# Evaluator-blind candidate audit

Verdict: **PASS**

The review began only from `README.md`, `pages/index.md`, and the files named by `logbook.json`. No repository knowledge was used to supply missing evidence.

## Files opened

- `README.md`
- `pages/index.md`
- `pages/current-verification/page.md`
- `pages/claim-1/page.md`
- `pages/claim-2/page.md`
- `pages/claim-3/page.md`
- `pages/claim-4/page.md`
- `pages/claim-5/page.md`
- `pages/claim-6/page.md`
- `pages/verification-run/page.md`
- `pages/historical-archive/page.md`
- `report.md`
- `verify_release.py`
- `historical/judged-space-859b3272122d1b3d9b97fa711eb82cbf121567f5/README.md`
- `raw/full_results.json`
- `evidence/claim_1/raw_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_1/independent_checker_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_1/negative_control_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_2/raw_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_2/independent_checker_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_2/negative_control_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_3/raw_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_3/independent_checker_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_3/negative_control_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_4/raw_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_4/independent_checker_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_4/negative_control_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_5/raw_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_5/independent_checker_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_5/negative_control_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_6/raw_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_6/independent_checker_output.json`
- `evidence/claim_6/negative_control_output.json`
- `code/uv.lock`
- `evidence/claim_1/source_audit.md`
- `evidence/claim_1/claim_contract.json`
- `code/sosmc_repro/claim1_checker.py`
- `code/sosmc_repro/run.py`
- `code/pyproject.toml`
- `evidence/claim_1/runtime.json`
- `evidence/claim_2/source_audit.md`
- `evidence/claim_2/claim_contract.json`
- `code/sosmc_repro/theory.py`
- `evidence/claim_2/runtime.json`
- `evidence/claim_3/source_audit.md`
- `evidence/claim_3/claim_contract.json`
- `evidence/claim_3/runtime.json`
- `evidence/claim_4/source_audit.md`
- `evidence/claim_4/claim_contract.json`
- `code/sosmc_repro/claim4_checker.py`
- `evidence/claim_4/runtime.json`
- `evidence/claim_5/source_audit.md`
- `evidence/claim_5/claim_contract.json`
- `code/sosmc_repro/claim5_checker.py`
- `evidence/claim_5/runtime.json`
- `evidence/claim_6/source_audit.md`
- `evidence/claim_6/claim_contract.json`
- `code/sosmc_repro/claim6_checker.py`
- `evidence/claim_6/runtime.json`
- `historical/judged-space-859b3272122d1b3d9b97fa711eb82cbf121567f5/logbook.json`
- `historical/judged-space-859b3272122d1b3d9b97fa711eb82cbf121567f5/pages/index.md`
- `pages/overview/page.md`
- `pages/claims/page.md`
- `pages/evidence/page.md`
- `historical/judged-space-859b3272122d1b3d9b97fa711eb82cbf121567f5/pages/verification-run/page.md`
- `pages/conclusion/page.md`

## Conclusions

- All six canonical claim pages were reachable.
- Every visibility-matrix row exposed code, inline data, raw evidence, an independent checker, a failing control, and the exact contract.
- The current verifier passed the unchanged candidate.
- A modified Claim 6 summary made the verifier exit nonzero.
- No supported secret pattern appeared in text artifacts.
- No conclusion remained unverifiable from the candidate traversal.