hackathon_code4change / src /monitoring /ripeness_calibrator.py
RoyAalekh's picture
refactored project structure. renamed scheduler dir to src
6a28f91
"""Ripeness classifier calibration based on accuracy metrics.
Analyzes classification performance and suggests threshold adjustments
to improve accuracy over time.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
from dataclasses import dataclass
from typing import Optional
from src.monitoring.ripeness_metrics import RipenessMetrics
@dataclass
class ThresholdAdjustment:
"""Suggested threshold adjustment with reasoning."""
threshold_name: str
current_value: int | float
suggested_value: int | float
reason: str
confidence: str # "high", "medium", "low"
class RipenessCalibrator:
"""Analyzes ripeness metrics and suggests threshold calibration."""
# Calibration rules thresholds
HIGH_FALSE_POSITIVE_THRESHOLD = 0.20
HIGH_FALSE_NEGATIVE_THRESHOLD = 0.15
LOW_UNKNOWN_THRESHOLD = 0.05
LOW_RIPE_PRECISION_THRESHOLD = 0.70
LOW_UNRIPE_RECALL_THRESHOLD = 0.60
@classmethod
def analyze_metrics(
cls,
metrics: RipenessMetrics,
current_thresholds: Optional[dict[str, int | float]] = None,
) -> list[ThresholdAdjustment]:
"""Analyze metrics and suggest threshold adjustments.
Args:
metrics: RipenessMetrics with classification history
current_thresholds: Current threshold values (optional)
Returns:
List of suggested adjustments with reasoning
"""
accuracy = metrics.get_accuracy_metrics()
adjustments: list[ThresholdAdjustment] = []
# Default current thresholds if not provided
if current_thresholds is None:
from src.core.ripeness import RipenessClassifier
current_thresholds = {
"MIN_SERVICE_HEARINGS": RipenessClassifier.MIN_SERVICE_HEARINGS,
"MIN_STAGE_DAYS": RipenessClassifier.MIN_STAGE_DAYS,
"MIN_CASE_AGE_DAYS": RipenessClassifier.MIN_CASE_AGE_DAYS,
}
# Check if we have enough data
if accuracy["completed_predictions"] < 50:
print(
"Warning: Insufficient data for calibration (need at least 50 predictions)"
)
return adjustments
# Rule 1: High false positive rate -> increase MIN_SERVICE_HEARINGS
if accuracy["false_positive_rate"] > cls.HIGH_FALSE_POSITIVE_THRESHOLD:
current_hearings = current_thresholds.get("MIN_SERVICE_HEARINGS", 1)
suggested_hearings = current_hearings + 1
adjustments.append(
ThresholdAdjustment(
threshold_name="MIN_SERVICE_HEARINGS",
current_value=current_hearings,
suggested_value=suggested_hearings,
reason=(
f"False positive rate {accuracy['false_positive_rate']:.1%} exceeds "
f"{cls.HIGH_FALSE_POSITIVE_THRESHOLD:.0%}. Cases marked RIPE are adjourning. "
f"Require more hearings as evidence of readiness."
),
confidence="high",
)
)
# Rule 2: High false negative rate -> decrease MIN_STAGE_DAYS
if accuracy["false_negative_rate"] > cls.HIGH_FALSE_NEGATIVE_THRESHOLD:
current_days = current_thresholds.get("MIN_STAGE_DAYS", 7)
suggested_days = max(3, current_days - 2) # Don't go below 3 days
adjustments.append(
ThresholdAdjustment(
threshold_name="MIN_STAGE_DAYS",
current_value=current_days,
suggested_value=suggested_days,
reason=(
f"False negative rate {accuracy['false_negative_rate']:.1%} exceeds "
f"{cls.HIGH_FALSE_NEGATIVE_THRESHOLD:.0%}. UNRIPE cases are progressing. "
f"Relax stage maturity requirement."
),
confidence="medium",
)
)
# Rule 3: Low UNKNOWN rate -> system too confident, add uncertainty
if accuracy["unknown_rate"] < cls.LOW_UNKNOWN_THRESHOLD:
current_age = current_thresholds.get("MIN_CASE_AGE_DAYS", 14)
suggested_age = current_age + 7
adjustments.append(
ThresholdAdjustment(
threshold_name="MIN_CASE_AGE_DAYS",
current_value=current_age,
suggested_value=suggested_age,
reason=(
f"UNKNOWN rate {accuracy['unknown_rate']:.1%} below "
f"{cls.LOW_UNKNOWN_THRESHOLD:.0%}. System is overconfident. "
f"Increase case age requirement to add uncertainty for immature cases."
),
confidence="medium",
)
)
# Rule 4: Low RIPE precision -> more conservative RIPE classification
if accuracy["ripe_precision"] < cls.LOW_RIPE_PRECISION_THRESHOLD:
current_hearings = current_thresholds.get("MIN_SERVICE_HEARINGS", 1)
suggested_hearings = current_hearings + 1
adjustments.append(
ThresholdAdjustment(
threshold_name="MIN_SERVICE_HEARINGS",
current_value=current_hearings,
suggested_value=suggested_hearings,
reason=(
f"RIPE precision {accuracy['ripe_precision']:.1%} below "
f"{cls.LOW_RIPE_PRECISION_THRESHOLD:.0%}. Too many RIPE predictions fail. "
f"Be more conservative in marking cases RIPE."
),
confidence="high",
)
)
# Rule 5: Low UNRIPE recall -> missing bottlenecks
if accuracy["unripe_recall"] < cls.LOW_UNRIPE_RECALL_THRESHOLD:
current_days = current_thresholds.get("MIN_STAGE_DAYS", 7)
suggested_days = current_days + 3
adjustments.append(
ThresholdAdjustment(
threshold_name="MIN_STAGE_DAYS",
current_value=current_days,
suggested_value=suggested_days,
reason=(
f"UNRIPE recall {accuracy['unripe_recall']:.1%} below "
f"{cls.LOW_UNRIPE_RECALL_THRESHOLD:.0%}. Missing many bottlenecks. "
f"Increase stage maturity requirement to catch more unripe cases."
),
confidence="medium",
)
)
# Deduplicate adjustments (same threshold suggested multiple times)
deduplicated = cls._deduplicate_adjustments(adjustments)
return deduplicated
@classmethod
def _deduplicate_adjustments(
cls, adjustments: list[ThresholdAdjustment]
) -> list[ThresholdAdjustment]:
"""Deduplicate adjustments for same threshold, prefer high confidence."""
threshold_map: dict[str, ThresholdAdjustment] = {}
for adj in adjustments:
if adj.threshold_name not in threshold_map:
threshold_map[adj.threshold_name] = adj
else:
# Keep adjustment with higher confidence or larger change
existing = threshold_map[adj.threshold_name]
confidence_order = {"high": 3, "medium": 2, "low": 1}
if (
confidence_order[adj.confidence]
> confidence_order[existing.confidence]
):
threshold_map[adj.threshold_name] = adj
elif (
confidence_order[adj.confidence]
== confidence_order[existing.confidence]
):
# Same confidence - keep larger adjustment magnitude
existing_delta = abs(
existing.suggested_value - existing.current_value
)
new_delta = abs(adj.suggested_value - adj.current_value)
if new_delta > existing_delta:
threshold_map[adj.threshold_name] = adj
return list(threshold_map.values())
@classmethod
def generate_calibration_report(
cls,
metrics: RipenessMetrics,
adjustments: list[ThresholdAdjustment],
output_path: str | None = None,
) -> str:
"""Generate human-readable calibration report.
Args:
metrics: RipenessMetrics with classification history
adjustments: List of suggested adjustments
output_path: Optional file path to save report
Returns:
Report text
"""
accuracy = metrics.get_accuracy_metrics()
lines = [
"Ripeness Classifier Calibration Report",
"=" * 70,
"",
"Current Performance:",
f" Total predictions: {accuracy['total_predictions']}",
f" Completed: {accuracy['completed_predictions']}",
f" False positive rate: {accuracy['false_positive_rate']:.1%}",
f" False negative rate: {accuracy['false_negative_rate']:.1%}",
f" UNKNOWN rate: {accuracy['unknown_rate']:.1%}",
f" RIPE precision: {accuracy['ripe_precision']:.1%}",
f" UNRIPE recall: {accuracy['unripe_recall']:.1%}",
"",
]
if not adjustments:
lines.extend(
[
"Recommended Adjustments:",
" No adjustments needed - performance is within acceptable ranges.",
"",
"Current thresholds are performing well. Continue monitoring.",
]
)
else:
lines.extend(
[
"Recommended Adjustments:",
"",
]
)
for i, adj in enumerate(adjustments, 1):
lines.extend(
[
f"{i}. {adj.threshold_name}",
f" Current: {adj.current_value}",
f" Suggested: {adj.suggested_value}",
f" Confidence: {adj.confidence.upper()}",
f" Reason: {adj.reason}",
"",
]
)
lines.extend(
[
"Implementation:",
" 1. Review suggested adjustments",
" 2. Apply using: RipenessClassifier.set_thresholds(new_values)",
" 3. Re-run simulation to validate improvements",
" 4. Compare new metrics with baseline",
"",
]
)
report = "\n".join(lines)
if output_path:
with open(output_path, "w") as f:
f.write(report)
print(f"Calibration report saved to {output_path}")
return report
@classmethod
def apply_adjustments(
cls,
adjustments: list[ThresholdAdjustment],
auto_apply: bool = False,
) -> dict[str, int | float]:
"""Apply threshold adjustments to RipenessClassifier.
Args:
adjustments: List of adjustments to apply
auto_apply: If True, apply immediately; if False, return dict only
Returns:
Dictionary of new threshold values
"""
new_thresholds: dict[str, int | float] = {}
for adj in adjustments:
new_thresholds[adj.threshold_name] = adj.suggested_value
if auto_apply:
from src.core.ripeness import RipenessClassifier
RipenessClassifier.set_thresholds(new_thresholds)
print(f"Applied {len(adjustments)} threshold adjustments")
return new_thresholds