"""Validation gates for defensible OCR quality claims.""" from __future__ import annotations import json import math import random from dataclasses import dataclass, field from pathlib import Path from typing import Any from .errors import ValidationError from .manifest import ManifestEntry, load_manifest, sha256_file, sha256_text LOWER_IS_BETTER = { "cer", "wer", "text_cer", "text_wer", "document_reconstruction_cer", "document_reconstruction_wer", "figure_count_error", "figure_caption_cer", } HIGHER_IS_BETTER = { "quality_score", "document_reconstruction_similarity", "figure_detection_precision", "figure_detection_recall", "figure_detection_f1", "reading_order_pair_accuracy", "table_cell_precision", "table_cell_recall", "table_cell_f1", "table_exact_match", "table_structure_similarity", "table_teds_structure", "table_teds_text", } @dataclass(slots=True) class ClaimGate: baseline: str metric: str direction: str slice: str | None = None slices: list[str] = field(default_factory=list) min_absolute_margin: float = 0.0 min_relative_improvement: float = 0.0 min_pairs: int = 1 min_pair_win_rate: float | None = None max_p_value: float | None = None require_ci_above_zero: bool = True @classmethod def from_dict(cls, data: dict[str, Any]) -> "ClaimGate": metric = str(data.get("metric") or "") direction = str(data.get("direction") or metric_direction(metric)) if direction not in {"lower", "higher"}: raise ValidationError(f"gate direction must be lower or higher: {direction}") baseline = str(data.get("baseline") or "") if not baseline: raise ValidationError("gate baseline is required") if not metric: raise ValidationError("gate metric is required") slices_payload = data.get("slices") if slices_payload is None: slices = [str(data["slice"])] if data.get("slice") else [] elif isinstance(slices_payload, list): slices = [str(item) for item in slices_payload if str(item)] else: raise ValidationError("gate slices must be a list when provided") min_pair_win_rate = _optional_rate(data.get("min_pair_win_rate"), "min_pair_win_rate") return cls( baseline=baseline, metric=metric, direction=direction, slice=data.get("slice"), slices=slices, min_absolute_margin=float(data.get("min_absolute_margin", 0.0)), min_relative_improvement=float(data.get("min_relative_improvement", 0.0)), min_pairs=int(data.get("min_pairs", 1)), min_pair_win_rate=min_pair_win_rate, max_p_value=float(data["max_p_value"]) if data.get("max_p_value") is not None else None, require_ci_above_zero=bool(data.get("require_ci_above_zero", True)), ) def to_dict(self) -> dict[str, Any]: return { "baseline": self.baseline, "metric": self.metric, "direction": self.direction, "slice": self.slice, "slices": self.slices, "min_absolute_margin": self.min_absolute_margin, "min_relative_improvement": self.min_relative_improvement, "min_pairs": self.min_pairs, "min_pair_win_rate": self.min_pair_win_rate, "max_p_value": self.max_p_value, "require_ci_above_zero": self.require_ci_above_zero, } @dataclass(slots=True) class ValidationConfig: candidate: str = "ours" min_samples: int = 30 required_slices: dict[str, int] = field(default_factory=dict) gates: list[ClaimGate] = field(default_factory=list) require_full_eval_manifest_coverage: bool = False bootstrap_iterations: int = 1000 bootstrap_confidence: float = 0.95 random_seed: int = 13 @classmethod def from_path(cls, path: str | Path | None) -> "ValidationConfig": if path is None: return default_validation_config() try: payload = json.loads(Path(path).read_text(encoding="utf-8")) except json.JSONDecodeError as exc: raise ValidationError(f"Invalid validation config JSON {path}: {exc}") from exc if not isinstance(payload, dict): raise ValidationError("validation config must be a JSON object") return cls( candidate=str(payload.get("candidate", "ours")), min_samples=int(payload.get("min_samples", 30)), required_slices={str(key): int(value) for key, value in dict(payload.get("required_slices", {})).items()}, gates=[ClaimGate.from_dict(item) for item in payload.get("gates", [])], require_full_eval_manifest_coverage=bool(payload.get("require_full_eval_manifest_coverage", False)), bootstrap_iterations=int(payload.get("bootstrap_iterations", 1000)), bootstrap_confidence=float(payload.get("bootstrap_confidence", 0.95)), random_seed=int(payload.get("random_seed", 13)), ) @dataclass(slots=True) class LeakageReport: train_manifests: list[str] eval_manifest: str | None overlaps: dict[str, list[str]] warnings: dict[str, list[str]] = field(default_factory=dict) @property def passed(self) -> bool: return not any(self.overlaps.values()) def to_dict(self) -> dict[str, Any]: return { "passed": self.passed, "train_manifests": self.train_manifests, "eval_manifest": self.eval_manifest, "overlaps": self.overlaps, "warnings": self.warnings, } @dataclass(slots=True) class GateResult: gate: ClaimGate passed: bool pairs: int candidate_mean: float | None baseline_mean: float | None absolute_improvement: float | None relative_improvement: float | None improvement_ci_low: float | None improvement_ci_high: float | None win_count: int loss_count: int tie_count: int win_rate: float | None pair_win_rate: float | None sign_test_p_value: float | None reason: str | None = None def to_dict(self) -> dict[str, Any]: return { "gate": self.gate.to_dict(), "passed": self.passed, "pairs": self.pairs, "candidate_mean": self.candidate_mean, "baseline_mean": self.baseline_mean, "absolute_improvement": self.absolute_improvement, "relative_improvement": self.relative_improvement, "improvement_ci_low": self.improvement_ci_low, "improvement_ci_high": self.improvement_ci_high, "win_count": self.win_count, "loss_count": self.loss_count, "tie_count": self.tie_count, "win_rate": self.win_rate, "pair_win_rate": self.pair_win_rate, "sign_test_p_value": self.sign_test_p_value, "reason": self.reason, } @dataclass(slots=True) class ValidationReport: claim_status: str passed: bool sample_count: int slice_counts: dict[str, int] aggregate_metrics: dict[str, dict[str, dict[str, float | int]]] missing_requirements: list[str] leakage: LeakageReport gates: list[GateResult] provenance: dict[str, Any] = field(default_factory=dict) def to_dict(self) -> dict[str, Any]: return { "claim_status": self.claim_status, "passed": self.passed, "sample_count": self.sample_count, "slice_counts": self.slice_counts, "aggregate_metrics": self.aggregate_metrics, "missing_requirements": self.missing_requirements, "leakage": self.leakage.to_dict(), "gates": [gate.to_dict() for gate in self.gates], "provenance": self.provenance, } def validate_claim( benchmark_report: str | Path, output_dir: str | Path, *, config_path: str | Path | None = None, eval_manifest: str | Path | None = None, train_manifests: list[str | Path] | None = None, candidate_model_config: str | Path | None = None, fallback_model_config: str | Path | None = None, ) -> ValidationReport: config = ValidationConfig.from_path(config_path) results = _load_benchmark_results(benchmark_report) eval_entries = load_manifest(eval_manifest) if eval_manifest else [] enriched = [_enrich_result(item, eval_entries) for item in results] candidate_rows = [item for item in enriched if item["baseline"] == config.candidate and item["status"] == "ok"] sample_count = len({sample_key(item) for item in candidate_rows}) slice_counts = _slice_counts(candidate_rows) leakage = check_leakage(train_manifests or [], eval_manifest) missing: list[str] = [] if sample_count < config.min_samples: missing.append(f"candidate sample count {sample_count} < required {config.min_samples}") for slice_name, required_count in config.required_slices.items(): actual = slice_counts.get(slice_name, 0) if actual < required_count: missing.append(f"slice {slice_name!r} count {actual} < required {required_count}") missing.extend(_full_eval_manifest_coverage_failures(enriched, config, eval_entries)) if not leakage.passed: missing.append("train/eval leakage detected") gate_results = [_evaluate_gate(enriched, config, gate) for gate in config.gates] for gate_result in gate_results: if not gate_result.passed: missing.append(gate_result.reason or f"gate failed: {gate_result.gate.metric} vs {gate_result.gate.baseline}") passed = not missing and bool(config.gates) report = ValidationReport( claim_status="validated" if passed else "not_validated", passed=passed, sample_count=sample_count, slice_counts=slice_counts, aggregate_metrics=_aggregate_metrics(enriched), missing_requirements=missing, leakage=leakage, gates=gate_results, provenance=_validation_provenance( benchmark_report, config_path, eval_manifest, train_manifests or [], candidate_model_config, fallback_model_config, ), ) _write_validation_report(report, Path(output_dir)) return report def check_leakage(train_manifests: list[str | Path], eval_manifest: str | Path | None) -> LeakageReport: if eval_manifest is None or not train_manifests: return LeakageReport([str(item) for item in train_manifests], str(eval_manifest) if eval_manifest else None, {}) eval_entries = load_manifest(eval_manifest) train_entries: list[ManifestEntry] = [] for manifest in train_manifests: train_entries.extend(load_manifest(manifest)) overlaps = { "sample_id": sorted({entry.sample_id for entry in train_entries} & {entry.sample_id for entry in eval_entries}), "image_sha256": _hash_overlap(train_entries, eval_entries, "sha256"), "sample_sha256": _sample_hash_overlap(train_entries, eval_entries), "text_sha256": _text_hash_overlap(train_entries, eval_entries), "image_path": sorted({entry.image_path for entry in train_entries} & {entry.image_path for entry in eval_entries}), } warnings = {"text_sha256": overlaps.pop("text_sha256")} return LeakageReport([str(item) for item in train_manifests], str(eval_manifest), overlaps, warnings) def _validation_provenance( benchmark_report: str | Path, config_path: str | Path | None, eval_manifest: str | Path | None, train_manifests: list[str | Path], candidate_model_config: str | Path | None, fallback_model_config: str | Path | None, ) -> dict[str, Any]: benchmark_path = Path(benchmark_report) payload: dict[str, Any] = { "benchmark_report": { "path": str(benchmark_path), "sha256": _sha256_if_file(benchmark_path), }, "validation_config": None, "eval_manifest": None, "candidate_model_config": None, "fallback_model_config": None, "train_manifests": [], } if config_path is not None: config = Path(config_path) payload["validation_config"] = {"path": str(config), "sha256": _sha256_if_file(config)} if eval_manifest is not None: eval_path = Path(eval_manifest) payload["eval_manifest"] = {"path": str(eval_path), "sha256": _sha256_if_file(eval_path)} if candidate_model_config is not None: candidate_path = Path(candidate_model_config) payload["candidate_model_config"] = {"path": str(candidate_path), "sha256": _sha256_if_file(candidate_path)} if fallback_model_config is not None: fallback_path = Path(fallback_model_config) payload["fallback_model_config"] = {"path": str(fallback_path), "sha256": _sha256_if_file(fallback_path)} for manifest in train_manifests: path = Path(manifest) payload["train_manifests"].append({"path": str(path), "sha256": _sha256_if_file(path)}) return payload def _sha256_if_file(path: Path) -> str | None: if not path.exists() or not path.is_file(): return None return sha256_file(path) def _optional_rate(value: object, field_name: str) -> float | None: if value is None: return None rate = float(value) if rate < 0 or rate > 1: raise ValidationError(f"{field_name} must be between 0 and 1") return rate def default_validation_config() -> ValidationConfig: return ValidationConfig( candidate="ours", min_samples=30, required_slices={"nepali": 10, "english": 10, "table": 5, "reading_order": 5, "figure": 5}, require_full_eval_manifest_coverage=False, gates=[ ClaimGate(baseline="tesseract", metric="cer", direction="lower", slice="nepali", min_relative_improvement=0.05, min_pair_win_rate=0.55), ClaimGate(baseline="tesseract", metric="wer", direction="lower", slice="nepali", min_relative_improvement=0.02, min_pair_win_rate=0.55), ClaimGate(baseline="stock-paddle", metric="cer", direction="lower", slice="nepali", min_relative_improvement=0.02, min_pair_win_rate=0.55), ClaimGate(baseline="stock-paddle", metric="cer", direction="lower", slice="english", min_relative_improvement=0.0, require_ci_above_zero=False), ClaimGate(baseline="stock-paddle", metric="wer", direction="lower", slice="english", min_relative_improvement=0.0, require_ci_above_zero=False), ClaimGate(baseline="glm-ocr", metric="cer", direction="lower", slice="nepali", min_relative_improvement=0.02, min_pair_win_rate=0.55), ClaimGate(baseline="surya", metric="table_cell_f1", direction="higher", slice="table", min_absolute_margin=0.01, min_pair_win_rate=0.55), ClaimGate(baseline="surya", metric="table_teds_text", direction="higher", slice="table", min_absolute_margin=0.01, min_pair_win_rate=0.55), ClaimGate(baseline="paddleocr-vl", metric="reading_order_pair_accuracy", direction="higher", slice="reading_order", min_absolute_margin=0.01, min_pair_win_rate=0.55), ClaimGate(baseline="paddleocr-vl", metric="document_reconstruction_similarity", direction="higher", slice="figure", min_absolute_margin=0.01, min_pair_win_rate=0.55), ClaimGate(baseline="surya", metric="figure_detection_f1", direction="higher", slice="figure", min_absolute_margin=0.0, require_ci_above_zero=False), ClaimGate(baseline="surya", metric="figure_caption_cer", direction="lower", slice="figure", min_absolute_margin=0.01, min_pair_win_rate=0.55), ], ) def metric_direction(metric: str) -> str: if metric in LOWER_IS_BETTER: return "lower" if metric in HIGHER_IS_BETTER: return "higher" raise ValidationError(f"Unknown metric direction for {metric!r}; specify direction explicitly") def sample_key(result: dict[str, Any]) -> str: return str(result.get("sample_id") or result.get("input_path") or "") def _load_benchmark_results(path: str | Path) -> list[dict[str, Any]]: payload = json.loads(Path(path).read_text(encoding="utf-8")) if not isinstance(payload, list): raise ValidationError("benchmark report must be a JSON list") rows: list[dict[str, Any]] = [] for index, item in enumerate(payload): if not isinstance(item, dict): raise ValidationError(f"benchmark row {index} must be an object") rows.append(dict(item)) return rows def _enrich_result(row: dict[str, Any], eval_entries: list[ManifestEntry]) -> dict[str, Any]: enriched = dict(row) entry = _entry_for_input(str(row.get("input_path", "")), eval_entries) if entry: enriched["sample_id"] = row.get("sample_id") or entry.sample_id existing_slices = row.get("slices") if isinstance(row.get("slices"), list) else [] enriched["slices"] = sorted({*existing_slices, *_slices_for_entry(entry)}) else: enriched.setdefault("slices", []) return enriched def _entry_for_input(input_path: str, entries: list[ManifestEntry]) -> ManifestEntry | None: if not entries: return None path = Path(input_path) try: resolved = path.resolve() except OSError: resolved = path for entry in entries: entry_path = Path(entry.image_path) try: resolved_entry = entry_path.resolve() except OSError: resolved_entry = entry_path if resolved == resolved_entry or input_path == entry.image_path: return entry return None def _slices_for_entry(entry: ManifestEntry) -> list[str]: values: set[str] = set() metadata = entry.metadata or {} for key in ("slice", "script", "document_type", "degradation", "language"): value = metadata.get(key) if isinstance(value, str) and value: values.add(value) for key in ("slices", "scripts", "tags"): value = metadata.get(key) if isinstance(value, list): values.update(str(item) for item in value if str(item)) elif isinstance(value, str) and value: values.add(value) return sorted(values) def _slice_counts(rows: list[dict[str, Any]]) -> dict[str, int]: counts: dict[str, int] = {} seen: set[tuple[str, str]] = set() for row in rows: key = sample_key(row) for slice_name in row.get("slices", []) or []: pair = (key, str(slice_name)) if pair in seen: continue seen.add(pair) counts[str(slice_name)] = counts.get(str(slice_name), 0) + 1 return counts def _full_eval_manifest_coverage_failures( rows: list[dict[str, Any]], config: ValidationConfig, eval_entries: list[ManifestEntry], ) -> list[str]: if not config.require_full_eval_manifest_coverage: return [] if not eval_entries: return ["eval manifest is required when require_full_eval_manifest_coverage is true"] eval_sample_ids = {entry.sample_id for entry in eval_entries} required_baselines = {config.candidate, *(gate.baseline for gate in config.gates)} failures: list[str] = [] for baseline in sorted(required_baselines): ok_sample_ids = { str(row.get("sample_id")) for row in rows if row.get("baseline") == baseline and row.get("status") == "ok" and str(row.get("sample_id") or "") } missing = sorted(eval_sample_ids - ok_sample_ids) if missing: preview = ", ".join(missing[:5]) suffix = "" if len(missing) <= 5 else f", ... (+{len(missing) - 5} more)" failures.append( f"baseline {baseline!r} is missing successful rows for {len(missing)} eval manifest samples: {preview}{suffix}" ) return failures def _evaluate_gate(rows: list[dict[str, Any]], config: ValidationConfig, gate: ClaimGate) -> GateResult: gate_slices = gate.slices or ([gate.slice] if gate.slice else []) candidate = _rows_by_sample(rows, config.candidate, gate.metric, gate_slices) baseline = _rows_by_sample(rows, gate.baseline, gate.metric, gate_slices) shared = sorted(set(candidate) & set(baseline)) if not shared: return GateResult(gate, False, 0, None, None, None, None, None, None, 0, 0, 0, None, None, None, f"no paired samples for {config.candidate} vs {gate.baseline} on {gate.metric}") candidate_values = [candidate[key] for key in shared] baseline_values = [baseline[key] for key in shared] improvements = [ _absolute_improvement(candidate_value, baseline_value, gate.direction) for candidate_value, baseline_value in zip(candidate_values, baseline_values, strict=True) ] candidate_mean = sum(candidate_values) / len(candidate_values) baseline_mean = sum(baseline_values) / len(baseline_values) absolute = _absolute_improvement(candidate_mean, baseline_mean, gate.direction) relative = _relative_improvement(absolute, baseline_mean) ci_low, ci_high = _bootstrap_ci(improvements, config.bootstrap_iterations, config.bootstrap_confidence, config.random_seed) wins, losses, ties = _paired_outcome_counts(candidate_values, baseline_values, gate.direction) non_ties = wins + losses win_rate = (wins / non_ties) if non_ties else None pair_win_rate = wins / len(shared) sign_test_p_value = _sign_test_p_value(wins, losses) reasons: list[str] = [] if len(shared) < gate.min_pairs: reasons.append(f"paired samples {len(shared)} < required {gate.min_pairs}") if absolute < gate.min_absolute_margin: reasons.append(f"absolute improvement {absolute:.6f} < required {gate.min_absolute_margin:.6f}") if relative < gate.min_relative_improvement: reasons.append(f"relative improvement {relative:.6f} < required {gate.min_relative_improvement:.6f}") if gate.min_pair_win_rate is not None and pair_win_rate < gate.min_pair_win_rate: reasons.append(f"paired win rate {pair_win_rate:.6f} < required {gate.min_pair_win_rate:.6f}") if gate.max_p_value is not None: if sign_test_p_value is None: reasons.append("sign test p-value is unavailable because all paired outcomes are ties") elif sign_test_p_value > gate.max_p_value: reasons.append(f"sign test p-value {sign_test_p_value:.6f} > required {gate.max_p_value:.6f}") if gate.require_ci_above_zero and ci_low <= 0: reasons.append(f"bootstrap CI low {ci_low:.6f} <= 0") return GateResult( gate=gate, passed=not reasons, pairs=len(shared), candidate_mean=candidate_mean, baseline_mean=baseline_mean, absolute_improvement=absolute, relative_improvement=relative, improvement_ci_low=ci_low, improvement_ci_high=ci_high, win_count=wins, loss_count=losses, tie_count=ties, win_rate=win_rate, pair_win_rate=pair_win_rate, sign_test_p_value=sign_test_p_value, reason="; ".join(reasons) if reasons else None, ) def gate_has_quantitative_evidence(item: dict[str, Any]) -> bool: gate = item.get("gate") gate_payload = gate if isinstance(gate, dict) else {} pairs = item.get("pairs") if isinstance(pairs, bool) or not isinstance(pairs, int | float) or int(pairs) <= 0: return False pair_count = int(pairs) for key in ("candidate_mean", "baseline_mean", "absolute_improvement"): value = item.get(key) if isinstance(value, bool) or not isinstance(value, int | float) or not math.isfinite(float(value)): return False counts: list[int] = [] for key in ("win_count", "loss_count", "tie_count"): value = item.get(key) if isinstance(value, bool) or not isinstance(value, int | float): return False count = int(value) if count < 0: return False counts.append(count) if sum(counts) != pair_count: return False min_pairs = gate_payload.get("min_pairs") if min_pairs is not None: if isinstance(min_pairs, bool) or not isinstance(min_pairs, int | float): return False if pair_count < int(min_pairs): return False min_absolute_margin = gate_payload.get("min_absolute_margin") if min_absolute_margin is not None and not _numeric_threshold_passes(item.get("absolute_improvement"), min_absolute_margin): return False min_relative_improvement = gate_payload.get("min_relative_improvement") if min_relative_improvement is not None and not _numeric_threshold_passes(item.get("relative_improvement"), min_relative_improvement): return False min_pair_win_rate = gate_payload.get("min_pair_win_rate") if min_pair_win_rate is not None and not _numeric_threshold_passes(item.get("pair_win_rate"), min_pair_win_rate): return False max_p_value = gate_payload.get("max_p_value") if max_p_value is not None and not _numeric_max_threshold_passes(item.get("sign_test_p_value"), max_p_value): return False if bool(gate_payload.get("require_ci_above_zero", True)): ci_low = item.get("improvement_ci_low") if isinstance(ci_low, bool) or not isinstance(ci_low, int | float) or not math.isfinite(float(ci_low)) or float(ci_low) <= 0: return False return True def _numeric_threshold_passes(value: Any, threshold: Any) -> bool: if isinstance(value, bool) or isinstance(threshold, bool): return False if not isinstance(value, int | float) or not isinstance(threshold, int | float): return False if not math.isfinite(float(value)) or not math.isfinite(float(threshold)): return False return float(value) >= float(threshold) def _numeric_max_threshold_passes(value: Any, threshold: Any) -> bool: if isinstance(value, bool) or isinstance(threshold, bool): return False if not isinstance(value, int | float) or not isinstance(threshold, int | float): return False if not math.isfinite(float(value)) or not math.isfinite(float(threshold)): return False return float(value) <= float(threshold) def _rows_by_sample(rows: list[dict[str, Any]], baseline: str, metric: str, slice_names: list[str] | None) -> dict[str, float]: values: dict[str, float] = {} required_slices = {str(item) for item in slice_names or [] if str(item)} for row in rows: if row.get("baseline") != baseline or row.get("status") != "ok": continue row_slices = {str(item) for item in row.get("slices") or []} if required_slices and not required_slices.issubset(row_slices): continue metrics = row.get("metrics") or {} if metric not in metrics: continue value = metrics[metric] if isinstance(value, int | float) and math.isfinite(float(value)): values[sample_key(row)] = float(value) return values def _absolute_improvement(candidate_value: float, baseline_value: float, direction: str) -> float: if direction == "lower": return baseline_value - candidate_value return candidate_value - baseline_value def _relative_improvement(absolute_improvement: float, baseline_mean: float) -> float: denominator = abs(baseline_mean) if denominator == 0: return math.inf if absolute_improvement > 0 else 0.0 return absolute_improvement / denominator def _bootstrap_ci(values: list[float], iterations: int, confidence: float, seed: int) -> tuple[float, float]: if not values: return 0.0, 0.0 if len(values) == 1 or iterations <= 0: mean = sum(values) / len(values) return mean, mean rng = random.Random(seed) means: list[float] = [] for _ in range(iterations): sample = [values[rng.randrange(len(values))] for _ in values] means.append(sum(sample) / len(sample)) means.sort() alpha = 1 - confidence low_index = max(0, min(len(means) - 1, int((alpha / 2) * len(means)))) high_index = max(0, min(len(means) - 1, int((1 - alpha / 2) * len(means)) - 1)) return means[low_index], means[high_index] def _paired_outcome_counts(candidate_values: list[float], baseline_values: list[float], direction: str) -> tuple[int, int, int]: wins = 0 losses = 0 ties = 0 for candidate_value, baseline_value in zip(candidate_values, baseline_values, strict=True): improvement = _absolute_improvement(candidate_value, baseline_value, direction) if improvement > 0: wins += 1 elif improvement < 0: losses += 1 else: ties += 1 return wins, losses, ties def _sign_test_p_value(wins: int, losses: int) -> float | None: trials = wins + losses if trials == 0: return None numerator = sum(math.comb(trials, success_count) for success_count in range(wins, trials + 1)) return numerator / (2**trials) def _aggregate_metrics(rows: list[dict[str, Any]]) -> dict[str, dict[str, dict[str, float | int]]]: grouped: dict[str, dict[str, dict[str, list[float]]]] = {} for row in rows: if row.get("status") != "ok": continue baseline = str(row.get("baseline") or "") if not baseline: continue slices = [*({str(item) for item in row.get("slices") or []} or {"all"})] slices.append("all") metrics = row.get("metrics") if not isinstance(metrics, dict): continue for slice_name in slices: slice_bucket = grouped.setdefault(baseline, {}).setdefault(slice_name, {}) for metric_name, value in metrics.items(): if isinstance(value, int | float) and math.isfinite(float(value)): slice_bucket.setdefault(str(metric_name), []).append(float(value)) aggregates: dict[str, dict[str, dict[str, float | int]]] = {} for baseline, slice_map in grouped.items(): aggregates[baseline] = {} for slice_name, metric_map in slice_map.items(): aggregates[baseline][slice_name] = { metric_name: sum(values) / len(values) for metric_name, values in sorted(metric_map.items()) if values } if metric_map: first_values = next(iter(metric_map.values())) aggregates[baseline][slice_name]["sample_count"] = len(first_values) return aggregates def _hash_overlap(train_entries: list[ManifestEntry], eval_entries: list[ManifestEntry], attr: str) -> list[str]: train_values = {getattr(entry, attr) for entry in train_entries if getattr(entry, attr)} eval_values = {getattr(entry, attr) for entry in eval_entries if getattr(entry, attr)} return sorted(str(item) for item in train_values & eval_values) def _text_hash_overlap(train_entries: list[ManifestEntry], eval_entries: list[ManifestEntry]) -> list[str]: def text_hash(entry: ManifestEntry) -> str: value = entry.metadata.get("text_sha256") if entry.metadata else None return str(value) if value else sha256_text(entry.text) return sorted({text_hash(entry) for entry in train_entries} & {text_hash(entry) for entry in eval_entries}) def _sample_hash_overlap(train_entries: list[ManifestEntry], eval_entries: list[ManifestEntry]) -> list[str]: def sample_hash(entry: ManifestEntry) -> str: value = entry.metadata.get("sample_sha256") if entry.metadata else None if value: return str(value) image_hash = entry.sha256 or "" return sha256_text(f"{image_hash}\n{sha256_text(entry.text)}") return sorted({sample_hash(entry) for entry in train_entries} & {sample_hash(entry) for entry in eval_entries}) def _write_validation_report(report: ValidationReport, output_dir: Path) -> None: output_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) (output_dir / "validation.json").write_text(json.dumps(report.to_dict(), ensure_ascii=False, indent=2) + "\n", encoding="utf-8") lines = [ "# OCR Claim Validation", "", f"Status: `{report.claim_status}`", f"Samples: `{report.sample_count}`", f"Leakage check: `{'pass' if report.leakage.passed else 'fail'}`", "", "## Missing Requirements", "", ] if report.missing_requirements: lines.extend(f"- {item}" for item in report.missing_requirements) else: lines.append("- none") lines.extend( [ "", "## Gates", "", "| baseline | slice | metric | pairs | wins | losses | ties | win_rate | pair_win_rate | p_value | candidate | baseline_mean | improvement | ci_low | pass | reason |", "| --- | --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- | --- |", ] ) for gate in report.gates: lines.append( "| {baseline} | {slice} | {metric} | {pairs} | {wins} | {losses} | {ties} | {win_rate} | {pair_win_rate} | {p_value} | {candidate} | {baseline_mean} | {improvement} | {ci_low} | {passed} | {reason} |".format( baseline=gate.gate.baseline, slice=",".join(gate.gate.slices or ([gate.gate.slice] if gate.gate.slice else [])), metric=gate.gate.metric, pairs=gate.pairs, wins=gate.win_count, losses=gate.loss_count, ties=gate.tie_count, win_rate=f"{gate.win_rate:.4f}" if gate.win_rate is not None else "", pair_win_rate=f"{gate.pair_win_rate:.4f}" if gate.pair_win_rate is not None else "", p_value=f"{gate.sign_test_p_value:.6f}" if gate.sign_test_p_value is not None else "", candidate=f"{gate.candidate_mean:.6f}" if gate.candidate_mean is not None else "", baseline_mean=f"{gate.baseline_mean:.6f}" if gate.baseline_mean is not None else "", improvement=f"{gate.absolute_improvement:.6f}" if gate.absolute_improvement is not None else "", ci_low=f"{gate.improvement_ci_low:.6f}" if gate.improvement_ci_low is not None else "", passed="yes" if gate.passed else "no", reason=(gate.reason or "").replace("|", "\\|"), ) ) lines.extend(["", "## Aggregate Metrics", ""]) for baseline, slice_map in sorted(report.aggregate_metrics.items()): lines.append(f"### {baseline}") lines.append("") lines.append("| slice | sample_count | metric | mean |") lines.append("| --- | ---: | --- | ---: |") for slice_name, metrics in sorted(slice_map.items()): sample_count = metrics.get("sample_count", "") for metric_name, value in sorted(metrics.items()): if metric_name == "sample_count": continue lines.append(f"| {slice_name} | {sample_count} | {metric_name} | {float(value):.6f} |") lines.append("") (output_dir / "validation.md").write_text("\n".join(lines) + "\n", encoding="utf-8")