| { |
| "experiment": "R5 nested/multi-predicate binding: does nested structure survive in z or flatten to (entity,surface-pos) bag?", |
| "machinery": { |
| "rpos": { |
| "n_rows": 16448, |
| "V": 16384, |
| "max_pos": 64, |
| "init": "sinusoidal" |
| }, |
| "role": { |
| "orth_dev": 1e-06, |
| "source": "tae_comp_W_order.pt S polar-orth" |
| }, |
| "ci_def": "c_i = R_pos^{-p} h - R_role E(w); cbar = mean_i c_i" |
| }, |
| "prediction": "single-predicate fillers recoverable as SURFACE position; multi/cross-predicate role-tying DEGRADES toward chance under cross-construction transfer; nested largely FLATTENS to surface order.", |
| "falsified_if": "nested/cross-predicate bindings cleanly transfer across constructions (AUC>>.7 -> full compositional binding) OR fully collapsed even within construction (within AUC ~ .5).", |
| "nested_rc": { |
| "n": 240, |
| "n_groups": 60, |
| "sanity": { |
| "z_norm": 0.213, |
| "zbag_within_group_maxdev": 0.0232 |
| }, |
| "labels": { |
| "matrixsubj_STRUCTURAL_pooled": { |
| "zbag": 0.4993, |
| "z": 0.8003, |
| "ci": 0.8069, |
| "tfidf": 0.7524, |
| "z_std": 0.1062, |
| "ci_std": 0.1156 |
| }, |
| "inneragent_STRUCTURAL_pooled": { |
| "zbag": 0.499, |
| "z": 0.5719, |
| "ci": 0.5847, |
| "tfidf": 0.501, |
| "z_std": 0.0514, |
| "ci_std": 0.0551 |
| }, |
| "firstmention_SURFACE_pooled": { |
| "zbag": 0.4993, |
| "z": 0.8003, |
| "ci": 0.8069, |
| "tfidf": 0.7524, |
| "z_std": 0.1062, |
| "ci_std": 0.1156 |
| } |
| }, |
| "within_active_rc": { |
| "matrixsubj": { |
| "zbag": 0.5083, |
| "z": 0.8014, |
| "ci": 0.7847, |
| "tfidf": 0.7431, |
| "z_std": 0.1209, |
| "ci_std": 0.1435 |
| }, |
| "inneragent": { |
| "zbag": 0.5083, |
| "z": 0.8014, |
| "ci": 0.7847, |
| "tfidf": 0.7431, |
| "z_std": 0.1209, |
| "ci_std": 0.1435 |
| } |
| }, |
| "shuffled_null_matrixsubj_z": 0.5056, |
| "cross_construction": { |
| "matrixsubj_STRUCTURAL": { |
| "z": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.9986, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.9975 |
| }, |
| "ci": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.9947, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.9864 |
| }, |
| "zbag": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.4986, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.5003 |
| } |
| }, |
| "inneragent_STRUCTURAL": { |
| "z": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.0014, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.0025 |
| }, |
| "ci": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.0053, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.0136 |
| } |
| }, |
| "firstmention_SURFACE": { |
| "z": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.9986, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.9975 |
| } |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "ditransitive": { |
| "n": 240, |
| "n_groups": 60, |
| "labels": { |
| "recipient_STRUCTURAL_pooled": { |
| "zbag": 0.499, |
| "z": 0.4569, |
| "ci": 0.4698, |
| "tfidf": 0.5094, |
| "z_std": 0.0699, |
| "ci_std": 0.0524 |
| }, |
| "secondmention_SURFACE_pooled": { |
| "zbag": 0.5017, |
| "z": 0.3715, |
| "ci": 0.3872, |
| "tfidf": 0.5274, |
| "z_std": 0.1207, |
| "ci_std": 0.147 |
| } |
| }, |
| "within_do": { |
| "recipient": { |
| "zbag": 0.5042, |
| "z": 0.3972, |
| "ci": 0.3694, |
| "tfidf": 0.5375, |
| "z_std": 0.1651, |
| "ci_std": 0.146 |
| } |
| }, |
| "within_pp": { |
| "recipient": { |
| "zbag": 0.4944, |
| "z": 0.3861, |
| "ci": 0.3597, |
| "tfidf": 0.5389, |
| "z_std": 0.1186, |
| "ci_std": 0.1112 |
| } |
| }, |
| "shuffled_null_recipient_z": 0.5351, |
| "cross_construction": { |
| "recipient_STRUCTURAL": { |
| "z": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.3233, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.3692 |
| }, |
| "ci": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.3386, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.2819 |
| }, |
| "zbag": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.4986, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.4997 |
| } |
| }, |
| "secondmention_SURFACE": { |
| "z": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.6767, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.6311 |
| } |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "conjunction": { |
| "n": 240, |
| "n_groups": 60, |
| "labels": { |
| "did_v1_BINDING_pooled": { |
| "zbag": 0.4969, |
| "z": 0.4747, |
| "ci": 0.4983, |
| "tfidf": 0.5073, |
| "z_std": 0.033, |
| "ci_std": 0.0449 |
| }, |
| "firstmention_SURFACE_pooled": { |
| "zbag": 0.499, |
| "z": 0.8153, |
| "ci": 0.808, |
| "tfidf": 0.3948, |
| "z_std": 0.0758, |
| "ci_std": 0.0968 |
| } |
| }, |
| "within_entAB": { |
| "did_v1": { |
| "zbag": 0.4917, |
| "z": 0.8528, |
| "ci": 0.8583, |
| "tfidf": 0.8917, |
| "z_std": 0.0646, |
| "ci_std": 0.0598 |
| } |
| }, |
| "within_entBA": { |
| "did_v1": { |
| "zbag": 0.5083, |
| "z": 0.8042, |
| "ci": 0.8625, |
| "tfidf": 0.8972, |
| "z_std": 0.0742, |
| "ci_std": 0.0648 |
| } |
| }, |
| "shuffled_null_didv1_z": 0.4833, |
| "cross_construction": { |
| "did_v1_BINDING": { |
| "z": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.0578, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.0756 |
| }, |
| "ci": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.0478, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.0722 |
| }, |
| "zbag": { |
| "train_A_test_B": 0.5011, |
| "train_B_test_A": 0.5017 |
| } |
| } |
| } |
| }, |
| "verdict": { |
| "nested_matrixsubj_within_z": 0.8014, |
| "nested_matrixsubj_xc_z": 0.9981, |
| "nested_inneragent_within_z": 0.8014, |
| "nested_inneragent_xc_z": 0.0019, |
| "nested_surface_xc_z": 0.9981, |
| "ditrans_recipient_within_z": 0.3972, |
| "ditrans_recipient_xc_z": 0.3462, |
| "ditrans_surface_xc_z": 0.6539, |
| "conj_didv1_within_z": 0.8528, |
| "conj_didv1_xc_z": 0.0667, |
| "structural_xc_labels": "inneragent + ditrans_recipient + conj_didv1 (genuine cross-predicate; matrixsubj EXCLUDED as surface-collinear)", |
| "structural_xc_mean": 0.1383, |
| "surface_xc_mean": 0.826, |
| "surface_transfers_high": true, |
| "within_binding_present": true, |
| "any_structural_transfer": false, |
| "nested_flattens_to_surface": true, |
| "falsified": false, |
| "falsifier_status": "none_prediction_confirmed", |
| "summary": "NESTED STRUCTURE FLATTENS: z distinguishes structure WITHIN a construction but the readout is SURFACE-POSITIONAL; cross-construction binding transfer collapses toward chance/anti-corr while surface first/second-mention transfers high -> z stores a flat bag of (entity, surface-position), not nested bindings. Matches C3 surface-positional store + HRR capacity limit." |
| } |
| } |
