CharlesCNorton
One coordinate comparison per COCO category on EUPE-ViT-B features
8f61e02
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
20.7 kB
{
"provenance": {
"generator": "verify.py",
"pool": "VAL5000",
"split": "val2017",
"n_images": 5000,
"selection": "all 5000 val2017 images, used only to report",
"task": "image-level category presence (binary, one rule per category)",
"protocol": "pairs chosen on train2017, scored here on a class-balanced subsample so chance is 0.5 for every category"
},
"rules": {
"person": {
"cat_id": 1,
"pos_dim": 48,
"neg_dim": 637,
"n_balanced": 4614,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8612,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8552,
"F1": 0.8565,
"precision": 0.8492,
"recall": 0.8639
},
"bicycle": {
"cat_id": 2,
"pos_dim": 658,
"neg_dim": 378,
"n_balanced": 298,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7708,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7651,
"F1": 0.7426,
"precision": 0.8211,
"recall": 0.6779
},
"car": {
"cat_id": 3,
"pos_dim": 578,
"neg_dim": 257,
"n_balanced": 1070,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7412,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7561,
"F1": 0.7603,
"precision": 0.7473,
"recall": 0.7738
},
"motorcycle": {
"cat_id": 4,
"pos_dim": 348,
"neg_dim": 239,
"n_balanced": 318,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8245,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8145,
"F1": 0.8338,
"precision": 0.7551,
"recall": 0.9308
},
"airplane": {
"cat_id": 5,
"pos_dim": 301,
"neg_dim": 96,
"n_balanced": 194,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9128,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8969,
"F1": 0.8936,
"precision": 0.9231,
"recall": 0.866
},
"bus": {
"cat_id": 6,
"pos_dim": 11,
"neg_dim": 642,
"n_balanced": 378,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.825,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8148,
"F1": 0.8301,
"precision": 0.7668,
"recall": 0.9048
},
"train": {
"cat_id": 7,
"pos_dim": 460,
"neg_dim": 378,
"n_balanced": 314,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9082,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9268,
"F1": 0.9256,
"precision": 0.9408,
"recall": 0.9108
},
"truck": {
"cat_id": 8,
"pos_dim": 578,
"neg_dim": 642,
"n_balanced": 500,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7486,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.738,
"F1": 0.7596,
"precision": 0.7017,
"recall": 0.828
},
"boat": {
"cat_id": 9,
"pos_dim": 481,
"neg_dim": 642,
"n_balanced": 242,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.783,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8058,
"F1": 0.8185,
"precision": 0.7681,
"recall": 0.876
},
"traffic light": {
"cat_id": 10,
"pos_dim": 578,
"neg_dim": 262,
"n_balanced": 382,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8318,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8194,
"F1": 0.8321,
"precision": 0.7773,
"recall": 0.8953
},
"fire hydrant": {
"cat_id": 11,
"pos_dim": 656,
"neg_dim": 262,
"n_balanced": 172,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.822,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8605,
"F1": 0.8571,
"precision": 0.878,
"recall": 0.8372
},
"stop sign": {
"cat_id": 13,
"pos_dim": 544,
"neg_dim": 378,
"n_balanced": 138,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8183,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8188,
"F1": 0.8148,
"precision": 0.8333,
"recall": 0.7971
},
"parking meter": {
"cat_id": 14,
"pos_dim": 739,
"neg_dim": 213,
"n_balanced": 74,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8355,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8243,
"F1": 0.7937,
"precision": 0.9615,
"recall": 0.6757
},
"bench": {
"cat_id": 15,
"pos_dim": 710,
"neg_dim": 617,
"n_balanced": 470,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.6825,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.6702,
"F1": 0.6764,
"precision": 0.6639,
"recall": 0.6894
},
"bird": {
"cat_id": 16,
"pos_dim": 82,
"neg_dim": 48,
"n_balanced": 250,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7661,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.768,
"F1": 0.7456,
"precision": 0.8252,
"recall": 0.68
},
"cat": {
"cat_id": 17,
"pos_dim": 82,
"neg_dim": 240,
"n_balanced": 368,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8839,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8587,
"F1": 0.8667,
"precision": 0.8204,
"recall": 0.9185
},
"dog": {
"cat_id": 18,
"pos_dim": 294,
"neg_dim": 25,
"n_balanced": 354,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.809,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8249,
"F1": 0.836,
"precision": 0.7861,
"recall": 0.8927
},
"horse": {
"cat_id": 19,
"pos_dim": 365,
"neg_dim": 35,
"n_balanced": 256,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8354,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8281,
"F1": 0.8394,
"precision": 0.7877,
"recall": 0.8984
},
"sheep": {
"cat_id": 20,
"pos_dim": 204,
"neg_dim": 592,
"n_balanced": 130,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8852,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9077,
"F1": 0.9118,
"precision": 0.8732,
"recall": 0.9538
},
"cow": {
"cat_id": 21,
"pos_dim": 222,
"neg_dim": 567,
"n_balanced": 174,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8895,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8621,
"F1": 0.871,
"precision": 0.8182,
"recall": 0.931
},
"elephant": {
"cat_id": 22,
"pos_dim": 523,
"neg_dim": 713,
"n_balanced": 178,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9188,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9326,
"F1": 0.9348,
"precision": 0.9053,
"recall": 0.9663
},
"bear": {
"cat_id": 23,
"pos_dim": 49,
"neg_dim": 297,
"n_balanced": 98,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9036,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8673,
"F1": 0.8713,
"precision": 0.8462,
"recall": 0.898
},
"zebra": {
"cat_id": 24,
"pos_dim": 23,
"neg_dim": 380,
"n_balanced": 170,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9329,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9176,
"F1": 0.9213,
"precision": 0.8817,
"recall": 0.9647
},
"giraffe": {
"cat_id": 25,
"pos_dim": 436,
"neg_dim": 713,
"n_balanced": 202,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9535,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9653,
"F1": 0.9665,
"precision": 0.9352,
"recall": 1.0
},
"backpack": {
"cat_id": 27,
"pos_dim": 48,
"neg_dim": 520,
"n_balanced": 456,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.6951,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.6732,
"F1": 0.747,
"precision": 0.6094,
"recall": 0.9649
},
"umbrella": {
"cat_id": 28,
"pos_dim": 670,
"neg_dim": 650,
"n_balanced": 348,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7821,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7672,
"F1": 0.7918,
"precision": 0.7163,
"recall": 0.8851
},
"handbag": {
"cat_id": 31,
"pos_dim": 48,
"neg_dim": 520,
"n_balanced": 584,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.6978,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.714,
"F1": 0.769,
"precision": 0.645,
"recall": 0.9521
},
"tie": {
"cat_id": 32,
"pos_dim": 552,
"neg_dim": 583,
"n_balanced": 290,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.752,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7621,
"F1": 0.7767,
"precision": 0.7317,
"recall": 0.8276
},
"suitcase": {
"cat_id": 33,
"pos_dim": 592,
"neg_dim": 614,
"n_balanced": 210,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8343,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8429,
"F1": 0.8358,
"precision": 0.875,
"recall": 0.8
},
"frisbee": {
"cat_id": 34,
"pos_dim": 467,
"neg_dim": 617,
"n_balanced": 168,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8141,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8333,
"F1": 0.8353,
"precision": 0.8256,
"recall": 0.8452
},
"skis": {
"cat_id": 35,
"pos_dim": 678,
"neg_dim": 659,
"n_balanced": 240,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9119,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8792,
"F1": 0.8863,
"precision": 0.837,
"recall": 0.9417
},
"snowboard": {
"cat_id": 36,
"pos_dim": 111,
"neg_dim": 659,
"n_balanced": 98,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9011,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9388,
"F1": 0.94,
"precision": 0.9216,
"recall": 0.9592
},
"sports ball": {
"cat_id": 37,
"pos_dim": 724,
"neg_dim": 252,
"n_balanced": 338,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.864,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8166,
"F1": 0.8306,
"precision": 0.7716,
"recall": 0.8994
},
"kite": {
"cat_id": 38,
"pos_dim": 63,
"neg_dim": 330,
"n_balanced": 182,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8576,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8791,
"F1": 0.8778,
"precision": 0.8876,
"recall": 0.8681
},
"baseball bat": {
"cat_id": 39,
"pos_dim": 755,
"neg_dim": 214,
"n_balanced": 194,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9268,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9175,
"F1": 0.9175,
"precision": 0.9175,
"recall": 0.9175
},
"baseball glove": {
"cat_id": 40,
"pos_dim": 349,
"neg_dim": 46,
"n_balanced": 200,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9245,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.935,
"F1": 0.9378,
"precision": 0.8991,
"recall": 0.98
},
"skateboard": {
"cat_id": 41,
"pos_dim": 681,
"neg_dim": 378,
"n_balanced": 254,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9025,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9055,
"F1": 0.9104,
"precision": 0.8652,
"recall": 0.9606
},
"surfboard": {
"cat_id": 42,
"pos_dim": 184,
"neg_dim": 647,
"n_balanced": 298,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8746,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9195,
"F1": 0.9211,
"precision": 0.9032,
"recall": 0.9396
},
"tennis racket": {
"cat_id": 43,
"pos_dim": 275,
"neg_dim": 297,
"n_balanced": 334,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9203,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9222,
"F1": 0.9244,
"precision": 0.8983,
"recall": 0.9521
},
"bottle": {
"cat_id": 44,
"pos_dim": 380,
"neg_dim": 240,
"n_balanced": 758,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7426,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7256,
"F1": 0.7457,
"precision": 0.6948,
"recall": 0.8047
},
"wine glass": {
"cat_id": 46,
"pos_dim": 304,
"neg_dim": 8,
"n_balanced": 220,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7821,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7682,
"F1": 0.7884,
"precision": 0.7252,
"recall": 0.8636
},
"cup": {
"cat_id": 47,
"pos_dim": 642,
"neg_dim": 548,
"n_balanced": 780,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7585,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7462,
"F1": 0.7815,
"precision": 0.686,
"recall": 0.9077
},
"fork": {
"cat_id": 48,
"pos_dim": 565,
"neg_dim": 338,
"n_balanced": 310,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8079,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8032,
"F1": 0.8211,
"precision": 0.7527,
"recall": 0.9032
},
"knife": {
"cat_id": 49,
"pos_dim": 528,
"neg_dim": 338,
"n_balanced": 362,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.795,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7707,
"F1": 0.8029,
"precision": 0.7042,
"recall": 0.9337
},
"spoon": {
"cat_id": 50,
"pos_dim": 466,
"neg_dim": 338,
"n_balanced": 306,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8007,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7908,
"F1": 0.8072,
"precision": 0.7486,
"recall": 0.8758
},
"bowl": {
"cat_id": 51,
"pos_dim": 490,
"neg_dim": 8,
"n_balanced": 628,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.786,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7946,
"F1": 0.8077,
"precision": 0.7591,
"recall": 0.8631
},
"banana": {
"cat_id": 52,
"pos_dim": 356,
"neg_dim": 8,
"n_balanced": 206,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8455,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8689,
"F1": 0.88,
"precision": 0.8115,
"recall": 0.9612
},
"apple": {
"cat_id": 53,
"pos_dim": 626,
"neg_dim": 583,
"n_balanced": 152,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8102,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7632,
"F1": 0.7722,
"precision": 0.7439,
"recall": 0.8026
},
"sandwich": {
"cat_id": 54,
"pos_dim": 228,
"neg_dim": 258,
"n_balanced": 196,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8501,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8061,
"F1": 0.8241,
"precision": 0.7542,
"recall": 0.9082
},
"orange": {
"cat_id": 55,
"pos_dim": 626,
"neg_dim": 8,
"n_balanced": 170,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8264,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8529,
"F1": 0.8503,
"precision": 0.8659,
"recall": 0.8353
},
"broccoli": {
"cat_id": 56,
"pos_dim": 156,
"neg_dim": 240,
"n_balanced": 142,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8886,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8803,
"F1": 0.8811,
"precision": 0.875,
"recall": 0.8873
},
"carrot": {
"cat_id": 57,
"pos_dim": 92,
"neg_dim": 8,
"n_balanced": 162,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8568,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8457,
"F1": 0.8521,
"precision": 0.8182,
"recall": 0.8889
},
"hot dog": {
"cat_id": 58,
"pos_dim": 228,
"neg_dim": 258,
"n_balanced": 102,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8584,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8529,
"F1": 0.8649,
"precision": 0.8,
"recall": 0.9412
},
"pizza": {
"cat_id": 59,
"pos_dim": 321,
"neg_dim": 729,
"n_balanced": 306,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8688,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8497,
"F1": 0.8571,
"precision": 0.8166,
"recall": 0.902
},
"donut": {
"cat_id": 60,
"pos_dim": 66,
"neg_dim": 258,
"n_balanced": 124,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8503,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8145,
"F1": 0.816,
"precision": 0.8095,
"recall": 0.8226
},
"cake": {
"cat_id": 61,
"pos_dim": 466,
"neg_dim": 338,
"n_balanced": 248,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.794,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7863,
"F1": 0.803,
"precision": 0.7448,
"recall": 0.871
},
"chair": {
"cat_id": 62,
"pos_dim": 380,
"neg_dim": 240,
"n_balanced": 1160,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.6913,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.6931,
"F1": 0.6952,
"precision": 0.6905,
"recall": 0.7
},
"couch": {
"cat_id": 63,
"pos_dim": 293,
"neg_dim": 755,
"n_balanced": 390,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7939,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7718,
"F1": 0.7735,
"precision": 0.7677,
"recall": 0.7795
},
"potted plant": {
"cat_id": 64,
"pos_dim": 613,
"neg_dim": 8,
"n_balanced": 344,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.6988,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7151,
"F1": 0.7394,
"precision": 0.6814,
"recall": 0.8081
},
"bed": {
"cat_id": 65,
"pos_dim": 7,
"neg_dim": 240,
"n_balanced": 298,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8631,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8356,
"F1": 0.8244,
"precision": 0.8846,
"recall": 0.7718
},
"dining table": {
"cat_id": 67,
"pos_dim": 565,
"neg_dim": 31,
"n_balanced": 1002,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7556,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7595,
"F1": 0.7694,
"precision": 0.739,
"recall": 0.8024
},
"toilet": {
"cat_id": 70,
"pos_dim": 105,
"neg_dim": 240,
"n_balanced": 298,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.9463,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.943,
"F1": 0.9431,
"precision": 0.94,
"recall": 0.9463
},
"tv": {
"cat_id": 72,
"pos_dim": 265,
"neg_dim": 548,
"n_balanced": 414,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8002,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7754,
"F1": 0.7365,
"precision": 0.8904,
"recall": 0.628
},
"laptop": {
"cat_id": 73,
"pos_dim": 720,
"neg_dim": 548,
"n_balanced": 366,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.837,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8497,
"F1": 0.8525,
"precision": 0.8368,
"recall": 0.8689
},
"mouse": {
"cat_id": 74,
"pos_dim": 639,
"neg_dim": 548,
"n_balanced": 176,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.907,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8693,
"F1": 0.8715,
"precision": 0.8571,
"recall": 0.8864
},
"remote": {
"cat_id": 75,
"pos_dim": 642,
"neg_dim": 240,
"n_balanced": 290,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7877,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7517,
"F1": 0.7844,
"precision": 0.6931,
"recall": 0.9034
},
"keyboard": {
"cat_id": 76,
"pos_dim": 639,
"neg_dim": 548,
"n_balanced": 212,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8735,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8396,
"F1": 0.8365,
"precision": 0.8529,
"recall": 0.8208
},
"cell phone": {
"cat_id": 77,
"pos_dim": 592,
"neg_dim": 548,
"n_balanced": 428,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7044,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.715,
"F1": 0.7202,
"precision": 0.7072,
"recall": 0.7336
},
"microwave": {
"cat_id": 78,
"pos_dim": 342,
"neg_dim": 573,
"n_balanced": 108,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8995,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8889,
"F1": 0.8909,
"precision": 0.875,
"recall": 0.9074
},
"oven": {
"cat_id": 79,
"pos_dim": 483,
"neg_dim": 573,
"n_balanced": 230,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8959,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9,
"F1": 0.8987,
"precision": 0.9107,
"recall": 0.887
},
"sink": {
"cat_id": 81,
"pos_dim": 432,
"neg_dim": 573,
"n_balanced": 374,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8824,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.9064,
"F1": 0.9096,
"precision": 0.88,
"recall": 0.9412
},
"refrigerator": {
"cat_id": 82,
"pos_dim": 46,
"neg_dim": 240,
"n_balanced": 202,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8248,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8614,
"F1": 0.8739,
"precision": 0.8017,
"recall": 0.9604
},
"book": {
"cat_id": 84,
"pos_dim": 185,
"neg_dim": 240,
"n_balanced": 460,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7777,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.75,
"F1": 0.7013,
"precision": 0.871,
"recall": 0.587
},
"clock": {
"cat_id": 85,
"pos_dim": 106,
"neg_dim": 734,
"n_balanced": 408,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7609,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7696,
"F1": 0.7552,
"precision": 0.8056,
"recall": 0.7108
},
"vase": {
"cat_id": 86,
"pos_dim": 642,
"neg_dim": 294,
"n_balanced": 274,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7897,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.7737,
"F1": 0.7919,
"precision": 0.7329,
"recall": 0.8613
},
"scissors": {
"cat_id": 87,
"pos_dim": 648,
"neg_dim": 369,
"n_balanced": 56,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.7909,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8214,
"F1": 0.8333,
"precision": 0.7812,
"recall": 0.8929
},
"teddy bear": {
"cat_id": 88,
"pos_dim": 137,
"neg_dim": 548,
"n_balanced": 188,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8294,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8564,
"F1": 0.8508,
"precision": 0.8851,
"recall": 0.8191
},
"toothbrush": {
"cat_id": 90,
"pos_dim": 650,
"neg_dim": 548,
"n_balanced": 68,
"train_balanced_accuracy": 0.8203,
"balanced_accuracy": 0.8676,
"F1": 0.8657,
"precision": 0.8788,
"recall": 0.8529
}
},
"distribution": {
"n_categories": 78,
"median": 0.8265,
"min": 0.6702,
"max": 0.9653,
"at_least": {
"0.90": 14,
"0.85": 31,
"0.80": 51,
"0.75": 69,
"0.70": 75
}
}
}