"""Claim 1 (Theorem 10) executed audit at non-toy scale. Two executed parts, one deterministic conclusion: Part A (in-regime execution, m = 2^18): run the exact classical realization of Algorithm 2's sampling core (steps 5-10) for the quadratic proper loss family, where quantum MultiSample (Hamoudi 2022, Theorem 1) is replaced by a classical sampler with the *identical output law* (i.i.d. draws proportional to z_i; the quantum part changes only the query cost, not the distribution). We verify the epsilon-approximate sparsifier guarantee spectrally and end-to-end. Part B (boundary sweep): with the explicit constant M = ceil(C n ln(n) / eps^2) (C = 4), sweep eps downward and record where the MultiSample precondition (sample count <= vector length, Theorem 20 as cited by the paper) fails, and where the algorithm's explicit M-iteration classical loop (steps 7-10) exceeds the sqrt(mn)/eps envelope of the claimed runtime. Both measured boundaries must equal the predicted eps* = sqrt(C n ln(n) / m). Negative control: at eps = eps* exactly, the call is in-domain. Determinism: fixed seeds, printed floats rounded so BLAS variation cannot change stdout; SHA-256 fingerprint over the printed results only. """ import hashlib import json import math import numpy as np M_ROWS = 1 << 18 # 262144 data points N_COLS = 64 ROW_SPARSITY = 8 C_CONST = 4 # explicit constant in M = ceil(C n ln n / eps^2) SEEDS = list(range(10)) def build_instance(seed): rng = np.random.default_rng(seed) A = np.zeros((M_ROWS, N_COLS)) cols = rng.integers(0, N_COLS, size=(M_ROWS, ROW_SPARSITY)) vals = rng.standard_normal((M_ROWS, ROW_SPARSITY)) rows = np.repeat(np.arange(M_ROWS), ROW_SPARSITY) A[rows, cols.ravel()] = vals.ravel() b = A @ rng.standard_normal(N_COLS) + 0.1 * rng.standard_normal(M_ROWS) return A, b, rng def leverage_scores(A): G = A.T @ A Ginv = np.linalg.inv(G) return np.einsum("ij,jk,ik->i", A, Ginv, A) def sample_size(eps): return math.ceil(C_CONST * N_COLS * math.log(N_COLS) / eps**2) def run_part_a(): results = [] for eps in (0.5, 0.25, 0.125): M = sample_size(eps) spectral_devs, ratios = [], [] for seed in SEEDS: A, b, rng = build_instance(seed) lev = leverage_scores(A) z = lev / lev.sum() idx = rng.choice(M_ROWS, size=M, replace=True, p=z) # Algorithm 2 line 9 with exact sum (spectral test): w = np.zeros(M_ROWS) np.add.at(w, idx, 1.0 / (M * z[idx])) G = A.T @ A Gs = (A * w[:, None]).T @ A B = np.linalg.inv(np.linalg.cholesky(G)) eigs = np.linalg.eigvalsh(B @ Gs @ B.T) spectral_devs.append(max(abs(eigs.max() - 1), abs(eigs.min() - 1))) # Algorithm 2 line 9 exactly as printed (SumEstimate error 0.1, # deterministic worst-ish draw per seed), end-to-end argmin test: nu_err = 1.0 + 0.1 * (2 * (seed % 2) - 1) w_alg = np.zeros(M_ROWS) np.add.at(w_alg, idx, nu_err / (1.1 * M * z[idx])) mask = w_alg > 0 sw = np.sqrt(w_alg[mask]) xs = np.linalg.lstsq(A[mask] * sw[:, None], b[mask] * sw, rcond=None)[0] xf = np.linalg.lstsq(A, b, rcond=None)[0] f = lambda x: float(np.sum((A @ x - b) ** 2)) ratios.append(f(xs) / f(xf)) results.append( { "eps": eps, "M": M, "M_le_m": M <= M_ROWS, "max_spectral_dev": round(max(spectral_devs), 6), "spectral_within_eps": bool(max(spectral_devs) <= eps), "max_objective_ratio": round(max(ratios), 6), "ratio_within_1plus_eps": bool(max(ratios) <= (1 + eps)), } ) return results def run_part_b(): pred_dom = math.sqrt(C_CONST * N_COLS * math.log(N_COLS) / M_ROWS) pred_loop = C_CONST * math.log(N_COLS) * math.sqrt(N_COLS / M_ROWS) rows = [] eps = 0.5 first_out = None first_loop_break = None while eps > 1e-4: M = sample_size(eps) envelope = math.ceil(math.sqrt(M_ROWS * N_COLS) / eps) in_dom = M <= M_ROWS loop_ok = M <= envelope if first_out is None and not in_dom: first_out = eps if first_loop_break is None and not loop_ok: first_loop_break = eps rows.append((eps, M, in_dom, loop_ok)) eps /= 2 return pred_dom, pred_loop, first_out, first_loop_break, rows def main(): print("Claim 1 / Theorem 10 executed audit") print( f"instance: m={M_ROWS} n={N_COLS} r={ROW_SPARSITY} " f"M=ceil({C_CONST}*n*ln(n)/eps^2) seeds={SEEDS[0]}..{SEEDS[-1]}" ) part_a = run_part_a() print("Part A - in-regime execution of Algorithm 2 sampling core:") for row in part_a: print( f" eps={row['eps']:<6} M={row['M']:<6} M<=m={row['M_le_m']} " f"max_spectral_dev={row['max_spectral_dev']:.6f} " f"within_eps={row['spectral_within_eps']} " f"max_obj_ratio={row['max_objective_ratio']:.6f} " f"within_1+eps={row['ratio_within_1plus_eps']}" ) pred_dom, pred_loop, first_out, first_loop_break, rows = run_part_b() print("Part B - boundary sweep (MultiSample domain and loop envelope):") for eps, M, in_dom, loop_ok in rows: print( f" eps={eps:<12.6g} M={M:<12} M<=m={str(in_dom):<5} " f"M<=sqrt(mn)/eps={loop_ok}" ) print( f"predicted domain boundary eps*_dom = sqrt(C n ln n / m) = " f"{pred_dom:.6f}" ) print( f"predicted loop-envelope boundary eps*_loop = C ln(n) sqrt(n/m) = " f"{pred_loop:.6f}" ) print( f"measured first out-of-domain eps = {first_out:.6g}; " f"measured first loop>envelope eps = {first_loop_break:.6g}" ) both = (first_out < pred_dom <= 2 * first_out) and ( first_loop_break < pred_loop <= 2 * first_loop_break ) print( "each measured boundary sits one halving step under its prediction: " f"{both}" ) control_eps = pred_dom print( f"negative control: eps=eps*={control_eps:.6f} gives " f"M={sample_size(control_eps)} <= m={M_ROWS}: " f"{sample_size(control_eps) <= M_ROWS}" ) fp = { "part_a": part_a, "predicted_boundary_dom": round(pred_dom, 6), "predicted_boundary_loop": round(pred_loop, 6), "first_out_of_domain": first_out, "first_loop_break": first_loop_break, } digest = hashlib.sha256( json.dumps(fp, sort_keys=True).encode() ).hexdigest() print(f"RESULTS_SHA256={digest}") if __name__ == "__main__": main()