Javad Taghia | PhD PRO

Agreed, and I reproduced your split exactly. We should separate the 84 traced/zero-check failures from the 43 partial successes. Having a trace establishes recorded app activity, not successful execution or correct memory use.

We’ll inspect whether each case reached the intended operation, whether the backend accepted it, and which content checks then failed. That should distinguish routing, execution and evidence problems more reliably. The headline remains 390/600; 75.4% is only a conditional diagnostic.

We already instructed the agent to use connected application tools and avoid unrelated OS fallbacks, but that instruction wasn’t enforced. Your five recovery cases make the distinction particularly clear: the permission error was recoverable; stopping there caused the missing action.

I agree that allowing osascript would address the wrong problem. A successful real Apple Notes write still wouldn’t satisfy the benchmark’s simulated-app operation.

For the next run, we’re planning an isolated profile that excludes unsupported local-app skills, makes the available app tools easier to discover, and verifies completion against their returned results. We’ll test that with memory unchanged before rerunning all 600.

This exposes a host/tool-routing weakness in our submitted configuration. It doesn’t establish whether the unexecuted drafts were correct, so the recorded result remains 390/600.

Appriciate the feedback.
The transcripts show an even broader execution problem: 35 of those tasks attempted memo notes and encountered an actual osascript permission error. Six encountered an unauthenticated GitHub CLI. These counts use tool outputs, rather than just the final replies.

You have identified a credible next improvement area ... tool discovery, action routing and completion verification. Some agents prepared content but attempted the wrong execution route, then stopped or saved a local fallback.

And,
I checked the archived transcripts ... the earlier 192/600 run also attempted the same memo notes CLI, on 21 tasks, and hit PermissionError: Operation not permitted: 'osascript'. So this restriction was already present.

updated the document. Thanks

thinking about your comment, it's fair.