decisive-dory / evaluation /llama-comparison.json
rdaum's picture
Add matched base and fine-tuned Q8_0 accuracy results from llama.cpp
b729352 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
5.37 kB
{
"schema": "dory-llama-q8-comparison/v1",
"test_data_sha256": "e2ca7413a306fc2b0e9e044aa685c94d5aa8e0def7cfcec6448941b7369ae625",
"server_sha256": "577c2b294fbf44483b3999032f6db11743c42dc0d5420f2b07f8e6cf76665ccb",
"llama_revision": "3834b4ae1ee6f63b8bf314a07dfb9c45407975b9",
"local_llama_changes": "",
"quantization": "Q8_0",
"device": "NVIDIA DGX Spark / GB10",
"loops": 2,
"calibrated": false,
"same_prompt_and_labels_as_eider": true,
"base": {
"questions": 512,
"modal_accuracy": 0.384765625,
"brier": 0.6735945644865479,
"median_request_ms": 108.9351789560169,
"mean_request_ms": 133.98210436844238,
"by_source": {
"helpsteer2": {
"questions": 128,
"modal_accuracy": 0.4921875,
"brier": 0.3753410996249456,
"median_request_ms": 210.46100556850433,
"mean_request_ms": 206.47532288785442
},
"planning": {
"questions": 192,
"modal_accuracy": 0.3802083333333333,
"brier": 0.650590381539687,
"median_request_ms": 111.42371664755046,
"mean_request_ms": 118.42679404556596
},
"scone": {
"questions": 192,
"modal_accuracy": 0.3177083333333333,
"brier": 0.8954343906744768,
"median_request_ms": 102.34942147508264,
"mean_request_ms": 101.2086023450441
}
},
"by_kind": {
"choice": {
"questions": 241,
"modal_accuracy": 0.2863070539419087,
"brier": 0.7614253393748526,
"median_request_ms": 109.7046872600913,
"mean_request_ms": 119.73183251206311
},
"noul": {
"questions": 94,
"modal_accuracy": 0.5106382978723404,
"brier": 0.6795592626548467,
"median_request_ms": 101.0505030862987,
"mean_request_ms": 96.79506232149582
},
"score": {
"questions": 177,
"modal_accuracy": 0.4519774011299435,
"brier": 0.5508380764871043,
"median_request_ms": 132.75975128635764,
"mean_request_ms": 173.13406747465922
}
},
"model_sha256": "b04185f003dff2c18097b565427b8c0e7be3e203e56cbad084069aa887042bad",
"loops": 2,
"prompt_parity_questions": 512,
"command": [
"llama-server",
"--model",
"dory-base-Q8_0.gguf",
"--alias",
"dory-gguf-eval",
"--host",
"127.0.0.1",
"--port",
"18091",
"--ctx-size",
"4096",
"--parallel",
"1",
"--threads",
"4",
"--threads-batch",
"4",
"--batch-size",
"512",
"--ubatch-size",
"512",
"--fit",
"off",
"--gpu-layers",
"all",
"--no-warmup"
]
},
"fine_tuned": {
"questions": 512,
"modal_accuracy": 0.77734375,
"brier": 0.2599162990600157,
"median_request_ms": 109.77665497921407,
"mean_request_ms": 135.0687600670426,
"by_source": {
"helpsteer2": {
"questions": 128,
"modal_accuracy": 0.515625,
"brier": 0.23377195573417558,
"median_request_ms": 211.45723038353026,
"mean_request_ms": 208.28389131929725
},
"planning": {
"questions": 192,
"modal_accuracy": 0.96875,
"brier": 0.14051244957828152,
"median_request_ms": 112.26724414154887,
"mean_request_ms": 119.26124551003643
},
"scone": {
"questions": 192,
"modal_accuracy": 0.7604166666666666,
"brier": 0.3967497107589765,
"median_request_ms": 103.08765154331923,
"mean_request_ms": 102.06618712254567
}
},
"by_kind": {
"choice": {
"questions": 241,
"modal_accuracy": 0.8257261410788381,
"brier": 0.3344495604077365,
"median_request_ms": 110.2855778299272,
"mean_request_ms": 120.80057657659981
},
"noul": {
"questions": 94,
"modal_accuracy": 0.9680851063829787,
"brier": 0.07220308279158415,
"median_request_ms": 101.73197486437857,
"mean_request_ms": 97.29551964815944
},
"score": {
"questions": 177,
"modal_accuracy": 0.6101694915254238,
"brier": 0.2581226625878792,
"median_request_ms": 134.17465519160032,
"mean_request_ms": 174.55642571999024
}
},
"model_sha256": "bb36b8ed263ce633649ccfad9c6e1dc065e9c3d333624fc27028f496089a38b8",
"loops": 2,
"prompt_parity_questions": 512,
"command": [
"llama-server",
"--model",
"dory-decisions-Q8_0.gguf",
"--alias",
"dory-gguf-eval",
"--host",
"127.0.0.1",
"--port",
"18091",
"--ctx-size",
"4096",
"--parallel",
"1",
"--threads",
"4",
"--threads-batch",
"4",
"--batch-size",
"512",
"--ubatch-size",
"512",
"--fit",
"off",
"--gpu-layers",
"all",
"--no-warmup"
]
},
"cross_entropy_omitted": "The native API returns binary probability rather than raw logits; subtraction can round the complement to zero.",
"base_model": "nvidia/NVIDIA-Nemotron-Labs-Dory1.0-4B-BF16",
"base_model_revision": "b366b87f762ea334ba3eb55912031baba1515810",
"description": "Same 512 questions as the NVFP4 comparison; native /v1/systemone endpoint, no source patches, no calibration, no generated reasoning."
}