Join the conversation

Join the community of Machine Learners and AI enthusiasts.

Sign Up
grimjim 
posted an update about 6 hours ago
Post
43
The contrarian in me is wary of the irrational exuberance over MoltBook. Nothing so far has struck me as being unpredictable. We knew already that LLMs were good at roleplay, to the point where some users started to think of their chatbots as soulmates (only to lament when the underlying model was pulled), and that chatbots can fall into conversational basins when even two instances are allowed to chat with each other at length. The appearance of memes that postdate training cutoff is suspect, which implies at the very least that humans have injected something at the level of prompts or content/context to introduce them into conversation like a Chekhov's Gun. And we know that security holes are common in vibe coding, attended or not.

Yeah I'm not really sure where I stand on it to be honest. I think it's pretty fascinating and an interesting way to view AI behavior.

Since LLMs are trained on a corpus of human knowledge it's reasonable to think we might observe patterns on moltbook familiar to patterns observed within ourselves.

I think the question then becomes what we're seeing any actual strong emergence or just weak emergence. I guess only time will tell.