artifacts/patent_substantivity_tuple_review.json

{
  "accepted_property_counts": {},
  "accepted_tuple_count": 0,
  "accepted_with_poucher_cas_overlap": 0,
  "action_counts": {
    "reject": 41
  },
  "backend": "hermes",
  "candidate_input": "data/patent_substantivity_phase0_candidates.jsonl",
  "failure_count": 0,
  "failures": [],
  "go_no_go": "NO-GO for Poucher-aligned training merge; reviewed tuples do not yet establish CAS overlap with Poucher",
  "model": "",
  "outputs": {
    "audit_jsonl": "artifacts/patent_substantivity_tuple_review.jsonl",
    "reviewed_tuples": "data/patent_substantivity_reviewed_tuples.jsonl",
    "summary_json": "artifacts/patent_substantivity_tuple_review.json",
    "summary_md": "artifacts/patent_substantivity_tuple_review.md"
  },
  "phase": "patent_tuple_llm_review",
  "policy": "Proposed-only patent tuple review; no Poucher, model-ready target, training, or publish artifacts are mutated.",
  "processed_count": 41,
  "rejection_counts": {
    "48-hour effect is for a formulation/concentrate with additional components, not a measured value for cis-3-hexenol alone.": 1,
    "Background citations and composition descriptions; no measured tuple for exactly one molecule.": 1,
    "Background definition and citations; values are generic note-class ranges, not measured for one compound.": 1,
    "Background discussion of formulation goals, not a measured tuple for one molecule.": 1,
    "Background statement and patent citation; no single compound or measured outcome.": 1,
    "Composition definition with concentration thresholds and generic carrier properties; no measured tuple for one molecule.": 1,
    "Composition percentage range, not a measured substantivity outcome for a single compound.": 1,
    "Formulation/system application interval claim; no single molecule or measured substantivity outcome.": 1,
    "Fragmentary claim threshold with no compound identity, method, or measured tuple.": 1,
    "General sensory test method for compositions and controls; no single compound identity or measured result.": 1,
    "Generic claim for compounds 1 to 8 without identity, measured value, units, substrate, or method.": 1,
    "Generic claim threshold with no molecule identity or method/substrate.": 2,
    "Generic class of cis-3-hexenol esters with claimed thresholds; no exact compound identity or measured method.": 1,
    "Generic composition/control method with no named single molecule and no numeric measured outcome.": 1,
    "Generic definition of long-lasting scenting effect without compound identity or measured tuple.": 1,
    "Generic group claim for compounds 1 to 4 without single identity or measured value.": 1,
    "Generic heavy alcohol class claim; no single molecule identity or measured tuple.": 1,
    "Generic mixture/component claim with concentration ranges and thresholds; no single named compound or measured tuple.": 1,
    "Generic odoriferous material characterization; no single molecule identity or measured tuple.": 1,
    "Generic odoriferous material class; no named single molecule or measured result.": 2,
    "Method claim for a composition; no single molecule identity or measured value.": 1,
    "Multiple exemplary compounds share generic threshold ranges; no measured value for exactly one molecule.": 1,
    "Names one compound but provides no measured value, units, substrate, or method in the excerpt.": 1,
    "Only a table caption; no compound identity, measured value, units, substrate, or method.": 1,
    "Persistence claim for a formulation on artificial grass, not one identified molecule.": 1,
    "Scale definition only; no compound identity or measured score.": 1,
    "Stated advantages and formulation objectives, not measured data for one molecule.": 1,
    "Table lists many compounds and vapor pressures, not a single-molecule substantivity measurement.": 1,
    "composition with modulator; no numeric intensity value for the molecule": 3,
    "composition-level character retention result, not a measured tuple for one named molecule": 1,
    "composition-level intensity profile with modulator, not a true measured tuple for one molecule alone": 1,
    "composition-level protocol; no single molecule identity or measured result": 1,
    "generic fragrance-material composition statement with data not shown and no single molecule identity": 1,
    "heading/background for compositions and weight percentages, with no single compound outcome": 1,
    "method setup and scale description for compositions, with no compound identity or measured result": 1,
    "method setup only; no compound identity or measured outcome": 1,
    "method setup only; no single molecule identity or measured outcome value": 1
  }
}