tytskiy commited on
Commit
d9db327
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 8d96396

Update benchmarks/yambda/evaluation/metrics.py

Browse files

These bugs could substantially distort absolute metric values (especially NDCG), but as far as we can judge it does not change the ranking of the models reported in the paper.

P.S. Thanks to Kirill Khrylchenko for identifying these issues

benchmarks/yambda/evaluation/metrics.py CHANGED
@@ -47,6 +47,9 @@ class Recall(Metric):
47
  num_positives = targets.lengths.to(torch.float32)
48
  num_positives[num_positives == 0] = torch.inf
49
 
 
 
 
50
  values[k] = target_mask[:, :k].to(torch.float32).sum(dim=-1) / num_positives
51
 
52
  values[k] = torch.mean(values[k]).item()
@@ -134,6 +137,12 @@ class NDCG(Metric):
134
  def __call__(
135
  self, ranked: Ranked | None, targets: Targets, target_mask: torch.Tensor, ks: Iterable[int]
136
  ) -> dict[int, float]:
 
 
 
 
 
 
137
  actual_dcg = DCG()(ranked, targets, target_mask, ks)
138
 
139
  ideal_target_mask = (
 
47
  num_positives = targets.lengths.to(torch.float32)
48
  num_positives[num_positives == 0] = torch.inf
49
 
50
+ # there is a bug: we divide by num_positives instead of max(num_positives, k)
51
+ # this may slightly affect the absolute metric values,
52
+ # but as far as we can judge it does not change the ranking of the models reported in the paper.
53
  values[k] = target_mask[:, :k].to(torch.float32).sum(dim=-1) / num_positives
54
 
55
  values[k] = torch.mean(values[k]).item()
 
137
  def __call__(
138
  self, ranked: Ranked | None, targets: Targets, target_mask: torch.Tensor, ks: Iterable[int]
139
  ) -> dict[int, float]:
140
+
141
+ # there is a bug: we compute (dcg_1 + ... + dcg_n) / (idcg_1 + ... + idcg_n)
142
+ # instead of (1 / n) * (dcg_1 / idcg_1 + ... + dcg_n / idcg_n)
143
+ # this may affect the absolute metric values,
144
+ # but as far as we can judge it does not change the ranking of the models reported in the paper.
145
+
146
  actual_dcg = DCG()(ranked, targets, target_mask, ks)
147
 
148
  ideal_target_mask = (