmath48p collision at @xmath49 gev .\",\n \"it is also found that fitted @xmath11 increases quite rapidly with centre - of - mass energy reflecting the rise of average @xmath21 of gluon radiation . since our parametrisation of transverse momentum spectra with an average transverse four - velocity @xmath11 requires @xmath11 to be @xmath73 ( see discussion in sect .\",\n \"2 ) , it is quite natural that fit quality deteriorates as centre - of - mass energy increases .\",\n \"this is indeed found already at 44 gev where @xmath74 can not longer be considered small .\",\n \"as energy increases , particle @xmath21 spectra become sensitive to the shape of clusters @xmath75 distribution ( related in turn to radiated gluon @xmath21 spectrum ) and not only to its mean value .\",\n \"further on , they become dominated by the shape of gluon radiation spectrum whilst hadronisation @xmath21 plays the role of a small superimposed noise .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the analysis of transverse momentum spectra of several identified hadrons , accurately taking into account the effect of hadron decays , indicates that they can be well reproduced within the statistical hadronisation model for several high energy hadronic collisions .\",\n \"furthermore , a good agreement is found between the temperatures estimated by fits to average particles multiplicities and those extracted by fitting transverse momentum spectra . this can be seen especially by comparing figs .\",\n \"( [ gpcont],[kpcont],[ppcont ] ) ; in fact , the location of the best @xmath14 value for transverse momentum spectra , determined by @xmath43 s lowest contour line , is apparently correlated to the best @xmath14 value defined by particle multiplicities as spotted by the vertical band .\",\n \"indeed , those temperatures move toghether from @xmath76 mev in pp collisions at @xmath47 27.4 gev to @xmath77 mev in @xmath45p and k@xmath48p collisions at @xmath47 21.7 gev . in our view\",\n \", this finding is a strong indication in favour of one of the key predictions of the statistical hadronisation model , namely the existence of a close relationship between the laws governing the production of particles as a function of their mass and , for each particle species , the production as a function of momentum ( measured in the rest frame of the cluster they belong to ) at the hadronisation .\",\n \"+ besides this main conclusion , there are many remarks to be made .\",\n \"first of all , our calculations assumed a canonical framework and so they are expected to have only a limited validity at low centre - of - mass energies where the effect of exact transverse momentum conservation must show up .\",\n \"indeed , in collisions at a centre - of - mass energy of 14 gev and k@xmath48p collisions at 11.5 gev , a clear disagreement is found between the temperatures determined in the two fashions ( see fig .\",\n \"( [ kpcontlow ] ) ) . secondly ,\",\n \"whilst the results obtained in pp collisions for different particles are in very good agreement among them , there are some significant discrepancies between different particles in @xmath45p and k@xmath48p collisions , especially for k@xmath71 s , which are not understood at the present .\",\n \"finally , it is evident in the analysis of moderately high energy collisions , at @xmath47 44 gev , that our parametrisation of transverse momentum spectra as a function of an average transverse four - velocity alone , is not accurate enough . as the average @xmath21 of radiated gluons and , as a consequence , of hadronising clusters , rises ,\",\n \"particle spectra are influenced more by the shape of clusters transverse four - velocity spectrum than by primordial hadronisation @xmath21 spectrum so that more accurate calculations are needed involving perturbative qcd to perform such an analysis .\",\n \"finally , in the very high energy regime , @xmath21 spectra become insensitive to hadronisation and , as a consequence , it is no longer interesting to study its properties . in summary , the presently used parametrisation of @xmath21 spectra is found to work well only in a limited centre - of - mass energy range ( roughly between 20 and 30 gev ) . at lower energies , the study of @xmath21 is still of great interest in probing the statistical features of hadronisation but complex microcanonical calculations are required . at higher energy ,\",\n \"hadronisation is swamped by hard qcd dynamics in @xmath21 spectra and all it can do is to add a little smearing .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we would like to thank the organizers of the `` correlations and fluctuations '' conference in torino .\",\n \"we are grateful to u. heinz and u. a. wiedemann for clarifying discussions .\",\n \"many thanks to j. a. baldry for the careful revision of the manuscript .\",\n \"this work would have not been possible without the great durham reaction data database ; we wish to express our gratitude to their editors and curators .\",\n \"e. fermi , progr .\",\n \"phys . 5 ( 1950 ) 570 .\",\n \"r. hagedorn , nuovo cimento 15 ( 1960 ) 434 .\",\n \"f. becattini , z. phys .\",\n \"c 69 ( 1996 ) 485 .\",\n \"f. becattini , proc . of xxxiii eloisatron workshop on `` universality features in multihadron production '' ( 1996 ) 74 .\",\n \"f. becattini and u. heinz , z. phys .\",\n \"c 76 ( 1997 ) 269 .\",\n \"r. hagedorn , `` hot hadronic matter : theory and experiment '' ( 1994 ) 13 .\",\n \"r. hagedorn , riv .\",\n \"nuovo cimento 6 ( 1984 ) 1983 .\",\n \"j. sollfrank , p. koch and u. heinz , phys .\",\n \"b 252 ( 1990 ) 256 .\",\n \"j. sollfrank , p. koch and u. heinz , z. phys .\",\n \"c 52 ( 1991 ) 593 .\",\n \"u. a. wiedemann and u. heinz , phys .\",\n \"c 56 ( 1997 ) 3265 .\",\n \"t. peitzmann , nucl .\",\n \"phys . a 638 ( 1998 ) 415c . for\",\n \"a description of the model in the canonical approximation see f. becattini , proc . of xi chris engelbrecht summer school `` hadrons in dense matter and hadrosynthesis '' ( 1998 ) 71 .\",\n \"g. marchesini and b. webber , nucl .\",\n \"b 238 ( 1984 ) 1 .\",\n \"f. becattini , l. bellucci and g. passaleva , in preparation .\",\n \"f. becattini , l. bellucci , g. passaleva , proc . of xxix international symposium on multiparticle dynamics ( 1999 ) 220 .\",\n \"p. chliapnikov , private communication .\",\n \"m. aguilar - benitez et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 50 ( 1991 ) 405 .\",\n \"the durham reaction data database , http://durpdg.dur.ac.uk/hepdata/reac .\",\n \"particle data book , c. caso et al , eur .\",\n \"j. c 3 ( 1998 ) 1 .\",\n \"f. becattini , m. gazdzicki and j. sollfrank , eur .\",\n \"j. c 5 ( 1998 ) 143\",\n \". m. i. gorenstein , m. gazdzicki and w. greiner , phys .\",\n \"b 483 ( 2000 ) 60 . m. barth et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 22 ( 1984 ) 23 + m. barth et al . , nucl .\",\n \"b 191 ( 1981 ) 39 . m. adamus et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 35 ( 1987 ) 7 + n.m .\",\n \"agababyan et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 41 ( 1989 ) 539 + m. adamus et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 39 ( 1988 ) 311 + i.v .\",\n \"azhinenko et al .\",\n \", z. phys .\",\n \"c 46 ( 1990 ) 525 . m. adamus et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 35 ( 1987 ) 7 + n.m .\",\n \"agababyan et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 46 ( 1990 ) 387 + m. adamus et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 39 ( 1988 ) 311 + i.v .\",\n \"azhinenko et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 46 ( 1990 ) 525 .\",\n \"m. aguilar - benitez et al . , z. phys .\",\n \"c 50 ( 1991 ) 405 ; numerical values of @xmath21 spectra can be found in durham reaction data database @xcite + a. suzuki , lett .\",\n \"nuovo cimento 24 ( 1979 ) 31 .\",\n \"m. althoff et al . ,\",\n \"tasso coll .\",\n \". c 22 ( 1984 ) 307 + d. bender et al . ,\",\n \"d 31 ( 1985 ) 1 + w. braunschweig et al .\",\n \", tasso coll .\",\n \", z. phys .\",\n \"c 47 ( 1990 ) 187 .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":89,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"nucl-th9908015"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["i would like to discuss in this talk three topics which superficially would look unrelated but in essence can be connected by the general theme of cheshire cat .","i will first look at two - nucleon systems in terms of macroscopic variables of qcd , namely hadrons ; i will then go back to an elementary hadron , in particular the proton and examine its microscopic structure by punching \" a hole in the proton and then putting quarks and gluons of the appropriate quantum numbers inside and argue that there is a continuity in the descriptions in terms of hadronic variables and in terms of quark - gluon variables ; finally the continuity of quarks and hadrons at high density will be described in terms of qualitons quark solitons .","many of my collaborators have contributed to the development discussed in this talk . among them are gerry brown , bengt friman , deog ki hong , kuniharu kubodera , kurt langfeld , hee - jung lee , dong - pil min , byung - yoon park , tae - sun park , vicente vento and ismail zahed .","consider two nucleon interactions at very low energy .","we are generically interested in the energy - momentum probe much less than the pion mass @xmath0 mev . at this energy , according to weinberg s theorem , \" the content of qcd can be phrased in terms of the nucleons and pions .","in fact if we are probing a scale much less than the pion mass , we can even ignore the pions and work with the nucleons only .","the corresponding framework is an effective field theory ( eft ) .","much work has been done on this eft for two - nucleon systems @xcite ( see @xcite for recent reviews ) .","there are two classes of observables to look at .","one is scattering process and the other is response function to external fields .","the two are of course complementary in revealing the physics involved .","recent efforts have been put more on scattering than on response functions although more information has traditionally been gained from the latter in nuclear physics .","both need to be treated simultaneously which i will do here . in the literature","so far , there are broadly two approaches to eft in nuclear physics .","one is the original weinberg approach @xcite where a systematic power counting is made only to the `` irreducible graphs , '' for which chiral perturbation theory ( with pions figuring crucially ) becomes applicable in organizing the expansion and the reducible graphs are summed to all orders with the irreducible graphs entering as vertices .","this scheme used in ref.@xcite which in spirit is close to the original wilsonian eft but incurs possible errors in the power counting involves a scale @xmath1 as the counting is applied only to the irreducible terms .","i will call this the @xmath2 counting .","the other approach @xcite motivated to account more transparently for the large s - wave scattering lengths in two - nucleon scattering purports to do a systematic counting for the s - matrix as a whole which amounts to summing all graphs involving leading non - derivative four - fermi contact interactions while treating all others , including pion exchanges , as perturbation .","this approach renders a more systematic accounting of the powers of @xmath3 where @xmath4 , @xmath5 as well as @xmath6 but at the expense of certain predictivity .","this is referred to as @xmath7-counting scheme .","there have been lots of hot debates as to whether one scheme is more powerful and or more consistent than the other , mainly in connection with the scattering @xcite .","while the situation is not completely settled , i believe that it is fair to say that the two are both consistent with the tenet of eft and roughly equivalent in its power . eschewing the debate which seems somewhat academic ,","i will simply focus on the @xmath2-counting approach in this talk .","in fact , in the processes that i will consider , i would claim that the @xmath2 counting is more adaptable to and more predictive in treating ","nuclear physics problems than the @xmath7 counting .","one great advantage of the @xmath2 scheme is that it allows one to calculate precisely defined corrections to what can be obtained from so - called realistic potential models ( pm in short ) that have been developed by nuclear theorists since a long time , thus giving the realistic potential models ( pm ) a first - principle justification .","it allows us to study processes involving not just few - body but also many - body systems .","for instance , it is possible to calculate the ","hep \" process in the sun @xmath8 ( which is currently an exciting issue after the recent surperkamiokande neutrino data ) with an accuracy that can be controlled systematically .","it has also been successfully applied to calculating axial charge transitions of heavy nuclei ( see @xcite ) with the additional ingredient of br scaling @xcite .","while there is no definitive evidence that the @xmath2 scheme is fully justified for n - body systems with @xmath9 , it definitely works for @xmath10 systems . in ref.@xcite , it has been shown in a cutoff regularization ( with a finite cutoff as required by eft @xcite ) that the eft results of the leading order terms in all two - body observables at low energy @xmath11 are precisely reproduced by the potential model results .","this is the case not only for scattering amplitudes but also all electroweak response functions .","what eft brings in addition to what we get from the pm is a systematic procedure to compute corrections to the leading order results . for low - energy processes , this status of the pm can be understood by the fact that the tail of the wave functions is a physical quantity and the realistic potential models which are fit to experiments have the _ correct _ asymptotic properties in the wave function . this point has also been stressed and clarified by phillips and cohen in a recent important paper @xcite .","considered to order @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the order in the @xmath2 counting ( which i will consider relative to the leading order term in the expansion of the irreducible graphs ) , the s - wave scattering amplitudes are accurately postdicted @xcite up to @xmath14 for @xmath10 and a cutoff appropriate to the number of pions exchanged ( one or two ) in the irreducible graphs .","deuteron properties are also well understood within the same scheme @xcite .","the scheme allowed the calculations to order @xmath15 and @xmath16 of the proton fusion process in the sun @xcite p+pd+e^+ + _ e[pp ] and of the threshold np capture @xcite with polarized projectile and target nucleons + d+.[np ] the process ( [ pp ] ) crucial for the solar neutrino problem is given in the scheme to an accuracy of @xmath17 percents ( the uncertainty here is due to the exchange current that appears at order @xmath16 ) .","the unpolarized cross section for ( [ np ] ) has been computed to the accuracy of 1 percent in a complete agreement with the experiment .","more significantly , the polarization observables @xmath18 ( circular polarization ) and @xmath19 ( anisotropy ) have been predicted _ parameter - free _ in ref.@xcite scheme was made by chen , rupak and savage @xcite . ] .","this is a genuine prediction since there are no experimental data available .","( they are currently being measured in ill of grenoble @xcite . ) in all these postdictions and predictions , there is very little @xmath2 dependence as required by the tenet of eft .","this is a clear indication that the scheme is fully consistent .","one can go up in the momentum range by doing higher order calculations .","phillips and cohen @xcite discuss how the two - body em form factors can be described in the @xmath2 scheme . pushing somewhat the validity of the scheme",", one can calculate even the process e+de+n+p involving large momentum transfers @xmath20 gev .","in fact this process measured in 1980 s at als of saclay and elsewhere is considered to be the _ unambiguous _ confirmation of meson - exchange currents in nuclei ( see @xcite ) .","counting , everyone ( ! ) in the audience chuckled and said the process is completely out of reach for eft ( see @xcite ) .","i grant that this may be true in the @xmath7 scheme at least for the moment but _ not _ in the @xmath2 scheme where it has worked stunningly , confirming the chiral filter hypothesis . \" _ voil _ the power of the @xmath2 scheme ! ]","the nucleons that figured in the above section were color - singlet point - like fields that say nothing explicit about quarks and gluons .","let me now imagine puncturing a hole of size of radius @xmath21 in the proton and populating the inside with the qcd degrees of freedom , quarks and gluons . how to do this consistently with qcd","is known and the model involved is the chiral bag ( this is described extensively in @xcite ) which consists of a quark - gluon sector inside the bag and a color - singlet hadronic sector outside , with the two sectors connected by suitable boundary conditions .","when constructed with relevant degrees of freedom and in consistency with the symmetries of qcd , the model gives what is now called ","cheshire cat . \" in short , the cheshire cat principle @xcite states that at low energy , physics involving hadrons should be independent of the bag size @xmath21 .","it has been shown that this principle is operative semi - quantitatively in _ all _ properties of the nucleon @xcite _ except for _ the flavor - singlet axial charge ( fsac ) of the proton which is related to the proton spin .","\" here i will briefly describe leaving the details to the paper by lee et al @xcite how this cheshire cat property can be recovered in the fsac when chiral symmetry and chiral anomaly are judiciously taken into account .","it turns out that the interplay between the boundary conditions and casimir effects plays a crucial role . since the flavor - singlet axial current","is not conserved because of the anomaly , the color can not be confined inside the bag unless a suitable boundary condition is put at the surface that cancels the outflow of the color @xcite .","the boundary term that does this is proportional to the chern - simons current on the surface , i.e. , the chern - simons flux ( which is invariant under neither small nor large gauge transformation ) .","this influences the fsac of the proton nontrivially .","briefly , what happens is that the fsac contributed by the matter fields ( quarks inside the bag and @xmath22 outside the bag ) and the fsac contributed by the gauge field ( gluons inside the bag ) more or less ( or possibly exactly if treated rigorously ) cancel , leaving behind only the small contribution from the ( gauge field ) vacuum fluctuation which is effectively a casimir effect caused by the boundary with its color - anomalous boundary condition .","the cancellation and the remnant small fsac are shown in fig .","[ fsac ] . the upshot of the small result left over which is independent of the size @xmath21 provides yet another compelling evidence that the proton could be equivalently understood _ both _ in terms of quarks / gluons and in terms of macroscopic hadronic variables .","when @xmath21 is taken to be big , it is the qcd variables that take over , e.g. , the mit bag . when the size @xmath21 is shrunk to a point , the proton is a skyrmion .","thus we have the equivalence of the skyrmionic proton and the quark - gluonic ( qcd ) proton , that is , the cheshire cat .","since there is no way one can exactly bosonize four - dimensional qcd , the equivalence can not be made exact .","we simply have an approximate equivalence which can be made more precise by doing more work .","what determines the language to use is the kinematic condition of the process one looks at .","the last topic i would like to discuss is infinite nuclear matter at large density . the old lore that at an asymptotic density , the matter can be described by perturbative qcd with weakly interacting boring quarks is simply wrong","what may be happening at high density is something a lot more exciting than that .","this explains why lots of people are presently writing papers about it .","what is most surprising and in some sense unexpected is that at high density the cheshire cat picture becomes more prominent .","in fact , at high density , there ceases to be any real distinction between quarks and hadrons .","this can be best seen in terms of a quark soliton analogous to the qualiton kaplan @xcite introduced as a model for the constituent quark .","the mechanism i will discuss exploits that at high density diquarks condense giving rise to color superconductivity as recently discussed in the literature @xcite . since the resulting qualiton is formed from a color superconducting ground state , it seems proper to call it superqualiton @xcite .","it has been argued on general symmetry and dynamical grounds @xcite that at high density , hadronic matter of flavor @xmath23 is characterized by the condensate = - = ^ij^abi_i [ 1 ] where @xmath24 is some constant , @xmath25 are @xmath26 indices , @xmath27 are color indices , and @xmath28 are flavor indices .","equation ( [ 1 ] ) holds for parity - even states .","such a condensate locks color and flavor so that global color and chiral symmetry are broken to the diagonal subgroup @xmath29 .","the consequence of this is that there is an invariant @xmath30 subgroup that contains a twisted \" photon , measured with which all excitations carry integer charges reminiscent of the han - nambu quarks and have quantum numbers that correspond to those of the mesons and baryons present at zero density .","there is then a continuity between the excitations at high density in terms of quarks and gluons and hadronic excitations at low density in terms of baryons and mesons .","this clearly is a case of cheshire cat . now to see that this is the cheshire cat in the sense formulated in terms of the chiral bag @xcite , consider the excitation of a quark on top of the diquark - condensed vacuum . \" in @xcite , such a quark is argued to behave like a baryon .","now i claim that this quark is a quark soliton , i.e. , superqualiton @xcite . to describe the low - energy dynamics of the color - flavor locking phase , introduce a field @xmath31 which maps space - time to the coset space , @xmath32 .","one can take it to be @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the anomalous dimension of the diquark field of order @xmath35 and @xmath36 denotes the quark field with momentum close to a fermi momentum @xmath37 .","the pairing involves quarks near the opposite edge of the fermi surface .","similarly , we introduce a right - handed field @xmath38 , also a map from space - time to @xmath39 , to describe the excitations of the right - handed diquark condensate . if this field takes a vacuum expectation value as a consequence of the diquark condensation which will , owing to ( [ 1 ] ) , have the form = -= _ a , then 16 nambu - goldstone bosons will get excited .","eight of them will get eaten up by the gluons to give masses to the gluons .","the massive gluons then turn into massive vector mesons whose quantum numbers are those of the light - quark vector mesons present at zero density .","the remaining eight ( pseudoscalar ) nambu - goldstone bosons are the equivalents of the ones present at zero density and are represented by the interpolating field ( [ u ] ) . in analogy to the usual skyrmion at zero density , this field supports a soliton which is a fermion , the quantum numbers of which are identical to those of the usual baryon .","the effective lagrangian that gives rise to this soliton should in principle be derived from qcd with the help of renormalization group flows toward the fermi surface of high quark density .","such a derivation would determine the parameters that figure in the effective lagrangian such as the pion decay constant \" @xmath40 etc which would carry information on the superconductivity gap etc . at the moment","such an effective lagrangian is not known , so a detailed study of it excitation structure can not be discussed .","however one can venture to make a few interesting conjectures .","viewed as a superqualiton whose mass is given by the soliton mass , there is nothing that requires that the soliton mass be equal to or near the superconductivity gap @xmath41 ( which is dictated by the condensate ) .","in fact there is nothing which would prevent the mass from being much less than the gap .","thus one could imagine that light fermions are excited _ within _ the gap .","correlations between light superqualitons could rearrange the ground state into a different form from that of the standard superconductivity .","for this reason the phenomenon of color superconductivity in qcd at high density could be completely different from the usual bcs superconductivity .","a similar point in a different context was raised in @xcite .","the most important outcome of the recent development of eft in nuclear physics is that the highly successful approach to nuclear structure using realistic nuclear potentials ( pm ) is rendered a first - principle interpretation in that it represents the leading term in the eft expansion with the corrections thereof systematically calculable .","this confers the power of modern field theory techniques to the standard nuclear physics approach that has been practiced with success since a long time .","i am suggesting that this ","bridging \" comes about thanks to a possible duality between qcd variables and macroscopic ( color - singlet ) variables that i refer to as the cheshire cat principle .","the proton spin problem \" is an illustration of this in the basic structure of the hadron .","it is amusing that the notion of the cheshire cat which was conceived by the need to reconcile the traditional meson - exchange description with the modern qcd description for nuclear processes @xcite ( i.e. , the little bag \" with pion cloud , chiral bag etc ) at low density re - emerges at high density where one would have expected the bona - fide qcd to be uniquely applicable .","i would like to thank the organizers of this meeting , particularly chueng - ryong ji and dong - pil min for inviting me to give this talk .","i would also like to acknowledge the hospitality of kias and its director , c.w .","kim while this paper was being written .","99 s. weinberg , ; ; m. rho , ; t .- s .","park , d .-","min and m. rho , ; ; c. ordonez and u. van kolck , ; c. ordonez , l. ray and u. van kolck , ; ; u. van kolck , d.b .","kaplan , m. savage and m. wise , ; ; nucl - th/9801034 ; nucl - th/9802075 ; nucl - th/9804032 t .- s .","park , k. kubodera , d .-","min and m. rho , ; 1998 and 1999 joint caltech - int workshops : _ nuclear physics with effective field theory_. m. rho , chiral symmetry in nuclear physics , \" nucl - th/9812012 . g.e .","brown and m. rho , .","lepage , `` how to renormalize the schrdinger equation ? '' , nucl - th/9706029 d.r .","phillips and t.d .","cohen , deuteron electromagnetic properties and the viability of effective field theory methods un the two - nucleon system , \" nucl - th/9906091 . c.h .","hyun , d .-","min and t .- s .","park , next - to - leading order np scattering in cut - off effective field theory , \" to appear .","park , k. kubodera , d .-","min and m. rho , astrophys .","j. * 507 * , 443 ( 1998 ) .","park , k. kubodera , d .-","min and m. rho , nucl - th/9904053 , nucl - th/9906005 .","chen , g. rupak and m.j .","savage , suppressed amplitudes in @xmath42 , \" nucl - th/9905002 .","mller , private communication ; t.m .","mller , d. dubbers , p. hautle and o. zimmer , `` measurement of the @xmath43 anisotropy in the @xmath44-process , '' in proceedings of the `` international workshop on particle physics with slow neutrons , '' ill , grenoble , france , 22 - 24 october 1998 .","r. seki and h. griesshammer , ","open discussion and new ideas , \" in the proceedings of the 1999 joint int - caltech eft worskshop .","see e.g. b. frois and j.f .","mathiot , comments on nucl .","* 18 * , 307 ( 1989 ) .","nowak , m. rho and i. zahed , _ chiral nuclear dynamics_(world scientific , singapore , 1996 ) a. hosaka and h. toki , phys",". repts . *","277 * , 65 ( 1996 ) .","nielsen , m. rho , a. wirzba and i. zahed , phys .","b269 * , 389 ( 1991 ) ; phys . lett .","* 281 * , 345 ( 1992 ) .","min , b .- y .","park , m. rho and v. vento , the proton spin in the chiral bag model : casimir contribution and cheshire cat principle , \" nucl .","phys . * a * , in press , hep - ph/9810539 d.a .","kaplan , phys .","* b235 * , 163 ( 1990 ) ; nucl . phys .","* b351 * , 137 ( 1991 ) . m. alford , k. rajagopal and f. wilczek , phys .","b * 422 * , 247 ( 1998 ) ; r. rapp , t. schfer , e.v .","shuryak and m. velkovsky , phys .","81 * , 53 ( 1998 ) ; j. berges and k. rajagopal , nucl .","b * 538 * , 215 ( 1999 ) ; n. evans , s. hsu , and m. schwetz , nucl.phys . * b551 * , 275 ( 1999 ) ; phys . lett .","b * 449 * , 281 ( 1999 ) ; k. langfeld and m. rho , hep - ph/9811227 ; g. w. carter and d. diakonov , phys .","d * 60 * , 016004 ( 1999 ) ; m. alford , j. berges , and k. rajagopal , hep - ph/9903502 ; t. schwarz , s. klevansky and g. papp , hep - ph/9903048 ; d. t. son , hep - ph/9812287 , phys .","d * 59 * , 094019 ( 1999 ) ; r. d. pisarski and d. h. rischke , nucl - th/9811104 ; nucl - th/9903023 ; nucl - th/9906050 ; d. k. hong , hep - ph/9812510 ; hep - ph/9905523 ; d. k. hong , i. a. shovkovy , v. a. miransky , and l. c. r. wijewardhana , hep - ph/9906478 ; t. schfer and f. wilczek , hep - ph/9906512 . t. schfer and f. wilczek , phys .","lett . * 82 * , 3956 ( 1999 ) , hep - ph/9811473 ; hep - ph/9903503 .","hong , m. rho and i. zahed , ","qualitons at high density , \" hep - ph/9906551 .","r.d . pisarski and d.h .","rischke , why color - flavor locking is just like chiral symmetry breaking ? ,","\" nucl - th/9907094 . g.e .","brown and m. rho , phys . lett .","* b82 * , 177 ( 1979 ) ."],"string":"[\n \"i would like to discuss in this talk three topics which superficially would look unrelated but in essence can be connected by the general theme of cheshire cat .\",\n \"i will first look at two - nucleon systems in terms of macroscopic variables of qcd , namely hadrons ; i will then go back to an elementary hadron , in particular the proton and examine its microscopic structure by punching \\\" a hole in the proton and then putting quarks and gluons of the appropriate quantum numbers inside and argue that there is a continuity in the descriptions in terms of hadronic variables and in terms of quark - gluon variables ; finally the continuity of quarks and hadrons at high density will be described in terms of qualitons quark solitons .\",\n \"many of my collaborators have contributed to the development discussed in this talk . among them are gerry brown , bengt friman , deog ki hong , kuniharu kubodera , kurt langfeld , hee - jung lee , dong - pil min , byung - yoon park , tae - sun park , vicente vento and ismail zahed .\",\n \"consider two nucleon interactions at very low energy .\",\n \"we are generically interested in the energy - momentum probe much less than the pion mass @xmath0 mev . at this energy , according to weinberg s theorem , \\\" the content of qcd can be phrased in terms of the nucleons and pions .\",\n \"in fact if we are probing a scale much less than the pion mass , we can even ignore the pions and work with the nucleons only .\",\n \"the corresponding framework is an effective field theory ( eft ) .\",\n \"much work has been done on this eft for two - nucleon systems @xcite ( see @xcite for recent reviews ) .\",\n \"there are two classes of observables to look at .\",\n \"one is scattering process and the other is response function to external fields .\",\n \"the two are of course complementary in revealing the physics involved .\",\n \"recent efforts have been put more on scattering than on response functions although more information has traditionally been gained from the latter in nuclear physics .\",\n \"both need to be treated simultaneously which i will do here . in the literature\",\n \"so far , there are broadly two approaches to eft in nuclear physics .\",\n \"one is the original weinberg approach @xcite where a systematic power counting is made only to the `` irreducible graphs , '' for which chiral perturbation theory ( with pions figuring crucially ) becomes applicable in organizing the expansion and the reducible graphs are summed to all orders with the irreducible graphs entering as vertices .\",\n \"this scheme used in ref.@xcite which in spirit is close to the original wilsonian eft but incurs possible errors in the power counting involves a scale @xmath1 as the counting is applied only to the irreducible terms .\",\n \"i will call this the @xmath2 counting .\",\n \"the other approach @xcite motivated to account more transparently for the large s - wave scattering lengths in two - nucleon scattering purports to do a systematic counting for the s - matrix as a whole which amounts to summing all graphs involving leading non - derivative four - fermi contact interactions while treating all others , including pion exchanges , as perturbation .\",\n \"this approach renders a more systematic accounting of the powers of @xmath3 where @xmath4 , @xmath5 as well as @xmath6 but at the expense of certain predictivity .\",\n \"this is referred to as @xmath7-counting scheme .\",\n \"there have been lots of hot debates as to whether one scheme is more powerful and or more consistent than the other , mainly in connection with the scattering @xcite .\",\n \"while the situation is not completely settled , i believe that it is fair to say that the two are both consistent with the tenet of eft and roughly equivalent in its power . eschewing the debate which seems somewhat academic ,\",\n \"i will simply focus on the @xmath2-counting approach in this talk .\",\n \"in fact , in the processes that i will consider , i would claim that the @xmath2 counting is more adaptable to and more predictive in treating \",\n \"nuclear physics problems than the @xmath7 counting .\",\n \"one great advantage of the @xmath2 scheme is that it allows one to calculate precisely defined corrections to what can be obtained from so - called realistic potential models ( pm in short ) that have been developed by nuclear theorists since a long time , thus giving the realistic potential models ( pm ) a first - principle justification .\",\n \"it allows us to study processes involving not just few - body but also many - body systems .\",\n \"for instance , it is possible to calculate the \",\n \"hep \\\" process in the sun @xmath8 ( which is currently an exciting issue after the recent surperkamiokande neutrino data ) with an accuracy that can be controlled systematically .\",\n \"it has also been successfully applied to calculating axial charge transitions of heavy nuclei ( see @xcite ) with the additional ingredient of br scaling @xcite .\",\n \"while there is no definitive evidence that the @xmath2 scheme is fully justified for n - body systems with @xmath9 , it definitely works for @xmath10 systems . in ref.@xcite , it has been shown in a cutoff regularization ( with a finite cutoff as required by eft @xcite ) that the eft results of the leading order terms in all two - body observables at low energy @xmath11 are precisely reproduced by the potential model results .\",\n \"this is the case not only for scattering amplitudes but also all electroweak response functions .\",\n \"what eft brings in addition to what we get from the pm is a systematic procedure to compute corrections to the leading order results . for low - energy processes , this status of the pm can be understood by the fact that the tail of the wave functions is a physical quantity and the realistic potential models which are fit to experiments have the _ correct _ asymptotic properties in the wave function . this point has also been stressed and clarified by phillips and cohen in a recent important paper @xcite .\",\n \"considered to order @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the order in the @xmath2 counting ( which i will consider relative to the leading order term in the expansion of the irreducible graphs ) , the s - wave scattering amplitudes are accurately postdicted @xcite up to @xmath14 for @xmath10 and a cutoff appropriate to the number of pions exchanged ( one or two ) in the irreducible graphs .\",\n \"deuteron properties are also well understood within the same scheme @xcite .\",\n \"the scheme allowed the calculations to order @xmath15 and @xmath16 of the proton fusion process in the sun @xcite p+pd+e^+ + _ e[pp ] and of the threshold np capture @xcite with polarized projectile and target nucleons + d+.[np ] the process ( [ pp ] ) crucial for the solar neutrino problem is given in the scheme to an accuracy of @xmath17 percents ( the uncertainty here is due to the exchange current that appears at order @xmath16 ) .\",\n \"the unpolarized cross section for ( [ np ] ) has been computed to the accuracy of 1 percent in a complete agreement with the experiment .\",\n \"more significantly , the polarization observables @xmath18 ( circular polarization ) and @xmath19 ( anisotropy ) have been predicted _ parameter - free _ in ref.@xcite scheme was made by chen , rupak and savage @xcite . ] .\",\n \"this is a genuine prediction since there are no experimental data available .\",\n \"( they are currently being measured in ill of grenoble @xcite . ) in all these postdictions and predictions , there is very little @xmath2 dependence as required by the tenet of eft .\",\n \"this is a clear indication that the scheme is fully consistent .\",\n \"one can go up in the momentum range by doing higher order calculations .\",\n \"phillips and cohen @xcite discuss how the two - body em form factors can be described in the @xmath2 scheme . pushing somewhat the validity of the scheme\",\n \", one can calculate even the process e+de+n+p involving large momentum transfers @xmath20 gev .\",\n \"in fact this process measured in 1980 s at als of saclay and elsewhere is considered to be the _ unambiguous _ confirmation of meson - exchange currents in nuclei ( see @xcite ) .\",\n \"counting , everyone ( ! ) in the audience chuckled and said the process is completely out of reach for eft ( see @xcite ) .\",\n \"i grant that this may be true in the @xmath7 scheme at least for the moment but _ not _ in the @xmath2 scheme where it has worked stunningly , confirming the chiral filter hypothesis . \\\" _ voil _ the power of the @xmath2 scheme ! ]\",\n \"the nucleons that figured in the above section were color - singlet point - like fields that say nothing explicit about quarks and gluons .\",\n \"let me now imagine puncturing a hole of size of radius @xmath21 in the proton and populating the inside with the qcd degrees of freedom , quarks and gluons . how to do this consistently with qcd\",\n \"is known and the model involved is the chiral bag ( this is described extensively in @xcite ) which consists of a quark - gluon sector inside the bag and a color - singlet hadronic sector outside , with the two sectors connected by suitable boundary conditions .\",\n \"when constructed with relevant degrees of freedom and in consistency with the symmetries of qcd , the model gives what is now called \",\n \"cheshire cat . \\\" in short , the cheshire cat principle @xcite states that at low energy , physics involving hadrons should be independent of the bag size @xmath21 .\",\n \"it has been shown that this principle is operative semi - quantitatively in _ all _ properties of the nucleon @xcite _ except for _ the flavor - singlet axial charge ( fsac ) of the proton which is related to the proton spin .\",\n \"\\\" here i will briefly describe leaving the details to the paper by lee et al @xcite how this cheshire cat property can be recovered in the fsac when chiral symmetry and chiral anomaly are judiciously taken into account .\",\n \"it turns out that the interplay between the boundary conditions and casimir effects plays a crucial role . since the flavor - singlet axial current\",\n \"is not conserved because of the anomaly , the color can not be confined inside the bag unless a suitable boundary condition is put at the surface that cancels the outflow of the color @xcite .\",\n \"the boundary term that does this is proportional to the chern - simons current on the surface , i.e. , the chern - simons flux ( which is invariant under neither small nor large gauge transformation ) .\",\n \"this influences the fsac of the proton nontrivially .\",\n \"briefly , what happens is that the fsac contributed by the matter fields ( quarks inside the bag and @xmath22 outside the bag ) and the fsac contributed by the gauge field ( gluons inside the bag ) more or less ( or possibly exactly if treated rigorously ) cancel , leaving behind only the small contribution from the ( gauge field ) vacuum fluctuation which is effectively a casimir effect caused by the boundary with its color - anomalous boundary condition .\",\n \"the cancellation and the remnant small fsac are shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fsac ] . the upshot of the small result left over which is independent of the size @xmath21 provides yet another compelling evidence that the proton could be equivalently understood _ both _ in terms of quarks / gluons and in terms of macroscopic hadronic variables .\",\n \"when @xmath21 is taken to be big , it is the qcd variables that take over , e.g. , the mit bag . when the size @xmath21 is shrunk to a point , the proton is a skyrmion .\",\n \"thus we have the equivalence of the skyrmionic proton and the quark - gluonic ( qcd ) proton , that is , the cheshire cat .\",\n \"since there is no way one can exactly bosonize four - dimensional qcd , the equivalence can not be made exact .\",\n \"we simply have an approximate equivalence which can be made more precise by doing more work .\",\n \"what determines the language to use is the kinematic condition of the process one looks at .\",\n \"the last topic i would like to discuss is infinite nuclear matter at large density . the old lore that at an asymptotic density , the matter can be described by perturbative qcd with weakly interacting boring quarks is simply wrong\",\n \"what may be happening at high density is something a lot more exciting than that .\",\n \"this explains why lots of people are presently writing papers about it .\",\n \"what is most surprising and in some sense unexpected is that at high density the cheshire cat picture becomes more prominent .\",\n \"in fact , at high density , there ceases to be any real distinction between quarks and hadrons .\",\n \"this can be best seen in terms of a quark soliton analogous to the qualiton kaplan @xcite introduced as a model for the constituent quark .\",\n \"the mechanism i will discuss exploits that at high density diquarks condense giving rise to color superconductivity as recently discussed in the literature @xcite . since the resulting qualiton is formed from a color superconducting ground state , it seems proper to call it superqualiton @xcite .\",\n \"it has been argued on general symmetry and dynamical grounds @xcite that at high density , hadronic matter of flavor @xmath23 is characterized by the condensate = - = ^ij^abi_i [ 1 ] where @xmath24 is some constant , @xmath25 are @xmath26 indices , @xmath27 are color indices , and @xmath28 are flavor indices .\",\n \"equation ( [ 1 ] ) holds for parity - even states .\",\n \"such a condensate locks color and flavor so that global color and chiral symmetry are broken to the diagonal subgroup @xmath29 .\",\n \"the consequence of this is that there is an invariant @xmath30 subgroup that contains a twisted \\\" photon , measured with which all excitations carry integer charges reminiscent of the han - nambu quarks and have quantum numbers that correspond to those of the mesons and baryons present at zero density .\",\n \"there is then a continuity between the excitations at high density in terms of quarks and gluons and hadronic excitations at low density in terms of baryons and mesons .\",\n \"this clearly is a case of cheshire cat . now to see that this is the cheshire cat in the sense formulated in terms of the chiral bag @xcite , consider the excitation of a quark on top of the diquark - condensed vacuum . \\\" in @xcite , such a quark is argued to behave like a baryon .\",\n \"now i claim that this quark is a quark soliton , i.e. , superqualiton @xcite . to describe the low - energy dynamics of the color - flavor locking phase , introduce a field @xmath31 which maps space - time to the coset space , @xmath32 .\",\n \"one can take it to be @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the anomalous dimension of the diquark field of order @xmath35 and @xmath36 denotes the quark field with momentum close to a fermi momentum @xmath37 .\",\n \"the pairing involves quarks near the opposite edge of the fermi surface .\",\n \"similarly , we introduce a right - handed field @xmath38 , also a map from space - time to @xmath39 , to describe the excitations of the right - handed diquark condensate . if this field takes a vacuum expectation value as a consequence of the diquark condensation which will , owing to ( [ 1 ] ) , have the form = -= _ a , then 16 nambu - goldstone bosons will get excited .\",\n \"eight of them will get eaten up by the gluons to give masses to the gluons .\",\n \"the massive gluons then turn into massive vector mesons whose quantum numbers are those of the light - quark vector mesons present at zero density .\",\n \"the remaining eight ( pseudoscalar ) nambu - goldstone bosons are the equivalents of the ones present at zero density and are represented by the interpolating field ( [ u ] ) . in analogy to the usual skyrmion at zero density , this field supports a soliton which is a fermion , the quantum numbers of which are identical to those of the usual baryon .\",\n \"the effective lagrangian that gives rise to this soliton should in principle be derived from qcd with the help of renormalization group flows toward the fermi surface of high quark density .\",\n \"such a derivation would determine the parameters that figure in the effective lagrangian such as the pion decay constant \\\" @xmath40 etc which would carry information on the superconductivity gap etc . at the moment\",\n \"such an effective lagrangian is not known , so a detailed study of it excitation structure can not be discussed .\",\n \"however one can venture to make a few interesting conjectures .\",\n \"viewed as a superqualiton whose mass is given by the soliton mass , there is nothing that requires that the soliton mass be equal to or near the superconductivity gap @xmath41 ( which is dictated by the condensate ) .\",\n \"in fact there is nothing which would prevent the mass from being much less than the gap .\",\n \"thus one could imagine that light fermions are excited _ within _ the gap .\",\n \"correlations between light superqualitons could rearrange the ground state into a different form from that of the standard superconductivity .\",\n \"for this reason the phenomenon of color superconductivity in qcd at high density could be completely different from the usual bcs superconductivity .\",\n \"a similar point in a different context was raised in @xcite .\",\n \"the most important outcome of the recent development of eft in nuclear physics is that the highly successful approach to nuclear structure using realistic nuclear potentials ( pm ) is rendered a first - principle interpretation in that it represents the leading term in the eft expansion with the corrections thereof systematically calculable .\",\n \"this confers the power of modern field theory techniques to the standard nuclear physics approach that has been practiced with success since a long time .\",\n \"i am suggesting that this \",\n \"bridging \\\" comes about thanks to a possible duality between qcd variables and macroscopic ( color - singlet ) variables that i refer to as the cheshire cat principle .\",\n \"the proton spin problem \\\" is an illustration of this in the basic structure of the hadron .\",\n \"it is amusing that the notion of the cheshire cat which was conceived by the need to reconcile the traditional meson - exchange description with the modern qcd description for nuclear processes @xcite ( i.e. , the little bag \\\" with pion cloud , chiral bag etc ) at low density re - emerges at high density where one would have expected the bona - fide qcd to be uniquely applicable .\",\n \"i would like to thank the organizers of this meeting , particularly chueng - ryong ji and dong - pil min for inviting me to give this talk .\",\n \"i would also like to acknowledge the hospitality of kias and its director , c.w .\",\n \"kim while this paper was being written .\",\n \"99 s. weinberg , ; ; m. rho , ; t .- s .\",\n \"park , d .-\",\n \"min and m. rho , ; ; c. ordonez and u. van kolck , ; c. ordonez , l. ray and u. van kolck , ; ; u. van kolck , d.b .\",\n \"kaplan , m. savage and m. wise , ; ; nucl - th/9801034 ; nucl - th/9802075 ; nucl - th/9804032 t .- s .\",\n \"park , k. kubodera , d .-\",\n \"min and m. rho , ; 1998 and 1999 joint caltech - int workshops : _ nuclear physics with effective field theory_. m. rho , chiral symmetry in nuclear physics , \\\" nucl - th/9812012 . g.e .\",\n \"brown and m. rho , .\",\n \"lepage , `` how to renormalize the schrdinger equation ? '' , nucl - th/9706029 d.r .\",\n \"phillips and t.d .\",\n \"cohen , deuteron electromagnetic properties and the viability of effective field theory methods un the two - nucleon system , \\\" nucl - th/9906091 . c.h .\",\n \"hyun , d .-\",\n \"min and t .- s .\",\n \"park , next - to - leading order np scattering in cut - off effective field theory , \\\" to appear .\",\n \"park , k. kubodera , d .-\",\n \"min and m. rho , astrophys .\",\n \"j. * 507 * , 443 ( 1998 ) .\",\n \"park , k. kubodera , d .-\",\n \"min and m. rho , nucl - th/9904053 , nucl - th/9906005 .\",\n \"chen , g. rupak and m.j .\",\n \"savage , suppressed amplitudes in @xmath42 , \\\" nucl - th/9905002 .\",\n \"mller , private communication ; t.m .\",\n \"mller , d. dubbers , p. hautle and o. zimmer , `` measurement of the @xmath43 anisotropy in the @xmath44-process , '' in proceedings of the `` international workshop on particle physics with slow neutrons , '' ill , grenoble , france , 22 - 24 october 1998 .\",\n \"r. seki and h. griesshammer , \",\n \"open discussion and new ideas , \\\" in the proceedings of the 1999 joint int - caltech eft worskshop .\",\n \"see e.g. b. frois and j.f .\",\n \"mathiot , comments on nucl .\",\n \"* 18 * , 307 ( 1989 ) .\",\n \"nowak , m. rho and i. zahed , _ chiral nuclear dynamics_(world scientific , singapore , 1996 ) a. hosaka and h. toki , phys\",\n \". repts . *\",\n \"277 * , 65 ( 1996 ) .\",\n \"nielsen , m. rho , a. wirzba and i. zahed , phys .\",\n \"b269 * , 389 ( 1991 ) ; phys . lett .\",\n \"* 281 * , 345 ( 1992 ) .\",\n \"min , b .- y .\",\n \"park , m. rho and v. vento , the proton spin in the chiral bag model : casimir contribution and cheshire cat principle , \\\" nucl .\",\n \"phys . * a * , in press , hep - ph/9810539 d.a .\",\n \"kaplan , phys .\",\n \"* b235 * , 163 ( 1990 ) ; nucl . phys .\",\n \"* b351 * , 137 ( 1991 ) . m. alford , k. rajagopal and f. wilczek , phys .\",\n \"b * 422 * , 247 ( 1998 ) ; r. rapp , t. schfer , e.v .\",\n \"shuryak and m. velkovsky , phys .\",\n \"81 * , 53 ( 1998 ) ; j. berges and k. rajagopal , nucl .\",\n \"b * 538 * , 215 ( 1999 ) ; n. evans , s. hsu , and m. schwetz , nucl.phys . * b551 * , 275 ( 1999 ) ; phys . lett .\",\n \"b * 449 * , 281 ( 1999 ) ; k. langfeld and m. rho , hep - ph/9811227 ; g. w. carter and d. diakonov , phys .\",\n \"d * 60 * , 016004 ( 1999 ) ; m. alford , j. berges , and k. rajagopal , hep - ph/9903502 ; t. schwarz , s. klevansky and g. papp , hep - ph/9903048 ; d. t. son , hep - ph/9812287 , phys .\",\n \"d * 59 * , 094019 ( 1999 ) ; r. d. pisarski and d. h. rischke , nucl - th/9811104 ; nucl - th/9903023 ; nucl - th/9906050 ; d. k. hong , hep - ph/9812510 ; hep - ph/9905523 ; d. k. hong , i. a. shovkovy , v. a. miransky , and l. c. r. wijewardhana , hep - ph/9906478 ; t. schfer and f. wilczek , hep - ph/9906512 . t. schfer and f. wilczek , phys .\",\n \"lett . * 82 * , 3956 ( 1999 ) , hep - ph/9811473 ; hep - ph/9903503 .\",\n \"hong , m. rho and i. zahed , \",\n \"qualitons at high density , \\\" hep - ph/9906551 .\",\n \"r.d . pisarski and d.h .\",\n \"rischke , why color - flavor locking is just like chiral symmetry breaking ? ,\",\n \"\\\" nucl - th/9907094 . g.e .\",\n \"brown and m. rho , phys . lett .\",\n \"* b82 * , 177 ( 1979 ) .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> in this talk i discuss three related topics based on some of the recent developments in hadron and nuclear physics : one , effective field theory approach to two - nucleon systems ; two , an explanation of the flavor singlet axial charge in the proton ( i.e. , proton spin problem \" ) in terms of a cheshire cat phenomenon ; and three , the quark - hadron duality in hadronic matter at high density and qualitons \" at high density ( `` superqualitons '' ) . </S>","<S> the principal common theme in these discussions will be the emergence of the generic feature of the cheshire cat principle . </S>","<S> -.7 in .25 in # 1#2#3#4 # 1 * # 2 * , # 3 ( # 4 ) # 1 # 1| # 1 | # 1 0.4 cm * effective field theory for nuclei , * 0.2 cm * dense matter and the cheshire cat * 1.5 cm mannque rho 0.5 cm _ school of physics , korea institute for advanced study , seoul 130 - 012 , korea _ and _ service de physique thorique , ce saclay , 91191 gif - sur - yvette , france _ </S>","<S> e - mail : rho@spht.saclay.cea.fr 0.5 cm </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> in this talk i discuss three related topics based on some of the recent developments in hadron and nuclear physics : one , effective field theory approach to two - nucleon systems ; two , an explanation of the flavor singlet axial charge in the proton ( i.e. , proton spin problem \\\" ) in terms of a cheshire cat phenomenon ; and three , the quark - hadron duality in hadronic matter at high density and qualitons \\\" at high density ( `` superqualitons '' ) . </S>\",\n \"<S> the principal common theme in these discussions will be the emergence of the generic feature of the cheshire cat principle . </S>\",\n \"<S> -.7 in .25 in # 1#2#3#4 # 1 * # 2 * , # 3 ( # 4 ) # 1 # 1| # 1 | # 1 0.4 cm * effective field theory for nuclei , * 0.2 cm * dense matter and the cheshire cat * 1.5 cm mannque rho 0.5 cm _ school of physics , korea institute for advanced study , seoul 130 - 012 , korea _ and _ service de physique thorique , ce saclay , 91191 gif - sur - yvette , france _ </S>\",\n \"<S> e - mail : rho@spht.saclay.cea.fr 0.5 cm </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","two-nucleon systems in effective field theory","proton spin\" and the cheshire cat","dense matter and the cheshire cat","conclusion"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"two-nucleon systems in effective field theory\",\n \"proton spin\\\" and the cheshire cat\",\n \"dense matter and the cheshire cat\",\n \"conclusion\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["i would like to discuss in this talk three topics which superficially would look unrelated but in essence can be connected by the general theme of cheshire cat .","i will first look at two - nucleon systems in terms of macroscopic variables of qcd , namely hadrons ; i will then go back to an elementary hadron , in particular the proton and examine its microscopic structure by punching \" a hole in the proton and then putting quarks and gluons of the appropriate quantum numbers inside and argue that there is a continuity in the descriptions in terms of hadronic variables and in terms of quark - gluon variables ; finally the continuity of quarks and hadrons at high density will be described in terms of qualitons quark solitons .","many of my collaborators have contributed to the development discussed in this talk . among them are gerry brown , bengt friman , deog ki hong , kuniharu kubodera , kurt langfeld , hee - jung lee , dong - pil min , byung - yoon park , tae - sun park , vicente vento and ismail zahed ."],["consider two nucleon interactions at very low energy .","we are generically interested in the energy - momentum probe much less than the pion mass @xmath0 mev . at this energy , according to weinberg s theorem , \" the content of qcd can be phrased in terms of the nucleons and pions .","in fact if we are probing a scale much less than the pion mass , we can even ignore the pions and work with the nucleons only .","the corresponding framework is an effective field theory ( eft ) .","much work has been done on this eft for two - nucleon systems @xcite ( see @xcite for recent reviews ) .","there are two classes of observables to look at .","one is scattering process and the other is response function to external fields .","the two are of course complementary in revealing the physics involved .","recent efforts have been put more on scattering than on response functions although more information has traditionally been gained from the latter in nuclear physics .","both need to be treated simultaneously which i will do here . in the literature","so far , there are broadly two approaches to eft in nuclear physics .","one is the original weinberg approach @xcite where a systematic power counting is made only to the `` irreducible graphs , '' for which chiral perturbation theory ( with pions figuring crucially ) becomes applicable in organizing the expansion and the reducible graphs are summed to all orders with the irreducible graphs entering as vertices .","this scheme used in ref.@xcite which in spirit is close to the original wilsonian eft but incurs possible errors in the power counting involves a scale @xmath1 as the counting is applied only to the irreducible terms .","i will call this the @xmath2 counting .","the other approach @xcite motivated to account more transparently for the large s - wave scattering lengths in two - nucleon scattering purports to do a systematic counting for the s - matrix as a whole which amounts to summing all graphs involving leading non - derivative four - fermi contact interactions while treating all others , including pion exchanges , as perturbation .","this approach renders a more systematic accounting of the powers of @xmath3 where @xmath4 , @xmath5 as well as @xmath6 but at the expense of certain predictivity .","this is referred to as @xmath7-counting scheme .","there have been lots of hot debates as to whether one scheme is more powerful and or more consistent than the other , mainly in connection with the scattering @xcite .","while the situation is not completely settled , i believe that it is fair to say that the two are both consistent with the tenet of eft and roughly equivalent in its power . eschewing the debate which seems somewhat academic ,","i will simply focus on the @xmath2-counting approach in this talk .","in fact , in the processes that i will consider , i would claim that the @xmath2 counting is more adaptable to and more predictive in treating ","nuclear physics problems than the @xmath7 counting .","one great advantage of the @xmath2 scheme is that it allows one to calculate precisely defined corrections to what can be obtained from so - called realistic potential models ( pm in short ) that have been developed by nuclear theorists since a long time , thus giving the realistic potential models ( pm ) a first - principle justification .","it allows us to study processes involving not just few - body but also many - body systems .","for instance , it is possible to calculate the ","hep \" process in the sun @xmath8 ( which is currently an exciting issue after the recent surperkamiokande neutrino data ) with an accuracy that can be controlled systematically .","it has also been successfully applied to calculating axial charge transitions of heavy nuclei ( see @xcite ) with the additional ingredient of br scaling @xcite .","while there is no definitive evidence that the @xmath2 scheme is fully justified for n - body systems with @xmath9 , it definitely works for @xmath10 systems . in ref.@xcite , it has been shown in a cutoff regularization ( with a finite cutoff as required by eft @xcite ) that the eft results of the leading order terms in all two - body observables at low energy @xmath11 are precisely reproduced by the potential model results .","this is the case not only for scattering amplitudes but also all electroweak response functions .","what eft brings in addition to what we get from the pm is a systematic procedure to compute corrections to the leading order results . for low - energy processes , this status of the pm can be understood by the fact that the tail of the wave functions is a physical quantity and the realistic potential models which are fit to experiments have the _ correct _ asymptotic properties in the wave function . this point has also been stressed and clarified by phillips and cohen in a recent important paper @xcite .","considered to order @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the order in the @xmath2 counting ( which i will consider relative to the leading order term in the expansion of the irreducible graphs ) , the s - wave scattering amplitudes are accurately postdicted @xcite up to @xmath14 for @xmath10 and a cutoff appropriate to the number of pions exchanged ( one or two ) in the irreducible graphs .","deuteron properties are also well understood within the same scheme @xcite .","the scheme allowed the calculations to order @xmath15 and @xmath16 of the proton fusion process in the sun @xcite p+pd+e^+ + _ e[pp ] and of the threshold np capture @xcite with polarized projectile and target nucleons + d+.[np ] the process ( [ pp ] ) crucial for the solar neutrino problem is given in the scheme to an accuracy of @xmath17 percents ( the uncertainty here is due to the exchange current that appears at order @xmath16 ) .","the unpolarized cross section for ( [ np ] ) has been computed to the accuracy of 1 percent in a complete agreement with the experiment .","more significantly , the polarization observables @xmath18 ( circular polarization ) and @xmath19 ( anisotropy ) have been predicted _ parameter - free _ in ref.@xcite scheme was made by chen , rupak and savage @xcite . ] .","this is a genuine prediction since there are no experimental data available .","( they are currently being measured in ill of grenoble @xcite . ) in all these postdictions and predictions , there is very little @xmath2 dependence as required by the tenet of eft .","this is a clear indication that the scheme is fully consistent .","one can go up in the momentum range by doing higher order calculations .","phillips and cohen @xcite discuss how the two - body em form factors can be described in the @xmath2 scheme . pushing somewhat the validity of the scheme",", one can calculate even the process e+de+n+p involving large momentum transfers @xmath20 gev .","in fact this process measured in 1980 s at als of saclay and elsewhere is considered to be the _ unambiguous _ confirmation of meson - exchange currents in nuclei ( see @xcite ) .","counting , everyone ( ! ) in the audience chuckled and said the process is completely out of reach for eft ( see @xcite ) .","i grant that this may be true in the @xmath7 scheme at least for the moment but _ not _ in the @xmath2 scheme where it has worked stunningly , confirming the chiral filter hypothesis . \" _ voil _ the power of the @xmath2 scheme ! ]"],["the nucleons that figured in the above section were color - singlet point - like fields that say nothing explicit about quarks and gluons .","let me now imagine puncturing a hole of size of radius @xmath21 in the proton and populating the inside with the qcd degrees of freedom , quarks and gluons . how to do this consistently with qcd","is known and the model involved is the chiral bag ( this is described extensively in @xcite ) which consists of a quark - gluon sector inside the bag and a color - singlet hadronic sector outside , with the two sectors connected by suitable boundary conditions .","when constructed with relevant degrees of freedom and in consistency with the symmetries of qcd , the model gives what is now called ","cheshire cat . \" in short , the cheshire cat principle @xcite states that at low energy , physics involving hadrons should be independent of the bag size @xmath21 .","it has been shown that this principle is operative semi - quantitatively in _ all _ properties of the nucleon @xcite _ except for _ the flavor - singlet axial charge ( fsac ) of the proton which is related to the proton spin .","\" here i will briefly describe leaving the details to the paper by lee et al @xcite how this cheshire cat property can be recovered in the fsac when chiral symmetry and chiral anomaly are judiciously taken into account .","it turns out that the interplay between the boundary conditions and casimir effects plays a crucial role . since the flavor - singlet axial current","is not conserved because of the anomaly , the color can not be confined inside the bag unless a suitable boundary condition is put at the surface that cancels the outflow of the color @xcite .","the boundary term that does this is proportional to the chern - simons current on the surface , i.e. , the chern - simons flux ( which is invariant under neither small nor large gauge transformation ) .","this influences the fsac of the proton nontrivially .","briefly , what happens is that the fsac contributed by the matter fields ( quarks inside the bag and @xmath22 outside the bag ) and the fsac contributed by the gauge field ( gluons inside the bag ) more or less ( or possibly exactly if treated rigorously ) cancel , leaving behind only the small contribution from the ( gauge field ) vacuum fluctuation which is effectively a casimir effect caused by the boundary with its color - anomalous boundary condition .","the cancellation and the remnant small fsac are shown in fig .","[ fsac ] . the upshot of the small result left over which is independent of the size @xmath21 provides yet another compelling evidence that the proton could be equivalently understood _ both _ in terms of quarks / gluons and in terms of macroscopic hadronic variables .","when @xmath21 is taken to be big , it is the qcd variables that take over , e.g. , the mit bag . when the size @xmath21 is shrunk to a point , the proton is a skyrmion .","thus we have the equivalence of the skyrmionic proton and the quark - gluonic ( qcd ) proton , that is , the cheshire cat .","since there is no way one can exactly bosonize four - dimensional qcd , the equivalence can not be made exact .","we simply have an approximate equivalence which can be made more precise by doing more work .","what determines the language to use is the kinematic condition of the process one looks at ."],["the last topic i would like to discuss is infinite nuclear matter at large density . the old lore that at an asymptotic density , the matter can be described by perturbative qcd with weakly interacting boring quarks is simply wrong","what may be happening at high density is something a lot more exciting than that .","this explains why lots of people are presently writing papers about it .","what is most surprising and in some sense unexpected is that at high density the cheshire cat picture becomes more prominent .","in fact , at high density , there ceases to be any real distinction between quarks and hadrons .","this can be best seen in terms of a quark soliton analogous to the qualiton kaplan @xcite introduced as a model for the constituent quark .","the mechanism i will discuss exploits that at high density diquarks condense giving rise to color superconductivity as recently discussed in the literature @xcite . since the resulting qualiton is formed from a color superconducting ground state , it seems proper to call it superqualiton @xcite .","it has been argued on general symmetry and dynamical grounds @xcite that at high density , hadronic matter of flavor @xmath23 is characterized by the condensate = - = ^ij^abi_i [ 1 ] where @xmath24 is some constant , @xmath25 are @xmath26 indices , @xmath27 are color indices , and @xmath28 are flavor indices .","equation ( [ 1 ] ) holds for parity - even states .","such a condensate locks color and flavor so that global color and chiral symmetry are broken to the diagonal subgroup @xmath29 .","the consequence of this is that there is an invariant @xmath30 subgroup that contains a twisted \" photon , measured with which all excitations carry integer charges reminiscent of the han - nambu quarks and have quantum numbers that correspond to those of the mesons and baryons present at zero density .","there is then a continuity between the excitations at high density in terms of quarks and gluons and hadronic excitations at low density in terms of baryons and mesons .","this clearly is a case of cheshire cat . now to see that this is the cheshire cat in the sense formulated in terms of the chiral bag @xcite , consider the excitation of a quark on top of the diquark - condensed vacuum . \" in @xcite , such a quark is argued to behave like a baryon .","now i claim that this quark is a quark soliton , i.e. , superqualiton @xcite . to describe the low - energy dynamics of the color - flavor locking phase , introduce a field @xmath31 which maps space - time to the coset space , @xmath32 .","one can take it to be @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the anomalous dimension of the diquark field of order @xmath35 and @xmath36 denotes the quark field with momentum close to a fermi momentum @xmath37 .","the pairing involves quarks near the opposite edge of the fermi surface .","similarly , we introduce a right - handed field @xmath38 , also a map from space - time to @xmath39 , to describe the excitations of the right - handed diquark condensate . if this field takes a vacuum expectation value as a consequence of the diquark condensation which will , owing to ( [ 1 ] ) , have the form = -= _ a , then 16 nambu - goldstone bosons will get excited .","eight of them will get eaten up by the gluons to give masses to the gluons .","the massive gluons then turn into massive vector mesons whose quantum numbers are those of the light - quark vector mesons present at zero density .","the remaining eight ( pseudoscalar ) nambu - goldstone bosons are the equivalents of the ones present at zero density and are represented by the interpolating field ( [ u ] ) . in analogy to the usual skyrmion at zero density , this field supports a soliton which is a fermion , the quantum numbers of which are identical to those of the usual baryon .","the effective lagrangian that gives rise to this soliton should in principle be derived from qcd with the help of renormalization group flows toward the fermi surface of high quark density .","such a derivation would determine the parameters that figure in the effective lagrangian such as the pion decay constant \" @xmath40 etc which would carry information on the superconductivity gap etc . at the moment","such an effective lagrangian is not known , so a detailed study of it excitation structure can not be discussed .","however one can venture to make a few interesting conjectures .","viewed as a superqualiton whose mass is given by the soliton mass , there is nothing that requires that the soliton mass be equal to or near the superconductivity gap @xmath41 ( which is dictated by the condensate ) .","in fact there is nothing which would prevent the mass from being much less than the gap .","thus one could imagine that light fermions are excited _ within _ the gap .","correlations between light superqualitons could rearrange the ground state into a different form from that of the standard superconductivity .","for this reason the phenomenon of color superconductivity in qcd at high density could be completely different from the usual bcs superconductivity .","a similar point in a different context was raised in @xcite ."],["the most important outcome of the recent development of eft in nuclear physics is that the highly successful approach to nuclear structure using realistic nuclear potentials ( pm ) is rendered a first - principle interpretation in that it represents the leading term in the eft expansion with the corrections thereof systematically calculable .","this confers the power of modern field theory techniques to the standard nuclear physics approach that has been practiced with success since a long time .","i am suggesting that this ","bridging \" comes about thanks to a possible duality between qcd variables and macroscopic ( color - singlet ) variables that i refer to as the cheshire cat principle .","the proton spin problem \" is an illustration of this in the basic structure of the hadron .","it is amusing that the notion of the cheshire cat which was conceived by the need to reconcile the traditional meson - exchange description with the modern qcd description for nuclear processes @xcite ( i.e. , the little bag \" with pion cloud , chiral bag etc ) at low density re - emerges at high density where one would have expected the bona - fide qcd to be uniquely applicable .","i would like to thank the organizers of this meeting , particularly chueng - ryong ji and dong - pil min for inviting me to give this talk .","i would also like to acknowledge the hospitality of kias and its director , c.w .","kim while this paper was being written .","99 s. weinberg , ; ; m. rho , ; t .- s .","park , d .-","min and m. rho , ; ; c. ordonez and u. van kolck , ; c. ordonez , l. ray and u. van kolck , ; ; u. van kolck , d.b .","kaplan , m. savage and m. wise , ; ; nucl - th/9801034 ; nucl - th/9802075 ; nucl - th/9804032 t .- s .","park , k. kubodera , d .-","min and m. rho , ; 1998 and 1999 joint caltech - int workshops : _ nuclear physics with effective field theory_. m. rho , chiral symmetry in nuclear physics , \" nucl - th/9812012 . g.e .","brown and m. rho , .","lepage , `` how to renormalize the schrdinger equation ? '' , nucl - th/9706029 d.r .","phillips and t.d .","cohen , deuteron electromagnetic properties and the viability of effective field theory methods un the two - nucleon system , \" nucl - th/9906091 . c.h .","hyun , d .-","min and t .- s .","park , next - to - leading order np scattering in cut - off effective field theory , \" to appear .","park , k. kubodera , d .-","min and m. rho , astrophys .","j. * 507 * , 443 ( 1998 ) .","park , k. kubodera , d .-","min and m. rho , nucl - th/9904053 , nucl - th/9906005 .","chen , g. rupak and m.j .","savage , suppressed amplitudes in @xmath42 , \" nucl - th/9905002 .","mller , private communication ; t.m .","mller , d. dubbers , p. hautle and o. zimmer , `` measurement of the @xmath43 anisotropy in the @xmath44-process , '' in proceedings of the `` international workshop on particle physics with slow neutrons , '' ill , grenoble , france , 22 - 24 october 1998 .","r. seki and h. griesshammer , ","open discussion and new ideas , \" in the proceedings of the 1999 joint int - caltech eft worskshop .","see e.g. b. frois and j.f .","mathiot , comments on nucl .","* 18 * , 307 ( 1989 ) .","nowak , m. rho and i. zahed , _ chiral nuclear dynamics_(world scientific , singapore , 1996 ) a. hosaka and h. toki , phys",". repts . *","277 * , 65 ( 1996 ) .","nielsen , m. rho , a. wirzba and i. zahed , phys .","b269 * , 389 ( 1991 ) ; phys . lett .","* 281 * , 345 ( 1992 ) .","min , b .- y .","park , m. rho and v. vento , the proton spin in the chiral bag model : casimir contribution and cheshire cat principle , \" nucl .","phys . * a * , in press , hep - ph/9810539 d.a .","kaplan , phys .","* b235 * , 163 ( 1990 ) ; nucl . phys .","* b351 * , 137 ( 1991 ) . m. alford , k. rajagopal and f. wilczek , phys .","b * 422 * , 247 ( 1998 ) ; r. rapp , t. schfer , e.v .","shuryak and m. velkovsky , phys .","81 * , 53 ( 1998 ) ; j. berges and k. rajagopal , nucl .","b * 538 * , 215 ( 1999 ) ; n. evans , s. hsu , and m. schwetz , nucl.phys . * b551 * , 275 ( 1999 ) ; phys . lett .","b * 449 * , 281 ( 1999 ) ; k. langfeld and m. rho , hep - ph/9811227 ; g. w. carter and d. diakonov , phys .","d * 60 * , 016004 ( 1999 ) ; m. alford , j. berges , and k. rajagopal , hep - ph/9903502 ; t. schwarz , s. klevansky and g. papp , hep - ph/9903048 ; d. t. son , hep - ph/9812287 , phys .","d * 59 * , 094019 ( 1999 ) ; r. d. pisarski and d. h. rischke , nucl - th/9811104 ; nucl - th/9903023 ; nucl - th/9906050 ; d. k. hong , hep - ph/9812510 ; hep - ph/9905523 ; d. k. hong , i. a. shovkovy , v. a. miransky , and l. c. r. wijewardhana , hep - ph/9906478 ; t. schfer and f. wilczek , hep - ph/9906512 . t. schfer and f. wilczek , phys .","lett . * 82 * , 3956 ( 1999 ) , hep - ph/9811473 ; hep - ph/9903503 .","hong , m. rho and i. zahed , ","qualitons at high density , \" hep - ph/9906551 .","r.d . pisarski and d.h .","rischke , why color - flavor locking is just like chiral symmetry breaking ? ,","\" nucl - th/9907094 . g.e .","brown and m. rho , phys . lett .","* b82 * , 177 ( 1979 ) ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"i would like to discuss in this talk three topics which superficially would look unrelated but in essence can be connected by the general theme of cheshire cat .\",\n \"i will first look at two - nucleon systems in terms of macroscopic variables of qcd , namely hadrons ; i will then go back to an elementary hadron , in particular the proton and examine its microscopic structure by punching \\\" a hole in the proton and then putting quarks and gluons of the appropriate quantum numbers inside and argue that there is a continuity in the descriptions in terms of hadronic variables and in terms of quark - gluon variables ; finally the continuity of quarks and hadrons at high density will be described in terms of qualitons quark solitons .\",\n \"many of my collaborators have contributed to the development discussed in this talk . among them are gerry brown , bengt friman , deog ki hong , kuniharu kubodera , kurt langfeld , hee - jung lee , dong - pil min , byung - yoon park , tae - sun park , vicente vento and ismail zahed .\"\n ],\n [\n \"consider two nucleon interactions at very low energy .\",\n \"we are generically interested in the energy - momentum probe much less than the pion mass @xmath0 mev . at this energy , according to weinberg s theorem , \\\" the content of qcd can be phrased in terms of the nucleons and pions .\",\n \"in fact if we are probing a scale much less than the pion mass , we can even ignore the pions and work with the nucleons only .\",\n \"the corresponding framework is an effective field theory ( eft ) .\",\n \"much work has been done on this eft for two - nucleon systems @xcite ( see @xcite for recent reviews ) .\",\n \"there are two classes of observables to look at .\",\n \"one is scattering process and the other is response function to external fields .\",\n \"the two are of course complementary in revealing the physics involved .\",\n \"recent efforts have been put more on scattering than on response functions although more information has traditionally been gained from the latter in nuclear physics .\",\n \"both need to be treated simultaneously which i will do here . in the literature\",\n \"so far , there are broadly two approaches to eft in nuclear physics .\",\n \"one is the original weinberg approach @xcite where a systematic power counting is made only to the `` irreducible graphs , '' for which chiral perturbation theory ( with pions figuring crucially ) becomes applicable in organizing the expansion and the reducible graphs are summed to all orders with the irreducible graphs entering as vertices .\",\n \"this scheme used in ref.@xcite which in spirit is close to the original wilsonian eft but incurs possible errors in the power counting involves a scale @xmath1 as the counting is applied only to the irreducible terms .\",\n \"i will call this the @xmath2 counting .\",\n \"the other approach @xcite motivated to account more transparently for the large s - wave scattering lengths in two - nucleon scattering purports to do a systematic counting for the s - matrix as a whole which amounts to summing all graphs involving leading non - derivative four - fermi contact interactions while treating all others , including pion exchanges , as perturbation .\",\n \"this approach renders a more systematic accounting of the powers of @xmath3 where @xmath4 , @xmath5 as well as @xmath6 but at the expense of certain predictivity .\",\n \"this is referred to as @xmath7-counting scheme .\",\n \"there have been lots of hot debates as to whether one scheme is more powerful and or more consistent than the other , mainly in connection with the scattering @xcite .\",\n \"while the situation is not completely settled , i believe that it is fair to say that the two are both consistent with the tenet of eft and roughly equivalent in its power . eschewing the debate which seems somewhat academic ,\",\n \"i will simply focus on the @xmath2-counting approach in this talk .\",\n \"in fact , in the processes that i will consider , i would claim that the @xmath2 counting is more adaptable to and more predictive in treating \",\n \"nuclear physics problems than the @xmath7 counting .\",\n \"one great advantage of the @xmath2 scheme is that it allows one to calculate precisely defined corrections to what can be obtained from so - called realistic potential models ( pm in short ) that have been developed by nuclear theorists since a long time , thus giving the realistic potential models ( pm ) a first - principle justification .\",\n \"it allows us to study processes involving not just few - body but also many - body systems .\",\n \"for instance , it is possible to calculate the \",\n \"hep \\\" process in the sun @xmath8 ( which is currently an exciting issue after the recent surperkamiokande neutrino data ) with an accuracy that can be controlled systematically .\",\n \"it has also been successfully applied to calculating axial charge transitions of heavy nuclei ( see @xcite ) with the additional ingredient of br scaling @xcite .\",\n \"while there is no definitive evidence that the @xmath2 scheme is fully justified for n - body systems with @xmath9 , it definitely works for @xmath10 systems . in ref.@xcite , it has been shown in a cutoff regularization ( with a finite cutoff as required by eft @xcite ) that the eft results of the leading order terms in all two - body observables at low energy @xmath11 are precisely reproduced by the potential model results .\",\n \"this is the case not only for scattering amplitudes but also all electroweak response functions .\",\n \"what eft brings in addition to what we get from the pm is a systematic procedure to compute corrections to the leading order results . for low - energy processes , this status of the pm can be understood by the fact that the tail of the wave functions is a physical quantity and the realistic potential models which are fit to experiments have the _ correct _ asymptotic properties in the wave function . this point has also been stressed and clarified by phillips and cohen in a recent important paper @xcite .\",\n \"considered to order @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the order in the @xmath2 counting ( which i will consider relative to the leading order term in the expansion of the irreducible graphs ) , the s - wave scattering amplitudes are accurately postdicted @xcite up to @xmath14 for @xmath10 and a cutoff appropriate to the number of pions exchanged ( one or two ) in the irreducible graphs .\",\n \"deuteron properties are also well understood within the same scheme @xcite .\",\n \"the scheme allowed the calculations to order @xmath15 and @xmath16 of the proton fusion process in the sun @xcite p+pd+e^+ + _ e[pp ] and of the threshold np capture @xcite with polarized projectile and target nucleons + d+.[np ] the process ( [ pp ] ) crucial for the solar neutrino problem is given in the scheme to an accuracy of @xmath17 percents ( the uncertainty here is due to the exchange current that appears at order @xmath16 ) .\",\n \"the unpolarized cross section for ( [ np ] ) has been computed to the accuracy of 1 percent in a complete agreement with the experiment .\",\n \"more significantly , the polarization observables @xmath18 ( circular polarization ) and @xmath19 ( anisotropy ) have been predicted _ parameter - free _ in ref.@xcite scheme was made by chen , rupak and savage @xcite . ] .\",\n \"this is a genuine prediction since there are no experimental data available .\",\n \"( they are currently being measured in ill of grenoble @xcite . ) in all these postdictions and predictions , there is very little @xmath2 dependence as required by the tenet of eft .\",\n \"this is a clear indication that the scheme is fully consistent .\",\n \"one can go up in the momentum range by doing higher order calculations .\",\n \"phillips and cohen @xcite discuss how the two - body em form factors can be described in the @xmath2 scheme . pushing somewhat the validity of the scheme\",\n \", one can calculate even the process e+de+n+p involving large momentum transfers @xmath20 gev .\",\n \"in fact this process measured in 1980 s at als of saclay and elsewhere is considered to be the _ unambiguous _ confirmation of meson - exchange currents in nuclei ( see @xcite ) .\",\n \"counting , everyone ( ! ) in the audience chuckled and said the process is completely out of reach for eft ( see @xcite ) .\",\n \"i grant that this may be true in the @xmath7 scheme at least for the moment but _ not _ in the @xmath2 scheme where it has worked stunningly , confirming the chiral filter hypothesis . \\\" _ voil _ the power of the @xmath2 scheme ! ]\"\n ],\n [\n \"the nucleons that figured in the above section were color - singlet point - like fields that say nothing explicit about quarks and gluons .\",\n \"let me now imagine puncturing a hole of size of radius @xmath21 in the proton and populating the inside with the qcd degrees of freedom , quarks and gluons . how to do this consistently with qcd\",\n \"is known and the model involved is the chiral bag ( this is described extensively in @xcite ) which consists of a quark - gluon sector inside the bag and a color - singlet hadronic sector outside , with the two sectors connected by suitable boundary conditions .\",\n \"when constructed with relevant degrees of freedom and in consistency with the symmetries of qcd , the model gives what is now called \",\n \"cheshire cat . \\\" in short , the cheshire cat principle @xcite states that at low energy , physics involving hadrons should be independent of the bag size @xmath21 .\",\n \"it has been shown that this principle is operative semi - quantitatively in _ all _ properties of the nucleon @xcite _ except for _ the flavor - singlet axial charge ( fsac ) of the proton which is related to the proton spin .\",\n \"\\\" here i will briefly describe leaving the details to the paper by lee et al @xcite how this cheshire cat property can be recovered in the fsac when chiral symmetry and chiral anomaly are judiciously taken into account .\",\n \"it turns out that the interplay between the boundary conditions and casimir effects plays a crucial role . since the flavor - singlet axial current\",\n \"is not conserved because of the anomaly , the color can not be confined inside the bag unless a suitable boundary condition is put at the surface that cancels the outflow of the color @xcite .\",\n \"the boundary term that does this is proportional to the chern - simons current on the surface , i.e. , the chern - simons flux ( which is invariant under neither small nor large gauge transformation ) .\",\n \"this influences the fsac of the proton nontrivially .\",\n \"briefly , what happens is that the fsac contributed by the matter fields ( quarks inside the bag and @xmath22 outside the bag ) and the fsac contributed by the gauge field ( gluons inside the bag ) more or less ( or possibly exactly if treated rigorously ) cancel , leaving behind only the small contribution from the ( gauge field ) vacuum fluctuation which is effectively a casimir effect caused by the boundary with its color - anomalous boundary condition .\",\n \"the cancellation and the remnant small fsac are shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fsac ] . the upshot of the small result left over which is independent of the size @xmath21 provides yet another compelling evidence that the proton could be equivalently understood _ both _ in terms of quarks / gluons and in terms of macroscopic hadronic variables .\",\n \"when @xmath21 is taken to be big , it is the qcd variables that take over , e.g. , the mit bag . when the size @xmath21 is shrunk to a point , the proton is a skyrmion .\",\n \"thus we have the equivalence of the skyrmionic proton and the quark - gluonic ( qcd ) proton , that is , the cheshire cat .\",\n \"since there is no way one can exactly bosonize four - dimensional qcd , the equivalence can not be made exact .\",\n \"we simply have an approximate equivalence which can be made more precise by doing more work .\",\n \"what determines the language to use is the kinematic condition of the process one looks at .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the last topic i would like to discuss is infinite nuclear matter at large density . the old lore that at an asymptotic density , the matter can be described by perturbative qcd with weakly interacting boring quarks is simply wrong\",\n \"what may be happening at high density is something a lot more exciting than that .\",\n \"this explains why lots of people are presently writing papers about it .\",\n \"what is most surprising and in some sense unexpected is that at high density the cheshire cat picture becomes more prominent .\",\n \"in fact , at high density , there ceases to be any real distinction between quarks and hadrons .\",\n \"this can be best seen in terms of a quark soliton analogous to the qualiton kaplan @xcite introduced as a model for the constituent quark .\",\n \"the mechanism i will discuss exploits that at high density diquarks condense giving rise to color superconductivity as recently discussed in the literature @xcite . since the resulting qualiton is formed from a color superconducting ground state , it seems proper to call it superqualiton @xcite .\",\n \"it has been argued on general symmetry and dynamical grounds @xcite that at high density , hadronic matter of flavor @xmath23 is characterized by the condensate = - = ^ij^abi_i [ 1 ] where @xmath24 is some constant , @xmath25 are @xmath26 indices , @xmath27 are color indices , and @xmath28 are flavor indices .\",\n \"equation ( [ 1 ] ) holds for parity - even states .\",\n \"such a condensate locks color and flavor so that global color and chiral symmetry are broken to the diagonal subgroup @xmath29 .\",\n \"the consequence of this is that there is an invariant @xmath30 subgroup that contains a twisted \\\" photon , measured with which all excitations carry integer charges reminiscent of the han - nambu quarks and have quantum numbers that correspond to those of the mesons and baryons present at zero density .\",\n \"there is then a continuity between the excitations at high density in terms of quarks and gluons and hadronic excitations at low density in terms of baryons and mesons .\",\n \"this clearly is a case of cheshire cat . now to see that this is the cheshire cat in the sense formulated in terms of the chiral bag @xcite , consider the excitation of a quark on top of the diquark - condensed vacuum . \\\" in @xcite , such a quark is argued to behave like a baryon .\",\n \"now i claim that this quark is a quark soliton , i.e. , superqualiton @xcite . to describe the low - energy dynamics of the color - flavor locking phase , introduce a field @xmath31 which maps space - time to the coset space , @xmath32 .\",\n \"one can take it to be @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the anomalous dimension of the diquark field of order @xmath35 and @xmath36 denotes the quark field with momentum close to a fermi momentum @xmath37 .\",\n \"the pairing involves quarks near the opposite edge of the fermi surface .\",\n \"similarly , we introduce a right - handed field @xmath38 , also a map from space - time to @xmath39 , to describe the excitations of the right - handed diquark condensate . if this field takes a vacuum expectation value as a consequence of the diquark condensation which will , owing to ( [ 1 ] ) , have the form = -= _ a , then 16 nambu - goldstone bosons will get excited .\",\n \"eight of them will get eaten up by the gluons to give masses to the gluons .\",\n \"the massive gluons then turn into massive vector mesons whose quantum numbers are those of the light - quark vector mesons present at zero density .\",\n \"the remaining eight ( pseudoscalar ) nambu - goldstone bosons are the equivalents of the ones present at zero density and are represented by the interpolating field ( [ u ] ) . in analogy to the usual skyrmion at zero density , this field supports a soliton which is a fermion , the quantum numbers of which are identical to those of the usual baryon .\",\n \"the effective lagrangian that gives rise to this soliton should in principle be derived from qcd with the help of renormalization group flows toward the fermi surface of high quark density .\",\n \"such a derivation would determine the parameters that figure in the effective lagrangian such as the pion decay constant \\\" @xmath40 etc which would carry information on the superconductivity gap etc . at the moment\",\n \"such an effective lagrangian is not known , so a detailed study of it excitation structure can not be discussed .\",\n \"however one can venture to make a few interesting conjectures .\",\n \"viewed as a superqualiton whose mass is given by the soliton mass , there is nothing that requires that the soliton mass be equal to or near the superconductivity gap @xmath41 ( which is dictated by the condensate ) .\",\n \"in fact there is nothing which would prevent the mass from being much less than the gap .\",\n \"thus one could imagine that light fermions are excited _ within _ the gap .\",\n \"correlations between light superqualitons could rearrange the ground state into a different form from that of the standard superconductivity .\",\n \"for this reason the phenomenon of color superconductivity in qcd at high density could be completely different from the usual bcs superconductivity .\",\n \"a similar point in a different context was raised in @xcite .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the most important outcome of the recent development of eft in nuclear physics is that the highly successful approach to nuclear structure using realistic nuclear potentials ( pm ) is rendered a first - principle interpretation in that it represents the leading term in the eft expansion with the corrections thereof systematically calculable .\",\n \"this confers the power of modern field theory techniques to the standard nuclear physics approach that has been practiced with success since a long time .\",\n \"i am suggesting that this \",\n \"bridging \\\" comes about thanks to a possible duality between qcd variables and macroscopic ( color - singlet ) variables that i refer to as the cheshire cat principle .\",\n \"the proton spin problem \\\" is an illustration of this in the basic structure of the hadron .\",\n \"it is amusing that the notion of the cheshire cat which was conceived by the need to reconcile the traditional meson - exchange description with the modern qcd description for nuclear processes @xcite ( i.e. , the little bag \\\" with pion cloud , chiral bag etc ) at low density re - emerges at high density where one would have expected the bona - fide qcd to be uniquely applicable .\",\n \"i would like to thank the organizers of this meeting , particularly chueng - ryong ji and dong - pil min for inviting me to give this talk .\",\n \"i would also like to acknowledge the hospitality of kias and its director , c.w .\",\n \"kim while this paper was being written .\",\n \"99 s. weinberg , ; ; m. rho , ; t .- s .\",\n \"park , d .-\",\n \"min and m. rho , ; ; c. ordonez and u. van kolck , ; c. ordonez , l. ray and u. van kolck , ; ; u. van kolck , d.b .\",\n \"kaplan , m. savage and m. wise , ; ; nucl - th/9801034 ; nucl - th/9802075 ; nucl - th/9804032 t .- s .\",\n \"park , k. kubodera , d .-\",\n \"min and m. rho , ; 1998 and 1999 joint caltech - int workshops : _ nuclear physics with effective field theory_. m. rho , chiral symmetry in nuclear physics , \\\" nucl - th/9812012 . g.e .\",\n \"brown and m. rho , .\",\n \"lepage , `` how to renormalize the schrdinger equation ? '' , nucl - th/9706029 d.r .\",\n \"phillips and t.d .\",\n \"cohen , deuteron electromagnetic properties and the viability of effective field theory methods un the two - nucleon system , \\\" nucl - th/9906091 . c.h .\",\n \"hyun , d .-\",\n \"min and t .- s .\",\n \"park , next - to - leading order np scattering in cut - off effective field theory , \\\" to appear .\",\n \"park , k. kubodera , d .-\",\n \"min and m. rho , astrophys .\",\n \"j. * 507 * , 443 ( 1998 ) .\",\n \"park , k. kubodera , d .-\",\n \"min and m. rho , nucl - th/9904053 , nucl - th/9906005 .\",\n \"chen , g. rupak and m.j .\",\n \"savage , suppressed amplitudes in @xmath42 , \\\" nucl - th/9905002 .\",\n \"mller , private communication ; t.m .\",\n \"mller , d. dubbers , p. hautle and o. zimmer , `` measurement of the @xmath43 anisotropy in the @xmath44-process , '' in proceedings of the `` international workshop on particle physics with slow neutrons , '' ill , grenoble , france , 22 - 24 october 1998 .\",\n \"r. seki and h. griesshammer , \",\n \"open discussion and new ideas , \\\" in the proceedings of the 1999 joint int - caltech eft worskshop .\",\n \"see e.g. b. frois and j.f .\",\n \"mathiot , comments on nucl .\",\n \"* 18 * , 307 ( 1989 ) .\",\n \"nowak , m. rho and i. zahed , _ chiral nuclear dynamics_(world scientific , singapore , 1996 ) a. hosaka and h. toki , phys\",\n \". repts . *\",\n \"277 * , 65 ( 1996 ) .\",\n \"nielsen , m. rho , a. wirzba and i. zahed , phys .\",\n \"b269 * , 389 ( 1991 ) ; phys . lett .\",\n \"* 281 * , 345 ( 1992 ) .\",\n \"min , b .- y .\",\n \"park , m. rho and v. vento , the proton spin in the chiral bag model : casimir contribution and cheshire cat principle , \\\" nucl .\",\n \"phys . * a * , in press , hep - ph/9810539 d.a .\",\n \"kaplan , phys .\",\n \"* b235 * , 163 ( 1990 ) ; nucl . phys .\",\n \"* b351 * , 137 ( 1991 ) . m. alford , k. rajagopal and f. wilczek , phys .\",\n \"b * 422 * , 247 ( 1998 ) ; r. rapp , t. schfer , e.v .\",\n \"shuryak and m. velkovsky , phys .\",\n \"81 * , 53 ( 1998 ) ; j. berges and k. rajagopal , nucl .\",\n \"b * 538 * , 215 ( 1999 ) ; n. evans , s. hsu , and m. schwetz , nucl.phys . * b551 * , 275 ( 1999 ) ; phys . lett .\",\n \"b * 449 * , 281 ( 1999 ) ; k. langfeld and m. rho , hep - ph/9811227 ; g. w. carter and d. diakonov , phys .\",\n \"d * 60 * , 016004 ( 1999 ) ; m. alford , j. berges , and k. rajagopal , hep - ph/9903502 ; t. schwarz , s. klevansky and g. papp , hep - ph/9903048 ; d. t. son , hep - ph/9812287 , phys .\",\n \"d * 59 * , 094019 ( 1999 ) ; r. d. pisarski and d. h. rischke , nucl - th/9811104 ; nucl - th/9903023 ; nucl - th/9906050 ; d. k. hong , hep - ph/9812510 ; hep - ph/9905523 ; d. k. hong , i. a. shovkovy , v. a. miransky , and l. c. r. wijewardhana , hep - ph/9906478 ; t. schfer and f. wilczek , hep - ph/9906512 . t. schfer and f. wilczek , phys .\",\n \"lett . * 82 * , 3956 ( 1999 ) , hep - ph/9811473 ; hep - ph/9903503 .\",\n \"hong , m. rho and i. zahed , \",\n \"qualitons at high density , \\\" hep - ph/9906551 .\",\n \"r.d . pisarski and d.h .\",\n \"rischke , why color - flavor locking is just like chiral symmetry breaking ? ,\",\n \"\\\" nucl - th/9907094 . g.e .\",\n \"brown and m. rho , phys . lett .\",\n \"* b82 * , 177 ( 1979 ) .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":90,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"1109.2474"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["magnetic reconnection is a fundamental process in astrophysical plasmas and is believed to be responsible for a wide range of solar phenomena , including solar flares ( for a review see * ? ? ?","unfortunately , magnetic reconnection occurs on spatial scales that are too small to be resolved with current solar instrumentation and can not be observed directly .","there is , however , considerable indirect evidence that magnetic reconnection plays a central role in solar flares .","perhaps the most compelling piece of indirect evidence is the supra - arcade downflows that have been observed above many post - flare loop arcades ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","these downflows appear to be related to highly non - potential field lines that have reconnected and are propagating away from the current sheet .","supra - arcade downflows have been observed with a number of instruments and their properties are summarized in the comprehensive review by @xcite .","the downlows often appear as dark , collapsing features that look like small `` tadpoles '' ( voids with a trailing dark tail ) .","some downflows have a loop - like appearance while others appear to evolve from voids into loops .","the downflows generally begin at relatively high velocities ( 100200 km s@xmath1 is typical ) and then quickly decelerate to about 4 km s@xmath1 . observations at high spatial resolution give the impression that much of high temperature plasma in a flare is formed from collapsing loops @xcite , even when individual features can not be tracked .","similar features are observed in the outer corona when the streamer belt is viewed face on ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","despite the extensive analysis of previous observations a number of questions remain regarding the downflows and their relationship to magnetic reconnection .","the initial velocities measured for the downflows tend to be much smaller than the estimated alfvn speed in the lower corona ( @xmath01000 km s@xmath1 ) , the velocity expected for reconnection outflows .","it is possible that the downflows are formed at large heights and are observed only after they have experienced some deceleration . in most models of solar flares","the release of energy in the corona ultimately drives chromospheric evaporation and leads to the formation of hot , dense loops ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","many of the downflows , however , are observed as dark features and it is not clear that all of the high temperature emission in the flare is formed from descending loops . finally , why some downflows appear as voids and while others appear as loops is unclear .","it is possible that the observed morphology is strongly influenced by the viewing angle .","the launch of the atmospheric imaging assembly ( aia ) on the _ solar dynamics observatory _ ( _ sdo _ ) provides a new opportunity to investigate the dynamics of newly reconnected flux tubes in solar flares .","aia has several advantages over previous solar euv imagers , including a higher cadence ( 12s ) and more channels that observe at flare temperatures .","the higher cadence allows us to create data sets optimized for observing the downflows at large heights .","the aia 94 and 131 channels observe emission from and , respectively .","these lines are formed close to 10mk , the temperature at which the flare emission measure generally peaks .","observations from the twin _ stereo _ spacecraft @xcite can also be applied to this problem . during the 20102012 time frame the spacecraft","are approximately 90@xmath2 from the earth - sun line , which allows flares to be observed simultaneously as limb events by aia and disk events by the euvi imagers on _","stereo_. in this paper we report new observations of supra - arcade downflows taken with aia and euvi . with the improved capabilities of aia we are able to track features at larger heights and in much weaker events than in previous studies .","the combined aia and euvi observations provide compelling evidence that the downflowing voids and loops are manifestations of the same phenomenon observed along different lines of sight .","we find , however , that the initial velocities are consistent with previous measurements and well below the estimated alfvn speed .","the relationship between the brightest emission in the flare and the downflows is also not resolved .","we find no evidence that the emission from the downflows rises with time , as would be expected from chromospheric evaporation .","also , for these events the initial high temperature flare loops are observed to form almost `` in place '' with very little associated downward motion .","these difficulties suggest that simple two - dimensional models of magnetic reconnection can not be applied directly to detailed observations of solar flares .","the aia instrument on _ sdo _ is a multilayer imaging telescope .","a full description of the instrument is given in @xcite . in brief",", the aia instrument images the full sun in 10 different channels with 0.6 pixels at a typical cadence of 12s .","there are 7 euv channels for imaging emission from the transition region and corona .","the aia 94 , 131 , and 193 channels observe flare emission from , , and , respectively .","each of the channels is also sensitive to emission formed at cooler temperatures .","the 193 channel includes 195 , which is an intrinsically bright line and makes difficult to observe in smaller events .","the lower temperature response for the 131 channel is primarily from emission lines that are much weaker than 195 , making the high temperature emission much easier to observe .","the lower temperature lines in the 94 bandpass are largely unidentified , but they are also relatively weak . for a more complete description of the aia temperature response see @xcite .","all of the aia data that we have analyzed are sub - fields of the full disk images obtained from the lmsal cutout service .","the data has been processed using ` aia_prep ` to remove any energetic particle spikes and co - register the images from the different wavelengths to a common plate scale . for this work","we consider three flares that occurred at the solar limb as viewed from earth : a c3.8 event that began at about 18:00 ut on 2011 march 16 , a c5.4 flare that began at about 20:30 ut on 2011 may 9 , and a c2.1 flare that begin at about 18:00 ut on 2011 may 18 .","the soft x - ray light curves from the _ goes _ 15 spacecraft are shown in figure [ fig : goes ] .","the _ goes _ light curves indicate that these flares are all long duration events that evolve over many hours .","some representative aia 131 images are shown in figures [ fig : stereo0 ] , [ fig : stereo1 ] , and [ fig : stereo2 ] .","all three events are clearly associated with a coronal mass ejection and have the classic morphology of a two - ribbon flare .","each event shows a diffuse `` cloud '' of high temperature ( @xmath010mk ) plasma that rises with time . over time relatively narrow , lower temperature ( @xmath01mk ) loops form at the lowest heights and material is observed to drain back down to the surface of the sun along these loops .","the temperatures that we give here are approximate and based on comparisons with previous work ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","high temperature emission is observed only in the 94 and 131 channels while only low temperature loops are observed in channels such as 171 , which has a significant response only at low temperatures .","very little emission is observed in the 193 channel images for these flares .","the _ goes _ soft x - ray fluxes for these events are approximately 100 times smaller than was observed in the x - class flares considered previously ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ) , so this is not surprising .","movies of the data for each event show evidence for features forming at large heights and descending onto the accumulating post - flare loop arcade .","these features are generally difficult to track in the raw intensity images . to eliminate the contribution of the more slowly varying emission it is useful to compute running difference images . with the high cadence of aia we have considerable flexibility in constructing these images . through trial and error","we have found that averaging sets of 7 images taken 72s apart produced the best results .","since the downflows move at relatively high velocities , too much averaging or too long an interval between frames blurs the features . averaging fewer frames or choosing a shorter interval between frames leads to noisier difference images .","example running difference images are displayed in figures [ fig : stereo0 ] , [ fig : stereo1 ] , and [ fig : stereo2 ] .","movies of the running difference images , which are available in the electronic version of the manuscript , show the downflows much more clearly than the raw intensity images .","in general , the downflows appear as dark features in the running difference images , indicating that they are dark relative to the emission into which they are descending . in the march 16 event","all of the downflows appear as elongated loop - like features .","as illustrated in the example shown in figure [ fig : examples ] , when the loops first appear they are relatively broad but they are compressed as they descend .","many of the descending loops that are the easiest to observe appear relatively late in the event ( after approximately 20:00 ut ) . at earlier times , 18:2019:00 ut for example , high temperature emission appears at relatively low heights very suddenly and does not appear to descend from larger heights .","the loops that appear near 18:30 ut and are shown in the first column of figure [ fig : stereo0 ] illustrate this .","there is , however , some downward motion after the emission appears , consistent with the shrinkage of post - reconnection loops ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) .","some of the downflows in these events are observed as dark voids during the entirety of their descent .","this is true for almost all of the downflows observed in the may 9 event . as with the loops observed in the march 16 event , the voids are relatively wide when they appear and are compressed in size as they descend .","an example downflow is shown in figure [ fig : examples ] .","the timing of the downflows is similar to that of the march 16 event , with many of the most easily observed downflows being observed somewhat later in the evolution of the flare .","many downflows are observed after 21:15 ut , which is after the peak of the _ goes _ soft x - ray flux . in the may 18 event a mixture of descending voids and loops is observed .","for this flare there are also some downflows that evolve from voids into loops .","an example of a downflow that begins as a void and evolves into a loop is shown in figure [ fig : examples ] .","the earliest high temperature emission in this event is also observed to appear very suddenly at low heights without any downward motion as the loops brighten . after these loops appear , they do to contract downward to lower heights .","as in the march 16 flare , most of the downflows that are easily observed appear after the peak of the soft x - ray emission .","the _ stereo _ observations suggest that the orientation of the may 18 event is particularly interesting .","the third panel of figure [ fig : stereo2 ] shows that the post - flare loop arcade forms an `` @xmath3 '' shape , with part of the `` @xmath3 '' oriented parallel to the line of sight and another part oriented perpendicular to it .","when the axis of the arcade is along the line of sight the downflows appear as loops or as voids that transition to loops .","_ stereo _ observations indicate that the other events are consistent with this interpretation .","the arcade in the march 16 event is oriented at an angle to the line of sight and loops are observed ( see figure [ fig : stereo0 ] ) .","the arcade in the may 9 event is essentially perpendicular to the line of sight and only voids are observed ( see figure [ fig : stereo1 ] ) . for each event we also inspected the 94 images .","as noted earlier , this channel includes a strong emission line and is sensitive to somewhat lower temperature plasma than the 131 channel . as one would expect , these images tend to show the somewhat cooler plasma at the lower part of the arcade and as a result tend to show the terminal phase of the downflows . for this reason we focus on the data from the aia 131 channel in this paper .","rrcrr + 00 & 132.6 & 0.039 & 831.7 & -32.1 + 01 & 149.0 & 2.282 & 119.0 & -271.6 + 02 & 178.6 & 0.274 & 454.1 & -124.5 + 03 & 196.6 & 0.492 & 290.6 & -143.0 + 04 & 204.3 & 0.857 & 226.7 & -194.2 + 05 & 136.5 & 0.619 & 261.2 & -161.7 + 06 & 188.9 & 0.271 & 500.6 & -135.8 + 07 & 180.9 & 0.308 & 507.7 & -156.2 + 08 & 225.6 & 0.089 & 1031.3 & -91.7 + 09 & 250.4 & 0.044 & 1938.6 & -84.6 + + 00 & 113.6 & 2.185 & 128.1 & -279.9 + 01 & 118.9 & 1.043 & 212.5 & -221.7 + 02 & 131.1 & 1.506 & 166.6 & -250.9 + 03 & 117.6 & 0.581 & 231.3 & -134.3 + 04 & 128.2 & 0.440 & 345.3 & -152.1 + 05 & 110.8 & 0.161 & 406.1 & -65.3 + 06 & 63.8 & 0.087 & 659.1 & -57.1 + 07 & 82.0 & 0.237 & 363.8 & -86.1 + 08 & 80.4 & 1.050 & 115.6 & -121.3 + 09 & 103.7 & 0.786 & 192.2 & -151.1 + 10 & 73.8 & 0.306 & 245.1 & -75.1 + 11 & 90.9 & 0.375 & 270.7 & -101.7 + + 00 & 75.2 & 2.687 & 102.1 & -274.4 + 01 & 84.7 & 2.726 & 97.1 & -264.8 + 02 & 83.3 & 0.451 & 274.1 & -123.7 + 03 & 70.5 & 3.407 & 77.7 & -264.8 + 04 & 61.7 & 1.190 & 120.0 & -142.8 + 05 & 75.1 & 0.867 & 165.8 & -143.7 + 06 & 88.3 & 0.473 & 316.6 & -149.9 + 07 & 70.7 & 1.059 & 155.9 & -165.0 + 08 & 76.7 & 0.438 & 243.4 & -106.5 + 09 & 83.1 & 0.403 & 440.2 & -177.0 [ table : inflows ] a useful way of tracking features as they descend is to create height - time maps .","these maps are formed by extracting a narrow `` slit '' from each image and stacking them horizontally as a function of time ( see * ? ? ?","interpolation is used to extract intensities at arbitrary angles .","an example height - time map computed from the difference images is shown in figure [ fig : ht0 ] . here","the downflows are evident as dark tracks , indicating that the downflows are generally less intense than the emission into which they are descending . to characterize the kinematics of the downflows we fit selected height - time tracks to a function of the form @xmath4 with this assumption the velocity of the downflow as a function of time is @xmath5 and the acceleration is @xmath6 this functional form for the height captures the rapid transition from a relatively high initial velocity of @xmath7 at a height of @xmath8 , to a relatively slow terminal descent , @xmath9 .","note that for features that descend at progressively slower speeds the initial velocity will be negative and the acceleration will be positive .","we have selected approximately 10 downflows from each event and traced out their tracks in the height - time maps .","the best - fit parameters for equation [ eq : h ] were determined for each track using a least - squares algorithm and are given in table [ table : inflows ] .","each track is also indicated in the movies included in the electronic version of the manuscript .","we tended to select high velocity tracks that appeared at relatively large heights since they were easier to track and are more relevant to the initial dynamics of post - reconnection flux tubes .","many of the tracks that we selected decelerate quickly and could not be followed for long periods of time .","this means the asymptotic behavior is not well observed for these tracks . if we leave @xmath9 as a free parameter in the fitting of these tracks the terminal velocity often converges to relatively large number , inconsistent with the general trend in the data . for tracks that do have a well observed terminal phase , the terminal velocity is typically about 45 km s@xmath1 . since the terminal velocities are generally small and we are more interested in the initial dynamics we have forced @xmath10 for the final fits given in table [ table : inflows ] . with the improved imaging capabilities of aia we anticipated being able to track downflows at larger heights above the solar surface . comparing the values for @xmath8","given in table [ table : inflows ] with figures 6 from @xcite we see that is the case .","our median initial height is approximately 111 mm compared with 82 mm with the earlier data .","our initial velocities and accelerations , however , are very similar to those presented by @xcite in their figure 5 . for the initial velocity","we have a median value of -144 km s@xmath1 compared with -146 km s@xmath1 in @xcite .","our median initial acceleration is 0.68 km s@xmath11 compared with 0.42 km s@xmath11 .","thus it appears that small initial velocities relative to the alfvn speed are not an artifact of the lower heights at which the downflows have been observed previously .","chromospheric evaporation is an essential component of solar flares models based on magnetic reconnection ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","the release of energy on reconnected field lines will ultimately lead to the heating and evaporation of chromospheric material .","this should lead to loops that brighten over time and numerical simulations suggest that this process should occur rapidly ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","one limitation of the running difference images is that they can obscure the evolution of the absolute intensities .","the downflows are dark features in the running difference images , indicating that they have lower intensities than the surrounding emission .","it is not clear , however , if they remain dark in an absolute sense or brighten over time . to address this issue","we have followed the intensities along each track in the unsubtracted images .","for comparison we also determined intensities at several locations outside of the track . in all cases the intensity in the center of the feature simply tracks the background intensities measured outside of the downflow .","there is no evidence for the intensities in the downflows rising faster than the background .","unfortunately , these measurements are difficult to make and subject to considerable uncertainty .","the downflows have a very low contrast relative to the ambient emission in the flare .","the difference images shown in figures [ fig : stereo0][fig : ht0 ] are all scaled over a range of about @xmath125dn s@xmath1 , which is typically only a few percent of the absolute intensity .","we have presented the first observations of supra - arcade downflows with the aia instrument on _ sdo_. with the new capabilities of aia we are able to track inflows at much larger heights and for much smaller events than in previous observations .","these observations provide many new examples of features forming at large heights and descending onto the accumulating post - flare loop arcade .","the dynamics and morphology of the downflows provides compelling evidence for the role of magnetic reconnection in eruptive solar flares . despite the qualitative agreement between the observations and the standard picture of magnetic reconnection",", there are several problems that remain .","the low velocities that are observed for these outflows , for example , are incompatible with the simple 2d models of sweet - parker and petschek reconnection , which have alfvnic velocities for the outflows .","@xcite suggest that the interaction of the reconnected flux tubes with pre - existing magnetic fields provide a drag force that slows the downflows .","another difficulty in interpreting the downflows as evidence for magnetic reconnection is the formation of the initial flare plasma . for most events","the downflows that are easily observed occur late in the flare and descend into an existing cloud of hot emission .","the initial flare emission forms essentially `` in place , '' and not as a descending loop although there is some evidence for collapsing motions after these loops appear .","finally , the reconnection of magnetic fields should lead to the release of energy that drives chromospheric evaporation .","all of the downflows that we detect here , however , are observed as depletions relative to the ambient high temperature emission into which they are descending .","recent work by @xcite suggests that density depletions can be formed in reconnecting flux tubes that move through a nonuniform current sheet . their model",", however , does not include chromospheric evaporation and it is not clear how long such density depletions would persist .","the inability of the simple , two - dimensional reconnection models to describe many details of the downflows suggests that three - dimensional modeling is required .","the aia observations we have shown here give ample evidence for inhomogeneity in the reconnecting magnetic fields and this inhomogeneity will be a component of any successful model .","high resolution observations of the photospheric magnetic field in active regions , such as those taken with the solar optical telescope ( sot ) on _ hinode _ ( e.g , * ? ? ?","* ) , show that the magnetic field is structured on the spatial scale of the granules ( @xmath01000 km ) and we conjecture that this inhomogeneity is reflected in the highly structured appearance of the flare plasma ."],"string":"[\n \"magnetic reconnection is a fundamental process in astrophysical plasmas and is believed to be responsible for a wide range of solar phenomena , including solar flares ( for a review see * ? ? ?\",\n \"unfortunately , magnetic reconnection occurs on spatial scales that are too small to be resolved with current solar instrumentation and can not be observed directly .\",\n \"there is , however , considerable indirect evidence that magnetic reconnection plays a central role in solar flares .\",\n \"perhaps the most compelling piece of indirect evidence is the supra - arcade downflows that have been observed above many post - flare loop arcades ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"these downflows appear to be related to highly non - potential field lines that have reconnected and are propagating away from the current sheet .\",\n \"supra - arcade downflows have been observed with a number of instruments and their properties are summarized in the comprehensive review by @xcite .\",\n \"the downlows often appear as dark , collapsing features that look like small `` tadpoles '' ( voids with a trailing dark tail ) .\",\n \"some downflows have a loop - like appearance while others appear to evolve from voids into loops .\",\n \"the downflows generally begin at relatively high velocities ( 100200 km s@xmath1 is typical ) and then quickly decelerate to about 4 km s@xmath1 . observations at high spatial resolution give the impression that much of high temperature plasma in a flare is formed from collapsing loops @xcite , even when individual features can not be tracked .\",\n \"similar features are observed in the outer corona when the streamer belt is viewed face on ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"despite the extensive analysis of previous observations a number of questions remain regarding the downflows and their relationship to magnetic reconnection .\",\n \"the initial velocities measured for the downflows tend to be much smaller than the estimated alfvn speed in the lower corona ( @xmath01000 km s@xmath1 ) , the velocity expected for reconnection outflows .\",\n \"it is possible that the downflows are formed at large heights and are observed only after they have experienced some deceleration . in most models of solar flares\",\n \"the release of energy in the corona ultimately drives chromospheric evaporation and leads to the formation of hot , dense loops ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"many of the downflows , however , are observed as dark features and it is not clear that all of the high temperature emission in the flare is formed from descending loops . finally , why some downflows appear as voids and while others appear as loops is unclear .\",\n \"it is possible that the observed morphology is strongly influenced by the viewing angle .\",\n \"the launch of the atmospheric imaging assembly ( aia ) on the _ solar dynamics observatory _ ( _ sdo _ ) provides a new opportunity to investigate the dynamics of newly reconnected flux tubes in solar flares .\",\n \"aia has several advantages over previous solar euv imagers , including a higher cadence ( 12s ) and more channels that observe at flare temperatures .\",\n \"the higher cadence allows us to create data sets optimized for observing the downflows at large heights .\",\n \"the aia 94 and 131 channels observe emission from and , respectively .\",\n \"these lines are formed close to 10mk , the temperature at which the flare emission measure generally peaks .\",\n \"observations from the twin _ stereo _ spacecraft @xcite can also be applied to this problem . during the 20102012 time frame the spacecraft\",\n \"are approximately 90@xmath2 from the earth - sun line , which allows flares to be observed simultaneously as limb events by aia and disk events by the euvi imagers on _\",\n \"stereo_. in this paper we report new observations of supra - arcade downflows taken with aia and euvi . with the improved capabilities of aia we are able to track features at larger heights and in much weaker events than in previous studies .\",\n \"the combined aia and euvi observations provide compelling evidence that the downflowing voids and loops are manifestations of the same phenomenon observed along different lines of sight .\",\n \"we find , however , that the initial velocities are consistent with previous measurements and well below the estimated alfvn speed .\",\n \"the relationship between the brightest emission in the flare and the downflows is also not resolved .\",\n \"we find no evidence that the emission from the downflows rises with time , as would be expected from chromospheric evaporation .\",\n \"also , for these events the initial high temperature flare loops are observed to form almost `` in place '' with very little associated downward motion .\",\n \"these difficulties suggest that simple two - dimensional models of magnetic reconnection can not be applied directly to detailed observations of solar flares .\",\n \"the aia instrument on _ sdo _ is a multilayer imaging telescope .\",\n \"a full description of the instrument is given in @xcite . in brief\",\n \", the aia instrument images the full sun in 10 different channels with 0.6 pixels at a typical cadence of 12s .\",\n \"there are 7 euv channels for imaging emission from the transition region and corona .\",\n \"the aia 94 , 131 , and 193 channels observe flare emission from , , and , respectively .\",\n \"each of the channels is also sensitive to emission formed at cooler temperatures .\",\n \"the 193 channel includes 195 , which is an intrinsically bright line and makes difficult to observe in smaller events .\",\n \"the lower temperature response for the 131 channel is primarily from emission lines that are much weaker than 195 , making the high temperature emission much easier to observe .\",\n \"the lower temperature lines in the 94 bandpass are largely unidentified , but they are also relatively weak . for a more complete description of the aia temperature response see @xcite .\",\n \"all of the aia data that we have analyzed are sub - fields of the full disk images obtained from the lmsal cutout service .\",\n \"the data has been processed using ` aia_prep ` to remove any energetic particle spikes and co - register the images from the different wavelengths to a common plate scale . for this work\",\n \"we consider three flares that occurred at the solar limb as viewed from earth : a c3.8 event that began at about 18:00 ut on 2011 march 16 , a c5.4 flare that began at about 20:30 ut on 2011 may 9 , and a c2.1 flare that begin at about 18:00 ut on 2011 may 18 .\",\n \"the soft x - ray light curves from the _ goes _ 15 spacecraft are shown in figure [ fig : goes ] .\",\n \"the _ goes _ light curves indicate that these flares are all long duration events that evolve over many hours .\",\n \"some representative aia 131 images are shown in figures [ fig : stereo0 ] , [ fig : stereo1 ] , and [ fig : stereo2 ] .\",\n \"all three events are clearly associated with a coronal mass ejection and have the classic morphology of a two - ribbon flare .\",\n \"each event shows a diffuse `` cloud '' of high temperature ( @xmath010mk ) plasma that rises with time . over time relatively narrow , lower temperature ( @xmath01mk ) loops form at the lowest heights and material is observed to drain back down to the surface of the sun along these loops .\",\n \"the temperatures that we give here are approximate and based on comparisons with previous work ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"high temperature emission is observed only in the 94 and 131 channels while only low temperature loops are observed in channels such as 171 , which has a significant response only at low temperatures .\",\n \"very little emission is observed in the 193 channel images for these flares .\",\n \"the _ goes _ soft x - ray fluxes for these events are approximately 100 times smaller than was observed in the x - class flares considered previously ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ) , so this is not surprising .\",\n \"movies of the data for each event show evidence for features forming at large heights and descending onto the accumulating post - flare loop arcade .\",\n \"these features are generally difficult to track in the raw intensity images . to eliminate the contribution of the more slowly varying emission it is useful to compute running difference images . with the high cadence of aia we have considerable flexibility in constructing these images . through trial and error\",\n \"we have found that averaging sets of 7 images taken 72s apart produced the best results .\",\n \"since the downflows move at relatively high velocities , too much averaging or too long an interval between frames blurs the features . averaging fewer frames or choosing a shorter interval between frames leads to noisier difference images .\",\n \"example running difference images are displayed in figures [ fig : stereo0 ] , [ fig : stereo1 ] , and [ fig : stereo2 ] .\",\n \"movies of the running difference images , which are available in the electronic version of the manuscript , show the downflows much more clearly than the raw intensity images .\",\n \"in general , the downflows appear as dark features in the running difference images , indicating that they are dark relative to the emission into which they are descending . in the march 16 event\",\n \"all of the downflows appear as elongated loop - like features .\",\n \"as illustrated in the example shown in figure [ fig : examples ] , when the loops first appear they are relatively broad but they are compressed as they descend .\",\n \"many of the descending loops that are the easiest to observe appear relatively late in the event ( after approximately 20:00 ut ) . at earlier times , 18:2019:00 ut for example , high temperature emission appears at relatively low heights very suddenly and does not appear to descend from larger heights .\",\n \"the loops that appear near 18:30 ut and are shown in the first column of figure [ fig : stereo0 ] illustrate this .\",\n \"there is , however , some downward motion after the emission appears , consistent with the shrinkage of post - reconnection loops ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) .\",\n \"some of the downflows in these events are observed as dark voids during the entirety of their descent .\",\n \"this is true for almost all of the downflows observed in the may 9 event . as with the loops observed in the march 16 event , the voids are relatively wide when they appear and are compressed in size as they descend .\",\n \"an example downflow is shown in figure [ fig : examples ] .\",\n \"the timing of the downflows is similar to that of the march 16 event , with many of the most easily observed downflows being observed somewhat later in the evolution of the flare .\",\n \"many downflows are observed after 21:15 ut , which is after the peak of the _ goes _ soft x - ray flux . in the may 18 event a mixture of descending voids and loops is observed .\",\n \"for this flare there are also some downflows that evolve from voids into loops .\",\n \"an example of a downflow that begins as a void and evolves into a loop is shown in figure [ fig : examples ] .\",\n \"the earliest high temperature emission in this event is also observed to appear very suddenly at low heights without any downward motion as the loops brighten . after these loops appear , they do to contract downward to lower heights .\",\n \"as in the march 16 flare , most of the downflows that are easily observed appear after the peak of the soft x - ray emission .\",\n \"the _ stereo _ observations suggest that the orientation of the may 18 event is particularly interesting .\",\n \"the third panel of figure [ fig : stereo2 ] shows that the post - flare loop arcade forms an `` @xmath3 '' shape , with part of the `` @xmath3 '' oriented parallel to the line of sight and another part oriented perpendicular to it .\",\n \"when the axis of the arcade is along the line of sight the downflows appear as loops or as voids that transition to loops .\",\n \"_ stereo _ observations indicate that the other events are consistent with this interpretation .\",\n \"the arcade in the march 16 event is oriented at an angle to the line of sight and loops are observed ( see figure [ fig : stereo0 ] ) .\",\n \"the arcade in the may 9 event is essentially perpendicular to the line of sight and only voids are observed ( see figure [ fig : stereo1 ] ) . for each event we also inspected the 94 images .\",\n \"as noted earlier , this channel includes a strong emission line and is sensitive to somewhat lower temperature plasma than the 131 channel . as one would expect , these images tend to show the somewhat cooler plasma at the lower part of the arcade and as a result tend to show the terminal phase of the downflows . for this reason we focus on the data from the aia 131 channel in this paper .\",\n \"rrcrr + 00 & 132.6 & 0.039 & 831.7 & -32.1 + 01 & 149.0 & 2.282 & 119.0 & -271.6 + 02 & 178.6 & 0.274 & 454.1 & -124.5 + 03 & 196.6 & 0.492 & 290.6 & -143.0 + 04 & 204.3 & 0.857 & 226.7 & -194.2 + 05 & 136.5 & 0.619 & 261.2 & -161.7 + 06 & 188.9 & 0.271 & 500.6 & -135.8 + 07 & 180.9 & 0.308 & 507.7 & -156.2 + 08 & 225.6 & 0.089 & 1031.3 & -91.7 + 09 & 250.4 & 0.044 & 1938.6 & -84.6 + + 00 & 113.6 & 2.185 & 128.1 & -279.9 + 01 & 118.9 & 1.043 & 212.5 & -221.7 + 02 & 131.1 & 1.506 & 166.6 & -250.9 + 03 & 117.6 & 0.581 & 231.3 & -134.3 + 04 & 128.2 & 0.440 & 345.3 & -152.1 + 05 & 110.8 & 0.161 & 406.1 & -65.3 + 06 & 63.8 & 0.087 & 659.1 & -57.1 + 07 & 82.0 & 0.237 & 363.8 & -86.1 + 08 & 80.4 & 1.050 & 115.6 & -121.3 + 09 & 103.7 & 0.786 & 192.2 & -151.1 + 10 & 73.8 & 0.306 & 245.1 & -75.1 + 11 & 90.9 & 0.375 & 270.7 & -101.7 + + 00 & 75.2 & 2.687 & 102.1 & -274.4 + 01 & 84.7 & 2.726 & 97.1 & -264.8 + 02 & 83.3 & 0.451 & 274.1 & -123.7 + 03 & 70.5 & 3.407 & 77.7 & -264.8 + 04 & 61.7 & 1.190 & 120.0 & -142.8 + 05 & 75.1 & 0.867 & 165.8 & -143.7 + 06 & 88.3 & 0.473 & 316.6 & -149.9 + 07 & 70.7 & 1.059 & 155.9 & -165.0 + 08 & 76.7 & 0.438 & 243.4 & -106.5 + 09 & 83.1 & 0.403 & 440.2 & -177.0 [ table : inflows ] a useful way of tracking features as they descend is to create height - time maps .\",\n \"these maps are formed by extracting a narrow `` slit '' from each image and stacking them horizontally as a function of time ( see * ? ? ?\",\n \"interpolation is used to extract intensities at arbitrary angles .\",\n \"an example height - time map computed from the difference images is shown in figure [ fig : ht0 ] . here\",\n \"the downflows are evident as dark tracks , indicating that the downflows are generally less intense than the emission into which they are descending . to characterize the kinematics of the downflows we fit selected height - time tracks to a function of the form @xmath4 with this assumption the velocity of the downflow as a function of time is @xmath5 and the acceleration is @xmath6 this functional form for the height captures the rapid transition from a relatively high initial velocity of @xmath7 at a height of @xmath8 , to a relatively slow terminal descent , @xmath9 .\",\n \"note that for features that descend at progressively slower speeds the initial velocity will be negative and the acceleration will be positive .\",\n \"we have selected approximately 10 downflows from each event and traced out their tracks in the height - time maps .\",\n \"the best - fit parameters for equation [ eq : h ] were determined for each track using a least - squares algorithm and are given in table [ table : inflows ] .\",\n \"each track is also indicated in the movies included in the electronic version of the manuscript .\",\n \"we tended to select high velocity tracks that appeared at relatively large heights since they were easier to track and are more relevant to the initial dynamics of post - reconnection flux tubes .\",\n \"many of the tracks that we selected decelerate quickly and could not be followed for long periods of time .\",\n \"this means the asymptotic behavior is not well observed for these tracks . if we leave @xmath9 as a free parameter in the fitting of these tracks the terminal velocity often converges to relatively large number , inconsistent with the general trend in the data . for tracks that do have a well observed terminal phase , the terminal velocity is typically about 45 km s@xmath1 . since the terminal velocities are generally small and we are more interested in the initial dynamics we have forced @xmath10 for the final fits given in table [ table : inflows ] . with the improved imaging capabilities of aia we anticipated being able to track downflows at larger heights above the solar surface . comparing the values for @xmath8\",\n \"given in table [ table : inflows ] with figures 6 from @xcite we see that is the case .\",\n \"our median initial height is approximately 111 mm compared with 82 mm with the earlier data .\",\n \"our initial velocities and accelerations , however , are very similar to those presented by @xcite in their figure 5 . for the initial velocity\",\n \"we have a median value of -144 km s@xmath1 compared with -146 km s@xmath1 in @xcite .\",\n \"our median initial acceleration is 0.68 km s@xmath11 compared with 0.42 km s@xmath11 .\",\n \"thus it appears that small initial velocities relative to the alfvn speed are not an artifact of the lower heights at which the downflows have been observed previously .\",\n \"chromospheric evaporation is an essential component of solar flares models based on magnetic reconnection ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"the release of energy on reconnected field lines will ultimately lead to the heating and evaporation of chromospheric material .\",\n \"this should lead to loops that brighten over time and numerical simulations suggest that this process should occur rapidly ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"one limitation of the running difference images is that they can obscure the evolution of the absolute intensities .\",\n \"the downflows are dark features in the running difference images , indicating that they have lower intensities than the surrounding emission .\",\n \"it is not clear , however , if they remain dark in an absolute sense or brighten over time . to address this issue\",\n \"we have followed the intensities along each track in the unsubtracted images .\",\n \"for comparison we also determined intensities at several locations outside of the track . in all cases the intensity in the center of the feature simply tracks the background intensities measured outside of the downflow .\",\n \"there is no evidence for the intensities in the downflows rising faster than the background .\",\n \"unfortunately , these measurements are difficult to make and subject to considerable uncertainty .\",\n \"the downflows have a very low contrast relative to the ambient emission in the flare .\",\n \"the difference images shown in figures [ fig : stereo0][fig : ht0 ] are all scaled over a range of about @xmath125dn s@xmath1 , which is typically only a few percent of the absolute intensity .\",\n \"we have presented the first observations of supra - arcade downflows with the aia instrument on _ sdo_. with the new capabilities of aia we are able to track inflows at much larger heights and for much smaller events than in previous observations .\",\n \"these observations provide many new examples of features forming at large heights and descending onto the accumulating post - flare loop arcade .\",\n \"the dynamics and morphology of the downflows provides compelling evidence for the role of magnetic reconnection in eruptive solar flares . despite the qualitative agreement between the observations and the standard picture of magnetic reconnection\",\n \", there are several problems that remain .\",\n \"the low velocities that are observed for these outflows , for example , are incompatible with the simple 2d models of sweet - parker and petschek reconnection , which have alfvnic velocities for the outflows .\",\n \"@xcite suggest that the interaction of the reconnected flux tubes with pre - existing magnetic fields provide a drag force that slows the downflows .\",\n \"another difficulty in interpreting the downflows as evidence for magnetic reconnection is the formation of the initial flare plasma . for most events\",\n \"the downflows that are easily observed occur late in the flare and descend into an existing cloud of hot emission .\",\n \"the initial flare emission forms essentially `` in place , '' and not as a descending loop although there is some evidence for collapsing motions after these loops appear .\",\n \"finally , the reconnection of magnetic fields should lead to the release of energy that drives chromospheric evaporation .\",\n \"all of the downflows that we detect here , however , are observed as depletions relative to the ambient high temperature emission into which they are descending .\",\n \"recent work by @xcite suggests that density depletions can be formed in reconnecting flux tubes that move through a nonuniform current sheet . their model\",\n \", however , does not include chromospheric evaporation and it is not clear how long such density depletions would persist .\",\n \"the inability of the simple , two - dimensional reconnection models to describe many details of the downflows suggests that three - dimensional modeling is required .\",\n \"the aia observations we have shown here give ample evidence for inhomogeneity in the reconnecting magnetic fields and this inhomogeneity will be a component of any successful model .\",\n \"high resolution observations of the photospheric magnetic field in active regions , such as those taken with the solar optical telescope ( sot ) on _ hinode _ ( e.g , * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ) , show that the magnetic field is structured on the spatial scale of the granules ( @xmath01000 km ) and we conjecture that this inhomogeneity is reflected in the highly structured appearance of the flare plasma .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> perhaps the most compelling evidence for the role of magnetic reconnection in solar flares comes from the supra - arcade downflows that have been observed above many post - flare loop arcades . </S>","<S> these downflows are thought to be related to highly non - potential field lines that have reconnected and are propagating away from the current sheet . </S>","<S> we present new observations of supra - arcade downflows taken with the atmospheric imagining assembly ( aia ) on the _ solar dynamics observatory _ ( _ sdo _ ) . </S>","<S> the morphology and dynamics of the downflows observed with aia provide new evidence for the role of magnetic reconnection in solar flares . with these new observations we are able to measure downflows originating at much larger heights than in previous studies . </S>","<S> we find , however , that the initial velocities measured here ( @xmath0144 km s@xmath1 ) are well below the alfvn speed expected in the lower corona , and consistent with previous results . </S>","<S> we also find no evidence that the downflows brighten with time , as would be expected from chromospheric evaporation . </S>","<S> these observations suggest that simple two - dimensional models can not explain the detailed observations of solar flares . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> perhaps the most compelling evidence for the role of magnetic reconnection in solar flares comes from the supra - arcade downflows that have been observed above many post - flare loop arcades . </S>\",\n \"<S> these downflows are thought to be related to highly non - potential field lines that have reconnected and are propagating away from the current sheet . </S>\",\n \"<S> we present new observations of supra - arcade downflows taken with the atmospheric imagining assembly ( aia ) on the _ solar dynamics observatory _ ( _ sdo _ ) . </S>\",\n \"<S> the morphology and dynamics of the downflows observed with aia provide new evidence for the role of magnetic reconnection in solar flares . with these new observations we are able to measure downflows originating at much larger heights than in previous studies . </S>\",\n \"<S> we find , however , that the initial velocities measured here ( @xmath0144 km s@xmath1 ) are well below the alfvn speed expected in the lower corona , and consistent with previous results . </S>\",\n \"<S> we also find no evidence that the downflows brighten with time , as would be expected from chromospheric evaporation . </S>\",\n \"<S> these observations suggest that simple two - dimensional models can not explain the detailed observations of solar flares . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","observations","discussion"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"observations\",\n \"discussion\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["magnetic reconnection is a fundamental process in astrophysical plasmas and is believed to be responsible for a wide range of solar phenomena , including solar flares ( for a review see * ? ? ?","unfortunately , magnetic reconnection occurs on spatial scales that are too small to be resolved with current solar instrumentation and can not be observed directly .","there is , however , considerable indirect evidence that magnetic reconnection plays a central role in solar flares .","perhaps the most compelling piece of indirect evidence is the supra - arcade downflows that have been observed above many post - flare loop arcades ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","these downflows appear to be related to highly non - potential field lines that have reconnected and are propagating away from the current sheet .","supra - arcade downflows have been observed with a number of instruments and their properties are summarized in the comprehensive review by @xcite .","the downlows often appear as dark , collapsing features that look like small `` tadpoles '' ( voids with a trailing dark tail ) .","some downflows have a loop - like appearance while others appear to evolve from voids into loops .","the downflows generally begin at relatively high velocities ( 100200 km s@xmath1 is typical ) and then quickly decelerate to about 4 km s@xmath1 . observations at high spatial resolution give the impression that much of high temperature plasma in a flare is formed from collapsing loops @xcite , even when individual features can not be tracked .","similar features are observed in the outer corona when the streamer belt is viewed face on ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","despite the extensive analysis of previous observations a number of questions remain regarding the downflows and their relationship to magnetic reconnection .","the initial velocities measured for the downflows tend to be much smaller than the estimated alfvn speed in the lower corona ( @xmath01000 km s@xmath1 ) , the velocity expected for reconnection outflows .","it is possible that the downflows are formed at large heights and are observed only after they have experienced some deceleration . in most models of solar flares","the release of energy in the corona ultimately drives chromospheric evaporation and leads to the formation of hot , dense loops ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","many of the downflows , however , are observed as dark features and it is not clear that all of the high temperature emission in the flare is formed from descending loops . finally , why some downflows appear as voids and while others appear as loops is unclear .","it is possible that the observed morphology is strongly influenced by the viewing angle .","the launch of the atmospheric imaging assembly ( aia ) on the _ solar dynamics observatory _ ( _ sdo _ ) provides a new opportunity to investigate the dynamics of newly reconnected flux tubes in solar flares .","aia has several advantages over previous solar euv imagers , including a higher cadence ( 12s ) and more channels that observe at flare temperatures .","the higher cadence allows us to create data sets optimized for observing the downflows at large heights .","the aia 94 and 131 channels observe emission from and , respectively .","these lines are formed close to 10mk , the temperature at which the flare emission measure generally peaks .","observations from the twin _ stereo _ spacecraft @xcite can also be applied to this problem . during the 20102012 time frame the spacecraft","are approximately 90@xmath2 from the earth - sun line , which allows flares to be observed simultaneously as limb events by aia and disk events by the euvi imagers on _","stereo_. in this paper we report new observations of supra - arcade downflows taken with aia and euvi . with the improved capabilities of aia we are able to track features at larger heights and in much weaker events than in previous studies .","the combined aia and euvi observations provide compelling evidence that the downflowing voids and loops are manifestations of the same phenomenon observed along different lines of sight .","we find , however , that the initial velocities are consistent with previous measurements and well below the estimated alfvn speed .","the relationship between the brightest emission in the flare and the downflows is also not resolved .","we find no evidence that the emission from the downflows rises with time , as would be expected from chromospheric evaporation .","also , for these events the initial high temperature flare loops are observed to form almost `` in place '' with very little associated downward motion .","these difficulties suggest that simple two - dimensional models of magnetic reconnection can not be applied directly to detailed observations of solar flares ."],["the aia instrument on _ sdo _ is a multilayer imaging telescope .","a full description of the instrument is given in @xcite . in brief",", the aia instrument images the full sun in 10 different channels with 0.6 pixels at a typical cadence of 12s .","there are 7 euv channels for imaging emission from the transition region and corona .","the aia 94 , 131 , and 193 channels observe flare emission from , , and , respectively .","each of the channels is also sensitive to emission formed at cooler temperatures .","the 193 channel includes 195 , which is an intrinsically bright line and makes difficult to observe in smaller events .","the lower temperature response for the 131 channel is primarily from emission lines that are much weaker than 195 , making the high temperature emission much easier to observe .","the lower temperature lines in the 94 bandpass are largely unidentified , but they are also relatively weak . for a more complete description of the aia temperature response see @xcite .","all of the aia data that we have analyzed are sub - fields of the full disk images obtained from the lmsal cutout service .","the data has been processed using ` aia_prep ` to remove any energetic particle spikes and co - register the images from the different wavelengths to a common plate scale . for this work","we consider three flares that occurred at the solar limb as viewed from earth : a c3.8 event that began at about 18:00 ut on 2011 march 16 , a c5.4 flare that began at about 20:30 ut on 2011 may 9 , and a c2.1 flare that begin at about 18:00 ut on 2011 may 18 .","the soft x - ray light curves from the _ goes _ 15 spacecraft are shown in figure [ fig : goes ] .","the _ goes _ light curves indicate that these flares are all long duration events that evolve over many hours .","some representative aia 131 images are shown in figures [ fig : stereo0 ] , [ fig : stereo1 ] , and [ fig : stereo2 ] .","all three events are clearly associated with a coronal mass ejection and have the classic morphology of a two - ribbon flare .","each event shows a diffuse `` cloud '' of high temperature ( @xmath010mk ) plasma that rises with time . over time relatively narrow , lower temperature ( @xmath01mk ) loops form at the lowest heights and material is observed to drain back down to the surface of the sun along these loops .","the temperatures that we give here are approximate and based on comparisons with previous work ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","high temperature emission is observed only in the 94 and 131 channels while only low temperature loops are observed in channels such as 171 , which has a significant response only at low temperatures .","very little emission is observed in the 193 channel images for these flares .","the _ goes _ soft x - ray fluxes for these events are approximately 100 times smaller than was observed in the x - class flares considered previously ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","* ; * ? ? ?","* ) , so this is not surprising .","movies of the data for each event show evidence for features forming at large heights and descending onto the accumulating post - flare loop arcade .","these features are generally difficult to track in the raw intensity images . to eliminate the contribution of the more slowly varying emission it is useful to compute running difference images . with the high cadence of aia we have considerable flexibility in constructing these images . through trial and error","we have found that averaging sets of 7 images taken 72s apart produced the best results .","since the downflows move at relatively high velocities , too much averaging or too long an interval between frames blurs the features . averaging fewer frames or choosing a shorter interval between frames leads to noisier difference images .","example running difference images are displayed in figures [ fig : stereo0 ] , [ fig : stereo1 ] , and [ fig : stereo2 ] .","movies of the running difference images , which are available in the electronic version of the manuscript , show the downflows much more clearly than the raw intensity images .","in general , the downflows appear as dark features in the running difference images , indicating that they are dark relative to the emission into which they are descending . in the march 16 event","all of the downflows appear as elongated loop - like features .","as illustrated in the example shown in figure [ fig : examples ] , when the loops first appear they are relatively broad but they are compressed as they descend .","many of the descending loops that are the easiest to observe appear relatively late in the event ( after approximately 20:00 ut ) . at earlier times , 18:2019:00 ut for example , high temperature emission appears at relatively low heights very suddenly and does not appear to descend from larger heights .","the loops that appear near 18:30 ut and are shown in the first column of figure [ fig : stereo0 ] illustrate this .","there is , however , some downward motion after the emission appears , consistent with the shrinkage of post - reconnection loops ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) .","some of the downflows in these events are observed as dark voids during the entirety of their descent .","this is true for almost all of the downflows observed in the may 9 event . as with the loops observed in the march 16 event , the voids are relatively wide when they appear and are compressed in size as they descend .","an example downflow is shown in figure [ fig : examples ] .","the timing of the downflows is similar to that of the march 16 event , with many of the most easily observed downflows being observed somewhat later in the evolution of the flare .","many downflows are observed after 21:15 ut , which is after the peak of the _ goes _ soft x - ray flux . in the may 18 event a mixture of descending voids and loops is observed .","for this flare there are also some downflows that evolve from voids into loops .","an example of a downflow that begins as a void and evolves into a loop is shown in figure [ fig : examples ] .","the earliest high temperature emission in this event is also observed to appear very suddenly at low heights without any downward motion as the loops brighten . after these loops appear , they do to contract downward to lower heights .","as in the march 16 flare , most of the downflows that are easily observed appear after the peak of the soft x - ray emission .","the _ stereo _ observations suggest that the orientation of the may 18 event is particularly interesting .","the third panel of figure [ fig : stereo2 ] shows that the post - flare loop arcade forms an `` @xmath3 '' shape , with part of the `` @xmath3 '' oriented parallel to the line of sight and another part oriented perpendicular to it .","when the axis of the arcade is along the line of sight the downflows appear as loops or as voids that transition to loops .","_ stereo _ observations indicate that the other events are consistent with this interpretation .","the arcade in the march 16 event is oriented at an angle to the line of sight and loops are observed ( see figure [ fig : stereo0 ] ) .","the arcade in the may 9 event is essentially perpendicular to the line of sight and only voids are observed ( see figure [ fig : stereo1 ] ) . for each event we also inspected the 94 images .","as noted earlier , this channel includes a strong emission line and is sensitive to somewhat lower temperature plasma than the 131 channel . as one would expect , these images tend to show the somewhat cooler plasma at the lower part of the arcade and as a result tend to show the terminal phase of the downflows . for this reason we focus on the data from the aia 131 channel in this paper .","rrcrr + 00 & 132.6 & 0.039 & 831.7 & -32.1 + 01 & 149.0 & 2.282 & 119.0 & -271.6 + 02 & 178.6 & 0.274 & 454.1 & -124.5 + 03 & 196.6 & 0.492 & 290.6 & -143.0 + 04 & 204.3 & 0.857 & 226.7 & -194.2 + 05 & 136.5 & 0.619 & 261.2 & -161.7 + 06 & 188.9 & 0.271 & 500.6 & -135.8 + 07 & 180.9 & 0.308 & 507.7 & -156.2 + 08 & 225.6 & 0.089 & 1031.3 & -91.7 + 09 & 250.4 & 0.044 & 1938.6 & -84.6 + + 00 & 113.6 & 2.185 & 128.1 & -279.9 + 01 & 118.9 & 1.043 & 212.5 & -221.7 + 02 & 131.1 & 1.506 & 166.6 & -250.9 + 03 & 117.6 & 0.581 & 231.3 & -134.3 + 04 & 128.2 & 0.440 & 345.3 & -152.1 + 05 & 110.8 & 0.161 & 406.1 & -65.3 + 06 & 63.8 & 0.087 & 659.1 & -57.1 + 07 & 82.0 & 0.237 & 363.8 & -86.1 + 08 & 80.4 & 1.050 & 115.6 & -121.3 + 09 & 103.7 & 0.786 & 192.2 & -151.1 + 10 & 73.8 & 0.306 & 245.1 & -75.1 + 11 & 90.9 & 0.375 & 270.7 & -101.7 + + 00 & 75.2 & 2.687 & 102.1 & -274.4 + 01 & 84.7 & 2.726 & 97.1 & -264.8 + 02 & 83.3 & 0.451 & 274.1 & -123.7 + 03 & 70.5 & 3.407 & 77.7 & -264.8 + 04 & 61.7 & 1.190 & 120.0 & -142.8 + 05 & 75.1 & 0.867 & 165.8 & -143.7 + 06 & 88.3 & 0.473 & 316.6 & -149.9 + 07 & 70.7 & 1.059 & 155.9 & -165.0 + 08 & 76.7 & 0.438 & 243.4 & -106.5 + 09 & 83.1 & 0.403 & 440.2 & -177.0 [ table : inflows ] a useful way of tracking features as they descend is to create height - time maps .","these maps are formed by extracting a narrow `` slit '' from each image and stacking them horizontally as a function of time ( see * ? ? ?","interpolation is used to extract intensities at arbitrary angles .","an example height - time map computed from the difference images is shown in figure [ fig : ht0 ] . here","the downflows are evident as dark tracks , indicating that the downflows are generally less intense than the emission into which they are descending . to characterize the kinematics of the downflows we fit selected height - time tracks to a function of the form @xmath4 with this assumption the velocity of the downflow as a function of time is @xmath5 and the acceleration is @xmath6 this functional form for the height captures the rapid transition from a relatively high initial velocity of @xmath7 at a height of @xmath8 , to a relatively slow terminal descent , @xmath9 .","note that for features that descend at progressively slower speeds the initial velocity will be negative and the acceleration will be positive .","we have selected approximately 10 downflows from each event and traced out their tracks in the height - time maps .","the best - fit parameters for equation [ eq : h ] were determined for each track using a least - squares algorithm and are given in table [ table : inflows ] .","each track is also indicated in the movies included in the electronic version of the manuscript .","we tended to select high velocity tracks that appeared at relatively large heights since they were easier to track and are more relevant to the initial dynamics of post - reconnection flux tubes .","many of the tracks that we selected decelerate quickly and could not be followed for long periods of time .","this means the asymptotic behavior is not well observed for these tracks . if we leave @xmath9 as a free parameter in the fitting of these tracks the terminal velocity often converges to relatively large number , inconsistent with the general trend in the data . for tracks that do have a well observed terminal phase , the terminal velocity is typically about 45 km s@xmath1 . since the terminal velocities are generally small and we are more interested in the initial dynamics we have forced @xmath10 for the final fits given in table [ table : inflows ] . with the improved imaging capabilities of aia we anticipated being able to track downflows at larger heights above the solar surface . comparing the values for @xmath8","given in table [ table : inflows ] with figures 6 from @xcite we see that is the case .","our median initial height is approximately 111 mm compared with 82 mm with the earlier data .","our initial velocities and accelerations , however , are very similar to those presented by @xcite in their figure 5 . for the initial velocity","we have a median value of -144 km s@xmath1 compared with -146 km s@xmath1 in @xcite .","our median initial acceleration is 0.68 km s@xmath11 compared with 0.42 km s@xmath11 .","thus it appears that small initial velocities relative to the alfvn speed are not an artifact of the lower heights at which the downflows have been observed previously .","chromospheric evaporation is an essential component of solar flares models based on magnetic reconnection ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","the release of energy on reconnected field lines will ultimately lead to the heating and evaporation of chromospheric material .","this should lead to loops that brighten over time and numerical simulations suggest that this process should occur rapidly ( e.g. , * ? ? ?","one limitation of the running difference images is that they can obscure the evolution of the absolute intensities .","the downflows are dark features in the running difference images , indicating that they have lower intensities than the surrounding emission .","it is not clear , however , if they remain dark in an absolute sense or brighten over time . to address this issue","we have followed the intensities along each track in the unsubtracted images .","for comparison we also determined intensities at several locations outside of the track . in all cases the intensity in the center of the feature simply tracks the background intensities measured outside of the downflow .","there is no evidence for the intensities in the downflows rising faster than the background .","unfortunately , these measurements are difficult to make and subject to considerable uncertainty .","the downflows have a very low contrast relative to the ambient emission in the flare .","the difference images shown in figures [ fig : stereo0][fig : ht0 ] are all scaled over a range of about @xmath125dn s@xmath1 , which is typically only a few percent of the absolute intensity ."],["we have presented the first observations of supra - arcade downflows with the aia instrument on _ sdo_. with the new capabilities of aia we are able to track inflows at much larger heights and for much smaller events than in previous observations .","these observations provide many new examples of features forming at large heights and descending onto the accumulating post - flare loop arcade .","the dynamics and morphology of the downflows provides compelling evidence for the role of magnetic reconnection in eruptive solar flares . despite the qualitative agreement between the observations and the standard picture of magnetic reconnection",", there are several problems that remain .","the low velocities that are observed for these outflows , for example , are incompatible with the simple 2d models of sweet - parker and petschek reconnection , which have alfvnic velocities for the outflows .","@xcite suggest that the interaction of the reconnected flux tubes with pre - existing magnetic fields provide a drag force that slows the downflows .","another difficulty in interpreting the downflows as evidence for magnetic reconnection is the formation of the initial flare plasma . for most events","the downflows that are easily observed occur late in the flare and descend into an existing cloud of hot emission .","the initial flare emission forms essentially `` in place , '' and not as a descending loop although there is some evidence for collapsing motions after these loops appear .","finally , the reconnection of magnetic fields should lead to the release of energy that drives chromospheric evaporation .","all of the downflows that we detect here , however , are observed as depletions relative to the ambient high temperature emission into which they are descending .","recent work by @xcite suggests that density depletions can be formed in reconnecting flux tubes that move through a nonuniform current sheet . their model",", however , does not include chromospheric evaporation and it is not clear how long such density depletions would persist .","the inability of the simple , two - dimensional reconnection models to describe many details of the downflows suggests that three - dimensional modeling is required .","the aia observations we have shown here give ample evidence for inhomogeneity in the reconnecting magnetic fields and this inhomogeneity will be a component of any successful model .","high resolution observations of the photospheric magnetic field in active regions , such as those taken with the solar optical telescope ( sot ) on _ hinode _ ( e.g , * ? ? ?","* ) , show that the magnetic field is structured on the spatial scale of the granules ( @xmath01000 km ) and we conjecture that this inhomogeneity is reflected in the highly structured appearance of the flare plasma ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"magnetic reconnection is a fundamental process in astrophysical plasmas and is believed to be responsible for a wide range of solar phenomena , including solar flares ( for a review see * ? ? ?\",\n \"unfortunately , magnetic reconnection occurs on spatial scales that are too small to be resolved with current solar instrumentation and can not be observed directly .\",\n \"there is , however , considerable indirect evidence that magnetic reconnection plays a central role in solar flares .\",\n \"perhaps the most compelling piece of indirect evidence is the supra - arcade downflows that have been observed above many post - flare loop arcades ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"these downflows appear to be related to highly non - potential field lines that have reconnected and are propagating away from the current sheet .\",\n \"supra - arcade downflows have been observed with a number of instruments and their properties are summarized in the comprehensive review by @xcite .\",\n \"the downlows often appear as dark , collapsing features that look like small `` tadpoles '' ( voids with a trailing dark tail ) .\",\n \"some downflows have a loop - like appearance while others appear to evolve from voids into loops .\",\n \"the downflows generally begin at relatively high velocities ( 100200 km s@xmath1 is typical ) and then quickly decelerate to about 4 km s@xmath1 . observations at high spatial resolution give the impression that much of high temperature plasma in a flare is formed from collapsing loops @xcite , even when individual features can not be tracked .\",\n \"similar features are observed in the outer corona when the streamer belt is viewed face on ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"despite the extensive analysis of previous observations a number of questions remain regarding the downflows and their relationship to magnetic reconnection .\",\n \"the initial velocities measured for the downflows tend to be much smaller than the estimated alfvn speed in the lower corona ( @xmath01000 km s@xmath1 ) , the velocity expected for reconnection outflows .\",\n \"it is possible that the downflows are formed at large heights and are observed only after they have experienced some deceleration . in most models of solar flares\",\n \"the release of energy in the corona ultimately drives chromospheric evaporation and leads to the formation of hot , dense loops ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"many of the downflows , however , are observed as dark features and it is not clear that all of the high temperature emission in the flare is formed from descending loops . finally , why some downflows appear as voids and while others appear as loops is unclear .\",\n \"it is possible that the observed morphology is strongly influenced by the viewing angle .\",\n \"the launch of the atmospheric imaging assembly ( aia ) on the _ solar dynamics observatory _ ( _ sdo _ ) provides a new opportunity to investigate the dynamics of newly reconnected flux tubes in solar flares .\",\n \"aia has several advantages over previous solar euv imagers , including a higher cadence ( 12s ) and more channels that observe at flare temperatures .\",\n \"the higher cadence allows us to create data sets optimized for observing the downflows at large heights .\",\n \"the aia 94 and 131 channels observe emission from and , respectively .\",\n \"these lines are formed close to 10mk , the temperature at which the flare emission measure generally peaks .\",\n \"observations from the twin _ stereo _ spacecraft @xcite can also be applied to this problem . during the 20102012 time frame the spacecraft\",\n \"are approximately 90@xmath2 from the earth - sun line , which allows flares to be observed simultaneously as limb events by aia and disk events by the euvi imagers on _\",\n \"stereo_. in this paper we report new observations of supra - arcade downflows taken with aia and euvi . with the improved capabilities of aia we are able to track features at larger heights and in much weaker events than in previous studies .\",\n \"the combined aia and euvi observations provide compelling evidence that the downflowing voids and loops are manifestations of the same phenomenon observed along different lines of sight .\",\n \"we find , however , that the initial velocities are consistent with previous measurements and well below the estimated alfvn speed .\",\n \"the relationship between the brightest emission in the flare and the downflows is also not resolved .\",\n \"we find no evidence that the emission from the downflows rises with time , as would be expected from chromospheric evaporation .\",\n \"also , for these events the initial high temperature flare loops are observed to form almost `` in place '' with very little associated downward motion .\",\n \"these difficulties suggest that simple two - dimensional models of magnetic reconnection can not be applied directly to detailed observations of solar flares .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the aia instrument on _ sdo _ is a multilayer imaging telescope .\",\n \"a full description of the instrument is given in @xcite . in brief\",\n \", the aia instrument images the full sun in 10 different channels with 0.6 pixels at a typical cadence of 12s .\",\n \"there are 7 euv channels for imaging emission from the transition region and corona .\",\n \"the aia 94 , 131 , and 193 channels observe flare emission from , , and , respectively .\",\n \"each of the channels is also sensitive to emission formed at cooler temperatures .\",\n \"the 193 channel includes 195 , which is an intrinsically bright line and makes difficult to observe in smaller events .\",\n \"the lower temperature response for the 131 channel is primarily from emission lines that are much weaker than 195 , making the high temperature emission much easier to observe .\",\n \"the lower temperature lines in the 94 bandpass are largely unidentified , but they are also relatively weak . for a more complete description of the aia temperature response see @xcite .\",\n \"all of the aia data that we have analyzed are sub - fields of the full disk images obtained from the lmsal cutout service .\",\n \"the data has been processed using ` aia_prep ` to remove any energetic particle spikes and co - register the images from the different wavelengths to a common plate scale . for this work\",\n \"we consider three flares that occurred at the solar limb as viewed from earth : a c3.8 event that began at about 18:00 ut on 2011 march 16 , a c5.4 flare that began at about 20:30 ut on 2011 may 9 , and a c2.1 flare that begin at about 18:00 ut on 2011 may 18 .\",\n \"the soft x - ray light curves from the _ goes _ 15 spacecraft are shown in figure [ fig : goes ] .\",\n \"the _ goes _ light curves indicate that these flares are all long duration events that evolve over many hours .\",\n \"some representative aia 131 images are shown in figures [ fig : stereo0 ] , [ fig : stereo1 ] , and [ fig : stereo2 ] .\",\n \"all three events are clearly associated with a coronal mass ejection and have the classic morphology of a two - ribbon flare .\",\n \"each event shows a diffuse `` cloud '' of high temperature ( @xmath010mk ) plasma that rises with time . over time relatively narrow , lower temperature ( @xmath01mk ) loops form at the lowest heights and material is observed to drain back down to the surface of the sun along these loops .\",\n \"the temperatures that we give here are approximate and based on comparisons with previous work ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"high temperature emission is observed only in the 94 and 131 channels while only low temperature loops are observed in channels such as 171 , which has a significant response only at low temperatures .\",\n \"very little emission is observed in the 193 channel images for these flares .\",\n \"the _ goes _ soft x - ray fluxes for these events are approximately 100 times smaller than was observed in the x - class flares considered previously ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ; * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ) , so this is not surprising .\",\n \"movies of the data for each event show evidence for features forming at large heights and descending onto the accumulating post - flare loop arcade .\",\n \"these features are generally difficult to track in the raw intensity images . to eliminate the contribution of the more slowly varying emission it is useful to compute running difference images . with the high cadence of aia we have considerable flexibility in constructing these images . through trial and error\",\n \"we have found that averaging sets of 7 images taken 72s apart produced the best results .\",\n \"since the downflows move at relatively high velocities , too much averaging or too long an interval between frames blurs the features . averaging fewer frames or choosing a shorter interval between frames leads to noisier difference images .\",\n \"example running difference images are displayed in figures [ fig : stereo0 ] , [ fig : stereo1 ] , and [ fig : stereo2 ] .\",\n \"movies of the running difference images , which are available in the electronic version of the manuscript , show the downflows much more clearly than the raw intensity images .\",\n \"in general , the downflows appear as dark features in the running difference images , indicating that they are dark relative to the emission into which they are descending . in the march 16 event\",\n \"all of the downflows appear as elongated loop - like features .\",\n \"as illustrated in the example shown in figure [ fig : examples ] , when the loops first appear they are relatively broad but they are compressed as they descend .\",\n \"many of the descending loops that are the easiest to observe appear relatively late in the event ( after approximately 20:00 ut ) . at earlier times , 18:2019:00 ut for example , high temperature emission appears at relatively low heights very suddenly and does not appear to descend from larger heights .\",\n \"the loops that appear near 18:30 ut and are shown in the first column of figure [ fig : stereo0 ] illustrate this .\",\n \"there is , however , some downward motion after the emission appears , consistent with the shrinkage of post - reconnection loops ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) .\",\n \"some of the downflows in these events are observed as dark voids during the entirety of their descent .\",\n \"this is true for almost all of the downflows observed in the may 9 event . as with the loops observed in the march 16 event , the voids are relatively wide when they appear and are compressed in size as they descend .\",\n \"an example downflow is shown in figure [ fig : examples ] .\",\n \"the timing of the downflows is similar to that of the march 16 event , with many of the most easily observed downflows being observed somewhat later in the evolution of the flare .\",\n \"many downflows are observed after 21:15 ut , which is after the peak of the _ goes _ soft x - ray flux . in the may 18 event a mixture of descending voids and loops is observed .\",\n \"for this flare there are also some downflows that evolve from voids into loops .\",\n \"an example of a downflow that begins as a void and evolves into a loop is shown in figure [ fig : examples ] .\",\n \"the earliest high temperature emission in this event is also observed to appear very suddenly at low heights without any downward motion as the loops brighten . after these loops appear , they do to contract downward to lower heights .\",\n \"as in the march 16 flare , most of the downflows that are easily observed appear after the peak of the soft x - ray emission .\",\n \"the _ stereo _ observations suggest that the orientation of the may 18 event is particularly interesting .\",\n \"the third panel of figure [ fig : stereo2 ] shows that the post - flare loop arcade forms an `` @xmath3 '' shape , with part of the `` @xmath3 '' oriented parallel to the line of sight and another part oriented perpendicular to it .\",\n \"when the axis of the arcade is along the line of sight the downflows appear as loops or as voids that transition to loops .\",\n \"_ stereo _ observations indicate that the other events are consistent with this interpretation .\",\n \"the arcade in the march 16 event is oriented at an angle to the line of sight and loops are observed ( see figure [ fig : stereo0 ] ) .\",\n \"the arcade in the may 9 event is essentially perpendicular to the line of sight and only voids are observed ( see figure [ fig : stereo1 ] ) . for each event we also inspected the 94 images .\",\n \"as noted earlier , this channel includes a strong emission line and is sensitive to somewhat lower temperature plasma than the 131 channel . as one would expect , these images tend to show the somewhat cooler plasma at the lower part of the arcade and as a result tend to show the terminal phase of the downflows . for this reason we focus on the data from the aia 131 channel in this paper .\",\n \"rrcrr + 00 & 132.6 & 0.039 & 831.7 & -32.1 + 01 & 149.0 & 2.282 & 119.0 & -271.6 + 02 & 178.6 & 0.274 & 454.1 & -124.5 + 03 & 196.6 & 0.492 & 290.6 & -143.0 + 04 & 204.3 & 0.857 & 226.7 & -194.2 + 05 & 136.5 & 0.619 & 261.2 & -161.7 + 06 & 188.9 & 0.271 & 500.6 & -135.8 + 07 & 180.9 & 0.308 & 507.7 & -156.2 + 08 & 225.6 & 0.089 & 1031.3 & -91.7 + 09 & 250.4 & 0.044 & 1938.6 & -84.6 + + 00 & 113.6 & 2.185 & 128.1 & -279.9 + 01 & 118.9 & 1.043 & 212.5 & -221.7 + 02 & 131.1 & 1.506 & 166.6 & -250.9 + 03 & 117.6 & 0.581 & 231.3 & -134.3 + 04 & 128.2 & 0.440 & 345.3 & -152.1 + 05 & 110.8 & 0.161 & 406.1 & -65.3 + 06 & 63.8 & 0.087 & 659.1 & -57.1 + 07 & 82.0 & 0.237 & 363.8 & -86.1 + 08 & 80.4 & 1.050 & 115.6 & -121.3 + 09 & 103.7 & 0.786 & 192.2 & -151.1 + 10 & 73.8 & 0.306 & 245.1 & -75.1 + 11 & 90.9 & 0.375 & 270.7 & -101.7 + + 00 & 75.2 & 2.687 & 102.1 & -274.4 + 01 & 84.7 & 2.726 & 97.1 & -264.8 + 02 & 83.3 & 0.451 & 274.1 & -123.7 + 03 & 70.5 & 3.407 & 77.7 & -264.8 + 04 & 61.7 & 1.190 & 120.0 & -142.8 + 05 & 75.1 & 0.867 & 165.8 & -143.7 + 06 & 88.3 & 0.473 & 316.6 & -149.9 + 07 & 70.7 & 1.059 & 155.9 & -165.0 + 08 & 76.7 & 0.438 & 243.4 & -106.5 + 09 & 83.1 & 0.403 & 440.2 & -177.0 [ table : inflows ] a useful way of tracking features as they descend is to create height - time maps .\",\n \"these maps are formed by extracting a narrow `` slit '' from each image and stacking them horizontally as a function of time ( see * ? ? ?\",\n \"interpolation is used to extract intensities at arbitrary angles .\",\n \"an example height - time map computed from the difference images is shown in figure [ fig : ht0 ] . here\",\n \"the downflows are evident as dark tracks , indicating that the downflows are generally less intense than the emission into which they are descending . to characterize the kinematics of the downflows we fit selected height - time tracks to a function of the form @xmath4 with this assumption the velocity of the downflow as a function of time is @xmath5 and the acceleration is @xmath6 this functional form for the height captures the rapid transition from a relatively high initial velocity of @xmath7 at a height of @xmath8 , to a relatively slow terminal descent , @xmath9 .\",\n \"note that for features that descend at progressively slower speeds the initial velocity will be negative and the acceleration will be positive .\",\n \"we have selected approximately 10 downflows from each event and traced out their tracks in the height - time maps .\",\n \"the best - fit parameters for equation [ eq : h ] were determined for each track using a least - squares algorithm and are given in table [ table : inflows ] .\",\n \"each track is also indicated in the movies included in the electronic version of the manuscript .\",\n \"we tended to select high velocity tracks that appeared at relatively large heights since they were easier to track and are more relevant to the initial dynamics of post - reconnection flux tubes .\",\n \"many of the tracks that we selected decelerate quickly and could not be followed for long periods of time .\",\n \"this means the asymptotic behavior is not well observed for these tracks . if we leave @xmath9 as a free parameter in the fitting of these tracks the terminal velocity often converges to relatively large number , inconsistent with the general trend in the data . for tracks that do have a well observed terminal phase , the terminal velocity is typically about 45 km s@xmath1 . since the terminal velocities are generally small and we are more interested in the initial dynamics we have forced @xmath10 for the final fits given in table [ table : inflows ] . with the improved imaging capabilities of aia we anticipated being able to track downflows at larger heights above the solar surface . comparing the values for @xmath8\",\n \"given in table [ table : inflows ] with figures 6 from @xcite we see that is the case .\",\n \"our median initial height is approximately 111 mm compared with 82 mm with the earlier data .\",\n \"our initial velocities and accelerations , however , are very similar to those presented by @xcite in their figure 5 . for the initial velocity\",\n \"we have a median value of -144 km s@xmath1 compared with -146 km s@xmath1 in @xcite .\",\n \"our median initial acceleration is 0.68 km s@xmath11 compared with 0.42 km s@xmath11 .\",\n \"thus it appears that small initial velocities relative to the alfvn speed are not an artifact of the lower heights at which the downflows have been observed previously .\",\n \"chromospheric evaporation is an essential component of solar flares models based on magnetic reconnection ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"the release of energy on reconnected field lines will ultimately lead to the heating and evaporation of chromospheric material .\",\n \"this should lead to loops that brighten over time and numerical simulations suggest that this process should occur rapidly ( e.g. , * ? ? ?\",\n \"one limitation of the running difference images is that they can obscure the evolution of the absolute intensities .\",\n \"the downflows are dark features in the running difference images , indicating that they have lower intensities than the surrounding emission .\",\n \"it is not clear , however , if they remain dark in an absolute sense or brighten over time . to address this issue\",\n \"we have followed the intensities along each track in the unsubtracted images .\",\n \"for comparison we also determined intensities at several locations outside of the track . in all cases the intensity in the center of the feature simply tracks the background intensities measured outside of the downflow .\",\n \"there is no evidence for the intensities in the downflows rising faster than the background .\",\n \"unfortunately , these measurements are difficult to make and subject to considerable uncertainty .\",\n \"the downflows have a very low contrast relative to the ambient emission in the flare .\",\n \"the difference images shown in figures [ fig : stereo0][fig : ht0 ] are all scaled over a range of about @xmath125dn s@xmath1 , which is typically only a few percent of the absolute intensity .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we have presented the first observations of supra - arcade downflows with the aia instrument on _ sdo_. with the new capabilities of aia we are able to track inflows at much larger heights and for much smaller events than in previous observations .\",\n \"these observations provide many new examples of features forming at large heights and descending onto the accumulating post - flare loop arcade .\",\n \"the dynamics and morphology of the downflows provides compelling evidence for the role of magnetic reconnection in eruptive solar flares . despite the qualitative agreement between the observations and the standard picture of magnetic reconnection\",\n \", there are several problems that remain .\",\n \"the low velocities that are observed for these outflows , for example , are incompatible with the simple 2d models of sweet - parker and petschek reconnection , which have alfvnic velocities for the outflows .\",\n \"@xcite suggest that the interaction of the reconnected flux tubes with pre - existing magnetic fields provide a drag force that slows the downflows .\",\n \"another difficulty in interpreting the downflows as evidence for magnetic reconnection is the formation of the initial flare plasma . for most events\",\n \"the downflows that are easily observed occur late in the flare and descend into an existing cloud of hot emission .\",\n \"the initial flare emission forms essentially `` in place , '' and not as a descending loop although there is some evidence for collapsing motions after these loops appear .\",\n \"finally , the reconnection of magnetic fields should lead to the release of energy that drives chromospheric evaporation .\",\n \"all of the downflows that we detect here , however , are observed as depletions relative to the ambient high temperature emission into which they are descending .\",\n \"recent work by @xcite suggests that density depletions can be formed in reconnecting flux tubes that move through a nonuniform current sheet . their model\",\n \", however , does not include chromospheric evaporation and it is not clear how long such density depletions would persist .\",\n \"the inability of the simple , two - dimensional reconnection models to describe many details of the downflows suggests that three - dimensional modeling is required .\",\n \"the aia observations we have shown here give ample evidence for inhomogeneity in the reconnecting magnetic fields and this inhomogeneity will be a component of any successful model .\",\n \"high resolution observations of the photospheric magnetic field in active regions , such as those taken with the solar optical telescope ( sot ) on _ hinode _ ( e.g , * ? ? ?\",\n \"* ) , show that the magnetic field is structured on the spatial scale of the granules ( @xmath01000 km ) and we conjecture that this inhomogeneity is reflected in the highly structured appearance of the flare plasma .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":91,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"gr-qc9901040"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["a laser interferometer to detect gravitational waves , such as the laser interferometric gravitational wave observatory(ligo ) , virgo , geo600 , or tama300 , will be in operation within several years@xcite .","it is one of the most urgent subjects for theoretical relativists to make a set of templates of gravitational waves .","the direct detection of gravitational waves is very important not only as a new eye \" observing the universe ( gravitational wave astronomy ) but also as a new probe for fundamental physics .","for example , we know that a neutron star , which is observed as a pulsar , has a mass @xmath1 and a radius @xmath2 @xmath3 .","although we can guess its central region with some theoretical ansatz , we have no direct information from the inside of a neutron star because neither radiation nor a neutrino is transparent in the central region .","the direct detection of gravitational waves may provide some information about the inside of a neutron star when it is formed , resulting in new observational facts or constraints about the equation of state for high density matter .","one of the most promising astronomical sources for these ground - based detectors is a coalesced compact binary such as a neutron star binary . to complete a set of templates from such a source",", many studies about the emitted gravitational waves have been done using various techniques .","a numerical simulation without approximations ( numerical relativity ) is probably one of the best ways to calculate gravitational waves emitted from the compact binary system @xcite .","although steady progress in numerical relativity has been achieved , there are still some difficulties which prevent us from finding the final results . instead , there are some powerful approximation methods to mimic the coalescence of a compact binary system .","one such approximation is the perturbative approach .","regge and wheeler @xcite and zerilli @xcite first formulated a method for metric perturbations in a schwarzschild black hole spacetime .","then there are many works using such a black hole perturbation method in which we describe gravitational waves by metric perturbations in a black hole background spacetime and treat a companion of the binary as a test particle@xcite .","this approximation for gravitational waves in a head - on collision of two black holes gives a good agreement with the results obtained by numerical simulation@xcite .","thus , such a perturbative approach may provide a good approximation for gravitational waves from a compact binary as well . however , there are so far few works for neutron star perturbations",". one may think that if we have two @xmath4 neutron stars , it will be a black hole after coalescence , when the ringing tail of the gravitational waves can be described by quasinormal modes of the black hole .","the quasinormal modes of a neutron star may have nothing to do with the final stage of the coalescence .","however , before black hole formation , we have to analyze the orbital evolution of the neutron star binary .","therefore , we believe that a perturbation analysis for a neutron star is also important . for a nonradial pulsation of a spherically symmetric relativistic star , perturbation equations both for axial and polar modes were first derived by thorne and campolattaro @xcite .","similar to the black hole perturbation , the axial mode for a spherical star is described by a second order differential equation .","on the other hand , the polar mode was first described by a fifth order differential equation@xcite . however , because of the dynamical degrees of freedom of polar modes , i.e. , sound waves and gravitational waves , the basic equation can be reduced to a fourth order differential equation as shown by lindblom and detweiler @xcite .","lindblom , mendell , and ipser @xcite also derived a couple of second order differential equations , which could be interpreted as those for sound waves and gravitational waves , respectively .","as in the case of black hole perturbations , quasinormal modes , if they exist , will be important in the analysis of gravitational waves from a compact binary . for the polar mode",", there are two types of quasinormal modes of a neutron star ; one is a fluid oscillation mode similar to the @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath7 modes of a newtonian star ( cf .","@xcite ) ; the other is a wave mode ( @xmath8 mode ) , which exists only in general relativity @xcite . even for the axial mode ,","chandrasekhar and ferrari@xcite illustrated that quasinormal modes exist if the effective potential has a minimal as that in an ultracompact star .","kokkotas @xcite numerically calculated such axial quasinormal modes for various ultracompact stars .","kojima @xcite extended it to a slowly rotating star , setting regge - wheeler gauge conditions .","as for emitted gravitational waves from a binary system , kojima @xcite studied them for the case that a test particle is moving in a circular orbit around a polytropic star . for a circular orbit ,","the axial mode cancels from the orbital symmetry so that the polar mode was only taken into account .","he showed that the resonance mode appears in the energy flux when the orbit reaches the radius where the orbital frequency coincides with that of the quasinormal mode .","for the axial mode , recently , borrelli @xcite calculated energy spectra of gravitational waves emitted by a test particle spiraling into an ultracompact star . in his result ,","its energy spectrum shows many peaks , which correspond to axial quasinormal modes of the star .","although it is important , since we are interested in a compact binary , a direct collision might show some different features from the binary case .","we also do not know what will happen when a test particle reaches the surface of the star .","to avoid such an unknown factor and to analyze the case of a compact binary , we first study gravitational waves emitted when a test particle is scattered by a neutron star in this paper . for a schwarzschild black hole , oohara and","nakamura @xcite analyzed it and showed that the energy spectrum has no peak except for one which corresponds to the orbital frequency .","here we consider a spherical star instead of a schwarzschild black hole .","we study only the axial mode which does not exist in newton gravity . to discuss the dependence of the equations of state , we analyze two models : a uniform density star as in @xcite and a polytropic star .","this paper is organized as follows . in secs .","[ sec : linear]a and [ sec : linear]b , we briefly review the perturbation theory for a spherically symmetric relativistic star .","we show our numerical results in sec .","[ sec : gw ] .","section [ sec : discussion ] is devoted to a discussion .","some numerical techniques for calculating gravitational waves are summarized in the appendix . throughout this paper",", we use units of @xmath9 and a metric signature of @xmath10 .","we start with summarizing briefly the metric perturbation of a spherically symmetric relativistic star . a spherically symmetric background metric @xmath11 is described as @xmath12 @xmath13 where @xmath14 is a mass function inside a radius @xmath15 .","we assume a perfect fluid as the stellar matter , i.e. @xmath16 where @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the total energy density and the pressure , respectively , which satisfy a barotropic equation of state , @xmath19 .","using tolman - oppenheimer - volkov equations , we construct a stellar model and its spacetime metric numerically except for the constant density star case .","the radius @xmath20 of a star is defined by a surface where the pressure vanishes , and the mass of the star @xmath21 is given by @xmath22 . for linearized einstein equations",", we can decompose the perturbed metric into an axial mode @xmath23 and a polar mode @xmath24 : @xmath25 using regge - wheeler gauge conditions , we will integrate the interior and exterior regions of the linearized einstein equations , separately , and impose appropriate junction conditions at the surface @xmath20 to find the solution . in this paper",", we only deal with axial mode perturbation .","then , we write down the linearized einstein equation only for axial modes in the following subsections . in order to find the linearized einstein equations for axial modes , we expand the perturbed metric by tensor harmonics for polar angle @xmath26 and azimuthal angle @xmath27 @xcite , and proceed to a fourier transformation for the time coordinate @xmath28 .","although there are ten independent components for the linearized metric , four of them are gauge freedoms of coordinate transformations , which are fixed by a choice of regge - wheeler gauge @xcite , resulting in two components belonging to axial modes , while the rest of the four correspond to polar modes . for axial mode perturbations , we can set @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are functions of the radial coordinate @xmath15 defined below , and @xmath32 is a spherical harmonics .","the axial mode in the interior region of a star is described by a single wave equation for gravitational waves , because a rotation does not exist in a spherically symmetric background spacetime .","that is , we have a single wave function @xmath33 , which determines the behaviors of axial modes as @xmath34 the equation for the wave function @xmath33 is derived from the linearized einstein equation for axial modes as @xmath35 where the `` tortoise '' coordinate @xmath36 and the effective potential @xmath37 are defined as @xmath38 respectively .","as for the boundary condition , the wave function @xmath33 must be regular at the center of a star .","expanding @xmath33 around the center @xmath39 , we find @xmath40 r^{l + 3 } + o(r^{l+5 } ) \\right\\ } , \\label{eq : bc_x}\\ ] ] where @xmath41 is an arbitrary constant , and @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 are the central density , pressure , and metric functions , respectively .","apart from a free parameter @xmath41 , we obtain a solution @xmath33 by integrating eq .","( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) with the boundary condition ( @xmath45 ) .","further details of the numerical techniques constructing the wave function @xmath33 are given in the appendix , subsection [ subsec : app_interior ] .","the background metric outside the star is the schwarzschild spacetime , i.e. , eq .","( [ eq : bgmetric ] ) , with @xmath46 as for the trajectory of a test particle , without loss of generality , we can assume that the particle moves on the equatorial plane ( @xmath47 ) .","then , the equation of motion for the particle is described as @xmath48 where the particle trajectory is @xmath49 , and @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 are the mass , the normalized energy , and the normalized orbital angular momentum of the particle , respectively , with @xmath53 and @xmath54 .","the normalized effective potential energy @xmath55 of the particle is given as @xmath56 in this paper , since we only consider the motion of a test particle scattered by a spherical star , the particle orbit is unbounded , i.e. , @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the maximum value of the potential .","the perturbed metric outside a star only comes from an oscillation of spacetime , that is , gravitational waves .","then , similar to the interior region , the linearized einstein equations for the metric @xmath59 and @xmath60 defined as eq .","( [ metric ] ) are reduced to a single wave equation for a new wave function @xmath61 defined by @xmath62 where @xmath63 and @xmath64 is one of the source terms given below . from the linearized vacuum einstein equations",", we find the wave equation for @xmath61 ( regge - wheeler equation)@xcite as @xmath65 where @xmath36 is the tortoise coordinate defined by @xmath66 @xmath67 is regge - wheeler potential given by @xmath68 and @xmath69 is the source term , which is described by the energy - momentum tensor of a test particle expanded by tensor harmonics@xcite as @xmath70 \\right ] , \\label{source}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] with @xmath71 and @xmath72 being @xmath73 , \\label{eq : def_q } \\\\","d_{lm}(t , r ) & = & - \\frac{1}{\\sqrt{2n(n+1 ) } } \\mu \\int_{-\\infty}^{\\infty } d \\tau \\delta { \\bf ( } t - \\hat{t}(\\tau ) { \\bf ) } \\delta { \\bf ( } r - \\hat{r}(\\tau ) { \\bf ) } \\nonumber \\\\ & & \\quad \\times \\biggl\\ { \\frac{1}{2 } \\left [ \\left ( \\frac{d \\hat{\\theta}}{d \\tau } \\right)^2 - \\sin^2 \\hat{\\theta } \\left ( \\frac{d \\hat{\\phi}}{d \\tau}\\right)^2 \\right ] \\frac{1}{\\sin \\hat{\\theta } } \\bar{x}_{lm } ( \\hat{\\omega } ) \\nonumber \\\\ & & \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad - \\sin \\hat{\\theta } \\frac{d \\hat{\\theta}}{d \\tau } \\frac{d \\hat{\\phi}}{d \\tau } \\bar{w}_{lm}(\\hat{\\omega } ) \\biggr\\}. \\label{eq : def_d}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] @xmath74 , @xmath75 are the tensorial part of a tensor harmonics defined by @xmath76 and the overbar denotes the complex conjugate . the boundary condition outside the star should be imposed such that there is no incoming wave at infinity , @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the amplitude of an outgoing wave at infinity .","the details of constructing the wave function @xmath61 are given in the appendix , subsections [ subsec : app_exterior ] and [ subsec : app_turning_point ] .","we have to combine two wave functions , the interior wave function @xmath33 and the exterior one @xmath61 , at the surface of the star .","the matching condition is that the wave function must be continuous and smooth at the surface . for the case of the axial mode ,","since the wave function inside the star does not couple to perturbations of the matter fluid , the condition turns out to be very simple as @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the radius of the star by use of the tortoise \" coordinate .","then we calculate the amplitude of the gravitational waves @xmath78 as follows : we first integrate eqs .","( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) and ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation ] ) using their boundary conditions , eqs .","( [ eq : bc_x ] ) and ( [ eq : bc_infty ] ) .","next , we connect those solutions at the surface of the star using eqs .","( [ eq : s_condition1 ] ) and ( [ eq : s_condition2 ] ) , which determine two unknown coefficients @xmath41 and @xmath78 . from the wave function","obtained as above , we obtain some information about gravitational waves emitted by a scattered particle .","when we discuss the gravitational waves , we usually decompose them into two modes : @xmath81 and @xmath82 modes .","then , we have to transform our coordinate system from the regge - wheeler gauge to the transverse - traceless one , which metric near infinity is described as @xmath83 then the axial mode in transverse - traceless gauge at infinity turns out to be @xmath84 where the spin - weighted spherical harmonics @xmath85 is defined by @xmath86 the energy - momentum tensor of the gravitational waves at infinity is given by @xmath87 in the transverse - traceless gauge , where the angular brackets denote an appropriate average . from this definition ,","we find the energy spectrum @xmath88 of gravitational waves at infinity for the axial mode as @xmath89","in this subsection , we consider a uniform density star . we restrict our analysis only to the case of the @xmath90 mode , just for simplicity .","we find that features of the energy spectrum of emitted gravitational waves can be classified into two cases , which mainly depend on the shape of the effective potential .","figure [ fig : potential ] shows the effective potential [ eqs .","( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) and ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) ] for a uniform density star with three different compactness parameters @xmath91 .","the effective potential has the following three features .","first , the regge - wheeler potential [ eq .","( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) ] has a maximum point near @xmath92 ( accurately at @xmath93 for @xmath94 ) .","second , the potential is discontinuous at the surface because of a discontinuity of the energy density of the star at the surface .","finally , a potential minimum appears inside the star , if the star is ultracompact ( for the case of @xmath0 ) . according to the last feature",", we study two cases separately .","the first stellar type is the case that the surface is outside the potential barrier ( @xmath95 ) . for a usual neutron star , @xmath96 , and","then the first type is most likely a realistic astronomical object .","the second stellar type is the case that the surface is inside the potential barrier ( @xmath97 ) , which may be an exotic star , if it exists .","first we show our result for the first type . for the case of @xmath98",", we show the energy spectra of emitted gravitational waves in fig .","[ fig : rm5 ] . in this figure",", there exists only a single peak in each spectrum .","this peak corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point , i.e. , periastron .","this means that most gravitational waves are emitted around the turning point , where the effect of the gravitational field is the strongest .","no other feature is found in this spectrum .","in fact , fixing the energy @xmath99 and orbital angular momentum @xmath100 , the spectrum depends less on the compactness parameter @xmath91 ( see fig . [","fig : rm5bh ] ) . for a black hole background",", we find quite similar behaviors in the energy spectrum ( fig .","[ fig : rm5bh ] ) , except for the high frequency region , where the difference of the boundary conditions is crucial .","we also find that the spectrum approaches closer to that of a black hole as the star gets smaller .","we also calculate the waveform for the case of @xmath101 and black holes , respectively .","we see that a burst wave due to the encounter of a test particle emerges for each case . as the same as the energy spectrum , the difference between these waveform is very little ( see fig .","[ fig : wf5 ] ) therefore , for the first stellar type of @xmath102 , the energy spectrum largely depends on the trajectory , but not on the background object .","next we discuss an ultracompact star , which shows much more various structure in the spectrum . in this case",", a minimum point of the effective potential appears inside the star . as for the trajectory of a test particle , we have two possibilities : one is that the particle gets into the inside region beyond the potential barrier and the other is that one passes through outside the barrier . since the particle approaches closer to the star , it feels a stronger gravitational field . as a result ,","the excitation by the particle is more efficient and the emitted gravitational waves are enhanced . as a numerical example , we show those energy spectra for the model with radius @xmath103 with the turning points @xmath104 and @xmath105 in fig . [","fig : rm2.26 ] . apart from a global maximum , which appears in the first type model as well and corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point",", we also find many small periodic peaks in fig .","[ fig : rm2.26 ] .","this microscopic peak structure is classified into two types , which are divided at the frequency of the maximum @xmath106 ( @xmath107 for @xmath94 ) of the effective potential . in the lower frequency region ( @xmath108 )",", small and sharp peaks correspond to the quasinormal modes , as we will show it next . for the higher frequency region ( @xmath109 ) , we find small periodic peaks , which may appear because of a resonance between two potential barriers .","we will also discuss this later . in order to analyze our numerical results",", we first have to know the axial quasinormal modes . our method to calculate a quasinormal mode","is based on the continued fraction expansion method which was originally used for black holes by leaver @xcite , and adopted for the polar mode of a spherical star by leins , nollert , and soffel @xcite .","we apply this method to axial modes as well .","we show our results in table [ tab : qnm_urm2.26 ] with those of kokkotas@xcite whose method is different from ours .","the table shows that both results agree quite well . in fig .","[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] , we present both the quasinormal mode and energy spectrum . as seen from fig .","[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] , axial ","quasinormal \" modes are classified into two : the lower frequency mode ( @xmath110 ) , which imaginary part is very small @xmath111 , and the higher frequency mode ( @xmath112 ) , which imaginary part is rather large @xmath113 .","the reason is very simple . for a frequency lower than @xmath114",", we can have a quasibound state .","since trapped waves tunnel through the potential barrier , the energy will decrease .","it is similar to the quasinormal mode of a black hole .","then , we may call it the axial quasinormal mode as well . however , if the frequency is higher than @xmath114 , we have no bound state .","nevertheless , we can find the ","quasinormal \" mode , by which we mean a wave solution with the same boundary condition as that of the conventional quasinormal mode , which is the outgoing wave condition . in the present case , although we find such wave solutions , those waves decay very quickly because the frequency is higher than the potential barrier .","this is the reason why we find a large imaginary part of the mode frequency .","the solutions which satisfy the boundary condition appear periodically as seen from fig .","[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] .","we find that the frequencies of these quasinormal modes coincide with those of spectrum peaks in the frequency region lower than @xmath114 .","this is because a test particle excites those quasinormal modes .","in fact , when we see the waveform ( fig . [","fig : wf2.26 ] ) , the wave consists of two parts : large one , which corresponds to the burst wave by the encounter by a test particle , and the other part with several oscillations , which comes from exited quasinormal modes in the spectrum .","actually the waveform in the region after @xmath115 in fig .","[ fig : wf2.26 ] is similar to kokkotas s result for a gaussian pulse wave @xcite . on the other hand , in a frequency region","higher than @xmath114 , although many periodic peaks appear , those positions are not exactly the same as the frequencies of quasinormal \" modes .","we may understand this fact as follows .","even if the wave frequency @xmath116 is higher than the potential barrier , the reflection coefficient does not vanish and oscillates with respect to @xmath116 , which period is determined by the potential form . in the present case , we have also an infinite wall near the center of a star .","we then expect that small periodic peaks appearing in the spectrum are due to an interference between the incoming and outgoing waves reflected by two potential barriers .","since these waves decay very quickly as mentioned above , the process is quite dynamical , and then the peaks in the spectrum do not coincide with the frequencies of quasinormal \" modes . in fig .","[ fig : rm2.26 - 2.3 ] , we show the energy spectra for two stellar models with @xmath117 , and @xmath118 , which correspond to the cases that the turning point is inside and outside the barrier , respectively . for fixed energy @xmath119 and angular momentum @xmath100",", the global peaks corresponding to the orbital frequency at the turning point agree with each other . on the other hand , the other small periodic peaks from the excited quasinormal modes do not agree with and rather depend on the compactness parameter @xmath91 . consequently , from the analysis of the energy spectrum of axial modes , we may determine the compactness parameter @xmath91 of an ultracompact star .","we can also compare a black hole and an ultracompact star . in fig .","[ fig : rm2.26bh ] , we show the energy spectra both for a black hole @xcite and an ultracompact star with @xmath120 . from fig .","[ fig : rm2.26bh ] , we see that even for the case of a schwarzschild black hole , the global peak due to the orbital motion of the particle coincides with that for the star . however , unlike the stellar model ,","no small periodic peaks appear in the case of a black hole .","in fact for a black hole , there is no peak after @xmath115 ( see fig .","this is because the effective potential of the star has an infinite potential wall near the center , which guarantees the existence of quasinormal modes , while that of a schwarzschild black hole has no such wall , and incoming waves fall entirely into the event horizon @xmath121 .","hence , we can also distinguish a background object , i.e. , whether it is an ultracompact star or a black hole , analyzing only axial modes .","as for the total energy of emitted gravitational waves @xmath122 , we find @xmath123 with @xmath124 and @xmath125 for @xmath126 and @xmath127 , respectively , and for @xmath128 and @xmath129 .","the efficiency @xmath130 increases monotonically as the compactness gets smaller , and seems to end up with that for schwarzschild black holes ( @xmath131 ) . for @xmath132 and @xmath133 , the efficiency , which is @xmath134 ,","little depends on @xmath135 up to the case of a black hole . from the analysis of the energy spectrum for a uniform density star , we find that the spectrum strongly depends on the shape of effective potential . therefore ,","it may be important to see the dependence of the equation of state on the energy spectrum . then , in this section , we study a polytropic star . just for simplicity",", we use the newtonian polytropic equation of state as @xmath136 where @xmath137 is a polytropic index and @xmath138 is a constant value . first , we consider the first type stellar model with @xmath139 .","we set the polytropic index @xmath140 and the constant @xmath141 , and choose the central energy density @xmath142 .","this choice gives a stellar model with mass @xmath143 and radius @xmath144 .","the compact parameter is @xmath145 , and then the surface locates outside the peak of the regge - wheeler potential .","we show the energy spectra of gravitational waves from a scattering test particle in fig .","[ fig : polytropic1.0 ] .","we find the same feature as that for the uniform density star with @xmath146 , i.e. , there is only a single global peak which frequency corresponds to the orbital one of the particle at the turning point .","next , we discuss the second type stellar model , i.e. , an ultracompact star . to construct an ultracompact star with a polytropic equation of state",", we set the polytropic index @xmath147 , the constant @xmath148 , and choose the central energy density @xmath149 , for which the compactness parameter @xmath135 turns out to be the smallest .","for such a choice , the radius , mass , and compactness parameters of the star are @xmath150 , @xmath151 , and @xmath152 , respectively .","although this seems very implausible for a realistic star , we will use this solution in our analysis to study the dependence of the equation of state on the energy spectrum . in fig .","[ fig : polytropic0.5 ] , we show the energy spectra for two trajectories of a test particle .","one is the case that a particle goes into the inside of the potential barrier , while the other is the case that a particle passes through only outside the potential barrier .","we find the same feature as that of the uniform density star with @xmath153 .","the difference is found in the frequencies of quasinormal modes because of the different shapes of the potential .","then , we find many small and sharp peaks in the spectrum at the positions different from those for a uniform density star .","consequently , we may be able to distinguish the inside structure of an ultracompact star by observing the energy spectrum of emitted gravitational waves .","we have studied the axial modes of gravitational waves from a test particle scattered by a spherically symmetric relativistic star .","we have considered both a uniform density star and a polytropic star .","we find that the energy spectrum depends mainly on the shape of the effective potential for gravitational waves , i.e. , whether its minimum exists or not .","when there is no minimum ( e.g. , a regular type of neutron star with a compactness parameter @xmath154 ) , the energy spectrum shows only a single global peak , which corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point .","gravitational waves are mostly emitted around the turning point , where the effect of the gravitational field is strongest . while if a minimum of the effective potential exists ( i.e. , some exotic relativistic star with small compactness parameter @xmath155 ) , the energy spectrum shows a variety in its structure in addition to the global peak as the same as that found in the previous case .","we find small and sharp periodic peaks in the region lower than @xmath114 ( the maximum value of the effective potential ) , which correspond to an excitation of the axial quasinormal modes .","the existence of the potential minimum allows the existence of a quasibound state of gravitational waves , i.e. , quasinormal modes .","then those modes are excited by a scattered particle .","this becomes more conspicuous when the particle gets into the inside region beyond the potential barrier .","we also find small periodic peaks in the frequency region beyond @xmath114 , which may come from an interference between two waves reflected by the potential barrier and the infinite wall near the center of the star . from the observation of the energy spectrum of the axial mode ,","what we can determine ? naively speaking , we may not find any information about the constituent of the star , because the axial mode does not couple to matter fluid .","this is true for the first type stellar model , i.e. , a regular neutron star . emitted gravitational waves","are mostly determined by the particle orbit .","the case of black holes also belongs to this case , although there is a small difference in the high frequency part because of the difference of the boundary condition .","however , if a star is compact enough to make a potential minimum ( @xmath156 ) , emitted gravitational waves show much more abundant information .","it may determine a compactness parameter @xmath91 .","we also find quasinormal mode frequencies , which depend on the shape of the potential , and then could depend on the equation of state . in the axial mode case , however , in general , we can not have direct information about the matter fluid , in particular about the equation of state .","the polar mode of gravitational waves will provide us a more conspicuous dependence of matter property .","work on the polar modes is under way .","we would like to thank yasufumi kojima for kind suggestions at the beginning of this study .","the numerical computations were mainly performed by the fujitsu - vx vector computer at the media network center , waseda university .","this work was supported partially by a jsps grant - in - aid ( no . 5689 and specially promoted research no .","08102010 ) , and by the waseda university grant for special research projects .","here , we present numerical techniques solving the wave equations .","we improved borrelli s method@xcite to guarantee numerical accuracy .","for the interior region , the numerical error of the wave function accumulates and becomes maximal at the surface , because the pressure vanishes there . in order to overcome this difficulty , we solve the wave equation both from the center and from the surface , and connect two wave functions at some inner point , e.g. ,","@xmath157 . for the exterior solution",", we integrate the wave equation from the surface to infinity , by which we can reduce the numerical error . in the present model ,","the test particle mainly emits gravitational waves at the turning point , where we have to solve the wave equation very carefully because an apparent divergence appears .","we shall discuss these three methods in order .","here we show how to solve the interior wave equation ( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) . transforming the wave function @xmath33 to @xmath158","we find the perturbation equation for @xmath159 as @xmath160 \\frac{dz_{l\\omega}}{dr } + e^{\\lambda - \\nu } \\left ( \\omega^2 -\\frac{2n}{r^2}e^{\\nu } \\right ) z_{l\\omega } = 0 .","\\label{eq : near_center_z_equation}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] from the regularity condition at the center , we obtain the asymptotic behavior at @xmath161 as @xmath162 r^{l + 4 } + o(r^{l+6 } ) \\right\\ } , \\label{eq : near_center_z}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] where @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 are density , pressure , and metric functions evaluated at the center , respectively .","in order to reduce the numerical error at the surface , we adopt the following procedure . then , we find two independent wave functions @xmath165 by integrating eq .","( [ eq : near_center_z_equation ] ) from the surface to the middle point .","the boundary conditions of those wave functions at the surface are given as @xmath166 , @xmath167 .","by those two independent solutions , we construct the wave function @xmath168 as @xmath169 where the coefficients @xmath170 and @xmath171 are fixed by junction conditions at @xmath157 .","since the wave functions constructed above must be continuous and smooth at @xmath157 , we find the junction conditions @xmath172 from these two conditions , we find @xmath170 and @xmath171 , and then the interior wave function @xmath159 .","next we construct the exterior wave function . in order to use the green s function method",", we first consider the homogeneous wave function @xmath176 , which satisfies the wave equation @xmath177 and the boundary condition at the surface , which we have already evaluated in the previous subsection , that is , @xmath178 then , we construct a particular solution @xmath179 with a source term , which equation is described as @xmath180 where @xmath69 comes from the motion of a test particle . at the surface ,","the solution @xmath179 satisfies the following condition : @xmath181 for the homogeneous equation ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_homogeneout ] ) , we have two independent solutions @xmath182 and @xmath183 , which correspond to outgoing and incoming waves at infinity , respectively .","then , we describe the wave function @xmath176 by these two independent solutions as @xmath184 where @xmath185 and @xmath186 are complex constants , which are fixed by eqs .","( [ boundary1 ] ) , ( [ boundary2 ] ) . the green s function @xmath187 for eq . ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_inhomogeneout ] ) is also constructed by @xmath188 and @xmath189 as @xmath190 \\theta(r^ { * } - s^ { * } ) \\qquad ( r^ { * } > s^{*}),\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] where @xmath191 is the wronskian and @xmath192 is the heaviside function . the wave function @xmath193 is obtained by integration as @xmath194 then , the solution for the exterior wave equation ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation ] ) with the same boundary conditions as eqs .","( [ boundary1 ] ) , ( [ boundary2 ] ) is given as @xmath195 the asymptotic behavior of @xmath196 as @xmath197 is given by @xmath198 where @xmath199 and @xmath200 are defined by @xmath201 since there is no incoming wave , we find the boundary condition such that @xmath202 then , the amplitude @xmath78 of gravitational waves at infinity is given by @xmath203 in order to extract the amplitude @xmath78 from our solution , we use the relation @xmath204 s_{lm\\omega}^{\\rm ( ext ) } ( s^ { * } ) ds^ { * } \\nonumber \\\\ & = & \\frac{1}{w } \\int_{r^{*}}^{\\infty } x_{lm\\omega}^{\\rm ( ext)(0)}(s^ { * } ) s_{lm\\omega}^{\\rm ( ext ) } ( s^ { * } ) ds^{*}. \\label{eq : boundary_condition_infinity2}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] with eqs .","( [ eq : boundary_condition_infinity ] ) and ( [ eq : boundary_condition_infinity2 ] ) , we finally obtain the amplitude as @xmath205 where @xmath186 is already obtained up to an unknown constant @xmath206 , which is canceled out with that of @xmath176 in eq .","( [ eq : amplitude_result ] ) when a test particle is scattered by a star , the orbit includes a turning point ( @xmath207 or @xmath208 by the tortoise coordinate ) , where the radial velocity @xmath209 vanishes .","the source term @xmath69 in eq .","( [ eq : amplitude_result ] ) is given by eq .","( [ source ] ) , where @xmath210 and @xmath211 , defined by eqs .","( [ eq : def_q ] ) and ( [ eq : def_d ] ) , for the present orbit ( @xmath212 ) are described as @xmath213 where @xmath214 which is a normalization constant of a spherical harmonics @xmath215 , and @xmath216 is the associated legendre function .","integration over the proper time @xmath217 gives the term of @xmath218 in eq .","( [ d_lm ] ) , which diverges at the turning point , and then the integration @xmath219 diverges apparently",". however , this is not a physical divergence , but rather comes from the change of integration variables from the proper time @xmath217 to the radius @xmath15 .","this transformation becomes singular at the turning point because @xmath220 . in order to avoid this difficulty ,","we shall use a time coordinate @xmath221 in the integration .","since the trajectory before and after the turning point is symmetric , we choose the initial position of the particle @xmath222 , @xmath223 at the turning point and integrate from there to infinity .","the integral , eq .","( [ integration ] ) , is then written as @xmath224 \\nonumber \\\\ & & \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad + \\hat{r } \\left ( 1 - \\frac{2m}{\\hat{r } } \\right ) \\frac{1}{d \\hat{r}/ d \\hat{t } } \\frac{d x_{lm\\omega}^{\\rm ( ext)(0)}}{d \\hat{t } } s_{lm}^{(1 ) } ( \\hat{t } ) \\biggr ] , \\label{eq : source_term_integral_t } \\\\ & & \\qquad \\hat{s}_{lm}^{(0 ) } = \\frac{8 \\pi}{\\tilde{e } } \\biggl [ \\sqrt{\\frac{2}{l(l + 1 ) } } \\left ( 1- \\frac{2m}{\\hat{r } } \\right)^2 \\hat{q}_{lm } \\nonumber \\\\ & & \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad + \\sqrt{\\frac{2}{l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\frac{2m}{\\hat{r } } \\left ( 1 - \\frac{2m}{\\hat{r } } \\right ) \\hat{d}_{lm } \\biggr ] , \\\\ & & \\qquad \\hat{s}_{lm}^{(1 ) } = -\\frac{8 \\pi}{\\tilde{e } } \\sqrt{\\frac{2}{l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\left ( 1 - \\frac{2m}{\\hat{r } } \\right ) \\hat{d}_{lm } , \\\\ & & \\qquad \\hat{q}_{lm } = - 2 i c_{lm } \\sqrt{\\frac{2}{l(l + 1 ) } } \\frac{\\mu \\tilde{l}}{\\hat{r}^3 ( 1 - 2m/\\hat{r } ) } \\gamma^{1/2 } \\frac{d p_{lm}}{d \\hat{\\theta } } \\left({\\pi\\over 2}\\right ) \\sin ( \\omega \\hat{t } - m \\hat{\\phi } ) , \\\\ & & \\qquad \\hat{d}_{lm } = \\frac{- 4imc_{lm}}{\\sqrt{2l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\frac{\\mu \\tilde{l}^2}{\\hat{r}^4 } \\frac{d p_{lm}}{d \\hat{\\theta}}\\left({\\pi\\over 2}\\right ) \\cos ( \\omega \\hat{t } - m \\hat{\\phi}),\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] where @xmath225 and @xmath226 is its time derivative .","however , the term in eq .","( [ eq : source_term_integral_t ] ) , @xmath227 is still apparently divergent because @xmath228 vanishes at the turning point . to avoid this difficulty , we expand @xmath176 , @xmath229 near the turning point . from the equation of motion , we find @xmath230 which is integrated as @xmath231 where @xmath232 is an integration constant .","then , we find the wave function near the turning point as @xmath233 where @xmath176 , @xmath234 , and @xmath235 at the turning point @xmath208 are found easily by integration of eq .","( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_homogeneout ] ) .","since those functions are regular at the turning point , we can evaluate eq .","( [ eq : source_term_integral_t ] ) without any difficulty .","see , for example , a. abramovici _","et al . _ , science * 256 * , 325 ( 1992 ) , for ligo ; c. bradaschia _ et al . _ ,","methods phys .","a * 289 * , 518 ( 1990 ) , for virgo ; j. hough , in _ proceedings of the sixth marcel grossmann meeting _ , edited by h. sato and t. nakamura ( world scientific , singapore , 1992 ) , p. 192",", for geo600 ; k. kuroda _ et al .","_ , in _ proceedings of international conference on gravitational waves : sources and detectors _ , edited by i. ciufolini and f. fidecaro ( world scientific , singapore , 1997 ) , p. 100",", for tama300 . .","quasinormal \" modes for a uniform density star with @xmath236 .","we use the continued fraction expansion method , which was first used to calculate black hole quasinormal modes by leaver [ 24 ] , and @xmath8 modes of a polytropic star by leins , nollert , and soffel [ 16 ] .","our results agree quite well with those of kokkotas , who adopted a different method [ 20 ] .","our imaginary part has opposite sign to kokkotas s result , because our definition of the fourier transformation is opposite to his . [","cols=\"^,^,^,^ \" , ]"],"string":"[\n \"a laser interferometer to detect gravitational waves , such as the laser interferometric gravitational wave observatory(ligo ) , virgo , geo600 , or tama300 , will be in operation within several years@xcite .\",\n \"it is one of the most urgent subjects for theoretical relativists to make a set of templates of gravitational waves .\",\n \"the direct detection of gravitational waves is very important not only as a new eye \\\" observing the universe ( gravitational wave astronomy ) but also as a new probe for fundamental physics .\",\n \"for example , we know that a neutron star , which is observed as a pulsar , has a mass @xmath1 and a radius @xmath2 @xmath3 .\",\n \"although we can guess its central region with some theoretical ansatz , we have no direct information from the inside of a neutron star because neither radiation nor a neutrino is transparent in the central region .\",\n \"the direct detection of gravitational waves may provide some information about the inside of a neutron star when it is formed , resulting in new observational facts or constraints about the equation of state for high density matter .\",\n \"one of the most promising astronomical sources for these ground - based detectors is a coalesced compact binary such as a neutron star binary . to complete a set of templates from such a source\",\n \", many studies about the emitted gravitational waves have been done using various techniques .\",\n \"a numerical simulation without approximations ( numerical relativity ) is probably one of the best ways to calculate gravitational waves emitted from the compact binary system @xcite .\",\n \"although steady progress in numerical relativity has been achieved , there are still some difficulties which prevent us from finding the final results . instead , there are some powerful approximation methods to mimic the coalescence of a compact binary system .\",\n \"one such approximation is the perturbative approach .\",\n \"regge and wheeler @xcite and zerilli @xcite first formulated a method for metric perturbations in a schwarzschild black hole spacetime .\",\n \"then there are many works using such a black hole perturbation method in which we describe gravitational waves by metric perturbations in a black hole background spacetime and treat a companion of the binary as a test particle@xcite .\",\n \"this approximation for gravitational waves in a head - on collision of two black holes gives a good agreement with the results obtained by numerical simulation@xcite .\",\n \"thus , such a perturbative approach may provide a good approximation for gravitational waves from a compact binary as well . however , there are so far few works for neutron star perturbations\",\n \". one may think that if we have two @xmath4 neutron stars , it will be a black hole after coalescence , when the ringing tail of the gravitational waves can be described by quasinormal modes of the black hole .\",\n \"the quasinormal modes of a neutron star may have nothing to do with the final stage of the coalescence .\",\n \"however , before black hole formation , we have to analyze the orbital evolution of the neutron star binary .\",\n \"therefore , we believe that a perturbation analysis for a neutron star is also important . for a nonradial pulsation of a spherically symmetric relativistic star , perturbation equations both for axial and polar modes were first derived by thorne and campolattaro @xcite .\",\n \"similar to the black hole perturbation , the axial mode for a spherical star is described by a second order differential equation .\",\n \"on the other hand , the polar mode was first described by a fifth order differential equation@xcite . however , because of the dynamical degrees of freedom of polar modes , i.e. , sound waves and gravitational waves , the basic equation can be reduced to a fourth order differential equation as shown by lindblom and detweiler @xcite .\",\n \"lindblom , mendell , and ipser @xcite also derived a couple of second order differential equations , which could be interpreted as those for sound waves and gravitational waves , respectively .\",\n \"as in the case of black hole perturbations , quasinormal modes , if they exist , will be important in the analysis of gravitational waves from a compact binary . for the polar mode\",\n \", there are two types of quasinormal modes of a neutron star ; one is a fluid oscillation mode similar to the @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath7 modes of a newtonian star ( cf .\",\n \"@xcite ) ; the other is a wave mode ( @xmath8 mode ) , which exists only in general relativity @xcite . even for the axial mode ,\",\n \"chandrasekhar and ferrari@xcite illustrated that quasinormal modes exist if the effective potential has a minimal as that in an ultracompact star .\",\n \"kokkotas @xcite numerically calculated such axial quasinormal modes for various ultracompact stars .\",\n \"kojima @xcite extended it to a slowly rotating star , setting regge - wheeler gauge conditions .\",\n \"as for emitted gravitational waves from a binary system , kojima @xcite studied them for the case that a test particle is moving in a circular orbit around a polytropic star . for a circular orbit ,\",\n \"the axial mode cancels from the orbital symmetry so that the polar mode was only taken into account .\",\n \"he showed that the resonance mode appears in the energy flux when the orbit reaches the radius where the orbital frequency coincides with that of the quasinormal mode .\",\n \"for the axial mode , recently , borrelli @xcite calculated energy spectra of gravitational waves emitted by a test particle spiraling into an ultracompact star . in his result ,\",\n \"its energy spectrum shows many peaks , which correspond to axial quasinormal modes of the star .\",\n \"although it is important , since we are interested in a compact binary , a direct collision might show some different features from the binary case .\",\n \"we also do not know what will happen when a test particle reaches the surface of the star .\",\n \"to avoid such an unknown factor and to analyze the case of a compact binary , we first study gravitational waves emitted when a test particle is scattered by a neutron star in this paper . for a schwarzschild black hole , oohara and\",\n \"nakamura @xcite analyzed it and showed that the energy spectrum has no peak except for one which corresponds to the orbital frequency .\",\n \"here we consider a spherical star instead of a schwarzschild black hole .\",\n \"we study only the axial mode which does not exist in newton gravity . to discuss the dependence of the equations of state , we analyze two models : a uniform density star as in @xcite and a polytropic star .\",\n \"this paper is organized as follows . in secs .\",\n \"[ sec : linear]a and [ sec : linear]b , we briefly review the perturbation theory for a spherically symmetric relativistic star .\",\n \"we show our numerical results in sec .\",\n \"[ sec : gw ] .\",\n \"section [ sec : discussion ] is devoted to a discussion .\",\n \"some numerical techniques for calculating gravitational waves are summarized in the appendix . throughout this paper\",\n \", we use units of @xmath9 and a metric signature of @xmath10 .\",\n \"we start with summarizing briefly the metric perturbation of a spherically symmetric relativistic star . a spherically symmetric background metric @xmath11 is described as @xmath12 @xmath13 where @xmath14 is a mass function inside a radius @xmath15 .\",\n \"we assume a perfect fluid as the stellar matter , i.e. @xmath16 where @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the total energy density and the pressure , respectively , which satisfy a barotropic equation of state , @xmath19 .\",\n \"using tolman - oppenheimer - volkov equations , we construct a stellar model and its spacetime metric numerically except for the constant density star case .\",\n \"the radius @xmath20 of a star is defined by a surface where the pressure vanishes , and the mass of the star @xmath21 is given by @xmath22 . for linearized einstein equations\",\n \", we can decompose the perturbed metric into an axial mode @xmath23 and a polar mode @xmath24 : @xmath25 using regge - wheeler gauge conditions , we will integrate the interior and exterior regions of the linearized einstein equations , separately , and impose appropriate junction conditions at the surface @xmath20 to find the solution . in this paper\",\n \", we only deal with axial mode perturbation .\",\n \"then , we write down the linearized einstein equation only for axial modes in the following subsections . in order to find the linearized einstein equations for axial modes , we expand the perturbed metric by tensor harmonics for polar angle @xmath26 and azimuthal angle @xmath27 @xcite , and proceed to a fourier transformation for the time coordinate @xmath28 .\",\n \"although there are ten independent components for the linearized metric , four of them are gauge freedoms of coordinate transformations , which are fixed by a choice of regge - wheeler gauge @xcite , resulting in two components belonging to axial modes , while the rest of the four correspond to polar modes . for axial mode perturbations , we can set @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are functions of the radial coordinate @xmath15 defined below , and @xmath32 is a spherical harmonics .\",\n \"the axial mode in the interior region of a star is described by a single wave equation for gravitational waves , because a rotation does not exist in a spherically symmetric background spacetime .\",\n \"that is , we have a single wave function @xmath33 , which determines the behaviors of axial modes as @xmath34 the equation for the wave function @xmath33 is derived from the linearized einstein equation for axial modes as @xmath35 where the `` tortoise '' coordinate @xmath36 and the effective potential @xmath37 are defined as @xmath38 respectively .\",\n \"as for the boundary condition , the wave function @xmath33 must be regular at the center of a star .\",\n \"expanding @xmath33 around the center @xmath39 , we find @xmath40 r^{l + 3 } + o(r^{l+5 } ) \\\\right\\\\ } , \\\\label{eq : bc_x}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath41 is an arbitrary constant , and @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 are the central density , pressure , and metric functions , respectively .\",\n \"apart from a free parameter @xmath41 , we obtain a solution @xmath33 by integrating eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) with the boundary condition ( @xmath45 ) .\",\n \"further details of the numerical techniques constructing the wave function @xmath33 are given in the appendix , subsection [ subsec : app_interior ] .\",\n \"the background metric outside the star is the schwarzschild spacetime , i.e. , eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : bgmetric ] ) , with @xmath46 as for the trajectory of a test particle , without loss of generality , we can assume that the particle moves on the equatorial plane ( @xmath47 ) .\",\n \"then , the equation of motion for the particle is described as @xmath48 where the particle trajectory is @xmath49 , and @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 are the mass , the normalized energy , and the normalized orbital angular momentum of the particle , respectively , with @xmath53 and @xmath54 .\",\n \"the normalized effective potential energy @xmath55 of the particle is given as @xmath56 in this paper , since we only consider the motion of a test particle scattered by a spherical star , the particle orbit is unbounded , i.e. , @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the maximum value of the potential .\",\n \"the perturbed metric outside a star only comes from an oscillation of spacetime , that is , gravitational waves .\",\n \"then , similar to the interior region , the linearized einstein equations for the metric @xmath59 and @xmath60 defined as eq .\",\n \"( [ metric ] ) are reduced to a single wave equation for a new wave function @xmath61 defined by @xmath62 where @xmath63 and @xmath64 is one of the source terms given below . from the linearized vacuum einstein equations\",\n \", we find the wave equation for @xmath61 ( regge - wheeler equation)@xcite as @xmath65 where @xmath36 is the tortoise coordinate defined by @xmath66 @xmath67 is regge - wheeler potential given by @xmath68 and @xmath69 is the source term , which is described by the energy - momentum tensor of a test particle expanded by tensor harmonics@xcite as @xmath70 \\\\right ] , \\\\label{source}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] with @xmath71 and @xmath72 being @xmath73 , \\\\label{eq : def_q } \\\\\\\\\",\n \"d_{lm}(t , r ) & = & - \\\\frac{1}{\\\\sqrt{2n(n+1 ) } } \\\\mu \\\\int_{-\\\\infty}^{\\\\infty } d \\\\tau \\\\delta { \\\\bf ( } t - \\\\hat{t}(\\\\tau ) { \\\\bf ) } \\\\delta { \\\\bf ( } r - \\\\hat{r}(\\\\tau ) { \\\\bf ) } \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\quad \\\\times \\\\biggl\\\\ { \\\\frac{1}{2 } \\\\left [ \\\\left ( \\\\frac{d \\\\hat{\\\\theta}}{d \\\\tau } \\\\right)^2 - \\\\sin^2 \\\\hat{\\\\theta } \\\\left ( \\\\frac{d \\\\hat{\\\\phi}}{d \\\\tau}\\\\right)^2 \\\\right ] \\\\frac{1}{\\\\sin \\\\hat{\\\\theta } } \\\\bar{x}_{lm } ( \\\\hat{\\\\omega } ) \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad - \\\\sin \\\\hat{\\\\theta } \\\\frac{d \\\\hat{\\\\theta}}{d \\\\tau } \\\\frac{d \\\\hat{\\\\phi}}{d \\\\tau } \\\\bar{w}_{lm}(\\\\hat{\\\\omega } ) \\\\biggr\\\\}. \\\\label{eq : def_d}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] @xmath74 , @xmath75 are the tensorial part of a tensor harmonics defined by @xmath76 and the overbar denotes the complex conjugate . the boundary condition outside the star should be imposed such that there is no incoming wave at infinity , @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the amplitude of an outgoing wave at infinity .\",\n \"the details of constructing the wave function @xmath61 are given in the appendix , subsections [ subsec : app_exterior ] and [ subsec : app_turning_point ] .\",\n \"we have to combine two wave functions , the interior wave function @xmath33 and the exterior one @xmath61 , at the surface of the star .\",\n \"the matching condition is that the wave function must be continuous and smooth at the surface . for the case of the axial mode ,\",\n \"since the wave function inside the star does not couple to perturbations of the matter fluid , the condition turns out to be very simple as @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the radius of the star by use of the tortoise \\\" coordinate .\",\n \"then we calculate the amplitude of the gravitational waves @xmath78 as follows : we first integrate eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) and ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation ] ) using their boundary conditions , eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : bc_x ] ) and ( [ eq : bc_infty ] ) .\",\n \"next , we connect those solutions at the surface of the star using eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : s_condition1 ] ) and ( [ eq : s_condition2 ] ) , which determine two unknown coefficients @xmath41 and @xmath78 . from the wave function\",\n \"obtained as above , we obtain some information about gravitational waves emitted by a scattered particle .\",\n \"when we discuss the gravitational waves , we usually decompose them into two modes : @xmath81 and @xmath82 modes .\",\n \"then , we have to transform our coordinate system from the regge - wheeler gauge to the transverse - traceless one , which metric near infinity is described as @xmath83 then the axial mode in transverse - traceless gauge at infinity turns out to be @xmath84 where the spin - weighted spherical harmonics @xmath85 is defined by @xmath86 the energy - momentum tensor of the gravitational waves at infinity is given by @xmath87 in the transverse - traceless gauge , where the angular brackets denote an appropriate average . from this definition ,\",\n \"we find the energy spectrum @xmath88 of gravitational waves at infinity for the axial mode as @xmath89\",\n \"in this subsection , we consider a uniform density star . we restrict our analysis only to the case of the @xmath90 mode , just for simplicity .\",\n \"we find that features of the energy spectrum of emitted gravitational waves can be classified into two cases , which mainly depend on the shape of the effective potential .\",\n \"figure [ fig : potential ] shows the effective potential [ eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) and ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) ] for a uniform density star with three different compactness parameters @xmath91 .\",\n \"the effective potential has the following three features .\",\n \"first , the regge - wheeler potential [ eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) ] has a maximum point near @xmath92 ( accurately at @xmath93 for @xmath94 ) .\",\n \"second , the potential is discontinuous at the surface because of a discontinuity of the energy density of the star at the surface .\",\n \"finally , a potential minimum appears inside the star , if the star is ultracompact ( for the case of @xmath0 ) . according to the last feature\",\n \", we study two cases separately .\",\n \"the first stellar type is the case that the surface is outside the potential barrier ( @xmath95 ) . for a usual neutron star , @xmath96 , and\",\n \"then the first type is most likely a realistic astronomical object .\",\n \"the second stellar type is the case that the surface is inside the potential barrier ( @xmath97 ) , which may be an exotic star , if it exists .\",\n \"first we show our result for the first type . for the case of @xmath98\",\n \", we show the energy spectra of emitted gravitational waves in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm5 ] . in this figure\",\n \", there exists only a single peak in each spectrum .\",\n \"this peak corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point , i.e. , periastron .\",\n \"this means that most gravitational waves are emitted around the turning point , where the effect of the gravitational field is the strongest .\",\n \"no other feature is found in this spectrum .\",\n \"in fact , fixing the energy @xmath99 and orbital angular momentum @xmath100 , the spectrum depends less on the compactness parameter @xmath91 ( see fig . [\",\n \"fig : rm5bh ] ) . for a black hole background\",\n \", we find quite similar behaviors in the energy spectrum ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm5bh ] ) , except for the high frequency region , where the difference of the boundary conditions is crucial .\",\n \"we also find that the spectrum approaches closer to that of a black hole as the star gets smaller .\",\n \"we also calculate the waveform for the case of @xmath101 and black holes , respectively .\",\n \"we see that a burst wave due to the encounter of a test particle emerges for each case . as the same as the energy spectrum , the difference between these waveform is very little ( see fig .\",\n \"[ fig : wf5 ] ) therefore , for the first stellar type of @xmath102 , the energy spectrum largely depends on the trajectory , but not on the background object .\",\n \"next we discuss an ultracompact star , which shows much more various structure in the spectrum . in this case\",\n \", a minimum point of the effective potential appears inside the star . as for the trajectory of a test particle , we have two possibilities : one is that the particle gets into the inside region beyond the potential barrier and the other is that one passes through outside the barrier . since the particle approaches closer to the star , it feels a stronger gravitational field . as a result ,\",\n \"the excitation by the particle is more efficient and the emitted gravitational waves are enhanced . as a numerical example , we show those energy spectra for the model with radius @xmath103 with the turning points @xmath104 and @xmath105 in fig . [\",\n \"fig : rm2.26 ] . apart from a global maximum , which appears in the first type model as well and corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point\",\n \", we also find many small periodic peaks in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26 ] .\",\n \"this microscopic peak structure is classified into two types , which are divided at the frequency of the maximum @xmath106 ( @xmath107 for @xmath94 ) of the effective potential . in the lower frequency region ( @xmath108 )\",\n \", small and sharp peaks correspond to the quasinormal modes , as we will show it next . for the higher frequency region ( @xmath109 ) , we find small periodic peaks , which may appear because of a resonance between two potential barriers .\",\n \"we will also discuss this later . in order to analyze our numerical results\",\n \", we first have to know the axial quasinormal modes . our method to calculate a quasinormal mode\",\n \"is based on the continued fraction expansion method which was originally used for black holes by leaver @xcite , and adopted for the polar mode of a spherical star by leins , nollert , and soffel @xcite .\",\n \"we apply this method to axial modes as well .\",\n \"we show our results in table [ tab : qnm_urm2.26 ] with those of kokkotas@xcite whose method is different from ours .\",\n \"the table shows that both results agree quite well . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] , we present both the quasinormal mode and energy spectrum . as seen from fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] , axial \",\n \"quasinormal \\\" modes are classified into two : the lower frequency mode ( @xmath110 ) , which imaginary part is very small @xmath111 , and the higher frequency mode ( @xmath112 ) , which imaginary part is rather large @xmath113 .\",\n \"the reason is very simple . for a frequency lower than @xmath114\",\n \", we can have a quasibound state .\",\n \"since trapped waves tunnel through the potential barrier , the energy will decrease .\",\n \"it is similar to the quasinormal mode of a black hole .\",\n \"then , we may call it the axial quasinormal mode as well . however , if the frequency is higher than @xmath114 , we have no bound state .\",\n \"nevertheless , we can find the \",\n \"quasinormal \\\" mode , by which we mean a wave solution with the same boundary condition as that of the conventional quasinormal mode , which is the outgoing wave condition . in the present case , although we find such wave solutions , those waves decay very quickly because the frequency is higher than the potential barrier .\",\n \"this is the reason why we find a large imaginary part of the mode frequency .\",\n \"the solutions which satisfy the boundary condition appear periodically as seen from fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] .\",\n \"we find that the frequencies of these quasinormal modes coincide with those of spectrum peaks in the frequency region lower than @xmath114 .\",\n \"this is because a test particle excites those quasinormal modes .\",\n \"in fact , when we see the waveform ( fig . [\",\n \"fig : wf2.26 ] ) , the wave consists of two parts : large one , which corresponds to the burst wave by the encounter by a test particle , and the other part with several oscillations , which comes from exited quasinormal modes in the spectrum .\",\n \"actually the waveform in the region after @xmath115 in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : wf2.26 ] is similar to kokkotas s result for a gaussian pulse wave @xcite . on the other hand , in a frequency region\",\n \"higher than @xmath114 , although many periodic peaks appear , those positions are not exactly the same as the frequencies of quasinormal \\\" modes .\",\n \"we may understand this fact as follows .\",\n \"even if the wave frequency @xmath116 is higher than the potential barrier , the reflection coefficient does not vanish and oscillates with respect to @xmath116 , which period is determined by the potential form . in the present case , we have also an infinite wall near the center of a star .\",\n \"we then expect that small periodic peaks appearing in the spectrum are due to an interference between the incoming and outgoing waves reflected by two potential barriers .\",\n \"since these waves decay very quickly as mentioned above , the process is quite dynamical , and then the peaks in the spectrum do not coincide with the frequencies of quasinormal \\\" modes . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26 - 2.3 ] , we show the energy spectra for two stellar models with @xmath117 , and @xmath118 , which correspond to the cases that the turning point is inside and outside the barrier , respectively . for fixed energy @xmath119 and angular momentum @xmath100\",\n \", the global peaks corresponding to the orbital frequency at the turning point agree with each other . on the other hand , the other small periodic peaks from the excited quasinormal modes do not agree with and rather depend on the compactness parameter @xmath91 . consequently , from the analysis of the energy spectrum of axial modes , we may determine the compactness parameter @xmath91 of an ultracompact star .\",\n \"we can also compare a black hole and an ultracompact star . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26bh ] , we show the energy spectra both for a black hole @xcite and an ultracompact star with @xmath120 . from fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26bh ] , we see that even for the case of a schwarzschild black hole , the global peak due to the orbital motion of the particle coincides with that for the star . however , unlike the stellar model ,\",\n \"no small periodic peaks appear in the case of a black hole .\",\n \"in fact for a black hole , there is no peak after @xmath115 ( see fig .\",\n \"this is because the effective potential of the star has an infinite potential wall near the center , which guarantees the existence of quasinormal modes , while that of a schwarzschild black hole has no such wall , and incoming waves fall entirely into the event horizon @xmath121 .\",\n \"hence , we can also distinguish a background object , i.e. , whether it is an ultracompact star or a black hole , analyzing only axial modes .\",\n \"as for the total energy of emitted gravitational waves @xmath122 , we find @xmath123 with @xmath124 and @xmath125 for @xmath126 and @xmath127 , respectively , and for @xmath128 and @xmath129 .\",\n \"the efficiency @xmath130 increases monotonically as the compactness gets smaller , and seems to end up with that for schwarzschild black holes ( @xmath131 ) . for @xmath132 and @xmath133 , the efficiency , which is @xmath134 ,\",\n \"little depends on @xmath135 up to the case of a black hole . from the analysis of the energy spectrum for a uniform density star , we find that the spectrum strongly depends on the shape of effective potential . therefore ,\",\n \"it may be important to see the dependence of the equation of state on the energy spectrum . then , in this section , we study a polytropic star . just for simplicity\",\n \", we use the newtonian polytropic equation of state as @xmath136 where @xmath137 is a polytropic index and @xmath138 is a constant value . first , we consider the first type stellar model with @xmath139 .\",\n \"we set the polytropic index @xmath140 and the constant @xmath141 , and choose the central energy density @xmath142 .\",\n \"this choice gives a stellar model with mass @xmath143 and radius @xmath144 .\",\n \"the compact parameter is @xmath145 , and then the surface locates outside the peak of the regge - wheeler potential .\",\n \"we show the energy spectra of gravitational waves from a scattering test particle in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : polytropic1.0 ] .\",\n \"we find the same feature as that for the uniform density star with @xmath146 , i.e. , there is only a single global peak which frequency corresponds to the orbital one of the particle at the turning point .\",\n \"next , we discuss the second type stellar model , i.e. , an ultracompact star . to construct an ultracompact star with a polytropic equation of state\",\n \", we set the polytropic index @xmath147 , the constant @xmath148 , and choose the central energy density @xmath149 , for which the compactness parameter @xmath135 turns out to be the smallest .\",\n \"for such a choice , the radius , mass , and compactness parameters of the star are @xmath150 , @xmath151 , and @xmath152 , respectively .\",\n \"although this seems very implausible for a realistic star , we will use this solution in our analysis to study the dependence of the equation of state on the energy spectrum . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : polytropic0.5 ] , we show the energy spectra for two trajectories of a test particle .\",\n \"one is the case that a particle goes into the inside of the potential barrier , while the other is the case that a particle passes through only outside the potential barrier .\",\n \"we find the same feature as that of the uniform density star with @xmath153 .\",\n \"the difference is found in the frequencies of quasinormal modes because of the different shapes of the potential .\",\n \"then , we find many small and sharp peaks in the spectrum at the positions different from those for a uniform density star .\",\n \"consequently , we may be able to distinguish the inside structure of an ultracompact star by observing the energy spectrum of emitted gravitational waves .\",\n \"we have studied the axial modes of gravitational waves from a test particle scattered by a spherically symmetric relativistic star .\",\n \"we have considered both a uniform density star and a polytropic star .\",\n \"we find that the energy spectrum depends mainly on the shape of the effective potential for gravitational waves , i.e. , whether its minimum exists or not .\",\n \"when there is no minimum ( e.g. , a regular type of neutron star with a compactness parameter @xmath154 ) , the energy spectrum shows only a single global peak , which corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point .\",\n \"gravitational waves are mostly emitted around the turning point , where the effect of the gravitational field is strongest . while if a minimum of the effective potential exists ( i.e. , some exotic relativistic star with small compactness parameter @xmath155 ) , the energy spectrum shows a variety in its structure in addition to the global peak as the same as that found in the previous case .\",\n \"we find small and sharp periodic peaks in the region lower than @xmath114 ( the maximum value of the effective potential ) , which correspond to an excitation of the axial quasinormal modes .\",\n \"the existence of the potential minimum allows the existence of a quasibound state of gravitational waves , i.e. , quasinormal modes .\",\n \"then those modes are excited by a scattered particle .\",\n \"this becomes more conspicuous when the particle gets into the inside region beyond the potential barrier .\",\n \"we also find small periodic peaks in the frequency region beyond @xmath114 , which may come from an interference between two waves reflected by the potential barrier and the infinite wall near the center of the star . from the observation of the energy spectrum of the axial mode ,\",\n \"what we can determine ? naively speaking , we may not find any information about the constituent of the star , because the axial mode does not couple to matter fluid .\",\n \"this is true for the first type stellar model , i.e. , a regular neutron star . emitted gravitational waves\",\n \"are mostly determined by the particle orbit .\",\n \"the case of black holes also belongs to this case , although there is a small difference in the high frequency part because of the difference of the boundary condition .\",\n \"however , if a star is compact enough to make a potential minimum ( @xmath156 ) , emitted gravitational waves show much more abundant information .\",\n \"it may determine a compactness parameter @xmath91 .\",\n \"we also find quasinormal mode frequencies , which depend on the shape of the potential , and then could depend on the equation of state . in the axial mode case , however , in general , we can not have direct information about the matter fluid , in particular about the equation of state .\",\n \"the polar mode of gravitational waves will provide us a more conspicuous dependence of matter property .\",\n \"work on the polar modes is under way .\",\n \"we would like to thank yasufumi kojima for kind suggestions at the beginning of this study .\",\n \"the numerical computations were mainly performed by the fujitsu - vx vector computer at the media network center , waseda university .\",\n \"this work was supported partially by a jsps grant - in - aid ( no . 5689 and specially promoted research no .\",\n \"08102010 ) , and by the waseda university grant for special research projects .\",\n \"here , we present numerical techniques solving the wave equations .\",\n \"we improved borrelli s method@xcite to guarantee numerical accuracy .\",\n \"for the interior region , the numerical error of the wave function accumulates and becomes maximal at the surface , because the pressure vanishes there . in order to overcome this difficulty , we solve the wave equation both from the center and from the surface , and connect two wave functions at some inner point , e.g. ,\",\n \"@xmath157 . for the exterior solution\",\n \", we integrate the wave equation from the surface to infinity , by which we can reduce the numerical error . in the present model ,\",\n \"the test particle mainly emits gravitational waves at the turning point , where we have to solve the wave equation very carefully because an apparent divergence appears .\",\n \"we shall discuss these three methods in order .\",\n \"here we show how to solve the interior wave equation ( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) . transforming the wave function @xmath33 to @xmath158\",\n \"we find the perturbation equation for @xmath159 as @xmath160 \\\\frac{dz_{l\\\\omega}}{dr } + e^{\\\\lambda - \\\\nu } \\\\left ( \\\\omega^2 -\\\\frac{2n}{r^2}e^{\\\\nu } \\\\right ) z_{l\\\\omega } = 0 .\",\n \"\\\\label{eq : near_center_z_equation}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] from the regularity condition at the center , we obtain the asymptotic behavior at @xmath161 as @xmath162 r^{l + 4 } + o(r^{l+6 } ) \\\\right\\\\ } , \\\\label{eq : near_center_z}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 are density , pressure , and metric functions evaluated at the center , respectively .\",\n \"in order to reduce the numerical error at the surface , we adopt the following procedure . then , we find two independent wave functions @xmath165 by integrating eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : near_center_z_equation ] ) from the surface to the middle point .\",\n \"the boundary conditions of those wave functions at the surface are given as @xmath166 , @xmath167 .\",\n \"by those two independent solutions , we construct the wave function @xmath168 as @xmath169 where the coefficients @xmath170 and @xmath171 are fixed by junction conditions at @xmath157 .\",\n \"since the wave functions constructed above must be continuous and smooth at @xmath157 , we find the junction conditions @xmath172 from these two conditions , we find @xmath170 and @xmath171 , and then the interior wave function @xmath159 .\",\n \"next we construct the exterior wave function . in order to use the green s function method\",\n \", we first consider the homogeneous wave function @xmath176 , which satisfies the wave equation @xmath177 and the boundary condition at the surface , which we have already evaluated in the previous subsection , that is , @xmath178 then , we construct a particular solution @xmath179 with a source term , which equation is described as @xmath180 where @xmath69 comes from the motion of a test particle . at the surface ,\",\n \"the solution @xmath179 satisfies the following condition : @xmath181 for the homogeneous equation ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_homogeneout ] ) , we have two independent solutions @xmath182 and @xmath183 , which correspond to outgoing and incoming waves at infinity , respectively .\",\n \"then , we describe the wave function @xmath176 by these two independent solutions as @xmath184 where @xmath185 and @xmath186 are complex constants , which are fixed by eqs .\",\n \"( [ boundary1 ] ) , ( [ boundary2 ] ) . the green s function @xmath187 for eq . ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_inhomogeneout ] ) is also constructed by @xmath188 and @xmath189 as @xmath190 \\\\theta(r^ { * } - s^ { * } ) \\\\qquad ( r^ { * } > s^{*}),\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath191 is the wronskian and @xmath192 is the heaviside function . the wave function @xmath193 is obtained by integration as @xmath194 then , the solution for the exterior wave equation ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation ] ) with the same boundary conditions as eqs .\",\n \"( [ boundary1 ] ) , ( [ boundary2 ] ) is given as @xmath195 the asymptotic behavior of @xmath196 as @xmath197 is given by @xmath198 where @xmath199 and @xmath200 are defined by @xmath201 since there is no incoming wave , we find the boundary condition such that @xmath202 then , the amplitude @xmath78 of gravitational waves at infinity is given by @xmath203 in order to extract the amplitude @xmath78 from our solution , we use the relation @xmath204 s_{lm\\\\omega}^{\\\\rm ( ext ) } ( s^ { * } ) ds^ { * } \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & = & \\\\frac{1}{w } \\\\int_{r^{*}}^{\\\\infty } x_{lm\\\\omega}^{\\\\rm ( ext)(0)}(s^ { * } ) s_{lm\\\\omega}^{\\\\rm ( ext ) } ( s^ { * } ) ds^{*}. \\\\label{eq : boundary_condition_infinity2}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] with eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : boundary_condition_infinity ] ) and ( [ eq : boundary_condition_infinity2 ] ) , we finally obtain the amplitude as @xmath205 where @xmath186 is already obtained up to an unknown constant @xmath206 , which is canceled out with that of @xmath176 in eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : amplitude_result ] ) when a test particle is scattered by a star , the orbit includes a turning point ( @xmath207 or @xmath208 by the tortoise coordinate ) , where the radial velocity @xmath209 vanishes .\",\n \"the source term @xmath69 in eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : amplitude_result ] ) is given by eq .\",\n \"( [ source ] ) , where @xmath210 and @xmath211 , defined by eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : def_q ] ) and ( [ eq : def_d ] ) , for the present orbit ( @xmath212 ) are described as @xmath213 where @xmath214 which is a normalization constant of a spherical harmonics @xmath215 , and @xmath216 is the associated legendre function .\",\n \"integration over the proper time @xmath217 gives the term of @xmath218 in eq .\",\n \"( [ d_lm ] ) , which diverges at the turning point , and then the integration @xmath219 diverges apparently\",\n \". however , this is not a physical divergence , but rather comes from the change of integration variables from the proper time @xmath217 to the radius @xmath15 .\",\n \"this transformation becomes singular at the turning point because @xmath220 . in order to avoid this difficulty ,\",\n \"we shall use a time coordinate @xmath221 in the integration .\",\n \"since the trajectory before and after the turning point is symmetric , we choose the initial position of the particle @xmath222 , @xmath223 at the turning point and integrate from there to infinity .\",\n \"the integral , eq .\",\n \"( [ integration ] ) , is then written as @xmath224 \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad + \\\\hat{r } \\\\left ( 1 - \\\\frac{2m}{\\\\hat{r } } \\\\right ) \\\\frac{1}{d \\\\hat{r}/ d \\\\hat{t } } \\\\frac{d x_{lm\\\\omega}^{\\\\rm ( ext)(0)}}{d \\\\hat{t } } s_{lm}^{(1 ) } ( \\\\hat{t } ) \\\\biggr ] , \\\\label{eq : source_term_integral_t } \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\hat{s}_{lm}^{(0 ) } = \\\\frac{8 \\\\pi}{\\\\tilde{e } } \\\\biggl [ \\\\sqrt{\\\\frac{2}{l(l + 1 ) } } \\\\left ( 1- \\\\frac{2m}{\\\\hat{r } } \\\\right)^2 \\\\hat{q}_{lm } \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad + \\\\sqrt{\\\\frac{2}{l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\\\frac{2m}{\\\\hat{r } } \\\\left ( 1 - \\\\frac{2m}{\\\\hat{r } } \\\\right ) \\\\hat{d}_{lm } \\\\biggr ] , \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\hat{s}_{lm}^{(1 ) } = -\\\\frac{8 \\\\pi}{\\\\tilde{e } } \\\\sqrt{\\\\frac{2}{l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\\\left ( 1 - \\\\frac{2m}{\\\\hat{r } } \\\\right ) \\\\hat{d}_{lm } , \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\hat{q}_{lm } = - 2 i c_{lm } \\\\sqrt{\\\\frac{2}{l(l + 1 ) } } \\\\frac{\\\\mu \\\\tilde{l}}{\\\\hat{r}^3 ( 1 - 2m/\\\\hat{r } ) } \\\\gamma^{1/2 } \\\\frac{d p_{lm}}{d \\\\hat{\\\\theta } } \\\\left({\\\\pi\\\\over 2}\\\\right ) \\\\sin ( \\\\omega \\\\hat{t } - m \\\\hat{\\\\phi } ) , \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\hat{d}_{lm } = \\\\frac{- 4imc_{lm}}{\\\\sqrt{2l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\\\frac{\\\\mu \\\\tilde{l}^2}{\\\\hat{r}^4 } \\\\frac{d p_{lm}}{d \\\\hat{\\\\theta}}\\\\left({\\\\pi\\\\over 2}\\\\right ) \\\\cos ( \\\\omega \\\\hat{t } - m \\\\hat{\\\\phi}),\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath225 and @xmath226 is its time derivative .\",\n \"however , the term in eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : source_term_integral_t ] ) , @xmath227 is still apparently divergent because @xmath228 vanishes at the turning point . to avoid this difficulty , we expand @xmath176 , @xmath229 near the turning point . from the equation of motion , we find @xmath230 which is integrated as @xmath231 where @xmath232 is an integration constant .\",\n \"then , we find the wave function near the turning point as @xmath233 where @xmath176 , @xmath234 , and @xmath235 at the turning point @xmath208 are found easily by integration of eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_homogeneout ] ) .\",\n \"since those functions are regular at the turning point , we can evaluate eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : source_term_integral_t ] ) without any difficulty .\",\n \"see , for example , a. abramovici _\",\n \"et al . _ , science * 256 * , 325 ( 1992 ) , for ligo ; c. bradaschia _ et al . _ ,\",\n \"methods phys .\",\n \"a * 289 * , 518 ( 1990 ) , for virgo ; j. hough , in _ proceedings of the sixth marcel grossmann meeting _ , edited by h. sato and t. nakamura ( world scientific , singapore , 1992 ) , p. 192\",\n \", for geo600 ; k. kuroda _ et al .\",\n \"_ , in _ proceedings of international conference on gravitational waves : sources and detectors _ , edited by i. ciufolini and f. fidecaro ( world scientific , singapore , 1997 ) , p. 100\",\n \", for tama300 . .\",\n \"quasinormal \\\" modes for a uniform density star with @xmath236 .\",\n \"we use the continued fraction expansion method , which was first used to calculate black hole quasinormal modes by leaver [ 24 ] , and @xmath8 modes of a polytropic star by leins , nollert , and soffel [ 16 ] .\",\n \"our results agree quite well with those of kokkotas , who adopted a different method [ 20 ] .\",\n \"our imaginary part has opposite sign to kokkotas s result , because our definition of the fourier transformation is opposite to his . [\",\n \"cols=\\\"^,^,^,^ \\\" , ]\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> using a metric perturbation method , we study gravitational waves from a test particle scattered by a spherically symmetric relativistic star . </S>","<S> we calculate the energy spectrum and the waveform of gravitational waves for axial modes . </S>","<S> since metric perturbations in axial modes do not couple to the matter fluid of the star , emitted waves for a normal neutron star show only one peak in the spectrum , which corresponds to the orbital frequency at the turning point , where the gravitational field is strongest . </S>","<S> however , for an ultracompact star ( the radius @xmath0 ) , another type of resonant periodic peak appears in the spectrum . </S>","<S> this is just because of an excitation by a scattered particle of axial quasinormal modes , which were found by chandrasekhar and ferrari . </S>","<S> this excitation comes from the existence of the potential minimum inside of a star . </S>","<S> we also find for an ultracompact star many small periodic peaks at the frequency region beyond the maximum of the potential , which would be due to a resonance of two waves reflected by two potential barriers ( regge - wheeler type and one at the center of the star ) . such resonant peaks appear neither for a normal neutron star nor for a schwarzschild black hole . </S>","<S> consequently , even if we analyze the energy spectrum of gravitational waves only for axial modes , it would be possible to distinguish between an ultracompact star and a normal neutron star ( or a schwarzschild black hole ) . </S>","<S> + pacs number(s ) : 04.25.nx , 04.30.-w , 04.40.dg </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> using a metric perturbation method , we study gravitational waves from a test particle scattered by a spherically symmetric relativistic star . </S>\",\n \"<S> we calculate the energy spectrum and the waveform of gravitational waves for axial modes . </S>\",\n \"<S> since metric perturbations in axial modes do not couple to the matter fluid of the star , emitted waves for a normal neutron star show only one peak in the spectrum , which corresponds to the orbital frequency at the turning point , where the gravitational field is strongest . </S>\",\n \"<S> however , for an ultracompact star ( the radius @xmath0 ) , another type of resonant periodic peak appears in the spectrum . </S>\",\n \"<S> this is just because of an excitation by a scattered particle of axial quasinormal modes , which were found by chandrasekhar and ferrari . </S>\",\n \"<S> this excitation comes from the existence of the potential minimum inside of a star . </S>\",\n \"<S> we also find for an ultracompact star many small periodic peaks at the frequency region beyond the maximum of the potential , which would be due to a resonance of two waves reflected by two potential barriers ( regge - wheeler type and one at the center of the star ) . such resonant peaks appear neither for a normal neutron star nor for a schwarzschild black hole . </S>\",\n \"<S> consequently , even if we analyze the energy spectrum of gravitational waves only for axial modes , it would be possible to distinguish between an ultracompact star and a normal neutron star ( or a schwarzschild black hole ) . </S>\",\n \"<S> + pacs number(s ) : 04.25.nx , 04.30.-w , 04.40.dg </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","linearized einstein equations: axial modes","gravitational waves from a scattered test particle","concluding remarks","numerical techniques solving the linearized einstein equations"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"linearized einstein equations: axial modes\",\n \"gravitational waves from a scattered test particle\",\n \"concluding remarks\",\n \"numerical techniques solving the linearized einstein equations\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["a laser interferometer to detect gravitational waves , such as the laser interferometric gravitational wave observatory(ligo ) , virgo , geo600 , or tama300 , will be in operation within several years@xcite .","it is one of the most urgent subjects for theoretical relativists to make a set of templates of gravitational waves .","the direct detection of gravitational waves is very important not only as a new eye \" observing the universe ( gravitational wave astronomy ) but also as a new probe for fundamental physics .","for example , we know that a neutron star , which is observed as a pulsar , has a mass @xmath1 and a radius @xmath2 @xmath3 .","although we can guess its central region with some theoretical ansatz , we have no direct information from the inside of a neutron star because neither radiation nor a neutrino is transparent in the central region .","the direct detection of gravitational waves may provide some information about the inside of a neutron star when it is formed , resulting in new observational facts or constraints about the equation of state for high density matter .","one of the most promising astronomical sources for these ground - based detectors is a coalesced compact binary such as a neutron star binary . to complete a set of templates from such a source",", many studies about the emitted gravitational waves have been done using various techniques .","a numerical simulation without approximations ( numerical relativity ) is probably one of the best ways to calculate gravitational waves emitted from the compact binary system @xcite .","although steady progress in numerical relativity has been achieved , there are still some difficulties which prevent us from finding the final results . instead , there are some powerful approximation methods to mimic the coalescence of a compact binary system .","one such approximation is the perturbative approach .","regge and wheeler @xcite and zerilli @xcite first formulated a method for metric perturbations in a schwarzschild black hole spacetime .","then there are many works using such a black hole perturbation method in which we describe gravitational waves by metric perturbations in a black hole background spacetime and treat a companion of the binary as a test particle@xcite .","this approximation for gravitational waves in a head - on collision of two black holes gives a good agreement with the results obtained by numerical simulation@xcite .","thus , such a perturbative approach may provide a good approximation for gravitational waves from a compact binary as well . however , there are so far few works for neutron star perturbations",". one may think that if we have two @xmath4 neutron stars , it will be a black hole after coalescence , when the ringing tail of the gravitational waves can be described by quasinormal modes of the black hole .","the quasinormal modes of a neutron star may have nothing to do with the final stage of the coalescence .","however , before black hole formation , we have to analyze the orbital evolution of the neutron star binary .","therefore , we believe that a perturbation analysis for a neutron star is also important . for a nonradial pulsation of a spherically symmetric relativistic star , perturbation equations both for axial and polar modes were first derived by thorne and campolattaro @xcite .","similar to the black hole perturbation , the axial mode for a spherical star is described by a second order differential equation .","on the other hand , the polar mode was first described by a fifth order differential equation@xcite . however , because of the dynamical degrees of freedom of polar modes , i.e. , sound waves and gravitational waves , the basic equation can be reduced to a fourth order differential equation as shown by lindblom and detweiler @xcite .","lindblom , mendell , and ipser @xcite also derived a couple of second order differential equations , which could be interpreted as those for sound waves and gravitational waves , respectively .","as in the case of black hole perturbations , quasinormal modes , if they exist , will be important in the analysis of gravitational waves from a compact binary . for the polar mode",", there are two types of quasinormal modes of a neutron star ; one is a fluid oscillation mode similar to the @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath7 modes of a newtonian star ( cf .","@xcite ) ; the other is a wave mode ( @xmath8 mode ) , which exists only in general relativity @xcite . even for the axial mode ,","chandrasekhar and ferrari@xcite illustrated that quasinormal modes exist if the effective potential has a minimal as that in an ultracompact star .","kokkotas @xcite numerically calculated such axial quasinormal modes for various ultracompact stars .","kojima @xcite extended it to a slowly rotating star , setting regge - wheeler gauge conditions .","as for emitted gravitational waves from a binary system , kojima @xcite studied them for the case that a test particle is moving in a circular orbit around a polytropic star . for a circular orbit ,","the axial mode cancels from the orbital symmetry so that the polar mode was only taken into account .","he showed that the resonance mode appears in the energy flux when the orbit reaches the radius where the orbital frequency coincides with that of the quasinormal mode .","for the axial mode , recently , borrelli @xcite calculated energy spectra of gravitational waves emitted by a test particle spiraling into an ultracompact star . in his result ,","its energy spectrum shows many peaks , which correspond to axial quasinormal modes of the star .","although it is important , since we are interested in a compact binary , a direct collision might show some different features from the binary case .","we also do not know what will happen when a test particle reaches the surface of the star .","to avoid such an unknown factor and to analyze the case of a compact binary , we first study gravitational waves emitted when a test particle is scattered by a neutron star in this paper . for a schwarzschild black hole , oohara and","nakamura @xcite analyzed it and showed that the energy spectrum has no peak except for one which corresponds to the orbital frequency .","here we consider a spherical star instead of a schwarzschild black hole .","we study only the axial mode which does not exist in newton gravity . to discuss the dependence of the equations of state , we analyze two models : a uniform density star as in @xcite and a polytropic star .","this paper is organized as follows . in secs .","[ sec : linear]a and [ sec : linear]b , we briefly review the perturbation theory for a spherically symmetric relativistic star .","we show our numerical results in sec .","[ sec : gw ] .","section [ sec : discussion ] is devoted to a discussion .","some numerical techniques for calculating gravitational waves are summarized in the appendix . throughout this paper",", we use units of @xmath9 and a metric signature of @xmath10 ."],["we start with summarizing briefly the metric perturbation of a spherically symmetric relativistic star . a spherically symmetric background metric @xmath11 is described as @xmath12 @xmath13 where @xmath14 is a mass function inside a radius @xmath15 .","we assume a perfect fluid as the stellar matter , i.e. @xmath16 where @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the total energy density and the pressure , respectively , which satisfy a barotropic equation of state , @xmath19 .","using tolman - oppenheimer - volkov equations , we construct a stellar model and its spacetime metric numerically except for the constant density star case .","the radius @xmath20 of a star is defined by a surface where the pressure vanishes , and the mass of the star @xmath21 is given by @xmath22 . for linearized einstein equations",", we can decompose the perturbed metric into an axial mode @xmath23 and a polar mode @xmath24 : @xmath25 using regge - wheeler gauge conditions , we will integrate the interior and exterior regions of the linearized einstein equations , separately , and impose appropriate junction conditions at the surface @xmath20 to find the solution . in this paper",", we only deal with axial mode perturbation .","then , we write down the linearized einstein equation only for axial modes in the following subsections . in order to find the linearized einstein equations for axial modes , we expand the perturbed metric by tensor harmonics for polar angle @xmath26 and azimuthal angle @xmath27 @xcite , and proceed to a fourier transformation for the time coordinate @xmath28 .","although there are ten independent components for the linearized metric , four of them are gauge freedoms of coordinate transformations , which are fixed by a choice of regge - wheeler gauge @xcite , resulting in two components belonging to axial modes , while the rest of the four correspond to polar modes . for axial mode perturbations , we can set @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are functions of the radial coordinate @xmath15 defined below , and @xmath32 is a spherical harmonics .","the axial mode in the interior region of a star is described by a single wave equation for gravitational waves , because a rotation does not exist in a spherically symmetric background spacetime .","that is , we have a single wave function @xmath33 , which determines the behaviors of axial modes as @xmath34 the equation for the wave function @xmath33 is derived from the linearized einstein equation for axial modes as @xmath35 where the `` tortoise '' coordinate @xmath36 and the effective potential @xmath37 are defined as @xmath38 respectively .","as for the boundary condition , the wave function @xmath33 must be regular at the center of a star .","expanding @xmath33 around the center @xmath39 , we find @xmath40 r^{l + 3 } + o(r^{l+5 } ) \\right\\ } , \\label{eq : bc_x}\\ ] ] where @xmath41 is an arbitrary constant , and @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 are the central density , pressure , and metric functions , respectively .","apart from a free parameter @xmath41 , we obtain a solution @xmath33 by integrating eq .","( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) with the boundary condition ( @xmath45 ) .","further details of the numerical techniques constructing the wave function @xmath33 are given in the appendix , subsection [ subsec : app_interior ] .","the background metric outside the star is the schwarzschild spacetime , i.e. , eq .","( [ eq : bgmetric ] ) , with @xmath46 as for the trajectory of a test particle , without loss of generality , we can assume that the particle moves on the equatorial plane ( @xmath47 ) .","then , the equation of motion for the particle is described as @xmath48 where the particle trajectory is @xmath49 , and @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 are the mass , the normalized energy , and the normalized orbital angular momentum of the particle , respectively , with @xmath53 and @xmath54 .","the normalized effective potential energy @xmath55 of the particle is given as @xmath56 in this paper , since we only consider the motion of a test particle scattered by a spherical star , the particle orbit is unbounded , i.e. , @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the maximum value of the potential .","the perturbed metric outside a star only comes from an oscillation of spacetime , that is , gravitational waves .","then , similar to the interior region , the linearized einstein equations for the metric @xmath59 and @xmath60 defined as eq .","( [ metric ] ) are reduced to a single wave equation for a new wave function @xmath61 defined by @xmath62 where @xmath63 and @xmath64 is one of the source terms given below . from the linearized vacuum einstein equations",", we find the wave equation for @xmath61 ( regge - wheeler equation)@xcite as @xmath65 where @xmath36 is the tortoise coordinate defined by @xmath66 @xmath67 is regge - wheeler potential given by @xmath68 and @xmath69 is the source term , which is described by the energy - momentum tensor of a test particle expanded by tensor harmonics@xcite as @xmath70 \\right ] , \\label{source}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] with @xmath71 and @xmath72 being @xmath73 , \\label{eq : def_q } \\\\","d_{lm}(t , r ) & = & - \\frac{1}{\\sqrt{2n(n+1 ) } } \\mu \\int_{-\\infty}^{\\infty } d \\tau \\delta { \\bf ( } t - \\hat{t}(\\tau ) { \\bf ) } \\delta { \\bf ( } r - \\hat{r}(\\tau ) { \\bf ) } \\nonumber \\\\ & & \\quad \\times \\biggl\\ { \\frac{1}{2 } \\left [ \\left ( \\frac{d \\hat{\\theta}}{d \\tau } \\right)^2 - \\sin^2 \\hat{\\theta } \\left ( \\frac{d \\hat{\\phi}}{d \\tau}\\right)^2 \\right ] \\frac{1}{\\sin \\hat{\\theta } } \\bar{x}_{lm } ( \\hat{\\omega } ) \\nonumber \\\\ & & \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad - \\sin \\hat{\\theta } \\frac{d \\hat{\\theta}}{d \\tau } \\frac{d \\hat{\\phi}}{d \\tau } \\bar{w}_{lm}(\\hat{\\omega } ) \\biggr\\}. \\label{eq : def_d}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] @xmath74 , @xmath75 are the tensorial part of a tensor harmonics defined by @xmath76 and the overbar denotes the complex conjugate . the boundary condition outside the star should be imposed such that there is no incoming wave at infinity , @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the amplitude of an outgoing wave at infinity .","the details of constructing the wave function @xmath61 are given in the appendix , subsections [ subsec : app_exterior ] and [ subsec : app_turning_point ] .","we have to combine two wave functions , the interior wave function @xmath33 and the exterior one @xmath61 , at the surface of the star .","the matching condition is that the wave function must be continuous and smooth at the surface . for the case of the axial mode ,","since the wave function inside the star does not couple to perturbations of the matter fluid , the condition turns out to be very simple as @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the radius of the star by use of the tortoise \" coordinate .","then we calculate the amplitude of the gravitational waves @xmath78 as follows : we first integrate eqs .","( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) and ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation ] ) using their boundary conditions , eqs .","( [ eq : bc_x ] ) and ( [ eq : bc_infty ] ) .","next , we connect those solutions at the surface of the star using eqs .","( [ eq : s_condition1 ] ) and ( [ eq : s_condition2 ] ) , which determine two unknown coefficients @xmath41 and @xmath78 . from the wave function","obtained as above , we obtain some information about gravitational waves emitted by a scattered particle .","when we discuss the gravitational waves , we usually decompose them into two modes : @xmath81 and @xmath82 modes .","then , we have to transform our coordinate system from the regge - wheeler gauge to the transverse - traceless one , which metric near infinity is described as @xmath83 then the axial mode in transverse - traceless gauge at infinity turns out to be @xmath84 where the spin - weighted spherical harmonics @xmath85 is defined by @xmath86 the energy - momentum tensor of the gravitational waves at infinity is given by @xmath87 in the transverse - traceless gauge , where the angular brackets denote an appropriate average . from this definition ,","we find the energy spectrum @xmath88 of gravitational waves at infinity for the axial mode as @xmath89"],["in this subsection , we consider a uniform density star . we restrict our analysis only to the case of the @xmath90 mode , just for simplicity .","we find that features of the energy spectrum of emitted gravitational waves can be classified into two cases , which mainly depend on the shape of the effective potential .","figure [ fig : potential ] shows the effective potential [ eqs .","( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) and ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) ] for a uniform density star with three different compactness parameters @xmath91 .","the effective potential has the following three features .","first , the regge - wheeler potential [ eq .","( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) ] has a maximum point near @xmath92 ( accurately at @xmath93 for @xmath94 ) .","second , the potential is discontinuous at the surface because of a discontinuity of the energy density of the star at the surface .","finally , a potential minimum appears inside the star , if the star is ultracompact ( for the case of @xmath0 ) . according to the last feature",", we study two cases separately .","the first stellar type is the case that the surface is outside the potential barrier ( @xmath95 ) . for a usual neutron star , @xmath96 , and","then the first type is most likely a realistic astronomical object .","the second stellar type is the case that the surface is inside the potential barrier ( @xmath97 ) , which may be an exotic star , if it exists .","first we show our result for the first type . for the case of @xmath98",", we show the energy spectra of emitted gravitational waves in fig .","[ fig : rm5 ] . in this figure",", there exists only a single peak in each spectrum .","this peak corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point , i.e. , periastron .","this means that most gravitational waves are emitted around the turning point , where the effect of the gravitational field is the strongest .","no other feature is found in this spectrum .","in fact , fixing the energy @xmath99 and orbital angular momentum @xmath100 , the spectrum depends less on the compactness parameter @xmath91 ( see fig . [","fig : rm5bh ] ) . for a black hole background",", we find quite similar behaviors in the energy spectrum ( fig .","[ fig : rm5bh ] ) , except for the high frequency region , where the difference of the boundary conditions is crucial .","we also find that the spectrum approaches closer to that of a black hole as the star gets smaller .","we also calculate the waveform for the case of @xmath101 and black holes , respectively .","we see that a burst wave due to the encounter of a test particle emerges for each case . as the same as the energy spectrum , the difference between these waveform is very little ( see fig .","[ fig : wf5 ] ) therefore , for the first stellar type of @xmath102 , the energy spectrum largely depends on the trajectory , but not on the background object .","next we discuss an ultracompact star , which shows much more various structure in the spectrum . in this case",", a minimum point of the effective potential appears inside the star . as for the trajectory of a test particle , we have two possibilities : one is that the particle gets into the inside region beyond the potential barrier and the other is that one passes through outside the barrier . since the particle approaches closer to the star , it feels a stronger gravitational field . as a result ,","the excitation by the particle is more efficient and the emitted gravitational waves are enhanced . as a numerical example , we show those energy spectra for the model with radius @xmath103 with the turning points @xmath104 and @xmath105 in fig . [","fig : rm2.26 ] . apart from a global maximum , which appears in the first type model as well and corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point",", we also find many small periodic peaks in fig .","[ fig : rm2.26 ] .","this microscopic peak structure is classified into two types , which are divided at the frequency of the maximum @xmath106 ( @xmath107 for @xmath94 ) of the effective potential . in the lower frequency region ( @xmath108 )",", small and sharp peaks correspond to the quasinormal modes , as we will show it next . for the higher frequency region ( @xmath109 ) , we find small periodic peaks , which may appear because of a resonance between two potential barriers .","we will also discuss this later . in order to analyze our numerical results",", we first have to know the axial quasinormal modes . our method to calculate a quasinormal mode","is based on the continued fraction expansion method which was originally used for black holes by leaver @xcite , and adopted for the polar mode of a spherical star by leins , nollert , and soffel @xcite .","we apply this method to axial modes as well .","we show our results in table [ tab : qnm_urm2.26 ] with those of kokkotas@xcite whose method is different from ours .","the table shows that both results agree quite well . in fig .","[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] , we present both the quasinormal mode and energy spectrum . as seen from fig .","[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] , axial ","quasinormal \" modes are classified into two : the lower frequency mode ( @xmath110 ) , which imaginary part is very small @xmath111 , and the higher frequency mode ( @xmath112 ) , which imaginary part is rather large @xmath113 .","the reason is very simple . for a frequency lower than @xmath114",", we can have a quasibound state .","since trapped waves tunnel through the potential barrier , the energy will decrease .","it is similar to the quasinormal mode of a black hole .","then , we may call it the axial quasinormal mode as well . however , if the frequency is higher than @xmath114 , we have no bound state .","nevertheless , we can find the ","quasinormal \" mode , by which we mean a wave solution with the same boundary condition as that of the conventional quasinormal mode , which is the outgoing wave condition . in the present case , although we find such wave solutions , those waves decay very quickly because the frequency is higher than the potential barrier .","this is the reason why we find a large imaginary part of the mode frequency .","the solutions which satisfy the boundary condition appear periodically as seen from fig .","[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] .","we find that the frequencies of these quasinormal modes coincide with those of spectrum peaks in the frequency region lower than @xmath114 .","this is because a test particle excites those quasinormal modes .","in fact , when we see the waveform ( fig . [","fig : wf2.26 ] ) , the wave consists of two parts : large one , which corresponds to the burst wave by the encounter by a test particle , and the other part with several oscillations , which comes from exited quasinormal modes in the spectrum .","actually the waveform in the region after @xmath115 in fig .","[ fig : wf2.26 ] is similar to kokkotas s result for a gaussian pulse wave @xcite . on the other hand , in a frequency region","higher than @xmath114 , although many periodic peaks appear , those positions are not exactly the same as the frequencies of quasinormal \" modes .","we may understand this fact as follows .","even if the wave frequency @xmath116 is higher than the potential barrier , the reflection coefficient does not vanish and oscillates with respect to @xmath116 , which period is determined by the potential form . in the present case , we have also an infinite wall near the center of a star .","we then expect that small periodic peaks appearing in the spectrum are due to an interference between the incoming and outgoing waves reflected by two potential barriers .","since these waves decay very quickly as mentioned above , the process is quite dynamical , and then the peaks in the spectrum do not coincide with the frequencies of quasinormal \" modes . in fig .","[ fig : rm2.26 - 2.3 ] , we show the energy spectra for two stellar models with @xmath117 , and @xmath118 , which correspond to the cases that the turning point is inside and outside the barrier , respectively . for fixed energy @xmath119 and angular momentum @xmath100",", the global peaks corresponding to the orbital frequency at the turning point agree with each other . on the other hand , the other small periodic peaks from the excited quasinormal modes do not agree with and rather depend on the compactness parameter @xmath91 . consequently , from the analysis of the energy spectrum of axial modes , we may determine the compactness parameter @xmath91 of an ultracompact star .","we can also compare a black hole and an ultracompact star . in fig .","[ fig : rm2.26bh ] , we show the energy spectra both for a black hole @xcite and an ultracompact star with @xmath120 . from fig .","[ fig : rm2.26bh ] , we see that even for the case of a schwarzschild black hole , the global peak due to the orbital motion of the particle coincides with that for the star . however , unlike the stellar model ,","no small periodic peaks appear in the case of a black hole .","in fact for a black hole , there is no peak after @xmath115 ( see fig .","this is because the effective potential of the star has an infinite potential wall near the center , which guarantees the existence of quasinormal modes , while that of a schwarzschild black hole has no such wall , and incoming waves fall entirely into the event horizon @xmath121 .","hence , we can also distinguish a background object , i.e. , whether it is an ultracompact star or a black hole , analyzing only axial modes .","as for the total energy of emitted gravitational waves @xmath122 , we find @xmath123 with @xmath124 and @xmath125 for @xmath126 and @xmath127 , respectively , and for @xmath128 and @xmath129 .","the efficiency @xmath130 increases monotonically as the compactness gets smaller , and seems to end up with that for schwarzschild black holes ( @xmath131 ) . for @xmath132 and @xmath133 , the efficiency , which is @xmath134 ,","little depends on @xmath135 up to the case of a black hole . from the analysis of the energy spectrum for a uniform density star , we find that the spectrum strongly depends on the shape of effective potential . therefore ,","it may be important to see the dependence of the equation of state on the energy spectrum . then , in this section , we study a polytropic star . just for simplicity",", we use the newtonian polytropic equation of state as @xmath136 where @xmath137 is a polytropic index and @xmath138 is a constant value . first , we consider the first type stellar model with @xmath139 .","we set the polytropic index @xmath140 and the constant @xmath141 , and choose the central energy density @xmath142 .","this choice gives a stellar model with mass @xmath143 and radius @xmath144 .","the compact parameter is @xmath145 , and then the surface locates outside the peak of the regge - wheeler potential .","we show the energy spectra of gravitational waves from a scattering test particle in fig .","[ fig : polytropic1.0 ] .","we find the same feature as that for the uniform density star with @xmath146 , i.e. , there is only a single global peak which frequency corresponds to the orbital one of the particle at the turning point .","next , we discuss the second type stellar model , i.e. , an ultracompact star . to construct an ultracompact star with a polytropic equation of state",", we set the polytropic index @xmath147 , the constant @xmath148 , and choose the central energy density @xmath149 , for which the compactness parameter @xmath135 turns out to be the smallest .","for such a choice , the radius , mass , and compactness parameters of the star are @xmath150 , @xmath151 , and @xmath152 , respectively .","although this seems very implausible for a realistic star , we will use this solution in our analysis to study the dependence of the equation of state on the energy spectrum . in fig .","[ fig : polytropic0.5 ] , we show the energy spectra for two trajectories of a test particle .","one is the case that a particle goes into the inside of the potential barrier , while the other is the case that a particle passes through only outside the potential barrier .","we find the same feature as that of the uniform density star with @xmath153 .","the difference is found in the frequencies of quasinormal modes because of the different shapes of the potential .","then , we find many small and sharp peaks in the spectrum at the positions different from those for a uniform density star .","consequently , we may be able to distinguish the inside structure of an ultracompact star by observing the energy spectrum of emitted gravitational waves ."],["we have studied the axial modes of gravitational waves from a test particle scattered by a spherically symmetric relativistic star .","we have considered both a uniform density star and a polytropic star .","we find that the energy spectrum depends mainly on the shape of the effective potential for gravitational waves , i.e. , whether its minimum exists or not .","when there is no minimum ( e.g. , a regular type of neutron star with a compactness parameter @xmath154 ) , the energy spectrum shows only a single global peak , which corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point .","gravitational waves are mostly emitted around the turning point , where the effect of the gravitational field is strongest . while if a minimum of the effective potential exists ( i.e. , some exotic relativistic star with small compactness parameter @xmath155 ) , the energy spectrum shows a variety in its structure in addition to the global peak as the same as that found in the previous case .","we find small and sharp periodic peaks in the region lower than @xmath114 ( the maximum value of the effective potential ) , which correspond to an excitation of the axial quasinormal modes .","the existence of the potential minimum allows the existence of a quasibound state of gravitational waves , i.e. , quasinormal modes .","then those modes are excited by a scattered particle .","this becomes more conspicuous when the particle gets into the inside region beyond the potential barrier .","we also find small periodic peaks in the frequency region beyond @xmath114 , which may come from an interference between two waves reflected by the potential barrier and the infinite wall near the center of the star . from the observation of the energy spectrum of the axial mode ,","what we can determine ? naively speaking , we may not find any information about the constituent of the star , because the axial mode does not couple to matter fluid .","this is true for the first type stellar model , i.e. , a regular neutron star . emitted gravitational waves","are mostly determined by the particle orbit .","the case of black holes also belongs to this case , although there is a small difference in the high frequency part because of the difference of the boundary condition .","however , if a star is compact enough to make a potential minimum ( @xmath156 ) , emitted gravitational waves show much more abundant information .","it may determine a compactness parameter @xmath91 .","we also find quasinormal mode frequencies , which depend on the shape of the potential , and then could depend on the equation of state . in the axial mode case , however , in general , we can not have direct information about the matter fluid , in particular about the equation of state .","the polar mode of gravitational waves will provide us a more conspicuous dependence of matter property .","work on the polar modes is under way .","we would like to thank yasufumi kojima for kind suggestions at the beginning of this study .","the numerical computations were mainly performed by the fujitsu - vx vector computer at the media network center , waseda university .","this work was supported partially by a jsps grant - in - aid ( no . 5689 and specially promoted research no .","08102010 ) , and by the waseda university grant for special research projects ."],["here , we present numerical techniques solving the wave equations .","we improved borrelli s method@xcite to guarantee numerical accuracy .","for the interior region , the numerical error of the wave function accumulates and becomes maximal at the surface , because the pressure vanishes there . in order to overcome this difficulty , we solve the wave equation both from the center and from the surface , and connect two wave functions at some inner point , e.g. ,","@xmath157 . for the exterior solution",", we integrate the wave equation from the surface to infinity , by which we can reduce the numerical error . in the present model ,","the test particle mainly emits gravitational waves at the turning point , where we have to solve the wave equation very carefully because an apparent divergence appears .","we shall discuss these three methods in order .","here we show how to solve the interior wave equation ( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) . transforming the wave function @xmath33 to @xmath158","we find the perturbation equation for @xmath159 as @xmath160 \\frac{dz_{l\\omega}}{dr } + e^{\\lambda - \\nu } \\left ( \\omega^2 -\\frac{2n}{r^2}e^{\\nu } \\right ) z_{l\\omega } = 0 .","\\label{eq : near_center_z_equation}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] from the regularity condition at the center , we obtain the asymptotic behavior at @xmath161 as @xmath162 r^{l + 4 } + o(r^{l+6 } ) \\right\\ } , \\label{eq : near_center_z}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] where @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 are density , pressure , and metric functions evaluated at the center , respectively .","in order to reduce the numerical error at the surface , we adopt the following procedure . then , we find two independent wave functions @xmath165 by integrating eq .","( [ eq : near_center_z_equation ] ) from the surface to the middle point .","the boundary conditions of those wave functions at the surface are given as @xmath166 , @xmath167 .","by those two independent solutions , we construct the wave function @xmath168 as @xmath169 where the coefficients @xmath170 and @xmath171 are fixed by junction conditions at @xmath157 .","since the wave functions constructed above must be continuous and smooth at @xmath157 , we find the junction conditions @xmath172 from these two conditions , we find @xmath170 and @xmath171 , and then the interior wave function @xmath159 .","next we construct the exterior wave function . in order to use the green s function method",", we first consider the homogeneous wave function @xmath176 , which satisfies the wave equation @xmath177 and the boundary condition at the surface , which we have already evaluated in the previous subsection , that is , @xmath178 then , we construct a particular solution @xmath179 with a source term , which equation is described as @xmath180 where @xmath69 comes from the motion of a test particle . at the surface ,","the solution @xmath179 satisfies the following condition : @xmath181 for the homogeneous equation ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_homogeneout ] ) , we have two independent solutions @xmath182 and @xmath183 , which correspond to outgoing and incoming waves at infinity , respectively .","then , we describe the wave function @xmath176 by these two independent solutions as @xmath184 where @xmath185 and @xmath186 are complex constants , which are fixed by eqs .","( [ boundary1 ] ) , ( [ boundary2 ] ) . the green s function @xmath187 for eq . ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_inhomogeneout ] ) is also constructed by @xmath188 and @xmath189 as @xmath190 \\theta(r^ { * } - s^ { * } ) \\qquad ( r^ { * } > s^{*}),\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] where @xmath191 is the wronskian and @xmath192 is the heaviside function . the wave function @xmath193 is obtained by integration as @xmath194 then , the solution for the exterior wave equation ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation ] ) with the same boundary conditions as eqs .","( [ boundary1 ] ) , ( [ boundary2 ] ) is given as @xmath195 the asymptotic behavior of @xmath196 as @xmath197 is given by @xmath198 where @xmath199 and @xmath200 are defined by @xmath201 since there is no incoming wave , we find the boundary condition such that @xmath202 then , the amplitude @xmath78 of gravitational waves at infinity is given by @xmath203 in order to extract the amplitude @xmath78 from our solution , we use the relation @xmath204 s_{lm\\omega}^{\\rm ( ext ) } ( s^ { * } ) ds^ { * } \\nonumber \\\\ & = & \\frac{1}{w } \\int_{r^{*}}^{\\infty } x_{lm\\omega}^{\\rm ( ext)(0)}(s^ { * } ) s_{lm\\omega}^{\\rm ( ext ) } ( s^ { * } ) ds^{*}. \\label{eq : boundary_condition_infinity2}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] with eqs .","( [ eq : boundary_condition_infinity ] ) and ( [ eq : boundary_condition_infinity2 ] ) , we finally obtain the amplitude as @xmath205 where @xmath186 is already obtained up to an unknown constant @xmath206 , which is canceled out with that of @xmath176 in eq .","( [ eq : amplitude_result ] ) when a test particle is scattered by a star , the orbit includes a turning point ( @xmath207 or @xmath208 by the tortoise coordinate ) , where the radial velocity @xmath209 vanishes .","the source term @xmath69 in eq .","( [ eq : amplitude_result ] ) is given by eq .","( [ source ] ) , where @xmath210 and @xmath211 , defined by eqs .","( [ eq : def_q ] ) and ( [ eq : def_d ] ) , for the present orbit ( @xmath212 ) are described as @xmath213 where @xmath214 which is a normalization constant of a spherical harmonics @xmath215 , and @xmath216 is the associated legendre function .","integration over the proper time @xmath217 gives the term of @xmath218 in eq .","( [ d_lm ] ) , which diverges at the turning point , and then the integration @xmath219 diverges apparently",". however , this is not a physical divergence , but rather comes from the change of integration variables from the proper time @xmath217 to the radius @xmath15 .","this transformation becomes singular at the turning point because @xmath220 . in order to avoid this difficulty ,","we shall use a time coordinate @xmath221 in the integration .","since the trajectory before and after the turning point is symmetric , we choose the initial position of the particle @xmath222 , @xmath223 at the turning point and integrate from there to infinity .","the integral , eq .","( [ integration ] ) , is then written as @xmath224 \\nonumber \\\\ & & \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad + \\hat{r } \\left ( 1 - \\frac{2m}{\\hat{r } } \\right ) \\frac{1}{d \\hat{r}/ d \\hat{t } } \\frac{d x_{lm\\omega}^{\\rm ( ext)(0)}}{d \\hat{t } } s_{lm}^{(1 ) } ( \\hat{t } ) \\biggr ] , \\label{eq : source_term_integral_t } \\\\ & & \\qquad \\hat{s}_{lm}^{(0 ) } = \\frac{8 \\pi}{\\tilde{e } } \\biggl [ \\sqrt{\\frac{2}{l(l + 1 ) } } \\left ( 1- \\frac{2m}{\\hat{r } } \\right)^2 \\hat{q}_{lm } \\nonumber \\\\ & & \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad \\qquad + \\sqrt{\\frac{2}{l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\frac{2m}{\\hat{r } } \\left ( 1 - \\frac{2m}{\\hat{r } } \\right ) \\hat{d}_{lm } \\biggr ] , \\\\ & & \\qquad \\hat{s}_{lm}^{(1 ) } = -\\frac{8 \\pi}{\\tilde{e } } \\sqrt{\\frac{2}{l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\left ( 1 - \\frac{2m}{\\hat{r } } \\right ) \\hat{d}_{lm } , \\\\ & & \\qquad \\hat{q}_{lm } = - 2 i c_{lm } \\sqrt{\\frac{2}{l(l + 1 ) } } \\frac{\\mu \\tilde{l}}{\\hat{r}^3 ( 1 - 2m/\\hat{r } ) } \\gamma^{1/2 } \\frac{d p_{lm}}{d \\hat{\\theta } } \\left({\\pi\\over 2}\\right ) \\sin ( \\omega \\hat{t } - m \\hat{\\phi } ) , \\\\ & & \\qquad \\hat{d}_{lm } = \\frac{- 4imc_{lm}}{\\sqrt{2l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\frac{\\mu \\tilde{l}^2}{\\hat{r}^4 } \\frac{d p_{lm}}{d \\hat{\\theta}}\\left({\\pi\\over 2}\\right ) \\cos ( \\omega \\hat{t } - m \\hat{\\phi}),\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] where @xmath225 and @xmath226 is its time derivative .","however , the term in eq .","( [ eq : source_term_integral_t ] ) , @xmath227 is still apparently divergent because @xmath228 vanishes at the turning point . to avoid this difficulty , we expand @xmath176 , @xmath229 near the turning point . from the equation of motion , we find @xmath230 which is integrated as @xmath231 where @xmath232 is an integration constant .","then , we find the wave function near the turning point as @xmath233 where @xmath176 , @xmath234 , and @xmath235 at the turning point @xmath208 are found easily by integration of eq .","( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_homogeneout ] ) .","since those functions are regular at the turning point , we can evaluate eq .","( [ eq : source_term_integral_t ] ) without any difficulty .","see , for example , a. abramovici _","et al . _ , science * 256 * , 325 ( 1992 ) , for ligo ; c. bradaschia _ et al . _ ,","methods phys .","a * 289 * , 518 ( 1990 ) , for virgo ; j. hough , in _ proceedings of the sixth marcel grossmann meeting _ , edited by h. sato and t. nakamura ( world scientific , singapore , 1992 ) , p. 192",", for geo600 ; k. kuroda _ et al .","_ , in _ proceedings of international conference on gravitational waves : sources and detectors _ , edited by i. ciufolini and f. fidecaro ( world scientific , singapore , 1997 ) , p. 100",", for tama300 . .","quasinormal \" modes for a uniform density star with @xmath236 .","we use the continued fraction expansion method , which was first used to calculate black hole quasinormal modes by leaver [ 24 ] , and @xmath8 modes of a polytropic star by leins , nollert , and soffel [ 16 ] .","our results agree quite well with those of kokkotas , who adopted a different method [ 20 ] .","our imaginary part has opposite sign to kokkotas s result , because our definition of the fourier transformation is opposite to his . [","cols=\"^,^,^,^ \" , ]"]],"string":"[\n [\n \"a laser interferometer to detect gravitational waves , such as the laser interferometric gravitational wave observatory(ligo ) , virgo , geo600 , or tama300 , will be in operation within several years@xcite .\",\n \"it is one of the most urgent subjects for theoretical relativists to make a set of templates of gravitational waves .\",\n \"the direct detection of gravitational waves is very important not only as a new eye \\\" observing the universe ( gravitational wave astronomy ) but also as a new probe for fundamental physics .\",\n \"for example , we know that a neutron star , which is observed as a pulsar , has a mass @xmath1 and a radius @xmath2 @xmath3 .\",\n \"although we can guess its central region with some theoretical ansatz , we have no direct information from the inside of a neutron star because neither radiation nor a neutrino is transparent in the central region .\",\n \"the direct detection of gravitational waves may provide some information about the inside of a neutron star when it is formed , resulting in new observational facts or constraints about the equation of state for high density matter .\",\n \"one of the most promising astronomical sources for these ground - based detectors is a coalesced compact binary such as a neutron star binary . to complete a set of templates from such a source\",\n \", many studies about the emitted gravitational waves have been done using various techniques .\",\n \"a numerical simulation without approximations ( numerical relativity ) is probably one of the best ways to calculate gravitational waves emitted from the compact binary system @xcite .\",\n \"although steady progress in numerical relativity has been achieved , there are still some difficulties which prevent us from finding the final results . instead , there are some powerful approximation methods to mimic the coalescence of a compact binary system .\",\n \"one such approximation is the perturbative approach .\",\n \"regge and wheeler @xcite and zerilli @xcite first formulated a method for metric perturbations in a schwarzschild black hole spacetime .\",\n \"then there are many works using such a black hole perturbation method in which we describe gravitational waves by metric perturbations in a black hole background spacetime and treat a companion of the binary as a test particle@xcite .\",\n \"this approximation for gravitational waves in a head - on collision of two black holes gives a good agreement with the results obtained by numerical simulation@xcite .\",\n \"thus , such a perturbative approach may provide a good approximation for gravitational waves from a compact binary as well . however , there are so far few works for neutron star perturbations\",\n \". one may think that if we have two @xmath4 neutron stars , it will be a black hole after coalescence , when the ringing tail of the gravitational waves can be described by quasinormal modes of the black hole .\",\n \"the quasinormal modes of a neutron star may have nothing to do with the final stage of the coalescence .\",\n \"however , before black hole formation , we have to analyze the orbital evolution of the neutron star binary .\",\n \"therefore , we believe that a perturbation analysis for a neutron star is also important . for a nonradial pulsation of a spherically symmetric relativistic star , perturbation equations both for axial and polar modes were first derived by thorne and campolattaro @xcite .\",\n \"similar to the black hole perturbation , the axial mode for a spherical star is described by a second order differential equation .\",\n \"on the other hand , the polar mode was first described by a fifth order differential equation@xcite . however , because of the dynamical degrees of freedom of polar modes , i.e. , sound waves and gravitational waves , the basic equation can be reduced to a fourth order differential equation as shown by lindblom and detweiler @xcite .\",\n \"lindblom , mendell , and ipser @xcite also derived a couple of second order differential equations , which could be interpreted as those for sound waves and gravitational waves , respectively .\",\n \"as in the case of black hole perturbations , quasinormal modes , if they exist , will be important in the analysis of gravitational waves from a compact binary . for the polar mode\",\n \", there are two types of quasinormal modes of a neutron star ; one is a fluid oscillation mode similar to the @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath7 modes of a newtonian star ( cf .\",\n \"@xcite ) ; the other is a wave mode ( @xmath8 mode ) , which exists only in general relativity @xcite . even for the axial mode ,\",\n \"chandrasekhar and ferrari@xcite illustrated that quasinormal modes exist if the effective potential has a minimal as that in an ultracompact star .\",\n \"kokkotas @xcite numerically calculated such axial quasinormal modes for various ultracompact stars .\",\n \"kojima @xcite extended it to a slowly rotating star , setting regge - wheeler gauge conditions .\",\n \"as for emitted gravitational waves from a binary system , kojima @xcite studied them for the case that a test particle is moving in a circular orbit around a polytropic star . for a circular orbit ,\",\n \"the axial mode cancels from the orbital symmetry so that the polar mode was only taken into account .\",\n \"he showed that the resonance mode appears in the energy flux when the orbit reaches the radius where the orbital frequency coincides with that of the quasinormal mode .\",\n \"for the axial mode , recently , borrelli @xcite calculated energy spectra of gravitational waves emitted by a test particle spiraling into an ultracompact star . in his result ,\",\n \"its energy spectrum shows many peaks , which correspond to axial quasinormal modes of the star .\",\n \"although it is important , since we are interested in a compact binary , a direct collision might show some different features from the binary case .\",\n \"we also do not know what will happen when a test particle reaches the surface of the star .\",\n \"to avoid such an unknown factor and to analyze the case of a compact binary , we first study gravitational waves emitted when a test particle is scattered by a neutron star in this paper . for a schwarzschild black hole , oohara and\",\n \"nakamura @xcite analyzed it and showed that the energy spectrum has no peak except for one which corresponds to the orbital frequency .\",\n \"here we consider a spherical star instead of a schwarzschild black hole .\",\n \"we study only the axial mode which does not exist in newton gravity . to discuss the dependence of the equations of state , we analyze two models : a uniform density star as in @xcite and a polytropic star .\",\n \"this paper is organized as follows . in secs .\",\n \"[ sec : linear]a and [ sec : linear]b , we briefly review the perturbation theory for a spherically symmetric relativistic star .\",\n \"we show our numerical results in sec .\",\n \"[ sec : gw ] .\",\n \"section [ sec : discussion ] is devoted to a discussion .\",\n \"some numerical techniques for calculating gravitational waves are summarized in the appendix . throughout this paper\",\n \", we use units of @xmath9 and a metric signature of @xmath10 .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we start with summarizing briefly the metric perturbation of a spherically symmetric relativistic star . a spherically symmetric background metric @xmath11 is described as @xmath12 @xmath13 where @xmath14 is a mass function inside a radius @xmath15 .\",\n \"we assume a perfect fluid as the stellar matter , i.e. @xmath16 where @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the total energy density and the pressure , respectively , which satisfy a barotropic equation of state , @xmath19 .\",\n \"using tolman - oppenheimer - volkov equations , we construct a stellar model and its spacetime metric numerically except for the constant density star case .\",\n \"the radius @xmath20 of a star is defined by a surface where the pressure vanishes , and the mass of the star @xmath21 is given by @xmath22 . for linearized einstein equations\",\n \", we can decompose the perturbed metric into an axial mode @xmath23 and a polar mode @xmath24 : @xmath25 using regge - wheeler gauge conditions , we will integrate the interior and exterior regions of the linearized einstein equations , separately , and impose appropriate junction conditions at the surface @xmath20 to find the solution . in this paper\",\n \", we only deal with axial mode perturbation .\",\n \"then , we write down the linearized einstein equation only for axial modes in the following subsections . in order to find the linearized einstein equations for axial modes , we expand the perturbed metric by tensor harmonics for polar angle @xmath26 and azimuthal angle @xmath27 @xcite , and proceed to a fourier transformation for the time coordinate @xmath28 .\",\n \"although there are ten independent components for the linearized metric , four of them are gauge freedoms of coordinate transformations , which are fixed by a choice of regge - wheeler gauge @xcite , resulting in two components belonging to axial modes , while the rest of the four correspond to polar modes . for axial mode perturbations , we can set @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are functions of the radial coordinate @xmath15 defined below , and @xmath32 is a spherical harmonics .\",\n \"the axial mode in the interior region of a star is described by a single wave equation for gravitational waves , because a rotation does not exist in a spherically symmetric background spacetime .\",\n \"that is , we have a single wave function @xmath33 , which determines the behaviors of axial modes as @xmath34 the equation for the wave function @xmath33 is derived from the linearized einstein equation for axial modes as @xmath35 where the `` tortoise '' coordinate @xmath36 and the effective potential @xmath37 are defined as @xmath38 respectively .\",\n \"as for the boundary condition , the wave function @xmath33 must be regular at the center of a star .\",\n \"expanding @xmath33 around the center @xmath39 , we find @xmath40 r^{l + 3 } + o(r^{l+5 } ) \\\\right\\\\ } , \\\\label{eq : bc_x}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath41 is an arbitrary constant , and @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 are the central density , pressure , and metric functions , respectively .\",\n \"apart from a free parameter @xmath41 , we obtain a solution @xmath33 by integrating eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) with the boundary condition ( @xmath45 ) .\",\n \"further details of the numerical techniques constructing the wave function @xmath33 are given in the appendix , subsection [ subsec : app_interior ] .\",\n \"the background metric outside the star is the schwarzschild spacetime , i.e. , eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : bgmetric ] ) , with @xmath46 as for the trajectory of a test particle , without loss of generality , we can assume that the particle moves on the equatorial plane ( @xmath47 ) .\",\n \"then , the equation of motion for the particle is described as @xmath48 where the particle trajectory is @xmath49 , and @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 are the mass , the normalized energy , and the normalized orbital angular momentum of the particle , respectively , with @xmath53 and @xmath54 .\",\n \"the normalized effective potential energy @xmath55 of the particle is given as @xmath56 in this paper , since we only consider the motion of a test particle scattered by a spherical star , the particle orbit is unbounded , i.e. , @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the maximum value of the potential .\",\n \"the perturbed metric outside a star only comes from an oscillation of spacetime , that is , gravitational waves .\",\n \"then , similar to the interior region , the linearized einstein equations for the metric @xmath59 and @xmath60 defined as eq .\",\n \"( [ metric ] ) are reduced to a single wave equation for a new wave function @xmath61 defined by @xmath62 where @xmath63 and @xmath64 is one of the source terms given below . from the linearized vacuum einstein equations\",\n \", we find the wave equation for @xmath61 ( regge - wheeler equation)@xcite as @xmath65 where @xmath36 is the tortoise coordinate defined by @xmath66 @xmath67 is regge - wheeler potential given by @xmath68 and @xmath69 is the source term , which is described by the energy - momentum tensor of a test particle expanded by tensor harmonics@xcite as @xmath70 \\\\right ] , \\\\label{source}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] with @xmath71 and @xmath72 being @xmath73 , \\\\label{eq : def_q } \\\\\\\\\",\n \"d_{lm}(t , r ) & = & - \\\\frac{1}{\\\\sqrt{2n(n+1 ) } } \\\\mu \\\\int_{-\\\\infty}^{\\\\infty } d \\\\tau \\\\delta { \\\\bf ( } t - \\\\hat{t}(\\\\tau ) { \\\\bf ) } \\\\delta { \\\\bf ( } r - \\\\hat{r}(\\\\tau ) { \\\\bf ) } \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\quad \\\\times \\\\biggl\\\\ { \\\\frac{1}{2 } \\\\left [ \\\\left ( \\\\frac{d \\\\hat{\\\\theta}}{d \\\\tau } \\\\right)^2 - \\\\sin^2 \\\\hat{\\\\theta } \\\\left ( \\\\frac{d \\\\hat{\\\\phi}}{d \\\\tau}\\\\right)^2 \\\\right ] \\\\frac{1}{\\\\sin \\\\hat{\\\\theta } } \\\\bar{x}_{lm } ( \\\\hat{\\\\omega } ) \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad - \\\\sin \\\\hat{\\\\theta } \\\\frac{d \\\\hat{\\\\theta}}{d \\\\tau } \\\\frac{d \\\\hat{\\\\phi}}{d \\\\tau } \\\\bar{w}_{lm}(\\\\hat{\\\\omega } ) \\\\biggr\\\\}. \\\\label{eq : def_d}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] @xmath74 , @xmath75 are the tensorial part of a tensor harmonics defined by @xmath76 and the overbar denotes the complex conjugate . the boundary condition outside the star should be imposed such that there is no incoming wave at infinity , @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the amplitude of an outgoing wave at infinity .\",\n \"the details of constructing the wave function @xmath61 are given in the appendix , subsections [ subsec : app_exterior ] and [ subsec : app_turning_point ] .\",\n \"we have to combine two wave functions , the interior wave function @xmath33 and the exterior one @xmath61 , at the surface of the star .\",\n \"the matching condition is that the wave function must be continuous and smooth at the surface . for the case of the axial mode ,\",\n \"since the wave function inside the star does not couple to perturbations of the matter fluid , the condition turns out to be very simple as @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the radius of the star by use of the tortoise \\\" coordinate .\",\n \"then we calculate the amplitude of the gravitational waves @xmath78 as follows : we first integrate eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) and ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation ] ) using their boundary conditions , eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : bc_x ] ) and ( [ eq : bc_infty ] ) .\",\n \"next , we connect those solutions at the surface of the star using eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : s_condition1 ] ) and ( [ eq : s_condition2 ] ) , which determine two unknown coefficients @xmath41 and @xmath78 . from the wave function\",\n \"obtained as above , we obtain some information about gravitational waves emitted by a scattered particle .\",\n \"when we discuss the gravitational waves , we usually decompose them into two modes : @xmath81 and @xmath82 modes .\",\n \"then , we have to transform our coordinate system from the regge - wheeler gauge to the transverse - traceless one , which metric near infinity is described as @xmath83 then the axial mode in transverse - traceless gauge at infinity turns out to be @xmath84 where the spin - weighted spherical harmonics @xmath85 is defined by @xmath86 the energy - momentum tensor of the gravitational waves at infinity is given by @xmath87 in the transverse - traceless gauge , where the angular brackets denote an appropriate average . from this definition ,\",\n \"we find the energy spectrum @xmath88 of gravitational waves at infinity for the axial mode as @xmath89\"\n ],\n [\n \"in this subsection , we consider a uniform density star . we restrict our analysis only to the case of the @xmath90 mode , just for simplicity .\",\n \"we find that features of the energy spectrum of emitted gravitational waves can be classified into two cases , which mainly depend on the shape of the effective potential .\",\n \"figure [ fig : potential ] shows the effective potential [ eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) and ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) ] for a uniform density star with three different compactness parameters @xmath91 .\",\n \"the effective potential has the following three features .\",\n \"first , the regge - wheeler potential [ eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation_potential ] ) ] has a maximum point near @xmath92 ( accurately at @xmath93 for @xmath94 ) .\",\n \"second , the potential is discontinuous at the surface because of a discontinuity of the energy density of the star at the surface .\",\n \"finally , a potential minimum appears inside the star , if the star is ultracompact ( for the case of @xmath0 ) . according to the last feature\",\n \", we study two cases separately .\",\n \"the first stellar type is the case that the surface is outside the potential barrier ( @xmath95 ) . for a usual neutron star , @xmath96 , and\",\n \"then the first type is most likely a realistic astronomical object .\",\n \"the second stellar type is the case that the surface is inside the potential barrier ( @xmath97 ) , which may be an exotic star , if it exists .\",\n \"first we show our result for the first type . for the case of @xmath98\",\n \", we show the energy spectra of emitted gravitational waves in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm5 ] . in this figure\",\n \", there exists only a single peak in each spectrum .\",\n \"this peak corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point , i.e. , periastron .\",\n \"this means that most gravitational waves are emitted around the turning point , where the effect of the gravitational field is the strongest .\",\n \"no other feature is found in this spectrum .\",\n \"in fact , fixing the energy @xmath99 and orbital angular momentum @xmath100 , the spectrum depends less on the compactness parameter @xmath91 ( see fig . [\",\n \"fig : rm5bh ] ) . for a black hole background\",\n \", we find quite similar behaviors in the energy spectrum ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm5bh ] ) , except for the high frequency region , where the difference of the boundary conditions is crucial .\",\n \"we also find that the spectrum approaches closer to that of a black hole as the star gets smaller .\",\n \"we also calculate the waveform for the case of @xmath101 and black holes , respectively .\",\n \"we see that a burst wave due to the encounter of a test particle emerges for each case . as the same as the energy spectrum , the difference between these waveform is very little ( see fig .\",\n \"[ fig : wf5 ] ) therefore , for the first stellar type of @xmath102 , the energy spectrum largely depends on the trajectory , but not on the background object .\",\n \"next we discuss an ultracompact star , which shows much more various structure in the spectrum . in this case\",\n \", a minimum point of the effective potential appears inside the star . as for the trajectory of a test particle , we have two possibilities : one is that the particle gets into the inside region beyond the potential barrier and the other is that one passes through outside the barrier . since the particle approaches closer to the star , it feels a stronger gravitational field . as a result ,\",\n \"the excitation by the particle is more efficient and the emitted gravitational waves are enhanced . as a numerical example , we show those energy spectra for the model with radius @xmath103 with the turning points @xmath104 and @xmath105 in fig . [\",\n \"fig : rm2.26 ] . apart from a global maximum , which appears in the first type model as well and corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point\",\n \", we also find many small periodic peaks in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26 ] .\",\n \"this microscopic peak structure is classified into two types , which are divided at the frequency of the maximum @xmath106 ( @xmath107 for @xmath94 ) of the effective potential . in the lower frequency region ( @xmath108 )\",\n \", small and sharp peaks correspond to the quasinormal modes , as we will show it next . for the higher frequency region ( @xmath109 ) , we find small periodic peaks , which may appear because of a resonance between two potential barriers .\",\n \"we will also discuss this later . in order to analyze our numerical results\",\n \", we first have to know the axial quasinormal modes . our method to calculate a quasinormal mode\",\n \"is based on the continued fraction expansion method which was originally used for black holes by leaver @xcite , and adopted for the polar mode of a spherical star by leins , nollert , and soffel @xcite .\",\n \"we apply this method to axial modes as well .\",\n \"we show our results in table [ tab : qnm_urm2.26 ] with those of kokkotas@xcite whose method is different from ours .\",\n \"the table shows that both results agree quite well . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] , we present both the quasinormal mode and energy spectrum . as seen from fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] , axial \",\n \"quasinormal \\\" modes are classified into two : the lower frequency mode ( @xmath110 ) , which imaginary part is very small @xmath111 , and the higher frequency mode ( @xmath112 ) , which imaginary part is rather large @xmath113 .\",\n \"the reason is very simple . for a frequency lower than @xmath114\",\n \", we can have a quasibound state .\",\n \"since trapped waves tunnel through the potential barrier , the energy will decrease .\",\n \"it is similar to the quasinormal mode of a black hole .\",\n \"then , we may call it the axial quasinormal mode as well . however , if the frequency is higher than @xmath114 , we have no bound state .\",\n \"nevertheless , we can find the \",\n \"quasinormal \\\" mode , by which we mean a wave solution with the same boundary condition as that of the conventional quasinormal mode , which is the outgoing wave condition . in the present case , although we find such wave solutions , those waves decay very quickly because the frequency is higher than the potential barrier .\",\n \"this is the reason why we find a large imaginary part of the mode frequency .\",\n \"the solutions which satisfy the boundary condition appear periodically as seen from fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26qnm ] .\",\n \"we find that the frequencies of these quasinormal modes coincide with those of spectrum peaks in the frequency region lower than @xmath114 .\",\n \"this is because a test particle excites those quasinormal modes .\",\n \"in fact , when we see the waveform ( fig . [\",\n \"fig : wf2.26 ] ) , the wave consists of two parts : large one , which corresponds to the burst wave by the encounter by a test particle , and the other part with several oscillations , which comes from exited quasinormal modes in the spectrum .\",\n \"actually the waveform in the region after @xmath115 in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : wf2.26 ] is similar to kokkotas s result for a gaussian pulse wave @xcite . on the other hand , in a frequency region\",\n \"higher than @xmath114 , although many periodic peaks appear , those positions are not exactly the same as the frequencies of quasinormal \\\" modes .\",\n \"we may understand this fact as follows .\",\n \"even if the wave frequency @xmath116 is higher than the potential barrier , the reflection coefficient does not vanish and oscillates with respect to @xmath116 , which period is determined by the potential form . in the present case , we have also an infinite wall near the center of a star .\",\n \"we then expect that small periodic peaks appearing in the spectrum are due to an interference between the incoming and outgoing waves reflected by two potential barriers .\",\n \"since these waves decay very quickly as mentioned above , the process is quite dynamical , and then the peaks in the spectrum do not coincide with the frequencies of quasinormal \\\" modes . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26 - 2.3 ] , we show the energy spectra for two stellar models with @xmath117 , and @xmath118 , which correspond to the cases that the turning point is inside and outside the barrier , respectively . for fixed energy @xmath119 and angular momentum @xmath100\",\n \", the global peaks corresponding to the orbital frequency at the turning point agree with each other . on the other hand , the other small periodic peaks from the excited quasinormal modes do not agree with and rather depend on the compactness parameter @xmath91 . consequently , from the analysis of the energy spectrum of axial modes , we may determine the compactness parameter @xmath91 of an ultracompact star .\",\n \"we can also compare a black hole and an ultracompact star . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26bh ] , we show the energy spectra both for a black hole @xcite and an ultracompact star with @xmath120 . from fig .\",\n \"[ fig : rm2.26bh ] , we see that even for the case of a schwarzschild black hole , the global peak due to the orbital motion of the particle coincides with that for the star . however , unlike the stellar model ,\",\n \"no small periodic peaks appear in the case of a black hole .\",\n \"in fact for a black hole , there is no peak after @xmath115 ( see fig .\",\n \"this is because the effective potential of the star has an infinite potential wall near the center , which guarantees the existence of quasinormal modes , while that of a schwarzschild black hole has no such wall , and incoming waves fall entirely into the event horizon @xmath121 .\",\n \"hence , we can also distinguish a background object , i.e. , whether it is an ultracompact star or a black hole , analyzing only axial modes .\",\n \"as for the total energy of emitted gravitational waves @xmath122 , we find @xmath123 with @xmath124 and @xmath125 for @xmath126 and @xmath127 , respectively , and for @xmath128 and @xmath129 .\",\n \"the efficiency @xmath130 increases monotonically as the compactness gets smaller , and seems to end up with that for schwarzschild black holes ( @xmath131 ) . for @xmath132 and @xmath133 , the efficiency , which is @xmath134 ,\",\n \"little depends on @xmath135 up to the case of a black hole . from the analysis of the energy spectrum for a uniform density star , we find that the spectrum strongly depends on the shape of effective potential . therefore ,\",\n \"it may be important to see the dependence of the equation of state on the energy spectrum . then , in this section , we study a polytropic star . just for simplicity\",\n \", we use the newtonian polytropic equation of state as @xmath136 where @xmath137 is a polytropic index and @xmath138 is a constant value . first , we consider the first type stellar model with @xmath139 .\",\n \"we set the polytropic index @xmath140 and the constant @xmath141 , and choose the central energy density @xmath142 .\",\n \"this choice gives a stellar model with mass @xmath143 and radius @xmath144 .\",\n \"the compact parameter is @xmath145 , and then the surface locates outside the peak of the regge - wheeler potential .\",\n \"we show the energy spectra of gravitational waves from a scattering test particle in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : polytropic1.0 ] .\",\n \"we find the same feature as that for the uniform density star with @xmath146 , i.e. , there is only a single global peak which frequency corresponds to the orbital one of the particle at the turning point .\",\n \"next , we discuss the second type stellar model , i.e. , an ultracompact star . to construct an ultracompact star with a polytropic equation of state\",\n \", we set the polytropic index @xmath147 , the constant @xmath148 , and choose the central energy density @xmath149 , for which the compactness parameter @xmath135 turns out to be the smallest .\",\n \"for such a choice , the radius , mass , and compactness parameters of the star are @xmath150 , @xmath151 , and @xmath152 , respectively .\",\n \"although this seems very implausible for a realistic star , we will use this solution in our analysis to study the dependence of the equation of state on the energy spectrum . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : polytropic0.5 ] , we show the energy spectra for two trajectories of a test particle .\",\n \"one is the case that a particle goes into the inside of the potential barrier , while the other is the case that a particle passes through only outside the potential barrier .\",\n \"we find the same feature as that of the uniform density star with @xmath153 .\",\n \"the difference is found in the frequencies of quasinormal modes because of the different shapes of the potential .\",\n \"then , we find many small and sharp peaks in the spectrum at the positions different from those for a uniform density star .\",\n \"consequently , we may be able to distinguish the inside structure of an ultracompact star by observing the energy spectrum of emitted gravitational waves .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we have studied the axial modes of gravitational waves from a test particle scattered by a spherically symmetric relativistic star .\",\n \"we have considered both a uniform density star and a polytropic star .\",\n \"we find that the energy spectrum depends mainly on the shape of the effective potential for gravitational waves , i.e. , whether its minimum exists or not .\",\n \"when there is no minimum ( e.g. , a regular type of neutron star with a compactness parameter @xmath154 ) , the energy spectrum shows only a single global peak , which corresponds to the orbital frequency of a test particle at the turning point .\",\n \"gravitational waves are mostly emitted around the turning point , where the effect of the gravitational field is strongest . while if a minimum of the effective potential exists ( i.e. , some exotic relativistic star with small compactness parameter @xmath155 ) , the energy spectrum shows a variety in its structure in addition to the global peak as the same as that found in the previous case .\",\n \"we find small and sharp periodic peaks in the region lower than @xmath114 ( the maximum value of the effective potential ) , which correspond to an excitation of the axial quasinormal modes .\",\n \"the existence of the potential minimum allows the existence of a quasibound state of gravitational waves , i.e. , quasinormal modes .\",\n \"then those modes are excited by a scattered particle .\",\n \"this becomes more conspicuous when the particle gets into the inside region beyond the potential barrier .\",\n \"we also find small periodic peaks in the frequency region beyond @xmath114 , which may come from an interference between two waves reflected by the potential barrier and the infinite wall near the center of the star . from the observation of the energy spectrum of the axial mode ,\",\n \"what we can determine ? naively speaking , we may not find any information about the constituent of the star , because the axial mode does not couple to matter fluid .\",\n \"this is true for the first type stellar model , i.e. , a regular neutron star . emitted gravitational waves\",\n \"are mostly determined by the particle orbit .\",\n \"the case of black holes also belongs to this case , although there is a small difference in the high frequency part because of the difference of the boundary condition .\",\n \"however , if a star is compact enough to make a potential minimum ( @xmath156 ) , emitted gravitational waves show much more abundant information .\",\n \"it may determine a compactness parameter @xmath91 .\",\n \"we also find quasinormal mode frequencies , which depend on the shape of the potential , and then could depend on the equation of state . in the axial mode case , however , in general , we can not have direct information about the matter fluid , in particular about the equation of state .\",\n \"the polar mode of gravitational waves will provide us a more conspicuous dependence of matter property .\",\n \"work on the polar modes is under way .\",\n \"we would like to thank yasufumi kojima for kind suggestions at the beginning of this study .\",\n \"the numerical computations were mainly performed by the fujitsu - vx vector computer at the media network center , waseda university .\",\n \"this work was supported partially by a jsps grant - in - aid ( no . 5689 and specially promoted research no .\",\n \"08102010 ) , and by the waseda university grant for special research projects .\"\n ],\n [\n \"here , we present numerical techniques solving the wave equations .\",\n \"we improved borrelli s method@xcite to guarantee numerical accuracy .\",\n \"for the interior region , the numerical error of the wave function accumulates and becomes maximal at the surface , because the pressure vanishes there . in order to overcome this difficulty , we solve the wave equation both from the center and from the surface , and connect two wave functions at some inner point , e.g. ,\",\n \"@xmath157 . for the exterior solution\",\n \", we integrate the wave equation from the surface to infinity , by which we can reduce the numerical error . in the present model ,\",\n \"the test particle mainly emits gravitational waves at the turning point , where we have to solve the wave equation very carefully because an apparent divergence appears .\",\n \"we shall discuss these three methods in order .\",\n \"here we show how to solve the interior wave equation ( [ eq : inside_perturbation_equation ] ) . transforming the wave function @xmath33 to @xmath158\",\n \"we find the perturbation equation for @xmath159 as @xmath160 \\\\frac{dz_{l\\\\omega}}{dr } + e^{\\\\lambda - \\\\nu } \\\\left ( \\\\omega^2 -\\\\frac{2n}{r^2}e^{\\\\nu } \\\\right ) z_{l\\\\omega } = 0 .\",\n \"\\\\label{eq : near_center_z_equation}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] from the regularity condition at the center , we obtain the asymptotic behavior at @xmath161 as @xmath162 r^{l + 4 } + o(r^{l+6 } ) \\\\right\\\\ } , \\\\label{eq : near_center_z}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 are density , pressure , and metric functions evaluated at the center , respectively .\",\n \"in order to reduce the numerical error at the surface , we adopt the following procedure . then , we find two independent wave functions @xmath165 by integrating eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : near_center_z_equation ] ) from the surface to the middle point .\",\n \"the boundary conditions of those wave functions at the surface are given as @xmath166 , @xmath167 .\",\n \"by those two independent solutions , we construct the wave function @xmath168 as @xmath169 where the coefficients @xmath170 and @xmath171 are fixed by junction conditions at @xmath157 .\",\n \"since the wave functions constructed above must be continuous and smooth at @xmath157 , we find the junction conditions @xmath172 from these two conditions , we find @xmath170 and @xmath171 , and then the interior wave function @xmath159 .\",\n \"next we construct the exterior wave function . in order to use the green s function method\",\n \", we first consider the homogeneous wave function @xmath176 , which satisfies the wave equation @xmath177 and the boundary condition at the surface , which we have already evaluated in the previous subsection , that is , @xmath178 then , we construct a particular solution @xmath179 with a source term , which equation is described as @xmath180 where @xmath69 comes from the motion of a test particle . at the surface ,\",\n \"the solution @xmath179 satisfies the following condition : @xmath181 for the homogeneous equation ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_homogeneout ] ) , we have two independent solutions @xmath182 and @xmath183 , which correspond to outgoing and incoming waves at infinity , respectively .\",\n \"then , we describe the wave function @xmath176 by these two independent solutions as @xmath184 where @xmath185 and @xmath186 are complex constants , which are fixed by eqs .\",\n \"( [ boundary1 ] ) , ( [ boundary2 ] ) . the green s function @xmath187 for eq . ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_inhomogeneout ] ) is also constructed by @xmath188 and @xmath189 as @xmath190 \\\\theta(r^ { * } - s^ { * } ) \\\\qquad ( r^ { * } > s^{*}),\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath191 is the wronskian and @xmath192 is the heaviside function . the wave function @xmath193 is obtained by integration as @xmath194 then , the solution for the exterior wave equation ( [ eq : outside_perturbation_equation ] ) with the same boundary conditions as eqs .\",\n \"( [ boundary1 ] ) , ( [ boundary2 ] ) is given as @xmath195 the asymptotic behavior of @xmath196 as @xmath197 is given by @xmath198 where @xmath199 and @xmath200 are defined by @xmath201 since there is no incoming wave , we find the boundary condition such that @xmath202 then , the amplitude @xmath78 of gravitational waves at infinity is given by @xmath203 in order to extract the amplitude @xmath78 from our solution , we use the relation @xmath204 s_{lm\\\\omega}^{\\\\rm ( ext ) } ( s^ { * } ) ds^ { * } \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & = & \\\\frac{1}{w } \\\\int_{r^{*}}^{\\\\infty } x_{lm\\\\omega}^{\\\\rm ( ext)(0)}(s^ { * } ) s_{lm\\\\omega}^{\\\\rm ( ext ) } ( s^ { * } ) ds^{*}. \\\\label{eq : boundary_condition_infinity2}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] with eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : boundary_condition_infinity ] ) and ( [ eq : boundary_condition_infinity2 ] ) , we finally obtain the amplitude as @xmath205 where @xmath186 is already obtained up to an unknown constant @xmath206 , which is canceled out with that of @xmath176 in eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : amplitude_result ] ) when a test particle is scattered by a star , the orbit includes a turning point ( @xmath207 or @xmath208 by the tortoise coordinate ) , where the radial velocity @xmath209 vanishes .\",\n \"the source term @xmath69 in eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : amplitude_result ] ) is given by eq .\",\n \"( [ source ] ) , where @xmath210 and @xmath211 , defined by eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : def_q ] ) and ( [ eq : def_d ] ) , for the present orbit ( @xmath212 ) are described as @xmath213 where @xmath214 which is a normalization constant of a spherical harmonics @xmath215 , and @xmath216 is the associated legendre function .\",\n \"integration over the proper time @xmath217 gives the term of @xmath218 in eq .\",\n \"( [ d_lm ] ) , which diverges at the turning point , and then the integration @xmath219 diverges apparently\",\n \". however , this is not a physical divergence , but rather comes from the change of integration variables from the proper time @xmath217 to the radius @xmath15 .\",\n \"this transformation becomes singular at the turning point because @xmath220 . in order to avoid this difficulty ,\",\n \"we shall use a time coordinate @xmath221 in the integration .\",\n \"since the trajectory before and after the turning point is symmetric , we choose the initial position of the particle @xmath222 , @xmath223 at the turning point and integrate from there to infinity .\",\n \"the integral , eq .\",\n \"( [ integration ] ) , is then written as @xmath224 \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad + \\\\hat{r } \\\\left ( 1 - \\\\frac{2m}{\\\\hat{r } } \\\\right ) \\\\frac{1}{d \\\\hat{r}/ d \\\\hat{t } } \\\\frac{d x_{lm\\\\omega}^{\\\\rm ( ext)(0)}}{d \\\\hat{t } } s_{lm}^{(1 ) } ( \\\\hat{t } ) \\\\biggr ] , \\\\label{eq : source_term_integral_t } \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\hat{s}_{lm}^{(0 ) } = \\\\frac{8 \\\\pi}{\\\\tilde{e } } \\\\biggl [ \\\\sqrt{\\\\frac{2}{l(l + 1 ) } } \\\\left ( 1- \\\\frac{2m}{\\\\hat{r } } \\\\right)^2 \\\\hat{q}_{lm } \\\\nonumber \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad \\\\qquad + \\\\sqrt{\\\\frac{2}{l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\\\frac{2m}{\\\\hat{r } } \\\\left ( 1 - \\\\frac{2m}{\\\\hat{r } } \\\\right ) \\\\hat{d}_{lm } \\\\biggr ] , \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\hat{s}_{lm}^{(1 ) } = -\\\\frac{8 \\\\pi}{\\\\tilde{e } } \\\\sqrt{\\\\frac{2}{l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\\\left ( 1 - \\\\frac{2m}{\\\\hat{r } } \\\\right ) \\\\hat{d}_{lm } , \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\hat{q}_{lm } = - 2 i c_{lm } \\\\sqrt{\\\\frac{2}{l(l + 1 ) } } \\\\frac{\\\\mu \\\\tilde{l}}{\\\\hat{r}^3 ( 1 - 2m/\\\\hat{r } ) } \\\\gamma^{1/2 } \\\\frac{d p_{lm}}{d \\\\hat{\\\\theta } } \\\\left({\\\\pi\\\\over 2}\\\\right ) \\\\sin ( \\\\omega \\\\hat{t } - m \\\\hat{\\\\phi } ) , \\\\\\\\ & & \\\\qquad \\\\hat{d}_{lm } = \\\\frac{- 4imc_{lm}}{\\\\sqrt{2l(l + 1)(l - 1)(l + 2 ) } } \\\\frac{\\\\mu \\\\tilde{l}^2}{\\\\hat{r}^4 } \\\\frac{d p_{lm}}{d \\\\hat{\\\\theta}}\\\\left({\\\\pi\\\\over 2}\\\\right ) \\\\cos ( \\\\omega \\\\hat{t } - m \\\\hat{\\\\phi}),\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath225 and @xmath226 is its time derivative .\",\n \"however , the term in eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : source_term_integral_t ] ) , @xmath227 is still apparently divergent because @xmath228 vanishes at the turning point . to avoid this difficulty , we expand @xmath176 , @xmath229 near the turning point . from the equation of motion , we find @xmath230 which is integrated as @xmath231 where @xmath232 is an integration constant .\",\n \"then , we find the wave function near the turning point as @xmath233 where @xmath176 , @xmath234 , and @xmath235 at the turning point @xmath208 are found easily by integration of eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : outside_perturbation_eq_homogeneout ] ) .\",\n \"since those functions are regular at the turning point , we can evaluate eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : source_term_integral_t ] ) without any difficulty .\",\n \"see , for example , a. abramovici _\",\n \"et al . _ , science * 256 * , 325 ( 1992 ) , for ligo ; c. bradaschia _ et al . _ ,\",\n \"methods phys .\",\n \"a * 289 * , 518 ( 1990 ) , for virgo ; j. hough , in _ proceedings of the sixth marcel grossmann meeting _ , edited by h. sato and t. nakamura ( world scientific , singapore , 1992 ) , p. 192\",\n \", for geo600 ; k. kuroda _ et al .\",\n \"_ , in _ proceedings of international conference on gravitational waves : sources and detectors _ , edited by i. ciufolini and f. fidecaro ( world scientific , singapore , 1997 ) , p. 100\",\n \", for tama300 . .\",\n \"quasinormal \\\" modes for a uniform density star with @xmath236 .\",\n \"we use the continued fraction expansion method , which was first used to calculate black hole quasinormal modes by leaver [ 24 ] , and @xmath8 modes of a polytropic star by leins , nollert , and soffel [ 16 ] .\",\n \"our results agree quite well with those of kokkotas , who adopted a different method [ 20 ] .\",\n \"our imaginary part has opposite sign to kokkotas s result , because our definition of the fourier transformation is opposite to his . [\",\n \"cols=\\\"^,^,^,^ \\\" , ]\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":92,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"1007.4453"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["in recent years , there has been a growing interest in the topic of consensus decision making in several fields including animal behaviour @xcite , social sciences @xcite and control theory @xcite . in this paper","we use the paradigm of animal groups but we would like to stress already at this point that there is a considerable analogy between the decision - making processes in very different systems and we expect that our simple model should be applicable to a wider range of systems . our object of study is the phenomenon during which the animals moving in groups , seemingly make unanimous decisions on the choice and time of performing activities even in the absence of global leaders . it is expected that because of the heterogeneity in the attributes like the age , sex and social status of the animals in a group or the differences in their perception of external stimuli there will be differences in the motivations of the members at the time of making choices . however , in spite of the differences , synchronization is seen to take place .","examples include takeoff of swarm of honeybees from nest sites @xcite , activity synchronization in sheep @xcite , collective movement in monkeys @xcite , group departures of domestic geese @xcite and departure of ants from a feeding site @xcite .","the study of collective opinion formation in physics has mainly focused on human societies @xcite .","parallels have been drawn between phase transitions in magnets and the opinion dynamics in populations .","alternatively , the subject of collective motion of animal groups has been extensively modelled @xcite . here","point - like particles , representing animals , move with constant speed , each tending to align with its immediate neighbours , for low noise levels , giving rise to a globally ordered state replicating the motion of flocks where all animals move in the same direction . in this report","we model the process of landing of bird flocks performing foraging flights as a typical example of collective decision making .","we view this phenomena as a shift of the average opinion of the flock from that of continuing horizontal flight about some preferred altitude to that of descent towards the surface below .","we model the fact that birds land almost synchronously even in the presence of heterogeneity in motivations , along the lines of the random field ising model ( rfim ) @xcite .","our approach is similar to that used in @xcite where the authors analyze ( among other cases ) the manner in which people in concert halls , initially joining the applause , stop clapping almost at the same time . in a very recent model @xcite for collective landing ,","birds are assumed to move under the action of different _ social _ forces .","in addition , the internal state of each bird is characterized by a continuous variable called _ landing intent _ such that the internal state of each bird is directly coupled to the internal state of its neighbours .","in contrast we allow motivation of individual birds to be influenced by only the observable variables of their neighbours , like position and velocity .","in addition as a part of the model we introduce a method which enables us to work in open boundary conditions where the birds in flight move cohesively and do not spread out in the horizontal plane even in the presence of perturbations . with this model","we investigate the level of synchronicity in collective landing across time and space and explore the nature of fluctuations close to the point in time when landing occurs .","below we describe the two aspects of the model , _ viz . _ collective decision making and collective motion in detail .","the birds in our model are represented by particles characterized by the dynamical variables of position @xmath0 and velocity @xmath1 in three dimensional space .","the only _ natural _ boundary that we allow in the system is the @xmath2 plane which we consider to be the landing surface .","the @xmath3-coordinate of a flying bird gives its height above the ground .","we assign to each particle @xmath4 a variable @xmath5 such that we refer to a bird in the flying state as active ( @xmath6 ) and a bird in the landed state as inactive ( @xmath7 ) .","this variable is updated at discrete times @xmath8 according to the condition : @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the time increment . once a bird @xmath4","has landed we keep its position unchanged till the end of the simulation .","also , from here on we use the words `` bird '' and `` particle '' synonymously .","first we focus on the variables @xmath11 and @xmath12 governing the cruising motion of the birds parallel to the landing surface .","this motion is assumed to be essentially decoupled from the motion in the vertical direction and is modelled in the spirit of @xcite .","a particle @xmath4 is assumed to move , with some uncertainty , in the average direction of motion of all neighboring particles @xmath13 whose separation @xmath14 from @xmath4 is less than a interaction radius @xmath15 . from now on we refer to the set of particles in this neighbourhood as @xmath16 with respect to a particle @xmath4 such that , the inactive particles and the particle @xmath4 are included as well .","the expression for updating velocity at a time @xmath8 is given by @xmath17,\\ ] ] where @xmath18 is the magnitude of the velocity , @xmath19 is the rotation matrix in two dimensions representing a random perturbation by an angle @xmath20 and @xmath21 denotes the unit vector @xmath22 . here","@xmath20 is chosen with a uniform probability from the interval @xmath23 $ ] , where @xmath24 is the amplitude of the noise .","we describe the force - like term @xmath25 below .","we follow the standard version @xcite of the original spp model @xcite for the updating of positions : @xmath26 we mention here that it is a well - known problem with existing models of collective motion to maintain the cohesiveness of a moving flock in the presence of a finite amount of noise @xmath24 and with finite ranged ( as @xmath15 ) interaction between the members .","a flock tends to break up into smaller sub - flocks which eventually move in independent directions .","a periodic boundary condition ( pbc ) is used to prevent the flock from spreading out perpendicular to the direction of motion . however , in the problem of landing we find that the imposition of a pbc would be unrealistic in the sense that there will be a possibility of a particle that has become inactive and hence ceased to move , to continually exchange information with the rest of the moving flock .","therefore , we introduce a new kind of `` comoving boundary '' condition where we imagine the motion of the particles on the @xmath27-plane to be governed by a circular bounding region with radius @xmath28 and the centre lying on the centre of mass ( _ com _ ) of all active particles ( mass of each assumed to be unity ) .","this boundary therefore translates with the flock as the _ com _ is put into motion due to collective motion of the particles .","when a particle which is inside the region tries to leave it , the particle is subjected to an attraction proportional to the distance from the boundary .","the direction of this attraction is along the resultant of the direction towards the location of the _ com _ and the direction of motion of the _ com _ itself . for a particle located at @xmath29 at an instant of time , the attraction @xmath30 is given by : @xmath31\\mathbf{c}\\big(\\mathbf{x^{\\shortparallel}}\\big ) & \\mbox { if $ |\\mathbf{x}^{\\shortparallel}-\\mathbf{\\overline{x}}^{\\shortparallel}| > r_\\mathrm{b}$ } \\\\ 0 & \\mbox { otherwise , } \\end{array } \\right.\\ ] ] with @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the strength of the attraction , @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the position and the velocity of the _ com _ , respectively , parallel to the @xmath27-plane at that instant and @xmath36 is a parameter . the _ com _ and its velocity","are calculated with respect to the active particles . in the figure [ field ] we plot","@xmath25 when the motion of the _ com _ is in a direction parallel to the y - axis .","similarly , we assume that the boundary adjusts itself to keep average separation between active particles constant .","thus , in general @xmath28 is a function of time , given by , @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the fraction of the active particles at time @xmath8 and @xmath39 is the number of particles , initially active , per unit area of the @xmath27-plane . on the @xmath27-plane , defined through ( [ bound-1 ] ) for the value of @xmath40 .","the direction of motion of the _ com _ is assumed to be along the y - axis , indicated by the arrow at the centre of the circle .","the length of a vector is directly proportional to the distance from the boundary .",", width=340 ] now we explain how the collective decision making process takes place in the flock and how it is related to the cohesion and eventual landing along the vertical direction .","we characterize the decision of an individual bird as a binary choice problem @xcite . to each bird","@xmath4 we assign an internal state variable @xmath41 such that when @xmath42 the bird continues to cruise above ground and when @xmath43 the bird decides to land . for the cruising state","we assume that a bird likes to fly about an altitude @xmath44 on average without deviating too far above or below .","however , we expect the elevation of a bird to fluctuate with time pertaining to factors like the noise in the medium and collision avoidance .","thus when @xmath42 we consider the vertical motion of the particle to be essentially a random walk bounded by imaginary walls at @xmath45 and @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the thickness of the flock . in case the bird decides to land the vertical motion is directed towards the landing surface at @xmath2 .","formally we define , @xmath48 & \\textrm{if $ s_i(t)=1 $ and $ |\\delta(t-\\delta t)|>\\delta z_0/2 $ } \\\\","-v & \\textrm{if $ s_i(t)=-1 $ , } \\end{array}\\right.\\ ] ] where @xmath49 takes values @xmath50 with equal probability and @xmath51 , is the amount of deviation from the height @xmath44 at time @xmath52 . to model the motivational differences in birds we assign to each bird @xmath4 , an inherent switching time @xmath53 @xcite such that if the bird begins an isolated flight at time @xmath54 , it would decide to land at time @xmath55 .","we assume that the value of @xmath53 for the bird @xmath4 will in general depend on its energy reserves @xcite and thus in general will be different for different birds .","we choose @xmath53 s from a gaussian distribution with a given standard deviation @xmath56 .","the value of @xmath56 allows us to control the level of heterogeneity in a flock .","although we assign _ a priori _ values of @xmath53 to birds , due to the randomness in the choice of these switching times , they can be thought to be additionally include the effect of the environment such as quality of foraging patches over which the flocks fly . for a particle in the flock",", it will have a finite number of particles in its neighbourhood and therefore will be influenced by their actions while taking a decision .","hence the internal state of a particle will be a function of two competing factors , ( i ) its inherent switching time and ( ii ) the internal state of the neighbours , which we assume to be reflected by the nature of their motion . in an approach similar to that of the rfim at zero temperature @xcite we write down : @xmath57\\ ] ] where @xmath58 is the propensity of a particle to follow the decision of its neighbours and @xmath59 is the _ local mean field _ through which the bird @xmath4 senses the average decision in its neighbourhood @xmath16 .","we expect that the inclination of a bird @xmath4 to land will be enhanced by a resultant motion of birds in @xmath16 towards the landing surface , and also by the number of birds that have already landed .","we define @xmath59 at a time @xmath8 as : @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 are the average value of @xmath3-component of velocity of active particles and fraction of active particles , respectively , in the neighbourhood @xmath16 at time @xmath8 . at times","@xmath63 , the birds on average have no inclination to land and therefore we expect them to maintain a height around @xmath64 without any resultant vertical motion towards the landing surface .","in this regime we expect for any particle @xmath4 , @xmath65 and also , @xmath66 , implying that @xmath67 .","on the other hand a resultant vertical motion in negative @xmath3-direction would imply @xmath68 .","thus in a regime when majority move towards the landing surface at @xmath2 and eventually reach inactive states , we expect @xmath69 .","we now move on to characterize the resulting collective landing as a function of different states of collective motion .","_ we would like to emphasize at this point that although the detailed description of our model involves specifying nine expressions , the essential concept and the ingredients of the model are rather simple ( spp + rfim ) and the number of independent parameters is low ( @xmath24 , @xmath15 , @xmath70 , @xmath58)_.","we note that in our model , the shape of a coherently moving flock , far from the landing regime , is roughly cylindrical with a radius of cross section @xmath71 and thickness @xmath47 .","we argue that from the point of view of our model for large flocks @xmath47 will have in general weak or no dependence on the number of birds .","we choose the thickness of the flock @xmath47 as the unit to measure distances ( @xmath72 ) .","we choose the projected density @xmath73 , the interaction radius @xmath74 and the preferred altitude of flying @xmath75 . in our simulations","we take @xmath76 , unless mentioned otherwise , the order of which is typical for moderately large flocks @xcite .","also the ratio @xmath77 would be typical in these flocks which have thickness of order @xmath78 m and fly at altitudes of around @xmath79 m. at the time @xmath54 in ( [ rfim ] ) we expect the flock to be already in the steady state of collective motion .","so before we switch on time as in ( [ rfim ] ) we evolve a flock to its steady state of motion according to equations ( [ eom - xy ] ) , ( [ eq_snm_pos ] ) and ( [ spin ] ) where each particle @xmath4 has @xmath42 .","it is known @xcite that the nature of the collective motion depends on the amplitude of the noise .","we find that for sufficiently low values of @xmath24 , all the particles align their directions and the flock as a whole translates in some spontaneously chosen direction parallel to the @xmath27-plane . as the value of @xmath24","is increased , the tendency of alignment is gradually lost leading to weak or no translation .","however , the actual nature of this transition is not known precisely enough and its detailed investigation is outside of the scope of the present paper .","we make an observation that there are two independent time scales in the problem - the time scale of motion and the time scale over which the inherent switching times are distributed .","the former is given by @xmath80 which is the time required to move one unit of length ( or half interaction radius @xmath81 ) .","in presence of finite amount of noise @xmath24 , this time scale would also govern the mixing between particles .","the width of the distribution of @xmath53 s ( @xmath82 ) gives a measure of the time over which the energy reserves of the majority in the flock are exhausted .","therefore , when @xmath83 , there is hardly any motion during the collective decision making .","when @xmath84 the flock actually translates ( at low values of @xmath24 ) over a long distance during the process .","we call the ratio of these two time scales as @xmath85 , where @xmath86 , and we investigate the nature of landing at its different values .","we set the time scale for choosing values of @xmath18 and @xmath56 as the time increment @xmath87 .","the value of magnitude of velocity @xmath18 is kept around and below @xmath88 so that change in the set of neighbours @xmath16 of any bird @xmath4 is gradual .","we choose the value of the parameters for the comoving boundary described by equations ( [ bound-1 ] ) and ( [ bound-2 ] ) to be @xmath89 and @xmath90 .","we also observe that parameter @xmath36 controls the degree of asymmetry of the vector field @xmath91 ( [ bound-2 ] ) outside the comoving boundary . for @xmath92","the system enters into a rotating phase @xcite , and for @xmath93 the flock has a tendency to accumulate at the boundary . the role played by the coupling @xmath58 in ( [ rfim ] )","is well known @xcite and has also been the matter of investigation . however ,","in our model we fix @xmath58 to an optimal value for which we find the desired behaviour , as explained below . in the figure [ trans - land](a )","we compare the process of landing across time for different values of the coupling . for a flock with inherent switching times @xmath94 chosen with a fixed @xmath56","we monitor the fraction of active particles @xmath95 with time @xmath8 for different values of @xmath58 .","we observe that when @xmath96 the particles become inactive independent of each other at their own switching times as seen from the curve @xmath97 which falls smoothly with time . on choosing @xmath98","the behaviour is quite opposite .","a very sharp fall occurs in the curve @xmath99 implying that there is indeed a collective decision making taking place when a large number of particles reach inactive states within a short period of time .","however , comparing the two curves @xmath97 and @xmath99 it appears that in the latter case , the collective landing occurs at point in time which is much larger than ( by an amount of order @xmath56 ) than the switching times of most of the birds .","we find that a much lower value of @xmath100 is relevant biologically .","the curve @xmath101 sharply falls indicating collective behaviour and the fall occurs near at a time when about half of the birds have just crossed their inherent switching times . in the figure [ trans - land](a )","we also plot @xmath102 which is the fraction of birds which have a momentary intention to land at time @xmath8 _","i.e. _ , the fraction of particles with @xmath43 . unlike @xmath101 , the quantity @xmath102 is seen to fluctuate before becoming equal to the maximum value unity .","this shows that before finally deciding to land , birds may intermittently change their decision .","this is caused by the fluctuations in the vertical motion ( [ spin ] ) of neighbours as well as the changing neighbourhood due to finite value of @xmath24 .","however , these fluctuations become only important near the landing regime .","we explore an aspect of these fluctuations later . in the figure [ trans - land](b )","we plot the velocity field of a typical flock when the majority has decided to land .","denotes the fraction of birds not landed yet as the time @xmath8 progresses .","the curves @xmath97 , @xmath101 and @xmath99 correspond to values of coupling @xmath103 and @xmath104 , respectively . also , @xmath102 shows the fraction of birds in state @xmath43 at time @xmath8 for @xmath100 .","( b ) a snapshot of a collective landing of a bird flock with @xmath105 and @xmath106 with @xmath107 and @xmath100 . the arrowheads point in the direction of the velocity of the birds . , width=566 ] ) of actual landing times to the standard deviation ( @xmath56 ) of inherent switching times as a function of noise @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 , _","i.e. _ , @xmath56 scaled by the scale of motion @xmath108 , as indicated by different symbols .","inset ( a ) shows variation of @xmath109 _ i.e. _ , @xmath70 scaled by @xmath108 , with noise .","inset ( b ) shows the variation of @xmath110 which ignores the first and last @xmath111 of the landings .","( b ) the variation of the spread of the landed flock over the @xmath27-plane , relative to the spread at time @xmath54 , as a function of noise .",", width=566 ] below we quantify the extent to which the presence of the coupling affects the collectiveness in landing as we vary the scaled value of the heterogeneity ( @xmath85 ) .","we define a measure of the sharpness of the decrease in the fraction of active particles @xmath112 ( figure [ trans - land ] ) . during the process of landing ,","we record the times at which individual particles become inactive .","then we calculate the standard deviation @xmath70 of the distribution of these landing times .","finally , we divide @xmath70 by @xmath56 to get the normalized measure .","the dimensionless quantity @xmath113 averaged over different realizations of @xmath114 s , provides a measure of the extent to which the landing of the flock is coherent in time such that @xmath115 implies the complete absence of collective decision making . in the figure [ t2080-r](a )","we plot @xmath113 versus @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 .","we make the following observations . for @xmath116","the flock reaches consensus almost in the absence of any motion . as a result","there is no variation of @xmath113 with the magnitude of noise . in this regime","the value of @xmath70 is governed by the spread of the flock in the steady state along the vertical direction _","i.e. _ , @xmath47",". therefore we expect that @xmath117 . in the inset ( a ) of the figure [ t2080-r](a )","we plot the ratio @xmath118 against @xmath24 .","it is worth mentioning that the quantity @xmath109 provides an alternate normalization of @xmath70 with respect to the other independent time scale @xmath108(@xmath119 ) .","we find that for @xmath85 close to unity , @xmath120 asserting that the landing is coherent and the separation between landing times is due to the width @xmath47 . for larger values of @xmath85","the value of @xmath113 also becomes large signifying gradual loss of coherence .","we also observe that in general @xmath113 has a maximum for intermediate values of the noise .","we find that if we choose to ignore the particles which become inactive either too early or too late , then the level of temporal coherence appears better . for a particular landing","we measure the times @xmath121 and @xmath122 at which @xmath111 and @xmath123 of the particles , respectively , in the flock has just become inactive .","thus we define , @xmath124 as the width of the time window in which a majority _ i.e. _ , @xmath125 of the particles become inactive .","we normalize @xmath126 by the corresponding time window ( @xmath127 ) for a flock with the coupling @xmath96 . in the inset ( b ) of the figure [ t2080-r](a )","we plot @xmath110 versus @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 .","the average behaviour reveals a level of coherence such that two birds originally having their inherent switching times separated by @xmath127 land within a period of around @xmath128 of @xmath127 .","we investigate the degree of collectiveness as a function of the distance over which a flock lands in figure [ t2080-r](b ) .","we calculate the following quantity : @xmath129 this quantifies the spread of the flock across the landing surface .","we normalize the value of this spread ( @xmath130 ) when all particles become inactive by the corresponding value ( @xmath131 ) calculated with the positions of the active particles at time @xmath54 . in the figure [ t2080-r](b )","we plot @xmath132 as function of noise varying values of @xmath85 . for low and moderate values of @xmath85 ,","the value of @xmath132 is of the order of unity .","the landing occurs over a region whose dimensions are comparable to dimensions of the flock . we observe that in the regime of large @xmath85 , the value of noise plays a major role in deciding the overall nature of landing .","for very low values of @xmath24 the flock translates over large distances . due to this translation ,","the particles reaching inactive states early are unable to influence the decision of the active particles in the flock as the _ com _ moves away from these particles . in this case","the landing occurs in few large clusters separated in space and time . in case of higher values of the noise there","is weak or no translation of the _ com_. however , the scale of the difference in inherent switching times _ i.e. _ , @xmath56 being very slow as compared to the scale of motion , it provides the scope for a particle with a low value of @xmath53 to diffuse to the boundary . as a result , temporarily the influence of the neighbourhood is weakened .","this allows the particle to switch its state and become inactive .","initially , the excursions of the particles to the comoving boundary becomes the reason behind independent landings .","the shrinking of the boundary ( [ rb ] ) effectively screens ( depending upon the interaction radius @xmath15 ) the active particles from the inactive particles . for moderate values of @xmath24 the path of the _ com _ becomes tortuous .","however , the effect of segregation of inactive particles from the active particles still persists .","the landing occurs in large number of smaller clusters .","we further characterize the above behaviour by the following definition .","after the landing we calculate the _ com _ of the particles positioned on the @xmath27-plane .","we define the measure of spatial coherence @xmath133 as the fraction of particles that lie within a distance @xmath134 from the _","com_. formally , @xmath135 where , @xmath136 is the position of the @xmath4-th inactive particle , @xmath34 is the position of the _ com _ and @xmath137 is the heaviside step function .","we expect from the above observations that @xmath133 is close to unity for a spatially coherent landing and zero in the opposite case .","( b ) , has landed .","the line shows the trajectory of the centre of mass of the birds in flight .","the arrows indicate the average direction of motion of the centre of mass at different points in time .","the circle drawn is centred on the centre of mass of all landed birds and is drawn with the radius @xmath138 of the comoving boundary .","( b ) the measure of spatial coherence @xmath133 as a function of @xmath85 for the value of @xmath139 .","different symbols indicate the system sizes @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 , and @xmath143 .","inset ( a ) shows the plots with @xmath85 rescaled to @xmath144 . inset ( b ) shows the variation of @xmath145 with system size @xmath146.,width=566 ] ) of the standard deviation of the actual landing times as function of the scaled values ( @xmath85 ) of the standard deviation of the assigned switching times for different system sizes ( @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 and @xmath143 ) indicated by different symbols .","inset ( a ) shows the collapse of the previous plots as result of transformation of the horizontal axis from @xmath85 to @xmath147 with @xmath148 and @xmath149 .","inset ( b ) shows the variation of the ratio @xmath113 with @xmath85 .","( b ) the variation of @xmath109 as a function of the interaction radius @xmath15 for different values of @xmath150 , @xmath151 and @xmath152 as indicated by different symbols , in flocks of size @xmath76 .","the value of @xmath24 in both ( a ) and ( b ) is @xmath153.,width=566 ] in the figure [ com - psi](a ) we plot the positions of the birds on the @xmath27-plane after all the birds have landed .","the line shows the trajectory of the _ com _ and the circle is drawn with the radius @xmath138 about the centre of mass calculated with the final positions of the landed birds .","majority of the birds lying within the circle shows that in such a case spatial coherence is retained . in the figure [ com - psi](b ) we plot @xmath133 as function of @xmath85 for the value of @xmath139 .","the different plots corresponds to different system sizes .","the decrease in @xmath133 with increase in @xmath85 is consistent with all the previous observations . in the inset ( a ) of the figure [ com - psi](b )","we obtain a collapse of the data after rescaling @xmath85 by @xmath145 .","the variation of @xmath154 with the system size @xmath146 , as shown in the inset ( b ) , is found to be @xmath155 where @xmath156 ( we note that the dimension of the flock varies as @xmath157 ) .","this relation suggests that with the increase in the system size there is an increase in the value of @xmath85 below which spatial coherence is expected .","we investigate the dependence on system size of the temporal behaviour in the next paragraph .","in the figure [ t - r](a ) we plot @xmath109 versus @xmath85 for four different system sizes for value of noise @xmath139 .","the figure reveals how the spread in actual landing times increases with the value of @xmath85 . a data collapse in the inset ( a ) reveals a scaling relation of the form : @xmath158^{\\frac{1}{n^\\alpha } } , \\label{lambda - scale}\\ ] ] with @xmath148 and @xmath149 . in general , we expect @xmath159 to be function of the parameters like @xmath39 and @xmath15 .","the equation ( [ lambda - scale ] ) suggests that for a fixed value of @xmath85 , with the increase in the system size there is increase in temporal coherence .","we also plot the corresponding values of the ratio @xmath113 in the inset ( b ) .","the plot shows how this ratio approaches the maximum value unity with the increase in the value of @xmath85 .","the reason for the rise in @xmath113 for very low values of @xmath85 is already stated with respect to the figure [ t2080-r](a ) . in all the above investigations we have assumed that the interaction radius controlling the average number of neighbours of any particle is @xmath74 .","we now address the issue of having larger ( or smaller ) interaction radii . in the figure [ t - r](b )","we plot the variation of @xmath109 with the value of @xmath15 for different values of @xmath85 with value of noise set at @xmath139 .","we find significant decrease in the spread @xmath109 for large values of @xmath15 .","this suggests that global information can lead to a more coherent decision making process . of the maximum depth @xmath160 of excursions below the flock by birds , before returning to the flock as a result of temporarily reverting from the decision to land .","the parameter sets indicated by symbols are @xmath161 , @xmath162 ( circles ) and @xmath106 , @xmath107 ( squares ) . the solid line has a slope @xmath163 and is a guide to the eye .","( b ) the probability density function @xmath164 of the distance travelled by the centre of mass of birds in flight , @xmath165 between consecutive time steps .","the parameter sets indicated by symbols are same as in the case of ( a ) .","the measured slopes of the power - law fits to the curves are around @xmath166 . in both (","a ) and ( b ) the value of @xmath167 , @xmath168 and the magnitude of the velocity @xmath18 controls the lower cut - off of the power - law decays.,width=529 ]","lastly , we focus on the nature of fluctuations during the landing process . as a result of the decision reversals in birds under the influence from the neighbourhood ( as reflected by @xmath102 in the figure [ trans - land](a ) )","we find that birds originally moving towards the landing surface sometimes return back to the cruising altitude .","we characterize these fluctuations by the maximum depth @xmath160 to which a bird makes an excursion before returning to an altitude greater than @xmath169 . in the figure [ aval - dcm](a )","we plot the probability density @xmath170 .","we find that the distribution of @xmath160 is a power - law decay bounded by a minimum and maximum governed by the magnitude of velocity @xmath18 and the maximum possible depth @xmath44 , respectively .","we also study the jumps that occur in position of the _ com _","( on the @xmath27 plane ) of flying birds once the landing process starts .","as is seen from the figure [ com - psi](a ) the trajectory of the _ com _ becomes irregular near the end .","the _ com _ actually jumps from a cluster which ceases to move to a cluster which continues moving .","we construct the probability density @xmath164 for the separation @xmath165 between the centres of mass at two consecutive time steps .","we find that @xmath164 has a fat tail during the landing process . in the figure [ aval - dcm](b )","we plot the tail of @xmath164 after binning .","the plots reveals power law decays with close by exponents .","the power law has a cut - off which governed by @xmath138 .","in this paper we have investigated the interplay between the dynamics of collective motion and collective decision making . in particular","we have presented a model for landing of bird flocks .","we have identified the relevant scales in such a problem and we have worked in the coupling regime which is expected to be biologically relevant .","it appears that higher values of the coupling delays the process of the global opinion shift .","we have characterized the degree of the resulting collective behaviour by different measures .","we found that as a function of the few parameters of our model the collective switching from the flying to the landing state is indeed much sharper than the distribution of the individual ( inherent ) landing intentions . among the several interesting features of the model we proposed",", we showed that if the flock is subject to larger fluctuations , the spatial spreading of the fully landed flock becomes smaller due to a better mixing of the information about the momentary landing intentions of the birds .","we also find that there is a characteristic value of heterogeneity which scales with the size of the flock .","below this value of heterogeneity , flocks remain spatially coherent in the process of landing and above this value , the coherence is lost .","in addition we have formulated a boundary condition which is pertinent to models of flocking .","we believe that the approach we proposed is also relevant for many other systems where abrupt behavioural changes are observed .","possible applications include various kinds of animal or even robotic groups in which an almost instantaneous global switching to a new desired state takes place .","99 conradt l and roper t j 2005 _ trends ecol",". evol . _ * 20 * 449"],"string":"[\n \"in recent years , there has been a growing interest in the topic of consensus decision making in several fields including animal behaviour @xcite , social sciences @xcite and control theory @xcite . in this paper\",\n \"we use the paradigm of animal groups but we would like to stress already at this point that there is a considerable analogy between the decision - making processes in very different systems and we expect that our simple model should be applicable to a wider range of systems . our object of study is the phenomenon during which the animals moving in groups , seemingly make unanimous decisions on the choice and time of performing activities even in the absence of global leaders . it is expected that because of the heterogeneity in the attributes like the age , sex and social status of the animals in a group or the differences in their perception of external stimuli there will be differences in the motivations of the members at the time of making choices . however , in spite of the differences , synchronization is seen to take place .\",\n \"examples include takeoff of swarm of honeybees from nest sites @xcite , activity synchronization in sheep @xcite , collective movement in monkeys @xcite , group departures of domestic geese @xcite and departure of ants from a feeding site @xcite .\",\n \"the study of collective opinion formation in physics has mainly focused on human societies @xcite .\",\n \"parallels have been drawn between phase transitions in magnets and the opinion dynamics in populations .\",\n \"alternatively , the subject of collective motion of animal groups has been extensively modelled @xcite . here\",\n \"point - like particles , representing animals , move with constant speed , each tending to align with its immediate neighbours , for low noise levels , giving rise to a globally ordered state replicating the motion of flocks where all animals move in the same direction . in this report\",\n \"we model the process of landing of bird flocks performing foraging flights as a typical example of collective decision making .\",\n \"we view this phenomena as a shift of the average opinion of the flock from that of continuing horizontal flight about some preferred altitude to that of descent towards the surface below .\",\n \"we model the fact that birds land almost synchronously even in the presence of heterogeneity in motivations , along the lines of the random field ising model ( rfim ) @xcite .\",\n \"our approach is similar to that used in @xcite where the authors analyze ( among other cases ) the manner in which people in concert halls , initially joining the applause , stop clapping almost at the same time . in a very recent model @xcite for collective landing ,\",\n \"birds are assumed to move under the action of different _ social _ forces .\",\n \"in addition , the internal state of each bird is characterized by a continuous variable called _ landing intent _ such that the internal state of each bird is directly coupled to the internal state of its neighbours .\",\n \"in contrast we allow motivation of individual birds to be influenced by only the observable variables of their neighbours , like position and velocity .\",\n \"in addition as a part of the model we introduce a method which enables us to work in open boundary conditions where the birds in flight move cohesively and do not spread out in the horizontal plane even in the presence of perturbations . with this model\",\n \"we investigate the level of synchronicity in collective landing across time and space and explore the nature of fluctuations close to the point in time when landing occurs .\",\n \"below we describe the two aspects of the model , _ viz . _ collective decision making and collective motion in detail .\",\n \"the birds in our model are represented by particles characterized by the dynamical variables of position @xmath0 and velocity @xmath1 in three dimensional space .\",\n \"the only _ natural _ boundary that we allow in the system is the @xmath2 plane which we consider to be the landing surface .\",\n \"the @xmath3-coordinate of a flying bird gives its height above the ground .\",\n \"we assign to each particle @xmath4 a variable @xmath5 such that we refer to a bird in the flying state as active ( @xmath6 ) and a bird in the landed state as inactive ( @xmath7 ) .\",\n \"this variable is updated at discrete times @xmath8 according to the condition : @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the time increment . once a bird @xmath4\",\n \"has landed we keep its position unchanged till the end of the simulation .\",\n \"also , from here on we use the words `` bird '' and `` particle '' synonymously .\",\n \"first we focus on the variables @xmath11 and @xmath12 governing the cruising motion of the birds parallel to the landing surface .\",\n \"this motion is assumed to be essentially decoupled from the motion in the vertical direction and is modelled in the spirit of @xcite .\",\n \"a particle @xmath4 is assumed to move , with some uncertainty , in the average direction of motion of all neighboring particles @xmath13 whose separation @xmath14 from @xmath4 is less than a interaction radius @xmath15 . from now on we refer to the set of particles in this neighbourhood as @xmath16 with respect to a particle @xmath4 such that , the inactive particles and the particle @xmath4 are included as well .\",\n \"the expression for updating velocity at a time @xmath8 is given by @xmath17,\\\\ ] ] where @xmath18 is the magnitude of the velocity , @xmath19 is the rotation matrix in two dimensions representing a random perturbation by an angle @xmath20 and @xmath21 denotes the unit vector @xmath22 . here\",\n \"@xmath20 is chosen with a uniform probability from the interval @xmath23 $ ] , where @xmath24 is the amplitude of the noise .\",\n \"we describe the force - like term @xmath25 below .\",\n \"we follow the standard version @xcite of the original spp model @xcite for the updating of positions : @xmath26 we mention here that it is a well - known problem with existing models of collective motion to maintain the cohesiveness of a moving flock in the presence of a finite amount of noise @xmath24 and with finite ranged ( as @xmath15 ) interaction between the members .\",\n \"a flock tends to break up into smaller sub - flocks which eventually move in independent directions .\",\n \"a periodic boundary condition ( pbc ) is used to prevent the flock from spreading out perpendicular to the direction of motion . however , in the problem of landing we find that the imposition of a pbc would be unrealistic in the sense that there will be a possibility of a particle that has become inactive and hence ceased to move , to continually exchange information with the rest of the moving flock .\",\n \"therefore , we introduce a new kind of `` comoving boundary '' condition where we imagine the motion of the particles on the @xmath27-plane to be governed by a circular bounding region with radius @xmath28 and the centre lying on the centre of mass ( _ com _ ) of all active particles ( mass of each assumed to be unity ) .\",\n \"this boundary therefore translates with the flock as the _ com _ is put into motion due to collective motion of the particles .\",\n \"when a particle which is inside the region tries to leave it , the particle is subjected to an attraction proportional to the distance from the boundary .\",\n \"the direction of this attraction is along the resultant of the direction towards the location of the _ com _ and the direction of motion of the _ com _ itself . for a particle located at @xmath29 at an instant of time , the attraction @xmath30 is given by : @xmath31\\\\mathbf{c}\\\\big(\\\\mathbf{x^{\\\\shortparallel}}\\\\big ) & \\\\mbox { if $ |\\\\mathbf{x}^{\\\\shortparallel}-\\\\mathbf{\\\\overline{x}}^{\\\\shortparallel}| > r_\\\\mathrm{b}$ } \\\\\\\\ 0 & \\\\mbox { otherwise , } \\\\end{array } \\\\right.\\\\ ] ] with @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the strength of the attraction , @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the position and the velocity of the _ com _ , respectively , parallel to the @xmath27-plane at that instant and @xmath36 is a parameter . the _ com _ and its velocity\",\n \"are calculated with respect to the active particles . in the figure [ field ] we plot\",\n \"@xmath25 when the motion of the _ com _ is in a direction parallel to the y - axis .\",\n \"similarly , we assume that the boundary adjusts itself to keep average separation between active particles constant .\",\n \"thus , in general @xmath28 is a function of time , given by , @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the fraction of the active particles at time @xmath8 and @xmath39 is the number of particles , initially active , per unit area of the @xmath27-plane . on the @xmath27-plane , defined through ( [ bound-1 ] ) for the value of @xmath40 .\",\n \"the direction of motion of the _ com _ is assumed to be along the y - axis , indicated by the arrow at the centre of the circle .\",\n \"the length of a vector is directly proportional to the distance from the boundary .\",\n \", width=340 ] now we explain how the collective decision making process takes place in the flock and how it is related to the cohesion and eventual landing along the vertical direction .\",\n \"we characterize the decision of an individual bird as a binary choice problem @xcite . to each bird\",\n \"@xmath4 we assign an internal state variable @xmath41 such that when @xmath42 the bird continues to cruise above ground and when @xmath43 the bird decides to land . for the cruising state\",\n \"we assume that a bird likes to fly about an altitude @xmath44 on average without deviating too far above or below .\",\n \"however , we expect the elevation of a bird to fluctuate with time pertaining to factors like the noise in the medium and collision avoidance .\",\n \"thus when @xmath42 we consider the vertical motion of the particle to be essentially a random walk bounded by imaginary walls at @xmath45 and @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the thickness of the flock . in case the bird decides to land the vertical motion is directed towards the landing surface at @xmath2 .\",\n \"formally we define , @xmath48 & \\\\textrm{if $ s_i(t)=1 $ and $ |\\\\delta(t-\\\\delta t)|>\\\\delta z_0/2 $ } \\\\\\\\\",\n \"-v & \\\\textrm{if $ s_i(t)=-1 $ , } \\\\end{array}\\\\right.\\\\ ] ] where @xmath49 takes values @xmath50 with equal probability and @xmath51 , is the amount of deviation from the height @xmath44 at time @xmath52 . to model the motivational differences in birds we assign to each bird @xmath4 , an inherent switching time @xmath53 @xcite such that if the bird begins an isolated flight at time @xmath54 , it would decide to land at time @xmath55 .\",\n \"we assume that the value of @xmath53 for the bird @xmath4 will in general depend on its energy reserves @xcite and thus in general will be different for different birds .\",\n \"we choose @xmath53 s from a gaussian distribution with a given standard deviation @xmath56 .\",\n \"the value of @xmath56 allows us to control the level of heterogeneity in a flock .\",\n \"although we assign _ a priori _ values of @xmath53 to birds , due to the randomness in the choice of these switching times , they can be thought to be additionally include the effect of the environment such as quality of foraging patches over which the flocks fly . for a particle in the flock\",\n \", it will have a finite number of particles in its neighbourhood and therefore will be influenced by their actions while taking a decision .\",\n \"hence the internal state of a particle will be a function of two competing factors , ( i ) its inherent switching time and ( ii ) the internal state of the neighbours , which we assume to be reflected by the nature of their motion . in an approach similar to that of the rfim at zero temperature @xcite we write down : @xmath57\\\\ ] ] where @xmath58 is the propensity of a particle to follow the decision of its neighbours and @xmath59 is the _ local mean field _ through which the bird @xmath4 senses the average decision in its neighbourhood @xmath16 .\",\n \"we expect that the inclination of a bird @xmath4 to land will be enhanced by a resultant motion of birds in @xmath16 towards the landing surface , and also by the number of birds that have already landed .\",\n \"we define @xmath59 at a time @xmath8 as : @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 are the average value of @xmath3-component of velocity of active particles and fraction of active particles , respectively , in the neighbourhood @xmath16 at time @xmath8 . at times\",\n \"@xmath63 , the birds on average have no inclination to land and therefore we expect them to maintain a height around @xmath64 without any resultant vertical motion towards the landing surface .\",\n \"in this regime we expect for any particle @xmath4 , @xmath65 and also , @xmath66 , implying that @xmath67 .\",\n \"on the other hand a resultant vertical motion in negative @xmath3-direction would imply @xmath68 .\",\n \"thus in a regime when majority move towards the landing surface at @xmath2 and eventually reach inactive states , we expect @xmath69 .\",\n \"we now move on to characterize the resulting collective landing as a function of different states of collective motion .\",\n \"_ we would like to emphasize at this point that although the detailed description of our model involves specifying nine expressions , the essential concept and the ingredients of the model are rather simple ( spp + rfim ) and the number of independent parameters is low ( @xmath24 , @xmath15 , @xmath70 , @xmath58)_.\",\n \"we note that in our model , the shape of a coherently moving flock , far from the landing regime , is roughly cylindrical with a radius of cross section @xmath71 and thickness @xmath47 .\",\n \"we argue that from the point of view of our model for large flocks @xmath47 will have in general weak or no dependence on the number of birds .\",\n \"we choose the thickness of the flock @xmath47 as the unit to measure distances ( @xmath72 ) .\",\n \"we choose the projected density @xmath73 , the interaction radius @xmath74 and the preferred altitude of flying @xmath75 . in our simulations\",\n \"we take @xmath76 , unless mentioned otherwise , the order of which is typical for moderately large flocks @xcite .\",\n \"also the ratio @xmath77 would be typical in these flocks which have thickness of order @xmath78 m and fly at altitudes of around @xmath79 m. at the time @xmath54 in ( [ rfim ] ) we expect the flock to be already in the steady state of collective motion .\",\n \"so before we switch on time as in ( [ rfim ] ) we evolve a flock to its steady state of motion according to equations ( [ eom - xy ] ) , ( [ eq_snm_pos ] ) and ( [ spin ] ) where each particle @xmath4 has @xmath42 .\",\n \"it is known @xcite that the nature of the collective motion depends on the amplitude of the noise .\",\n \"we find that for sufficiently low values of @xmath24 , all the particles align their directions and the flock as a whole translates in some spontaneously chosen direction parallel to the @xmath27-plane . as the value of @xmath24\",\n \"is increased , the tendency of alignment is gradually lost leading to weak or no translation .\",\n \"however , the actual nature of this transition is not known precisely enough and its detailed investigation is outside of the scope of the present paper .\",\n \"we make an observation that there are two independent time scales in the problem - the time scale of motion and the time scale over which the inherent switching times are distributed .\",\n \"the former is given by @xmath80 which is the time required to move one unit of length ( or half interaction radius @xmath81 ) .\",\n \"in presence of finite amount of noise @xmath24 , this time scale would also govern the mixing between particles .\",\n \"the width of the distribution of @xmath53 s ( @xmath82 ) gives a measure of the time over which the energy reserves of the majority in the flock are exhausted .\",\n \"therefore , when @xmath83 , there is hardly any motion during the collective decision making .\",\n \"when @xmath84 the flock actually translates ( at low values of @xmath24 ) over a long distance during the process .\",\n \"we call the ratio of these two time scales as @xmath85 , where @xmath86 , and we investigate the nature of landing at its different values .\",\n \"we set the time scale for choosing values of @xmath18 and @xmath56 as the time increment @xmath87 .\",\n \"the value of magnitude of velocity @xmath18 is kept around and below @xmath88 so that change in the set of neighbours @xmath16 of any bird @xmath4 is gradual .\",\n \"we choose the value of the parameters for the comoving boundary described by equations ( [ bound-1 ] ) and ( [ bound-2 ] ) to be @xmath89 and @xmath90 .\",\n \"we also observe that parameter @xmath36 controls the degree of asymmetry of the vector field @xmath91 ( [ bound-2 ] ) outside the comoving boundary . for @xmath92\",\n \"the system enters into a rotating phase @xcite , and for @xmath93 the flock has a tendency to accumulate at the boundary . the role played by the coupling @xmath58 in ( [ rfim ] )\",\n \"is well known @xcite and has also been the matter of investigation . however ,\",\n \"in our model we fix @xmath58 to an optimal value for which we find the desired behaviour , as explained below . in the figure [ trans - land](a )\",\n \"we compare the process of landing across time for different values of the coupling . for a flock with inherent switching times @xmath94 chosen with a fixed @xmath56\",\n \"we monitor the fraction of active particles @xmath95 with time @xmath8 for different values of @xmath58 .\",\n \"we observe that when @xmath96 the particles become inactive independent of each other at their own switching times as seen from the curve @xmath97 which falls smoothly with time . on choosing @xmath98\",\n \"the behaviour is quite opposite .\",\n \"a very sharp fall occurs in the curve @xmath99 implying that there is indeed a collective decision making taking place when a large number of particles reach inactive states within a short period of time .\",\n \"however , comparing the two curves @xmath97 and @xmath99 it appears that in the latter case , the collective landing occurs at point in time which is much larger than ( by an amount of order @xmath56 ) than the switching times of most of the birds .\",\n \"we find that a much lower value of @xmath100 is relevant biologically .\",\n \"the curve @xmath101 sharply falls indicating collective behaviour and the fall occurs near at a time when about half of the birds have just crossed their inherent switching times . in the figure [ trans - land](a )\",\n \"we also plot @xmath102 which is the fraction of birds which have a momentary intention to land at time @xmath8 _\",\n \"i.e. _ , the fraction of particles with @xmath43 . unlike @xmath101 , the quantity @xmath102 is seen to fluctuate before becoming equal to the maximum value unity .\",\n \"this shows that before finally deciding to land , birds may intermittently change their decision .\",\n \"this is caused by the fluctuations in the vertical motion ( [ spin ] ) of neighbours as well as the changing neighbourhood due to finite value of @xmath24 .\",\n \"however , these fluctuations become only important near the landing regime .\",\n \"we explore an aspect of these fluctuations later . in the figure [ trans - land](b )\",\n \"we plot the velocity field of a typical flock when the majority has decided to land .\",\n \"denotes the fraction of birds not landed yet as the time @xmath8 progresses .\",\n \"the curves @xmath97 , @xmath101 and @xmath99 correspond to values of coupling @xmath103 and @xmath104 , respectively . also , @xmath102 shows the fraction of birds in state @xmath43 at time @xmath8 for @xmath100 .\",\n \"( b ) a snapshot of a collective landing of a bird flock with @xmath105 and @xmath106 with @xmath107 and @xmath100 . the arrowheads point in the direction of the velocity of the birds . , width=566 ] ) of actual landing times to the standard deviation ( @xmath56 ) of inherent switching times as a function of noise @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 , _\",\n \"i.e. _ , @xmath56 scaled by the scale of motion @xmath108 , as indicated by different symbols .\",\n \"inset ( a ) shows variation of @xmath109 _ i.e. _ , @xmath70 scaled by @xmath108 , with noise .\",\n \"inset ( b ) shows the variation of @xmath110 which ignores the first and last @xmath111 of the landings .\",\n \"( b ) the variation of the spread of the landed flock over the @xmath27-plane , relative to the spread at time @xmath54 , as a function of noise .\",\n \", width=566 ] below we quantify the extent to which the presence of the coupling affects the collectiveness in landing as we vary the scaled value of the heterogeneity ( @xmath85 ) .\",\n \"we define a measure of the sharpness of the decrease in the fraction of active particles @xmath112 ( figure [ trans - land ] ) . during the process of landing ,\",\n \"we record the times at which individual particles become inactive .\",\n \"then we calculate the standard deviation @xmath70 of the distribution of these landing times .\",\n \"finally , we divide @xmath70 by @xmath56 to get the normalized measure .\",\n \"the dimensionless quantity @xmath113 averaged over different realizations of @xmath114 s , provides a measure of the extent to which the landing of the flock is coherent in time such that @xmath115 implies the complete absence of collective decision making . in the figure [ t2080-r](a )\",\n \"we plot @xmath113 versus @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 .\",\n \"we make the following observations . for @xmath116\",\n \"the flock reaches consensus almost in the absence of any motion . as a result\",\n \"there is no variation of @xmath113 with the magnitude of noise . in this regime\",\n \"the value of @xmath70 is governed by the spread of the flock in the steady state along the vertical direction _\",\n \"i.e. _ , @xmath47\",\n \". therefore we expect that @xmath117 . in the inset ( a ) of the figure [ t2080-r](a )\",\n \"we plot the ratio @xmath118 against @xmath24 .\",\n \"it is worth mentioning that the quantity @xmath109 provides an alternate normalization of @xmath70 with respect to the other independent time scale @xmath108(@xmath119 ) .\",\n \"we find that for @xmath85 close to unity , @xmath120 asserting that the landing is coherent and the separation between landing times is due to the width @xmath47 . for larger values of @xmath85\",\n \"the value of @xmath113 also becomes large signifying gradual loss of coherence .\",\n \"we also observe that in general @xmath113 has a maximum for intermediate values of the noise .\",\n \"we find that if we choose to ignore the particles which become inactive either too early or too late , then the level of temporal coherence appears better . for a particular landing\",\n \"we measure the times @xmath121 and @xmath122 at which @xmath111 and @xmath123 of the particles , respectively , in the flock has just become inactive .\",\n \"thus we define , @xmath124 as the width of the time window in which a majority _ i.e. _ , @xmath125 of the particles become inactive .\",\n \"we normalize @xmath126 by the corresponding time window ( @xmath127 ) for a flock with the coupling @xmath96 . in the inset ( b ) of the figure [ t2080-r](a )\",\n \"we plot @xmath110 versus @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 .\",\n \"the average behaviour reveals a level of coherence such that two birds originally having their inherent switching times separated by @xmath127 land within a period of around @xmath128 of @xmath127 .\",\n \"we investigate the degree of collectiveness as a function of the distance over which a flock lands in figure [ t2080-r](b ) .\",\n \"we calculate the following quantity : @xmath129 this quantifies the spread of the flock across the landing surface .\",\n \"we normalize the value of this spread ( @xmath130 ) when all particles become inactive by the corresponding value ( @xmath131 ) calculated with the positions of the active particles at time @xmath54 . in the figure [ t2080-r](b )\",\n \"we plot @xmath132 as function of noise varying values of @xmath85 . for low and moderate values of @xmath85 ,\",\n \"the value of @xmath132 is of the order of unity .\",\n \"the landing occurs over a region whose dimensions are comparable to dimensions of the flock . we observe that in the regime of large @xmath85 , the value of noise plays a major role in deciding the overall nature of landing .\",\n \"for very low values of @xmath24 the flock translates over large distances . due to this translation ,\",\n \"the particles reaching inactive states early are unable to influence the decision of the active particles in the flock as the _ com _ moves away from these particles . in this case\",\n \"the landing occurs in few large clusters separated in space and time . in case of higher values of the noise there\",\n \"is weak or no translation of the _ com_. however , the scale of the difference in inherent switching times _ i.e. _ , @xmath56 being very slow as compared to the scale of motion , it provides the scope for a particle with a low value of @xmath53 to diffuse to the boundary . as a result , temporarily the influence of the neighbourhood is weakened .\",\n \"this allows the particle to switch its state and become inactive .\",\n \"initially , the excursions of the particles to the comoving boundary becomes the reason behind independent landings .\",\n \"the shrinking of the boundary ( [ rb ] ) effectively screens ( depending upon the interaction radius @xmath15 ) the active particles from the inactive particles . for moderate values of @xmath24 the path of the _ com _ becomes tortuous .\",\n \"however , the effect of segregation of inactive particles from the active particles still persists .\",\n \"the landing occurs in large number of smaller clusters .\",\n \"we further characterize the above behaviour by the following definition .\",\n \"after the landing we calculate the _ com _ of the particles positioned on the @xmath27-plane .\",\n \"we define the measure of spatial coherence @xmath133 as the fraction of particles that lie within a distance @xmath134 from the _\",\n \"com_. formally , @xmath135 where , @xmath136 is the position of the @xmath4-th inactive particle , @xmath34 is the position of the _ com _ and @xmath137 is the heaviside step function .\",\n \"we expect from the above observations that @xmath133 is close to unity for a spatially coherent landing and zero in the opposite case .\",\n \"( b ) , has landed .\",\n \"the line shows the trajectory of the centre of mass of the birds in flight .\",\n \"the arrows indicate the average direction of motion of the centre of mass at different points in time .\",\n \"the circle drawn is centred on the centre of mass of all landed birds and is drawn with the radius @xmath138 of the comoving boundary .\",\n \"( b ) the measure of spatial coherence @xmath133 as a function of @xmath85 for the value of @xmath139 .\",\n \"different symbols indicate the system sizes @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 , and @xmath143 .\",\n \"inset ( a ) shows the plots with @xmath85 rescaled to @xmath144 . inset ( b ) shows the variation of @xmath145 with system size @xmath146.,width=566 ] ) of the standard deviation of the actual landing times as function of the scaled values ( @xmath85 ) of the standard deviation of the assigned switching times for different system sizes ( @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 and @xmath143 ) indicated by different symbols .\",\n \"inset ( a ) shows the collapse of the previous plots as result of transformation of the horizontal axis from @xmath85 to @xmath147 with @xmath148 and @xmath149 .\",\n \"inset ( b ) shows the variation of the ratio @xmath113 with @xmath85 .\",\n \"( b ) the variation of @xmath109 as a function of the interaction radius @xmath15 for different values of @xmath150 , @xmath151 and @xmath152 as indicated by different symbols , in flocks of size @xmath76 .\",\n \"the value of @xmath24 in both ( a ) and ( b ) is @xmath153.,width=566 ] in the figure [ com - psi](a ) we plot the positions of the birds on the @xmath27-plane after all the birds have landed .\",\n \"the line shows the trajectory of the _ com _ and the circle is drawn with the radius @xmath138 about the centre of mass calculated with the final positions of the landed birds .\",\n \"majority of the birds lying within the circle shows that in such a case spatial coherence is retained . in the figure [ com - psi](b ) we plot @xmath133 as function of @xmath85 for the value of @xmath139 .\",\n \"the different plots corresponds to different system sizes .\",\n \"the decrease in @xmath133 with increase in @xmath85 is consistent with all the previous observations . in the inset ( a ) of the figure [ com - psi](b )\",\n \"we obtain a collapse of the data after rescaling @xmath85 by @xmath145 .\",\n \"the variation of @xmath154 with the system size @xmath146 , as shown in the inset ( b ) , is found to be @xmath155 where @xmath156 ( we note that the dimension of the flock varies as @xmath157 ) .\",\n \"this relation suggests that with the increase in the system size there is an increase in the value of @xmath85 below which spatial coherence is expected .\",\n \"we investigate the dependence on system size of the temporal behaviour in the next paragraph .\",\n \"in the figure [ t - r](a ) we plot @xmath109 versus @xmath85 for four different system sizes for value of noise @xmath139 .\",\n \"the figure reveals how the spread in actual landing times increases with the value of @xmath85 . a data collapse in the inset ( a ) reveals a scaling relation of the form : @xmath158^{\\\\frac{1}{n^\\\\alpha } } , \\\\label{lambda - scale}\\\\ ] ] with @xmath148 and @xmath149 . in general , we expect @xmath159 to be function of the parameters like @xmath39 and @xmath15 .\",\n \"the equation ( [ lambda - scale ] ) suggests that for a fixed value of @xmath85 , with the increase in the system size there is increase in temporal coherence .\",\n \"we also plot the corresponding values of the ratio @xmath113 in the inset ( b ) .\",\n \"the plot shows how this ratio approaches the maximum value unity with the increase in the value of @xmath85 .\",\n \"the reason for the rise in @xmath113 for very low values of @xmath85 is already stated with respect to the figure [ t2080-r](a ) . in all the above investigations we have assumed that the interaction radius controlling the average number of neighbours of any particle is @xmath74 .\",\n \"we now address the issue of having larger ( or smaller ) interaction radii . in the figure [ t - r](b )\",\n \"we plot the variation of @xmath109 with the value of @xmath15 for different values of @xmath85 with value of noise set at @xmath139 .\",\n \"we find significant decrease in the spread @xmath109 for large values of @xmath15 .\",\n \"this suggests that global information can lead to a more coherent decision making process . of the maximum depth @xmath160 of excursions below the flock by birds , before returning to the flock as a result of temporarily reverting from the decision to land .\",\n \"the parameter sets indicated by symbols are @xmath161 , @xmath162 ( circles ) and @xmath106 , @xmath107 ( squares ) . the solid line has a slope @xmath163 and is a guide to the eye .\",\n \"( b ) the probability density function @xmath164 of the distance travelled by the centre of mass of birds in flight , @xmath165 between consecutive time steps .\",\n \"the parameter sets indicated by symbols are same as in the case of ( a ) .\",\n \"the measured slopes of the power - law fits to the curves are around @xmath166 . in both (\",\n \"a ) and ( b ) the value of @xmath167 , @xmath168 and the magnitude of the velocity @xmath18 controls the lower cut - off of the power - law decays.,width=529 ]\",\n \"lastly , we focus on the nature of fluctuations during the landing process . as a result of the decision reversals in birds under the influence from the neighbourhood ( as reflected by @xmath102 in the figure [ trans - land](a ) )\",\n \"we find that birds originally moving towards the landing surface sometimes return back to the cruising altitude .\",\n \"we characterize these fluctuations by the maximum depth @xmath160 to which a bird makes an excursion before returning to an altitude greater than @xmath169 . in the figure [ aval - dcm](a )\",\n \"we plot the probability density @xmath170 .\",\n \"we find that the distribution of @xmath160 is a power - law decay bounded by a minimum and maximum governed by the magnitude of velocity @xmath18 and the maximum possible depth @xmath44 , respectively .\",\n \"we also study the jumps that occur in position of the _ com _\",\n \"( on the @xmath27 plane ) of flying birds once the landing process starts .\",\n \"as is seen from the figure [ com - psi](a ) the trajectory of the _ com _ becomes irregular near the end .\",\n \"the _ com _ actually jumps from a cluster which ceases to move to a cluster which continues moving .\",\n \"we construct the probability density @xmath164 for the separation @xmath165 between the centres of mass at two consecutive time steps .\",\n \"we find that @xmath164 has a fat tail during the landing process . in the figure [ aval - dcm](b )\",\n \"we plot the tail of @xmath164 after binning .\",\n \"the plots reveals power law decays with close by exponents .\",\n \"the power law has a cut - off which governed by @xmath138 .\",\n \"in this paper we have investigated the interplay between the dynamics of collective motion and collective decision making . in particular\",\n \"we have presented a model for landing of bird flocks .\",\n \"we have identified the relevant scales in such a problem and we have worked in the coupling regime which is expected to be biologically relevant .\",\n \"it appears that higher values of the coupling delays the process of the global opinion shift .\",\n \"we have characterized the degree of the resulting collective behaviour by different measures .\",\n \"we found that as a function of the few parameters of our model the collective switching from the flying to the landing state is indeed much sharper than the distribution of the individual ( inherent ) landing intentions . among the several interesting features of the model we proposed\",\n \", we showed that if the flock is subject to larger fluctuations , the spatial spreading of the fully landed flock becomes smaller due to a better mixing of the information about the momentary landing intentions of the birds .\",\n \"we also find that there is a characteristic value of heterogeneity which scales with the size of the flock .\",\n \"below this value of heterogeneity , flocks remain spatially coherent in the process of landing and above this value , the coherence is lost .\",\n \"in addition we have formulated a boundary condition which is pertinent to models of flocking .\",\n \"we believe that the approach we proposed is also relevant for many other systems where abrupt behavioural changes are observed .\",\n \"possible applications include various kinds of animal or even robotic groups in which an almost instantaneous global switching to a new desired state takes place .\",\n \"99 conradt l and roper t j 2005 _ trends ecol\",\n \". evol . _ * 20 * 449\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> most of us must have been fascinated by the eye catching displays of collectively moving animals . </S>","<S> schools of fish can move in a rather orderly fashion and then change direction amazingly abruptly . </S>","<S> there are a huge number of further examples both from the living and the non - living world for phenomena during which the many interacting , permanently moving units seem to arrive at a common behavioural pattern taking place in a short time . as a paradigm of this type of phenomena we consider the problem of how birds arrive at a decision resulting in their synchronized landing . </S>","<S> we introduce a simple model to interpret this process . </S>","<S> collective motion prior to landing is modelled using a simple self - propelled particle ( spp ) system with a new kind of boundary condition , while the tendency and the sudden propagation of the intention of landing is introduced through rules analogous to the random field ising model in an external field . </S>","<S> we show that our approach is capable of capturing the most relevant features of collective decision making in a system of units with a variance of individual intentions and being under an increasing level of pressure to switch states . </S>","<S> we find that as a function of the few parameters of our model </S>","<S> the collective switching from the flying to the landing state is indeed much sharper than the distribution of the individual landing intentions . </S>","<S> the transition is accompanied by a number of interesting features discussed in this report . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> most of us must have been fascinated by the eye catching displays of collectively moving animals . </S>\",\n \"<S> schools of fish can move in a rather orderly fashion and then change direction amazingly abruptly . </S>\",\n \"<S> there are a huge number of further examples both from the living and the non - living world for phenomena during which the many interacting , permanently moving units seem to arrive at a common behavioural pattern taking place in a short time . as a paradigm of this type of phenomena we consider the problem of how birds arrive at a decision resulting in their synchronized landing . </S>\",\n \"<S> we introduce a simple model to interpret this process . </S>\",\n \"<S> collective motion prior to landing is modelled using a simple self - propelled particle ( spp ) system with a new kind of boundary condition , while the tendency and the sudden propagation of the intention of landing is introduced through rules analogous to the random field ising model in an external field . </S>\",\n \"<S> we show that our approach is capable of capturing the most relevant features of collective decision making in a system of units with a variance of individual intentions and being under an increasing level of pressure to switch states . </S>\",\n \"<S> we find that as a function of the few parameters of our model </S>\",\n \"<S> the collective switching from the flying to the landing state is indeed much sharper than the distribution of the individual landing intentions . </S>\",\n \"<S> the transition is accompanied by a number of interesting features discussed in this report . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","model","results","conclusion","references"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"model\",\n \"results\",\n \"conclusion\",\n \"references\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["in recent years , there has been a growing interest in the topic of consensus decision making in several fields including animal behaviour @xcite , social sciences @xcite and control theory @xcite . in this paper","we use the paradigm of animal groups but we would like to stress already at this point that there is a considerable analogy between the decision - making processes in very different systems and we expect that our simple model should be applicable to a wider range of systems . our object of study is the phenomenon during which the animals moving in groups , seemingly make unanimous decisions on the choice and time of performing activities even in the absence of global leaders . it is expected that because of the heterogeneity in the attributes like the age , sex and social status of the animals in a group or the differences in their perception of external stimuli there will be differences in the motivations of the members at the time of making choices . however , in spite of the differences , synchronization is seen to take place .","examples include takeoff of swarm of honeybees from nest sites @xcite , activity synchronization in sheep @xcite , collective movement in monkeys @xcite , group departures of domestic geese @xcite and departure of ants from a feeding site @xcite .","the study of collective opinion formation in physics has mainly focused on human societies @xcite .","parallels have been drawn between phase transitions in magnets and the opinion dynamics in populations .","alternatively , the subject of collective motion of animal groups has been extensively modelled @xcite . here","point - like particles , representing animals , move with constant speed , each tending to align with its immediate neighbours , for low noise levels , giving rise to a globally ordered state replicating the motion of flocks where all animals move in the same direction . in this report","we model the process of landing of bird flocks performing foraging flights as a typical example of collective decision making .","we view this phenomena as a shift of the average opinion of the flock from that of continuing horizontal flight about some preferred altitude to that of descent towards the surface below .","we model the fact that birds land almost synchronously even in the presence of heterogeneity in motivations , along the lines of the random field ising model ( rfim ) @xcite .","our approach is similar to that used in @xcite where the authors analyze ( among other cases ) the manner in which people in concert halls , initially joining the applause , stop clapping almost at the same time . in a very recent model @xcite for collective landing ,","birds are assumed to move under the action of different _ social _ forces .","in addition , the internal state of each bird is characterized by a continuous variable called _ landing intent _ such that the internal state of each bird is directly coupled to the internal state of its neighbours .","in contrast we allow motivation of individual birds to be influenced by only the observable variables of their neighbours , like position and velocity .","in addition as a part of the model we introduce a method which enables us to work in open boundary conditions where the birds in flight move cohesively and do not spread out in the horizontal plane even in the presence of perturbations . with this model","we investigate the level of synchronicity in collective landing across time and space and explore the nature of fluctuations close to the point in time when landing occurs ."],["below we describe the two aspects of the model , _ viz . _ collective decision making and collective motion in detail .","the birds in our model are represented by particles characterized by the dynamical variables of position @xmath0 and velocity @xmath1 in three dimensional space .","the only _ natural _ boundary that we allow in the system is the @xmath2 plane which we consider to be the landing surface .","the @xmath3-coordinate of a flying bird gives its height above the ground .","we assign to each particle @xmath4 a variable @xmath5 such that we refer to a bird in the flying state as active ( @xmath6 ) and a bird in the landed state as inactive ( @xmath7 ) .","this variable is updated at discrete times @xmath8 according to the condition : @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the time increment . once a bird @xmath4","has landed we keep its position unchanged till the end of the simulation .","also , from here on we use the words `` bird '' and `` particle '' synonymously .","first we focus on the variables @xmath11 and @xmath12 governing the cruising motion of the birds parallel to the landing surface .","this motion is assumed to be essentially decoupled from the motion in the vertical direction and is modelled in the spirit of @xcite .","a particle @xmath4 is assumed to move , with some uncertainty , in the average direction of motion of all neighboring particles @xmath13 whose separation @xmath14 from @xmath4 is less than a interaction radius @xmath15 . from now on we refer to the set of particles in this neighbourhood as @xmath16 with respect to a particle @xmath4 such that , the inactive particles and the particle @xmath4 are included as well .","the expression for updating velocity at a time @xmath8 is given by @xmath17,\\ ] ] where @xmath18 is the magnitude of the velocity , @xmath19 is the rotation matrix in two dimensions representing a random perturbation by an angle @xmath20 and @xmath21 denotes the unit vector @xmath22 . here","@xmath20 is chosen with a uniform probability from the interval @xmath23 $ ] , where @xmath24 is the amplitude of the noise .","we describe the force - like term @xmath25 below .","we follow the standard version @xcite of the original spp model @xcite for the updating of positions : @xmath26 we mention here that it is a well - known problem with existing models of collective motion to maintain the cohesiveness of a moving flock in the presence of a finite amount of noise @xmath24 and with finite ranged ( as @xmath15 ) interaction between the members .","a flock tends to break up into smaller sub - flocks which eventually move in independent directions .","a periodic boundary condition ( pbc ) is used to prevent the flock from spreading out perpendicular to the direction of motion . however , in the problem of landing we find that the imposition of a pbc would be unrealistic in the sense that there will be a possibility of a particle that has become inactive and hence ceased to move , to continually exchange information with the rest of the moving flock .","therefore , we introduce a new kind of `` comoving boundary '' condition where we imagine the motion of the particles on the @xmath27-plane to be governed by a circular bounding region with radius @xmath28 and the centre lying on the centre of mass ( _ com _ ) of all active particles ( mass of each assumed to be unity ) .","this boundary therefore translates with the flock as the _ com _ is put into motion due to collective motion of the particles .","when a particle which is inside the region tries to leave it , the particle is subjected to an attraction proportional to the distance from the boundary .","the direction of this attraction is along the resultant of the direction towards the location of the _ com _ and the direction of motion of the _ com _ itself . for a particle located at @xmath29 at an instant of time , the attraction @xmath30 is given by : @xmath31\\mathbf{c}\\big(\\mathbf{x^{\\shortparallel}}\\big ) & \\mbox { if $ |\\mathbf{x}^{\\shortparallel}-\\mathbf{\\overline{x}}^{\\shortparallel}| > r_\\mathrm{b}$ } \\\\ 0 & \\mbox { otherwise , } \\end{array } \\right.\\ ] ] with @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the strength of the attraction , @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the position and the velocity of the _ com _ , respectively , parallel to the @xmath27-plane at that instant and @xmath36 is a parameter . the _ com _ and its velocity","are calculated with respect to the active particles . in the figure [ field ] we plot","@xmath25 when the motion of the _ com _ is in a direction parallel to the y - axis .","similarly , we assume that the boundary adjusts itself to keep average separation between active particles constant .","thus , in general @xmath28 is a function of time , given by , @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the fraction of the active particles at time @xmath8 and @xmath39 is the number of particles , initially active , per unit area of the @xmath27-plane . on the @xmath27-plane , defined through ( [ bound-1 ] ) for the value of @xmath40 .","the direction of motion of the _ com _ is assumed to be along the y - axis , indicated by the arrow at the centre of the circle .","the length of a vector is directly proportional to the distance from the boundary .",", width=340 ] now we explain how the collective decision making process takes place in the flock and how it is related to the cohesion and eventual landing along the vertical direction .","we characterize the decision of an individual bird as a binary choice problem @xcite . to each bird","@xmath4 we assign an internal state variable @xmath41 such that when @xmath42 the bird continues to cruise above ground and when @xmath43 the bird decides to land . for the cruising state","we assume that a bird likes to fly about an altitude @xmath44 on average without deviating too far above or below .","however , we expect the elevation of a bird to fluctuate with time pertaining to factors like the noise in the medium and collision avoidance .","thus when @xmath42 we consider the vertical motion of the particle to be essentially a random walk bounded by imaginary walls at @xmath45 and @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the thickness of the flock . in case the bird decides to land the vertical motion is directed towards the landing surface at @xmath2 .","formally we define , @xmath48 & \\textrm{if $ s_i(t)=1 $ and $ |\\delta(t-\\delta t)|>\\delta z_0/2 $ } \\\\","-v & \\textrm{if $ s_i(t)=-1 $ , } \\end{array}\\right.\\ ] ] where @xmath49 takes values @xmath50 with equal probability and @xmath51 , is the amount of deviation from the height @xmath44 at time @xmath52 . to model the motivational differences in birds we assign to each bird @xmath4 , an inherent switching time @xmath53 @xcite such that if the bird begins an isolated flight at time @xmath54 , it would decide to land at time @xmath55 .","we assume that the value of @xmath53 for the bird @xmath4 will in general depend on its energy reserves @xcite and thus in general will be different for different birds .","we choose @xmath53 s from a gaussian distribution with a given standard deviation @xmath56 .","the value of @xmath56 allows us to control the level of heterogeneity in a flock .","although we assign _ a priori _ values of @xmath53 to birds , due to the randomness in the choice of these switching times , they can be thought to be additionally include the effect of the environment such as quality of foraging patches over which the flocks fly . for a particle in the flock",", it will have a finite number of particles in its neighbourhood and therefore will be influenced by their actions while taking a decision .","hence the internal state of a particle will be a function of two competing factors , ( i ) its inherent switching time and ( ii ) the internal state of the neighbours , which we assume to be reflected by the nature of their motion . in an approach similar to that of the rfim at zero temperature @xcite we write down : @xmath57\\ ] ] where @xmath58 is the propensity of a particle to follow the decision of its neighbours and @xmath59 is the _ local mean field _ through which the bird @xmath4 senses the average decision in its neighbourhood @xmath16 .","we expect that the inclination of a bird @xmath4 to land will be enhanced by a resultant motion of birds in @xmath16 towards the landing surface , and also by the number of birds that have already landed .","we define @xmath59 at a time @xmath8 as : @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 are the average value of @xmath3-component of velocity of active particles and fraction of active particles , respectively , in the neighbourhood @xmath16 at time @xmath8 . at times","@xmath63 , the birds on average have no inclination to land and therefore we expect them to maintain a height around @xmath64 without any resultant vertical motion towards the landing surface .","in this regime we expect for any particle @xmath4 , @xmath65 and also , @xmath66 , implying that @xmath67 .","on the other hand a resultant vertical motion in negative @xmath3-direction would imply @xmath68 .","thus in a regime when majority move towards the landing surface at @xmath2 and eventually reach inactive states , we expect @xmath69 .","we now move on to characterize the resulting collective landing as a function of different states of collective motion .","_ we would like to emphasize at this point that although the detailed description of our model involves specifying nine expressions , the essential concept and the ingredients of the model are rather simple ( spp + rfim ) and the number of independent parameters is low ( @xmath24 , @xmath15 , @xmath70 , @xmath58)_."],["we note that in our model , the shape of a coherently moving flock , far from the landing regime , is roughly cylindrical with a radius of cross section @xmath71 and thickness @xmath47 .","we argue that from the point of view of our model for large flocks @xmath47 will have in general weak or no dependence on the number of birds .","we choose the thickness of the flock @xmath47 as the unit to measure distances ( @xmath72 ) .","we choose the projected density @xmath73 , the interaction radius @xmath74 and the preferred altitude of flying @xmath75 . in our simulations","we take @xmath76 , unless mentioned otherwise , the order of which is typical for moderately large flocks @xcite .","also the ratio @xmath77 would be typical in these flocks which have thickness of order @xmath78 m and fly at altitudes of around @xmath79 m. at the time @xmath54 in ( [ rfim ] ) we expect the flock to be already in the steady state of collective motion .","so before we switch on time as in ( [ rfim ] ) we evolve a flock to its steady state of motion according to equations ( [ eom - xy ] ) , ( [ eq_snm_pos ] ) and ( [ spin ] ) where each particle @xmath4 has @xmath42 .","it is known @xcite that the nature of the collective motion depends on the amplitude of the noise .","we find that for sufficiently low values of @xmath24 , all the particles align their directions and the flock as a whole translates in some spontaneously chosen direction parallel to the @xmath27-plane . as the value of @xmath24","is increased , the tendency of alignment is gradually lost leading to weak or no translation .","however , the actual nature of this transition is not known precisely enough and its detailed investigation is outside of the scope of the present paper .","we make an observation that there are two independent time scales in the problem - the time scale of motion and the time scale over which the inherent switching times are distributed .","the former is given by @xmath80 which is the time required to move one unit of length ( or half interaction radius @xmath81 ) .","in presence of finite amount of noise @xmath24 , this time scale would also govern the mixing between particles .","the width of the distribution of @xmath53 s ( @xmath82 ) gives a measure of the time over which the energy reserves of the majority in the flock are exhausted .","therefore , when @xmath83 , there is hardly any motion during the collective decision making .","when @xmath84 the flock actually translates ( at low values of @xmath24 ) over a long distance during the process .","we call the ratio of these two time scales as @xmath85 , where @xmath86 , and we investigate the nature of landing at its different values .","we set the time scale for choosing values of @xmath18 and @xmath56 as the time increment @xmath87 .","the value of magnitude of velocity @xmath18 is kept around and below @xmath88 so that change in the set of neighbours @xmath16 of any bird @xmath4 is gradual .","we choose the value of the parameters for the comoving boundary described by equations ( [ bound-1 ] ) and ( [ bound-2 ] ) to be @xmath89 and @xmath90 .","we also observe that parameter @xmath36 controls the degree of asymmetry of the vector field @xmath91 ( [ bound-2 ] ) outside the comoving boundary . for @xmath92","the system enters into a rotating phase @xcite , and for @xmath93 the flock has a tendency to accumulate at the boundary . the role played by the coupling @xmath58 in ( [ rfim ] )","is well known @xcite and has also been the matter of investigation . however ,","in our model we fix @xmath58 to an optimal value for which we find the desired behaviour , as explained below . in the figure [ trans - land](a )","we compare the process of landing across time for different values of the coupling . for a flock with inherent switching times @xmath94 chosen with a fixed @xmath56","we monitor the fraction of active particles @xmath95 with time @xmath8 for different values of @xmath58 .","we observe that when @xmath96 the particles become inactive independent of each other at their own switching times as seen from the curve @xmath97 which falls smoothly with time . on choosing @xmath98","the behaviour is quite opposite .","a very sharp fall occurs in the curve @xmath99 implying that there is indeed a collective decision making taking place when a large number of particles reach inactive states within a short period of time .","however , comparing the two curves @xmath97 and @xmath99 it appears that in the latter case , the collective landing occurs at point in time which is much larger than ( by an amount of order @xmath56 ) than the switching times of most of the birds .","we find that a much lower value of @xmath100 is relevant biologically .","the curve @xmath101 sharply falls indicating collective behaviour and the fall occurs near at a time when about half of the birds have just crossed their inherent switching times . in the figure [ trans - land](a )","we also plot @xmath102 which is the fraction of birds which have a momentary intention to land at time @xmath8 _","i.e. _ , the fraction of particles with @xmath43 . unlike @xmath101 , the quantity @xmath102 is seen to fluctuate before becoming equal to the maximum value unity .","this shows that before finally deciding to land , birds may intermittently change their decision .","this is caused by the fluctuations in the vertical motion ( [ spin ] ) of neighbours as well as the changing neighbourhood due to finite value of @xmath24 .","however , these fluctuations become only important near the landing regime .","we explore an aspect of these fluctuations later . in the figure [ trans - land](b )","we plot the velocity field of a typical flock when the majority has decided to land .","denotes the fraction of birds not landed yet as the time @xmath8 progresses .","the curves @xmath97 , @xmath101 and @xmath99 correspond to values of coupling @xmath103 and @xmath104 , respectively . also , @xmath102 shows the fraction of birds in state @xmath43 at time @xmath8 for @xmath100 .","( b ) a snapshot of a collective landing of a bird flock with @xmath105 and @xmath106 with @xmath107 and @xmath100 . the arrowheads point in the direction of the velocity of the birds . , width=566 ] ) of actual landing times to the standard deviation ( @xmath56 ) of inherent switching times as a function of noise @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 , _","i.e. _ , @xmath56 scaled by the scale of motion @xmath108 , as indicated by different symbols .","inset ( a ) shows variation of @xmath109 _ i.e. _ , @xmath70 scaled by @xmath108 , with noise .","inset ( b ) shows the variation of @xmath110 which ignores the first and last @xmath111 of the landings .","( b ) the variation of the spread of the landed flock over the @xmath27-plane , relative to the spread at time @xmath54 , as a function of noise .",", width=566 ] below we quantify the extent to which the presence of the coupling affects the collectiveness in landing as we vary the scaled value of the heterogeneity ( @xmath85 ) .","we define a measure of the sharpness of the decrease in the fraction of active particles @xmath112 ( figure [ trans - land ] ) . during the process of landing ,","we record the times at which individual particles become inactive .","then we calculate the standard deviation @xmath70 of the distribution of these landing times .","finally , we divide @xmath70 by @xmath56 to get the normalized measure .","the dimensionless quantity @xmath113 averaged over different realizations of @xmath114 s , provides a measure of the extent to which the landing of the flock is coherent in time such that @xmath115 implies the complete absence of collective decision making . in the figure [ t2080-r](a )","we plot @xmath113 versus @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 .","we make the following observations . for @xmath116","the flock reaches consensus almost in the absence of any motion . as a result","there is no variation of @xmath113 with the magnitude of noise . in this regime","the value of @xmath70 is governed by the spread of the flock in the steady state along the vertical direction _","i.e. _ , @xmath47",". therefore we expect that @xmath117 . in the inset ( a ) of the figure [ t2080-r](a )","we plot the ratio @xmath118 against @xmath24 .","it is worth mentioning that the quantity @xmath109 provides an alternate normalization of @xmath70 with respect to the other independent time scale @xmath108(@xmath119 ) .","we find that for @xmath85 close to unity , @xmath120 asserting that the landing is coherent and the separation between landing times is due to the width @xmath47 . for larger values of @xmath85","the value of @xmath113 also becomes large signifying gradual loss of coherence .","we also observe that in general @xmath113 has a maximum for intermediate values of the noise .","we find that if we choose to ignore the particles which become inactive either too early or too late , then the level of temporal coherence appears better . for a particular landing","we measure the times @xmath121 and @xmath122 at which @xmath111 and @xmath123 of the particles , respectively , in the flock has just become inactive .","thus we define , @xmath124 as the width of the time window in which a majority _ i.e. _ , @xmath125 of the particles become inactive .","we normalize @xmath126 by the corresponding time window ( @xmath127 ) for a flock with the coupling @xmath96 . in the inset ( b ) of the figure [ t2080-r](a )","we plot @xmath110 versus @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 .","the average behaviour reveals a level of coherence such that two birds originally having their inherent switching times separated by @xmath127 land within a period of around @xmath128 of @xmath127 .","we investigate the degree of collectiveness as a function of the distance over which a flock lands in figure [ t2080-r](b ) .","we calculate the following quantity : @xmath129 this quantifies the spread of the flock across the landing surface .","we normalize the value of this spread ( @xmath130 ) when all particles become inactive by the corresponding value ( @xmath131 ) calculated with the positions of the active particles at time @xmath54 . in the figure [ t2080-r](b )","we plot @xmath132 as function of noise varying values of @xmath85 . for low and moderate values of @xmath85 ,","the value of @xmath132 is of the order of unity .","the landing occurs over a region whose dimensions are comparable to dimensions of the flock . we observe that in the regime of large @xmath85 , the value of noise plays a major role in deciding the overall nature of landing .","for very low values of @xmath24 the flock translates over large distances . due to this translation ,","the particles reaching inactive states early are unable to influence the decision of the active particles in the flock as the _ com _ moves away from these particles . in this case","the landing occurs in few large clusters separated in space and time . in case of higher values of the noise there","is weak or no translation of the _ com_. however , the scale of the difference in inherent switching times _ i.e. _ , @xmath56 being very slow as compared to the scale of motion , it provides the scope for a particle with a low value of @xmath53 to diffuse to the boundary . as a result , temporarily the influence of the neighbourhood is weakened .","this allows the particle to switch its state and become inactive .","initially , the excursions of the particles to the comoving boundary becomes the reason behind independent landings .","the shrinking of the boundary ( [ rb ] ) effectively screens ( depending upon the interaction radius @xmath15 ) the active particles from the inactive particles . for moderate values of @xmath24 the path of the _ com _ becomes tortuous .","however , the effect of segregation of inactive particles from the active particles still persists .","the landing occurs in large number of smaller clusters .","we further characterize the above behaviour by the following definition .","after the landing we calculate the _ com _ of the particles positioned on the @xmath27-plane .","we define the measure of spatial coherence @xmath133 as the fraction of particles that lie within a distance @xmath134 from the _","com_. formally , @xmath135 where , @xmath136 is the position of the @xmath4-th inactive particle , @xmath34 is the position of the _ com _ and @xmath137 is the heaviside step function .","we expect from the above observations that @xmath133 is close to unity for a spatially coherent landing and zero in the opposite case .","( b ) , has landed .","the line shows the trajectory of the centre of mass of the birds in flight .","the arrows indicate the average direction of motion of the centre of mass at different points in time .","the circle drawn is centred on the centre of mass of all landed birds and is drawn with the radius @xmath138 of the comoving boundary .","( b ) the measure of spatial coherence @xmath133 as a function of @xmath85 for the value of @xmath139 .","different symbols indicate the system sizes @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 , and @xmath143 .","inset ( a ) shows the plots with @xmath85 rescaled to @xmath144 . inset ( b ) shows the variation of @xmath145 with system size @xmath146.,width=566 ] ) of the standard deviation of the actual landing times as function of the scaled values ( @xmath85 ) of the standard deviation of the assigned switching times for different system sizes ( @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 and @xmath143 ) indicated by different symbols .","inset ( a ) shows the collapse of the previous plots as result of transformation of the horizontal axis from @xmath85 to @xmath147 with @xmath148 and @xmath149 .","inset ( b ) shows the variation of the ratio @xmath113 with @xmath85 .","( b ) the variation of @xmath109 as a function of the interaction radius @xmath15 for different values of @xmath150 , @xmath151 and @xmath152 as indicated by different symbols , in flocks of size @xmath76 .","the value of @xmath24 in both ( a ) and ( b ) is @xmath153.,width=566 ] in the figure [ com - psi](a ) we plot the positions of the birds on the @xmath27-plane after all the birds have landed .","the line shows the trajectory of the _ com _ and the circle is drawn with the radius @xmath138 about the centre of mass calculated with the final positions of the landed birds .","majority of the birds lying within the circle shows that in such a case spatial coherence is retained . in the figure [ com - psi](b ) we plot @xmath133 as function of @xmath85 for the value of @xmath139 .","the different plots corresponds to different system sizes .","the decrease in @xmath133 with increase in @xmath85 is consistent with all the previous observations . in the inset ( a ) of the figure [ com - psi](b )","we obtain a collapse of the data after rescaling @xmath85 by @xmath145 .","the variation of @xmath154 with the system size @xmath146 , as shown in the inset ( b ) , is found to be @xmath155 where @xmath156 ( we note that the dimension of the flock varies as @xmath157 ) .","this relation suggests that with the increase in the system size there is an increase in the value of @xmath85 below which spatial coherence is expected .","we investigate the dependence on system size of the temporal behaviour in the next paragraph .","in the figure [ t - r](a ) we plot @xmath109 versus @xmath85 for four different system sizes for value of noise @xmath139 .","the figure reveals how the spread in actual landing times increases with the value of @xmath85 . a data collapse in the inset ( a ) reveals a scaling relation of the form : @xmath158^{\\frac{1}{n^\\alpha } } , \\label{lambda - scale}\\ ] ] with @xmath148 and @xmath149 . in general , we expect @xmath159 to be function of the parameters like @xmath39 and @xmath15 .","the equation ( [ lambda - scale ] ) suggests that for a fixed value of @xmath85 , with the increase in the system size there is increase in temporal coherence .","we also plot the corresponding values of the ratio @xmath113 in the inset ( b ) .","the plot shows how this ratio approaches the maximum value unity with the increase in the value of @xmath85 .","the reason for the rise in @xmath113 for very low values of @xmath85 is already stated with respect to the figure [ t2080-r](a ) . in all the above investigations we have assumed that the interaction radius controlling the average number of neighbours of any particle is @xmath74 .","we now address the issue of having larger ( or smaller ) interaction radii . in the figure [ t - r](b )","we plot the variation of @xmath109 with the value of @xmath15 for different values of @xmath85 with value of noise set at @xmath139 .","we find significant decrease in the spread @xmath109 for large values of @xmath15 .","this suggests that global information can lead to a more coherent decision making process . of the maximum depth @xmath160 of excursions below the flock by birds , before returning to the flock as a result of temporarily reverting from the decision to land .","the parameter sets indicated by symbols are @xmath161 , @xmath162 ( circles ) and @xmath106 , @xmath107 ( squares ) . the solid line has a slope @xmath163 and is a guide to the eye .","( b ) the probability density function @xmath164 of the distance travelled by the centre of mass of birds in flight , @xmath165 between consecutive time steps .","the parameter sets indicated by symbols are same as in the case of ( a ) .","the measured slopes of the power - law fits to the curves are around @xmath166 . in both (","a ) and ( b ) the value of @xmath167 , @xmath168 and the magnitude of the velocity @xmath18 controls the lower cut - off of the power - law decays.,width=529 ]","lastly , we focus on the nature of fluctuations during the landing process . as a result of the decision reversals in birds under the influence from the neighbourhood ( as reflected by @xmath102 in the figure [ trans - land](a ) )","we find that birds originally moving towards the landing surface sometimes return back to the cruising altitude .","we characterize these fluctuations by the maximum depth @xmath160 to which a bird makes an excursion before returning to an altitude greater than @xmath169 . in the figure [ aval - dcm](a )","we plot the probability density @xmath170 .","we find that the distribution of @xmath160 is a power - law decay bounded by a minimum and maximum governed by the magnitude of velocity @xmath18 and the maximum possible depth @xmath44 , respectively .","we also study the jumps that occur in position of the _ com _","( on the @xmath27 plane ) of flying birds once the landing process starts .","as is seen from the figure [ com - psi](a ) the trajectory of the _ com _ becomes irregular near the end .","the _ com _ actually jumps from a cluster which ceases to move to a cluster which continues moving .","we construct the probability density @xmath164 for the separation @xmath165 between the centres of mass at two consecutive time steps .","we find that @xmath164 has a fat tail during the landing process . in the figure [ aval - dcm](b )","we plot the tail of @xmath164 after binning .","the plots reveals power law decays with close by exponents .","the power law has a cut - off which governed by @xmath138 ."],["in this paper we have investigated the interplay between the dynamics of collective motion and collective decision making . in particular","we have presented a model for landing of bird flocks .","we have identified the relevant scales in such a problem and we have worked in the coupling regime which is expected to be biologically relevant .","it appears that higher values of the coupling delays the process of the global opinion shift .","we have characterized the degree of the resulting collective behaviour by different measures .","we found that as a function of the few parameters of our model the collective switching from the flying to the landing state is indeed much sharper than the distribution of the individual ( inherent ) landing intentions . among the several interesting features of the model we proposed",", we showed that if the flock is subject to larger fluctuations , the spatial spreading of the fully landed flock becomes smaller due to a better mixing of the information about the momentary landing intentions of the birds .","we also find that there is a characteristic value of heterogeneity which scales with the size of the flock .","below this value of heterogeneity , flocks remain spatially coherent in the process of landing and above this value , the coherence is lost .","in addition we have formulated a boundary condition which is pertinent to models of flocking .","we believe that the approach we proposed is also relevant for many other systems where abrupt behavioural changes are observed .","possible applications include various kinds of animal or even robotic groups in which an almost instantaneous global switching to a new desired state takes place ."],["99 conradt l and roper t j 2005 _ trends ecol",". evol . _ * 20 * 449"]],"string":"[\n [\n \"in recent years , there has been a growing interest in the topic of consensus decision making in several fields including animal behaviour @xcite , social sciences @xcite and control theory @xcite . in this paper\",\n \"we use the paradigm of animal groups but we would like to stress already at this point that there is a considerable analogy between the decision - making processes in very different systems and we expect that our simple model should be applicable to a wider range of systems . our object of study is the phenomenon during which the animals moving in groups , seemingly make unanimous decisions on the choice and time of performing activities even in the absence of global leaders . it is expected that because of the heterogeneity in the attributes like the age , sex and social status of the animals in a group or the differences in their perception of external stimuli there will be differences in the motivations of the members at the time of making choices . however , in spite of the differences , synchronization is seen to take place .\",\n \"examples include takeoff of swarm of honeybees from nest sites @xcite , activity synchronization in sheep @xcite , collective movement in monkeys @xcite , group departures of domestic geese @xcite and departure of ants from a feeding site @xcite .\",\n \"the study of collective opinion formation in physics has mainly focused on human societies @xcite .\",\n \"parallels have been drawn between phase transitions in magnets and the opinion dynamics in populations .\",\n \"alternatively , the subject of collective motion of animal groups has been extensively modelled @xcite . here\",\n \"point - like particles , representing animals , move with constant speed , each tending to align with its immediate neighbours , for low noise levels , giving rise to a globally ordered state replicating the motion of flocks where all animals move in the same direction . in this report\",\n \"we model the process of landing of bird flocks performing foraging flights as a typical example of collective decision making .\",\n \"we view this phenomena as a shift of the average opinion of the flock from that of continuing horizontal flight about some preferred altitude to that of descent towards the surface below .\",\n \"we model the fact that birds land almost synchronously even in the presence of heterogeneity in motivations , along the lines of the random field ising model ( rfim ) @xcite .\",\n \"our approach is similar to that used in @xcite where the authors analyze ( among other cases ) the manner in which people in concert halls , initially joining the applause , stop clapping almost at the same time . in a very recent model @xcite for collective landing ,\",\n \"birds are assumed to move under the action of different _ social _ forces .\",\n \"in addition , the internal state of each bird is characterized by a continuous variable called _ landing intent _ such that the internal state of each bird is directly coupled to the internal state of its neighbours .\",\n \"in contrast we allow motivation of individual birds to be influenced by only the observable variables of their neighbours , like position and velocity .\",\n \"in addition as a part of the model we introduce a method which enables us to work in open boundary conditions where the birds in flight move cohesively and do not spread out in the horizontal plane even in the presence of perturbations . with this model\",\n \"we investigate the level of synchronicity in collective landing across time and space and explore the nature of fluctuations close to the point in time when landing occurs .\"\n ],\n [\n \"below we describe the two aspects of the model , _ viz . _ collective decision making and collective motion in detail .\",\n \"the birds in our model are represented by particles characterized by the dynamical variables of position @xmath0 and velocity @xmath1 in three dimensional space .\",\n \"the only _ natural _ boundary that we allow in the system is the @xmath2 plane which we consider to be the landing surface .\",\n \"the @xmath3-coordinate of a flying bird gives its height above the ground .\",\n \"we assign to each particle @xmath4 a variable @xmath5 such that we refer to a bird in the flying state as active ( @xmath6 ) and a bird in the landed state as inactive ( @xmath7 ) .\",\n \"this variable is updated at discrete times @xmath8 according to the condition : @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the time increment . once a bird @xmath4\",\n \"has landed we keep its position unchanged till the end of the simulation .\",\n \"also , from here on we use the words `` bird '' and `` particle '' synonymously .\",\n \"first we focus on the variables @xmath11 and @xmath12 governing the cruising motion of the birds parallel to the landing surface .\",\n \"this motion is assumed to be essentially decoupled from the motion in the vertical direction and is modelled in the spirit of @xcite .\",\n \"a particle @xmath4 is assumed to move , with some uncertainty , in the average direction of motion of all neighboring particles @xmath13 whose separation @xmath14 from @xmath4 is less than a interaction radius @xmath15 . from now on we refer to the set of particles in this neighbourhood as @xmath16 with respect to a particle @xmath4 such that , the inactive particles and the particle @xmath4 are included as well .\",\n \"the expression for updating velocity at a time @xmath8 is given by @xmath17,\\\\ ] ] where @xmath18 is the magnitude of the velocity , @xmath19 is the rotation matrix in two dimensions representing a random perturbation by an angle @xmath20 and @xmath21 denotes the unit vector @xmath22 . here\",\n \"@xmath20 is chosen with a uniform probability from the interval @xmath23 $ ] , where @xmath24 is the amplitude of the noise .\",\n \"we describe the force - like term @xmath25 below .\",\n \"we follow the standard version @xcite of the original spp model @xcite for the updating of positions : @xmath26 we mention here that it is a well - known problem with existing models of collective motion to maintain the cohesiveness of a moving flock in the presence of a finite amount of noise @xmath24 and with finite ranged ( as @xmath15 ) interaction between the members .\",\n \"a flock tends to break up into smaller sub - flocks which eventually move in independent directions .\",\n \"a periodic boundary condition ( pbc ) is used to prevent the flock from spreading out perpendicular to the direction of motion . however , in the problem of landing we find that the imposition of a pbc would be unrealistic in the sense that there will be a possibility of a particle that has become inactive and hence ceased to move , to continually exchange information with the rest of the moving flock .\",\n \"therefore , we introduce a new kind of `` comoving boundary '' condition where we imagine the motion of the particles on the @xmath27-plane to be governed by a circular bounding region with radius @xmath28 and the centre lying on the centre of mass ( _ com _ ) of all active particles ( mass of each assumed to be unity ) .\",\n \"this boundary therefore translates with the flock as the _ com _ is put into motion due to collective motion of the particles .\",\n \"when a particle which is inside the region tries to leave it , the particle is subjected to an attraction proportional to the distance from the boundary .\",\n \"the direction of this attraction is along the resultant of the direction towards the location of the _ com _ and the direction of motion of the _ com _ itself . for a particle located at @xmath29 at an instant of time , the attraction @xmath30 is given by : @xmath31\\\\mathbf{c}\\\\big(\\\\mathbf{x^{\\\\shortparallel}}\\\\big ) & \\\\mbox { if $ |\\\\mathbf{x}^{\\\\shortparallel}-\\\\mathbf{\\\\overline{x}}^{\\\\shortparallel}| > r_\\\\mathrm{b}$ } \\\\\\\\ 0 & \\\\mbox { otherwise , } \\\\end{array } \\\\right.\\\\ ] ] with @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the strength of the attraction , @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the position and the velocity of the _ com _ , respectively , parallel to the @xmath27-plane at that instant and @xmath36 is a parameter . the _ com _ and its velocity\",\n \"are calculated with respect to the active particles . in the figure [ field ] we plot\",\n \"@xmath25 when the motion of the _ com _ is in a direction parallel to the y - axis .\",\n \"similarly , we assume that the boundary adjusts itself to keep average separation between active particles constant .\",\n \"thus , in general @xmath28 is a function of time , given by , @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the fraction of the active particles at time @xmath8 and @xmath39 is the number of particles , initially active , per unit area of the @xmath27-plane . on the @xmath27-plane , defined through ( [ bound-1 ] ) for the value of @xmath40 .\",\n \"the direction of motion of the _ com _ is assumed to be along the y - axis , indicated by the arrow at the centre of the circle .\",\n \"the length of a vector is directly proportional to the distance from the boundary .\",\n \", width=340 ] now we explain how the collective decision making process takes place in the flock and how it is related to the cohesion and eventual landing along the vertical direction .\",\n \"we characterize the decision of an individual bird as a binary choice problem @xcite . to each bird\",\n \"@xmath4 we assign an internal state variable @xmath41 such that when @xmath42 the bird continues to cruise above ground and when @xmath43 the bird decides to land . for the cruising state\",\n \"we assume that a bird likes to fly about an altitude @xmath44 on average without deviating too far above or below .\",\n \"however , we expect the elevation of a bird to fluctuate with time pertaining to factors like the noise in the medium and collision avoidance .\",\n \"thus when @xmath42 we consider the vertical motion of the particle to be essentially a random walk bounded by imaginary walls at @xmath45 and @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the thickness of the flock . in case the bird decides to land the vertical motion is directed towards the landing surface at @xmath2 .\",\n \"formally we define , @xmath48 & \\\\textrm{if $ s_i(t)=1 $ and $ |\\\\delta(t-\\\\delta t)|>\\\\delta z_0/2 $ } \\\\\\\\\",\n \"-v & \\\\textrm{if $ s_i(t)=-1 $ , } \\\\end{array}\\\\right.\\\\ ] ] where @xmath49 takes values @xmath50 with equal probability and @xmath51 , is the amount of deviation from the height @xmath44 at time @xmath52 . to model the motivational differences in birds we assign to each bird @xmath4 , an inherent switching time @xmath53 @xcite such that if the bird begins an isolated flight at time @xmath54 , it would decide to land at time @xmath55 .\",\n \"we assume that the value of @xmath53 for the bird @xmath4 will in general depend on its energy reserves @xcite and thus in general will be different for different birds .\",\n \"we choose @xmath53 s from a gaussian distribution with a given standard deviation @xmath56 .\",\n \"the value of @xmath56 allows us to control the level of heterogeneity in a flock .\",\n \"although we assign _ a priori _ values of @xmath53 to birds , due to the randomness in the choice of these switching times , they can be thought to be additionally include the effect of the environment such as quality of foraging patches over which the flocks fly . for a particle in the flock\",\n \", it will have a finite number of particles in its neighbourhood and therefore will be influenced by their actions while taking a decision .\",\n \"hence the internal state of a particle will be a function of two competing factors , ( i ) its inherent switching time and ( ii ) the internal state of the neighbours , which we assume to be reflected by the nature of their motion . in an approach similar to that of the rfim at zero temperature @xcite we write down : @xmath57\\\\ ] ] where @xmath58 is the propensity of a particle to follow the decision of its neighbours and @xmath59 is the _ local mean field _ through which the bird @xmath4 senses the average decision in its neighbourhood @xmath16 .\",\n \"we expect that the inclination of a bird @xmath4 to land will be enhanced by a resultant motion of birds in @xmath16 towards the landing surface , and also by the number of birds that have already landed .\",\n \"we define @xmath59 at a time @xmath8 as : @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 are the average value of @xmath3-component of velocity of active particles and fraction of active particles , respectively , in the neighbourhood @xmath16 at time @xmath8 . at times\",\n \"@xmath63 , the birds on average have no inclination to land and therefore we expect them to maintain a height around @xmath64 without any resultant vertical motion towards the landing surface .\",\n \"in this regime we expect for any particle @xmath4 , @xmath65 and also , @xmath66 , implying that @xmath67 .\",\n \"on the other hand a resultant vertical motion in negative @xmath3-direction would imply @xmath68 .\",\n \"thus in a regime when majority move towards the landing surface at @xmath2 and eventually reach inactive states , we expect @xmath69 .\",\n \"we now move on to characterize the resulting collective landing as a function of different states of collective motion .\",\n \"_ we would like to emphasize at this point that although the detailed description of our model involves specifying nine expressions , the essential concept and the ingredients of the model are rather simple ( spp + rfim ) and the number of independent parameters is low ( @xmath24 , @xmath15 , @xmath70 , @xmath58)_.\"\n ],\n [\n \"we note that in our model , the shape of a coherently moving flock , far from the landing regime , is roughly cylindrical with a radius of cross section @xmath71 and thickness @xmath47 .\",\n \"we argue that from the point of view of our model for large flocks @xmath47 will have in general weak or no dependence on the number of birds .\",\n \"we choose the thickness of the flock @xmath47 as the unit to measure distances ( @xmath72 ) .\",\n \"we choose the projected density @xmath73 , the interaction radius @xmath74 and the preferred altitude of flying @xmath75 . in our simulations\",\n \"we take @xmath76 , unless mentioned otherwise , the order of which is typical for moderately large flocks @xcite .\",\n \"also the ratio @xmath77 would be typical in these flocks which have thickness of order @xmath78 m and fly at altitudes of around @xmath79 m. at the time @xmath54 in ( [ rfim ] ) we expect the flock to be already in the steady state of collective motion .\",\n \"so before we switch on time as in ( [ rfim ] ) we evolve a flock to its steady state of motion according to equations ( [ eom - xy ] ) , ( [ eq_snm_pos ] ) and ( [ spin ] ) where each particle @xmath4 has @xmath42 .\",\n \"it is known @xcite that the nature of the collective motion depends on the amplitude of the noise .\",\n \"we find that for sufficiently low values of @xmath24 , all the particles align their directions and the flock as a whole translates in some spontaneously chosen direction parallel to the @xmath27-plane . as the value of @xmath24\",\n \"is increased , the tendency of alignment is gradually lost leading to weak or no translation .\",\n \"however , the actual nature of this transition is not known precisely enough and its detailed investigation is outside of the scope of the present paper .\",\n \"we make an observation that there are two independent time scales in the problem - the time scale of motion and the time scale over which the inherent switching times are distributed .\",\n \"the former is given by @xmath80 which is the time required to move one unit of length ( or half interaction radius @xmath81 ) .\",\n \"in presence of finite amount of noise @xmath24 , this time scale would also govern the mixing between particles .\",\n \"the width of the distribution of @xmath53 s ( @xmath82 ) gives a measure of the time over which the energy reserves of the majority in the flock are exhausted .\",\n \"therefore , when @xmath83 , there is hardly any motion during the collective decision making .\",\n \"when @xmath84 the flock actually translates ( at low values of @xmath24 ) over a long distance during the process .\",\n \"we call the ratio of these two time scales as @xmath85 , where @xmath86 , and we investigate the nature of landing at its different values .\",\n \"we set the time scale for choosing values of @xmath18 and @xmath56 as the time increment @xmath87 .\",\n \"the value of magnitude of velocity @xmath18 is kept around and below @xmath88 so that change in the set of neighbours @xmath16 of any bird @xmath4 is gradual .\",\n \"we choose the value of the parameters for the comoving boundary described by equations ( [ bound-1 ] ) and ( [ bound-2 ] ) to be @xmath89 and @xmath90 .\",\n \"we also observe that parameter @xmath36 controls the degree of asymmetry of the vector field @xmath91 ( [ bound-2 ] ) outside the comoving boundary . for @xmath92\",\n \"the system enters into a rotating phase @xcite , and for @xmath93 the flock has a tendency to accumulate at the boundary . the role played by the coupling @xmath58 in ( [ rfim ] )\",\n \"is well known @xcite and has also been the matter of investigation . however ,\",\n \"in our model we fix @xmath58 to an optimal value for which we find the desired behaviour , as explained below . in the figure [ trans - land](a )\",\n \"we compare the process of landing across time for different values of the coupling . for a flock with inherent switching times @xmath94 chosen with a fixed @xmath56\",\n \"we monitor the fraction of active particles @xmath95 with time @xmath8 for different values of @xmath58 .\",\n \"we observe that when @xmath96 the particles become inactive independent of each other at their own switching times as seen from the curve @xmath97 which falls smoothly with time . on choosing @xmath98\",\n \"the behaviour is quite opposite .\",\n \"a very sharp fall occurs in the curve @xmath99 implying that there is indeed a collective decision making taking place when a large number of particles reach inactive states within a short period of time .\",\n \"however , comparing the two curves @xmath97 and @xmath99 it appears that in the latter case , the collective landing occurs at point in time which is much larger than ( by an amount of order @xmath56 ) than the switching times of most of the birds .\",\n \"we find that a much lower value of @xmath100 is relevant biologically .\",\n \"the curve @xmath101 sharply falls indicating collective behaviour and the fall occurs near at a time when about half of the birds have just crossed their inherent switching times . in the figure [ trans - land](a )\",\n \"we also plot @xmath102 which is the fraction of birds which have a momentary intention to land at time @xmath8 _\",\n \"i.e. _ , the fraction of particles with @xmath43 . unlike @xmath101 , the quantity @xmath102 is seen to fluctuate before becoming equal to the maximum value unity .\",\n \"this shows that before finally deciding to land , birds may intermittently change their decision .\",\n \"this is caused by the fluctuations in the vertical motion ( [ spin ] ) of neighbours as well as the changing neighbourhood due to finite value of @xmath24 .\",\n \"however , these fluctuations become only important near the landing regime .\",\n \"we explore an aspect of these fluctuations later . in the figure [ trans - land](b )\",\n \"we plot the velocity field of a typical flock when the majority has decided to land .\",\n \"denotes the fraction of birds not landed yet as the time @xmath8 progresses .\",\n \"the curves @xmath97 , @xmath101 and @xmath99 correspond to values of coupling @xmath103 and @xmath104 , respectively . also , @xmath102 shows the fraction of birds in state @xmath43 at time @xmath8 for @xmath100 .\",\n \"( b ) a snapshot of a collective landing of a bird flock with @xmath105 and @xmath106 with @xmath107 and @xmath100 . the arrowheads point in the direction of the velocity of the birds . , width=566 ] ) of actual landing times to the standard deviation ( @xmath56 ) of inherent switching times as a function of noise @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 , _\",\n \"i.e. _ , @xmath56 scaled by the scale of motion @xmath108 , as indicated by different symbols .\",\n \"inset ( a ) shows variation of @xmath109 _ i.e. _ , @xmath70 scaled by @xmath108 , with noise .\",\n \"inset ( b ) shows the variation of @xmath110 which ignores the first and last @xmath111 of the landings .\",\n \"( b ) the variation of the spread of the landed flock over the @xmath27-plane , relative to the spread at time @xmath54 , as a function of noise .\",\n \", width=566 ] below we quantify the extent to which the presence of the coupling affects the collectiveness in landing as we vary the scaled value of the heterogeneity ( @xmath85 ) .\",\n \"we define a measure of the sharpness of the decrease in the fraction of active particles @xmath112 ( figure [ trans - land ] ) . during the process of landing ,\",\n \"we record the times at which individual particles become inactive .\",\n \"then we calculate the standard deviation @xmath70 of the distribution of these landing times .\",\n \"finally , we divide @xmath70 by @xmath56 to get the normalized measure .\",\n \"the dimensionless quantity @xmath113 averaged over different realizations of @xmath114 s , provides a measure of the extent to which the landing of the flock is coherent in time such that @xmath115 implies the complete absence of collective decision making . in the figure [ t2080-r](a )\",\n \"we plot @xmath113 versus @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 .\",\n \"we make the following observations . for @xmath116\",\n \"the flock reaches consensus almost in the absence of any motion . as a result\",\n \"there is no variation of @xmath113 with the magnitude of noise . in this regime\",\n \"the value of @xmath70 is governed by the spread of the flock in the steady state along the vertical direction _\",\n \"i.e. _ , @xmath47\",\n \". therefore we expect that @xmath117 . in the inset ( a ) of the figure [ t2080-r](a )\",\n \"we plot the ratio @xmath118 against @xmath24 .\",\n \"it is worth mentioning that the quantity @xmath109 provides an alternate normalization of @xmath70 with respect to the other independent time scale @xmath108(@xmath119 ) .\",\n \"we find that for @xmath85 close to unity , @xmath120 asserting that the landing is coherent and the separation between landing times is due to the width @xmath47 . for larger values of @xmath85\",\n \"the value of @xmath113 also becomes large signifying gradual loss of coherence .\",\n \"we also observe that in general @xmath113 has a maximum for intermediate values of the noise .\",\n \"we find that if we choose to ignore the particles which become inactive either too early or too late , then the level of temporal coherence appears better . for a particular landing\",\n \"we measure the times @xmath121 and @xmath122 at which @xmath111 and @xmath123 of the particles , respectively , in the flock has just become inactive .\",\n \"thus we define , @xmath124 as the width of the time window in which a majority _ i.e. _ , @xmath125 of the particles become inactive .\",\n \"we normalize @xmath126 by the corresponding time window ( @xmath127 ) for a flock with the coupling @xmath96 . in the inset ( b ) of the figure [ t2080-r](a )\",\n \"we plot @xmath110 versus @xmath24 for different values of @xmath85 .\",\n \"the average behaviour reveals a level of coherence such that two birds originally having their inherent switching times separated by @xmath127 land within a period of around @xmath128 of @xmath127 .\",\n \"we investigate the degree of collectiveness as a function of the distance over which a flock lands in figure [ t2080-r](b ) .\",\n \"we calculate the following quantity : @xmath129 this quantifies the spread of the flock across the landing surface .\",\n \"we normalize the value of this spread ( @xmath130 ) when all particles become inactive by the corresponding value ( @xmath131 ) calculated with the positions of the active particles at time @xmath54 . in the figure [ t2080-r](b )\",\n \"we plot @xmath132 as function of noise varying values of @xmath85 . for low and moderate values of @xmath85 ,\",\n \"the value of @xmath132 is of the order of unity .\",\n \"the landing occurs over a region whose dimensions are comparable to dimensions of the flock . we observe that in the regime of large @xmath85 , the value of noise plays a major role in deciding the overall nature of landing .\",\n \"for very low values of @xmath24 the flock translates over large distances . due to this translation ,\",\n \"the particles reaching inactive states early are unable to influence the decision of the active particles in the flock as the _ com _ moves away from these particles . in this case\",\n \"the landing occurs in few large clusters separated in space and time . in case of higher values of the noise there\",\n \"is weak or no translation of the _ com_. however , the scale of the difference in inherent switching times _ i.e. _ , @xmath56 being very slow as compared to the scale of motion , it provides the scope for a particle with a low value of @xmath53 to diffuse to the boundary . as a result , temporarily the influence of the neighbourhood is weakened .\",\n \"this allows the particle to switch its state and become inactive .\",\n \"initially , the excursions of the particles to the comoving boundary becomes the reason behind independent landings .\",\n \"the shrinking of the boundary ( [ rb ] ) effectively screens ( depending upon the interaction radius @xmath15 ) the active particles from the inactive particles . for moderate values of @xmath24 the path of the _ com _ becomes tortuous .\",\n \"however , the effect of segregation of inactive particles from the active particles still persists .\",\n \"the landing occurs in large number of smaller clusters .\",\n \"we further characterize the above behaviour by the following definition .\",\n \"after the landing we calculate the _ com _ of the particles positioned on the @xmath27-plane .\",\n \"we define the measure of spatial coherence @xmath133 as the fraction of particles that lie within a distance @xmath134 from the _\",\n \"com_. formally , @xmath135 where , @xmath136 is the position of the @xmath4-th inactive particle , @xmath34 is the position of the _ com _ and @xmath137 is the heaviside step function .\",\n \"we expect from the above observations that @xmath133 is close to unity for a spatially coherent landing and zero in the opposite case .\",\n \"( b ) , has landed .\",\n \"the line shows the trajectory of the centre of mass of the birds in flight .\",\n \"the arrows indicate the average direction of motion of the centre of mass at different points in time .\",\n \"the circle drawn is centred on the centre of mass of all landed birds and is drawn with the radius @xmath138 of the comoving boundary .\",\n \"( b ) the measure of spatial coherence @xmath133 as a function of @xmath85 for the value of @xmath139 .\",\n \"different symbols indicate the system sizes @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 , and @xmath143 .\",\n \"inset ( a ) shows the plots with @xmath85 rescaled to @xmath144 . inset ( b ) shows the variation of @xmath145 with system size @xmath146.,width=566 ] ) of the standard deviation of the actual landing times as function of the scaled values ( @xmath85 ) of the standard deviation of the assigned switching times for different system sizes ( @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 and @xmath143 ) indicated by different symbols .\",\n \"inset ( a ) shows the collapse of the previous plots as result of transformation of the horizontal axis from @xmath85 to @xmath147 with @xmath148 and @xmath149 .\",\n \"inset ( b ) shows the variation of the ratio @xmath113 with @xmath85 .\",\n \"( b ) the variation of @xmath109 as a function of the interaction radius @xmath15 for different values of @xmath150 , @xmath151 and @xmath152 as indicated by different symbols , in flocks of size @xmath76 .\",\n \"the value of @xmath24 in both ( a ) and ( b ) is @xmath153.,width=566 ] in the figure [ com - psi](a ) we plot the positions of the birds on the @xmath27-plane after all the birds have landed .\",\n \"the line shows the trajectory of the _ com _ and the circle is drawn with the radius @xmath138 about the centre of mass calculated with the final positions of the landed birds .\",\n \"majority of the birds lying within the circle shows that in such a case spatial coherence is retained . in the figure [ com - psi](b ) we plot @xmath133 as function of @xmath85 for the value of @xmath139 .\",\n \"the different plots corresponds to different system sizes .\",\n \"the decrease in @xmath133 with increase in @xmath85 is consistent with all the previous observations . in the inset ( a ) of the figure [ com - psi](b )\",\n \"we obtain a collapse of the data after rescaling @xmath85 by @xmath145 .\",\n \"the variation of @xmath154 with the system size @xmath146 , as shown in the inset ( b ) , is found to be @xmath155 where @xmath156 ( we note that the dimension of the flock varies as @xmath157 ) .\",\n \"this relation suggests that with the increase in the system size there is an increase in the value of @xmath85 below which spatial coherence is expected .\",\n \"we investigate the dependence on system size of the temporal behaviour in the next paragraph .\",\n \"in the figure [ t - r](a ) we plot @xmath109 versus @xmath85 for four different system sizes for value of noise @xmath139 .\",\n \"the figure reveals how the spread in actual landing times increases with the value of @xmath85 . a data collapse in the inset ( a ) reveals a scaling relation of the form : @xmath158^{\\\\frac{1}{n^\\\\alpha } } , \\\\label{lambda - scale}\\\\ ] ] with @xmath148 and @xmath149 . in general , we expect @xmath159 to be function of the parameters like @xmath39 and @xmath15 .\",\n \"the equation ( [ lambda - scale ] ) suggests that for a fixed value of @xmath85 , with the increase in the system size there is increase in temporal coherence .\",\n \"we also plot the corresponding values of the ratio @xmath113 in the inset ( b ) .\",\n \"the plot shows how this ratio approaches the maximum value unity with the increase in the value of @xmath85 .\",\n \"the reason for the rise in @xmath113 for very low values of @xmath85 is already stated with respect to the figure [ t2080-r](a ) . in all the above investigations we have assumed that the interaction radius controlling the average number of neighbours of any particle is @xmath74 .\",\n \"we now address the issue of having larger ( or smaller ) interaction radii . in the figure [ t - r](b )\",\n \"we plot the variation of @xmath109 with the value of @xmath15 for different values of @xmath85 with value of noise set at @xmath139 .\",\n \"we find significant decrease in the spread @xmath109 for large values of @xmath15 .\",\n \"this suggests that global information can lead to a more coherent decision making process . of the maximum depth @xmath160 of excursions below the flock by birds , before returning to the flock as a result of temporarily reverting from the decision to land .\",\n \"the parameter sets indicated by symbols are @xmath161 , @xmath162 ( circles ) and @xmath106 , @xmath107 ( squares ) . the solid line has a slope @xmath163 and is a guide to the eye .\",\n \"( b ) the probability density function @xmath164 of the distance travelled by the centre of mass of birds in flight , @xmath165 between consecutive time steps .\",\n \"the parameter sets indicated by symbols are same as in the case of ( a ) .\",\n \"the measured slopes of the power - law fits to the curves are around @xmath166 . in both (\",\n \"a ) and ( b ) the value of @xmath167 , @xmath168 and the magnitude of the velocity @xmath18 controls the lower cut - off of the power - law decays.,width=529 ]\",\n \"lastly , we focus on the nature of fluctuations during the landing process . as a result of the decision reversals in birds under the influence from the neighbourhood ( as reflected by @xmath102 in the figure [ trans - land](a ) )\",\n \"we find that birds originally moving towards the landing surface sometimes return back to the cruising altitude .\",\n \"we characterize these fluctuations by the maximum depth @xmath160 to which a bird makes an excursion before returning to an altitude greater than @xmath169 . in the figure [ aval - dcm](a )\",\n \"we plot the probability density @xmath170 .\",\n \"we find that the distribution of @xmath160 is a power - law decay bounded by a minimum and maximum governed by the magnitude of velocity @xmath18 and the maximum possible depth @xmath44 , respectively .\",\n \"we also study the jumps that occur in position of the _ com _\",\n \"( on the @xmath27 plane ) of flying birds once the landing process starts .\",\n \"as is seen from the figure [ com - psi](a ) the trajectory of the _ com _ becomes irregular near the end .\",\n \"the _ com _ actually jumps from a cluster which ceases to move to a cluster which continues moving .\",\n \"we construct the probability density @xmath164 for the separation @xmath165 between the centres of mass at two consecutive time steps .\",\n \"we find that @xmath164 has a fat tail during the landing process . in the figure [ aval - dcm](b )\",\n \"we plot the tail of @xmath164 after binning .\",\n \"the plots reveals power law decays with close by exponents .\",\n \"the power law has a cut - off which governed by @xmath138 .\"\n ],\n [\n \"in this paper we have investigated the interplay between the dynamics of collective motion and collective decision making . in particular\",\n \"we have presented a model for landing of bird flocks .\",\n \"we have identified the relevant scales in such a problem and we have worked in the coupling regime which is expected to be biologically relevant .\",\n \"it appears that higher values of the coupling delays the process of the global opinion shift .\",\n \"we have characterized the degree of the resulting collective behaviour by different measures .\",\n \"we found that as a function of the few parameters of our model the collective switching from the flying to the landing state is indeed much sharper than the distribution of the individual ( inherent ) landing intentions . among the several interesting features of the model we proposed\",\n \", we showed that if the flock is subject to larger fluctuations , the spatial spreading of the fully landed flock becomes smaller due to a better mixing of the information about the momentary landing intentions of the birds .\",\n \"we also find that there is a characteristic value of heterogeneity which scales with the size of the flock .\",\n \"below this value of heterogeneity , flocks remain spatially coherent in the process of landing and above this value , the coherence is lost .\",\n \"in addition we have formulated a boundary condition which is pertinent to models of flocking .\",\n \"we believe that the approach we proposed is also relevant for many other systems where abrupt behavioural changes are observed .\",\n \"possible applications include various kinds of animal or even robotic groups in which an almost instantaneous global switching to a new desired state takes place .\"\n ],\n [\n \"99 conradt l and roper t j 2005 _ trends ecol\",\n \". evol . _ * 20 * 449\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":93,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"1404.0136"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["in the solar system , there are many small bodies such as asteroids and comets .","since these small astronomical objects could keep the ancient information of the history of the solar system , a lot of efforts have been devoted to investigations of these objects so far ( e.g. , @xcite ) .","for instance , the asteroid itokawa was explored by the japanese space craft _ hayabusa _ from september 2005 .","the exploration uncovered the details of itokawa s surface terrain .","itokawa is covered by various sizes of granular matter such as regolith , pebbles , and boulders @xcite .","moreover , migrations and sorting of the regolith could occur on the surface of itokawa @xcite , although the surface gravity of itokawa is extremely low .","impact craters located on the surface of itokawa were very subtle , i.e. , they show indistinct morphologies @xcite .","this is probably due to the erasure of the craters by seismic shaking @xcite .","in addition , tiny samples returned from itokawa allow us to analyze the detail of its history .","@xcite revealed that itokawa s surface grains are relatively young in terms of cosmic - rays exposure .","the estimated age is approximately eight million years . besides , using x - ray microtomography , @xcite found that some particles had rounded edges .","all these facts suggest that the surface of itokawa would be active and continue to be renewed until recently",". one possible explanation of such young surface is the regolith convection caused by impact - induced seismic shaking .","although the direct measurement of the seismic wave has not been achieved , @xcite and @xcite studied the possibility of global seismic shaking of asteroid eros in order to explain its surface modification processes .","they built a model of seismic shaking by considering the attenuating diffusion of the seismic wave .","@xcite partially applied the model to the asteroid itokawa and showed that the global regolith convection might occur even by small - scale impacts . to unlock the regolith grains network supported by gravity , the maximum acceleration induced by the seismic shaking has to be greater than the gravitational acceleration .","@xcite revealed that this criterion can be satisfied by a small - scale impact since the gravity on the surface of itokawa @xmath3 is very small , @xmath4 m / s@xmath5 @xcite .","the value of @xmath3 is about five orders of magnitude smaller than the earth s gravitational acceleration , @xmath6 m / s@xmath5 .","the evaluation is still qualitative since they only assessed the onset criterion of the regolith convection .","while the quantitative assessment of the convective velocity is necessary to discuss the feasibility of the regolith convection , there have been very few such studies .","granular convection can be generally observed in a granular matter under the mechanical vibration . when a granular matter is subjected to a steady vertical vibration , granular convection","is readily induced .","if the vibrated granular matter is polydisperse , the size segregation of grains occurs usually in vertical direction .","this vibration - induced size segregation is called brazil nut effect ( bne ) .","the bne can be caused by the granular convection @xcite .","this means that the grains can be migrated and sorted simultaneously by vibration .","although the regolith convection accompanied by migration and sorting seems to be a natural outcome of global seismic shaking , the scaling approach to the granular convective velocity is needed to discuss the consistency between regolith convection and observational data such as surface age of the asteroid .","therefore , we experimentally measure and scale the velocity of granular convection in this study , as a first - step approach to this problem . fundamental nature of granular convection itself is an intriguing problem .","the granular convection has long been studied both by experiments @xcite and numerical simulations @xcite . the onset of granular convection depends on the maximum acceleration of the applied vibration .","if the maximum acceleration is less than the gravitational acceleration , any granular convection does not occur at all ( e.g. , @xcite ) .","thus the dimensionless parameter @xmath7 , which represents the balance between the maximum vibrational acceleration and the gravitational acceleration @xmath1 , has been used to characterize the behavior of granular convection .","@xmath7 is defined as , @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the vibration amplitude and @xmath10 is the frequency . in this study ,","the scaling method is applied to the analysis of granular convective velocity .","we are interested in asteroidal - scale granular convection while the actual experiment is limited within the laboratory scale .","in such a situation , the scaling is the only way to derive a meaningful quantitative relation . in the scaling analysis ,","dimensionless parameters such as @xmath7 are useful since they do not depend on the system of unit .","the weak point of the scaling analysis is its arbitrariness .","of course , @xmath7 is one of the most important dimensionless parameters to discuss the vibrated granular matter .","however , the choice of the important dimensionless parameter is not unique .","specifically , another dimensionless parameter called shaking parameter @xmath11 was firstly introduced by @xcite and recently used to describe the transitions among the granular leidenfrost , bouncing bed , undulations , convection , and so on @xcite .","particularly , @xmath11 is relevant to characterize a strongly shaken shallow granular convection @xcite .","@xmath11 is defined as , @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the constitutive grains diameter .","@xmath11 denotes the balance between the squared vibrational velocity and the squared gravitational velocity .","furthermore , @xmath11 can be also obtained by the natural non - dimensionalization of the granular - hydrodynamic model for the strongly shaken granular convection @xcite . using the aforementioned dimensionless parameters",", we would like to find a useful scaling relation between granular convective velocity , the gravitational acceleration , and other parameters .","therefore , we carry out a systematic laboratory experiments of the vibration - induced granular convection",". this paper is constructed by following sections . in section","[ sec : experiment ] , we explain the experimental setup and how to measure the convective velocity . section [ sec : results ] shows the characterization of some convective - roll patterns and the result of the scaling . in section [ sec : discussion ] , we discuss physical meaning and tentative implication of the scaling to the microgravity environment .","section [ sec : conclusions ] contains a conclusions .","a schematic illustration of the experimental apparatus is shown in fig . [","fig : setup ] .","the experimental setup consists of a cylinder made by plexiglass of its height @xmath14 mm and inner radius @xmath15 ( @xmath16 , @xmath17 , or @xmath18 mm ) .","glass beads are poured in the cylindrical cell to make a granular bed of the height @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , or @xmath22 mm .","the system is mounted on an electromechanical vibrator ( emic 513-b / a ) and shaken vertically .","the vibration frequency @xmath10 is varied from @xmath23 to @xmath24 hz and @xmath7 is varied from @xmath25 to @xmath26 .","the grains used in this study are glass beads .","most of experiments are carried out with glass beads of diameter @xmath27 mm ( as - one corp .","bz08 ) and some of them are performed with glass beads of @xmath28 or @xmath25 mm ( as - one corp .","bz04 , bz2 ) .","size dispersion of glass beads is less than @xmath29% , and the true density of glass beads is @xmath30 kg / m@xmath31 .","[ 0.9 ] to measure the granular convective velocity , particle imaging velocimetry ( piv ) method is utilized @xcite .","motions of glass beads are filmed by a high - speed camera ( photoron sa-5 ) through a transparent side wall . to erase the memory effect of granular matter ,","one minute pre - vibration is applied before each experimental realization .","this means that we measure the steady granular convection .","while the actual impact - induced regolith convection might be transient , we have to concentrate on the steady convection to eliminate the memory effect .","the frame rate is fixed at @xmath32 fps and spatial resolution of the image ranges from @xmath33 @xmath34m / pixel to @xmath35 @xmath34m / pixel depending on the experimental conditions .","the high - speed images are acquired for @xmath36 s. since each image consists of @xmath37 pixels , the size of field of view ranges from @xmath38 to @xmath39 mm@xmath5 .","raw data images are shown in backgrounds of figs .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] . since it is hard to completely follow all the grains motion , we use piv method instead of the direct particle tracking . in the analyses of figs .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] ( a ) , each instantaneous image is divided into @xmath40 boxes , i.e. , each box consists of @xmath41 pixels .","note that the number of image partitioning depends on the experimental condition .","then the velocity at each box is computed by detecting a peak of the cross - correlation between two different time snapshots .","obtained ( time - averaged ) examples of the velocity field are shown by colored vectors in figs .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] . an interval time to compute the velocity ( cross - correlation )","is kept constant so that it corresponds to a multiple of the period of vibration , i.e. , two cross - correlated images are kept in same phase .","for instance , @xmath42 s time interval is used for @xmath43 hz vibration .","if we use a full temporal resolution to calculate the velocity field , vibrational motion of individual grains can be captured just like @xcite measurement .","however , we are mainly interested in the global convective motion rather than such microscopic vibration . therefore , we use phase - matching images to compute the velocity . as shown in fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] , convective - velocity vectors are decomposed into @xmath44 ( vertical ) and @xmath45 ( horizontal ) directions .","they are averaged along the horizontal axis since we are mainly focusing on the axisymmetric convective flow ( like fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] ) for the reason mentioned later",". then we obtain vertical and horizontal components of velocities as functions of @xmath44 , respectively as , @xmath46 and @xmath47 . in fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] , panels ( b ) and ( c ) respectively show @xmath46 and @xmath47 computed from the velocity field shown in panel ( a ) . the positive direction of @xmath44 axis is taken to downward , and @xmath48 corresponds to the top surface of the granular bed .","@xmath49 is the center of container . above the surface of granular bed ( @xmath50 ) ,","saltations of grains are dominant and the measured velocity becomes random .","this is the reason of large errors in @xmath51 and @xmath52 at @xmath50 ( fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b , c ) ) .","first , we are going to focus on the global structure of the granular convective motion .","we find that the global structure shows a transition from a single roll to a toroidal roll as @xmath10 increases . in the former state ,","grains rise up on the one side wall and fall down on the opposite side wall .","thus , in this state , the resultant velocity field shows a certain circularity . due to this circularity ,","a gradient of the velocity field is observed as shown in fig .","[ fig : vectorplot](a ) . in this single - roll state ,","the degree of velocity gradient or circularity strongly depends on the viewing spot . in the latter state ,","on the other hand , grains rise up at the center of container and fall down on all over the wall homogeneously .","the inner structure of this granular convective mode has been observed by using the magnetic resonance imaging ( mri ) method @xcite . in other words ,","this toroidal convection state is axisymmetric .","typical examples of raw images for such homogeneous convection are shown in figs .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](a ) and [ fig : vectorplot](b ) .","a phase diagram of the global structure in @xmath10-@xmath7 space is displayed in fig . [","fig : phase_diagram ] . as seen in fig .","[ fig : phase_diagram ] , the transition occurs at @xmath53 hz .","the transition is almost independent of @xmath7 at least under the current experimental condition .","note that the phase diagram is constructed only based on the experiment with @xmath27 mm glass beads . besides ,","although we define two types of convective roll structures , this classification is not conclusive .","detail measurements of inner structures of convective rolls are necessary to completely categorize the convective structures .","the current classification is still tentative since it is based only on the observation by eye . -@xmath7 space with @xmath54 mm , @xmath55 mm and @xmath27 mm .","the symbols represent the observed structures of granular convection ; open circles correspond to the single - roll state and cross markers indicate the toroidal - roll state .","a phase boundary can be found around @xmath56 hz independently of @xmath7.,title=\"fig : \" ] next , we analyze the convective velocity . since the main motivation of this study is to characterize the scaling behavior of the representative convective velocity in a vibrated granular matter , we are going to focus on the toroidal - roll ( axisymmetric ) state . in the single - roll state ,","convective velocity is spatially heterogeneous in horizontal direction as shown in fig .","[ fig : vectorplot](a ) .","as mentioned above , the observable velocity field depends on the camera angle since the rolling direction is stochastically determined and can not be controlled in the single - roll state .","such a state is inappropriate to extract a representative velocity of the system .","by contrast , the toroidal - roll state is rather homogeneous everywhere in @xmath45 direction of the side wall as shown in figs .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](a ) and [ fig : vectorplot](b ) .","furthermore , @xmath52 is always almost zero at any @xmath44 ( fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](c ) ) , and @xmath57 is basically a simple decreasing function of @xmath44 ( fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) ) in the toroidal - roll state .","@xcite found a qualitatively similar velocity profile in the vibrated granular convection .","they also used the maximum velocity to characterize the convective velocity .","therefore , we use the same strategy in the analysis of the representative convective velocity .","namely , we employ the maximum value of the vertical component of velocity , @xmath58 , as a representative convective velocity to characterize the velocity field .","temporal homogeneity of @xmath51 is also examined . in the toroidal - roll state ,","its spatial structure of the convective velocity is symmetric and simple as discussed above .","then , how about the temporal structure ?","[ fig : time_changing ] , a typical time series data of @xmath59 ( @xmath58 at each time @xmath60 ) is shown . while @xmath58 basically looks more or less steady , a sort of intermittent velocity spikes","can be observed in fig .","[ fig : time_changing ] .","this slight intermittency might come from the inherent complexity of the granular flow due to the frictional effect .","at @xmath61 , @xmath62 hz , @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .","intermittent spikes can be observed as well as random fluctuation around the mean value .","a horizontal solid line indicates the average value ( @xmath63 mm / s ) and dotted lines show standard deviation levels ( @xmath64 mm / s).,title=\"fig : \" ] the distribution of velocities @xmath65 obtained from the data of fig . [","fig : time_changing ] is displayed in fig .","[ fig : histogram ] .","here , @xmath65 indicates the number in the range of @xmath66 and @xmath67 mm / s is the bin size .","the distribution has a clear peak around @xmath68 mm / s .","however , an asymmetric tail can be observed at large @xmath58 regime .","whereas this statistical property of the convective velocity field could contain rich physics , here we neglect the asymmetric structure for simplicity s sake . in fig .","[ fig : histogram ] , the mean value and standard deviation of the entire data set are shown as a filled circle and an error bar shown above the histogram .","more detail analyses of @xmath59 by its distribution and temporal correlation etc .","are interesting future problems . computed from the data in fig .","[ fig : time_changing ] .","width of each bin is @xmath69 mm / s .","one can confirm the peak of @xmath70 around @xmath71 mm / s and the asymmetric tail in large velocity regime . above the histogram , mean and standard deviation are shown as a filled circle and an error bar , respectively ( @xmath72 mm / s ) .","the corresponding standard error is @xmath73 mm / s which is smaller than the size of the circle mark.,title=\"fig : \" ] finally , a scaling of the granular convective velocity is derived . as a first step of the scaling , we focus on the effect of vibration - conditions ( @xmath10 and @xmath7 ) by fixing the geometric conditions : @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .","as mentioned above , we regard @xmath58 as a representative granular convective velocity .","more precisely , we use the maximum value of @xmath46 profile ( e.g. , fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) ) as @xmath58 . in order to discuss the scale - free nature ,","a relation among dimensionless parameters should be analyzed .","thus @xmath58 is normalized to the characteristic velocity created by gravity as , @xmath74 in fig .","[ fig : g_scaling ] , @xmath75 vs. @xmath7 for various @xmath10 is shown .","one can confirm that all the @xmath75 data are similar increasing functions of @xmath7 .","however , these specific values depend not only on @xmath7 but also on @xmath10 . therefore , it is hard to obtain a universal scale - free relation from this plot .","in other words , sole @xmath7 can not characterize the granular convective velocity very well . while @xcite used @xmath7 and the normalized bed height to collapse the convective velocity data ,","here we consider a different quantity to deduce a simple power - law form for the granular convective velocity .","note that the specific functional form of the granular convective velocity was not obtained by @xcite .","we find that the shaking parameter @xmath11 is a relevant dimensionless parameter to scale @xmath75 .","corresponding scaling plot is shown in fig .","[ fig : s_scaling ] . all of the @xmath75 data collapse to a power - law form , @xmath76 where @xmath77 is a characteristic exponent obtained by the data fitting shown as a dashed line in fig .","[ fig : s_scaling ] .","the solid line corresponds to @xmath78 which is determined by the scaling with various system size data ( fig .","[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) . as mentioned before",", @xmath11 represents the balance between the vibrational and gravitational velocities .","thus it is rather natural that another velocity balance ( convective velocity vs. gravitational velocity ; @xmath79 ) is scaled by @xmath11 .","the range of @xmath11 we used in this study is slightly different from that in the previous studies . in @xcite ,","@xmath11 was used to characterize the onset of convection in the strongly shaken shallow granular bed . in this study",", we experimentally confirm that @xmath11 is also useful to the scaling analysis of the convective velocity in a weakly shaken thick granular bed .","the range of @xmath11 for our experiment is from @xmath80 to @xmath81 .","although the order of this regime is about one order of magnitude smaller than that in the experiment of @xcite ( @xmath82 ) , the current experimental result is also well explained by @xmath11 . by @xmath7 .","each open symbol shows the data of glass beads bed of @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .","while a systematic correlation between @xmath75 and @xmath7 can be observed , a universal form can not be obtained solely by @xmath7 scaling.,title=\"fig : \" ] by @xmath11 .","colors and markers used are identical to those in fig .","[ fig : g_scaling ] .","the dashed line represents the power law fit ( eqs .","( [ eq : fitting ] ) ) . the slope ( power ) of the dashed line","is computed as @xmath77 .","the solid line corresponds to @xmath78 which is obtained by the least square search for all the data including various system size parameters ( fig .","[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) .",", title=\"fig : \" ] as a next step of the scaling , we investigate the system size dependence of @xmath75 by the varying geometric parameters : bed height @xmath83 and its radius @xmath15 . in fig .","[ fig : aspect_ratio ] , the data of @xmath75 vs. @xmath84 for various @xmath7 and @xmath10 are shown .","non - axisymmetric convection patterns such as a single - roll state are sometimes found in the experiment at some @xmath84 . due to the inhomogeneity ,","the representative velocities in these states show extremely large dispersion .","since we restrict ourselves within the analysis of representative velocity in the homogeneous convection , these data are excluded from the analysis . as shown in fig .","[ fig : aspect_ratio ] , we find that @xmath75 is roughly independent of @xmath84 although its specific value clearly depends on vibrational conditions ( @xmath7 and @xmath10 ) .","this simple relation @xmath85 suggests that @xmath75 can be scaled equivalently both by @xmath15 and @xmath83 .","namely , @xmath75 is the increasing function both of @xmath15 and @xmath83",". then we can reduce the number of geometric parameters , i.e. , @xmath15 and @xmath83 can be unified into a single parameter . in specific , a dimensionless parameter for the system size @xmath86 can be introduced by using grains diameter @xmath13 as , @xmath87 to the aspect ratio of the shaken granular bed , @xmath84 .","colors and shapes of markers indicate vibrational conditions as denoted in the legend .","all the data points are originated from the experiments with glass beads of @xmath27 mm ( bz08 ) .","we remove the data of single - roll state from this plot .","although the level of @xmath75 depends on vibrational conditions , it is roughly independent of @xmath84 .","dashed lines are the average levels for each condition.,title=\"fig : \" ] to prove the validity of the dimensionless parameter @xmath86 , @xmath13 should be varied as well as @xmath15 and @xmath83 .","therefore , we also examine the @xmath13 dependence of @xmath88 . for this purpose ,","the aspect ratio is fixed ( @xmath54 mm and @xmath55 mm ) and glass beads of @xmath28 mm ( bz04 ) and @xmath89 mm ( bz2 ) are used in the experiment . while @xmath75 of bz04 is in the same order as the bz08 case",", @xmath75 of bz2 is about one order of magnitude smaller than that of bz08 , under the same vibrational condition .","this is due to the effect of crystallization which prevents the convective motion .","besides , the solidification ( complete crystallization ) of glass beads bed occurs when bz2 is shaken by @xmath90 .","the crystallization is unavoidable for the larger grains as long as we use nearly mono - disperse spherical grains . whereas the number of data points is not enough to discuss the specific scaling form",", we qualitatively confirm that the convective velocity is a decreasing function of @xmath13 .","altogether , we can assume a simple scaling relation among these dimensionless parameters to compile all the data .","the assumed scaling form is written as , @xmath91 the values of @xmath92 and @xmath93 are computed by searching the least square point in the range of @xmath94 and @xmath95 .","the least square fitting in fig .","( [ fig : sl_scaling ] ) is computed with weighting of the standard deviation ( velocity scattering degree ) .","the obtained values are @xmath78 and @xmath96 .","and the computed numerical prefactor is @xmath97 .","the scaling result for all the experimentally obtained data is shown in fig . [","fig : sl_scaling ] .","as can be seen , the data are basically well scaled by the variable @xmath98 . the corresponding scaling line ( @xmath99 )","is also plotted in fig .","[ fig : s_scaling ] as a solid line .","the value of @xmath92 is slightly improved from the fixed system size case ( fig .","( [ fig : s_scaling ] ) ) . in fig .","[ fig : sl_scaling ] , two data points deviate significantly from the scaling .","this deviation comes from the crystallization effect of large glass beads ( bz2 ) .","the inset of fig .","[ fig : sl_scaling ] shows a linear plot of the same data .","this scaling relation is the main result of this experimental investigation .","there are some missing parameters in the scaling of eq .","( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) . for example",", density is not involved in it .","that is , the scaling is a kind of kinematic one .","the density dependence has to be clarified to understand the dynamic scaling including the effect of inertia @xcite .","perhaps , this would not be so critical because the density of glass beads ( @xmath30 kg / m@xmath31 ) is close to ( at least in the same order with ) the real regolith density ( e.g. , @xmath100 kg / m@xmath31 for itokawa @xcite ) .","another example of the missing parameters is the cohesive force among grains .","although the gravitational force is very small on the surface of small asteroids , the cohesive effect would instead play a crucial role @xcite .","it is hard to check this effect by the current experiment since we do not vary the cohesiveness of grains . in the current experiment ,","the cohesive force is negligible since it is much smaller than the gravitational force .","we assume that interstitial air and electrostatic effects do not play essential roles , i.e. , they are much smaller than gravity effect . indeed , the air effect is negligible as long as we use @xmath101 mm grains ( see e.g. , supplementary information of @xcite ) .","we also think that the gravitational force is more dominant than the electrostatic force for the bulk convective motion of glass beads .","in fact , while we saw a few glass beads sticking on the sidewall due to the electrostatic effect , those were really few . the electrostatic effect might slightly affect the convective motion .","however , we consider it can not be a dominant effect .","a much more serious problem is the absence of frictional properties in the scaling .","the frictional properties are a possible origin of intermittent velocity fluctuation shown in fig .","[ fig : time_changing ] .","in addition , it might affect the representative value of convective velocity .","frictional properties relate to the shape of constitutive grains . obviously , actual regolith grains shapes are irregular and rough . by a preliminary experiment",", we actually confirm that @xmath58 significantly reduces when the rough - shaped sand grains are used . on the contrary",", some previous studies have reported that the friction can enhance the convective velocity @xcite . moreover ,","the grain - wall friction is different from grain - grain friction .","the grain - wall friction could be a reason of the onset of granular convection in this experiment .","the detailed study for the effect of friction is a very important future problem .","the origin of granular convection in the current experiment is plausibly the effect of wall . as already mentioned , the structure of the convective roll changes spontaneously when @xmath10 or @xmath15 are varied","this implies that there is an inherent length scale in the granular convection .","however , the wall effect to the velocity scaling is still significant even in split ( doubled ) roll state since we observe the grains motion on the wall .","moreover , it has been shown that experimental conditions including the container s shape and interstitial air influence the convective roll structure @xcite . in these previous studies",", the interaction between grains and wall seems to be a key factor .","nevertheless , astronomical objects obviously maintain their own shapes without any wall .","it is hard to eliminate the container wall effect in usual granular experiments even in microgravity environment .","rather , highly heterogenous structure of small asteroids might work as an effective wall which triggers the granular convection .","put another way , there could be a lot of effective boundaries and/or gradients of frictional properties in actual small asteroids .","thus it is not quite clear whether the granular convection occurs globally or locally in small asteroids .","the structure of the velocity profile @xmath46 is informative both for the granular physics and planetary science . in the previous studies of granular convection @xcite",", convective velocity decays rapidly ( exponentially ) with depth .","and the deep region of the vibrated granular matter is almost at rest .","if this peculiar regime called _ frozen zone _ presents in the real asteroids convection , the regolith migration occurs only within a shallow region . in the current experiment ,","most of velocity profiles do not show the clear frozen zone .","the convective velocity decays calmly as typically shown in fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) .","thus the convective velocity is simply scaled by @xmath86 with the nontrivial exponent @xmath102 .","if the frozen zone is clearly observed , the convective velocity would be saturated at a certain @xmath83 , and it can not be simply scaled by a single exponent . actually , the frozen zone can be partially observed also in the current experiment under small @xmath7 , large @xmath10 , and large @xmath83 conditions .","since we are interested in the principal flow velocity of the granular convection , we have focused only on the axisymmetric convective state and its maximum velocity @xmath58 , in this study .","detailed analysis of @xmath46 profile is a next important step to reveal the granular convection dynamics that relates to the depth of regolith convection occurring in small astronomical objects .","so far , the scaling form for the granular convective velocity has been discussed on the basis of systematically performed experimental results . in this subsection",", we discuss the implication of the obtained scaling law .","the scaling of eq .","( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) can be rewritten by considering its physical meaning .","then the scaling is compared with a recent experimental result of two - dimensional granular convection .","equation ( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) can be transformed into a following form , @xmath103 this form is more understandable than eq .","( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) .","the representative velocity @xmath58 is expressed by a power law product of two characteristic velocities : gravitational @xmath104 and vibrational @xmath105 .","in addition , the system size dependence is scaled by the last factor @xmath106 .","the scaling of eq .","( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) is qualitatively consistent with a recent experiment performed by @xcite .","they investigated the convective - driven bne and found that the convective velocity linearly depends on @xmath105 .","to better explain the experimental data , the use of @xmath105 was much better than @xmath7 . according to eq .","( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , convective velocity depends on vibrational velocity as , @xmath107 .","these two experimental results show a good agreement . however , they reported the presence of critical vibrational velocity below which the granular convection was not induced .","this critical vibrational velocity probably corresponds to the onset criterion . in the current analysis",", however , we do not clearly confirm this offset in the scaling ( see fig .","[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) .","instead , we varied @xmath11 over two orders of magnitude to obtain the power - law relation .","the range of @xmath11 and other parameters were relatively narrow in the study of @xcite since they are not interested in the scale - free form .","thus they reported the linear relation between the convective velocity and the vibrational velocity . on the other hand",", we obtain the scaling ( power law ) relation between the convective velocity , the vibrational velocity , and the gravitational velocity .","it should be noted that the system size dependence of the scaling is bounded . according to eq .","( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , the value of @xmath58 can be very large when @xmath108 becomes large .","this condition corresponds to a large @xmath109 or a small @xmath13 case . at the limit of @xmath110 or @xmath111",", @xmath58 diverges .","however , such a divergence does not occur in the actual granular convection .","the convective roll size can not grow to the infinitely large size .","in fact , we experimentally observed the split of the convective roll ( double toroidal - roll ) in a very shallow layer , although such a split rarely happened .","this preliminary observation indicates that there might be an intrinsic length scale which determines the maximum convective roll size .","since the current experimental system size is limited , it is hard to systematically reveal the effect of this intrinsic length scale . at a small @xmath13 regime ,","on the other hand , the cohesive force among grains becomes dominant instead of the gravitational force .","the current scaling form can not be applied to such a situation .","the detailed investigation on the size - dependent scaling form for more widely spreading size regime is an important future problem . to investigate the small @xmath13 regime ,","the experiment under the vacuum condition is also necessary .","finally , the experimentally obtained scaling is cast into a form in which the gravity effect can be directly evaluated .","since the interpretation of scaling is not unique in general , we have to take a special care for its understanding . whereas the discussion in this subsection is speculative , the result is consistent with other related works .","moreover , the obtained scaling includes various parameters such as vibration frequency and system size .","thus the form is very efficient to estimate the timescale of regolith convection occurring on the surface of small asteroid .","recently , some granular flow experiments were performed under microgravity conditions created by parabolic flights @xcite .","@xcite used a taylor - couette geometry and measured both sheared and convective flows induced by the shearing .","particularly , @xcite reported the effect of gravity to the sheared granular convection .","they claimed that the gravity plays an essential role to make a stiff grains network in a bulk granular matter .","such a grains network is necessary to transform a shear stress into a driving force of the convective motion .","therefore , the granular convective velocity under the microgravity became almost zero .","moreover , the convective velocity under the high - gravity condition became large @xcite .","@xcite measured the rising velocity of intruders in convective - driven bne under the reduced gravity .","they found that the rising velocity is almost linearly scaled by the gravity . to compare the current result with above - mentioned microgravity experiments ,","here we evaluate the gravity influence to the convective velocity based on eq .","( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) . at a glance of eq .","( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , the convective velocity is scaled as @xmath112 .","this scaling implicitly assumes the fixed @xmath105 under different @xmath1 environment .","this assumption is not practical to estimate the granular convective velocity induced under the different @xmath1 .","for instance , under the microgravity environment , very small vibrational acceleration is enough to satisfy the onset criterion of granular convection ( @xmath113 ) . however , if @xmath105 is fixed to consider the granular convective velocity under the microgravity environment , the corresponding @xmath7 becomes extremely large .","it is not a realistic assumption . instead",", the value of @xmath7 should be fixed to estimate the convective velocity by means of similarity law .","in fact , fixed @xmath7 was used to discuss the possibility of convection on the surface of itokawa @xcite . @xcite","also fixed @xmath7 to discuss @xmath1 dependence .","therefore , the typical vibrational velocity should be written as @xmath114 instead of @xmath105 .","then , eq . ( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) can be modified into the following form , @xmath115 according to eq .","( [ eq : scaling2 ] ) , @xmath58 depends on @xmath1 as , @xmath116 .","the value @xmath117 is close to unity .","this result is qualitatively similar to @xcite and @xcite .","however , note that we do not directly vary the gravitational acceleration .","the @xmath1 dependence is indirectly deduced from the scaling . besides , the convective motion of @xcite was induced by shear in a taylor - couette cell . thus the similarity is rather qualitative .","using eq .","( [ eq : scaling2 ] ) and a model of seismic shaking induced by impacts @xcite , we are able to estimate the convective velocity for various astronomical objects .","to do that , we have to be careful in the estimate of @xmath106 .","whereas its value strongly affects the estimate of @xmath58 , it is still very uncertain",". then it might be possible to evaluate the surface age ( resurfacing timescale ) of the microgravity asteroid by considering the population of impactors .","such an estimate for itokawa or eros is an interesting application of this scaling .","this topic is a part of ongoing investigation .","an experimental study of the granular convection was performed with a vertically shaken glass beads bed .","the maximum convective velocity @xmath58 was measured by piv method .","although the @xmath58 was measured on the wall , we assume that it corresponds to a representative value of the convective velocity .","the normalized convective velocity @xmath118 was scaled by the shaking parameter @xmath119 and the dimensionless system size @xmath108 .","the obtained scaling ( eq ( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) ) indicates that the representative convective velocity can be written as a certain power - law product of the vibrational velocity @xmath105 , the gravitational velocity @xmath104 , and the dimensionless system size @xmath86 .","this experimentally obtained scaling law is qualitatively consistent with other previous studies of granular convection or bne . using the scaling law",", one can roughly estimate the convective velocity for various vibrational conditions , in principle . since the gravitational acceleration and frictional properties","are not varied in this experiment , applicability of the current result toward actual regolith migration might be still limited .","systematic further studies have to be carried out to unveil the regolith migration dynamics owing to the granular convection .","we would like to thank to s. watanabe , h. kumagai , s. sirono , and t. morota for fruitful discussions and suggestions . this research has been partly supported by jsps kakenhi grant number 23654134 and nagoya university program for leading graduate schools ( leadership development program for space exploration and research ) .","39 natexlab#1#1[1]`#1 ` [ 2]#2 [ 1]#1 [ 1]http://dx.doi.org/#1 [ ] [ 1]pmid:#1 [ ] [ 2]#2 , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,",", , , , . . , . , , ,",". . , . , , , ( eds . ) , . .",", , , . . ,",", , , , , , . . ,",", , , , , , . . , . , , , , ,",", , , , . . ,",". , . . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,",". . , . , , , ,",", , , , . . ,",", , , , . . ,",", , , , , , , , , , , . . ,",". , . . , . , ,",", , , , , , . . ,",", , , . . ,",", , , , , . . ,",", , , . . ,",", , , , . . ,",", , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,",", , , , , , a. . , .",", , , , , , , b. . , .",", , , , , , , c. . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,",", , , . . ,",", , , , , . . ,",", , , . . ,",", , , , . . ,",", , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,",", , , , . . ,",". , . . , . , , , , ,",". . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,",". . , . , , , , ,"],"string":"[\n \"in the solar system , there are many small bodies such as asteroids and comets .\",\n \"since these small astronomical objects could keep the ancient information of the history of the solar system , a lot of efforts have been devoted to investigations of these objects so far ( e.g. , @xcite ) .\",\n \"for instance , the asteroid itokawa was explored by the japanese space craft _ hayabusa _ from september 2005 .\",\n \"the exploration uncovered the details of itokawa s surface terrain .\",\n \"itokawa is covered by various sizes of granular matter such as regolith , pebbles , and boulders @xcite .\",\n \"moreover , migrations and sorting of the regolith could occur on the surface of itokawa @xcite , although the surface gravity of itokawa is extremely low .\",\n \"impact craters located on the surface of itokawa were very subtle , i.e. , they show indistinct morphologies @xcite .\",\n \"this is probably due to the erasure of the craters by seismic shaking @xcite .\",\n \"in addition , tiny samples returned from itokawa allow us to analyze the detail of its history .\",\n \"@xcite revealed that itokawa s surface grains are relatively young in terms of cosmic - rays exposure .\",\n \"the estimated age is approximately eight million years . besides , using x - ray microtomography , @xcite found that some particles had rounded edges .\",\n \"all these facts suggest that the surface of itokawa would be active and continue to be renewed until recently\",\n \". one possible explanation of such young surface is the regolith convection caused by impact - induced seismic shaking .\",\n \"although the direct measurement of the seismic wave has not been achieved , @xcite and @xcite studied the possibility of global seismic shaking of asteroid eros in order to explain its surface modification processes .\",\n \"they built a model of seismic shaking by considering the attenuating diffusion of the seismic wave .\",\n \"@xcite partially applied the model to the asteroid itokawa and showed that the global regolith convection might occur even by small - scale impacts . to unlock the regolith grains network supported by gravity , the maximum acceleration induced by the seismic shaking has to be greater than the gravitational acceleration .\",\n \"@xcite revealed that this criterion can be satisfied by a small - scale impact since the gravity on the surface of itokawa @xmath3 is very small , @xmath4 m / s@xmath5 @xcite .\",\n \"the value of @xmath3 is about five orders of magnitude smaller than the earth s gravitational acceleration , @xmath6 m / s@xmath5 .\",\n \"the evaluation is still qualitative since they only assessed the onset criterion of the regolith convection .\",\n \"while the quantitative assessment of the convective velocity is necessary to discuss the feasibility of the regolith convection , there have been very few such studies .\",\n \"granular convection can be generally observed in a granular matter under the mechanical vibration . when a granular matter is subjected to a steady vertical vibration , granular convection\",\n \"is readily induced .\",\n \"if the vibrated granular matter is polydisperse , the size segregation of grains occurs usually in vertical direction .\",\n \"this vibration - induced size segregation is called brazil nut effect ( bne ) .\",\n \"the bne can be caused by the granular convection @xcite .\",\n \"this means that the grains can be migrated and sorted simultaneously by vibration .\",\n \"although the regolith convection accompanied by migration and sorting seems to be a natural outcome of global seismic shaking , the scaling approach to the granular convective velocity is needed to discuss the consistency between regolith convection and observational data such as surface age of the asteroid .\",\n \"therefore , we experimentally measure and scale the velocity of granular convection in this study , as a first - step approach to this problem . fundamental nature of granular convection itself is an intriguing problem .\",\n \"the granular convection has long been studied both by experiments @xcite and numerical simulations @xcite . the onset of granular convection depends on the maximum acceleration of the applied vibration .\",\n \"if the maximum acceleration is less than the gravitational acceleration , any granular convection does not occur at all ( e.g. , @xcite ) .\",\n \"thus the dimensionless parameter @xmath7 , which represents the balance between the maximum vibrational acceleration and the gravitational acceleration @xmath1 , has been used to characterize the behavior of granular convection .\",\n \"@xmath7 is defined as , @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the vibration amplitude and @xmath10 is the frequency . in this study ,\",\n \"the scaling method is applied to the analysis of granular convective velocity .\",\n \"we are interested in asteroidal - scale granular convection while the actual experiment is limited within the laboratory scale .\",\n \"in such a situation , the scaling is the only way to derive a meaningful quantitative relation . in the scaling analysis ,\",\n \"dimensionless parameters such as @xmath7 are useful since they do not depend on the system of unit .\",\n \"the weak point of the scaling analysis is its arbitrariness .\",\n \"of course , @xmath7 is one of the most important dimensionless parameters to discuss the vibrated granular matter .\",\n \"however , the choice of the important dimensionless parameter is not unique .\",\n \"specifically , another dimensionless parameter called shaking parameter @xmath11 was firstly introduced by @xcite and recently used to describe the transitions among the granular leidenfrost , bouncing bed , undulations , convection , and so on @xcite .\",\n \"particularly , @xmath11 is relevant to characterize a strongly shaken shallow granular convection @xcite .\",\n \"@xmath11 is defined as , @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the constitutive grains diameter .\",\n \"@xmath11 denotes the balance between the squared vibrational velocity and the squared gravitational velocity .\",\n \"furthermore , @xmath11 can be also obtained by the natural non - dimensionalization of the granular - hydrodynamic model for the strongly shaken granular convection @xcite . using the aforementioned dimensionless parameters\",\n \", we would like to find a useful scaling relation between granular convective velocity , the gravitational acceleration , and other parameters .\",\n \"therefore , we carry out a systematic laboratory experiments of the vibration - induced granular convection\",\n \". this paper is constructed by following sections . in section\",\n \"[ sec : experiment ] , we explain the experimental setup and how to measure the convective velocity . section [ sec : results ] shows the characterization of some convective - roll patterns and the result of the scaling . in section [ sec : discussion ] , we discuss physical meaning and tentative implication of the scaling to the microgravity environment .\",\n \"section [ sec : conclusions ] contains a conclusions .\",\n \"a schematic illustration of the experimental apparatus is shown in fig . [\",\n \"fig : setup ] .\",\n \"the experimental setup consists of a cylinder made by plexiglass of its height @xmath14 mm and inner radius @xmath15 ( @xmath16 , @xmath17 , or @xmath18 mm ) .\",\n \"glass beads are poured in the cylindrical cell to make a granular bed of the height @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , or @xmath22 mm .\",\n \"the system is mounted on an electromechanical vibrator ( emic 513-b / a ) and shaken vertically .\",\n \"the vibration frequency @xmath10 is varied from @xmath23 to @xmath24 hz and @xmath7 is varied from @xmath25 to @xmath26 .\",\n \"the grains used in this study are glass beads .\",\n \"most of experiments are carried out with glass beads of diameter @xmath27 mm ( as - one corp .\",\n \"bz08 ) and some of them are performed with glass beads of @xmath28 or @xmath25 mm ( as - one corp .\",\n \"bz04 , bz2 ) .\",\n \"size dispersion of glass beads is less than @xmath29% , and the true density of glass beads is @xmath30 kg / m@xmath31 .\",\n \"[ 0.9 ] to measure the granular convective velocity , particle imaging velocimetry ( piv ) method is utilized @xcite .\",\n \"motions of glass beads are filmed by a high - speed camera ( photoron sa-5 ) through a transparent side wall . to erase the memory effect of granular matter ,\",\n \"one minute pre - vibration is applied before each experimental realization .\",\n \"this means that we measure the steady granular convection .\",\n \"while the actual impact - induced regolith convection might be transient , we have to concentrate on the steady convection to eliminate the memory effect .\",\n \"the frame rate is fixed at @xmath32 fps and spatial resolution of the image ranges from @xmath33 @xmath34m / pixel to @xmath35 @xmath34m / pixel depending on the experimental conditions .\",\n \"the high - speed images are acquired for @xmath36 s. since each image consists of @xmath37 pixels , the size of field of view ranges from @xmath38 to @xmath39 mm@xmath5 .\",\n \"raw data images are shown in backgrounds of figs .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] . since it is hard to completely follow all the grains motion , we use piv method instead of the direct particle tracking . in the analyses of figs .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] ( a ) , each instantaneous image is divided into @xmath40 boxes , i.e. , each box consists of @xmath41 pixels .\",\n \"note that the number of image partitioning depends on the experimental condition .\",\n \"then the velocity at each box is computed by detecting a peak of the cross - correlation between two different time snapshots .\",\n \"obtained ( time - averaged ) examples of the velocity field are shown by colored vectors in figs .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] . an interval time to compute the velocity ( cross - correlation )\",\n \"is kept constant so that it corresponds to a multiple of the period of vibration , i.e. , two cross - correlated images are kept in same phase .\",\n \"for instance , @xmath42 s time interval is used for @xmath43 hz vibration .\",\n \"if we use a full temporal resolution to calculate the velocity field , vibrational motion of individual grains can be captured just like @xcite measurement .\",\n \"however , we are mainly interested in the global convective motion rather than such microscopic vibration . therefore , we use phase - matching images to compute the velocity . as shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] , convective - velocity vectors are decomposed into @xmath44 ( vertical ) and @xmath45 ( horizontal ) directions .\",\n \"they are averaged along the horizontal axis since we are mainly focusing on the axisymmetric convective flow ( like fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] ) for the reason mentioned later\",\n \". then we obtain vertical and horizontal components of velocities as functions of @xmath44 , respectively as , @xmath46 and @xmath47 . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] , panels ( b ) and ( c ) respectively show @xmath46 and @xmath47 computed from the velocity field shown in panel ( a ) . the positive direction of @xmath44 axis is taken to downward , and @xmath48 corresponds to the top surface of the granular bed .\",\n \"@xmath49 is the center of container . above the surface of granular bed ( @xmath50 ) ,\",\n \"saltations of grains are dominant and the measured velocity becomes random .\",\n \"this is the reason of large errors in @xmath51 and @xmath52 at @xmath50 ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b , c ) ) .\",\n \"first , we are going to focus on the global structure of the granular convective motion .\",\n \"we find that the global structure shows a transition from a single roll to a toroidal roll as @xmath10 increases . in the former state ,\",\n \"grains rise up on the one side wall and fall down on the opposite side wall .\",\n \"thus , in this state , the resultant velocity field shows a certain circularity . due to this circularity ,\",\n \"a gradient of the velocity field is observed as shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vectorplot](a ) . in this single - roll state ,\",\n \"the degree of velocity gradient or circularity strongly depends on the viewing spot . in the latter state ,\",\n \"on the other hand , grains rise up at the center of container and fall down on all over the wall homogeneously .\",\n \"the inner structure of this granular convective mode has been observed by using the magnetic resonance imaging ( mri ) method @xcite . in other words ,\",\n \"this toroidal convection state is axisymmetric .\",\n \"typical examples of raw images for such homogeneous convection are shown in figs .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](a ) and [ fig : vectorplot](b ) .\",\n \"a phase diagram of the global structure in @xmath10-@xmath7 space is displayed in fig . [\",\n \"fig : phase_diagram ] . as seen in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : phase_diagram ] , the transition occurs at @xmath53 hz .\",\n \"the transition is almost independent of @xmath7 at least under the current experimental condition .\",\n \"note that the phase diagram is constructed only based on the experiment with @xmath27 mm glass beads . besides ,\",\n \"although we define two types of convective roll structures , this classification is not conclusive .\",\n \"detail measurements of inner structures of convective rolls are necessary to completely categorize the convective structures .\",\n \"the current classification is still tentative since it is based only on the observation by eye . -@xmath7 space with @xmath54 mm , @xmath55 mm and @xmath27 mm .\",\n \"the symbols represent the observed structures of granular convection ; open circles correspond to the single - roll state and cross markers indicate the toroidal - roll state .\",\n \"a phase boundary can be found around @xmath56 hz independently of @xmath7.,title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] next , we analyze the convective velocity . since the main motivation of this study is to characterize the scaling behavior of the representative convective velocity in a vibrated granular matter , we are going to focus on the toroidal - roll ( axisymmetric ) state . in the single - roll state ,\",\n \"convective velocity is spatially heterogeneous in horizontal direction as shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vectorplot](a ) .\",\n \"as mentioned above , the observable velocity field depends on the camera angle since the rolling direction is stochastically determined and can not be controlled in the single - roll state .\",\n \"such a state is inappropriate to extract a representative velocity of the system .\",\n \"by contrast , the toroidal - roll state is rather homogeneous everywhere in @xmath45 direction of the side wall as shown in figs .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](a ) and [ fig : vectorplot](b ) .\",\n \"furthermore , @xmath52 is always almost zero at any @xmath44 ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](c ) ) , and @xmath57 is basically a simple decreasing function of @xmath44 ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) ) in the toroidal - roll state .\",\n \"@xcite found a qualitatively similar velocity profile in the vibrated granular convection .\",\n \"they also used the maximum velocity to characterize the convective velocity .\",\n \"therefore , we use the same strategy in the analysis of the representative convective velocity .\",\n \"namely , we employ the maximum value of the vertical component of velocity , @xmath58 , as a representative convective velocity to characterize the velocity field .\",\n \"temporal homogeneity of @xmath51 is also examined . in the toroidal - roll state ,\",\n \"its spatial structure of the convective velocity is symmetric and simple as discussed above .\",\n \"then , how about the temporal structure ?\",\n \"[ fig : time_changing ] , a typical time series data of @xmath59 ( @xmath58 at each time @xmath60 ) is shown . while @xmath58 basically looks more or less steady , a sort of intermittent velocity spikes\",\n \"can be observed in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : time_changing ] .\",\n \"this slight intermittency might come from the inherent complexity of the granular flow due to the frictional effect .\",\n \"at @xmath61 , @xmath62 hz , @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .\",\n \"intermittent spikes can be observed as well as random fluctuation around the mean value .\",\n \"a horizontal solid line indicates the average value ( @xmath63 mm / s ) and dotted lines show standard deviation levels ( @xmath64 mm / s).,title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] the distribution of velocities @xmath65 obtained from the data of fig . [\",\n \"fig : time_changing ] is displayed in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : histogram ] .\",\n \"here , @xmath65 indicates the number in the range of @xmath66 and @xmath67 mm / s is the bin size .\",\n \"the distribution has a clear peak around @xmath68 mm / s .\",\n \"however , an asymmetric tail can be observed at large @xmath58 regime .\",\n \"whereas this statistical property of the convective velocity field could contain rich physics , here we neglect the asymmetric structure for simplicity s sake . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : histogram ] , the mean value and standard deviation of the entire data set are shown as a filled circle and an error bar shown above the histogram .\",\n \"more detail analyses of @xmath59 by its distribution and temporal correlation etc .\",\n \"are interesting future problems . computed from the data in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : time_changing ] .\",\n \"width of each bin is @xmath69 mm / s .\",\n \"one can confirm the peak of @xmath70 around @xmath71 mm / s and the asymmetric tail in large velocity regime . above the histogram , mean and standard deviation are shown as a filled circle and an error bar , respectively ( @xmath72 mm / s ) .\",\n \"the corresponding standard error is @xmath73 mm / s which is smaller than the size of the circle mark.,title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] finally , a scaling of the granular convective velocity is derived . as a first step of the scaling , we focus on the effect of vibration - conditions ( @xmath10 and @xmath7 ) by fixing the geometric conditions : @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .\",\n \"as mentioned above , we regard @xmath58 as a representative granular convective velocity .\",\n \"more precisely , we use the maximum value of @xmath46 profile ( e.g. , fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) ) as @xmath58 . in order to discuss the scale - free nature ,\",\n \"a relation among dimensionless parameters should be analyzed .\",\n \"thus @xmath58 is normalized to the characteristic velocity created by gravity as , @xmath74 in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : g_scaling ] , @xmath75 vs. @xmath7 for various @xmath10 is shown .\",\n \"one can confirm that all the @xmath75 data are similar increasing functions of @xmath7 .\",\n \"however , these specific values depend not only on @xmath7 but also on @xmath10 . therefore , it is hard to obtain a universal scale - free relation from this plot .\",\n \"in other words , sole @xmath7 can not characterize the granular convective velocity very well . while @xcite used @xmath7 and the normalized bed height to collapse the convective velocity data ,\",\n \"here we consider a different quantity to deduce a simple power - law form for the granular convective velocity .\",\n \"note that the specific functional form of the granular convective velocity was not obtained by @xcite .\",\n \"we find that the shaking parameter @xmath11 is a relevant dimensionless parameter to scale @xmath75 .\",\n \"corresponding scaling plot is shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : s_scaling ] . all of the @xmath75 data collapse to a power - law form , @xmath76 where @xmath77 is a characteristic exponent obtained by the data fitting shown as a dashed line in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : s_scaling ] .\",\n \"the solid line corresponds to @xmath78 which is determined by the scaling with various system size data ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) . as mentioned before\",\n \", @xmath11 represents the balance between the vibrational and gravitational velocities .\",\n \"thus it is rather natural that another velocity balance ( convective velocity vs. gravitational velocity ; @xmath79 ) is scaled by @xmath11 .\",\n \"the range of @xmath11 we used in this study is slightly different from that in the previous studies . in @xcite ,\",\n \"@xmath11 was used to characterize the onset of convection in the strongly shaken shallow granular bed . in this study\",\n \", we experimentally confirm that @xmath11 is also useful to the scaling analysis of the convective velocity in a weakly shaken thick granular bed .\",\n \"the range of @xmath11 for our experiment is from @xmath80 to @xmath81 .\",\n \"although the order of this regime is about one order of magnitude smaller than that in the experiment of @xcite ( @xmath82 ) , the current experimental result is also well explained by @xmath11 . by @xmath7 .\",\n \"each open symbol shows the data of glass beads bed of @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .\",\n \"while a systematic correlation between @xmath75 and @xmath7 can be observed , a universal form can not be obtained solely by @xmath7 scaling.,title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] by @xmath11 .\",\n \"colors and markers used are identical to those in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : g_scaling ] .\",\n \"the dashed line represents the power law fit ( eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : fitting ] ) ) . the slope ( power ) of the dashed line\",\n \"is computed as @xmath77 .\",\n \"the solid line corresponds to @xmath78 which is obtained by the least square search for all the data including various system size parameters ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] as a next step of the scaling , we investigate the system size dependence of @xmath75 by the varying geometric parameters : bed height @xmath83 and its radius @xmath15 . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : aspect_ratio ] , the data of @xmath75 vs. @xmath84 for various @xmath7 and @xmath10 are shown .\",\n \"non - axisymmetric convection patterns such as a single - roll state are sometimes found in the experiment at some @xmath84 . due to the inhomogeneity ,\",\n \"the representative velocities in these states show extremely large dispersion .\",\n \"since we restrict ourselves within the analysis of representative velocity in the homogeneous convection , these data are excluded from the analysis . as shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : aspect_ratio ] , we find that @xmath75 is roughly independent of @xmath84 although its specific value clearly depends on vibrational conditions ( @xmath7 and @xmath10 ) .\",\n \"this simple relation @xmath85 suggests that @xmath75 can be scaled equivalently both by @xmath15 and @xmath83 .\",\n \"namely , @xmath75 is the increasing function both of @xmath15 and @xmath83\",\n \". then we can reduce the number of geometric parameters , i.e. , @xmath15 and @xmath83 can be unified into a single parameter . in specific , a dimensionless parameter for the system size @xmath86 can be introduced by using grains diameter @xmath13 as , @xmath87 to the aspect ratio of the shaken granular bed , @xmath84 .\",\n \"colors and shapes of markers indicate vibrational conditions as denoted in the legend .\",\n \"all the data points are originated from the experiments with glass beads of @xmath27 mm ( bz08 ) .\",\n \"we remove the data of single - roll state from this plot .\",\n \"although the level of @xmath75 depends on vibrational conditions , it is roughly independent of @xmath84 .\",\n \"dashed lines are the average levels for each condition.,title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] to prove the validity of the dimensionless parameter @xmath86 , @xmath13 should be varied as well as @xmath15 and @xmath83 .\",\n \"therefore , we also examine the @xmath13 dependence of @xmath88 . for this purpose ,\",\n \"the aspect ratio is fixed ( @xmath54 mm and @xmath55 mm ) and glass beads of @xmath28 mm ( bz04 ) and @xmath89 mm ( bz2 ) are used in the experiment . while @xmath75 of bz04 is in the same order as the bz08 case\",\n \", @xmath75 of bz2 is about one order of magnitude smaller than that of bz08 , under the same vibrational condition .\",\n \"this is due to the effect of crystallization which prevents the convective motion .\",\n \"besides , the solidification ( complete crystallization ) of glass beads bed occurs when bz2 is shaken by @xmath90 .\",\n \"the crystallization is unavoidable for the larger grains as long as we use nearly mono - disperse spherical grains . whereas the number of data points is not enough to discuss the specific scaling form\",\n \", we qualitatively confirm that the convective velocity is a decreasing function of @xmath13 .\",\n \"altogether , we can assume a simple scaling relation among these dimensionless parameters to compile all the data .\",\n \"the assumed scaling form is written as , @xmath91 the values of @xmath92 and @xmath93 are computed by searching the least square point in the range of @xmath94 and @xmath95 .\",\n \"the least square fitting in fig .\",\n \"( [ fig : sl_scaling ] ) is computed with weighting of the standard deviation ( velocity scattering degree ) .\",\n \"the obtained values are @xmath78 and @xmath96 .\",\n \"and the computed numerical prefactor is @xmath97 .\",\n \"the scaling result for all the experimentally obtained data is shown in fig . [\",\n \"fig : sl_scaling ] .\",\n \"as can be seen , the data are basically well scaled by the variable @xmath98 . the corresponding scaling line ( @xmath99 )\",\n \"is also plotted in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : s_scaling ] as a solid line .\",\n \"the value of @xmath92 is slightly improved from the fixed system size case ( fig .\",\n \"( [ fig : s_scaling ] ) ) . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : sl_scaling ] , two data points deviate significantly from the scaling .\",\n \"this deviation comes from the crystallization effect of large glass beads ( bz2 ) .\",\n \"the inset of fig .\",\n \"[ fig : sl_scaling ] shows a linear plot of the same data .\",\n \"this scaling relation is the main result of this experimental investigation .\",\n \"there are some missing parameters in the scaling of eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) . for example\",\n \", density is not involved in it .\",\n \"that is , the scaling is a kind of kinematic one .\",\n \"the density dependence has to be clarified to understand the dynamic scaling including the effect of inertia @xcite .\",\n \"perhaps , this would not be so critical because the density of glass beads ( @xmath30 kg / m@xmath31 ) is close to ( at least in the same order with ) the real regolith density ( e.g. , @xmath100 kg / m@xmath31 for itokawa @xcite ) .\",\n \"another example of the missing parameters is the cohesive force among grains .\",\n \"although the gravitational force is very small on the surface of small asteroids , the cohesive effect would instead play a crucial role @xcite .\",\n \"it is hard to check this effect by the current experiment since we do not vary the cohesiveness of grains . in the current experiment ,\",\n \"the cohesive force is negligible since it is much smaller than the gravitational force .\",\n \"we assume that interstitial air and electrostatic effects do not play essential roles , i.e. , they are much smaller than gravity effect . indeed , the air effect is negligible as long as we use @xmath101 mm grains ( see e.g. , supplementary information of @xcite ) .\",\n \"we also think that the gravitational force is more dominant than the electrostatic force for the bulk convective motion of glass beads .\",\n \"in fact , while we saw a few glass beads sticking on the sidewall due to the electrostatic effect , those were really few . the electrostatic effect might slightly affect the convective motion .\",\n \"however , we consider it can not be a dominant effect .\",\n \"a much more serious problem is the absence of frictional properties in the scaling .\",\n \"the frictional properties are a possible origin of intermittent velocity fluctuation shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : time_changing ] .\",\n \"in addition , it might affect the representative value of convective velocity .\",\n \"frictional properties relate to the shape of constitutive grains . obviously , actual regolith grains shapes are irregular and rough . by a preliminary experiment\",\n \", we actually confirm that @xmath58 significantly reduces when the rough - shaped sand grains are used . on the contrary\",\n \", some previous studies have reported that the friction can enhance the convective velocity @xcite . moreover ,\",\n \"the grain - wall friction is different from grain - grain friction .\",\n \"the grain - wall friction could be a reason of the onset of granular convection in this experiment .\",\n \"the detailed study for the effect of friction is a very important future problem .\",\n \"the origin of granular convection in the current experiment is plausibly the effect of wall . as already mentioned , the structure of the convective roll changes spontaneously when @xmath10 or @xmath15 are varied\",\n \"this implies that there is an inherent length scale in the granular convection .\",\n \"however , the wall effect to the velocity scaling is still significant even in split ( doubled ) roll state since we observe the grains motion on the wall .\",\n \"moreover , it has been shown that experimental conditions including the container s shape and interstitial air influence the convective roll structure @xcite . in these previous studies\",\n \", the interaction between grains and wall seems to be a key factor .\",\n \"nevertheless , astronomical objects obviously maintain their own shapes without any wall .\",\n \"it is hard to eliminate the container wall effect in usual granular experiments even in microgravity environment .\",\n \"rather , highly heterogenous structure of small asteroids might work as an effective wall which triggers the granular convection .\",\n \"put another way , there could be a lot of effective boundaries and/or gradients of frictional properties in actual small asteroids .\",\n \"thus it is not quite clear whether the granular convection occurs globally or locally in small asteroids .\",\n \"the structure of the velocity profile @xmath46 is informative both for the granular physics and planetary science . in the previous studies of granular convection @xcite\",\n \", convective velocity decays rapidly ( exponentially ) with depth .\",\n \"and the deep region of the vibrated granular matter is almost at rest .\",\n \"if this peculiar regime called _ frozen zone _ presents in the real asteroids convection , the regolith migration occurs only within a shallow region . in the current experiment ,\",\n \"most of velocity profiles do not show the clear frozen zone .\",\n \"the convective velocity decays calmly as typically shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) .\",\n \"thus the convective velocity is simply scaled by @xmath86 with the nontrivial exponent @xmath102 .\",\n \"if the frozen zone is clearly observed , the convective velocity would be saturated at a certain @xmath83 , and it can not be simply scaled by a single exponent . actually , the frozen zone can be partially observed also in the current experiment under small @xmath7 , large @xmath10 , and large @xmath83 conditions .\",\n \"since we are interested in the principal flow velocity of the granular convection , we have focused only on the axisymmetric convective state and its maximum velocity @xmath58 , in this study .\",\n \"detailed analysis of @xmath46 profile is a next important step to reveal the granular convection dynamics that relates to the depth of regolith convection occurring in small astronomical objects .\",\n \"so far , the scaling form for the granular convective velocity has been discussed on the basis of systematically performed experimental results . in this subsection\",\n \", we discuss the implication of the obtained scaling law .\",\n \"the scaling of eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) can be rewritten by considering its physical meaning .\",\n \"then the scaling is compared with a recent experimental result of two - dimensional granular convection .\",\n \"equation ( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) can be transformed into a following form , @xmath103 this form is more understandable than eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) .\",\n \"the representative velocity @xmath58 is expressed by a power law product of two characteristic velocities : gravitational @xmath104 and vibrational @xmath105 .\",\n \"in addition , the system size dependence is scaled by the last factor @xmath106 .\",\n \"the scaling of eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) is qualitatively consistent with a recent experiment performed by @xcite .\",\n \"they investigated the convective - driven bne and found that the convective velocity linearly depends on @xmath105 .\",\n \"to better explain the experimental data , the use of @xmath105 was much better than @xmath7 . according to eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , convective velocity depends on vibrational velocity as , @xmath107 .\",\n \"these two experimental results show a good agreement . however , they reported the presence of critical vibrational velocity below which the granular convection was not induced .\",\n \"this critical vibrational velocity probably corresponds to the onset criterion . in the current analysis\",\n \", however , we do not clearly confirm this offset in the scaling ( see fig .\",\n \"[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) .\",\n \"instead , we varied @xmath11 over two orders of magnitude to obtain the power - law relation .\",\n \"the range of @xmath11 and other parameters were relatively narrow in the study of @xcite since they are not interested in the scale - free form .\",\n \"thus they reported the linear relation between the convective velocity and the vibrational velocity . on the other hand\",\n \", we obtain the scaling ( power law ) relation between the convective velocity , the vibrational velocity , and the gravitational velocity .\",\n \"it should be noted that the system size dependence of the scaling is bounded . according to eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , the value of @xmath58 can be very large when @xmath108 becomes large .\",\n \"this condition corresponds to a large @xmath109 or a small @xmath13 case . at the limit of @xmath110 or @xmath111\",\n \", @xmath58 diverges .\",\n \"however , such a divergence does not occur in the actual granular convection .\",\n \"the convective roll size can not grow to the infinitely large size .\",\n \"in fact , we experimentally observed the split of the convective roll ( double toroidal - roll ) in a very shallow layer , although such a split rarely happened .\",\n \"this preliminary observation indicates that there might be an intrinsic length scale which determines the maximum convective roll size .\",\n \"since the current experimental system size is limited , it is hard to systematically reveal the effect of this intrinsic length scale . at a small @xmath13 regime ,\",\n \"on the other hand , the cohesive force among grains becomes dominant instead of the gravitational force .\",\n \"the current scaling form can not be applied to such a situation .\",\n \"the detailed investigation on the size - dependent scaling form for more widely spreading size regime is an important future problem . to investigate the small @xmath13 regime ,\",\n \"the experiment under the vacuum condition is also necessary .\",\n \"finally , the experimentally obtained scaling is cast into a form in which the gravity effect can be directly evaluated .\",\n \"since the interpretation of scaling is not unique in general , we have to take a special care for its understanding . whereas the discussion in this subsection is speculative , the result is consistent with other related works .\",\n \"moreover , the obtained scaling includes various parameters such as vibration frequency and system size .\",\n \"thus the form is very efficient to estimate the timescale of regolith convection occurring on the surface of small asteroid .\",\n \"recently , some granular flow experiments were performed under microgravity conditions created by parabolic flights @xcite .\",\n \"@xcite used a taylor - couette geometry and measured both sheared and convective flows induced by the shearing .\",\n \"particularly , @xcite reported the effect of gravity to the sheared granular convection .\",\n \"they claimed that the gravity plays an essential role to make a stiff grains network in a bulk granular matter .\",\n \"such a grains network is necessary to transform a shear stress into a driving force of the convective motion .\",\n \"therefore , the granular convective velocity under the microgravity became almost zero .\",\n \"moreover , the convective velocity under the high - gravity condition became large @xcite .\",\n \"@xcite measured the rising velocity of intruders in convective - driven bne under the reduced gravity .\",\n \"they found that the rising velocity is almost linearly scaled by the gravity . to compare the current result with above - mentioned microgravity experiments ,\",\n \"here we evaluate the gravity influence to the convective velocity based on eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) . at a glance of eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , the convective velocity is scaled as @xmath112 .\",\n \"this scaling implicitly assumes the fixed @xmath105 under different @xmath1 environment .\",\n \"this assumption is not practical to estimate the granular convective velocity induced under the different @xmath1 .\",\n \"for instance , under the microgravity environment , very small vibrational acceleration is enough to satisfy the onset criterion of granular convection ( @xmath113 ) . however , if @xmath105 is fixed to consider the granular convective velocity under the microgravity environment , the corresponding @xmath7 becomes extremely large .\",\n \"it is not a realistic assumption . instead\",\n \", the value of @xmath7 should be fixed to estimate the convective velocity by means of similarity law .\",\n \"in fact , fixed @xmath7 was used to discuss the possibility of convection on the surface of itokawa @xcite . @xcite\",\n \"also fixed @xmath7 to discuss @xmath1 dependence .\",\n \"therefore , the typical vibrational velocity should be written as @xmath114 instead of @xmath105 .\",\n \"then , eq . ( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) can be modified into the following form , @xmath115 according to eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling2 ] ) , @xmath58 depends on @xmath1 as , @xmath116 .\",\n \"the value @xmath117 is close to unity .\",\n \"this result is qualitatively similar to @xcite and @xcite .\",\n \"however , note that we do not directly vary the gravitational acceleration .\",\n \"the @xmath1 dependence is indirectly deduced from the scaling . besides , the convective motion of @xcite was induced by shear in a taylor - couette cell . thus the similarity is rather qualitative .\",\n \"using eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling2 ] ) and a model of seismic shaking induced by impacts @xcite , we are able to estimate the convective velocity for various astronomical objects .\",\n \"to do that , we have to be careful in the estimate of @xmath106 .\",\n \"whereas its value strongly affects the estimate of @xmath58 , it is still very uncertain\",\n \". then it might be possible to evaluate the surface age ( resurfacing timescale ) of the microgravity asteroid by considering the population of impactors .\",\n \"such an estimate for itokawa or eros is an interesting application of this scaling .\",\n \"this topic is a part of ongoing investigation .\",\n \"an experimental study of the granular convection was performed with a vertically shaken glass beads bed .\",\n \"the maximum convective velocity @xmath58 was measured by piv method .\",\n \"although the @xmath58 was measured on the wall , we assume that it corresponds to a representative value of the convective velocity .\",\n \"the normalized convective velocity @xmath118 was scaled by the shaking parameter @xmath119 and the dimensionless system size @xmath108 .\",\n \"the obtained scaling ( eq ( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) ) indicates that the representative convective velocity can be written as a certain power - law product of the vibrational velocity @xmath105 , the gravitational velocity @xmath104 , and the dimensionless system size @xmath86 .\",\n \"this experimentally obtained scaling law is qualitatively consistent with other previous studies of granular convection or bne . using the scaling law\",\n \", one can roughly estimate the convective velocity for various vibrational conditions , in principle . since the gravitational acceleration and frictional properties\",\n \"are not varied in this experiment , applicability of the current result toward actual regolith migration might be still limited .\",\n \"systematic further studies have to be carried out to unveil the regolith migration dynamics owing to the granular convection .\",\n \"we would like to thank to s. watanabe , h. kumagai , s. sirono , and t. morota for fruitful discussions and suggestions . this research has been partly supported by jsps kakenhi grant number 23654134 and nagoya university program for leading graduate schools ( leadership development program for space exploration and research ) .\",\n \"39 natexlab#1#1[1]`#1 ` [ 2]#2 [ 1]#1 [ 1]http://dx.doi.org/#1 [ ] [ 1]pmid:#1 [ ] [ 2]#2 , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , . . , . , , ,\",\n \". . , . , , , ( eds . ) , . .\",\n \", , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , . . , . , , , , ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \". , . . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,\",\n \". . , . , , , ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , , , , , , . . ,\",\n \". , . . , . , ,\",\n \", , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , a. . , .\",\n \", , , , , , , b. . , .\",\n \", , , , , , , c. . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \". , . . , . , , , , ,\",\n \". . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,\",\n \". . , . , , , , ,\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> we experimentally study the velocity scaling of granular convection which is a possible mechanism of the regolith migration on the surface of small asteroids . in order to evaluate the contribution of granular convection to the regolith migration </S>","<S> , the velocity of granular convection under the microgravity condition has to be revealed . </S>","<S> although it is hard to control the gravitational acceleration in laboratory experiments , scaling relations involving the gravitational effect can be evaluated by systematic experiments . </S>","<S> therefore , we perform such a systematic experiment of the vibration - induced granular convection . from the experimental data , a scaling form for the granular convective velocity is obtained . </S>","<S> the obtained scaling form implies that the granular convective velocity can be decomposed into two characteristic velocity components : vibrational and gravitational velocities . </S>","<S> in addition , the system size dependence is also scaled . according to the scaling form , the granular convective velocity @xmath0 depends on the gravitational acceleration @xmath1 as @xmath2 when the normalized vibrational acceleration is fixed . </S>","<S> regolith migration , granular convection , scaling analysis , gravitational acceleration . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> we experimentally study the velocity scaling of granular convection which is a possible mechanism of the regolith migration on the surface of small asteroids . in order to evaluate the contribution of granular convection to the regolith migration </S>\",\n \"<S> , the velocity of granular convection under the microgravity condition has to be revealed . </S>\",\n \"<S> although it is hard to control the gravitational acceleration in laboratory experiments , scaling relations involving the gravitational effect can be evaluated by systematic experiments . </S>\",\n \"<S> therefore , we perform such a systematic experiment of the vibration - induced granular convection . from the experimental data , a scaling form for the granular convective velocity is obtained . </S>\",\n \"<S> the obtained scaling form implies that the granular convective velocity can be decomposed into two characteristic velocity components : vibrational and gravitational velocities . </S>\",\n \"<S> in addition , the system size dependence is also scaled . according to the scaling form , the granular convective velocity @xmath0 depends on the gravitational acceleration @xmath1 as @xmath2 when the normalized vibrational acceleration is fixed . </S>\",\n \"<S> regolith migration , granular convection , scaling analysis , gravitational acceleration . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","materials and methods","results and analyses","discussion","conclusions","acknowledgments"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"materials and methods\",\n \"results and analyses\",\n \"discussion\",\n \"conclusions\",\n \"acknowledgments\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["in the solar system , there are many small bodies such as asteroids and comets .","since these small astronomical objects could keep the ancient information of the history of the solar system , a lot of efforts have been devoted to investigations of these objects so far ( e.g. , @xcite ) .","for instance , the asteroid itokawa was explored by the japanese space craft _ hayabusa _ from september 2005 .","the exploration uncovered the details of itokawa s surface terrain .","itokawa is covered by various sizes of granular matter such as regolith , pebbles , and boulders @xcite .","moreover , migrations and sorting of the regolith could occur on the surface of itokawa @xcite , although the surface gravity of itokawa is extremely low .","impact craters located on the surface of itokawa were very subtle , i.e. , they show indistinct morphologies @xcite .","this is probably due to the erasure of the craters by seismic shaking @xcite .","in addition , tiny samples returned from itokawa allow us to analyze the detail of its history .","@xcite revealed that itokawa s surface grains are relatively young in terms of cosmic - rays exposure .","the estimated age is approximately eight million years . besides , using x - ray microtomography , @xcite found that some particles had rounded edges .","all these facts suggest that the surface of itokawa would be active and continue to be renewed until recently",". one possible explanation of such young surface is the regolith convection caused by impact - induced seismic shaking .","although the direct measurement of the seismic wave has not been achieved , @xcite and @xcite studied the possibility of global seismic shaking of asteroid eros in order to explain its surface modification processes .","they built a model of seismic shaking by considering the attenuating diffusion of the seismic wave .","@xcite partially applied the model to the asteroid itokawa and showed that the global regolith convection might occur even by small - scale impacts . to unlock the regolith grains network supported by gravity , the maximum acceleration induced by the seismic shaking has to be greater than the gravitational acceleration .","@xcite revealed that this criterion can be satisfied by a small - scale impact since the gravity on the surface of itokawa @xmath3 is very small , @xmath4 m / s@xmath5 @xcite .","the value of @xmath3 is about five orders of magnitude smaller than the earth s gravitational acceleration , @xmath6 m / s@xmath5 .","the evaluation is still qualitative since they only assessed the onset criterion of the regolith convection .","while the quantitative assessment of the convective velocity is necessary to discuss the feasibility of the regolith convection , there have been very few such studies .","granular convection can be generally observed in a granular matter under the mechanical vibration . when a granular matter is subjected to a steady vertical vibration , granular convection","is readily induced .","if the vibrated granular matter is polydisperse , the size segregation of grains occurs usually in vertical direction .","this vibration - induced size segregation is called brazil nut effect ( bne ) .","the bne can be caused by the granular convection @xcite .","this means that the grains can be migrated and sorted simultaneously by vibration .","although the regolith convection accompanied by migration and sorting seems to be a natural outcome of global seismic shaking , the scaling approach to the granular convective velocity is needed to discuss the consistency between regolith convection and observational data such as surface age of the asteroid .","therefore , we experimentally measure and scale the velocity of granular convection in this study , as a first - step approach to this problem . fundamental nature of granular convection itself is an intriguing problem .","the granular convection has long been studied both by experiments @xcite and numerical simulations @xcite . the onset of granular convection depends on the maximum acceleration of the applied vibration .","if the maximum acceleration is less than the gravitational acceleration , any granular convection does not occur at all ( e.g. , @xcite ) .","thus the dimensionless parameter @xmath7 , which represents the balance between the maximum vibrational acceleration and the gravitational acceleration @xmath1 , has been used to characterize the behavior of granular convection .","@xmath7 is defined as , @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the vibration amplitude and @xmath10 is the frequency . in this study ,","the scaling method is applied to the analysis of granular convective velocity .","we are interested in asteroidal - scale granular convection while the actual experiment is limited within the laboratory scale .","in such a situation , the scaling is the only way to derive a meaningful quantitative relation . in the scaling analysis ,","dimensionless parameters such as @xmath7 are useful since they do not depend on the system of unit .","the weak point of the scaling analysis is its arbitrariness .","of course , @xmath7 is one of the most important dimensionless parameters to discuss the vibrated granular matter .","however , the choice of the important dimensionless parameter is not unique .","specifically , another dimensionless parameter called shaking parameter @xmath11 was firstly introduced by @xcite and recently used to describe the transitions among the granular leidenfrost , bouncing bed , undulations , convection , and so on @xcite .","particularly , @xmath11 is relevant to characterize a strongly shaken shallow granular convection @xcite .","@xmath11 is defined as , @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the constitutive grains diameter .","@xmath11 denotes the balance between the squared vibrational velocity and the squared gravitational velocity .","furthermore , @xmath11 can be also obtained by the natural non - dimensionalization of the granular - hydrodynamic model for the strongly shaken granular convection @xcite . using the aforementioned dimensionless parameters",", we would like to find a useful scaling relation between granular convective velocity , the gravitational acceleration , and other parameters .","therefore , we carry out a systematic laboratory experiments of the vibration - induced granular convection",". this paper is constructed by following sections . in section","[ sec : experiment ] , we explain the experimental setup and how to measure the convective velocity . section [ sec : results ] shows the characterization of some convective - roll patterns and the result of the scaling . in section [ sec : discussion ] , we discuss physical meaning and tentative implication of the scaling to the microgravity environment .","section [ sec : conclusions ] contains a conclusions ."],["a schematic illustration of the experimental apparatus is shown in fig . [","fig : setup ] .","the experimental setup consists of a cylinder made by plexiglass of its height @xmath14 mm and inner radius @xmath15 ( @xmath16 , @xmath17 , or @xmath18 mm ) .","glass beads are poured in the cylindrical cell to make a granular bed of the height @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , or @xmath22 mm .","the system is mounted on an electromechanical vibrator ( emic 513-b / a ) and shaken vertically .","the vibration frequency @xmath10 is varied from @xmath23 to @xmath24 hz and @xmath7 is varied from @xmath25 to @xmath26 .","the grains used in this study are glass beads .","most of experiments are carried out with glass beads of diameter @xmath27 mm ( as - one corp .","bz08 ) and some of them are performed with glass beads of @xmath28 or @xmath25 mm ( as - one corp .","bz04 , bz2 ) .","size dispersion of glass beads is less than @xmath29% , and the true density of glass beads is @xmath30 kg / m@xmath31 .","[ 0.9 ] to measure the granular convective velocity , particle imaging velocimetry ( piv ) method is utilized @xcite .","motions of glass beads are filmed by a high - speed camera ( photoron sa-5 ) through a transparent side wall . to erase the memory effect of granular matter ,","one minute pre - vibration is applied before each experimental realization .","this means that we measure the steady granular convection .","while the actual impact - induced regolith convection might be transient , we have to concentrate on the steady convection to eliminate the memory effect .","the frame rate is fixed at @xmath32 fps and spatial resolution of the image ranges from @xmath33 @xmath34m / pixel to @xmath35 @xmath34m / pixel depending on the experimental conditions .","the high - speed images are acquired for @xmath36 s. since each image consists of @xmath37 pixels , the size of field of view ranges from @xmath38 to @xmath39 mm@xmath5 .","raw data images are shown in backgrounds of figs .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] . since it is hard to completely follow all the grains motion , we use piv method instead of the direct particle tracking . in the analyses of figs .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] ( a ) , each instantaneous image is divided into @xmath40 boxes , i.e. , each box consists of @xmath41 pixels .","note that the number of image partitioning depends on the experimental condition .","then the velocity at each box is computed by detecting a peak of the cross - correlation between two different time snapshots .","obtained ( time - averaged ) examples of the velocity field are shown by colored vectors in figs .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] . an interval time to compute the velocity ( cross - correlation )","is kept constant so that it corresponds to a multiple of the period of vibration , i.e. , two cross - correlated images are kept in same phase .","for instance , @xmath42 s time interval is used for @xmath43 hz vibration .","if we use a full temporal resolution to calculate the velocity field , vibrational motion of individual grains can be captured just like @xcite measurement .","however , we are mainly interested in the global convective motion rather than such microscopic vibration . therefore , we use phase - matching images to compute the velocity . as shown in fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] , convective - velocity vectors are decomposed into @xmath44 ( vertical ) and @xmath45 ( horizontal ) directions .","they are averaged along the horizontal axis since we are mainly focusing on the axisymmetric convective flow ( like fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] ) for the reason mentioned later",". then we obtain vertical and horizontal components of velocities as functions of @xmath44 , respectively as , @xmath46 and @xmath47 . in fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] , panels ( b ) and ( c ) respectively show @xmath46 and @xmath47 computed from the velocity field shown in panel ( a ) . the positive direction of @xmath44 axis is taken to downward , and @xmath48 corresponds to the top surface of the granular bed .","@xmath49 is the center of container . above the surface of granular bed ( @xmath50 ) ,","saltations of grains are dominant and the measured velocity becomes random .","this is the reason of large errors in @xmath51 and @xmath52 at @xmath50 ( fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b , c ) ) ."],["first , we are going to focus on the global structure of the granular convective motion .","we find that the global structure shows a transition from a single roll to a toroidal roll as @xmath10 increases . in the former state ,","grains rise up on the one side wall and fall down on the opposite side wall .","thus , in this state , the resultant velocity field shows a certain circularity . due to this circularity ,","a gradient of the velocity field is observed as shown in fig .","[ fig : vectorplot](a ) . in this single - roll state ,","the degree of velocity gradient or circularity strongly depends on the viewing spot . in the latter state ,","on the other hand , grains rise up at the center of container and fall down on all over the wall homogeneously .","the inner structure of this granular convective mode has been observed by using the magnetic resonance imaging ( mri ) method @xcite . in other words ,","this toroidal convection state is axisymmetric .","typical examples of raw images for such homogeneous convection are shown in figs .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](a ) and [ fig : vectorplot](b ) .","a phase diagram of the global structure in @xmath10-@xmath7 space is displayed in fig . [","fig : phase_diagram ] . as seen in fig .","[ fig : phase_diagram ] , the transition occurs at @xmath53 hz .","the transition is almost independent of @xmath7 at least under the current experimental condition .","note that the phase diagram is constructed only based on the experiment with @xmath27 mm glass beads . besides ,","although we define two types of convective roll structures , this classification is not conclusive .","detail measurements of inner structures of convective rolls are necessary to completely categorize the convective structures .","the current classification is still tentative since it is based only on the observation by eye . -@xmath7 space with @xmath54 mm , @xmath55 mm and @xmath27 mm .","the symbols represent the observed structures of granular convection ; open circles correspond to the single - roll state and cross markers indicate the toroidal - roll state .","a phase boundary can be found around @xmath56 hz independently of @xmath7.,title=\"fig : \" ] next , we analyze the convective velocity . since the main motivation of this study is to characterize the scaling behavior of the representative convective velocity in a vibrated granular matter , we are going to focus on the toroidal - roll ( axisymmetric ) state . in the single - roll state ,","convective velocity is spatially heterogeneous in horizontal direction as shown in fig .","[ fig : vectorplot](a ) .","as mentioned above , the observable velocity field depends on the camera angle since the rolling direction is stochastically determined and can not be controlled in the single - roll state .","such a state is inappropriate to extract a representative velocity of the system .","by contrast , the toroidal - roll state is rather homogeneous everywhere in @xmath45 direction of the side wall as shown in figs .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](a ) and [ fig : vectorplot](b ) .","furthermore , @xmath52 is always almost zero at any @xmath44 ( fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](c ) ) , and @xmath57 is basically a simple decreasing function of @xmath44 ( fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) ) in the toroidal - roll state .","@xcite found a qualitatively similar velocity profile in the vibrated granular convection .","they also used the maximum velocity to characterize the convective velocity .","therefore , we use the same strategy in the analysis of the representative convective velocity .","namely , we employ the maximum value of the vertical component of velocity , @xmath58 , as a representative convective velocity to characterize the velocity field .","temporal homogeneity of @xmath51 is also examined . in the toroidal - roll state ,","its spatial structure of the convective velocity is symmetric and simple as discussed above .","then , how about the temporal structure ?","[ fig : time_changing ] , a typical time series data of @xmath59 ( @xmath58 at each time @xmath60 ) is shown . while @xmath58 basically looks more or less steady , a sort of intermittent velocity spikes","can be observed in fig .","[ fig : time_changing ] .","this slight intermittency might come from the inherent complexity of the granular flow due to the frictional effect .","at @xmath61 , @xmath62 hz , @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .","intermittent spikes can be observed as well as random fluctuation around the mean value .","a horizontal solid line indicates the average value ( @xmath63 mm / s ) and dotted lines show standard deviation levels ( @xmath64 mm / s).,title=\"fig : \" ] the distribution of velocities @xmath65 obtained from the data of fig . [","fig : time_changing ] is displayed in fig .","[ fig : histogram ] .","here , @xmath65 indicates the number in the range of @xmath66 and @xmath67 mm / s is the bin size .","the distribution has a clear peak around @xmath68 mm / s .","however , an asymmetric tail can be observed at large @xmath58 regime .","whereas this statistical property of the convective velocity field could contain rich physics , here we neglect the asymmetric structure for simplicity s sake . in fig .","[ fig : histogram ] , the mean value and standard deviation of the entire data set are shown as a filled circle and an error bar shown above the histogram .","more detail analyses of @xmath59 by its distribution and temporal correlation etc .","are interesting future problems . computed from the data in fig .","[ fig : time_changing ] .","width of each bin is @xmath69 mm / s .","one can confirm the peak of @xmath70 around @xmath71 mm / s and the asymmetric tail in large velocity regime . above the histogram , mean and standard deviation are shown as a filled circle and an error bar , respectively ( @xmath72 mm / s ) .","the corresponding standard error is @xmath73 mm / s which is smaller than the size of the circle mark.,title=\"fig : \" ] finally , a scaling of the granular convective velocity is derived . as a first step of the scaling , we focus on the effect of vibration - conditions ( @xmath10 and @xmath7 ) by fixing the geometric conditions : @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .","as mentioned above , we regard @xmath58 as a representative granular convective velocity .","more precisely , we use the maximum value of @xmath46 profile ( e.g. , fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) ) as @xmath58 . in order to discuss the scale - free nature ,","a relation among dimensionless parameters should be analyzed .","thus @xmath58 is normalized to the characteristic velocity created by gravity as , @xmath74 in fig .","[ fig : g_scaling ] , @xmath75 vs. @xmath7 for various @xmath10 is shown .","one can confirm that all the @xmath75 data are similar increasing functions of @xmath7 .","however , these specific values depend not only on @xmath7 but also on @xmath10 . therefore , it is hard to obtain a universal scale - free relation from this plot .","in other words , sole @xmath7 can not characterize the granular convective velocity very well . while @xcite used @xmath7 and the normalized bed height to collapse the convective velocity data ,","here we consider a different quantity to deduce a simple power - law form for the granular convective velocity .","note that the specific functional form of the granular convective velocity was not obtained by @xcite .","we find that the shaking parameter @xmath11 is a relevant dimensionless parameter to scale @xmath75 .","corresponding scaling plot is shown in fig .","[ fig : s_scaling ] . all of the @xmath75 data collapse to a power - law form , @xmath76 where @xmath77 is a characteristic exponent obtained by the data fitting shown as a dashed line in fig .","[ fig : s_scaling ] .","the solid line corresponds to @xmath78 which is determined by the scaling with various system size data ( fig .","[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) . as mentioned before",", @xmath11 represents the balance between the vibrational and gravitational velocities .","thus it is rather natural that another velocity balance ( convective velocity vs. gravitational velocity ; @xmath79 ) is scaled by @xmath11 .","the range of @xmath11 we used in this study is slightly different from that in the previous studies . in @xcite ,","@xmath11 was used to characterize the onset of convection in the strongly shaken shallow granular bed . in this study",", we experimentally confirm that @xmath11 is also useful to the scaling analysis of the convective velocity in a weakly shaken thick granular bed .","the range of @xmath11 for our experiment is from @xmath80 to @xmath81 .","although the order of this regime is about one order of magnitude smaller than that in the experiment of @xcite ( @xmath82 ) , the current experimental result is also well explained by @xmath11 . by @xmath7 .","each open symbol shows the data of glass beads bed of @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .","while a systematic correlation between @xmath75 and @xmath7 can be observed , a universal form can not be obtained solely by @xmath7 scaling.,title=\"fig : \" ] by @xmath11 .","colors and markers used are identical to those in fig .","[ fig : g_scaling ] .","the dashed line represents the power law fit ( eqs .","( [ eq : fitting ] ) ) . the slope ( power ) of the dashed line","is computed as @xmath77 .","the solid line corresponds to @xmath78 which is obtained by the least square search for all the data including various system size parameters ( fig .","[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) .",", title=\"fig : \" ] as a next step of the scaling , we investigate the system size dependence of @xmath75 by the varying geometric parameters : bed height @xmath83 and its radius @xmath15 . in fig .","[ fig : aspect_ratio ] , the data of @xmath75 vs. @xmath84 for various @xmath7 and @xmath10 are shown .","non - axisymmetric convection patterns such as a single - roll state are sometimes found in the experiment at some @xmath84 . due to the inhomogeneity ,","the representative velocities in these states show extremely large dispersion .","since we restrict ourselves within the analysis of representative velocity in the homogeneous convection , these data are excluded from the analysis . as shown in fig .","[ fig : aspect_ratio ] , we find that @xmath75 is roughly independent of @xmath84 although its specific value clearly depends on vibrational conditions ( @xmath7 and @xmath10 ) .","this simple relation @xmath85 suggests that @xmath75 can be scaled equivalently both by @xmath15 and @xmath83 .","namely , @xmath75 is the increasing function both of @xmath15 and @xmath83",". then we can reduce the number of geometric parameters , i.e. , @xmath15 and @xmath83 can be unified into a single parameter . in specific , a dimensionless parameter for the system size @xmath86 can be introduced by using grains diameter @xmath13 as , @xmath87 to the aspect ratio of the shaken granular bed , @xmath84 .","colors and shapes of markers indicate vibrational conditions as denoted in the legend .","all the data points are originated from the experiments with glass beads of @xmath27 mm ( bz08 ) .","we remove the data of single - roll state from this plot .","although the level of @xmath75 depends on vibrational conditions , it is roughly independent of @xmath84 .","dashed lines are the average levels for each condition.,title=\"fig : \" ] to prove the validity of the dimensionless parameter @xmath86 , @xmath13 should be varied as well as @xmath15 and @xmath83 .","therefore , we also examine the @xmath13 dependence of @xmath88 . for this purpose ,","the aspect ratio is fixed ( @xmath54 mm and @xmath55 mm ) and glass beads of @xmath28 mm ( bz04 ) and @xmath89 mm ( bz2 ) are used in the experiment . while @xmath75 of bz04 is in the same order as the bz08 case",", @xmath75 of bz2 is about one order of magnitude smaller than that of bz08 , under the same vibrational condition .","this is due to the effect of crystallization which prevents the convective motion .","besides , the solidification ( complete crystallization ) of glass beads bed occurs when bz2 is shaken by @xmath90 .","the crystallization is unavoidable for the larger grains as long as we use nearly mono - disperse spherical grains . whereas the number of data points is not enough to discuss the specific scaling form",", we qualitatively confirm that the convective velocity is a decreasing function of @xmath13 .","altogether , we can assume a simple scaling relation among these dimensionless parameters to compile all the data .","the assumed scaling form is written as , @xmath91 the values of @xmath92 and @xmath93 are computed by searching the least square point in the range of @xmath94 and @xmath95 .","the least square fitting in fig .","( [ fig : sl_scaling ] ) is computed with weighting of the standard deviation ( velocity scattering degree ) .","the obtained values are @xmath78 and @xmath96 .","and the computed numerical prefactor is @xmath97 .","the scaling result for all the experimentally obtained data is shown in fig . [","fig : sl_scaling ] .","as can be seen , the data are basically well scaled by the variable @xmath98 . the corresponding scaling line ( @xmath99 )","is also plotted in fig .","[ fig : s_scaling ] as a solid line .","the value of @xmath92 is slightly improved from the fixed system size case ( fig .","( [ fig : s_scaling ] ) ) . in fig .","[ fig : sl_scaling ] , two data points deviate significantly from the scaling .","this deviation comes from the crystallization effect of large glass beads ( bz2 ) .","the inset of fig .","[ fig : sl_scaling ] shows a linear plot of the same data .","this scaling relation is the main result of this experimental investigation ."],["there are some missing parameters in the scaling of eq .","( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) . for example",", density is not involved in it .","that is , the scaling is a kind of kinematic one .","the density dependence has to be clarified to understand the dynamic scaling including the effect of inertia @xcite .","perhaps , this would not be so critical because the density of glass beads ( @xmath30 kg / m@xmath31 ) is close to ( at least in the same order with ) the real regolith density ( e.g. , @xmath100 kg / m@xmath31 for itokawa @xcite ) .","another example of the missing parameters is the cohesive force among grains .","although the gravitational force is very small on the surface of small asteroids , the cohesive effect would instead play a crucial role @xcite .","it is hard to check this effect by the current experiment since we do not vary the cohesiveness of grains . in the current experiment ,","the cohesive force is negligible since it is much smaller than the gravitational force .","we assume that interstitial air and electrostatic effects do not play essential roles , i.e. , they are much smaller than gravity effect . indeed , the air effect is negligible as long as we use @xmath101 mm grains ( see e.g. , supplementary information of @xcite ) .","we also think that the gravitational force is more dominant than the electrostatic force for the bulk convective motion of glass beads .","in fact , while we saw a few glass beads sticking on the sidewall due to the electrostatic effect , those were really few . the electrostatic effect might slightly affect the convective motion .","however , we consider it can not be a dominant effect .","a much more serious problem is the absence of frictional properties in the scaling .","the frictional properties are a possible origin of intermittent velocity fluctuation shown in fig .","[ fig : time_changing ] .","in addition , it might affect the representative value of convective velocity .","frictional properties relate to the shape of constitutive grains . obviously , actual regolith grains shapes are irregular and rough . by a preliminary experiment",", we actually confirm that @xmath58 significantly reduces when the rough - shaped sand grains are used . on the contrary",", some previous studies have reported that the friction can enhance the convective velocity @xcite . moreover ,","the grain - wall friction is different from grain - grain friction .","the grain - wall friction could be a reason of the onset of granular convection in this experiment .","the detailed study for the effect of friction is a very important future problem .","the origin of granular convection in the current experiment is plausibly the effect of wall . as already mentioned , the structure of the convective roll changes spontaneously when @xmath10 or @xmath15 are varied","this implies that there is an inherent length scale in the granular convection .","however , the wall effect to the velocity scaling is still significant even in split ( doubled ) roll state since we observe the grains motion on the wall .","moreover , it has been shown that experimental conditions including the container s shape and interstitial air influence the convective roll structure @xcite . in these previous studies",", the interaction between grains and wall seems to be a key factor .","nevertheless , astronomical objects obviously maintain their own shapes without any wall .","it is hard to eliminate the container wall effect in usual granular experiments even in microgravity environment .","rather , highly heterogenous structure of small asteroids might work as an effective wall which triggers the granular convection .","put another way , there could be a lot of effective boundaries and/or gradients of frictional properties in actual small asteroids .","thus it is not quite clear whether the granular convection occurs globally or locally in small asteroids .","the structure of the velocity profile @xmath46 is informative both for the granular physics and planetary science . in the previous studies of granular convection @xcite",", convective velocity decays rapidly ( exponentially ) with depth .","and the deep region of the vibrated granular matter is almost at rest .","if this peculiar regime called _ frozen zone _ presents in the real asteroids convection , the regolith migration occurs only within a shallow region . in the current experiment ,","most of velocity profiles do not show the clear frozen zone .","the convective velocity decays calmly as typically shown in fig .","[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) .","thus the convective velocity is simply scaled by @xmath86 with the nontrivial exponent @xmath102 .","if the frozen zone is clearly observed , the convective velocity would be saturated at a certain @xmath83 , and it can not be simply scaled by a single exponent . actually , the frozen zone can be partially observed also in the current experiment under small @xmath7 , large @xmath10 , and large @xmath83 conditions .","since we are interested in the principal flow velocity of the granular convection , we have focused only on the axisymmetric convective state and its maximum velocity @xmath58 , in this study .","detailed analysis of @xmath46 profile is a next important step to reveal the granular convection dynamics that relates to the depth of regolith convection occurring in small astronomical objects .","so far , the scaling form for the granular convective velocity has been discussed on the basis of systematically performed experimental results . in this subsection",", we discuss the implication of the obtained scaling law .","the scaling of eq .","( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) can be rewritten by considering its physical meaning .","then the scaling is compared with a recent experimental result of two - dimensional granular convection .","equation ( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) can be transformed into a following form , @xmath103 this form is more understandable than eq .","( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) .","the representative velocity @xmath58 is expressed by a power law product of two characteristic velocities : gravitational @xmath104 and vibrational @xmath105 .","in addition , the system size dependence is scaled by the last factor @xmath106 .","the scaling of eq .","( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) is qualitatively consistent with a recent experiment performed by @xcite .","they investigated the convective - driven bne and found that the convective velocity linearly depends on @xmath105 .","to better explain the experimental data , the use of @xmath105 was much better than @xmath7 . according to eq .","( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , convective velocity depends on vibrational velocity as , @xmath107 .","these two experimental results show a good agreement . however , they reported the presence of critical vibrational velocity below which the granular convection was not induced .","this critical vibrational velocity probably corresponds to the onset criterion . in the current analysis",", however , we do not clearly confirm this offset in the scaling ( see fig .","[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) .","instead , we varied @xmath11 over two orders of magnitude to obtain the power - law relation .","the range of @xmath11 and other parameters were relatively narrow in the study of @xcite since they are not interested in the scale - free form .","thus they reported the linear relation between the convective velocity and the vibrational velocity . on the other hand",", we obtain the scaling ( power law ) relation between the convective velocity , the vibrational velocity , and the gravitational velocity .","it should be noted that the system size dependence of the scaling is bounded . according to eq .","( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , the value of @xmath58 can be very large when @xmath108 becomes large .","this condition corresponds to a large @xmath109 or a small @xmath13 case . at the limit of @xmath110 or @xmath111",", @xmath58 diverges .","however , such a divergence does not occur in the actual granular convection .","the convective roll size can not grow to the infinitely large size .","in fact , we experimentally observed the split of the convective roll ( double toroidal - roll ) in a very shallow layer , although such a split rarely happened .","this preliminary observation indicates that there might be an intrinsic length scale which determines the maximum convective roll size .","since the current experimental system size is limited , it is hard to systematically reveal the effect of this intrinsic length scale . at a small @xmath13 regime ,","on the other hand , the cohesive force among grains becomes dominant instead of the gravitational force .","the current scaling form can not be applied to such a situation .","the detailed investigation on the size - dependent scaling form for more widely spreading size regime is an important future problem . to investigate the small @xmath13 regime ,","the experiment under the vacuum condition is also necessary .","finally , the experimentally obtained scaling is cast into a form in which the gravity effect can be directly evaluated .","since the interpretation of scaling is not unique in general , we have to take a special care for its understanding . whereas the discussion in this subsection is speculative , the result is consistent with other related works .","moreover , the obtained scaling includes various parameters such as vibration frequency and system size .","thus the form is very efficient to estimate the timescale of regolith convection occurring on the surface of small asteroid .","recently , some granular flow experiments were performed under microgravity conditions created by parabolic flights @xcite .","@xcite used a taylor - couette geometry and measured both sheared and convective flows induced by the shearing .","particularly , @xcite reported the effect of gravity to the sheared granular convection .","they claimed that the gravity plays an essential role to make a stiff grains network in a bulk granular matter .","such a grains network is necessary to transform a shear stress into a driving force of the convective motion .","therefore , the granular convective velocity under the microgravity became almost zero .","moreover , the convective velocity under the high - gravity condition became large @xcite .","@xcite measured the rising velocity of intruders in convective - driven bne under the reduced gravity .","they found that the rising velocity is almost linearly scaled by the gravity . to compare the current result with above - mentioned microgravity experiments ,","here we evaluate the gravity influence to the convective velocity based on eq .","( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) . at a glance of eq .","( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , the convective velocity is scaled as @xmath112 .","this scaling implicitly assumes the fixed @xmath105 under different @xmath1 environment .","this assumption is not practical to estimate the granular convective velocity induced under the different @xmath1 .","for instance , under the microgravity environment , very small vibrational acceleration is enough to satisfy the onset criterion of granular convection ( @xmath113 ) . however , if @xmath105 is fixed to consider the granular convective velocity under the microgravity environment , the corresponding @xmath7 becomes extremely large .","it is not a realistic assumption . instead",", the value of @xmath7 should be fixed to estimate the convective velocity by means of similarity law .","in fact , fixed @xmath7 was used to discuss the possibility of convection on the surface of itokawa @xcite . @xcite","also fixed @xmath7 to discuss @xmath1 dependence .","therefore , the typical vibrational velocity should be written as @xmath114 instead of @xmath105 .","then , eq . ( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) can be modified into the following form , @xmath115 according to eq .","( [ eq : scaling2 ] ) , @xmath58 depends on @xmath1 as , @xmath116 .","the value @xmath117 is close to unity .","this result is qualitatively similar to @xcite and @xcite .","however , note that we do not directly vary the gravitational acceleration .","the @xmath1 dependence is indirectly deduced from the scaling . besides , the convective motion of @xcite was induced by shear in a taylor - couette cell . thus the similarity is rather qualitative .","using eq .","( [ eq : scaling2 ] ) and a model of seismic shaking induced by impacts @xcite , we are able to estimate the convective velocity for various astronomical objects .","to do that , we have to be careful in the estimate of @xmath106 .","whereas its value strongly affects the estimate of @xmath58 , it is still very uncertain",". then it might be possible to evaluate the surface age ( resurfacing timescale ) of the microgravity asteroid by considering the population of impactors .","such an estimate for itokawa or eros is an interesting application of this scaling .","this topic is a part of ongoing investigation ."],["an experimental study of the granular convection was performed with a vertically shaken glass beads bed .","the maximum convective velocity @xmath58 was measured by piv method .","although the @xmath58 was measured on the wall , we assume that it corresponds to a representative value of the convective velocity .","the normalized convective velocity @xmath118 was scaled by the shaking parameter @xmath119 and the dimensionless system size @xmath108 .","the obtained scaling ( eq ( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) ) indicates that the representative convective velocity can be written as a certain power - law product of the vibrational velocity @xmath105 , the gravitational velocity @xmath104 , and the dimensionless system size @xmath86 .","this experimentally obtained scaling law is qualitatively consistent with other previous studies of granular convection or bne . using the scaling law",", one can roughly estimate the convective velocity for various vibrational conditions , in principle . since the gravitational acceleration and frictional properties","are not varied in this experiment , applicability of the current result toward actual regolith migration might be still limited .","systematic further studies have to be carried out to unveil the regolith migration dynamics owing to the granular convection ."],["we would like to thank to s. watanabe , h. kumagai , s. sirono , and t. morota for fruitful discussions and suggestions . this research has been partly supported by jsps kakenhi grant number 23654134 and nagoya university program for leading graduate schools ( leadership development program for space exploration and research ) .","39 natexlab#1#1[1]`#1 ` [ 2]#2 [ 1]#1 [ 1]http://dx.doi.org/#1 [ ] [ 1]pmid:#1 [ ] [ 2]#2 , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,",", , , , . . , . , , ,",". . , . , , , ( eds . ) , . .",", , , . . ,",", , , , , , . . ,",", , , , , , . . , . , , , , ,",", , , , . . ,",". , . . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,",". . , . , , , ,",", , , , . . ,",", , , , . . ,",", , , , , , , , , , , . . ,",". , . . , . , ,",", , , , , , . . ,",", , , . . ,",", , , , , . . ,",", , , . . ,",", , , , . . ,",", , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,",", , , , , , a. . , .",", , , , , , , b. . , .",", , , , , , , c. . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,",", , , . . ,",", , , , , . . ,",", , , . . ,",", , , , . . ,",", , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,",", , , , . . ,",". , . . , . , , , , ,",". . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,",". . , . , , , , ,"]],"string":"[\n [\n \"in the solar system , there are many small bodies such as asteroids and comets .\",\n \"since these small astronomical objects could keep the ancient information of the history of the solar system , a lot of efforts have been devoted to investigations of these objects so far ( e.g. , @xcite ) .\",\n \"for instance , the asteroid itokawa was explored by the japanese space craft _ hayabusa _ from september 2005 .\",\n \"the exploration uncovered the details of itokawa s surface terrain .\",\n \"itokawa is covered by various sizes of granular matter such as regolith , pebbles , and boulders @xcite .\",\n \"moreover , migrations and sorting of the regolith could occur on the surface of itokawa @xcite , although the surface gravity of itokawa is extremely low .\",\n \"impact craters located on the surface of itokawa were very subtle , i.e. , they show indistinct morphologies @xcite .\",\n \"this is probably due to the erasure of the craters by seismic shaking @xcite .\",\n \"in addition , tiny samples returned from itokawa allow us to analyze the detail of its history .\",\n \"@xcite revealed that itokawa s surface grains are relatively young in terms of cosmic - rays exposure .\",\n \"the estimated age is approximately eight million years . besides , using x - ray microtomography , @xcite found that some particles had rounded edges .\",\n \"all these facts suggest that the surface of itokawa would be active and continue to be renewed until recently\",\n \". one possible explanation of such young surface is the regolith convection caused by impact - induced seismic shaking .\",\n \"although the direct measurement of the seismic wave has not been achieved , @xcite and @xcite studied the possibility of global seismic shaking of asteroid eros in order to explain its surface modification processes .\",\n \"they built a model of seismic shaking by considering the attenuating diffusion of the seismic wave .\",\n \"@xcite partially applied the model to the asteroid itokawa and showed that the global regolith convection might occur even by small - scale impacts . to unlock the regolith grains network supported by gravity , the maximum acceleration induced by the seismic shaking has to be greater than the gravitational acceleration .\",\n \"@xcite revealed that this criterion can be satisfied by a small - scale impact since the gravity on the surface of itokawa @xmath3 is very small , @xmath4 m / s@xmath5 @xcite .\",\n \"the value of @xmath3 is about five orders of magnitude smaller than the earth s gravitational acceleration , @xmath6 m / s@xmath5 .\",\n \"the evaluation is still qualitative since they only assessed the onset criterion of the regolith convection .\",\n \"while the quantitative assessment of the convective velocity is necessary to discuss the feasibility of the regolith convection , there have been very few such studies .\",\n \"granular convection can be generally observed in a granular matter under the mechanical vibration . when a granular matter is subjected to a steady vertical vibration , granular convection\",\n \"is readily induced .\",\n \"if the vibrated granular matter is polydisperse , the size segregation of grains occurs usually in vertical direction .\",\n \"this vibration - induced size segregation is called brazil nut effect ( bne ) .\",\n \"the bne can be caused by the granular convection @xcite .\",\n \"this means that the grains can be migrated and sorted simultaneously by vibration .\",\n \"although the regolith convection accompanied by migration and sorting seems to be a natural outcome of global seismic shaking , the scaling approach to the granular convective velocity is needed to discuss the consistency between regolith convection and observational data such as surface age of the asteroid .\",\n \"therefore , we experimentally measure and scale the velocity of granular convection in this study , as a first - step approach to this problem . fundamental nature of granular convection itself is an intriguing problem .\",\n \"the granular convection has long been studied both by experiments @xcite and numerical simulations @xcite . the onset of granular convection depends on the maximum acceleration of the applied vibration .\",\n \"if the maximum acceleration is less than the gravitational acceleration , any granular convection does not occur at all ( e.g. , @xcite ) .\",\n \"thus the dimensionless parameter @xmath7 , which represents the balance between the maximum vibrational acceleration and the gravitational acceleration @xmath1 , has been used to characterize the behavior of granular convection .\",\n \"@xmath7 is defined as , @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the vibration amplitude and @xmath10 is the frequency . in this study ,\",\n \"the scaling method is applied to the analysis of granular convective velocity .\",\n \"we are interested in asteroidal - scale granular convection while the actual experiment is limited within the laboratory scale .\",\n \"in such a situation , the scaling is the only way to derive a meaningful quantitative relation . in the scaling analysis ,\",\n \"dimensionless parameters such as @xmath7 are useful since they do not depend on the system of unit .\",\n \"the weak point of the scaling analysis is its arbitrariness .\",\n \"of course , @xmath7 is one of the most important dimensionless parameters to discuss the vibrated granular matter .\",\n \"however , the choice of the important dimensionless parameter is not unique .\",\n \"specifically , another dimensionless parameter called shaking parameter @xmath11 was firstly introduced by @xcite and recently used to describe the transitions among the granular leidenfrost , bouncing bed , undulations , convection , and so on @xcite .\",\n \"particularly , @xmath11 is relevant to characterize a strongly shaken shallow granular convection @xcite .\",\n \"@xmath11 is defined as , @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the constitutive grains diameter .\",\n \"@xmath11 denotes the balance between the squared vibrational velocity and the squared gravitational velocity .\",\n \"furthermore , @xmath11 can be also obtained by the natural non - dimensionalization of the granular - hydrodynamic model for the strongly shaken granular convection @xcite . using the aforementioned dimensionless parameters\",\n \", we would like to find a useful scaling relation between granular convective velocity , the gravitational acceleration , and other parameters .\",\n \"therefore , we carry out a systematic laboratory experiments of the vibration - induced granular convection\",\n \". this paper is constructed by following sections . in section\",\n \"[ sec : experiment ] , we explain the experimental setup and how to measure the convective velocity . section [ sec : results ] shows the characterization of some convective - roll patterns and the result of the scaling . in section [ sec : discussion ] , we discuss physical meaning and tentative implication of the scaling to the microgravity environment .\",\n \"section [ sec : conclusions ] contains a conclusions .\"\n ],\n [\n \"a schematic illustration of the experimental apparatus is shown in fig . [\",\n \"fig : setup ] .\",\n \"the experimental setup consists of a cylinder made by plexiglass of its height @xmath14 mm and inner radius @xmath15 ( @xmath16 , @xmath17 , or @xmath18 mm ) .\",\n \"glass beads are poured in the cylindrical cell to make a granular bed of the height @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , or @xmath22 mm .\",\n \"the system is mounted on an electromechanical vibrator ( emic 513-b / a ) and shaken vertically .\",\n \"the vibration frequency @xmath10 is varied from @xmath23 to @xmath24 hz and @xmath7 is varied from @xmath25 to @xmath26 .\",\n \"the grains used in this study are glass beads .\",\n \"most of experiments are carried out with glass beads of diameter @xmath27 mm ( as - one corp .\",\n \"bz08 ) and some of them are performed with glass beads of @xmath28 or @xmath25 mm ( as - one corp .\",\n \"bz04 , bz2 ) .\",\n \"size dispersion of glass beads is less than @xmath29% , and the true density of glass beads is @xmath30 kg / m@xmath31 .\",\n \"[ 0.9 ] to measure the granular convective velocity , particle imaging velocimetry ( piv ) method is utilized @xcite .\",\n \"motions of glass beads are filmed by a high - speed camera ( photoron sa-5 ) through a transparent side wall . to erase the memory effect of granular matter ,\",\n \"one minute pre - vibration is applied before each experimental realization .\",\n \"this means that we measure the steady granular convection .\",\n \"while the actual impact - induced regolith convection might be transient , we have to concentrate on the steady convection to eliminate the memory effect .\",\n \"the frame rate is fixed at @xmath32 fps and spatial resolution of the image ranges from @xmath33 @xmath34m / pixel to @xmath35 @xmath34m / pixel depending on the experimental conditions .\",\n \"the high - speed images are acquired for @xmath36 s. since each image consists of @xmath37 pixels , the size of field of view ranges from @xmath38 to @xmath39 mm@xmath5 .\",\n \"raw data images are shown in backgrounds of figs .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] . since it is hard to completely follow all the grains motion , we use piv method instead of the direct particle tracking . in the analyses of figs .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] ( a ) , each instantaneous image is divided into @xmath40 boxes , i.e. , each box consists of @xmath41 pixels .\",\n \"note that the number of image partitioning depends on the experimental condition .\",\n \"then the velocity at each box is computed by detecting a peak of the cross - correlation between two different time snapshots .\",\n \"obtained ( time - averaged ) examples of the velocity field are shown by colored vectors in figs .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] and [ fig : vectorplot ] . an interval time to compute the velocity ( cross - correlation )\",\n \"is kept constant so that it corresponds to a multiple of the period of vibration , i.e. , two cross - correlated images are kept in same phase .\",\n \"for instance , @xmath42 s time interval is used for @xmath43 hz vibration .\",\n \"if we use a full temporal resolution to calculate the velocity field , vibrational motion of individual grains can be captured just like @xcite measurement .\",\n \"however , we are mainly interested in the global convective motion rather than such microscopic vibration . therefore , we use phase - matching images to compute the velocity . as shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] , convective - velocity vectors are decomposed into @xmath44 ( vertical ) and @xmath45 ( horizontal ) directions .\",\n \"they are averaged along the horizontal axis since we are mainly focusing on the axisymmetric convective flow ( like fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] ) for the reason mentioned later\",\n \". then we obtain vertical and horizontal components of velocities as functions of @xmath44 , respectively as , @xmath46 and @xmath47 . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot ] , panels ( b ) and ( c ) respectively show @xmath46 and @xmath47 computed from the velocity field shown in panel ( a ) . the positive direction of @xmath44 axis is taken to downward , and @xmath48 corresponds to the top surface of the granular bed .\",\n \"@xmath49 is the center of container . above the surface of granular bed ( @xmath50 ) ,\",\n \"saltations of grains are dominant and the measured velocity becomes random .\",\n \"this is the reason of large errors in @xmath51 and @xmath52 at @xmath50 ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b , c ) ) .\"\n ],\n [\n \"first , we are going to focus on the global structure of the granular convective motion .\",\n \"we find that the global structure shows a transition from a single roll to a toroidal roll as @xmath10 increases . in the former state ,\",\n \"grains rise up on the one side wall and fall down on the opposite side wall .\",\n \"thus , in this state , the resultant velocity field shows a certain circularity . due to this circularity ,\",\n \"a gradient of the velocity field is observed as shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vectorplot](a ) . in this single - roll state ,\",\n \"the degree of velocity gradient or circularity strongly depends on the viewing spot . in the latter state ,\",\n \"on the other hand , grains rise up at the center of container and fall down on all over the wall homogeneously .\",\n \"the inner structure of this granular convective mode has been observed by using the magnetic resonance imaging ( mri ) method @xcite . in other words ,\",\n \"this toroidal convection state is axisymmetric .\",\n \"typical examples of raw images for such homogeneous convection are shown in figs .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](a ) and [ fig : vectorplot](b ) .\",\n \"a phase diagram of the global structure in @xmath10-@xmath7 space is displayed in fig . [\",\n \"fig : phase_diagram ] . as seen in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : phase_diagram ] , the transition occurs at @xmath53 hz .\",\n \"the transition is almost independent of @xmath7 at least under the current experimental condition .\",\n \"note that the phase diagram is constructed only based on the experiment with @xmath27 mm glass beads . besides ,\",\n \"although we define two types of convective roll structures , this classification is not conclusive .\",\n \"detail measurements of inner structures of convective rolls are necessary to completely categorize the convective structures .\",\n \"the current classification is still tentative since it is based only on the observation by eye . -@xmath7 space with @xmath54 mm , @xmath55 mm and @xmath27 mm .\",\n \"the symbols represent the observed structures of granular convection ; open circles correspond to the single - roll state and cross markers indicate the toroidal - roll state .\",\n \"a phase boundary can be found around @xmath56 hz independently of @xmath7.,title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] next , we analyze the convective velocity . since the main motivation of this study is to characterize the scaling behavior of the representative convective velocity in a vibrated granular matter , we are going to focus on the toroidal - roll ( axisymmetric ) state . in the single - roll state ,\",\n \"convective velocity is spatially heterogeneous in horizontal direction as shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vectorplot](a ) .\",\n \"as mentioned above , the observable velocity field depends on the camera angle since the rolling direction is stochastically determined and can not be controlled in the single - roll state .\",\n \"such a state is inappropriate to extract a representative velocity of the system .\",\n \"by contrast , the toroidal - roll state is rather homogeneous everywhere in @xmath45 direction of the side wall as shown in figs .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](a ) and [ fig : vectorplot](b ) .\",\n \"furthermore , @xmath52 is always almost zero at any @xmath44 ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](c ) ) , and @xmath57 is basically a simple decreasing function of @xmath44 ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) ) in the toroidal - roll state .\",\n \"@xcite found a qualitatively similar velocity profile in the vibrated granular convection .\",\n \"they also used the maximum velocity to characterize the convective velocity .\",\n \"therefore , we use the same strategy in the analysis of the representative convective velocity .\",\n \"namely , we employ the maximum value of the vertical component of velocity , @xmath58 , as a representative convective velocity to characterize the velocity field .\",\n \"temporal homogeneity of @xmath51 is also examined . in the toroidal - roll state ,\",\n \"its spatial structure of the convective velocity is symmetric and simple as discussed above .\",\n \"then , how about the temporal structure ?\",\n \"[ fig : time_changing ] , a typical time series data of @xmath59 ( @xmath58 at each time @xmath60 ) is shown . while @xmath58 basically looks more or less steady , a sort of intermittent velocity spikes\",\n \"can be observed in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : time_changing ] .\",\n \"this slight intermittency might come from the inherent complexity of the granular flow due to the frictional effect .\",\n \"at @xmath61 , @xmath62 hz , @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .\",\n \"intermittent spikes can be observed as well as random fluctuation around the mean value .\",\n \"a horizontal solid line indicates the average value ( @xmath63 mm / s ) and dotted lines show standard deviation levels ( @xmath64 mm / s).,title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] the distribution of velocities @xmath65 obtained from the data of fig . [\",\n \"fig : time_changing ] is displayed in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : histogram ] .\",\n \"here , @xmath65 indicates the number in the range of @xmath66 and @xmath67 mm / s is the bin size .\",\n \"the distribution has a clear peak around @xmath68 mm / s .\",\n \"however , an asymmetric tail can be observed at large @xmath58 regime .\",\n \"whereas this statistical property of the convective velocity field could contain rich physics , here we neglect the asymmetric structure for simplicity s sake . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : histogram ] , the mean value and standard deviation of the entire data set are shown as a filled circle and an error bar shown above the histogram .\",\n \"more detail analyses of @xmath59 by its distribution and temporal correlation etc .\",\n \"are interesting future problems . computed from the data in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : time_changing ] .\",\n \"width of each bin is @xmath69 mm / s .\",\n \"one can confirm the peak of @xmath70 around @xmath71 mm / s and the asymmetric tail in large velocity regime . above the histogram , mean and standard deviation are shown as a filled circle and an error bar , respectively ( @xmath72 mm / s ) .\",\n \"the corresponding standard error is @xmath73 mm / s which is smaller than the size of the circle mark.,title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] finally , a scaling of the granular convective velocity is derived . as a first step of the scaling , we focus on the effect of vibration - conditions ( @xmath10 and @xmath7 ) by fixing the geometric conditions : @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .\",\n \"as mentioned above , we regard @xmath58 as a representative granular convective velocity .\",\n \"more precisely , we use the maximum value of @xmath46 profile ( e.g. , fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) ) as @xmath58 . in order to discuss the scale - free nature ,\",\n \"a relation among dimensionless parameters should be analyzed .\",\n \"thus @xmath58 is normalized to the characteristic velocity created by gravity as , @xmath74 in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : g_scaling ] , @xmath75 vs. @xmath7 for various @xmath10 is shown .\",\n \"one can confirm that all the @xmath75 data are similar increasing functions of @xmath7 .\",\n \"however , these specific values depend not only on @xmath7 but also on @xmath10 . therefore , it is hard to obtain a universal scale - free relation from this plot .\",\n \"in other words , sole @xmath7 can not characterize the granular convective velocity very well . while @xcite used @xmath7 and the normalized bed height to collapse the convective velocity data ,\",\n \"here we consider a different quantity to deduce a simple power - law form for the granular convective velocity .\",\n \"note that the specific functional form of the granular convective velocity was not obtained by @xcite .\",\n \"we find that the shaking parameter @xmath11 is a relevant dimensionless parameter to scale @xmath75 .\",\n \"corresponding scaling plot is shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : s_scaling ] . all of the @xmath75 data collapse to a power - law form , @xmath76 where @xmath77 is a characteristic exponent obtained by the data fitting shown as a dashed line in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : s_scaling ] .\",\n \"the solid line corresponds to @xmath78 which is determined by the scaling with various system size data ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) . as mentioned before\",\n \", @xmath11 represents the balance between the vibrational and gravitational velocities .\",\n \"thus it is rather natural that another velocity balance ( convective velocity vs. gravitational velocity ; @xmath79 ) is scaled by @xmath11 .\",\n \"the range of @xmath11 we used in this study is slightly different from that in the previous studies . in @xcite ,\",\n \"@xmath11 was used to characterize the onset of convection in the strongly shaken shallow granular bed . in this study\",\n \", we experimentally confirm that @xmath11 is also useful to the scaling analysis of the convective velocity in a weakly shaken thick granular bed .\",\n \"the range of @xmath11 for our experiment is from @xmath80 to @xmath81 .\",\n \"although the order of this regime is about one order of magnitude smaller than that in the experiment of @xcite ( @xmath82 ) , the current experimental result is also well explained by @xmath11 . by @xmath7 .\",\n \"each open symbol shows the data of glass beads bed of @xmath27 mm , @xmath55 mm , and @xmath54 mm .\",\n \"while a systematic correlation between @xmath75 and @xmath7 can be observed , a universal form can not be obtained solely by @xmath7 scaling.,title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] by @xmath11 .\",\n \"colors and markers used are identical to those in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : g_scaling ] .\",\n \"the dashed line represents the power law fit ( eqs .\",\n \"( [ eq : fitting ] ) ) . the slope ( power ) of the dashed line\",\n \"is computed as @xmath77 .\",\n \"the solid line corresponds to @xmath78 which is obtained by the least square search for all the data including various system size parameters ( fig .\",\n \"[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] as a next step of the scaling , we investigate the system size dependence of @xmath75 by the varying geometric parameters : bed height @xmath83 and its radius @xmath15 . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : aspect_ratio ] , the data of @xmath75 vs. @xmath84 for various @xmath7 and @xmath10 are shown .\",\n \"non - axisymmetric convection patterns such as a single - roll state are sometimes found in the experiment at some @xmath84 . due to the inhomogeneity ,\",\n \"the representative velocities in these states show extremely large dispersion .\",\n \"since we restrict ourselves within the analysis of representative velocity in the homogeneous convection , these data are excluded from the analysis . as shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : aspect_ratio ] , we find that @xmath75 is roughly independent of @xmath84 although its specific value clearly depends on vibrational conditions ( @xmath7 and @xmath10 ) .\",\n \"this simple relation @xmath85 suggests that @xmath75 can be scaled equivalently both by @xmath15 and @xmath83 .\",\n \"namely , @xmath75 is the increasing function both of @xmath15 and @xmath83\",\n \". then we can reduce the number of geometric parameters , i.e. , @xmath15 and @xmath83 can be unified into a single parameter . in specific , a dimensionless parameter for the system size @xmath86 can be introduced by using grains diameter @xmath13 as , @xmath87 to the aspect ratio of the shaken granular bed , @xmath84 .\",\n \"colors and shapes of markers indicate vibrational conditions as denoted in the legend .\",\n \"all the data points are originated from the experiments with glass beads of @xmath27 mm ( bz08 ) .\",\n \"we remove the data of single - roll state from this plot .\",\n \"although the level of @xmath75 depends on vibrational conditions , it is roughly independent of @xmath84 .\",\n \"dashed lines are the average levels for each condition.,title=\\\"fig : \\\" ] to prove the validity of the dimensionless parameter @xmath86 , @xmath13 should be varied as well as @xmath15 and @xmath83 .\",\n \"therefore , we also examine the @xmath13 dependence of @xmath88 . for this purpose ,\",\n \"the aspect ratio is fixed ( @xmath54 mm and @xmath55 mm ) and glass beads of @xmath28 mm ( bz04 ) and @xmath89 mm ( bz2 ) are used in the experiment . while @xmath75 of bz04 is in the same order as the bz08 case\",\n \", @xmath75 of bz2 is about one order of magnitude smaller than that of bz08 , under the same vibrational condition .\",\n \"this is due to the effect of crystallization which prevents the convective motion .\",\n \"besides , the solidification ( complete crystallization ) of glass beads bed occurs when bz2 is shaken by @xmath90 .\",\n \"the crystallization is unavoidable for the larger grains as long as we use nearly mono - disperse spherical grains . whereas the number of data points is not enough to discuss the specific scaling form\",\n \", we qualitatively confirm that the convective velocity is a decreasing function of @xmath13 .\",\n \"altogether , we can assume a simple scaling relation among these dimensionless parameters to compile all the data .\",\n \"the assumed scaling form is written as , @xmath91 the values of @xmath92 and @xmath93 are computed by searching the least square point in the range of @xmath94 and @xmath95 .\",\n \"the least square fitting in fig .\",\n \"( [ fig : sl_scaling ] ) is computed with weighting of the standard deviation ( velocity scattering degree ) .\",\n \"the obtained values are @xmath78 and @xmath96 .\",\n \"and the computed numerical prefactor is @xmath97 .\",\n \"the scaling result for all the experimentally obtained data is shown in fig . [\",\n \"fig : sl_scaling ] .\",\n \"as can be seen , the data are basically well scaled by the variable @xmath98 . the corresponding scaling line ( @xmath99 )\",\n \"is also plotted in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : s_scaling ] as a solid line .\",\n \"the value of @xmath92 is slightly improved from the fixed system size case ( fig .\",\n \"( [ fig : s_scaling ] ) ) . in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : sl_scaling ] , two data points deviate significantly from the scaling .\",\n \"this deviation comes from the crystallization effect of large glass beads ( bz2 ) .\",\n \"the inset of fig .\",\n \"[ fig : sl_scaling ] shows a linear plot of the same data .\",\n \"this scaling relation is the main result of this experimental investigation .\"\n ],\n [\n \"there are some missing parameters in the scaling of eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) . for example\",\n \", density is not involved in it .\",\n \"that is , the scaling is a kind of kinematic one .\",\n \"the density dependence has to be clarified to understand the dynamic scaling including the effect of inertia @xcite .\",\n \"perhaps , this would not be so critical because the density of glass beads ( @xmath30 kg / m@xmath31 ) is close to ( at least in the same order with ) the real regolith density ( e.g. , @xmath100 kg / m@xmath31 for itokawa @xcite ) .\",\n \"another example of the missing parameters is the cohesive force among grains .\",\n \"although the gravitational force is very small on the surface of small asteroids , the cohesive effect would instead play a crucial role @xcite .\",\n \"it is hard to check this effect by the current experiment since we do not vary the cohesiveness of grains . in the current experiment ,\",\n \"the cohesive force is negligible since it is much smaller than the gravitational force .\",\n \"we assume that interstitial air and electrostatic effects do not play essential roles , i.e. , they are much smaller than gravity effect . indeed , the air effect is negligible as long as we use @xmath101 mm grains ( see e.g. , supplementary information of @xcite ) .\",\n \"we also think that the gravitational force is more dominant than the electrostatic force for the bulk convective motion of glass beads .\",\n \"in fact , while we saw a few glass beads sticking on the sidewall due to the electrostatic effect , those were really few . the electrostatic effect might slightly affect the convective motion .\",\n \"however , we consider it can not be a dominant effect .\",\n \"a much more serious problem is the absence of frictional properties in the scaling .\",\n \"the frictional properties are a possible origin of intermittent velocity fluctuation shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : time_changing ] .\",\n \"in addition , it might affect the representative value of convective velocity .\",\n \"frictional properties relate to the shape of constitutive grains . obviously , actual regolith grains shapes are irregular and rough . by a preliminary experiment\",\n \", we actually confirm that @xmath58 significantly reduces when the rough - shaped sand grains are used . on the contrary\",\n \", some previous studies have reported that the friction can enhance the convective velocity @xcite . moreover ,\",\n \"the grain - wall friction is different from grain - grain friction .\",\n \"the grain - wall friction could be a reason of the onset of granular convection in this experiment .\",\n \"the detailed study for the effect of friction is a very important future problem .\",\n \"the origin of granular convection in the current experiment is plausibly the effect of wall . as already mentioned , the structure of the convective roll changes spontaneously when @xmath10 or @xmath15 are varied\",\n \"this implies that there is an inherent length scale in the granular convection .\",\n \"however , the wall effect to the velocity scaling is still significant even in split ( doubled ) roll state since we observe the grains motion on the wall .\",\n \"moreover , it has been shown that experimental conditions including the container s shape and interstitial air influence the convective roll structure @xcite . in these previous studies\",\n \", the interaction between grains and wall seems to be a key factor .\",\n \"nevertheless , astronomical objects obviously maintain their own shapes without any wall .\",\n \"it is hard to eliminate the container wall effect in usual granular experiments even in microgravity environment .\",\n \"rather , highly heterogenous structure of small asteroids might work as an effective wall which triggers the granular convection .\",\n \"put another way , there could be a lot of effective boundaries and/or gradients of frictional properties in actual small asteroids .\",\n \"thus it is not quite clear whether the granular convection occurs globally or locally in small asteroids .\",\n \"the structure of the velocity profile @xmath46 is informative both for the granular physics and planetary science . in the previous studies of granular convection @xcite\",\n \", convective velocity decays rapidly ( exponentially ) with depth .\",\n \"and the deep region of the vibrated granular matter is almost at rest .\",\n \"if this peculiar regime called _ frozen zone _ presents in the real asteroids convection , the regolith migration occurs only within a shallow region . in the current experiment ,\",\n \"most of velocity profiles do not show the clear frozen zone .\",\n \"the convective velocity decays calmly as typically shown in fig .\",\n \"[ fig : vector_and_vertical_plot](b ) .\",\n \"thus the convective velocity is simply scaled by @xmath86 with the nontrivial exponent @xmath102 .\",\n \"if the frozen zone is clearly observed , the convective velocity would be saturated at a certain @xmath83 , and it can not be simply scaled by a single exponent . actually , the frozen zone can be partially observed also in the current experiment under small @xmath7 , large @xmath10 , and large @xmath83 conditions .\",\n \"since we are interested in the principal flow velocity of the granular convection , we have focused only on the axisymmetric convective state and its maximum velocity @xmath58 , in this study .\",\n \"detailed analysis of @xmath46 profile is a next important step to reveal the granular convection dynamics that relates to the depth of regolith convection occurring in small astronomical objects .\",\n \"so far , the scaling form for the granular convective velocity has been discussed on the basis of systematically performed experimental results . in this subsection\",\n \", we discuss the implication of the obtained scaling law .\",\n \"the scaling of eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) can be rewritten by considering its physical meaning .\",\n \"then the scaling is compared with a recent experimental result of two - dimensional granular convection .\",\n \"equation ( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) can be transformed into a following form , @xmath103 this form is more understandable than eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : sl_scaling ] ) .\",\n \"the representative velocity @xmath58 is expressed by a power law product of two characteristic velocities : gravitational @xmath104 and vibrational @xmath105 .\",\n \"in addition , the system size dependence is scaled by the last factor @xmath106 .\",\n \"the scaling of eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) is qualitatively consistent with a recent experiment performed by @xcite .\",\n \"they investigated the convective - driven bne and found that the convective velocity linearly depends on @xmath105 .\",\n \"to better explain the experimental data , the use of @xmath105 was much better than @xmath7 . according to eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , convective velocity depends on vibrational velocity as , @xmath107 .\",\n \"these two experimental results show a good agreement . however , they reported the presence of critical vibrational velocity below which the granular convection was not induced .\",\n \"this critical vibrational velocity probably corresponds to the onset criterion . in the current analysis\",\n \", however , we do not clearly confirm this offset in the scaling ( see fig .\",\n \"[ fig : sl_scaling ] ) .\",\n \"instead , we varied @xmath11 over two orders of magnitude to obtain the power - law relation .\",\n \"the range of @xmath11 and other parameters were relatively narrow in the study of @xcite since they are not interested in the scale - free form .\",\n \"thus they reported the linear relation between the convective velocity and the vibrational velocity . on the other hand\",\n \", we obtain the scaling ( power law ) relation between the convective velocity , the vibrational velocity , and the gravitational velocity .\",\n \"it should be noted that the system size dependence of the scaling is bounded . according to eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , the value of @xmath58 can be very large when @xmath108 becomes large .\",\n \"this condition corresponds to a large @xmath109 or a small @xmath13 case . at the limit of @xmath110 or @xmath111\",\n \", @xmath58 diverges .\",\n \"however , such a divergence does not occur in the actual granular convection .\",\n \"the convective roll size can not grow to the infinitely large size .\",\n \"in fact , we experimentally observed the split of the convective roll ( double toroidal - roll ) in a very shallow layer , although such a split rarely happened .\",\n \"this preliminary observation indicates that there might be an intrinsic length scale which determines the maximum convective roll size .\",\n \"since the current experimental system size is limited , it is hard to systematically reveal the effect of this intrinsic length scale . at a small @xmath13 regime ,\",\n \"on the other hand , the cohesive force among grains becomes dominant instead of the gravitational force .\",\n \"the current scaling form can not be applied to such a situation .\",\n \"the detailed investigation on the size - dependent scaling form for more widely spreading size regime is an important future problem . to investigate the small @xmath13 regime ,\",\n \"the experiment under the vacuum condition is also necessary .\",\n \"finally , the experimentally obtained scaling is cast into a form in which the gravity effect can be directly evaluated .\",\n \"since the interpretation of scaling is not unique in general , we have to take a special care for its understanding . whereas the discussion in this subsection is speculative , the result is consistent with other related works .\",\n \"moreover , the obtained scaling includes various parameters such as vibration frequency and system size .\",\n \"thus the form is very efficient to estimate the timescale of regolith convection occurring on the surface of small asteroid .\",\n \"recently , some granular flow experiments were performed under microgravity conditions created by parabolic flights @xcite .\",\n \"@xcite used a taylor - couette geometry and measured both sheared and convective flows induced by the shearing .\",\n \"particularly , @xcite reported the effect of gravity to the sheared granular convection .\",\n \"they claimed that the gravity plays an essential role to make a stiff grains network in a bulk granular matter .\",\n \"such a grains network is necessary to transform a shear stress into a driving force of the convective motion .\",\n \"therefore , the granular convective velocity under the microgravity became almost zero .\",\n \"moreover , the convective velocity under the high - gravity condition became large @xcite .\",\n \"@xcite measured the rising velocity of intruders in convective - driven bne under the reduced gravity .\",\n \"they found that the rising velocity is almost linearly scaled by the gravity . to compare the current result with above - mentioned microgravity experiments ,\",\n \"here we evaluate the gravity influence to the convective velocity based on eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) . at a glance of eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) , the convective velocity is scaled as @xmath112 .\",\n \"this scaling implicitly assumes the fixed @xmath105 under different @xmath1 environment .\",\n \"this assumption is not practical to estimate the granular convective velocity induced under the different @xmath1 .\",\n \"for instance , under the microgravity environment , very small vibrational acceleration is enough to satisfy the onset criterion of granular convection ( @xmath113 ) . however , if @xmath105 is fixed to consider the granular convective velocity under the microgravity environment , the corresponding @xmath7 becomes extremely large .\",\n \"it is not a realistic assumption . instead\",\n \", the value of @xmath7 should be fixed to estimate the convective velocity by means of similarity law .\",\n \"in fact , fixed @xmath7 was used to discuss the possibility of convection on the surface of itokawa @xcite . @xcite\",\n \"also fixed @xmath7 to discuss @xmath1 dependence .\",\n \"therefore , the typical vibrational velocity should be written as @xmath114 instead of @xmath105 .\",\n \"then , eq . ( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) can be modified into the following form , @xmath115 according to eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling2 ] ) , @xmath58 depends on @xmath1 as , @xmath116 .\",\n \"the value @xmath117 is close to unity .\",\n \"this result is qualitatively similar to @xcite and @xcite .\",\n \"however , note that we do not directly vary the gravitational acceleration .\",\n \"the @xmath1 dependence is indirectly deduced from the scaling . besides , the convective motion of @xcite was induced by shear in a taylor - couette cell . thus the similarity is rather qualitative .\",\n \"using eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : scaling2 ] ) and a model of seismic shaking induced by impacts @xcite , we are able to estimate the convective velocity for various astronomical objects .\",\n \"to do that , we have to be careful in the estimate of @xmath106 .\",\n \"whereas its value strongly affects the estimate of @xmath58 , it is still very uncertain\",\n \". then it might be possible to evaluate the surface age ( resurfacing timescale ) of the microgravity asteroid by considering the population of impactors .\",\n \"such an estimate for itokawa or eros is an interesting application of this scaling .\",\n \"this topic is a part of ongoing investigation .\"\n ],\n [\n \"an experimental study of the granular convection was performed with a vertically shaken glass beads bed .\",\n \"the maximum convective velocity @xmath58 was measured by piv method .\",\n \"although the @xmath58 was measured on the wall , we assume that it corresponds to a representative value of the convective velocity .\",\n \"the normalized convective velocity @xmath118 was scaled by the shaking parameter @xmath119 and the dimensionless system size @xmath108 .\",\n \"the obtained scaling ( eq ( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) ) indicates that the representative convective velocity can be written as a certain power - law product of the vibrational velocity @xmath105 , the gravitational velocity @xmath104 , and the dimensionless system size @xmath86 .\",\n \"this experimentally obtained scaling law is qualitatively consistent with other previous studies of granular convection or bne . using the scaling law\",\n \", one can roughly estimate the convective velocity for various vibrational conditions , in principle . since the gravitational acceleration and frictional properties\",\n \"are not varied in this experiment , applicability of the current result toward actual regolith migration might be still limited .\",\n \"systematic further studies have to be carried out to unveil the regolith migration dynamics owing to the granular convection .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we would like to thank to s. watanabe , h. kumagai , s. sirono , and t. morota for fruitful discussions and suggestions . this research has been partly supported by jsps kakenhi grant number 23654134 and nagoya university program for leading graduate schools ( leadership development program for space exploration and research ) .\",\n \"39 natexlab#1#1[1]`#1 ` [ 2]#2 [ 1]#1 [ 1]http://dx.doi.org/#1 [ ] [ 1]pmid:#1 [ ] [ 2]#2 , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , . . , . , , ,\",\n \". . , . , , , ( eds . ) , . .\",\n \", , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , . . , . , , , , ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \". , . . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,\",\n \". . , . , , , ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , , , , , , . . ,\",\n \". , . . , . , ,\",\n \", , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , a. . , .\",\n \", , , , , , , b. . , .\",\n \", , , , , , , c. . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . . ,\",\n \", , , , . . ,\",\n \". , . . , . , , , , ,\",\n \". . , . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,\",\n \". . , . , , , , ,\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":94,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"nlin0608031"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["m. kac s classical paper can one hear the shape of a drum \" @xcite , triggered intensive research in two complementary aspects of this problem . on the one hand ,","a search for systems for which kac s question is answered in the affirmative was conducted , and , on the other hand , various examples of pairs of systems which are isospectral but not isometric were identified . in the present paper","we shall focus our attention to quantum graphs and in the following lines will review the subject of isospectrality in this limited context .","the interested reader is referred to [ 1 - 11 ] for a broader view of the field where spectral inversion and its uniqueness are discussed .","spectral problems related to graphs emerge in two distinct ways . in the first , the spectrum of the connectivity ( adjacency ) matrix is considered .","it represents a discrete version of the laplacian , and for finite graphs , the spectrum is finite .","this set of problems is often referred to as combinatorial graphs .","quantum ( metric ) graphs are obtained by associating the standard metric to the bonds which connect the vertices .","the schrdinger operator consists of the one - dimensional laplacians on the bonds complemented by appropriate boundary conditions at the vertices ( see next section ) .","the spectrum of quantum graphs is unbounded , and it displays many interesting features which made it a convenient paradigm in the study of quantum chaos @xcite . shortly after the appearance of kac s paper , m. e. fisher published his work on hearing the shape of a drum \" @xcite , where he addresses isospectrality for the discrete version of the laplacian .","since then , the study of isospectral combinatorial graphs made very impressive progress .","in particular , several methods to construct isospectral yet different graphs were proposed .","a review of this problem can be found in @xcite . in particular , a method which was originally put forward by sunada @xcite to construct isospectral laplace - beltrami operators on riemann manifolds , was adapted for the corresponding problem in the context of combinatorial graphs . here","we shall go one step further , and show that it can be also adapted for quantum graphs .","the conditions under which the spectral inversion of quantum graphs is unique were studied previously . in @xcite","it was shown that in general , the spectrum does not determine uniquely the length of the bonds and their connectivity .","however , it was shown in @xcite that quantum graphs whose bond lengths are _ rationally independent _ can be heard \" - that is - their spectra determine uniquely their connectivity matrices and their bond lengths .","this fact follows from the existence of an exact trace formula for quantum graphs @xcite .","thus , isospectral pairs of non congruent graphs , must have rationally dependent bond lengths .","the sunada method , which is based on constructing the isospectral domains by concatenating several copies of a given building block , automatically provides us with graphs with rationally dependent lengths .","an example of a pair of metrically distinct graphs which share the same spectrum was already discussed in @xcite . in a previous report","we have shown that all the known isospectral domains in @xmath0 @xcite have corresponding isospectral pairs of quantum graphs @xcite . here , we shall take the subject one step further , and propose that isospectral graphs can be resolved by counting their nodal domains .","that is , the nodal counts of eigenfunctions belonging to the same spectral value are not the same .","the idea that nodal counts resolve isospectrality was suggested in @xcite for a family of isospectral flat tori in 4-d , and was tested numerically . the present work offers both rigorous and numerical evidence to substantiate the validity of this conjecture in a few examples of isospectral graphs . for these examples","the nodal counts differences ocur on a substantial fraction of the spectrum .","the paper is organized in the following way .","for the sake of completeness we shall give a short review of some elementary definitions and facts on quantum graphs .","we shall then show how pairs of isospectral domains in @xmath0 can be reduced to isospectral pairs of quantum graphs , and discuss their spectra and eigenfunctions .","finally , we shall study the nodal domains of these eigenfunctions and show that by counting nodal domains one can resolve the isospectral ambiguity of the graphs presented .","we consider finite graphs consisting of @xmath1 _ vertices _ connected by @xmath2 _","bonds_. the @xmath3 _ connectivity matrix _ will be denoted by @xmath4 : @xmath5 when the vertices @xmath6 and @xmath7 are connected by @xmath8 bonds , and it vanishes otherwise .","the group of bonds which emerge from the vertex @xmath6 form a star \" which will be denoted by @xmath9 .","@xmath10 of a vertex is defined as the cardinality of the star @xmath9 and @xmath11 .","vertices with @xmath12 belong to the graph _","boundary_. the vertices with @xmath13 belong to the graph _ interior_. the bonds are endowed with the standard metric , and the coordinates along the bonds @xmath14 are denoted by @xmath15 . the length of the bonds will be denoted by @xmath16 , and the total length of the graph is @xmath17 .","the domain of the schrdinger operator on the graph is the space of functions which belong to sobolev space @xmath18 on each bond b and at the vertices they are continuous and obey boundary conditions as is mentioned in ( [ eq : bc ] ) .","the operator is constructed in the following way .","on the bonds , it is identified as the laplacian in 1-d @xmath19 .","it is supplemented by boundary conditions on the vertices which ensure that the resulting operator is self adjoint .","we shall consider in this paper the neumann and dirichlet boundary conditions : @xmath20 the derivatives in ( [ eq : bc ] ) are directed out of the vertex @xmath6 .","_ comment _ : the neumann boundary conditions will be assumed throughout , unless otherwise stated .","a wave function with a wave number @xmath21 can be written as @xmath22 where @xmath14 connects the vertices @xmath6 and @xmath7 , where the wave function @xmath23 takes the values @xmath24 and @xmath25 respectively .","the form ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) ensures continuity .","the spectrum @xmath26 and the corresponding eigenfunctions are determined by substituting ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) in ( [ eq : bc ] ) .","the resulting homogeneous linear equations for the @xmath24 are written as @xmath27 and a non trivial solution exists when @xmath28 the spectrum @xmath29 , which is a discrete , positive and unbounded sequence is the zero set of the _ secular function _ @xmath30 .","the secular functions of the type ( [ eq : secular ] ) have poles on the real @xmath21 axis , which renders them rather inconvenient for numerical studies .","the secular function can be easily regularized in various ways , ( see e.g. , @xcite ) .","it is easy to show that the complete wave function can be written down in terms of the vertex wave functions at the interior vertices with @xmath31 only . in the sequel","we shall denote their number by @xmath32 .","this reduces the dimension of the matrix @xmath33 above from @xmath1 to @xmath32 .","the nodal domains of the eigenfunctions ( the connected domains where the wave function is of constant sign ) , are of two types .","the ones that are confined to a single bond are rather trivial .","their length is exactly half a wavelength and their number is on average @xmath34 .","the nodal domains which extend over several bonds emanating from a single vertex vary in length and their existence is the reason why counting nodal domains on graphs is not a trivial task .","the number of nodal domains in a general graph can be written as @xmath35\\mathrm{sign}[\\phi_j ] \\right ) \\right \\ } -b + v \\ .","\\label{eq : nnb2}\\ ] ] where @xmath36 stands for the largest integer which is smaller than @xmath37 , and @xmath38 are the values of the eigenfunction at the vertices connected by the bond @xmath14 @xcite .","( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) holds for the case of an eigenfunction which does not vanish on any vertex : @xmath39 .","recently schapotschnikow @xcite proved that sturm s oscillation theorem extends to finite tree ( loop - less ) graphs :","the number of nodal domains of the @xmath40th eigenfunction ( ordered by increasing eigenvalues ) is @xmath40 .","berkolaiko @xcite have shown that the number of nodal domains is bounded to the interval @xmath41 $ ] where @xmath42 is the minimal number of bonds which should be cut so that the resulting graph is a tree .","nodal domains can be also defined and counted in an alternative way which makes use of the vertex wave functions @xmath43 ( see ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) ) exclusively : _ a nodal domain consists of a maximal set of connected interior vertices ( @xmath31 ) _ _ where the vertex wave functions have the same sign .","_ this definition has to be modified if any of the @xmath24 vanishes .","then , the sign attributed to it is chosen to maximize the number of nodal domains @xcite .","we thus have two independent ways to define and count nodal domains . to distinguish between them","we shall refer to the first as _ metric _ nodal domains , and the number of metric domains in the @xmath40th eigenfunction will be denoted by @xmath44 .","berkolaiko s theorem states that @xmath45 .","the domains defined in terms of the vertex wave functions will be referred to as the _ discrete _ nodal domains .","the number of discrete nodal domains of the @xmath40th vertex wave function will be denoted by @xmath46 .","the sequences of metric and discrete nodal domains counts @xmath47 and @xmath48 are the main objects of study of the present paper .","the first pair of isospectral planar domains which was introduced by gordon , web and wolpert @xcite is a member of a much larger set which was discussed in @xcite .","this was extended in @xcite to include domains which differ in the distribution of boundary conditions ( dirichlet or neumann ) along their boundaries .","the common feature of these sets of pairs of isospectral domains is that they are constructed using the sunada method @xcite , and they share a few important and distinctive attributes : * the domains are constructed by concatenating an elementary building block \" in two different prescribed ways to form the two domains .","a building block is joined to another by reflecting along the common boundary .","the shape of the building block is constrained only by symmetry requirements , but otherwise it is quite general . *","the eigenfunctions corresponding to the same eigenvalue are related to each other by a _","transplantation_. that is , the eigenfunction in a building block of one domain can be expressed as a linear combination of the eigenfunction in several building blocks in the other domain .","the transplantation matrix is independent of the considered eigenvalue . * the construction of these pairs reflects an abstract algebraic structure which was identified by sunada @xcite .","an example of an isospectral pair of domains in @xmath49 and its building block is given in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](a ) ) .","this is a pair whose construction is described in @xcite .","it is denoted there by @xmath50 .","other examples are displayed in e.g. , @xcite .","we can construct _ metric _ graphs which are analogous to these domains , by replacing the building blocks by appropriate graphs which preserve the requires symmetry .","as an example , the triangular building block in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](a ) ) can be replaced by a 3 - star with bonds of lengths @xmath51 , @xmath14 and @xmath52 as shown in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](b ) ) .","this yields the pair of isospectral but non isometric graphs shown in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](c ) ) .","( in drawing figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](c ) ) we took advantage of the fact that the angles \" between the bonds are insignificant ) .","note that the two graphs share the same connectivity matrix ( they are topologically congruent ) however they are not isometric . as a matter of fact the right and the left graphs are interchanged when the bonds @xmath14 \" with ","@xmath52 \" are switched .","thus , the lengths @xmath14 and @xmath52 must be different to ensure that the two graphs are not isometric .","this is an example of an asymmetry requirement which the building block must satisfy .","all other pairs of isospectral domains proposed in @xcite can be converted to their analogous quantum graphs ( see @xcite for details ) .","two examples are shown in figure ( [ fig:13 - 3and13 - 8 ] ) .","the most simple pair of isospectral domains can be built by applying the sunada method to the dihedral group @xmath53 .","the resulting graphs are shown in figure ( [ fig : isospectral pair+notations ] ) , where the letters @xmath54 or @xmath55 specify the boundary conditions at the boundary vertices .","( the boundary conditions at the interior vertices are always neumann ) .","note that the two graphs are connected differently , in contrast with the previous example where the topology of the two graphs is the same . in [ appendix1 ] we give a brief description of the construction of this pair , as an example of the sunada method . in a way of illustration","we shall write explicitly the secular functions for the graphs shown above .","starting with the @xmath50 pair , we have @xmath56 ( the interior vertices are marked by a black dot and are enumerated in figure 1(c ) ) . the secular function for the graph @xmath57","is written in terms of the matrix @xmath58 here , @xmath59 and @xmath60 the corresponding vertex eigenfunction @xmath61 is the eigenvector of @xmath62 with a vanishing eigenvalue .","the @xmath33 matrix for the graph @xmath63 is obtained from the matrix @xmath64 by interchanging @xmath52 and @xmath14 .","explicit computation shows that @xmath65 .","this proves the isospectrality of the two graphs .","the sum of the elements of any of the columns of @xmath66 is @xmath67 .","hence the vector @xmath68 is an eigenvector with an eigenvalue @xmath67 .","the values of @xmath21 for which @xmath69 are in the spectrum of both graphs .","they correspond to eigenfunctions which are the same on each of the 3-stars - the building block of the complete graphs ( figure 1(b ) ) . as a matter of fact",", the condition @xmath69 is the secular equation for this 3-star with bond lengths @xmath70 @xcite .","this subset exhausts 1/7 of the spectrum of the graphs , and in this set the transplantation property is trivial .","the transplantation property which is basic to the proof of isospectrality for the @xmath49 domains in @xcite can be explicitly formulated by the transplantation matrix @xmath71 we observe that the inverse transplantation is also effected by @xmath72 : @xmath73 even though @xmath72 is not self inversive .","the fact that @xmath72 induces the transplantation in the two directions , implies that the vertex wave functions @xmath74 must be eigenvectors of @xmath75 ( as long as the eigenvalue is not degenerate ) .","the wave functions are defined up to normalization , and therefore the corresponding eigenvalues can be different than unity .","the spectrum of @xmath75 consists of the eigenvalue @xmath76 and the six - fold degenerate eigenvalue @xmath77 .","thus , the vertex wave functions are either proportional to @xmath78 , or belong to the 6 dimensional subspace of vectors orthogonal to @xmath78 .","this observation will be used in the next section when the nodal structure of the eigenfunctions is to be discussed .","other examples of pairs of isospectral graphs such as e.g. , the pair described in @xcite can be obtained from the isospectral graphs constructed above , by setting the length of the @xmath52 bond to zero .","this was explicitly shown in @xcite .","using similar special cases one can generate a rich variety of isospectral but not isometric quantum graphs .","finally , it should be emphasized , that the skeleton of interior vertices form graphs which are identical to the topological , colored graphs which were introduced in @xcite to express the transplantation properties of the isospectral domains in @xmath49 .","the quantum , metric graphs can be obtained simply by completing each topological vertex to a 3-vertex star graph with lengths @xmath70 .","topological bonds are associated with lengths according to their colors , and bonds are added to the topological vertices with valency less than three , to complete them to 3- stars .","this proves the statement made above that the computation carried out here can be repeated for any of the topological graphs shown in @xcite .","the graphs corresponding to the isospectral domains @xmath79 and @xmath80 are shown in figure [ fig:13 - 3and13 - 8 ] .","+ i ii the dihedral graphs are much simpler , with @xmath81 .","their secular determinants can be shown to be identical functions of @xmath21 .","this is an explicit demonstration that the graphs are indeed isospectral .","the secular equation is obtained from @xmath82 as can be easily seen , @xmath83 has poles , and to get a regular secular function we have to multiply it by @xmath84 .","it takes the form @xmath85 the transplantation matrix for this pair of graphs is derived in [ appendix1 ] .","it reads @xmath86 the eigenvectors @xmath87 point at the directions @xmath88 , with @xmath89 .","the transplantation ( [ eq : transdi ] ) implies that @xmath90 is obtained from @xmath91 by a rotation of @xmath92 counterclockwise .","direct substitutions shows that @xmath93 where , @xmath94 the explicit form of the functions @xmath95 and @xmath96 will be used in the discussion of nodal counting in the next section .","the real eigenfunctions of laplace - beltrami operators on two dimensional manifolds display usually an intricate sets of nodal domains - which are the connected domains where the sign of the eigenfunction is constant @xcite .","sturm s oscillation theorem for systems in 1-d , and its extension by courant to any dimension , establish the connection between the number of nodal domains and the spectrum : the number of nodal domains @xmath44 of the @xmath40th eigenfunction is bounded by @xmath40 .","( the eigenfunctions are arranged by increasing value of their eigenvalues ) .","theorem for combinatorial graphs and for quantum graphs were proved in @xcite , respectively . given a pair of isospectral domains .","are the sequences of nodal counts @xmath97 identical ?","in other words , can one use the information stored in the nodal sequences to resolve isospectrality ?","this question was recently discussed in the context of isospectral flat tori in @xmath98 with @xmath99 @xcite , and numerical as well as analytical evidence was brought to substantiate the conjecture that the nodal sequences resolve isospectrality . in this section we shall provide rigorous as well as numerical evidence to show that the same is true for isospectral quantum graphs of the types discussed above .","we shall start by discussing the _ discrete _ nodal sequences and then proceed to the _ metric _ nodal sequences .","the _ discrete _ nodal domains were defined as the maximally connected sets of interior vertices with vertex wave functions of equal sign .","their number is denoted by @xmath46 , and the nodal sequence is @xmath100 .","we shall prove in the next subsection that for the dihedral graphs half of the entries in the sequences of discrete nodal counts are different .","we are not able to provide a similar proof for the more complex graphs , but we shall bring numerical evidence which supports the conjecture that their sequences of discrete nodal counts are different",". the number of discrete nodal domains for this pair of dihedral graphs ( see figure [ fig : isospectral pair+notations ] ) can be either one or two , depending on whether the signs of the components of the ( two dimensional ) vertex eigenfunctions have the same sign or not .","in other words ( see ( [ eq : tan ] ) ) , the number of nodal domains depend on the quadrant in the @xmath101 plane where the eigenvectors point : @xmath102 in the first and the third quadrants , and @xmath103 in the second and the fourth quadrants : @xmath104 the transplantation implies that the eigenvectors @xmath105 are obtained by rotating @xmath106 by @xmath92 counterclockwise",". therefore , @xmath107 if the transplantation rotates the vectors across the quadrant borders . in other words , @xmath108 this observation is essential to our discussion since it expresses the problem of nodal counting in geometrical terms .","it is convenient to construct finite subsequences @xmath109 and @xmath110 of discrete nodal count of graphs i and ii , restricted to the spectral points in the interval @xmath111 .","we denote the number of terms by @xmath112 .","define @xmath113 we shall now prove [ thm1 ] consider the dihedral graphs i , ii discussed above with rationally independent bond lengths @xmath70 . then @xmath114 _ proof of theorem [ thm1 ] : _ the rational independence of @xmath70 implies that the eigenfunctions never vanish on the inner vertices and hence that the spectrum is simple . in order to study @xmath115 above",", we consider the distribution of the directions of the eigenfunctions @xmath116 in the spectral interval . using ( [ eq : secdireg],[eq : tan ] , [ eq : gfunction ] ) we get @xmath117 in taking the limit @xmath118 we use @xmath119 @xcite . moreover , since @xmath70 are assumed to be rationally independent , @xmath21 creates an ergodic flow on the 3-torus @xmath120 spanned by @xmath121 .","ergodicity implies that the integral over @xmath21 in ( [ eq : ndist1 ] ) may be replaced by an integral over @xmath120 leading to @xmath122 \\label{eq : ndist2}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] now we note that under the transformation @xmath123 we have @xmath124 thus , we conclude that @xmath125 at this stage we are not able to prove the validity of the conjecture that the nodal sequences resolve the isospectrality of the graphs @xmath50 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 .","however , numerical tests show that for an appreciable fraction of the wave functions , the nodal counts are distinct",". we shall start the discussion by considering the case @xmath50 , for which we can turn the counting problem into a geometrical problem .","the vertex wave functions which correspond to the same eigenvalues are related by transplantation : @xmath126 where @xmath74 stand now for the vertex wave function restricted to the 7 interior vertices in these graphs .","we have already shown that eigenvectors @xmath127 are either proportional to @xmath128 ( the vector with constant entries)- in which case both have a single nodal domain , and @xmath129 , or the @xmath127 are orthogonal to @xmath128 .","the 6 eigenvectors of @xmath75 with eigenvalue @xmath77 span the orthogonal subspace : three of them correspond to the eigenvalue @xmath130 of @xmath72 , and the other three correspond to the eigenvalue @xmath131 of @xmath72 . any vertex wave function @xmath132 which is not proportional to @xmath128 , can be written as @xmath133 where @xmath134 stand for arbitrary normalized vectors in the three dimensional subspaces mention above , and @xmath135 $ ] .","thus , latexmath:[\\[\\vec{\\phi}^{\\ ii } = t \\vec{\\phi}^{\\ i } = \\sqrt2 ( \\cos\\alpha \\ difference in nodal numbers comes only through the change of sign of the linear combination .","we are not able to make further progress beyond this point , and we shall therefore summarize the numerical findings . _ the graph _ @xmath50 - based on the study of approximately 6600 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath137 only .","the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 19 @xmath139 of the wave - functions . _ the graph _ @xmath79 - based on the study of approximately 2000 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath137 only .","the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 22@xmath139 of the wave - functions . _","the graph _ @xmath80 - based on the study of approximately 4700 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath140 only .","the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 22 @xmath139 of the wave - functions .","this result is certainly encouraging but not sufficient , and we are trying various options to substantiate it more rigourously . the discussion of the metric nodal sequences is facilitated in the present examples of isospectral graphs since most of them are trees .","then , by making use of schapotschnikow s theorem @xcite , the _ metric _ nodal counts @xmath141 .","this applies in particular to the isospectral graphs of the types @xmath50 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 which are tree graphs and @xmath142 .","the metric counts do not resolve the isospectrality in these case .","however , less trivially connected graphs can be constructed by replacing the basic building block . for such graphs schapotschnikow s theorem does not apply , and we expect their metric sequences to be different .","below we shall show that this is true for the pair of dihedral graph where graph ii is not a tree .","consider the pair of dihedral graphs , and let @xmath143 denote the metric nodal counts of graphs i and and ii . using ( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) we express the difference @xmath144 as @xmath145\\nonumber\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] to obtain ( [ eq : nd_diff ] ) a slight modification of ( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) was needed : the term in the sum that corresponds to a bond with boundary vertex that has dirichlet boundary conditions should be modified to be @xmath146 instead of @xmath147\\mathrm{sign}[\\phi_j ] \\right ) $ ] .","in addition while deriving ( [ eq : nd_diff ] ) we made use of the identity @xmath148 and of the freedom to choose the sign of the first component of the wave - functions to be positive .","a theorem by berkolaiko @xcite guarantees that @xmath149 can only take the values @xmath150 and @xmath151 .","we would like to compute the distribution of these values on the spectrum .","for this purpose we consider the spectral interval @xmath152 and study the function @xmath153 and prove the following theorem .","[ theorem1]theorem [ thm2 ] consider the dihedral graphs i , ii discussed above with rationally independent bond lengths @xmath70 . then @xmath154 _ proof of theorem [ thm2 ] : _ in order to study the @xmath155 above we consider the distribution of @xmath149 , which is given by the integral @xmath156 where the spectral secular function @xmath95 is defined in ( [ eq : secdireg ] ) above , and @xmath157 coincides with @xmath149 for @xmath158 and can be written explicitly as @xmath159 \\ .\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] following the same route as in the proof of theorem ( [ thm1 ] ) we take the limit @xmath118 while making use of the ergodic theorem , and replace the @xmath21 integration by an integration over the 3 - torus with coordinates @xmath160 .","@xmath161 the last line follows from the fact that @xmath37 is an integer which is written as half the sum of four unimodular numbers .","next we note that under the transformation @xmath162 we have @xmath163 thus , we conclude that @xmath164 .","but due to berkolaiko s theorem @xcite @xmath165 .","therefore , @xmath166","there is now a growing amount of evidence that nodal - count sequences store information on the geometry of the system under study , which is similar but not equivalent to the information stored in the spectral sequence . in a recent paper @xcite","it was shown that the nodal count sequence for separable laplace - beltrami operators can be expressed in terms of a trace formula which consists of a smooth ( weyl - like ) part , and an oscillatory part .","the smooth part depends on constants which can be derived from the geometry of the domain , and the oscillatory part depends on the classical periodic orbits , much in the same way as the spectral trace formula . however , what we have shown in the present paper is that the information stored in the two sequences is not identical : for the isospectral pairs of graphs considered here , the nodal - count sequences are different in a substantial way . in this respect ,","the nodal sequence resolves isospectrality .","till this work was done , the conjecture that isospectrality is resolved by counting nodal domains was substantiated by numerical studies only .","here we presented for the first time a system where this fact is proved rigorously . the main breakthrough which enabled the proof was by formulating the counting problem in a geometrical setting .","we hope that this way will pave the way to further analytical studies , where more complex systems will be dealt with .","finally , we would like to mention a set of open problems which naturally arise in the present context : can one find metrically different domains where the laplacians have different spectra but the nodal counting sequences are the same ? a positive answer is provided for domains in @xmath151 dimension ( sturm ) or for tree graphs ( schapotschnikow ) .","are there other less trivial examples ?","it is a pleasure to acknowledge s gnutzmann , m solomyak and g berkolaiko for valuable discussions and comments .","we are indebted to m sieber for discussions and for sharing with us his notes which formed the basis for the results discussed in [ appendix1 ] .","the work was supported by the minerva center for non - linear physics and the einstein ( minerva ) center at the weizmann institute , and by grants from the gif ( grant i-808 - 228.14/2003 ) , and epsrc ( grant gr / t06872/01 . us","thanks the school of mathematics in bristol for their hospitality and support .","the dihedral group @xmath167 is the symmetry group of a square .","let @xmath51 be the transformation of rotating the square @xmath168 counterclockwise and b be the transformation of reflecting it along the x axis .","the dihedral group is generated by @xmath169 which obey @xmath170,@xmath171 .","the 8 group elements of @xmath172 are @xmath173 .","@xmath174 are reflections along the axis @xmath175 respectively ( figure [ fig : basic square ] ) .","note that the multiplication should be read from right to left since the elements are transformations .","this group has 5 irreducible representations ( irreps ) .","four of them are one dimensional and one , which is of our interest , is two dimensional .","the two dimensional representation is : denote the second basis by @xmath181 .","so that @xmath182 . notice that in the first form of the representation @xmath183 and @xmath184 are diagonal and in the second one @xmath185 and @xmath186 are diagonal .","this will be exploited soon .","the graph in figure [ fig : complete graph](a ) obeys the dihedral symmetry .","examine the eigenfunctions of the schrdinger operator with neumann boundary conditions on all the vertices .","the set of all the eigenfuncions of a certain eigenvalue @xmath187 form a finite dimensional vector space @xmath1 with some dimension @xmath188 .","this vector space is invariant under the action of the dihedral group and therefore @xmath1 is the carrier space of some representation of @xmath172 .","we are interested in the case that this representation is the two dimensional irrep of @xmath189 or that this representation is a reducible representation that contains the two dimensional irrep .","consider the basis @xmath177 of this 2d irrep ( note that now @xmath190 have the meaning of wave functions on the graph in figure [ fig : complete graph ] ) . from the matrix which corresponds to @xmath183 in this basis ( see ( [ eq : repform1 ] ) ) we deduce that @xmath191 vanish on the axis x ( as an odd function with respect to that axis ) and as for @xmath192 , its derivative vanishes on the x axis ( since @xmath193 is an even function with respect to that axis and therefore its derivative is odd ) .","using the notation from figure [ fig : complete graph](b ) , we have : + similarly , examining the matrix of @xmath184 in this basis ( [ eq : repform1 ] ) yields @xmath195 + we can get similar observations by looking on the matrices of @xmath185 , @xmath186 , this time for the basis @xmath196 ( [ eq : repform2 ] ) .","we get the following @xmath197 + now , a pair of isospectral graphs will be constructed out of the complete graph .","each of the graphs in the pair will be a subgraph of the complete graph .","graph i is the graph that consists of the vertices b , c , d , e , f and all the bonds which connect them .","graph ii is the graph that consists of the vertices a , b , c , d and all the bonds which connect them ( figure [ fig : boundary conditions ] ) .","we can define the subgraphs in another way which will become convenient later : using the axis @xmath198 as in figure [ fig : basic square ] we define two sets of coordinates @xmath199 and @xmath200 and use them to examine the complete graph .","graph i is obtained when restricting ourselves to the region @xmath201 of the complete graph .","graph ii is obtained when restricting to the region @xmath202 . for a certain eigenvalue @xmath187 of the complete graph","whose representation contains the 2d irrep discussed before , we can define appropriate eigenfunctions on the two subgraphs by @xmath203 .","the boundary conditions of @xmath204 are obtained from ( [ eq : bndcnds1.1]),([eq : bndcnds1.2]),([eq : bndcnds2.1 ] ) , ( [ eq : bndcnds2.2 ] ) and are shown in figure [ fig : boundary conditions ] .","_ proof of theorem [ thm3 ] : _ we will make use of the results above in order to construct a transplantation which proves the theorem .","let @xmath208 .","denote by @xmath209 the space of eigenfunctions which belong to the eigenvalue @xmath187 .","@xmath210 define the functions @xmath211 on the complete graph by the following : @xmath212 where we have used again the coordinates @xmath213 as defined trivially by the axis @xmath214 ( scaling is obviously not important for our purposes ) .","it can be verified that @xmath191 , @xmath192 are valid eigenfunctions of the eigenvalue @xmath187 defined on the complete graph .","if @xmath215 for some @xmath216 then we get that @xmath217 ( this can simply be concluded by considering the boundary conditions ) . therefore @xmath211 are independent eigenfunctions and form a basis @xmath218 for the appropriate eigenspace .","this is exactly the basis @xmath219 of the first form of the 2d irrep of @xmath220 ( see [ eq : repform1 ] ) .","( this can be verified for example by examining the representation of the generators @xmath221 of @xmath220 ) .","now , we construct the basis @xmath222 by @xmath223 . and now define the function @xmath224 on graph ii by @xmath225 .","we get that @xmath224 is an eigenfunction of graph ii which belongs to the eigenvalue @xmath187 and obeys the appropriate boundary conditions @xmath226 . following this procedure",", one can verify that @xmath72 is the transplantation matrix of the vertex wave functions .","we can similarly describe the inverse transplantation .","the inverse transplantation is linear and therefore if we have an independent set of eigenfunctions ( with the same eigenvalue ) they would remain independent after the transplantation . thus , the degeneracies of @xmath187 in @xmath227 and @xmath228 are equal .","the existence of the inverse transplantation also proves that @xmath229 and the degeneracy is again the same .","therefore @xmath230 with account of multiplicities.@xmath231"],"string":"[\n \"m. kac s classical paper can one hear the shape of a drum \\\" @xcite , triggered intensive research in two complementary aspects of this problem . on the one hand ,\",\n \"a search for systems for which kac s question is answered in the affirmative was conducted , and , on the other hand , various examples of pairs of systems which are isospectral but not isometric were identified . in the present paper\",\n \"we shall focus our attention to quantum graphs and in the following lines will review the subject of isospectrality in this limited context .\",\n \"the interested reader is referred to [ 1 - 11 ] for a broader view of the field where spectral inversion and its uniqueness are discussed .\",\n \"spectral problems related to graphs emerge in two distinct ways . in the first , the spectrum of the connectivity ( adjacency ) matrix is considered .\",\n \"it represents a discrete version of the laplacian , and for finite graphs , the spectrum is finite .\",\n \"this set of problems is often referred to as combinatorial graphs .\",\n \"quantum ( metric ) graphs are obtained by associating the standard metric to the bonds which connect the vertices .\",\n \"the schrdinger operator consists of the one - dimensional laplacians on the bonds complemented by appropriate boundary conditions at the vertices ( see next section ) .\",\n \"the spectrum of quantum graphs is unbounded , and it displays many interesting features which made it a convenient paradigm in the study of quantum chaos @xcite . shortly after the appearance of kac s paper , m. e. fisher published his work on hearing the shape of a drum \\\" @xcite , where he addresses isospectrality for the discrete version of the laplacian .\",\n \"since then , the study of isospectral combinatorial graphs made very impressive progress .\",\n \"in particular , several methods to construct isospectral yet different graphs were proposed .\",\n \"a review of this problem can be found in @xcite . in particular , a method which was originally put forward by sunada @xcite to construct isospectral laplace - beltrami operators on riemann manifolds , was adapted for the corresponding problem in the context of combinatorial graphs . here\",\n \"we shall go one step further , and show that it can be also adapted for quantum graphs .\",\n \"the conditions under which the spectral inversion of quantum graphs is unique were studied previously . in @xcite\",\n \"it was shown that in general , the spectrum does not determine uniquely the length of the bonds and their connectivity .\",\n \"however , it was shown in @xcite that quantum graphs whose bond lengths are _ rationally independent _ can be heard \\\" - that is - their spectra determine uniquely their connectivity matrices and their bond lengths .\",\n \"this fact follows from the existence of an exact trace formula for quantum graphs @xcite .\",\n \"thus , isospectral pairs of non congruent graphs , must have rationally dependent bond lengths .\",\n \"the sunada method , which is based on constructing the isospectral domains by concatenating several copies of a given building block , automatically provides us with graphs with rationally dependent lengths .\",\n \"an example of a pair of metrically distinct graphs which share the same spectrum was already discussed in @xcite . in a previous report\",\n \"we have shown that all the known isospectral domains in @xmath0 @xcite have corresponding isospectral pairs of quantum graphs @xcite . here , we shall take the subject one step further , and propose that isospectral graphs can be resolved by counting their nodal domains .\",\n \"that is , the nodal counts of eigenfunctions belonging to the same spectral value are not the same .\",\n \"the idea that nodal counts resolve isospectrality was suggested in @xcite for a family of isospectral flat tori in 4-d , and was tested numerically . the present work offers both rigorous and numerical evidence to substantiate the validity of this conjecture in a few examples of isospectral graphs . for these examples\",\n \"the nodal counts differences ocur on a substantial fraction of the spectrum .\",\n \"the paper is organized in the following way .\",\n \"for the sake of completeness we shall give a short review of some elementary definitions and facts on quantum graphs .\",\n \"we shall then show how pairs of isospectral domains in @xmath0 can be reduced to isospectral pairs of quantum graphs , and discuss their spectra and eigenfunctions .\",\n \"finally , we shall study the nodal domains of these eigenfunctions and show that by counting nodal domains one can resolve the isospectral ambiguity of the graphs presented .\",\n \"we consider finite graphs consisting of @xmath1 _ vertices _ connected by @xmath2 _\",\n \"bonds_. the @xmath3 _ connectivity matrix _ will be denoted by @xmath4 : @xmath5 when the vertices @xmath6 and @xmath7 are connected by @xmath8 bonds , and it vanishes otherwise .\",\n \"the group of bonds which emerge from the vertex @xmath6 form a star \\\" which will be denoted by @xmath9 .\",\n \"@xmath10 of a vertex is defined as the cardinality of the star @xmath9 and @xmath11 .\",\n \"vertices with @xmath12 belong to the graph _\",\n \"boundary_. the vertices with @xmath13 belong to the graph _ interior_. the bonds are endowed with the standard metric , and the coordinates along the bonds @xmath14 are denoted by @xmath15 . the length of the bonds will be denoted by @xmath16 , and the total length of the graph is @xmath17 .\",\n \"the domain of the schrdinger operator on the graph is the space of functions which belong to sobolev space @xmath18 on each bond b and at the vertices they are continuous and obey boundary conditions as is mentioned in ( [ eq : bc ] ) .\",\n \"the operator is constructed in the following way .\",\n \"on the bonds , it is identified as the laplacian in 1-d @xmath19 .\",\n \"it is supplemented by boundary conditions on the vertices which ensure that the resulting operator is self adjoint .\",\n \"we shall consider in this paper the neumann and dirichlet boundary conditions : @xmath20 the derivatives in ( [ eq : bc ] ) are directed out of the vertex @xmath6 .\",\n \"_ comment _ : the neumann boundary conditions will be assumed throughout , unless otherwise stated .\",\n \"a wave function with a wave number @xmath21 can be written as @xmath22 where @xmath14 connects the vertices @xmath6 and @xmath7 , where the wave function @xmath23 takes the values @xmath24 and @xmath25 respectively .\",\n \"the form ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) ensures continuity .\",\n \"the spectrum @xmath26 and the corresponding eigenfunctions are determined by substituting ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) in ( [ eq : bc ] ) .\",\n \"the resulting homogeneous linear equations for the @xmath24 are written as @xmath27 and a non trivial solution exists when @xmath28 the spectrum @xmath29 , which is a discrete , positive and unbounded sequence is the zero set of the _ secular function _ @xmath30 .\",\n \"the secular functions of the type ( [ eq : secular ] ) have poles on the real @xmath21 axis , which renders them rather inconvenient for numerical studies .\",\n \"the secular function can be easily regularized in various ways , ( see e.g. , @xcite ) .\",\n \"it is easy to show that the complete wave function can be written down in terms of the vertex wave functions at the interior vertices with @xmath31 only . in the sequel\",\n \"we shall denote their number by @xmath32 .\",\n \"this reduces the dimension of the matrix @xmath33 above from @xmath1 to @xmath32 .\",\n \"the nodal domains of the eigenfunctions ( the connected domains where the wave function is of constant sign ) , are of two types .\",\n \"the ones that are confined to a single bond are rather trivial .\",\n \"their length is exactly half a wavelength and their number is on average @xmath34 .\",\n \"the nodal domains which extend over several bonds emanating from a single vertex vary in length and their existence is the reason why counting nodal domains on graphs is not a trivial task .\",\n \"the number of nodal domains in a general graph can be written as @xmath35\\\\mathrm{sign}[\\\\phi_j ] \\\\right ) \\\\right \\\\ } -b + v \\\\ .\",\n \"\\\\label{eq : nnb2}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath36 stands for the largest integer which is smaller than @xmath37 , and @xmath38 are the values of the eigenfunction at the vertices connected by the bond @xmath14 @xcite .\",\n \"( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) holds for the case of an eigenfunction which does not vanish on any vertex : @xmath39 .\",\n \"recently schapotschnikow @xcite proved that sturm s oscillation theorem extends to finite tree ( loop - less ) graphs :\",\n \"the number of nodal domains of the @xmath40th eigenfunction ( ordered by increasing eigenvalues ) is @xmath40 .\",\n \"berkolaiko @xcite have shown that the number of nodal domains is bounded to the interval @xmath41 $ ] where @xmath42 is the minimal number of bonds which should be cut so that the resulting graph is a tree .\",\n \"nodal domains can be also defined and counted in an alternative way which makes use of the vertex wave functions @xmath43 ( see ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) ) exclusively : _ a nodal domain consists of a maximal set of connected interior vertices ( @xmath31 ) _ _ where the vertex wave functions have the same sign .\",\n \"_ this definition has to be modified if any of the @xmath24 vanishes .\",\n \"then , the sign attributed to it is chosen to maximize the number of nodal domains @xcite .\",\n \"we thus have two independent ways to define and count nodal domains . to distinguish between them\",\n \"we shall refer to the first as _ metric _ nodal domains , and the number of metric domains in the @xmath40th eigenfunction will be denoted by @xmath44 .\",\n \"berkolaiko s theorem states that @xmath45 .\",\n \"the domains defined in terms of the vertex wave functions will be referred to as the _ discrete _ nodal domains .\",\n \"the number of discrete nodal domains of the @xmath40th vertex wave function will be denoted by @xmath46 .\",\n \"the sequences of metric and discrete nodal domains counts @xmath47 and @xmath48 are the main objects of study of the present paper .\",\n \"the first pair of isospectral planar domains which was introduced by gordon , web and wolpert @xcite is a member of a much larger set which was discussed in @xcite .\",\n \"this was extended in @xcite to include domains which differ in the distribution of boundary conditions ( dirichlet or neumann ) along their boundaries .\",\n \"the common feature of these sets of pairs of isospectral domains is that they are constructed using the sunada method @xcite , and they share a few important and distinctive attributes : * the domains are constructed by concatenating an elementary building block \\\" in two different prescribed ways to form the two domains .\",\n \"a building block is joined to another by reflecting along the common boundary .\",\n \"the shape of the building block is constrained only by symmetry requirements , but otherwise it is quite general . *\",\n \"the eigenfunctions corresponding to the same eigenvalue are related to each other by a _\",\n \"transplantation_. that is , the eigenfunction in a building block of one domain can be expressed as a linear combination of the eigenfunction in several building blocks in the other domain .\",\n \"the transplantation matrix is independent of the considered eigenvalue . * the construction of these pairs reflects an abstract algebraic structure which was identified by sunada @xcite .\",\n \"an example of an isospectral pair of domains in @xmath49 and its building block is given in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](a ) ) .\",\n \"this is a pair whose construction is described in @xcite .\",\n \"it is denoted there by @xmath50 .\",\n \"other examples are displayed in e.g. , @xcite .\",\n \"we can construct _ metric _ graphs which are analogous to these domains , by replacing the building blocks by appropriate graphs which preserve the requires symmetry .\",\n \"as an example , the triangular building block in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](a ) ) can be replaced by a 3 - star with bonds of lengths @xmath51 , @xmath14 and @xmath52 as shown in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](b ) ) .\",\n \"this yields the pair of isospectral but non isometric graphs shown in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](c ) ) .\",\n \"( in drawing figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](c ) ) we took advantage of the fact that the angles \\\" between the bonds are insignificant ) .\",\n \"note that the two graphs share the same connectivity matrix ( they are topologically congruent ) however they are not isometric . as a matter of fact the right and the left graphs are interchanged when the bonds @xmath14 \\\" with \",\n \"@xmath52 \\\" are switched .\",\n \"thus , the lengths @xmath14 and @xmath52 must be different to ensure that the two graphs are not isometric .\",\n \"this is an example of an asymmetry requirement which the building block must satisfy .\",\n \"all other pairs of isospectral domains proposed in @xcite can be converted to their analogous quantum graphs ( see @xcite for details ) .\",\n \"two examples are shown in figure ( [ fig:13 - 3and13 - 8 ] ) .\",\n \"the most simple pair of isospectral domains can be built by applying the sunada method to the dihedral group @xmath53 .\",\n \"the resulting graphs are shown in figure ( [ fig : isospectral pair+notations ] ) , where the letters @xmath54 or @xmath55 specify the boundary conditions at the boundary vertices .\",\n \"( the boundary conditions at the interior vertices are always neumann ) .\",\n \"note that the two graphs are connected differently , in contrast with the previous example where the topology of the two graphs is the same . in [ appendix1 ] we give a brief description of the construction of this pair , as an example of the sunada method . in a way of illustration\",\n \"we shall write explicitly the secular functions for the graphs shown above .\",\n \"starting with the @xmath50 pair , we have @xmath56 ( the interior vertices are marked by a black dot and are enumerated in figure 1(c ) ) . the secular function for the graph @xmath57\",\n \"is written in terms of the matrix @xmath58 here , @xmath59 and @xmath60 the corresponding vertex eigenfunction @xmath61 is the eigenvector of @xmath62 with a vanishing eigenvalue .\",\n \"the @xmath33 matrix for the graph @xmath63 is obtained from the matrix @xmath64 by interchanging @xmath52 and @xmath14 .\",\n \"explicit computation shows that @xmath65 .\",\n \"this proves the isospectrality of the two graphs .\",\n \"the sum of the elements of any of the columns of @xmath66 is @xmath67 .\",\n \"hence the vector @xmath68 is an eigenvector with an eigenvalue @xmath67 .\",\n \"the values of @xmath21 for which @xmath69 are in the spectrum of both graphs .\",\n \"they correspond to eigenfunctions which are the same on each of the 3-stars - the building block of the complete graphs ( figure 1(b ) ) . as a matter of fact\",\n \", the condition @xmath69 is the secular equation for this 3-star with bond lengths @xmath70 @xcite .\",\n \"this subset exhausts 1/7 of the spectrum of the graphs , and in this set the transplantation property is trivial .\",\n \"the transplantation property which is basic to the proof of isospectrality for the @xmath49 domains in @xcite can be explicitly formulated by the transplantation matrix @xmath71 we observe that the inverse transplantation is also effected by @xmath72 : @xmath73 even though @xmath72 is not self inversive .\",\n \"the fact that @xmath72 induces the transplantation in the two directions , implies that the vertex wave functions @xmath74 must be eigenvectors of @xmath75 ( as long as the eigenvalue is not degenerate ) .\",\n \"the wave functions are defined up to normalization , and therefore the corresponding eigenvalues can be different than unity .\",\n \"the spectrum of @xmath75 consists of the eigenvalue @xmath76 and the six - fold degenerate eigenvalue @xmath77 .\",\n \"thus , the vertex wave functions are either proportional to @xmath78 , or belong to the 6 dimensional subspace of vectors orthogonal to @xmath78 .\",\n \"this observation will be used in the next section when the nodal structure of the eigenfunctions is to be discussed .\",\n \"other examples of pairs of isospectral graphs such as e.g. , the pair described in @xcite can be obtained from the isospectral graphs constructed above , by setting the length of the @xmath52 bond to zero .\",\n \"this was explicitly shown in @xcite .\",\n \"using similar special cases one can generate a rich variety of isospectral but not isometric quantum graphs .\",\n \"finally , it should be emphasized , that the skeleton of interior vertices form graphs which are identical to the topological , colored graphs which were introduced in @xcite to express the transplantation properties of the isospectral domains in @xmath49 .\",\n \"the quantum , metric graphs can be obtained simply by completing each topological vertex to a 3-vertex star graph with lengths @xmath70 .\",\n \"topological bonds are associated with lengths according to their colors , and bonds are added to the topological vertices with valency less than three , to complete them to 3- stars .\",\n \"this proves the statement made above that the computation carried out here can be repeated for any of the topological graphs shown in @xcite .\",\n \"the graphs corresponding to the isospectral domains @xmath79 and @xmath80 are shown in figure [ fig:13 - 3and13 - 8 ] .\",\n \"+ i ii the dihedral graphs are much simpler , with @xmath81 .\",\n \"their secular determinants can be shown to be identical functions of @xmath21 .\",\n \"this is an explicit demonstration that the graphs are indeed isospectral .\",\n \"the secular equation is obtained from @xmath82 as can be easily seen , @xmath83 has poles , and to get a regular secular function we have to multiply it by @xmath84 .\",\n \"it takes the form @xmath85 the transplantation matrix for this pair of graphs is derived in [ appendix1 ] .\",\n \"it reads @xmath86 the eigenvectors @xmath87 point at the directions @xmath88 , with @xmath89 .\",\n \"the transplantation ( [ eq : transdi ] ) implies that @xmath90 is obtained from @xmath91 by a rotation of @xmath92 counterclockwise .\",\n \"direct substitutions shows that @xmath93 where , @xmath94 the explicit form of the functions @xmath95 and @xmath96 will be used in the discussion of nodal counting in the next section .\",\n \"the real eigenfunctions of laplace - beltrami operators on two dimensional manifolds display usually an intricate sets of nodal domains - which are the connected domains where the sign of the eigenfunction is constant @xcite .\",\n \"sturm s oscillation theorem for systems in 1-d , and its extension by courant to any dimension , establish the connection between the number of nodal domains and the spectrum : the number of nodal domains @xmath44 of the @xmath40th eigenfunction is bounded by @xmath40 .\",\n \"( the eigenfunctions are arranged by increasing value of their eigenvalues ) .\",\n \"theorem for combinatorial graphs and for quantum graphs were proved in @xcite , respectively . given a pair of isospectral domains .\",\n \"are the sequences of nodal counts @xmath97 identical ?\",\n \"in other words , can one use the information stored in the nodal sequences to resolve isospectrality ?\",\n \"this question was recently discussed in the context of isospectral flat tori in @xmath98 with @xmath99 @xcite , and numerical as well as analytical evidence was brought to substantiate the conjecture that the nodal sequences resolve isospectrality . in this section we shall provide rigorous as well as numerical evidence to show that the same is true for isospectral quantum graphs of the types discussed above .\",\n \"we shall start by discussing the _ discrete _ nodal sequences and then proceed to the _ metric _ nodal sequences .\",\n \"the _ discrete _ nodal domains were defined as the maximally connected sets of interior vertices with vertex wave functions of equal sign .\",\n \"their number is denoted by @xmath46 , and the nodal sequence is @xmath100 .\",\n \"we shall prove in the next subsection that for the dihedral graphs half of the entries in the sequences of discrete nodal counts are different .\",\n \"we are not able to provide a similar proof for the more complex graphs , but we shall bring numerical evidence which supports the conjecture that their sequences of discrete nodal counts are different\",\n \". the number of discrete nodal domains for this pair of dihedral graphs ( see figure [ fig : isospectral pair+notations ] ) can be either one or two , depending on whether the signs of the components of the ( two dimensional ) vertex eigenfunctions have the same sign or not .\",\n \"in other words ( see ( [ eq : tan ] ) ) , the number of nodal domains depend on the quadrant in the @xmath101 plane where the eigenvectors point : @xmath102 in the first and the third quadrants , and @xmath103 in the second and the fourth quadrants : @xmath104 the transplantation implies that the eigenvectors @xmath105 are obtained by rotating @xmath106 by @xmath92 counterclockwise\",\n \". therefore , @xmath107 if the transplantation rotates the vectors across the quadrant borders . in other words , @xmath108 this observation is essential to our discussion since it expresses the problem of nodal counting in geometrical terms .\",\n \"it is convenient to construct finite subsequences @xmath109 and @xmath110 of discrete nodal count of graphs i and ii , restricted to the spectral points in the interval @xmath111 .\",\n \"we denote the number of terms by @xmath112 .\",\n \"define @xmath113 we shall now prove [ thm1 ] consider the dihedral graphs i , ii discussed above with rationally independent bond lengths @xmath70 . then @xmath114 _ proof of theorem [ thm1 ] : _ the rational independence of @xmath70 implies that the eigenfunctions never vanish on the inner vertices and hence that the spectrum is simple . in order to study @xmath115 above\",\n \", we consider the distribution of the directions of the eigenfunctions @xmath116 in the spectral interval . using ( [ eq : secdireg],[eq : tan ] , [ eq : gfunction ] ) we get @xmath117 in taking the limit @xmath118 we use @xmath119 @xcite . moreover , since @xmath70 are assumed to be rationally independent , @xmath21 creates an ergodic flow on the 3-torus @xmath120 spanned by @xmath121 .\",\n \"ergodicity implies that the integral over @xmath21 in ( [ eq : ndist1 ] ) may be replaced by an integral over @xmath120 leading to @xmath122 \\\\label{eq : ndist2}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] now we note that under the transformation @xmath123 we have @xmath124 thus , we conclude that @xmath125 at this stage we are not able to prove the validity of the conjecture that the nodal sequences resolve the isospectrality of the graphs @xmath50 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 .\",\n \"however , numerical tests show that for an appreciable fraction of the wave functions , the nodal counts are distinct\",\n \". we shall start the discussion by considering the case @xmath50 , for which we can turn the counting problem into a geometrical problem .\",\n \"the vertex wave functions which correspond to the same eigenvalues are related by transplantation : @xmath126 where @xmath74 stand now for the vertex wave function restricted to the 7 interior vertices in these graphs .\",\n \"we have already shown that eigenvectors @xmath127 are either proportional to @xmath128 ( the vector with constant entries)- in which case both have a single nodal domain , and @xmath129 , or the @xmath127 are orthogonal to @xmath128 .\",\n \"the 6 eigenvectors of @xmath75 with eigenvalue @xmath77 span the orthogonal subspace : three of them correspond to the eigenvalue @xmath130 of @xmath72 , and the other three correspond to the eigenvalue @xmath131 of @xmath72 . any vertex wave function @xmath132 which is not proportional to @xmath128 , can be written as @xmath133 where @xmath134 stand for arbitrary normalized vectors in the three dimensional subspaces mention above , and @xmath135 $ ] .\",\n \"thus , latexmath:[\\\\[\\\\vec{\\\\phi}^{\\\\ ii } = t \\\\vec{\\\\phi}^{\\\\ i } = \\\\sqrt2 ( \\\\cos\\\\alpha \\\\ difference in nodal numbers comes only through the change of sign of the linear combination .\",\n \"we are not able to make further progress beyond this point , and we shall therefore summarize the numerical findings . _ the graph _ @xmath50 - based on the study of approximately 6600 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath137 only .\",\n \"the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 19 @xmath139 of the wave - functions . _ the graph _ @xmath79 - based on the study of approximately 2000 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath137 only .\",\n \"the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 22@xmath139 of the wave - functions . _\",\n \"the graph _ @xmath80 - based on the study of approximately 4700 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath140 only .\",\n \"the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 22 @xmath139 of the wave - functions .\",\n \"this result is certainly encouraging but not sufficient , and we are trying various options to substantiate it more rigourously . the discussion of the metric nodal sequences is facilitated in the present examples of isospectral graphs since most of them are trees .\",\n \"then , by making use of schapotschnikow s theorem @xcite , the _ metric _ nodal counts @xmath141 .\",\n \"this applies in particular to the isospectral graphs of the types @xmath50 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 which are tree graphs and @xmath142 .\",\n \"the metric counts do not resolve the isospectrality in these case .\",\n \"however , less trivially connected graphs can be constructed by replacing the basic building block . for such graphs schapotschnikow s theorem does not apply , and we expect their metric sequences to be different .\",\n \"below we shall show that this is true for the pair of dihedral graph where graph ii is not a tree .\",\n \"consider the pair of dihedral graphs , and let @xmath143 denote the metric nodal counts of graphs i and and ii . using ( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) we express the difference @xmath144 as @xmath145\\\\nonumber\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] to obtain ( [ eq : nd_diff ] ) a slight modification of ( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) was needed : the term in the sum that corresponds to a bond with boundary vertex that has dirichlet boundary conditions should be modified to be @xmath146 instead of @xmath147\\\\mathrm{sign}[\\\\phi_j ] \\\\right ) $ ] .\",\n \"in addition while deriving ( [ eq : nd_diff ] ) we made use of the identity @xmath148 and of the freedom to choose the sign of the first component of the wave - functions to be positive .\",\n \"a theorem by berkolaiko @xcite guarantees that @xmath149 can only take the values @xmath150 and @xmath151 .\",\n \"we would like to compute the distribution of these values on the spectrum .\",\n \"for this purpose we consider the spectral interval @xmath152 and study the function @xmath153 and prove the following theorem .\",\n \"[ theorem1]theorem [ thm2 ] consider the dihedral graphs i , ii discussed above with rationally independent bond lengths @xmath70 . then @xmath154 _ proof of theorem [ thm2 ] : _ in order to study the @xmath155 above we consider the distribution of @xmath149 , which is given by the integral @xmath156 where the spectral secular function @xmath95 is defined in ( [ eq : secdireg ] ) above , and @xmath157 coincides with @xmath149 for @xmath158 and can be written explicitly as @xmath159 \\\\ .\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] following the same route as in the proof of theorem ( [ thm1 ] ) we take the limit @xmath118 while making use of the ergodic theorem , and replace the @xmath21 integration by an integration over the 3 - torus with coordinates @xmath160 .\",\n \"@xmath161 the last line follows from the fact that @xmath37 is an integer which is written as half the sum of four unimodular numbers .\",\n \"next we note that under the transformation @xmath162 we have @xmath163 thus , we conclude that @xmath164 .\",\n \"but due to berkolaiko s theorem @xcite @xmath165 .\",\n \"therefore , @xmath166\",\n \"there is now a growing amount of evidence that nodal - count sequences store information on the geometry of the system under study , which is similar but not equivalent to the information stored in the spectral sequence . in a recent paper @xcite\",\n \"it was shown that the nodal count sequence for separable laplace - beltrami operators can be expressed in terms of a trace formula which consists of a smooth ( weyl - like ) part , and an oscillatory part .\",\n \"the smooth part depends on constants which can be derived from the geometry of the domain , and the oscillatory part depends on the classical periodic orbits , much in the same way as the spectral trace formula . however , what we have shown in the present paper is that the information stored in the two sequences is not identical : for the isospectral pairs of graphs considered here , the nodal - count sequences are different in a substantial way . in this respect ,\",\n \"the nodal sequence resolves isospectrality .\",\n \"till this work was done , the conjecture that isospectrality is resolved by counting nodal domains was substantiated by numerical studies only .\",\n \"here we presented for the first time a system where this fact is proved rigorously . the main breakthrough which enabled the proof was by formulating the counting problem in a geometrical setting .\",\n \"we hope that this way will pave the way to further analytical studies , where more complex systems will be dealt with .\",\n \"finally , we would like to mention a set of open problems which naturally arise in the present context : can one find metrically different domains where the laplacians have different spectra but the nodal counting sequences are the same ? a positive answer is provided for domains in @xmath151 dimension ( sturm ) or for tree graphs ( schapotschnikow ) .\",\n \"are there other less trivial examples ?\",\n \"it is a pleasure to acknowledge s gnutzmann , m solomyak and g berkolaiko for valuable discussions and comments .\",\n \"we are indebted to m sieber for discussions and for sharing with us his notes which formed the basis for the results discussed in [ appendix1 ] .\",\n \"the work was supported by the minerva center for non - linear physics and the einstein ( minerva ) center at the weizmann institute , and by grants from the gif ( grant i-808 - 228.14/2003 ) , and epsrc ( grant gr / t06872/01 . us\",\n \"thanks the school of mathematics in bristol for their hospitality and support .\",\n \"the dihedral group @xmath167 is the symmetry group of a square .\",\n \"let @xmath51 be the transformation of rotating the square @xmath168 counterclockwise and b be the transformation of reflecting it along the x axis .\",\n \"the dihedral group is generated by @xmath169 which obey @xmath170,@xmath171 .\",\n \"the 8 group elements of @xmath172 are @xmath173 .\",\n \"@xmath174 are reflections along the axis @xmath175 respectively ( figure [ fig : basic square ] ) .\",\n \"note that the multiplication should be read from right to left since the elements are transformations .\",\n \"this group has 5 irreducible representations ( irreps ) .\",\n \"four of them are one dimensional and one , which is of our interest , is two dimensional .\",\n \"the two dimensional representation is : denote the second basis by @xmath181 .\",\n \"so that @xmath182 . notice that in the first form of the representation @xmath183 and @xmath184 are diagonal and in the second one @xmath185 and @xmath186 are diagonal .\",\n \"this will be exploited soon .\",\n \"the graph in figure [ fig : complete graph](a ) obeys the dihedral symmetry .\",\n \"examine the eigenfunctions of the schrdinger operator with neumann boundary conditions on all the vertices .\",\n \"the set of all the eigenfuncions of a certain eigenvalue @xmath187 form a finite dimensional vector space @xmath1 with some dimension @xmath188 .\",\n \"this vector space is invariant under the action of the dihedral group and therefore @xmath1 is the carrier space of some representation of @xmath172 .\",\n \"we are interested in the case that this representation is the two dimensional irrep of @xmath189 or that this representation is a reducible representation that contains the two dimensional irrep .\",\n \"consider the basis @xmath177 of this 2d irrep ( note that now @xmath190 have the meaning of wave functions on the graph in figure [ fig : complete graph ] ) . from the matrix which corresponds to @xmath183 in this basis ( see ( [ eq : repform1 ] ) ) we deduce that @xmath191 vanish on the axis x ( as an odd function with respect to that axis ) and as for @xmath192 , its derivative vanishes on the x axis ( since @xmath193 is an even function with respect to that axis and therefore its derivative is odd ) .\",\n \"using the notation from figure [ fig : complete graph](b ) , we have : + similarly , examining the matrix of @xmath184 in this basis ( [ eq : repform1 ] ) yields @xmath195 + we can get similar observations by looking on the matrices of @xmath185 , @xmath186 , this time for the basis @xmath196 ( [ eq : repform2 ] ) .\",\n \"we get the following @xmath197 + now , a pair of isospectral graphs will be constructed out of the complete graph .\",\n \"each of the graphs in the pair will be a subgraph of the complete graph .\",\n \"graph i is the graph that consists of the vertices b , c , d , e , f and all the bonds which connect them .\",\n \"graph ii is the graph that consists of the vertices a , b , c , d and all the bonds which connect them ( figure [ fig : boundary conditions ] ) .\",\n \"we can define the subgraphs in another way which will become convenient later : using the axis @xmath198 as in figure [ fig : basic square ] we define two sets of coordinates @xmath199 and @xmath200 and use them to examine the complete graph .\",\n \"graph i is obtained when restricting ourselves to the region @xmath201 of the complete graph .\",\n \"graph ii is obtained when restricting to the region @xmath202 . for a certain eigenvalue @xmath187 of the complete graph\",\n \"whose representation contains the 2d irrep discussed before , we can define appropriate eigenfunctions on the two subgraphs by @xmath203 .\",\n \"the boundary conditions of @xmath204 are obtained from ( [ eq : bndcnds1.1]),([eq : bndcnds1.2]),([eq : bndcnds2.1 ] ) , ( [ eq : bndcnds2.2 ] ) and are shown in figure [ fig : boundary conditions ] .\",\n \"_ proof of theorem [ thm3 ] : _ we will make use of the results above in order to construct a transplantation which proves the theorem .\",\n \"let @xmath208 .\",\n \"denote by @xmath209 the space of eigenfunctions which belong to the eigenvalue @xmath187 .\",\n \"@xmath210 define the functions @xmath211 on the complete graph by the following : @xmath212 where we have used again the coordinates @xmath213 as defined trivially by the axis @xmath214 ( scaling is obviously not important for our purposes ) .\",\n \"it can be verified that @xmath191 , @xmath192 are valid eigenfunctions of the eigenvalue @xmath187 defined on the complete graph .\",\n \"if @xmath215 for some @xmath216 then we get that @xmath217 ( this can simply be concluded by considering the boundary conditions ) . therefore @xmath211 are independent eigenfunctions and form a basis @xmath218 for the appropriate eigenspace .\",\n \"this is exactly the basis @xmath219 of the first form of the 2d irrep of @xmath220 ( see [ eq : repform1 ] ) .\",\n \"( this can be verified for example by examining the representation of the generators @xmath221 of @xmath220 ) .\",\n \"now , we construct the basis @xmath222 by @xmath223 . and now define the function @xmath224 on graph ii by @xmath225 .\",\n \"we get that @xmath224 is an eigenfunction of graph ii which belongs to the eigenvalue @xmath187 and obeys the appropriate boundary conditions @xmath226 . following this procedure\",\n \", one can verify that @xmath72 is the transplantation matrix of the vertex wave functions .\",\n \"we can similarly describe the inverse transplantation .\",\n \"the inverse transplantation is linear and therefore if we have an independent set of eigenfunctions ( with the same eigenvalue ) they would remain independent after the transplantation . thus , the degeneracies of @xmath187 in @xmath227 and @xmath228 are equal .\",\n \"the existence of the inverse transplantation also proves that @xmath229 and the degeneracy is again the same .\",\n \"therefore @xmath230 with account of multiplicities.@xmath231\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> we present and discuss isospectral quantum graphs which are not isometric . </S>","<S> these graphs are the analogues of the isospectral domains in @xmath0 which were introduced recently in [ 1 - 5 ] all based on sunada s construction of isospectral domains @xcite . after presenting some of the properties of these graphs , we discuss a few examples which support the conjecture that by counting the nodal domains of the corresponding eigenfunctions one can resolve the isospectral ambiguity . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> we present and discuss isospectral quantum graphs which are not isometric . </S>\",\n \"<S> these graphs are the analogues of the isospectral domains in @xmath0 which were introduced recently in [ 1 - 5 ] all based on sunada s construction of isospectral domains @xcite . after presenting some of the properties of these graphs , we discuss a few examples which support the conjecture that by counting the nodal domains of the corresponding eigenfunctions one can resolve the isospectral ambiguity . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","isospectral quantum graphs","nodal counts and the resolution of isospectrality","discussion and summary","acknowledgments","construction of the isospectral dihedral graphs"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"isospectral quantum graphs\",\n \"nodal counts and the resolution of isospectrality\",\n \"discussion and summary\",\n \"acknowledgments\",\n \"construction of the isospectral dihedral graphs\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["m. kac s classical paper can one hear the shape of a drum \" @xcite , triggered intensive research in two complementary aspects of this problem . on the one hand ,","a search for systems for which kac s question is answered in the affirmative was conducted , and , on the other hand , various examples of pairs of systems which are isospectral but not isometric were identified . in the present paper","we shall focus our attention to quantum graphs and in the following lines will review the subject of isospectrality in this limited context .","the interested reader is referred to [ 1 - 11 ] for a broader view of the field where spectral inversion and its uniqueness are discussed .","spectral problems related to graphs emerge in two distinct ways . in the first , the spectrum of the connectivity ( adjacency ) matrix is considered .","it represents a discrete version of the laplacian , and for finite graphs , the spectrum is finite .","this set of problems is often referred to as combinatorial graphs .","quantum ( metric ) graphs are obtained by associating the standard metric to the bonds which connect the vertices .","the schrdinger operator consists of the one - dimensional laplacians on the bonds complemented by appropriate boundary conditions at the vertices ( see next section ) .","the spectrum of quantum graphs is unbounded , and it displays many interesting features which made it a convenient paradigm in the study of quantum chaos @xcite . shortly after the appearance of kac s paper , m. e. fisher published his work on hearing the shape of a drum \" @xcite , where he addresses isospectrality for the discrete version of the laplacian .","since then , the study of isospectral combinatorial graphs made very impressive progress .","in particular , several methods to construct isospectral yet different graphs were proposed .","a review of this problem can be found in @xcite . in particular , a method which was originally put forward by sunada @xcite to construct isospectral laplace - beltrami operators on riemann manifolds , was adapted for the corresponding problem in the context of combinatorial graphs . here","we shall go one step further , and show that it can be also adapted for quantum graphs .","the conditions under which the spectral inversion of quantum graphs is unique were studied previously . in @xcite","it was shown that in general , the spectrum does not determine uniquely the length of the bonds and their connectivity .","however , it was shown in @xcite that quantum graphs whose bond lengths are _ rationally independent _ can be heard \" - that is - their spectra determine uniquely their connectivity matrices and their bond lengths .","this fact follows from the existence of an exact trace formula for quantum graphs @xcite .","thus , isospectral pairs of non congruent graphs , must have rationally dependent bond lengths .","the sunada method , which is based on constructing the isospectral domains by concatenating several copies of a given building block , automatically provides us with graphs with rationally dependent lengths .","an example of a pair of metrically distinct graphs which share the same spectrum was already discussed in @xcite . in a previous report","we have shown that all the known isospectral domains in @xmath0 @xcite have corresponding isospectral pairs of quantum graphs @xcite . here , we shall take the subject one step further , and propose that isospectral graphs can be resolved by counting their nodal domains .","that is , the nodal counts of eigenfunctions belonging to the same spectral value are not the same .","the idea that nodal counts resolve isospectrality was suggested in @xcite for a family of isospectral flat tori in 4-d , and was tested numerically . the present work offers both rigorous and numerical evidence to substantiate the validity of this conjecture in a few examples of isospectral graphs . for these examples","the nodal counts differences ocur on a substantial fraction of the spectrum .","the paper is organized in the following way .","for the sake of completeness we shall give a short review of some elementary definitions and facts on quantum graphs .","we shall then show how pairs of isospectral domains in @xmath0 can be reduced to isospectral pairs of quantum graphs , and discuss their spectra and eigenfunctions .","finally , we shall study the nodal domains of these eigenfunctions and show that by counting nodal domains one can resolve the isospectral ambiguity of the graphs presented .","we consider finite graphs consisting of @xmath1 _ vertices _ connected by @xmath2 _","bonds_. the @xmath3 _ connectivity matrix _ will be denoted by @xmath4 : @xmath5 when the vertices @xmath6 and @xmath7 are connected by @xmath8 bonds , and it vanishes otherwise .","the group of bonds which emerge from the vertex @xmath6 form a star \" which will be denoted by @xmath9 .","@xmath10 of a vertex is defined as the cardinality of the star @xmath9 and @xmath11 .","vertices with @xmath12 belong to the graph _","boundary_. the vertices with @xmath13 belong to the graph _ interior_. the bonds are endowed with the standard metric , and the coordinates along the bonds @xmath14 are denoted by @xmath15 . the length of the bonds will be denoted by @xmath16 , and the total length of the graph is @xmath17 .","the domain of the schrdinger operator on the graph is the space of functions which belong to sobolev space @xmath18 on each bond b and at the vertices they are continuous and obey boundary conditions as is mentioned in ( [ eq : bc ] ) .","the operator is constructed in the following way .","on the bonds , it is identified as the laplacian in 1-d @xmath19 .","it is supplemented by boundary conditions on the vertices which ensure that the resulting operator is self adjoint .","we shall consider in this paper the neumann and dirichlet boundary conditions : @xmath20 the derivatives in ( [ eq : bc ] ) are directed out of the vertex @xmath6 .","_ comment _ : the neumann boundary conditions will be assumed throughout , unless otherwise stated .","a wave function with a wave number @xmath21 can be written as @xmath22 where @xmath14 connects the vertices @xmath6 and @xmath7 , where the wave function @xmath23 takes the values @xmath24 and @xmath25 respectively .","the form ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) ensures continuity .","the spectrum @xmath26 and the corresponding eigenfunctions are determined by substituting ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) in ( [ eq : bc ] ) .","the resulting homogeneous linear equations for the @xmath24 are written as @xmath27 and a non trivial solution exists when @xmath28 the spectrum @xmath29 , which is a discrete , positive and unbounded sequence is the zero set of the _ secular function _ @xmath30 .","the secular functions of the type ( [ eq : secular ] ) have poles on the real @xmath21 axis , which renders them rather inconvenient for numerical studies .","the secular function can be easily regularized in various ways , ( see e.g. , @xcite ) .","it is easy to show that the complete wave function can be written down in terms of the vertex wave functions at the interior vertices with @xmath31 only . in the sequel","we shall denote their number by @xmath32 .","this reduces the dimension of the matrix @xmath33 above from @xmath1 to @xmath32 .","the nodal domains of the eigenfunctions ( the connected domains where the wave function is of constant sign ) , are of two types .","the ones that are confined to a single bond are rather trivial .","their length is exactly half a wavelength and their number is on average @xmath34 .","the nodal domains which extend over several bonds emanating from a single vertex vary in length and their existence is the reason why counting nodal domains on graphs is not a trivial task .","the number of nodal domains in a general graph can be written as @xmath35\\mathrm{sign}[\\phi_j ] \\right ) \\right \\ } -b + v \\ .","\\label{eq : nnb2}\\ ] ] where @xmath36 stands for the largest integer which is smaller than @xmath37 , and @xmath38 are the values of the eigenfunction at the vertices connected by the bond @xmath14 @xcite .","( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) holds for the case of an eigenfunction which does not vanish on any vertex : @xmath39 .","recently schapotschnikow @xcite proved that sturm s oscillation theorem extends to finite tree ( loop - less ) graphs :","the number of nodal domains of the @xmath40th eigenfunction ( ordered by increasing eigenvalues ) is @xmath40 .","berkolaiko @xcite have shown that the number of nodal domains is bounded to the interval @xmath41 $ ] where @xmath42 is the minimal number of bonds which should be cut so that the resulting graph is a tree .","nodal domains can be also defined and counted in an alternative way which makes use of the vertex wave functions @xmath43 ( see ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) ) exclusively : _ a nodal domain consists of a maximal set of connected interior vertices ( @xmath31 ) _ _ where the vertex wave functions have the same sign .","_ this definition has to be modified if any of the @xmath24 vanishes .","then , the sign attributed to it is chosen to maximize the number of nodal domains @xcite .","we thus have two independent ways to define and count nodal domains . to distinguish between them","we shall refer to the first as _ metric _ nodal domains , and the number of metric domains in the @xmath40th eigenfunction will be denoted by @xmath44 .","berkolaiko s theorem states that @xmath45 .","the domains defined in terms of the vertex wave functions will be referred to as the _ discrete _ nodal domains .","the number of discrete nodal domains of the @xmath40th vertex wave function will be denoted by @xmath46 .","the sequences of metric and discrete nodal domains counts @xmath47 and @xmath48 are the main objects of study of the present paper ."],["the first pair of isospectral planar domains which was introduced by gordon , web and wolpert @xcite is a member of a much larger set which was discussed in @xcite .","this was extended in @xcite to include domains which differ in the distribution of boundary conditions ( dirichlet or neumann ) along their boundaries .","the common feature of these sets of pairs of isospectral domains is that they are constructed using the sunada method @xcite , and they share a few important and distinctive attributes : * the domains are constructed by concatenating an elementary building block \" in two different prescribed ways to form the two domains .","a building block is joined to another by reflecting along the common boundary .","the shape of the building block is constrained only by symmetry requirements , but otherwise it is quite general . *","the eigenfunctions corresponding to the same eigenvalue are related to each other by a _","transplantation_. that is , the eigenfunction in a building block of one domain can be expressed as a linear combination of the eigenfunction in several building blocks in the other domain .","the transplantation matrix is independent of the considered eigenvalue . * the construction of these pairs reflects an abstract algebraic structure which was identified by sunada @xcite .","an example of an isospectral pair of domains in @xmath49 and its building block is given in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](a ) ) .","this is a pair whose construction is described in @xcite .","it is denoted there by @xmath50 .","other examples are displayed in e.g. , @xcite .","we can construct _ metric _ graphs which are analogous to these domains , by replacing the building blocks by appropriate graphs which preserve the requires symmetry .","as an example , the triangular building block in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](a ) ) can be replaced by a 3 - star with bonds of lengths @xmath51 , @xmath14 and @xmath52 as shown in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](b ) ) .","this yields the pair of isospectral but non isometric graphs shown in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](c ) ) .","( in drawing figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](c ) ) we took advantage of the fact that the angles \" between the bonds are insignificant ) .","note that the two graphs share the same connectivity matrix ( they are topologically congruent ) however they are not isometric . as a matter of fact the right and the left graphs are interchanged when the bonds @xmath14 \" with ","@xmath52 \" are switched .","thus , the lengths @xmath14 and @xmath52 must be different to ensure that the two graphs are not isometric .","this is an example of an asymmetry requirement which the building block must satisfy .","all other pairs of isospectral domains proposed in @xcite can be converted to their analogous quantum graphs ( see @xcite for details ) .","two examples are shown in figure ( [ fig:13 - 3and13 - 8 ] ) .","the most simple pair of isospectral domains can be built by applying the sunada method to the dihedral group @xmath53 .","the resulting graphs are shown in figure ( [ fig : isospectral pair+notations ] ) , where the letters @xmath54 or @xmath55 specify the boundary conditions at the boundary vertices .","( the boundary conditions at the interior vertices are always neumann ) .","note that the two graphs are connected differently , in contrast with the previous example where the topology of the two graphs is the same . in [ appendix1 ] we give a brief description of the construction of this pair , as an example of the sunada method . in a way of illustration","we shall write explicitly the secular functions for the graphs shown above .","starting with the @xmath50 pair , we have @xmath56 ( the interior vertices are marked by a black dot and are enumerated in figure 1(c ) ) . the secular function for the graph @xmath57","is written in terms of the matrix @xmath58 here , @xmath59 and @xmath60 the corresponding vertex eigenfunction @xmath61 is the eigenvector of @xmath62 with a vanishing eigenvalue .","the @xmath33 matrix for the graph @xmath63 is obtained from the matrix @xmath64 by interchanging @xmath52 and @xmath14 .","explicit computation shows that @xmath65 .","this proves the isospectrality of the two graphs .","the sum of the elements of any of the columns of @xmath66 is @xmath67 .","hence the vector @xmath68 is an eigenvector with an eigenvalue @xmath67 .","the values of @xmath21 for which @xmath69 are in the spectrum of both graphs .","they correspond to eigenfunctions which are the same on each of the 3-stars - the building block of the complete graphs ( figure 1(b ) ) . as a matter of fact",", the condition @xmath69 is the secular equation for this 3-star with bond lengths @xmath70 @xcite .","this subset exhausts 1/7 of the spectrum of the graphs , and in this set the transplantation property is trivial .","the transplantation property which is basic to the proof of isospectrality for the @xmath49 domains in @xcite can be explicitly formulated by the transplantation matrix @xmath71 we observe that the inverse transplantation is also effected by @xmath72 : @xmath73 even though @xmath72 is not self inversive .","the fact that @xmath72 induces the transplantation in the two directions , implies that the vertex wave functions @xmath74 must be eigenvectors of @xmath75 ( as long as the eigenvalue is not degenerate ) .","the wave functions are defined up to normalization , and therefore the corresponding eigenvalues can be different than unity .","the spectrum of @xmath75 consists of the eigenvalue @xmath76 and the six - fold degenerate eigenvalue @xmath77 .","thus , the vertex wave functions are either proportional to @xmath78 , or belong to the 6 dimensional subspace of vectors orthogonal to @xmath78 .","this observation will be used in the next section when the nodal structure of the eigenfunctions is to be discussed .","other examples of pairs of isospectral graphs such as e.g. , the pair described in @xcite can be obtained from the isospectral graphs constructed above , by setting the length of the @xmath52 bond to zero .","this was explicitly shown in @xcite .","using similar special cases one can generate a rich variety of isospectral but not isometric quantum graphs .","finally , it should be emphasized , that the skeleton of interior vertices form graphs which are identical to the topological , colored graphs which were introduced in @xcite to express the transplantation properties of the isospectral domains in @xmath49 .","the quantum , metric graphs can be obtained simply by completing each topological vertex to a 3-vertex star graph with lengths @xmath70 .","topological bonds are associated with lengths according to their colors , and bonds are added to the topological vertices with valency less than three , to complete them to 3- stars .","this proves the statement made above that the computation carried out here can be repeated for any of the topological graphs shown in @xcite .","the graphs corresponding to the isospectral domains @xmath79 and @xmath80 are shown in figure [ fig:13 - 3and13 - 8 ] .","+ i ii the dihedral graphs are much simpler , with @xmath81 .","their secular determinants can be shown to be identical functions of @xmath21 .","this is an explicit demonstration that the graphs are indeed isospectral .","the secular equation is obtained from @xmath82 as can be easily seen , @xmath83 has poles , and to get a regular secular function we have to multiply it by @xmath84 .","it takes the form @xmath85 the transplantation matrix for this pair of graphs is derived in [ appendix1 ] .","it reads @xmath86 the eigenvectors @xmath87 point at the directions @xmath88 , with @xmath89 .","the transplantation ( [ eq : transdi ] ) implies that @xmath90 is obtained from @xmath91 by a rotation of @xmath92 counterclockwise .","direct substitutions shows that @xmath93 where , @xmath94 the explicit form of the functions @xmath95 and @xmath96 will be used in the discussion of nodal counting in the next section ."],["the real eigenfunctions of laplace - beltrami operators on two dimensional manifolds display usually an intricate sets of nodal domains - which are the connected domains where the sign of the eigenfunction is constant @xcite .","sturm s oscillation theorem for systems in 1-d , and its extension by courant to any dimension , establish the connection between the number of nodal domains and the spectrum : the number of nodal domains @xmath44 of the @xmath40th eigenfunction is bounded by @xmath40 .","( the eigenfunctions are arranged by increasing value of their eigenvalues ) .","theorem for combinatorial graphs and for quantum graphs were proved in @xcite , respectively . given a pair of isospectral domains .","are the sequences of nodal counts @xmath97 identical ?","in other words , can one use the information stored in the nodal sequences to resolve isospectrality ?","this question was recently discussed in the context of isospectral flat tori in @xmath98 with @xmath99 @xcite , and numerical as well as analytical evidence was brought to substantiate the conjecture that the nodal sequences resolve isospectrality . in this section we shall provide rigorous as well as numerical evidence to show that the same is true for isospectral quantum graphs of the types discussed above .","we shall start by discussing the _ discrete _ nodal sequences and then proceed to the _ metric _ nodal sequences .","the _ discrete _ nodal domains were defined as the maximally connected sets of interior vertices with vertex wave functions of equal sign .","their number is denoted by @xmath46 , and the nodal sequence is @xmath100 .","we shall prove in the next subsection that for the dihedral graphs half of the entries in the sequences of discrete nodal counts are different .","we are not able to provide a similar proof for the more complex graphs , but we shall bring numerical evidence which supports the conjecture that their sequences of discrete nodal counts are different",". the number of discrete nodal domains for this pair of dihedral graphs ( see figure [ fig : isospectral pair+notations ] ) can be either one or two , depending on whether the signs of the components of the ( two dimensional ) vertex eigenfunctions have the same sign or not .","in other words ( see ( [ eq : tan ] ) ) , the number of nodal domains depend on the quadrant in the @xmath101 plane where the eigenvectors point : @xmath102 in the first and the third quadrants , and @xmath103 in the second and the fourth quadrants : @xmath104 the transplantation implies that the eigenvectors @xmath105 are obtained by rotating @xmath106 by @xmath92 counterclockwise",". therefore , @xmath107 if the transplantation rotates the vectors across the quadrant borders . in other words , @xmath108 this observation is essential to our discussion since it expresses the problem of nodal counting in geometrical terms .","it is convenient to construct finite subsequences @xmath109 and @xmath110 of discrete nodal count of graphs i and ii , restricted to the spectral points in the interval @xmath111 .","we denote the number of terms by @xmath112 .","define @xmath113 we shall now prove [ thm1 ] consider the dihedral graphs i , ii discussed above with rationally independent bond lengths @xmath70 . then @xmath114 _ proof of theorem [ thm1 ] : _ the rational independence of @xmath70 implies that the eigenfunctions never vanish on the inner vertices and hence that the spectrum is simple . in order to study @xmath115 above",", we consider the distribution of the directions of the eigenfunctions @xmath116 in the spectral interval . using ( [ eq : secdireg],[eq : tan ] , [ eq : gfunction ] ) we get @xmath117 in taking the limit @xmath118 we use @xmath119 @xcite . moreover , since @xmath70 are assumed to be rationally independent , @xmath21 creates an ergodic flow on the 3-torus @xmath120 spanned by @xmath121 .","ergodicity implies that the integral over @xmath21 in ( [ eq : ndist1 ] ) may be replaced by an integral over @xmath120 leading to @xmath122 \\label{eq : ndist2}\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] now we note that under the transformation @xmath123 we have @xmath124 thus , we conclude that @xmath125 at this stage we are not able to prove the validity of the conjecture that the nodal sequences resolve the isospectrality of the graphs @xmath50 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 .","however , numerical tests show that for an appreciable fraction of the wave functions , the nodal counts are distinct",". we shall start the discussion by considering the case @xmath50 , for which we can turn the counting problem into a geometrical problem .","the vertex wave functions which correspond to the same eigenvalues are related by transplantation : @xmath126 where @xmath74 stand now for the vertex wave function restricted to the 7 interior vertices in these graphs .","we have already shown that eigenvectors @xmath127 are either proportional to @xmath128 ( the vector with constant entries)- in which case both have a single nodal domain , and @xmath129 , or the @xmath127 are orthogonal to @xmath128 .","the 6 eigenvectors of @xmath75 with eigenvalue @xmath77 span the orthogonal subspace : three of them correspond to the eigenvalue @xmath130 of @xmath72 , and the other three correspond to the eigenvalue @xmath131 of @xmath72 . any vertex wave function @xmath132 which is not proportional to @xmath128 , can be written as @xmath133 where @xmath134 stand for arbitrary normalized vectors in the three dimensional subspaces mention above , and @xmath135 $ ] .","thus , latexmath:[\\[\\vec{\\phi}^{\\ ii } = t \\vec{\\phi}^{\\ i } = \\sqrt2 ( \\cos\\alpha \\ difference in nodal numbers comes only through the change of sign of the linear combination .","we are not able to make further progress beyond this point , and we shall therefore summarize the numerical findings . _ the graph _ @xmath50 - based on the study of approximately 6600 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath137 only .","the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 19 @xmath139 of the wave - functions . _ the graph _ @xmath79 - based on the study of approximately 2000 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath137 only .","the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 22@xmath139 of the wave - functions . _","the graph _ @xmath80 - based on the study of approximately 4700 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath140 only .","the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 22 @xmath139 of the wave - functions .","this result is certainly encouraging but not sufficient , and we are trying various options to substantiate it more rigourously . the discussion of the metric nodal sequences is facilitated in the present examples of isospectral graphs since most of them are trees .","then , by making use of schapotschnikow s theorem @xcite , the _ metric _ nodal counts @xmath141 .","this applies in particular to the isospectral graphs of the types @xmath50 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 which are tree graphs and @xmath142 .","the metric counts do not resolve the isospectrality in these case .","however , less trivially connected graphs can be constructed by replacing the basic building block . for such graphs schapotschnikow s theorem does not apply , and we expect their metric sequences to be different .","below we shall show that this is true for the pair of dihedral graph where graph ii is not a tree .","consider the pair of dihedral graphs , and let @xmath143 denote the metric nodal counts of graphs i and and ii . using ( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) we express the difference @xmath144 as @xmath145\\nonumber\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] to obtain ( [ eq : nd_diff ] ) a slight modification of ( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) was needed : the term in the sum that corresponds to a bond with boundary vertex that has dirichlet boundary conditions should be modified to be @xmath146 instead of @xmath147\\mathrm{sign}[\\phi_j ] \\right ) $ ] .","in addition while deriving ( [ eq : nd_diff ] ) we made use of the identity @xmath148 and of the freedom to choose the sign of the first component of the wave - functions to be positive .","a theorem by berkolaiko @xcite guarantees that @xmath149 can only take the values @xmath150 and @xmath151 .","we would like to compute the distribution of these values on the spectrum .","for this purpose we consider the spectral interval @xmath152 and study the function @xmath153 and prove the following theorem .","[ theorem1]theorem [ thm2 ] consider the dihedral graphs i , ii discussed above with rationally independent bond lengths @xmath70 . then @xmath154 _ proof of theorem [ thm2 ] : _ in order to study the @xmath155 above we consider the distribution of @xmath149 , which is given by the integral @xmath156 where the spectral secular function @xmath95 is defined in ( [ eq : secdireg ] ) above , and @xmath157 coincides with @xmath149 for @xmath158 and can be written explicitly as @xmath159 \\ .\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] following the same route as in the proof of theorem ( [ thm1 ] ) we take the limit @xmath118 while making use of the ergodic theorem , and replace the @xmath21 integration by an integration over the 3 - torus with coordinates @xmath160 .","@xmath161 the last line follows from the fact that @xmath37 is an integer which is written as half the sum of four unimodular numbers .","next we note that under the transformation @xmath162 we have @xmath163 thus , we conclude that @xmath164 .","but due to berkolaiko s theorem @xcite @xmath165 .","therefore , @xmath166"],["there is now a growing amount of evidence that nodal - count sequences store information on the geometry of the system under study , which is similar but not equivalent to the information stored in the spectral sequence . in a recent paper @xcite","it was shown that the nodal count sequence for separable laplace - beltrami operators can be expressed in terms of a trace formula which consists of a smooth ( weyl - like ) part , and an oscillatory part .","the smooth part depends on constants which can be derived from the geometry of the domain , and the oscillatory part depends on the classical periodic orbits , much in the same way as the spectral trace formula . however , what we have shown in the present paper is that the information stored in the two sequences is not identical : for the isospectral pairs of graphs considered here , the nodal - count sequences are different in a substantial way . in this respect ,","the nodal sequence resolves isospectrality .","till this work was done , the conjecture that isospectrality is resolved by counting nodal domains was substantiated by numerical studies only .","here we presented for the first time a system where this fact is proved rigorously . the main breakthrough which enabled the proof was by formulating the counting problem in a geometrical setting .","we hope that this way will pave the way to further analytical studies , where more complex systems will be dealt with .","finally , we would like to mention a set of open problems which naturally arise in the present context : can one find metrically different domains where the laplacians have different spectra but the nodal counting sequences are the same ? a positive answer is provided for domains in @xmath151 dimension ( sturm ) or for tree graphs ( schapotschnikow ) .","are there other less trivial examples ?"],["it is a pleasure to acknowledge s gnutzmann , m solomyak and g berkolaiko for valuable discussions and comments .","we are indebted to m sieber for discussions and for sharing with us his notes which formed the basis for the results discussed in [ appendix1 ] .","the work was supported by the minerva center for non - linear physics and the einstein ( minerva ) center at the weizmann institute , and by grants from the gif ( grant i-808 - 228.14/2003 ) , and epsrc ( grant gr / t06872/01 . us","thanks the school of mathematics in bristol for their hospitality and support ."],["the dihedral group @xmath167 is the symmetry group of a square .","let @xmath51 be the transformation of rotating the square @xmath168 counterclockwise and b be the transformation of reflecting it along the x axis .","the dihedral group is generated by @xmath169 which obey @xmath170,@xmath171 .","the 8 group elements of @xmath172 are @xmath173 .","@xmath174 are reflections along the axis @xmath175 respectively ( figure [ fig : basic square ] ) .","note that the multiplication should be read from right to left since the elements are transformations .","this group has 5 irreducible representations ( irreps ) .","four of them are one dimensional and one , which is of our interest , is two dimensional .","the two dimensional representation is : denote the second basis by @xmath181 .","so that @xmath182 . notice that in the first form of the representation @xmath183 and @xmath184 are diagonal and in the second one @xmath185 and @xmath186 are diagonal .","this will be exploited soon .","the graph in figure [ fig : complete graph](a ) obeys the dihedral symmetry .","examine the eigenfunctions of the schrdinger operator with neumann boundary conditions on all the vertices .","the set of all the eigenfuncions of a certain eigenvalue @xmath187 form a finite dimensional vector space @xmath1 with some dimension @xmath188 .","this vector space is invariant under the action of the dihedral group and therefore @xmath1 is the carrier space of some representation of @xmath172 .","we are interested in the case that this representation is the two dimensional irrep of @xmath189 or that this representation is a reducible representation that contains the two dimensional irrep .","consider the basis @xmath177 of this 2d irrep ( note that now @xmath190 have the meaning of wave functions on the graph in figure [ fig : complete graph ] ) . from the matrix which corresponds to @xmath183 in this basis ( see ( [ eq : repform1 ] ) ) we deduce that @xmath191 vanish on the axis x ( as an odd function with respect to that axis ) and as for @xmath192 , its derivative vanishes on the x axis ( since @xmath193 is an even function with respect to that axis and therefore its derivative is odd ) .","using the notation from figure [ fig : complete graph](b ) , we have : + similarly , examining the matrix of @xmath184 in this basis ( [ eq : repform1 ] ) yields @xmath195 + we can get similar observations by looking on the matrices of @xmath185 , @xmath186 , this time for the basis @xmath196 ( [ eq : repform2 ] ) .","we get the following @xmath197 + now , a pair of isospectral graphs will be constructed out of the complete graph .","each of the graphs in the pair will be a subgraph of the complete graph .","graph i is the graph that consists of the vertices b , c , d , e , f and all the bonds which connect them .","graph ii is the graph that consists of the vertices a , b , c , d and all the bonds which connect them ( figure [ fig : boundary conditions ] ) .","we can define the subgraphs in another way which will become convenient later : using the axis @xmath198 as in figure [ fig : basic square ] we define two sets of coordinates @xmath199 and @xmath200 and use them to examine the complete graph .","graph i is obtained when restricting ourselves to the region @xmath201 of the complete graph .","graph ii is obtained when restricting to the region @xmath202 . for a certain eigenvalue @xmath187 of the complete graph","whose representation contains the 2d irrep discussed before , we can define appropriate eigenfunctions on the two subgraphs by @xmath203 .","the boundary conditions of @xmath204 are obtained from ( [ eq : bndcnds1.1]),([eq : bndcnds1.2]),([eq : bndcnds2.1 ] ) , ( [ eq : bndcnds2.2 ] ) and are shown in figure [ fig : boundary conditions ] .","_ proof of theorem [ thm3 ] : _ we will make use of the results above in order to construct a transplantation which proves the theorem .","let @xmath208 .","denote by @xmath209 the space of eigenfunctions which belong to the eigenvalue @xmath187 .","@xmath210 define the functions @xmath211 on the complete graph by the following : @xmath212 where we have used again the coordinates @xmath213 as defined trivially by the axis @xmath214 ( scaling is obviously not important for our purposes ) .","it can be verified that @xmath191 , @xmath192 are valid eigenfunctions of the eigenvalue @xmath187 defined on the complete graph .","if @xmath215 for some @xmath216 then we get that @xmath217 ( this can simply be concluded by considering the boundary conditions ) . therefore @xmath211 are independent eigenfunctions and form a basis @xmath218 for the appropriate eigenspace .","this is exactly the basis @xmath219 of the first form of the 2d irrep of @xmath220 ( see [ eq : repform1 ] ) .","( this can be verified for example by examining the representation of the generators @xmath221 of @xmath220 ) .","now , we construct the basis @xmath222 by @xmath223 . and now define the function @xmath224 on graph ii by @xmath225 .","we get that @xmath224 is an eigenfunction of graph ii which belongs to the eigenvalue @xmath187 and obeys the appropriate boundary conditions @xmath226 . following this procedure",", one can verify that @xmath72 is the transplantation matrix of the vertex wave functions .","we can similarly describe the inverse transplantation .","the inverse transplantation is linear and therefore if we have an independent set of eigenfunctions ( with the same eigenvalue ) they would remain independent after the transplantation . thus , the degeneracies of @xmath187 in @xmath227 and @xmath228 are equal .","the existence of the inverse transplantation also proves that @xmath229 and the degeneracy is again the same .","therefore @xmath230 with account of multiplicities.@xmath231"]],"string":"[\n [\n \"m. kac s classical paper can one hear the shape of a drum \\\" @xcite , triggered intensive research in two complementary aspects of this problem . on the one hand ,\",\n \"a search for systems for which kac s question is answered in the affirmative was conducted , and , on the other hand , various examples of pairs of systems which are isospectral but not isometric were identified . in the present paper\",\n \"we shall focus our attention to quantum graphs and in the following lines will review the subject of isospectrality in this limited context .\",\n \"the interested reader is referred to [ 1 - 11 ] for a broader view of the field where spectral inversion and its uniqueness are discussed .\",\n \"spectral problems related to graphs emerge in two distinct ways . in the first , the spectrum of the connectivity ( adjacency ) matrix is considered .\",\n \"it represents a discrete version of the laplacian , and for finite graphs , the spectrum is finite .\",\n \"this set of problems is often referred to as combinatorial graphs .\",\n \"quantum ( metric ) graphs are obtained by associating the standard metric to the bonds which connect the vertices .\",\n \"the schrdinger operator consists of the one - dimensional laplacians on the bonds complemented by appropriate boundary conditions at the vertices ( see next section ) .\",\n \"the spectrum of quantum graphs is unbounded , and it displays many interesting features which made it a convenient paradigm in the study of quantum chaos @xcite . shortly after the appearance of kac s paper , m. e. fisher published his work on hearing the shape of a drum \\\" @xcite , where he addresses isospectrality for the discrete version of the laplacian .\",\n \"since then , the study of isospectral combinatorial graphs made very impressive progress .\",\n \"in particular , several methods to construct isospectral yet different graphs were proposed .\",\n \"a review of this problem can be found in @xcite . in particular , a method which was originally put forward by sunada @xcite to construct isospectral laplace - beltrami operators on riemann manifolds , was adapted for the corresponding problem in the context of combinatorial graphs . here\",\n \"we shall go one step further , and show that it can be also adapted for quantum graphs .\",\n \"the conditions under which the spectral inversion of quantum graphs is unique were studied previously . in @xcite\",\n \"it was shown that in general , the spectrum does not determine uniquely the length of the bonds and their connectivity .\",\n \"however , it was shown in @xcite that quantum graphs whose bond lengths are _ rationally independent _ can be heard \\\" - that is - their spectra determine uniquely their connectivity matrices and their bond lengths .\",\n \"this fact follows from the existence of an exact trace formula for quantum graphs @xcite .\",\n \"thus , isospectral pairs of non congruent graphs , must have rationally dependent bond lengths .\",\n \"the sunada method , which is based on constructing the isospectral domains by concatenating several copies of a given building block , automatically provides us with graphs with rationally dependent lengths .\",\n \"an example of a pair of metrically distinct graphs which share the same spectrum was already discussed in @xcite . in a previous report\",\n \"we have shown that all the known isospectral domains in @xmath0 @xcite have corresponding isospectral pairs of quantum graphs @xcite . here , we shall take the subject one step further , and propose that isospectral graphs can be resolved by counting their nodal domains .\",\n \"that is , the nodal counts of eigenfunctions belonging to the same spectral value are not the same .\",\n \"the idea that nodal counts resolve isospectrality was suggested in @xcite for a family of isospectral flat tori in 4-d , and was tested numerically . the present work offers both rigorous and numerical evidence to substantiate the validity of this conjecture in a few examples of isospectral graphs . for these examples\",\n \"the nodal counts differences ocur on a substantial fraction of the spectrum .\",\n \"the paper is organized in the following way .\",\n \"for the sake of completeness we shall give a short review of some elementary definitions and facts on quantum graphs .\",\n \"we shall then show how pairs of isospectral domains in @xmath0 can be reduced to isospectral pairs of quantum graphs , and discuss their spectra and eigenfunctions .\",\n \"finally , we shall study the nodal domains of these eigenfunctions and show that by counting nodal domains one can resolve the isospectral ambiguity of the graphs presented .\",\n \"we consider finite graphs consisting of @xmath1 _ vertices _ connected by @xmath2 _\",\n \"bonds_. the @xmath3 _ connectivity matrix _ will be denoted by @xmath4 : @xmath5 when the vertices @xmath6 and @xmath7 are connected by @xmath8 bonds , and it vanishes otherwise .\",\n \"the group of bonds which emerge from the vertex @xmath6 form a star \\\" which will be denoted by @xmath9 .\",\n \"@xmath10 of a vertex is defined as the cardinality of the star @xmath9 and @xmath11 .\",\n \"vertices with @xmath12 belong to the graph _\",\n \"boundary_. the vertices with @xmath13 belong to the graph _ interior_. the bonds are endowed with the standard metric , and the coordinates along the bonds @xmath14 are denoted by @xmath15 . the length of the bonds will be denoted by @xmath16 , and the total length of the graph is @xmath17 .\",\n \"the domain of the schrdinger operator on the graph is the space of functions which belong to sobolev space @xmath18 on each bond b and at the vertices they are continuous and obey boundary conditions as is mentioned in ( [ eq : bc ] ) .\",\n \"the operator is constructed in the following way .\",\n \"on the bonds , it is identified as the laplacian in 1-d @xmath19 .\",\n \"it is supplemented by boundary conditions on the vertices which ensure that the resulting operator is self adjoint .\",\n \"we shall consider in this paper the neumann and dirichlet boundary conditions : @xmath20 the derivatives in ( [ eq : bc ] ) are directed out of the vertex @xmath6 .\",\n \"_ comment _ : the neumann boundary conditions will be assumed throughout , unless otherwise stated .\",\n \"a wave function with a wave number @xmath21 can be written as @xmath22 where @xmath14 connects the vertices @xmath6 and @xmath7 , where the wave function @xmath23 takes the values @xmath24 and @xmath25 respectively .\",\n \"the form ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) ensures continuity .\",\n \"the spectrum @xmath26 and the corresponding eigenfunctions are determined by substituting ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) in ( [ eq : bc ] ) .\",\n \"the resulting homogeneous linear equations for the @xmath24 are written as @xmath27 and a non trivial solution exists when @xmath28 the spectrum @xmath29 , which is a discrete , positive and unbounded sequence is the zero set of the _ secular function _ @xmath30 .\",\n \"the secular functions of the type ( [ eq : secular ] ) have poles on the real @xmath21 axis , which renders them rather inconvenient for numerical studies .\",\n \"the secular function can be easily regularized in various ways , ( see e.g. , @xcite ) .\",\n \"it is easy to show that the complete wave function can be written down in terms of the vertex wave functions at the interior vertices with @xmath31 only . in the sequel\",\n \"we shall denote their number by @xmath32 .\",\n \"this reduces the dimension of the matrix @xmath33 above from @xmath1 to @xmath32 .\",\n \"the nodal domains of the eigenfunctions ( the connected domains where the wave function is of constant sign ) , are of two types .\",\n \"the ones that are confined to a single bond are rather trivial .\",\n \"their length is exactly half a wavelength and their number is on average @xmath34 .\",\n \"the nodal domains which extend over several bonds emanating from a single vertex vary in length and their existence is the reason why counting nodal domains on graphs is not a trivial task .\",\n \"the number of nodal domains in a general graph can be written as @xmath35\\\\mathrm{sign}[\\\\phi_j ] \\\\right ) \\\\right \\\\ } -b + v \\\\ .\",\n \"\\\\label{eq : nnb2}\\\\ ] ] where @xmath36 stands for the largest integer which is smaller than @xmath37 , and @xmath38 are the values of the eigenfunction at the vertices connected by the bond @xmath14 @xcite .\",\n \"( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) holds for the case of an eigenfunction which does not vanish on any vertex : @xmath39 .\",\n \"recently schapotschnikow @xcite proved that sturm s oscillation theorem extends to finite tree ( loop - less ) graphs :\",\n \"the number of nodal domains of the @xmath40th eigenfunction ( ordered by increasing eigenvalues ) is @xmath40 .\",\n \"berkolaiko @xcite have shown that the number of nodal domains is bounded to the interval @xmath41 $ ] where @xmath42 is the minimal number of bonds which should be cut so that the resulting graph is a tree .\",\n \"nodal domains can be also defined and counted in an alternative way which makes use of the vertex wave functions @xmath43 ( see ( [ eq : wavefun ] ) ) exclusively : _ a nodal domain consists of a maximal set of connected interior vertices ( @xmath31 ) _ _ where the vertex wave functions have the same sign .\",\n \"_ this definition has to be modified if any of the @xmath24 vanishes .\",\n \"then , the sign attributed to it is chosen to maximize the number of nodal domains @xcite .\",\n \"we thus have two independent ways to define and count nodal domains . to distinguish between them\",\n \"we shall refer to the first as _ metric _ nodal domains , and the number of metric domains in the @xmath40th eigenfunction will be denoted by @xmath44 .\",\n \"berkolaiko s theorem states that @xmath45 .\",\n \"the domains defined in terms of the vertex wave functions will be referred to as the _ discrete _ nodal domains .\",\n \"the number of discrete nodal domains of the @xmath40th vertex wave function will be denoted by @xmath46 .\",\n \"the sequences of metric and discrete nodal domains counts @xmath47 and @xmath48 are the main objects of study of the present paper .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the first pair of isospectral planar domains which was introduced by gordon , web and wolpert @xcite is a member of a much larger set which was discussed in @xcite .\",\n \"this was extended in @xcite to include domains which differ in the distribution of boundary conditions ( dirichlet or neumann ) along their boundaries .\",\n \"the common feature of these sets of pairs of isospectral domains is that they are constructed using the sunada method @xcite , and they share a few important and distinctive attributes : * the domains are constructed by concatenating an elementary building block \\\" in two different prescribed ways to form the two domains .\",\n \"a building block is joined to another by reflecting along the common boundary .\",\n \"the shape of the building block is constrained only by symmetry requirements , but otherwise it is quite general . *\",\n \"the eigenfunctions corresponding to the same eigenvalue are related to each other by a _\",\n \"transplantation_. that is , the eigenfunction in a building block of one domain can be expressed as a linear combination of the eigenfunction in several building blocks in the other domain .\",\n \"the transplantation matrix is independent of the considered eigenvalue . * the construction of these pairs reflects an abstract algebraic structure which was identified by sunada @xcite .\",\n \"an example of an isospectral pair of domains in @xmath49 and its building block is given in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](a ) ) .\",\n \"this is a pair whose construction is described in @xcite .\",\n \"it is denoted there by @xmath50 .\",\n \"other examples are displayed in e.g. , @xcite .\",\n \"we can construct _ metric _ graphs which are analogous to these domains , by replacing the building blocks by appropriate graphs which preserve the requires symmetry .\",\n \"as an example , the triangular building block in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](a ) ) can be replaced by a 3 - star with bonds of lengths @xmath51 , @xmath14 and @xmath52 as shown in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](b ) ) .\",\n \"this yields the pair of isospectral but non isometric graphs shown in figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](c ) ) .\",\n \"( in drawing figure ( [ fig:7 - 3](c ) ) we took advantage of the fact that the angles \\\" between the bonds are insignificant ) .\",\n \"note that the two graphs share the same connectivity matrix ( they are topologically congruent ) however they are not isometric . as a matter of fact the right and the left graphs are interchanged when the bonds @xmath14 \\\" with \",\n \"@xmath52 \\\" are switched .\",\n \"thus , the lengths @xmath14 and @xmath52 must be different to ensure that the two graphs are not isometric .\",\n \"this is an example of an asymmetry requirement which the building block must satisfy .\",\n \"all other pairs of isospectral domains proposed in @xcite can be converted to their analogous quantum graphs ( see @xcite for details ) .\",\n \"two examples are shown in figure ( [ fig:13 - 3and13 - 8 ] ) .\",\n \"the most simple pair of isospectral domains can be built by applying the sunada method to the dihedral group @xmath53 .\",\n \"the resulting graphs are shown in figure ( [ fig : isospectral pair+notations ] ) , where the letters @xmath54 or @xmath55 specify the boundary conditions at the boundary vertices .\",\n \"( the boundary conditions at the interior vertices are always neumann ) .\",\n \"note that the two graphs are connected differently , in contrast with the previous example where the topology of the two graphs is the same . in [ appendix1 ] we give a brief description of the construction of this pair , as an example of the sunada method . in a way of illustration\",\n \"we shall write explicitly the secular functions for the graphs shown above .\",\n \"starting with the @xmath50 pair , we have @xmath56 ( the interior vertices are marked by a black dot and are enumerated in figure 1(c ) ) . the secular function for the graph @xmath57\",\n \"is written in terms of the matrix @xmath58 here , @xmath59 and @xmath60 the corresponding vertex eigenfunction @xmath61 is the eigenvector of @xmath62 with a vanishing eigenvalue .\",\n \"the @xmath33 matrix for the graph @xmath63 is obtained from the matrix @xmath64 by interchanging @xmath52 and @xmath14 .\",\n \"explicit computation shows that @xmath65 .\",\n \"this proves the isospectrality of the two graphs .\",\n \"the sum of the elements of any of the columns of @xmath66 is @xmath67 .\",\n \"hence the vector @xmath68 is an eigenvector with an eigenvalue @xmath67 .\",\n \"the values of @xmath21 for which @xmath69 are in the spectrum of both graphs .\",\n \"they correspond to eigenfunctions which are the same on each of the 3-stars - the building block of the complete graphs ( figure 1(b ) ) . as a matter of fact\",\n \", the condition @xmath69 is the secular equation for this 3-star with bond lengths @xmath70 @xcite .\",\n \"this subset exhausts 1/7 of the spectrum of the graphs , and in this set the transplantation property is trivial .\",\n \"the transplantation property which is basic to the proof of isospectrality for the @xmath49 domains in @xcite can be explicitly formulated by the transplantation matrix @xmath71 we observe that the inverse transplantation is also effected by @xmath72 : @xmath73 even though @xmath72 is not self inversive .\",\n \"the fact that @xmath72 induces the transplantation in the two directions , implies that the vertex wave functions @xmath74 must be eigenvectors of @xmath75 ( as long as the eigenvalue is not degenerate ) .\",\n \"the wave functions are defined up to normalization , and therefore the corresponding eigenvalues can be different than unity .\",\n \"the spectrum of @xmath75 consists of the eigenvalue @xmath76 and the six - fold degenerate eigenvalue @xmath77 .\",\n \"thus , the vertex wave functions are either proportional to @xmath78 , or belong to the 6 dimensional subspace of vectors orthogonal to @xmath78 .\",\n \"this observation will be used in the next section when the nodal structure of the eigenfunctions is to be discussed .\",\n \"other examples of pairs of isospectral graphs such as e.g. , the pair described in @xcite can be obtained from the isospectral graphs constructed above , by setting the length of the @xmath52 bond to zero .\",\n \"this was explicitly shown in @xcite .\",\n \"using similar special cases one can generate a rich variety of isospectral but not isometric quantum graphs .\",\n \"finally , it should be emphasized , that the skeleton of interior vertices form graphs which are identical to the topological , colored graphs which were introduced in @xcite to express the transplantation properties of the isospectral domains in @xmath49 .\",\n \"the quantum , metric graphs can be obtained simply by completing each topological vertex to a 3-vertex star graph with lengths @xmath70 .\",\n \"topological bonds are associated with lengths according to their colors , and bonds are added to the topological vertices with valency less than three , to complete them to 3- stars .\",\n \"this proves the statement made above that the computation carried out here can be repeated for any of the topological graphs shown in @xcite .\",\n \"the graphs corresponding to the isospectral domains @xmath79 and @xmath80 are shown in figure [ fig:13 - 3and13 - 8 ] .\",\n \"+ i ii the dihedral graphs are much simpler , with @xmath81 .\",\n \"their secular determinants can be shown to be identical functions of @xmath21 .\",\n \"this is an explicit demonstration that the graphs are indeed isospectral .\",\n \"the secular equation is obtained from @xmath82 as can be easily seen , @xmath83 has poles , and to get a regular secular function we have to multiply it by @xmath84 .\",\n \"it takes the form @xmath85 the transplantation matrix for this pair of graphs is derived in [ appendix1 ] .\",\n \"it reads @xmath86 the eigenvectors @xmath87 point at the directions @xmath88 , with @xmath89 .\",\n \"the transplantation ( [ eq : transdi ] ) implies that @xmath90 is obtained from @xmath91 by a rotation of @xmath92 counterclockwise .\",\n \"direct substitutions shows that @xmath93 where , @xmath94 the explicit form of the functions @xmath95 and @xmath96 will be used in the discussion of nodal counting in the next section .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the real eigenfunctions of laplace - beltrami operators on two dimensional manifolds display usually an intricate sets of nodal domains - which are the connected domains where the sign of the eigenfunction is constant @xcite .\",\n \"sturm s oscillation theorem for systems in 1-d , and its extension by courant to any dimension , establish the connection between the number of nodal domains and the spectrum : the number of nodal domains @xmath44 of the @xmath40th eigenfunction is bounded by @xmath40 .\",\n \"( the eigenfunctions are arranged by increasing value of their eigenvalues ) .\",\n \"theorem for combinatorial graphs and for quantum graphs were proved in @xcite , respectively . given a pair of isospectral domains .\",\n \"are the sequences of nodal counts @xmath97 identical ?\",\n \"in other words , can one use the information stored in the nodal sequences to resolve isospectrality ?\",\n \"this question was recently discussed in the context of isospectral flat tori in @xmath98 with @xmath99 @xcite , and numerical as well as analytical evidence was brought to substantiate the conjecture that the nodal sequences resolve isospectrality . in this section we shall provide rigorous as well as numerical evidence to show that the same is true for isospectral quantum graphs of the types discussed above .\",\n \"we shall start by discussing the _ discrete _ nodal sequences and then proceed to the _ metric _ nodal sequences .\",\n \"the _ discrete _ nodal domains were defined as the maximally connected sets of interior vertices with vertex wave functions of equal sign .\",\n \"their number is denoted by @xmath46 , and the nodal sequence is @xmath100 .\",\n \"we shall prove in the next subsection that for the dihedral graphs half of the entries in the sequences of discrete nodal counts are different .\",\n \"we are not able to provide a similar proof for the more complex graphs , but we shall bring numerical evidence which supports the conjecture that their sequences of discrete nodal counts are different\",\n \". the number of discrete nodal domains for this pair of dihedral graphs ( see figure [ fig : isospectral pair+notations ] ) can be either one or two , depending on whether the signs of the components of the ( two dimensional ) vertex eigenfunctions have the same sign or not .\",\n \"in other words ( see ( [ eq : tan ] ) ) , the number of nodal domains depend on the quadrant in the @xmath101 plane where the eigenvectors point : @xmath102 in the first and the third quadrants , and @xmath103 in the second and the fourth quadrants : @xmath104 the transplantation implies that the eigenvectors @xmath105 are obtained by rotating @xmath106 by @xmath92 counterclockwise\",\n \". therefore , @xmath107 if the transplantation rotates the vectors across the quadrant borders . in other words , @xmath108 this observation is essential to our discussion since it expresses the problem of nodal counting in geometrical terms .\",\n \"it is convenient to construct finite subsequences @xmath109 and @xmath110 of discrete nodal count of graphs i and ii , restricted to the spectral points in the interval @xmath111 .\",\n \"we denote the number of terms by @xmath112 .\",\n \"define @xmath113 we shall now prove [ thm1 ] consider the dihedral graphs i , ii discussed above with rationally independent bond lengths @xmath70 . then @xmath114 _ proof of theorem [ thm1 ] : _ the rational independence of @xmath70 implies that the eigenfunctions never vanish on the inner vertices and hence that the spectrum is simple . in order to study @xmath115 above\",\n \", we consider the distribution of the directions of the eigenfunctions @xmath116 in the spectral interval . using ( [ eq : secdireg],[eq : tan ] , [ eq : gfunction ] ) we get @xmath117 in taking the limit @xmath118 we use @xmath119 @xcite . moreover , since @xmath70 are assumed to be rationally independent , @xmath21 creates an ergodic flow on the 3-torus @xmath120 spanned by @xmath121 .\",\n \"ergodicity implies that the integral over @xmath21 in ( [ eq : ndist1 ] ) may be replaced by an integral over @xmath120 leading to @xmath122 \\\\label{eq : ndist2}\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] now we note that under the transformation @xmath123 we have @xmath124 thus , we conclude that @xmath125 at this stage we are not able to prove the validity of the conjecture that the nodal sequences resolve the isospectrality of the graphs @xmath50 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 .\",\n \"however , numerical tests show that for an appreciable fraction of the wave functions , the nodal counts are distinct\",\n \". we shall start the discussion by considering the case @xmath50 , for which we can turn the counting problem into a geometrical problem .\",\n \"the vertex wave functions which correspond to the same eigenvalues are related by transplantation : @xmath126 where @xmath74 stand now for the vertex wave function restricted to the 7 interior vertices in these graphs .\",\n \"we have already shown that eigenvectors @xmath127 are either proportional to @xmath128 ( the vector with constant entries)- in which case both have a single nodal domain , and @xmath129 , or the @xmath127 are orthogonal to @xmath128 .\",\n \"the 6 eigenvectors of @xmath75 with eigenvalue @xmath77 span the orthogonal subspace : three of them correspond to the eigenvalue @xmath130 of @xmath72 , and the other three correspond to the eigenvalue @xmath131 of @xmath72 . any vertex wave function @xmath132 which is not proportional to @xmath128 , can be written as @xmath133 where @xmath134 stand for arbitrary normalized vectors in the three dimensional subspaces mention above , and @xmath135 $ ] .\",\n \"thus , latexmath:[\\\\[\\\\vec{\\\\phi}^{\\\\ ii } = t \\\\vec{\\\\phi}^{\\\\ i } = \\\\sqrt2 ( \\\\cos\\\\alpha \\\\ difference in nodal numbers comes only through the change of sign of the linear combination .\",\n \"we are not able to make further progress beyond this point , and we shall therefore summarize the numerical findings . _ the graph _ @xmath50 - based on the study of approximately 6600 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath137 only .\",\n \"the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 19 @xmath139 of the wave - functions . _ the graph _ @xmath79 - based on the study of approximately 2000 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath137 only .\",\n \"the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 22@xmath139 of the wave - functions . _\",\n \"the graph _ @xmath80 - based on the study of approximately 4700 eigenfunctions we find that the difference between the discrete nodal counts can take the values @xmath140 only .\",\n \"the nodal counts are different for @xmath138 22 @xmath139 of the wave - functions .\",\n \"this result is certainly encouraging but not sufficient , and we are trying various options to substantiate it more rigourously . the discussion of the metric nodal sequences is facilitated in the present examples of isospectral graphs since most of them are trees .\",\n \"then , by making use of schapotschnikow s theorem @xcite , the _ metric _ nodal counts @xmath141 .\",\n \"this applies in particular to the isospectral graphs of the types @xmath50 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 which are tree graphs and @xmath142 .\",\n \"the metric counts do not resolve the isospectrality in these case .\",\n \"however , less trivially connected graphs can be constructed by replacing the basic building block . for such graphs schapotschnikow s theorem does not apply , and we expect their metric sequences to be different .\",\n \"below we shall show that this is true for the pair of dihedral graph where graph ii is not a tree .\",\n \"consider the pair of dihedral graphs , and let @xmath143 denote the metric nodal counts of graphs i and and ii . using ( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) we express the difference @xmath144 as @xmath145\\\\nonumber\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] to obtain ( [ eq : nd_diff ] ) a slight modification of ( [ eq : nnb2 ] ) was needed : the term in the sum that corresponds to a bond with boundary vertex that has dirichlet boundary conditions should be modified to be @xmath146 instead of @xmath147\\\\mathrm{sign}[\\\\phi_j ] \\\\right ) $ ] .\",\n \"in addition while deriving ( [ eq : nd_diff ] ) we made use of the identity @xmath148 and of the freedom to choose the sign of the first component of the wave - functions to be positive .\",\n \"a theorem by berkolaiko @xcite guarantees that @xmath149 can only take the values @xmath150 and @xmath151 .\",\n \"we would like to compute the distribution of these values on the spectrum .\",\n \"for this purpose we consider the spectral interval @xmath152 and study the function @xmath153 and prove the following theorem .\",\n \"[ theorem1]theorem [ thm2 ] consider the dihedral graphs i , ii discussed above with rationally independent bond lengths @xmath70 . then @xmath154 _ proof of theorem [ thm2 ] : _ in order to study the @xmath155 above we consider the distribution of @xmath149 , which is given by the integral @xmath156 where the spectral secular function @xmath95 is defined in ( [ eq : secdireg ] ) above , and @xmath157 coincides with @xmath149 for @xmath158 and can be written explicitly as @xmath159 \\\\ .\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] following the same route as in the proof of theorem ( [ thm1 ] ) we take the limit @xmath118 while making use of the ergodic theorem , and replace the @xmath21 integration by an integration over the 3 - torus with coordinates @xmath160 .\",\n \"@xmath161 the last line follows from the fact that @xmath37 is an integer which is written as half the sum of four unimodular numbers .\",\n \"next we note that under the transformation @xmath162 we have @xmath163 thus , we conclude that @xmath164 .\",\n \"but due to berkolaiko s theorem @xcite @xmath165 .\",\n \"therefore , @xmath166\"\n ],\n [\n \"there is now a growing amount of evidence that nodal - count sequences store information on the geometry of the system under study , which is similar but not equivalent to the information stored in the spectral sequence . in a recent paper @xcite\",\n \"it was shown that the nodal count sequence for separable laplace - beltrami operators can be expressed in terms of a trace formula which consists of a smooth ( weyl - like ) part , and an oscillatory part .\",\n \"the smooth part depends on constants which can be derived from the geometry of the domain , and the oscillatory part depends on the classical periodic orbits , much in the same way as the spectral trace formula . however , what we have shown in the present paper is that the information stored in the two sequences is not identical : for the isospectral pairs of graphs considered here , the nodal - count sequences are different in a substantial way . in this respect ,\",\n \"the nodal sequence resolves isospectrality .\",\n \"till this work was done , the conjecture that isospectrality is resolved by counting nodal domains was substantiated by numerical studies only .\",\n \"here we presented for the first time a system where this fact is proved rigorously . the main breakthrough which enabled the proof was by formulating the counting problem in a geometrical setting .\",\n \"we hope that this way will pave the way to further analytical studies , where more complex systems will be dealt with .\",\n \"finally , we would like to mention a set of open problems which naturally arise in the present context : can one find metrically different domains where the laplacians have different spectra but the nodal counting sequences are the same ? a positive answer is provided for domains in @xmath151 dimension ( sturm ) or for tree graphs ( schapotschnikow ) .\",\n \"are there other less trivial examples ?\"\n ],\n [\n \"it is a pleasure to acknowledge s gnutzmann , m solomyak and g berkolaiko for valuable discussions and comments .\",\n \"we are indebted to m sieber for discussions and for sharing with us his notes which formed the basis for the results discussed in [ appendix1 ] .\",\n \"the work was supported by the minerva center for non - linear physics and the einstein ( minerva ) center at the weizmann institute , and by grants from the gif ( grant i-808 - 228.14/2003 ) , and epsrc ( grant gr / t06872/01 . us\",\n \"thanks the school of mathematics in bristol for their hospitality and support .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the dihedral group @xmath167 is the symmetry group of a square .\",\n \"let @xmath51 be the transformation of rotating the square @xmath168 counterclockwise and b be the transformation of reflecting it along the x axis .\",\n \"the dihedral group is generated by @xmath169 which obey @xmath170,@xmath171 .\",\n \"the 8 group elements of @xmath172 are @xmath173 .\",\n \"@xmath174 are reflections along the axis @xmath175 respectively ( figure [ fig : basic square ] ) .\",\n \"note that the multiplication should be read from right to left since the elements are transformations .\",\n \"this group has 5 irreducible representations ( irreps ) .\",\n \"four of them are one dimensional and one , which is of our interest , is two dimensional .\",\n \"the two dimensional representation is : denote the second basis by @xmath181 .\",\n \"so that @xmath182 . notice that in the first form of the representation @xmath183 and @xmath184 are diagonal and in the second one @xmath185 and @xmath186 are diagonal .\",\n \"this will be exploited soon .\",\n \"the graph in figure [ fig : complete graph](a ) obeys the dihedral symmetry .\",\n \"examine the eigenfunctions of the schrdinger operator with neumann boundary conditions on all the vertices .\",\n \"the set of all the eigenfuncions of a certain eigenvalue @xmath187 form a finite dimensional vector space @xmath1 with some dimension @xmath188 .\",\n \"this vector space is invariant under the action of the dihedral group and therefore @xmath1 is the carrier space of some representation of @xmath172 .\",\n \"we are interested in the case that this representation is the two dimensional irrep of @xmath189 or that this representation is a reducible representation that contains the two dimensional irrep .\",\n \"consider the basis @xmath177 of this 2d irrep ( note that now @xmath190 have the meaning of wave functions on the graph in figure [ fig : complete graph ] ) . from the matrix which corresponds to @xmath183 in this basis ( see ( [ eq : repform1 ] ) ) we deduce that @xmath191 vanish on the axis x ( as an odd function with respect to that axis ) and as for @xmath192 , its derivative vanishes on the x axis ( since @xmath193 is an even function with respect to that axis and therefore its derivative is odd ) .\",\n \"using the notation from figure [ fig : complete graph](b ) , we have : + similarly , examining the matrix of @xmath184 in this basis ( [ eq : repform1 ] ) yields @xmath195 + we can get similar observations by looking on the matrices of @xmath185 , @xmath186 , this time for the basis @xmath196 ( [ eq : repform2 ] ) .\",\n \"we get the following @xmath197 + now , a pair of isospectral graphs will be constructed out of the complete graph .\",\n \"each of the graphs in the pair will be a subgraph of the complete graph .\",\n \"graph i is the graph that consists of the vertices b , c , d , e , f and all the bonds which connect them .\",\n \"graph ii is the graph that consists of the vertices a , b , c , d and all the bonds which connect them ( figure [ fig : boundary conditions ] ) .\",\n \"we can define the subgraphs in another way which will become convenient later : using the axis @xmath198 as in figure [ fig : basic square ] we define two sets of coordinates @xmath199 and @xmath200 and use them to examine the complete graph .\",\n \"graph i is obtained when restricting ourselves to the region @xmath201 of the complete graph .\",\n \"graph ii is obtained when restricting to the region @xmath202 . for a certain eigenvalue @xmath187 of the complete graph\",\n \"whose representation contains the 2d irrep discussed before , we can define appropriate eigenfunctions on the two subgraphs by @xmath203 .\",\n \"the boundary conditions of @xmath204 are obtained from ( [ eq : bndcnds1.1]),([eq : bndcnds1.2]),([eq : bndcnds2.1 ] ) , ( [ eq : bndcnds2.2 ] ) and are shown in figure [ fig : boundary conditions ] .\",\n \"_ proof of theorem [ thm3 ] : _ we will make use of the results above in order to construct a transplantation which proves the theorem .\",\n \"let @xmath208 .\",\n \"denote by @xmath209 the space of eigenfunctions which belong to the eigenvalue @xmath187 .\",\n \"@xmath210 define the functions @xmath211 on the complete graph by the following : @xmath212 where we have used again the coordinates @xmath213 as defined trivially by the axis @xmath214 ( scaling is obviously not important for our purposes ) .\",\n \"it can be verified that @xmath191 , @xmath192 are valid eigenfunctions of the eigenvalue @xmath187 defined on the complete graph .\",\n \"if @xmath215 for some @xmath216 then we get that @xmath217 ( this can simply be concluded by considering the boundary conditions ) . therefore @xmath211 are independent eigenfunctions and form a basis @xmath218 for the appropriate eigenspace .\",\n \"this is exactly the basis @xmath219 of the first form of the 2d irrep of @xmath220 ( see [ eq : repform1 ] ) .\",\n \"( this can be verified for example by examining the representation of the generators @xmath221 of @xmath220 ) .\",\n \"now , we construct the basis @xmath222 by @xmath223 . and now define the function @xmath224 on graph ii by @xmath225 .\",\n \"we get that @xmath224 is an eigenfunction of graph ii which belongs to the eigenvalue @xmath187 and obeys the appropriate boundary conditions @xmath226 . following this procedure\",\n \", one can verify that @xmath72 is the transplantation matrix of the vertex wave functions .\",\n \"we can similarly describe the inverse transplantation .\",\n \"the inverse transplantation is linear and therefore if we have an independent set of eigenfunctions ( with the same eigenvalue ) they would remain independent after the transplantation . thus , the degeneracies of @xmath187 in @xmath227 and @xmath228 are equal .\",\n \"the existence of the inverse transplantation also proves that @xmath229 and the degeneracy is again the same .\",\n \"therefore @xmath230 with account of multiplicities.@xmath231\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":95,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"0901.0535"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["the ongoing heavy ion physics program with the star detector at rhic has accumulated the wealth of experimental data , stimulating important advances in the understanding of properties of hot strongly interacting matter @xcite .","some of the focus areas currently under study are the thermodynamic and hydrodynamic properties of the matter created , in - medium effects on parton propagation , and hadronization mechanisms in qcd matter .","uniform azimuthal acceptance and extended pseudo - rapidity coverage of the star detector is exceptionally suited for studies of jets and jet - medium interactions via triggered and non - triggered correlations .","the data provided quantitative constrains on jet fragmentation and theoretical models of energy loss .","systematic studies of medium effects are advanced by analysis of system size effects on tomographic probes .","data collected with lighter cu ions have expanded those studies by providing additional control over the system size variations .","complimentary data samples at lower beam energy of 62 gev have also allowed systematic studies as function of energy to be performed .","star full capabilities for particle identification in a wide kinematic range have enabled new advances in more quantitative tests of qcd predictions .","different detectors provide complimentary capabilities and coverage .","pions , kaons , electrons and ( anti)protons are identified via their specific ionization energy loss in the time - projection chamber ( tpc ) material at low and high transverse momenta ( @xmath0 ) . in the intermediate momentum range","tpc results are enhanced by the time - of - flight ( tof ) capabilities .","muons can be identified in the muon telescope detector ( mtd ) prototype .","photons at forward rapidities are measured using the photon multiplicity detector ( pmd ) .","weakly decaying strange and multi - strange hadrons are identified geometrically by their decay vertices with the tpc and tof information on decay daughter particles .","short - lived resonances are reconstructed combinatorially by the invariant mass technique .","these capabilities have allowed measuring the yields and transverse momentum spectra addressing a variety of physics topics , including strangeness and heavy flavor production that are of topical interest for this conference .","strangeness enhancement was long thought as one of the signatures for the quark - gluon plasma formation @xcite .","early data suggested that strangeness equilibration is achieved at rhic and that initial collision geometry affects the strangeness systematics . in star studies of the collision geometry effects on strangeness production","is being accomplished by comprehensive analysis of various strange species ( @xmath1,@xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath6 ) in light vs. heavy systems at all rhic energies . the latest update on those developments","is reported in @xcite .","new advances in heavy flavor sector afforded by star particle identification capabilities include the measurements of j/@xmath7 spectra and nuclear modification factors in cu+cu collisions , measurements of charm total cross - section for @xmath8 , d+au , au+au and cu+cu systems , new constrains on bottom contribution to heavy flavor from j/@xmath7-hadron and @xmath9-@xmath10 azimuthal correlation studies .","these and other highlights on heavy quark measurements from star are reported in @xcite .","the following two sections will focus on some of the new results from triggered and non - triggered correlation analyses .","elliptic flow results have produced a lot of excitement from the beginning of rhic program .","for the first time in heavy ion collisions the large @xmath11 values reported could be described by ideal hydrodynamics @xcite .","theoretical calculations successful in description of flow results indicated the values of the shear viscosity over the entropy ratio consistent with the expectations for strongly interacting medium @xcite .","although recent work seem to question the applicability of ideal hydro @xcite , most theories agree that the matter created at rhic is extremely dense , with the hydrodynamic description applicability limits extending to higher @xmath0 for more central collisions .","flow results provide strong indications for partonic nature of the medium : constituent quark scaling observed for all measured hadron species ( including @xmath6 and @xmath5 with their small hadronic interaction cross - sections ) points on relevance of partonic degrees of freedom at hadronization @xcite .","similar results are observed in the cu+cu collisions although the overall @xmath11 values are lower at a given centrality for the cu+cu compared to au+au at the same energy .","new result reported recently by star on non - triggered two - particle correlations provide independent means to extract and cross - check azimuthal anisotropy parameters , but also to characterize other processes that induce relative angular correlations between the particles pairs . in this analysis di - hadron correlation formed with no transverse momentum restrictions on either hadron","is used to study centrality evolution of characteristic structures in relative azimuth and pseudo - rapidity .","it has been shown that the resulting correlation can be decomposed into a few structures , and information related to the individual sources can be extracted @xcite . per - particle","pair densities for various centrality bins of 200 gev minimum bias au+au data sample are shown in figure 1 .","minijet contribution , measured as the same - side two - dimensional gaussian correlation structure , was found to exhibit a threshold behavior .","while approximate binary scaling is observed from @xmath8 and most peripheral au+au to mid - central collisions , a sharp transition is found for both 200 and 62 gev au+au data at about 55% and 40% event centrality , respectively . as shown in figure 2 , from this point","the minijet peak amplitude exhibits rapid growth and the peak width in relative pseudo - rapidity broadens by more than a factor of 2 . here","the transverse density , calculated as @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is initial collision overlap area s from glauber model , is used as a centrality measure .","also shown in figure 2 is the total yield or `` volume '' of the minijet peak .","it is estimated to include approximately one third of all produced particles in central collisions .","novel features have been also observed by star in the triggered correlations .","early results on the disappearance of away - side jet ( in certain kinematic range ) unambiguously established the presence of the jet quenching phenomena at rhic @xcite .","experimental observations are found to be consistent with theoretical expectations for partonic energy loss @xcite , prompting more studies of the mechanisms of jet - medium interactions .","two - dimensional study of the correlation structures for charged hadrons associated with a high-@xmath0 trigger shows shape modifications in both @xmath14 and @xmath15 dimensions compared to a @xmath8 reference . within a two - component approach the intermediate @xmath0 structure","can be decomposed into a jet - like part , and the so - called `` ridge '' .","the jet part appears similar in shape to the structures seen in @xmath8 data , while `` ridge '' resembles properties of the bulk medium .","left panel of figure 3 illustrates the ridge - long range @xmath15 structure accompanying the jet peak in central 200 gev au+au collisions@xcite .","jet - medium interaction is likely to be the origin of the ridge formation and modification of the jet - like peaks .","di - hadron correlations with identified hadrons provide additional means to study parton propagation in the medium .","measurements of identified particle spectra and ratios for associated hadrons in the jet cones and ridges could address the issues of color - charge dependence of energy loss , presence of meson / baryon effects and interplay between various hadronization scenarios .","strong enhancement of baryon production at intermediate momentum range in inclusive measurements was theorized as an evidence for quark coalescence . however , in azimuthal correlations with the hyperon - triggers significant jet - like structures were observed for all species of hyperons ( including @xmath6 ) @xcite , which contradicts initial expectations from coalescence picture .","associated hadron yields in ( multi)strange hadron correlations show no dependence on strangeness content . following those observations , a medium response to the propagating parton or `` phantom jet '' was proposed to accommodate the data within the coalescence picture @xcite .","this theoretical explanation preserves the correlation in azimuthal space and produces ridge - like structure in pseudo - rapidity . to confront the models and further the understanding of physics mechanisms producing the ridge , it was essential to extend the correlation studies into @xmath15-@xmath14 space separately for baryons and mesons .","preliminary star results show significant differences in strange ( central panel of figure 3 ) and non - strange ( figure 3 , right ) baryon to meson ratios measured in jet part around a 4 gev/@xmath16 triggers , with respect to the ridge part .","the jet - part ratios for @xmath17 and @xmath18 are found to be significantly lower in central au+au collisions compared to non - triggered distributions , and are consistent with the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 data @xcite . at the same time",", the ridge ratios suggest relative baryon enhancement for both strange and non - strange species , which might be related to direct fragmentation of the gluons , radiated of the hard - scattered quark , or their subsequent recombination with the medium partons .","higher statistics a+a data samples , expected to be collected in future runs , are required to address ridge hadro - chemistry in more details .","-@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .","@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions . , title=\"fig:\",height=120 ] -@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .","@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison","are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions .",", title=\"fig:\",height=120 ] -@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .","@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions .",", title=\"fig:\",height=120 ] to add yet another dimension to the ridge studies , one can bring in additional particle to the correlation to explore internal structure of the observed peak .","preliminary results of three - particle triggered correlation analysis for unidentified hadrons are presented in figure 4 for minimum bias d+au , peripheral and central au+au collisions at 200 gev .","a jet - like peak is observed in all three correlations at small relative pseudo - rapidity values .","in addition , a uniform distribution of associated yields is observed in au+au collisions , particularly , for most central events .","this observation is quite puzzling for ridge phenomenology , contradicting to model predictions @xcite .","specifically we note the absence of axial strips in the correlation structure .","axial strips in three - particle correlation should be formed by associate hadron pairs , in which one of the hadrons is coming from the cone - part , and the other one - from the ridge .","absence of these strips thus suggests complete decoupling of jet and ridge events .","albeit the current statistic limitations , these early results have already provided more stringent constraints on the interpretation of ridge formation .","full jet reconstruction could provide new means to measure the energy loss of propagating partons .","experimental techniques for such reconstruction have been successfully used in elementary collision experiments .","recently full jet reconstruction was attempted for the first time for heavy ion events @xcite .","a combination of charged hadron measurements from the tpc and neutral energy measurements from electro - magnetic calorimeter were utilized in star for this analysis .","left panel of figure 5 depicts a 47 gev single jet from 20% central high - tower triggered ( ht ) au+au data of 200 gev .","the aim of this analysis is to quantify the jet energy loss by detailed studies of possible modification in the fragmentation functions due to quenching effects in au+au with respect to @xmath8 reference measurements .","preliminary results from this study are shown in the right panel of figure 5 , where fragmentation functions , defined as @xmath21 , are compared for two colliding systems .","no modification in the fragmentation functions in excess of 10 - 20% is observed within the uncertainties from utilizing the current jet finding algorithms and background subtraction procedures .","this preliminary conclusion depends heavily on the assumptions of pythia fragmentation , and could be additionally affected by the bias induced in the jet - sample by applying background - suppressing analysis cuts .","this work will be continued with the anticipated higher statistics au+au data in the coming years .","shaded area indicates the region where au+au measurement are dominated by the underlying background.,title=\"fig:\",height=151 ] data .","shaded area indicates the region where au+au measurement are dominated by the underlying background.,title=\"fig:\",height=136 ]","new physics focus will soon be added to the existing experimental program at rhic @xcite .","the compelling evidences gathered for the new form of matter created in heavy ion collisions , called for more explorations of the qcd phase diagram .","the phase diagram , defined in terms of temperature ( t ) with respect to the baryon chemical potential ( @xmath22 ) , is believed to contain a number of phase boundaries , including the one that separates qgp partonic degrees of freedom from the ordinary ( hadronic gas ) matter .","lattice qcd ( lqcd ) predicts that in zero-@xmath22 limit the phase transition occurs as a smooth cross - over , while at higher @xmath22 values it is expected to be a first order transition . a critical point ( cp )","is expected on a phase diagram , marking the location where qgp phase transition will change from a cross - over to a first order transition . in the absence of analytical solution","various approximation techniques are used in the theoretical calculations , with variations of lattice spacing , assumptions of quark masses and flavors , etc @xcite .","the resulting predictions with regard to the exact cp location vary considerably . in the coming years star","will engage in the beam energy scan program , continuing years of research at ags , sps , and rhic itself . to locate the critical point","the energy scan program will vary incident energies to achieve desirable variations of t and @xmath22 .","decreasing the center - of - mass energies leads to formation of colder matter with higher baryon potential , allowing one to move across the phase map . with the detailed scan star","will search for various cp signatures , as well as investigate the evolution of medium properties indicative of the non - hadronic matter .","novel phenomena , such as constituent quark scaling of the elliptic flow , hadron suppression at high-@xmath0 sigh signal the onset of deconfinment . from theory ,","the divergences are expected for the baryon number and the net charge susceptibilities , as well as for the specific heat near the critical point .","such divergences might lead to large fluctuations in a number of physical parameters , including baryon number density , quark number , and charge , which could be observed experimentally in hadronic yields , net - charge and mean-@xmath0 fluctuations , as well as particle ratios ( @xmath23 , @xmath17 , etc ) .","previous experimental results might already provide some hints regarding the cp location .","one such example is the excitation function for the @xmath24 ratio , that shows a drastic change - over near the center - of - mass energy of 8 gev ( figure 6 ) .","it is suggested that the `` horn '' feature could be linked directly to the qcd phase transition @xcite .","the rhic energy scan program will span a range of energies going slightly below that , covering a suggested region of ( t,@xmath22 ) values from most theoretical expectations .","star experiment is uniquely suited for the search armed not only by aforementioned pid capabilities , further enhanced by the completion of the full tof barrel , but also by full azimuthal coverage with large acceptance , which is essential for all fluctuation measurements .","the physics impact of fluctuation measurements , for example in mean-@xmath0 , has been already shown for the available rhic energies , providing essential baseline for the low energy scan .","ratio ; the @xmath25 is shown with the open ones .","star symbols depict first results for mid - rapidity kaon to pion ratios from 9.2 gev au+au collisions.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] the energy scan has essentially begun in star with the systematic studies of all available rhic energies : 200 , 130 , 62.4 and 19.6 gev . in the most recent run (","run 8) an engineering study was undertaken by the collider and accelerator department in conjunction with the energy scan program . during this study ,","the accelerator physicists demonstrated successful developments on injection and collisions of au ions at @xmath26 gev .","star was able to record the first low energy collisions , collecting about 3000 good events suitable for physics analysis . despite such limited statistics ,","first results for identified hadron spectra , azimuthal anisotropy measurements and pion interferometry were already obtained @xcite .","new data points added to the studies of the @xmath23 ratio systematics illustrate these achievements in figure 6 . with star s proven performance at low energy we are looking forward for new data in upcoming runs to further explore the qcd phase diagram and pin - point the location of the critical point .","we have discussed selected recent results from ongoing correlation analyses from star experiment . the results on ridge properties from triggered and non - triggered correlation studies were highlighted .","the large baryon to meson ratios , the uniformity of the ridge yield in @xmath15-@xmath15 space on event - by - event basis is suggestive of the bulk matter being the ridge origin .","first attempts towards full jet reconstruction in heavy ion collisions hold a lot of potential to provide further constraints on energy loss in qcd medium .","the data sample currently available is limited in statistics to fully exploit this technique . in the coming years",", star will continue collecting top energy data for @xmath8 and au+au collisions , providing the possibilities for more differential analyses .","another direction of star physics program is to partake in the rhic energy scan .","we will explore the qcd phase diagram in search for the onset of deconfinement and the location of critical point .","star has demonstrated the readiness to deliver physics results for the program with the analysis of the recent low energy test run .","10 adams j _ et al .","_ 2005 _ nucl . phys . _ * a*757 102 rafelski j and muller b 1982 _ phys .","lett . _ * 48 * 1066 timmins a _","these proceedings _ xu z _ these proceedings _ ackermann k _","_ 2001 _ phys .","lett . _ * 86 * ( 2001 ) 402 romatschke p and romatschke u 2007 _ phys .","lett . _ * 99 * 172301 tang a 2008 _ nucl - ex:_0808.2144 abelev b _","_ 2007 _ phys.rev.lett . _ * 99 * 112301 ; abelev b _ et al .","_ 2007_phys.rev . _","* c*75 054906"],"string":"[\n \"the ongoing heavy ion physics program with the star detector at rhic has accumulated the wealth of experimental data , stimulating important advances in the understanding of properties of hot strongly interacting matter @xcite .\",\n \"some of the focus areas currently under study are the thermodynamic and hydrodynamic properties of the matter created , in - medium effects on parton propagation , and hadronization mechanisms in qcd matter .\",\n \"uniform azimuthal acceptance and extended pseudo - rapidity coverage of the star detector is exceptionally suited for studies of jets and jet - medium interactions via triggered and non - triggered correlations .\",\n \"the data provided quantitative constrains on jet fragmentation and theoretical models of energy loss .\",\n \"systematic studies of medium effects are advanced by analysis of system size effects on tomographic probes .\",\n \"data collected with lighter cu ions have expanded those studies by providing additional control over the system size variations .\",\n \"complimentary data samples at lower beam energy of 62 gev have also allowed systematic studies as function of energy to be performed .\",\n \"star full capabilities for particle identification in a wide kinematic range have enabled new advances in more quantitative tests of qcd predictions .\",\n \"different detectors provide complimentary capabilities and coverage .\",\n \"pions , kaons , electrons and ( anti)protons are identified via their specific ionization energy loss in the time - projection chamber ( tpc ) material at low and high transverse momenta ( @xmath0 ) . in the intermediate momentum range\",\n \"tpc results are enhanced by the time - of - flight ( tof ) capabilities .\",\n \"muons can be identified in the muon telescope detector ( mtd ) prototype .\",\n \"photons at forward rapidities are measured using the photon multiplicity detector ( pmd ) .\",\n \"weakly decaying strange and multi - strange hadrons are identified geometrically by their decay vertices with the tpc and tof information on decay daughter particles .\",\n \"short - lived resonances are reconstructed combinatorially by the invariant mass technique .\",\n \"these capabilities have allowed measuring the yields and transverse momentum spectra addressing a variety of physics topics , including strangeness and heavy flavor production that are of topical interest for this conference .\",\n \"strangeness enhancement was long thought as one of the signatures for the quark - gluon plasma formation @xcite .\",\n \"early data suggested that strangeness equilibration is achieved at rhic and that initial collision geometry affects the strangeness systematics . in star studies of the collision geometry effects on strangeness production\",\n \"is being accomplished by comprehensive analysis of various strange species ( @xmath1,@xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath6 ) in light vs. heavy systems at all rhic energies . the latest update on those developments\",\n \"is reported in @xcite .\",\n \"new advances in heavy flavor sector afforded by star particle identification capabilities include the measurements of j/@xmath7 spectra and nuclear modification factors in cu+cu collisions , measurements of charm total cross - section for @xmath8 , d+au , au+au and cu+cu systems , new constrains on bottom contribution to heavy flavor from j/@xmath7-hadron and @xmath9-@xmath10 azimuthal correlation studies .\",\n \"these and other highlights on heavy quark measurements from star are reported in @xcite .\",\n \"the following two sections will focus on some of the new results from triggered and non - triggered correlation analyses .\",\n \"elliptic flow results have produced a lot of excitement from the beginning of rhic program .\",\n \"for the first time in heavy ion collisions the large @xmath11 values reported could be described by ideal hydrodynamics @xcite .\",\n \"theoretical calculations successful in description of flow results indicated the values of the shear viscosity over the entropy ratio consistent with the expectations for strongly interacting medium @xcite .\",\n \"although recent work seem to question the applicability of ideal hydro @xcite , most theories agree that the matter created at rhic is extremely dense , with the hydrodynamic description applicability limits extending to higher @xmath0 for more central collisions .\",\n \"flow results provide strong indications for partonic nature of the medium : constituent quark scaling observed for all measured hadron species ( including @xmath6 and @xmath5 with their small hadronic interaction cross - sections ) points on relevance of partonic degrees of freedom at hadronization @xcite .\",\n \"similar results are observed in the cu+cu collisions although the overall @xmath11 values are lower at a given centrality for the cu+cu compared to au+au at the same energy .\",\n \"new result reported recently by star on non - triggered two - particle correlations provide independent means to extract and cross - check azimuthal anisotropy parameters , but also to characterize other processes that induce relative angular correlations between the particles pairs . in this analysis di - hadron correlation formed with no transverse momentum restrictions on either hadron\",\n \"is used to study centrality evolution of characteristic structures in relative azimuth and pseudo - rapidity .\",\n \"it has been shown that the resulting correlation can be decomposed into a few structures , and information related to the individual sources can be extracted @xcite . per - particle\",\n \"pair densities for various centrality bins of 200 gev minimum bias au+au data sample are shown in figure 1 .\",\n \"minijet contribution , measured as the same - side two - dimensional gaussian correlation structure , was found to exhibit a threshold behavior .\",\n \"while approximate binary scaling is observed from @xmath8 and most peripheral au+au to mid - central collisions , a sharp transition is found for both 200 and 62 gev au+au data at about 55% and 40% event centrality , respectively . as shown in figure 2 , from this point\",\n \"the minijet peak amplitude exhibits rapid growth and the peak width in relative pseudo - rapidity broadens by more than a factor of 2 . here\",\n \"the transverse density , calculated as @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is initial collision overlap area s from glauber model , is used as a centrality measure .\",\n \"also shown in figure 2 is the total yield or `` volume '' of the minijet peak .\",\n \"it is estimated to include approximately one third of all produced particles in central collisions .\",\n \"novel features have been also observed by star in the triggered correlations .\",\n \"early results on the disappearance of away - side jet ( in certain kinematic range ) unambiguously established the presence of the jet quenching phenomena at rhic @xcite .\",\n \"experimental observations are found to be consistent with theoretical expectations for partonic energy loss @xcite , prompting more studies of the mechanisms of jet - medium interactions .\",\n \"two - dimensional study of the correlation structures for charged hadrons associated with a high-@xmath0 trigger shows shape modifications in both @xmath14 and @xmath15 dimensions compared to a @xmath8 reference . within a two - component approach the intermediate @xmath0 structure\",\n \"can be decomposed into a jet - like part , and the so - called `` ridge '' .\",\n \"the jet part appears similar in shape to the structures seen in @xmath8 data , while `` ridge '' resembles properties of the bulk medium .\",\n \"left panel of figure 3 illustrates the ridge - long range @xmath15 structure accompanying the jet peak in central 200 gev au+au collisions@xcite .\",\n \"jet - medium interaction is likely to be the origin of the ridge formation and modification of the jet - like peaks .\",\n \"di - hadron correlations with identified hadrons provide additional means to study parton propagation in the medium .\",\n \"measurements of identified particle spectra and ratios for associated hadrons in the jet cones and ridges could address the issues of color - charge dependence of energy loss , presence of meson / baryon effects and interplay between various hadronization scenarios .\",\n \"strong enhancement of baryon production at intermediate momentum range in inclusive measurements was theorized as an evidence for quark coalescence . however , in azimuthal correlations with the hyperon - triggers significant jet - like structures were observed for all species of hyperons ( including @xmath6 ) @xcite , which contradicts initial expectations from coalescence picture .\",\n \"associated hadron yields in ( multi)strange hadron correlations show no dependence on strangeness content . following those observations , a medium response to the propagating parton or `` phantom jet '' was proposed to accommodate the data within the coalescence picture @xcite .\",\n \"this theoretical explanation preserves the correlation in azimuthal space and produces ridge - like structure in pseudo - rapidity . to confront the models and further the understanding of physics mechanisms producing the ridge , it was essential to extend the correlation studies into @xmath15-@xmath14 space separately for baryons and mesons .\",\n \"preliminary star results show significant differences in strange ( central panel of figure 3 ) and non - strange ( figure 3 , right ) baryon to meson ratios measured in jet part around a 4 gev/@xmath16 triggers , with respect to the ridge part .\",\n \"the jet - part ratios for @xmath17 and @xmath18 are found to be significantly lower in central au+au collisions compared to non - triggered distributions , and are consistent with the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 data @xcite . at the same time\",\n \", the ridge ratios suggest relative baryon enhancement for both strange and non - strange species , which might be related to direct fragmentation of the gluons , radiated of the hard - scattered quark , or their subsequent recombination with the medium partons .\",\n \"higher statistics a+a data samples , expected to be collected in future runs , are required to address ridge hadro - chemistry in more details .\",\n \"-@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .\",\n \"@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions . , title=\\\"fig:\\\",height=120 ] -@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .\",\n \"@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison\",\n \"are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig:\\\",height=120 ] -@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .\",\n \"@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig:\\\",height=120 ] to add yet another dimension to the ridge studies , one can bring in additional particle to the correlation to explore internal structure of the observed peak .\",\n \"preliminary results of three - particle triggered correlation analysis for unidentified hadrons are presented in figure 4 for minimum bias d+au , peripheral and central au+au collisions at 200 gev .\",\n \"a jet - like peak is observed in all three correlations at small relative pseudo - rapidity values .\",\n \"in addition , a uniform distribution of associated yields is observed in au+au collisions , particularly , for most central events .\",\n \"this observation is quite puzzling for ridge phenomenology , contradicting to model predictions @xcite .\",\n \"specifically we note the absence of axial strips in the correlation structure .\",\n \"axial strips in three - particle correlation should be formed by associate hadron pairs , in which one of the hadrons is coming from the cone - part , and the other one - from the ridge .\",\n \"absence of these strips thus suggests complete decoupling of jet and ridge events .\",\n \"albeit the current statistic limitations , these early results have already provided more stringent constraints on the interpretation of ridge formation .\",\n \"full jet reconstruction could provide new means to measure the energy loss of propagating partons .\",\n \"experimental techniques for such reconstruction have been successfully used in elementary collision experiments .\",\n \"recently full jet reconstruction was attempted for the first time for heavy ion events @xcite .\",\n \"a combination of charged hadron measurements from the tpc and neutral energy measurements from electro - magnetic calorimeter were utilized in star for this analysis .\",\n \"left panel of figure 5 depicts a 47 gev single jet from 20% central high - tower triggered ( ht ) au+au data of 200 gev .\",\n \"the aim of this analysis is to quantify the jet energy loss by detailed studies of possible modification in the fragmentation functions due to quenching effects in au+au with respect to @xmath8 reference measurements .\",\n \"preliminary results from this study are shown in the right panel of figure 5 , where fragmentation functions , defined as @xmath21 , are compared for two colliding systems .\",\n \"no modification in the fragmentation functions in excess of 10 - 20% is observed within the uncertainties from utilizing the current jet finding algorithms and background subtraction procedures .\",\n \"this preliminary conclusion depends heavily on the assumptions of pythia fragmentation , and could be additionally affected by the bias induced in the jet - sample by applying background - suppressing analysis cuts .\",\n \"this work will be continued with the anticipated higher statistics au+au data in the coming years .\",\n \"shaded area indicates the region where au+au measurement are dominated by the underlying background.,title=\\\"fig:\\\",height=151 ] data .\",\n \"shaded area indicates the region where au+au measurement are dominated by the underlying background.,title=\\\"fig:\\\",height=136 ]\",\n \"new physics focus will soon be added to the existing experimental program at rhic @xcite .\",\n \"the compelling evidences gathered for the new form of matter created in heavy ion collisions , called for more explorations of the qcd phase diagram .\",\n \"the phase diagram , defined in terms of temperature ( t ) with respect to the baryon chemical potential ( @xmath22 ) , is believed to contain a number of phase boundaries , including the one that separates qgp partonic degrees of freedom from the ordinary ( hadronic gas ) matter .\",\n \"lattice qcd ( lqcd ) predicts that in zero-@xmath22 limit the phase transition occurs as a smooth cross - over , while at higher @xmath22 values it is expected to be a first order transition . a critical point ( cp )\",\n \"is expected on a phase diagram , marking the location where qgp phase transition will change from a cross - over to a first order transition . in the absence of analytical solution\",\n \"various approximation techniques are used in the theoretical calculations , with variations of lattice spacing , assumptions of quark masses and flavors , etc @xcite .\",\n \"the resulting predictions with regard to the exact cp location vary considerably . in the coming years star\",\n \"will engage in the beam energy scan program , continuing years of research at ags , sps , and rhic itself . to locate the critical point\",\n \"the energy scan program will vary incident energies to achieve desirable variations of t and @xmath22 .\",\n \"decreasing the center - of - mass energies leads to formation of colder matter with higher baryon potential , allowing one to move across the phase map . with the detailed scan star\",\n \"will search for various cp signatures , as well as investigate the evolution of medium properties indicative of the non - hadronic matter .\",\n \"novel phenomena , such as constituent quark scaling of the elliptic flow , hadron suppression at high-@xmath0 sigh signal the onset of deconfinment . from theory ,\",\n \"the divergences are expected for the baryon number and the net charge susceptibilities , as well as for the specific heat near the critical point .\",\n \"such divergences might lead to large fluctuations in a number of physical parameters , including baryon number density , quark number , and charge , which could be observed experimentally in hadronic yields , net - charge and mean-@xmath0 fluctuations , as well as particle ratios ( @xmath23 , @xmath17 , etc ) .\",\n \"previous experimental results might already provide some hints regarding the cp location .\",\n \"one such example is the excitation function for the @xmath24 ratio , that shows a drastic change - over near the center - of - mass energy of 8 gev ( figure 6 ) .\",\n \"it is suggested that the `` horn '' feature could be linked directly to the qcd phase transition @xcite .\",\n \"the rhic energy scan program will span a range of energies going slightly below that , covering a suggested region of ( t,@xmath22 ) values from most theoretical expectations .\",\n \"star experiment is uniquely suited for the search armed not only by aforementioned pid capabilities , further enhanced by the completion of the full tof barrel , but also by full azimuthal coverage with large acceptance , which is essential for all fluctuation measurements .\",\n \"the physics impact of fluctuation measurements , for example in mean-@xmath0 , has been already shown for the available rhic energies , providing essential baseline for the low energy scan .\",\n \"ratio ; the @xmath25 is shown with the open ones .\",\n \"star symbols depict first results for mid - rapidity kaon to pion ratios from 9.2 gev au+au collisions.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] the energy scan has essentially begun in star with the systematic studies of all available rhic energies : 200 , 130 , 62.4 and 19.6 gev . in the most recent run (\",\n \"run 8) an engineering study was undertaken by the collider and accelerator department in conjunction with the energy scan program . during this study ,\",\n \"the accelerator physicists demonstrated successful developments on injection and collisions of au ions at @xmath26 gev .\",\n \"star was able to record the first low energy collisions , collecting about 3000 good events suitable for physics analysis . despite such limited statistics ,\",\n \"first results for identified hadron spectra , azimuthal anisotropy measurements and pion interferometry were already obtained @xcite .\",\n \"new data points added to the studies of the @xmath23 ratio systematics illustrate these achievements in figure 6 . with star s proven performance at low energy we are looking forward for new data in upcoming runs to further explore the qcd phase diagram and pin - point the location of the critical point .\",\n \"we have discussed selected recent results from ongoing correlation analyses from star experiment . the results on ridge properties from triggered and non - triggered correlation studies were highlighted .\",\n \"the large baryon to meson ratios , the uniformity of the ridge yield in @xmath15-@xmath15 space on event - by - event basis is suggestive of the bulk matter being the ridge origin .\",\n \"first attempts towards full jet reconstruction in heavy ion collisions hold a lot of potential to provide further constraints on energy loss in qcd medium .\",\n \"the data sample currently available is limited in statistics to fully exploit this technique . in the coming years\",\n \", star will continue collecting top energy data for @xmath8 and au+au collisions , providing the possibilities for more differential analyses .\",\n \"another direction of star physics program is to partake in the rhic energy scan .\",\n \"we will explore the qcd phase diagram in search for the onset of deconfinement and the location of critical point .\",\n \"star has demonstrated the readiness to deliver physics results for the program with the analysis of the recent low energy test run .\",\n \"10 adams j _ et al .\",\n \"_ 2005 _ nucl . phys . _ * a*757 102 rafelski j and muller b 1982 _ phys .\",\n \"lett . _ * 48 * 1066 timmins a _\",\n \"these proceedings _ xu z _ these proceedings _ ackermann k _\",\n \"_ 2001 _ phys .\",\n \"lett . _ * 86 * ( 2001 ) 402 romatschke p and romatschke u 2007 _ phys .\",\n \"lett . _ * 99 * 172301 tang a 2008 _ nucl - ex:_0808.2144 abelev b _\",\n \"_ 2007 _ phys.rev.lett . _ * 99 * 112301 ; abelev b _ et al .\",\n \"_ 2007_phys.rev . _\",\n \"* c*75 054906\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> two major advantages of the star detector - uniform azimuthal acceptance complementing extended pseudo - rapidity coverage , and the ability to identify a wide variety of the hadron species in almost all kinematic ranges - have allowed us to address successfully a set of key physics topics at rhic . </S>","<S> we report here selected recent results from the star experiment , including insights on system size effects on medium properties , hadronization mechanisms , and partonic energy loss from triggered and non - triggered probes . in conclusion </S>","<S> , we present an outlook on the star new physics program in upcoming years . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> two major advantages of the star detector - uniform azimuthal acceptance complementing extended pseudo - rapidity coverage , and the ability to identify a wide variety of the hadron species in almost all kinematic ranges - have allowed us to address successfully a set of key physics topics at rhic . </S>\",\n \"<S> we report here selected recent results from the star experiment , including insights on system size effects on medium properties , hadronization mechanisms , and partonic energy loss from triggered and non - triggered probes . in conclusion </S>\",\n \"<S> , we present an outlook on the star new physics program in upcoming years . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","particle identification","non-triggered correlations","triggered correlations","beam energy scan","conclusions and outlook","references"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"particle identification\",\n \"non-triggered correlations\",\n \"triggered correlations\",\n \"beam energy scan\",\n \"conclusions and outlook\",\n \"references\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["the ongoing heavy ion physics program with the star detector at rhic has accumulated the wealth of experimental data , stimulating important advances in the understanding of properties of hot strongly interacting matter @xcite .","some of the focus areas currently under study are the thermodynamic and hydrodynamic properties of the matter created , in - medium effects on parton propagation , and hadronization mechanisms in qcd matter .","uniform azimuthal acceptance and extended pseudo - rapidity coverage of the star detector is exceptionally suited for studies of jets and jet - medium interactions via triggered and non - triggered correlations .","the data provided quantitative constrains on jet fragmentation and theoretical models of energy loss .","systematic studies of medium effects are advanced by analysis of system size effects on tomographic probes .","data collected with lighter cu ions have expanded those studies by providing additional control over the system size variations .","complimentary data samples at lower beam energy of 62 gev have also allowed systematic studies as function of energy to be performed ."],["star full capabilities for particle identification in a wide kinematic range have enabled new advances in more quantitative tests of qcd predictions .","different detectors provide complimentary capabilities and coverage .","pions , kaons , electrons and ( anti)protons are identified via their specific ionization energy loss in the time - projection chamber ( tpc ) material at low and high transverse momenta ( @xmath0 ) . in the intermediate momentum range","tpc results are enhanced by the time - of - flight ( tof ) capabilities .","muons can be identified in the muon telescope detector ( mtd ) prototype .","photons at forward rapidities are measured using the photon multiplicity detector ( pmd ) .","weakly decaying strange and multi - strange hadrons are identified geometrically by their decay vertices with the tpc and tof information on decay daughter particles .","short - lived resonances are reconstructed combinatorially by the invariant mass technique .","these capabilities have allowed measuring the yields and transverse momentum spectra addressing a variety of physics topics , including strangeness and heavy flavor production that are of topical interest for this conference .","strangeness enhancement was long thought as one of the signatures for the quark - gluon plasma formation @xcite .","early data suggested that strangeness equilibration is achieved at rhic and that initial collision geometry affects the strangeness systematics . in star studies of the collision geometry effects on strangeness production","is being accomplished by comprehensive analysis of various strange species ( @xmath1,@xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath6 ) in light vs. heavy systems at all rhic energies . the latest update on those developments","is reported in @xcite .","new advances in heavy flavor sector afforded by star particle identification capabilities include the measurements of j/@xmath7 spectra and nuclear modification factors in cu+cu collisions , measurements of charm total cross - section for @xmath8 , d+au , au+au and cu+cu systems , new constrains on bottom contribution to heavy flavor from j/@xmath7-hadron and @xmath9-@xmath10 azimuthal correlation studies .","these and other highlights on heavy quark measurements from star are reported in @xcite .","the following two sections will focus on some of the new results from triggered and non - triggered correlation analyses ."],["elliptic flow results have produced a lot of excitement from the beginning of rhic program .","for the first time in heavy ion collisions the large @xmath11 values reported could be described by ideal hydrodynamics @xcite .","theoretical calculations successful in description of flow results indicated the values of the shear viscosity over the entropy ratio consistent with the expectations for strongly interacting medium @xcite .","although recent work seem to question the applicability of ideal hydro @xcite , most theories agree that the matter created at rhic is extremely dense , with the hydrodynamic description applicability limits extending to higher @xmath0 for more central collisions .","flow results provide strong indications for partonic nature of the medium : constituent quark scaling observed for all measured hadron species ( including @xmath6 and @xmath5 with their small hadronic interaction cross - sections ) points on relevance of partonic degrees of freedom at hadronization @xcite .","similar results are observed in the cu+cu collisions although the overall @xmath11 values are lower at a given centrality for the cu+cu compared to au+au at the same energy .","new result reported recently by star on non - triggered two - particle correlations provide independent means to extract and cross - check azimuthal anisotropy parameters , but also to characterize other processes that induce relative angular correlations between the particles pairs . in this analysis di - hadron correlation formed with no transverse momentum restrictions on either hadron","is used to study centrality evolution of characteristic structures in relative azimuth and pseudo - rapidity .","it has been shown that the resulting correlation can be decomposed into a few structures , and information related to the individual sources can be extracted @xcite . per - particle","pair densities for various centrality bins of 200 gev minimum bias au+au data sample are shown in figure 1 .","minijet contribution , measured as the same - side two - dimensional gaussian correlation structure , was found to exhibit a threshold behavior .","while approximate binary scaling is observed from @xmath8 and most peripheral au+au to mid - central collisions , a sharp transition is found for both 200 and 62 gev au+au data at about 55% and 40% event centrality , respectively . as shown in figure 2 , from this point","the minijet peak amplitude exhibits rapid growth and the peak width in relative pseudo - rapidity broadens by more than a factor of 2 . here","the transverse density , calculated as @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is initial collision overlap area s from glauber model , is used as a centrality measure .","also shown in figure 2 is the total yield or `` volume '' of the minijet peak .","it is estimated to include approximately one third of all produced particles in central collisions ."],["novel features have been also observed by star in the triggered correlations .","early results on the disappearance of away - side jet ( in certain kinematic range ) unambiguously established the presence of the jet quenching phenomena at rhic @xcite .","experimental observations are found to be consistent with theoretical expectations for partonic energy loss @xcite , prompting more studies of the mechanisms of jet - medium interactions .","two - dimensional study of the correlation structures for charged hadrons associated with a high-@xmath0 trigger shows shape modifications in both @xmath14 and @xmath15 dimensions compared to a @xmath8 reference . within a two - component approach the intermediate @xmath0 structure","can be decomposed into a jet - like part , and the so - called `` ridge '' .","the jet part appears similar in shape to the structures seen in @xmath8 data , while `` ridge '' resembles properties of the bulk medium .","left panel of figure 3 illustrates the ridge - long range @xmath15 structure accompanying the jet peak in central 200 gev au+au collisions@xcite .","jet - medium interaction is likely to be the origin of the ridge formation and modification of the jet - like peaks .","di - hadron correlations with identified hadrons provide additional means to study parton propagation in the medium .","measurements of identified particle spectra and ratios for associated hadrons in the jet cones and ridges could address the issues of color - charge dependence of energy loss , presence of meson / baryon effects and interplay between various hadronization scenarios .","strong enhancement of baryon production at intermediate momentum range in inclusive measurements was theorized as an evidence for quark coalescence . however , in azimuthal correlations with the hyperon - triggers significant jet - like structures were observed for all species of hyperons ( including @xmath6 ) @xcite , which contradicts initial expectations from coalescence picture .","associated hadron yields in ( multi)strange hadron correlations show no dependence on strangeness content . following those observations , a medium response to the propagating parton or `` phantom jet '' was proposed to accommodate the data within the coalescence picture @xcite .","this theoretical explanation preserves the correlation in azimuthal space and produces ridge - like structure in pseudo - rapidity . to confront the models and further the understanding of physics mechanisms producing the ridge , it was essential to extend the correlation studies into @xmath15-@xmath14 space separately for baryons and mesons .","preliminary star results show significant differences in strange ( central panel of figure 3 ) and non - strange ( figure 3 , right ) baryon to meson ratios measured in jet part around a 4 gev/@xmath16 triggers , with respect to the ridge part .","the jet - part ratios for @xmath17 and @xmath18 are found to be significantly lower in central au+au collisions compared to non - triggered distributions , and are consistent with the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 data @xcite . at the same time",", the ridge ratios suggest relative baryon enhancement for both strange and non - strange species , which might be related to direct fragmentation of the gluons , radiated of the hard - scattered quark , or their subsequent recombination with the medium partons .","higher statistics a+a data samples , expected to be collected in future runs , are required to address ridge hadro - chemistry in more details .","-@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .","@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions . , title=\"fig:\",height=120 ] -@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .","@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison","are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions .",", title=\"fig:\",height=120 ] -@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .","@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions .",", title=\"fig:\",height=120 ] to add yet another dimension to the ridge studies , one can bring in additional particle to the correlation to explore internal structure of the observed peak .","preliminary results of three - particle triggered correlation analysis for unidentified hadrons are presented in figure 4 for minimum bias d+au , peripheral and central au+au collisions at 200 gev .","a jet - like peak is observed in all three correlations at small relative pseudo - rapidity values .","in addition , a uniform distribution of associated yields is observed in au+au collisions , particularly , for most central events .","this observation is quite puzzling for ridge phenomenology , contradicting to model predictions @xcite .","specifically we note the absence of axial strips in the correlation structure .","axial strips in three - particle correlation should be formed by associate hadron pairs , in which one of the hadrons is coming from the cone - part , and the other one - from the ridge .","absence of these strips thus suggests complete decoupling of jet and ridge events .","albeit the current statistic limitations , these early results have already provided more stringent constraints on the interpretation of ridge formation .","full jet reconstruction could provide new means to measure the energy loss of propagating partons .","experimental techniques for such reconstruction have been successfully used in elementary collision experiments .","recently full jet reconstruction was attempted for the first time for heavy ion events @xcite .","a combination of charged hadron measurements from the tpc and neutral energy measurements from electro - magnetic calorimeter were utilized in star for this analysis .","left panel of figure 5 depicts a 47 gev single jet from 20% central high - tower triggered ( ht ) au+au data of 200 gev .","the aim of this analysis is to quantify the jet energy loss by detailed studies of possible modification in the fragmentation functions due to quenching effects in au+au with respect to @xmath8 reference measurements .","preliminary results from this study are shown in the right panel of figure 5 , where fragmentation functions , defined as @xmath21 , are compared for two colliding systems .","no modification in the fragmentation functions in excess of 10 - 20% is observed within the uncertainties from utilizing the current jet finding algorithms and background subtraction procedures .","this preliminary conclusion depends heavily on the assumptions of pythia fragmentation , and could be additionally affected by the bias induced in the jet - sample by applying background - suppressing analysis cuts .","this work will be continued with the anticipated higher statistics au+au data in the coming years .","shaded area indicates the region where au+au measurement are dominated by the underlying background.,title=\"fig:\",height=151 ] data .","shaded area indicates the region where au+au measurement are dominated by the underlying background.,title=\"fig:\",height=136 ]"],["new physics focus will soon be added to the existing experimental program at rhic @xcite .","the compelling evidences gathered for the new form of matter created in heavy ion collisions , called for more explorations of the qcd phase diagram .","the phase diagram , defined in terms of temperature ( t ) with respect to the baryon chemical potential ( @xmath22 ) , is believed to contain a number of phase boundaries , including the one that separates qgp partonic degrees of freedom from the ordinary ( hadronic gas ) matter .","lattice qcd ( lqcd ) predicts that in zero-@xmath22 limit the phase transition occurs as a smooth cross - over , while at higher @xmath22 values it is expected to be a first order transition . a critical point ( cp )","is expected on a phase diagram , marking the location where qgp phase transition will change from a cross - over to a first order transition . in the absence of analytical solution","various approximation techniques are used in the theoretical calculations , with variations of lattice spacing , assumptions of quark masses and flavors , etc @xcite .","the resulting predictions with regard to the exact cp location vary considerably . in the coming years star","will engage in the beam energy scan program , continuing years of research at ags , sps , and rhic itself . to locate the critical point","the energy scan program will vary incident energies to achieve desirable variations of t and @xmath22 .","decreasing the center - of - mass energies leads to formation of colder matter with higher baryon potential , allowing one to move across the phase map . with the detailed scan star","will search for various cp signatures , as well as investigate the evolution of medium properties indicative of the non - hadronic matter .","novel phenomena , such as constituent quark scaling of the elliptic flow , hadron suppression at high-@xmath0 sigh signal the onset of deconfinment . from theory ,","the divergences are expected for the baryon number and the net charge susceptibilities , as well as for the specific heat near the critical point .","such divergences might lead to large fluctuations in a number of physical parameters , including baryon number density , quark number , and charge , which could be observed experimentally in hadronic yields , net - charge and mean-@xmath0 fluctuations , as well as particle ratios ( @xmath23 , @xmath17 , etc ) .","previous experimental results might already provide some hints regarding the cp location .","one such example is the excitation function for the @xmath24 ratio , that shows a drastic change - over near the center - of - mass energy of 8 gev ( figure 6 ) .","it is suggested that the `` horn '' feature could be linked directly to the qcd phase transition @xcite .","the rhic energy scan program will span a range of energies going slightly below that , covering a suggested region of ( t,@xmath22 ) values from most theoretical expectations .","star experiment is uniquely suited for the search armed not only by aforementioned pid capabilities , further enhanced by the completion of the full tof barrel , but also by full azimuthal coverage with large acceptance , which is essential for all fluctuation measurements .","the physics impact of fluctuation measurements , for example in mean-@xmath0 , has been already shown for the available rhic energies , providing essential baseline for the low energy scan .","ratio ; the @xmath25 is shown with the open ones .","star symbols depict first results for mid - rapidity kaon to pion ratios from 9.2 gev au+au collisions.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] the energy scan has essentially begun in star with the systematic studies of all available rhic energies : 200 , 130 , 62.4 and 19.6 gev . in the most recent run (","run 8) an engineering study was undertaken by the collider and accelerator department in conjunction with the energy scan program . during this study ,","the accelerator physicists demonstrated successful developments on injection and collisions of au ions at @xmath26 gev .","star was able to record the first low energy collisions , collecting about 3000 good events suitable for physics analysis . despite such limited statistics ,","first results for identified hadron spectra , azimuthal anisotropy measurements and pion interferometry were already obtained @xcite .","new data points added to the studies of the @xmath23 ratio systematics illustrate these achievements in figure 6 . with star s proven performance at low energy we are looking forward for new data in upcoming runs to further explore the qcd phase diagram and pin - point the location of the critical point ."],["we have discussed selected recent results from ongoing correlation analyses from star experiment . the results on ridge properties from triggered and non - triggered correlation studies were highlighted .","the large baryon to meson ratios , the uniformity of the ridge yield in @xmath15-@xmath15 space on event - by - event basis is suggestive of the bulk matter being the ridge origin .","first attempts towards full jet reconstruction in heavy ion collisions hold a lot of potential to provide further constraints on energy loss in qcd medium .","the data sample currently available is limited in statistics to fully exploit this technique . in the coming years",", star will continue collecting top energy data for @xmath8 and au+au collisions , providing the possibilities for more differential analyses .","another direction of star physics program is to partake in the rhic energy scan .","we will explore the qcd phase diagram in search for the onset of deconfinement and the location of critical point .","star has demonstrated the readiness to deliver physics results for the program with the analysis of the recent low energy test run ."],["10 adams j _ et al .","_ 2005 _ nucl . phys . _ * a*757 102 rafelski j and muller b 1982 _ phys .","lett . _ * 48 * 1066 timmins a _","these proceedings _ xu z _ these proceedings _ ackermann k _","_ 2001 _ phys .","lett . _ * 86 * ( 2001 ) 402 romatschke p and romatschke u 2007 _ phys .","lett . _ * 99 * 172301 tang a 2008 _ nucl - ex:_0808.2144 abelev b _","_ 2007 _ phys.rev.lett . _ * 99 * 112301 ; abelev b _ et al .","_ 2007_phys.rev . _","* c*75 054906"]],"string":"[\n [\n \"the ongoing heavy ion physics program with the star detector at rhic has accumulated the wealth of experimental data , stimulating important advances in the understanding of properties of hot strongly interacting matter @xcite .\",\n \"some of the focus areas currently under study are the thermodynamic and hydrodynamic properties of the matter created , in - medium effects on parton propagation , and hadronization mechanisms in qcd matter .\",\n \"uniform azimuthal acceptance and extended pseudo - rapidity coverage of the star detector is exceptionally suited for studies of jets and jet - medium interactions via triggered and non - triggered correlations .\",\n \"the data provided quantitative constrains on jet fragmentation and theoretical models of energy loss .\",\n \"systematic studies of medium effects are advanced by analysis of system size effects on tomographic probes .\",\n \"data collected with lighter cu ions have expanded those studies by providing additional control over the system size variations .\",\n \"complimentary data samples at lower beam energy of 62 gev have also allowed systematic studies as function of energy to be performed .\"\n ],\n [\n \"star full capabilities for particle identification in a wide kinematic range have enabled new advances in more quantitative tests of qcd predictions .\",\n \"different detectors provide complimentary capabilities and coverage .\",\n \"pions , kaons , electrons and ( anti)protons are identified via their specific ionization energy loss in the time - projection chamber ( tpc ) material at low and high transverse momenta ( @xmath0 ) . in the intermediate momentum range\",\n \"tpc results are enhanced by the time - of - flight ( tof ) capabilities .\",\n \"muons can be identified in the muon telescope detector ( mtd ) prototype .\",\n \"photons at forward rapidities are measured using the photon multiplicity detector ( pmd ) .\",\n \"weakly decaying strange and multi - strange hadrons are identified geometrically by their decay vertices with the tpc and tof information on decay daughter particles .\",\n \"short - lived resonances are reconstructed combinatorially by the invariant mass technique .\",\n \"these capabilities have allowed measuring the yields and transverse momentum spectra addressing a variety of physics topics , including strangeness and heavy flavor production that are of topical interest for this conference .\",\n \"strangeness enhancement was long thought as one of the signatures for the quark - gluon plasma formation @xcite .\",\n \"early data suggested that strangeness equilibration is achieved at rhic and that initial collision geometry affects the strangeness systematics . in star studies of the collision geometry effects on strangeness production\",\n \"is being accomplished by comprehensive analysis of various strange species ( @xmath1,@xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath6 ) in light vs. heavy systems at all rhic energies . the latest update on those developments\",\n \"is reported in @xcite .\",\n \"new advances in heavy flavor sector afforded by star particle identification capabilities include the measurements of j/@xmath7 spectra and nuclear modification factors in cu+cu collisions , measurements of charm total cross - section for @xmath8 , d+au , au+au and cu+cu systems , new constrains on bottom contribution to heavy flavor from j/@xmath7-hadron and @xmath9-@xmath10 azimuthal correlation studies .\",\n \"these and other highlights on heavy quark measurements from star are reported in @xcite .\",\n \"the following two sections will focus on some of the new results from triggered and non - triggered correlation analyses .\"\n ],\n [\n \"elliptic flow results have produced a lot of excitement from the beginning of rhic program .\",\n \"for the first time in heavy ion collisions the large @xmath11 values reported could be described by ideal hydrodynamics @xcite .\",\n \"theoretical calculations successful in description of flow results indicated the values of the shear viscosity over the entropy ratio consistent with the expectations for strongly interacting medium @xcite .\",\n \"although recent work seem to question the applicability of ideal hydro @xcite , most theories agree that the matter created at rhic is extremely dense , with the hydrodynamic description applicability limits extending to higher @xmath0 for more central collisions .\",\n \"flow results provide strong indications for partonic nature of the medium : constituent quark scaling observed for all measured hadron species ( including @xmath6 and @xmath5 with their small hadronic interaction cross - sections ) points on relevance of partonic degrees of freedom at hadronization @xcite .\",\n \"similar results are observed in the cu+cu collisions although the overall @xmath11 values are lower at a given centrality for the cu+cu compared to au+au at the same energy .\",\n \"new result reported recently by star on non - triggered two - particle correlations provide independent means to extract and cross - check azimuthal anisotropy parameters , but also to characterize other processes that induce relative angular correlations between the particles pairs . in this analysis di - hadron correlation formed with no transverse momentum restrictions on either hadron\",\n \"is used to study centrality evolution of characteristic structures in relative azimuth and pseudo - rapidity .\",\n \"it has been shown that the resulting correlation can be decomposed into a few structures , and information related to the individual sources can be extracted @xcite . per - particle\",\n \"pair densities for various centrality bins of 200 gev minimum bias au+au data sample are shown in figure 1 .\",\n \"minijet contribution , measured as the same - side two - dimensional gaussian correlation structure , was found to exhibit a threshold behavior .\",\n \"while approximate binary scaling is observed from @xmath8 and most peripheral au+au to mid - central collisions , a sharp transition is found for both 200 and 62 gev au+au data at about 55% and 40% event centrality , respectively . as shown in figure 2 , from this point\",\n \"the minijet peak amplitude exhibits rapid growth and the peak width in relative pseudo - rapidity broadens by more than a factor of 2 . here\",\n \"the transverse density , calculated as @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is initial collision overlap area s from glauber model , is used as a centrality measure .\",\n \"also shown in figure 2 is the total yield or `` volume '' of the minijet peak .\",\n \"it is estimated to include approximately one third of all produced particles in central collisions .\"\n ],\n [\n \"novel features have been also observed by star in the triggered correlations .\",\n \"early results on the disappearance of away - side jet ( in certain kinematic range ) unambiguously established the presence of the jet quenching phenomena at rhic @xcite .\",\n \"experimental observations are found to be consistent with theoretical expectations for partonic energy loss @xcite , prompting more studies of the mechanisms of jet - medium interactions .\",\n \"two - dimensional study of the correlation structures for charged hadrons associated with a high-@xmath0 trigger shows shape modifications in both @xmath14 and @xmath15 dimensions compared to a @xmath8 reference . within a two - component approach the intermediate @xmath0 structure\",\n \"can be decomposed into a jet - like part , and the so - called `` ridge '' .\",\n \"the jet part appears similar in shape to the structures seen in @xmath8 data , while `` ridge '' resembles properties of the bulk medium .\",\n \"left panel of figure 3 illustrates the ridge - long range @xmath15 structure accompanying the jet peak in central 200 gev au+au collisions@xcite .\",\n \"jet - medium interaction is likely to be the origin of the ridge formation and modification of the jet - like peaks .\",\n \"di - hadron correlations with identified hadrons provide additional means to study parton propagation in the medium .\",\n \"measurements of identified particle spectra and ratios for associated hadrons in the jet cones and ridges could address the issues of color - charge dependence of energy loss , presence of meson / baryon effects and interplay between various hadronization scenarios .\",\n \"strong enhancement of baryon production at intermediate momentum range in inclusive measurements was theorized as an evidence for quark coalescence . however , in azimuthal correlations with the hyperon - triggers significant jet - like structures were observed for all species of hyperons ( including @xmath6 ) @xcite , which contradicts initial expectations from coalescence picture .\",\n \"associated hadron yields in ( multi)strange hadron correlations show no dependence on strangeness content . following those observations , a medium response to the propagating parton or `` phantom jet '' was proposed to accommodate the data within the coalescence picture @xcite .\",\n \"this theoretical explanation preserves the correlation in azimuthal space and produces ridge - like structure in pseudo - rapidity . to confront the models and further the understanding of physics mechanisms producing the ridge , it was essential to extend the correlation studies into @xmath15-@xmath14 space separately for baryons and mesons .\",\n \"preliminary star results show significant differences in strange ( central panel of figure 3 ) and non - strange ( figure 3 , right ) baryon to meson ratios measured in jet part around a 4 gev/@xmath16 triggers , with respect to the ridge part .\",\n \"the jet - part ratios for @xmath17 and @xmath18 are found to be significantly lower in central au+au collisions compared to non - triggered distributions , and are consistent with the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 data @xcite . at the same time\",\n \", the ridge ratios suggest relative baryon enhancement for both strange and non - strange species , which might be related to direct fragmentation of the gluons , radiated of the hard - scattered quark , or their subsequent recombination with the medium partons .\",\n \"higher statistics a+a data samples , expected to be collected in future runs , are required to address ridge hadro - chemistry in more details .\",\n \"-@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .\",\n \"@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions . , title=\\\"fig:\\\",height=120 ] -@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .\",\n \"@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison\",\n \"are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig:\\\",height=120 ] -@xmath14 di - hadron correlation in 200 gev 12% central au+au collisions for hadronic triggers with @xmath19 gev/@xmath16 and associate hadrons with @xmath20 gev/@xmath16 .\",\n \"@xmath18 ( center ) and @xmath17 ( right ) ratios as function of @xmath0 for inclusive data , and ridge and jet parts in 200 gev a+a data . shown for comparison are the inclusive ratios from 200 gev @xmath8 and/or d+au collisions .\",\n \", title=\\\"fig:\\\",height=120 ] to add yet another dimension to the ridge studies , one can bring in additional particle to the correlation to explore internal structure of the observed peak .\",\n \"preliminary results of three - particle triggered correlation analysis for unidentified hadrons are presented in figure 4 for minimum bias d+au , peripheral and central au+au collisions at 200 gev .\",\n \"a jet - like peak is observed in all three correlations at small relative pseudo - rapidity values .\",\n \"in addition , a uniform distribution of associated yields is observed in au+au collisions , particularly , for most central events .\",\n \"this observation is quite puzzling for ridge phenomenology , contradicting to model predictions @xcite .\",\n \"specifically we note the absence of axial strips in the correlation structure .\",\n \"axial strips in three - particle correlation should be formed by associate hadron pairs , in which one of the hadrons is coming from the cone - part , and the other one - from the ridge .\",\n \"absence of these strips thus suggests complete decoupling of jet and ridge events .\",\n \"albeit the current statistic limitations , these early results have already provided more stringent constraints on the interpretation of ridge formation .\",\n \"full jet reconstruction could provide new means to measure the energy loss of propagating partons .\",\n \"experimental techniques for such reconstruction have been successfully used in elementary collision experiments .\",\n \"recently full jet reconstruction was attempted for the first time for heavy ion events @xcite .\",\n \"a combination of charged hadron measurements from the tpc and neutral energy measurements from electro - magnetic calorimeter were utilized in star for this analysis .\",\n \"left panel of figure 5 depicts a 47 gev single jet from 20% central high - tower triggered ( ht ) au+au data of 200 gev .\",\n \"the aim of this analysis is to quantify the jet energy loss by detailed studies of possible modification in the fragmentation functions due to quenching effects in au+au with respect to @xmath8 reference measurements .\",\n \"preliminary results from this study are shown in the right panel of figure 5 , where fragmentation functions , defined as @xmath21 , are compared for two colliding systems .\",\n \"no modification in the fragmentation functions in excess of 10 - 20% is observed within the uncertainties from utilizing the current jet finding algorithms and background subtraction procedures .\",\n \"this preliminary conclusion depends heavily on the assumptions of pythia fragmentation , and could be additionally affected by the bias induced in the jet - sample by applying background - suppressing analysis cuts .\",\n \"this work will be continued with the anticipated higher statistics au+au data in the coming years .\",\n \"shaded area indicates the region where au+au measurement are dominated by the underlying background.,title=\\\"fig:\\\",height=151 ] data .\",\n \"shaded area indicates the region where au+au measurement are dominated by the underlying background.,title=\\\"fig:\\\",height=136 ]\"\n ],\n [\n \"new physics focus will soon be added to the existing experimental program at rhic @xcite .\",\n \"the compelling evidences gathered for the new form of matter created in heavy ion collisions , called for more explorations of the qcd phase diagram .\",\n \"the phase diagram , defined in terms of temperature ( t ) with respect to the baryon chemical potential ( @xmath22 ) , is believed to contain a number of phase boundaries , including the one that separates qgp partonic degrees of freedom from the ordinary ( hadronic gas ) matter .\",\n \"lattice qcd ( lqcd ) predicts that in zero-@xmath22 limit the phase transition occurs as a smooth cross - over , while at higher @xmath22 values it is expected to be a first order transition . a critical point ( cp )\",\n \"is expected on a phase diagram , marking the location where qgp phase transition will change from a cross - over to a first order transition . in the absence of analytical solution\",\n \"various approximation techniques are used in the theoretical calculations , with variations of lattice spacing , assumptions of quark masses and flavors , etc @xcite .\",\n \"the resulting predictions with regard to the exact cp location vary considerably . in the coming years star\",\n \"will engage in the beam energy scan program , continuing years of research at ags , sps , and rhic itself . to locate the critical point\",\n \"the energy scan program will vary incident energies to achieve desirable variations of t and @xmath22 .\",\n \"decreasing the center - of - mass energies leads to formation of colder matter with higher baryon potential , allowing one to move across the phase map . with the detailed scan star\",\n \"will search for various cp signatures , as well as investigate the evolution of medium properties indicative of the non - hadronic matter .\",\n \"novel phenomena , such as constituent quark scaling of the elliptic flow , hadron suppression at high-@xmath0 sigh signal the onset of deconfinment . from theory ,\",\n \"the divergences are expected for the baryon number and the net charge susceptibilities , as well as for the specific heat near the critical point .\",\n \"such divergences might lead to large fluctuations in a number of physical parameters , including baryon number density , quark number , and charge , which could be observed experimentally in hadronic yields , net - charge and mean-@xmath0 fluctuations , as well as particle ratios ( @xmath23 , @xmath17 , etc ) .\",\n \"previous experimental results might already provide some hints regarding the cp location .\",\n \"one such example is the excitation function for the @xmath24 ratio , that shows a drastic change - over near the center - of - mass energy of 8 gev ( figure 6 ) .\",\n \"it is suggested that the `` horn '' feature could be linked directly to the qcd phase transition @xcite .\",\n \"the rhic energy scan program will span a range of energies going slightly below that , covering a suggested region of ( t,@xmath22 ) values from most theoretical expectations .\",\n \"star experiment is uniquely suited for the search armed not only by aforementioned pid capabilities , further enhanced by the completion of the full tof barrel , but also by full azimuthal coverage with large acceptance , which is essential for all fluctuation measurements .\",\n \"the physics impact of fluctuation measurements , for example in mean-@xmath0 , has been already shown for the available rhic energies , providing essential baseline for the low energy scan .\",\n \"ratio ; the @xmath25 is shown with the open ones .\",\n \"star symbols depict first results for mid - rapidity kaon to pion ratios from 9.2 gev au+au collisions.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] the energy scan has essentially begun in star with the systematic studies of all available rhic energies : 200 , 130 , 62.4 and 19.6 gev . in the most recent run (\",\n \"run 8) an engineering study was undertaken by the collider and accelerator department in conjunction with the energy scan program . during this study ,\",\n \"the accelerator physicists demonstrated successful developments on injection and collisions of au ions at @xmath26 gev .\",\n \"star was able to record the first low energy collisions , collecting about 3000 good events suitable for physics analysis . despite such limited statistics ,\",\n \"first results for identified hadron spectra , azimuthal anisotropy measurements and pion interferometry were already obtained @xcite .\",\n \"new data points added to the studies of the @xmath23 ratio systematics illustrate these achievements in figure 6 . with star s proven performance at low energy we are looking forward for new data in upcoming runs to further explore the qcd phase diagram and pin - point the location of the critical point .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we have discussed selected recent results from ongoing correlation analyses from star experiment . the results on ridge properties from triggered and non - triggered correlation studies were highlighted .\",\n \"the large baryon to meson ratios , the uniformity of the ridge yield in @xmath15-@xmath15 space on event - by - event basis is suggestive of the bulk matter being the ridge origin .\",\n \"first attempts towards full jet reconstruction in heavy ion collisions hold a lot of potential to provide further constraints on energy loss in qcd medium .\",\n \"the data sample currently available is limited in statistics to fully exploit this technique . in the coming years\",\n \", star will continue collecting top energy data for @xmath8 and au+au collisions , providing the possibilities for more differential analyses .\",\n \"another direction of star physics program is to partake in the rhic energy scan .\",\n \"we will explore the qcd phase diagram in search for the onset of deconfinement and the location of critical point .\",\n \"star has demonstrated the readiness to deliver physics results for the program with the analysis of the recent low energy test run .\"\n ],\n [\n \"10 adams j _ et al .\",\n \"_ 2005 _ nucl . phys . _ * a*757 102 rafelski j and muller b 1982 _ phys .\",\n \"lett . _ * 48 * 1066 timmins a _\",\n \"these proceedings _ xu z _ these proceedings _ ackermann k _\",\n \"_ 2001 _ phys .\",\n \"lett . _ * 86 * ( 2001 ) 402 romatschke p and romatschke u 2007 _ phys .\",\n \"lett . _ * 99 * 172301 tang a 2008 _ nucl - ex:_0808.2144 abelev b _\",\n \"_ 2007 _ phys.rev.lett . _ * 99 * 112301 ; abelev b _ et al .\",\n \"_ 2007_phys.rev . _\",\n \"* c*75 054906\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":96,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"1702.06621"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["in june 2015 , the large hadron collider ( lhc ) has resumed its physics program with proton - proton ( pp ) collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev .","currently , this is the highest centre - of - mass energy reached in the laboratory .","a full description of particle production in pp collisions can not be obtained from perturbative quantum chromodynamics and hence modelling efforts typically employ various empirical components that have to be adjusted based on experimental data .","the measurement of light flavour particles production in pp collisions provides important input for event generators to model the soft parton interactions and the hadronization processes .","furthermore , pp collisions are used as reference to isolate medium effects present in larger colliding systems .","previous alice measurements @xcite , @xcite , @xcite on identified particles in pp collisions at lower energies show that the models usually give a fair description of the shapes of the @xmath1 spectra but fail on the description of the pion , kaon and proton yields .","@xmath5 , k@xmath6 , p and @xmath7 are identified in the rapidity window @xmath8 0.5 using several particle identification ( pid ) techniques in the different alice sub - detectors : the inner tracking system ( its ) , the time projection chamber ( tpc ) , the time of flight detector ( tof ) and high momentum particle identification detector ( hmpid ) .","the combined information of these detectors in different @xmath1 regions allows us to measure the particle production in the region starting from 150 mev/_c _ up to 20 gev/_c_. the @xmath9 and @xmath10 mesons are measured with invariant - mass analyses via the reconstruction of their hadronic decays .","the combinatorial background is subtracted using either a like - sign or event mixing technique .","the resulting invariant - mass distributions are then fitted .","previous measurements by alice and details on the analysis procedure can be found in @xcite .","the multi - strange @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 baryons are reconstructed via their weak hadronic decay products .","candidates are selected with restrictions on the topology of the decay and the signal is extracted from the resulting invariant mass distributions .","the full analysis procedure is described in @xcite .","the @xmath1-dependent @xmath15 and @xmath16 ratios measured in central rapidity ( @xmath17 0.5 ) at @xmath4 = 2.76 , 7.0 and 13 tev are shown in fig .","[ ratios ] . the comparison to pythia 8 @xcite ( monash-2013 @xcite ) for the different energies","is also shown . within the systematic uncertainties","the @xmath16 ratio is consistent for the three different energies .","the @xmath15 ratio for the low - intermediate @xmath1 region shows a slight shift towards higher @xmath1 when increasing @xmath4 . within our systematic uncertainties","the ratio is compatible for the three different energies in the @xmath1 region above 10 gev/_c_. this shift is also observed on the monte carlo predictions from the pythia 8 model . the origin of the peak in pythia 8 is attributed to the colour reconnection mechanism @xcite , and is expected to become more important at higher centre - of - mass energy . the @xmath1-integrated @xmath16 and @xmath15 ratios in pp collisions as a function of @xmath4 are shown in fig.[ratios_energies ] .","results at different energies for different experiments are also shown .","results from e735 at @xmath4 = 0.3 , 0.54 , 1.0 and 1.8 tev @xcite , @xcite , from phenix at @xmath4 = 62.4 and 200 gev @xcite and cms at @xmath4 = 0.9 , 2.76 and 7 tev @xcite are compared for both particle ratios .","the last added point at 13 tev confirms the similar trend and saturation for @xmath18 900 gev observed in alice previous measurements .","the hyperon - to - pion ratio as a function of @xmath4 measured in alice is shown in fig .","[ hyperon_ratio ] . in comparison with the kaon- and proton - to - pion ratio","the strange- and multi - strange - to - pion ratios show a hint of increase at 13 tev with respect to the lower collision energies .","this enhanced production may be related to the enhancement observed as a function of multiplicity in pp collisions at @xmath4 = 7 tev @xcite , as the charged particle multiplicity density increases with the collision energy .","the @xmath9 and @xmath10 meson production has been also measured in pp collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev .","the @xmath1-integrated @xmath19 and @xmath20 ratios are shown in fig .","[ ratios_resonances ] .","however , no energy evolution is observed in the range from rhic to the highest lhc energy .","the @xmath1 dependence of the @xmath21 and @xmath16 is the same at lhc energies within our systematic errors .","pythia 8 describes the shape but exhibits large deviations from the data for transverse momenta larger than 2 gev/_c_. above @xmath22 900 gev the @xmath21 and @xmath16 ratios are energy independent within systematic uncertainties . the relative production of strange resonances ( @xmath19 and @xmath20 ) remains constant within a wide range of centre of mass energy .","multiplicity dependent studies in pp collisions at 13 tev will help disentangle the role of collision energy and event multiplicity in the identified particle production of pp collisions .","9 alice collaboration 2011 , _ eur . phys .","j. c _ * 71 * 1655 .","alice collaboration 2014 , _ phys .","lett . b _ * 736 * 196 - 207 .","alice collaboration 2015 , _ eur phys .","j.c _ * 75 * 226 .","alice collaboration 2012 , _ eur .","j. c _ * 72 * 2183 .","alice collaboration 2012 , _ phys .","b _ * 712 * 309 - 318 .","t. sjstrand , s. mrenna , and p. z. skands 2008 , _ comput .","commun . _ * 178 * 852 - 867 .","z. skands , s. carrazza , and j. rojo 2014 , _ eur .","j. c _ * 74*. e735 collaboration , 1993 _ phys.rev .","d _ * 48 * 984 - 997 .","e735 collaboration 1992 , _ phys.rev .","d _ * 46 * 2773 - 2786 .","phenix collaboration 2011 , _ phys.rev .","c _ * 83 * 064903 .","cms collaboration 2012 , _ eur.phys.j .","c _ * 72 * 2164 .","alice collaboration 2016 , arxiv:1606.07424 [ nucl - ex ] ."],"string":"[\n \"in june 2015 , the large hadron collider ( lhc ) has resumed its physics program with proton - proton ( pp ) collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev .\",\n \"currently , this is the highest centre - of - mass energy reached in the laboratory .\",\n \"a full description of particle production in pp collisions can not be obtained from perturbative quantum chromodynamics and hence modelling efforts typically employ various empirical components that have to be adjusted based on experimental data .\",\n \"the measurement of light flavour particles production in pp collisions provides important input for event generators to model the soft parton interactions and the hadronization processes .\",\n \"furthermore , pp collisions are used as reference to isolate medium effects present in larger colliding systems .\",\n \"previous alice measurements @xcite , @xcite , @xcite on identified particles in pp collisions at lower energies show that the models usually give a fair description of the shapes of the @xmath1 spectra but fail on the description of the pion , kaon and proton yields .\",\n \"@xmath5 , k@xmath6 , p and @xmath7 are identified in the rapidity window @xmath8 0.5 using several particle identification ( pid ) techniques in the different alice sub - detectors : the inner tracking system ( its ) , the time projection chamber ( tpc ) , the time of flight detector ( tof ) and high momentum particle identification detector ( hmpid ) .\",\n \"the combined information of these detectors in different @xmath1 regions allows us to measure the particle production in the region starting from 150 mev/_c _ up to 20 gev/_c_. the @xmath9 and @xmath10 mesons are measured with invariant - mass analyses via the reconstruction of their hadronic decays .\",\n \"the combinatorial background is subtracted using either a like - sign or event mixing technique .\",\n \"the resulting invariant - mass distributions are then fitted .\",\n \"previous measurements by alice and details on the analysis procedure can be found in @xcite .\",\n \"the multi - strange @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 baryons are reconstructed via their weak hadronic decay products .\",\n \"candidates are selected with restrictions on the topology of the decay and the signal is extracted from the resulting invariant mass distributions .\",\n \"the full analysis procedure is described in @xcite .\",\n \"the @xmath1-dependent @xmath15 and @xmath16 ratios measured in central rapidity ( @xmath17 0.5 ) at @xmath4 = 2.76 , 7.0 and 13 tev are shown in fig .\",\n \"[ ratios ] . the comparison to pythia 8 @xcite ( monash-2013 @xcite ) for the different energies\",\n \"is also shown . within the systematic uncertainties\",\n \"the @xmath16 ratio is consistent for the three different energies .\",\n \"the @xmath15 ratio for the low - intermediate @xmath1 region shows a slight shift towards higher @xmath1 when increasing @xmath4 . within our systematic uncertainties\",\n \"the ratio is compatible for the three different energies in the @xmath1 region above 10 gev/_c_. this shift is also observed on the monte carlo predictions from the pythia 8 model . the origin of the peak in pythia 8 is attributed to the colour reconnection mechanism @xcite , and is expected to become more important at higher centre - of - mass energy . the @xmath1-integrated @xmath16 and @xmath15 ratios in pp collisions as a function of @xmath4 are shown in fig.[ratios_energies ] .\",\n \"results at different energies for different experiments are also shown .\",\n \"results from e735 at @xmath4 = 0.3 , 0.54 , 1.0 and 1.8 tev @xcite , @xcite , from phenix at @xmath4 = 62.4 and 200 gev @xcite and cms at @xmath4 = 0.9 , 2.76 and 7 tev @xcite are compared for both particle ratios .\",\n \"the last added point at 13 tev confirms the similar trend and saturation for @xmath18 900 gev observed in alice previous measurements .\",\n \"the hyperon - to - pion ratio as a function of @xmath4 measured in alice is shown in fig .\",\n \"[ hyperon_ratio ] . in comparison with the kaon- and proton - to - pion ratio\",\n \"the strange- and multi - strange - to - pion ratios show a hint of increase at 13 tev with respect to the lower collision energies .\",\n \"this enhanced production may be related to the enhancement observed as a function of multiplicity in pp collisions at @xmath4 = 7 tev @xcite , as the charged particle multiplicity density increases with the collision energy .\",\n \"the @xmath9 and @xmath10 meson production has been also measured in pp collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev .\",\n \"the @xmath1-integrated @xmath19 and @xmath20 ratios are shown in fig .\",\n \"[ ratios_resonances ] .\",\n \"however , no energy evolution is observed in the range from rhic to the highest lhc energy .\",\n \"the @xmath1 dependence of the @xmath21 and @xmath16 is the same at lhc energies within our systematic errors .\",\n \"pythia 8 describes the shape but exhibits large deviations from the data for transverse momenta larger than 2 gev/_c_. above @xmath22 900 gev the @xmath21 and @xmath16 ratios are energy independent within systematic uncertainties . the relative production of strange resonances ( @xmath19 and @xmath20 ) remains constant within a wide range of centre of mass energy .\",\n \"multiplicity dependent studies in pp collisions at 13 tev will help disentangle the role of collision energy and event multiplicity in the identified particle production of pp collisions .\",\n \"9 alice collaboration 2011 , _ eur . phys .\",\n \"j. c _ * 71 * 1655 .\",\n \"alice collaboration 2014 , _ phys .\",\n \"lett . b _ * 736 * 196 - 207 .\",\n \"alice collaboration 2015 , _ eur phys .\",\n \"j.c _ * 75 * 226 .\",\n \"alice collaboration 2012 , _ eur .\",\n \"j. c _ * 72 * 2183 .\",\n \"alice collaboration 2012 , _ phys .\",\n \"b _ * 712 * 309 - 318 .\",\n \"t. sjstrand , s. mrenna , and p. z. skands 2008 , _ comput .\",\n \"commun . _ * 178 * 852 - 867 .\",\n \"z. skands , s. carrazza , and j. rojo 2014 , _ eur .\",\n \"j. c _ * 74*. e735 collaboration , 1993 _ phys.rev .\",\n \"d _ * 48 * 984 - 997 .\",\n \"e735 collaboration 1992 , _ phys.rev .\",\n \"d _ * 46 * 2773 - 2786 .\",\n \"phenix collaboration 2011 , _ phys.rev .\",\n \"c _ * 83 * 064903 .\",\n \"cms collaboration 2012 , _ eur.phys.j .\",\n \"c _ * 72 * 2164 .\",\n \"alice collaboration 2016 , arxiv:1606.07424 [ nucl - ex ] .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> the alice detector has excellent particle identification ( pid ) capabilities in the central barrel ( @xmath0 0.9 ) . </S>","<S> this allows identified hadron production to be measured over a wide transverse momentum ( @xmath1 ) range , using different sub - detectors and techniques : their specific energy loss ( d@xmath2/d@xmath3 ) , the velocity determination via time - of - flight measurement , the cherenkov angle or their characteristic weak decay topology . </S>","<S> results on identified light flavour hadron production at mid - rapidity measured by alice in proton - proton collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev are presented and compared with previous measurements performed at lower energies . </S>","<S> the results cover a wide range of particle species including long - lived hadrons , resonances and multi - strange baryons over the @xmath1 range from 150 mev/_c _ up to 20 gev/_c _ , depending on the particle species . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> the alice detector has excellent particle identification ( pid ) capabilities in the central barrel ( @xmath0 0.9 ) . </S>\",\n \"<S> this allows identified hadron production to be measured over a wide transverse momentum ( @xmath1 ) range , using different sub - detectors and techniques : their specific energy loss ( d@xmath2/d@xmath3 ) , the velocity determination via time - of - flight measurement , the cherenkov angle or their characteristic weak decay topology . </S>\",\n \"<S> results on identified light flavour hadron production at mid - rapidity measured by alice in proton - proton collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev are presented and compared with previous measurements performed at lower energies . </S>\",\n \"<S> the results cover a wide range of particle species including long - lived hadrons , resonances and multi - strange baryons over the @xmath1 range from 150 mev/_c _ up to 20 gev/_c _ , depending on the particle species . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","particle identification","results","conclusions","references"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"particle identification\",\n \"results\",\n \"conclusions\",\n \"references\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["in june 2015 , the large hadron collider ( lhc ) has resumed its physics program with proton - proton ( pp ) collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev .","currently , this is the highest centre - of - mass energy reached in the laboratory .","a full description of particle production in pp collisions can not be obtained from perturbative quantum chromodynamics and hence modelling efforts typically employ various empirical components that have to be adjusted based on experimental data .","the measurement of light flavour particles production in pp collisions provides important input for event generators to model the soft parton interactions and the hadronization processes .","furthermore , pp collisions are used as reference to isolate medium effects present in larger colliding systems .","previous alice measurements @xcite , @xcite , @xcite on identified particles in pp collisions at lower energies show that the models usually give a fair description of the shapes of the @xmath1 spectra but fail on the description of the pion , kaon and proton yields ."],["@xmath5 , k@xmath6 , p and @xmath7 are identified in the rapidity window @xmath8 0.5 using several particle identification ( pid ) techniques in the different alice sub - detectors : the inner tracking system ( its ) , the time projection chamber ( tpc ) , the time of flight detector ( tof ) and high momentum particle identification detector ( hmpid ) .","the combined information of these detectors in different @xmath1 regions allows us to measure the particle production in the region starting from 150 mev/_c _ up to 20 gev/_c_. the @xmath9 and @xmath10 mesons are measured with invariant - mass analyses via the reconstruction of their hadronic decays .","the combinatorial background is subtracted using either a like - sign or event mixing technique .","the resulting invariant - mass distributions are then fitted .","previous measurements by alice and details on the analysis procedure can be found in @xcite .","the multi - strange @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 baryons are reconstructed via their weak hadronic decay products .","candidates are selected with restrictions on the topology of the decay and the signal is extracted from the resulting invariant mass distributions .","the full analysis procedure is described in @xcite ."],["the @xmath1-dependent @xmath15 and @xmath16 ratios measured in central rapidity ( @xmath17 0.5 ) at @xmath4 = 2.76 , 7.0 and 13 tev are shown in fig .","[ ratios ] . the comparison to pythia 8 @xcite ( monash-2013 @xcite ) for the different energies","is also shown . within the systematic uncertainties","the @xmath16 ratio is consistent for the three different energies .","the @xmath15 ratio for the low - intermediate @xmath1 region shows a slight shift towards higher @xmath1 when increasing @xmath4 . within our systematic uncertainties","the ratio is compatible for the three different energies in the @xmath1 region above 10 gev/_c_. this shift is also observed on the monte carlo predictions from the pythia 8 model . the origin of the peak in pythia 8 is attributed to the colour reconnection mechanism @xcite , and is expected to become more important at higher centre - of - mass energy . the @xmath1-integrated @xmath16 and @xmath15 ratios in pp collisions as a function of @xmath4 are shown in fig.[ratios_energies ] .","results at different energies for different experiments are also shown .","results from e735 at @xmath4 = 0.3 , 0.54 , 1.0 and 1.8 tev @xcite , @xcite , from phenix at @xmath4 = 62.4 and 200 gev @xcite and cms at @xmath4 = 0.9 , 2.76 and 7 tev @xcite are compared for both particle ratios .","the last added point at 13 tev confirms the similar trend and saturation for @xmath18 900 gev observed in alice previous measurements .","the hyperon - to - pion ratio as a function of @xmath4 measured in alice is shown in fig .","[ hyperon_ratio ] . in comparison with the kaon- and proton - to - pion ratio","the strange- and multi - strange - to - pion ratios show a hint of increase at 13 tev with respect to the lower collision energies .","this enhanced production may be related to the enhancement observed as a function of multiplicity in pp collisions at @xmath4 = 7 tev @xcite , as the charged particle multiplicity density increases with the collision energy .","the @xmath9 and @xmath10 meson production has been also measured in pp collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev .","the @xmath1-integrated @xmath19 and @xmath20 ratios are shown in fig .","[ ratios_resonances ] .","however , no energy evolution is observed in the range from rhic to the highest lhc energy ."],["the @xmath1 dependence of the @xmath21 and @xmath16 is the same at lhc energies within our systematic errors .","pythia 8 describes the shape but exhibits large deviations from the data for transverse momenta larger than 2 gev/_c_. above @xmath22 900 gev the @xmath21 and @xmath16 ratios are energy independent within systematic uncertainties . the relative production of strange resonances ( @xmath19 and @xmath20 ) remains constant within a wide range of centre of mass energy .","multiplicity dependent studies in pp collisions at 13 tev will help disentangle the role of collision energy and event multiplicity in the identified particle production of pp collisions ."],["9 alice collaboration 2011 , _ eur . phys .","j. c _ * 71 * 1655 .","alice collaboration 2014 , _ phys .","lett . b _ * 736 * 196 - 207 .","alice collaboration 2015 , _ eur phys .","j.c _ * 75 * 226 .","alice collaboration 2012 , _ eur .","j. c _ * 72 * 2183 .","alice collaboration 2012 , _ phys .","b _ * 712 * 309 - 318 .","t. sjstrand , s. mrenna , and p. z. skands 2008 , _ comput .","commun . _ * 178 * 852 - 867 .","z. skands , s. carrazza , and j. rojo 2014 , _ eur .","j. c _ * 74*. e735 collaboration , 1993 _ phys.rev .","d _ * 48 * 984 - 997 .","e735 collaboration 1992 , _ phys.rev .","d _ * 46 * 2773 - 2786 .","phenix collaboration 2011 , _ phys.rev .","c _ * 83 * 064903 .","cms collaboration 2012 , _ eur.phys.j .","c _ * 72 * 2164 .","alice collaboration 2016 , arxiv:1606.07424 [ nucl - ex ] ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"in june 2015 , the large hadron collider ( lhc ) has resumed its physics program with proton - proton ( pp ) collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev .\",\n \"currently , this is the highest centre - of - mass energy reached in the laboratory .\",\n \"a full description of particle production in pp collisions can not be obtained from perturbative quantum chromodynamics and hence modelling efforts typically employ various empirical components that have to be adjusted based on experimental data .\",\n \"the measurement of light flavour particles production in pp collisions provides important input for event generators to model the soft parton interactions and the hadronization processes .\",\n \"furthermore , pp collisions are used as reference to isolate medium effects present in larger colliding systems .\",\n \"previous alice measurements @xcite , @xcite , @xcite on identified particles in pp collisions at lower energies show that the models usually give a fair description of the shapes of the @xmath1 spectra but fail on the description of the pion , kaon and proton yields .\"\n ],\n [\n \"@xmath5 , k@xmath6 , p and @xmath7 are identified in the rapidity window @xmath8 0.5 using several particle identification ( pid ) techniques in the different alice sub - detectors : the inner tracking system ( its ) , the time projection chamber ( tpc ) , the time of flight detector ( tof ) and high momentum particle identification detector ( hmpid ) .\",\n \"the combined information of these detectors in different @xmath1 regions allows us to measure the particle production in the region starting from 150 mev/_c _ up to 20 gev/_c_. the @xmath9 and @xmath10 mesons are measured with invariant - mass analyses via the reconstruction of their hadronic decays .\",\n \"the combinatorial background is subtracted using either a like - sign or event mixing technique .\",\n \"the resulting invariant - mass distributions are then fitted .\",\n \"previous measurements by alice and details on the analysis procedure can be found in @xcite .\",\n \"the multi - strange @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 baryons are reconstructed via their weak hadronic decay products .\",\n \"candidates are selected with restrictions on the topology of the decay and the signal is extracted from the resulting invariant mass distributions .\",\n \"the full analysis procedure is described in @xcite .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the @xmath1-dependent @xmath15 and @xmath16 ratios measured in central rapidity ( @xmath17 0.5 ) at @xmath4 = 2.76 , 7.0 and 13 tev are shown in fig .\",\n \"[ ratios ] . the comparison to pythia 8 @xcite ( monash-2013 @xcite ) for the different energies\",\n \"is also shown . within the systematic uncertainties\",\n \"the @xmath16 ratio is consistent for the three different energies .\",\n \"the @xmath15 ratio for the low - intermediate @xmath1 region shows a slight shift towards higher @xmath1 when increasing @xmath4 . within our systematic uncertainties\",\n \"the ratio is compatible for the three different energies in the @xmath1 region above 10 gev/_c_. this shift is also observed on the monte carlo predictions from the pythia 8 model . the origin of the peak in pythia 8 is attributed to the colour reconnection mechanism @xcite , and is expected to become more important at higher centre - of - mass energy . the @xmath1-integrated @xmath16 and @xmath15 ratios in pp collisions as a function of @xmath4 are shown in fig.[ratios_energies ] .\",\n \"results at different energies for different experiments are also shown .\",\n \"results from e735 at @xmath4 = 0.3 , 0.54 , 1.0 and 1.8 tev @xcite , @xcite , from phenix at @xmath4 = 62.4 and 200 gev @xcite and cms at @xmath4 = 0.9 , 2.76 and 7 tev @xcite are compared for both particle ratios .\",\n \"the last added point at 13 tev confirms the similar trend and saturation for @xmath18 900 gev observed in alice previous measurements .\",\n \"the hyperon - to - pion ratio as a function of @xmath4 measured in alice is shown in fig .\",\n \"[ hyperon_ratio ] . in comparison with the kaon- and proton - to - pion ratio\",\n \"the strange- and multi - strange - to - pion ratios show a hint of increase at 13 tev with respect to the lower collision energies .\",\n \"this enhanced production may be related to the enhancement observed as a function of multiplicity in pp collisions at @xmath4 = 7 tev @xcite , as the charged particle multiplicity density increases with the collision energy .\",\n \"the @xmath9 and @xmath10 meson production has been also measured in pp collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev .\",\n \"the @xmath1-integrated @xmath19 and @xmath20 ratios are shown in fig .\",\n \"[ ratios_resonances ] .\",\n \"however , no energy evolution is observed in the range from rhic to the highest lhc energy .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the @xmath1 dependence of the @xmath21 and @xmath16 is the same at lhc energies within our systematic errors .\",\n \"pythia 8 describes the shape but exhibits large deviations from the data for transverse momenta larger than 2 gev/_c_. above @xmath22 900 gev the @xmath21 and @xmath16 ratios are energy independent within systematic uncertainties . the relative production of strange resonances ( @xmath19 and @xmath20 ) remains constant within a wide range of centre of mass energy .\",\n \"multiplicity dependent studies in pp collisions at 13 tev will help disentangle the role of collision energy and event multiplicity in the identified particle production of pp collisions .\"\n ],\n [\n \"9 alice collaboration 2011 , _ eur . phys .\",\n \"j. c _ * 71 * 1655 .\",\n \"alice collaboration 2014 , _ phys .\",\n \"lett . b _ * 736 * 196 - 207 .\",\n \"alice collaboration 2015 , _ eur phys .\",\n \"j.c _ * 75 * 226 .\",\n \"alice collaboration 2012 , _ eur .\",\n \"j. c _ * 72 * 2183 .\",\n \"alice collaboration 2012 , _ phys .\",\n \"b _ * 712 * 309 - 318 .\",\n \"t. sjstrand , s. mrenna , and p. z. skands 2008 , _ comput .\",\n \"commun . _ * 178 * 852 - 867 .\",\n \"z. skands , s. carrazza , and j. rojo 2014 , _ eur .\",\n \"j. c _ * 74*. e735 collaboration , 1993 _ phys.rev .\",\n \"d _ * 48 * 984 - 997 .\",\n \"e735 collaboration 1992 , _ phys.rev .\",\n \"d _ * 46 * 2773 - 2786 .\",\n \"phenix collaboration 2011 , _ phys.rev .\",\n \"c _ * 83 * 064903 .\",\n \"cms collaboration 2012 , _ eur.phys.j .\",\n \"c _ * 72 * 2164 .\",\n \"alice collaboration 2016 , arxiv:1606.07424 [ nucl - ex ] .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":97,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"0907.4446"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["hanle effect measurements ( bommier et al . 1994 ) have shown that quiescent ( non active - region ) filaments have `` inverse '' magnetic polarity , meaning that their transverse field component is opposite in sign to that of the coronal loops crossing high over the photospheric neutral line .","the usual interpretation of this result is that the filament material is supported in the dipped or concave - upward portions of a twisted flux rope ( see , e.g. , van ballegooijen & martens 1989 ; rust & kumar 1994 ; low 1996 ; aulanier & dmoulin 1998 ; amari et al .","1999 ; lites 2005 ; gibson & fan 2006 ) . for this topology ,","it is natural to assume that one sign of helicity prevails throughout the flux rope and its overlying arcade . in an alternative scenario ,","the filament is regarded as a sheared arcade whose intermediate legs or `` barbs '' are rooted in minority polarity on the `` wrong '' side of the neutral line ( martin 1998 ) . in that case , the helicity of the filament itself would be opposite in sign to that of the overlying coronal loops , contrary to most theoretical models .","possible support for this picture comes from the observation of continual flows along the spines and up and down the barbs of filaments ( zirker et al . 1998 ; wang 1999 ; kucera et al .","2003 ; lin et al .","2003 , 2005 ) ; such flows , which may be driven by chromospheric reconnection ( litvinenko & martin 1999 ; martin et al .","2008 ) , seem to obviate the need for static support within magnetic dips , one of the principal arguments in favor of a flux rope geometry .","statistically ( and independently of the flux rope / sheared arcade question ) , it is found that filaments in the northern ( southern ) hemisphere are predominantly `` dextral '' ( `` sinistral '' ) , meaning that their axial fields point to the right ( left ) when viewed from the positive - polarity side of the photospheric neutral line ( martin 1998 ; pevtsov et al .","2003 ; yeates et al . 2007 ; yeates & mackay 2009 ) .","dextral ( sinistral ) filaments have right - bearing ( left - bearing ) barbs but underlie arcades with left - handed ( right - handed ) helicity",". the helicity sign of the overlying arcade can be inferred from the skew of the arcade loops relative to the polarity inversion line ( pil ) .","although the magnetic topology of a stable filament / prominence remains a subject of debate , it is almost universally accepted that an erupting filament and its surrounding field have the structure of a twisted flux rope . in a three - dimensional system ,","the pinching - off of pairs of stretched , opposite - polarity field lines beneath the rising filament will necessarily give rise to a flux rope ; reconnections may occur among the legs / barbs of the filament , between the legs and the overlying arcade , and among the highly distended arcade field lines themselves .","as the bright post - eruption arcade expands outward from the pil , the orientation of the reconnected loops ( seen projected against the photosphere ) will appear to rotate clockwise ( counterclockwise ) if the arcade has right - handed ( left - handed ) helicity ; this apparent rotation is due to the tendency for the loops rooted farther from the pil to cross it more nearly at right angles .","the axes of the erupting filaments themselves are sometimes observed to rotate about the vertical direction . as viewed from above",", this rotation is again usually clockwise if the post - event arcade has right - handed helicity , and counterclockwise if it has left - handed helicity ( for examples , see rust & labonte 2005 ; green et al . 2007 ; wang et al . 2009 ) .","the sense of rotation is consistent with the conversion of field - line twist into writhe ( three - dimensional twisting of the axis itself ) , as predicted by mhd simulations of kink - unstable flux ropes ( linton et al .","1999 ; kliem et al .","2004 ; trk & kliem 2005 ) and of sheared arcades that have been converted into erupting flux ropes via reconnection ( lynch et al .","it is reasonable to assume that the net helicity of the erupting structure is the sum of the helicity of the original filament and that of the surrounding field with which it has become entrained by reconnection ( see berger 1998 ) .","if the barb system and the overlying coronal field have opposite helicity signs , as suggested by martin ( 1998 ) , then in most events the main contribution to the helicity of the erupting structure must come from the surrounding field ( compare also the discussion of ruzmaikin et al .","however , the question arises as to whether the rotation ever occurs in the direction opposite to that implied by the helicity of the overlying arcade , thereby providing stronger support for the barb picture of martin . here","we describe two events observed with the extreme - ultraviolet imaging telescope ( eit ; delaboudinire et al .","1995 ) on the _ solar and heliospheric observatory _","( _ soho _ ) , in which the erupting quiescent filament appeared to rotate counterclockwise but the post - eruption arcade had right - handed helicity .","the sequence of 19.5 nm images in figure 1 shows the eruption of a southern - hemisphere filament on 1999 september 20 .","the dark filament in fact represents the western half of a longer structure that occupies a circular filament channel .","the axis of the erupting feature undergoes a continual counterclockwise rotation between @xmath003:00 and @xmath005:00 ut . in order to exhibit this rotation more clearly",", we have traced the filament spine at successive times and superposed these traces in figure 2 , after shifting them in longitude to correct for the average photospheric rotation .","we note that the observed motions can not be interpreted simply as a straightening of the initially highly curved filament as it rises , which would require both the northern and southern portions of the filament to move eastward ; instead , the northern section moves eastward but the southern section moves westward , consistent with a counterclockwise rotation of the filament axis .","subsequently ( after 04:48 ut ) , the rotation `` overshoots '' near both the northern and southern ends of the erupting filament , which thus kinks into a forward - s shape .","as shown in figure 1 , the post - event arcade with its double row of footpoint brightenings begins to form after @xmath004:36 ut .","in addition , in the images recorded between 04:36 and 05:12 ut , euv brightenings ( circled in figure","1 ) may be seen at the far endpoints of the erupting filament ; these brightenings occur as the filament threads , anchored well outside the filament channel itself , are jerked upward into a vertical orientation ( see wang et al .","2009 ) . from the slant of the post - eruption loops in the image taken at 06:00 ut , and from the apparent clockwise rotation of the loop orientation between 06:00 and 07:13 ut",", we conclude that the overlying arcade has right - handed helicity , even though the filament rotates counterclockwise . the first post - eruption loops ( observed at 06:00 ut ) are located near the original pivot point of the filament rotation , where the traces approximately intersect in figure 2 , suggesting that the instability and rapid upward motion of the filament were initiated in this region .","figure 3 shows the distribution of photospheric magnetic flux underlying the erupting filament . here",", we compare a michelson doppler imager ( mdi ) line - of - sight magnetogram taken at 04:48 ut with the difference between the 19.5 nm images recorded at 04:48 and 04:36 ut . the magnetogram , saturated at @xmath150 g , represents a 5-minute average of higher - cadence data .","the circular filament channel evidently encloses a positive - polarity region . since the northern ( southern ) end of the erupting filament","is rooted in negative - polarity ( positive - polarity ) network flux , the axial field of the filament points toward the left as viewed from the positive - polarity region , and the filament is sinistral according to the chirality definition of martin ( 1998 ) .","correspondingly , an h@xmath2 image taken on september 18 at the big bear solar observatory ( bbso ) shows left - bearing barbs ( figure 4 , top panel ) . as indicated by the 30.4 nm images in the left column of figure 5 , the filament re - forms immediately after the eruption ; however , its northern end now bends westward rather than eastward ( see also the h@xmath2 image in figure 4 , bottom panel ) .","the mdi magnetograms in the right column of figure 5 suggest that this change in the shape of the filament , as well as the eruption itself , may have been associated with the emergence of a small magnetic bipole to the west of the original filament channel .","the new bipole ( circled in the magnetograms taken at 06:27 and 13:19 ut ) appears to have altered the shape of the photospheric neutral line in the vicinity of the filament . in association with this filament event ,","the large angle and spectrometric coronagraph ( lasco ) on _ soho _ observed a faint halo coronal mass ejection ( cme ) with an average speed of 600 km s@xmath3 .","the sequence of eit 30.4 nm images in figure 6 , taken at 6-hourly intervals , shows the disappearance of a high - latitude filament in the southern hemisphere on 2001 september 28 . in the frame","recorded at 13:19 ut , during the eruption itself , the axis of the filament shows a pronounced counterclockwise rotation relative to its pre - eruption orientation .","this kinking into a forward - s shape is seen even more clearly in figure 7 , where we have superposed four successive traces of the filament spine taken between 19:19 ut on september 27 and 13:19 ut on september 28 , after removing the effect of the photospheric differential rotation .","the eruption is shown in more detail in the sequence of 19.5 nm running - difference images in figure 8 .","the post - event arcade begins to form at 15:00 ut , with the appearance of a compact bundle of highly sheared loops that are almost aligned with the filament channel . from the mdi magnetogram ( fourth panel of figure 8)",", we conclude that the western end of this narrow bundle of reconnected loops lies on the negative - polarity side of the photospheric neutral line , implying right - handed helicity . that the overlying arcade is indeed right - handed is confirmed by the subsequently forming loops ( bottom panel of figure 8) , which are rooted farther from the pil and are shifted clockwise relative to the earlier loops .","h@xmath2 images recorded at bbso on september 27 show that the pre - eruption filament had left - bearing barbs ( see figure 9 ) , consistent with sinistral chirality .","filaments are conventionally regarded as cool material supported inside the dips of a helical flux rope of a given `` handedness . ''","if the flux rope becomes unstable , its axis rotates about the direction of ascent , with the rotation being clockwise ( counterclockwise ) if the flux rope has right - handed ( left - handed ) helicity . although observations of filament eruptions have tended to support this picture , we have here described two events in which the filament rotated in the opposite sense to that implied by the handedness of the surrounding arcade .","both of these quiescent filaments were located in the southern hemisphere and had left - bearing barbs ; their axes rotated counterclockwise , even though the post - event arcades were clearly right - handed . by helicity conservation ( berger 1984 ) , the source regions must have had mixed helicity , since the left - handed writhe acquired through the counterclockwise rotation could only have originated in negative helicity embodied as twist or shear in the pre - eruption field .","if the filament barbs are concave - downward features , as advocated by martin ( 1998 ) , their helicity sign or handedness would be opposite to that of the overlying coronal loops .","the direction of rotation of the erupting structure would then depend on whether the barbs or the overlying arcade provides the main contribution to the net helicity . from a preliminary survey of the entire eit database for solar cycle 23",", we were able to determine unambiguously the direction of rotation of an erupting filament in only @xmath010 events .","presumably because of the relatively low cadence of the eit observations , all of these events involved non active - region filaments , of which only the two discussed here rotated in the `` wrong '' sense . in the active region events examined by rust & labonte ( 2005 ) and green et al .","( 2007 ) , the acquired writhe of the erupting filament and the helicity observed in the surrounding field were always of the same sign .","thus , if the barbs and the surrounding field have opposite helicity signs , then the helicity of the overlying arcade must dominate in most eruptions , particularly those occurring in active regions . that the exceptions found here involve quiescent filaments","might be due to the fact that the latter are more likely to have well - developed barb systems than active region filaments . as suggested by wang ( 2001 ) ,","barbs form when flux elements that have become connected to the overlying axial field diffuse across the filament channel and undergo flux cancellation on the other side .","that the helicity tends to be concentrated in the surrounding field rather than in the filament itself is consistent with recent models of active region fields , in which a flux rope is inserted into a potential configuration and the system is allowed to relax , including the effect of a helicity - conserving magnetic diffusion ( bobra et al .","2008 ; su et al .","the observed h@xmath2 filament and surrounding coronal - loop structure are best fit with a highly sheared but weakly twisted flux rope held down by the overlying arcade ; as in a hollow solenoid , the electric currents and magnetic helicity are concentrated in a semi - cylindrical shell around the outer edge of the flux rope , not within its interior , where the field lines are essentially straight and not much current flows .","moreover , for stability , the amount of axial flux must be small compared with the total flux that holds down the filament .","thus it is not surprising that it is the helicity of the surrounding field that usually determines the direction of rotation of an erupting active - region filament .","the event of 1999 september 20 provides support for the hypothesis that some filament eruptions are triggered by the emergence of flux near the filament channel ( see , e.g. , bruzek 1952 ; feynman & martin 1995 ; wang & sheeley 1999 ) . in this particular case ,","the eruption was accompanied by a reconfiguration of both the underlying photospheric neutral line and the shape of the filament itself .","sheeley et al .","( 1975 ) described a rather similar event in which the eastward hook of an h@xmath2 filament disappeared and was replaced by a westward hook that pointed toward a region of newly emerging flux ( the sense in which the filament axis rotated during the eruption is unknown ) .","we are indebted to the eit and mdi teams for the _ soho _ observations , and to bbso / new jersey institute of technology for the h@xmath2 images .","we also thank a. a. van ballegooijen and p. dmoulin for informative discussions , and the referee for helpful comments .","this work was supported by nasa and the office of naval research .","g ( black ) and @xmath4 g ( white ) .","bottom : 19.5 nm running - difference image taken at 04:48 ut .","the locations of the brightenings at the endpoints of the erupted filament are circled in both the mdi and the eit image . as viewed from the positive - polarity region inside the circular filament channel , the axial field points to the left , so that the filament is sinistral . ]","images recorded on 1999 september 18 ( top ) and 1999 september 20 ( bottom ) .","the left - bearing barbs of this southern - hemisphere filament are clearly seen in the pre - eruption image . after the filament erupted early on september 20 , the re - formed structure hooks westward instead of eastward ( see also figure 5 ) . ]"],"string":"[\n \"hanle effect measurements ( bommier et al . 1994 ) have shown that quiescent ( non active - region ) filaments have `` inverse '' magnetic polarity , meaning that their transverse field component is opposite in sign to that of the coronal loops crossing high over the photospheric neutral line .\",\n \"the usual interpretation of this result is that the filament material is supported in the dipped or concave - upward portions of a twisted flux rope ( see , e.g. , van ballegooijen & martens 1989 ; rust & kumar 1994 ; low 1996 ; aulanier & dmoulin 1998 ; amari et al .\",\n \"1999 ; lites 2005 ; gibson & fan 2006 ) . for this topology ,\",\n \"it is natural to assume that one sign of helicity prevails throughout the flux rope and its overlying arcade . in an alternative scenario ,\",\n \"the filament is regarded as a sheared arcade whose intermediate legs or `` barbs '' are rooted in minority polarity on the `` wrong '' side of the neutral line ( martin 1998 ) . in that case , the helicity of the filament itself would be opposite in sign to that of the overlying coronal loops , contrary to most theoretical models .\",\n \"possible support for this picture comes from the observation of continual flows along the spines and up and down the barbs of filaments ( zirker et al . 1998 ; wang 1999 ; kucera et al .\",\n \"2003 ; lin et al .\",\n \"2003 , 2005 ) ; such flows , which may be driven by chromospheric reconnection ( litvinenko & martin 1999 ; martin et al .\",\n \"2008 ) , seem to obviate the need for static support within magnetic dips , one of the principal arguments in favor of a flux rope geometry .\",\n \"statistically ( and independently of the flux rope / sheared arcade question ) , it is found that filaments in the northern ( southern ) hemisphere are predominantly `` dextral '' ( `` sinistral '' ) , meaning that their axial fields point to the right ( left ) when viewed from the positive - polarity side of the photospheric neutral line ( martin 1998 ; pevtsov et al .\",\n \"2003 ; yeates et al . 2007 ; yeates & mackay 2009 ) .\",\n \"dextral ( sinistral ) filaments have right - bearing ( left - bearing ) barbs but underlie arcades with left - handed ( right - handed ) helicity\",\n \". the helicity sign of the overlying arcade can be inferred from the skew of the arcade loops relative to the polarity inversion line ( pil ) .\",\n \"although the magnetic topology of a stable filament / prominence remains a subject of debate , it is almost universally accepted that an erupting filament and its surrounding field have the structure of a twisted flux rope . in a three - dimensional system ,\",\n \"the pinching - off of pairs of stretched , opposite - polarity field lines beneath the rising filament will necessarily give rise to a flux rope ; reconnections may occur among the legs / barbs of the filament , between the legs and the overlying arcade , and among the highly distended arcade field lines themselves .\",\n \"as the bright post - eruption arcade expands outward from the pil , the orientation of the reconnected loops ( seen projected against the photosphere ) will appear to rotate clockwise ( counterclockwise ) if the arcade has right - handed ( left - handed ) helicity ; this apparent rotation is due to the tendency for the loops rooted farther from the pil to cross it more nearly at right angles .\",\n \"the axes of the erupting filaments themselves are sometimes observed to rotate about the vertical direction . as viewed from above\",\n \", this rotation is again usually clockwise if the post - event arcade has right - handed helicity , and counterclockwise if it has left - handed helicity ( for examples , see rust & labonte 2005 ; green et al . 2007 ; wang et al . 2009 ) .\",\n \"the sense of rotation is consistent with the conversion of field - line twist into writhe ( three - dimensional twisting of the axis itself ) , as predicted by mhd simulations of kink - unstable flux ropes ( linton et al .\",\n \"1999 ; kliem et al .\",\n \"2004 ; trk & kliem 2005 ) and of sheared arcades that have been converted into erupting flux ropes via reconnection ( lynch et al .\",\n \"it is reasonable to assume that the net helicity of the erupting structure is the sum of the helicity of the original filament and that of the surrounding field with which it has become entrained by reconnection ( see berger 1998 ) .\",\n \"if the barb system and the overlying coronal field have opposite helicity signs , as suggested by martin ( 1998 ) , then in most events the main contribution to the helicity of the erupting structure must come from the surrounding field ( compare also the discussion of ruzmaikin et al .\",\n \"however , the question arises as to whether the rotation ever occurs in the direction opposite to that implied by the helicity of the overlying arcade , thereby providing stronger support for the barb picture of martin . here\",\n \"we describe two events observed with the extreme - ultraviolet imaging telescope ( eit ; delaboudinire et al .\",\n \"1995 ) on the _ solar and heliospheric observatory _\",\n \"( _ soho _ ) , in which the erupting quiescent filament appeared to rotate counterclockwise but the post - eruption arcade had right - handed helicity .\",\n \"the sequence of 19.5 nm images in figure 1 shows the eruption of a southern - hemisphere filament on 1999 september 20 .\",\n \"the dark filament in fact represents the western half of a longer structure that occupies a circular filament channel .\",\n \"the axis of the erupting feature undergoes a continual counterclockwise rotation between @xmath003:00 and @xmath005:00 ut . in order to exhibit this rotation more clearly\",\n \", we have traced the filament spine at successive times and superposed these traces in figure 2 , after shifting them in longitude to correct for the average photospheric rotation .\",\n \"we note that the observed motions can not be interpreted simply as a straightening of the initially highly curved filament as it rises , which would require both the northern and southern portions of the filament to move eastward ; instead , the northern section moves eastward but the southern section moves westward , consistent with a counterclockwise rotation of the filament axis .\",\n \"subsequently ( after 04:48 ut ) , the rotation `` overshoots '' near both the northern and southern ends of the erupting filament , which thus kinks into a forward - s shape .\",\n \"as shown in figure 1 , the post - event arcade with its double row of footpoint brightenings begins to form after @xmath004:36 ut .\",\n \"in addition , in the images recorded between 04:36 and 05:12 ut , euv brightenings ( circled in figure\",\n \"1 ) may be seen at the far endpoints of the erupting filament ; these brightenings occur as the filament threads , anchored well outside the filament channel itself , are jerked upward into a vertical orientation ( see wang et al .\",\n \"2009 ) . from the slant of the post - eruption loops in the image taken at 06:00 ut , and from the apparent clockwise rotation of the loop orientation between 06:00 and 07:13 ut\",\n \", we conclude that the overlying arcade has right - handed helicity , even though the filament rotates counterclockwise . the first post - eruption loops ( observed at 06:00 ut ) are located near the original pivot point of the filament rotation , where the traces approximately intersect in figure 2 , suggesting that the instability and rapid upward motion of the filament were initiated in this region .\",\n \"figure 3 shows the distribution of photospheric magnetic flux underlying the erupting filament . here\",\n \", we compare a michelson doppler imager ( mdi ) line - of - sight magnetogram taken at 04:48 ut with the difference between the 19.5 nm images recorded at 04:48 and 04:36 ut . the magnetogram , saturated at @xmath150 g , represents a 5-minute average of higher - cadence data .\",\n \"the circular filament channel evidently encloses a positive - polarity region . since the northern ( southern ) end of the erupting filament\",\n \"is rooted in negative - polarity ( positive - polarity ) network flux , the axial field of the filament points toward the left as viewed from the positive - polarity region , and the filament is sinistral according to the chirality definition of martin ( 1998 ) .\",\n \"correspondingly , an h@xmath2 image taken on september 18 at the big bear solar observatory ( bbso ) shows left - bearing barbs ( figure 4 , top panel ) . as indicated by the 30.4 nm images in the left column of figure 5 , the filament re - forms immediately after the eruption ; however , its northern end now bends westward rather than eastward ( see also the h@xmath2 image in figure 4 , bottom panel ) .\",\n \"the mdi magnetograms in the right column of figure 5 suggest that this change in the shape of the filament , as well as the eruption itself , may have been associated with the emergence of a small magnetic bipole to the west of the original filament channel .\",\n \"the new bipole ( circled in the magnetograms taken at 06:27 and 13:19 ut ) appears to have altered the shape of the photospheric neutral line in the vicinity of the filament . in association with this filament event ,\",\n \"the large angle and spectrometric coronagraph ( lasco ) on _ soho _ observed a faint halo coronal mass ejection ( cme ) with an average speed of 600 km s@xmath3 .\",\n \"the sequence of eit 30.4 nm images in figure 6 , taken at 6-hourly intervals , shows the disappearance of a high - latitude filament in the southern hemisphere on 2001 september 28 . in the frame\",\n \"recorded at 13:19 ut , during the eruption itself , the axis of the filament shows a pronounced counterclockwise rotation relative to its pre - eruption orientation .\",\n \"this kinking into a forward - s shape is seen even more clearly in figure 7 , where we have superposed four successive traces of the filament spine taken between 19:19 ut on september 27 and 13:19 ut on september 28 , after removing the effect of the photospheric differential rotation .\",\n \"the eruption is shown in more detail in the sequence of 19.5 nm running - difference images in figure 8 .\",\n \"the post - event arcade begins to form at 15:00 ut , with the appearance of a compact bundle of highly sheared loops that are almost aligned with the filament channel . from the mdi magnetogram ( fourth panel of figure 8)\",\n \", we conclude that the western end of this narrow bundle of reconnected loops lies on the negative - polarity side of the photospheric neutral line , implying right - handed helicity . that the overlying arcade is indeed right - handed is confirmed by the subsequently forming loops ( bottom panel of figure 8) , which are rooted farther from the pil and are shifted clockwise relative to the earlier loops .\",\n \"h@xmath2 images recorded at bbso on september 27 show that the pre - eruption filament had left - bearing barbs ( see figure 9 ) , consistent with sinistral chirality .\",\n \"filaments are conventionally regarded as cool material supported inside the dips of a helical flux rope of a given `` handedness . ''\",\n \"if the flux rope becomes unstable , its axis rotates about the direction of ascent , with the rotation being clockwise ( counterclockwise ) if the flux rope has right - handed ( left - handed ) helicity . although observations of filament eruptions have tended to support this picture , we have here described two events in which the filament rotated in the opposite sense to that implied by the handedness of the surrounding arcade .\",\n \"both of these quiescent filaments were located in the southern hemisphere and had left - bearing barbs ; their axes rotated counterclockwise , even though the post - event arcades were clearly right - handed . by helicity conservation ( berger 1984 ) , the source regions must have had mixed helicity , since the left - handed writhe acquired through the counterclockwise rotation could only have originated in negative helicity embodied as twist or shear in the pre - eruption field .\",\n \"if the filament barbs are concave - downward features , as advocated by martin ( 1998 ) , their helicity sign or handedness would be opposite to that of the overlying coronal loops .\",\n \"the direction of rotation of the erupting structure would then depend on whether the barbs or the overlying arcade provides the main contribution to the net helicity . from a preliminary survey of the entire eit database for solar cycle 23\",\n \", we were able to determine unambiguously the direction of rotation of an erupting filament in only @xmath010 events .\",\n \"presumably because of the relatively low cadence of the eit observations , all of these events involved non active - region filaments , of which only the two discussed here rotated in the `` wrong '' sense . in the active region events examined by rust & labonte ( 2005 ) and green et al .\",\n \"( 2007 ) , the acquired writhe of the erupting filament and the helicity observed in the surrounding field were always of the same sign .\",\n \"thus , if the barbs and the surrounding field have opposite helicity signs , then the helicity of the overlying arcade must dominate in most eruptions , particularly those occurring in active regions . that the exceptions found here involve quiescent filaments\",\n \"might be due to the fact that the latter are more likely to have well - developed barb systems than active region filaments . as suggested by wang ( 2001 ) ,\",\n \"barbs form when flux elements that have become connected to the overlying axial field diffuse across the filament channel and undergo flux cancellation on the other side .\",\n \"that the helicity tends to be concentrated in the surrounding field rather than in the filament itself is consistent with recent models of active region fields , in which a flux rope is inserted into a potential configuration and the system is allowed to relax , including the effect of a helicity - conserving magnetic diffusion ( bobra et al .\",\n \"2008 ; su et al .\",\n \"the observed h@xmath2 filament and surrounding coronal - loop structure are best fit with a highly sheared but weakly twisted flux rope held down by the overlying arcade ; as in a hollow solenoid , the electric currents and magnetic helicity are concentrated in a semi - cylindrical shell around the outer edge of the flux rope , not within its interior , where the field lines are essentially straight and not much current flows .\",\n \"moreover , for stability , the amount of axial flux must be small compared with the total flux that holds down the filament .\",\n \"thus it is not surprising that it is the helicity of the surrounding field that usually determines the direction of rotation of an erupting active - region filament .\",\n \"the event of 1999 september 20 provides support for the hypothesis that some filament eruptions are triggered by the emergence of flux near the filament channel ( see , e.g. , bruzek 1952 ; feynman & martin 1995 ; wang & sheeley 1999 ) . in this particular case ,\",\n \"the eruption was accompanied by a reconfiguration of both the underlying photospheric neutral line and the shape of the filament itself .\",\n \"sheeley et al .\",\n \"( 1975 ) described a rather similar event in which the eastward hook of an h@xmath2 filament disappeared and was replaced by a westward hook that pointed toward a region of newly emerging flux ( the sense in which the filament axis rotated during the eruption is unknown ) .\",\n \"we are indebted to the eit and mdi teams for the _ soho _ observations , and to bbso / new jersey institute of technology for the h@xmath2 images .\",\n \"we also thank a. a. van ballegooijen and p. dmoulin for informative discussions , and the referee for helpful comments .\",\n \"this work was supported by nasa and the office of naval research .\",\n \"g ( black ) and @xmath4 g ( white ) .\",\n \"bottom : 19.5 nm running - difference image taken at 04:48 ut .\",\n \"the locations of the brightenings at the endpoints of the erupted filament are circled in both the mdi and the eit image . as viewed from the positive - polarity region inside the circular filament channel , the axial field points to the left , so that the filament is sinistral . ]\",\n \"images recorded on 1999 september 18 ( top ) and 1999 september 20 ( bottom ) .\",\n \"the left - bearing barbs of this southern - hemisphere filament are clearly seen in the pre - eruption image . after the filament erupted early on september 20 , the re - formed structure hooks westward instead of eastward ( see also figure 5 ) . ]\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> erupting filaments are sometimes observed to undergo a rotation about the vertical direction as they rise . </S>","<S> this rotation of the filament axis is generally interpreted as a conversion of twist into writhe in a kink - unstable magnetic flux rope . </S>","<S> consistent with this interpretation , the rotation is usually found to be clockwise ( as viewed from above ) if the post - eruption arcade has right - handed helicity , but counterclockwise if it has left - handed helicity . here </S>","<S> , we describe two non active - region filament events recorded with the extreme - ultraviolet imaging telescope ( eit ) on the _ solar and heliospheric observatory _ ( _ soho _ ) , in which the sense of rotation appears to be opposite to that expected from the helicity of the post - event arcade . based on these observations </S>","<S> , we suggest that the rotation of the filament axis is in general determined by the net helicity of the erupting system , and that the axially aligned core of the filament can have the opposite helicity sign to the surrounding field . in most cases , </S>","<S> the surrounding field provides the main contribution to the net helicity . in the events reported here , </S>","<S> however , the helicity associated with the filament `` barbs '' is opposite in sign to and dominates that of the overlying arcade . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> erupting filaments are sometimes observed to undergo a rotation about the vertical direction as they rise . </S>\",\n \"<S> this rotation of the filament axis is generally interpreted as a conversion of twist into writhe in a kink - unstable magnetic flux rope . </S>\",\n \"<S> consistent with this interpretation , the rotation is usually found to be clockwise ( as viewed from above ) if the post - eruption arcade has right - handed helicity , but counterclockwise if it has left - handed helicity . here </S>\",\n \"<S> , we describe two non active - region filament events recorded with the extreme - ultraviolet imaging telescope ( eit ) on the _ solar and heliospheric observatory _ ( _ soho _ ) , in which the sense of rotation appears to be opposite to that expected from the helicity of the post - event arcade . based on these observations </S>\",\n \"<S> , we suggest that the rotation of the filament axis is in general determined by the net helicity of the erupting system , and that the axially aligned core of the filament can have the opposite helicity sign to the surrounding field . in most cases , </S>\",\n \"<S> the surrounding field provides the main contribution to the net helicity . in the events reported here , </S>\",\n \"<S> however , the helicity associated with the filament `` barbs '' is opposite in sign to and dominates that of the overlying arcade . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","event of 1999 september 20","event of 2001 september 28","discussion"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"event of 1999 september 20\",\n \"event of 2001 september 28\",\n \"discussion\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["hanle effect measurements ( bommier et al . 1994 ) have shown that quiescent ( non active - region ) filaments have `` inverse '' magnetic polarity , meaning that their transverse field component is opposite in sign to that of the coronal loops crossing high over the photospheric neutral line .","the usual interpretation of this result is that the filament material is supported in the dipped or concave - upward portions of a twisted flux rope ( see , e.g. , van ballegooijen & martens 1989 ; rust & kumar 1994 ; low 1996 ; aulanier & dmoulin 1998 ; amari et al .","1999 ; lites 2005 ; gibson & fan 2006 ) . for this topology ,","it is natural to assume that one sign of helicity prevails throughout the flux rope and its overlying arcade . in an alternative scenario ,","the filament is regarded as a sheared arcade whose intermediate legs or `` barbs '' are rooted in minority polarity on the `` wrong '' side of the neutral line ( martin 1998 ) . in that case , the helicity of the filament itself would be opposite in sign to that of the overlying coronal loops , contrary to most theoretical models .","possible support for this picture comes from the observation of continual flows along the spines and up and down the barbs of filaments ( zirker et al . 1998 ; wang 1999 ; kucera et al .","2003 ; lin et al .","2003 , 2005 ) ; such flows , which may be driven by chromospheric reconnection ( litvinenko & martin 1999 ; martin et al .","2008 ) , seem to obviate the need for static support within magnetic dips , one of the principal arguments in favor of a flux rope geometry .","statistically ( and independently of the flux rope / sheared arcade question ) , it is found that filaments in the northern ( southern ) hemisphere are predominantly `` dextral '' ( `` sinistral '' ) , meaning that their axial fields point to the right ( left ) when viewed from the positive - polarity side of the photospheric neutral line ( martin 1998 ; pevtsov et al .","2003 ; yeates et al . 2007 ; yeates & mackay 2009 ) .","dextral ( sinistral ) filaments have right - bearing ( left - bearing ) barbs but underlie arcades with left - handed ( right - handed ) helicity",". the helicity sign of the overlying arcade can be inferred from the skew of the arcade loops relative to the polarity inversion line ( pil ) .","although the magnetic topology of a stable filament / prominence remains a subject of debate , it is almost universally accepted that an erupting filament and its surrounding field have the structure of a twisted flux rope . in a three - dimensional system ,","the pinching - off of pairs of stretched , opposite - polarity field lines beneath the rising filament will necessarily give rise to a flux rope ; reconnections may occur among the legs / barbs of the filament , between the legs and the overlying arcade , and among the highly distended arcade field lines themselves .","as the bright post - eruption arcade expands outward from the pil , the orientation of the reconnected loops ( seen projected against the photosphere ) will appear to rotate clockwise ( counterclockwise ) if the arcade has right - handed ( left - handed ) helicity ; this apparent rotation is due to the tendency for the loops rooted farther from the pil to cross it more nearly at right angles .","the axes of the erupting filaments themselves are sometimes observed to rotate about the vertical direction . as viewed from above",", this rotation is again usually clockwise if the post - event arcade has right - handed helicity , and counterclockwise if it has left - handed helicity ( for examples , see rust & labonte 2005 ; green et al . 2007 ; wang et al . 2009 ) .","the sense of rotation is consistent with the conversion of field - line twist into writhe ( three - dimensional twisting of the axis itself ) , as predicted by mhd simulations of kink - unstable flux ropes ( linton et al .","1999 ; kliem et al .","2004 ; trk & kliem 2005 ) and of sheared arcades that have been converted into erupting flux ropes via reconnection ( lynch et al .","it is reasonable to assume that the net helicity of the erupting structure is the sum of the helicity of the original filament and that of the surrounding field with which it has become entrained by reconnection ( see berger 1998 ) .","if the barb system and the overlying coronal field have opposite helicity signs , as suggested by martin ( 1998 ) , then in most events the main contribution to the helicity of the erupting structure must come from the surrounding field ( compare also the discussion of ruzmaikin et al .","however , the question arises as to whether the rotation ever occurs in the direction opposite to that implied by the helicity of the overlying arcade , thereby providing stronger support for the barb picture of martin . here","we describe two events observed with the extreme - ultraviolet imaging telescope ( eit ; delaboudinire et al .","1995 ) on the _ solar and heliospheric observatory _","( _ soho _ ) , in which the erupting quiescent filament appeared to rotate counterclockwise but the post - eruption arcade had right - handed helicity ."],["the sequence of 19.5 nm images in figure 1 shows the eruption of a southern - hemisphere filament on 1999 september 20 .","the dark filament in fact represents the western half of a longer structure that occupies a circular filament channel .","the axis of the erupting feature undergoes a continual counterclockwise rotation between @xmath003:00 and @xmath005:00 ut . in order to exhibit this rotation more clearly",", we have traced the filament spine at successive times and superposed these traces in figure 2 , after shifting them in longitude to correct for the average photospheric rotation .","we note that the observed motions can not be interpreted simply as a straightening of the initially highly curved filament as it rises , which would require both the northern and southern portions of the filament to move eastward ; instead , the northern section moves eastward but the southern section moves westward , consistent with a counterclockwise rotation of the filament axis .","subsequently ( after 04:48 ut ) , the rotation `` overshoots '' near both the northern and southern ends of the erupting filament , which thus kinks into a forward - s shape .","as shown in figure 1 , the post - event arcade with its double row of footpoint brightenings begins to form after @xmath004:36 ut .","in addition , in the images recorded between 04:36 and 05:12 ut , euv brightenings ( circled in figure","1 ) may be seen at the far endpoints of the erupting filament ; these brightenings occur as the filament threads , anchored well outside the filament channel itself , are jerked upward into a vertical orientation ( see wang et al .","2009 ) . from the slant of the post - eruption loops in the image taken at 06:00 ut , and from the apparent clockwise rotation of the loop orientation between 06:00 and 07:13 ut",", we conclude that the overlying arcade has right - handed helicity , even though the filament rotates counterclockwise . the first post - eruption loops ( observed at 06:00 ut ) are located near the original pivot point of the filament rotation , where the traces approximately intersect in figure 2 , suggesting that the instability and rapid upward motion of the filament were initiated in this region .","figure 3 shows the distribution of photospheric magnetic flux underlying the erupting filament . here",", we compare a michelson doppler imager ( mdi ) line - of - sight magnetogram taken at 04:48 ut with the difference between the 19.5 nm images recorded at 04:48 and 04:36 ut . the magnetogram , saturated at @xmath150 g , represents a 5-minute average of higher - cadence data .","the circular filament channel evidently encloses a positive - polarity region . since the northern ( southern ) end of the erupting filament","is rooted in negative - polarity ( positive - polarity ) network flux , the axial field of the filament points toward the left as viewed from the positive - polarity region , and the filament is sinistral according to the chirality definition of martin ( 1998 ) .","correspondingly , an h@xmath2 image taken on september 18 at the big bear solar observatory ( bbso ) shows left - bearing barbs ( figure 4 , top panel ) . as indicated by the 30.4 nm images in the left column of figure 5 , the filament re - forms immediately after the eruption ; however , its northern end now bends westward rather than eastward ( see also the h@xmath2 image in figure 4 , bottom panel ) .","the mdi magnetograms in the right column of figure 5 suggest that this change in the shape of the filament , as well as the eruption itself , may have been associated with the emergence of a small magnetic bipole to the west of the original filament channel .","the new bipole ( circled in the magnetograms taken at 06:27 and 13:19 ut ) appears to have altered the shape of the photospheric neutral line in the vicinity of the filament . in association with this filament event ,","the large angle and spectrometric coronagraph ( lasco ) on _ soho _ observed a faint halo coronal mass ejection ( cme ) with an average speed of 600 km s@xmath3 ."],["the sequence of eit 30.4 nm images in figure 6 , taken at 6-hourly intervals , shows the disappearance of a high - latitude filament in the southern hemisphere on 2001 september 28 . in the frame","recorded at 13:19 ut , during the eruption itself , the axis of the filament shows a pronounced counterclockwise rotation relative to its pre - eruption orientation .","this kinking into a forward - s shape is seen even more clearly in figure 7 , where we have superposed four successive traces of the filament spine taken between 19:19 ut on september 27 and 13:19 ut on september 28 , after removing the effect of the photospheric differential rotation .","the eruption is shown in more detail in the sequence of 19.5 nm running - difference images in figure 8 .","the post - event arcade begins to form at 15:00 ut , with the appearance of a compact bundle of highly sheared loops that are almost aligned with the filament channel . from the mdi magnetogram ( fourth panel of figure 8)",", we conclude that the western end of this narrow bundle of reconnected loops lies on the negative - polarity side of the photospheric neutral line , implying right - handed helicity . that the overlying arcade is indeed right - handed is confirmed by the subsequently forming loops ( bottom panel of figure 8) , which are rooted farther from the pil and are shifted clockwise relative to the earlier loops .","h@xmath2 images recorded at bbso on september 27 show that the pre - eruption filament had left - bearing barbs ( see figure 9 ) , consistent with sinistral chirality ."],["filaments are conventionally regarded as cool material supported inside the dips of a helical flux rope of a given `` handedness . ''","if the flux rope becomes unstable , its axis rotates about the direction of ascent , with the rotation being clockwise ( counterclockwise ) if the flux rope has right - handed ( left - handed ) helicity . although observations of filament eruptions have tended to support this picture , we have here described two events in which the filament rotated in the opposite sense to that implied by the handedness of the surrounding arcade .","both of these quiescent filaments were located in the southern hemisphere and had left - bearing barbs ; their axes rotated counterclockwise , even though the post - event arcades were clearly right - handed . by helicity conservation ( berger 1984 ) , the source regions must have had mixed helicity , since the left - handed writhe acquired through the counterclockwise rotation could only have originated in negative helicity embodied as twist or shear in the pre - eruption field .","if the filament barbs are concave - downward features , as advocated by martin ( 1998 ) , their helicity sign or handedness would be opposite to that of the overlying coronal loops .","the direction of rotation of the erupting structure would then depend on whether the barbs or the overlying arcade provides the main contribution to the net helicity . from a preliminary survey of the entire eit database for solar cycle 23",", we were able to determine unambiguously the direction of rotation of an erupting filament in only @xmath010 events .","presumably because of the relatively low cadence of the eit observations , all of these events involved non active - region filaments , of which only the two discussed here rotated in the `` wrong '' sense . in the active region events examined by rust & labonte ( 2005 ) and green et al .","( 2007 ) , the acquired writhe of the erupting filament and the helicity observed in the surrounding field were always of the same sign .","thus , if the barbs and the surrounding field have opposite helicity signs , then the helicity of the overlying arcade must dominate in most eruptions , particularly those occurring in active regions . that the exceptions found here involve quiescent filaments","might be due to the fact that the latter are more likely to have well - developed barb systems than active region filaments . as suggested by wang ( 2001 ) ,","barbs form when flux elements that have become connected to the overlying axial field diffuse across the filament channel and undergo flux cancellation on the other side .","that the helicity tends to be concentrated in the surrounding field rather than in the filament itself is consistent with recent models of active region fields , in which a flux rope is inserted into a potential configuration and the system is allowed to relax , including the effect of a helicity - conserving magnetic diffusion ( bobra et al .","2008 ; su et al .","the observed h@xmath2 filament and surrounding coronal - loop structure are best fit with a highly sheared but weakly twisted flux rope held down by the overlying arcade ; as in a hollow solenoid , the electric currents and magnetic helicity are concentrated in a semi - cylindrical shell around the outer edge of the flux rope , not within its interior , where the field lines are essentially straight and not much current flows .","moreover , for stability , the amount of axial flux must be small compared with the total flux that holds down the filament .","thus it is not surprising that it is the helicity of the surrounding field that usually determines the direction of rotation of an erupting active - region filament .","the event of 1999 september 20 provides support for the hypothesis that some filament eruptions are triggered by the emergence of flux near the filament channel ( see , e.g. , bruzek 1952 ; feynman & martin 1995 ; wang & sheeley 1999 ) . in this particular case ,","the eruption was accompanied by a reconfiguration of both the underlying photospheric neutral line and the shape of the filament itself .","sheeley et al .","( 1975 ) described a rather similar event in which the eastward hook of an h@xmath2 filament disappeared and was replaced by a westward hook that pointed toward a region of newly emerging flux ( the sense in which the filament axis rotated during the eruption is unknown ) .","we are indebted to the eit and mdi teams for the _ soho _ observations , and to bbso / new jersey institute of technology for the h@xmath2 images .","we also thank a. a. van ballegooijen and p. dmoulin for informative discussions , and the referee for helpful comments .","this work was supported by nasa and the office of naval research .","g ( black ) and @xmath4 g ( white ) .","bottom : 19.5 nm running - difference image taken at 04:48 ut .","the locations of the brightenings at the endpoints of the erupted filament are circled in both the mdi and the eit image . as viewed from the positive - polarity region inside the circular filament channel , the axial field points to the left , so that the filament is sinistral . ]","images recorded on 1999 september 18 ( top ) and 1999 september 20 ( bottom ) .","the left - bearing barbs of this southern - hemisphere filament are clearly seen in the pre - eruption image . after the filament erupted early on september 20 , the re - formed structure hooks westward instead of eastward ( see also figure 5 ) . ]"]],"string":"[\n [\n \"hanle effect measurements ( bommier et al . 1994 ) have shown that quiescent ( non active - region ) filaments have `` inverse '' magnetic polarity , meaning that their transverse field component is opposite in sign to that of the coronal loops crossing high over the photospheric neutral line .\",\n \"the usual interpretation of this result is that the filament material is supported in the dipped or concave - upward portions of a twisted flux rope ( see , e.g. , van ballegooijen & martens 1989 ; rust & kumar 1994 ; low 1996 ; aulanier & dmoulin 1998 ; amari et al .\",\n \"1999 ; lites 2005 ; gibson & fan 2006 ) . for this topology ,\",\n \"it is natural to assume that one sign of helicity prevails throughout the flux rope and its overlying arcade . in an alternative scenario ,\",\n \"the filament is regarded as a sheared arcade whose intermediate legs or `` barbs '' are rooted in minority polarity on the `` wrong '' side of the neutral line ( martin 1998 ) . in that case , the helicity of the filament itself would be opposite in sign to that of the overlying coronal loops , contrary to most theoretical models .\",\n \"possible support for this picture comes from the observation of continual flows along the spines and up and down the barbs of filaments ( zirker et al . 1998 ; wang 1999 ; kucera et al .\",\n \"2003 ; lin et al .\",\n \"2003 , 2005 ) ; such flows , which may be driven by chromospheric reconnection ( litvinenko & martin 1999 ; martin et al .\",\n \"2008 ) , seem to obviate the need for static support within magnetic dips , one of the principal arguments in favor of a flux rope geometry .\",\n \"statistically ( and independently of the flux rope / sheared arcade question ) , it is found that filaments in the northern ( southern ) hemisphere are predominantly `` dextral '' ( `` sinistral '' ) , meaning that their axial fields point to the right ( left ) when viewed from the positive - polarity side of the photospheric neutral line ( martin 1998 ; pevtsov et al .\",\n \"2003 ; yeates et al . 2007 ; yeates & mackay 2009 ) .\",\n \"dextral ( sinistral ) filaments have right - bearing ( left - bearing ) barbs but underlie arcades with left - handed ( right - handed ) helicity\",\n \". the helicity sign of the overlying arcade can be inferred from the skew of the arcade loops relative to the polarity inversion line ( pil ) .\",\n \"although the magnetic topology of a stable filament / prominence remains a subject of debate , it is almost universally accepted that an erupting filament and its surrounding field have the structure of a twisted flux rope . in a three - dimensional system ,\",\n \"the pinching - off of pairs of stretched , opposite - polarity field lines beneath the rising filament will necessarily give rise to a flux rope ; reconnections may occur among the legs / barbs of the filament , between the legs and the overlying arcade , and among the highly distended arcade field lines themselves .\",\n \"as the bright post - eruption arcade expands outward from the pil , the orientation of the reconnected loops ( seen projected against the photosphere ) will appear to rotate clockwise ( counterclockwise ) if the arcade has right - handed ( left - handed ) helicity ; this apparent rotation is due to the tendency for the loops rooted farther from the pil to cross it more nearly at right angles .\",\n \"the axes of the erupting filaments themselves are sometimes observed to rotate about the vertical direction . as viewed from above\",\n \", this rotation is again usually clockwise if the post - event arcade has right - handed helicity , and counterclockwise if it has left - handed helicity ( for examples , see rust & labonte 2005 ; green et al . 2007 ; wang et al . 2009 ) .\",\n \"the sense of rotation is consistent with the conversion of field - line twist into writhe ( three - dimensional twisting of the axis itself ) , as predicted by mhd simulations of kink - unstable flux ropes ( linton et al .\",\n \"1999 ; kliem et al .\",\n \"2004 ; trk & kliem 2005 ) and of sheared arcades that have been converted into erupting flux ropes via reconnection ( lynch et al .\",\n \"it is reasonable to assume that the net helicity of the erupting structure is the sum of the helicity of the original filament and that of the surrounding field with which it has become entrained by reconnection ( see berger 1998 ) .\",\n \"if the barb system and the overlying coronal field have opposite helicity signs , as suggested by martin ( 1998 ) , then in most events the main contribution to the helicity of the erupting structure must come from the surrounding field ( compare also the discussion of ruzmaikin et al .\",\n \"however , the question arises as to whether the rotation ever occurs in the direction opposite to that implied by the helicity of the overlying arcade , thereby providing stronger support for the barb picture of martin . here\",\n \"we describe two events observed with the extreme - ultraviolet imaging telescope ( eit ; delaboudinire et al .\",\n \"1995 ) on the _ solar and heliospheric observatory _\",\n \"( _ soho _ ) , in which the erupting quiescent filament appeared to rotate counterclockwise but the post - eruption arcade had right - handed helicity .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the sequence of 19.5 nm images in figure 1 shows the eruption of a southern - hemisphere filament on 1999 september 20 .\",\n \"the dark filament in fact represents the western half of a longer structure that occupies a circular filament channel .\",\n \"the axis of the erupting feature undergoes a continual counterclockwise rotation between @xmath003:00 and @xmath005:00 ut . in order to exhibit this rotation more clearly\",\n \", we have traced the filament spine at successive times and superposed these traces in figure 2 , after shifting them in longitude to correct for the average photospheric rotation .\",\n \"we note that the observed motions can not be interpreted simply as a straightening of the initially highly curved filament as it rises , which would require both the northern and southern portions of the filament to move eastward ; instead , the northern section moves eastward but the southern section moves westward , consistent with a counterclockwise rotation of the filament axis .\",\n \"subsequently ( after 04:48 ut ) , the rotation `` overshoots '' near both the northern and southern ends of the erupting filament , which thus kinks into a forward - s shape .\",\n \"as shown in figure 1 , the post - event arcade with its double row of footpoint brightenings begins to form after @xmath004:36 ut .\",\n \"in addition , in the images recorded between 04:36 and 05:12 ut , euv brightenings ( circled in figure\",\n \"1 ) may be seen at the far endpoints of the erupting filament ; these brightenings occur as the filament threads , anchored well outside the filament channel itself , are jerked upward into a vertical orientation ( see wang et al .\",\n \"2009 ) . from the slant of the post - eruption loops in the image taken at 06:00 ut , and from the apparent clockwise rotation of the loop orientation between 06:00 and 07:13 ut\",\n \", we conclude that the overlying arcade has right - handed helicity , even though the filament rotates counterclockwise . the first post - eruption loops ( observed at 06:00 ut ) are located near the original pivot point of the filament rotation , where the traces approximately intersect in figure 2 , suggesting that the instability and rapid upward motion of the filament were initiated in this region .\",\n \"figure 3 shows the distribution of photospheric magnetic flux underlying the erupting filament . here\",\n \", we compare a michelson doppler imager ( mdi ) line - of - sight magnetogram taken at 04:48 ut with the difference between the 19.5 nm images recorded at 04:48 and 04:36 ut . the magnetogram , saturated at @xmath150 g , represents a 5-minute average of higher - cadence data .\",\n \"the circular filament channel evidently encloses a positive - polarity region . since the northern ( southern ) end of the erupting filament\",\n \"is rooted in negative - polarity ( positive - polarity ) network flux , the axial field of the filament points toward the left as viewed from the positive - polarity region , and the filament is sinistral according to the chirality definition of martin ( 1998 ) .\",\n \"correspondingly , an h@xmath2 image taken on september 18 at the big bear solar observatory ( bbso ) shows left - bearing barbs ( figure 4 , top panel ) . as indicated by the 30.4 nm images in the left column of figure 5 , the filament re - forms immediately after the eruption ; however , its northern end now bends westward rather than eastward ( see also the h@xmath2 image in figure 4 , bottom panel ) .\",\n \"the mdi magnetograms in the right column of figure 5 suggest that this change in the shape of the filament , as well as the eruption itself , may have been associated with the emergence of a small magnetic bipole to the west of the original filament channel .\",\n \"the new bipole ( circled in the magnetograms taken at 06:27 and 13:19 ut ) appears to have altered the shape of the photospheric neutral line in the vicinity of the filament . in association with this filament event ,\",\n \"the large angle and spectrometric coronagraph ( lasco ) on _ soho _ observed a faint halo coronal mass ejection ( cme ) with an average speed of 600 km s@xmath3 .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the sequence of eit 30.4 nm images in figure 6 , taken at 6-hourly intervals , shows the disappearance of a high - latitude filament in the southern hemisphere on 2001 september 28 . in the frame\",\n \"recorded at 13:19 ut , during the eruption itself , the axis of the filament shows a pronounced counterclockwise rotation relative to its pre - eruption orientation .\",\n \"this kinking into a forward - s shape is seen even more clearly in figure 7 , where we have superposed four successive traces of the filament spine taken between 19:19 ut on september 27 and 13:19 ut on september 28 , after removing the effect of the photospheric differential rotation .\",\n \"the eruption is shown in more detail in the sequence of 19.5 nm running - difference images in figure 8 .\",\n \"the post - event arcade begins to form at 15:00 ut , with the appearance of a compact bundle of highly sheared loops that are almost aligned with the filament channel . from the mdi magnetogram ( fourth panel of figure 8)\",\n \", we conclude that the western end of this narrow bundle of reconnected loops lies on the negative - polarity side of the photospheric neutral line , implying right - handed helicity . that the overlying arcade is indeed right - handed is confirmed by the subsequently forming loops ( bottom panel of figure 8) , which are rooted farther from the pil and are shifted clockwise relative to the earlier loops .\",\n \"h@xmath2 images recorded at bbso on september 27 show that the pre - eruption filament had left - bearing barbs ( see figure 9 ) , consistent with sinistral chirality .\"\n ],\n [\n \"filaments are conventionally regarded as cool material supported inside the dips of a helical flux rope of a given `` handedness . ''\",\n \"if the flux rope becomes unstable , its axis rotates about the direction of ascent , with the rotation being clockwise ( counterclockwise ) if the flux rope has right - handed ( left - handed ) helicity . although observations of filament eruptions have tended to support this picture , we have here described two events in which the filament rotated in the opposite sense to that implied by the handedness of the surrounding arcade .\",\n \"both of these quiescent filaments were located in the southern hemisphere and had left - bearing barbs ; their axes rotated counterclockwise , even though the post - event arcades were clearly right - handed . by helicity conservation ( berger 1984 ) , the source regions must have had mixed helicity , since the left - handed writhe acquired through the counterclockwise rotation could only have originated in negative helicity embodied as twist or shear in the pre - eruption field .\",\n \"if the filament barbs are concave - downward features , as advocated by martin ( 1998 ) , their helicity sign or handedness would be opposite to that of the overlying coronal loops .\",\n \"the direction of rotation of the erupting structure would then depend on whether the barbs or the overlying arcade provides the main contribution to the net helicity . from a preliminary survey of the entire eit database for solar cycle 23\",\n \", we were able to determine unambiguously the direction of rotation of an erupting filament in only @xmath010 events .\",\n \"presumably because of the relatively low cadence of the eit observations , all of these events involved non active - region filaments , of which only the two discussed here rotated in the `` wrong '' sense . in the active region events examined by rust & labonte ( 2005 ) and green et al .\",\n \"( 2007 ) , the acquired writhe of the erupting filament and the helicity observed in the surrounding field were always of the same sign .\",\n \"thus , if the barbs and the surrounding field have opposite helicity signs , then the helicity of the overlying arcade must dominate in most eruptions , particularly those occurring in active regions . that the exceptions found here involve quiescent filaments\",\n \"might be due to the fact that the latter are more likely to have well - developed barb systems than active region filaments . as suggested by wang ( 2001 ) ,\",\n \"barbs form when flux elements that have become connected to the overlying axial field diffuse across the filament channel and undergo flux cancellation on the other side .\",\n \"that the helicity tends to be concentrated in the surrounding field rather than in the filament itself is consistent with recent models of active region fields , in which a flux rope is inserted into a potential configuration and the system is allowed to relax , including the effect of a helicity - conserving magnetic diffusion ( bobra et al .\",\n \"2008 ; su et al .\",\n \"the observed h@xmath2 filament and surrounding coronal - loop structure are best fit with a highly sheared but weakly twisted flux rope held down by the overlying arcade ; as in a hollow solenoid , the electric currents and magnetic helicity are concentrated in a semi - cylindrical shell around the outer edge of the flux rope , not within its interior , where the field lines are essentially straight and not much current flows .\",\n \"moreover , for stability , the amount of axial flux must be small compared with the total flux that holds down the filament .\",\n \"thus it is not surprising that it is the helicity of the surrounding field that usually determines the direction of rotation of an erupting active - region filament .\",\n \"the event of 1999 september 20 provides support for the hypothesis that some filament eruptions are triggered by the emergence of flux near the filament channel ( see , e.g. , bruzek 1952 ; feynman & martin 1995 ; wang & sheeley 1999 ) . in this particular case ,\",\n \"the eruption was accompanied by a reconfiguration of both the underlying photospheric neutral line and the shape of the filament itself .\",\n \"sheeley et al .\",\n \"( 1975 ) described a rather similar event in which the eastward hook of an h@xmath2 filament disappeared and was replaced by a westward hook that pointed toward a region of newly emerging flux ( the sense in which the filament axis rotated during the eruption is unknown ) .\",\n \"we are indebted to the eit and mdi teams for the _ soho _ observations , and to bbso / new jersey institute of technology for the h@xmath2 images .\",\n \"we also thank a. a. van ballegooijen and p. dmoulin for informative discussions , and the referee for helpful comments .\",\n \"this work was supported by nasa and the office of naval research .\",\n \"g ( black ) and @xmath4 g ( white ) .\",\n \"bottom : 19.5 nm running - difference image taken at 04:48 ut .\",\n \"the locations of the brightenings at the endpoints of the erupted filament are circled in both the mdi and the eit image . as viewed from the positive - polarity region inside the circular filament channel , the axial field points to the left , so that the filament is sinistral . ]\",\n \"images recorded on 1999 september 18 ( top ) and 1999 september 20 ( bottom ) .\",\n \"the left - bearing barbs of this southern - hemisphere filament are clearly seen in the pre - eruption image . after the filament erupted early on september 20 , the re - formed structure hooks westward instead of eastward ( see also figure 5 ) . ]\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":98,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"1506.00282"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["noncovalent functionalization of single - walled carbon nanotubes ( cnts ) with photoactive molecules is becoming a promising technique to explore functional materials for light - harvesting or optoelectronic applications .","@xcite the coupling of the exceptional cnt transport properties with the optical properties of functional dyes , like porphyrins with a strong absorption in the near infrared and visible , make of cnt / dye complexes good candidates for sensitive nanoscale devices with potential applications in biomedical imaging , @xcite and hybrid organic - inorganic photovoltaic devices .","@xcite however , the strength of the @xmath4-stacking interaction with respect to the cnt structural parameters , like the diameter and chirality , is still lacking .","in addition , a better understanding of the cnt / dye optical properties considering changes in the dye structure due to the @xmath4-conjugation is needed .","recently , the kinetics and thermodynamics properties of non - covalently bound cnt / porphyrin oligomers have been investigated by uv / visible spectroscopy and fluorescence titration.@xcite it was reported that the affinity of the cnts increases sharply with the porphyrin coverage , showing strongest binding energies for semiconducting cnts , particularly those with chiral indices ( 7,5 ) and ( 8,6 ) . in addition , others works have also investigated a supposed selective interaction of porphyrins towards semiconducting cnts , suggesting that the semiconducting and metallic cnts would have significantly different surface properties.@xcite these works have also suggested that noncovalent functionalization of a mixture of cnts with porphyrins may be an effective method for the separation of semiconducting cnts from metallic cnts .","previously , we reported physisorption properties of iron porphyrin on both metallic and semiconducting cnts with similar diameters.@xcite our results showed a surprising strong @xmath4-stacking interaction , but with negligible energy differences .","similar results were found for the physisorption strength of free - base and zinc porphyrins on the same semiconducting cnt,@xcite showing no clue on the suspected selectivity .","considering the increasing interest in the noncovalent complexation of cnt - based materials for optoelectronic applications , we carry out an in - depth investigation on the stability and optical response of free - base tetraphenyporphyrin ( tpp ) molecules @xmath4-stacked on single - walled cnts with different chiralities and diameters , and also on graphene .","our purpose is to give a theoretically insight into the binding strength and optical properties of these compounds as a function of the cnt structural parameters .","our results show that the diameter instead chirality would be the relevant cnt parameter to explain the unusual strength of the tpp @xmath4-stacking interaction .","in addition , the tpp binding energy on metallic and semiconducting cnts does not exhibit important differences that might suggest distinct interactions .","regarding optical properties , we find that transition bands of the @xmath4-stacked tpp remain at almost the same energy position than those found in the isolated tpp , being independent of the cnt structural parameters .","for the tpp physisorption on graphene , we find a very strong binding energy , of about 3.2 ev , providing an upper limit for the stability of cnt - tpp compounds .","we also find a @xmath5-type doping on graphene induced by the tpp adsorption .","our density functional theory ( dft ) calculations were performed using the siesta _ ab initio _ package,@xcite which employ norm - conserving pseudopotentials and localized atomic orbitals as basis set ( double-@xmath6 , singly polarized ) .","the physisorption of tpp on both the cnt sidewall and graphene is assessed by van der waals density functional ( vdw - df ) as proposed by dion _","et al._@xcite this approach has been successfully applied to describe the dispersive interaction of aromatic molecules on the graphite surface , showing good agreement with available experimental data.@xcite in recent experiments , the functionalization of cnts with tpp molecules has been achieved by the micelle swelling methods in water suspension,@xcite where the cnt - tpp compound stays in the micelle core .","because of the hydrophobic character of this core , it is not expected water molecules surrounding the compound , which can be considered close to a vacuum situation . in the present work we study the tpp physisorption 42 different cnt species , particularly those with chiral indices ( @xmath0,@xmath1 ) , with @xmath7 and @xmath3 .","the cnt - tpp compounds are studied within the supercell approach , with periodic boundary conditions along the nanotube axis ( @xmath8 direction ) .","we use unit cells with a volume of ( @xmath9 ) @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is cnt lattice constant and @xmath12 a factor to keep a minimum distance among tpp images along the cnts , chosen to be of 10 .","this procedure results in supercell lengths ( @xmath13 ) between 22 - 57 , which can contain up to 754 atoms .","a grid cutoff of 100 ry and the @xmath14 point were used for the real - space and @xmath15-space integration , respectively . for the optical calculations , we use a @xmath16 @xmath15-point mesh , for incident light polarized along the cnt axis .","the accuracy of these parameters were tested considering larger grid cutoff ( 150 ry ) and @xmath15-point mesh ( @xmath17 ) .","negligible variations in the total energies , optical spectra , and band structures were found , ensuring that our results are converged .","for the tpp physisorption on graphene , we use a squared unit cell with @xmath18 periodicity and the @xmath14 point for the @xmath15-space integration . here , a vacuum region of 20 among graphene an their images was considered . for the optical response we use a @xmath15-point mesh of @xmath19 , for incident light polarized parallel to the graphene plane ( @xmath20 and @xmath21 directions ) . the tpp binding energy on the substrates is calculated by the energy difference between adsorbed and separated constituents , considering corrections due to the basis set superposition error .","the complexes were fully relaxed by conjugate gradient minimization until the forces on the atoms were less than 0.05 ev / .","the optical response of the functionalized cnts and graphene is obtained through first order time dependent perturbation theory , by calculating the imaginary part of the dielectric function ( @xmath22 ) .","@xmath22 gives us a first approach for the optical absorption coefficient and it is calculated according to the equation : @xmath23 here @xmath24 is a constant that depends on the cell sizes ; @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the occupied and empty kohn - sham orbitals , respectively .","the delta function represents the conservation of energy , which is described by a gaussian function with a smearing of 0.06 ev .","it is important to note that dft calculations fail in describing electron - hole and electron - electron interactions , the so called many - body effects .","these effects are responsible for the formation of excitons and the quasiparticle excitation .","@xcite therefore , an accurate description of photoexcitations in cnts and graphene needs theories beyond dft , like those based on the gw - bethe - salpeter equation ( gw - bse).@xcite however , these calculations are not possible right now , considering the size of the systems under study .","thus , @xmath22 can give us a first approach for the optical response of @xmath4-stacked tpp on cnts and graphene .","the main difference of dft calculations with respect to gw - bse is a redshift in the absorption spectrum .","for instance , in graphene this redshift is found to be about 0.6 ev.@xcite","we first discuss different adsorption geometries for the tpp molecule on the cnts .","figure [ f1 ] shows the equilibrium geometry of a tpp adsorbed on a ( 8,7 ) cnt . here , the n - h bonds of tpp are oriented perpendicular to the cnt axis , that we called position ( i ) .","two other positions for tpp are likely to be found : with the n - h bonds parallel to the cnt axis ( ii ) , and with the n - h bonds forming an angle of 45@xmath27 with respect to the cnt axis ( iii ) . although position ( i ) is found to be the most stable , the other positions have total energies within 0.3 ev , suggesting that all three are equally probables . in the equilibrium geometry , the tpp phenyl groups exhibit a small rotation , which come with a molecular twisting . to compare the stability of different cnt - tpp complexes , only position ( i ) will be considered throughout this work .","the adsorption distance is measured between the cnt surface and the n atoms of tpp , as shown in figure [ f1 ] .",".adsorption distance ( @xmath28 ) , binding energy ( @xmath29 ) , and bandgap energy ( @xmath30 ) of cnt - tpp complexes .","@xmath31 and @xmath32 are the cnt diameter and chiral angle , respectively .","results for tpp on graphene ( g - tpp ) are also included . [","cols=\"<,<,<,<,<,<\",options=\"header \" , ] [ t1 ] table [ t1 ] lists tpp binding energies and binding distances for all the complex under study .","we also include the dft bandgaps for the semiconducting complexes .","those with small bandgaps ( @xmath330.1 ev ) are consistent with empirical model predictions of @xmath34 as well as with experimental data.@xcite we observe that binding energies and adsorption distances vary in ranges given by @xmath35 ev and @xmath36 , respectively .","we note that stronger tpp @xmath4-stacking interactions result in larger adsorption distance .","this can be understood by look at the tpp phenyl groups , whose h atoms become closer to the cnt surface for large diameter cnts , as can be seen in figure [ f1 ] . to estimate an upper limit for @xmath29 and @xmath28",", we calculate the tpp physisorption on graphene , which can be considered as a cnt with an infinite diameter .","we find @xmath37 ev and @xmath38 .","although the binding distance is similar to those found on cnts with @xmath39 , the binding energy is considerably larger , with almost twice the value found on the cnts .","this can be understood because of the larger graphene - tpp overlap area , which tend to maximize the @xmath4-stacking interaction .","figure [ f2 ] shows the cnt - tpp binding energy as a function of the cnt diameter .","we observe an almost linear increase in the tpp attachment strength with the cnt diameter , which in some way confirms our assumption that larger cnt - tpp overlap area tends to increase the binding energy of the molecule .","however , this general tendency is not followed in some cases , as can be seen in fig .","for instance , ( i ) the larger tpp binding energy found for the ( 5,0 ) cnt ( @xmath40 ) with respect to the ( 6,0 ) cnt ( @xmath41 ) , by about 0.2 ev , and ( ii ) the abrupt changes in the tpp binding energy profile going from ( 6,0 ) to ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,5 ) to ( 7,6 ) , and ( 8,5 ) to ( 8,6 ) .","we attribute these results to the particular atomic geometry of the cnt atoms just below the tpp molecule .","we observe that the cnt - tpp binding distance tends to increase when the h atoms of the phenyl groups nearest neighbors to the cnt surface , lie exactly above nanotube c - atoms .","this effect is due to the steric repulsion between them , which also explain the broad variation on the binding distances between the cnt surface and the tpp n - atoms , as shown in figure [ f3 ] .","figure [ f4 ] shows the cnt - tpp binding energy as a function of the cnt chiral angle .","apparently , higher chiral angles would induce stronger tpp attachment .","however , if we compare the tpp attachment on cnts with similar diameters and binding distances with those plotted as a function of the chiral angle , we observe that they have also similar binding energy , suggesting that the cnt diameter instead chirality is the relevant parameter involved in the strong tpp binding energy .","for instance , if we take the cnts with chiral indices ( 5,4 ) and ( 7,2 ) , they show almost the same tpp binding energy when plotted with respect to both the cnt diameter ( fig . [ f2 ] ) and adsorption distance ( fig .","however , they also show the same binding energy when plotted with respect to the chiral angle ( fig .","the same behavior can be verified for the pairs of cnts ( 5,5)-(6,4 ) and ( 6,5)-(7,4 ) .","these results suggest that the strength of the tpp interaction on the cnts would not be related to the cnt surface geometry or chirality , but to the cnt diameter . the adsorption energy of benzene and naphthalene on cnts ( 7 - 8 diameter ) , using electron - correlated moller - plasset ( mp2 ) method reports binding energies for benzene and naphthalene of 0.18 and 0.48 ev , respectively .","@xcite this results suggest an overestimation of the tpp adsorption energy on cnts . however , temperature programmed desorption experiments performed in ultrahigh vacuum have measured the binding energy of polyaromatic hydrocarbons ( pahs ) adsorbed on graphite , showing quite strong desorption energies .","@xcite in that work , benzene , naphthalene , coronene , and ovalene adsorbed on graphite show desorption energies of 0.50 , 0.85 , 1.4 , and 2.1 ev , respectively .","for the case of benzene and naphthalene , the experimental values almost double the mp2-theory values . even considering the cnt curvatures , the @xmath4-stacking interaction appears to be much more larger than the usually expected .","in addition , a recent study of pahs adsorption on graphene shows that the vdw - df calculations exhibit excellent agreement with the available experimental data , while empirical and semiempirical calculations only preserve the correct trends.@xcite in summary , the work concludes that the adsorption interaction of @xmath4-conjugate systems on graphene are a complex combination of dispersive and electrostatic interactions , which would explains to some extent our results for the large adsorption energies of tpp on both graphene and cnts .","noncovalent functionalization of a single - walled ( 6,5 ) cnt with tpp molecules have been reported in aqueous solution by mean of the micellar suspension method.@xcite the optical absorption of ( 6,5)-tpp complexes shows resonances at 2.357 and 2.831 ev , which are associated to the @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( soret ) tpp bands , respectively.@xcite our results for the optical response of the ( 6,5)-tpp complex for a polarization parallel to the tube axis , show clear transitions at 1.60 and 2.04 ev , which we associate to the tpp @xmath42 and @xmath43 bands , respectively .","the difference in energy between these peaks ( 0.44 ev ) is almost the same than those observed in the experiments ( 0.474 ev).@xcite however , the theoretical peaks show a redshift of about 0.8 ev with respect to the experimental ones , while the shape of the absorption spectra would be preserved .","this shift is associated to many - body effects previously discussed .","therefore , through the @xmath22 calculation it is possible to investigate , qualitatively , changes in the optical properties of different cnt - tpp complexes in term of the cnt structural parameters , like diameter or chirality .","figure [ f5 ] and [ f6 ] show @xmath22 as a function of the photon energy , for incident light polarized parallel to the tube axis , for the semiconducting cnt - tpp complexes .","the red and black spectra indicate the optical response of cnt - tpp and the isolated cnt , respectively .","the vertical dashed lines indicate the position of the tpp @xmath42 ( 1.60 ev ) and @xmath43 ( 2.04 ev ) bands .","the optical spectra clearly show the absorption of the @xmath4-stacked tpp at almost the same position than the isolated tpp , indicating that the tpp absorption properties would be preserved in the complexes , being independent of the cnt diameter or chirality .","however , we must note that the present results were obtained considering only one tpp molecule on the cnts .","increasing tpp coverages may change this conclusion .","the optical response of complexes considering metallic and semimetallic cnts ( not shown ) exhibit the same properties .","another interesting feature is the resonance between the cnt @xmath44 transition with the @xmath43 band for the cnts : ( 5,4 ) , ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,3 ) , and ( 10,0 ) , and with the @xmath42 band for the cnts : ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,5 ) , ( 7,6 ) , and ( 7,2 ) .","this tuning between @xmath44 and the tpp bands would increase the emission of the corresponding complex .","figure [ f7 ] shows the electronic band structure and density of states ( dos ) of the graphene - tpp compound described in a squared reciprocal lattice .","the vertical arrows show the optical transition between the frontier molecular orbitals of the @xmath4-stacked tpp , which correspond to the dispersionless subbands . here , @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) is the transition from homo to lumo ( lumo+1 ) , while @xmath47 ( @xmath48 ) is the transitions from homo-1 to lumo ( lumo+1 ) .","these absorptions arise from @xmath49 transitions and can be characterized approximately by considering only the four molecular levels above mentioned .","@xcite in pristine graphene , the valence - band maximum and conduction - band minimum touch at one point in the @xmath15 space , the dirac point , which occurs at the fermi energy .","this indicates that graphene is a zero - gap semiconductor . in fig .","[ f7 ] , we observe that the fermi energy ( the dashed line ) is shifted upward with respect to the dirac point energy , which indicates a charge transfer from tpp to graphene , revealing a @xmath0-type doping mechanism . therefore , graphene would change its electronic characteristic induced by the strong tpp complexation . as the @xmath4-stacking molecule do not alter the graphene atomic structure , their transport properties would be preserved .","similar results have been reported for other aromatic molecules physisorbed on graphene.@xcite figure [ f8 ] shows @xmath22 of a tpp @xmath4-stacked on graphene , the g - tpp compound , considering an in - plain polarizations of incident light . for pristine graphene , we find a strong absorption in the infrared , below 1 ev , and a less intense absorption in the ultraviolet , at around 4 ev , which are attributed to transitions among @xmath4 and @xmath50 bands .","these results are in qualitative agreement with calculated absorption spectra using the gw - bse approach as well as with experiments,@xcite unless the redshift previously discussed . for functionalized graphene ,","we observe two intense absorptions at around 1.57 and 1.96 ev , corresponding to the @xmath51 and @xmath52 bands of the @xmath4-stacked tpp .","these peaks show a redshift with respect to those of the isolated tpp of 0.05 ev , which is associated to the distortion of the tpp phenyl groups due to the strong @xmath4-stacking interaction .","additional peaks at around 2.6 and 3.1 ev are also associated to the tpp molecule .","we have theoretically investigated the stability and optical absorption properties of a free - base tpp molecule @xmath4-stacked on single - walled cnts , as well as on graphene .","42 cnts with chiral indices ( @xmath0,@xmath1 ) , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 , have been studied . in term of the diameter ,","they range within @xmath53 .","the tpp physisorption is described by van der waals density functional while the optical properties through the imaginary part of the dielectric function in the linear optical response .","we find a strong cnt - tpp @xmath4-stacking interaction , with binding energies and adsorption distance varying within @xmath35 ev and @xmath36 , respectively , where larger @xmath29 and @xmath28 are obtained for increasing cnt diameters .","our results indicates that diameter instead chirality is the relevant parameter for the strong tpp physisorption , which would be originated in the increasing overlap area between tpp and the cnts .","an upper limit for the cnt - tpp binding strength can be estimated through the tpp physisorption on graphene , which can be viewed as an infinite - diameter cnt .","we find very strong @xmath4-stacking interactions , with @xmath37 ev and @xmath38 .","however , this strong interaction is not enough to open an energy gap in the functionalized graphene , but it can induce a charge transfer from tpp , suggesting a @xmath0-type doping mechanism without compromising the graphene structure and transport properties . concerning optical properties , we find that @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( soret ) tpp absorption bands remain at almost the same energy position after the physisorption on the cnts , being independent of the cnt structural parameters . whereas on graphene , the tpp bands show a redshift of about 0.05 ev , which are associated to the distortion of the phenyl groups due to the strong @xmath4-stacking interaction .","finally , our results suggest that both compounds cnt - tpp and g - tpp exhibit remarkable stability while preserving the absorption properties of the chromophore , which may be of interest for light - harvesting and bio - labeling applications ."],"string":"[\n \"noncovalent functionalization of single - walled carbon nanotubes ( cnts ) with photoactive molecules is becoming a promising technique to explore functional materials for light - harvesting or optoelectronic applications .\",\n \"@xcite the coupling of the exceptional cnt transport properties with the optical properties of functional dyes , like porphyrins with a strong absorption in the near infrared and visible , make of cnt / dye complexes good candidates for sensitive nanoscale devices with potential applications in biomedical imaging , @xcite and hybrid organic - inorganic photovoltaic devices .\",\n \"@xcite however , the strength of the @xmath4-stacking interaction with respect to the cnt structural parameters , like the diameter and chirality , is still lacking .\",\n \"in addition , a better understanding of the cnt / dye optical properties considering changes in the dye structure due to the @xmath4-conjugation is needed .\",\n \"recently , the kinetics and thermodynamics properties of non - covalently bound cnt / porphyrin oligomers have been investigated by uv / visible spectroscopy and fluorescence titration.@xcite it was reported that the affinity of the cnts increases sharply with the porphyrin coverage , showing strongest binding energies for semiconducting cnts , particularly those with chiral indices ( 7,5 ) and ( 8,6 ) . in addition , others works have also investigated a supposed selective interaction of porphyrins towards semiconducting cnts , suggesting that the semiconducting and metallic cnts would have significantly different surface properties.@xcite these works have also suggested that noncovalent functionalization of a mixture of cnts with porphyrins may be an effective method for the separation of semiconducting cnts from metallic cnts .\",\n \"previously , we reported physisorption properties of iron porphyrin on both metallic and semiconducting cnts with similar diameters.@xcite our results showed a surprising strong @xmath4-stacking interaction , but with negligible energy differences .\",\n \"similar results were found for the physisorption strength of free - base and zinc porphyrins on the same semiconducting cnt,@xcite showing no clue on the suspected selectivity .\",\n \"considering the increasing interest in the noncovalent complexation of cnt - based materials for optoelectronic applications , we carry out an in - depth investigation on the stability and optical response of free - base tetraphenyporphyrin ( tpp ) molecules @xmath4-stacked on single - walled cnts with different chiralities and diameters , and also on graphene .\",\n \"our purpose is to give a theoretically insight into the binding strength and optical properties of these compounds as a function of the cnt structural parameters .\",\n \"our results show that the diameter instead chirality would be the relevant cnt parameter to explain the unusual strength of the tpp @xmath4-stacking interaction .\",\n \"in addition , the tpp binding energy on metallic and semiconducting cnts does not exhibit important differences that might suggest distinct interactions .\",\n \"regarding optical properties , we find that transition bands of the @xmath4-stacked tpp remain at almost the same energy position than those found in the isolated tpp , being independent of the cnt structural parameters .\",\n \"for the tpp physisorption on graphene , we find a very strong binding energy , of about 3.2 ev , providing an upper limit for the stability of cnt - tpp compounds .\",\n \"we also find a @xmath5-type doping on graphene induced by the tpp adsorption .\",\n \"our density functional theory ( dft ) calculations were performed using the siesta _ ab initio _ package,@xcite which employ norm - conserving pseudopotentials and localized atomic orbitals as basis set ( double-@xmath6 , singly polarized ) .\",\n \"the physisorption of tpp on both the cnt sidewall and graphene is assessed by van der waals density functional ( vdw - df ) as proposed by dion _\",\n \"et al._@xcite this approach has been successfully applied to describe the dispersive interaction of aromatic molecules on the graphite surface , showing good agreement with available experimental data.@xcite in recent experiments , the functionalization of cnts with tpp molecules has been achieved by the micelle swelling methods in water suspension,@xcite where the cnt - tpp compound stays in the micelle core .\",\n \"because of the hydrophobic character of this core , it is not expected water molecules surrounding the compound , which can be considered close to a vacuum situation . in the present work we study the tpp physisorption 42 different cnt species , particularly those with chiral indices ( @xmath0,@xmath1 ) , with @xmath7 and @xmath3 .\",\n \"the cnt - tpp compounds are studied within the supercell approach , with periodic boundary conditions along the nanotube axis ( @xmath8 direction ) .\",\n \"we use unit cells with a volume of ( @xmath9 ) @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is cnt lattice constant and @xmath12 a factor to keep a minimum distance among tpp images along the cnts , chosen to be of 10 .\",\n \"this procedure results in supercell lengths ( @xmath13 ) between 22 - 57 , which can contain up to 754 atoms .\",\n \"a grid cutoff of 100 ry and the @xmath14 point were used for the real - space and @xmath15-space integration , respectively . for the optical calculations , we use a @xmath16 @xmath15-point mesh , for incident light polarized along the cnt axis .\",\n \"the accuracy of these parameters were tested considering larger grid cutoff ( 150 ry ) and @xmath15-point mesh ( @xmath17 ) .\",\n \"negligible variations in the total energies , optical spectra , and band structures were found , ensuring that our results are converged .\",\n \"for the tpp physisorption on graphene , we use a squared unit cell with @xmath18 periodicity and the @xmath14 point for the @xmath15-space integration . here , a vacuum region of 20 among graphene an their images was considered . for the optical response we use a @xmath15-point mesh of @xmath19 , for incident light polarized parallel to the graphene plane ( @xmath20 and @xmath21 directions ) . the tpp binding energy on the substrates is calculated by the energy difference between adsorbed and separated constituents , considering corrections due to the basis set superposition error .\",\n \"the complexes were fully relaxed by conjugate gradient minimization until the forces on the atoms were less than 0.05 ev / .\",\n \"the optical response of the functionalized cnts and graphene is obtained through first order time dependent perturbation theory , by calculating the imaginary part of the dielectric function ( @xmath22 ) .\",\n \"@xmath22 gives us a first approach for the optical absorption coefficient and it is calculated according to the equation : @xmath23 here @xmath24 is a constant that depends on the cell sizes ; @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the occupied and empty kohn - sham orbitals , respectively .\",\n \"the delta function represents the conservation of energy , which is described by a gaussian function with a smearing of 0.06 ev .\",\n \"it is important to note that dft calculations fail in describing electron - hole and electron - electron interactions , the so called many - body effects .\",\n \"these effects are responsible for the formation of excitons and the quasiparticle excitation .\",\n \"@xcite therefore , an accurate description of photoexcitations in cnts and graphene needs theories beyond dft , like those based on the gw - bethe - salpeter equation ( gw - bse).@xcite however , these calculations are not possible right now , considering the size of the systems under study .\",\n \"thus , @xmath22 can give us a first approach for the optical response of @xmath4-stacked tpp on cnts and graphene .\",\n \"the main difference of dft calculations with respect to gw - bse is a redshift in the absorption spectrum .\",\n \"for instance , in graphene this redshift is found to be about 0.6 ev.@xcite\",\n \"we first discuss different adsorption geometries for the tpp molecule on the cnts .\",\n \"figure [ f1 ] shows the equilibrium geometry of a tpp adsorbed on a ( 8,7 ) cnt . here , the n - h bonds of tpp are oriented perpendicular to the cnt axis , that we called position ( i ) .\",\n \"two other positions for tpp are likely to be found : with the n - h bonds parallel to the cnt axis ( ii ) , and with the n - h bonds forming an angle of 45@xmath27 with respect to the cnt axis ( iii ) . although position ( i ) is found to be the most stable , the other positions have total energies within 0.3 ev , suggesting that all three are equally probables . in the equilibrium geometry , the tpp phenyl groups exhibit a small rotation , which come with a molecular twisting . to compare the stability of different cnt - tpp complexes , only position ( i ) will be considered throughout this work .\",\n \"the adsorption distance is measured between the cnt surface and the n atoms of tpp , as shown in figure [ f1 ] .\",\n \".adsorption distance ( @xmath28 ) , binding energy ( @xmath29 ) , and bandgap energy ( @xmath30 ) of cnt - tpp complexes .\",\n \"@xmath31 and @xmath32 are the cnt diameter and chiral angle , respectively .\",\n \"results for tpp on graphene ( g - tpp ) are also included . [\",\n \"cols=\\\"<,<,<,<,<,<\\\",options=\\\"header \\\" , ] [ t1 ] table [ t1 ] lists tpp binding energies and binding distances for all the complex under study .\",\n \"we also include the dft bandgaps for the semiconducting complexes .\",\n \"those with small bandgaps ( @xmath330.1 ev ) are consistent with empirical model predictions of @xmath34 as well as with experimental data.@xcite we observe that binding energies and adsorption distances vary in ranges given by @xmath35 ev and @xmath36 , respectively .\",\n \"we note that stronger tpp @xmath4-stacking interactions result in larger adsorption distance .\",\n \"this can be understood by look at the tpp phenyl groups , whose h atoms become closer to the cnt surface for large diameter cnts , as can be seen in figure [ f1 ] . to estimate an upper limit for @xmath29 and @xmath28\",\n \", we calculate the tpp physisorption on graphene , which can be considered as a cnt with an infinite diameter .\",\n \"we find @xmath37 ev and @xmath38 .\",\n \"although the binding distance is similar to those found on cnts with @xmath39 , the binding energy is considerably larger , with almost twice the value found on the cnts .\",\n \"this can be understood because of the larger graphene - tpp overlap area , which tend to maximize the @xmath4-stacking interaction .\",\n \"figure [ f2 ] shows the cnt - tpp binding energy as a function of the cnt diameter .\",\n \"we observe an almost linear increase in the tpp attachment strength with the cnt diameter , which in some way confirms our assumption that larger cnt - tpp overlap area tends to increase the binding energy of the molecule .\",\n \"however , this general tendency is not followed in some cases , as can be seen in fig .\",\n \"for instance , ( i ) the larger tpp binding energy found for the ( 5,0 ) cnt ( @xmath40 ) with respect to the ( 6,0 ) cnt ( @xmath41 ) , by about 0.2 ev , and ( ii ) the abrupt changes in the tpp binding energy profile going from ( 6,0 ) to ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,5 ) to ( 7,6 ) , and ( 8,5 ) to ( 8,6 ) .\",\n \"we attribute these results to the particular atomic geometry of the cnt atoms just below the tpp molecule .\",\n \"we observe that the cnt - tpp binding distance tends to increase when the h atoms of the phenyl groups nearest neighbors to the cnt surface , lie exactly above nanotube c - atoms .\",\n \"this effect is due to the steric repulsion between them , which also explain the broad variation on the binding distances between the cnt surface and the tpp n - atoms , as shown in figure [ f3 ] .\",\n \"figure [ f4 ] shows the cnt - tpp binding energy as a function of the cnt chiral angle .\",\n \"apparently , higher chiral angles would induce stronger tpp attachment .\",\n \"however , if we compare the tpp attachment on cnts with similar diameters and binding distances with those plotted as a function of the chiral angle , we observe that they have also similar binding energy , suggesting that the cnt diameter instead chirality is the relevant parameter involved in the strong tpp binding energy .\",\n \"for instance , if we take the cnts with chiral indices ( 5,4 ) and ( 7,2 ) , they show almost the same tpp binding energy when plotted with respect to both the cnt diameter ( fig . [ f2 ] ) and adsorption distance ( fig .\",\n \"however , they also show the same binding energy when plotted with respect to the chiral angle ( fig .\",\n \"the same behavior can be verified for the pairs of cnts ( 5,5)-(6,4 ) and ( 6,5)-(7,4 ) .\",\n \"these results suggest that the strength of the tpp interaction on the cnts would not be related to the cnt surface geometry or chirality , but to the cnt diameter . the adsorption energy of benzene and naphthalene on cnts ( 7 - 8 diameter ) , using electron - correlated moller - plasset ( mp2 ) method reports binding energies for benzene and naphthalene of 0.18 and 0.48 ev , respectively .\",\n \"@xcite this results suggest an overestimation of the tpp adsorption energy on cnts . however , temperature programmed desorption experiments performed in ultrahigh vacuum have measured the binding energy of polyaromatic hydrocarbons ( pahs ) adsorbed on graphite , showing quite strong desorption energies .\",\n \"@xcite in that work , benzene , naphthalene , coronene , and ovalene adsorbed on graphite show desorption energies of 0.50 , 0.85 , 1.4 , and 2.1 ev , respectively .\",\n \"for the case of benzene and naphthalene , the experimental values almost double the mp2-theory values . even considering the cnt curvatures , the @xmath4-stacking interaction appears to be much more larger than the usually expected .\",\n \"in addition , a recent study of pahs adsorption on graphene shows that the vdw - df calculations exhibit excellent agreement with the available experimental data , while empirical and semiempirical calculations only preserve the correct trends.@xcite in summary , the work concludes that the adsorption interaction of @xmath4-conjugate systems on graphene are a complex combination of dispersive and electrostatic interactions , which would explains to some extent our results for the large adsorption energies of tpp on both graphene and cnts .\",\n \"noncovalent functionalization of a single - walled ( 6,5 ) cnt with tpp molecules have been reported in aqueous solution by mean of the micellar suspension method.@xcite the optical absorption of ( 6,5)-tpp complexes shows resonances at 2.357 and 2.831 ev , which are associated to the @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( soret ) tpp bands , respectively.@xcite our results for the optical response of the ( 6,5)-tpp complex for a polarization parallel to the tube axis , show clear transitions at 1.60 and 2.04 ev , which we associate to the tpp @xmath42 and @xmath43 bands , respectively .\",\n \"the difference in energy between these peaks ( 0.44 ev ) is almost the same than those observed in the experiments ( 0.474 ev).@xcite however , the theoretical peaks show a redshift of about 0.8 ev with respect to the experimental ones , while the shape of the absorption spectra would be preserved .\",\n \"this shift is associated to many - body effects previously discussed .\",\n \"therefore , through the @xmath22 calculation it is possible to investigate , qualitatively , changes in the optical properties of different cnt - tpp complexes in term of the cnt structural parameters , like diameter or chirality .\",\n \"figure [ f5 ] and [ f6 ] show @xmath22 as a function of the photon energy , for incident light polarized parallel to the tube axis , for the semiconducting cnt - tpp complexes .\",\n \"the red and black spectra indicate the optical response of cnt - tpp and the isolated cnt , respectively .\",\n \"the vertical dashed lines indicate the position of the tpp @xmath42 ( 1.60 ev ) and @xmath43 ( 2.04 ev ) bands .\",\n \"the optical spectra clearly show the absorption of the @xmath4-stacked tpp at almost the same position than the isolated tpp , indicating that the tpp absorption properties would be preserved in the complexes , being independent of the cnt diameter or chirality .\",\n \"however , we must note that the present results were obtained considering only one tpp molecule on the cnts .\",\n \"increasing tpp coverages may change this conclusion .\",\n \"the optical response of complexes considering metallic and semimetallic cnts ( not shown ) exhibit the same properties .\",\n \"another interesting feature is the resonance between the cnt @xmath44 transition with the @xmath43 band for the cnts : ( 5,4 ) , ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,3 ) , and ( 10,0 ) , and with the @xmath42 band for the cnts : ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,5 ) , ( 7,6 ) , and ( 7,2 ) .\",\n \"this tuning between @xmath44 and the tpp bands would increase the emission of the corresponding complex .\",\n \"figure [ f7 ] shows the electronic band structure and density of states ( dos ) of the graphene - tpp compound described in a squared reciprocal lattice .\",\n \"the vertical arrows show the optical transition between the frontier molecular orbitals of the @xmath4-stacked tpp , which correspond to the dispersionless subbands . here , @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) is the transition from homo to lumo ( lumo+1 ) , while @xmath47 ( @xmath48 ) is the transitions from homo-1 to lumo ( lumo+1 ) .\",\n \"these absorptions arise from @xmath49 transitions and can be characterized approximately by considering only the four molecular levels above mentioned .\",\n \"@xcite in pristine graphene , the valence - band maximum and conduction - band minimum touch at one point in the @xmath15 space , the dirac point , which occurs at the fermi energy .\",\n \"this indicates that graphene is a zero - gap semiconductor . in fig .\",\n \"[ f7 ] , we observe that the fermi energy ( the dashed line ) is shifted upward with respect to the dirac point energy , which indicates a charge transfer from tpp to graphene , revealing a @xmath0-type doping mechanism . therefore , graphene would change its electronic characteristic induced by the strong tpp complexation . as the @xmath4-stacking molecule do not alter the graphene atomic structure , their transport properties would be preserved .\",\n \"similar results have been reported for other aromatic molecules physisorbed on graphene.@xcite figure [ f8 ] shows @xmath22 of a tpp @xmath4-stacked on graphene , the g - tpp compound , considering an in - plain polarizations of incident light . for pristine graphene , we find a strong absorption in the infrared , below 1 ev , and a less intense absorption in the ultraviolet , at around 4 ev , which are attributed to transitions among @xmath4 and @xmath50 bands .\",\n \"these results are in qualitative agreement with calculated absorption spectra using the gw - bse approach as well as with experiments,@xcite unless the redshift previously discussed . for functionalized graphene ,\",\n \"we observe two intense absorptions at around 1.57 and 1.96 ev , corresponding to the @xmath51 and @xmath52 bands of the @xmath4-stacked tpp .\",\n \"these peaks show a redshift with respect to those of the isolated tpp of 0.05 ev , which is associated to the distortion of the tpp phenyl groups due to the strong @xmath4-stacking interaction .\",\n \"additional peaks at around 2.6 and 3.1 ev are also associated to the tpp molecule .\",\n \"we have theoretically investigated the stability and optical absorption properties of a free - base tpp molecule @xmath4-stacked on single - walled cnts , as well as on graphene .\",\n \"42 cnts with chiral indices ( @xmath0,@xmath1 ) , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 , have been studied . in term of the diameter ,\",\n \"they range within @xmath53 .\",\n \"the tpp physisorption is described by van der waals density functional while the optical properties through the imaginary part of the dielectric function in the linear optical response .\",\n \"we find a strong cnt - tpp @xmath4-stacking interaction , with binding energies and adsorption distance varying within @xmath35 ev and @xmath36 , respectively , where larger @xmath29 and @xmath28 are obtained for increasing cnt diameters .\",\n \"our results indicates that diameter instead chirality is the relevant parameter for the strong tpp physisorption , which would be originated in the increasing overlap area between tpp and the cnts .\",\n \"an upper limit for the cnt - tpp binding strength can be estimated through the tpp physisorption on graphene , which can be viewed as an infinite - diameter cnt .\",\n \"we find very strong @xmath4-stacking interactions , with @xmath37 ev and @xmath38 .\",\n \"however , this strong interaction is not enough to open an energy gap in the functionalized graphene , but it can induce a charge transfer from tpp , suggesting a @xmath0-type doping mechanism without compromising the graphene structure and transport properties . concerning optical properties , we find that @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( soret ) tpp absorption bands remain at almost the same energy position after the physisorption on the cnts , being independent of the cnt structural parameters . whereas on graphene , the tpp bands show a redshift of about 0.05 ev , which are associated to the distortion of the phenyl groups due to the strong @xmath4-stacking interaction .\",\n \"finally , our results suggest that both compounds cnt - tpp and g - tpp exhibit remarkable stability while preserving the absorption properties of the chromophore , which may be of interest for light - harvesting and bio - labeling applications .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> the stability , electronic and optical properties of single - walled carbon nanotubes ( cnts ) and graphene noncovalently functionalized with free - base tetraphenylporphyrin ( tpp ) molecules is addressed by density functional theory calculations , including corrections to dispersive interactions . </S>","<S> we study the tpp physisorption on 42 cnt species , particularly those with chiral indices ( @xmath0,@xmath1 ) , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 . </S>","<S> our results show a quite strong @xmath4-@xmath4 interaction between tpp and the cnt surface , with binding energies ranging from 1.1 to 1.8 ev , where higher energies can be associated with increasing cnt diameters . </S>","<S> we also find that the tpp optical absorptions would not be affected by the cnt diameter or chirality . </S>","<S> results for the tpp physisorption on graphene show a remarkable stability with binding energy of 3.2 ev , inducing a small redshift on the @xmath4-stacked tpp absorption bands . </S>","<S> the strong graphene - tpp interaction also induces a charge transfer from tpp to graphene , indicating a @xmath0-type doping mechanism without compromising the graphene structure . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> the stability , electronic and optical properties of single - walled carbon nanotubes ( cnts ) and graphene noncovalently functionalized with free - base tetraphenylporphyrin ( tpp ) molecules is addressed by density functional theory calculations , including corrections to dispersive interactions . </S>\",\n \"<S> we study the tpp physisorption on 42 cnt species , particularly those with chiral indices ( @xmath0,@xmath1 ) , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 . </S>\",\n \"<S> our results show a quite strong @xmath4-@xmath4 interaction between tpp and the cnt surface , with binding energies ranging from 1.1 to 1.8 ev , where higher energies can be associated with increasing cnt diameters . </S>\",\n \"<S> we also find that the tpp optical absorptions would not be affected by the cnt diameter or chirality . </S>\",\n \"<S> results for the tpp physisorption on graphene show a remarkable stability with binding energy of 3.2 ev , inducing a small redshift on the @xmath4-stacked tpp absorption bands . </S>\",\n \"<S> the strong graphene - tpp interaction also induces a charge transfer from tpp to graphene , indicating a @xmath0-type doping mechanism without compromising the graphene structure . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","theoretical approach","results and discussion","summary and conclusions"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"theoretical approach\",\n \"results and discussion\",\n \"summary and conclusions\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["noncovalent functionalization of single - walled carbon nanotubes ( cnts ) with photoactive molecules is becoming a promising technique to explore functional materials for light - harvesting or optoelectronic applications .","@xcite the coupling of the exceptional cnt transport properties with the optical properties of functional dyes , like porphyrins with a strong absorption in the near infrared and visible , make of cnt / dye complexes good candidates for sensitive nanoscale devices with potential applications in biomedical imaging , @xcite and hybrid organic - inorganic photovoltaic devices .","@xcite however , the strength of the @xmath4-stacking interaction with respect to the cnt structural parameters , like the diameter and chirality , is still lacking .","in addition , a better understanding of the cnt / dye optical properties considering changes in the dye structure due to the @xmath4-conjugation is needed .","recently , the kinetics and thermodynamics properties of non - covalently bound cnt / porphyrin oligomers have been investigated by uv / visible spectroscopy and fluorescence titration.@xcite it was reported that the affinity of the cnts increases sharply with the porphyrin coverage , showing strongest binding energies for semiconducting cnts , particularly those with chiral indices ( 7,5 ) and ( 8,6 ) . in addition , others works have also investigated a supposed selective interaction of porphyrins towards semiconducting cnts , suggesting that the semiconducting and metallic cnts would have significantly different surface properties.@xcite these works have also suggested that noncovalent functionalization of a mixture of cnts with porphyrins may be an effective method for the separation of semiconducting cnts from metallic cnts .","previously , we reported physisorption properties of iron porphyrin on both metallic and semiconducting cnts with similar diameters.@xcite our results showed a surprising strong @xmath4-stacking interaction , but with negligible energy differences .","similar results were found for the physisorption strength of free - base and zinc porphyrins on the same semiconducting cnt,@xcite showing no clue on the suspected selectivity .","considering the increasing interest in the noncovalent complexation of cnt - based materials for optoelectronic applications , we carry out an in - depth investigation on the stability and optical response of free - base tetraphenyporphyrin ( tpp ) molecules @xmath4-stacked on single - walled cnts with different chiralities and diameters , and also on graphene .","our purpose is to give a theoretically insight into the binding strength and optical properties of these compounds as a function of the cnt structural parameters .","our results show that the diameter instead chirality would be the relevant cnt parameter to explain the unusual strength of the tpp @xmath4-stacking interaction .","in addition , the tpp binding energy on metallic and semiconducting cnts does not exhibit important differences that might suggest distinct interactions .","regarding optical properties , we find that transition bands of the @xmath4-stacked tpp remain at almost the same energy position than those found in the isolated tpp , being independent of the cnt structural parameters .","for the tpp physisorption on graphene , we find a very strong binding energy , of about 3.2 ev , providing an upper limit for the stability of cnt - tpp compounds .","we also find a @xmath5-type doping on graphene induced by the tpp adsorption ."],["our density functional theory ( dft ) calculations were performed using the siesta _ ab initio _ package,@xcite which employ norm - conserving pseudopotentials and localized atomic orbitals as basis set ( double-@xmath6 , singly polarized ) .","the physisorption of tpp on both the cnt sidewall and graphene is assessed by van der waals density functional ( vdw - df ) as proposed by dion _","et al._@xcite this approach has been successfully applied to describe the dispersive interaction of aromatic molecules on the graphite surface , showing good agreement with available experimental data.@xcite in recent experiments , the functionalization of cnts with tpp molecules has been achieved by the micelle swelling methods in water suspension,@xcite where the cnt - tpp compound stays in the micelle core .","because of the hydrophobic character of this core , it is not expected water molecules surrounding the compound , which can be considered close to a vacuum situation . in the present work we study the tpp physisorption 42 different cnt species , particularly those with chiral indices ( @xmath0,@xmath1 ) , with @xmath7 and @xmath3 .","the cnt - tpp compounds are studied within the supercell approach , with periodic boundary conditions along the nanotube axis ( @xmath8 direction ) .","we use unit cells with a volume of ( @xmath9 ) @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is cnt lattice constant and @xmath12 a factor to keep a minimum distance among tpp images along the cnts , chosen to be of 10 .","this procedure results in supercell lengths ( @xmath13 ) between 22 - 57 , which can contain up to 754 atoms .","a grid cutoff of 100 ry and the @xmath14 point were used for the real - space and @xmath15-space integration , respectively . for the optical calculations , we use a @xmath16 @xmath15-point mesh , for incident light polarized along the cnt axis .","the accuracy of these parameters were tested considering larger grid cutoff ( 150 ry ) and @xmath15-point mesh ( @xmath17 ) .","negligible variations in the total energies , optical spectra , and band structures were found , ensuring that our results are converged .","for the tpp physisorption on graphene , we use a squared unit cell with @xmath18 periodicity and the @xmath14 point for the @xmath15-space integration . here , a vacuum region of 20 among graphene an their images was considered . for the optical response we use a @xmath15-point mesh of @xmath19 , for incident light polarized parallel to the graphene plane ( @xmath20 and @xmath21 directions ) . the tpp binding energy on the substrates is calculated by the energy difference between adsorbed and separated constituents , considering corrections due to the basis set superposition error .","the complexes were fully relaxed by conjugate gradient minimization until the forces on the atoms were less than 0.05 ev / .","the optical response of the functionalized cnts and graphene is obtained through first order time dependent perturbation theory , by calculating the imaginary part of the dielectric function ( @xmath22 ) .","@xmath22 gives us a first approach for the optical absorption coefficient and it is calculated according to the equation : @xmath23 here @xmath24 is a constant that depends on the cell sizes ; @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the occupied and empty kohn - sham orbitals , respectively .","the delta function represents the conservation of energy , which is described by a gaussian function with a smearing of 0.06 ev .","it is important to note that dft calculations fail in describing electron - hole and electron - electron interactions , the so called many - body effects .","these effects are responsible for the formation of excitons and the quasiparticle excitation .","@xcite therefore , an accurate description of photoexcitations in cnts and graphene needs theories beyond dft , like those based on the gw - bethe - salpeter equation ( gw - bse).@xcite however , these calculations are not possible right now , considering the size of the systems under study .","thus , @xmath22 can give us a first approach for the optical response of @xmath4-stacked tpp on cnts and graphene .","the main difference of dft calculations with respect to gw - bse is a redshift in the absorption spectrum .","for instance , in graphene this redshift is found to be about 0.6 ev.@xcite"],["we first discuss different adsorption geometries for the tpp molecule on the cnts .","figure [ f1 ] shows the equilibrium geometry of a tpp adsorbed on a ( 8,7 ) cnt . here , the n - h bonds of tpp are oriented perpendicular to the cnt axis , that we called position ( i ) .","two other positions for tpp are likely to be found : with the n - h bonds parallel to the cnt axis ( ii ) , and with the n - h bonds forming an angle of 45@xmath27 with respect to the cnt axis ( iii ) . although position ( i ) is found to be the most stable , the other positions have total energies within 0.3 ev , suggesting that all three are equally probables . in the equilibrium geometry , the tpp phenyl groups exhibit a small rotation , which come with a molecular twisting . to compare the stability of different cnt - tpp complexes , only position ( i ) will be considered throughout this work .","the adsorption distance is measured between the cnt surface and the n atoms of tpp , as shown in figure [ f1 ] .",".adsorption distance ( @xmath28 ) , binding energy ( @xmath29 ) , and bandgap energy ( @xmath30 ) of cnt - tpp complexes .","@xmath31 and @xmath32 are the cnt diameter and chiral angle , respectively .","results for tpp on graphene ( g - tpp ) are also included . [","cols=\"<,<,<,<,<,<\",options=\"header \" , ] [ t1 ] table [ t1 ] lists tpp binding energies and binding distances for all the complex under study .","we also include the dft bandgaps for the semiconducting complexes .","those with small bandgaps ( @xmath330.1 ev ) are consistent with empirical model predictions of @xmath34 as well as with experimental data.@xcite we observe that binding energies and adsorption distances vary in ranges given by @xmath35 ev and @xmath36 , respectively .","we note that stronger tpp @xmath4-stacking interactions result in larger adsorption distance .","this can be understood by look at the tpp phenyl groups , whose h atoms become closer to the cnt surface for large diameter cnts , as can be seen in figure [ f1 ] . to estimate an upper limit for @xmath29 and @xmath28",", we calculate the tpp physisorption on graphene , which can be considered as a cnt with an infinite diameter .","we find @xmath37 ev and @xmath38 .","although the binding distance is similar to those found on cnts with @xmath39 , the binding energy is considerably larger , with almost twice the value found on the cnts .","this can be understood because of the larger graphene - tpp overlap area , which tend to maximize the @xmath4-stacking interaction .","figure [ f2 ] shows the cnt - tpp binding energy as a function of the cnt diameter .","we observe an almost linear increase in the tpp attachment strength with the cnt diameter , which in some way confirms our assumption that larger cnt - tpp overlap area tends to increase the binding energy of the molecule .","however , this general tendency is not followed in some cases , as can be seen in fig .","for instance , ( i ) the larger tpp binding energy found for the ( 5,0 ) cnt ( @xmath40 ) with respect to the ( 6,0 ) cnt ( @xmath41 ) , by about 0.2 ev , and ( ii ) the abrupt changes in the tpp binding energy profile going from ( 6,0 ) to ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,5 ) to ( 7,6 ) , and ( 8,5 ) to ( 8,6 ) .","we attribute these results to the particular atomic geometry of the cnt atoms just below the tpp molecule .","we observe that the cnt - tpp binding distance tends to increase when the h atoms of the phenyl groups nearest neighbors to the cnt surface , lie exactly above nanotube c - atoms .","this effect is due to the steric repulsion between them , which also explain the broad variation on the binding distances between the cnt surface and the tpp n - atoms , as shown in figure [ f3 ] .","figure [ f4 ] shows the cnt - tpp binding energy as a function of the cnt chiral angle .","apparently , higher chiral angles would induce stronger tpp attachment .","however , if we compare the tpp attachment on cnts with similar diameters and binding distances with those plotted as a function of the chiral angle , we observe that they have also similar binding energy , suggesting that the cnt diameter instead chirality is the relevant parameter involved in the strong tpp binding energy .","for instance , if we take the cnts with chiral indices ( 5,4 ) and ( 7,2 ) , they show almost the same tpp binding energy when plotted with respect to both the cnt diameter ( fig . [ f2 ] ) and adsorption distance ( fig .","however , they also show the same binding energy when plotted with respect to the chiral angle ( fig .","the same behavior can be verified for the pairs of cnts ( 5,5)-(6,4 ) and ( 6,5)-(7,4 ) .","these results suggest that the strength of the tpp interaction on the cnts would not be related to the cnt surface geometry or chirality , but to the cnt diameter . the adsorption energy of benzene and naphthalene on cnts ( 7 - 8 diameter ) , using electron - correlated moller - plasset ( mp2 ) method reports binding energies for benzene and naphthalene of 0.18 and 0.48 ev , respectively .","@xcite this results suggest an overestimation of the tpp adsorption energy on cnts . however , temperature programmed desorption experiments performed in ultrahigh vacuum have measured the binding energy of polyaromatic hydrocarbons ( pahs ) adsorbed on graphite , showing quite strong desorption energies .","@xcite in that work , benzene , naphthalene , coronene , and ovalene adsorbed on graphite show desorption energies of 0.50 , 0.85 , 1.4 , and 2.1 ev , respectively .","for the case of benzene and naphthalene , the experimental values almost double the mp2-theory values . even considering the cnt curvatures , the @xmath4-stacking interaction appears to be much more larger than the usually expected .","in addition , a recent study of pahs adsorption on graphene shows that the vdw - df calculations exhibit excellent agreement with the available experimental data , while empirical and semiempirical calculations only preserve the correct trends.@xcite in summary , the work concludes that the adsorption interaction of @xmath4-conjugate systems on graphene are a complex combination of dispersive and electrostatic interactions , which would explains to some extent our results for the large adsorption energies of tpp on both graphene and cnts .","noncovalent functionalization of a single - walled ( 6,5 ) cnt with tpp molecules have been reported in aqueous solution by mean of the micellar suspension method.@xcite the optical absorption of ( 6,5)-tpp complexes shows resonances at 2.357 and 2.831 ev , which are associated to the @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( soret ) tpp bands , respectively.@xcite our results for the optical response of the ( 6,5)-tpp complex for a polarization parallel to the tube axis , show clear transitions at 1.60 and 2.04 ev , which we associate to the tpp @xmath42 and @xmath43 bands , respectively .","the difference in energy between these peaks ( 0.44 ev ) is almost the same than those observed in the experiments ( 0.474 ev).@xcite however , the theoretical peaks show a redshift of about 0.8 ev with respect to the experimental ones , while the shape of the absorption spectra would be preserved .","this shift is associated to many - body effects previously discussed .","therefore , through the @xmath22 calculation it is possible to investigate , qualitatively , changes in the optical properties of different cnt - tpp complexes in term of the cnt structural parameters , like diameter or chirality .","figure [ f5 ] and [ f6 ] show @xmath22 as a function of the photon energy , for incident light polarized parallel to the tube axis , for the semiconducting cnt - tpp complexes .","the red and black spectra indicate the optical response of cnt - tpp and the isolated cnt , respectively .","the vertical dashed lines indicate the position of the tpp @xmath42 ( 1.60 ev ) and @xmath43 ( 2.04 ev ) bands .","the optical spectra clearly show the absorption of the @xmath4-stacked tpp at almost the same position than the isolated tpp , indicating that the tpp absorption properties would be preserved in the complexes , being independent of the cnt diameter or chirality .","however , we must note that the present results were obtained considering only one tpp molecule on the cnts .","increasing tpp coverages may change this conclusion .","the optical response of complexes considering metallic and semimetallic cnts ( not shown ) exhibit the same properties .","another interesting feature is the resonance between the cnt @xmath44 transition with the @xmath43 band for the cnts : ( 5,4 ) , ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,3 ) , and ( 10,0 ) , and with the @xmath42 band for the cnts : ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,5 ) , ( 7,6 ) , and ( 7,2 ) .","this tuning between @xmath44 and the tpp bands would increase the emission of the corresponding complex .","figure [ f7 ] shows the electronic band structure and density of states ( dos ) of the graphene - tpp compound described in a squared reciprocal lattice .","the vertical arrows show the optical transition between the frontier molecular orbitals of the @xmath4-stacked tpp , which correspond to the dispersionless subbands . here , @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) is the transition from homo to lumo ( lumo+1 ) , while @xmath47 ( @xmath48 ) is the transitions from homo-1 to lumo ( lumo+1 ) .","these absorptions arise from @xmath49 transitions and can be characterized approximately by considering only the four molecular levels above mentioned .","@xcite in pristine graphene , the valence - band maximum and conduction - band minimum touch at one point in the @xmath15 space , the dirac point , which occurs at the fermi energy .","this indicates that graphene is a zero - gap semiconductor . in fig .","[ f7 ] , we observe that the fermi energy ( the dashed line ) is shifted upward with respect to the dirac point energy , which indicates a charge transfer from tpp to graphene , revealing a @xmath0-type doping mechanism . therefore , graphene would change its electronic characteristic induced by the strong tpp complexation . as the @xmath4-stacking molecule do not alter the graphene atomic structure , their transport properties would be preserved .","similar results have been reported for other aromatic molecules physisorbed on graphene.@xcite figure [ f8 ] shows @xmath22 of a tpp @xmath4-stacked on graphene , the g - tpp compound , considering an in - plain polarizations of incident light . for pristine graphene , we find a strong absorption in the infrared , below 1 ev , and a less intense absorption in the ultraviolet , at around 4 ev , which are attributed to transitions among @xmath4 and @xmath50 bands .","these results are in qualitative agreement with calculated absorption spectra using the gw - bse approach as well as with experiments,@xcite unless the redshift previously discussed . for functionalized graphene ,","we observe two intense absorptions at around 1.57 and 1.96 ev , corresponding to the @xmath51 and @xmath52 bands of the @xmath4-stacked tpp .","these peaks show a redshift with respect to those of the isolated tpp of 0.05 ev , which is associated to the distortion of the tpp phenyl groups due to the strong @xmath4-stacking interaction .","additional peaks at around 2.6 and 3.1 ev are also associated to the tpp molecule ."],["we have theoretically investigated the stability and optical absorption properties of a free - base tpp molecule @xmath4-stacked on single - walled cnts , as well as on graphene .","42 cnts with chiral indices ( @xmath0,@xmath1 ) , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 , have been studied . in term of the diameter ,","they range within @xmath53 .","the tpp physisorption is described by van der waals density functional while the optical properties through the imaginary part of the dielectric function in the linear optical response .","we find a strong cnt - tpp @xmath4-stacking interaction , with binding energies and adsorption distance varying within @xmath35 ev and @xmath36 , respectively , where larger @xmath29 and @xmath28 are obtained for increasing cnt diameters .","our results indicates that diameter instead chirality is the relevant parameter for the strong tpp physisorption , which would be originated in the increasing overlap area between tpp and the cnts .","an upper limit for the cnt - tpp binding strength can be estimated through the tpp physisorption on graphene , which can be viewed as an infinite - diameter cnt .","we find very strong @xmath4-stacking interactions , with @xmath37 ev and @xmath38 .","however , this strong interaction is not enough to open an energy gap in the functionalized graphene , but it can induce a charge transfer from tpp , suggesting a @xmath0-type doping mechanism without compromising the graphene structure and transport properties . concerning optical properties , we find that @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( soret ) tpp absorption bands remain at almost the same energy position after the physisorption on the cnts , being independent of the cnt structural parameters . whereas on graphene , the tpp bands show a redshift of about 0.05 ev , which are associated to the distortion of the phenyl groups due to the strong @xmath4-stacking interaction .","finally , our results suggest that both compounds cnt - tpp and g - tpp exhibit remarkable stability while preserving the absorption properties of the chromophore , which may be of interest for light - harvesting and bio - labeling applications ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"noncovalent functionalization of single - walled carbon nanotubes ( cnts ) with photoactive molecules is becoming a promising technique to explore functional materials for light - harvesting or optoelectronic applications .\",\n \"@xcite the coupling of the exceptional cnt transport properties with the optical properties of functional dyes , like porphyrins with a strong absorption in the near infrared and visible , make of cnt / dye complexes good candidates for sensitive nanoscale devices with potential applications in biomedical imaging , @xcite and hybrid organic - inorganic photovoltaic devices .\",\n \"@xcite however , the strength of the @xmath4-stacking interaction with respect to the cnt structural parameters , like the diameter and chirality , is still lacking .\",\n \"in addition , a better understanding of the cnt / dye optical properties considering changes in the dye structure due to the @xmath4-conjugation is needed .\",\n \"recently , the kinetics and thermodynamics properties of non - covalently bound cnt / porphyrin oligomers have been investigated by uv / visible spectroscopy and fluorescence titration.@xcite it was reported that the affinity of the cnts increases sharply with the porphyrin coverage , showing strongest binding energies for semiconducting cnts , particularly those with chiral indices ( 7,5 ) and ( 8,6 ) . in addition , others works have also investigated a supposed selective interaction of porphyrins towards semiconducting cnts , suggesting that the semiconducting and metallic cnts would have significantly different surface properties.@xcite these works have also suggested that noncovalent functionalization of a mixture of cnts with porphyrins may be an effective method for the separation of semiconducting cnts from metallic cnts .\",\n \"previously , we reported physisorption properties of iron porphyrin on both metallic and semiconducting cnts with similar diameters.@xcite our results showed a surprising strong @xmath4-stacking interaction , but with negligible energy differences .\",\n \"similar results were found for the physisorption strength of free - base and zinc porphyrins on the same semiconducting cnt,@xcite showing no clue on the suspected selectivity .\",\n \"considering the increasing interest in the noncovalent complexation of cnt - based materials for optoelectronic applications , we carry out an in - depth investigation on the stability and optical response of free - base tetraphenyporphyrin ( tpp ) molecules @xmath4-stacked on single - walled cnts with different chiralities and diameters , and also on graphene .\",\n \"our purpose is to give a theoretically insight into the binding strength and optical properties of these compounds as a function of the cnt structural parameters .\",\n \"our results show that the diameter instead chirality would be the relevant cnt parameter to explain the unusual strength of the tpp @xmath4-stacking interaction .\",\n \"in addition , the tpp binding energy on metallic and semiconducting cnts does not exhibit important differences that might suggest distinct interactions .\",\n \"regarding optical properties , we find that transition bands of the @xmath4-stacked tpp remain at almost the same energy position than those found in the isolated tpp , being independent of the cnt structural parameters .\",\n \"for the tpp physisorption on graphene , we find a very strong binding energy , of about 3.2 ev , providing an upper limit for the stability of cnt - tpp compounds .\",\n \"we also find a @xmath5-type doping on graphene induced by the tpp adsorption .\"\n ],\n [\n \"our density functional theory ( dft ) calculations were performed using the siesta _ ab initio _ package,@xcite which employ norm - conserving pseudopotentials and localized atomic orbitals as basis set ( double-@xmath6 , singly polarized ) .\",\n \"the physisorption of tpp on both the cnt sidewall and graphene is assessed by van der waals density functional ( vdw - df ) as proposed by dion _\",\n \"et al._@xcite this approach has been successfully applied to describe the dispersive interaction of aromatic molecules on the graphite surface , showing good agreement with available experimental data.@xcite in recent experiments , the functionalization of cnts with tpp molecules has been achieved by the micelle swelling methods in water suspension,@xcite where the cnt - tpp compound stays in the micelle core .\",\n \"because of the hydrophobic character of this core , it is not expected water molecules surrounding the compound , which can be considered close to a vacuum situation . in the present work we study the tpp physisorption 42 different cnt species , particularly those with chiral indices ( @xmath0,@xmath1 ) , with @xmath7 and @xmath3 .\",\n \"the cnt - tpp compounds are studied within the supercell approach , with periodic boundary conditions along the nanotube axis ( @xmath8 direction ) .\",\n \"we use unit cells with a volume of ( @xmath9 ) @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is cnt lattice constant and @xmath12 a factor to keep a minimum distance among tpp images along the cnts , chosen to be of 10 .\",\n \"this procedure results in supercell lengths ( @xmath13 ) between 22 - 57 , which can contain up to 754 atoms .\",\n \"a grid cutoff of 100 ry and the @xmath14 point were used for the real - space and @xmath15-space integration , respectively . for the optical calculations , we use a @xmath16 @xmath15-point mesh , for incident light polarized along the cnt axis .\",\n \"the accuracy of these parameters were tested considering larger grid cutoff ( 150 ry ) and @xmath15-point mesh ( @xmath17 ) .\",\n \"negligible variations in the total energies , optical spectra , and band structures were found , ensuring that our results are converged .\",\n \"for the tpp physisorption on graphene , we use a squared unit cell with @xmath18 periodicity and the @xmath14 point for the @xmath15-space integration . here , a vacuum region of 20 among graphene an their images was considered . for the optical response we use a @xmath15-point mesh of @xmath19 , for incident light polarized parallel to the graphene plane ( @xmath20 and @xmath21 directions ) . the tpp binding energy on the substrates is calculated by the energy difference between adsorbed and separated constituents , considering corrections due to the basis set superposition error .\",\n \"the complexes were fully relaxed by conjugate gradient minimization until the forces on the atoms were less than 0.05 ev / .\",\n \"the optical response of the functionalized cnts and graphene is obtained through first order time dependent perturbation theory , by calculating the imaginary part of the dielectric function ( @xmath22 ) .\",\n \"@xmath22 gives us a first approach for the optical absorption coefficient and it is calculated according to the equation : @xmath23 here @xmath24 is a constant that depends on the cell sizes ; @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the occupied and empty kohn - sham orbitals , respectively .\",\n \"the delta function represents the conservation of energy , which is described by a gaussian function with a smearing of 0.06 ev .\",\n \"it is important to note that dft calculations fail in describing electron - hole and electron - electron interactions , the so called many - body effects .\",\n \"these effects are responsible for the formation of excitons and the quasiparticle excitation .\",\n \"@xcite therefore , an accurate description of photoexcitations in cnts and graphene needs theories beyond dft , like those based on the gw - bethe - salpeter equation ( gw - bse).@xcite however , these calculations are not possible right now , considering the size of the systems under study .\",\n \"thus , @xmath22 can give us a first approach for the optical response of @xmath4-stacked tpp on cnts and graphene .\",\n \"the main difference of dft calculations with respect to gw - bse is a redshift in the absorption spectrum .\",\n \"for instance , in graphene this redshift is found to be about 0.6 ev.@xcite\"\n ],\n [\n \"we first discuss different adsorption geometries for the tpp molecule on the cnts .\",\n \"figure [ f1 ] shows the equilibrium geometry of a tpp adsorbed on a ( 8,7 ) cnt . here , the n - h bonds of tpp are oriented perpendicular to the cnt axis , that we called position ( i ) .\",\n \"two other positions for tpp are likely to be found : with the n - h bonds parallel to the cnt axis ( ii ) , and with the n - h bonds forming an angle of 45@xmath27 with respect to the cnt axis ( iii ) . although position ( i ) is found to be the most stable , the other positions have total energies within 0.3 ev , suggesting that all three are equally probables . in the equilibrium geometry , the tpp phenyl groups exhibit a small rotation , which come with a molecular twisting . to compare the stability of different cnt - tpp complexes , only position ( i ) will be considered throughout this work .\",\n \"the adsorption distance is measured between the cnt surface and the n atoms of tpp , as shown in figure [ f1 ] .\",\n \".adsorption distance ( @xmath28 ) , binding energy ( @xmath29 ) , and bandgap energy ( @xmath30 ) of cnt - tpp complexes .\",\n \"@xmath31 and @xmath32 are the cnt diameter and chiral angle , respectively .\",\n \"results for tpp on graphene ( g - tpp ) are also included . [\",\n \"cols=\\\"<,<,<,<,<,<\\\",options=\\\"header \\\" , ] [ t1 ] table [ t1 ] lists tpp binding energies and binding distances for all the complex under study .\",\n \"we also include the dft bandgaps for the semiconducting complexes .\",\n \"those with small bandgaps ( @xmath330.1 ev ) are consistent with empirical model predictions of @xmath34 as well as with experimental data.@xcite we observe that binding energies and adsorption distances vary in ranges given by @xmath35 ev and @xmath36 , respectively .\",\n \"we note that stronger tpp @xmath4-stacking interactions result in larger adsorption distance .\",\n \"this can be understood by look at the tpp phenyl groups , whose h atoms become closer to the cnt surface for large diameter cnts , as can be seen in figure [ f1 ] . to estimate an upper limit for @xmath29 and @xmath28\",\n \", we calculate the tpp physisorption on graphene , which can be considered as a cnt with an infinite diameter .\",\n \"we find @xmath37 ev and @xmath38 .\",\n \"although the binding distance is similar to those found on cnts with @xmath39 , the binding energy is considerably larger , with almost twice the value found on the cnts .\",\n \"this can be understood because of the larger graphene - tpp overlap area , which tend to maximize the @xmath4-stacking interaction .\",\n \"figure [ f2 ] shows the cnt - tpp binding energy as a function of the cnt diameter .\",\n \"we observe an almost linear increase in the tpp attachment strength with the cnt diameter , which in some way confirms our assumption that larger cnt - tpp overlap area tends to increase the binding energy of the molecule .\",\n \"however , this general tendency is not followed in some cases , as can be seen in fig .\",\n \"for instance , ( i ) the larger tpp binding energy found for the ( 5,0 ) cnt ( @xmath40 ) with respect to the ( 6,0 ) cnt ( @xmath41 ) , by about 0.2 ev , and ( ii ) the abrupt changes in the tpp binding energy profile going from ( 6,0 ) to ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,5 ) to ( 7,6 ) , and ( 8,5 ) to ( 8,6 ) .\",\n \"we attribute these results to the particular atomic geometry of the cnt atoms just below the tpp molecule .\",\n \"we observe that the cnt - tpp binding distance tends to increase when the h atoms of the phenyl groups nearest neighbors to the cnt surface , lie exactly above nanotube c - atoms .\",\n \"this effect is due to the steric repulsion between them , which also explain the broad variation on the binding distances between the cnt surface and the tpp n - atoms , as shown in figure [ f3 ] .\",\n \"figure [ f4 ] shows the cnt - tpp binding energy as a function of the cnt chiral angle .\",\n \"apparently , higher chiral angles would induce stronger tpp attachment .\",\n \"however , if we compare the tpp attachment on cnts with similar diameters and binding distances with those plotted as a function of the chiral angle , we observe that they have also similar binding energy , suggesting that the cnt diameter instead chirality is the relevant parameter involved in the strong tpp binding energy .\",\n \"for instance , if we take the cnts with chiral indices ( 5,4 ) and ( 7,2 ) , they show almost the same tpp binding energy when plotted with respect to both the cnt diameter ( fig . [ f2 ] ) and adsorption distance ( fig .\",\n \"however , they also show the same binding energy when plotted with respect to the chiral angle ( fig .\",\n \"the same behavior can be verified for the pairs of cnts ( 5,5)-(6,4 ) and ( 6,5)-(7,4 ) .\",\n \"these results suggest that the strength of the tpp interaction on the cnts would not be related to the cnt surface geometry or chirality , but to the cnt diameter . the adsorption energy of benzene and naphthalene on cnts ( 7 - 8 diameter ) , using electron - correlated moller - plasset ( mp2 ) method reports binding energies for benzene and naphthalene of 0.18 and 0.48 ev , respectively .\",\n \"@xcite this results suggest an overestimation of the tpp adsorption energy on cnts . however , temperature programmed desorption experiments performed in ultrahigh vacuum have measured the binding energy of polyaromatic hydrocarbons ( pahs ) adsorbed on graphite , showing quite strong desorption energies .\",\n \"@xcite in that work , benzene , naphthalene , coronene , and ovalene adsorbed on graphite show desorption energies of 0.50 , 0.85 , 1.4 , and 2.1 ev , respectively .\",\n \"for the case of benzene and naphthalene , the experimental values almost double the mp2-theory values . even considering the cnt curvatures , the @xmath4-stacking interaction appears to be much more larger than the usually expected .\",\n \"in addition , a recent study of pahs adsorption on graphene shows that the vdw - df calculations exhibit excellent agreement with the available experimental data , while empirical and semiempirical calculations only preserve the correct trends.@xcite in summary , the work concludes that the adsorption interaction of @xmath4-conjugate systems on graphene are a complex combination of dispersive and electrostatic interactions , which would explains to some extent our results for the large adsorption energies of tpp on both graphene and cnts .\",\n \"noncovalent functionalization of a single - walled ( 6,5 ) cnt with tpp molecules have been reported in aqueous solution by mean of the micellar suspension method.@xcite the optical absorption of ( 6,5)-tpp complexes shows resonances at 2.357 and 2.831 ev , which are associated to the @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( soret ) tpp bands , respectively.@xcite our results for the optical response of the ( 6,5)-tpp complex for a polarization parallel to the tube axis , show clear transitions at 1.60 and 2.04 ev , which we associate to the tpp @xmath42 and @xmath43 bands , respectively .\",\n \"the difference in energy between these peaks ( 0.44 ev ) is almost the same than those observed in the experiments ( 0.474 ev).@xcite however , the theoretical peaks show a redshift of about 0.8 ev with respect to the experimental ones , while the shape of the absorption spectra would be preserved .\",\n \"this shift is associated to many - body effects previously discussed .\",\n \"therefore , through the @xmath22 calculation it is possible to investigate , qualitatively , changes in the optical properties of different cnt - tpp complexes in term of the cnt structural parameters , like diameter or chirality .\",\n \"figure [ f5 ] and [ f6 ] show @xmath22 as a function of the photon energy , for incident light polarized parallel to the tube axis , for the semiconducting cnt - tpp complexes .\",\n \"the red and black spectra indicate the optical response of cnt - tpp and the isolated cnt , respectively .\",\n \"the vertical dashed lines indicate the position of the tpp @xmath42 ( 1.60 ev ) and @xmath43 ( 2.04 ev ) bands .\",\n \"the optical spectra clearly show the absorption of the @xmath4-stacked tpp at almost the same position than the isolated tpp , indicating that the tpp absorption properties would be preserved in the complexes , being independent of the cnt diameter or chirality .\",\n \"however , we must note that the present results were obtained considering only one tpp molecule on the cnts .\",\n \"increasing tpp coverages may change this conclusion .\",\n \"the optical response of complexes considering metallic and semimetallic cnts ( not shown ) exhibit the same properties .\",\n \"another interesting feature is the resonance between the cnt @xmath44 transition with the @xmath43 band for the cnts : ( 5,4 ) , ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,3 ) , and ( 10,0 ) , and with the @xmath42 band for the cnts : ( 6,1 ) , ( 7,5 ) , ( 7,6 ) , and ( 7,2 ) .\",\n \"this tuning between @xmath44 and the tpp bands would increase the emission of the corresponding complex .\",\n \"figure [ f7 ] shows the electronic band structure and density of states ( dos ) of the graphene - tpp compound described in a squared reciprocal lattice .\",\n \"the vertical arrows show the optical transition between the frontier molecular orbitals of the @xmath4-stacked tpp , which correspond to the dispersionless subbands . here , @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) is the transition from homo to lumo ( lumo+1 ) , while @xmath47 ( @xmath48 ) is the transitions from homo-1 to lumo ( lumo+1 ) .\",\n \"these absorptions arise from @xmath49 transitions and can be characterized approximately by considering only the four molecular levels above mentioned .\",\n \"@xcite in pristine graphene , the valence - band maximum and conduction - band minimum touch at one point in the @xmath15 space , the dirac point , which occurs at the fermi energy .\",\n \"this indicates that graphene is a zero - gap semiconductor . in fig .\",\n \"[ f7 ] , we observe that the fermi energy ( the dashed line ) is shifted upward with respect to the dirac point energy , which indicates a charge transfer from tpp to graphene , revealing a @xmath0-type doping mechanism . therefore , graphene would change its electronic characteristic induced by the strong tpp complexation . as the @xmath4-stacking molecule do not alter the graphene atomic structure , their transport properties would be preserved .\",\n \"similar results have been reported for other aromatic molecules physisorbed on graphene.@xcite figure [ f8 ] shows @xmath22 of a tpp @xmath4-stacked on graphene , the g - tpp compound , considering an in - plain polarizations of incident light . for pristine graphene , we find a strong absorption in the infrared , below 1 ev , and a less intense absorption in the ultraviolet , at around 4 ev , which are attributed to transitions among @xmath4 and @xmath50 bands .\",\n \"these results are in qualitative agreement with calculated absorption spectra using the gw - bse approach as well as with experiments,@xcite unless the redshift previously discussed . for functionalized graphene ,\",\n \"we observe two intense absorptions at around 1.57 and 1.96 ev , corresponding to the @xmath51 and @xmath52 bands of the @xmath4-stacked tpp .\",\n \"these peaks show a redshift with respect to those of the isolated tpp of 0.05 ev , which is associated to the distortion of the tpp phenyl groups due to the strong @xmath4-stacking interaction .\",\n \"additional peaks at around 2.6 and 3.1 ev are also associated to the tpp molecule .\"\n ],\n [\n \"we have theoretically investigated the stability and optical absorption properties of a free - base tpp molecule @xmath4-stacked on single - walled cnts , as well as on graphene .\",\n \"42 cnts with chiral indices ( @xmath0,@xmath1 ) , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 , have been studied . in term of the diameter ,\",\n \"they range within @xmath53 .\",\n \"the tpp physisorption is described by van der waals density functional while the optical properties through the imaginary part of the dielectric function in the linear optical response .\",\n \"we find a strong cnt - tpp @xmath4-stacking interaction , with binding energies and adsorption distance varying within @xmath35 ev and @xmath36 , respectively , where larger @xmath29 and @xmath28 are obtained for increasing cnt diameters .\",\n \"our results indicates that diameter instead chirality is the relevant parameter for the strong tpp physisorption , which would be originated in the increasing overlap area between tpp and the cnts .\",\n \"an upper limit for the cnt - tpp binding strength can be estimated through the tpp physisorption on graphene , which can be viewed as an infinite - diameter cnt .\",\n \"we find very strong @xmath4-stacking interactions , with @xmath37 ev and @xmath38 .\",\n \"however , this strong interaction is not enough to open an energy gap in the functionalized graphene , but it can induce a charge transfer from tpp , suggesting a @xmath0-type doping mechanism without compromising the graphene structure and transport properties . concerning optical properties , we find that @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( soret ) tpp absorption bands remain at almost the same energy position after the physisorption on the cnts , being independent of the cnt structural parameters . whereas on graphene , the tpp bands show a redshift of about 0.05 ev , which are associated to the distortion of the phenyl groups due to the strong @xmath4-stacking interaction .\",\n \"finally , our results suggest that both compounds cnt - tpp and g - tpp exhibit remarkable stability while preserving the absorption properties of the chromophore , which may be of interest for light - harvesting and bio - labeling applications .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}},{"rowIdx":99,"cells":{"article_id":{"kind":"string","value":"1605.07266"},"article_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["monitoring the activity of large - scale neuronal ensembles during complex behavioral states is fundamental to neuroscience research",". continued advances in optical imaging technology are greatly expanding the number and depth of neuronal populations that can be visualized .","specifically , in vivo calcium imaging through microendoscopic lenses and the development of miniaturized microscopes have enabled deep brain imaging of previously inaccessible neuronal populations of freely moving mice ( @xcite ) . while these techniques have been widely used by neuroscientists ,","automatic methods for extracting cellular signals from this data are currently limited and suboptimal .","the desired method should be able to ( 1 ) identify spatial footprints of all neurons , ( 2 ) denoise , demix and deconvolve the temporal signals ( @xcite ) .","figure [ fig : example]a is an example frame from microendoscopic data , where the weak neuronal signals are submerged in the large background ( the raw video data can we watched here ) . for illustrative purposes , we draw two rois in the optical field and compute their mean fluorescence intensities ( figure [ fig : example]c , d ) .","the red roi overlaps with one neuron and the green roi only has the background ( figure [ fig : example]b ) .","thus the fluorescence in the red roi ( figure [ fig : example]c ) is a superposition of the background and the neuron s temporal activity , whereas the green ( figure [ fig : example]d ) provides an estimation of the background signal . by subtracting these two traces",", we are able to roughly estimate the temporal activity of the neuron within the red roi ( figure [ fig : example]e ) . from this example",", we can see that the background is an order of magnitude larger than the neural activity and its fluctuations are as fast as neuronal calcium transients .","these features make it difficult to detect and demix cellular signals automatically from the raw video .","our work is based on a matrix factorization approach , which can simultaneously segment cells and estimate changes in fluorescence in the temporal domain .","this approach stems from the observation that spatiotemporal calcium activity can be approximated as product of two matrices : a spatial matrix that encodes the location of each neuron and a temporal matrix that characterizes the calcium concentration evolution for each neuron .","it has several variations with different constraints , such as independent component analysis ( pca - ica , @xcite ) , nonnegative matrix factorization ( nmf , @xcite ) , sparse space - time deconvolution ( sstd , @xcite ) and constrained nonnegative matrix factorization ( cnmf , @xcite ) . in particular , pca - ica seeks spatiotemporal components that have reduced dependence .","it is an inherently linear demixing method and can fail in the case when the neural components exhibit significant spatial overlaps ( @xcite ) .","nonlinear methods like nmf , sstd and cnmf can deal with overlapping neural sources more effectively , and often outperform pca - ica .","the main applications of these nonlinear methods are 2-photon or light - sheet imaging data , where the background is weak and has simple spatiotemporally separable structure .","they usually model the background with a rank-1 nonnegative matrix .","however , applying these nonlinear matrix factorization methods to the microendoscopic data faces two problems : ( 1 ) the background term is not well modeled by rank-1 nmf and its large residual could contaminate the extracted neuronal signals ; ( 2 ) the procedures of initializing the model parameters , especially spatial and temporal components of neurons , in these models do not work well because the strong and noisy background mixes with the weak neural signals .","since the optimization problem in these methods are non - convex , without good initialization , it may lead to low - quality results or require excessive time for convergent results . in this paper , we extend the cnmf framework ( @xcite ) to address strong fluctuations in background fluorescence , and make it applicable to microendoscopic data .","like the proposed cnmf in @xcite , our extended cnmf for microendoscopic data ( cnmf - e ) also has the capability of identifying neurons with low signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) and simultaneously denoising , deconvolving and demixing large - scale microendoscopic data . to accomplish this : ( 1 ) we replace the rank-1 nmf approximation of the background with a more sophisticated approximation , which can better account the complex background and avoid absorbing cellular signals , and ( 2 ) we develop an efficient initialization procedure to extract neural activities with minimal influence from the background .","the structure of the paper is as follows . in section [ sec : cnmf ]","we briefly review the cnmf model and describe our modifications to the model . in section [ sec : fit_model ]",", we develop our specialized model fitting procedure . in section [ sec : result ] we validate our new proposed cnmf - e on simulated and experimental data , and we also compare it with the widely used pca - ica method ( @xcite ) . * notation * a matrix @xmath0 represents the spatiotemporal activity of @xmath1 pixels in @xmath2 frames .","the column vector @xmath3 is the observation of the whole frame in time - step @xmath4 .","we use @xmath5 to refer the spatial location of one pixel , thus @xmath6 is the fluorescence intensity in @xmath4-th frame at location @xmath7 . for a column vector @xmath8 encoding the spatial information of @xmath1 pixels , @xmath9 indicates the value of @xmath10 at pixel @xmath7 .","the video data we have are observations from the optical field for a total number of @xmath2 frames .","the recorded data can be represented by a matrix @xmath11 , where @xmath1 is the number of pixels in the field .","each neuron is characterized by its spatial ` footprint ' vector @xmath12 and ` calcium activity ' @xmath13 . here","both @xmath14 and @xmath15 are forced to be nonnegative because of their physical interpretations .","given @xmath16 of one neuron , its spatiotemporal activity is represented as @xmath17 .","the background activity is represented by a matrix @xmath18 .","suppose the field contains a total number of @xmath19 neurons , then the observation is a superposition of all neurons spatiotemporal activity , time - varying background and additive noise : @xmath20 where @xmath21 , c=[\\mathbf{c}_1 , \\cdots , \\mathbf{c}_k]^t$ ] .","the noise term @xmath22 is assumed to be gaussian and @xmath23 .","@xmath24 is a diagonal matrix indicating that the noise is spatially and temporally uncorrelated .","@xcite also explicitly model the calcium dynamics @xmath15 with a stable autoregressive process ( ar ) of order @xmath25 , @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the number of spikes that neuron fired at the @xmath4-th frame and it is sparse in the neural systems .","the ar coefficients @xmath28 are different for each neuron and they are estimated from the data . estimating the model parameters @xmath29 in model ( [ eq : y])([eq : arp ] ) can give us all neurons spatial footprints and their deconvolved temporal activities . to fit the model , we also have to constrain the background term to have simplified structure , otherwise letting @xmath30 leads to the least reconstruction error .","this framework is general and we use it in our new method as well .","compared with the proposed implementation in @xcite , our method models the background term differently . in the work of @xcite , they model the background with a rank-1 nonnegative matrix @xmath31 , where @xmath32 and @xmath33 encode the background spatial and temporal structure respectively","this is a good assumption for two - photon or light - sheet imaging data , but the background in microendoscopic data requires a more complex model .","we also have to avoid the increased complexity from absorbing cellular signals into the background .","thus the ideal model should explicitly model the background features that are distinct from neurons of interest . here","we include two main features of the background into the model of @xmath34 : ( 1 ) the temporal component of each pixel has a constant large baseline and some slow trends ( see figure [ fig : example]d ) and ( 2 ) background is usually spatially smooth in a larger spatial range compared with neuron size ( figure [ fig : example ] ) , which means the background of all pixels within a neuron does not have large spatial gradients .","this is because the fluctuations in the background reflects the out - of - focus fluorescence and they are significantly blurred .","hence we model the background term as @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 .","@xmath38 explains the constant baselines and slow trends for all pixels ( figure [ fig : example]c ) and their temporal dynamics are much slower than calcium indicators .","the second term @xmath39 models the fast fluctuation in the background and the spatial component @xmath40 has low spatial - frequency structure .","the constraint of @xmath40 excludes cellular signals from the background term .","in this section , we will describe our customized algorithm for fitting the model ( [ eq : y])([eq : arp])([eq : bg ] ) .","we frequently use the pixel - wise formulation of model ( [ eq : y ] ) and ignore the noise term : @xmath41 our framework can be summarized into the following steps : 1 .","initialize @xmath42 using the new initialization procedure .","2 . approximate the background @xmath43 using model ( [ eq : bg ] ) .","update @xmath42 from data @xmath44 using constrained alternating matrix factorization .","4 . post - process the results automatically or manually : delete neurons , pick the missed neurons from the residuals , and merge neurons with high temporal correlations .","repeat steps 2 , 3 , 4 until the results are biologically meaningful .","our techniques differ from @xcite in the following aspects : ( 1 ) the initialization step for @xmath45 and @xmath46 here requires careful considerations of the background contaminations and our approach is totally new .","( 2 ) instead of updating the background term iteratively , we update the background independently in different iterations and the rank of the background model can be modified in each iteration . as a result , our algorithm has a better control of the residual levels in background . in the followings , we mainly describe our novel initialization step and briefly summarize the procedure of fitting the background term . as for steps ( 3 - 5 ) and discussions for scalability issue , we put them in the supplementary materials ( section [ supp : iterative_manual ] and [ supp : speed ] ) . , the initialized temporal activity of one neuron .","d@xmath47 , raw data of the cropped small window ( green square in a and b ) .","e@xmath47 , the estimated time - varying local backgrounds in the small cropped window .","c@xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the re - ordered version of c@xmath47 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 .","c@xmath53 is the temporal differencing of c@xmath48 and the result has been thresholded with its @xmath54 standard deviation .","similarly , d@xmath53 is differencing result of d@xmath48 .","f , the initialized spatial and temporal components of the neuron.,width=529 ] here we develop a robust procedure for initializing @xmath45 and @xmath46 without estimation of the background .","this procedure utilizes the spatial smoothness feature in the background and removes it by spatial high - pass filtering of the raw data .","we estimate the temporal component of one neuron @xmath15 from spatially filtered data and then use it to extract the corresponding spatial footprint @xmath14 from the raw data . in the step of estimating @xmath14 , we re - order all frames to make nearby frames share the similar local background levels and then take the temporal differencing to remove the background signals temporally .","after that , we can use regression to get @xmath14 . repeating","this process can initialize the required number of neurons .","the whole procedure is schematically illustrated in figure [ fig : initialization ] and described in algorithm [ alg : init ] in the supplementary materials .","the spatial smoothness assumption of the background leads to @xmath55 i.e. , within the spatial range of a cell body , the background is spatially invariant .","based on this assumption , we use @xmath56 to filter the raw data @xmath6 , and @xmath56 is defined as @xmath57 where @xmath58 .","@xmath59 is a gaussian kernel with width @xmath60 and @xmath61 is the the average size of the neurons .","@xmath56 is a template matching filter to detect spatial structures with similar shapes and sizes . for flat structures in the small regions , like background , filtering them with @xmath56","get results close to 0 .","thus in the filtered data @xmath62 , the background @xmath63 has been roughly removed and @xmath64 is mainly composed of cellular signals ( figure [ fig : initialization]b ) .","more interestingly , the calcium concentrations of most neurons can be directly approximated by the temporal traces of some pixels in @xmath64 .","( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath47 , see section [ supp : filter ] in supplementary materials for derivation ) .","we call these pixels seed pixels because we can use them to initialize neurons .","we initialize neurons with a greedy algorithm . in each iteration , we find one seed pixel @xmath65 ( see supplementary materials section [ sec : seed ] for details of how to detect seed pixels ) and initialize its spatial footprint @xmath66 and temporal course @xmath67",". then we subtract @xmath68 from the raw video data , find the next seed pixel and repeat the initialization procedure until specified number of neurons have been initialized or no more seed pixels exist . given a seed pixel @xmath65 , we can initialize the neuron s temporal component as @xmath69 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath47 ) .","this approximation is usually good , and here we propose an efficient method to extract its spatial component @xmath14 from the raw data @xmath70 .","we first crop the optical field with a square centered at @xmath65 and the square size is twice larger than the average neuron size @xmath61 ( figure [ fig : initialization]d@xmath47 ) .","since cell bodies have localized structure , the spatial shape of the expected neuron is completely covered by this square .","then we approximate the local background level in this cropped area @xmath71 using the median of the fluorescence intensities on the square boundary ( figure [ fig : initialization]e@xmath47 ) . by sorting all frames in an order of @xmath72 such that @xmath73 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath48d@xmath48e@xmath48 ) , nearby frames have the minimal differences ( @xmath74 ) in the background term .","hence the differencing of the sorted video data is @xmath75 we already have @xmath76 , so we can initialize @xmath14 by regressing @xmath77 on @xmath78 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath53d@xmath53 ) . empirically we found that thresholding @xmath79 achieves better results .","after we get @xmath80 ( figure [ fig : initialization]f ) , we can reestimate @xmath81 using a simple formula : @xmath82 where @xmath83 is a vector replacing all nonzero pixels of @xmath84 with the mean of those nonzero pixels . by running this initialization procedure iteratively",", we can extract almost all neurons . after we get @xmath85 and @xmath86",", @xmath87 is mainly the background component and we will approximate it with a matrix described in eq .","( [ eq : bg ] ) .","first we use a spline basis with low temporal dynamics to approximate the first term @xmath88 ( baseline + slow trend ) , then we factorize the residual @xmath89 with @xmath39 . by constraining @xmath40 with high spatial smoothness , we can avoid cellular signals being absorbed into the background .","we use singular value decomposition ( svd ) together with low - pass filtering of the estimated spatial components to estimate @xmath90 and @xmath91 .","( see supplementary materials [ supp : bg ] for details ) .","pca - ica ( @xcite ) is the most widely used automatic methods for analyzing microendoscopic data ( @xcite ) .","it seeks spatially and temporally independent components as individual neurons . in this section","we compared our cnmf - e with pca - ica method using simulated and experimental data .","we simulated @xmath92 neurons activity in the optical field ( @xmath93 pixels ) for @xmath94 frames ( @xmath95 hz ) . to ensure that the background had similar features as real data",", we utilized the background extracted from our experimental data as the background in our simulation .","we also add i.i.d .","gaussian noise to our model ( the simulated video data can be found here ) .","after removing all false positives , pca - ica detected @xmath96 neurons and our cnmf - e method found @xmath97 neurons of the @xmath92 neurons .","most neurons detected by pca - ica did not have localized structures and multiple neurons were combined together ( see supplementary figure [ fig : supp_ac ] ) .","we superimposed the contours of all extracted neurons together on top of the locations of simulated neurons .","pca - ica - based segmentation failed to identify a large proportion of the neurons in this dataset , whereas nearly every neuron was identified by the cnmf - e approach ( figure [ fig : sim]cd ) .","we matched each simulated neuron with a neuron among all the extracted neurons by selecting the one most correlated with the simulated neuron temporally .","for a pair of matched neuron , they should have both high temporal and spatial correlations in the perfect case , i.e. , the real cellular signal is extracted from the data with high fidelity .","we displayed spatial and temporal correlations of all simulated neurons with their matched neurons detected by two approaches ( figure [ fig : sim]bd ) . a total number of @xmath97 simulated neurons were accurately recovered by our cnmf - e method ( figure [ fig : sim]d ) . while for pca - ica , a large proportion of the matched neurons have low spatial and temporal correlations ( figure [ fig : sim ] ) indicating failures in recovering real neurons signals .","we also display @xmath98 tightly clustered neurons in the simulated data ( figure [ fig : sim]e ) to demonstrate that our cnmf - e approach can accurately detect and demix their activity ( figure [ fig : sim]g ) .","the spatiotemporal similarity between the 4 neurons segmented with cnmf - e ( figure 3 g ) and ground truth ( figure 3e ) indicates a good performance in extracting the neural activity .","in contrast , pca - ica based detection can only detect two neurons and the calcium traces have high level of noise .","the reason is that pca - ica merges multiple neurons together spatially and distorts the calcium traces in the temporal domain .","furthermore , the distorted calcium traces reduces the number of detected neurons .","the data used here was collected from the prefrontal cortex ( pfc ) of a freely moving mouse .","the frame rate is 15 hz . the raw image ( figure [ fig : data_example]a ) is blurry and it is difficult to visually detect any neurons .","its local correlation image ( @xcite ) of the raw data is approximately uniform @xmath99 ( figure [ fig : data_example]c ) , which means neighboring pixels share strong background fluctuations .","here we removed the background by spatially filtering the raw data with @xmath56 and then calculated local correlation image using eq .","( [ eq : pnr_corr ] ) in supplementary materials .","figure [ fig : data_example]d clearly shows the locations of all neurons .","appying our proposed cnmf - e method is able to detect @xmath100 neurons from the raw data .","their contours are depicted on top the the correlation image and we can see that our method efficiently identifies neurons in the optical field ( figure [ fig : data_example]d ) .","after subtracting the extracted background from the raw data , neural activity is visualized more effectively ( figure [ fig : data_example]b ) .","the quality of this background correction on the raw data is important for extracting neural signals and demixing neurons . in the supplementary video ( )",", we showed the raw video , extracted background video , background corrected video and reconstructed cellular activity @xmath101 . from the video , we can see that cnmf - e reliably extracted the weak cellular signals from the rapidly fluctuating background .","we choose three neighboring neurons within a small field to show the performance of our method . in figure","[ fig : data_example]e , we showed their rois and the local correlation image .","the mean fluorescence traces within each roi are too noisy to infer any calcium events .","both pca - ica and cnmf - e isolated these three neurons and extracted the spiking signals , but the traces extracted with the pca - ica have higher levels of noise .","further , note that traces extracted with pca - ica have large artifactual negative peaks .","cnmf - e does not have this problem due to the nonnegative requirements . in the shaded region of figure [ fig : data_example]f ,","we demonstrate potential crosstalk between two neurons , that is avoided by cnmf - e but not pca - ica based segmentation ( watch video here .","the temporal traces in the video are extracted from cnmf - e ) . detected neurons and the correlation image calculated using our cnmf - e method ( see eq .","( [ eq : pnr_corr ] ) in supplementary materials ) .","e , mean fluorescence traces from three rois .","f , extracted spatial / temporal components of three neurons using pca - ica method .","g , results using our cnmf - e method .",", width=529 ]","in this paper , we proposed an efficient method for extracting cellular signals from microendoscopic data ; such methods are in very high demand in the neuroscience community .","the analysis of this video data is the first stage of processing in many experiments , so the quality of source extraction in this step highly influences the scientific conclusions drawn in downstream analysis . as shown in figure [ fig : sim ] and [ fig : data_example ] ,","our method shows credible performances in recovering the real neuronal signals and outperforms the previous standard pca - ica method .","thus the methods introduced here ( which we plan to release as open source software ) will be a powerful and important tool for the neuroscience community .","funding for this research was provided by nih 2r01mh064537 ( p.z .",", r.k . ) , nih r90da023426 ( p.z . ) , national institute of child health nichd and human development hd079124 ( g.s . ) , nichd grant t32 hd040127 ( s.r . ) , simons research foundation ( g.s . ) , simons foundation global brain research awards 325171 , 365002 , aro muri w911nf-12 - 1 - 0594 , darpa n66001 - 15-c-4032 ( simplex ) , and a google faculty research award ( l.p . ) ; in addition , this work was supported by the intelligence advanced research projects activity ( iarpa ) via department of interior/ interior business center ( doi / ibc ) contract number d16pc00003 ( l.p . ) , d16pc00007 ( p.z . ) . the u.s .","government is authorized to reproduce and distribute reprints for governmental purposes notwithstanding any copyright annotation thereon .","disclaimer : the views and conclusions contained herein are those of the authors and should not be interpreted as necessarily representing the official policies or endorsements , either expressed or implied , of iarpa , doi / ibc , or the u.s .","government .","11 [ 1]#1 [ 1]`#1 ` urlstyle [ 1]doi : # 1 ferran diego andilla and fred a. hamprecht . .","_ advances in neural information processing systems _ , pages 6472 , 2014 .","andrzej cichocki , rafal zdunek , and shun - ichi amari . .","_ independent component analysis and signal separation _ ,","46660 ( 1):0 169176 , 2007 . benjamin a flusberg , axel nimmerjahn , eric d cocker , eran a mukamel , robert p j barretto , tony h ko , laurie d burns , juergen c jung , and mark j schnitzer . _ nature methods _ , 50 ( 11):0 9358 , 2008 .","johannes friedrich , daniel soudry , yu mu , jeremy freeman , misha ahrens , and liam paninski . .","in _ conference on neural information processing systems _ , 2015 .","kunal k ghosh , laurie d burns , eric d cocker , axel nimmerjahn , yaniv ziv , abbas el gamal , and mark j schnitzer .","_ nature methods _ , 80 ( 10):0 871878 , 2011 . ryuichi maruyama , kazuma maeda , hajime moroda , ichiro kato , masashi inoue , hiroyoshi miyakawa , and toru aonishi . .","_ neural networks _ ,","55:0 1119 , 2014 .","eran a. mukamel , axel nimmerjahn , and mark j. schnitzer . .","_ neuron _ , 630 ( 6):0 747760 , 2009 .","eftychios a pnevmatikakis , daniel soudry , yuanjun gao , timothy a machado , josh merel , david pfau , thomas reardon , yu mu , clay lacefield , weijian yang , misha ahrens , randy bruno , thomas m jessell , darcy s peterka , rafael yuste , and liam paninski . .","_ neuron _ , 890 ( 2):0 285299 , 2016 . shanna l resendez , josh h jennings , randall l ung , vijay mohan k namboodiri , zhe charles zhou , james m otis , hiroshi nomura , jenna a mchenry , oksana kosyk , and garret d stuber . .","_ nature protocols _ , 110 ( 3):0 566597 , 2016 .","spencer l smith and michael husser . .","_ nature neuroscience _ , 130 ( 9):0 11441149 , 2010 .","yaniv ziv and kunal k ghosh . .","_ current opinion in neurobiology _ , 32:0 141147 , 2015","since @xmath103 filtering the raw data with @xmath56 results @xmath104(\\mathbf{x})\\cdot c_i(t).\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] for each neuron , there is an area @xmath105(\\mathbf{x } ) > 0\\}$ ] .","usually @xmath106 corresponds to the central area for a neuron with gaussian shape . for @xmath107 , @xmath108(\\mathbf{x})\\cdot c_i(t ) +","\\sum_{j\\neq i}^k [ \\tilde{h}\\ast a_j](\\mathbf{x})\\cdot c_j(t ) .","\\label{eq : zxt}\\ ] ] if @xmath109(\\mathbf{x})=0 $ ] for all @xmath110 , i.e. , the @xmath111 th neuron is well isolated from the others , then @xmath112 this is a nice feature because we can estimate @xmath102 from @xmath64 directly .","empirically we found that this condition can be relaxed to @xmath109(\\mathbf{x})\\leq0 $ ] .","when @xmath109(\\mathbf{x})<0 $ ] , @xmath113 has negative spikes from neuron @xmath114 and we can remove them simply by thresholding @xmath64 with its median .","thus for each neuron @xmath111 , as long as there exist some @xmath107 and @xmath109(\\mathbf{x})\\leq0 $ ] for all @xmath110 ( small positive values are still tolerable ) , we can simply approximate its calcium concentration @xmath102 with @xmath64 .","a seed pixel @xmath7 should have two main features : first , @xmath113 has high peak - to - noise ratio ( pnr ) because it encodes the calcium concentration @xmath102 of one neuron and usually @xmath102 has large calcium transients ; second , seed pixel has high temporal correlations with its neighboring pixels because they are likely to share the same @xmath102 .","we computed two metrics for each of these two features : @xmath115 where @xmath116 ( we use @xmath117 ) determines the range of neighbors and @xmath118 is the total number of neighboring pixels .","@xmath119 calculates the temporal correlation between two time series @xmath120 and @xmath121 .","the function @xmath122 is a pre - processing of @xmath64 before computing local correlation . in our implementation , we threshold the differencing of @xmath113 by @xmath123 ( e.g. , @xmath124 .","this is equivalent to a rough detection of calcium transients . it is better than using @xmath64 directly because it reduces the influence of the background residual , noise and negative spikes from nearby neurons . to avoid unnecessary searches of the seed pixels , we usually set thresholds for both @xmath125 ( e.g. , 5 ) and @xmath126 ( e.g. , 0.5 ) . in each iteration of the initialization",", we find the pixel with the maximum value of @xmath127 and set it as a seed pixel . here","we use point - wise product of @xmath125 and @xmath126 to emphasize the characteristics of seed pixels .","if we successfully initialize one neuron from this seed pixel , the spatiotemporal activity of this initialized neuron @xmath128 will be peeled off from the residual data ( it is @xmath70 at the beginning of the initialization ) .","we also have to locally update @xmath125 and @xmath126 in the initialized area .","each neuron can only be visited once for initialization .","we will stop the initialization procedure until the specified number @xmath19 reaches or there are no more seed pixels .","define @xmath130 as nonzero pixels of @xmath84 and @xmath131 then @xmath132 again , the spatial smoothness of the background term @xmath133 induces @xmath134 . when the overlaps between neurons are not severe , @xmath135 , hence , we have @xmath136 the trends of all pixels are independent and we approximate all trends with b - spline basis @xmath137 , i.e. , @xmath138 , where the row vectors of @xmath137 are cubic b - spline basis given a sequences of knots . by increasing the intervals between knots ,","we lower the number of basis and constrain the dynamics of @xmath139 to be slow .","we usually choose evenly distributed knots over the whole time period with an interval of @xmath140 seconds .","this is much larger than dynamics of the calcium indicators ( @xmath141 seconds ) .","@xmath142 contains coefficients of each spline basis .","it is estimated with regression @xmath143\\cdot[xx^t]^{-1}$ ] . after we remove the @xmath38 , we move on to approximate the the fast fluctuations @xmath144 with low rank-@xmath118 matrix @xmath39 .","the truncated svd of @xmath145 has the globally minimum frobenious norm of the difference between @xmath145 and @xmath39 .","here we choose row vectors of @xmath91 be the top @xmath118 right singular vectors of @xmath145 and then @xmath146 .","however , the computed @xmath40 is not guaranteed to have low spatial frequency structure .","we post - process @xmath40 to enforce this constraint . here","we low - pass filter it with a median filter to get @xmath90 .","the size of the median filter is chosen larger than a neuron size .","then the background is estimated with @xmath147 empirically after the initialization of @xmath42 and approximating @xmath43 with model ( [ eq : bg ] ) , the results are very close to the optimal solutions .","but we can still make the parameter estimations better by iteratively updating model parameters .","there are several things we can do : ( 1 ) deconvolve the temporal components in @xmath46 to get denoised calcium traces , ( 2 ) delete false positive neurons , ( 3 ) pick neurons from the residual @xmath148 , and ( 4 ) merge neurons that were inappropriately split into several components .","all these operations can lead to better extraction of cellular signals .","each time when we update @xmath43 , we run the same procedure as section [ supp : bg ] again",". we can adaptively change the b - spline basis and rank of @xmath39 to get better approximation .","for example , when we see some trend in cellular signals , we can use spline basis with more knots to explain this trend in the background .","sometimes the background corrected data is still blurry because we do not remove the background cleanly . in this case , we can increase the rank to @xmath39 term in background to explain it . to update @xmath85 and @xmath86",", we keep the background @xmath43 unchanged , i.e. , we fit the model @xmath149 .","this can be done using the same approaches described in @xcite and we need to make changes by removing the background term ( see section [ sec : updateac ] )",". our method can also allow users verify the extracted cells visually and delete those low - quality neurons .","the spatiotemporal activity of these deleted neurons will be absorbed by the background @xmath43 or other neurons .","the signal qualities of nearby neurons might be improved . to add a neuron from the residual @xmath148 , we first select one pixel @xmath65 ( usually the one with the maximum residual ) and then run a rank-1 nmf in a small window centered at @xmath65 to get its spatial and temporal components . we can also manually or automatically select @xmath65 .","although these steps are simple , they showed great helps in speeding up the model fitting procedure . as a comparison ,","pca - ica method has no manual intervention steps .","removing false positive neurons could not improve signal extraction of other neurons .","after subtracting the background from the raw data , we can optimize @xmath45 and @xmath46 by fitting the model @xmath150 this is the same cnmf problem as proposed by @xcite .","the trivial difference is that eq .","( [ eq : new_cnmf ] ) has no background term .","we can use the same optimization procedure to estimate @xmath29 . here","we rewrite their approaches for this optimization approach .","briefly they iteratively update @xmath45 and @xmath46 by solving two optimization problems .","( 1 ) given the estimates of @xmath151 in previously iterations , @xmath152 can be updated by solving the following convex problem @xmath153 where @xmath154 is the standard deviation of the gaussian noise for each pixel @xmath111 . ( 2 ) once we update @xmath155 , we update @xmath156 column by column . to update the @xmath114th column",", we first form the quantity @xmath157[\\mathbf{c}_1^{(k)},\\cdots , \\mathbf{c}_{j-1}^{(k ) } , \\mathbf{c}_{j+1}^{(k-1)}\\cdots , \\mathbf{c}_k^{(k-1)}]^t\\big),\\ ] ] and then apply any deconvolution method of choice to @xmath158 to obtain @xmath159 .","we usually use the noise - constrained deconvolution method used in @xcite . removing the spatial sparsity constraint and the temporal dynamics can","significantly reduces the computation time and the results are close to the optimal solution . in this case ,","( [ eq : new_cnmf ] ) is a plain nmf problem with some locality constrains .","@xcite adapted the hierarchical alternating least squares ( hals ) method ( @xcite ) algorithm to solve it with fast speed .","in our implementations , we frequently use the hals algorithm to get convergent results before running the full cnmf approaches .","our method is very fast in analyzing data . in the example of the simulated data ( @xmath93 pixels , 3000 frames ) , our naive matlab implementation took @xmath160 minutes to initialize @xmath161 neurons out of @xmath92 on a single desktop . fitting the background model given","@xmath42 requires @xmath162 seconds .","the manual interventions of adding / deleting neurons only need few clicks and they can be processed in real time .","the results of our initialization step are very close the final solutions , so we only need @xmath163 cnmf iterations to update model parameters .","the performances of those algorithms used for solving cnmf have been reported in @xcite and @xcite .","our implementations can be easily optimized to be faster . in the initialization step ,","spatial filtering and calculation of the local correlation images are the only computation - intensive parts in the processing of huge data sets .","these computations themselves are very classical matrix operations and utilizing gpu can significantly make it faster . since the initialization of each neuron is only dependent on a very small window , the whole initialization step can be easily processed in parallel by segmenting the optical field into multiple small patches .","we can also use distributed computing to process the data patch by patch .","fitting the background model requires two steps : ( 1 ) the first step is approximating the baseline and slow trends .","since all pixels are independent , we can easily run it in parallel without effort ; ( 2 ) the second step is basically svd and there are plenties of existing algorithms or packages to deal with this problem for extremely large datasets . in summary , all the algorithm proposed in this paper has no scalability issues and can be easily scaled for processing any large - scale datasets ."],"string":"[\n \"monitoring the activity of large - scale neuronal ensembles during complex behavioral states is fundamental to neuroscience research\",\n \". continued advances in optical imaging technology are greatly expanding the number and depth of neuronal populations that can be visualized .\",\n \"specifically , in vivo calcium imaging through microendoscopic lenses and the development of miniaturized microscopes have enabled deep brain imaging of previously inaccessible neuronal populations of freely moving mice ( @xcite ) . while these techniques have been widely used by neuroscientists ,\",\n \"automatic methods for extracting cellular signals from this data are currently limited and suboptimal .\",\n \"the desired method should be able to ( 1 ) identify spatial footprints of all neurons , ( 2 ) denoise , demix and deconvolve the temporal signals ( @xcite ) .\",\n \"figure [ fig : example]a is an example frame from microendoscopic data , where the weak neuronal signals are submerged in the large background ( the raw video data can we watched here ) . for illustrative purposes , we draw two rois in the optical field and compute their mean fluorescence intensities ( figure [ fig : example]c , d ) .\",\n \"the red roi overlaps with one neuron and the green roi only has the background ( figure [ fig : example]b ) .\",\n \"thus the fluorescence in the red roi ( figure [ fig : example]c ) is a superposition of the background and the neuron s temporal activity , whereas the green ( figure [ fig : example]d ) provides an estimation of the background signal . by subtracting these two traces\",\n \", we are able to roughly estimate the temporal activity of the neuron within the red roi ( figure [ fig : example]e ) . from this example\",\n \", we can see that the background is an order of magnitude larger than the neural activity and its fluctuations are as fast as neuronal calcium transients .\",\n \"these features make it difficult to detect and demix cellular signals automatically from the raw video .\",\n \"our work is based on a matrix factorization approach , which can simultaneously segment cells and estimate changes in fluorescence in the temporal domain .\",\n \"this approach stems from the observation that spatiotemporal calcium activity can be approximated as product of two matrices : a spatial matrix that encodes the location of each neuron and a temporal matrix that characterizes the calcium concentration evolution for each neuron .\",\n \"it has several variations with different constraints , such as independent component analysis ( pca - ica , @xcite ) , nonnegative matrix factorization ( nmf , @xcite ) , sparse space - time deconvolution ( sstd , @xcite ) and constrained nonnegative matrix factorization ( cnmf , @xcite ) . in particular , pca - ica seeks spatiotemporal components that have reduced dependence .\",\n \"it is an inherently linear demixing method and can fail in the case when the neural components exhibit significant spatial overlaps ( @xcite ) .\",\n \"nonlinear methods like nmf , sstd and cnmf can deal with overlapping neural sources more effectively , and often outperform pca - ica .\",\n \"the main applications of these nonlinear methods are 2-photon or light - sheet imaging data , where the background is weak and has simple spatiotemporally separable structure .\",\n \"they usually model the background with a rank-1 nonnegative matrix .\",\n \"however , applying these nonlinear matrix factorization methods to the microendoscopic data faces two problems : ( 1 ) the background term is not well modeled by rank-1 nmf and its large residual could contaminate the extracted neuronal signals ; ( 2 ) the procedures of initializing the model parameters , especially spatial and temporal components of neurons , in these models do not work well because the strong and noisy background mixes with the weak neural signals .\",\n \"since the optimization problem in these methods are non - convex , without good initialization , it may lead to low - quality results or require excessive time for convergent results . in this paper , we extend the cnmf framework ( @xcite ) to address strong fluctuations in background fluorescence , and make it applicable to microendoscopic data .\",\n \"like the proposed cnmf in @xcite , our extended cnmf for microendoscopic data ( cnmf - e ) also has the capability of identifying neurons with low signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) and simultaneously denoising , deconvolving and demixing large - scale microendoscopic data . to accomplish this : ( 1 ) we replace the rank-1 nmf approximation of the background with a more sophisticated approximation , which can better account the complex background and avoid absorbing cellular signals , and ( 2 ) we develop an efficient initialization procedure to extract neural activities with minimal influence from the background .\",\n \"the structure of the paper is as follows . in section [ sec : cnmf ]\",\n \"we briefly review the cnmf model and describe our modifications to the model . in section [ sec : fit_model ]\",\n \", we develop our specialized model fitting procedure . in section [ sec : result ] we validate our new proposed cnmf - e on simulated and experimental data , and we also compare it with the widely used pca - ica method ( @xcite ) . * notation * a matrix @xmath0 represents the spatiotemporal activity of @xmath1 pixels in @xmath2 frames .\",\n \"the column vector @xmath3 is the observation of the whole frame in time - step @xmath4 .\",\n \"we use @xmath5 to refer the spatial location of one pixel , thus @xmath6 is the fluorescence intensity in @xmath4-th frame at location @xmath7 . for a column vector @xmath8 encoding the spatial information of @xmath1 pixels , @xmath9 indicates the value of @xmath10 at pixel @xmath7 .\",\n \"the video data we have are observations from the optical field for a total number of @xmath2 frames .\",\n \"the recorded data can be represented by a matrix @xmath11 , where @xmath1 is the number of pixels in the field .\",\n \"each neuron is characterized by its spatial ` footprint ' vector @xmath12 and ` calcium activity ' @xmath13 . here\",\n \"both @xmath14 and @xmath15 are forced to be nonnegative because of their physical interpretations .\",\n \"given @xmath16 of one neuron , its spatiotemporal activity is represented as @xmath17 .\",\n \"the background activity is represented by a matrix @xmath18 .\",\n \"suppose the field contains a total number of @xmath19 neurons , then the observation is a superposition of all neurons spatiotemporal activity , time - varying background and additive noise : @xmath20 where @xmath21 , c=[\\\\mathbf{c}_1 , \\\\cdots , \\\\mathbf{c}_k]^t$ ] .\",\n \"the noise term @xmath22 is assumed to be gaussian and @xmath23 .\",\n \"@xmath24 is a diagonal matrix indicating that the noise is spatially and temporally uncorrelated .\",\n \"@xcite also explicitly model the calcium dynamics @xmath15 with a stable autoregressive process ( ar ) of order @xmath25 , @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the number of spikes that neuron fired at the @xmath4-th frame and it is sparse in the neural systems .\",\n \"the ar coefficients @xmath28 are different for each neuron and they are estimated from the data . estimating the model parameters @xmath29 in model ( [ eq : y])([eq : arp ] ) can give us all neurons spatial footprints and their deconvolved temporal activities . to fit the model , we also have to constrain the background term to have simplified structure , otherwise letting @xmath30 leads to the least reconstruction error .\",\n \"this framework is general and we use it in our new method as well .\",\n \"compared with the proposed implementation in @xcite , our method models the background term differently . in the work of @xcite , they model the background with a rank-1 nonnegative matrix @xmath31 , where @xmath32 and @xmath33 encode the background spatial and temporal structure respectively\",\n \"this is a good assumption for two - photon or light - sheet imaging data , but the background in microendoscopic data requires a more complex model .\",\n \"we also have to avoid the increased complexity from absorbing cellular signals into the background .\",\n \"thus the ideal model should explicitly model the background features that are distinct from neurons of interest . here\",\n \"we include two main features of the background into the model of @xmath34 : ( 1 ) the temporal component of each pixel has a constant large baseline and some slow trends ( see figure [ fig : example]d ) and ( 2 ) background is usually spatially smooth in a larger spatial range compared with neuron size ( figure [ fig : example ] ) , which means the background of all pixels within a neuron does not have large spatial gradients .\",\n \"this is because the fluctuations in the background reflects the out - of - focus fluorescence and they are significantly blurred .\",\n \"hence we model the background term as @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 .\",\n \"@xmath38 explains the constant baselines and slow trends for all pixels ( figure [ fig : example]c ) and their temporal dynamics are much slower than calcium indicators .\",\n \"the second term @xmath39 models the fast fluctuation in the background and the spatial component @xmath40 has low spatial - frequency structure .\",\n \"the constraint of @xmath40 excludes cellular signals from the background term .\",\n \"in this section , we will describe our customized algorithm for fitting the model ( [ eq : y])([eq : arp])([eq : bg ] ) .\",\n \"we frequently use the pixel - wise formulation of model ( [ eq : y ] ) and ignore the noise term : @xmath41 our framework can be summarized into the following steps : 1 .\",\n \"initialize @xmath42 using the new initialization procedure .\",\n \"2 . approximate the background @xmath43 using model ( [ eq : bg ] ) .\",\n \"update @xmath42 from data @xmath44 using constrained alternating matrix factorization .\",\n \"4 . post - process the results automatically or manually : delete neurons , pick the missed neurons from the residuals , and merge neurons with high temporal correlations .\",\n \"repeat steps 2 , 3 , 4 until the results are biologically meaningful .\",\n \"our techniques differ from @xcite in the following aspects : ( 1 ) the initialization step for @xmath45 and @xmath46 here requires careful considerations of the background contaminations and our approach is totally new .\",\n \"( 2 ) instead of updating the background term iteratively , we update the background independently in different iterations and the rank of the background model can be modified in each iteration . as a result , our algorithm has a better control of the residual levels in background . in the followings , we mainly describe our novel initialization step and briefly summarize the procedure of fitting the background term . as for steps ( 3 - 5 ) and discussions for scalability issue , we put them in the supplementary materials ( section [ supp : iterative_manual ] and [ supp : speed ] ) . , the initialized temporal activity of one neuron .\",\n \"d@xmath47 , raw data of the cropped small window ( green square in a and b ) .\",\n \"e@xmath47 , the estimated time - varying local backgrounds in the small cropped window .\",\n \"c@xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the re - ordered version of c@xmath47 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 .\",\n \"c@xmath53 is the temporal differencing of c@xmath48 and the result has been thresholded with its @xmath54 standard deviation .\",\n \"similarly , d@xmath53 is differencing result of d@xmath48 .\",\n \"f , the initialized spatial and temporal components of the neuron.,width=529 ] here we develop a robust procedure for initializing @xmath45 and @xmath46 without estimation of the background .\",\n \"this procedure utilizes the spatial smoothness feature in the background and removes it by spatial high - pass filtering of the raw data .\",\n \"we estimate the temporal component of one neuron @xmath15 from spatially filtered data and then use it to extract the corresponding spatial footprint @xmath14 from the raw data . in the step of estimating @xmath14 , we re - order all frames to make nearby frames share the similar local background levels and then take the temporal differencing to remove the background signals temporally .\",\n \"after that , we can use regression to get @xmath14 . repeating\",\n \"this process can initialize the required number of neurons .\",\n \"the whole procedure is schematically illustrated in figure [ fig : initialization ] and described in algorithm [ alg : init ] in the supplementary materials .\",\n \"the spatial smoothness assumption of the background leads to @xmath55 i.e. , within the spatial range of a cell body , the background is spatially invariant .\",\n \"based on this assumption , we use @xmath56 to filter the raw data @xmath6 , and @xmath56 is defined as @xmath57 where @xmath58 .\",\n \"@xmath59 is a gaussian kernel with width @xmath60 and @xmath61 is the the average size of the neurons .\",\n \"@xmath56 is a template matching filter to detect spatial structures with similar shapes and sizes . for flat structures in the small regions , like background , filtering them with @xmath56\",\n \"get results close to 0 .\",\n \"thus in the filtered data @xmath62 , the background @xmath63 has been roughly removed and @xmath64 is mainly composed of cellular signals ( figure [ fig : initialization]b ) .\",\n \"more interestingly , the calcium concentrations of most neurons can be directly approximated by the temporal traces of some pixels in @xmath64 .\",\n \"( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath47 , see section [ supp : filter ] in supplementary materials for derivation ) .\",\n \"we call these pixels seed pixels because we can use them to initialize neurons .\",\n \"we initialize neurons with a greedy algorithm . in each iteration , we find one seed pixel @xmath65 ( see supplementary materials section [ sec : seed ] for details of how to detect seed pixels ) and initialize its spatial footprint @xmath66 and temporal course @xmath67\",\n \". then we subtract @xmath68 from the raw video data , find the next seed pixel and repeat the initialization procedure until specified number of neurons have been initialized or no more seed pixels exist . given a seed pixel @xmath65 , we can initialize the neuron s temporal component as @xmath69 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath47 ) .\",\n \"this approximation is usually good , and here we propose an efficient method to extract its spatial component @xmath14 from the raw data @xmath70 .\",\n \"we first crop the optical field with a square centered at @xmath65 and the square size is twice larger than the average neuron size @xmath61 ( figure [ fig : initialization]d@xmath47 ) .\",\n \"since cell bodies have localized structure , the spatial shape of the expected neuron is completely covered by this square .\",\n \"then we approximate the local background level in this cropped area @xmath71 using the median of the fluorescence intensities on the square boundary ( figure [ fig : initialization]e@xmath47 ) . by sorting all frames in an order of @xmath72 such that @xmath73 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath48d@xmath48e@xmath48 ) , nearby frames have the minimal differences ( @xmath74 ) in the background term .\",\n \"hence the differencing of the sorted video data is @xmath75 we already have @xmath76 , so we can initialize @xmath14 by regressing @xmath77 on @xmath78 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath53d@xmath53 ) . empirically we found that thresholding @xmath79 achieves better results .\",\n \"after we get @xmath80 ( figure [ fig : initialization]f ) , we can reestimate @xmath81 using a simple formula : @xmath82 where @xmath83 is a vector replacing all nonzero pixels of @xmath84 with the mean of those nonzero pixels . by running this initialization procedure iteratively\",\n \", we can extract almost all neurons . after we get @xmath85 and @xmath86\",\n \", @xmath87 is mainly the background component and we will approximate it with a matrix described in eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : bg ] ) .\",\n \"first we use a spline basis with low temporal dynamics to approximate the first term @xmath88 ( baseline + slow trend ) , then we factorize the residual @xmath89 with @xmath39 . by constraining @xmath40 with high spatial smoothness , we can avoid cellular signals being absorbed into the background .\",\n \"we use singular value decomposition ( svd ) together with low - pass filtering of the estimated spatial components to estimate @xmath90 and @xmath91 .\",\n \"( see supplementary materials [ supp : bg ] for details ) .\",\n \"pca - ica ( @xcite ) is the most widely used automatic methods for analyzing microendoscopic data ( @xcite ) .\",\n \"it seeks spatially and temporally independent components as individual neurons . in this section\",\n \"we compared our cnmf - e with pca - ica method using simulated and experimental data .\",\n \"we simulated @xmath92 neurons activity in the optical field ( @xmath93 pixels ) for @xmath94 frames ( @xmath95 hz ) . to ensure that the background had similar features as real data\",\n \", we utilized the background extracted from our experimental data as the background in our simulation .\",\n \"we also add i.i.d .\",\n \"gaussian noise to our model ( the simulated video data can be found here ) .\",\n \"after removing all false positives , pca - ica detected @xmath96 neurons and our cnmf - e method found @xmath97 neurons of the @xmath92 neurons .\",\n \"most neurons detected by pca - ica did not have localized structures and multiple neurons were combined together ( see supplementary figure [ fig : supp_ac ] ) .\",\n \"we superimposed the contours of all extracted neurons together on top of the locations of simulated neurons .\",\n \"pca - ica - based segmentation failed to identify a large proportion of the neurons in this dataset , whereas nearly every neuron was identified by the cnmf - e approach ( figure [ fig : sim]cd ) .\",\n \"we matched each simulated neuron with a neuron among all the extracted neurons by selecting the one most correlated with the simulated neuron temporally .\",\n \"for a pair of matched neuron , they should have both high temporal and spatial correlations in the perfect case , i.e. , the real cellular signal is extracted from the data with high fidelity .\",\n \"we displayed spatial and temporal correlations of all simulated neurons with their matched neurons detected by two approaches ( figure [ fig : sim]bd ) . a total number of @xmath97 simulated neurons were accurately recovered by our cnmf - e method ( figure [ fig : sim]d ) . while for pca - ica , a large proportion of the matched neurons have low spatial and temporal correlations ( figure [ fig : sim ] ) indicating failures in recovering real neurons signals .\",\n \"we also display @xmath98 tightly clustered neurons in the simulated data ( figure [ fig : sim]e ) to demonstrate that our cnmf - e approach can accurately detect and demix their activity ( figure [ fig : sim]g ) .\",\n \"the spatiotemporal similarity between the 4 neurons segmented with cnmf - e ( figure 3 g ) and ground truth ( figure 3e ) indicates a good performance in extracting the neural activity .\",\n \"in contrast , pca - ica based detection can only detect two neurons and the calcium traces have high level of noise .\",\n \"the reason is that pca - ica merges multiple neurons together spatially and distorts the calcium traces in the temporal domain .\",\n \"furthermore , the distorted calcium traces reduces the number of detected neurons .\",\n \"the data used here was collected from the prefrontal cortex ( pfc ) of a freely moving mouse .\",\n \"the frame rate is 15 hz . the raw image ( figure [ fig : data_example]a ) is blurry and it is difficult to visually detect any neurons .\",\n \"its local correlation image ( @xcite ) of the raw data is approximately uniform @xmath99 ( figure [ fig : data_example]c ) , which means neighboring pixels share strong background fluctuations .\",\n \"here we removed the background by spatially filtering the raw data with @xmath56 and then calculated local correlation image using eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : pnr_corr ] ) in supplementary materials .\",\n \"figure [ fig : data_example]d clearly shows the locations of all neurons .\",\n \"appying our proposed cnmf - e method is able to detect @xmath100 neurons from the raw data .\",\n \"their contours are depicted on top the the correlation image and we can see that our method efficiently identifies neurons in the optical field ( figure [ fig : data_example]d ) .\",\n \"after subtracting the extracted background from the raw data , neural activity is visualized more effectively ( figure [ fig : data_example]b ) .\",\n \"the quality of this background correction on the raw data is important for extracting neural signals and demixing neurons . in the supplementary video ( )\",\n \", we showed the raw video , extracted background video , background corrected video and reconstructed cellular activity @xmath101 . from the video , we can see that cnmf - e reliably extracted the weak cellular signals from the rapidly fluctuating background .\",\n \"we choose three neighboring neurons within a small field to show the performance of our method . in figure\",\n \"[ fig : data_example]e , we showed their rois and the local correlation image .\",\n \"the mean fluorescence traces within each roi are too noisy to infer any calcium events .\",\n \"both pca - ica and cnmf - e isolated these three neurons and extracted the spiking signals , but the traces extracted with the pca - ica have higher levels of noise .\",\n \"further , note that traces extracted with pca - ica have large artifactual negative peaks .\",\n \"cnmf - e does not have this problem due to the nonnegative requirements . in the shaded region of figure [ fig : data_example]f ,\",\n \"we demonstrate potential crosstalk between two neurons , that is avoided by cnmf - e but not pca - ica based segmentation ( watch video here .\",\n \"the temporal traces in the video are extracted from cnmf - e ) . detected neurons and the correlation image calculated using our cnmf - e method ( see eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : pnr_corr ] ) in supplementary materials ) .\",\n \"e , mean fluorescence traces from three rois .\",\n \"f , extracted spatial / temporal components of three neurons using pca - ica method .\",\n \"g , results using our cnmf - e method .\",\n \", width=529 ]\",\n \"in this paper , we proposed an efficient method for extracting cellular signals from microendoscopic data ; such methods are in very high demand in the neuroscience community .\",\n \"the analysis of this video data is the first stage of processing in many experiments , so the quality of source extraction in this step highly influences the scientific conclusions drawn in downstream analysis . as shown in figure [ fig : sim ] and [ fig : data_example ] ,\",\n \"our method shows credible performances in recovering the real neuronal signals and outperforms the previous standard pca - ica method .\",\n \"thus the methods introduced here ( which we plan to release as open source software ) will be a powerful and important tool for the neuroscience community .\",\n \"funding for this research was provided by nih 2r01mh064537 ( p.z .\",\n \", r.k . ) , nih r90da023426 ( p.z . ) , national institute of child health nichd and human development hd079124 ( g.s . ) , nichd grant t32 hd040127 ( s.r . ) , simons research foundation ( g.s . ) , simons foundation global brain research awards 325171 , 365002 , aro muri w911nf-12 - 1 - 0594 , darpa n66001 - 15-c-4032 ( simplex ) , and a google faculty research award ( l.p . ) ; in addition , this work was supported by the intelligence advanced research projects activity ( iarpa ) via department of interior/ interior business center ( doi / ibc ) contract number d16pc00003 ( l.p . ) , d16pc00007 ( p.z . ) . the u.s .\",\n \"government is authorized to reproduce and distribute reprints for governmental purposes notwithstanding any copyright annotation thereon .\",\n \"disclaimer : the views and conclusions contained herein are those of the authors and should not be interpreted as necessarily representing the official policies or endorsements , either expressed or implied , of iarpa , doi / ibc , or the u.s .\",\n \"government .\",\n \"11 [ 1]#1 [ 1]`#1 ` urlstyle [ 1]doi : # 1 ferran diego andilla and fred a. hamprecht . .\",\n \"_ advances in neural information processing systems _ , pages 6472 , 2014 .\",\n \"andrzej cichocki , rafal zdunek , and shun - ichi amari . .\",\n \"_ independent component analysis and signal separation _ ,\",\n \"46660 ( 1):0 169176 , 2007 . benjamin a flusberg , axel nimmerjahn , eric d cocker , eran a mukamel , robert p j barretto , tony h ko , laurie d burns , juergen c jung , and mark j schnitzer . _ nature methods _ , 50 ( 11):0 9358 , 2008 .\",\n \"johannes friedrich , daniel soudry , yu mu , jeremy freeman , misha ahrens , and liam paninski . .\",\n \"in _ conference on neural information processing systems _ , 2015 .\",\n \"kunal k ghosh , laurie d burns , eric d cocker , axel nimmerjahn , yaniv ziv , abbas el gamal , and mark j schnitzer .\",\n \"_ nature methods _ , 80 ( 10):0 871878 , 2011 . ryuichi maruyama , kazuma maeda , hajime moroda , ichiro kato , masashi inoue , hiroyoshi miyakawa , and toru aonishi . .\",\n \"_ neural networks _ ,\",\n \"55:0 1119 , 2014 .\",\n \"eran a. mukamel , axel nimmerjahn , and mark j. schnitzer . .\",\n \"_ neuron _ , 630 ( 6):0 747760 , 2009 .\",\n \"eftychios a pnevmatikakis , daniel soudry , yuanjun gao , timothy a machado , josh merel , david pfau , thomas reardon , yu mu , clay lacefield , weijian yang , misha ahrens , randy bruno , thomas m jessell , darcy s peterka , rafael yuste , and liam paninski . .\",\n \"_ neuron _ , 890 ( 2):0 285299 , 2016 . shanna l resendez , josh h jennings , randall l ung , vijay mohan k namboodiri , zhe charles zhou , james m otis , hiroshi nomura , jenna a mchenry , oksana kosyk , and garret d stuber . .\",\n \"_ nature protocols _ , 110 ( 3):0 566597 , 2016 .\",\n \"spencer l smith and michael husser . .\",\n \"_ nature neuroscience _ , 130 ( 9):0 11441149 , 2010 .\",\n \"yaniv ziv and kunal k ghosh . .\",\n \"_ current opinion in neurobiology _ , 32:0 141147 , 2015\",\n \"since @xmath103 filtering the raw data with @xmath56 results @xmath104(\\\\mathbf{x})\\\\cdot c_i(t).\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] for each neuron , there is an area @xmath105(\\\\mathbf{x } ) > 0\\\\}$ ] .\",\n \"usually @xmath106 corresponds to the central area for a neuron with gaussian shape . for @xmath107 , @xmath108(\\\\mathbf{x})\\\\cdot c_i(t ) +\",\n \"\\\\sum_{j\\\\neq i}^k [ \\\\tilde{h}\\\\ast a_j](\\\\mathbf{x})\\\\cdot c_j(t ) .\",\n \"\\\\label{eq : zxt}\\\\ ] ] if @xmath109(\\\\mathbf{x})=0 $ ] for all @xmath110 , i.e. , the @xmath111 th neuron is well isolated from the others , then @xmath112 this is a nice feature because we can estimate @xmath102 from @xmath64 directly .\",\n \"empirically we found that this condition can be relaxed to @xmath109(\\\\mathbf{x})\\\\leq0 $ ] .\",\n \"when @xmath109(\\\\mathbf{x})<0 $ ] , @xmath113 has negative spikes from neuron @xmath114 and we can remove them simply by thresholding @xmath64 with its median .\",\n \"thus for each neuron @xmath111 , as long as there exist some @xmath107 and @xmath109(\\\\mathbf{x})\\\\leq0 $ ] for all @xmath110 ( small positive values are still tolerable ) , we can simply approximate its calcium concentration @xmath102 with @xmath64 .\",\n \"a seed pixel @xmath7 should have two main features : first , @xmath113 has high peak - to - noise ratio ( pnr ) because it encodes the calcium concentration @xmath102 of one neuron and usually @xmath102 has large calcium transients ; second , seed pixel has high temporal correlations with its neighboring pixels because they are likely to share the same @xmath102 .\",\n \"we computed two metrics for each of these two features : @xmath115 where @xmath116 ( we use @xmath117 ) determines the range of neighbors and @xmath118 is the total number of neighboring pixels .\",\n \"@xmath119 calculates the temporal correlation between two time series @xmath120 and @xmath121 .\",\n \"the function @xmath122 is a pre - processing of @xmath64 before computing local correlation . in our implementation , we threshold the differencing of @xmath113 by @xmath123 ( e.g. , @xmath124 .\",\n \"this is equivalent to a rough detection of calcium transients . it is better than using @xmath64 directly because it reduces the influence of the background residual , noise and negative spikes from nearby neurons . to avoid unnecessary searches of the seed pixels , we usually set thresholds for both @xmath125 ( e.g. , 5 ) and @xmath126 ( e.g. , 0.5 ) . in each iteration of the initialization\",\n \", we find the pixel with the maximum value of @xmath127 and set it as a seed pixel . here\",\n \"we use point - wise product of @xmath125 and @xmath126 to emphasize the characteristics of seed pixels .\",\n \"if we successfully initialize one neuron from this seed pixel , the spatiotemporal activity of this initialized neuron @xmath128 will be peeled off from the residual data ( it is @xmath70 at the beginning of the initialization ) .\",\n \"we also have to locally update @xmath125 and @xmath126 in the initialized area .\",\n \"each neuron can only be visited once for initialization .\",\n \"we will stop the initialization procedure until the specified number @xmath19 reaches or there are no more seed pixels .\",\n \"define @xmath130 as nonzero pixels of @xmath84 and @xmath131 then @xmath132 again , the spatial smoothness of the background term @xmath133 induces @xmath134 . when the overlaps between neurons are not severe , @xmath135 , hence , we have @xmath136 the trends of all pixels are independent and we approximate all trends with b - spline basis @xmath137 , i.e. , @xmath138 , where the row vectors of @xmath137 are cubic b - spline basis given a sequences of knots . by increasing the intervals between knots ,\",\n \"we lower the number of basis and constrain the dynamics of @xmath139 to be slow .\",\n \"we usually choose evenly distributed knots over the whole time period with an interval of @xmath140 seconds .\",\n \"this is much larger than dynamics of the calcium indicators ( @xmath141 seconds ) .\",\n \"@xmath142 contains coefficients of each spline basis .\",\n \"it is estimated with regression @xmath143\\\\cdot[xx^t]^{-1}$ ] . after we remove the @xmath38 , we move on to approximate the the fast fluctuations @xmath144 with low rank-@xmath118 matrix @xmath39 .\",\n \"the truncated svd of @xmath145 has the globally minimum frobenious norm of the difference between @xmath145 and @xmath39 .\",\n \"here we choose row vectors of @xmath91 be the top @xmath118 right singular vectors of @xmath145 and then @xmath146 .\",\n \"however , the computed @xmath40 is not guaranteed to have low spatial frequency structure .\",\n \"we post - process @xmath40 to enforce this constraint . here\",\n \"we low - pass filter it with a median filter to get @xmath90 .\",\n \"the size of the median filter is chosen larger than a neuron size .\",\n \"then the background is estimated with @xmath147 empirically after the initialization of @xmath42 and approximating @xmath43 with model ( [ eq : bg ] ) , the results are very close to the optimal solutions .\",\n \"but we can still make the parameter estimations better by iteratively updating model parameters .\",\n \"there are several things we can do : ( 1 ) deconvolve the temporal components in @xmath46 to get denoised calcium traces , ( 2 ) delete false positive neurons , ( 3 ) pick neurons from the residual @xmath148 , and ( 4 ) merge neurons that were inappropriately split into several components .\",\n \"all these operations can lead to better extraction of cellular signals .\",\n \"each time when we update @xmath43 , we run the same procedure as section [ supp : bg ] again\",\n \". we can adaptively change the b - spline basis and rank of @xmath39 to get better approximation .\",\n \"for example , when we see some trend in cellular signals , we can use spline basis with more knots to explain this trend in the background .\",\n \"sometimes the background corrected data is still blurry because we do not remove the background cleanly . in this case , we can increase the rank to @xmath39 term in background to explain it . to update @xmath85 and @xmath86\",\n \", we keep the background @xmath43 unchanged , i.e. , we fit the model @xmath149 .\",\n \"this can be done using the same approaches described in @xcite and we need to make changes by removing the background term ( see section [ sec : updateac ] )\",\n \". our method can also allow users verify the extracted cells visually and delete those low - quality neurons .\",\n \"the spatiotemporal activity of these deleted neurons will be absorbed by the background @xmath43 or other neurons .\",\n \"the signal qualities of nearby neurons might be improved . to add a neuron from the residual @xmath148 , we first select one pixel @xmath65 ( usually the one with the maximum residual ) and then run a rank-1 nmf in a small window centered at @xmath65 to get its spatial and temporal components . we can also manually or automatically select @xmath65 .\",\n \"although these steps are simple , they showed great helps in speeding up the model fitting procedure . as a comparison ,\",\n \"pca - ica method has no manual intervention steps .\",\n \"removing false positive neurons could not improve signal extraction of other neurons .\",\n \"after subtracting the background from the raw data , we can optimize @xmath45 and @xmath46 by fitting the model @xmath150 this is the same cnmf problem as proposed by @xcite .\",\n \"the trivial difference is that eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : new_cnmf ] ) has no background term .\",\n \"we can use the same optimization procedure to estimate @xmath29 . here\",\n \"we rewrite their approaches for this optimization approach .\",\n \"briefly they iteratively update @xmath45 and @xmath46 by solving two optimization problems .\",\n \"( 1 ) given the estimates of @xmath151 in previously iterations , @xmath152 can be updated by solving the following convex problem @xmath153 where @xmath154 is the standard deviation of the gaussian noise for each pixel @xmath111 . ( 2 ) once we update @xmath155 , we update @xmath156 column by column . to update the @xmath114th column\",\n \", we first form the quantity @xmath157[\\\\mathbf{c}_1^{(k)},\\\\cdots , \\\\mathbf{c}_{j-1}^{(k ) } , \\\\mathbf{c}_{j+1}^{(k-1)}\\\\cdots , \\\\mathbf{c}_k^{(k-1)}]^t\\\\big),\\\\ ] ] and then apply any deconvolution method of choice to @xmath158 to obtain @xmath159 .\",\n \"we usually use the noise - constrained deconvolution method used in @xcite . removing the spatial sparsity constraint and the temporal dynamics can\",\n \"significantly reduces the computation time and the results are close to the optimal solution . in this case ,\",\n \"( [ eq : new_cnmf ] ) is a plain nmf problem with some locality constrains .\",\n \"@xcite adapted the hierarchical alternating least squares ( hals ) method ( @xcite ) algorithm to solve it with fast speed .\",\n \"in our implementations , we frequently use the hals algorithm to get convergent results before running the full cnmf approaches .\",\n \"our method is very fast in analyzing data . in the example of the simulated data ( @xmath93 pixels , 3000 frames ) , our naive matlab implementation took @xmath160 minutes to initialize @xmath161 neurons out of @xmath92 on a single desktop . fitting the background model given\",\n \"@xmath42 requires @xmath162 seconds .\",\n \"the manual interventions of adding / deleting neurons only need few clicks and they can be processed in real time .\",\n \"the results of our initialization step are very close the final solutions , so we only need @xmath163 cnmf iterations to update model parameters .\",\n \"the performances of those algorithms used for solving cnmf have been reported in @xcite and @xcite .\",\n \"our implementations can be easily optimized to be faster . in the initialization step ,\",\n \"spatial filtering and calculation of the local correlation images are the only computation - intensive parts in the processing of huge data sets .\",\n \"these computations themselves are very classical matrix operations and utilizing gpu can significantly make it faster . since the initialization of each neuron is only dependent on a very small window , the whole initialization step can be easily processed in parallel by segmenting the optical field into multiple small patches .\",\n \"we can also use distributed computing to process the data patch by patch .\",\n \"fitting the background model requires two steps : ( 1 ) the first step is approximating the baseline and slow trends .\",\n \"since all pixels are independent , we can easily run it in parallel without effort ; ( 2 ) the second step is basically svd and there are plenties of existing algorithms or packages to deal with this problem for extremely large datasets . in summary , all the algorithm proposed in this paper has no scalability issues and can be easily scaled for processing any large - scale datasets .\"\n]","isConversational":false},"abstract_text":{"kind":"list like","value":["<S> in vivo calcium imaging through microscopes has enabled deep brain imaging of previously inaccessible neuronal populations within the brains of freely moving subjects . </S>","<S> however , microendoscopic data suffer from high levels of background fluorescence as well as an increased potential for overlapping neuronal signals . </S>","<S> previous methods fail in identifying neurons and demixing their temporal activity because the cellular signals are often submerged in the large fluctuating background . here </S>","<S> we develop an efficient method to extract cellular signals with minimal influence from the background . </S>","<S> we model the background with two realistic components : ( 1 ) one models the constant baseline and slow trends of each pixel , and ( 2 ) the other models the fast fluctuations from out - of - focus signals and is therefore constrained to have low spatial - frequency structure . </S>","<S> this decomposition avoids cellular signals being absorbed into the background term . after subtracting the background approximated with this model , we use constrained nonnegative matrix factorization ( cnmf , @xcite ) to better demix neural signals and get their denoised and deconvolved temporal activity . </S>","<S> we validate our method on simulated and experimental data , where it shows fast , reliable , and high quality signal extraction under a wide variety of imaging parameters . </S>"],"string":"[\n \"<S> in vivo calcium imaging through microscopes has enabled deep brain imaging of previously inaccessible neuronal populations within the brains of freely moving subjects . </S>\",\n \"<S> however , microendoscopic data suffer from high levels of background fluorescence as well as an increased potential for overlapping neuronal signals . </S>\",\n \"<S> previous methods fail in identifying neurons and demixing their temporal activity because the cellular signals are often submerged in the large fluctuating background . here </S>\",\n \"<S> we develop an efficient method to extract cellular signals with minimal influence from the background . </S>\",\n \"<S> we model the background with two realistic components : ( 1 ) one models the constant baseline and slow trends of each pixel , and ( 2 ) the other models the fast fluctuations from out - of - focus signals and is therefore constrained to have low spatial - frequency structure . </S>\",\n \"<S> this decomposition avoids cellular signals being absorbed into the background term . after subtracting the background approximated with this model , we use constrained nonnegative matrix factorization ( cnmf , @xcite ) to better demix neural signals and get their denoised and deconvolved temporal activity . </S>\",\n \"<S> we validate our method on simulated and experimental data , where it shows fast , reliable , and high quality signal extraction under a wide variety of imaging parameters . </S>\"\n]","isConversational":false},"labels":{"kind":"null"},"section_names":{"kind":"list like","value":["introduction","model description","model fitting","results","conclusion","supplementary materials"],"string":"[\n \"introduction\",\n \"model description\",\n \"model fitting\",\n \"results\",\n \"conclusion\",\n \"supplementary materials\"\n]","isConversational":false},"sections":{"kind":"list like","value":[["monitoring the activity of large - scale neuronal ensembles during complex behavioral states is fundamental to neuroscience research",". continued advances in optical imaging technology are greatly expanding the number and depth of neuronal populations that can be visualized .","specifically , in vivo calcium imaging through microendoscopic lenses and the development of miniaturized microscopes have enabled deep brain imaging of previously inaccessible neuronal populations of freely moving mice ( @xcite ) . while these techniques have been widely used by neuroscientists ,","automatic methods for extracting cellular signals from this data are currently limited and suboptimal .","the desired method should be able to ( 1 ) identify spatial footprints of all neurons , ( 2 ) denoise , demix and deconvolve the temporal signals ( @xcite ) .","figure [ fig : example]a is an example frame from microendoscopic data , where the weak neuronal signals are submerged in the large background ( the raw video data can we watched here ) . for illustrative purposes , we draw two rois in the optical field and compute their mean fluorescence intensities ( figure [ fig : example]c , d ) .","the red roi overlaps with one neuron and the green roi only has the background ( figure [ fig : example]b ) .","thus the fluorescence in the red roi ( figure [ fig : example]c ) is a superposition of the background and the neuron s temporal activity , whereas the green ( figure [ fig : example]d ) provides an estimation of the background signal . by subtracting these two traces",", we are able to roughly estimate the temporal activity of the neuron within the red roi ( figure [ fig : example]e ) . from this example",", we can see that the background is an order of magnitude larger than the neural activity and its fluctuations are as fast as neuronal calcium transients .","these features make it difficult to detect and demix cellular signals automatically from the raw video .","our work is based on a matrix factorization approach , which can simultaneously segment cells and estimate changes in fluorescence in the temporal domain .","this approach stems from the observation that spatiotemporal calcium activity can be approximated as product of two matrices : a spatial matrix that encodes the location of each neuron and a temporal matrix that characterizes the calcium concentration evolution for each neuron .","it has several variations with different constraints , such as independent component analysis ( pca - ica , @xcite ) , nonnegative matrix factorization ( nmf , @xcite ) , sparse space - time deconvolution ( sstd , @xcite ) and constrained nonnegative matrix factorization ( cnmf , @xcite ) . in particular , pca - ica seeks spatiotemporal components that have reduced dependence .","it is an inherently linear demixing method and can fail in the case when the neural components exhibit significant spatial overlaps ( @xcite ) .","nonlinear methods like nmf , sstd and cnmf can deal with overlapping neural sources more effectively , and often outperform pca - ica .","the main applications of these nonlinear methods are 2-photon or light - sheet imaging data , where the background is weak and has simple spatiotemporally separable structure .","they usually model the background with a rank-1 nonnegative matrix .","however , applying these nonlinear matrix factorization methods to the microendoscopic data faces two problems : ( 1 ) the background term is not well modeled by rank-1 nmf and its large residual could contaminate the extracted neuronal signals ; ( 2 ) the procedures of initializing the model parameters , especially spatial and temporal components of neurons , in these models do not work well because the strong and noisy background mixes with the weak neural signals .","since the optimization problem in these methods are non - convex , without good initialization , it may lead to low - quality results or require excessive time for convergent results . in this paper , we extend the cnmf framework ( @xcite ) to address strong fluctuations in background fluorescence , and make it applicable to microendoscopic data .","like the proposed cnmf in @xcite , our extended cnmf for microendoscopic data ( cnmf - e ) also has the capability of identifying neurons with low signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) and simultaneously denoising , deconvolving and demixing large - scale microendoscopic data . to accomplish this : ( 1 ) we replace the rank-1 nmf approximation of the background with a more sophisticated approximation , which can better account the complex background and avoid absorbing cellular signals , and ( 2 ) we develop an efficient initialization procedure to extract neural activities with minimal influence from the background .","the structure of the paper is as follows . in section [ sec : cnmf ]","we briefly review the cnmf model and describe our modifications to the model . in section [ sec : fit_model ]",", we develop our specialized model fitting procedure . in section [ sec : result ] we validate our new proposed cnmf - e on simulated and experimental data , and we also compare it with the widely used pca - ica method ( @xcite ) . * notation * a matrix @xmath0 represents the spatiotemporal activity of @xmath1 pixels in @xmath2 frames .","the column vector @xmath3 is the observation of the whole frame in time - step @xmath4 .","we use @xmath5 to refer the spatial location of one pixel , thus @xmath6 is the fluorescence intensity in @xmath4-th frame at location @xmath7 . for a column vector @xmath8 encoding the spatial information of @xmath1 pixels , @xmath9 indicates the value of @xmath10 at pixel @xmath7 ."],["the video data we have are observations from the optical field for a total number of @xmath2 frames .","the recorded data can be represented by a matrix @xmath11 , where @xmath1 is the number of pixels in the field .","each neuron is characterized by its spatial ` footprint ' vector @xmath12 and ` calcium activity ' @xmath13 . here","both @xmath14 and @xmath15 are forced to be nonnegative because of their physical interpretations .","given @xmath16 of one neuron , its spatiotemporal activity is represented as @xmath17 .","the background activity is represented by a matrix @xmath18 .","suppose the field contains a total number of @xmath19 neurons , then the observation is a superposition of all neurons spatiotemporal activity , time - varying background and additive noise : @xmath20 where @xmath21 , c=[\\mathbf{c}_1 , \\cdots , \\mathbf{c}_k]^t$ ] .","the noise term @xmath22 is assumed to be gaussian and @xmath23 .","@xmath24 is a diagonal matrix indicating that the noise is spatially and temporally uncorrelated .","@xcite also explicitly model the calcium dynamics @xmath15 with a stable autoregressive process ( ar ) of order @xmath25 , @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the number of spikes that neuron fired at the @xmath4-th frame and it is sparse in the neural systems .","the ar coefficients @xmath28 are different for each neuron and they are estimated from the data . estimating the model parameters @xmath29 in model ( [ eq : y])([eq : arp ] ) can give us all neurons spatial footprints and their deconvolved temporal activities . to fit the model , we also have to constrain the background term to have simplified structure , otherwise letting @xmath30 leads to the least reconstruction error .","this framework is general and we use it in our new method as well .","compared with the proposed implementation in @xcite , our method models the background term differently . in the work of @xcite , they model the background with a rank-1 nonnegative matrix @xmath31 , where @xmath32 and @xmath33 encode the background spatial and temporal structure respectively","this is a good assumption for two - photon or light - sheet imaging data , but the background in microendoscopic data requires a more complex model .","we also have to avoid the increased complexity from absorbing cellular signals into the background .","thus the ideal model should explicitly model the background features that are distinct from neurons of interest . here","we include two main features of the background into the model of @xmath34 : ( 1 ) the temporal component of each pixel has a constant large baseline and some slow trends ( see figure [ fig : example]d ) and ( 2 ) background is usually spatially smooth in a larger spatial range compared with neuron size ( figure [ fig : example ] ) , which means the background of all pixels within a neuron does not have large spatial gradients .","this is because the fluctuations in the background reflects the out - of - focus fluorescence and they are significantly blurred .","hence we model the background term as @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 .","@xmath38 explains the constant baselines and slow trends for all pixels ( figure [ fig : example]c ) and their temporal dynamics are much slower than calcium indicators .","the second term @xmath39 models the fast fluctuation in the background and the spatial component @xmath40 has low spatial - frequency structure .","the constraint of @xmath40 excludes cellular signals from the background term ."],["in this section , we will describe our customized algorithm for fitting the model ( [ eq : y])([eq : arp])([eq : bg ] ) .","we frequently use the pixel - wise formulation of model ( [ eq : y ] ) and ignore the noise term : @xmath41 our framework can be summarized into the following steps : 1 .","initialize @xmath42 using the new initialization procedure .","2 . approximate the background @xmath43 using model ( [ eq : bg ] ) .","update @xmath42 from data @xmath44 using constrained alternating matrix factorization .","4 . post - process the results automatically or manually : delete neurons , pick the missed neurons from the residuals , and merge neurons with high temporal correlations .","repeat steps 2 , 3 , 4 until the results are biologically meaningful .","our techniques differ from @xcite in the following aspects : ( 1 ) the initialization step for @xmath45 and @xmath46 here requires careful considerations of the background contaminations and our approach is totally new .","( 2 ) instead of updating the background term iteratively , we update the background independently in different iterations and the rank of the background model can be modified in each iteration . as a result , our algorithm has a better control of the residual levels in background . in the followings , we mainly describe our novel initialization step and briefly summarize the procedure of fitting the background term . as for steps ( 3 - 5 ) and discussions for scalability issue , we put them in the supplementary materials ( section [ supp : iterative_manual ] and [ supp : speed ] ) . , the initialized temporal activity of one neuron .","d@xmath47 , raw data of the cropped small window ( green square in a and b ) .","e@xmath47 , the estimated time - varying local backgrounds in the small cropped window .","c@xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the re - ordered version of c@xmath47 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 .","c@xmath53 is the temporal differencing of c@xmath48 and the result has been thresholded with its @xmath54 standard deviation .","similarly , d@xmath53 is differencing result of d@xmath48 .","f , the initialized spatial and temporal components of the neuron.,width=529 ] here we develop a robust procedure for initializing @xmath45 and @xmath46 without estimation of the background .","this procedure utilizes the spatial smoothness feature in the background and removes it by spatial high - pass filtering of the raw data .","we estimate the temporal component of one neuron @xmath15 from spatially filtered data and then use it to extract the corresponding spatial footprint @xmath14 from the raw data . in the step of estimating @xmath14 , we re - order all frames to make nearby frames share the similar local background levels and then take the temporal differencing to remove the background signals temporally .","after that , we can use regression to get @xmath14 . repeating","this process can initialize the required number of neurons .","the whole procedure is schematically illustrated in figure [ fig : initialization ] and described in algorithm [ alg : init ] in the supplementary materials .","the spatial smoothness assumption of the background leads to @xmath55 i.e. , within the spatial range of a cell body , the background is spatially invariant .","based on this assumption , we use @xmath56 to filter the raw data @xmath6 , and @xmath56 is defined as @xmath57 where @xmath58 .","@xmath59 is a gaussian kernel with width @xmath60 and @xmath61 is the the average size of the neurons .","@xmath56 is a template matching filter to detect spatial structures with similar shapes and sizes . for flat structures in the small regions , like background , filtering them with @xmath56","get results close to 0 .","thus in the filtered data @xmath62 , the background @xmath63 has been roughly removed and @xmath64 is mainly composed of cellular signals ( figure [ fig : initialization]b ) .","more interestingly , the calcium concentrations of most neurons can be directly approximated by the temporal traces of some pixels in @xmath64 .","( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath47 , see section [ supp : filter ] in supplementary materials for derivation ) .","we call these pixels seed pixels because we can use them to initialize neurons .","we initialize neurons with a greedy algorithm . in each iteration , we find one seed pixel @xmath65 ( see supplementary materials section [ sec : seed ] for details of how to detect seed pixels ) and initialize its spatial footprint @xmath66 and temporal course @xmath67",". then we subtract @xmath68 from the raw video data , find the next seed pixel and repeat the initialization procedure until specified number of neurons have been initialized or no more seed pixels exist . given a seed pixel @xmath65 , we can initialize the neuron s temporal component as @xmath69 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath47 ) .","this approximation is usually good , and here we propose an efficient method to extract its spatial component @xmath14 from the raw data @xmath70 .","we first crop the optical field with a square centered at @xmath65 and the square size is twice larger than the average neuron size @xmath61 ( figure [ fig : initialization]d@xmath47 ) .","since cell bodies have localized structure , the spatial shape of the expected neuron is completely covered by this square .","then we approximate the local background level in this cropped area @xmath71 using the median of the fluorescence intensities on the square boundary ( figure [ fig : initialization]e@xmath47 ) . by sorting all frames in an order of @xmath72 such that @xmath73 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath48d@xmath48e@xmath48 ) , nearby frames have the minimal differences ( @xmath74 ) in the background term .","hence the differencing of the sorted video data is @xmath75 we already have @xmath76 , so we can initialize @xmath14 by regressing @xmath77 on @xmath78 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath53d@xmath53 ) . empirically we found that thresholding @xmath79 achieves better results .","after we get @xmath80 ( figure [ fig : initialization]f ) , we can reestimate @xmath81 using a simple formula : @xmath82 where @xmath83 is a vector replacing all nonzero pixels of @xmath84 with the mean of those nonzero pixels . by running this initialization procedure iteratively",", we can extract almost all neurons . after we get @xmath85 and @xmath86",", @xmath87 is mainly the background component and we will approximate it with a matrix described in eq .","( [ eq : bg ] ) .","first we use a spline basis with low temporal dynamics to approximate the first term @xmath88 ( baseline + slow trend ) , then we factorize the residual @xmath89 with @xmath39 . by constraining @xmath40 with high spatial smoothness , we can avoid cellular signals being absorbed into the background .","we use singular value decomposition ( svd ) together with low - pass filtering of the estimated spatial components to estimate @xmath90 and @xmath91 .","( see supplementary materials [ supp : bg ] for details ) ."],["pca - ica ( @xcite ) is the most widely used automatic methods for analyzing microendoscopic data ( @xcite ) .","it seeks spatially and temporally independent components as individual neurons . in this section","we compared our cnmf - e with pca - ica method using simulated and experimental data .","we simulated @xmath92 neurons activity in the optical field ( @xmath93 pixels ) for @xmath94 frames ( @xmath95 hz ) . to ensure that the background had similar features as real data",", we utilized the background extracted from our experimental data as the background in our simulation .","we also add i.i.d .","gaussian noise to our model ( the simulated video data can be found here ) .","after removing all false positives , pca - ica detected @xmath96 neurons and our cnmf - e method found @xmath97 neurons of the @xmath92 neurons .","most neurons detected by pca - ica did not have localized structures and multiple neurons were combined together ( see supplementary figure [ fig : supp_ac ] ) .","we superimposed the contours of all extracted neurons together on top of the locations of simulated neurons .","pca - ica - based segmentation failed to identify a large proportion of the neurons in this dataset , whereas nearly every neuron was identified by the cnmf - e approach ( figure [ fig : sim]cd ) .","we matched each simulated neuron with a neuron among all the extracted neurons by selecting the one most correlated with the simulated neuron temporally .","for a pair of matched neuron , they should have both high temporal and spatial correlations in the perfect case , i.e. , the real cellular signal is extracted from the data with high fidelity .","we displayed spatial and temporal correlations of all simulated neurons with their matched neurons detected by two approaches ( figure [ fig : sim]bd ) . a total number of @xmath97 simulated neurons were accurately recovered by our cnmf - e method ( figure [ fig : sim]d ) . while for pca - ica , a large proportion of the matched neurons have low spatial and temporal correlations ( figure [ fig : sim ] ) indicating failures in recovering real neurons signals .","we also display @xmath98 tightly clustered neurons in the simulated data ( figure [ fig : sim]e ) to demonstrate that our cnmf - e approach can accurately detect and demix their activity ( figure [ fig : sim]g ) .","the spatiotemporal similarity between the 4 neurons segmented with cnmf - e ( figure 3 g ) and ground truth ( figure 3e ) indicates a good performance in extracting the neural activity .","in contrast , pca - ica based detection can only detect two neurons and the calcium traces have high level of noise .","the reason is that pca - ica merges multiple neurons together spatially and distorts the calcium traces in the temporal domain .","furthermore , the distorted calcium traces reduces the number of detected neurons .","the data used here was collected from the prefrontal cortex ( pfc ) of a freely moving mouse .","the frame rate is 15 hz . the raw image ( figure [ fig : data_example]a ) is blurry and it is difficult to visually detect any neurons .","its local correlation image ( @xcite ) of the raw data is approximately uniform @xmath99 ( figure [ fig : data_example]c ) , which means neighboring pixels share strong background fluctuations .","here we removed the background by spatially filtering the raw data with @xmath56 and then calculated local correlation image using eq .","( [ eq : pnr_corr ] ) in supplementary materials .","figure [ fig : data_example]d clearly shows the locations of all neurons .","appying our proposed cnmf - e method is able to detect @xmath100 neurons from the raw data .","their contours are depicted on top the the correlation image and we can see that our method efficiently identifies neurons in the optical field ( figure [ fig : data_example]d ) .","after subtracting the extracted background from the raw data , neural activity is visualized more effectively ( figure [ fig : data_example]b ) .","the quality of this background correction on the raw data is important for extracting neural signals and demixing neurons . in the supplementary video ( )",", we showed the raw video , extracted background video , background corrected video and reconstructed cellular activity @xmath101 . from the video , we can see that cnmf - e reliably extracted the weak cellular signals from the rapidly fluctuating background .","we choose three neighboring neurons within a small field to show the performance of our method . in figure","[ fig : data_example]e , we showed their rois and the local correlation image .","the mean fluorescence traces within each roi are too noisy to infer any calcium events .","both pca - ica and cnmf - e isolated these three neurons and extracted the spiking signals , but the traces extracted with the pca - ica have higher levels of noise .","further , note that traces extracted with pca - ica have large artifactual negative peaks .","cnmf - e does not have this problem due to the nonnegative requirements . in the shaded region of figure [ fig : data_example]f ,","we demonstrate potential crosstalk between two neurons , that is avoided by cnmf - e but not pca - ica based segmentation ( watch video here .","the temporal traces in the video are extracted from cnmf - e ) . detected neurons and the correlation image calculated using our cnmf - e method ( see eq .","( [ eq : pnr_corr ] ) in supplementary materials ) .","e , mean fluorescence traces from three rois .","f , extracted spatial / temporal components of three neurons using pca - ica method .","g , results using our cnmf - e method .",", width=529 ]"],["in this paper , we proposed an efficient method for extracting cellular signals from microendoscopic data ; such methods are in very high demand in the neuroscience community .","the analysis of this video data is the first stage of processing in many experiments , so the quality of source extraction in this step highly influences the scientific conclusions drawn in downstream analysis . as shown in figure [ fig : sim ] and [ fig : data_example ] ,","our method shows credible performances in recovering the real neuronal signals and outperforms the previous standard pca - ica method .","thus the methods introduced here ( which we plan to release as open source software ) will be a powerful and important tool for the neuroscience community .","funding for this research was provided by nih 2r01mh064537 ( p.z .",", r.k . ) , nih r90da023426 ( p.z . ) , national institute of child health nichd and human development hd079124 ( g.s . ) , nichd grant t32 hd040127 ( s.r . ) , simons research foundation ( g.s . ) , simons foundation global brain research awards 325171 , 365002 , aro muri w911nf-12 - 1 - 0594 , darpa n66001 - 15-c-4032 ( simplex ) , and a google faculty research award ( l.p . ) ; in addition , this work was supported by the intelligence advanced research projects activity ( iarpa ) via department of interior/ interior business center ( doi / ibc ) contract number d16pc00003 ( l.p . ) , d16pc00007 ( p.z . ) . the u.s .","government is authorized to reproduce and distribute reprints for governmental purposes notwithstanding any copyright annotation thereon .","disclaimer : the views and conclusions contained herein are those of the authors and should not be interpreted as necessarily representing the official policies or endorsements , either expressed or implied , of iarpa , doi / ibc , or the u.s .","government .","11 [ 1]#1 [ 1]`#1 ` urlstyle [ 1]doi : # 1 ferran diego andilla and fred a. hamprecht . .","_ advances in neural information processing systems _ , pages 6472 , 2014 .","andrzej cichocki , rafal zdunek , and shun - ichi amari . .","_ independent component analysis and signal separation _ ,","46660 ( 1):0 169176 , 2007 . benjamin a flusberg , axel nimmerjahn , eric d cocker , eran a mukamel , robert p j barretto , tony h ko , laurie d burns , juergen c jung , and mark j schnitzer . _ nature methods _ , 50 ( 11):0 9358 , 2008 .","johannes friedrich , daniel soudry , yu mu , jeremy freeman , misha ahrens , and liam paninski . .","in _ conference on neural information processing systems _ , 2015 .","kunal k ghosh , laurie d burns , eric d cocker , axel nimmerjahn , yaniv ziv , abbas el gamal , and mark j schnitzer .","_ nature methods _ , 80 ( 10):0 871878 , 2011 . ryuichi maruyama , kazuma maeda , hajime moroda , ichiro kato , masashi inoue , hiroyoshi miyakawa , and toru aonishi . .","_ neural networks _ ,","55:0 1119 , 2014 .","eran a. mukamel , axel nimmerjahn , and mark j. schnitzer . .","_ neuron _ , 630 ( 6):0 747760 , 2009 .","eftychios a pnevmatikakis , daniel soudry , yuanjun gao , timothy a machado , josh merel , david pfau , thomas reardon , yu mu , clay lacefield , weijian yang , misha ahrens , randy bruno , thomas m jessell , darcy s peterka , rafael yuste , and liam paninski . .","_ neuron _ , 890 ( 2):0 285299 , 2016 . shanna l resendez , josh h jennings , randall l ung , vijay mohan k namboodiri , zhe charles zhou , james m otis , hiroshi nomura , jenna a mchenry , oksana kosyk , and garret d stuber . .","_ nature protocols _ , 110 ( 3):0 566597 , 2016 .","spencer l smith and michael husser . .","_ nature neuroscience _ , 130 ( 9):0 11441149 , 2010 .","yaniv ziv and kunal k ghosh . .","_ current opinion in neurobiology _ , 32:0 141147 , 2015"],["since @xmath103 filtering the raw data with @xmath56 results @xmath104(\\mathbf{x})\\cdot c_i(t).\\end{aligned}\\ ] ] for each neuron , there is an area @xmath105(\\mathbf{x } ) > 0\\}$ ] .","usually @xmath106 corresponds to the central area for a neuron with gaussian shape . for @xmath107 , @xmath108(\\mathbf{x})\\cdot c_i(t ) +","\\sum_{j\\neq i}^k [ \\tilde{h}\\ast a_j](\\mathbf{x})\\cdot c_j(t ) .","\\label{eq : zxt}\\ ] ] if @xmath109(\\mathbf{x})=0 $ ] for all @xmath110 , i.e. , the @xmath111 th neuron is well isolated from the others , then @xmath112 this is a nice feature because we can estimate @xmath102 from @xmath64 directly .","empirically we found that this condition can be relaxed to @xmath109(\\mathbf{x})\\leq0 $ ] .","when @xmath109(\\mathbf{x})<0 $ ] , @xmath113 has negative spikes from neuron @xmath114 and we can remove them simply by thresholding @xmath64 with its median .","thus for each neuron @xmath111 , as long as there exist some @xmath107 and @xmath109(\\mathbf{x})\\leq0 $ ] for all @xmath110 ( small positive values are still tolerable ) , we can simply approximate its calcium concentration @xmath102 with @xmath64 .","a seed pixel @xmath7 should have two main features : first , @xmath113 has high peak - to - noise ratio ( pnr ) because it encodes the calcium concentration @xmath102 of one neuron and usually @xmath102 has large calcium transients ; second , seed pixel has high temporal correlations with its neighboring pixels because they are likely to share the same @xmath102 .","we computed two metrics for each of these two features : @xmath115 where @xmath116 ( we use @xmath117 ) determines the range of neighbors and @xmath118 is the total number of neighboring pixels .","@xmath119 calculates the temporal correlation between two time series @xmath120 and @xmath121 .","the function @xmath122 is a pre - processing of @xmath64 before computing local correlation . in our implementation , we threshold the differencing of @xmath113 by @xmath123 ( e.g. , @xmath124 .","this is equivalent to a rough detection of calcium transients . it is better than using @xmath64 directly because it reduces the influence of the background residual , noise and negative spikes from nearby neurons . to avoid unnecessary searches of the seed pixels , we usually set thresholds for both @xmath125 ( e.g. , 5 ) and @xmath126 ( e.g. , 0.5 ) . in each iteration of the initialization",", we find the pixel with the maximum value of @xmath127 and set it as a seed pixel . here","we use point - wise product of @xmath125 and @xmath126 to emphasize the characteristics of seed pixels .","if we successfully initialize one neuron from this seed pixel , the spatiotemporal activity of this initialized neuron @xmath128 will be peeled off from the residual data ( it is @xmath70 at the beginning of the initialization ) .","we also have to locally update @xmath125 and @xmath126 in the initialized area .","each neuron can only be visited once for initialization .","we will stop the initialization procedure until the specified number @xmath19 reaches or there are no more seed pixels .","define @xmath130 as nonzero pixels of @xmath84 and @xmath131 then @xmath132 again , the spatial smoothness of the background term @xmath133 induces @xmath134 . when the overlaps between neurons are not severe , @xmath135 , hence , we have @xmath136 the trends of all pixels are independent and we approximate all trends with b - spline basis @xmath137 , i.e. , @xmath138 , where the row vectors of @xmath137 are cubic b - spline basis given a sequences of knots . by increasing the intervals between knots ,","we lower the number of basis and constrain the dynamics of @xmath139 to be slow .","we usually choose evenly distributed knots over the whole time period with an interval of @xmath140 seconds .","this is much larger than dynamics of the calcium indicators ( @xmath141 seconds ) .","@xmath142 contains coefficients of each spline basis .","it is estimated with regression @xmath143\\cdot[xx^t]^{-1}$ ] . after we remove the @xmath38 , we move on to approximate the the fast fluctuations @xmath144 with low rank-@xmath118 matrix @xmath39 .","the truncated svd of @xmath145 has the globally minimum frobenious norm of the difference between @xmath145 and @xmath39 .","here we choose row vectors of @xmath91 be the top @xmath118 right singular vectors of @xmath145 and then @xmath146 .","however , the computed @xmath40 is not guaranteed to have low spatial frequency structure .","we post - process @xmath40 to enforce this constraint . here","we low - pass filter it with a median filter to get @xmath90 .","the size of the median filter is chosen larger than a neuron size .","then the background is estimated with @xmath147 empirically after the initialization of @xmath42 and approximating @xmath43 with model ( [ eq : bg ] ) , the results are very close to the optimal solutions .","but we can still make the parameter estimations better by iteratively updating model parameters .","there are several things we can do : ( 1 ) deconvolve the temporal components in @xmath46 to get denoised calcium traces , ( 2 ) delete false positive neurons , ( 3 ) pick neurons from the residual @xmath148 , and ( 4 ) merge neurons that were inappropriately split into several components .","all these operations can lead to better extraction of cellular signals .","each time when we update @xmath43 , we run the same procedure as section [ supp : bg ] again",". we can adaptively change the b - spline basis and rank of @xmath39 to get better approximation .","for example , when we see some trend in cellular signals , we can use spline basis with more knots to explain this trend in the background .","sometimes the background corrected data is still blurry because we do not remove the background cleanly . in this case , we can increase the rank to @xmath39 term in background to explain it . to update @xmath85 and @xmath86",", we keep the background @xmath43 unchanged , i.e. , we fit the model @xmath149 .","this can be done using the same approaches described in @xcite and we need to make changes by removing the background term ( see section [ sec : updateac ] )",". our method can also allow users verify the extracted cells visually and delete those low - quality neurons .","the spatiotemporal activity of these deleted neurons will be absorbed by the background @xmath43 or other neurons .","the signal qualities of nearby neurons might be improved . to add a neuron from the residual @xmath148 , we first select one pixel @xmath65 ( usually the one with the maximum residual ) and then run a rank-1 nmf in a small window centered at @xmath65 to get its spatial and temporal components . we can also manually or automatically select @xmath65 .","although these steps are simple , they showed great helps in speeding up the model fitting procedure . as a comparison ,","pca - ica method has no manual intervention steps .","removing false positive neurons could not improve signal extraction of other neurons .","after subtracting the background from the raw data , we can optimize @xmath45 and @xmath46 by fitting the model @xmath150 this is the same cnmf problem as proposed by @xcite .","the trivial difference is that eq .","( [ eq : new_cnmf ] ) has no background term .","we can use the same optimization procedure to estimate @xmath29 . here","we rewrite their approaches for this optimization approach .","briefly they iteratively update @xmath45 and @xmath46 by solving two optimization problems .","( 1 ) given the estimates of @xmath151 in previously iterations , @xmath152 can be updated by solving the following convex problem @xmath153 where @xmath154 is the standard deviation of the gaussian noise for each pixel @xmath111 . ( 2 ) once we update @xmath155 , we update @xmath156 column by column . to update the @xmath114th column",", we first form the quantity @xmath157[\\mathbf{c}_1^{(k)},\\cdots , \\mathbf{c}_{j-1}^{(k ) } , \\mathbf{c}_{j+1}^{(k-1)}\\cdots , \\mathbf{c}_k^{(k-1)}]^t\\big),\\ ] ] and then apply any deconvolution method of choice to @xmath158 to obtain @xmath159 .","we usually use the noise - constrained deconvolution method used in @xcite . removing the spatial sparsity constraint and the temporal dynamics can","significantly reduces the computation time and the results are close to the optimal solution . in this case ,","( [ eq : new_cnmf ] ) is a plain nmf problem with some locality constrains .","@xcite adapted the hierarchical alternating least squares ( hals ) method ( @xcite ) algorithm to solve it with fast speed .","in our implementations , we frequently use the hals algorithm to get convergent results before running the full cnmf approaches .","our method is very fast in analyzing data . in the example of the simulated data ( @xmath93 pixels , 3000 frames ) , our naive matlab implementation took @xmath160 minutes to initialize @xmath161 neurons out of @xmath92 on a single desktop . fitting the background model given","@xmath42 requires @xmath162 seconds .","the manual interventions of adding / deleting neurons only need few clicks and they can be processed in real time .","the results of our initialization step are very close the final solutions , so we only need @xmath163 cnmf iterations to update model parameters .","the performances of those algorithms used for solving cnmf have been reported in @xcite and @xcite .","our implementations can be easily optimized to be faster . in the initialization step ,","spatial filtering and calculation of the local correlation images are the only computation - intensive parts in the processing of huge data sets .","these computations themselves are very classical matrix operations and utilizing gpu can significantly make it faster . since the initialization of each neuron is only dependent on a very small window , the whole initialization step can be easily processed in parallel by segmenting the optical field into multiple small patches .","we can also use distributed computing to process the data patch by patch .","fitting the background model requires two steps : ( 1 ) the first step is approximating the baseline and slow trends .","since all pixels are independent , we can easily run it in parallel without effort ; ( 2 ) the second step is basically svd and there are plenties of existing algorithms or packages to deal with this problem for extremely large datasets . in summary , all the algorithm proposed in this paper has no scalability issues and can be easily scaled for processing any large - scale datasets ."]],"string":"[\n [\n \"monitoring the activity of large - scale neuronal ensembles during complex behavioral states is fundamental to neuroscience research\",\n \". continued advances in optical imaging technology are greatly expanding the number and depth of neuronal populations that can be visualized .\",\n \"specifically , in vivo calcium imaging through microendoscopic lenses and the development of miniaturized microscopes have enabled deep brain imaging of previously inaccessible neuronal populations of freely moving mice ( @xcite ) . while these techniques have been widely used by neuroscientists ,\",\n \"automatic methods for extracting cellular signals from this data are currently limited and suboptimal .\",\n \"the desired method should be able to ( 1 ) identify spatial footprints of all neurons , ( 2 ) denoise , demix and deconvolve the temporal signals ( @xcite ) .\",\n \"figure [ fig : example]a is an example frame from microendoscopic data , where the weak neuronal signals are submerged in the large background ( the raw video data can we watched here ) . for illustrative purposes , we draw two rois in the optical field and compute their mean fluorescence intensities ( figure [ fig : example]c , d ) .\",\n \"the red roi overlaps with one neuron and the green roi only has the background ( figure [ fig : example]b ) .\",\n \"thus the fluorescence in the red roi ( figure [ fig : example]c ) is a superposition of the background and the neuron s temporal activity , whereas the green ( figure [ fig : example]d ) provides an estimation of the background signal . by subtracting these two traces\",\n \", we are able to roughly estimate the temporal activity of the neuron within the red roi ( figure [ fig : example]e ) . from this example\",\n \", we can see that the background is an order of magnitude larger than the neural activity and its fluctuations are as fast as neuronal calcium transients .\",\n \"these features make it difficult to detect and demix cellular signals automatically from the raw video .\",\n \"our work is based on a matrix factorization approach , which can simultaneously segment cells and estimate changes in fluorescence in the temporal domain .\",\n \"this approach stems from the observation that spatiotemporal calcium activity can be approximated as product of two matrices : a spatial matrix that encodes the location of each neuron and a temporal matrix that characterizes the calcium concentration evolution for each neuron .\",\n \"it has several variations with different constraints , such as independent component analysis ( pca - ica , @xcite ) , nonnegative matrix factorization ( nmf , @xcite ) , sparse space - time deconvolution ( sstd , @xcite ) and constrained nonnegative matrix factorization ( cnmf , @xcite ) . in particular , pca - ica seeks spatiotemporal components that have reduced dependence .\",\n \"it is an inherently linear demixing method and can fail in the case when the neural components exhibit significant spatial overlaps ( @xcite ) .\",\n \"nonlinear methods like nmf , sstd and cnmf can deal with overlapping neural sources more effectively , and often outperform pca - ica .\",\n \"the main applications of these nonlinear methods are 2-photon or light - sheet imaging data , where the background is weak and has simple spatiotemporally separable structure .\",\n \"they usually model the background with a rank-1 nonnegative matrix .\",\n \"however , applying these nonlinear matrix factorization methods to the microendoscopic data faces two problems : ( 1 ) the background term is not well modeled by rank-1 nmf and its large residual could contaminate the extracted neuronal signals ; ( 2 ) the procedures of initializing the model parameters , especially spatial and temporal components of neurons , in these models do not work well because the strong and noisy background mixes with the weak neural signals .\",\n \"since the optimization problem in these methods are non - convex , without good initialization , it may lead to low - quality results or require excessive time for convergent results . in this paper , we extend the cnmf framework ( @xcite ) to address strong fluctuations in background fluorescence , and make it applicable to microendoscopic data .\",\n \"like the proposed cnmf in @xcite , our extended cnmf for microendoscopic data ( cnmf - e ) also has the capability of identifying neurons with low signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) and simultaneously denoising , deconvolving and demixing large - scale microendoscopic data . to accomplish this : ( 1 ) we replace the rank-1 nmf approximation of the background with a more sophisticated approximation , which can better account the complex background and avoid absorbing cellular signals , and ( 2 ) we develop an efficient initialization procedure to extract neural activities with minimal influence from the background .\",\n \"the structure of the paper is as follows . in section [ sec : cnmf ]\",\n \"we briefly review the cnmf model and describe our modifications to the model . in section [ sec : fit_model ]\",\n \", we develop our specialized model fitting procedure . in section [ sec : result ] we validate our new proposed cnmf - e on simulated and experimental data , and we also compare it with the widely used pca - ica method ( @xcite ) . * notation * a matrix @xmath0 represents the spatiotemporal activity of @xmath1 pixels in @xmath2 frames .\",\n \"the column vector @xmath3 is the observation of the whole frame in time - step @xmath4 .\",\n \"we use @xmath5 to refer the spatial location of one pixel , thus @xmath6 is the fluorescence intensity in @xmath4-th frame at location @xmath7 . for a column vector @xmath8 encoding the spatial information of @xmath1 pixels , @xmath9 indicates the value of @xmath10 at pixel @xmath7 .\"\n ],\n [\n \"the video data we have are observations from the optical field for a total number of @xmath2 frames .\",\n \"the recorded data can be represented by a matrix @xmath11 , where @xmath1 is the number of pixels in the field .\",\n \"each neuron is characterized by its spatial ` footprint ' vector @xmath12 and ` calcium activity ' @xmath13 . here\",\n \"both @xmath14 and @xmath15 are forced to be nonnegative because of their physical interpretations .\",\n \"given @xmath16 of one neuron , its spatiotemporal activity is represented as @xmath17 .\",\n \"the background activity is represented by a matrix @xmath18 .\",\n \"suppose the field contains a total number of @xmath19 neurons , then the observation is a superposition of all neurons spatiotemporal activity , time - varying background and additive noise : @xmath20 where @xmath21 , c=[\\\\mathbf{c}_1 , \\\\cdots , \\\\mathbf{c}_k]^t$ ] .\",\n \"the noise term @xmath22 is assumed to be gaussian and @xmath23 .\",\n \"@xmath24 is a diagonal matrix indicating that the noise is spatially and temporally uncorrelated .\",\n \"@xcite also explicitly model the calcium dynamics @xmath15 with a stable autoregressive process ( ar ) of order @xmath25 , @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the number of spikes that neuron fired at the @xmath4-th frame and it is sparse in the neural systems .\",\n \"the ar coefficients @xmath28 are different for each neuron and they are estimated from the data . estimating the model parameters @xmath29 in model ( [ eq : y])([eq : arp ] ) can give us all neurons spatial footprints and their deconvolved temporal activities . to fit the model , we also have to constrain the background term to have simplified structure , otherwise letting @xmath30 leads to the least reconstruction error .\",\n \"this framework is general and we use it in our new method as well .\",\n \"compared with the proposed implementation in @xcite , our method models the background term differently . in the work of @xcite , they model the background with a rank-1 nonnegative matrix @xmath31 , where @xmath32 and @xmath33 encode the background spatial and temporal structure respectively\",\n \"this is a good assumption for two - photon or light - sheet imaging data , but the background in microendoscopic data requires a more complex model .\",\n \"we also have to avoid the increased complexity from absorbing cellular signals into the background .\",\n \"thus the ideal model should explicitly model the background features that are distinct from neurons of interest . here\",\n \"we include two main features of the background into the model of @xmath34 : ( 1 ) the temporal component of each pixel has a constant large baseline and some slow trends ( see figure [ fig : example]d ) and ( 2 ) background is usually spatially smooth in a larger spatial range compared with neuron size ( figure [ fig : example ] ) , which means the background of all pixels within a neuron does not have large spatial gradients .\",\n \"this is because the fluctuations in the background reflects the out - of - focus fluorescence and they are significantly blurred .\",\n \"hence we model the background term as @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 .\",\n \"@xmath38 explains the constant baselines and slow trends for all pixels ( figure [ fig : example]c ) and their temporal dynamics are much slower than calcium indicators .\",\n \"the second term @xmath39 models the fast fluctuation in the background and the spatial component @xmath40 has low spatial - frequency structure .\",\n \"the constraint of @xmath40 excludes cellular signals from the background term .\"\n ],\n [\n \"in this section , we will describe our customized algorithm for fitting the model ( [ eq : y])([eq : arp])([eq : bg ] ) .\",\n \"we frequently use the pixel - wise formulation of model ( [ eq : y ] ) and ignore the noise term : @xmath41 our framework can be summarized into the following steps : 1 .\",\n \"initialize @xmath42 using the new initialization procedure .\",\n \"2 . approximate the background @xmath43 using model ( [ eq : bg ] ) .\",\n \"update @xmath42 from data @xmath44 using constrained alternating matrix factorization .\",\n \"4 . post - process the results automatically or manually : delete neurons , pick the missed neurons from the residuals , and merge neurons with high temporal correlations .\",\n \"repeat steps 2 , 3 , 4 until the results are biologically meaningful .\",\n \"our techniques differ from @xcite in the following aspects : ( 1 ) the initialization step for @xmath45 and @xmath46 here requires careful considerations of the background contaminations and our approach is totally new .\",\n \"( 2 ) instead of updating the background term iteratively , we update the background independently in different iterations and the rank of the background model can be modified in each iteration . as a result , our algorithm has a better control of the residual levels in background . in the followings , we mainly describe our novel initialization step and briefly summarize the procedure of fitting the background term . as for steps ( 3 - 5 ) and discussions for scalability issue , we put them in the supplementary materials ( section [ supp : iterative_manual ] and [ supp : speed ] ) . , the initialized temporal activity of one neuron .\",\n \"d@xmath47 , raw data of the cropped small window ( green square in a and b ) .\",\n \"e@xmath47 , the estimated time - varying local backgrounds in the small cropped window .\",\n \"c@xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the re - ordered version of c@xmath47 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 .\",\n \"c@xmath53 is the temporal differencing of c@xmath48 and the result has been thresholded with its @xmath54 standard deviation .\",\n \"similarly , d@xmath53 is differencing result of d@xmath48 .\",\n \"f , the initialized spatial and temporal components of the neuron.,width=529 ] here we develop a robust procedure for initializing @xmath45 and @xmath46 without estimation of the background .\",\n \"this procedure utilizes the spatial smoothness feature in the background and removes it by spatial high - pass filtering of the raw data .\",\n \"we estimate the temporal component of one neuron @xmath15 from spatially filtered data and then use it to extract the corresponding spatial footprint @xmath14 from the raw data . in the step of estimating @xmath14 , we re - order all frames to make nearby frames share the similar local background levels and then take the temporal differencing to remove the background signals temporally .\",\n \"after that , we can use regression to get @xmath14 . repeating\",\n \"this process can initialize the required number of neurons .\",\n \"the whole procedure is schematically illustrated in figure [ fig : initialization ] and described in algorithm [ alg : init ] in the supplementary materials .\",\n \"the spatial smoothness assumption of the background leads to @xmath55 i.e. , within the spatial range of a cell body , the background is spatially invariant .\",\n \"based on this assumption , we use @xmath56 to filter the raw data @xmath6 , and @xmath56 is defined as @xmath57 where @xmath58 .\",\n \"@xmath59 is a gaussian kernel with width @xmath60 and @xmath61 is the the average size of the neurons .\",\n \"@xmath56 is a template matching filter to detect spatial structures with similar shapes and sizes . for flat structures in the small regions , like background , filtering them with @xmath56\",\n \"get results close to 0 .\",\n \"thus in the filtered data @xmath62 , the background @xmath63 has been roughly removed and @xmath64 is mainly composed of cellular signals ( figure [ fig : initialization]b ) .\",\n \"more interestingly , the calcium concentrations of most neurons can be directly approximated by the temporal traces of some pixels in @xmath64 .\",\n \"( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath47 , see section [ supp : filter ] in supplementary materials for derivation ) .\",\n \"we call these pixels seed pixels because we can use them to initialize neurons .\",\n \"we initialize neurons with a greedy algorithm . in each iteration , we find one seed pixel @xmath65 ( see supplementary materials section [ sec : seed ] for details of how to detect seed pixels ) and initialize its spatial footprint @xmath66 and temporal course @xmath67\",\n \". then we subtract @xmath68 from the raw video data , find the next seed pixel and repeat the initialization procedure until specified number of neurons have been initialized or no more seed pixels exist . given a seed pixel @xmath65 , we can initialize the neuron s temporal component as @xmath69 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath47 ) .\",\n \"this approximation is usually good , and here we propose an efficient method to extract its spatial component @xmath14 from the raw data @xmath70 .\",\n \"we first crop the optical field with a square centered at @xmath65 and the square size is twice larger than the average neuron size @xmath61 ( figure [ fig : initialization]d@xmath47 ) .\",\n \"since cell bodies have localized structure , the spatial shape of the expected neuron is completely covered by this square .\",\n \"then we approximate the local background level in this cropped area @xmath71 using the median of the fluorescence intensities on the square boundary ( figure [ fig : initialization]e@xmath47 ) . by sorting all frames in an order of @xmath72 such that @xmath73 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath48d@xmath48e@xmath48 ) , nearby frames have the minimal differences ( @xmath74 ) in the background term .\",\n \"hence the differencing of the sorted video data is @xmath75 we already have @xmath76 , so we can initialize @xmath14 by regressing @xmath77 on @xmath78 ( figure [ fig : initialization]c@xmath53d@xmath53 ) . empirically we found that thresholding @xmath79 achieves better results .\",\n \"after we get @xmath80 ( figure [ fig : initialization]f ) , we can reestimate @xmath81 using a simple formula : @xmath82 where @xmath83 is a vector replacing all nonzero pixels of @xmath84 with the mean of those nonzero pixels . by running this initialization procedure iteratively\",\n \", we can extract almost all neurons . after we get @xmath85 and @xmath86\",\n \", @xmath87 is mainly the background component and we will approximate it with a matrix described in eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : bg ] ) .\",\n \"first we use a spline basis with low temporal dynamics to approximate the first term @xmath88 ( baseline + slow trend ) , then we factorize the residual @xmath89 with @xmath39 . by constraining @xmath40 with high spatial smoothness , we can avoid cellular signals being absorbed into the background .\",\n \"we use singular value decomposition ( svd ) together with low - pass filtering of the estimated spatial components to estimate @xmath90 and @xmath91 .\",\n \"( see supplementary materials [ supp : bg ] for details ) .\"\n ],\n [\n \"pca - ica ( @xcite ) is the most widely used automatic methods for analyzing microendoscopic data ( @xcite ) .\",\n \"it seeks spatially and temporally independent components as individual neurons . in this section\",\n \"we compared our cnmf - e with pca - ica method using simulated and experimental data .\",\n \"we simulated @xmath92 neurons activity in the optical field ( @xmath93 pixels ) for @xmath94 frames ( @xmath95 hz ) . to ensure that the background had similar features as real data\",\n \", we utilized the background extracted from our experimental data as the background in our simulation .\",\n \"we also add i.i.d .\",\n \"gaussian noise to our model ( the simulated video data can be found here ) .\",\n \"after removing all false positives , pca - ica detected @xmath96 neurons and our cnmf - e method found @xmath97 neurons of the @xmath92 neurons .\",\n \"most neurons detected by pca - ica did not have localized structures and multiple neurons were combined together ( see supplementary figure [ fig : supp_ac ] ) .\",\n \"we superimposed the contours of all extracted neurons together on top of the locations of simulated neurons .\",\n \"pca - ica - based segmentation failed to identify a large proportion of the neurons in this dataset , whereas nearly every neuron was identified by the cnmf - e approach ( figure [ fig : sim]cd ) .\",\n \"we matched each simulated neuron with a neuron among all the extracted neurons by selecting the one most correlated with the simulated neuron temporally .\",\n \"for a pair of matched neuron , they should have both high temporal and spatial correlations in the perfect case , i.e. , the real cellular signal is extracted from the data with high fidelity .\",\n \"we displayed spatial and temporal correlations of all simulated neurons with their matched neurons detected by two approaches ( figure [ fig : sim]bd ) . a total number of @xmath97 simulated neurons were accurately recovered by our cnmf - e method ( figure [ fig : sim]d ) . while for pca - ica , a large proportion of the matched neurons have low spatial and temporal correlations ( figure [ fig : sim ] ) indicating failures in recovering real neurons signals .\",\n \"we also display @xmath98 tightly clustered neurons in the simulated data ( figure [ fig : sim]e ) to demonstrate that our cnmf - e approach can accurately detect and demix their activity ( figure [ fig : sim]g ) .\",\n \"the spatiotemporal similarity between the 4 neurons segmented with cnmf - e ( figure 3 g ) and ground truth ( figure 3e ) indicates a good performance in extracting the neural activity .\",\n \"in contrast , pca - ica based detection can only detect two neurons and the calcium traces have high level of noise .\",\n \"the reason is that pca - ica merges multiple neurons together spatially and distorts the calcium traces in the temporal domain .\",\n \"furthermore , the distorted calcium traces reduces the number of detected neurons .\",\n \"the data used here was collected from the prefrontal cortex ( pfc ) of a freely moving mouse .\",\n \"the frame rate is 15 hz . the raw image ( figure [ fig : data_example]a ) is blurry and it is difficult to visually detect any neurons .\",\n \"its local correlation image ( @xcite ) of the raw data is approximately uniform @xmath99 ( figure [ fig : data_example]c ) , which means neighboring pixels share strong background fluctuations .\",\n \"here we removed the background by spatially filtering the raw data with @xmath56 and then calculated local correlation image using eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : pnr_corr ] ) in supplementary materials .\",\n \"figure [ fig : data_example]d clearly shows the locations of all neurons .\",\n \"appying our proposed cnmf - e method is able to detect @xmath100 neurons from the raw data .\",\n \"their contours are depicted on top the the correlation image and we can see that our method efficiently identifies neurons in the optical field ( figure [ fig : data_example]d ) .\",\n \"after subtracting the extracted background from the raw data , neural activity is visualized more effectively ( figure [ fig : data_example]b ) .\",\n \"the quality of this background correction on the raw data is important for extracting neural signals and demixing neurons . in the supplementary video ( )\",\n \", we showed the raw video , extracted background video , background corrected video and reconstructed cellular activity @xmath101 . from the video , we can see that cnmf - e reliably extracted the weak cellular signals from the rapidly fluctuating background .\",\n \"we choose three neighboring neurons within a small field to show the performance of our method . in figure\",\n \"[ fig : data_example]e , we showed their rois and the local correlation image .\",\n \"the mean fluorescence traces within each roi are too noisy to infer any calcium events .\",\n \"both pca - ica and cnmf - e isolated these three neurons and extracted the spiking signals , but the traces extracted with the pca - ica have higher levels of noise .\",\n \"further , note that traces extracted with pca - ica have large artifactual negative peaks .\",\n \"cnmf - e does not have this problem due to the nonnegative requirements . in the shaded region of figure [ fig : data_example]f ,\",\n \"we demonstrate potential crosstalk between two neurons , that is avoided by cnmf - e but not pca - ica based segmentation ( watch video here .\",\n \"the temporal traces in the video are extracted from cnmf - e ) . detected neurons and the correlation image calculated using our cnmf - e method ( see eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : pnr_corr ] ) in supplementary materials ) .\",\n \"e , mean fluorescence traces from three rois .\",\n \"f , extracted spatial / temporal components of three neurons using pca - ica method .\",\n \"g , results using our cnmf - e method .\",\n \", width=529 ]\"\n ],\n [\n \"in this paper , we proposed an efficient method for extracting cellular signals from microendoscopic data ; such methods are in very high demand in the neuroscience community .\",\n \"the analysis of this video data is the first stage of processing in many experiments , so the quality of source extraction in this step highly influences the scientific conclusions drawn in downstream analysis . as shown in figure [ fig : sim ] and [ fig : data_example ] ,\",\n \"our method shows credible performances in recovering the real neuronal signals and outperforms the previous standard pca - ica method .\",\n \"thus the methods introduced here ( which we plan to release as open source software ) will be a powerful and important tool for the neuroscience community .\",\n \"funding for this research was provided by nih 2r01mh064537 ( p.z .\",\n \", r.k . ) , nih r90da023426 ( p.z . ) , national institute of child health nichd and human development hd079124 ( g.s . ) , nichd grant t32 hd040127 ( s.r . ) , simons research foundation ( g.s . ) , simons foundation global brain research awards 325171 , 365002 , aro muri w911nf-12 - 1 - 0594 , darpa n66001 - 15-c-4032 ( simplex ) , and a google faculty research award ( l.p . ) ; in addition , this work was supported by the intelligence advanced research projects activity ( iarpa ) via department of interior/ interior business center ( doi / ibc ) contract number d16pc00003 ( l.p . ) , d16pc00007 ( p.z . ) . the u.s .\",\n \"government is authorized to reproduce and distribute reprints for governmental purposes notwithstanding any copyright annotation thereon .\",\n \"disclaimer : the views and conclusions contained herein are those of the authors and should not be interpreted as necessarily representing the official policies or endorsements , either expressed or implied , of iarpa , doi / ibc , or the u.s .\",\n \"government .\",\n \"11 [ 1]#1 [ 1]`#1 ` urlstyle [ 1]doi : # 1 ferran diego andilla and fred a. hamprecht . .\",\n \"_ advances in neural information processing systems _ , pages 6472 , 2014 .\",\n \"andrzej cichocki , rafal zdunek , and shun - ichi amari . .\",\n \"_ independent component analysis and signal separation _ ,\",\n \"46660 ( 1):0 169176 , 2007 . benjamin a flusberg , axel nimmerjahn , eric d cocker , eran a mukamel , robert p j barretto , tony h ko , laurie d burns , juergen c jung , and mark j schnitzer . _ nature methods _ , 50 ( 11):0 9358 , 2008 .\",\n \"johannes friedrich , daniel soudry , yu mu , jeremy freeman , misha ahrens , and liam paninski . .\",\n \"in _ conference on neural information processing systems _ , 2015 .\",\n \"kunal k ghosh , laurie d burns , eric d cocker , axel nimmerjahn , yaniv ziv , abbas el gamal , and mark j schnitzer .\",\n \"_ nature methods _ , 80 ( 10):0 871878 , 2011 . ryuichi maruyama , kazuma maeda , hajime moroda , ichiro kato , masashi inoue , hiroyoshi miyakawa , and toru aonishi . .\",\n \"_ neural networks _ ,\",\n \"55:0 1119 , 2014 .\",\n \"eran a. mukamel , axel nimmerjahn , and mark j. schnitzer . .\",\n \"_ neuron _ , 630 ( 6):0 747760 , 2009 .\",\n \"eftychios a pnevmatikakis , daniel soudry , yuanjun gao , timothy a machado , josh merel , david pfau , thomas reardon , yu mu , clay lacefield , weijian yang , misha ahrens , randy bruno , thomas m jessell , darcy s peterka , rafael yuste , and liam paninski . .\",\n \"_ neuron _ , 890 ( 2):0 285299 , 2016 . shanna l resendez , josh h jennings , randall l ung , vijay mohan k namboodiri , zhe charles zhou , james m otis , hiroshi nomura , jenna a mchenry , oksana kosyk , and garret d stuber . .\",\n \"_ nature protocols _ , 110 ( 3):0 566597 , 2016 .\",\n \"spencer l smith and michael husser . .\",\n \"_ nature neuroscience _ , 130 ( 9):0 11441149 , 2010 .\",\n \"yaniv ziv and kunal k ghosh . .\",\n \"_ current opinion in neurobiology _ , 32:0 141147 , 2015\"\n ],\n [\n \"since @xmath103 filtering the raw data with @xmath56 results @xmath104(\\\\mathbf{x})\\\\cdot c_i(t).\\\\end{aligned}\\\\ ] ] for each neuron , there is an area @xmath105(\\\\mathbf{x } ) > 0\\\\}$ ] .\",\n \"usually @xmath106 corresponds to the central area for a neuron with gaussian shape . for @xmath107 , @xmath108(\\\\mathbf{x})\\\\cdot c_i(t ) +\",\n \"\\\\sum_{j\\\\neq i}^k [ \\\\tilde{h}\\\\ast a_j](\\\\mathbf{x})\\\\cdot c_j(t ) .\",\n \"\\\\label{eq : zxt}\\\\ ] ] if @xmath109(\\\\mathbf{x})=0 $ ] for all @xmath110 , i.e. , the @xmath111 th neuron is well isolated from the others , then @xmath112 this is a nice feature because we can estimate @xmath102 from @xmath64 directly .\",\n \"empirically we found that this condition can be relaxed to @xmath109(\\\\mathbf{x})\\\\leq0 $ ] .\",\n \"when @xmath109(\\\\mathbf{x})<0 $ ] , @xmath113 has negative spikes from neuron @xmath114 and we can remove them simply by thresholding @xmath64 with its median .\",\n \"thus for each neuron @xmath111 , as long as there exist some @xmath107 and @xmath109(\\\\mathbf{x})\\\\leq0 $ ] for all @xmath110 ( small positive values are still tolerable ) , we can simply approximate its calcium concentration @xmath102 with @xmath64 .\",\n \"a seed pixel @xmath7 should have two main features : first , @xmath113 has high peak - to - noise ratio ( pnr ) because it encodes the calcium concentration @xmath102 of one neuron and usually @xmath102 has large calcium transients ; second , seed pixel has high temporal correlations with its neighboring pixels because they are likely to share the same @xmath102 .\",\n \"we computed two metrics for each of these two features : @xmath115 where @xmath116 ( we use @xmath117 ) determines the range of neighbors and @xmath118 is the total number of neighboring pixels .\",\n \"@xmath119 calculates the temporal correlation between two time series @xmath120 and @xmath121 .\",\n \"the function @xmath122 is a pre - processing of @xmath64 before computing local correlation . in our implementation , we threshold the differencing of @xmath113 by @xmath123 ( e.g. , @xmath124 .\",\n \"this is equivalent to a rough detection of calcium transients . it is better than using @xmath64 directly because it reduces the influence of the background residual , noise and negative spikes from nearby neurons . to avoid unnecessary searches of the seed pixels , we usually set thresholds for both @xmath125 ( e.g. , 5 ) and @xmath126 ( e.g. , 0.5 ) . in each iteration of the initialization\",\n \", we find the pixel with the maximum value of @xmath127 and set it as a seed pixel . here\",\n \"we use point - wise product of @xmath125 and @xmath126 to emphasize the characteristics of seed pixels .\",\n \"if we successfully initialize one neuron from this seed pixel , the spatiotemporal activity of this initialized neuron @xmath128 will be peeled off from the residual data ( it is @xmath70 at the beginning of the initialization ) .\",\n \"we also have to locally update @xmath125 and @xmath126 in the initialized area .\",\n \"each neuron can only be visited once for initialization .\",\n \"we will stop the initialization procedure until the specified number @xmath19 reaches or there are no more seed pixels .\",\n \"define @xmath130 as nonzero pixels of @xmath84 and @xmath131 then @xmath132 again , the spatial smoothness of the background term @xmath133 induces @xmath134 . when the overlaps between neurons are not severe , @xmath135 , hence , we have @xmath136 the trends of all pixels are independent and we approximate all trends with b - spline basis @xmath137 , i.e. , @xmath138 , where the row vectors of @xmath137 are cubic b - spline basis given a sequences of knots . by increasing the intervals between knots ,\",\n \"we lower the number of basis and constrain the dynamics of @xmath139 to be slow .\",\n \"we usually choose evenly distributed knots over the whole time period with an interval of @xmath140 seconds .\",\n \"this is much larger than dynamics of the calcium indicators ( @xmath141 seconds ) .\",\n \"@xmath142 contains coefficients of each spline basis .\",\n \"it is estimated with regression @xmath143\\\\cdot[xx^t]^{-1}$ ] . after we remove the @xmath38 , we move on to approximate the the fast fluctuations @xmath144 with low rank-@xmath118 matrix @xmath39 .\",\n \"the truncated svd of @xmath145 has the globally minimum frobenious norm of the difference between @xmath145 and @xmath39 .\",\n \"here we choose row vectors of @xmath91 be the top @xmath118 right singular vectors of @xmath145 and then @xmath146 .\",\n \"however , the computed @xmath40 is not guaranteed to have low spatial frequency structure .\",\n \"we post - process @xmath40 to enforce this constraint . here\",\n \"we low - pass filter it with a median filter to get @xmath90 .\",\n \"the size of the median filter is chosen larger than a neuron size .\",\n \"then the background is estimated with @xmath147 empirically after the initialization of @xmath42 and approximating @xmath43 with model ( [ eq : bg ] ) , the results are very close to the optimal solutions .\",\n \"but we can still make the parameter estimations better by iteratively updating model parameters .\",\n \"there are several things we can do : ( 1 ) deconvolve the temporal components in @xmath46 to get denoised calcium traces , ( 2 ) delete false positive neurons , ( 3 ) pick neurons from the residual @xmath148 , and ( 4 ) merge neurons that were inappropriately split into several components .\",\n \"all these operations can lead to better extraction of cellular signals .\",\n \"each time when we update @xmath43 , we run the same procedure as section [ supp : bg ] again\",\n \". we can adaptively change the b - spline basis and rank of @xmath39 to get better approximation .\",\n \"for example , when we see some trend in cellular signals , we can use spline basis with more knots to explain this trend in the background .\",\n \"sometimes the background corrected data is still blurry because we do not remove the background cleanly . in this case , we can increase the rank to @xmath39 term in background to explain it . to update @xmath85 and @xmath86\",\n \", we keep the background @xmath43 unchanged , i.e. , we fit the model @xmath149 .\",\n \"this can be done using the same approaches described in @xcite and we need to make changes by removing the background term ( see section [ sec : updateac ] )\",\n \". our method can also allow users verify the extracted cells visually and delete those low - quality neurons .\",\n \"the spatiotemporal activity of these deleted neurons will be absorbed by the background @xmath43 or other neurons .\",\n \"the signal qualities of nearby neurons might be improved . to add a neuron from the residual @xmath148 , we first select one pixel @xmath65 ( usually the one with the maximum residual ) and then run a rank-1 nmf in a small window centered at @xmath65 to get its spatial and temporal components . we can also manually or automatically select @xmath65 .\",\n \"although these steps are simple , they showed great helps in speeding up the model fitting procedure . as a comparison ,\",\n \"pca - ica method has no manual intervention steps .\",\n \"removing false positive neurons could not improve signal extraction of other neurons .\",\n \"after subtracting the background from the raw data , we can optimize @xmath45 and @xmath46 by fitting the model @xmath150 this is the same cnmf problem as proposed by @xcite .\",\n \"the trivial difference is that eq .\",\n \"( [ eq : new_cnmf ] ) has no background term .\",\n \"we can use the same optimization procedure to estimate @xmath29 . here\",\n \"we rewrite their approaches for this optimization approach .\",\n \"briefly they iteratively update @xmath45 and @xmath46 by solving two optimization problems .\",\n \"( 1 ) given the estimates of @xmath151 in previously iterations , @xmath152 can be updated by solving the following convex problem @xmath153 where @xmath154 is the standard deviation of the gaussian noise for each pixel @xmath111 . ( 2 ) once we update @xmath155 , we update @xmath156 column by column . to update the @xmath114th column\",\n \", we first form the quantity @xmath157[\\\\mathbf{c}_1^{(k)},\\\\cdots , \\\\mathbf{c}_{j-1}^{(k ) } , \\\\mathbf{c}_{j+1}^{(k-1)}\\\\cdots , \\\\mathbf{c}_k^{(k-1)}]^t\\\\big),\\\\ ] ] and then apply any deconvolution method of choice to @xmath158 to obtain @xmath159 .\",\n \"we usually use the noise - constrained deconvolution method used in @xcite . removing the spatial sparsity constraint and the temporal dynamics can\",\n \"significantly reduces the computation time and the results are close to the optimal solution . in this case ,\",\n \"( [ eq : new_cnmf ] ) is a plain nmf problem with some locality constrains .\",\n \"@xcite adapted the hierarchical alternating least squares ( hals ) method ( @xcite ) algorithm to solve it with fast speed .\",\n \"in our implementations , we frequently use the hals algorithm to get convergent results before running the full cnmf approaches .\",\n \"our method is very fast in analyzing data . in the example of the simulated data ( @xmath93 pixels , 3000 frames ) , our naive matlab implementation took @xmath160 minutes to initialize @xmath161 neurons out of @xmath92 on a single desktop . fitting the background model given\",\n \"@xmath42 requires @xmath162 seconds .\",\n \"the manual interventions of adding / deleting neurons only need few clicks and they can be processed in real time .\",\n \"the results of our initialization step are very close the final solutions , so we only need @xmath163 cnmf iterations to update model parameters .\",\n \"the performances of those algorithms used for solving cnmf have been reported in @xcite and @xcite .\",\n \"our implementations can be easily optimized to be faster . in the initialization step ,\",\n \"spatial filtering and calculation of the local correlation images are the only computation - intensive parts in the processing of huge data sets .\",\n \"these computations themselves are very classical matrix operations and utilizing gpu can significantly make it faster . since the initialization of each neuron is only dependent on a very small window , the whole initialization step can be easily processed in parallel by segmenting the optical field into multiple small patches .\",\n \"we can also use distributed computing to process the data patch by patch .\",\n \"fitting the background model requires two steps : ( 1 ) the first step is approximating the baseline and slow trends .\",\n \"since all pixels are independent , we can easily run it in parallel without effort ; ( 2 ) the second step is basically svd and there are plenties of existing algorithms or packages to deal with this problem for extremely large datasets . in summary , all the algorithm proposed in this paper has no scalability issues and can be easily scaled for processing any large - scale datasets .\"\n ]\n]","isConversational":false}}}],"truncated":false,"partial":false},"paginationData":{"pageIndex":0,"numItemsPerPage":100,"numTotalItems":6440,"offset":0,"length":100}},"jwt":"eyJhbGciOiJFZERTQSJ9.eyJyZWFkIjp0cnVlLCJwZXJtaXNzaW9ucyI6eyJyZXBvLmNvbnRlbnQucmVhZCI6dHJ1ZX0sImlhdCI6MTc3NTM1MzE3Miwic3ViIjoiL2RhdGFzZXRzL3hOb3Blci9hcnhpdi1vcmlnLXRlc3QiLCJleHAiOjE3NzUzNTY3NzIsImlzcyI6Imh0dHBzOi8vaHVnZ2luZ2ZhY2UuY28ifQ.h5iiEYnbm6KPFkUMTxvBaJRL6adDcOrrvDntglw-nuofBHsBc65hcOJCgYbObiZyMOVdW_w_zOF7VtJrAO-dAg","displayUrls":true,"splitSizeSummaries":[{"config":"default","split":"test","numRows":6440,"numBytesParquet":216089821}]},"discussionsStats":{"closed":0,"open":1,"total":1},"fullWidth":true,"hasGatedAccess":true,"hasFullAccess":true,"isEmbedded":false,"savedQueries":{"community":[],"user":[]}}">
article_id stringlengths 9 15 | article_text listlengths 1 3.05k | abstract_text listlengths 1 25 | labels null | section_names listlengths 1 26 | sections listlengths 1 26 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1009.3123 | [
"for about 20 years the problem of properties of short - term changes of solar activity has been considered extensively .",
"many investigators studied the short - term periodicities of the various indices of solar activity .",
"several periodicities were detected , but the periodicities about 155 days and from... | [
"<S> the short - term periodicities of the daily sunspot area fluctuations from august 1923 to october 1933 are discussed . for these data </S>",
"<S> the correlative analysis indicates negative correlation for the periodicity of about @xmath0 days , but the power spectrum analysis indicates a statistically signi... | null | [
"introduction",
"methods of periodicity analysis",
"a method of the diagnosis of an echo-effect in the power spectrum",
"data analysis",
"the periodicity at about 155 days during the maximum activity period",
"conclusion",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"for about 20 years the problem of properties of short - term changes of solar activity has been considered extensively .",
"many investigators studied the short - term periodicities of the various indices of solar activity .",
"several periodicities were detected , but the periodicities about 155 day... |
1512.09139 | [
"it is believed that the direct detection of gravitational waves ( gws ) will bring the era of gravitational wave astronomy .",
"the interferometer detectors are now under operation and awaiting the first signal of gws @xcite .",
"it is also known that pulsar timing arrays ( ptas ) can be used as a detector fo... | [
"<S> we study the detectability of circular polarization in a stochastic gravitational wave background from various sources such as supermassive black hole binaries , cosmic strings , and inflation in the early universe with pulsar timing arrays . </S>",
"<S> we calculate generalized overlap reduction functions f... | null | [
"introduction",
"stokes parameters for plane gravitational waves",
"formulation",
"generalized overlap reduction function for circular polarization",
"extraction of circularly polarized components",
"conclusion",
"generalized overlap reduction function for circular polarization: dipole cases",
"genera... | [
[
"it is believed that the direct detection of gravitational waves ( gws ) will bring the era of gravitational wave astronomy .",
"the interferometer detectors are now under operation and awaiting the first signal of gws @xcite .",
"it is also known that pulsar timing arrays ( ptas ) can be used as a d... |
0909.1602 | [
"as a common quantum phenomenon , the tunneling through a potential barrier plays a very important role in the microscopic world and has been studied extensively since the birth of quantum mechanics .",
"one of the earliest applications of quantum tunneling is the explanation of @xmath0 decays in atomic nuclei ."... | [
"<S> starting from the wkb approximation , a new barrier penetration formula is proposed for potential barriers containing a long - range coulomb interaction . </S>",
"<S> this formula is especially proper for the barrier penetration with penetration energy much lower than the coulomb barrier . </S>",
"<S> the ... | null | [
"[sec:intro]introduction",
"[sec:formalism]formalism",
"[sec:results]results and discussions",
"conclusion",
"derivation of the new penetration formula"
] | [
[
"as a common quantum phenomenon , the tunneling through a potential barrier plays a very important role in the microscopic world and has been studied extensively since the birth of quantum mechanics .",
"one of the earliest applications of quantum tunneling is the explanation of @xmath0 decays in atomic n... |
1512.03812 | [
"for the hybrid monte carlo algorithm ( hmc)@xcite , often used to study quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) on the lattice , one is interested in efficient numerical time integration schemes which are optimal in terms of computational costs per trajectory for a given acceptance rate . high order",
"numerical methods ... | [
"<S> we study a novel class of numerical integrators , the adapted nested force - gradient schemes , used within the molecular dynamics step of the hybrid monte carlo ( hmc ) algorithm . </S>",
"<S> we test these methods in the schwinger model on the lattice , a well known benchmark problem . </S>",
"<S> we der... | null | [
"introduction",
"geometric integrators for hmc",
"the schwinger model and its force gradient terms",
"numerical results",
"conclusions and outlook",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"for the hybrid monte carlo algorithm ( hmc)@xcite , often used to study quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) on the lattice , one is interested in efficient numerical time integration schemes which are optimal in terms of computational costs per trajectory for a given acceptance rate . high order",
"numerical ... |
1512.09024 | [
"recently it was discovered that feynman integrals obey functional equations @xcite , @xcite .",
"different examples of functional equations were presented in refs .",
"@xcite , @xcite,@xcite . in these articles",
"only one - loop integrals were considered . in the present paper",
"we propose essentially... | [
"<S> new methods for obtaining functional equations for feynman integrals are presented . </S>",
"<S> application of these methods for finding functional equations for various one- and two- loop integrals described in detail . </S>",
"<S> it is shown that with the aid of functional equations feynman integrals i... | null | [
"introduction",
"deriving functional equations from recurrence relations",
"deriving functional equations from algebraic relations + between propagators",
"some examples of functional equations",
"deriving functional equation by deforming propagators",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgment"
] | [
[
"recently it was discovered that feynman integrals obey functional equations @xcite , @xcite .",
"different examples of functional equations were presented in refs .",
"@xcite , @xcite,@xcite . in these articles",
"only one - loop integrals were considered . in the present paper",
"we propo... |
0807.5065 | [
"one of the main goals of the search for periodic isolated sources of gravitational waves ( g.w . ) is to perform all sky surveys , based on `` blind searches '' , where the source parameters are unknown . in this case",
"hierarchical procedures are applied , based on a sequence of increasing resolution steps . i... | [
"<S> in the hierarchical search for periodic sources of gravitational waves , the candidate selection , in the incoherent step , can be performed with hough transform procedures . in this paper </S>",
"<S> we analyze the problem of sensitivity loss due to discretization of the parameters space vs computing cost ,... | null | [
"introduction",
"scheme of the hierarchical procedure and hough transforms",
"the problem",
"the frequency hough",
"main characteristics: frequency resolution and sky grid",
"study the efficiency of the methods"
] | [
[
"one of the main goals of the search for periodic isolated sources of gravitational waves ( g.w . ) is to perform all sky surveys , based on `` blind searches '' , where the source parameters are unknown . in this case",
"hierarchical procedures are applied , based on a sequence of increasing resolution s... |
0908.1812 | [
"this review focuses specifically on what we have learned about the progenitors of core - collapse supernovae ( cc sne ) by examining images of the supernova ( sn ) sites taken prior to the explosion . by registering pre - sn and post - sn images , usually taken at high resolution using either space - based optica... | [
"<S> i summarize what we have learned about the nature of stars that ultimately explode as core - collapse supernovae from the examination of images taken prior to the explosion . by registering pre - supernova and post - supernova images , usually taken at high resolution using either space - based optical detecto... | null | [
"introduction",
"background: sn classification and stellar evolution",
"seeking sn progenitors in pre-explosion images: case studies",
"summary of results to date",
"future directions"
] | [
[
"this review focuses specifically on what we have learned about the progenitors of core - collapse supernovae ( cc sne ) by examining images of the supernova ( sn ) sites taken prior to the explosion . by registering pre - sn and post - sn images , usually taken at high resolution using either space - based ... |
hep-ph0701277 | [
"single - transverse spin asymmetries ( ssas ) play a fundamental role for our understanding of qcd in high - energy hadronic scattering .",
"they may be obtained for reactions in , for example , lepton - proton or proton - proton scattering with one transversely polarized initial proton , by dividing the differe... | [
"<S> we present a phenomenological study of the single - transverse spin asymmetry in azimuthal correlations of two jets produced nearly `` back - to - back '' in @xmath0 collisions at rhic . </S>",
"<S> we properly take into account the initial- and final - state interactions of partons that can generate this as... | null | [
"introduction",
"spin-dependent cross section and @xmath6-moment",
"phenomenological results for rhic",
"conclusions"
] | [
[
"single - transverse spin asymmetries ( ssas ) play a fundamental role for our understanding of qcd in high - energy hadronic scattering .",
"they may be obtained for reactions in , for example , lepton - proton or proton - proton scattering with one transversely polarized initial proton , by dividing the... |
1311.0649 | [
"kingman s coalescent is a random tree introduced by @xcite as the genealogy arising in large population genetic models .",
"it has infinitely many leaves and is usually constructed from leaves to the root as follows : given that there are @xmath7 lines in the tree , after some exponential time with rate @xmath8 ... | [
"<S> kingman s coalescent is a random tree that arises from classical population genetic models such as the moran model . </S>",
"<S> the individuals alive in these models correspond to the leaves in the tree and the following two laws of large numbers concerning the structure of the tree - top are well - known :... | null | [
"introduction",
"main results",
"proof of theorem[t1] and corollary[cor:tnt]",
"proof of lemma[l:wn], theorem[t2] and theorem[t3]"
] | [
[
"kingman s coalescent is a random tree introduced by @xcite as the genealogy arising in large population genetic models .",
"it has infinitely many leaves and is usually constructed from leaves to the root as follows : given that there are @xmath7 lines in the tree , after some exponential time with rate ... |
nlin0001046 | [
"rapid progress in the design and manufacture of optical fiber systems is a result of worldwide demand for ultra - high bit - rate optical communications .",
"this explains the growing interest of the soliton community in soliton - based optical fiber communication systems .",
"this area of research was conside... | [
"<S> we discuss several novel types of multi - component ( temporal and spatial ) envelope solitary waves that appear in fiber and waveguide nonlinear optics . </S>",
"<S> in particular , we describe multi - channel solitary waves in bit - parallel - wavelength fiber transmission systems for high performance comp... | null | [
"introduction",
"temporal and spatial solitons",
"bit-parallel-wavelength solitons",
"parametric optical solitons due to multistep cascading",
"envelope solitons in fibonacci superlattices",
"conclusion",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"rapid progress in the design and manufacture of optical fiber systems is a result of worldwide demand for ultra - high bit - rate optical communications .",
"this explains the growing interest of the soliton community in soliton - based optical fiber communication systems .",
"this area of research w... |
quant-ph0307206 | [
"entanglement @xcite in a composite system refers to certain implicit correlation between the subsystems arising from their interaction .",
"it is the key resource of quantum computation and quantum information processing @xcite .",
"due to recent advances in this field , entanglement has generated renewed inte... | [
"<S> strong subadditivity inequality for a three - particle composite system is an important inequality in quantum information theory which can be studied via a four - particle entangled state . </S>",
"<S> we use two three - level atoms in @xmath0 configuration interacting with a two - mode cavity and the raman ... | null | [
"[sec:intro]introduction",
"strong subadditivity inequality",
"[sec:basic]preparation of four-particle entangled state",
"study of strong subadditivity inequality",
"conclusions"
] | [
[
"entanglement @xcite in a composite system refers to certain implicit correlation between the subsystems arising from their interaction .",
"it is the key resource of quantum computation and quantum information processing @xcite .",
"due to recent advances in this field , entanglement has generated re... |
1412.2508 | [
"slowly pulsating b - type supergiants ( spbsg ) have emerged as a new class of pulsating variables after saio et al .",
"( 2006 ) have detected pulsational frequencies in the most satellite data of the blue supergiant hd 163899 ( b2 ib / ii , klare & neckel 1977 , schmidt & carruthers 1996 ) .",
"saio et al ."... | [
"<S> evolutionary tracks and pulsational analysis of models with masses of 13 - 18 @xmath0 are presented . </S>",
"<S> we address two important questions . the first one deals with one of the most unresolved problems in astrophysics , i.e. , the existence of a blue loop after core helium ignition ; the so called ... | null | [
"introduction",
"theoretical models",
"pulsation modes before and after core helium ignition",
"photometric amplitudes and phases of pulsations in early b-type supergiants",
"pulsations in hd 163899",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"slowly pulsating b - type supergiants ( spbsg ) have emerged as a new class of pulsating variables after saio et al .",
"( 2006 ) have detected pulsational frequencies in the most satellite data of the blue supergiant hd 163899 ( b2 ib / ii , klare & neckel 1977 , schmidt & carruthers 1996 ) .",
"sai... |
1512.07656 | [
"binary systems , whose behavior crucially depends on the underlying condition of immiscibility or miscibility @xcite , play a fundamentally important role in many areas of physics . in the case of immiscibility , a major effect is the formation of domain walls ( dws ) between regions occupied by immiscible compone... | [
"<S> we consider one - dimensional mixtures of an atomic bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) and tonks - giradeau ( tg ) gas . the mixture is modeled by a coupled system of the gross - pitaevskii equation for the bec and the quintic nonlinear schrdinger equation for the tg component . </S>",
"<S> an immiscibility ... | null | [
" introduction",
"the model",
"domain walls",
"bubble-drop (bd) states",
"dark-bright solitons (dbs)",
"conclusion",
"acknowledgements"
] | [
[
"binary systems , whose behavior crucially depends on the underlying condition of immiscibility or miscibility @xcite , play a fundamentally important role in many areas of physics . in the case of immiscibility , a major effect is the formation of domain walls ( dws ) between regions occupied by immiscible c... |
1004.5347 | [
"primordial black holes ( pbhs ) can form in the early universe via the collapse of large density perturbations @xcite .",
"there are tight constraints on the abundance of pbhs formed from their present day gravitational effects and the consequences of their evaporation .",
"these limits can be used to constra... | [
"<S> primordial black hole ( pbh ) abundance limits constrain the primordial power spectrum , and hence models of inflation , on scales far smaller than those probed by cosmological observations . </S>",
"<S> single field inflation models which are compatible with all cosmological data can have large enough pertu... | null | [
"introduction",
"method",
"results",
"conclusions"
] | [
[
"primordial black holes ( pbhs ) can form in the early universe via the collapse of large density perturbations @xcite .",
"there are tight constraints on the abundance of pbhs formed from their present day gravitational effects and the consequences of their evaporation .",
"these limits can be used ... |
1001.0199 | [
"the flight management infrastructure ( fmi ) product is intended to keep the aircraft from interfering with preplanned observations on the sky .",
"it predicts the ground tracks necessary to execute its mission , and corrects the plan for actual conditions while airborne . to support this ,",
"it contains both... | [
"<S> sofia is a 2.5 meter airborne infrared telescope , mounted in a boeing 747sp aircraft . due to the large size of the telescope , </S>",
"<S> only a few degrees of azimuth are available at the telescope bearing . </S>",
"<S> this means the heading of the aircraft is fundamentally associated with the telesco... | null | [
"introduction",
"external constraints",
"sofia fmi",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"the flight management infrastructure ( fmi ) product is intended to keep the aircraft from interfering with preplanned observations on the sky .",
"it predicts the ground tracks necessary to execute its mission , and corrects the plan for actual conditions while airborne . to support this ,",
"it con... |
hep-lat0105026 | [
"qcd at finite quark / baryon - number density at zero and at finite temperature describes nuclear matter",
". nuclear matter at high temperatures ( and possibly densities ) was certainly present in the early universe .",
"neutron stars consist of dense cold nuclear matter .",
"rhic and the cern heavy - ion p... | [
"<S> we have simulated two - colour four - flavour qcd at non - zero chemical potential @xmath0 for quark number . </S>",
"<S> simulations were performed on @xmath1 and @xmath2 lattices . </S>",
"<S> clear evidence was seen for the formation of a colourless diquark condensate which breaks quark number spontaneo... | null | [
"introduction",
"lattice 2-colour qcd",
"simulations of 2-colour, 4-flavour lattice qcd",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgements"
] | [
[
"qcd at finite quark / baryon - number density at zero and at finite temperature describes nuclear matter",
". nuclear matter at high temperatures ( and possibly densities ) was certainly present in the early universe .",
"neutron stars consist of dense cold nuclear matter .",
"rhic and the cern h... |
quant-ph0305125 | [
"the dipole - dipole interaction is ubiquitous in physics and for example responsible for the ever present van der waals force .",
"it is also important for envisaged quantum computers based on atoms or ions in traps .",
"considerable interest in the literature has also been aroused by its cooperative effects o... | [
"<S> the mutual dipole - dipole interaction of atoms in a trap can affect their fluorescence . </S>",
"<S> extremely large effects were reported for double jumps between different intensity periods in experiments with two and three ba@xmath0 ions for distances in the range of about ten wave lengths of the strong ... | null | [
"introduction",
"two dipole-interacting d systems",
"two dipole-interacting four-level systems as a model for two b@xmath0 ions",
"conclusions",
"quantum jump approach for two d systems"
] | [
[
"the dipole - dipole interaction is ubiquitous in physics and for example responsible for the ever present van der waals force .",
"it is also important for envisaged quantum computers based on atoms or ions in traps .",
"considerable interest in the literature has also been aroused by its cooperative... |
0809.0691 | [
"a cluster category is a certain 2-calabi - yau orbit category of the derived category of a hereditary abelian category .",
"cluster categories were introduced in @xcite in order to give a categorical model for the combinatorics of fomin - zelevinsky cluster algebras @xcite .",
"they are triangulated @xcite and... | [
"<S> we define mutation on coloured quivers associated to tilting objects in higher cluster categories . </S>",
"<S> we show that this operation is compatible with the mutation operation on the tilting objects . </S>",
"<S> this gives a combinatorial approach to tilting in higher cluster categories and especial... | null | [
"introduction",
"higher cluster categories",
"coloured quiver mutation",
"further background on higher cluster categories",
"symmetry",
"complements after mutation",
"proof of the main result",
"@xmath0-cluster-tilted algebras",
"combinatorial computation",
"the @xmath0-cluster complex",
"an alt... | [
[
"a cluster category is a certain 2-calabi - yau orbit category of the derived category of a hereditary abelian category .",
"cluster categories were introduced in @xcite in order to give a categorical model for the combinatorics of fomin - zelevinsky cluster algebras @xcite .",
"they are triangulated ... |
hep-ph9602267 | [
"this paper explores the phenomenology of the standard model s minimal supersymmetric @xcite extension with a continuous @xmath1 symmetry ( hereafter called the ` mr model')@xcite .",
"this model of low - energy supersymmetry has a much smaller - dimensional parameter space than the minimal supersymmetric model w... | [
"<S> we compute the one - loop corrections to the @xmath0 vertex in the @xmath1 symmetric minimal supersymmetric extension of the standard model . we find that the predicted value of @xmath2 is consistent with experiment if the mass of the lighter top squark is no more than 180 gev . </S>",
"<S> furthermore , oth... | null | [
"introduction",
"minimal @xmath1 symmetric supersymmetry",
"@xmath0 in the mr model",
"constraints from other extant data",
"future experimental input",
"conclusion",
"acknowledgments",
"appendix"
] | [
[
"this paper explores the phenomenology of the standard model s minimal supersymmetric @xcite extension with a continuous @xmath1 symmetry ( hereafter called the ` mr model')@xcite .",
"this model of low - energy supersymmetry has a much smaller - dimensional parameter space than the minimal supersymmetric... |
1307.2735 | [
"the classical method of adding two integers of @xmath1-bits takes @xmath2 bit operations but the classical method of multiplying them takes @xmath3 bit operations .",
"complexity of addition is optimal in number of bit operations , whereas optimal multiplication algorithm for integers is an open problem .",
"t... | [
"<S> multiplication is one of the most important operation in computer arithmetic . </S>",
"<S> many integer operations such as squaring , division and computing reciprocal require same order of time as multiplication whereas some other operations such as computing gcd and residue operation require at most a fact... | null | [
"introduction",
"background and motivation",
"applications",
"conclusions and future work"
] | [
[
"the classical method of adding two integers of @xmath1-bits takes @xmath2 bit operations but the classical method of multiplying them takes @xmath3 bit operations .",
"complexity of addition is optimal in number of bit operations , whereas optimal multiplication algorithm for integers is an open problem ... |
astro-ph0205340 | [
"it has been known for a long time that the classical two - integral equilibrium theory in axisymmetric geometry is not sufficient to adequately describe the stellar discs of galaxies . in accordance with jeans theorem ( jeans 1915 )",
", the phase space distribution function of a stellar system in a steady state... | [
"<S> we present new equilibrium component distribution functions that depend on three analytic integrals in a stckel potential , and that can be used to model stellar discs of galaxies . </S>",
"<S> these components are generalizations of two - integral ones and can thus provide thin discs in the two - integral a... | null | [
"introduction",
"two-integral fundamentals",
"construction of three-integral components",
"moments",
"physical properties of the components",
"modelling",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgements"
] | [
[
"it has been known for a long time that the classical two - integral equilibrium theory in axisymmetric geometry is not sufficient to adequately describe the stellar discs of galaxies . in accordance with jeans theorem ( jeans 1915 )",
", the phase space distribution function of a stellar system in a stea... |
1111.4135 | [
"the control and manipulation of single electrons in mesoscopic systems constitutes one of the key ingredients in nanoelectronics .",
"the study of single - electron sources@xcite in the high - frequency regime has attracted a great interest due to their potential application in quantum electron optics experiment... | [
"<S> we analyze the dynamics of a single - level quantum dot with coulomb interaction , weakly tunnel coupled to an electronic reservoir , after it has been brought out of equilibrium , e.g. by a step - pulse potential . </S>",
"<S> we investigate the exponential decay towards the equilibrium state , which is gov... | null | [
"introduction",
"model",
"results",
"conclusion",
"[app_vectors] appendix: normal case. eigenvalues and eigenvectors in first order in the tunnel coupling"
] | [
[
"the control and manipulation of single electrons in mesoscopic systems constitutes one of the key ingredients in nanoelectronics .",
"the study of single - electron sources@xcite in the high - frequency regime has attracted a great interest due to their potential application in quantum electron optics ex... |
1602.03055 | [
"during the last two decades , a number of new paradigms for understanding complex living systems have emerged .",
"these include , e.g. theory of dynamical systems , theory of complexity , nonlinear dynamics , evolutionary physics , and critical phenomena@xcite . among these , chaotic attractors , ( multi-)fract... | [
"<S> mesoscopic dynamics of self - organized structures is the most important aspect in the description of complex living systems . </S>",
"<S> the belousov zhabotinsky ( b z ) reaction is in this respect a convenient testbed because it represents a prototype of chemical self - organization with a rich variety ... | null | [
"introduction",
"results",
"discussion",
"experimental"
] | [
[
"during the last two decades , a number of new paradigms for understanding complex living systems have emerged .",
"these include , e.g. theory of dynamical systems , theory of complexity , nonlinear dynamics , evolutionary physics , and critical phenomena@xcite . among these , chaotic attractors , ( mult... |
hep-ex0307059 | [
"the cosmic ray energy spectrum is nearly featureless over ten orders of magnitude in energy , from @xmath0 ev to @xmath1 ev , with the differential flux falling approximately as @xmath2 .",
"there are three small , though widely discussed , features : the `` knee '' , a hardening of the spectrum at @xmath3 ev ; ... | [
"<S> the hires collaboration has recently announced preliminary measurements of the energy spectrum of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecr ) , as seen in monocular analyses from each of the two hires sites . </S>",
"<S> this spectrum is consistent with the existence of the gzk cutoff , as well other aspects o... | null | [
"introduction",
"experimental techniques",
"the hires detector",
"monocular analyses",
"monte carlo simulation",
"flux",
"conclusion",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"the cosmic ray energy spectrum is nearly featureless over ten orders of magnitude in energy , from @xmath0 ev to @xmath1 ev , with the differential flux falling approximately as @xmath2 .",
"there are three small , though widely discussed , features : the `` knee '' , a hardening of the spectrum at @xmat... |
0801.1913 | [
"geometrical dynamics is a dynamics of elementary particles , generated by the space - time geometry . in the space - time of minkowski",
"the geometrical dynamics coincides with the conventional classical dynamics , and the geometrical dynamics may be considered to be a generalization of classical dynamics onto ... | [
"<S> dynamics is considered as a corollary of the space - time geometry . </S>",
"<S> evolution of a particle in the space - time is described as a chain of connected equivalent geometrical objects . </S>",
"<S> space - time geometry is determined uniquely by the world function @xmath0 . </S>",
"<S> proper mo... | null | [
"introduction",
"representations of the proper euclidean geometry",
"dynamics as a result of the space-time geometry",
"dynamics of classical dirac particle",
"existence of such a space-time geometry, where a spatial evolution may look as world line of classical dirac particle",
"stabilization of the spac... | [
[
"geometrical dynamics is a dynamics of elementary particles , generated by the space - time geometry . in the space - time of minkowski",
"the geometrical dynamics coincides with the conventional classical dynamics , and the geometrical dynamics may be considered to be a generalization of classical dynami... |
astro-ph0011128 | [
"the first detection of an extrasolar planet around a normal star ( mayor & queloz 1995 ) and subsequent deluge of similar discoveries by the radial velocity technique ( marcy , cochran & mayor 2000 ) , have taught us that @xmath05% of solar type stars harbor planetary systems very _ unlike _ our own .",
"what re... | [
"<S> specially - designed microlensing searches , some of which have been underway for several years , are sensitive to extrasolar planets orbiting the most common stars in our galaxy . </S>",
"<S> microlensing is particularly well - suited to the detection of jupiter - mass planets orbiting their parent stars at... | null | [
"introduction",
"galactic planetary systems as multiple microlenses",
"have exoplanets been discovered with microlensing?",
"limits on the abundance of jovian planets in the galaxy",
"prospects for the future"
] | [
[
"the first detection of an extrasolar planet around a normal star ( mayor & queloz 1995 ) and subsequent deluge of similar discoveries by the radial velocity technique ( marcy , cochran & mayor 2000 ) , have taught us that @xmath05% of solar type stars harbor planetary systems very _ unlike _ our own .",
... |
0907.5423 | [
"the value of the circular orbital velocity at the sun s radius in the milky way is of considerable interest in galactic and extragalactic astrophysics .",
"it is necessary to correct observed velocities of stars and galaxies for the motion of the sun around the galactic center .",
"the circular velocity also p... | [
"<S> masers found in massive star - forming regions can be located precisely in six - dimensional phase space and therefore serve as a tool for studying milky way dynamics . </S>",
"<S> the non - random orbital phases at which the masers are found and the sparseness of current samples require modeling . here we m... | null | [
"introduction",
"data and methodology",
"results",
"discussion",
"mcmc exploration of the posterior distribution"
] | [
[
"the value of the circular orbital velocity at the sun s radius in the milky way is of considerable interest in galactic and extragalactic astrophysics .",
"it is necessary to correct observed velocities of stars and galaxies for the motion of the sun around the galactic center .",
"the circular veloc... |
1601.05253 | [
"as has been pointed out previously by harney @xcite , finite vector analyzing powers @xmath3 arise in reaction processes only , if at least two different partial waves interfere . hence in case of an isolated @xmath4-channel resonance , which is formed by a single partial wave matching to spin and parity of the re... | [
"<S> we report on a high - statistics measurement of the most basic double pionic fusion reaction @xmath0 over the energy region of the @xmath1 resonance by use of a polarized deuteron beam and observing the double fusion reaction in the quasifree scattering mode . </S>",
"<S> the measurements were performed with... | null | [
"introduction",
"exclusive measurements at wasa",
"results",
"summary",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"as has been pointed out previously by harney @xcite , finite vector analyzing powers @xmath3 arise in reaction processes only , if at least two different partial waves interfere . hence in case of an isolated @xmath4-channel resonance , which is formed by a single partial wave matching to spin and parity of ... |
astro-ph9605008 | [
"one of the most fundamental aspects of the stellar content of galaxies is the distribution by mass of newly formed stars , the initial mass function ( imf ) .",
"evidence supporting or restricting variations in the imf for very low mass stars is of profound importance for an understanding of the mass content of ... | [
"<S> using hst and the wfpc2 we have acquired very deep v- and i - band photometry of stars in ngc 2420 and ngc 2477 to study cluster luminosity functions at approximately solar metallicity . </S>",
"<S> we have determined these cluster luminosity functions down to @xmath0 = 10.5 ( 0.2 m@xmath1 ) and find that th... | null | [
"introduction",
"observations and data reduction",
"analysis",
"discussion",
"conclusions"
] | [
[
"one of the most fundamental aspects of the stellar content of galaxies is the distribution by mass of newly formed stars , the initial mass function ( imf ) .",
"evidence supporting or restricting variations in the imf for very low mass stars is of profound importance for an understanding of the mass con... |
1508.03070 | [
"the rationale for , capabilities of , and scientific context of the mid - infrared instrument ( miri ) on jwst are described in rieke et al .",
"( 2014 ; hereafter paper i ) and the overall optical , thermal , mechanical / structural electronic and control aspects of the design are summarized in wright et al .",... | [
"<S> we describe the design and performance of the medium resolution spectrometer ( mrs ) for the jwst - miri instrument . </S>",
"<S> the mrs incorporates four coaxial spectral channels in a compact opto - mechanical layout that generates spectral images over fields of view up to 7.7 x 7.7 arcseconds in extent a... | null | [
"introduction",
"optical design",
"measured performance",
"conclusion",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"the rationale for , capabilities of , and scientific context of the mid - infrared instrument ( miri ) on jwst are described in rieke et al .",
"( 2014 ; hereafter paper i ) and the overall optical , thermal , mechanical / structural electronic and control aspects of the design are summarized in wright e... |
1702.04864 | [
"linear wave functions in quantum chemistry are fundamentally limited by their inability to compactly express wave functions in strongly correlated regimes , a difficulty that arises directly from the factorial growth of hilbert space in the quantum many - body problem . in practice , therefore , the field of quant... | [
"<S> we demonstrate that 4-body real space jastrow factors are , with the right type of jastrow basis function , capable of performing successful wave function stenciling to remove unwanted ionic terms from an overabundant fermionic reference without unduly modifying the remaining components . </S>",
"<S> in addi... | null | [
"introduction",
"theory",
"results",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgements"
] | [
[
"linear wave functions in quantum chemistry are fundamentally limited by their inability to compactly express wave functions in strongly correlated regimes , a difficulty that arises directly from the factorial growth of hilbert space in the quantum many - body problem . in practice , therefore , the field of... |
hep-ph9702208 | [
"the direct and precise measurement of the self - coupling between the electroweak gauge bosons in @xmath2-pair production will be a crucial step in testing the standard model of electroweak interactions and searching for physics beyond it .",
"it will form an important part of the physics programme at lep2 and a... | [
"<S> we show how one can measure anomalous @xmath0- and @xmath1-couplings with minimal statistical error using integrated observables , without having to assume that the anomalous couplings are small . </S>",
"<S> we propose a parametrisation of these couplings which is well suited for the extraction of both sing... | null | [
"introduction",
"optimal observables: analysis beyond leading order",
"diagonalisation in the couplings",
"numerical examples",
"simultaneous diagonalisation in practice",
"summary",
"acknowledgements",
"appendix: uniqueness of optimal observables"
] | [
[
"the direct and precise measurement of the self - coupling between the electroweak gauge bosons in @xmath2-pair production will be a crucial step in testing the standard model of electroweak interactions and searching for physics beyond it .",
"it will form an important part of the physics programme at le... |
hep-ph0205344 | [
"the standard model is greatly successful but it still has many free parameters which must be small to describe nature . while its supersymmetric extensions , e.g. , the minimal supersymmetric standard model , are attractive scenarios , small couplings are also required to explain observed facts such as the fermio... | [
"<S> we present four - dimensional gauge theories that describe physics on five - dimensional curved ( warped ) backgrounds , which includes bulk fields with various spins ( vectors , spinors , and scalars ) . </S>",
"<S> field theory on the ads@xmath0 geometry is examined as a simple example of our formulation .... | null | [
"introduction",
"4d formulation for curved geometries",
"numerical evaluation",
"toward dynamical realization",
"conclusion",
"appendix. bulk fields in ads@xmath0"
] | [
[
"the standard model is greatly successful but it still has many free parameters which must be small to describe nature . while its supersymmetric extensions , e.g. , the minimal supersymmetric standard model , are attractive scenarios , small couplings are also required to explain observed facts such as the ... |
astro-ph0612210 | [
"the study of the formation and evolution of galaxies is one of the most important issues of present - day astronomy .",
"the currently favoured models suggest that large galaxies such as the milky way formed through the hierarchical accretion of a number of smaller objects . one possible way to test this scen... | [
"<S> recent observations show that the number of stars with very low metallicities in the dwarf spheroidal satellites of the milky way is low , despite the low average metallicities of stars in these systems . </S>",
"<S> we undertake numerical simulations of star formation and metal enrichment of dwarf galaxies ... | null | [
"introduction",
"the simulations",
"results",
"discussion and conclusions"
] | [
[
"the study of the formation and evolution of galaxies is one of the most important issues of present - day astronomy .",
"the currently favoured models suggest that large galaxies such as the milky way formed through the hierarchical accretion of a number of smaller objects . one possible way to test t... |
1401.4918 | [
"the dynamical density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) @xcite and the closely related correction vector dmrg @xcite have been widely used in the last decade to compute the dynamical correlation functions and spectral functions of low - dimensional strongly correlated quantum systems .",
"@xcite although... | [
"<S> we present a numerical method for calculating piecewise smooth spectral functions of correlated quantum systems in the thermodynamic limit from the spectra of finite systems computed using the dynamical or correction - vector density - matrix renormalization group method . </S>",
"<S> the key idea is to cons... | null | [
"introduction",
"model and observable",
"deconvolution",
"dos of one-dimensional mott insulators",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"the dynamical density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) @xcite and the closely related correction vector dmrg @xcite have been widely used in the last decade to compute the dynamical correlation functions and spectral functions of low - dimensional strongly correlated quantum systems .",
"@xcite ... |
1212.0086 | [
"non - hermitian hamiltonians are often employed to describe the open systems due to their features of complex - valued energy and non - preserved particle probability .",
"recent observations show that a large families of non - hermitian hamiltonians can have all eigenvalues real , if the loss and gain are set i... | [
"<S> complex potential and non - hermitian hopping amplitude are building blocks of a non - hermitian quantum network . </S>",
"<S> appropriate configuration , such as @xmath0-symmetric distribution , can lead to a full real spectrum . to investigate the underlying mechanism of this phenomenon , we study the phas... | null | [
"introduction",
"semi-infinite system",
"connection between the semi-infinite systems and @xmath3 symmetric systems",
"wavepacket dynamics",
"summary"
] | [
[
"non - hermitian hamiltonians are often employed to describe the open systems due to their features of complex - valued energy and non - preserved particle probability .",
"recent observations show that a large families of non - hermitian hamiltonians can have all eigenvalues real , if the loss and gain a... |
cond-mat0512060 | [
"there has been considerable recent interest on the general dynamics of the glass transitions in bulk polymer systems@xcite .",
"a central experimental law which controls the rate of transition was long ago formulated by vogel , fulcher and tammann@xcite ; the empirical vft law of transition rates reads @xmath0 \... | [
"<S> a derivation is given for the vogel - fulcher - tammann thermal activation law for the glassy state of a bulk polymer . </S>",
"<S> our microscopic considerations involve the entropy of closed polymer molecular chains ( i.e. polymer closed strings ) . for thin film polymer glasses , </S>",
"<S> one obtains... | null | [
"introduction",
"entropy of closed mobile chains[closed]",
"surface effects",
"conclusion[conc]"
] | [
[
"there has been considerable recent interest on the general dynamics of the glass transitions in bulk polymer systems@xcite .",
"a central experimental law which controls the rate of transition was long ago formulated by vogel , fulcher and tammann@xcite ; the empirical vft law of transition rates reads @... |
quant-ph0302142 | [
"the principal limit in high precision measurements and optics communication is given by the quantum fluctuations of light . for several years , in order to beat the standard quantum limit , a number of methods consisting in generating squeezed states of light have been developed @xcite . in connection with quantum... | [
"<S> we present a theoretical study of an ensemble of x - like 4-level atoms placed in an optical cavity driven by a linearly polarized field . </S>",
"<S> we show that the self - rotation ( sr ) process leads to polarization switching ( ps ) . below the ps threshold , both the mean field mode and the orthogonal ... | null | [
"introduction",
"the model",
"steady-state",
"mean field fluctuations",
"vacuum fluctuations",
"polarization squeezing",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"the principal limit in high precision measurements and optics communication is given by the quantum fluctuations of light . for several years , in order to beat the standard quantum limit , a number of methods consisting in generating squeezed states of light have been developed @xcite . in connection with q... |
0911.1170 | [
"the tensor model was originally considered in @xcite to generalize the matrix model , which describes the two - dimensional simplicial quantum gravity , to higher dimensional cases .",
"while the matrix model is a successful tool to analyze the two - dimensional simplicial gravity , the tensor model has not been... | [
"<S> this paper gives a summary of the author s works concerning the emergent general relativity in a particular class of tensor models , which possess gaussian classical solutions . </S>",
"<S> in general , a classical solution in a tensor model may be physically regarded as a background space , and small fluctu... | null | [
"introduction",
"tensor models",
"gaussian backgrounds",
"correspondence between general relativity and tensor models around gaussian backgrounds",
"geometric fluctuations on flat tori",
"numerical analysis of small fluctuations around gaussian backgrounds in tensor models",
"brst gauge fixing of tensor... | [
[
"the tensor model was originally considered in @xcite to generalize the matrix model , which describes the two - dimensional simplicial quantum gravity , to higher dimensional cases .",
"while the matrix model is a successful tool to analyze the two - dimensional simplicial gravity , the tensor model has ... |
astro-ph0301640 | [
"the mystery of the dark energy / cosmological constant persists despite great efforts of particle physicists and cosmologists to find a convincing solution . since the famous article by s. weinberg",
", it is well known that candidate models should not only explain the smallness of the cosmological constant , if... | [
"<S> it is a known fact that a quintessence model with @xmath0 fits the publicly available super nova ( sn ) type ia data better than a model with cosmological constant or @xmath1 . </S>",
"<S> two types of models have this property : scalar fields with unconventional kinetic term and models with cosmological con... | null | [
"motivations and model",
"discussion and perspectives"
] | [
[
"the mystery of the dark energy / cosmological constant persists despite great efforts of particle physicists and cosmologists to find a convincing solution . since the famous article by s. weinberg",
", it is well known that candidate models should not only explain the smallness of the cosmological const... |
1309.3865 | [
"since the mid 1970 s the existence of heavy hadronic molecules ( composed by a pair of heavy hadrons instead of a pair of heavy quarks ) has been theorized@xcite .",
"this assumption was made based on the similarities between the heavy meson - heavy antimeson system and the deuteron .",
"however , it was not u... | [
"<S> in this work , we have used an effective field theory ( eft ) framework based on heavy quark spin ( hqss ) , heavy flavour ( hfs ) and heavy antiquark - diquark symmetries ( hads ) . using a standard lagrangian for the heavy meson - heavy antimeson system , we fit the counter - terms of the model to predict so... | null | [
"introduction",
"effective field theory for heavy mesonic molecules and lippmann-schwinger equation.",
"heavy antiquark-diquark symmetry and results.",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"since the mid 1970 s the existence of heavy hadronic molecules ( composed by a pair of heavy hadrons instead of a pair of heavy quarks ) has been theorized@xcite .",
"this assumption was made based on the similarities between the heavy meson - heavy antimeson system and the deuteron .",
"however , it... |
1503.03375 | [
"we are poised on the threshold of unprecedented technical growth in wide - field time domain astronomy , where ground - based observations yield very precise measurements of stellar brightness from high - volume data streams .",
"so far , wide - field time - series surveys has been spearheaded by relatively smal... | [
"<S> we introduce new methods for robust high - precision photometry from well - sampled images of a non - crowded field with a strongly varying point - spread function . for this work , we used archival imaging data of the open cluster m37 taken by mmt 6.5 m telescope . </S>",
"<S> we find that the archival ligh... | null | [
"introduction",
"archival mmt time-series data of m37",
"new photometric reduction",
"temporal trends in the re-calibrated lightcurves",
"impact of the new calibration of period search",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"we are poised on the threshold of unprecedented technical growth in wide - field time domain astronomy , where ground - based observations yield very precise measurements of stellar brightness from high - volume data streams .",
"so far , wide - field time - series surveys has been spearheaded by relativ... |
0811.2070 | [
"factorization of numbers into their prime factors is a hard non - polynomial problem for classical computers .",
"it was shor @xcite who proposed a quantum algorithm which can solve the problem of factorization of numbers on a quantum computer with a tremendous speedup as compared to a classical computer .",
"... | [
"<S> truncated fourier , gauss , kummer and exponential sums can be used to factorize numbers : for a factor these sums equal unity in absolute value , whereas they nearly vanish for any other number . </S>",
"<S> we show how this factorization algorithm can emerge from superpositions of classical light waves and... | null | [
"introduction[introduction]",
"truncated fourier, gauss, kummer and exponential sums",
"factorization using differences in time delay (interferometry)",
"factorization using differences in frequencies (beats)",
"factorization using faraday effect",
"conclusions"
] | [
[
"factorization of numbers into their prime factors is a hard non - polynomial problem for classical computers .",
"it was shor @xcite who proposed a quantum algorithm which can solve the problem of factorization of numbers on a quantum computer with a tremendous speedup as compared to a classical computer... |
0806.3537 | [
"suppose we are trying to learn a difficult classification problem : for example determining whether the given image contains a human face , or whether the mri image shows a malignant tumor , etc .",
"we may first try to train a simple model such as a small neural network .",
"if that fails , we may move on to ... | [
"<S> statistical learning theory chiefly studies restricted hypothesis classes , particularly those with finite vapnik - chervonenkis ( vc ) dimension . </S>",
"<S> the fundamental quantity of interest is the sample complexity : the number of samples required to learn to a specified level of accuracy . </S>",
"... | null | [
"introduction",
"relation to previous work",
"definitions",
"results",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"suppose we are trying to learn a difficult classification problem : for example determining whether the given image contains a human face , or whether the mri image shows a malignant tumor , etc .",
"we may first try to train a simple model such as a small neural network .",
"if that fails , we may m... |
1202.0294 | [
"it is well known that in standard model ( sm ) the higgs quartic coupling has a landau pole for a sufficiently heavy higgs mass .",
"the position of the pole is a function of the higgs boson mass . for light enough mass of the higgs boson , either landau pole is higher than the plank scale or it disappears , and... | [
"<S> electroweak corrections to longitudinal gauge and higgs boson scattering amplitudes are calculated . due to sudakov </S>",
"<S> double logarithms , the effect is a suppression of amplitude that grows rapidly with increasing center of mass energy leading to significant reduction of cross sections compared to ... | null | [
"introduction",
"theoretical framework",
"longitudinal bosons scattering at high energies",
"applications for unitarity analysis",
"conclusions"
] | [
[
"it is well known that in standard model ( sm ) the higgs quartic coupling has a landau pole for a sufficiently heavy higgs mass .",
"the position of the pole is a function of the higgs boson mass . for light enough mass of the higgs boson , either landau pole is higher than the plank scale or it disappea... |
1503.00807 | [
"the gaseous component of protoplanetary disks is crucial for understanding the planet formation process because it affects the structures and evolution of the disk via chemical reactions .",
"theoretical studies have predicted that protoplanetary disks have multiple layers in their vertical direction due to stel... | [
"<S> we performed single point [ c i ] @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0p@xmath2 and co @xmath3=43 observations toward three t tauri stars , dm tau , lkca 15 , and tw hya , using the atacama large millimeter / submillimeter array ( alma ) band 8 qualification model receiver installed on the atacama submillimeter telescope ex... | null | [
"introduction",
"observations",
"results",
"discussion"
] | [
[
"the gaseous component of protoplanetary disks is crucial for understanding the planet formation process because it affects the structures and evolution of the disk via chemical reactions .",
"theoretical studies have predicted that protoplanetary disks have multiple layers in their vertical direction due... |
physics0501017 | [
"in nature , there exists a variety of systems that involve chemical reactions .",
"some are on a geographical - scale , while others on a nano - scale .",
"chemical reactions are an integral part of life , including all living forms of life . to study the dynamics of reaction systems , we often adopt rate e... | [
"<S> to study the dynamics of chemical processes , we often adopt rate equations to observe the change in chemical concentrations . </S>",
"<S> however , when the number of the molecules is small , the fluctuations can not be neglected . </S>",
"<S> we often study the effects of fluctuations with the help of st... | null | [
"introduction: discrete reaction systems",
"discreteness-induced transitions",
"alteration of concentrations by the dit",
"discussion",
"appendix: methods for simulating discrete reaction systems"
] | [
[
"in nature , there exists a variety of systems that involve chemical reactions .",
"some are on a geographical - scale , while others on a nano - scale .",
"chemical reactions are an integral part of life , including all living forms of life . to study the dynamics of reaction systems , we often ad... |
1601.01316 | [
"white dwarfs are the end points of all low- to intermediate - mass stars , which are the majority of stars in the universe .",
"they are dense stellar remnants composed of electron degenerate cores surrounded by non - degenerate envelopes .",
"these evolved stars provide key insight into galactic star formatio... | [
"<S> we report the discovery of 42 white dwarfs in the original _ kepler _ mission field , including nine new confirmed pulsating hydrogen - atmosphere white dwarfs ( zzceti stars ) . </S>",
"<S> guided by the _ kepler_-int survey ( kis ) , we selected white dwarf candidates on the basis of their @xmath0 , @xmath... | null | [
"introduction",
"target selection",
"spectroscopy",
"conclusion",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"white dwarfs are the end points of all low- to intermediate - mass stars , which are the majority of stars in the universe .",
"they are dense stellar remnants composed of electron degenerate cores surrounded by non - degenerate envelopes .",
"these evolved stars provide key insight into galactic sta... |
0807.1354 | [
"speculations concerning the existence and frequency of brown dwarfs can be traced to before the introduction of the term @xcite . since then , wide - field surveys have uncovered hundreds of candidates in the field and revealed two new spectral types , the l and t dwarfs @xcite . yet the frequency of brown dwarfs ... | [
"<S> we present a combined analysis of the low - mass initial mass function ( imf ) for seven star - forming regions . </S>",
"<S> we first demonstrate that the ratios of stars to brown dwarfs are consistent with a single underlying imf . by assuming that the underlying imf is the same for all seven clusters and ... | null | [
"introduction",
"the approach",
"the results",
"discussion"
] | [
[
"speculations concerning the existence and frequency of brown dwarfs can be traced to before the introduction of the term @xcite . since then , wide - field surveys have uncovered hundreds of candidates in the field and revealed two new spectral types , the l and t dwarfs @xcite . yet the frequency of brown d... |
1506.01252 | [
"the study of spin dependent transport in low - dimensional systems has been largely dominated in the last few decades due to the rapid advancement in nano - scale science and technology @xcite .",
"controlling electron s spin degree of freedom is extremely important for the development of quantum information pr... | [
"<S> the robust effect of curvature on spin polarization is reported in a three - terminal bridge system where the bridging material is subjected to rashba spin - orbit interaction . </S>",
"<S> the results are examined considering two different geometric configurations , ring- and linear - like , of the material... | null | [
"introduction",
"model and theoretical framework",
"numerical results and discussion",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"the study of spin dependent transport in low - dimensional systems has been largely dominated in the last few decades due to the rapid advancement in nano - scale science and technology @xcite .",
"controlling electron s spin degree of freedom is extremely important for the development of quantum inform... |
1109.0147 | [
"the increasing possibilities and sophisticated ways to control larger and larger quantum systems require a thorough understanding of the dynamics of open quantum systems @xcite . as prime example",
", the phenomenon of decoherence is an effect of the environmental impact on quantum behavior of the system , lead... | [
"<S> we investigate system - environment correlations based on the exact dynamics of a qubit and its environment in the framework of pure decoherence ( phase damping ) . </S>",
"<S> we focus on the relation of decoherence and the build - up of system - reservoir entanglement for an arbitrary ( possibly mixed ) in... | null | [
"introduction",
"open quantum system model for decoherence and reduced dynamics",
"the total state",
"system-environment separability and decoherence",
"system-environment entanglement and decoherence",
"quality of entanglement detection for a single mode ``environment''",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgem... | [
[
"the increasing possibilities and sophisticated ways to control larger and larger quantum systems require a thorough understanding of the dynamics of open quantum systems @xcite . as prime example",
", the phenomenon of decoherence is an effect of the environmental impact on quantum behavior of the syste... |
0710.0405 | [
"the lab for adaptive optics ( lao ) currently has a testbed dedicated to the development of two key ao technologies for large telescopes ( called multi - conjugate ao ( mcao)@xcite and multi - object ao ( moao ) ) . both of these technologies take advantage of tomographic reconstructions using multiple guidestars ... | [
"<S> advances in micro deformable mirror ( dm ) technologies such as mems , have stimulated interest in the characteristics of systems that include a high stroke mirror in series with a high actuator count mirror . </S>",
"<S> this arrangement is referred to as a woofer - tweeter system . in certain situations </... | null | [
"motivation",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"the lab for adaptive optics ( lao ) currently has a testbed dedicated to the development of two key ao technologies for large telescopes ( called multi - conjugate ao ( mcao)@xcite and multi - object ao ( moao ) ) . both of these technologies take advantage of tomographic reconstructions using multiple guide... |
1606.04270 | [
"gamma - ray bursts ( grb ) are cosmological explosions which produce an enormous amount of energy @xmath2erg within a few seconds to a few minutes by means of a highly relativistic jet .",
"a grb light curve generally consists of a single or multiple broad pulses and rapid variability within the pulses on a time... | [
"<S> gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) are cosmological explosions which carry valuable information from the distant past of the expanding universe . </S>",
"<S> one of the greatest discoveries in modern cosmology is the finding of the accelerated expansion of the universe using type ia supernovae ( sn ia ) as standard... | null | [
"introduction",
"pulse-wise grb correlation",
"radiation mechanism thermal component",
"discussion",
"acknowledgement"
] | [
[
"gamma - ray bursts ( grb ) are cosmological explosions which produce an enormous amount of energy @xmath2erg within a few seconds to a few minutes by means of a highly relativistic jet .",
"a grb light curve generally consists of a single or multiple broad pulses and rapid variability within the pulses o... |
astro-ph9610265 | [
"neutrons stars are born in gravitational collapse of massive , degenerate stellar cores .",
"newly born neutron stars are hot and lepton rich objects , quite different from ordinary low temperature , lepton poor neutron stars . in view of these differences ,",
"newly born neutron stars are called _ protoneutro... | [
"<S> rapid uniform rotation of newborn neutron stars ( protoneutron stars ) is studied for a range of internal temperatures and entropies per baryon predicted by the existing numerical simulations . </S>",
"<S> calculations are performed using general relativistic equations of hydrostatic equilibrium of rotating ... | null | [
"introduction",
"physical state of the interior of protoneutron stars",
"formulation of the problem",
"numerical method",
"numerical results. maximally rotating protoneutron stars",
"empirical formula for @xmath2",
"numerical results. from hot protoneutron stars to cold neutron stars",
"discussion and... | [
[
"neutrons stars are born in gravitational collapse of massive , degenerate stellar cores .",
"newly born neutron stars are hot and lepton rich objects , quite different from ordinary low temperature , lepton poor neutron stars . in view of these differences ,",
"newly born neutron stars are called _ p... |
1201.4525 | [
"derived within linear response theory , the fluctuation dissipation theorem ( fdt ) predicts how the response function of a thermodynamic observable is related to correlation of thermal fluctuations at equilibrium .",
"let us assume that an equilibrium system described by a hamiltonian @xmath0 is perturbed at ti... | [
"<S> starting from the pioneering work of g. s. agarwal [ _ zeitschrift fr physik _ * 252 * , 25 ( 1972 ) ] , we present a unified derivation of a number of modified fluctuation - dissipation relations ( mfdr ) that relate response to small perturbations around non - equilibrium steady states to steady - state corr... | null | [
"introduction",
"the agarwal form of mfdr",
"mfdr in terms of stochastic entropy",
"velocity mfdr using langevin equation",
"velocity mfdr using master equation",
"einstein relation",
"flashing ratchet model of molecular motors",
"summary"
] | [
[
"derived within linear response theory , the fluctuation dissipation theorem ( fdt ) predicts how the response function of a thermodynamic observable is related to correlation of thermal fluctuations at equilibrium .",
"let us assume that an equilibrium system described by a hamiltonian @xmath0 is perturb... |
1502.06718 | [
"given a discrete distribution @xmath0 on @xmath1 classes @xmath2 , we consider an index called _ polarization measure _ , defined by @xmath3 the polarization measure has been introduced in economics for real distributions by .",
"the discrete version we consider here has been used in .",
"the polarization m... | [
"<S> the polarization measure is the probability that among 3 individuals chosen at random from a finite population exactly 2 come from the same class . </S>",
"<S> this index is maximum at the midpoints of the edges of the probability simplex . </S>",
"<S> we compute the gradient flow of this index that is the... | null | [
"introduction",
"natural gradient",
"the gradient flow of @xmath9",
"generalisation of the polarization measure",
"@xmath9 as expectation along an exponential family",
"conclusion and suggested applications",
"from lotka-volterra to the replicator",
"information geometry of the replicator in dimension... | [
[
"given a discrete distribution @xmath0 on @xmath1 classes @xmath2 , we consider an index called _ polarization measure _ , defined by @xmath3 the polarization measure has been introduced in economics for real distributions by .",
"the discrete version we consider here has been used in .",
"the pola... |
math0703438 | [
"recently there has been a considerable interest in trying to obtain atomic decompositions of the space @xmath6 .",
"these decompositions are usually obtained in terms of frames generated by a family of functions translated on a regular grid , and dilated by powers of a dilation matrix .",
"the uniformity of th... | [
"<S> in this article , we develop a general method for constructing wavelets @xmath0 on irregular lattices of the form @xmath1 , and with an arbitrary countable family of invertible @xmath2 matrices @xmath3 that do not necessarily have a group structure . this wavelet construction is a particular case of general at... | null | [
"introduction",
"notation",
"wavelets on arbitrary irregular grids and with arbitrary dilation matrices and other transformations",
"examples of wavelet frames on irregular lattices and with arbitrary set of dilation matrices and other transformations",
"general results on the construction of time-frequency... | [
[
"recently there has been a considerable interest in trying to obtain atomic decompositions of the space @xmath6 .",
"these decompositions are usually obtained in terms of frames generated by a family of functions translated on a regular grid , and dilated by powers of a dilation matrix .",
"the unifor... |
1108.3334 | [
"our current hypothesis is that the galaxies and black holes observed today originated over 13 gyr ago , growing from seeds of primordial density perturbations .",
"one can test this hypothesis by studying the star formation rate ( sfr ) history , from the epoch of reionization ( eor ) at redshifts @xmath21 , thr... | [
"<S> we assess the probable redshift ( @xmath0 ) for full reionization of the intergalactic medium ( igm ) using a prescription for the co - moving star - formation - rate ( sfr ) density ( @xmath1 ) required to maintain photoionization against recombination . </S>",
"<S> our newly developed on - line reionizatio... | null | [
"introduction",
"reionization with clumping and photon escape",
"results from simulations",
"discussion and implications"
] | [
[
"our current hypothesis is that the galaxies and black holes observed today originated over 13 gyr ago , growing from seeds of primordial density perturbations .",
"one can test this hypothesis by studying the star formation rate ( sfr ) history , from the epoch of reionization ( eor ) at redshifts @xmath... |
1511.00831 | [
"analysis of large amounts of high - dimensional big data is of great interest since it illuminates the underlying phenomena . to cope with high - dimensional big data",
", it is sometimes assumed that there are some ( unobservable ) dependencies between the parameters of the multidimensional data points .",
"m... | [
"<S> dimensionality reduction methods are very common in the field of high dimensional data analysis </S>",
"<S> . typically , algorithms for dimensionality reduction are computationally expensive . </S>",
"<S> therefore , their applications for the analysis of massive amounts of data are impractical . </S>",
... | null | [
"introduction",
"problem setup",
"construction of the out-of-sample extension",
"geometric-based covariance matrix",
"bounding the error of the out-of-sample extension",
"out-of-sample extension complexity",
"experimental results",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"analysis of large amounts of high - dimensional big data is of great interest since it illuminates the underlying phenomena . to cope with high - dimensional big data",
", it is sometimes assumed that there are some ( unobservable ) dependencies between the parameters of the multidimensional data points ... |
hep-ph9810245 | [
"the concept of chiral symmetry breaking in strong interactions goes back to the pioneering work by nambu @xcite , and it has been widely explored and discussed since that time .",
"restoration of chiral symmetry at high densities was proposed by lee and wick @xcite already in 1974 .",
"theoretical procedures f... | [
"<S> the composite operator formalism is applied to qcd at finite temperature to calculate the masses of scalar and pseudoscalar mesons . in particular the ratio of the sigma mass to the pion mass </S>",
"<S> is an interesting measure of the degree of chiral symmetry breaking at different temperatures . </S>",
... | null | [
"introduction",
"effective action for qcd composite operators",
"hadronic masses at @xmath60 and determination of the parameters",
"the scalar-pseudoscalar @xmath102 mass ratio",
"conclusions"
] | [
[
"the concept of chiral symmetry breaking in strong interactions goes back to the pioneering work by nambu @xcite , and it has been widely explored and discussed since that time .",
"restoration of chiral symmetry at high densities was proposed by lee and wick @xcite already in 1974 .",
"theoretical pr... |
0709.4317 | [
"quantum dots , their current and noise properties @xcite are widely investigated topics in today s nanophysics with a number of possible applications , the most revolutionary being a spin - based quantum computer @xcite . here",
", the spin of an electron in a quantum dot is used as a qubit , which serves as the... | [
"<S> we investigate the current and noise characteristics of a double quantum dot system . </S>",
"<S> the strong correlations induced by the coulomb interaction and the pauli principle create entangled two - electron states and lead to signatures in the transport properties . </S>",
"<S> we show that the inter... | null | [
"introduction",
"model and theoretical methods",
"current and fano factor",
"counting statistics",
"conclusions"
] | [
[
"quantum dots , their current and noise properties @xcite are widely investigated topics in today s nanophysics with a number of possible applications , the most revolutionary being a spin - based quantum computer @xcite . here",
", the spin of an electron in a quantum dot is used as a qubit , which serve... |
0710.1429 | [
"the use of general principles to investigate systems whose microscopic makeup is unclear can be very rewarding .",
"sometimes this method gives information on a whole class of systems . among such principles , thermodynamics ,",
"believed to be of universal applicability , stands out .",
"an instructive exam... | [
"<S> we describe a new paradox for ideal fluids . </S>",
"<S> it arises in the accretion of an _ ideal _ fluid onto a black hole , where , under suitable boundary conditions , the flow can violate the generalized second law of thermodynamics . </S>",
"<S> the paradox indicates that there is in fact a lower boun... | null | [
"introduction",
"ideal fluid paradox",
"gsl as framework for elucidating the kss bound",
"summary and outlook",
"equilibrium of matter near a black hole and realizability of slow accretion flows"
] | [
[
"the use of general principles to investigate systems whose microscopic makeup is unclear can be very rewarding .",
"sometimes this method gives information on a whole class of systems . among such principles , thermodynamics ,",
"believed to be of universal applicability , stands out .",
"an inst... |
1007.5492 | [
"when infrared dark clouds ( irdcs ) were originally identified as dark extinction features against the galactic background at mid - ir wavelengths @xcite , it was not clear what role , if any , they might play in the process of star formation .",
"their high column densities ( @xmath4@xmath5 @xmath6 ) , together... | [
"<S> the nessie \" nebula is a filamentary infrared dark cloud ( irdc ) with a large aspect ratio of over 150:1 ( 1.5@xmath0@xmath1 0.01@xmath0 , or 80 pc @xmath1 0.5 pc at a kinematic distance of 3.1 kpc ) . maps of ( 10)emission , a tracer of dense molecular gas , made with the australia telescope national facil... | null | [
"introduction",
"observations",
"results",
"discussion",
"conclusions"
] | [
[
"when infrared dark clouds ( irdcs ) were originally identified as dark extinction features against the galactic background at mid - ir wavelengths @xcite , it was not clear what role , if any , they might play in the process of star formation .",
"their high column densities ( @xmath4@xmath5 @xmath6 ) , ... |
cond-mat0701026 | [
"soon after the first experimental realization of graphene , a single - layer hexagonal form of carbon , the integral quantum hall effect ( iqhe)@xcite was observed by novoselov _ et al .",
"_ and zhang _ _ et al.__@xcite at filling factors @xmath2 .",
"the @xmath3 period is understood straightforwardly as a c... | [
"<S> theoretical studies of the fractional quantum hall effect ( fqhe ) in graphene have so far focused on the plausibility and stability of the previously known fqhe states for the interaction matrix elements appropriate for graphene . </S>",
"<S> we consider fqhe for su(4 ) symmetry , as appropriate for the sit... | null | [
"introduction",
"model",
"composite fermion theory for su(4) electrons",
"exact diagonalization results",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"soon after the first experimental realization of graphene , a single - layer hexagonal form of carbon , the integral quantum hall effect ( iqhe)@xcite was observed by novoselov _ et al .",
"_ and zhang _ _ et al.__@xcite at filling factors @xmath2 .",
"the @xmath3 period is understood straightforwar... |
1603.07736 | [
"central to a complete picture of galaxy evolution is the distribution of the interstellar matter ( ism ) within each galaxy and how that ism forms stars . given that the ism mass on galactic scales is dominated by molecular and atomic gas , observing the tracers of these gas components is necessary for measuring t... | [
"<S> we observed the spiral galaxies m@xmath051 and m@xmath083 at 20@xmath1 spatial resolution with the bolometer array _ </S>",
"<S> aztec _ on the _ jcmt _ in the 1.1@xmath0 mm continuum , recovering the extended emission out to galactocentric radii of more than 12@xmath0kpc in both galaxies . </S>",
"<S> t... | null | [
"introduction",
"discussion",
"summary and conclusions",
"flux determination",
"determination of surface densities and masses",
"determination of the x-factor maps",
"considerations of the comparison between sfr and gas surface densities",
"considerations for creating star formation rate surface densi... | [
[
"central to a complete picture of galaxy evolution is the distribution of the interstellar matter ( ism ) within each galaxy and how that ism forms stars . given that the ism mass on galactic scales is dominated by molecular and atomic gas , observing the tracers of these gas components is necessary for measu... |
hep-th0702068 | [
"general relativity and ordinary differential geometry should be replaced by non - commutative geometry at some point between the currently accessible energies of about 1 - 10 tev ( after starting the large hadron collider ( lhc ) at cern ) and the planck scale , which is @xmath2 times higher , where space - time a... | [
"<S> the first renormalisable quantum field theories on non - commutative space have been found recently . </S>",
"<S> we review this rapidly growing subject . _ </S>",
"<S> @xmath0laboratoire de physique thorique , bt . 210 + universit paris xi , f-91405 orsay cedex , france + e - mail : ` rivass@th.u-psud... | null | [
"introduction",
"non-commutative field theory",
"multi-scale analysis in the matrix basis",
"direct space"
] | [
[
"general relativity and ordinary differential geometry should be replaced by non - commutative geometry at some point between the currently accessible energies of about 1 - 10 tev ( after starting the large hadron collider ( lhc ) at cern ) and the planck scale , which is @xmath2 times higher , where space - ... |
cond-mat0408655 | [
"the interior of cells is both highly structured and dynamical .",
"active transport therefore plays a crucial role to target molecules to the various compartments of the cell as well as to maintain and reorganize the cell s structure .",
"these tasks are accomplished by the cytoskeleton , a network of protein ... | [
"<S> movements of molecular motors on cytoskeletal filaments are described by directed walks on a line . </S>",
"<S> detachment from this line is allowed to occur with a small probability . </S>",
"<S> motion in the surrounding fluid is described by symmetric random walks . </S>",
"<S> effects of detachment a... | null | [
"introduction",
"lattice models",
"the motors random walks on a lattice",
"motor movements in confined geometries",
"summary"
] | [
[
"the interior of cells is both highly structured and dynamical .",
"active transport therefore plays a crucial role to target molecules to the various compartments of the cell as well as to maintain and reorganize the cell s structure .",
"these tasks are accomplished by the cytoskeleton , a network o... |
quant-ph0506141 | [
"this paper is based on a talk given at a conference in naples @xcite .",
"it is well known that if backward time travel could be implemented , or if the present could shape the past by some other means , then closed causal chains , or causal loops , could be formed .",
"the possibility of causal loops must ari... | [
"<S> the closed causal chains arising from backward time travel do not lead to paradoxes if they are self consistent . </S>",
"<S> this raises the question as to how physics ensures that only self - consistent loops are possible . </S>",
"<S> we show that , for one particular case at least , the condition of se... | null | [
"introduction",
"quantum mechanics",
"beam splitters",
"uncontrollable time machine",
"a closed cycle",
"interfering amplitudes",
"conclusion",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"this paper is based on a talk given at a conference in naples @xcite .",
"it is well known that if backward time travel could be implemented , or if the present could shape the past by some other means , then closed causal chains , or causal loops , could be formed .",
"the possibility of causal loop... |
cond-mat0309695 | [
"in mesoscopic systems , the measurement of current and noise makes it possible to probe the effective charges which flow in conductors , and opens the possibility for studying the role of the statistics in stationary quantum transport experiments .",
"this has been illustrated experimentally and theoretically in... | [
"<S> the effect of an ac perturbation on the shot noise of a fractional quantum hall fluid is studied both in the weak and the strong backscattering regimes . </S>",
"<S> it is known that the zero - frequency current is linear in the bias voltage , while the noise derivative exhibits steps as a function of bias .... | null | [
"introduction",
"model hamiltonian",
"weak backscattering limit",
"strong backscattering limit",
"exact solution at @xmath1",
"summary and conclusion",
"useful integrals",
"@xmath1 solution"
] | [
[
"in mesoscopic systems , the measurement of current and noise makes it possible to probe the effective charges which flow in conductors , and opens the possibility for studying the role of the statistics in stationary quantum transport experiments .",
"this has been illustrated experimentally and theoreti... |
astro-ph0205016 | [
"since davis & peebles ( 1983 ) first analyzed the anisotropy in the galaxy distribution from center for astrophysics ( cfa ) redshift catalog , it has been recognized that the peculiar velocity field of galaxies induces a significant systematic effect in statistics of observed galaxy distributions in redshift spac... | [
"<S> we derive the pairwise peculiar velocity distribution function of dark matter particles applying the dark matter halo approach . unlike the previous work </S>",
"<S> , we do not assume a gaussian velocity distribution function of dark matter in a single halo , but compute it self - consistently with the assu... | null | [
"introduction",
"a dark matter halo approach to compute the pairwise velocity distribution function",
"pairwise relative peculiar velocity dispersions",
"summary"
] | [
[
"since davis & peebles ( 1983 ) first analyzed the anisotropy in the galaxy distribution from center for astrophysics ( cfa ) redshift catalog , it has been recognized that the peculiar velocity field of galaxies induces a significant systematic effect in statistics of observed galaxy distributions in redshif... |
1702.04923 | [
"in the early days of general relativity there was a common belief that the universe had to be eternal and unchanging . following this concept ,",
"albert einstein introduced the first cosmological model , subsequently named after him .",
"it consisted of a compact spatial hypersurface with positive curvature ,... | [
"<S> we present a time - dependent solution of the maxwell equations in the einstein universe , whose electric and magnetic fields , as seen by the stationary observers , are aligned with the clifford parallels of the @xmath0-sphere @xmath1 . </S>",
"<S> the conformal equivalence between minkowski s spacetime and... | null | [
"introduction",
"electromagnetic field in the einstein universe",
"expanding models",
"matter content"
] | [
[
"in the early days of general relativity there was a common belief that the universe had to be eternal and unchanging . following this concept ,",
"albert einstein introduced the first cosmological model , subsequently named after him .",
"it consisted of a compact spatial hypersurface with positive c... |
1107.5998 | [
"shape memory alloys [ sma ] are materials having many applications and attracting a lot of interest due to their unique properties of shape memory and pseudoelasticity , which stem from both temperature - induced and stress - induced martensitic phase transition .",
"the mechanical behaviour of such materials is... | [
"<S> a ginzburg - landau model for the macroscopic behaviour of a shape memory alloy is proposed . </S>",
"<S> the model is one - dimensional in essence , in that we consider the effect of the martensitic phase transition in terms of a uniaxial deformation along a fixed direction and we use a scalar order paramet... | null | [
"introduction",
"model",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgements"
] | [
[
"shape memory alloys [ sma ] are materials having many applications and attracting a lot of interest due to their unique properties of shape memory and pseudoelasticity , which stem from both temperature - induced and stress - induced martensitic phase transition .",
"the mechanical behaviour of such mate... |
1503.06481 | [
"we study surfaces in space @xmath0 such that through each point of the surface one can draw two circles fully contained in the surface . hereafter by a _",
"circle _ we mean either an ordinary circle in @xmath0 or a straight line . in this paper",
"we reduce finding all such surfaces to the algebraic problem o... | [
"<S> we study analytic surfaces in 3-dimensional euclidean space containing two circular arcs through each point . </S>",
"<S> the problem of finding such surfaces traces back to the works of darboux from xixth century . </S>",
"<S> we reduce finding all such surfaces to the algebraic problem of finding all pyt... | null | [
"introduction",
"classification results",
"parametrization results",
"factorization results"
] | [
[
"we study surfaces in space @xmath0 such that through each point of the surface one can draw two circles fully contained in the surface . hereafter by a _",
"circle _ we mean either an ordinary circle in @xmath0 or a straight line . in this paper",
"we reduce finding all such surfaces to the algebraic... |
1105.1172 | [
"bigravity is a theory of gravity with two independent _ dynamical _ metrics ( denoted by @xmath0 and @xmath1 ) .",
"the action , first considered by isham - salam - strathdee @xcite , is @xmath2 & = & { 1 \\over 16\\pi g } \\int \\big[\\ \\sqrt{g } r(g ) + \\sigma\\ , \\sqrt{f } r(f)- u(g , f ) \\big]\\end{align... | [
"<S> we argue that the isham - storey exact solution to bigravity does not describe black holes because the horizon is a singular surface . however , this is not a generic property of bigravity , but a property of a particular potential . </S>",
"<S> more general potentials do accept regular black holes . </S>",
... | null | [
"the bigravity action",
"the isham-storey exact solution",
"a bigravity black hole",
"regularity conditions",
"total energy and black hole temperature",
"entropy and free energy",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"bigravity is a theory of gravity with two independent _ dynamical _ metrics ( denoted by @xmath0 and @xmath1 ) .",
"the action , first considered by isham - salam - strathdee @xcite , is @xmath2 & = & { 1 \\over 16\\pi g } \\int \\big[\\ \\sqrt{g } r(g ) + \\sigma\\ , \\sqrt{f } r(f)- u(g , f ) \\big]\\e... |
0906.3185 | [
"a new class of massive x - ray binaries has been recognized in the last few years , mainly thanks to observations carried out with the _ integral _ satellite .",
"they are transient x - ray sources associated to o or b supergiant stars and characterized by short outbursts . these _ supergiant fast x@xmath0ray tr... | [
"<S> we have developed a stellar wind model for ob supergiants to investigate the effects of accretion from a clumpy wind on the luminosity and variability properties of high mass x </S>",
"<S> ray binaries . assuming that the clumps are confined by ram pressure of the ambient gas and exploring different distrib... | null | [
"introduction",
"clumpy stellar wind properties",
"luminosity computation",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"a new class of massive x - ray binaries has been recognized in the last few years , mainly thanks to observations carried out with the _ integral _ satellite .",
"they are transient x - ray sources associated to o or b supergiant stars and characterized by short outbursts . these _ supergiant fast x@xmat... |
1512.02039 | [
"it is convenient to split the problem of multiple populations in globular clusters ( gcs ) into two challenges or questions .",
"first , what is producing the chemical abundance anomalies giving rise to observable features such as the na - o anti - correlation and multiple sequences in the colour - magnitude dia... | [
"<S> we discuss constraints on the formation of multiple populations in globular clusters ( gcs ) imposed by their present - day kinematics ( velocity dispersion and anisotropy ) and spatial distribution . </S>",
"<S> we argue that the observational evidence collected so far in the outer parts of clusters is gene... | null | [
"introduction",
"spatial distribution & kinematics of subpopulations in the outer regions of gcs",
"differential rotation as a potential way to distinguish between formation scenarios",
"mass segregation and the spatial distribution of subpopulations in the centre of gcs",
"summary"
] | [
[
"it is convenient to split the problem of multiple populations in globular clusters ( gcs ) into two challenges or questions .",
"first , what is producing the chemical abundance anomalies giving rise to observable features such as the na - o anti - correlation and multiple sequences in the colour - magni... |
astro-ph0609731 | [
"in most of the cosmological studies , dark matter particles are treated as collisionless particles .",
"for instance , to describe the cosmological density evolution , collisionless boltzmann equation is adopted . in cosmological n - body simulations , a group of collisionless dark matter particles ,",
"are re... | [
"<S> flat density cores have been obtained for a limited number of clusters of galaxies by strong gravitational lensing . using a phenomenological equation of state ( eos ) describing the full - to - partial degeneracy </S>",
"<S> , we integrate the equation of hydrostatic equilibrium . </S>",
"<S> the eos is b... | null | [
"introduction",
"derivation of a volume density profile of a1689 from the column density profile of broadhurst et al.",
"modeling procedure",
"fermion candidates, particle properties, and mass fraction of fermions",
"results",
"discussion",
"concluding remark"
] | [
[
"in most of the cosmological studies , dark matter particles are treated as collisionless particles .",
"for instance , to describe the cosmological density evolution , collisionless boltzmann equation is adopted . in cosmological n - body simulations , a group of collisionless dark matter particles ,",
... |
astro-ph0307448 | [
"despite considerable progress obtained over the last century , astrophysicists are still far away from a thorough understanding on how magnetic fields are produced in the sun and other cool active stars ; the picture gets even worse when it comes to explain quantitatively how these fields generate the plethora of ... | [
"<S> this paper reports positive detections of surface differential rotation on two rapidly rotating cool stars at several epochs , by using stellar surface features ( both cool spots and magnetic regions ) as tracers of the large scale latitudinal shear that distorts the convective envelope in this type of stars .... | null | [
"introduction",
"observational material and modelling techniques",
"conclusion and prospectives",
"acknowledgements"
] | [
[
"despite considerable progress obtained over the last century , astrophysicists are still far away from a thorough understanding on how magnetic fields are produced in the sun and other cool active stars ; the picture gets even worse when it comes to explain quantitatively how these fields generate the pletho... |
physics9710011 | [
"the existence and uniqueness of solutions to the differential equations of physics is seldom an issue .",
"the very fact that these equations describe physical reality seems to argue that their solutions must exist and be unique .",
"textbook examples of nonuniqueness , for example clairaut s equation ( ref ."... | [
"<S> the possibility is considered that turbulence is described by differential equations for which uniqueness fails maximally , at least in some limit . the inviscid burgers equation , in the context of onsager s suggestion that turbulence should be described by a negative absolute temperature , is such a limit . ... | null | [
"nonuniqueness",
"inviscid burgers equation",
"negative temperature",
"interpretation"
] | [
[
"the existence and uniqueness of solutions to the differential equations of physics is seldom an issue .",
"the very fact that these equations describe physical reality seems to argue that their solutions must exist and be unique .",
"textbook examples of nonuniqueness , for example clairaut s equatio... |
astro-ph0404366 | [
"over the past decade , the search for sources of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) has begun to focus upon small scale anisotropy in event arrival directions .",
"this refers to statistically significant excesses occurring at the scale of @xmath1 .",
"the interest in this sort of anisotropy has largel... | [
"<S> in the past few years , small scale anisotropy has become a primary focus in the search for source of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) . the akeno giant air shower array ( agasa ) </S>",
"<S> has reported the presence of clusters of event arrival directions in their highest energy data set . </S>",... | null | [
"introduction",
"the hires-i monocular data",
"conclusion",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"over the past decade , the search for sources of ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) has begun to focus upon small scale anisotropy in event arrival directions .",
"this refers to statistically significant excesses occurring at the scale of @xmath1 .",
"the interest in this sort of anisotropy ... |
astro-ph9906217 | [
"interstellar gas in the solar neighborhood has a variety of thermal and chemical phases , including cold atomic gas inside or mixed with cold molecular clouds ( e.g. , sato & fukui 1978 ) , cool and warm atomic gas on the envelopes of molecular clouds ( chromey et al .",
"1989 ; andersson & wannier 1993 ; wannie... | [
"<S> the thermal and chemical phases of the cool component of interstellar gas are discussed . variations with galactocentric radius and from galaxy to galaxy are mostly the result of changes in the ambient interstellar pressure and radiation field . </S>",
"<S> interstellar structure that is hierarchical or frac... | null | [
"phases of interstellar gas",
"structure of interstellar gas",
"further implications of hierarchical/fractal structure"
] | [
[
"interstellar gas in the solar neighborhood has a variety of thermal and chemical phases , including cold atomic gas inside or mixed with cold molecular clouds ( e.g. , sato & fukui 1978 ) , cool and warm atomic gas on the envelopes of molecular clouds ( chromey et al .",
"1989 ; andersson & wannier 1993 ... |
hep-th9609016 | [
"it has long been known that there is an @xmath0 supermultiplet which , with respect to @xmath1 supersymmetry , appears as a combination of one vector and one chiral multiplet @xcite .",
"this supermultiplet is irreducible under @xmath0 supersymmetry and carries vanishing central charge .",
"it is usually refer... | [
"<S> we use the four - dimensional @xmath0 central charge superspace to give a geometrical construction of the abelian vector - tensor multiplet consisting , under @xmath1 supersymmetry , of one vector and one linear multiplet . </S>",
"<S> we derive the component field supersymmetry and central charge transforma... | null | [
"introduction",
"@xmath0 superspace",
"vector-tensor multiplet in @xmath0 superspace",
"supersymmetry and central charge transformations",
"concluding remarks",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"it has long been known that there is an @xmath0 supermultiplet which , with respect to @xmath1 supersymmetry , appears as a combination of one vector and one chiral multiplet @xcite .",
"this supermultiplet is irreducible under @xmath0 supersymmetry and carries vanishing central charge .",
"it is usu... |
1209.5999 | [
"the statistical toolkit @xcite was originally conceived as a statistical data analysis toolkit for the problem of comparing data distributions .",
"its development follows the unified software development process @xcite . according to this approach , the life - cycle of the software is iterative - incremental , ... | [
"<S> the statistical toolkit is an open source system specialized in the statistical comparison of distributions . </S>",
"<S> it addresses requirements common to different experimental domains , such as simulation validation ( e.g. comparison of experimental and simulated distributions ) , regression testing in ... | null | [
"introduction",
"overview of the current functionality of the statistical toolkit",
"software improvements",
"extension of functionality",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgment",
"references"
] | [
[
"the statistical toolkit @xcite was originally conceived as a statistical data analysis toolkit for the problem of comparing data distributions .",
"its development follows the unified software development process @xcite . according to this approach , the life - cycle of the software is iterative - increm... |
1510.00798 | [
"cognitive radio ( cr ) has been an important research area for its superiority in spectrum efficiency .",
"generally , there are two categories in cr transmissions : underlay and overlay . in the underlay mode",
", the primary users ( pus ) and the secondary users ( sus ) can transmit in the same spectrum simu... | [
"<S> renewable energy powered cognitive radio ( cr ) network has gained much attention due to its combination of the cr s spectrum efficiency and the renewable energy s greennature . in the paper </S>",
"<S> , we investigate the delay - optimal data transmission in the renewable energy aided cr networks . </S>",
... | null | [
"introduction",
"system model and problem formulation",
"problem analysis and algorithm design",
"discussion on the availability of the pus private information at the su",
"numerical results",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"cognitive radio ( cr ) has been an important research area for its superiority in spectrum efficiency .",
"generally , there are two categories in cr transmissions : underlay and overlay . in the underlay mode",
", the primary users ( pus ) and the secondary users ( sus ) can transmit in the same spe... |
1301.5274 | [
"the origin of cosmic rays is an unsolved problem since the discovery in 1912 .",
"the spectrum of cosmic rays has a break at the knee energy ( @xmath4 ev ) , and those below the knee energy are believed to have galactic origin .",
"recently , the high energy stereoscopic system ( h.e.s.s . ) found more than 5... | [
"<S> we report the discovery of an x - ray counterpart of the unidentified very high energy gamma - ray source hess j1427608 . in the sky field </S>",
"<S> coincident with hess j1427608 , an extended source was found in the 28 kev band , and was designated as suzaku j14276051 . </S>",
"<S> its x - ray radia... | null | [
"introduction",
"observation and data reduction",
"analysis",
"archival data of xmm-newton",
"discussion",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"the origin of cosmic rays is an unsolved problem since the discovery in 1912 .",
"the spectrum of cosmic rays has a break at the knee energy ( @xmath4 ev ) , and those below the knee energy are believed to have galactic origin .",
"recently , the high energy stereoscopic system ( h.e.s.s . ) found m... |
quant-ph0512038 | [
"a wealth of information about the motion of microscopic particles can be gathered by scattering a well - controlled probe , typically light in the case of atoms with optical resonances .",
"young s historic double slit experiment demonstrated that the probe light wave shows interference if it can propagate along... | [
"<S> we investigate coherent backscattering of light by two harmonically trapped atoms in the light of quantitative quantum duality . </S>",
"<S> including recoil and doppler shift close to an optical resonance , we calculate the interference visibility as well as the amount of which - path information , both for... | null | [
"introduction",
"the setting",
"transition operator for photon double scattering",
"quantitative quantum duality",
"zero temperature",
"finite temperatures",
"summary"
] | [
[
"a wealth of information about the motion of microscopic particles can be gathered by scattering a well - controlled probe , typically light in the case of atoms with optical resonances .",
"young s historic double slit experiment demonstrated that the probe light wave shows interference if it can propaga... |
physics0702182 | [
"tracking and vertexing in a high multiplicity environment such as the lhc is a challenging task . in order to get a good secondary vertex resolution",
", one needs measurements as close to the interaction point as possible .",
"to have acceptably low occupancies one needs a very fine segmented detector .",
"... | [
"<S> the pixel detector is the innermost tracking device of the cms experiment at the lhc . </S>",
"<S> it is built from two independent sub devices , the pixel barrel and the end disks . </S>",
"<S> the barrel consists of three concentric layers around the beam pipe with mean radii of 4.4 , 7.3 and 10.2 cm . <... | null | [
"introduction",
"mechanical structure",
"modules",
"detector control and readout",
"performance",
"conclusion and outlook"
] | [
[
"tracking and vertexing in a high multiplicity environment such as the lhc is a challenging task . in order to get a good secondary vertex resolution",
", one needs measurements as close to the interaction point as possible .",
"to have acceptably low occupancies one needs a very fine segmented detect... |
cond-mat0610661 | [
"quantum phase transitions constitute a very active topic in theoretical physics @xcite , to which disorder and frustration of a quantum spin glass add considerable intricacies @xcite .",
"although quantum effects were usually considered to be negligible in spin glasses at finite temperatures , diverse experiment... | [
"<S> the density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) has been extended to study quantum phase transitions on random graphs of fixed connectivity . as a relevant example </S>",
"<S> , we have analysed the random ising model in a transverse field . </S>",
"<S> if the couplings are random , the number of retaine... | null | [
"introduction",
"model",
"application of the dmrg",
"results",
"discussion and conclusions"
] | [
[
"quantum phase transitions constitute a very active topic in theoretical physics @xcite , to which disorder and frustration of a quantum spin glass add considerable intricacies @xcite .",
"although quantum effects were usually considered to be negligible in spin glasses at finite temperatures , diverse ex... |
hep-ph0010221 | [
"the idea of a statistical approach to hadron production in high energy collisions dates back to 50s @xcite and 60s @xcite and it has been recently revived by the observation that hadron multiplicities in collisions agree very well with a thermodynamical - like ansatz @xcite .",
"this finding has also been confir... | [
"<S> a detailed analysis is performed of transverse momentum spectra of several identified hadrons in high energy collisions within the framework of the statistical model of hadronisation . </S>",
"<S> the effect of the decay chain following hadron generation is accurately taken into account . </S>",
"<S> the c... | null | [
"introduction",
"statistical hadronisation and transverse momentum spectra",
"method of data analysis",
"data set and results for hadronic collisions",
"results for collisions",
"discussion and conclusions",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"the idea of a statistical approach to hadron production in high energy collisions dates back to 50s @xcite and 60s @xcite and it has been recently revived by the observation that hadron multiplicities in collisions agree very well with a thermodynamical - like ansatz @xcite .",
"this finding has also bee... |
nucl-th9908015 | [
"i would like to discuss in this talk three topics which superficially would look unrelated but in essence can be connected by the general theme of cheshire cat .",
"i will first look at two - nucleon systems in terms of macroscopic variables of qcd , namely hadrons ; i will then go back to an elementary hadron ,... | [
"<S> in this talk i discuss three related topics based on some of the recent developments in hadron and nuclear physics : one , effective field theory approach to two - nucleon systems ; two , an explanation of the flavor singlet axial charge in the proton ( i.e. , proton spin problem \" ) in terms of a cheshire c... | null | [
"introduction",
"two-nucleon systems in effective field theory",
"proton spin\" and the cheshire cat",
"dense matter and the cheshire cat",
"conclusion"
] | [
[
"i would like to discuss in this talk three topics which superficially would look unrelated but in essence can be connected by the general theme of cheshire cat .",
"i will first look at two - nucleon systems in terms of macroscopic variables of qcd , namely hadrons ; i will then go back to an elementary ... |
1109.2474 | [
"magnetic reconnection is a fundamental process in astrophysical plasmas and is believed to be responsible for a wide range of solar phenomena , including solar flares ( for a review see * ? ? ?",
"unfortunately , magnetic reconnection occurs on spatial scales that are too small to be resolved with current solar ... | [
"<S> perhaps the most compelling evidence for the role of magnetic reconnection in solar flares comes from the supra - arcade downflows that have been observed above many post - flare loop arcades . </S>",
"<S> these downflows are thought to be related to highly non - potential field lines that have reconnected a... | null | [
"introduction",
"observations",
"discussion"
] | [
[
"magnetic reconnection is a fundamental process in astrophysical plasmas and is believed to be responsible for a wide range of solar phenomena , including solar flares ( for a review see * ? ? ?",
"unfortunately , magnetic reconnection occurs on spatial scales that are too small to be resolved with curren... |
gr-qc9901040 | [
"a laser interferometer to detect gravitational waves , such as the laser interferometric gravitational wave observatory(ligo ) , virgo , geo600 , or tama300 , will be in operation within several years@xcite .",
"it is one of the most urgent subjects for theoretical relativists to make a set of templates of gravi... | [
"<S> using a metric perturbation method , we study gravitational waves from a test particle scattered by a spherically symmetric relativistic star . </S>",
"<S> we calculate the energy spectrum and the waveform of gravitational waves for axial modes . </S>",
"<S> since metric perturbations in axial modes do not... | null | [
"introduction",
"linearized einstein equations: axial modes",
"gravitational waves from a scattered test particle",
"concluding remarks",
"numerical techniques solving the linearized einstein equations"
] | [
[
"a laser interferometer to detect gravitational waves , such as the laser interferometric gravitational wave observatory(ligo ) , virgo , geo600 , or tama300 , will be in operation within several years@xcite .",
"it is one of the most urgent subjects for theoretical relativists to make a set of templates ... |
1007.4453 | [
"in recent years , there has been a growing interest in the topic of consensus decision making in several fields including animal behaviour @xcite , social sciences @xcite and control theory @xcite . in this paper",
"we use the paradigm of animal groups but we would like to stress already at this point that there... | [
"<S> most of us must have been fascinated by the eye catching displays of collectively moving animals . </S>",
"<S> schools of fish can move in a rather orderly fashion and then change direction amazingly abruptly . </S>",
"<S> there are a huge number of further examples both from the living and the non - livin... | null | [
"introduction",
"model",
"results",
"conclusion",
"references"
] | [
[
"in recent years , there has been a growing interest in the topic of consensus decision making in several fields including animal behaviour @xcite , social sciences @xcite and control theory @xcite . in this paper",
"we use the paradigm of animal groups but we would like to stress already at this point th... |
1404.0136 | [
"in the solar system , there are many small bodies such as asteroids and comets .",
"since these small astronomical objects could keep the ancient information of the history of the solar system , a lot of efforts have been devoted to investigations of these objects so far ( e.g. , @xcite ) .",
"for instance , ... | [
"<S> we experimentally study the velocity scaling of granular convection which is a possible mechanism of the regolith migration on the surface of small asteroids . in order to evaluate the contribution of granular convection to the regolith migration </S>",
"<S> , the velocity of granular convection under the mi... | null | [
"introduction",
"materials and methods",
"results and analyses",
"discussion",
"conclusions",
"acknowledgments"
] | [
[
"in the solar system , there are many small bodies such as asteroids and comets .",
"since these small astronomical objects could keep the ancient information of the history of the solar system , a lot of efforts have been devoted to investigations of these objects so far ( e.g. , @xcite ) .",
"for i... |
nlin0608031 | [
"m. kac s classical paper can one hear the shape of a drum \" @xcite , triggered intensive research in two complementary aspects of this problem . on the one hand ,",
"a search for systems for which kac s question is answered in the affirmative was conducted , and , on the other hand , various examples of pairs ... | [
"<S> we present and discuss isospectral quantum graphs which are not isometric . </S>",
"<S> these graphs are the analogues of the isospectral domains in @xmath0 which were introduced recently in [ 1 - 5 ] all based on sunada s construction of isospectral domains @xcite . after presenting some of the properties o... | null | [
"introduction",
"isospectral quantum graphs",
"nodal counts and the resolution of isospectrality",
"discussion and summary",
"acknowledgments",
"construction of the isospectral dihedral graphs"
] | [
[
"m. kac s classical paper can one hear the shape of a drum \" @xcite , triggered intensive research in two complementary aspects of this problem . on the one hand ,",
"a search for systems for which kac s question is answered in the affirmative was conducted , and , on the other hand , various examples o... |
0901.0535 | [
"the ongoing heavy ion physics program with the star detector at rhic has accumulated the wealth of experimental data , stimulating important advances in the understanding of properties of hot strongly interacting matter @xcite .",
"some of the focus areas currently under study are the thermodynamic and hydrodyna... | [
"<S> two major advantages of the star detector - uniform azimuthal acceptance complementing extended pseudo - rapidity coverage , and the ability to identify a wide variety of the hadron species in almost all kinematic ranges - have allowed us to address successfully a set of key physics topics at rhic . </S>",
"... | null | [
"introduction",
"particle identification",
"non-triggered correlations",
"triggered correlations",
"beam energy scan",
"conclusions and outlook",
"references"
] | [
[
"the ongoing heavy ion physics program with the star detector at rhic has accumulated the wealth of experimental data , stimulating important advances in the understanding of properties of hot strongly interacting matter @xcite .",
"some of the focus areas currently under study are the thermodynamic and h... |
1702.06621 | [
"in june 2015 , the large hadron collider ( lhc ) has resumed its physics program with proton - proton ( pp ) collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev .",
"currently , this is the highest centre - of - mass energy reached in the laboratory .",
"a full description of particle production in pp collisions can not be obtaine... | [
"<S> the alice detector has excellent particle identification ( pid ) capabilities in the central barrel ( @xmath0 0.9 ) . </S>",
"<S> this allows identified hadron production to be measured over a wide transverse momentum ( @xmath1 ) range , using different sub - detectors and techniques : their specific energy ... | null | [
"introduction",
"particle identification",
"results",
"conclusions",
"references"
] | [
[
"in june 2015 , the large hadron collider ( lhc ) has resumed its physics program with proton - proton ( pp ) collisions at @xmath4 = 13 tev .",
"currently , this is the highest centre - of - mass energy reached in the laboratory .",
"a full description of particle production in pp collisions can not ... |
0907.4446 | [
"hanle effect measurements ( bommier et al . 1994 ) have shown that quiescent ( non active - region ) filaments have `` inverse '' magnetic polarity , meaning that their transverse field component is opposite in sign to that of the coronal loops crossing high over the photospheric neutral line .",
"the usual int... | [
"<S> erupting filaments are sometimes observed to undergo a rotation about the vertical direction as they rise . </S>",
"<S> this rotation of the filament axis is generally interpreted as a conversion of twist into writhe in a kink - unstable magnetic flux rope . </S>",
"<S> consistent with this interpretation ... | null | [
"introduction",
"event of 1999 september 20",
"event of 2001 september 28",
"discussion"
] | [
[
"hanle effect measurements ( bommier et al . 1994 ) have shown that quiescent ( non active - region ) filaments have `` inverse '' magnetic polarity , meaning that their transverse field component is opposite in sign to that of the coronal loops crossing high over the photospheric neutral line .",
"the u... |
1506.00282 | [
"noncovalent functionalization of single - walled carbon nanotubes ( cnts ) with photoactive molecules is becoming a promising technique to explore functional materials for light - harvesting or optoelectronic applications .",
"@xcite the coupling of the exceptional cnt transport properties with the optical prope... | [
"<S> the stability , electronic and optical properties of single - walled carbon nanotubes ( cnts ) and graphene noncovalently functionalized with free - base tetraphenylporphyrin ( tpp ) molecules is addressed by density functional theory calculations , including corrections to dispersive interactions . </S>",
"... | null | [
"introduction",
"theoretical approach",
"results and discussion",
"summary and conclusions"
] | [
[
"noncovalent functionalization of single - walled carbon nanotubes ( cnts ) with photoactive molecules is becoming a promising technique to explore functional materials for light - harvesting or optoelectronic applications .",
"@xcite the coupling of the exceptional cnt transport properties with the optic... |
1605.07266 | [
"monitoring the activity of large - scale neuronal ensembles during complex behavioral states is fundamental to neuroscience research",
". continued advances in optical imaging technology are greatly expanding the number and depth of neuronal populations that can be visualized .",
"specifically , in vivo calciu... | [
"<S> in vivo calcium imaging through microscopes has enabled deep brain imaging of previously inaccessible neuronal populations within the brains of freely moving subjects . </S>",
"<S> however , microendoscopic data suffer from high levels of background fluorescence as well as an increased potential for overlapp... | null | [
"introduction",
"model description",
"model fitting",
"results",
"conclusion",
"supplementary materials"
] | [
[
"monitoring the activity of large - scale neuronal ensembles during complex behavioral states is fundamental to neuroscience research",
". continued advances in optical imaging technology are greatly expanding the number and depth of neuronal populations that can be visualized .",
"specifically , in v... |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.