{ "chart_id": "chart_0000969", "suite_id": "broad_coverage", "source_kind": "llm_program_synth", "chart_type": "stacked", "domain": "manufacturing_quality", "topic": "Yield monitoring", "caption_seed": "manufacturing_quality::Yield::ops", "title": "Manufacturing Quality Yield Review [%]", "subtitle": "stacked benchmark panel", "note": "Operational reading target preserved across rendering variants.", "annotation_mode": "unlabeled", "x_axis": { "label": "Production Batch", "scale": "linear", "tick_labels": [ "Batch-01", "Batch-02", "Batch-03", "Batch-04", "Batch-05", "Batch-06", "Batch-07", "Batch-08" ], "tick_values": [ 0.0, 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 7.0 ], "unit": null, "orientation": "x" }, "y_axis": { "label": "Yield (%)", "scale": "linear", "tick_labels": [], "tick_values": [], "unit": "%", "orientation": "y" }, "table": { "x_labels": [ "Batch-01", "Batch-02", "Batch-03", "Batch-04", "Batch-05", "Batch-06", "Batch-07", "Batch-08" ], "values": [ [ 93.19482333952716, 99.5, 86.75903113513111, 92.86660160685481, 99.5, 86.96621565866917, 92.49471536994807, 99.5 ], [ 89.83271141045707, 97.4486362452269, 88.11602999384728, 85.0, 93.29104974826157, 95.96065689566785, 85.17754613710215, 85.0 ], [ 91.55210378994897, 98.77340410093994, 91.35731647611031, 85.0, 91.70450452076992, 98.72687261732968, 91.0739411261851, 85.0 ], [ 93.58451308456583, 99.5, 90.36879453673352, 87.4907746773944, 99.5, 96.76467809794275, 86.45647270440938, 93.74390691039994 ] ], "series_labels": [ "Station 1", "Station 2", "Station 3", "Station 4" ], "table_rows": [ [ "Station 1", 93.1948, 99.5, 86.759, 92.8666, 99.5, 86.9662, 92.4947, 99.5 ], [ "Station 2", 89.8327, 97.4486, 88.116, 85.0, 93.291, 95.9607, 85.1775, 85.0 ], [ "Station 3", 91.5521, 98.7734, 91.3573, 85.0, 91.7045, 98.7269, 91.0739, 85.0 ], [ "Station 4", 93.5845, 99.5, 90.3688, 87.4908, 99.5, 96.7647, 86.4565, 93.7439 ] ] }, "series": [ { "name": "Station 1", "values": [ 93.1948, 99.5, 86.759, 92.8666, 99.5, 86.9662, 92.4947, 99.5 ], "render_role": "stacked", "axis": "primary", "color_hint": null, "extras": {} }, { "name": "Station 2", "values": [ 89.8327, 97.4486, 88.116, 85.0, 93.291, 95.9607, 85.1775, 85.0 ], "render_role": "stacked", "axis": "primary", "color_hint": null, "extras": {} }, { "name": "Station 3", "values": [ 91.5521, 98.7734, 91.3573, 85.0, 91.7045, 98.7269, 91.0739, 85.0 ], "render_role": "stacked", "axis": "primary", "color_hint": null, "extras": {} }, { "name": "Station 4", "values": [ 93.5845, 99.5, 90.3688, 87.4908, 99.5, 96.7647, 86.4565, 93.7439 ], "render_role": "stacked", "axis": "primary", "color_hint": null, "extras": {} } ], "legend": [ "Station 1", "Station 2", "Station 3", "Station 4" ], "style_profile": { "backend": "matplotlib", "style_family": "dashboard_minimal", "layout_family": "single_panel", "width": 7.0, "height": 4.5, "note_style": "callout" }, "layout_profile": { "layout_family": "single_panel" }, "risk_profile": { "axis_scale": "linear", "y_axis_truncated": true, "legend_confusion": true, "occlusion": false, "visual_noise_std": 2.566759683496116, "blur_radius": 0.3537457678778342, "jpeg_quality": 68, "misleader_type": "truncated_axis" }, "scene_objects": [ { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:0:0", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 1", "bbox": [ -139.125, -38269.79784, 349.125, 480.6 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 0, "point_idx": 0, "supports_answer": null, "value": 93.1948, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:0:1", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 1", "bbox": [ 511.875, -40891.5, 1000.125, 480.6 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 0, "point_idx": 1, "supports_answer": null, "value": 99.5, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:0:2", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 1", "bbox": [ 1162.875, -35593.7922, 1651.125, 480.6 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 0, "point_idx": 2, "supports_answer": null, "value": 86.759, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:0:3", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 1", "bbox": [ 1813.875, -38133.33228, 2302.125, 480.6 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 0, "point_idx": 3, "supports_answer": null, "value": 92.8666, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:0:4", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 1", "bbox": [ 2464.875, -40891.5, 2953.125, 480.6 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 0, "point_idx": 4, "supports_answer": null, "value": 99.5, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:0:5", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 1", "bbox": [ 3115.875, -35679.945960000005, 3604.125, 480.6 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 0, "point_idx": 5, "supports_answer": null, "value": 86.9662, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:0:6", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 1", "bbox": [ 3766.875, -37978.69626, 4255.125, 480.6 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 0, "point_idx": 6, "supports_answer": null, "value": 92.4947, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:0:7", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 1", "bbox": [ 4417.875, -40891.5, 4906.125, 480.6 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 0, "point_idx": 7, "supports_answer": null, "value": 99.5, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:1:0", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 2", "bbox": [ -139.125, -75622.23449999999, 349.125, -38269.79784 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 1, "point_idx": 0, "supports_answer": null, "value": 89.8327, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:1:1", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 2", "bbox": [ 511.875, -81410.62788, 1000.125, -40891.5 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 1, "point_idx": 1, "supports_answer": null, "value": 97.4486, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:1:2", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 2", "bbox": [ 1162.875, -72232.425, 1651.125, -35593.7922 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 1, "point_idx": 2, "supports_answer": null, "value": 88.116, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:1:3", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 2", "bbox": [ 1813.875, -73476.33228, 2302.125, -38133.33228 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 1, "point_idx": 3, "supports_answer": null, "value": 85.0, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:1:4", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 2", "bbox": [ 2464.875, -79681.8978, 2953.125, -40891.5 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 1, "point_idx": 4, "supports_answer": null, "value": 93.291, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:1:5", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 2", "bbox": [ 3115.875, -75580.40502, 3604.125, -35679.945960000005 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 1, "point_idx": 5, "supports_answer": null, "value": 95.9607, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:1:6", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 2", "bbox": [ 3766.875, -73395.50076, 4255.125, -37978.69626 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 1, "point_idx": 6, "supports_answer": null, "value": 85.1775, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:1:7", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 2", "bbox": [ 4417.875, -76234.5, 4906.125, -40891.5 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 1, "point_idx": 7, "supports_answer": null, "value": 85.0, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:2:0", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 3", "bbox": [ -139.125, -113689.59768, 349.125, -75622.23449999999 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 2, "point_idx": 0, "supports_answer": null, "value": 91.5521, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:2:1", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 3", "bbox": [ 511.875, -122480.60759999999, 1000.125, -81410.62788 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 2, "point_idx": 1, "supports_answer": null, "value": 98.7734, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:2:2", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 3", "bbox": [ 1162.875, -110218.79034, 1651.125, -72232.425 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 2, "point_idx": 2, "supports_answer": null, "value": 91.3573, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:2:3", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 3", "bbox": [ 1813.875, -108819.33228000003, 2302.125, -73476.33228 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 2, "point_idx": 3, "supports_answer": null, "value": 85.0, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:2:4", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 3", "bbox": [ 2464.875, -117812.62889999998, 2953.125, -79681.89779999999 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 2, "point_idx": 4, "supports_answer": null, "value": 91.7045, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:2:5", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 3", "bbox": [ 3115.875, -116631.05004000002, 3604.125, -75580.40501999999 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 2, "point_idx": 5, "supports_answer": null, "value": 98.7269, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:2:6", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 3", "bbox": [ 3766.875, -111264.02837999997, 4255.125, -73395.50075999998 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 2, "point_idx": 6, "supports_answer": null, "value": 91.0739, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:2:7", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 3", "bbox": [ 4417.875, -111577.5, 4906.125, -76234.5 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 2, "point_idx": 7, "supports_answer": null, "value": 85.0, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:3:0", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 4", "bbox": [ -139.125, -152602.03278, 349.125, -113689.59768 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 3, "point_idx": 0, "supports_answer": null, "value": 93.5845, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:3:1", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 4", "bbox": [ 511.875, -163852.7076, 1000.125, -122480.60759999999 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 3, "point_idx": 1, "supports_answer": null, "value": 99.5, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:3:2", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 4", "bbox": [ 1162.875, -147794.13738, 1651.125, -110218.79034 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 3, "point_idx": 2, "supports_answer": null, "value": 90.3688, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:3:3", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 4", "bbox": [ 1813.875, -145198.00691999999, 2302.125, -108819.33228 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 3, "point_idx": 3, "supports_answer": null, "value": 87.4908, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:3:4", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 4", "bbox": [ 2464.875, -159184.7289, 2953.125, -117812.6289 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 3, "point_idx": 4, "supports_answer": null, "value": 99.5, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:3:5", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 4", "bbox": [ 3115.875, -156865.8123, 3604.125, -116631.05003999999 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 3, "point_idx": 5, "supports_answer": null, "value": 96.7647, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:3:6", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 4", "bbox": [ 3766.875, -147212.64107999997, 4255.125, -111264.02837999997 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 3, "point_idx": 6, "supports_answer": null, "value": 86.4565, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:segment:3:7", "role": "bar_segment", "label": "Station 4", "bbox": [ 4417.875, -150556.21362, 4906.125, -111577.5 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": 3, "point_idx": 7, "supports_answer": null, "value": 93.7439, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:title", "role": "title", "label": "Manufacturing Quality Yield Review [%]", "bbox": [ 266.5, 40.80000000000001, 594.5, 58.80000000000001 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:xtick:0", "role": "tick_label", "label": "Batch-01", "bbox": [ 97.73150711986875, 492.26666666666665, 163.22727272727272, 557.7624322740706 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:xtick:1", "role": "tick_label", "label": "Batch-02", "bbox": [ 174.0951434835051, 492.26666666666665, 239.59090909090907, 557.7624322740706 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:xtick:2", "role": "tick_label", "label": "Batch-03", "bbox": [ 250.45877984714147, 492.26666666666665, 315.95454545454544, 557.7624322740706 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:xtick:3", "role": "tick_label", "label": "Batch-04", "bbox": [ 326.9108045584261, 492.26666666666665, 392.31818181818176, 557.6740439264223 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:xtick:4", "role": "tick_label", "label": "Batch-05", "bbox": [ 403.27444092206247, 492.26666666666665, 468.68181818181813, 557.6740439264223 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:xtick:5", "role": "tick_label", "label": "Batch-06", "bbox": [ 479.63807728569884, 492.26666666666665, 545.0454545454545, 557.6740439264223 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:xtick:6", "role": "tick_label", "label": "Batch-07", "bbox": [ 556.0017136493352, 492.26666666666665, 621.4090909090909, 557.6740439264223 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:xtick:7", "role": "tick_label", "label": "Batch-08", "bbox": [ 632.3653500129716, 492.26666666666665, 697.7727272727273, 557.6740439264223 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:0", "role": "tick_label", "label": "86", "bbox": [ 72.33333333333333, 492.4306216392374, 93.33333333333333, 510.4306216392374 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:1", "role": "tick_label", "label": "88", "bbox": [ 72.33333333333333, 445.37994541306807, 93.33333333333333, 463.37994541306807 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:2", "role": "tick_label", "label": "90", "bbox": [ 72.33333333333333, 398.3292691868992, 93.33333333333333, 416.3292691868992 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:3", "role": "tick_label", "label": "92", "bbox": [ 72.20833333333333, 351.27859296072984, 93.33333333333333, 369.27859296072984 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:4", "role": "tick_label", "label": "94", "bbox": [ 72.33333333333333, 304.22791673456095, 93.33333333333333, 322.22791673456095 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:5", "role": "tick_label", "label": "96", "bbox": [ 72.33333333333333, 257.17724050839206, 93.33333333333333, 275.17724050839206 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:6", "role": "tick_label", "label": "98", "bbox": [ 72.33333333333333, 210.12656428222272, 93.33333333333333, 228.12656428222272 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:7", "role": "tick_label", "label": "100", "bbox": [ 61.70833333333333, 163.07588805605383, 93.33333333333333, 181.07588805605383 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:8", "role": "tick_label", "label": "102", "bbox": [ 61.58333333333333, 116.02521182988448, 93.33333333333333, 134.02521182988448 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:9", "role": "tick_label", "label": "104", "bbox": [ 61.70833333333333, 68.9745356037156, 93.33333333333333, 86.9745356037156 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:ytick:10", "role": "tick_label", "label": "106", "bbox": [ 61.70833333333333, 21.92385937754625, 93.33333333333333, 39.92385937754625 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:legend:0", "role": "legend_item", "label": "Station 1", "bbox": [ 692.6249999999999, 75.30000000000001, 745.4999999999999, 88.30000000000001 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:legend:1", "role": "legend_item", "label": "Station 2", "bbox": [ 692.6249999999999, 94.13333333333333, 745.3749999999999, 107.13333333333333 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:legend:2", "role": "legend_item", "label": "Station 3", "bbox": [ 692.6249999999999, 112.9666666666667, 745.3749999999999, 125.9666666666667 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} }, { "object_id": "chart_0000969:main:legend:3", "role": "legend_item", "label": "Station 4", "bbox": [ 692.6249999999999, 131.8, 745.3749999999999, 144.8 ], "polygon": null, "panel_id": null, "series_idx": null, "point_idx": null, "supports_answer": null, "value": null, "metadata": {} } ], "provenance": { "scenario_id": "general", "pattern": "oscillating", "family": "cyclical", "title_template_id": "general:manufacturing_quality:t1", "metric_idx": 0, "challenge_score": 2, "llm_audit": { "enabled": false, "generator_model": "gpt-5-mini", "verifier_model": "gpt-5-mini", "judge_model": "gpt-5-mini", "candidate_count": 3, "selected_candidate_id": "fallback_2", "verifier_passed": true, "candidates": [ { "candidate_id": "fallback_1", "text_fields": { "title": "Manufacturing Yield Trend [%]", "subtitle": "Manufacturing Quality operating view", "note": null, "topic": "Yield", "caption_seed": "manufacturing_quality::Yield::baseline" }, "style_profile": { "style_family": "clean_report", "layout_family": "single_panel", "note_style": "subtle" }, "layout_profile": { "layout_family": "single_panel" }, "risk_profile": {}, "constrained_spec_patch": {} }, { "candidate_id": "fallback_2", "text_fields": { "title": "Manufacturing Quality Yield Review [%]", "subtitle": "stacked benchmark panel", "note": "Operational reading target preserved across rendering variants.", "topic": "Yield monitoring", "caption_seed": "manufacturing_quality::Yield::ops" }, "style_profile": { "style_family": "dashboard_minimal", "layout_family": "single_panel", "note_style": "callout" }, "layout_profile": { "layout_family": "single_panel" }, "risk_profile": {}, "constrained_spec_patch": {} }, { "candidate_id": "fallback_3", "text_fields": { "title": "Yield Stability Snapshot [%]", "subtitle": "Manufacturing Quality benchmark slice", "note": "Visual complexity is intentionally varied while table truth stays fixed.", "topic": "Yield stability", "caption_seed": "manufacturing_quality::Yield::stability" }, "style_profile": { "style_family": "paper_figure", "layout_family": "single_panel", "note_style": "footnote" }, "layout_profile": { "layout_family": "single_panel" }, "risk_profile": {}, "constrained_spec_patch": {} } ], "verification_reports": [ { "candidate_id": "fallback_1", "is_valid": true, "consistency_flags": [], "factuality_flags": [], "rejection_reason": null }, { "candidate_id": "fallback_2", "is_valid": true, "consistency_flags": [], "factuality_flags": [], "rejection_reason": null }, { "candidate_id": "fallback_3", "is_valid": true, "consistency_flags": [], "factuality_flags": [], "rejection_reason": null } ], "judgement_reports": [ { "candidate_id": "fallback_2", "naturalness_score": 0.89, "clarity_score": 1.0, "ambiguity_score": 0.15, "selection_rank": 1 }, { "candidate_id": "fallback_1", "naturalness_score": 0.86, "clarity_score": 1.0, "ambiguity_score": 0.15, "selection_rank": 2 }, { "candidate_id": "fallback_3", "naturalness_score": 0.86, "clarity_score": 1.0, "ambiguity_score": 0.15, "selection_rank": 3 } ] } }, "secondary_y_axis": null, "panel_specs": [], "difficulty_components": { "chart_type": "stacked", "n_series": 4, "n_points": 8, "layout_density": "medium", "legend_complexity": "medium", "tick_density": "low", "label_complexity": "medium", "mark_overlap": "medium", "axis_transform": "linear", "annotation_mode": "unlabeled", "image_degradation": "low", "source_kind": "llm_program_synth" } }