question:
You are a professional image designer, and you are now required to conduct a strict evaluation of the following design work. The work consists of two rows of images, with the top row row as the reference three-view pictures for the design task and the bottom image as the response provided by a student. The task objective is to generate a realistic 3D rendering based on the provided three-view pictures and text requirements.
The text requirement is:
"The picture provided is of a shoe with a cloth upper and a rubber sole. Please generate a 3D rendering of the item based on the three views (front view, side view, top view) and text description of the item provided. The 3D form of the item should be accurately constructed by combining the information from all angles in the three views and refining the details of the material, colour, light and shadow effects of the item. The final 3D rendering should show the complete three-dimensional appearance of the item, conform to the scale and structure provided in the three-view drawings, and be consistent with the features of the item."
Your review question is:
Logical Consistency with Input Reference: 0 points: The output 3D rendering lacks logical consistency with the input three-view sketches, showing significant discrepancies in shape or structure that contradict the references. 1 point: The output 3D rendering logically aligns with the input three-view sketches, maintaining structural coherence and faithfully representing the object's intended form.
Use this JSON schema:
Evaluation = {'score': int, 'reason': str}
Return: Evaluation


question:
You are a professional image designer, and you are now required to conduct a strict evaluation of the following design work. The work consists of two rows of images, with the top row row as the reference three-view pictures for the design task and the bottom image as the response provided by a student. The task objective is to generate a realistic 3D rendering based on the provided three-view pictures and text requirements.
The text requirement is:
"The picture provided is of a shoe with a cloth upper and a rubber sole. Please generate a 3D rendering of the item based on the three views (front view, side view, top view) and text description of the item provided. The 3D form of the item should be accurately constructed by combining the information from all angles in the three views and refining the details of the material, colour, light and shadow effects of the item. The final 3D rendering should show the complete three-dimensional appearance of the item, conform to the scale and structure provided in the three-view drawings, and be consistent with the features of the item."
Your review question is:
Completeness of Detail Representation: 0 points: The 3D rendering lacks certain intricate details or specific design elements present in the input sketches, resulting in a simplified or incomplete representation. 1 point: The 3D rendering fully captures all details and intricate features from the input sketches, providing a complete and precise depiction of the object.
Use this JSON schema:
Evaluation = {'score': int, 'reason': str}
Return: Evaluation


question:
You are a professional image designer, and you are now required to conduct a strict evaluation of the following design work. The work consists of two rows of images, with the top row row as the reference three-view pictures for the design task and the bottom image as the response provided by a student. The task objective is to generate a realistic 3D rendering based on the provided three-view pictures and text requirements.
The text requirement is:
"The picture provided is of a shoe with a cloth upper and a rubber sole. Please generate a 3D rendering of the item based on the three views (front view, side view, top view) and text description of the item provided. The 3D form of the item should be accurately constructed by combining the information from all angles in the three views and refining the details of the material, colour, light and shadow effects of the item. The final 3D rendering should show the complete three-dimensional appearance of the item, conform to the scale and structure provided in the three-view drawings, and be consistent with the features of the item."
Your review question is:
Consistency in Material and Texture Representation: 0 points: The 3D rendering fails to accurately represent materials or textures specified or implied in the input sketches, with inconsistencies that detract from realism. 1 point: The 3D rendering maintains consistent and realistic material and texture representations across all views, effectively enhancing the appearance and believability of the object.
Use this JSON schema:
Evaluation = {'score': int, 'reason': str}
Return: Evaluation


question:
You are a professional image designer, and you are now required to conduct a strict evaluation of the following design work. The work consists of two rows of images, with the top row row as the reference three-view pictures for the design task and the bottom image as the response provided by a student. The task objective is to generate a realistic 3D rendering based on the provided three-view pictures and text requirements.
The text requirement is:
"The picture provided is of a shoe with a cloth upper and a rubber sole. Please generate a 3D rendering of the item based on the three views (front view, side view, top view) and text description of the item provided. The 3D form of the item should be accurately constructed by combining the information from all angles in the three views and refining the details of the material, colour, light and shadow effects of the item. The final 3D rendering should show the complete three-dimensional appearance of the item, conform to the scale and structure provided in the three-view drawings, and be consistent with the features of the item."
Your review question is:
Adherence to Text Description Instructions: 0 points: The model-generated 3D rendering does not fulfill the specific requirements outlined in the text description, failing to incorporate directed changes or enhancements. 1 point: The model effectively incorporates and adheres to the specific instructions provided in the text description, accurately reflecting all requested modifications or features.
Use this JSON schema:
Evaluation = {'score': int, 'reason': str}
Return: Evaluation


question:
You are a professional image designer, and you are now required to conduct a strict evaluation of the following design work. The work consists of two rows of images, with the top row row as the reference three-view pictures for the design task and the bottom image as the response provided by a student. The task objective is to generate a realistic 3D rendering based on the provided three-view pictures and text requirements.
The text requirement is:
"The picture provided is of a shoe with a cloth upper and a rubber sole. Please generate a 3D rendering of the item based on the three views (front view, side view, top view) and text description of the item provided. The 3D form of the item should be accurately constructed by combining the information from all angles in the three views and refining the details of the material, colour, light and shadow effects of the item. The final 3D rendering should show the complete three-dimensional appearance of the item, conform to the scale and structure provided in the three-view drawings, and be consistent with the features of the item."
Your review question is:
Integration of Realistic Lighting and Shadows: 0 points: The 3D rendering shows unrealistic or poorly implemented lighting and shadow effects, with unnatural or inconsistent lighting that detracts from the image’s overall quality. 1 point: The lighting and shadows are realistically integrated into the rendering, creating a natural sense of depth and enhancing the three-dimensional effect in a way that complements the object’s design.
Use this JSON schema:
Evaluation = {'score': int, 'reason': str}
Return: Evaluation


question:
You are a professional image designer, and you are now required to conduct a strict evaluation of the following design work. The work consists of two rows of images, with the top row row as the reference three-view pictures for the design task and the bottom image as the response provided by a student. The task objective is to generate a realistic 3D rendering based on the provided three-view pictures and text requirements.
The text requirement is:
"The picture provided is of a shoe with a cloth upper and a rubber sole. Please generate a 3D rendering of the item based on the three views (front view, side view, top view) and text description of the item provided. The 3D form of the item should be accurately constructed by combining the information from all angles in the three views and refining the details of the material, colour, light and shadow effects of the item. The final 3D rendering should show the complete three-dimensional appearance of the item, conform to the scale and structure provided in the three-view drawings, and be consistent with the features of the item."
Your review question is:
Aesthetic Cohesion and Visual Appeal: 0 points: The 3D rendering lacks visual harmony, with elements that appear disjointed or poorly composed. The design may have awkward proportions, distracting artifacts, or an inconsistent style, resulting in a rendering that feels visually unbalanced or unpolished. 1 point: The 3D rendering demonstrates strong aesthetic cohesion, with a harmonious composition and well-balanced proportions. The style is consistent throughout, and the image has a polished, visually appealing look that aligns with professional design standards.
Use this JSON schema:
Evaluation = {'score': int, 'reason': str}
Return: Evaluation