{ "query_id": 1, "question": "Which viruses may not cause prolonged inflammation due to strong induction of antiviral clearance?", "prompt": "### ROLE\nYou are a Fact-Checking and Citation Specialist. Your task is to perform a rigorous audit of a response against provided documents to determine its accuracy, relevance, and level of support.\n\n### TASK OVERVIEW\n1. **Analyze Documents**: Review the provided documents and identify information relevant to the user's question.\n2. **Evaluate Response**: Review the provided answer sentence-by-sentence.\n3. **Verify Support**: Map each answer sentence to specific supporting sentences in the documents.\n4. **Identify Utilization**: Determine which document sentences were actually used (directly or implicitly) to form the answer.\n\n### INPUT DATA\n**Documents (Split into Sentences with Keys):**\n'''\n0a. Title: Respiratory Viral Infections in Exacerbation of Chronic Airway Inflammatory Diseases: Novel Mechanisms and Insights From the Upper Airway Epithelium\nPassage: On the other end of the spectrum, viruses that induce strong type 1 inflammation and cell death such as IFV and certain CoV , may not cause prolonged inflammation due to strong induction of antiviral clearance.\n1a. Title: Respiratory Viral Infections in Exacerbation of Chronic Airway Inflammatory Diseases: Novel Mechanisms and Insights From the Upper Airway Epithelium\nPassage: On the other end of the spectrum, viruses that induce strong type 1 inflammation and cell death such as IFV and certain CoV , may not cause prolonged inflammation due to strong induction of antiviral clearance.\n2a. Title: Respiratory Viral Infections in Exacerbation of Chronic Airway Inflammatory Diseases: Novel Mechanisms and Insights From the Upper Airway Epithelium\nPassage: On the other end of the spectrum, viruses that induce strong type 1 inflammation and cell death such as IFV and certain CoV , may not cause prolonged inflammation due to strong induction of antiviral clearance.\n3a. modifies the viral resistance of epithelial cells.\n3b. Hence, this may indicate that infections such as RV and RSV that weakly induce antiviral responses may result in an altered inflammatory state contributing to further viral persistence and exacerbation of chronic airway inflammatory diseases .\n4a. Title: Host susceptibility to severe influenza A virus infection\nPassage: Susceptible hosts may have impaired intracellular controls of viral replication , defective interferon responses , or defects in cell-mediated immunity with increased baseline levels of systemic inflammation .\n4b. In the context of any of these susceptibility mechanisms, failure to clear the virus is an expected consequence, indicating that a full course of effective antiviral therapy is likely to benefit this population.\n'''\n\n**The Original Question:**\n'''\nWhich viruses may not cause prolonged inflammation due to strong induction of antiviral clearance?\n'''\n\n**The Answer to Evaluate (Split into Sentences with Keys):**\n'''\na. IFV (Influenza Virus) and certain CoV (Coronaviruses) may not cause prolonged inflammation due to strong induction of antiviral clearance.\n'''\n\n### OUTPUT REQUIREMENTS\nYou must respond with a valid JSON object. \n**Constraints:**\n- Do NOT include any preamble or postamble (e.g., \"Here is the analysis...\").\n- Do NOT wrap the JSON in markdown code blocks (e.g., no ```json).\n- Use proper escaping for quotes and newlines within JSON strings.\n\n### JSON SCHEMA\n{\n \"relevance_explanation\": \"A step-by-step breakdown of document information and its utility for the question.\",\n \"all_relevant_sentence_keys\": [\"List of doc keys pertinent to the question, regardless of use in answer\"],\n \"overall_supported_explanation\": \"Claim-by-claim assessment of the response's accuracy before a final conclusion.\",\n \"overall_supported\": boolean,\n \"sentence_support_information\": [\n {\n \"response_sentence_key\": \"string\",\n \"explanation\": \"Why the sentence is or is not supported.\",\n \"supporting_sentence_keys\": [\"doc_keys\", \"OR: 'supported_without_sentence', 'general', 'well_known_fact', 'numerical_reasoning'\"],\n \"fully_supported\": boolean\n }\n ],\n \"all_utilized_sentence_keys\": [\"List of doc keys actually used to construct the answer\"]\n}", "llm_response": "```json\n{\n \"relevance_explanation\": \"The documents provided discuss the role of viral infections in exacerbating chronic airway inflammatory diseases and the mechanisms behind the immune response to different viruses. Document sentences 0a, 1a, and 2a directly address the question by mentioning that viruses like IFV and certain CoV may not cause prolonged inflammation due to strong induction of antiviral clearance.\",\n \"all_relevant_sentence_keys\": [\"0a\", \"1a\", \"2a\"],\n \"overall_supported_explanation\": \"The answer is directly supported by the information in the documents. The statement 'IFV (Influenza Virus) and certain CoV (Coronaviruses) may not cause prolonged inflammation due to strong induction of antiviral clearance' is a direct reflection of the content in documents 0a, 1a, and 2a.\",\n \"overall_supported\": true,\n \"sentence_support_information\": [\n {\n \"response_sentence_key\": \"a\",\n \"explanation\": \"The sentence is supported because it directly reflects the information given in documents 0a, 1a, and 2a, which all state that viruses like IFV and certain CoV may not cause prolonged inflammation due to strong induction of antiviral clearance.\",\n \"supporting_sentence_keys\": [\"0a\", \"1a\", \"2a\"],\n \"fully_supported\": true\n }\n ],\n \"all_utilized_sentence_keys\": [\"0a\", \"1a\", \"2a\"]\n}\n```", "metrics": { "context_relevance": 0.15, "context_utilization": 1.0, "completeness": 1.0, "adherence": 1.0, "average": 0.7875, "overall_supported": true, "fully_supported_sentences": 1, "partially_supported_sentences": 0, "unsupported_sentences": 0 } }