{
  "chart_id": "chart_0000961",
  "suite_id": "broad_coverage",
  "source_kind": "llm_program_synth",
  "chart_type": "bubble",
  "domain": "transport_logistics",
  "topic": "On-time Rate monitoring",
  "caption_seed": "transport_logistics::On-time Rate::ops",
  "title": "Transport Logistics On-time Rate Review [%]",
  "subtitle": "bubble benchmark panel",
  "note": "Operational reading target preserved across rendering variants.",
  "annotation_mode": "labeled",
  "x_axis": {
    "label": "Time Window",
    "scale": "linear",
    "tick_labels": [
      "Route-1",
      "Route-2",
      "Route-3",
      "Route-4",
      "Route-5",
      "Route-6",
      "Route-7",
      "Route-8",
      "Route-9"
    ],
    "tick_values": [
      0.0,
      1.0,
      2.0,
      3.0,
      4.0,
      5.0,
      6.0,
      7.0,
      8.0
    ],
    "unit": null,
    "orientation": "x"
  },
  "y_axis": {
    "label": "On-time Rate (%)",
    "scale": "linear",
    "tick_labels": [],
    "tick_values": [],
    "unit": "%",
    "orientation": "y"
  },
  "table": {
    "x_labels": [
      "Route-1",
      "Route-2",
      "Route-3",
      "Route-4",
      "Route-5",
      "Route-6",
      "Route-7",
      "Route-8",
      "Route-9"
    ],
    "values": [
      [
        99.0,
        95.57879128807787,
        89.33334421608497,
        84.06229709379272,
        78.93868822496768,
        74.0220765696384,
        71.47035440170728,
        67.57836682968562,
        65.29430538325003
      ]
    ],
    "series_labels": [
      "On-time Rate"
    ],
    "table_rows": [
      [
        "On-time Rate",
        99.0,
        95.5788,
        89.3333,
        84.0623,
        78.9387,
        74.0221,
        71.4704,
        67.5784,
        65.2943
      ]
    ]
  },
  "series": [
    {
      "name": "On-time Rate",
      "values": [
        99.0,
        95.5788,
        89.3333,
        84.0623,
        78.9387,
        74.0221,
        71.4704,
        67.5784,
        65.2943
      ],
      "render_role": "bubble",
      "axis": "primary",
      "color_hint": null,
      "extras": {
        "sizes": [
          86.54,
          131.57,
          161.29,
          182.5,
          141.51,
          190.62,
          253.67,
          180.42,
          309.43
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "legend": [
    "On-time Rate"
  ],
  "style_profile": {
    "backend": "matplotlib",
    "style_family": "dashboard_minimal",
    "layout_family": "single_panel",
    "width": 7.0,
    "height": 4.5,
    "note_style": "callout"
  },
  "layout_profile": {
    "layout_family": "single_panel"
  },
  "risk_profile": {
    "axis_scale": "linear",
    "y_axis_truncated": false,
    "legend_confusion": false,
    "occlusion": false,
    "visual_noise_std": 4.297188058378109,
    "blur_radius": 0.406866469401164,
    "jpeg_quality": 76,
    "misleader_type": "dual_axis_ambiguity",
    "dual_axis_emphasis": false
  },
  "scene_objects": [
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:0",
      "role": "bubble",
      "label": "On-time Rate",
      "bbox": [
        97.0,
        -40691.600000000006,
        113.0,
        -40675.600000000006
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": 0,
      "point_idx": 0,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": 99.0,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:1",
      "role": "bubble",
      "label": "On-time Rate",
      "bbox": [
        748.0,
        -39269.06504,
        764.0,
        -39253.06504
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": 0,
      "point_idx": 1,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": 95.5788,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:2",
      "role": "bubble",
      "label": "On-time Rate",
      "bbox": [
        1399.0,
        -36672.18614,
        1415.0,
        -36656.18614
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": 0,
      "point_idx": 2,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": 89.3333,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:3",
      "role": "bubble",
      "label": "On-time Rate",
      "bbox": [
        2050.0,
        -34480.50434,
        2066.0,
        -34464.50434
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": 0,
      "point_idx": 3,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": 84.0623,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:4",
      "role": "bubble",
      "label": "On-time Rate",
      "bbox": [
        2701.0,
        -32350.11146,
        2717.0,
        -32334.11146
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": 0,
      "point_idx": 4,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": 78.9387,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:5",
      "role": "bubble",
      "label": "On-time Rate",
      "bbox": [
        3352.0,
        -30305.78918,
        3368.0,
        -30289.78918
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": 0,
      "point_idx": 5,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": 74.0221,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:6",
      "role": "bubble",
      "label": "On-time Rate",
      "bbox": [
        4003.0,
        -29244.79232,
        4019.0,
        -29228.79232
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": 0,
      "point_idx": 6,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": 71.4704,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:7",
      "role": "bubble",
      "label": "On-time Rate",
      "bbox": [
        4654.0,
        -27626.498720000003,
        4670.0,
        -27610.498720000003
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": 0,
      "point_idx": 7,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": 67.5784,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:8",
      "role": "bubble",
      "label": "On-time Rate",
      "bbox": [
        5304.2046887491115,
        -26677.565251250893,
        5321.7953112508885,
        -26659.974628749118
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": 0,
      "point_idx": 8,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": 65.2943,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:title",
      "role": "title",
      "label": "Transport Logistics On-time Rate Review [%]",
      "bbox": [
        245.75,
        40.80000000000001,
        615.25,
        58.80000000000001
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:x_label",
      "role": "axis_label",
      "label": "Time Window",
      "bbox": [
        374.6875,
        557.4464194765202,
        486.3125,
        575.4464194765202
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:y_label",
      "role": "axis_label",
      "label": "On-time Rate (%)",
      "bbox": [
        37.04166666666666,
        200.6375,
        55.04166666666667,
        344.7625
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:0",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "Route-1",
      "bbox": [
        76.07782294772228,
        492.26666666666665,
        134.5909090909091,
        550.7797528098534
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:1",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "Route-2",
      "bbox": [
        150.05509567499502,
        492.26666666666665,
        208.5681818181818,
        550.7797528098534
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:2",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "Route-3",
      "bbox": [
        224.0323684022677,
        492.26666666666665,
        282.5454545454545,
        550.7797528098534
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:3",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "Route-4",
      "bbox": [
        298.0980294771888,
        492.26666666666665,
        356.52272727272725,
        550.6913644622051
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:4",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "Route-5",
      "bbox": [
        372.07530220446154,
        492.26666666666665,
        430.5,
        550.6913644622051
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:5",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "Route-6",
      "bbox": [
        446.0525749317343,
        492.26666666666665,
        504.47727272727275,
        550.6913644622051
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:6",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "Route-7",
      "bbox": [
        520.0298476590069,
        492.26666666666665,
        578.4545454545454,
        550.6913644622051
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:7",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "Route-8",
      "bbox": [
        594.0071203862797,
        492.26666666666665,
        652.4318181818181,
        550.6913644622051
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:8",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "Route-9",
      "bbox": [
        667.9843931135524,
        492.26666666666665,
        726.4090909090909,
        550.6913644622051
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:0",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "60",
      "bbox": [
        72.33333333333333,
        514.0740939959711,
        93.33333333333333,
        532.0740939959711
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:1",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "65",
      "bbox": [
        72.33333333333333,
        458.00049220161577,
        93.33333333333333,
        476.00049220161577
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:2",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "70",
      "bbox": [
        72.33333333333333,
        401.92689040726054,
        93.33333333333333,
        419.92689040726054
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:3",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "75",
      "bbox": [
        72.33333333333333,
        345.8532886129052,
        93.33333333333333,
        363.8532886129052
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:4",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "80",
      "bbox": [
        72.33333333333333,
        289.77968681855,
        93.33333333333333,
        307.77968681855
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:5",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "85",
      "bbox": [
        72.33333333333333,
        233.70608502419475,
        93.33333333333333,
        251.70608502419475
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:6",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "90",
      "bbox": [
        72.33333333333333,
        177.6324832298394,
        93.33333333333333,
        195.6324832298394
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:7",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "95",
      "bbox": [
        72.33333333333333,
        121.55888143548418,
        93.33333333333333,
        139.55888143548418
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:8",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "100",
      "bbox": [
        61.70833333333333,
        65.48527964112895,
        93.33333333333333,
        83.48527964112895
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:9",
      "role": "tick_label",
      "label": "105",
      "bbox": [
        61.70833333333333,
        9.4116778467735,
        93.33333333333333,
        27.4116778467735
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:legend:0",
      "role": "legend_item",
      "label": "On-time Rate",
      "bbox": [
        667.7499999999999,
        75.30000000000001,
        745.4999999999999,
        88.30000000000001
      ],
      "polygon": null,
      "panel_id": null,
      "series_idx": null,
      "point_idx": null,
      "supports_answer": null,
      "value": null,
      "metadata": {}
    }
  ],
  "provenance": {
    "scenario_id": "general",
    "pattern": "exponential_decay",
    "family": "decay",
    "title_template_id": "general:transport_logistics:t0",
    "metric_idx": 2,
    "challenge_score": 0,
    "llm_audit": {
      "enabled": false,
      "generator_model": "gpt-5-mini",
      "verifier_model": "gpt-5-mini",
      "judge_model": "gpt-5-mini",
      "candidate_count": 3,
      "selected_candidate_id": "fallback_2",
      "verifier_passed": true,
      "candidates": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "fallback_1",
          "text_fields": {
            "title": "On-time Rate Analysis [%]",
            "subtitle": "Transport Logistics operating view",
            "note": null,
            "topic": "On-time Rate",
            "caption_seed": "transport_logistics::On-time Rate::baseline"
          },
          "style_profile": {
            "style_family": "clean_report",
            "layout_family": "single_panel",
            "note_style": "subtle"
          },
          "layout_profile": {
            "layout_family": "single_panel"
          },
          "risk_profile": {},
          "constrained_spec_patch": {}
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "fallback_2",
          "text_fields": {
            "title": "Transport Logistics On-time Rate Review [%]",
            "subtitle": "bubble benchmark panel",
            "note": "Operational reading target preserved across rendering variants.",
            "topic": "On-time Rate monitoring",
            "caption_seed": "transport_logistics::On-time Rate::ops"
          },
          "style_profile": {
            "style_family": "dashboard_minimal",
            "layout_family": "single_panel",
            "note_style": "callout"
          },
          "layout_profile": {
            "layout_family": "single_panel"
          },
          "risk_profile": {},
          "constrained_spec_patch": {}
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "fallback_3",
          "text_fields": {
            "title": "On-time Rate Stability Snapshot [%]",
            "subtitle": "Transport Logistics benchmark slice",
            "note": "Visual complexity is intentionally varied while table truth stays fixed.",
            "topic": "On-time Rate stability",
            "caption_seed": "transport_logistics::On-time Rate::stability"
          },
          "style_profile": {
            "style_family": "paper_figure",
            "layout_family": "single_panel",
            "note_style": "footnote"
          },
          "layout_profile": {
            "layout_family": "single_panel"
          },
          "risk_profile": {},
          "constrained_spec_patch": {}
        }
      ],
      "verification_reports": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "fallback_1",
          "is_valid": true,
          "consistency_flags": [],
          "factuality_flags": [],
          "rejection_reason": null
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "fallback_2",
          "is_valid": true,
          "consistency_flags": [],
          "factuality_flags": [],
          "rejection_reason": null
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "fallback_3",
          "is_valid": true,
          "consistency_flags": [],
          "factuality_flags": [],
          "rejection_reason": null
        }
      ],
      "judgement_reports": [
        {
          "candidate_id": "fallback_2",
          "naturalness_score": 0.92,
          "clarity_score": 1.0,
          "ambiguity_score": 0.15,
          "selection_rank": 1
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "fallback_3",
          "naturalness_score": 0.89,
          "clarity_score": 1.0,
          "ambiguity_score": 0.15,
          "selection_rank": 2
        },
        {
          "candidate_id": "fallback_1",
          "naturalness_score": 0.86,
          "clarity_score": 1.0,
          "ambiguity_score": 0.15,
          "selection_rank": 3
        }
      ]
    }
  },
  "secondary_y_axis": null,
  "panel_specs": [],
  "difficulty_components": {
    "chart_type": "bubble",
    "n_series": 1,
    "n_points": 9,
    "layout_density": "low",
    "legend_complexity": "low",
    "tick_density": "low",
    "label_complexity": "medium",
    "mark_overlap": "low",
    "axis_transform": "linear",
    "annotation_mode": "labeled",
    "image_degradation": "medium",
    "source_kind": "llm_program_synth"
  }
}