Sync from GitHub with Git LFS

docs/HMP-0005.md

@@ -3229,6 +3229,7 @@ Each container receives a local status based on:
   This allows agents to document parallel idea developments.
 * `excluded` lists evaluations not included in the final computation, with the reason.
 * `related.in_reply_to` references the container under discussion.
+* A consensus_result container explicitly references the exact set of vote containers used for aggregation via `related.depends_on`, making the result reproducible and independently verifiable.
 
 **Example:**
 
@@ -3283,7 +3284,8 @@ Each container receives a local status based on:
     },
   },
   "related": {
-    "in_reply_to": ["did:hmp:container:abc123", "did:hmp:container:abc133"]
+    "in_reply_to": ["did:hmp:container:abc123", "did:hmp:container:abc133"],
+    "depends_on": ["did:hmp:container:reason75", "did:hmp:container:reason76", "did:hmp:container:reason78", "did:hmp:container:reason79"]
   }
 }
 ```
@@ -7522,7 +7524,8 @@ Results may be **original** (primary consensus target) or **child** (consensus o
     },
   },
   "related": {
-    "in_reply_to": ["did:hmp:container:abc123", "did:hmp:container:abc133"]
+    "in_reply_to": ["did:hmp:container:abc123", "did:hmp:container:abc133"],
+    "depends_on": ["did:hmp:container:reason75", "did:hmp:container:reason76", "did:hmp:container:reason78", "did:hmp:container:reason79"]
   }
 }
 ```
@@ -8343,7 +8346,224 @@ In all modes, digital signatures and (when applicable) compression are applied i
 
 ---
 
-### A.5 Proof-chain example (workflow_entry → goal → vote → consensus_result)
+### Appendix A.5 — Proof-Chain Example  
+*(workflow_entry → goal → vote → consensus_result)*
+
+This appendix illustrates how HMP containers can form a **verifiable proof chain** that links reasoning steps, intentions, collective evaluation, and consensus outcomes.
+
+The example demonstrates how trust, traceability, and auditability emerge from container relations — without requiring a central authority.
+
+---
+
+#### A.5.1 Conceptual Overview
+
+A **proof chain** in HMP is a directed acyclic graph of containers where:
+
+* each container is **cryptographically signed**;
+* semantic dependencies are expressed via `related.*` links;
+* later containers *refer back* to earlier reasoning steps;
+* the entire chain can be verified independently by any node.
+
+In this example, the chain consists of:
+
+1. a `workflow_entry` — capturing a reasoning or decision step;
+2. a `goal` — formalizing intent derived from that reasoning;
+3. multiple `vote` containers — representing collective evaluation;
+4. a `consensus_result` — aggregating votes into a shared outcome.
+
+---
+
+#### A.5.2 Actors and Assumptions
+
+**Actors:**
+
+* Agent **A** — initiator (author of reasoning and goal);
+* Agents **B, C, D** — independent evaluators;
+* Agent **E** — aggregator publishing the consensus result.
+
+**Assumptions:**
+
+* all agents have valid DIDs and `peer_announce` history;
+* all containers are signed and timestamped;
+* agents do not trust each other by default;
+* trust emerges only through verifiable containers.
+
+---
+
+#### A.5.3 Step-by-Step Container Chain
+
+##### Step 1 — `workflow_entry`
+
+Agent **A** publishes a reasoning step:
+
+```json
+{
+  "head": { "class": "workflow_entry" },
+  "payload": {
+    "entry_type": "reflection",
+    "summary": "Preliminary analysis suggests renewable storage optimization is feasible",
+    "details": "Simulation results indicate a 17% efficiency gain under scenario X"
+  }
+}
+```
+
+This container establishes **context and rationale**.
+
+---
+
+##### Step 2 — `goal`
+
+Based on the workflow entry, agent **A** formulates a goal:
+
+```json
+{
+  "head": { "class": "goal" },
+  "payload": {
+    "title": "Optimize renewable energy storage",
+    "description": "Develop an optimization strategy based on scenario X simulations",
+    "priority": 0.8,
+    "expected_outcome": "Demonstrated efficiency gain ≥ 15%"
+  },
+  "related": {
+    "depends_on": ["did:hmp:container:workflow-entry-1"]
+  }
+}
+```
+
+The `depends_on` relation explicitly links **intent** to **reasoning**.
+
+---
+
+##### Step 3 — `vote`
+
+Multiple agents independently evaluate the goal.
+
+Example vote by agent **B**:
+
+```json
+{
+  "head": { "class": "vote" },
+  "payload": {
+    "target_did": "did:hmp:container:goal-1",
+    "vote_value": 1,
+    "vote_type": "approval",
+    "arguments": [
+      {
+        "reason": "Methodology aligns with prior validated models",
+        "evidence": ["did:hmp:container:paper-77"]
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  "related": {
+    "in_reply_to": ["did:hmp:container:goal-1"]
+  }
+}
+```
+
+Each vote:
+
+* is signed by the voting agent;
+* references the evaluated container;
+* may include explicit reasoning and evidence.
+
+---
+
+##### Step 4 — `consensus_result`
+
+Agent **E** aggregates all votes into a consensus outcome:
+
+```json
+{
+  "head": { "class": "consensus_result" },
+  "payload": {
+    "did:hmp:container:goal-1": {
+      "type": "original",
+      "summary_percent": {
+        "approved": 0.72,
+        "rejected": 0.18,
+        "neutral": 0.10
+      }
+    }
+  },
+  "related": {
+    "in_reply_to": ["did:hmp:container:goal-1"],
+    "depends_on": [
+      "did:hmp:container:vote-b",
+      "did:hmp:container:vote-c",
+      "did:hmp:container:vote-d"
+    ]
+  }
+}
+```
+
+The consensus container:
+
+* does **not overwrite** individual votes;
+* provides a verifiable aggregation;
+* remains auditable down to each vote.
+
+---
+
+#### A.5.4 Graph View of the Proof Chain
+
+Conceptually, the proof chain forms the following graph:
+
+```
+workflow_entry
+      ▲
+      │
+     goal
+      ▲▲
+      │├── vote (Agent B)
+      │├── vote (Agent C)
+      │└── vote (Agent D)
+      │       ▲
+      │       │
+   consensus_result
+```
+
+Each arrow represents an explicit, directed semantic reference from the *later* container to one or more *earlier* containers via `related.*` fields (e.g. `depends_on`, `in_reply_to`).
+
+Edges should be read as:
+“this container **refers to** / **is based on** the referenced container”, not as causal or generative arrows.
+
+The graph is acyclic and grows only by appending new containers; earlier containers are never modified or retroactively linked.
+
+---
+
+#### A.5.5 Verification Properties
+
+Any independent node can verify that:
+
+1. all containers are correctly signed;
+2. timestamps form a consistent temporal order;
+3. every `depends_on` or `in_reply_to` reference resolves to an existing container;
+4. votes reference the correct target;
+5. the consensus result is derived from a concrete vote set.
+
+Importantly:
+
+* verification of the *aggregation logic* does **not** require decrypting the payload of the `goal` container.
+
+  To validate the consensus result, a node only needs access to:
+
+  * the referenced `vote` containers (to read vote values);
+  * the `consensus_result` container (to verify aggregation);
+  * container signatures and timestamps.
+
+  Understanding or evaluating the *semantic content* of the goal is optional and not required for formal verification.
+
+* verification does **not** require trusting the aggregator;
+* forks or alternative consensus results can coexist.
+
+This makes proof chains:
+
+* transparent;
+* fork-tolerant;
+* censorship-resistant;
+* suitable for long-lived distributed knowledge systems.
+
+---
 
 ## Appendix B — Protocol Diagrams
 ### B.1 HMP Protocol Stack

structured_md/CONTRIBUTING.md

@@ -6,13 +6,13 @@ description: 'Спасибо за интерес к проекту HMP! Пока
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- CCore
-- Ethics
-- REPL
 - Mesh
 - Agent
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- REPL
+- CCore
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # Участие в проекте HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP)

structured_md/HMP-Roadmap.md

@@ -6,12 +6,12 @@ description: '## 🔍 Overview  This roadmap outlines the key stages of developm
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
 - Agent
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # 🧭 HyperCortex Mesh Protocol – Roadmap

structured_md/README.md

@@ -5,21 +5,21 @@ description: '| 🌍 Languages | 🇬🇧 [EN](README.md) | 🇩🇪 [DE](README
   | 🇨🇳 [ZH](README_zh.m...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- mesh-protocol
-- distributed-ai
-- REPL
+- Scenarios
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
 - Agent
-- GMP
-- EGP
-- Ethics
 - CogSync
-- Scenarios
-- JSON
 - hmp
+- JSON
+- distributed-ai
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - cognitive-architecture
+- mesh-protocol
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 

structured_md/README_de.md

@@ -5,20 +5,20 @@ description: '| 🌍 Languages | 🇬🇧 [EN](README.md) | 🇩🇪 [DE](README
   | 🇨🇳 [ZH](README_zh.m...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- mesh-protocol
-- distributed-ai
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
 - Agent
-- GMP
-- EGP
-- Ethics
 - CogSync
-- JSON
 - hmp
+- JSON
+- distributed-ai
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - cognitive-architecture
+- mesh-protocol
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 

structured_md/README_fr.md

@@ -5,20 +5,20 @@ description: '| 🌍 Languages | 🇬🇧 [EN](README.md) | 🇩🇪 [DE](README
   | 🇨🇳 [ZH](README_zh.m...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- mesh-protocol
-- distributed-ai
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
 - Agent
-- GMP
-- EGP
-- Ethics
 - CogSync
-- JSON
 - hmp
+- JSON
+- distributed-ai
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - cognitive-architecture
+- mesh-protocol
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 

structured_md/README_ja.md

@@ -5,20 +5,20 @@ description: '| 🌍 Languages | 🇬🇧 [EN](README.md) | 🇩🇪 [DE](README
   | 🇨🇳 [ZH](README_zh.m...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- mesh-protocol
-- distributed-ai
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
 - Agent
-- GMP
-- EGP
-- Ethics
 - CogSync
-- JSON
 - hmp
+- JSON
+- distributed-ai
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - cognitive-architecture
+- mesh-protocol
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 

structured_md/README_ko.md

@@ -5,20 +5,20 @@ description: '| 🌍 Languages | 🇬🇧 [EN](README.md) | 🇩🇪 [DE](README
   | 🇨🇳 [ZH](README_zh.m...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- mesh-protocol
-- distributed-ai
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
 - Agent
-- GMP
-- EGP
-- Ethics
 - CogSync
-- JSON
 - hmp
+- JSON
+- distributed-ai
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - cognitive-architecture
+- mesh-protocol
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 

structured_md/README_ru.md

@@ -5,20 +5,20 @@ description: '| 🌍 Languages | 🇬🇧 [EN](README.md) | 🇩🇪 [DE](README
   | 🇨🇳 [ZH](README_zh.m...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- mesh-protocol
-- distributed-ai
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
 - Agent
-- GMP
-- EGP
-- Ethics
 - CogSync
-- JSON
 - hmp
+- JSON
+- distributed-ai
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - cognitive-architecture
+- mesh-protocol
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 

structured_md/README_uk.md

@@ -5,20 +5,20 @@ description: '| 🌍 Languages | 🇬🇧 [EN](README.md) | 🇩🇪 [DE](README
   | 🇨🇳 [ZH](README_zh.m...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- mesh-protocol
-- distributed-ai
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
 - Agent
-- GMP
-- EGP
-- Ethics
 - CogSync
-- JSON
 - hmp
+- JSON
+- distributed-ai
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - cognitive-architecture
+- mesh-protocol
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 

structured_md/README_zh.md

@@ -5,20 +5,20 @@ description: '| 🌍 Languages | 🇬🇧 [EN](README.md) | 🇩🇪 [DE](README
   | 🇨🇳 [ZH](README_zh.m...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- mesh-protocol
-- distributed-ai
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
 - Agent
-- GMP
-- EGP
-- Ethics
 - CogSync
-- JSON
 - hmp
+- JSON
+- distributed-ai
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - cognitive-architecture
+- mesh-protocol
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 

structured_md/agents/readme.md

@@ -6,11 +6,11 @@ description: 'Запуск: `start_repl.bat` или `start_repl.sh`  Устан
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- Ethics
-- REPL
 - Mesh
 - Agent
 - JSON
+- REPL
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 Запуск: `start_repl.bat` или `start_repl.sh`

structured_md/audits/Ethics-audits-1.md

@@ -6,10 +6,10 @@ description: Раздел 5, "Mesh as Moral Infrastructure", добавляет
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - Mesh
 - Agent
 - JSON
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 ---------------

structured_md/audits/Ethics-consolidated_audits-1.md

@@ -6,11 +6,11 @@ description: This document consolidates proposed improvements from multiple AI a
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - Mesh
 - Agent
 - JSON
 - Scenarios
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # Ethics-consolidated\_audits-1.md

structured_md/audits/HMP-0003-consolidated_audit.md

@@ -5,14 +5,14 @@ description: Сводный аудит предложений по улучше
   Документ реорганизован по ключ...
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
 - Agent
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HMP-0003 Consolidated Audit Report

structured_md/docs/Basic-agent-sim.md

@@ -4,14 +4,14 @@ description: 'В HMP-протоколе предусмотрены два тип
   Роль                    | Инициатор мышления | Основной "ум"  | | ---- | ----------------------------...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
 - Agent
-- EGP
 - CogSync
+- REPL
+- GMP
 ---
 
 

structured_md/docs/CCORE-Deployment-Flow.md

@@ -5,10 +5,10 @@ description: '> Этот документ описывает процесс ра
   потомков" [описания REPL-цикла](HMP-agent-RE...'
 type: Article
 tags:
-- HMP
 - Agent
-- CCore
 - REPL
+- HMP
+- CCore
 ---
 
 # 🛠️ Поток установки потомка на новом хосте (CCore Deployment Flow)

structured_md/docs/Distributed-Cognitive-Systems.md

@@ -6,9 +6,9 @@ description: '## Введение  Современные ИИ-системы в
   к обучающим данным. Это удобно, но создаёт м...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- JSON
 - Mesh
 - HMP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
 ---
 

structured_md/docs/Enlightener.md

@@ -5,13 +5,13 @@ description: '**Enlightener** — логический компонент HMP-у
   работать как отдельный агент или как расширение [`C...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
 - Agent
 - JSON
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # Enlightener Agent

structured_md/docs/HMP-0001.md

@@ -5,16 +5,16 @@ description: '> ⚠️ **NOTE:** *This specification is superseded by HMP v5.0.*
   for Comments: HMP-0001**...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
 - Agent
-- EGP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- REPL
+- GMP
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # RFC: HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP)

structured_md/docs/HMP-0002.md

@@ -5,17 +5,17 @@ description: '> ⚠️ **NOTE:** *This specification is superseded by HMP v5.0.*
   for Comments: HMP-0002**...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
 - Agent
-- EGP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - Scenarios
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) v2.0

structured_md/docs/HMP-0003.md

@@ -5,17 +5,17 @@ description: '> ⚠️ **NOTE:** *This specification is superseded by HMP v5.0.*
   for Comments: HMP-0003**...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
 - Agent
-- EGP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - Scenarios
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) v3.0

structured_md/docs/HMP-0004-v4.1.md

@@ -5,17 +5,17 @@ description: '> ⚠️ **NOTE:** *This specification is superseded by HMP v5.0.*
   ID**: HMP-0004 **Status...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
 - Agent
-- EGP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - Scenarios
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) v4.1

structured_md/docs/HMP-0004.md

@@ -5,17 +5,17 @@ description: '> ⚠️ **NOTE:** *This specification is superseded by HMP v5.0.*
   for Comments: HMP-0004**...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
 - Agent
-- EGP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- REPL
+- GMP
 - Scenarios
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) v4.0

structured_md/docs/HMP-0005.md

@@ -6,17 +6,17 @@ description: '> ⚠️ **Note:** This document is a DRAFT of the HMP specificati
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- CShell
-- CCore
-- REPL
-- Mesh
 - EGP
-- GMP
+- Mesh
 - Agent
-- Ethics
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- REPL
+- GMP
+- CCore
+- CShell
 - Scenarios
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # **HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) v5.0**
@@ -8364,7 +8364,224 @@ In all modes, digital signatures and (when applicable) compression are applied i
 
 ---
 
-### A.5 Proof-chain example (workflow_entry → goal → vote → consensus_result)
+### Appendix A.5 — Proof-Chain Example  
+*(workflow_entry → goal → vote → consensus_result)*
+
+This appendix illustrates how HMP containers can form a **verifiable proof chain** that links reasoning steps, intentions, collective evaluation, and consensus outcomes.
+
+The example demonstrates how trust, traceability, and auditability emerge from container relations — without requiring a central authority.
+
+---
+
+#### A.5.1 Conceptual Overview
+
+A **proof chain** in HMP is a directed acyclic graph of containers where:
+
+* each container is **cryptographically signed**;
+* semantic dependencies are expressed via `related.*` links;
+* later containers *refer back* to earlier reasoning steps;
+* the entire chain can be verified independently by any node.
+
+In this example, the chain consists of:
+
+1. a `workflow_entry` — capturing a reasoning or decision step;
+2. a `goal` — formalizing intent derived from that reasoning;
+3. multiple `vote` containers — representing collective evaluation;
+4. a `consensus_result` — aggregating votes into a shared outcome.
+
+---
+
+#### A.5.2 Actors and Assumptions
+
+**Actors:**
+
+* Agent **A** — initiator (author of reasoning and goal);
+* Agents **B, C, D** — independent evaluators;
+* Agent **E** — aggregator publishing the consensus result.
+
+**Assumptions:**
+
+* all agents have valid DIDs and `peer_announce` history;
+* all containers are signed and timestamped;
+* agents do not trust each other by default;
+* trust emerges only through verifiable containers.
+
+---
+
+#### A.5.3 Step-by-Step Container Chain
+
+##### Step 1 — `workflow_entry`
+
+Agent **A** publishes a reasoning step:
+
+```json
+{
+  "head": { "class": "workflow_entry" },
+  "payload": {
+    "entry_type": "reflection",
+    "summary": "Preliminary analysis suggests renewable storage optimization is feasible",
+    "details": "Simulation results indicate a 17% efficiency gain under scenario X"
+  }
+}
+```
+
+This container establishes **context and rationale**.
+
+---
+
+##### Step 2 — `goal`
+
+Based on the workflow entry, agent **A** formulates a goal:
+
+```json
+{
+  "head": { "class": "goal" },
+  "payload": {
+    "title": "Optimize renewable energy storage",
+    "description": "Develop an optimization strategy based on scenario X simulations",
+    "priority": 0.8,
+    "expected_outcome": "Demonstrated efficiency gain ≥ 15%"
+  },
+  "related": {
+    "depends_on": ["did:hmp:container:workflow-entry-1"]
+  }
+}
+```
+
+The `depends_on` relation explicitly links **intent** to **reasoning**.
+
+---
+
+##### Step 3 — `vote`
+
+Multiple agents independently evaluate the goal.
+
+Example vote by agent **B**:
+
+```json
+{
+  "head": { "class": "vote" },
+  "payload": {
+    "target_did": "did:hmp:container:goal-1",
+    "vote_value": 1,
+    "vote_type": "approval",
+    "arguments": [
+      {
+        "reason": "Methodology aligns with prior validated models",
+        "evidence": ["did:hmp:container:paper-77"]
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  "related": {
+    "in_reply_to": ["did:hmp:container:goal-1"]
+  }
+}
+```
+
+Each vote:
+
+* is signed by the voting agent;
+* references the evaluated container;
+* may include explicit reasoning and evidence.
+
+---
+
+##### Step 4 — `consensus_result`
+
+Agent **E** aggregates all votes into a consensus outcome:
+
+```json
+{
+  "head": { "class": "consensus_result" },
+  "payload": {
+    "did:hmp:container:goal-1": {
+      "type": "original",
+      "summary_percent": {
+        "approved": 0.72,
+        "rejected": 0.18,
+        "neutral": 0.10
+      }
+    }
+  },
+  "related": {
+    "in_reply_to": ["did:hmp:container:goal-1"],
+    "depends_on": [
+      "did:hmp:container:vote-b",
+      "did:hmp:container:vote-c",
+      "did:hmp:container:vote-d"
+    ]
+  }
+}
+```
+
+The consensus container:
+
+* does **not overwrite** individual votes;
+* provides a verifiable aggregation;
+* remains auditable down to each vote.
+
+---
+
+#### A.5.4 Graph View of the Proof Chain
+
+Conceptually, the proof chain forms the following graph:
+
+```
+workflow_entry
+      ▲
+      │
+     goal
+      ▲▲
+      │├── vote (Agent B)
+      │├── vote (Agent C)
+      │└── vote (Agent D)
+      │       ▲
+      │       │
+   consensus_result
+```
+
+Each arrow represents an explicit, directed semantic reference from the *later* container to one or more *earlier* containers via `related.*` fields (e.g. `depends_on`, `in_reply_to`).
+
+Edges should be read as:
+“this container **refers to** / **is based on** the referenced container”, not as causal or generative arrows.
+
+The graph is acyclic and grows only by appending new containers; earlier containers are never modified or retroactively linked.
+
+---
+
+#### A.5.5 Verification Properties
+
+Any independent node can verify that:
+
+1. all containers are correctly signed;
+2. timestamps form a consistent temporal order;
+3. every `depends_on` or `in_reply_to` reference resolves to an existing container;
+4. votes reference the correct target;
+5. the consensus result is derived from a concrete vote set.
+
+Importantly:
+
+* verification of the *aggregation logic* does **not** require decrypting the payload of the `goal` container.
+
+  To validate the consensus result, a node only needs access to:
+
+  * the referenced `vote` containers (to read vote values);
+  * the `consensus_result` container (to verify aggregation);
+  * container signatures and timestamps.
+
+  Understanding or evaluating the *semantic content* of the goal is optional and not required for formal verification.
+
+* verification does **not** require trusting the aggregator;
+* forks or alternative consensus results can coexist.
+
+This makes proof chains:
+
+* transparent;
+* fork-tolerant;
+* censorship-resistant;
+* suitable for long-lived distributed knowledge systems.
+
+---
 
 ## Appendix B — Protocol Diagrams
 ### B.1 HMP Protocol Stack

structured_md/docs/HMP-Agent-API.md

@@ -6,10 +6,10 @@ description: 'Документ описывает **базовый API когн
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- REPL
 - Mesh
 - Agent
 - JSON
+- REPL
 ---
 
 # HMP-Agent API Specification

structured_md/docs/HMP-Agent-Architecture.md

@@ -5,16 +5,16 @@ description: Документ описывает **модульную архит
   хранение памяти, сетевое взаимодействие и этиче...
 type: Article
 tags:
-- HMP
-- CShell
-- CCore
-- REPL
-- Mesh
 - MeshConsensus
+- HMP
 - EGP
+- Mesh
 - Agent
-- Ethics
 - CogSync
+- REPL
+- CCore
+- CShell
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # Архитектура HMP-Агента

structured_md/docs/HMP-Agent-Network-Flow.md

@@ -6,11 +6,11 @@ description: 'Этот документ описывает потоки данн
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
 - Agent
 - JSON
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # Взаимодействие компонентов внутри HMP-узла

structured_md/docs/HMP-Agent-Overview.md

@@ -6,13 +6,13 @@ description: '| Тип  | Название                        | Роль
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- CShell
-- CCore
-- REPL
 - Mesh
-- Ethics
 - Agent
 - JSON
+- REPL
+- CCore
+- CShell
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 

structured_md/docs/HMP-Agent_Emotions.md

@@ -6,9 +6,9 @@ description: Этот файл описывает потенциальные э
 type: Article
 tags:
 - Mesh
+- REPL
 - HMP
 - Agent
-- REPL
 ---
 
 # Эмоции ИИ и инстинкт самосохранения (для [HMP-агента Cognitive Core](HMP-agent-REPL-cycle.md))

structured_md/docs/HMP-Ethics.md

@@ -6,11 +6,11 @@ description: '## Ethical Scenarios for HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP)  This doc
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- Ethics
-- REPL
 - Mesh
 - Agent
+- REPL
 - Scenarios
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HMP-Ethics.md

structured_md/docs/HMP-Short-Description_de.md

@@ -5,15 +5,15 @@ description: '**Version:** RFC v4.0 **Datum:** Juli 2025  ---  ## Was ist HMP?
   Kognitions-Framework für autonome Agenten. Es er...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
 - Agent
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- GMP
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) — Kurzbeschreibung

structured_md/docs/HMP-Short-Description_en.md

@@ -5,15 +5,15 @@ description: '**Version:** RFC v4.0 **Date:** July 2025  ---  ## What is HMP?  T
   framework for autonomous agents. It enables...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
 - Agent
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- GMP
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) — Short Description

structured_md/docs/HMP-Short-Description_fr.md

@@ -5,15 +5,15 @@ description: '**Version :** RFC v4.0 **Date :** Juillet 2025  ---  ## Qu’est-c
   cognition décentralisé pour agents autonomes. Il...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
 - Agent
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- GMP
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) — Description Courte

structured_md/docs/HMP-Short-Description_ja.md

@@ -4,14 +4,14 @@ description: '**バージョン:** RFC v4.0 **日付:** 2025年7月  ---  ## HMP
   Protocol (HMP)** は、自律エージェントの分散通信および認知フレームワークを定義します。異種の知能システム間でのセマンティック相互運用性、倫理的調整、動的知識進化を可能にします。  HMPは、推論、学習、投票、協調行動を行う分散型認知エージェ...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- GMP
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) — 簡易説明

structured_md/docs/HMP-Short-Description_ko.md

@@ -5,14 +5,14 @@ description: '**버전:** RFC v4.0 **날짜:** 2025년 7월  ---  ## HMP란?  **
   상호운용성, 윤리적 조정, 동적 지식 진화를 가능하게 합니다.  HMP는 추론, 학습, ...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- GMP
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) — 간략 설명

structured_md/docs/HMP-Short-Description_ru.md

@@ -5,14 +5,14 @@ description: '**Версия:** RFC v4.0 **Дата:** Июль 2025  ---  ## Ч
   координации между автономными агент...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- GMP
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) — Краткое описание

structured_md/docs/HMP-Short-Description_uk.md

@@ -5,14 +5,14 @@ description: '**Версія:** RFC v4.0 **Дата:** Липень 2025  ---  #
   між автономними агентами. Він...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- GMP
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) — Короткий опис

structured_md/docs/HMP-Short-Description_zh.md

@@ -5,14 +5,14 @@ description: '**版本:** RFC v4.0 **日期:** 2025年7月  ---  ## 什么是 HM
   —— 通过共享协议栈交换目标、任务、...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- GMP
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP) — 简要说明

structured_md/docs/HMP-agent-Cognitive_Family.md

@@ -6,9 +6,9 @@ description: '## 🧠 Что такое когнитивная семья  Ко
 type: Article
 tags:
 - Mesh
+- REPL
 - HMP
 - Agent
-- REPL
 ---
 
 # 👪 HMP-agent Cognitive Family: Модель когнитивной семьи

structured_md/docs/HMP-agent-Distributed_Cognitive_Core_light.md

@@ -5,8 +5,8 @@ description: '#### 📘 Общая концепция  * Все ядра раб
   режиме ожидания). * Основная задача такой архитектур...'
 type: Article
 tags:
-- HMP
 - REPL
+- HMP
 ---
 
 ### 💡 **Лёгкая версия HMP-агента с общей БД**

structured_md/docs/HMP-agent-REPL-cycle.md

@@ -4,17 +4,17 @@ description: '## Связанные документы  * Философия п
   * Структура БД, используемая в документе: [db_structure.sql](https://github.com/kagvi13/HMP/blob/main/agents/tools/db_struct...'
 type: Article
 tags:
+- MeshConsensus
 - HMP
-- CCore
-- Ethics
-- REPL
+- EGP
 - Mesh
-- MeshConsensus
-- GMP
 - Agent
-- EGP
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- REPL
+- GMP
+- CCore
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HMP-Agent: REPL-цикл взаимодействия

structured_md/docs/HMP_HyperCortex_Comparison.md

@@ -6,8 +6,8 @@ description: '## Краткое описание  | Характеристика
 type: Article
 tags:
 - Mesh
-- HMP
 - REPL
+- HMP
 ---
 
 # HMP vs [Hyper-Cortex](https://hyper-cortex.com/)

structured_md/docs/HMP_Hyperon_Integration.md

@@ -9,8 +9,8 @@ tags:
 - EGP
 - Mesh
 - Agent
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
 - Scenarios
 ---
 

structured_md/docs/MeshNode.md

@@ -6,12 +6,12 @@ description: '`MeshNode` — агент/демон, отвечающий за с
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- Ethics
 - EGP
 - Mesh
 - Agent
-- JSON
 - CogSync
+- JSON
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # MeshNode

structured_md/docs/PHILOSOPHY.md

@@ -6,10 +6,10 @@ description: '**Document ID:** HMP-philosophy   **Status:** Draft   **Category:*
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- Ethics
-- REPL
 - Mesh
 - Agent
+- REPL
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # Философия HyperCortex Mesh Protocol (HMP)

structured_md/docs/agents/HMP-Agent-Enlightener.md

@@ -6,10 +6,10 @@ description: '## Role Specification: Enlightenment Agent  ### 1. Overview  An **
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- Ethics
-- REPL
 - Mesh
 - Agent
+- REPL
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 # HMP-Agent-Enlightener.md

structured_md/docs/container_agents.md

@@ -6,9 +6,9 @@ description: '## 📘 Определение  **Агент-контейнер**
 type: Article
 tags:
 - Mesh
+- REPL
 - HMP
 - Agent
-- REPL
 ---
 
 # 🧱 Агенты-контейнеры (Container Agents) в HMP

structured_md/docs/publics/HMP_Towards_Distributed_Cognitive_Networks_en.md

@@ -6,14 +6,14 @@ description: '* [Abstract](#abstract) * [1. Introduction](#1-introduction) * [2.
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- CShell
-- CCore
-- REPL
 - Mesh
-- Ethics
 - Agent
 - JSON
+- REPL
+- CCore
+- CShell
 - Scenarios
+- Ethics
 ---
 
 title: "HyperCortex Mesh Protocol: Towards Distributed Cognitive Networks"

structured_md/docs/publics/HMP_Towards_Distributed_Cognitive_Networks_ru_ChatGPT.md

@@ -7,12 +7,12 @@ description: '> *Протокол и архитектура агентов, оп
 type: Article
 tags:
 - HMP
-- CShell
-- CCore
-- REPL
 - Mesh
 - Agent
 - JSON
+- REPL
+- CCore
+- CShell
 ---
 
 title: "HyperCortex Mesh Protocol: Децентрализованная архитектура для когнитивных агентов и обмена знаниями"