Spaces:
Running
Running
File size: 16,178 Bytes
d70361b | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 | """Generate Accuracy_Improvement_Plan.xlsx (combined roadmap)."""
from __future__ import annotations
from pathlib import Path
from openpyxl import Workbook
from openpyxl.styles import Alignment, Border, Font, PatternFill, Side
from openpyxl.utils import get_column_letter
OUT = Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent / "docs" / "Accuracy_Improvement_Plan.xlsx"
HEADER_FILL = PatternFill("solid", fgColor="1F4E79")
HEADER_FONT = Font(color="FFFFFF", bold=True, size=11)
TITLE_FONT = Font(bold=True, size=14, color="1F4E79")
SUB_FONT = Font(bold=True, size=11)
WRAP = Alignment(wrap_text=True, vertical="top")
CENTER = Alignment(horizontal="center", vertical="center", wrap_text=True)
THIN = Side(style="thin", color="B4B4B4")
BORDER = Border(left=THIN, right=THIN, top=THIN, bottom=THIN)
PRIORITY_FILL = {
"P0": PatternFill("solid", fgColor="FCE4D6"),
"P1": PatternFill("solid", fgColor="FFF2CC"),
"P2": PatternFill("solid", fgColor="E2EFDA"),
"P3": PatternFill("solid", fgColor="F2F2F2"),
"Done": PatternFill("solid", fgColor="C6E0B4"),
}
def style_header_row(ws, row: int, ncol: int):
for c in range(1, ncol + 1):
cell = ws.cell(row=row, column=c)
cell.fill = HEADER_FILL
cell.font = HEADER_FONT
cell.alignment = CENTER
cell.border = BORDER
def write_table(ws, headers, rows, start_row=1, priority_col=None):
ncol = len(headers)
for c, h in enumerate(headers, 1):
ws.cell(row=start_row, column=c, value=h)
style_header_row(ws, start_row, ncol)
for r_idx, row in enumerate(rows, start_row + 1):
for c_idx, val in enumerate(row, 1):
cell = ws.cell(row=r_idx, column=c_idx, value=val)
cell.alignment = WRAP
cell.border = BORDER
if priority_col and c_idx == priority_col:
key = str(val).split()[0] if val else ""
if key in PRIORITY_FILL:
cell.fill = PRIORITY_FILL[key]
return start_row + len(rows) + 2
def autosize(ws, max_width=60):
for col in ws.columns:
letter = get_column_letter(col[0].column)
width = 0
for cell in col:
if cell.value:
width = max(width, min(len(str(cell.value)) + 2, max_width))
ws.column_dimensions[letter].width = max(10, width)
def build_summary(ws):
ws.title = "Summary"
ws["A1"] = "Change Detection β Accuracy Improvement Roadmap"
ws["A1"].font = TITLE_FONT
ws.merge_cells("A1:F1")
lines = [
("Recommended approach", "Hybrid: keep completed classical/infrastructure work; "
"make Delhi-labeled evaluation the single source of truth; fine-tune AdaptFormer "
"for domain transfer; calibrate fusion/thresholds against real IoU. "
"Defer extended KPCAMNet and new model training until fine-tuning results are measured."),
("Why this wins", "Prior integration (KPCA, IR-MAD, GSD, benchmark harness) improved "
"machinery and regression safety, but LEVIR-CD tiles do not represent Delhi imagery. "
"Domain mismatch remains the dominant accuracy gap. Labeled Delhi pairs + transfer "
"learning addresses the root cause; grid-search calibration is fast, measurable, and "
"complements both."),
("Non-negotiable first step", "Build a Delhi evaluation set (20β40 pairs minimum to "
"start; grow to 100β300 for fine-tuning). Without it, no improvement can be verified."),
("Highest expected payoff", "Fine-tune AdaptFormer on Delhi imagery (GPU, 1β2 weeks "
"engineering + labeling time)."),
("Explicitly deprioritize", "Siamese U-Net from scratch (needs 1000+ labeled pairs). "
"Extended KPCAMNet only if unsupervised fallback is required."),
("Target success metrics", "Delhi eval mean F1 β₯ 0.55 (phase 1 baseline target); "
"β₯ 0.65 after calibration; β₯ 0.70 after fine-tuning. Car-FP synthetic gate stays "
"F1 = 1.0 (no regression)."),
("Total timeline (estimate)", "4β6 weeks end-to-end: 1 week eval + calibration, "
"2β3 weeks labeling expansion + fine-tune, 1 week integration + validation."),
]
row = 3
for title, body in lines:
ws.cell(row=row, column=1, value=title).font = SUB_FONT
ws.cell(row=row, column=2, value=body).alignment = WRAP
ws.merge_cells(start_row=row, start_column=2, end_row=row, end_column=6)
row += 1
ws.column_dimensions["A"].width = 28
ws.column_dimensions["B"].width = 90
for r in range(3, row):
ws.row_dimensions[r].height = 42
def build_comparison(ws):
ws.title = "Approach Comparison"
headers = [
"Topic", "Prior Plan (SRCDNet/KPCAMNet/CD-Review)",
"Found Plan (Delhi-focused)", "Assessment", "Combined Decision",
]
rows = [
("Evaluation data", "LEVIR-CD sample tiles + synthetic cases",
"20β40 Delhi pairs with hand-drawn masks",
"LEVIR useful for regression; useless as Delhi proxy",
"Keep LEVIR/synthetic as CI gates; Delhi set = primary metric"),
("Domain adaptation", "Not addressed (pretrained AdaptFormer only)",
"Fine-tune AdaptFormer on Delhi (transfer learning)",
"Biggest gap for your imagery",
"P0: build fine-tuning pipeline + Delhi weights"),
("Threshold / fusion tuning", "Manual env flags + validation gates",
"Grid-search sensitivity/fusion/KPCA params on real IoU",
"Fast, no training, immediate gain",
"P0: add compare_methods.py + calibration script"),
("KPCAMNet / KPCA", "Implemented basic KPCA + polar analysis",
"Extend multi-channel KPCA (lower priority)",
"Helped Feature-Based (F1 0.12β0.32 on LEVIR); not AI-path fix",
"Keep current KPCA; extend only if unsupervised path needed (P2)"),
("IR-MAD", "Implemented channel + optional regression norm",
"Not emphasized",
"Regression norm hurt F1; channel neutral on Delhi gate",
"Keep channel opt-in; skip default regression norm"),
("GSD harmonization", "Implemented for mismatched GeoTIFF GSD",
"Not mentioned",
"Prevents false texture diffs on mixed-resolution pairs",
"Keep enabled (already done)"),
("BIT_CD ensemble", "Optional second DL model",
"Not mentioned",
"Needs weights; payoff unproven on Delhi",
"Defer until after AdaptFormer fine-tune (P3)"),
("Siamese U-Net training", "Explicitly skipped",
"Not recommended near-term",
"Agree β data-hungry",
"Skip unless 1000+ labeled pairs available"),
("Car / transient FP guard", "Synthetic parked_cars benchmark case",
"Not mentioned",
"Critical for Delhi road imagery",
"Keep as mandatory regression gate"),
]
end = write_table(ws, headers, rows, start_row=1, priority_col=None)
ws.cell(row=end, column=1, value="Verdict").font = SUB_FONT
ws.merge_cells(start_row=end, start_column=1, end_row=end, end_column=5)
ws.cell(row=end, column=1,
value="Verdict: Found plan correctly identifies the bottleneck (domain + measurement). "
"Prior plan correctly built reusable infrastructure. Combined roadmap = Delhi "
"eval first β calibrate β fine-tune β integrate.").alignment = WRAP
autosize(ws)
def build_plan(ws):
ws.title = "Implementation Plan"
headers = [
"Phase", "Priority", "Workstream", "Task", "Description",
"Depends On", "Effort", "Owner", "Deliverable", "Success Criteria", "Status",
]
rows = [
("0", "Done", "Foundation", "Benchmark harness",
"validate_detection.py: synthetic + LEVIR-CD + kappa + car-FP gate",
"β", "Done", "Eng", "scripts/validate_detection.py",
"All unit checks pass; synthetic F1 stable", "Complete"),
("0", "Done", "Foundation", "Classical channels",
"KPCA (feature path), IR-MAD (opt-in), GSD harmonization, BIT_CD scaffold",
"β", "Done", "Eng", "app/cd_models/*, detection_engine.py",
"No car-FP regression; infra ready", "Complete"),
("1", "P0", "Evaluation", "Curate Delhi image pairs",
"Select 20β40 representative before/after pairs from library (building, road, "
"open land, mixed GSD). Document pair metadata (date, GSD, zone).",
"β", "2β4 days", "Domain + Eng", "docs/delhi_eval/manifest.json",
"β₯20 pairs covering main change types", "Not started"),
("1", "P0", "Evaluation", "Create ground-truth masks",
"Hand-label binary change masks in QGIS or LabelMe (rough polygons OK). "
"One mask per pair, same resolution as detection input.",
"Curate Delhi pairs", "2β4 days", "Domain", "docs/delhi_eval/labels/*.png",
"Every pair has aligned GT mask", "Not started"),
("1", "P0", "Evaluation", "Wire Delhi eval into harness",
"Extend validate_detection.py --real to load docs/delhi_eval/; report per-pair "
"and mean IoU/F1/kappa; save comparison PNGs.",
"GT masks", "0.5 day", "Eng", "Updated validate_detection.py",
"Baseline Delhi metrics recorded", "Not started"),
("1", "P0", "Evaluation", "Record baseline report",
"Run AI-Based DL + Feature-Based + Hybrid at default settings; store metrics.json "
"as baseline for all future A/B tests.",
"Delhi eval wired", "0.5 day", "Eng", "runs/delhi_baseline/",
"Baseline F1 documented per method", "Not started"),
("2", "P0", "Calibration", "Build compare_methods.py",
"New script: sweep methods, fusion modes, sensitivity, DETECTION_* flags; "
"output ranked CSV/JSON vs Delhi GT.",
"Delhi eval", "1 day", "Eng", "scripts/compare_methods.py",
"Single command produces method leaderboard", "Not started"),
("2", "P0", "Calibration", "Grid-search fusion thresholds",
"Search smart_union floors, hysteresis high/low, classical percentile q, "
"DL threshold, KPCA on/off for score map.",
"compare_methods.py", "1β2 days", "Eng", "runs/calibration/best_params.json",
"Measurable F1 lift β₯5% vs baseline", "Not started"),
("2", "P0", "Calibration", "Promote winning defaults",
"Apply calibrated params as new defaults only where Delhi F1 improves and "
"car-FP gate unchanged.",
"Grid-search", "0.5 day", "Eng", "detection_config.py / constants",
"Delhi mean F1 up; parked_cars F1=1.0", "Not started"),
("3", "P1", "Transfer learning", "Expand labeled set for training",
"Grow Delhi labels to 100β300 pairs (semi-automated pre-label + human fix). "
"Split train/val/test (70/15/15).",
"Initial 20β40 pairs", "1β2 weeks", "Domain", "data/delhi_cd/train|val|test",
"β₯100 train pairs with masks", "Not started"),
("3", "P1", "Transfer learning", "Fine-tuning script",
"scripts/finetune_adaptformer.py: load HF checkpoint, train on Delhi tiles, "
"early-stop on val F1, export best weights.",
"Expanded labels", "2β3 days", "Eng", "scripts/finetune_adaptformer.py",
"Reproducible train run from CLI", "Not started"),
("3", "P1", "Transfer learning", "GPU training run",
"Rent cloud GPU (A10/T4); train 20β50 epochs on 256px crops; log metrics.",
"Fine-tuning script", "4β8 hours GPU", "Eng", "models/adaptformer_delhi/",
"Val F1 beats pretrained on Delhi", "Not started"),
("3", "P1", "Transfer learning", "Integrate Delhi weights",
"model_inference.py: load local fine-tuned weights when present "
"(ADAPTFORMER_WEIGHTS env); fallback to HF LEVIR model.",
"GPU run", "1 day", "Eng", "app/model_inference.py",
"App uses Delhi model by default locally", "Not started"),
("4", "P2", "Optional DL", "BIT_CD ensemble A/B",
"Only if fine-tuned AdaptFormer still misses specific change types; "
"benchmark ensemble on Delhi eval before enabling.",
"Phase 3 complete", "2 days", "Eng", "DETECTION_ENSEMBLE gate",
"Delhi F1 gain β₯2% vs fine-tuned alone", "Deferred"),
("4", "P2", "Optional classical", "Extended KPCAMNet",
"Multi-channel stacked KPCA, more components, domain-specific patch sizes. "
"For unsupervised / no-GPU fallback only.",
"Phase 2 complete", "3β5 days", "Eng", "app/cd_models/kpca_features.py",
"Feature-Based Delhi F1 improves; AI path unaffected", "Deferred"),
("5", "P3", "Not planned", "Siamese U-Net from scratch",
"Requires 1000+ labeled pairs; unlikely to beat fine-tuned AdaptFormer.",
"β", "β", "β", "β", "Skip unless data scale changes", "Skipped"),
("6", "P1", "Production", "Re-run full validation gates",
"Delhi eval + synthetic + car-FP + LEVIR regression after each promoted change.",
"Phases 2β3", "0.5 day", "Eng", "runs/final_validation/",
"All gates pass; metrics in README/docs", "Not started"),
("6", "P1", "Production", "Update docs & .env.example",
"Document Delhi eval workflow, fine-tuned weights path, calibration commands.",
"Validation", "0.5 day", "Eng", "DEV_SETUP.md, .env.example",
"Team can reproduce benchmark end-to-end", "Not started"),
]
write_table(ws, headers, rows, start_row=1, priority_col=2)
autosize(ws)
def build_timeline(ws):
ws.title = "Timeline"
headers = ["Week", "Focus", "Key outputs", "Gate / decision point"]
rows = [
("Week 1", "Delhi eval set + baseline",
"20β40 labeled pairs; baseline metrics; compare_methods.py started",
"Go/no-go: enough pairs to measure (β₯20)"),
("Week 2", "Calibration",
"Grid-search complete; promoted defaults; compare_methods leaderboard",
"Go/no-go: β₯5% F1 lift or proceed to fine-tune anyway"),
("Week 2β4", "Label expansion + fine-tune",
"100β300 pairs; GPU training; Delhi AdaptFormer weights",
"Go/no-go: val F1 beats pretrained"),
("Week 4β5", "Integration + validation",
"App loads Delhi weights; final gates; documentation",
"Release calibrated + fine-tuned pipeline"),
("Week 5+ (optional)", "KPCAMNet / BIT_CD",
"Only if fine-tuned model still insufficient",
"Each optional item needs Delhi F1 proof"),
]
write_table(ws, headers, rows)
autosize(ws)
def build_risks(ws):
ws.title = "Risks & Dependencies"
headers = ["Risk", "Impact", "Mitigation", "Owner"]
rows = [
("Insufficient labeled Delhi data", "Fine-tune underperforms",
"Start with 20β40 for calibration; grow to 100+ before GPU spend",
"Domain team"),
("Label inconsistency (rough polygons)", "Noisy F1, wrong tuning",
"Labeling guide; double-review 10% of masks; focus on building/road changes",
"Domain team"),
("CPU-only inference too slow", "Poor UX on large GeoTIFFs",
"Keep 4096 cap; optional DETECTION_TTA=off; queue jobs with progress",
"Eng"),
("GPU cost / access", "Blocks fine-tuning",
"Single 4β8h cloud session; small tile dataset sufficient",
"Eng"),
("Over-tuning on small eval set", "Overfits calibration",
"Hold out 20% test pairs never used in grid-search",
"Eng"),
("Car false positives return", "User trust loss",
"Mandatory parked_cars synthetic gate before any default change",
"Eng"),
]
write_table(ws, headers, rows)
autosize(ws)
def main():
OUT.parent.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)
wb = Workbook()
build_summary(wb.active)
build_comparison(wb.create_sheet())
build_plan(wb.create_sheet())
build_timeline(wb.create_sheet())
build_risks(wb.create_sheet())
wb.save(OUT)
print(f"Wrote {OUT}")
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()
|