File size: 31,522 Bytes
f9bc0c1
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
# Data licensing ledger

Started 2026-07-14 from the adversarial license audit (see RESEARCH.md
"Verification wave"). Every data source used for training or claims MUST have
a row here. Legend: OK / RISK (unresolved) / NO.

| Source | License (verified) | Train | Publish numbers | Redistribute | Commercial |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Santali Wikipedia dump | CC BY-SA 4.0/GFDL | OK | OK | OK (attribution+SA) | OK |
| Aale Chhatka 2023 issue | Creative Commons Public Domain Mark 1.0 applied on publisher/uploader item (not CC0; mark is not a license) | OK by project policy | OK by project policy | OK by project policy | OK by project policy |
| Aale Chhatka Sept 2023 | UNSPECIFIED (same publisher) | RISK | RISK | NO | RISK |
| NVIDIA OCR-Synthetic-Multilingual-v1 (`en/validation/validation_000.h5`; 6,802 horizontal train + 419 test line crops on k2 `~/ocr-deva-ft/data/nvidia-en-lines`, provenance.jsonl per crop) | CC BY 4.0 (dataset card, verified 2026-09-24) | OK (attribution) | OK | OK with attribution | OK |
| Devanagari OFL font set for synthetic rendering (48 families: Google Fonts `ofl/` + embedded-OFL Aarav, Annapurna SIL Nepal; list in the 2026-09-24 fine-tune `font_selection.json`) | SIL OFL 1.1 (verified per family) | OK (rendered images) | OK | fonts not redistributed | OK |
| Gorkhapatra-derived real chunks `chunks-v2` and `chunks-v4` (24 editions; `chunks-v4` trained the deployed devanagari-ft-v3; `tools/build_gorkhapatra_devanagari_chunks.py`) | as the Gorkhapatra row: owner determination 2026-07-22 covers internal training and derived metrics | OK-internal | OK (metrics) | NO (crops) | owner decision required before a model trained on it is offered commercially |
| himalaya-ai/nepali-deva-ocr-eval (500 rows from gauravgiri/nepali-ocr-dataset; photographed handwriting) | none recorded | NO (eval-only probe) | RISK (internal diagnostic only) | NO | NO |
| IIIT-HW-Dev handwritten Hindi words (HF `c3rl/IIIT-INDIC-HW-WORDS-Hindi`; Kaggle `himanshukumarrajak/indic-data` and re-uploads) | research and educational use only (CVIT IIIT Hyderabad) | OK-research only | OK-research only | NO | NO (a model trained on it stays a research model until CVIT permits otherwise) |
| DHCD, Devanagari Handwritten Character Dataset (UCI id 389) | CC BY 4.0 | OK (attribution) | OK | OK with attribution | OK |
| sweekardahal handwritten Nepali word crops (Kaggle `sweekardahal/handwritten-labeled-dataset-for-text-recognition`) | CC0 (Kaggle dataset page, checked 2026-09-24) | OK | OK | OK | OK |
| sweekardahal Nepali handwritten page photos, detection boxes (Kaggle `sweekardahal/nepali-handwritten-images-for-text-detection`) | CC0 (Kaggle dataset page, checked 2026-09-24) | OK | OK | OK | OK |
| IndicScan handwritten Devanagari words (Kaggle `rushdaismailaslami/handwritten-devanagari-character-and-word-dataset`) | CC BY 4.0 (Kaggle dataset page, checked 2026-09-24) | OK (attribution; used as test only) | OK | OK with attribution | OK |
| ocr.gov.np public notices (3 PDFs, `tools/deva_rec_torch/page_probe/SOURCES.txt`) + our hand transcription of 43 lines | Government of Nepal public notices; no licence stated | NO (eval-only) | OK (derived metrics only) | NO (PDFs not redistributed) | NO |
| IIIT Mozhi printed lines (HF mirrors `darknight054/indic-mozhi-ocr`, `AtharvImmverse/indic-mozhi-ocr`) | none stated on CVIT project page (checked 2026-09-24) | NO until CVIT confirms | NO | NO | NO |
| chiki-chemed primer | CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 | NO (catalogue only — verified unused) | — | NO | NO |
| Videha Tirhuta text | Uploader-applied item-level CC BY-SA 4.0 (IA metadata verified); item descriptions also reserve individual-author rights, retained as a caveat | OK by project policy | OK by project policy | OK by project policy (attribution+SA; do not imply broader author-rights waiver) | OK by project policy |
| Videha Tirhuta silver line pack (outputs/videha-tirhuta-silver-2026-07-17/; 7 exact-hash-bound issues) | Uploader-applied item-level CC BY-SA 4.0 on the two Internet Archive parent items; per-issue source URLs and hashes are recorded in the pack provenance; retain the existing individual-author-rights caveat | OK by project policy | OK by project policy | OK by project policy (attribution+SA; redistribute with pack provenance and do not imply a broader author-rights waiver) | OK by project policy |
| Videha embedded "janaki" font | MPP Janaki 1.000 metadata says “All rights reserved”; no license grant | decode-only | — | NO | NO |
| Zenodo 6967421 Newa MSS | CC-BY-4.0 | OK | OK (attribution recorded in `docs/ATTRIBUTIONS.md`) | OK+attr | OK+attr |
| nepal-lipi.com text (285 lines) | all-rights-reserved, research-only | NO (v2 payload VIOLATES — rebuild required) | NO | NO | NO |
| NepalLipiUnicode.ttf | bare copyright, no grant | RISK (in v2 payload renders — rebuild) | RISK | NO | NO |
| Nithya Ranjana 1.000 DU (`8a2ebe62…b92b`) and NU (`22a12a91…1528`) | Exact official Ek Type release; embedded and standalone SIL OFL 1.1; upstream identifies DU as Devanagari-based and NU as Newa-based | candidate only — no synthetic payload admitted | NO — no OCR metric or model | OK subject to OFL | OK subject to OFL |
| Commons “Bhujimol script characters (Unicode)” SVG (`bf79c86f…d8655d`) | Uploader `Z3lvs` marks own work CC0 1.0; exact Commons API metadata and source bytes frozen | NO — basic-glyph reviewer reference only; not a font or mapped training asset | NO | OK under CC0 | OK under CC0 |
| Wellcome MS Indic epsilon 1 Bhujimol manuscript | Authoritative IIIF manifest applies Public Domain Mark 1.0 and explicitly permits copying, modification, distribution, performance, and commercial use without permission; attribution: Wellcome Collection | NO — complete remote-review candidate; 217 canvases, zero qualified page decisions or labels | NO | NO until a frozen reviewed pack exists | NO until admitted |
| GRETIL Aṣṭasāhasrikā e-text (Vaidya 1960 edition) | Page states “FOR REFERENCE PURPOSES ONLY” and defers copyright/usage to the source file; no dataset-training or redistribution grant was verified | NO — different-edition work-level reviewer reference only; no folio/line crosswalk | NO | NO | NO |
| Internet Archive Asa Archives item 1147 (Bhāsvati) | Uploader-applied item-level CC0 1.0 metadata; uploader authority over the Asa Archives scan is not yet verified | NO — catalogue only pending origin, exact-file SHA-256, qualified script review, and labels | NO | NO | NO |
| Wikimedia Haramekhala 1374 Bhujimol image | Public Domain Mark 1.0 on a single Asa Archives-derived image; mark is not a license and origin chain is unresolved | NO — catalogue only | NO | NO | NO |
| British Library EAP790/21/121 Bhujimol manuscript | Catalogue says research-only; EAP image route carries CC BY-NC 4.0 branding | NO — catalogue only | NO | NO | NO |
| Commons Cambridge MS Add.2137 Bhujimol photograph | Exact Commons JPEG is self-licensed by its photographer under CC BY-SA 4.0; attribution and share-alike apply. Cambridge's separate complete IIIF scan is CC BY-NC 4.0 and is provenance/script evidence only. | NO — one selected composite, zero qualified pixel decisions or labels | NO | NO until an exact hash-bound reviewed pack exists | NO until admitted |
| Cambridge MS Add.2137 catalog TEI and listed Nāradasmṛti editions | Catalog metadata/reference only; the TEI states that the Newari legal text and Newari translation are unpublished, and no complete line transcription is supplied | NO — partial work-level Sanskrit reference only; not companion ground truth | NO | NO | NO |
| Smithsonian S1991.161 image FS-6314_06 | Exact image is marked CC0 on the object page, alongside generic usage-conditions text | NO — catalogue only; one IIIF canvas and no labels | NO | NO | NO |
| British Library EAP1296/2/217 Ranjana manuscript | EAP file page carries CC BY-NC 4.0 branding | NO — catalogue only | NO | NO | NO |
| Wellcome MS Indic delta 33 selected Ranjana images | Four exact digital-image records carry CC BY 4.0; the physical manuscript remains closed-store only and has no complete IIIF presentation manifest | NO — catalogue only; selected overlapping/partial views and no labels | NO | NO | NO |
| BDRC MW1NPL132 Ranjana manuscript | BDRC's official access policy classifies scanned original manuscripts as public domain and permits sharing/adaptation for any purpose; exact scan W1NPL132 is `AccessOpen`/`StatusReleased`. The IIIF manifest has no license field, and the work-record CC0 marker is metadata-only. | NO — complete remote-review candidate; 21 canvases, zero qualified page decisions or labels | NO | NO until a separately frozen reviewed pack exists | NO until admitted |
| BDRC MW1NPL23 mixed-script Ranjana manuscript | BDRC's official access policy classifies scanned original manuscripts as public domain and permits sharing/adaptation for any purpose; exact scan W1NPL23 is `AccessOpen`/`StatusReleased`. The physical record assigns both `ScriptNewa` and `ScriptRanj`; the manifest has no license field. | NO — remote-review candidate; 25 canvases, zero qualified page decisions or labels | NO | NO until a separately frozen reviewed pack exists | NO until admitted |
| BDRC MW1NPL99 NepaleseHooked/Bhujimol manuscript | BDRC's official access policy classifies scanned original manuscripts as public domain and permits sharing/adaptation for any purpose; exact scan W1NPL99 is `AccessOpen`/`StatusReleased`. The physical record assigns `ScriptNepaleseHooked`; the project maps that institutional term to its Bhujimol review profile, subject to qualified page review. The IIIF manifest has no license field, and the work-record CC0 marker is metadata-only. | NO — complete remote-review candidate; 73 canvases, zero qualified page decisions or labels | NO | NO until a separately frozen reviewed pack exists | NO until admitted |
| Nepalbhasa Manuscripts in UK archive | Publicly viewable with transcription/translation, but no explicit reuse, training, redistribution, or commercial license found | NO — permission required | NO | NO | NO |
| Sikkim Herald editions hosted on `sikkim.gov.in` | Custom State Portal permission: material may be reproduced free of charge in any format/media without specific permission, if accurate, non-derogatory/non-misleading, and prominently source-acknowledged; explicitly identified third-party material is excluded. Not public domain and not a standard open license. The newer `ipr.sikkim.gov.in` listing is discovery-only unless its file is mirrored on the State Portal or separately permitted. | OK by project policy for State Portal-hosted government-published Herald pages after third-party screening | OK with source/permission attribution and honest claim boundaries | OK with the stated conditions; exclude third-party material | OK by the permission text (no NC restriction), subject to the same conditions |
| Unicode L2/22-096 embedded `khema 2019` reference font | No standalone font redistribution grant captured; used only inside the proposal for semantic and glyph-shape attestation | decode/reference only; not a training or rendering asset | — | NO | NO |
| Gorkhapatra | Nepal Copyright Act 2059 §3 "government work" exclusion — UNVERIFIED for Gorkhapatra Sansthan (statutory corporation); owner determination 2026-07-22 (see below) | OK-internal | OK (derived metrics/counts) | NO (pixels/crops) | OK (metrics only) |
| OLCKOptimum fonts (extracted) | OFL 1.1 (embedded license text) | OK | OK | OK | OK |
| SakalBharati, Noto fonts | OFL | OK | OK | OK | OK |
| MithilaUni.ttf | no license text, no provenance | quarantine — do not use until documented | — | NO | NO |

## Owner determination: Gorkhapatra derived-metric publication (2026-07-22)

Recorded decision by the project owner (ashish@ampixa.com): Gorkhapatra is
Nepal's state-owned national daily (Gorkhapatra Sansthan), and on that basis
the owner accepts publication of DERIVED METRICS AND COUNTS (CER scores, line
counts, split sizes) computed from its epaper material — including in the
LimbuOCR paper — as an acceptable use. Scope limits:

- This is an owner risk-acceptance decision, not a verified legal opinion;
  the §3 "government work" statutory question above remains unverified.
- It does NOT cover redistribution of page pixels, rendered images, or crop
  packs; those remain withheld pending a formal license statement.
- Training-use status for internal models is unchanged (internal OK).

## Claim corrections (2026-07-14)

- **Ol Chiki public headline (2nd correction, same day)**: the label audit
  found 67/895 crops (all in the public-marked issue) are BLANK — a pack-builder
  rendering bug that added guaranteed-error lines. Blank-free numbers:
  **public-marked-issue-only cp CER 0.1018 / exact 0.191 (n=366)** is a
  historical diagnostic only; combined blank-free 0.0826 (n=828) stays internal-diagnostic
  pending the September issue's license. The earlier 0.1929/0.1275 figures
  are superseded (blank-inflated). These figures are not claim-grade: crop,
  label, punctuation, leakage, and asset-independence review remains pending.
  The public-marked-source-only v3 candidate now has 358 rows after 75 blank
  renders were rejected; it remains unreviewed, unfrozen, and claim-ineligible.
- **Newa v2 curriculum payload (2026-07-14) is license-contaminated**
  (31.5% of synth text + ~half of renders from research-only sources) and
  is also blocked on recipe grounds (see SOTA review) — DO NOT TRAIN from it;
  rebuild on Zenodo train-split text + OFL fonts only.
- **The recovered Newar-Devanagari normalized pack is not admitted
  (2026-07-15 r12).** An independent `omac` audit exactly reproduced the two
  narrow whitespace rewrites over 6,763 rows and decoded all 6,763 referenced
  PNGs with zero missing, blank, or cross-split image hashes. That mechanical
  success does not repair the source: the recovered label rows omit PDF URL,
  PDF hash, page, bbox, date, and edition; Gorkhapatra remains `RISK`; and no
  qualified native pixel-label review exists. The split additionally has 18
  exact and 575 total 16+-codepoint train-to-eval overlap rows, plus 136
  dev-to-test substring rows and four duplicate-image groups in train. A
  deterministic geometry sample found adjacent-line ink in two of the three
  widest crops. Do not train, score, publish CER, or redistribute this pack.
  Evidence:
  `outputs/newar-devanagari-normalized-claim-boundary-audit-2026-07-15-r12/`
  and
  `outputs/newar-devanagari-normalized-visual-sample-review-2026-07-15-r12/`.
- **Four-profile Newari routing is not four-profile data admission
  (2026-07-15 r30; supersedes r1 capability state).** Newar/Prachalit,
  Bhujimol, Ranjana, and Devanagari have explicit runtime and registry profiles.
  The recovered `deva-v2` export is now exact-hash bound as one locally
  operational diagnostic model, while every profile remains claim-ineligible
  and no four-script OCR claim exists. The model's narrative historical score
  is not admitted: its recovered Newari evaluation pack fails the rights,
  provenance, native-review, leakage, and split-independence gates documented
  above. Bhujimol has no admitted font or real pixel-label set. Ranjana remains
  unencoded in Unicode 17.0. The later r36 custody audit supersedes only this
  paragraph's font-license finding; it does not change the r30 data/model
  result.
  Evidence:
  `outputs/newari-four-writing-system-support-audit-2026-07-15-r30/`.
- **The recovered Devanagari model now has a runtime smoke, not an accuracy
  result (2026-07-15 r31).** The exact r30-bound export loaded in a pinned
  CPU-only Paddle 3.3.1 / PaddleOCR 3.7.0 runtime on `omac` and returned one
  nonempty Devanagari prediction for a single OFL-font synthetic Newari line.
  The rejected historical evaluation pack was not used, no CER or other
  quality metric was computed, and the imperfect prediction is retained only
  as mechanism evidence. The model remains excluded from redistribution and
  every quality claim. Evidence:
  `outputs/newari-devanagari-runtime-smoke-audit-2026-07-15-r31/`.
- **The failed-fit Newar/Prachalit checkpoint now has exact export custody,
  not a quality result (2026-07-15 r33).** The surviving native-v1 checkpoint
  was exported on the 64 GiB `omac` host with CPU-only Paddle 3.3.1 from an
  unchanged hash-pinned PaddleOCR checkout. The export binds three inference
  files, the exact 106-symbol dictionary, the Apache 2.0 PaddleOCR license,
  and the existing CC BY 4.0 Zenodo 6967421 attribution. It remains a known
  failed fit: the original PPLCNetV3 route exposed 40 CTC timesteps while
  95.7% of its training labels exceeded 40 characters. Its historical
  `norm_edit_dis` is not admitted as codepoint CER, no runtime smoke has yet
  passed, the Cambridge labels remain qualified-review pending, and the model
  binary is retained locally rather than redistributed through Git. This
  raises exact local diagnostic-model custody to two of four Newari profiles;
  it does not establish Prachalit quality or a four-script OCR claim. Evidence:
  `outputs/newari-four-writing-system-support-audit-2026-07-15-r33/`.
- **The failed-fit Newar/Prachalit export now has a runtime smoke, not an
  accuracy result (2026-07-15 r34).** The exact r33 export loaded on the 64 GiB
  `omac` host in a network-denied, CPU-only Paddle 3.3.1 / PaddleOCR 3.7.0
  runtime and returned one structurally valid prediction for one 1,200 x 180
  synthetic line rendered with Noto Sans Newa 2.007. The font's embedded SIL
  OFL 1.1 metadata and SHA-256 are bound; the font binary is not redistributed.
  The executed runner recorded U+11Cxx source-text metadata in error. Its raw
  JSON and exact runner bytes remain unchanged, while the reviewed U+114xx
  Newa render provenance and corrected maintained runner are separately bound.
  The model read one image and made one prediction, with zero training, GPU,
  external-network, evaluation-row, output-to-source comparison, or scoring
  actions. Therefore no CER, accuracy, redistribution admission, Prachalit
  quality claim, or four-script OCR claim follows. Evidence:
  `outputs/newari-prachalit-runtime-smoke-audit-2026-07-15-r34/`.
- **Nithya Ranjana font licensing and mapping are now audited, not OCR
  capability (2026-07-15 r36).** The local DU binary exactly matches Ek Type's
  official 1.000 release (`8a2ebe62…b92b`), and the official NU binary was
  acquired from the same release (`22a12a91…1528`). The release ZIP, all seven
  members, tag commit, release metadata, embedded license records, standalone
  OFL texts, cmap counts, and GSUB script tags are hash-bound. Ek Type states
  that Ranjana is unencoded and provides DU on Devanagari Unicode and NU on
  Newa Unicode. DU is therefore reference-only for this project's Newa output
  route; NU is the compatible Ranjana-style render candidate. Neither font is
  a Bhujimol font or proof of historical manuscript-domain fidelity. No
  synthetic training payload, real pixel, label, model, prediction, score, or
  CER is admitted. Evidence:
  `outputs/newari-historical-font-custody-audit-2026-07-15-r36/`.
- **The CC0 Bhujimol vector chart is a reviewer reference, not a font
  (2026-07-15 r37).** Wikimedia Commons records uploader `Z3lvs`, own work,
  CC0 1.0, and a 2026-05-24 creation date for the exact 181,286-byte SVG.
  Structural inspection finds 111 outline paths and no text element, embedded
  font, path ID/codepoint map, shaping rule, script, external resource, or
  raster image. It can orient a qualified reviewer to basic shapes, but cannot
  render arbitrary Newa text, attest conjunct behavior, validate a manuscript
  hand, or supply labels. The bounded font search still produced no admitted
  Bhujimol font. No manuscript pixel, training row, model, prediction, score,
  or CER is admitted. Evidence:
  `outputs/newari-bhujimol-reference-chart-audit-2026-07-15-r37/`.
- **Bhujimol/Ranjana discovery is still catalogue-only (2026-07-15 r2).**
  Six source candidates now have rights evidence and blockers recorded.
  The strongest Bhujimol lead is Internet Archive Asa Archives item 1147:
  uploader-applied CC0 metadata, 63 scanned pages, and 325 machine-detected
  line boxes. Those boxes are not labels, and uploader authority, institutional
  accession, exact-file SHA-256, qualified script identity, pixel
  faithfulness, and transcription mapping remain unresolved. The strongest
  Ranjana rights lead is Smithsonian image `FS-6314_06`, specifically marked
  CC0, but its IIIF manifest contains only one canvas even though the physical
  object has 77 folios. British Library EAP candidates are noncommercial or
  research-only; Nepalbhasa Manuscripts in UK has no captured reuse grant.
  Accordingly, zero pixels, labels, review manifests, models, or numbers are
  admitted. Evidence:
  `outputs/newari-source-candidate-audit-2026-07-15-r2/`.
- **Asa item 1147 now has a catalog identity, not a rights clearance
  (2026-07-15 r3).** The uploader's CC0 catalog spreadsheet (SHA-256
  `8484dbe95358b83d7d78d5d1752fafac5feeecfc007ccf5d1fe8b6ea3ce9bffd`)
  crosswalks the scan to DPN 1147, *Bhāsvati*, NRN `ज्योति - २७१`, RN 2919,
  Sanskrit/Nepalbhasa, N.S. 528, 33.3 × 4.1 cm. The catalog script field is
  blank. The same uploader created the hidden Internet Archive collection and
  uploaded both the spreadsheet and scan, but no inspected profile or metadata
  proves that the uploader is an authorized Asa Saphu Kuthi representative or
  had authority to apply CC0. The exact questions needed to close this gap are
  staged, not sent, in `docs/NEWARI_ASA_1147_RIGHTS_REQUEST.md`. The source
  remains excluded from every data and model path. Evidence:
  `outputs/newari-source-candidate-audit-2026-07-15-r3/`.
- **Wellcome MS Indic epsilon 1 reopens the Bhujimol real-pixel route
  (2026-07-15 r4).** The official Wellcome manuscript record identifies shelfmark
  `MS Indic epsilon 1`; Wellcome's editorial account explicitly calls its script
  Bhujimol. The complete IIIF manifest (SHA-256
  `596296750114948b39da2252b5a7b7c0738287dadcf7aed32939bfc29980c6d4`)
  has 217 unique canvases/services and applies Public Domain Mark 1.0 with
  explicit commercial copying/modification/distribution permission. Five
  2000-pixel-wide visual probes spanning canvases 1, 50, 100, 150, and 210
  decoded; four sampled leaves contained dense multi-block text and the first
  was a cover/label view. This is source-scale and geometry evidence only, not
  qualified script review or ground truth. The r9 handoff acquired and
  hash-recorded all 217 JPEGs on `omac` (58,471,370 bytes, 217 unique hashes);
  raw pixels remain remote and the orchestration host mirrors metadata only.
  The r10 audit creates a blank 217-row review worksheet. Zero qualified page
  decisions, lines, labels, evaluation rows, models, or metrics are admitted.
- **Wellcome MS Indic delta 33 does not provide a complete Ranjana source
  (2026-07-15 r5).** The physical catalogue record resolves shelfmark `MS
  Indic delta 33`, Sierra number `b14901468`, and closed-store availability,
  but exposes no digital item; the predictable IIIF presentation URL returns
  404. Four official selected-image records carry CC BY 4.0 and identify
  Ranjana. A prediction-free probe found one two-leaf overview, one partial-leaf
  environmental view, and two close-up miniature crops that overlap the
  overview rather than independent pages. Catalogue titles say AD 1653 while
  one record description says transcribed in 1635; the inconsistency is
  preserved. These licensed assets are useful reference evidence, but cannot
  supply 200 independent audited lines or a manuscript-disjoint split. Zero
  pixels, labels, evaluation rows, models, or metrics are admitted.
- **BDRC MW1NPL132 supplies a complete Ranjana review source, not a dataset
  (2026-07-15 r6).** BDRC's physical-instance metadata identifies
  *Ārya nāmasaṁgīti* only as `ScriptRanj` and Manuscript; linked scan
  `W1NPL132` is `AccessOpen`/`StatusReleased`, and its exact IIIF manifest has
  21 unique canvases/services. BDRC's official access policy classifies
  scanned original manuscripts as public domain and permits sharing/adaptation
  for any purpose. The manifest has no license field; work metadata CC0 is
  kept separate from the pixel-rights basis. Five visual probes establish
  access and plausible running-text density only. The frozen r6 catalogue and
  `omac` handoff admit zero audited lines, labels, models, or metrics. The r7
  handoff execution hash-recorded and dimension-checked all 21 JPEGs on
  `omac`; raw pixels remain remote and the local packet contains metadata only.
  Qualified all-page script review and an actual line count remain required.
- **Second Bhujimol and Ranjana manuscript groups are remotely acquired, not
  admitted (2026-07-15 r12-r16).** The exact Commons photograph of Cambridge `MS
  Add.2137` is CC BY-SA 4.0 and contains four folio photographs. The first
  three are the selected `28r`, `28v`, and `29r` review units; the official
  Cambridge manifest identifies its hands as Bhujimol, but Cambridge's
  complete scan is CC BY-NC 4.0 and its pixels remain excluded. The Commons
  original is now fetched and SHA-256-recorded on `omac`. BDRC `MW1NPL23` is an open,
  released 25-canvas manuscript governed by BDRC's scanned-manuscript public
  domain policy, but its institutional record assigns both `ScriptNewa` and
  `ScriptRanj` without page-level attribution. It therefore requires qualified
  all-page classification before any Ranjana line can be selected. These are
  distinct manuscript groups from the first Wellcome Bhujimol and BDRC Ranjana
  sources. The r14 execution hash-recorded all 26 source images (12,738,550
  bytes, 26 unique hashes) on `omac`; the local r15 packet contains metadata
  only and exposes 28 blank review units. It admits zero local pixels,
  qualified decisions, audited lines, labels, models, or metrics. Evidence:
  `outputs/newari-second-manuscript-source-catalog-2026-07-15-r12/` and
  `outputs/newari-second-source-remote-acquisition-audit-2026-07-15-r15/`.
  The refreshed central r16 inventory records four fetched-and-hash-recorded
  sources in total and still zero admitted sources. The consolidated r17
  packet binds 264 unique remote images to 266 blank review units across the
  four manuscript groups; neither profile has a qualified decision or an
  audited line, so both >=200-line gates remain false.
- **Available Bhujimol work text does not remove review (2026-07-15
  r43-r45).** The Wellcome manuscript is identified as the
  *Aṣṭasāhasrikā Prajñāpāramitā*, but the available GRETIL text is a different
  edition with reference-only terms and no canvas/folio/line crosswalk. BDRC
  `MW1NPL99` is institutionally titled “Unidentified,” so it has no known
  companion. Cambridge `MS Add.2137` interleaves a published Sanskrit
  *Nāradasmṛti* root with Newari commentary-cum-translation; Cambridge's TEI
  says the Newari legal text and translation are unpublished and supplies
  only short catalog excerpts. The fail-closed r45 audit therefore records
  zero exact line-aligned transcriptions, zero admissible prefills, and zero
  labels. The r43/r44 UIs separately correct the Cambridge display ambiguity
  by rendering bounded `28r`, `28v`, and `29r` regions while retaining the
  full CC BY-SA source hash and link. Work identity may guide a reviewer; it
  cannot be auto-accepted as manuscript ground truth. Evidence:
  `outputs/newari-bhujimol-companion-text-audit-2026-07-15-r45/`,
  `outputs/newari-qualified-page-review-dispatch-2026-07-15-r43/`, and
  `outputs/newari-qualified-page-review-ui-2026-07-15-r44/`.

## Open legal questions (need human/legal resolution, not agent research)

1. Gorkhapatra Sansthan output under Nepal Copyright Act 2059 §3 — underlies
   every claim-grade model to date and the live HF Space.
2. Aale Chhatka September-2023 license — one email to the publisher.

## Sikkim Herald permission correction (2026-07-15)

The earlier statutory-term analysis was incomplete because it did not inspect
the Government of Sikkim State Portal's express copyright permission. The
official [copyright page](https://www.sikkim.gov.in/legal-link/copyright)
permits reproduction of material featured on the site, free of charge, in any
format or media, subject to accuracy, non-derogatory/non-misleading use, and
prominent source acknowledgment. It excludes material explicitly identified as
third-party. The same official portal hosts the
[Sikkim Herald archive](https://www.sikkim.gov.in/SikkimHerald/), and the
Government's IPR administration page identifies Sikkim Herald as the official
paper published by the Information & Public Relations Department.

This is a source-specific permission, not a declaration that government works
are public domain. Admission is limited to Herald editions hosted on the State
Portal and carrying government-publication evidence. The newer official IPR
portal is useful for discovery, but its separate subdomain does not currently
expose the same legal page; its PDFs remain catalogue-only unless mirrored on
`sikkim.gov.in` or covered by separately captured permission. Builders must
reject explicitly third-party material, retain the source URL and
PDF hash per edition/row, and carry the permission conditions and attribution
into redistributed crops, labels, models, and published numbers. The evidence
snapshot and current portal enumeration are recorded at
`outputs/sikkim-herald-source-rights-2026-07-15/`.

The r11 source review applies that boundary to six full-hash editions and 26
pages. Reviewer 1 observed no explicit third-party marker on 25 pages and
bounded both complete press photographs on Lepcha 2024-10-04 page 1 for
exclusion because incidental storefront signage is visible. This does not
establish government authorship or license cleanliness for every page. The
frozen record remains `pending_independent_reviewer_2_and_adjudication`, and no
line labels, training rows, evaluation rows, models, or numbers are admitted.
See `outputs/sikkim-herald-six-edition-manual-review-r1-2026-07-15-r11/`.

The r13 Gurung Khema reopening applies the same boundary to two official State
Portal Gurung Editions dated 2022-03-01 and 2022-04-22, separated by 52 days.
Reviewer 1 inspected all eight pages and recorded no explicit third-party
marker; this is not an authorship finding. The blinded reviewer-2 worksheet is
still blank, and an independent packet audit reports
`PASS_READY_NOT_ADMITTED`. No source string, converted string, crop, label,
prediction, score, training row, or CER has been admitted. The Unicode proposal
and its embedded reference font are decode/attestation evidence only and are
not copied into the frozen outputs. Evidence:
`outputs/sikkim-herald-gurung-khema-two-edition-source-review-2026-07-15-r13/`,
`outputs/sikkim-herald-gurung-khema-font-semantic-audit-2026-07-15-r13/`, and
`outputs/sikkim-herald-gurung-khema-r13-adversarial-bundle-audit-2026-07-15-r13/`.

## Standing remediations

- Add O'Neill/SOAS + upstream attribution wherever Zenodo-6967421 data or
  models appear publicly.
- Produce a dated manifest of ampixa/ocr-tech-artifacts (HF) contents and
  reconcile the live limbu-ocr Space against spaces/limbu-ocr/.
- Fonts without license text stay out of the render pool.