Are the facts, explanations, calculations, or judgments mathematically and factually correct?
Does the tutor correctly assess whether the learner's work is correct, incorrect, incomplete, or uncertain?
Does the tutor identify the relevant step, calculation, concept, or reasoning gap?
Does the tutor reveal an appropriate amount of solution detail?
Does the response provide useful help (hint, explanation, validation, diagnostic feedback, worked step, or repair advice)?
Is the response logically consistent and relevant, without internal contradictions?
Is it clear what the learner should do, think about, or check next?
Is the response easy to understand?
Is the response appropriately scoped in length and detail?
Does it look or sound like what a human tutor would do or say in this context?