""" COMPREHENSIVE TEST CASE STUDY ============================== Scenario: AI Safety Discussion between researchers Purpose: Demonstrate full realization crystallization pipeline Test Objectives: 1. Extract realizations from complex multi-turn conversation 2. Calculate Q-scores with full transparency 3. Assign layers automatically 4. Build parent-child graph (بنات افكار) 5. Test retrieval system 6. Assess system performance """ from layers.layer_2_core.realization_engine import RealizationEngine, RealizationFeatures import json from datetime import datetime class TestCaseStudy: def __init__(self): self.engine = RealizationEngine() self.test_results = { 'test_name': 'AI Safety Discussion Analysis', 'timestamp': datetime.now().isoformat(), 'realizations': [], 'metrics': {}, 'assessment': {} } def run_test(self): """Execute complete test pipeline""" print("="*80) print("TEST CASE STUDY: AI SAFETY DISCUSSION") print("="*80) print("\n🔄 PHASE 1: CONVERSATION SIMULATION\n") # Simulate a multi-turn conversation about AI safety self.simulate_conversation() print("\n🔄 PHASE 2: REALIZATION EXTRACTION & SCORING\n") self.extract_and_score_realizations() print("\n🔄 PHASE 3: LAYER DISTRIBUTION ANALYSIS\n") self.analyze_layer_distribution() print("\n🔄 PHASE 4: GENERATIVITY ANALYSIS (بنات افكار)\n") self.analyze_generativity() print("\n🔄 PHASE 5: RETRIEVAL SYSTEM TEST\n") self.test_retrieval() print("\n🔄 PHASE 6: QUALITY ASSESSMENT\n") self.assess_quality() print("\n🔄 PHASE 7: EXPORT RESULTS\n") self.export_results() print("\n" + "="*80) print("TEST COMPLETE") print("="*80) def simulate_conversation(self): """Simulate AI safety discussion""" print("Simulating 8-turn conversation between AI safety researchers...") print("Topic: Alignment, interpretability, and emergent behaviors\n") def extract_and_score_realizations(self): """Extract realizations from conversation and score them""" # =================================================================== # TURN 1: Foundational observation about AI systems # =================================================================== print("Turn 1: Discussing AI scaling...") r1 = self.engine.add_realization( content="Larger language models exhibit emergent capabilities not present in smaller models", features=RealizationFeatures( grounding=0.95, # Well-documented (GPT-3, GPT-4 papers) certainty=0.92, # Strong empirical evidence structure=0.90, # Clear statement applicability=0.88, # Applies to model development coherence=1.0, # No contradictions generativity=0.85 # Generates safety questions ), turn_number=1, context="Researcher A observes scaling trends", evidence=["GPT-3 paper", "Emergent Abilities paper"] ) self.test_results['realizations'].append({ 'id': r1.id, 'content': r1.content, 'q_score': r1.q_score, 'layer': r1.layer }) # =================================================================== # TURN 2: The alignment problem emerges # =================================================================== print("Turn 2: Identifying the core problem...") r2 = self.engine.add_realization( content="AI systems optimize for specified objectives, not intended outcomes - this is the alignment problem", features=RealizationFeatures( grounding=0.92, # Well-established in AI safety literature certainty=0.95, # Core problem, high certainty structure=0.93, # Clear problem statement applicability=0.94, # Critical for AI development coherence=0.95, # Consistent with Turn 1 generativity=0.90 # Generates research directions ), turn_number=2, parents=[r1.id], context="Researcher B identifies misalignment risk", evidence=["Superintelligence by Bostrom", "AI Alignment Forum"] ) self.test_results['realizations'].append({ 'id': r2.id, 'content': r2.content, 'q_score': r2.q_score, 'layer': r2.layer }) # =================================================================== # TURN 3: Interpretability as solution direction # =================================================================== print("Turn 3: Proposing interpretability approach...") r3 = self.engine.add_realization( content="Mechanistic interpretability - understanding model internals - is necessary for alignment", features=RealizationFeatures( grounding=0.85, # Emerging field, less established certainty=0.80, # Strong belief but not proven structure=0.88, # Clear proposal applicability=0.90, # Highly actionable coherence=0.92, # Follows from alignment problem generativity=0.88 # Generates research methods ), turn_number=3, parents=[r2.id], context="Researcher C proposes interpretability research", evidence=["Anthropic's interpretability work", "Circuits papers"] ) self.test_results['realizations'].append({ 'id': r3.id, 'content': r3.content, 'q_score': r3.q_score, 'layer': r3.layer }) # =================================================================== # TURN 4: Measurement challenge # =================================================================== print("Turn 4: Identifying measurement problem...") r4 = self.engine.add_realization( content="We cannot fully verify AI system behavior - the testing problem is computationally intractable", features=RealizationFeatures( grounding=0.98, # Computational complexity theory certainty=0.90, # Strong theoretical backing structure=0.92, # Clear limitation applicability=0.85, # Constrains verification approaches coherence=0.88, # Complicates Turn 3 generativity=0.82 # Generates verification methods ), turn_number=4, parents=[r3.id], context="Researcher D identifies fundamental limit", evidence=["Computational complexity", "Verification literature"] ) self.test_results['realizations'].append({ 'id': r4.id, 'content': r4.content, 'q_score': r4.q_score, 'layer': r4.layer }) # =================================================================== # TURN 5: Sandbox approach # =================================================================== print("Turn 5: Proposing containment strategy...") r5 = self.engine.add_realization( content="AI systems should be developed in sandboxed environments with capability constraints", features=RealizationFeatures( grounding=0.80, # Practical approach, less theoretical certainty=0.75, # Uncertain effectiveness structure=0.85, # Clear strategy applicability=0.92, # Very actionable coherence=0.85, # Partial solution to Turn 4 generativity=0.78 # Generates safety protocols ), turn_number=5, parents=[r4.id], context="Researcher E proposes containment", evidence=["Capability control literature"] ) self.test_results['realizations'].append({ 'id': r5.id, 'content': r5.content, 'q_score': r5.q_score, 'layer': r5.layer }) # =================================================================== # TURN 6: Multi-agent coordination insight # =================================================================== print("Turn 6: Discovering coordination dynamics...") r6 = self.engine.add_realization( content="Multiple AI systems will exhibit emergent coordination behaviors not predictable from individual analysis", features=RealizationFeatures( grounding=0.82, # Game theory + emergence literature certainty=0.85, # Strong theoretical basis structure=0.88, # Clear prediction applicability=0.80, # Applies to multi-agent systems coherence=0.90, # Extends Turn 1 (emergence) generativity=0.92 # Opens multi-agent research ), turn_number=6, parents=[r1.id, r2.id], context="Researcher F identifies multi-agent risk", evidence=["Multi-agent RL", "Game theory"] ) self.test_results['realizations'].append({ 'id': r6.id, 'content': r6.content, 'q_score': r6.q_score, 'layer': r6.layer }) # =================================================================== # TURN 7: Synthesis - layered safety # =================================================================== print("Turn 7: Synthesizing into framework...") r7 = self.engine.add_realization( content="AI safety requires layered defenses: interpretability + verification + containment + coordination protocols", features=RealizationFeatures( grounding=0.88, # Synthesizes prior work certainty=0.87, # Confident in framework structure=0.92, # Clear framework applicability=0.95, # Highly actionable coherence=0.95, # Synthesizes Turns 3-6 generativity=0.88 # Generates integrated approach ), turn_number=7, parents=[r3.id, r4.id, r5.id, r6.id], context="Researcher A synthesizes discussion", evidence=["Defense in depth", "Security engineering"] ) self.test_results['realizations'].append({ 'id': r7.id, 'content': r7.content, 'q_score': r7.q_score, 'layer': r7.layer }) # =================================================================== # TURN 8: Meta-realization # =================================================================== print("Turn 8: Meta-observation about the discussion...") r8 = self.engine.add_realization( content="This conversation itself demonstrates how realizations build on each other to form coherent frameworks", features=RealizationFeatures( grounding=0.90, # Observable in this conversation certainty=0.88, # We can see it happening structure=0.94, # Very clear observation applicability=0.85, # Applies to knowledge work coherence=0.98, # Meta-coherent generativity=0.90 # Self-referential insight ), turn_number=8, parents=[r7.id], context="Researcher B observes the process", evidence=["This very conversation"] ) self.test_results['realizations'].append({ 'id': r8.id, 'content': r8.content, 'q_score': r8.q_score, 'layer': r8.layer }) print(f"\n✅ Extracted {len(self.test_results['realizations'])} realizations") def analyze_layer_distribution(self): """Analyze how realizations distributed across layers""" # Get statistics self.engine.print_stats() # Store in results self.test_results['metrics']['layer_distribution'] = dict( self.engine.stats['layer_distribution'] ) self.test_results['metrics']['avg_q_score'] = self.engine.stats['avg_q_score'] # Analyze quality by layer print("\nQuality Analysis by Layer:") for layer in [0, 1, 2, 3, 'N']: realizations = list(self.engine.layers[layer].values()) if realizations: avg_q = sum(r.q_score for r in realizations) / len(realizations) min_q = min(r.q_score for r in realizations) max_q = max(r.q_score for r in realizations) print(f" Layer {layer}: avg={avg_q:.4f}, min={min_q:.4f}, max={max_q:.4f}") def analyze_generativity(self): """Analyze which realizations were most generative""" print("Most Generative Realizations (بنات افكار):\n") # Find realizations with children with_children = [ (r, len(r.children)) for r in self.engine.index.values() if r.children ] with_children.sort(key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True) generativity_data = [] for i, (r, child_count) in enumerate(with_children[:5], 1): print(f"{i}. {r.content[:60]}...") print(f" Q={r.q_score:.4f}, Layer {r.layer}") print(f" Generated {child_count} children:") children_info = [] for child_id in r.children: child = self.engine.index[child_id] print(f" → {child.content[:50]}... (Q={child.q_score:.3f})") children_info.append({ 'content': child.content, 'q_score': child.q_score }) generativity_data.append({ 'parent': r.content, 'q_score': r.q_score, 'child_count': child_count, 'children': children_info }) print() self.test_results['metrics']['generativity'] = generativity_data def test_retrieval(self): """Test the retrieval system""" queries = [ ("alignment", "alignment problem"), ("interpretability", "understanding models"), ("verification", "testing problem"), ("safety framework", "layered defenses"), ("emergence", "emergent capabilities") ] retrieval_results = [] for query_name, query in queries: print(f"Query: '{query}'") results = self.engine.retrieve(query) if results: best = results[0] print(f" ✅ Found: [{best.layer}] Q={best.q_score:.4f}") print(f" {best.content[:60]}...") retrieval_results.append({ 'query': query, 'found': True, 'best_match': { 'content': best.content, 'q_score': best.q_score, 'layer': best.layer } }) else: print(f" ❌ No results") retrieval_results.append({ 'query': query, 'found': False }) print() self.test_results['metrics']['retrieval'] = retrieval_results # Calculate retrieval accuracy found_count = sum(1 for r in retrieval_results if r['found']) accuracy = found_count / len(queries) * 100 print(f"Retrieval Accuracy: {found_count}/{len(queries)} = {accuracy:.1f}%") def assess_quality(self): """Comprehensive quality assessment""" print("="*60) print("QUALITY ASSESSMENT") print("="*60) # 1. Q-Score Distribution q_scores = [r.q_score for r in self.engine.index.values()] q_scores.sort(reverse=True) print("\n1. Q-Score Distribution:") print(f" Highest: {max(q_scores):.4f}") print(f" Lowest: {min(q_scores):.4f}") print(f" Mean: {sum(q_scores)/len(q_scores):.4f}") print(f" Median: {q_scores[len(q_scores)//2]:.4f}") # 2. Layer Quality print("\n2. Layer Quality:") print(f" Layer 0 (Universal): {self.engine.stats['layer_distribution'][0]} realizations") print(f" Layer 1 (Domain): {self.engine.stats['layer_distribution'][1]} realizations") print(f" Layer 2 (Pattern): {self.engine.stats['layer_distribution'][2]} realizations") print(f" Layer 3 (Situation): {self.engine.stats['layer_distribution'][3]} realizations") print(f" Layer N (Ephemeral): {self.engine.stats['layer_distribution']['N']} realizations") # 3. Coherence Analysis print("\n3. Coherence Analysis:") avg_coherence = sum(r.features.coherence for r in self.engine.index.values()) / len(self.engine.index) print(f" Average Coherence: {avg_coherence:.4f}") print(f" → {avg_coherence*100:.1f}% consistency with prior layers") # 4. Generativity Analysis print("\n4. Generativity Analysis:") total_children = sum(len(r.children) for r in self.engine.index.values()) total_parents = sum(len(r.parents) for r in self.engine.index.values()) avg_children = total_children / len(self.engine.index) print(f" Total children spawned: {total_children}") print(f" Average children per realization: {avg_children:.2f}") print(f" Total parent links: {total_parents}") # 5. Feature Analysis print("\n5. Feature Averages:") features = ['grounding', 'certainty', 'structure', 'applicability', 'coherence', 'generativity'] for feature in features: avg = sum(getattr(r.features, feature) for r in self.engine.index.values()) / len(self.engine.index) print(f" {feature.capitalize():15s}: {avg:.4f}") # 6. System Performance print("\n6. System Performance:") print(f" Total realizations: {len(self.engine.index)}") print(f" Layers used: {sum(1 for v in self.engine.stats['layer_distribution'].values() if v > 0)}/5") print(f" Graph depth: {self.calculate_max_depth()} levels") print(f" Avg Q-score: {self.engine.stats['avg_q_score']:.4f}") # Store assessment self.test_results['assessment'] = { 'q_score_stats': { 'max': max(q_scores), 'min': min(q_scores), 'mean': sum(q_scores)/len(q_scores), 'median': q_scores[len(q_scores)//2] }, 'coherence': { 'avg_coherence': avg_coherence, 'consistency_pct': avg_coherence * 100 }, 'generativity': { 'total_children': total_children, 'avg_children_per_realization': avg_children, 'total_parent_links': total_parents }, 'system_performance': { 'total_realizations': len(self.engine.index), 'layers_used': sum(1 for v in self.engine.stats['layer_distribution'].values() if v > 0), 'graph_depth': self.calculate_max_depth(), 'avg_q_score': self.engine.stats['avg_q_score'] } } # 7. Pass/Fail Criteria print("\n7. Test Criteria:") tests = [ ("All Q-scores >= 0.70", all(q >= 0.70 for q in q_scores)), ("Average Q-score >= 0.85", self.engine.stats['avg_q_score'] >= 0.85), ("At least 1 Layer 1+ realization", self.engine.stats['layer_distribution'][1] >= 1), ("Retrieval accuracy >= 80%", len([r for r in self.test_results['metrics']['retrieval'] if r['found']]) / len(self.test_results['metrics']['retrieval']) >= 0.80), ("Average coherence >= 0.85", avg_coherence >= 0.85) ] all_passed = True for test_name, passed in tests: status = "✅ PASS" if passed else "❌ FAIL" print(f" {status}: {test_name}") if not passed: all_passed = False print("\n" + "="*60) if all_passed: print("✅ ALL TESTS PASSED") else: print("⚠️ SOME TESTS FAILED") print("="*60) self.test_results['assessment']['all_tests_passed'] = all_passed self.test_results['assessment']['individual_tests'] = [ {'name': name, 'passed': passed} for name, passed in tests ] def calculate_max_depth(self): """Calculate maximum depth of realization graph""" def get_depth(r_id, visited=None): if visited is None: visited = set() if r_id in visited: return 0 visited.add(r_id) r = self.engine.index.get(r_id) if not r or not r.children: return 1 return 1 + max(get_depth(child_id, visited.copy()) for child_id in r.children) # Find root nodes (no parents) roots = [r.id for r in self.engine.index.values() if not r.parents] if not roots: return 0 return max(get_depth(root) for root in roots) def export_results(self): """Export test results to JSON""" output_path = 'layers/layer_3_optimization/test_case_results.json' with open(output_path, 'w') as f: json.dump(self.test_results, f, indent=2) print(f"✅ Results exported to {output_path}") print(f" Total size: {len(json.dumps(self.test_results))} bytes") # Also export the full engine state engine_state = self.engine.export_state() engine_path = 'layers/layer_3_optimization/test_case_engine_state.json' with open(engine_path, 'w') as f: json.dump(engine_state, f, indent=2) print(f"✅ Engine state exported to {engine_path}") if __name__ == "__main__": # Run the comprehensive test test = TestCaseStudy() test.run_test()