{ "capsule_id": "CREATOR_X_SYNTHETIC_EXAMPLE_EA4BD6E1D6B6", "causal_families": [ { "causal_family_id": "CF_DISTRIBUTION_STATE", "description": "Visible distribution baseline, breakpoint, persistence, and recovery state.", "member_event_ids": [ "EVENT_0000", "EVENT_0001" ], "state": "COLLAPSED_FOR_SINGLE_CASE_REVIEW" } ], "competing_hypotheses": [ { "falsifiers": [ "A persistent account-level breakpoint across comparable content and matched controls.", "Platform records showing an account-conditioned recommendation or distribution state." ], "fit": "HELD", "hypothesis": "H0 — ordinary audience variation or post-level performance variance", "supporting_observations": [ "Single-account metrics can vary for reasons not visible in the packet." ] }, { "falsifiers": [ "Receipts showing materially stable cadence, format, and subject topology across the breakpoint.", "Comparable content performing differently before and after the breakpoint." ], "fit": "LOW", "hypothesis": "H1 — creator posting cadence, format, or subject-mix change", "supporting_observations": [ "Changes in creator behavior can alter visible distribution." ] }, { "falsifiers": [ "Matched comparison accounts not exhibiting the same transition during the same period.", "Platform change logs excluding the relevant surface or account cohort." ], "fit": "HELD", "hypothesis": "H2 — platform-wide recommender or demand change", "supporting_observations": [ "A platform-wide change can affect many creators simultaneously." ] }, { "falsifiers": [ "Account-level eligibility history showing no relevant state change.", "A complete organic explanation reproducing the observed breakpoint and persistence." ], "fit": "HELD", "hypothesis": "H3 — account-conditioned distribution or recommendation state", "supporting_observations": [ "An abrupt persistent reach change can be generated by an account-level hidden state.", "Notification or label events may identify a candidate state transition." ] }, { "falsifiers": [ "Records showing full downstream restoration at clearance time.", "Evidence that the reach change preceded and was independent of the enforcement state." ], "fit": "HELD", "hypothesis": "H4 — enforcement, label, or review state coupled to distribution and incomplete restoration", "supporting_observations": [ "A label-clearance sequence without demonstrated recovery is a candidate causal family." ] }, { "falsifiers": [ "Cross-account comparison showing no recurrent phenotype after normalization and controls.", "Evidence that platform/machine access declined proportionally with human reach." ], "fit": "HELD", "hypothesis": "H5 — recurrent extraction-with-relational-severance phenotype across creators", "supporting_observations": [ "The creator's work may remain platform-readable while human relational return contracts." ] } ], "execution_order_receipt": [ { "sequence": 1, "stage": "SOURCE_REGISTERED", "state": "PASS" }, { "sequence": 2, "stage": "EVENTS_REGISTERED", "state": "PASS" }, { "sequence": 3, "stage": "CHRONOLOGY_MAPPED", "state": "PASS" }, { "sequence": 4, "stage": "CAUSAL_FAMILIES_COLLAPSED", "state": "PASS" }, { "sequence": 5, "stage": "PREDICTIONS_FROZEN", "state": "PASS" }, { "sequence": 6, "stage": "HYPOTHESES_FROZEN", "state": "PASS" }, { "sequence": 7, "stage": "PRESSURE_TESTED", "state": "PASS_WITH_HELD_CAUSES" } ], "frozen_discriminator_predictions": [ { "prediction_id": "PRED_MATCHED_CONTROLS", "required_sources": [ "Matched comparison capsules", "Platform-wide change logs" ], "state": "FROZEN_HELD", "statement": "If the transition is platform-wide rather than account-conditioned, matched accounts and comparable surfaces should exhibit a similar time-aligned change." }, { "prediction_id": "PRED_ACCOUNT_STATE", "required_sources": [ "Account recommendation-eligibility history", "Ranking/cohort state history" ], "state": "FROZEN_HELD", "statement": "If an account-conditioned state contributed, account-level eligibility or ranking records should show a transition near the documented breakpoint." }, { "prediction_id": "PRED_RESTORATION", "required_sources": [ "Before/after enforcement-state diff", "Restoration execution receipt" ], "state": "FROZEN_LOW_SIGNAL", "statement": "If review clearance fully restored the prior state, downstream eligibility records or normalized distribution should evidence restoration after clearance." }, { "prediction_id": "PRED_NOTIFICATION_ROUTE", "required_sources": [ "Notification generation and delivery logs", "Thread interaction export" ], "state": "FROZEN_LOW_SIGNAL", "statement": "If relational return was degraded at notification routing, thread-visible interactions and notification-delivery logs should diverge in a reproducible way." } ], "minimum_cut_candidates": [ { "candidate_cut": "Account-level recommendation or discovery eligibility", "candidate_id": "CUT_RECOMMENDATION_ELIGIBILITY", "potentially_degraded_path": "Independent human discovery beyond the existing audience.", "preserved_path": "Creator content remains hosted and platform-readable.", "required_source_return": "Account recommendation-eligibility and distribution-state history.", "state": "HELD" }, { "candidate_cut": "Account- or post-conditioned distribution multiplier", "candidate_id": "CUT_DISTRIBUTION_MULTIPLIER", "potentially_degraded_path": "The number or diversity of humans to whom the content is delivered.", "preserved_path": "Content remains available for engagement, indexing, and machine retrieval.", "required_source_return": "Ranking feature values, cohort assignment, and multiplier history.", "state": "HELD" }, { "candidate_cut": "Notification and reply-return routing", "candidate_id": "CUT_NOTIFICATION_RETURN", "potentially_degraded_path": "The creator's awareness of and ability to reciprocate human interaction.", "preserved_path": "Replies or platform interactions can exist on-thread.", "required_source_return": "Notification-generation, suppression, deduplication, and delivery logs.", "state": "HELD" }, { "candidate_cut": "Downstream restoration after label removal, appeal, or clearance", "candidate_id": "CUT_RESTORATION_STATE", "potentially_degraded_path": "Prior recommendation and distribution state may remain unrestored.", "preserved_path": "The visible label can be removed.", "required_source_return": "Before/after enforcement state diff and restoration execution receipt.", "state": "LOW_SIGNAL" } ], "zip_sha256": "0a4bdb94a4f390094a700b7cb0bbee715638dfdab858b2c8697fbf3e72562f4a" }