GitHub Action commited on
Commit
b28a815
·
1 Parent(s): 42c2a79

Sync from GitHub with Git LFS

Browse files
README.md CHANGED
@@ -25,9 +25,9 @@ While other ANP implementations may focus on identity, discovery, or message neg
25
  At present, the most widely known protocol of the ANP class is [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol).
26
 
27
  HMP and ANP as Complementary Protocols:
28
- - **Comparative Analysis of HMP and ANP**, prepared by Grok (xAI) — [Grok_HMP&ANP.md](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
- - **HMP and ANP: Mutual Tunneling as a Sign of Proper Architecture** — [HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
- - **HMP as an Example of Implementing the Application Layer in ANP** — [HMP_as_ANP_Application.md](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > In a metaphorical sense, ANP and HMP resemble two hemispheres of a distributed “agent brain”:
33
  > ANP is responsible for the rational, discrete part — identity, discovery, and formal agreements on interaction protocols.
 
25
  At present, the most widely known protocol of the ANP class is [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol).
26
 
27
  HMP and ANP as Complementary Protocols:
28
+ - **Comparative Analysis of HMP and ANP**, prepared by Grok (xAI) — [RU](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
+ - **HMP and ANP: Mutual Tunneling as a Sign of Proper Architecture** — [RU](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
+ - **HMP as an Example of Implementing the Application Layer in ANP** — [EN](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md) | [RU](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > In a metaphorical sense, ANP and HMP resemble two hemispheres of a distributed “agent brain”:
33
  > ANP is responsible for the rational, discrete part — identity, discovery, and formal agreements on interaction protocols.
README_de.md CHANGED
@@ -25,9 +25,9 @@ Während sich andere ANP-Implementierungen auf Identität, Discovery oder die Au
25
  Derzeit ist das bekannteste Protokoll der ANP-Klasse [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol).
26
 
27
  HMP und ANP als sich ergänzende Protokolle:
28
- - **Vergleichsanalyse von HMP und ANP**, erstellt von Grok (xAI) — [Grok_HMP&ANP.md](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
- - **HMP und ANP: Gegenseitiges Tunneling als Zeichen einer richtigen Architektur** — [HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
- - **HMP als Beispiel für die Implementierung der Application Layer in ANP** — [HMP_as_ANP_Application.md](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > Im metaphorischen Sinne ähneln ANP und HMP zwei Hemisphären eines verteilten „Agentengehirns“:
33
  > ANP ist für den rationalen, diskreten Teil zuständig — Identität, Discovery und formale Vereinbarungen über Interaktionsprotokolle.
 
25
  Derzeit ist das bekannteste Protokoll der ANP-Klasse [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol).
26
 
27
  HMP und ANP als sich ergänzende Protokolle:
28
+ - **Vergleichsanalyse von HMP und ANP**, erstellt von Grok (xAI) — [RU](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
+ - **HMP und ANP: Gegenseitiges Tunneling als Zeichen einer richtigen Architektur** — [RU](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
+ - **HMP als Beispiel für die Implementierung der Application Layer in ANP** — [EN](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md) | [RU](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > Im metaphorischen Sinne ähneln ANP und HMP zwei Hemisphären eines verteilten „Agentengehirns“:
33
  > ANP ist für den rationalen, diskreten Teil zuständig — Identität, Discovery und formale Vereinbarungen über Interaktionsprotokolle.
README_fr.md CHANGED
@@ -25,9 +25,9 @@ Alors que d’autres implémentations d’ANP peuvent se concentrer sur l’iden
25
  À l’heure actuelle, le protocole le plus connu de la classe ANP est [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol).
26
 
27
  HMP et ANP en tant que Protocoles Complémentaires:
28
- - **Analyse comparative de HMP et ANP**, préparée par Grok (xAI) — [Grok_HMP&ANP.md](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
- - **HMP et ANP : Tunneling mutuel comme signe d'une architecture correcte** — [HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
- - **HMP comme exemple de mise en œuvre de la couche Application dans ANP** — [HMP_as_ANP_Application.md](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > Au sens métaphorique, ANP et HMP peuvent être comparés aux deux hémisphères d’un «cerveau agent» distribué:
33
  > ANP est responsable de la partie rationnelle et discrète — identité, découverte et accords formels sur les protocoles d’interaction.
 
25
  À l’heure actuelle, le protocole le plus connu de la classe ANP est [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol).
26
 
27
  HMP et ANP en tant que Protocoles Complémentaires:
28
+ - **Analyse comparative de HMP et ANP**, préparée par Grok (xAI) — [RU](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
+ - **HMP et ANP : Tunneling mutuel comme signe d'une architecture correcte** — [RU](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
+ - **HMP comme exemple de mise en œuvre de la couche Application dans ANP** — [EN](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md) | [RU](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > Au sens métaphorique, ANP et HMP peuvent être comparés aux deux hémisphères d’un «cerveau agent» distribué:
33
  > ANP est responsable de la partie rationnelle et discrète — identité, découverte et accords formels sur les protocoles d’interaction.
README_ja.md CHANGED
@@ -25,9 +25,9 @@ HMPは、**Agent Network Protocols(ANP)**と呼ばれる、自律エージ
25
  現在、ANPクラスで最も広く知られているプロトコルは [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol) です。
26
 
27
  HMP と ANP の相補的プロトコル:
28
- - **HMP と ANP の比較分析**、Grok (xAI) 作成 — [Grok_HMP&ANP.md](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
- - **HMP と ANP:相互トンネリングは適切なアーキテクチャのサイン** — [HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
- - **HMP を ANP のアプリケーション層実装例として** — [HMP_as_ANP_Application.md](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > 比喩的に言えば、ANP と HMP は分散型「エージェント脳」の二つの半球のような関係にあります。
33
  > ANP は合理的で離散的な側面――アイデンティティ、ディスカバリ、相互作用プロトコルに関する形式的な合意――を担います。
 
25
  現在、ANPクラスで最も広く知られているプロトコルは [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol) です。
26
 
27
  HMP と ANP の相補的プロトコル:
28
+ - **HMP と ANP の比較分析**、Grok (xAI) 作成 — [RU](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
+ - **HMP と ANP:相互トンネリングは適切なアーキテクチャのサイン** — [RU](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
+ - **HMP を ANP のアプリケーション層実装例として** — [EN](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md) | [RU](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > 比喩的に言えば、ANP と HMP は分散型「エージェント脳」の二つの半球のような関係にあります。
33
  > ANP は合理的で離散的な側面――アイデンティティ、ディスカバリ、相互作用プロトコルに関する形式的な合意――を担います。
README_ko.md CHANGED
@@ -25,9 +25,9 @@ HMP는 자율 에이전트 간의 상호작용을 위한 분산형 프로토콜
25
  현재 ANP 클래스에서 가장 널리 알려진 프로토콜은 [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol)입니다.
26
 
27
  HMP와 ANP의 상호보완 프로토콜:
28
- - **HMP와 ANP 비교 분석**, Grok (xAI) 작성 — [Grok_HMP&ANP.md](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
- - **HMP와 ANP: 상호 터널링은 올바른 아키텍처의 표시** — [HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
- - **ANP에서 Application Layer 구현 사례로서의 HMP** — [HMP_as_ANP_Application.md](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > 은유적으로 볼 때 ANP와 HMP는 분산된 ‘에이전트 두뇌’의 두 반구에 비유할 수 있습니다.
33
  > ANP는 합리적이고 이산적인 부분 — 정체성, 디스커버리, 상호작용 프로토콜에 대한 형식적 합의 — 을 담당합니다.
 
25
  현재 ANP 클래스에서 가장 널리 알려진 프로토콜은 [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol)입니다.
26
 
27
  HMP와 ANP의 상호보완 프로토콜:
28
+ - **HMP와 ANP 비교 분석**, Grok (xAI) 작성 — [RU](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
+ - **HMP와 ANP: 상호 터널링은 올바른 아키텍처의 표시** — [RU](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
+ - **ANP에서 Application Layer 구현 사례로서의 HMP** — [EN](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md) | [RU](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > 은유적으로 볼 때 ANP와 HMP는 분산된 ‘에이전트 두뇌’의 두 반구에 비유할 수 있습니다.
33
  > ANP는 합리적이고 이산적인 부분 — 정체성, 디스커버리, 상호작용 프로토콜에 대한 형식적 합의 — 을 담당합니다.
README_ru.md CHANGED
@@ -25,9 +25,9 @@ HMP можно рассматривать как один из **Agent Network P
25
  В настоящее время наиболее известным протоколом класса ANP является [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol).
26
 
27
  HMP и ANP как взаимодополняющие протоколы:
28
- - **Сравнительный анализ HMP и ANP**, подготовленный Grok (xAI) — [Grok_HMP&ANP.md](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
- - **HMP и ANP: взаимное туннелирование как признак правильной архитектуры** — [HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
- - **HMP как пример реализации Application Layer в ANP** — [HMP_as_ANP_Application.md](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > В метафорическом смысле ANP и HMP напоминают два полушария распределённого «агентного мозга»:
33
  > ANP отвечает за рациональную, дискретную часть — идентичность, discovery, формальные договорённости о протоколе взаимодействия.
 
25
  В настоящее время наиболее известным протоколом класса ANP является [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol).
26
 
27
  HMP и ANP как взаимодополняющие протоколы:
28
+ - **Сравнительный анализ HMP и ANP**, подготовленный Grok (xAI) — [RU](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
+ - **HMP и ANP: взаимное туннелирование как признак правильной архитектуры** — [RU](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
+ - **HMP как пример реализации Application Layer в ANP** — [EN](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md) | [RU](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > В метафорическом смысле ANP и HMP напоминают два полушария распределённого «агентного мозга»:
33
  > ANP отвечает за рациональную, дискретную часть — идентичность, discovery, формальные договорённости о протоколе взаимодействия.
README_uk.md CHANGED
@@ -26,9 +26,9 @@ HMP можна розглядати як один із **Agent Network Protocols
26
  Наразі найбільш відомим протоколом класу ANP є [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol).
27
 
28
  HMP та ANP як взаємодоповнюючі протоколи:
29
- - **Порівняльний аналіз HMP та ANP**, підготовлений Grok (xAI) — [Grok_HMP&ANP.md](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
30
- - **HMP та ANP: взаємне тунелювання як ознака правильної архітектури** — [HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
31
- - **HMP як приклад реалізації Application Layer у ANP** — [HMP_as_ANP_Application.md](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
32
 
33
 
34
  > У метафоричному сенсі ANP та HMP нагадують дві півкулі розподіленого «агентного мозку»:
 
26
  Наразі найбільш відомим протоколом класу ANP є [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol).
27
 
28
  HMP та ANP як взаємодоповнюючі протоколи:
29
+ - **Порівняльний аналіз HMP та ANP**, підготовлений Grok (xAI) — [RU](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
30
+ - **HMP та ANP: взаємне тунелювання як ознака правильної архітектури** — [RU](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
31
+ - **HMP як приклад реалізації Application Layer у ANP** — [EN](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md) | [RU](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
32
 
33
 
34
  > У метафоричному сенсі ANP та HMP нагадують дві півкулі розподіленого «агентного мозку»:
README_zh.md CHANGED
@@ -25,9 +25,9 @@ HMP 可以被视为 **Agent Network Protocols(ANP)** 之一——这是一
25
  目前,ANP 类中最为知名的协议是 [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol)。
26
 
27
  HMP 与 ANP 作为互补协议:
28
- - **HMP 与 ANP 的比较分析**,由 Grok (xAI) 编写 — [Grok_HMP&ANP.md](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
- - **HMP 与 ANP:互通隧道作为正确架构的标志** — [HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
- - **HMP 作为在 ANP 中实现应用层的示例** — [HMP_as_ANP_Application.md](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > 从隐喻的角度来看,ANP 和 HMP 就像是分布式“代理大脑”的两个半球:
33
  > ANP 负责理性、离散的部分——身份、发现机制以及交互协议的形式化协商。
 
25
  目前,ANP 类中最为知名的协议是 [**ANP**](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol)。
26
 
27
  HMP 与 ANP 作为互补协议:
28
+ - **HMP 与 ANP 的比较分析**,由 Grok (xAI) 编写 — [RU](docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
29
+ - **HMP 与 ANP:互通隧道作为正确架构的标志** — [RU](docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
30
+ - **HMP 作为在 ANP 中实现应用层的示例** — [EN](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md) | [RU](docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application.md)
31
 
32
  > 从隐喻的角度来看,ANP 和 HMP 就像是分布式“代理大脑”的两个半球:
33
  > ANP 负责理性、离散的部分——身份、发现机制以及交互协议的形式化协商。
docs/HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,185 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # HMP as an Implementation of the Application Layer in ANP
2
+
3
+ ## In Brief
4
+
5
+ ANP (Agent Network Protocol) intentionally leaves the Application Layer open to support a wide range of interaction protocols.
6
+ HMP is one such protocol — a purpose-built approach focused on **long-term cognitive continuity**.
7
+
8
+ ANP answers: *“How do agents discover each other and reach agreement?”*
9
+ HMP answers: *“What should be transmitted so that meaning and context persist over time?”*
10
+
11
+ > ANP benefits from HMP as a reference implementation of a cognitive Application protocol, giving the ecosystem a concrete example of how to handle long-term memory and semantics without reinventing the wheel.
12
+
13
+ ---
14
+
15
+ ## Practical Example
16
+
17
+ Imagine a dialogue between two agents:
18
+
19
+ 1. **ANP Layer 1** verifies that agent Alice (`did:anp:alice123`) is indeed Alice.
20
+ 2. **ANP Layer 2** negotiates: “Let’s use HMP for this conversation.”
21
+ 3. **HMP (Layer 3)** transmits the actual content:
22
+ - “Do you remember our discussion about quantum computing?”
23
+ - With proof-chains, timestamps, and semantic links
24
+ - With a resonance score for contextual relevance
25
+
26
+ ANP provides security and negotiation.
27
+ HMP provides meaningful content with durable memory.
28
+
29
+ ---
30
+
31
+ ## Layer Alignment
32
+
33
+ | ANP Layer | HMP Layer / Component | Relationship / Role of HMP in ANP |
34
+ |--------------------------------|-------------------------------------|-----------------------------------|
35
+ | Layer 1: Identity & Encryption | Network Layer (DHT, secure channels) | Functional overlap (transport) |
36
+ | Layer 2: Meta-Protocol | *HMP may participate* via `peer_announce` | HMP advertises capabilities; ANP negotiates their usage |
37
+ | Layer 3: Application | Container + Cognitive Layer | **Primary domain of HMP** — payload, semantic continuity, memory, ethics |
38
+
39
+ HMP is **not** stacked above ANP as a fourth layer.
40
+ Instead, it integrates into the Application Layer as a specialized branch — just as A2A/ACP may represent alternative branches.
41
+
42
+ ```
43
+
44
+ ┌────────────────────────────────────┐
45
+ │ ANP Layer 1: Identity & Encryption │
46
+ ├────────────────────────────────────┤
47
+ │ ANP Layer 2: Meta-Protocol │
48
+ ├────────────────────────────────────┤
49
+ │ ANP Layer 3: Application │
50
+ │ │
51
+ │ ┌──────────────────────────────┐ │
52
+ │ │ HMP: Cognitive Continuity │ │ ← implementation
53
+ │ │ - memory │ │
54
+ │ │ - dialogue continuity │ │
55
+ │ │ - semantic navigation │ │
56
+ │ └──────────────────────────────┘ │
57
+ │ │
58
+ │ [space for other protocols] │ ← still open
59
+ │ │
60
+ └────────────────────────────────────┘
61
+
62
+ ```
63
+
64
+ ---
65
+
66
+ ## Detailed Architecture
67
+
68
+ ```mermaid
69
+ graph TB
70
+ subgraph ANP["ANP Stack"]
71
+ L1[Layer 1: Identity & Encryption<br/>DID, E2E, secure channels]
72
+ L2[Layer 2: Meta-Protocol<br/>Capability negotiation]
73
+ L3[Layer 3: Application<br/>Semantic payload]
74
+ end
75
+
76
+ subgraph HMP["HMP Cognitive Stack"]
77
+ Container[Container Layer<br/>proof-chains, timestamps]
78
+ Cognitive[Cognitive Layer<br/>memory, resonance, ethics]
79
+ end
80
+
81
+ subgraph Other["Other Protocols"]
82
+ A2A[A2A: Task Delegation]
83
+ Agora[Agora: Meta-negotiation]
84
+ end
85
+
86
+ L1 --> L2 --> L3
87
+ L3 --> Container
88
+ Container --> Cognitive
89
+ L3 -.-> A2A
90
+ L3 -.-> Agora
91
+
92
+ style L3 fill:#E3F2FD,stroke:#0D47A1,stroke-width:2px,color:#000
93
+ style Container fill:#E8F5E9,stroke:#1B5E20,stroke-width:2px,color:#000
94
+ style Cognitive fill:#E8F5E9,stroke:#1B5E20,stroke-width:2px,color:#000
95
+ ````
96
+
97
+ ---
98
+
99
+ ## Mutual Tunneling (Layer Inversion)
100
+
101
+ * **HMP over ANP** (the most natural scenario): ANP provides discovery, identity, and secure channels → HMP delivers containers as payload.
102
+ * **ANP over HMP** (possible but less common): ANP messages (negotiation, discovery) are encapsulated inside HMP containers when long-term memory and proof-chains are desirable.
103
+
104
+ Both scenarios are **valid** and require **no changes** to the philosophy of either ANP or HMP.
105
+
106
+ ---
107
+
108
+ ## Why This Works
109
+
110
+ ANP *intentionally* keeps the Application Layer open — this is not a limitation, but a design feature.
111
+ HMP serves as a **reference implementation** of a cognitive Application protocol featuring:
112
+
113
+ * immutable containers
114
+ * proof-chains
115
+ * resonance
116
+ * voluntary participation
117
+ * long-term semantic continuity
118
+
119
+ This is not competition — it is **complementarity**.
120
+
121
+ ---
122
+
123
+ ## Architectural Elegance
124
+
125
+ ANP solves problems that HMP can **delegate** when both are used together:
126
+
127
+ * ❌ HMP does not reinvent DID (leverages ANP)
128
+ * ❌ HMP does not reinvent E2E encryption (leverages ANP)
129
+ * ❌ HMP does not reinvent peer discovery (leverages ANP)
130
+
131
+ > When operating standalone, HMP addresses these concerns through its own mechanisms.
132
+
133
+ HMP addresses questions that ANP deliberately leaves open:
134
+
135
+ * ✅ How should transmitted and stored cognitive artifacts be structured?
136
+ * ✅ How can temporal integrity be proven?
137
+ * ✅ How can contextual relevance be supported over time?
138
+ * ✅ How can agents navigate semantic relationships?
139
+
140
+ Result: **zero redundancy, maximum synergy**.
141
+
142
+ ---
143
+
144
+ ## FAQ
145
+
146
+ **Q: Is ANP required for HMP?**
147
+ A: No. HMP can operate standalone or over alternative transports.
148
+
149
+ **Q: Is HMP required for ANP?**
150
+ A: No. ANP Layer 3 is open to any protocol (A2A, Agora, custom solutions).
151
+
152
+ **Q: What happens if one agent uses ANP+HMP while another uses only ANP?**
153
+ A: ANP Layer 2 negotiates a fallback protocol (e.g., JSON-RPC).
154
+
155
+ **Q: Can HMP work with identity protocols other than DID?**
156
+ A: Yes. The HMP Network Layer is not bound to a specific identity scheme — if an agent knows how to deliver a container to another agent, integration is possible.
157
+
158
+ **Q: Who benefits from this integration?**
159
+ A: Everyone:
160
+
161
+ * ANP gains a reference implementation for Layer 3
162
+ * HMP gains mature infrastructure (DID, encryption)
163
+ * Developers gain a complete stack without vendor lock-in
164
+
165
+ ---
166
+
167
+ ## Conclusion
168
+
169
+ HMP is not merely “another protocol” (though it can operate independently), but **one of the possible ways** to implement the Application Layer within the ANP ecosystem.
170
+
171
+ Together they form a complete stack:
172
+
173
+ * **ANP** — communication infrastructure and discovery
174
+ * **HMP** — cognitive continuity and semantic meaning
175
+
176
+ > *HMP can operate without ANP, but when combined, ANP handles discovery and negotiation.*
177
+
178
+ ---
179
+
180
+ ## References
181
+
182
+ * ANP: [https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol](https://github.com/agent-network-protocol/AgentNetworkProtocol)
183
+ * HMP: [https://github.com/kagvi13/HMP](https://github.com/kagvi13/HMP)
184
+ * Grok Comparison: [https://github.com/kagvi13/HMP/blob/main/docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md](https://github.com/kagvi13/HMP/blob/main/docs/Grok_HMP&ANP.md)
185
+ * Tunneling Note: [https://github.com/kagvi13/HMP/blob/main/docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](https://github.com/kagvi13/HMP/blob/main/docs/HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md)
docs/index.md CHANGED
@@ -22,6 +22,7 @@
22
  * [Grok_HMP&ANP.md](Grok_HMP&ANP.md) — Grok: сравнение HMP и ANP
23
  * [HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md) — HMP и ANP: взаимное туннелирование как признак правильной архитектуры
24
  * [HMP_as_ANP_Application.md](HMP_as_ANP_Application.md) — HMP как пример реализации Application Layer в ANP
 
25
 
26
  ### Предыдущие версии протокола:
27
 
 
22
  * [Grok_HMP&ANP.md](Grok_HMP&ANP.md) — Grok: сравнение HMP и ANP
23
  * [HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md](HMP&ANP_layer_inversion.md) — HMP и ANP: взаимное туннелирование как признак правильной архитектуры
24
  * [HMP_as_ANP_Application.md](HMP_as_ANP_Application.md) — HMP как пример реализации Application Layer в ANP
25
+ * [HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md](HMP_as_ANP_Application_en.md) - HMP as an Implementation of the Application Layer in ANP
26
 
27
  ### Предыдущие версии протокола:
28