SOlPHMdSY3 / data /cumulative_run.json
DineshAI's picture
Publish cumulative five-claim reproduction evidence
beea5e8 verified
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
151 kB
{
"schema_version": 1,
"git_sha": "4236e14fff388b849196a0f53b77c39d16b88209",
"fixed_command": "uv sync --frozen --all-extras && uv run --frozen python -m reproduction.run_all",
"cpu": {
"actual_affinity_cpu_count": 64,
"actual_os_cpu_count": 64,
"cgroup": {
"cpu_max_raw": "800000 100000",
"cpuset_cpus_effective": "0-63",
"quota_cpu_count": 8.0
},
"core_estimate_before_run": 8,
"cuda_visible_devices_name_present": false,
"estimate_basis": "five-million-sample Claim 3 plus paper-scale Claims 4 and 5 use all 8 vCPUs for batched JAX CPU matrix products; estimated peak memory below 8 GB",
"flavor_contract": {
"gpu": false,
"ram_gb": 32,
"vcpus": 8
},
"machine": "x86_64",
"nvidia_smi_present": false,
"python": "3.11.14",
"selected_backend": "hf",
"selected_flavor": "cpu-upgrade"
},
"runtime_seconds": 5225.6622065010015,
"passed": true,
"claim1": {
"verifier": {
"certificate_sha256": "e6fa6bc262d4c3654ca9268e0204356dc3f8f07f7c3620e81aa2ba6394fcf889",
"checks": {
"F_direct_and_propagated_are_unique": true,
"F_has_two_admissible_channel_partitions": true,
"external_signatures_are_unique": true,
"invalid_unpaired_color_rejected": true,
"quartic_rule_covers_D_F_A_B": true,
"translations_include_direct_theta_and_recursive_F": true
},
"claim": "Section 4 graphical rules are executable and translate admissible order-1/n diagrams into layer-wise NTK-tensor recursions",
"covered_quartic_targets": {
"A": [
"ntk_a",
"ntk_a",
"ntk_b",
"ntk_b"
],
"B": [
"ntk_a",
"ntk_b",
"ntk_a",
"ntk_b"
],
"D": [
"z",
"z",
"ntk",
"ntk"
],
"F": [
"z",
"ntk",
"z",
"ntk"
]
},
"demonstrated_recursion": "F",
"diagrams": [
{
"id": "F:direct-propagator",
"partition": "same_internal_channel",
"translation": "Cw^2 E[sigma1 sigma2 sigma3' sigma4'] Theta34",
"vertices": [
"z-ntk cubic",
"z-ntk cubic",
"propagator"
]
},
{
"id": "F:propagated-quartic",
"partition": "distinct_internal_channels",
"translation": "(n_l/n_lm1) Cw^2 sum(E[sigma1 sigma3' z_a] E[sigma2 sigma4' z_b] Kinv[a,g] Kinv[b,d] F[g,3,d,4])",
"vertices": [
"z-ntk cubic",
"z-ntk cubic",
"propagator",
"propagator",
"internal F quartic"
]
}
],
"passed": true,
"source": {
"anchors": [
"S4.SS1",
"S4.E7",
"S4.E11"
],
"arxiv": "2508.11522v4",
"latex_labels": [
"theoremone",
"eq:F",
"feynmanrulesquartic"
]
}
},
"checker": {
"checks": {
"direct_term_has_one_propagator": true,
"recursive_term_has_internal_F": true,
"recursive_term_has_two_propagators": true,
"source_equation_structure": true,
"two_terms": true
},
"passed": true
}
},
"claim2": {
"verifier": {
"certificate_sha256": "3e60f600b5a623dbf3f5301bc1c59d848c12a4a95c1742ee26f34abf91ae7141",
"checks": {
"complete_unique_topologies": true,
"exactly_five_diagrams": true,
"paper_coefficients_match": true,
"three_quartic_vertices": true,
"two_quadratic_vertices": true
},
"claim": "Section 5.1 order-1/n NTK-mean recursion has exactly five diagrams",
"diagrams": [
{
"correction_vertex": {
"algebraic_term": "sum(K1[b1,b2]*E[d_b1_b2 DeltaOmega12])",
"coefficient": "1/2",
"derivative_order": 2,
"external_ntk_lines": 0,
"field": "preactivation",
"name": "K1"
},
"id": "delta_omega:K1",
"outer_vertex": {
"derivative_orders": [
2,
4
],
"insertion_field": "preactivation",
"name": "delta_omega"
}
},
{
"correction_vertex": {
"algebraic_term": "sum(V[(b1,b2),(b3,b4)]*E[d_b1_b2_b3_b4 DeltaOmega12])",
"coefficient": "1/8",
"derivative_order": 4,
"external_ntk_lines": 0,
"field": "preactivation",
"name": "V"
},
"id": "delta_omega:V",
"outer_vertex": {
"derivative_orders": [
2,
4
],
"insertion_field": "preactivation",
"name": "delta_omega"
}
},
{
"correction_vertex": {
"algebraic_term": "Cw*sum(E[d_b1_b2 sigma1_prime*sigma2_prime]*D[b1,b2,1,2])",
"coefficient": "1/2",
"derivative_order": 2,
"external_ntk_lines": 2,
"field": "ntk",
"name": "D"
},
"id": "sigma_prime_pair:D",
"outer_vertex": {
"derivative_orders": [
0,
2
],
"insertion_field": "ntk",
"name": "sigma_prime_pair"
}
},
{
"correction_vertex": {
"algebraic_term": "Cw*sum(E[d_b1_b2 sigma1_prime*sigma2_prime]*F[b1,1,b2,2])",
"coefficient": "1",
"derivative_order": 2,
"external_ntk_lines": 2,
"field": "ntk",
"name": "F"
},
"id": "sigma_prime_pair:F",
"outer_vertex": {
"derivative_orders": [
0,
2
],
"insertion_field": "ntk",
"name": "sigma_prime_pair"
}
},
{
"correction_vertex": {
"algebraic_term": "Cw*Theta1*E[sigma1_prime*sigma2_prime]",
"coefficient": "1",
"derivative_order": 0,
"external_ntk_lines": 2,
"field": "ntk",
"name": "Theta1"
},
"id": "sigma_prime_pair:Theta1",
"outer_vertex": {
"derivative_orders": [
0,
2
],
"insertion_field": "ntk",
"name": "sigma_prime_pair"
}
}
],
"passed": true,
"source": {
"arxiv": "2508.11522v4",
"equation_anchor": "S5.E12",
"html_anchor": "S5.SS1",
"source_sha256": "5237b9fec2f128b23266771acbc8e44837619d5309cd32840ce537071b64c47f"
}
},
"checker": {
"checks": {
"derivative_profile_0_2_2_2_4": true,
"five_serialized_diagrams": true,
"source_vertex_names": true,
"two_preactivation_three_ntk_insertions": true,
"unique_ids": true
},
"passed": true
},
"control": {
"actual_exit": 1,
"command": "python -m reproduction.claim2_negative_control",
"expected_exit": "nonzero",
"passed": true,
"stderr": "",
"stdout": "{\n \"expected\": \"verifier exits nonzero because only four diagrams remain\",\n \"mutation\": \"drop quartic F vertex\",\n \"observed_diagram_count\": 4,\n \"verifier_passed\": false\n}"
}
},
"claim3": {
"symbolic": {
"assumptions": {
"activation": "sigma(lambda*z)=lambda*sigma(z) for lambda>0",
"input": "diagonal x=x",
"network": "bias-free MLP in NTK parameterization",
"weights": "iid centered Gaussian with variance C_W per paper Appendix B"
},
"certificate_sha256": "9cb51c72e4e39a0129a9f0ab6163d9c70acc7fac79981798b8f0e4af8e1b9153",
"checks": {
"E_sigma_prime_squared_is_K_independent": true,
"E_sigma_squared_is_linear_in_K": true,
"all_nonpropagating_sources_vanish": true,
"only_same_order_previous_layer_correction_survives": true,
"positive_homogeneity_reduces_to_two_slopes": true,
"zero_base_closes_induction_for_every_depth_and_order": true
},
"claim": "For every positive-homogeneous scalar activation and every finite depth, every 1/n^k correction (k>=1) to the bias-free MLP NTK mean diagonal is zero",
"classification_lemma": "On R, positive homogeneity implies sigma(z)=a_plus*z for z>0 and sigma(z)=a_minus*z for z<0 (the value at zero is null-set).",
"gaussian_expectations": {
"E_Omega": "C_W*Theta*a_minus**2/2 + C_W*Theta*a_plus**2/2 + K*a_minus**2/2 + K*a_plus**2/2",
"E_sigma_prime_squared": "a_minus**2/2 + a_plus**2/2",
"E_sigma_squared": "K*a_minus**2/2 + K*a_plus**2/2"
},
"induction_schema": {
"base": "Theta_correction(k, layer=1)=0",
"conclusion": "Theta_correction(k, layer=l)=0 for every finite l",
"quantifier": "for every k>=1 and layer l>=1",
"recurrence": "C_W*Theta_correction*a_minus**2/2 + C_W*Theta_correction*a_plus**2/2"
},
"instances": {
"LeakyReLU(alpha=0.1)": {
"A": 0.505,
"a_minus": 0.1,
"a_plus": 1.0
},
"ReLU": {
"A": 0.5,
"a_minus": 0.0,
"a_plus": 1.0
},
"identity": {
"A": 1.0,
"a_minus": 1.0,
"a_plus": 1.0
}
},
"passed": true,
"vanishing_sources": {
"D_F_source_first_K_derivative": "0",
"K1_source_second_K_derivative": "0",
"V_source_second_K_derivative": "0"
}
},
"symbolic_checker": {
"checks": {
"gelu_control_is_K_dependent": true,
"piecewise_linear_quadrature_matches_closed_form": true
},
"gelu_control": {
"E_sigma_prime2": [
0.3556851396521125,
0.45585086564928723,
0.5060447941597346
],
"K": [
0.25,
1.0,
4.0
]
},
"max_abs_error": 8.881784197001252E-16,
"passed": true,
"rows": [
{
"E_sigma2": 0.12500000000000003,
"E_sigma_prime2": 0.5000000000000001,
"K": 0.25,
"activation": "ReLU",
"expected_E_sigma2": 0.125,
"expected_E_sigma_prime2": 0.5
},
{
"E_sigma2": 0.5000000000000001,
"E_sigma_prime2": 0.5000000000000001,
"K": 1.0,
"activation": "ReLU",
"expected_E_sigma2": 0.5,
"expected_E_sigma_prime2": 0.5
},
{
"E_sigma2": 2.0000000000000004,
"E_sigma_prime2": 0.5000000000000001,
"K": 4.0,
"activation": "ReLU",
"expected_E_sigma2": 2.0,
"expected_E_sigma_prime2": 0.5
},
{
"E_sigma2": 0.12625000000000006,
"E_sigma_prime2": 0.5050000000000001,
"K": 0.25,
"activation": "LeakyReLU(alpha=0.1)",
"expected_E_sigma2": 0.12625,
"expected_E_sigma_prime2": 0.505
},
{
"E_sigma2": 0.5050000000000002,
"E_sigma_prime2": 0.5050000000000001,
"K": 1.0,
"activation": "LeakyReLU(alpha=0.1)",
"expected_E_sigma2": 0.505,
"expected_E_sigma_prime2": 0.505
},
{
"E_sigma2": 2.020000000000001,
"E_sigma_prime2": 0.5050000000000001,
"K": 4.0,
"activation": "LeakyReLU(alpha=0.1)",
"expected_E_sigma2": 2.02,
"expected_E_sigma_prime2": 0.505
},
{
"E_sigma2": 0.25000000000000006,
"E_sigma_prime2": 1.0000000000000002,
"K": 0.25,
"activation": "identity",
"expected_E_sigma2": 0.25,
"expected_E_sigma_prime2": 1.0
},
{
"E_sigma2": 1.0000000000000002,
"E_sigma_prime2": 1.0000000000000002,
"K": 1.0,
"activation": "identity",
"expected_E_sigma2": 1.0,
"expected_E_sigma_prime2": 1.0
},
{
"E_sigma2": 4.000000000000001,
"E_sigma_prime2": 1.0000000000000002,
"K": 4.0,
"activation": "identity",
"expected_E_sigma2": 4.0,
"expected_E_sigma_prime2": 1.0
}
]
},
"symbolic_control": {
"actual_exit": 1,
"command": "python -m reproduction.claim3_negative_control",
"expected_exit": "nonzero",
"passed": true,
"stderr": "",
"stdout": "{\n \"E_sigma_prime2\": [\n 0.3556851396521125,\n 0.45585086564928723,\n 0.5060447941597346\n ],\n \"K\": [\n 0.25,\n 1.0,\n 4.0\n ],\n \"expected\": \"failure because E[sigma'(Z)^2] depends on K\",\n \"mutant_passed\": false,\n \"mutation\": \"treat GeLU as scale invariant\"\n}"
},
"empirical": {
"architecture": {
"bias": false,
"depth": 4,
"hidden_widths": [
20,
80
],
"output_width": 2,
"parameterization": "paper Appendix B standard/book convention",
"weight_variance": 2.0
},
"checks": {
"all_widths_at_least_20": true,
"exact_five_million_initializations_per_width": true,
"one_hundred_raw_block_means_per_activation_width": true,
"paper_four_layer_bias_free_architecture": true,
"paper_two_output_trace_average": true,
"paper_weight_variance": true,
"relu_and_leakyrelu_alpha_point_one": true,
"statistical_contract_passes": true
},
"claim": "At exact five-million-initialization scale, four-layer bias-free ReLU and LeakyReLU diagonal NTK means equal their infinite-width values",
"columns": [
"theta_00",
"theta_01"
],
"common_random_numbers": "ReLU and LeakyReLU share each Gaussian initialization and probe; networks remain iid within each activation",
"estimator_deviation": "Unbiased two-probe parameter-space Hutchinson estimator replaces the paper implementation's exact recursive Jacobian trace",
"hutchinson_probes_per_network": 2,
"inputs": [
[
-0.9895229339599609,
-0.5992491841316223
],
[
-0.17877478897571564,
2.253682851791382
]
],
"network_initializations_per_activation_width": 5000000,
"passed": true,
"rows": [
{
"activation": "ReLU",
"block_means_100_blocks_of_50000": [
[
2.6783425482870626,
0.9258352492427622
],
[
2.6761746195290477,
0.9322187282206309
],
[
2.6527065729109354,
0.9125695396642124
],
[
2.6549296094563273,
0.9363044664708726
],
[
2.665524776278125,
0.9297937898684541
],
[
2.6749055931950796,
0.9269220961732022
],
[
2.693386698950986,
0.9423445014164067
],
[
2.6852233529129217,
0.9593772871714561
],
[
2.6827467166832064,
0.9318991389081616
],
[
2.687101779731815,
0.9466628236979304
],
[
2.6573921861033885,
0.9350032624853535
],
[
2.678300516304922,
0.9471803678704089
],
[
2.6954035673536385,
0.9402840764690049
],
[
2.670214834606817,
0.9370065361609831
],
[
2.6600692990500874,
0.9464911748761317
],
[
2.6965018019626257,
0.9432597350928897
],
[
2.6660305497320067,
0.9452989253648376
],
[
2.6612933308351243,
0.9407292157783654
],
[
2.686372353241414,
0.922634197590508
],
[
2.6873273993369904,
0.9558120440327567
],
[
2.665090416901469,
0.9234591770089643
],
[
2.6653886898083834,
0.9426630106440594
],
[
2.670843515763823,
0.932396978522563
],
[
2.6808012397345187,
0.9342545547218901
],
[
2.6748898342386074,
0.942552271419812
],
[
2.6735201125276076,
0.9496047251812105
],
[
2.6834253252419304,
0.9401225760324091
],
[
2.6698999839418667,
0.9376250724614105
],
[
2.6956691217238316,
0.9374389187899956
],
[
2.671478388275465,
0.9365460086929673
],
[
2.677659724242862,
0.950169669589249
],
[
2.713323003161441,
0.9259988850924142
],
[
2.6859593922311276,
0.9588435543245283
],
[
2.6899404644880036,
0.9155384069045297
],
[
2.69284506402673,
0.927338062949414
],
[
2.6938980980289977,
0.9297974945635297
],
[
2.6553862829399546,
0.9455158768779146
],
[
2.6888064731214474,
0.92867477513721
],
[
2.673656426090894,
0.9195007197344934
],
[
2.6594293316936803,
0.9470181124029873
],
[
2.6929825981642677,
0.9306347151440012
],
[
2.660840785444638,
0.9486170232804119
],
[
2.688672569456027,
0.9443702577229656
],
[
2.6980735602150085,
0.9408773404166425
],
[
2.679952935754077,
0.9080158769317852
],
[
2.6788739716090664,
0.9571919544204505
],
[
2.665415763429007,
0.9297589229349416
],
[
2.685107606449169,
0.9671732754094372
],
[
2.6632551845221193,
0.9289956439896236
],
[
2.6541525214337716,
0.9304349981152771
],
[
2.66260918624293,
0.926674201203977
],
[
2.6725596506492297,
0.9410772917058312
],
[
2.693853727569917,
0.9461606928835891
],
[
2.66881113477589,
0.9439287392608334
],
[
2.6707606882630563,
0.9110219595031613
],
[
2.6895290304000112,
0.9035609242099018
],
[
2.6841537517961003,
0.9419865325869212
],
[
2.6836345136375646,
0.9378589083727407
],
[
2.6742542081561473,
0.92953676296977
],
[
2.6530904327114095,
0.9123710331666488
],
[
2.6558944009286347,
0.9204824712818757
],
[
2.70084680856936,
0.9356351964850066
],
[
2.6632324295436933,
0.9228836549390402
],
[
2.6732425237340265,
0.9253386298097184
],
[
2.662215134227018,
0.9094101987475379
],
[
2.694377721402639,
0.9470137298690097
],
[
2.6852206810630324,
0.9382347033161944
],
[
2.689725205105922,
0.9317856418523208
],
[
2.6756138053062006,
0.9367672381084861
],
[
2.66986570241971,
0.9159554444678478
],
[
2.6688079538152802,
0.9344086115224466
],
[
2.687062644206826,
0.943993120519866
],
[
2.6981847930036382,
0.9376177418344295
],
[
2.6662787359315843,
0.9157345172014597
],
[
2.6711269190455234,
0.9176304072626619
],
[
2.67854083667322,
0.9325076463597803
],
[
2.673815580411591,
0.9434964564973332
],
[
2.6897134909108025,
0.9312300670453264
],
[
2.6850909594038384,
0.936075244993932
],
[
2.6940371002641004,
0.940673441061155
],
[
2.679981584728044,
0.9260362481943208
],
[
2.675444184784478,
0.9263657753389102
],
[
2.6825269726236223,
0.9226757549833978
],
[
2.680969161601638,
0.9378714451955591
],
[
2.666032693915852,
0.9377984078096965
],
[
2.675402791474532,
0.9511708263592457
],
[
2.6702393855319744,
0.9430584033117992
],
[
2.70073558751275,
0.9423456549021464
],
[
2.6596871120480645,
0.9201222985550283
],
[
2.6762516919368027,
0.9421213526402673
],
[
2.6657077894731054,
0.9329670192769045
],
[
2.683571541034698,
0.9251511457942857
],
[
2.695674519285732,
0.947979751148422
],
[
2.673259230202085,
0.9374708884998011
],
[
2.6826764114221446,
0.921330016991207
],
[
2.6713818727637157,
0.9266984332465429
],
[
2.6554298104605394,
0.9396030445051559
],
[
2.6934330043961845,
0.9331498487755362
],
[
2.6848331179478784,
0.934194536025985
],
[
2.6888536163666856,
0.9446836380655141
]
],
"comparison": {
"diagonal_relative_99pct_upper": 0.0017220324996210816,
"diagonal_relative_shift": 0.0003974728290340073,
"diagonal_z": 0.7730040634090816,
"offdiagonal_relative_shift": 0.06421189315035206,
"offdiagonal_z": 48.487503357628626
},
"infinite_ntk": [
2.6765104430302884,
0.99886503184261
],
"mean": [
2.6775742832080187,
0.9347260171463093
],
"seed": 325081522,
"standard_deviation": [
3.0773692755370976,
2.9578589727124394
],
"standard_error": [
0.0013762413783940462,
0.0013227947461685419
],
"width": 20,
"width_runtime_seconds": 673.1639955029823
},
{
"activation": "LeakyReLU(alpha=0.1)",
"block_means_100_blocks_of_50000": [
[
2.7604664008666626,
0.6224261547772376
],
[
2.7644203813936206,
0.6317754216701004
],
[
2.7413785884095856,
0.6162242864359434
],
[
2.732027074248641,
0.6423951212665133
],
[
2.739933033384655,
0.6294706646659252
],
[
2.7516388538024668,
0.6317465936017391
],
[
2.7792268016311468,
0.6437033838399899
],
[
2.762476447396755,
0.6548780374401041
],
[
2.771627642132785,
0.6349838620682153
],
[
2.7689131111776533,
0.6451232568665455
],
[
2.733319763507397,
0.6411802055597993
],
[
2.7562406564675177,
0.6455323311357656
],
[
2.778095500450997,
0.6434484413226677
],
[
2.7480870313077124,
0.6514087435811688
],
[
2.739323535423916,
0.6506836250632462
],
[
2.7800310031721223,
0.6492303042515487
],
[
2.758788988592997,
0.656875854156976
],
[
2.7446676927185325,
0.6373817817795647
],
[
2.7669212335091165,
0.6219601965013783
],
[
2.7706052080928996,
0.6520726273125336
],
[
2.7440461338440634,
0.6207292854073817
],
[
2.743200552027711,
0.6368867115369546
],
[
2.755461778482693,
0.6263889613991579
],
[
2.7631716372407,
0.6317148978346263
],
[
2.747754992421778,
0.6474273167555488
],
[
2.758421039243154,
0.6505087713924568
],
[
2.7625078890772334,
0.6466732916221022
],
[
2.7473698388471735,
0.6367160737206947
],
[
2.7854817862565846,
0.6569882044511712
],
[
2.7553083893754695,
0.6382790741440182
],
[
2.754071223520162,
0.6540355924149632
],
[
2.7846636424633915,
0.6300710975556897
],
[
2.76350870387976,
0.6617014487204351
],
[
2.7686192785761103,
0.6197716941456014
],
[
2.7715724338258823,
0.6351446508935754
],
[
2.7682219531537924,
0.6314327324650664
],
[
2.738400623758084,
0.6541495983495759
],
[
2.768416107973596,
0.6226426204105099
],
[
2.748741455756826,
0.6140812560635498
],
[
2.7389227780308625,
0.6502590449321717
],
[
2.777603298171434,
0.6308585755297703
],
[
2.7462618580128426,
0.652388863032148
],
[
2.7763475018212036,
0.6379169179375499
],
[
2.7853778926732846,
0.641358075208008
],
[
2.765974112072297,
0.6244028095616029
],
[
2.756376765956118,
0.6509992516184717
],
[
2.7439619611719857,
0.6290431252691645
],
[
2.7676328455705974,
0.6641905977334444
],
[
2.7431427959575063,
0.6379053651424901
],
[
2.741461673404905,
0.6293636450337337
],
[
2.741002157081161,
0.6272593693898111
],
[
2.7584544163473184,
0.6488280697317577
],
[
2.7716295559391226,
0.653957343890914
],
[
2.7477587843212565,
0.648255554870982
],
[
2.751019461409742,
0.605018697236856
],
[
2.769985392089921,
0.6115679292917505
],
[
2.7663652284744744,
0.6421467815980729
],
[
2.7696221783948083,
0.6414534595902516
],
[
2.748440309416354,
0.6308901685218403
],
[
2.7373699942268392,
0.6196286150937517
],
[
2.735985360130624,
0.6257192563340003
],
[
2.776357633272058,
0.635566719033216
],
[
2.7488636650746257,
0.6306373216101037
],
[
2.753156308133066,
0.617547993517513
],
[
2.7435262966072362,
0.6186248993868886
],
[
2.7761616149609165,
0.6451360207202113
],
[
2.766077164049434,
0.6331767041609967
],
[
2.7793882918233592,
0.630907618996932
],
[
2.7590588841081916,
0.6493219000135934
],
[
2.7527059874221225,
0.611222490894738
],
[
2.7583483086069904,
0.6286702616202481
],
[
2.768117129353161,
0.6527848770324326
],
[
2.7897109775018913,
0.641112226048564
],
[
2.749546819587804,
0.63255357217092
],
[
2.7601383456076065,
0.6220638041841154
],
[
2.75716372746003,
0.6401846142636218
],
[
2.7577166488071314,
0.6310056221698288
],
[
2.776992188666474,
0.642525747702192
],
[
2.765287355157635,
0.6362382016662869
],
[
2.782958819297961,
0.6388926238989238
],
[
2.7600144359463283,
0.6288570672371397
],
[
2.7568124010100883,
0.6343692677649714
],
[
2.760278263056913,
0.6282365315157082
],
[
2.757223042295061,
0.6249803795533685
],
[
2.7448534899169212,
0.6411873499780423
],
[
2.7656993210752048,
0.643602400333187
],
[
2.7567785800160807,
0.6415477049899427
],
[
2.771919917789152,
0.6398056380542841
],
[
2.7522778958177736,
0.63164688045066
],
[
2.7558518168236343,
0.6389594770660514
],
[
2.7476772909249507,
0.636788925510137
],
[
2.7636071814181613,
0.6360445191465773
],
[
2.780651237965409,
0.6405481810605058
],
[
2.747553308426782,
0.6469636007793919
],
[
2.7607390751973004,
0.6177231310139312
],
[
2.7597166370869246,
0.6310408607913692
],
[
2.7362451708746143,
0.6439066027971683
],
[
2.771612945185243,
0.6265448661209533
],
[
2.7650825375102874,
0.6423663612309168
],
[
2.7633462001443516,
0.6474571376042646
]
],
"comparison": {
"diagonal_relative_99pct_upper": 0.0018775820115618886,
"diagonal_relative_shift": 0.0005653553883766018,
"diagonal_z": 1.1098353399681702,
"offdiagonal_relative_shift": 0.08298822887068236,
"offdiagonal_z": 43.62020428843196
},
"infinite_ntk": [
2.7576113859645495,
0.6944513450769862
],
"mean": [
2.759170416420653,
0.6368200579121841
],
"seed": 325081522,
"standard_deviation": [
3.141094857314975,
2.9543070197285686
],
"standard_error": [
0.0014047403249462572,
0.0013212062645035782
],
"width": 20,
"width_runtime_seconds": 673.1639955029823
},
{
"activation": "ReLU",
"block_means_100_blocks_of_50000": [
[
2.6856613944963943,
1.0149110284475644
],
[
2.671089685518959,
0.9869124039267865
],
[
2.671460652134416,
0.9862135679036343
],
[
2.6716262197791893,
0.9848043119058684
],
[
2.679773762548168,
0.9908798927796821
],
[
2.6813725164780213,
0.9948221996891514
],
[
2.6757426848543266,
0.9814054383135153
],
[
2.6755259394339648,
0.9918915378414278
],
[
2.674938068043258,
0.9624829515732125
],
[
2.676495433947211,
1.0012810206073188
],
[
2.6767217889647554,
0.9772352301880981
],
[
2.6808640130825947,
0.9755412666067919
],
[
2.6665424688624,
0.977824336674932
],
[
2.666722440884357,
0.9743099720187236
],
[
2.6785599065159,
0.985871314924498
],
[
2.6849176008043623,
1.0021248090909325
],
[
2.686805475988398,
0.9913679000316492
],
[
2.6842746502685477,
1.0027893142678173
],
[
2.679865207343694,
0.9939814402478985
],
[
2.6689391423176776,
0.9659957554791317
],
[
2.695557813667443,
0.9780192183161841
],
[
2.667542648698599,
0.9800556819265972
],
[
2.6656890556680723,
0.9859674448566947
],
[
2.6751711963797886,
0.9933755719974628
],
[
2.6756743516804526,
0.9859609025811732
],
[
2.676966676734294,
0.9916361135185564
],
[
2.6748190349177223,
0.9751707450366476
],
[
2.6856412113240453,
1.0062647762983248
],
[
2.6571995279253855,
0.9823255794579537
],
[
2.686548697316964,
1.0077487346594922
],
[
2.7059434566784564,
0.9941635359811899
],
[
2.6909445377135457,
0.9962667538162713
],
[
2.6679258623704887,
0.9737427139120457
],
[
2.6707646670810075,
1.0031059729944987
],
[
2.6688456018544966,
0.9846771604729506
],
[
2.688584274165827,
0.9982305815405753
],
[
2.674701710950169,
0.9935323788816245
],
[
2.6816691489391586,
0.9756608228882269
],
[
2.677031583611458,
0.9847922327434111
],
[
2.6605800763535843,
0.9619100117454141
],
[
2.6808076036102872,
0.9975816245416966
],
[
2.668518065241449,
0.9786160918649971
],
[
2.675999448061523,
0.9786463613699686
],
[
2.6791405667493042,
1.0028777857863393
],
[
2.672945844127781,
0.9950582666750014
],
[
2.6785502937914116,
0.9879348860273679
],
[
2.6894681162934932,
0.9637273557890975
],
[
2.6880104810481265,
0.9785734777830816
],
[
2.6799841555002186,
0.990282327809798
],
[
2.6776783360930843,
0.9785765291138191
],
[
2.6756546337058156,
0.9911509927775852
],
[
2.6677766614825598,
0.9839840478884073
],
[
2.6631827706540108,
0.9663696999437852
],
[
2.669566971412229,
0.9948231768033117
],
[
2.671068983252703,
0.9795203496171061
],
[
2.68302394519283,
0.988776856937853
],
[
2.684492004053772,
0.9900877940554619
],
[
2.6674856728302765,
0.9853763348211059
],
[
2.6783623133413474,
0.9806984666393642
],
[
2.658448380439567,
0.9787160038277001
],
[
2.6656957494590205,
0.9752209791867067
],
[
2.679980438374061,
1.0081515008874264
],
[
2.666122860467282,
0.9930937511125443
],
[
2.673972423380766,
0.9664861536650936
],
[
2.6895514356810817,
0.981458855244673
],
[
2.691402222927627,
0.9945121753681734
],
[
2.6765485944062695,
0.9703408630023115
],
[
2.682915195339002,
1.0129607376290495
],
[
2.6662193364180533,
0.9922289070750661
],
[
2.6728232231524167,
0.9872135182642321
],
[
2.6751755981625367,
0.969243972969811
],
[
2.691343111534995,
0.9641975300988135
],
[
2.691468177535064,
0.9928333511888073
],
[
2.6842797029771917,
0.9752266428361066
],
[
2.692572106835693,
0.9843287582154574
],
[
2.6998033001884356,
0.9796392485453395
],
[
2.6733118978526846,
0.9582184802756991
],
[
2.6623764008465023,
0.9991736242305668
],
[
2.6831817374161258,
0.9935526173934949
],
[
2.6800109703699606,
0.9810800146252576
],
[
2.6553189764542076,
0.9637920558819587
],
[
2.6738122414733696,
0.9977594749482501
],
[
2.670538965524953,
0.9995581879161308
],
[
2.6848900630072983,
0.9928245372337455
],
[
2.693914998102673,
1.0075922227852425
],
[
2.669446167494022,
0.9986345128923689
],
[
2.6687136341671103,
0.9694009675298422
],
[
2.6741340803082014,
0.9715238770246827
],
[
2.6807813740087476,
0.980324603115699
],
[
2.6752354339097475,
0.9825746857626417
],
[
2.6616952985093936,
0.9740344391171374
],
[
2.6722263579067214,
0.9736385036603532
],
[
2.694946430445112,
1.003567180898377
],
[
2.6634874565334417,
0.9791313148306048
],
[
2.6811847385525356,
0.9838433646777114
],
[
2.6602989721633086,
0.9825141388900014
],
[
2.6767197214022116,
0.9808713512071686
],
[
2.6802438543623133,
0.9909825405767384
],
[
2.6875057725017566,
0.9812299019917926
],
[
2.6633188297102857,
0.9644330136748142
]
],
"comparison": {
"diagonal_relative_99pct_upper": 0.0010697611625737245,
"diagonal_relative_shift": 0.00011951748627026498,
"diagonal_z": 0.32399799368291965,
"offdiagonal_relative_shift": 0.013440049744640092,
"offdiagonal_z": 10.976232638848568
},
"infinite_ntk": [
2.6765104430302884,
0.99886503184261
],
"mean": [
2.6768303328304155,
0.9854402361264638
],
"seed": 325181522,
"standard_deviation": [
2.207715332623401,
2.7348869865516883
],
"standard_error": [
0.0009873203117428968,
0.0012230786425418256
],
"width": 80,
"width_runtime_seconds": 3227.3077975248452
},
{
"activation": "LeakyReLU(alpha=0.1)",
"block_means_100_blocks_of_50000": [
[
2.7618616755555796,
0.7136928615888654
],
[
2.744754125164058,
0.6764322888154117
],
[
2.7441623310761014,
0.6777681289333681
],
[
2.755808345680072,
0.6873449009830683
],
[
2.761905983052042,
0.688311386135718
],
[
2.7613660266322744,
0.687940681908731
],
[
2.760064233450796,
0.6869223878180286
],
[
2.7527606418961224,
0.686422070987935
],
[
2.7533061512200923,
0.6607696735388164
],
[
2.745802171656287,
0.6909483958843572
],
[
2.750360559504201,
0.6714680965746948
],
[
2.7558690939010826,
0.662593708707735
],
[
2.748026967777,
0.67545888857795
],
[
2.7519313563005965,
0.6675751409708477
],
[
2.76035065680941,
0.6670915764376054
],
[
2.765622824386658,
0.6915665846451523
],
[
2.764791024543994,
0.6804368852484985
],
[
2.7617943302600314,
0.6955651333907312
],
[
2.7682407788651204,
0.6853709222402254
],
[
2.753447613661808,
0.6689793639043972
],
[
2.7694026557218696,
0.6796048459405893
],
[
2.749177028131922,
0.6744403068428939
],
[
2.7445210293497837,
0.6828918782477201
],
[
2.7612977360842836,
0.693901926020966
],
[
2.7564304917691276,
0.6902806699413567
],
[
2.753470027599266,
0.6781665458459599
],
[
2.7579303344993074,
0.6673172149727112
],
[
2.7681817202962042,
0.6962194590239643
],
[
2.7328114825349643,
0.6735206066071727
],
[
2.7709768702609265,
0.6969249074524068
],
[
2.781167487867511,
0.6970499790798121
],
[
2.770026749609882,
0.686025408466818
],
[
2.7521922188635655,
0.6772042242082736
],
[
2.748403321835362,
0.6912335285418452
],
[
2.7468399122816156,
0.684359650308714
],
[
2.759843453133584,
0.6890946919561742
],
[
2.760010594786313,
0.6929043527798129
],
[
2.7653006503367052,
0.6650506207289355
],
[
2.753707271041912,
0.6831208858890772
],
[
2.742918953952749,
0.6620124436833228
],
[
2.7584174801753423,
0.6901707550168786
],
[
2.747223809097245,
0.6742240042296381
],
[
2.756643170284574,
0.6691347396918106
],
[
2.7604359520160338,
0.6924634086961471
],
[
2.7527927496495326,
0.6779256887257044
],
[
2.7637221377294394,
0.6809104184269879
],
[
2.763458747321241,
0.6583510163797839
],
[
2.765680295680733,
0.6705257535148742
],
[
2.767753248526499,
0.6950603537604593
],
[
2.761124485788227,
0.6827431407346513
],
[
2.7567805121939926,
0.6880458949518351
],
[
2.7496800707076257,
0.6932604956333551
],
[
2.746145759017324,
0.666875366726258
],
[
2.7500815307225084,
0.6908585156014528
],
[
2.749838662113529,
0.6833894315242705
],
[
2.757015346010423,
0.6894412493683357
],
[
2.760702084811624,
0.6823566528074161
],
[
2.7515781050078973,
0.6846302267821978
],
[
2.7658392320483416,
0.6761344625314578
],
[
2.741517292598808,
0.6737258303561856
],
[
2.7494364182783024,
0.6715732778121001
],
[
2.7628697147322585,
0.7091246627110226
],
[
2.7450373261227377,
0.683521692418138
],
[
2.752059587426712,
0.6663800459227834
],
[
2.768691878849486,
0.6865754972455667
],
[
2.774122863598422,
0.6868210761479717
],
[
2.763117978618924,
0.6698142940851796
],
[
2.764179859130177,
0.7098722665215802
],
[
2.741390571700419,
0.6885904311859621
],
[
2.752419422771229,
0.6810620956372931
],
[
2.7497619846029986,
0.6633885454002735
],
[
2.7817875331330426,
0.6613375013602982
],
[
2.7655730101962233,
0.6876356484898756
],
[
2.7633752936902556,
0.6650823700842601
],
[
2.769574433259018,
0.6769578126004097
],
[
2.781299447803785,
0.6746414675983177
],
[
2.7482326606001823,
0.6575191889829638
],
[
2.7458941241553996,
0.6897722305898902
],
[
2.7614218498806387,
0.6789880231917005
],
[
2.7602977114801703,
0.6761774043033483
],
[
2.7357440377703734,
0.6693756063911367
],
[
2.757380594814326,
0.6991991424541903
],
[
2.7551472930569196,
0.6916182951127366
],
[
2.7613512330488477,
0.6827947908578018
],
[
2.7693183854779058,
0.7030566936365142
],
[
2.7428911948141472,
0.6976669176991396
],
[
2.7513189951086683,
0.6658449086024184
],
[
2.7535616847916295,
0.6765308010838474
],
[
2.764029709884479,
0.6759523408062791
],
[
2.761445436717987,
0.6810069530091294
],
[
2.7451454989475663,
0.6653490980283091
],
[
2.7524582587003916,
0.6814388876628399
],
[
2.771594940822348,
0.6999662355266044
],
[
2.743232299597559,
0.6840783146469436
],
[
2.754459091715333,
0.6784649935430376
],
[
2.7417341057879674,
0.682929400778807
],
[
2.753237938839562,
0.6671591332555068
],
[
2.760193634767628,
0.6792316073727571
],
[
2.763218197689311,
0.6773552767443666
],
[
2.7395646431484844,
0.6595332059241019
]
],
"comparison": {
"diagonal_relative_99pct_upper": 0.001274041083194552,
"diagonal_relative_shift": 0.0003274580259284991,
"diagonal_z": 0.8911335020385063,
"offdiagonal_relative_shift": 0.019260323310837536,
"offdiagonal_z": 10.78364594372259
},
"infinite_ntk": [
2.7576113859645495,
0.6944513450769862
],
"mean": [
2.7567083839838236,
0.6810759876471575
],
"seed": 325181522,
"standard_deviation": [
2.265848840943729,
2.7734783386378004
],
"standard_error": [
0.0010133184070178574,
0.0012403372198634605
],
"width": 80,
"width_runtime_seconds": 3227.3077975248452
}
],
"runtime_seconds": 3900.474571322091,
"source_pdf_sha256": {
"leakyrelu": "85a5e639eda539957ddcf835e734a8d4c37b7dcb10d9c7f6f13379be27fb52bd",
"relu": "9dcccaca6bf62d5d07ffd24e8b1c346e3e25b07bef099dc85b2f0eb88c187c0a"
},
"verification": {
"checks": {
"all_diagonal_99pct_intervals_inside_1pct_equivalence_margin": true,
"all_diagonal_means_within_4_standard_errors": true,
"all_offdiagonal_controls_detect_at_least_1pct_correction_at_5se": true,
"every_activation_width_pair_passes": true
},
"passed": true
}
},
"empirical_checker": {
"checks": {
"leakyrelu_hutchinson_matches_exact_jacobian": true,
"leakyrelu_recurrence_matches_independent_closed_form": true,
"relu_hutchinson_matches_exact_jacobian": true,
"relu_recurrence_matches_independent_closed_form": true
},
"hutchinson_probes": 8192,
"independent_closed_form_diagonal": {
"LeakyReLU(alpha=0.1)": 2.7576113859645495,
"ReLU": 2.6765104430302884
},
"leakyrelu": {
"exact_trace_average": [
1.9096932631592056,
-0.2748758359408663
],
"hutchinson_standard_error": [
0.025453807766088344,
0.01964332750399328
],
"hutchinson_trace_average": [
1.8920796307642112,
-0.23994862580947734
],
"max_z": 1.7780699387254328,
"passed": true
},
"passed": true,
"recurrence_diagonal": {
"LeakyReLU(alpha=0.1)": 2.7576113859645495,
"ReLU": 2.6765104430302884
},
"relu": {
"exact_trace_average": [
1.5889053692357984,
-0.1414386728305202
],
"hutchinson_standard_error": [
0.020472216681065997,
0.014102274452805928
],
"hutchinson_trace_average": [
1.5820683724508655,
-0.15406125132456708
],
"max_z": 0.8950739496872697,
"passed": true
},
"tiny_width": 3
},
"empirical_control": {
"actual_exit": 1,
"command": "python -m reproduction.claim3_empirical_negative_control",
"expected_exit": "nonzero",
"passed": true,
"stderr": "",
"stdout": "{\n \"checks\": {\n \"all_diagonal_99pct_intervals_inside_1pct_equivalence_margin\": false,\n \"all_diagonal_means_within_4_standard_errors\": false,\n \"all_offdiagonal_controls_detect_at_least_1pct_correction_at_5se\": true,\n \"every_activation_width_pair_passes\": false\n },\n \"expected\": \"equivalence verifier rejects every mutated diagonal\",\n \"mutation\": \"inject a two-percent diagonal finite-width correction\",\n \"verifier_passed\": false\n}"
}
},
"claim4": {
"verifier": {
"architecture": {
"activation": "exact GeLU",
"bias": false,
"depth": 4,
"parameterization": "paper Appendix B raw Gaussian weights",
"weight_variance": 1.98305826
},
"checks": {
"all_test_widths_above_20": true,
"fresh_data_passes_first_order_contract": true,
"infinite_width_negative_control_fails": true,
"paper_four_layer_gelu_architecture": true,
"paper_sample_count_each_width": true,
"source_curve_is_constant_first_order_coefficient": true,
"source_curve_widths_decode_to_integers": true
},
"claim": "Fresh four-layer GeLU NTK means at widths above 20 agree more closely with the paper's first-order recursion curve than with infinite width",
"columns": [
"theta_00",
"theta_01"
],
"hutchinson_probes_per_network": 2,
"inputs": [
[
0.6540248765053858,
-1.3592788739383235,
-0.3791179316445409,
0.34191025226280697
],
[
-0.6786403121150224,
-0.12161213502515096,
0.21716372787141658,
-1.4709063616118982
]
],
"negative_control_infinite_width_substitution": {
"absolute_residual": [
[
0.03354900455475662,
0.010339157362946966
],
[
0.02254474625769154,
0.00666040921643099
],
[
0.014485276675898717,
0.0034022301098928787
],
[
0.004925218909861417,
0.0018275873681600496
]
],
"absolute_residual_to_infinite_width": [
[
0.010650935157189512,
0.00019650085423597585
],
[
0.0027123621491347283,
0.0008646054971675754
],
[
0.00034129596807597196,
0.000156580027105363
],
[
0.0015038632300581334,
0.0003522918759839011
]
],
"checks": {
"all_ensemble_means_finite": true,
"all_points_closer_to_first_order_than_infinite_width": false,
"all_residuals_at_most_half_of_first_order_signal": false,
"all_standard_errors_positive": true,
"median_residual_at_most_quarter_of_first_order_signal": false
},
"median_residual_over_first_order_signal": 1.0217519140194198,
"passed": false,
"residual_over_first_order_signal": [
[
0.7590282876718306,
1.0193737068850959
],
[
0.8926099494270827,
1.1491778429786883
],
[
1.0241301211537435,
1.0482430401033511
],
[
0.7660843029644429,
1.2387941113168113
]
]
},
"network_initializations_per_width": 100000,
"passed": true,
"rows": [
{
"block_means_100_blocks_of_1000": [
[
1.700439177913868,
0.16329258138105754
],
[
1.7843803928119366,
0.15442773187338676
],
[
1.844508680391125,
0.172091615125474
],
[
1.7906628664141218,
0.1860522781338653
],
[
1.8535512180007088,
0.17998373624901512
],
[
1.8296513247629436,
0.16795013630768843
],
[
1.7967694830796972,
0.1755515638308441
],
[
1.7692442796675263,
0.16581412126032802
],
[
1.813310553651386,
0.16401666078004185
],
[
1.7875034756336612,
0.1670135381139438
],
[
1.8315118257746779,
0.15898505545660013
],
[
1.7372036103122992,
0.16471124215716917
],
[
1.7777704640890086,
0.179185505266473
],
[
1.6921526136366234,
0.1674962419680987
],
[
1.7801833249665715,
0.15760663751373608
],
[
1.7562584368857062,
0.16948926045193372
],
[
1.8237774723107316,
0.16385475165437857
],
[
1.7374647019845384,
0.1524836217396618
],
[
1.7478332812723458,
0.15154179042849264
],
[
1.8102533159788763,
0.17286535225204727
],
[
1.8044286745942606,
0.1474130813427027
],
[
1.7604016082764158,
0.1696433641092719
],
[
1.7617752276781764,
0.16930184822169744
],
[
1.7649993397863815,
0.14954552534212112
],
[
1.7814368667264624,
0.17656077827512237
],
[
1.751270381265168,
0.16247232191359914
],
[
1.817318772915778,
0.17703651623880995
],
[
1.777308837022827,
0.18390679839188867
],
[
1.7184798533609398,
0.17794524771929102
],
[
1.8459107122768454,
0.17530167240915684
],
[
1.776760652960195,
0.15820173901329848
],
[
1.7895239690889848,
0.16537143257345277
],
[
1.8291239670093726,
0.16848610443211062
],
[
1.7531270988508854,
0.16251299378552844
],
[
1.7045681673524362,
0.15918629067198706
],
[
1.7350617842597627,
0.16639354077693033
],
[
1.8566688771714468,
0.17688006505153905
],
[
1.802964524013342,
0.17004799593056938
],
[
1.7674090770355209,
0.16102460118849318
],
[
1.7067928266718901,
0.1620581616848092
],
[
1.7887433085676512,
0.15935634961521156
],
[
1.808105381547472,
0.18876704409589917
],
[
1.7608099117449438,
0.15651218664822597
],
[
1.7553306216168938,
0.15665050588600105
],
[
1.7299733833979412,
0.14145558023469135
],
[
1.8481315103201015,
0.1552611319620184
],
[
1.8155913097171295,
0.15641590910478992
],
[
1.7520931991417492,
0.15716866713439256
],
[
1.7690611370975307,
0.1605661311428016
],
[
1.8040715807993193,
0.16780831544460612
],
[
1.795646166215558,
0.16441635701321863
],
[
1.7894049304660913,
0.1497490948276722
],
[
1.7465658762803544,
0.17364959886841738
],
[
1.7074099322107654,
0.17225004486424533
],
[
1.8156406183684923,
0.16715391040911406
],
[
1.843605845041855,
0.19168653758872234
],
[
1.7654811194203202,
0.1523779103849125
],
[
1.7962307362345595,
0.16175669431895534
],
[
1.7880945541389102,
0.16834437473553104
],
[
1.7991075014789584,
0.1788492598441038
],
[
1.747059182505697,
0.16151031729104534
],
[
1.7411176243401845,
0.17265592779802483
],
[
1.7948471872329443,
0.1745188263416349
],
[
1.8018422845338946,
0.14977589533290112
],
[
1.7512815451264758,
0.17021726122081235
],
[
1.7863025955187346,
0.15985427515160533
],
[
1.7432115497987548,
0.1638933990772864
],
[
1.7701554097667753,
0.17873576103492794
],
[
1.803010936867684,
0.16539948473965732
],
[
1.8365663272028339,
0.18392563590872182
],
[
1.800560568162799,
0.1649192228475417
],
[
1.821426631123075,
0.1779560253057555
],
[
1.7453501152846373,
0.1740507042743461
],
[
1.735488001721337,
0.16376448230893698
],
[
1.7784525794098582,
0.16827234551483736
],
[
1.876352070400299,
0.16044179488955385
],
[
1.8031256643899762,
0.1487289994126789
],
[
1.834789669010908,
0.17143104096821318
],
[
1.7527615752059609,
0.16160659226331003
],
[
1.7233261561152153,
0.15986181951864628
],
[
1.7458927409842504,
0.16473517179422442
],
[
1.7931098919859199,
0.16362927424511814
],
[
1.8129310232024474,
0.17087544293088322
],
[
1.7509369586219552,
0.16884737991441937
],
[
1.8329479552314367,
0.1847235585773276
],
[
1.7824174098855503,
0.14951941109014938
],
[
1.7955558687654223,
0.17313164999305802
],
[
1.7815545296460196,
0.18262071250697604
],
[
1.844420539318966,
0.17214997312178024
],
[
1.820695033525652,
0.17766334224447583
],
[
1.801415524237302,
0.1566837647702773
],
[
1.779283616437183,
0.14599440522512278
],
[
1.8157001816204688,
0.1631653389894704
],
[
1.8292609147789651,
0.1798653243046659
],
[
1.8272701494952996,
0.19121451841988862
],
[
1.7456330108210043,
0.16653307532340395
],
[
1.7295991027856297,
0.14423580908885913
],
[
1.7314691857350202,
0.16792876083120106
],
[
1.7488790065314113,
0.1568738507285506
],
[
1.8164360828906618,
0.1858367825548683
]
],
"mean": [
1.7828129674188182,
0.16651646462995293
],
"runtime_seconds": 77.01055863802321,
"seed": 4250811522,
"source_first_order_prediction": [
1.7934639025760077,
0.1667129654841889
],
"source_infinite_width_prediction": [
1.7492639628640616,
0.1768556219928999
],
"standard_deviation": [
1.2901856382574248,
0.37957214005418755
],
"standard_error": [
0.004079925221331536,
0.0012003124989156606
],
"width": 32
},
{
"block_means_100_blocks_of_1000": [
[
1.734542380832323,
0.16960447540524276
],
[
1.795342631752241,
0.18461458758253746
],
[
1.7993295429769223,
0.16287026288818765
],
[
1.7378846784968274,
0.17403779797449664
],
[
1.7225147385830963,
0.16047182570428148
],
[
1.758142091770648,
0.1686123409496821
],
[
1.752336891898408,
0.16831569904369625
],
[
1.8042628805734384,
0.1811529907407143
],
[
1.8329185827502712,
0.18505731057355848
],
[
1.746201057371094,
0.1604847044285043
],
[
1.7729430311914232,
0.17542191118209655
],
[
1.7676397261107215,
0.1718732129476388
],
[
1.7984589176037513,
0.1737686871324241
],
[
1.7613602251558502,
0.16371122250571682
],
[
1.7596452434192371,
0.1747675583635692
],
[
1.8330021455243057,
0.1798958195425259
],
[
1.818589444314202,
0.1716088078079727
],
[
1.7435618888988658,
0.17357103990667636
],
[
1.798446823411479,
0.17724603800129396
],
[
1.7733098113091401,
0.1636175572834792
],
[
1.7591619347466378,
0.16011543428202357
],
[
1.7901322714813177,
0.1677216305472228
],
[
1.7651273086773402,
0.1627021860898746
],
[
1.7730641784269532,
0.17139934154385258
],
[
1.7932664782933883,
0.16991061934688842
],
[
1.756237085855058,
0.16476433931298617
],
[
1.744943580491901,
0.15914011254410335
],
[
1.754214247391814,
0.173337417384449
],
[
1.764018352619745,
0.17379976753353807
],
[
1.762342571785698,
0.1448888142131087
],
[
1.7914883083391002,
0.17626490077618168
],
[
1.766168195700167,
0.17363821170556148
],
[
1.779175890584612,
0.16608398758755874
],
[
1.8171933383305576,
0.18689887470508504
],
[
1.7510899853590525,
0.16568721561841948
],
[
1.7847946564462749,
0.18520579335733844
],
[
1.7867777550387416,
0.1692100584651166
],
[
1.7228432591331477,
0.1782394592227632
],
[
1.8005466176394092,
0.17078125253217447
],
[
1.7733576836656109,
0.16465908318658545
],
[
1.791777242671435,
0.17098644951145278
],
[
1.8247893689084864,
0.17503807482385442
],
[
1.7787849986366648,
0.1755866142736105
],
[
1.7537640862841544,
0.17203659791851952
],
[
1.7490265260463238,
0.17164859771897104
],
[
1.8142296874856843,
0.16933056332377888
],
[
1.8374952122949497,
0.17567867424880046
],
[
1.7780473214548218,
0.17807887426812813
],
[
1.7702989084890663,
0.15899955738291635
],
[
1.7744558080126422,
0.18754088212135603
],
[
1.7959372484175395,
0.16053976865340666
],
[
1.7209158944353276,
0.16869935220361906
],
[
1.782795638925808,
0.17968660970932124
],
[
1.7501253806779127,
0.17187382536601736
],
[
1.7621379826212171,
0.1658370693468355
],
[
1.7368891077715969,
0.17855305337194496
],
[
1.7069404081784894,
0.17370813701115256
],
[
1.7380939058064278,
0.1563161149349007
],
[
1.7503335558741866,
0.15963227324753607
],
[
1.7628848573526474,
0.17216248481433222
],
[
1.7950388737605698,
0.16140886019796225
],
[
1.7567251312227716,
0.15753834964918645
],
[
1.7900530657365603,
0.18169734646834743
],
[
1.7396284710534278,
0.16448356678261095
],
[
1.7665272697358059,
0.17634759948789383
],
[
1.7586153431798204,
0.16980985457019368
],
[
1.7835537772650405,
0.15840382945894718
],
[
1.7277765563378646,
0.17630178088223186
],
[
1.7496267051276602,
0.17292731569332803
],
[
1.7639575077483864,
0.17375739673476873
],
[
1.7869955459653852,
0.18432213853541787
],
[
1.7628653775221093,
0.17561868190378058
],
[
1.7375577555636892,
0.1586885171934636
],
[
1.7637563569508488,
0.17330749335382015
],
[
1.8301643421286338,
0.18337427720690527
],
[
1.7818668105188307,
0.16874002797567103
],
[
1.7512934049438549,
0.150990471810814
],
[
1.7702782722821484,
0.179491674044654
],
[
1.7393278089309026,
0.16093518042102772
],
[
1.7878837031524613,
0.17461650865189712
],
[
1.7681700983982536,
0.1690903163411351
],
[
1.7776525160327339,
0.17447082159981364
],
[
1.7758487427458216,
0.1697329826634811
],
[
1.8154277674497559,
0.1755217893793792
],
[
1.7421793595904935,
0.1754151268006193
],
[
1.7992897697918855,
0.16521431687667343
],
[
1.7511246443460786,
0.17113359105236792
],
[
1.8150107923331789,
0.15571664541577004
],
[
1.7839788958849245,
0.16473825206331288
],
[
1.7576237216064716,
0.16637000283632578
],
[
1.7530078908192006,
0.15735097830853714
],
[
1.776178482683058,
0.18027025330307708
],
[
1.7751065149435175,
0.1618018544620472
],
[
1.7913115823669754,
0.16755474370662635
],
[
1.7662706278138725,
0.1648663653143742
],
[
1.7963056080556095,
0.167082455376878
],
[
1.767652323808224,
0.16996886120925153
],
[
1.8006913959247988,
0.16134912936363896
],
[
1.7441702950130666,
0.16812943806060585
],
[
1.7542782291442185,
0.18389655832060628
]
],
"mean": [
1.7718087091217531,
0.1701952127764689
],
"runtime_seconds": 131.44878837512806,
"seed": 4250911522,
"source_first_order_prediction": [
1.7745210712708879,
0.17105981827363648
],
"source_infinite_width_prediction": [
1.7492639628640616,
0.1768556219928999
],
"standard_deviation": [
0.9440417682060976,
0.28242357482413777
],
"standard_error": [
0.0029853221938639977,
0.0008931017613712635
],
"width": 56
},
{
"block_means_100_blocks_of_1000": [
[
1.7485877535736092,
0.16690551851693786
],
[
1.7886043708356079,
0.165805222010866
],
[
1.748947991772127,
0.17385777270328054
],
[
1.7520055640989007,
0.1627303336658651
],
[
1.7805926551852882,
0.17925554267036792
],
[
1.7849784680213516,
0.1712013408475446
],
[
1.7680162616889397,
0.17076873971165882
],
[
1.7113624741707705,
0.17498920050780087
],
[
1.757137666046892,
0.17672860897295306
],
[
1.7524143381876118,
0.17722504428109306
],
[
1.7476510828286556,
0.18114831861504832
],
[
1.7564762006287815,
0.1722068999337312
],
[
1.746093382135767,
0.1757831328894707
],
[
1.7493818013629001,
0.17923748828214872
],
[
1.783087386463358,
0.17030465315819238
],
[
1.765916866489864,
0.16993973017308225
],
[
1.7503985186584523,
0.17049786735072017
],
[
1.7644987874052052,
0.17940998043527107
],
[
1.7440726007875929,
0.17084776137847577
],
[
1.7936139439231706,
0.1755972475933421
],
[
1.8188672222748066,
0.17466655323009975
],
[
1.7861153392360976,
0.17596491237374015
],
[
1.7489669176572669,
0.17017469244887562
],
[
1.7450720006681686,
0.1708202933718066
],
[
1.7588310057459542,
0.1626428912945823
],
[
1.7380014782232467,
0.16477427495624958
],
[
1.7330237703855549,
0.17273978224853392
],
[
1.7808770382115489,
0.17858610311747267
],
[
1.7602956357023294,
0.1611617695150433
],
[
1.7477671280689906,
0.169368707051452
],
[
1.7824625038320352,
0.18029619638535663
],
[
1.7228778754534795,
0.1762532476151627
],
[
1.776927148603237,
0.1759270340499176
],
[
1.7492297654066762,
0.17549632432860107
],
[
1.7242001225875787,
0.18167687223590673
],
[
1.7714129373722642,
0.1709824173900438
],
[
1.7320254197388385,
0.17410648344797797
],
[
1.7867609853698834,
0.1727213347924433
],
[
1.7668534326613312,
0.17828212177287867
],
[
1.736412793033774,
0.18075906124865765
],
[
1.7587808646070824,
0.16833207437327752
],
[
1.7745746205969235,
0.16443979985511484
],
[
1.8139236379529995,
0.17260252563872472
],
[
1.773961641145307,
0.1675652954268342
],
[
1.7807682337770634,
0.16848196529241694
],
[
1.7833870761734836,
0.17228331587877566
],
[
1.7622147497242489,
0.18379009994688236
],
[
1.797305316488763,
0.18970399245010697
],
[
1.7704565032665722,
0.17050941615892667
],
[
1.7458317817489921,
0.1655133615753054
],
[
1.74707149367172,
0.16143169028680202
],
[
1.7782394308421992,
0.17241194328521484
],
[
1.7737327829007767,
0.1730145675556682
],
[
1.785933386097949,
0.18509412685633883
],
[
1.7513967911527053,
0.17157759079407395
],
[
1.77097771596703,
0.17236100674861662
],
[
1.752880948120838,
0.16667719119222843
],
[
1.7586600426838417,
0.1796378722193113
],
[
1.7580276726399373,
0.1764154939492046
],
[
1.754326448487299,
0.17832833385761998
],
[
1.7564929451899514,
0.1727157635552463
],
[
1.777084386290032,
0.17021704399323434
],
[
1.7594943982656337,
0.1742600670065644
],
[
1.7647317768581061,
0.1872803836337699
],
[
1.7446732327825543,
0.16985816976435503
],
[
1.7611770608938577,
0.16949365407900222
],
[
1.7545040314371105,
0.17742788060130635
],
[
1.7593283334946144,
0.17445671940793772
],
[
1.7415170120127326,
0.16954526764499528
],
[
1.7635795182621354,
0.17293633523434898
],
[
1.7528787462167492,
0.16546875886738913
],
[
1.7560857875414604,
0.16449959871839803
],
[
1.7461747500665548,
0.16546509292981265
],
[
1.7820988063109147,
0.18205071896764097
],
[
1.8004375094371232,
0.18075033467538018
],
[
1.7676758945648416,
0.18229332989472863
],
[
1.7338114586643447,
0.17190507572764716
],
[
1.774454592665323,
0.18347352333478842
],
[
1.7860635529008362,
0.16919612620604849
],
[
1.8019304256869515,
0.16738570611288373
],
[
1.7617058771897565,
0.16569712941886514
],
[
1.7670505201211435,
0.17169358288334935
],
[
1.7689207350460605,
0.1798917863725109
],
[
1.763332330811297,
0.16945459908780533
],
[
1.746752269863525,
0.16999210217315774
],
[
1.791368798376168,
0.16885220257930184
],
[
1.7874345237802185,
0.1739095023841613
],
[
1.742296876444204,
0.18193313717464973
],
[
1.7567459546737665,
0.17155532030410095
],
[
1.7741401931253196,
0.17097906019248416
],
[
1.7855549471968082,
0.1756935361013457
],
[
1.7587744423073761,
0.172074095606796
],
[
1.754834631109448,
0.17673553094302874
],
[
1.774608799117222,
0.17457327274989254
],
[
1.76860456465966,
0.18443794572852296
],
[
1.7940124831852047,
0.17654914584548836
],
[
1.7489920416136677,
0.1668736923604112
],
[
1.792468667922966,
0.18695190111192053
],
[
1.7816755017695296,
0.18582848207906508
],
[
1.7181858035945248,
0.15897047293421257
]
],
"mean": [
1.7637492395399603,
0.173453391883007
],
"runtime_seconds": 180.4812352519948,
"seed": 4251011522,
"source_first_order_prediction": [
1.7634079435718844,
0.17360997191011238
],
"source_infinite_width_prediction": [
1.7492639628640616,
0.1768556219928999
],
"standard_deviation": [
0.6967172162399985,
0.20875505136402409
],
"standard_error": [
0.002203213288370449,
0.0006601414353757559
],
"width": 100
},
{
"block_means_100_blocks_of_1000": [
[
1.7438074414635305,
0.1711793550053186
],
[
1.7479345919428728,
0.16838752703028367
],
[
1.7683959362334485,
0.17776655921648604
],
[
1.78940579544524,
0.17628080809921393
],
[
1.7385107332721494,
0.1694606938068174
],
[
1.7575075163869267,
0.17659483749042781
],
[
1.7585677988916624,
0.18080258262374418
],
[
1.7524886679866574,
0.1714551666226898
],
[
1.7441031380784076,
0.17422611050876355
],
[
1.7460636581767615,
0.1687857036183683
],
[
1.7453882596526795,
0.17088344325518603
],
[
1.753055403209834,
0.17028573243672424
],
[
1.7521272644390238,
0.1783129174534786
],
[
1.7907707359154252,
0.17182638070937822
],
[
1.7528354932597674,
0.17402248992384162
],
[
1.7467753304006566,
0.17237454315761172
],
[
1.7523615579507497,
0.1670415976610965
],
[
1.7565825688889347,
0.17657815412812872
],
[
1.7398797462311697,
0.17577768314204809
],
[
1.7519270243763314,
0.16821064792583787
],
[
1.7775693469267555,
0.17271835454796397
],
[
1.7518035274227017,
0.1794874529806895
],
[
1.7429655058280904,
0.1712638703510108
],
[
1.7392773111681168,
0.17436034666330252
],
[
1.7621616858364906,
0.17633195804611987
],
[
1.747805091811085,
0.17293694588553826
],
[
1.7656953197067446,
0.18416054573006072
],
[
1.760076178680426,
0.17495284272568554
],
[
1.7757744414182801,
0.18328328808348757
],
[
1.7598212118782026,
0.16717367852234313
],
[
1.7647585224494529,
0.17739298927843652
],
[
1.757805085056009,
0.1755472393090369
],
[
1.7493145255885707,
0.179854672834106
],
[
1.761310299163392,
0.17741013944317355
],
[
1.7573450609544001,
0.17512549967930838
],
[
1.7560013636036103,
0.17593111536390688
],
[
1.7437583403198877,
0.17985055835702
],
[
1.7462326164926005,
0.17704578583307914
],
[
1.7532780869210667,
0.17437999084473035
],
[
1.7606159286128056,
0.17580811119508044
],
[
1.7769838480835167,
0.1710965454067084
],
[
1.7632803217354145,
0.17709181615083616
],
[
1.74982589076077,
0.1766890799590908
],
[
1.7728968827483031,
0.17934568188247865
],
[
1.7384752808862425,
0.17466381397644642
],
[
1.7446005005829286,
0.17335706009535823
],
[
1.7476345101883035,
0.1663474469346369
],
[
1.7604590476131317,
0.174242868912895
],
[
1.7480084482300982,
0.1686802695924908
],
[
1.7595387219232288,
0.1709165653076091
],
[
1.7496594648905752,
0.17215016340711628
],
[
1.757254939526394,
0.17362672065664406
],
[
1.7627111469828913,
0.18101748333092701
],
[
1.7611327677017556,
0.17294875199131096
],
[
1.7253633724282906,
0.17466680968610132
],
[
1.7533411343103993,
0.17894521434081004
],
[
1.7630230534520823,
0.1791151515627799
],
[
1.7645944185160323,
0.1801144714610727
],
[
1.7704306337012856,
0.17244797218585278
],
[
1.7569519892915773,
0.17591876852212218
],
[
1.7108483924744144,
0.17703808378280142
],
[
1.7562064286360175,
0.17378807425779802
],
[
1.762172671122617,
0.17123371563359738
],
[
1.755819140468481,
0.18165899410432745
],
[
1.747693392779453,
0.16884141517597537
],
[
1.7648175678039062,
0.1679991435961275
],
[
1.7749805565906618,
0.17813140553298146
],
[
1.7647671039908241,
0.1807619662973218
],
[
1.7585318666457561,
0.1700563110853505
],
[
1.7378346781676093,
0.17478984699373853
],
[
1.7599469834954573,
0.17256073774299058
],
[
1.7242347343712818,
0.1805714318189623
],
[
1.745240382240038,
0.17458792656612487
],
[
1.7647997862385352,
0.18015340497524993
],
[
1.7758356262596182,
0.17602471437794392
],
[
1.7504180246464438,
0.17951645136521252
],
[
1.7758585469215997,
0.17834425288092548
],
[
1.752072325973523,
0.171120381913164
],
[
1.748555898415566,
0.17972471424287317
],
[
1.7555348927299,
0.17288875788938737
],
[
1.7871960327215797,
0.17119185425277947
],
[
1.7192398357088268,
0.1774825933900738
],
[
1.7596371226384537,
0.17397134899278138
],
[
1.7589735773239852,
0.17693097503046895
],
[
1.7421046191760539,
0.17657687711591952
],
[
1.7585918609613693,
0.1833991502819208
],
[
1.7348150983342259,
0.16892324124673802
],
[
1.7360371993914234,
0.17481371134482862
],
[
1.748313190162888,
0.17114599525988583
],
[
1.7273061017596456,
0.17720220502597805
],
[
1.7221063001828911,
0.17391538300265993
],
[
1.772991255359483,
0.17944595771948688
],
[
1.7713909296317172,
0.17266881466853626
],
[
1.7354066811739415,
0.17674868681940228
],
[
1.7424898597223,
0.17604387923342976
],
[
1.7422393674732919,
0.17535874423661188
],
[
1.7659237262536047,
0.17860121524451666
],
[
1.754986305112888,
0.18279115315963534
],
[
1.7469811568017148,
0.1742795436858852
],
[
1.757994471936922,
0.17286942767667238
]
],
"mean": [
1.754189181773923,
0.17502803462473984
],
"runtime_seconds": 610.6134962220676,
"seed": 4251111522,
"source_first_order_prediction": [
1.7556930450039812,
0.17538032650072374
],
"source_infinite_width_prediction": [
1.7492639628640616,
0.1768556219928999
],
"standard_deviation": [
0.4616441647985645,
0.14002247344996008
],
"standard_error": [
0.00145984702928959,
0.00044278993971232875
],
"width": 220
}
],
"runtime_seconds": 999.5577921129297,
"source_prediction": {
"coefficient_values_from_all_11_vertices": [
[
1.414398070782277,
-0.32457195664343275
],
[
1.4144283293176465,
-0.32457889378869237
],
[
1.414367840552366,
-0.3245650082787519
],
[
1.4144787361931759,
-0.3245904675073755
],
[
1.4143981634183236,
-0.32457194483351587
],
[
1.414297308495687,
-0.3245487849957368
],
[
1.4145997806275485,
-0.3246182444322153
],
[
1.4140958148011913,
-0.3245025072453846
],
[
1.4133899538574703,
-0.3243405153375399
],
[
1.4135915916524848,
-0.32438677005855465
],
[
1.4152050027994105,
-0.32424801534344533
]
],
"decoded_widths": [
6.000481958160605,
10.99955776793256,
19.001106910832146,
32.00052392734829,
56.00051835611868,
83.00172901975046,
100.0,
149.98649836570806,
171.99143314446607,
199.98973125343815,
219.97986019154996
],
"first_order_coefficients": [
1.414398070782277,
-0.3245650082787519
],
"infinite_ntk": [
1.7492639628640616,
0.1768556219928999
],
"max_coefficient_digitization_spread": [
0.0010081169248066235,
0.00031699293530657036
],
"pdf_sha256": {
"diagonal": "865845aaa9c0f203e9fc041c7d5841c1548bc5d511abe55a8c9f9eef782683d6",
"offdiagonal": "6623a42cf5703a8374603e190beef9f6e267a9a1dd3f13a536ec94e7ba0fceb5"
},
"widths": [
6,
11,
19,
32,
56,
83,
100,
150,
172,
200,
220
]
},
"verification": {
"absolute_residual": [
[
0.010650935157189512,
0.00019650085423597585
],
[
0.0027123621491347283,
0.0008646054971675754
],
[
0.00034129596807597196,
0.000156580027105363
],
[
0.0015038632300581334,
0.0003522918759839011
]
],
"absolute_residual_to_infinite_width": [
[
0.03354900455475662,
0.010339157362946966
],
[
0.02254474625769154,
0.00666040921643099
],
[
0.014485276675898717,
0.0034022301098928787
],
[
0.004925218909861417,
0.0018275873681600496
]
],
"checks": {
"all_ensemble_means_finite": true,
"all_points_closer_to_first_order_than_infinite_width": true,
"all_residuals_at_most_half_of_first_order_signal": true,
"all_standard_errors_positive": true,
"median_residual_at_most_quarter_of_first_order_signal": true
},
"median_residual_over_first_order_signal": 0.12828394677580282,
"passed": true,
"residual_over_first_order_signal": [
[
0.24097171232816933,
0.019373706885095803
],
[
0.10739005057291733,
0.1491778429786883
],
[
0.024130121153743384,
0.04824304010335112
],
[
0.2339156970355572,
0.23879411131681128
]
]
}
},
"checker": {
"checks": {
"exact_diagonal_positive": true,
"hutchinson_matches_exact_jacobian_within_4_standard_errors": true
},
"exact_trace_average": [
0.5048955965576244,
-0.049564502180869885
],
"hutchinson_standard_error": [
0.0053614876663044325,
0.0008037300389291021
],
"hutchinson_trace_average": [
0.4983221620966973,
-0.0473656702518907
],
"max_z": 2.7357841843374784,
"parameter_count": 39,
"passed": true,
"probes": 8192,
"tiny_width": 3
}
},
"claim5": {
"verifier": {
"claim": "At C_W=2, a bias-free width-200 ReLU MLP has linearly scaling mean NTK through depth 30; away from C_W=2 it is exponentially unstable",
"columns": [
"theta_00",
"theta_01",
"theta_11"
],
"depth": 30,
"estimator": "Appendix C output-channel trace average with unbiased Rademacher Hutchinson parameter-space probes",
"hutchinson_probes_per_network": 4,
"inputs": [
[
-0.9895229339599609,
-0.5992491841316223
],
[
-0.17877478897571564,
2.253682851791382
]
],
"layers": [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28,
29,
30
],
"network_initializations_per_regime": 1000,
"passed": true,
"regimes": {
"critical": 2.0,
"high": 4.0,
"low": 0.25
},
"runtime_seconds": 318.54929400398396,
"seeds": {
"critical": 250911522,
"high": 251011522,
"low": 250811522
},
"summaries": {
"critical": {
"mean": [
[
0.6692638785243035,
-0.5870519854724408,
2.5554306843280794
],
[
1.3381770911812783,
-0.04052555605187081,
5.0895400838851925
],
[
2.0192700930833816,
0.47630823448300363,
7.63157291841507
],
[
2.7052703272104264,
1.0015738136991859,
10.180834122180938
],
[
3.3862841366529466,
1.5207446962296962,
12.680411201000213
],
[
4.068113737106323,
2.028415251582861,
15.232592504024506
],
[
4.73709102332592,
2.488701988041401,
17.754934866428375
],
[
5.396193558812142,
2.9722987492755055,
20.372773798942568
],
[
6.08210835659504,
3.446689959049225,
22.94213366651535
],
[
6.773809177160263,
3.9376793970167636,
25.55846619319916
],
[
7.493658598423004,
4.408411878705024,
28.064793186187742
],
[
8.13583403158188,
4.779651154920459,
30.5322900390625
],
[
8.799152136564254,
5.1456180299520495,
32.79262677955627
],
[
9.494311528921127,
5.583081236064434,
35.27302901649475
],
[
10.198178785562515,
6.037123610302806,
38.01753967666626
],
[
10.870875106573106,
6.445625134602189,
40.16359003543854
],
[
11.523756855726242,
6.87705672980845,
42.48142048168182
],
[
12.242518025159836,
7.310278050750494,
44.846150230407716
],
[
12.894857037067414,
7.634653021395207,
47.10699038648605
],
[
13.523115402460098,
8.041776612818241,
49.332285345554354
],
[
14.219423490047454,
8.501947780758142,
52.095296820163725
],
[
14.851294931173324,
8.939695041827857,
54.65366203117371
],
[
15.680168318986892,
9.392744810253381,
57.25959326982498
],
[
16.38060400748253,
9.959634913250804,
59.75629189109802
],
[
17.14951911020279,
10.44856491677463,
62.204029143333436
],
[
17.776536997795105,
10.891943603336811,
64.82003451347352
],
[
18.476985339164735,
11.361988397032022,
67.61744180631638
],
[
19.007777780771256,
11.66888049185276,
69.80318532276154
],
[
19.63237684369087,
12.071479145348071,
72.03884936571122
],
[
20.2601512465477,
12.471782049387693,
74.07056818437576
]
],
"runtime_seconds": 127.73658929602243,
"standard_deviation": [
[
0.021243691443211338,
0.03802808742717842,
0.014434304337973524
],
[
0.1511740559963215,
0.10350834957779202,
0.5812425660999687
],
[
0.3255570210030538,
0.2128389129863708,
1.2664261089322093
],
[
0.5486204885700706,
0.36951172019832507,
2.0652473153946906
],
[
0.7901062434974783,
0.5578950309157515,
2.993693227150647
],
[
1.0510560093598629,
0.7648865945525576,
3.9839016687755846
],
[
1.3350392595004972,
0.9892178192344991,
5.091151938947775
],
[
1.6416522730378265,
1.2450626328981167,
6.391132275314713
],
[
1.9797027794512407,
1.5749610969024457,
7.951976122034658
],
[
2.3279556122091676,
1.8880232919552398,
9.306268634821606
],
[
2.7675399732598622,
2.2636125809041823,
10.928238280950485
],
[
3.1762446595107083,
2.598015297199269,
12.484254401142751
],
[
3.617270921032653,
2.9758184510509285,
13.97048336016061
],
[
4.044105466851002,
3.348546976703292,
15.462493587471231
],
[
4.516499599589274,
3.7310023281052427,
17.640311603003823
],
[
5.099299886935529,
4.172772439693209,
19.302210347946826
],
[
5.585924013981034,
4.675033822612011,
21.199042427476993
],
[
6.2107804417347285,
5.04471278219325,
22.69121220804859
],
[
6.870893590491785,
5.53898629555732,
24.795163044620562
],
[
7.462062754192694,
5.896595430202909,
26.508424460797055
],
[
8.100726814356229,
6.475978354890777,
28.851299747078006
],
[
8.637126261687701,
6.986141795470556,
31.15475531139337
],
[
9.538416412490475,
7.710425308691044,
33.88541006109774
],
[
10.44582994501262,
8.500129541599113,
36.544816589523585
],
[
11.333999627262399,
9.200427919683694,
38.99742602035895
],
[
11.91849979636031,
9.7853083456156,
41.33353293281078
],
[
12.746385289513707,
10.386971786312069,
44.36086597093472
],
[
13.33474655228458,
10.65181474236,
47.186338598075146
],
[
14.231028929242932,
11.322356752976095,
50.05652547380632
],
[
15.032222001909645,
11.951465893191429,
53.57032917759456
]
],
"standard_error": [
[
0.0006717845087037737,
0.0012025537132989634,
0.00045645278148045206
],
[
0.004780543400742111,
0.003273221415107508,
0.018380503819168736
],
[
0.010295016946289249,
0.00673055739751322,
0.04004790992530292
],
[
0.01734890314915796,
0.011684986579535523,
0.06530885448195349
],
[
0.024985353229716335,
0.017642189929838285,
0.09466889213615873
],
[
0.03323730937984421,
0.024187837905158216,
0.12598203247476558
],
[
0.04221764825766158,
0.03128181410805739,
0.16099636041057477
],
[
0.051913603087921596,
0.03937233749524138,
0.2021053481740882
],
[
0.06260369873231907,
0.0498046429236889,
0.25146356444902584
],
[
0.07361642026352654,
0.059704538780276165,
0.2942900540342205
],
[
0.08751729831062656,
0.07158171495869384,
0.3455812378084661
],
[
0.10044167529999834,
0.0821564573510896,
0.3947867879659249
],
[
0.11438815024358256,
0.0941036420847522,
0.44178547431589976
],
[
0.1278858437318774,
0.10589035298453187,
0.48896698042157094
],
[
0.14282425785940592,
0.11798465312203422,
0.5578356330058805
],
[
0.16125402114955364,
0.1319546506700814,
0.6103894857518317
],
[
0.17664242720810308,
0.14783755017777545,
0.6703725828537215
],
[
0.19640212243108432,
0.15952782533095586,
0.7175591344765206
],
[
0.21727673306606277,
0.1751581262241972,
0.7840919017623618
],
[
0.23597114346358083,
0.18646671999981615,
0.8382699847863955
],
[
0.25616747436165666,
0.20478841679405077,
0.912358206570064
],
[
0.27312991425388644,
0.22092120130585152,
0.9851998672923141
],
[
0.3016312113460205,
0.2438250570407057,
1.0715507524185421
],
[
0.330326146770313,
0.2687976975793616,
1.1556485709600122
],
[
0.3584125382164862,
0.29094307674405184,
1.2332068910825018
],
[
0.3768960564875159,
0.30943861979199416,
1.3070810780926154
],
[
0.40307609448928056,
0.32846488836653903,
1.4028137544561052
],
[
0.42168171126296844,
0.33683995800017225,
1.4921630441383396
],
[
0.45002464864154856,
0.35804435820392894,
1.5829263225146712
],
[
0.4753605981933046,
0.37793853600303584,
1.694042552061736
]
],
"through_origin_slope_mean": [
0.6794990439584496,
0.4090459902208747,
2.4938138887447483
],
"through_origin_slope_standard_error": [
0.01218850284716703,
0.0094177193796795,
0.04325422089797619
]
},
"high": {
"mean": [
[
0.668745027422905,
-0.5861232003569603,
2.5557832233905793
],
[
2.6736817662715913,
-0.08858880206104368,
10.229193788528443
],
[
8.020080068111419,
1.876778450857848,
30.682356315612793
],
[
21.429349796295167,
7.822041485667229,
81.90364957427978
],
[
53.59633512306213,
23.881862693786623,
205.06395738220215
],
[
128.51597521209717,
62.81415895175934,
490.3882987060547
],
[
300.05006120300294,
155.3598706150055,
1141.0862084960938
],
[
683.2338864440918,
370.76207797145844,
2599.6621279296874
],
[
1543.6428915405274,
867.4108933906555,
5872.665838134765
],
[
3392.7517310180665,
1939.804314125061,
12966.205623779297
],
[
7468.509527099609,
4348.767804962158,
28441.149133789062
],
[
16264.028876464843,
9517.26200479126,
61872.48416699219
],
[
35158.82573828125,
20546.19678588867,
133893.101046875
],
[
75757.556328125,
44607.68198779297,
286865.0769296875
],
[
163014.07250195314,
96179.28670800781,
613866.217734375
],
[
348213.4734453125,
206102.58987597656,
1308491.42534375
],
[
744198.571671875,
443849.56758203125,
2791639.9071875
],
[
1577150.74365625,
936278.1426894531,
5886344.4105
],
[
3336065.038,
1986344.0320507812,
12388605.36025
],
[
7020966.676625,
4232887.783375,
26185919.3435
],
[
14643591.03575,
8924189.21265625,
55108854.985
],
[
30759428.916,
18707951.69584375,
115310400.126
],
[
64270232.549,
39170006.20825,
241159613.788
],
[
133673889.982,
81846261.5825,
503189140.192
],
[
278873983.944,
171033028.6375,
1048299271.504
],
[
582255308.448,
357595554.829,
2175923573.408
],
[
1204196392.912,
750007895.591,
4502611896.64
],
[
2510318925.92,
1564340382.188,
9403544656.384
],
[
5235240980.864,
3242703321.7,
19582452954.88
],
[
10828914498.944,
6750185956.552,
40780812016.128
]
],
"runtime_seconds": 91.91312368097715,
"standard_deviation": [
[
0.021702633987342724,
0.038849636110146336,
0.014746141635693103
],
[
0.3019963089570924,
0.1948848783985841,
1.1439780224822444
],
[
1.3043659817926567,
0.8476817977472242,
4.957936927187825
],
[
4.152602773622824,
2.8451134116115266,
16.44859857560009
],
[
12.42504664091608,
8.484620375929858,
48.574736852246744
],
[
34.49411049222539,
23.9459530415787,
128.49765823385613
],
[
90.37835225324314,
64.40201511595343,
321.10394712664066
],
[
223.07159178510614,
165.96729434916065,
802.7203103442357
],
[
542.5361447864813,
426.84729541802443,
1972.4363513549765
],
[
1254.5902908780176,
985.4953535220707,
4674.867405652619
],
[
2944.8474163948536,
2319.6022496270307,
10903.66058092649
],
[
6787.900450021733,
5319.670294773409,
25023.876448540203
],
[
15560.252879070375,
12211.401233638779,
57745.7761587981
],
[
34613.66932364241,
27790.166212873264,
129159.08450232603
],
[
77201.69261998299,
62012.62090956453,
287866.6597958206
],
[
172463.31352527044,
138479.38385794414,
632487.723477603
],
[
381738.52375372435,
311879.0391563437,
1412074.9285207952
],
[
839441.2405860708,
673542.3853175015,
3111415.1979238205
],
[
1883063.485928886,
1533161.2771354949,
6777895.670709573
],
[
4075156.8944641175,
3356917.4254995235,
14555372.174990892
],
[
8739431.955747375,
7232340.6248745825,
31056304.82785611
],
[
19058218.468374133,
15742497.679210043,
67054580.20435295
],
[
40659786.62736942,
34255580.42507314,
146825678.22242528
],
[
86001340.10279322,
70399925.07721984,
310774872.7261873
],
[
184784416.06951633,
150173197.02917966,
663941123.9641494
],
[
398106479.1938737,
327447486.4606552,
1418864451.9078095
],
[
826800940.6189449,
713805148.5275358,
3029802926.148221
],
[
1779752851.5140574,
1555503420.0278037,
6460114105.303748
],
[
3846636099.5051875,
3355127712.071394,
13978341237.354809
],
[
8106908086.728703,
7160395268.266031,
30114027424.701473
]
],
"standard_error": [
[
0.000686297546249849,
0.0012285333637678654,
0.00046631394268231106
],
[
0.009549961812683212,
0.006162800972644737,
0.03617576144219202
],
[
0.04124767404906513,
0.026806052119474174,
0.1567837318536992
],
[
0.13131682982580709,
0.08997038582184574,
0.520150358166976
],
[
0.3929144741911908,
0.2683072546981243,
1.5360680519641758
],
[
1.0907995501694405,
0.7572375235482538,
4.063452740168747
],
[
2.8580144429325927,
2.0365705367100584,
10.154198385904643
],
[
7.0541431132024135,
5.248346672389404,
25.38424504765005
],
[
17.15649930492167,
13.498096666037114,
62.37391409993871
],
[
39.67362849507704,
31.164099406425834,
147.83228761144585
],
[
93.12425197470014,
73.35226374471875,
344.80402269122413
],
[
214.65225952550617,
168.2227453262329,
791.3244546403233
],
[
492.0584006605495,
386.158413204885,
1826.0817791605105
],
[
1094.5803323860994,
878.8022178733522,
4084.3688752950557
],
[
2441.3318789935824,
1961.0112575080645,
9103.143073796144
],
[
5453.768835595778,
4379.102619678584,
20001.017982839796
],
[
12071.632056920587,
9862.48118198885,
44653.73000945172
],
[
26545.462821293615,
21299.280382660578,
98391.58771902874
],
[
59547.6959423171,
48482.81656120797,
214335.88062436855
],
[
128867.7760904503,
106155.04981687093,
460281.28264410136
],
[
276365.10436221573,
228706.6918876911,
982086.5896450876
],
[
602673.7850514795,
497821.4872621848,
2120452.009921942
],
[
1285775.3491894333,
1083256.5671431003,
4643035.621818464
],
[
2719601.1655160594,
2226241.1034922,
9827564.373636935
],
[
5843396.308838904,
4748893.461214392,
20995661.83978914
],
[
12589232.255230745,
10354798.71312818,
44868433.59075118
],
[
26145741.43925492,
22572500.749017984,
95810781.08071305
],
[
56280726.82963875,
49189337.15469435,
204286745.1734068
],
[
121641314.04262486,
106098454.10895216,
442033962.21097535
],
[
256362943.35700554,
226431579.9481304,
952289161.8283138
]
],
"through_origin_slope_mean": [
64254623.79069256,
39956198.29675845,
241272741.75319973
],
"through_origin_slope_standard_error": [
1474911.369393439,
1287068.754451411,
5427147.868191248
]
},
"low": {
"mean": [
[
0.6691660357117653,
-0.5868768416345119,
2.55549715924263
],
[
0.1668450469300151,
-0.004908929140365217,
0.6399587476849556
],
[
0.031402847373858095,
0.0074620040143781804,
0.12039269012957811
],
[
0.005215889458777383,
0.0019392308343376499,
0.0201546017723158
],
[
0.0008100404755678027,
0.00036080477573705136,
0.0031370550416177138
],
[
0.00012197337123870966,
0.00006016794825200122,
0.00046957568763173184
],
[
0.00001771461352291226,
0.000009303187130001333,
0.00006840061484399485
],
[
0.0000025280472054873826,
0.0000013872041474343178,
0.000009741109913193214
],
[
3.553706095402731E-7,
2.0011894817484331E-7,
0.0000013666769299049974
],
[
4.942472058644398E-8,
2.8633337466832386E-8,
1.8918215363328273E-7
],
[
6.816087400385307E-9,
4.040358560886137E-9,
2.610969121397133E-8
],
[
9.234903061983158E-10,
5.536594901607572E-10,
3.561032781318474E-9
],
[
1.2516902062748026E-10,
7.552326048527666E-11,
4.831796589985226E-10
],
[
1.68574498908558E-11,
1.0200585952275338E-11,
6.500966779742629E-11
],
[
2.2707412820183702E-12,
1.3687845140811845E-12,
8.760210633501977E-12
],
[
3.0275339471476284E-13,
1.8397041370412027E-13,
1.1685581239630204E-12
],
[
4.030386190534332E-14,
2.4321189890414183E-14,
1.5497562138279344E-13
],
[
5.343677008770726E-15,
3.2648844440382546E-15,
2.0570357304622062E-14
],
[
7.034731229010379E-16,
4.37241540347364E-16,
2.724501230034067E-15
],
[
9.209698780318175E-17,
5.752623128867322E-17,
3.5690793272455867E-16
],
[
1.2115163854031037E-17,
7.686418462856138E-18,
4.693339657853181E-17
],
[
1.573801118603991E-18,
9.983123168852456E-19,
6.116931043674199E-18
],
[
2.0615978683048806E-19,
1.2988956154073637E-19,
8.008661908086556E-19
],
[
2.710692307146891E-20,
1.7325769725895883E-20,
1.049028540243077E-19
],
[
3.551045876058866E-21,
2.2932952191247358E-21,
1.370030236887766E-20
],
[
4.616622905764688E-22,
2.9854062062358843E-22,
1.784196020960976E-21
],
[
6.025964025437843E-23,
3.9116839977344614E-23,
2.337791856893727E-22
],
[
7.881431863165786E-24,
5.160774613986424E-24,
3.0486526185955406E-23
],
[
1.019746352574707E-24,
6.74750569511279E-25,
3.9781019887042064E-24
],
[
1.3211991389290064E-25,
8.722721751184752E-26,
5.1083699682233965E-25
]
],
"runtime_seconds": 98.39070121292025,
"standard_deviation": [
[
0.020512671651716573,
0.03671949890577662,
0.013937596383641398
],
[
0.019356757196029962,
0.01348384751010582,
0.07101798495509785
],
[
0.005119797790454522,
0.0032543091683421487,
0.020015580505815277
],
[
0.0010487025920007172,
0.000681598890558711,
0.004187966225033504
],
[
0.0001885669840621704,
0.00013285568729684487,
0.0007510062064342538
],
[
0.00003246134489713627,
0.00002326670307579314,
0.00012508320260598292
],
[
0.00000514854753323712,
0.000003851567968217076,
0.00001956525278729905
],
[
7.941277970175338E-7,
6.199845981345462E-7,
0.000003093541830013532
],
[
1.1821651268979126E-7,
9.362498889173612E-8,
4.6516231093230617E-7
],
[
1.7880652819545485E-8,
1.4756047148371299E-8,
6.828043944309566E-8
],
[
2.6177713048159487E-9,
2.1567377736181214E-9,
9.976553857236642E-9
],
[
3.6848192474295915E-10,
3.0516806725733516E-10,
1.4355879243865293E-9
],
[
5.201630069879956E-11,
4.4266051356514E-11,
2.080705387283542E-10
],
[
7.2521661614308444E-12,
6.133279285676588E-12,
2.907133582408523E-11
],
[
1.0174428535590132E-12,
8.556920590128185E-13,
4.073090701023254E-12
],
[
1.4147408249742563E-13,
1.1861952230875862E-13,
5.648941319169128E-13
],
[
1.9417485172555352E-14,
1.6382699952426072E-14,
7.832254343670209E-14
],
[
2.6744144173627958E-15,
2.4031826604425636E-15,
1.1127944953020461E-14
],
[
3.7265340933328166E-16,
3.3902572154905267E-16,
1.5438318301829411E-15
],
[
5.0585120740120404E-17,
4.648021331516046E-17,
2.1186566855550634E-16
],
[
6.950746484968712E-18,
6.460523233738337E-18,
2.859180293604722E-17
],
[
9.088039763350523E-19,
8.3850882269249855E-19,
3.766766656581346E-18
],
[
1.2333535871617798E-19,
1.1284647528227783E-19,
5.069913645415962E-19
],
[
1.6827462087299693E-20,
1.5500841506732397E-20,
6.825070193204267E-20
],
[
2.2818128576067756E-21,
2.1183492572893697E-21,
9.13160398628232E-21
],
[
3.040879836313302E-22,
2.8142120752196863E-22,
1.2414893081856644E-21
],
[
4.0412952082357056E-23,
3.7637777199800484E-23,
1.6636060885893858E-22
],
[
5.492570434418456E-24,
5.269791620259616E-24,
2.2806913281899334E-23
],
[
7.160379347356289E-25,
6.96790372934012E-25,
3.0649317581485286E-24
],
[
9.594381414678526E-26,
9.207460933085914E-26,
3.8525634376820007E-25
]
],
"standard_error": [
[
0.0006486676331459254,
0.0011611725108231464,
0.00044074549680432786
],
[
0.0006121144085430907,
0.00042639669754324664,
0.0022457858729368002
],
[
0.00016190222177333763,
0.00010291029182329515,
0.0006329482308884136
],
[
0.000033162887788445425,
0.00002155404944809364,
0.00013243512034963152
],
[
0.000005963011611451283,
0.000004201265719651285,
0.00002374890149254843
],
[
0.0000010265178578723483,
7.357577536235156E-7,
0.00000395547817263215
],
[
1.6281136846670764E-7,
1.2179727342512975E-7,
6.187076180482291E-7
],
[
2.5112525918272765E-8,
1.9605634443293458E-8,
9.782638219848198E-8
],
[
3.738334371419386E-9,
2.960682108058498E-9,
1.4709723842135294E-8
],
[
5.654358896047543E-10,
4.666271824968588E-10,
2.1592170827738126E-9
],
[
8.278119716649304E-11,
6.820203680353872E-11,
3.154863338820611E-10
],
[
1.1652421587905057E-11,
9.650261616846324E-12,
4.539727622495014E-11
],
[
1.644899856644147E-12,
1.399815453085704E-12,
6.57976816359874E-12
],
[
2.293336304012183E-13,
1.9395132068668548E-13,
9.193163582775743E-13
],
[
3.217436806307635E-14,
2.7059358821997187E-14,
1.28802437316854E-13
],
[
4.473803305744274E-15,
3.751078654568321E-15,
1.786352093721063E-14
],
[
6.1403479577822535E-16,
5.180664607279854E-16,
2.4767762939745055E-15
],
[
8.457240966058601E-17,
7.599530840421532E-17,
3.518965172852007E-16
],
[
1.1784335513202193E-17,
1.0720934654770349E-17,
4.882024907644378E-17
],
[
1.599641972534029E-18,
1.4698334020639277E-18,
6.69978070629716E-18
],
[
2.1980190330910446E-19,
2.042996829504952E-19,
9.04152196885988E-19
],
[
2.873890511836529E-20,
2.6515977178545768E-20,
1.1911562049174328E-19
],
[
3.90020649577023E-21,
3.568518878138904E-21,
1.6032474659881728E-20
],
[
5.321310743599819E-22,
4.901796481055062E-22,
2.158276700105094E-21
],
[
7.215725824294878E-23,
6.698808532760452E-23,
2.88766672873251E-22
],
[
9.616106373630033E-24,
8.899319976443309E-24,
3.925933904613423E-23
],
[
1.2779697555149291E-24,
1.1902110201732385E-24,
5.260784369266313E-24
],
[
1.7369032781662815E-25,
1.6664544314489513E-25,
7.212179236874776E-25
],
[
2.264310764847583E-26,
2.20344463014962E-26,
9.692165228733686E-26
],
[
3.0340098010772594E-27,
2.9116548015570686E-27,
1.2182875293363285E-26
]
],
"through_origin_slope_mean": [
0.00011875814694346857,
-0.00005968359316585259,
0.0004543929268963687
],
"through_origin_slope_standard_error": [
2.0232812167293157E-7,
1.7425919505168615E-7,
6.981657337231785E-7
]
}
},
"verification": {
"checks": {
"critical_at_least_27_of_30_points_within_99pct_pointwise_ci": true,
"critical_diagonal_linear_r_squared_at_least_0_995": true,
"critical_max_relative_deviation_at_most_10_percent": true,
"critical_offdiagonal_asymptotic_linear_r_squared_at_least_0_98": true,
"critical_slope_within_3_standard_errors": true,
"exact_paper_scale": true,
"high_variance_control_has_positive_exponential_log_slope": true,
"high_variance_curve_rejected_by_critical_contract": true,
"low_variance_control_has_negative_exponential_log_slope": true
},
"critical_diagonal_regression": {
"intercept": -0.025294454516340548,
"r_squared": 0.9998995277420369,
"slope": 0.680743033524827
},
"critical_max_relative_deviation": 0.02518670611402943,
"critical_offdiagonal_regression_depths_10_to_30": {
"intercept": -0.4521829266839452,
"r_squared": 0.999026406337156,
"slope": 0.43191775587266945
},
"critical_points_within_99pct_pointwise_ci": 30,
"expected_critical_diagonal_slope": 0.6691276431083679,
"high_diagonal_log_regression_depths_10_to_30": {
"intercept": 0.7717190028394497,
"r_squared": 0.9998881914514658,
"slope": 0.7468471525072662
},
"low_diagonal_log_regression_depths_10_to_30": {
"intercept": 3.535222534942264,
"r_squared": 0.9999871698399195,
"slope": -2.02514775214555
},
"negative_control_high_falsely_accepted_as_critical": false,
"observed_critical_diagonal_slope_through_origin": 0.6794990439584496,
"observed_slope_standard_error": 0.01218850284716703,
"observed_slope_z": 0.8509167188234545,
"passed": true
},
"width": 200
},
"checker": {
"checks": {
"hutchinson_mean_matches_exact_trace_within_4_standard_errors": true,
"jax_jacobian_matches_independent_finite_difference": true
},
"exact_trace_average": [
[
0.8500000290942616,
-0.6350000217351248,
0.4850000166008434
],
[
1.158890445366346,
0.0,
0.19039484442890783
],
[
0.43244343983797134,
0.037503110699717665,
0.14808984647695647
]
],
"finite_difference_step": 0.0001,
"hutchinson_probes": 8192,
"hutchinson_standard_error": [
[
0.004899106453574751,
0.0034039246138473835,
0.0022904913289439805
],
[
0.008442854466806942,
0.0031026151266855184,
0.0014723627968990965
],
[
0.0034026110673436465,
0.002499659898877368,
0.001609465741862639
]
],
"hutchinson_trace_average": [
[
0.8531331672223035,
-0.6371769423824849,
0.4864648604010222
],
[
1.1568616280797064,
0.0013544184243774566,
0.1885558994400423
],
[
0.43391558660588014,
0.037114018222127884,
0.14673260983874303
]
],
"max_hutchinson_z": 1.2489754513890725,
"max_jacobian_absolute_error": 4.1071746559318E-8,
"passed": true,
"tiny_network": {
"depth": 3,
"parameters": 24,
"width": 3
}
}
}
}