oncodsl / app /viewer.py
govindbalki's picture
Upload folder using huggingface_hub
0fff343 verified
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
62.2 kB
"""OncoDSL sanity viewer.
Run with:
streamlit run app/viewer.py
Two top-level tabs (Glossary expander sits above both, available everywhere):
- **Dataset** β€” the five sanity panels: cohort overview, MSI counts, TMB-vs-MSI
histogram (the load-bearing sanity check), stage/age/missing fields, and a
small expression-matrix peek.
- **Hypothesis 1** β€” verification of the H1 program on the named matrix: a
short intro, the DSL reference (nouns + verbs), the composition diagram,
and the H1 outputs (conclusion β†’ score distributions β†’ Effect β†’ Fit).
Presentation (palette, fonts, chart theme) lives in app/theme.py and
.streamlit/config.toml. Importing `theme` registers and enables the Altair theme
used by every chart in this file.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import os
import sys
from pathlib import Path
import altair as alt
import numpy as np
import pandas as pd
import requests
import streamlit as st
# Allow `streamlit run app/viewer.py` from the repo root without installing the
# package: prepend the repo root to sys.path so `import data_pipeline` works.
REPO_ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent
if str(REPO_ROOT) not in sys.path:
sys.path.insert(0, str(REPO_ROOT))
from data_pipeline import schema # noqa: E402
from app import theme # noqa: E402 β€” registers the "oncodsl" Altair theme on import.
from airgap import anonymise, reveal # noqa: E402
from validate.h1 import IMMUNE_GENES, MMR_GENES, run_h1, usable_msi_cohort # noqa: E402
from dsl import Apply, Load # noqa: E402
CHART_HEIGHT = 300
st.set_page_config(page_title="OncoDSL β€” TCGA CRC sanity viewer", layout="wide")
# --- data loading -----------------------------------------------------------
@st.cache_data(show_spinner=False)
def load_clinical() -> pd.DataFrame | None:
p = schema.PROCESSED_DIR / "clinical.parquet"
if not p.exists():
return None
return pd.read_parquet(p)
@st.cache_data(show_spinner=False)
def load_expression_shape_and_sample() -> tuple[tuple[int, int], pd.DataFrame] | None:
p = schema.PROCESSED_DIR / "expression.parquet"
if not p.exists():
return None
df = pd.read_parquet(p)
sample = df.iloc[:20, :10]
return df.shape, sample
@st.cache_resource(show_spinner=False)
def _h1_result():
"""Run the full H1 program against the processed cohort."""
return run_h1()
@st.cache_data(show_spinner=False)
def _airgap_demo() -> tuple[pd.DataFrame, list[str], list[str]] | None:
"""Show the anonymised matrix head + reveal() round-trip."""
p = schema.PROCESSED_DIR / "expression.parquet"
if not p.exists():
return None
cohort = Load("processed")
anonymised = anonymise(cohort.expression)
head = anonymised.iloc[:5, :8]
revealed = reveal(list(head.columns))
return head, list(head.columns), revealed
def usable_mask(clinical: pd.DataFrame) -> pd.Series:
return (
clinical["msi_status"].isin(["MSI-H", "MSS"])
& clinical["has_expression"]
& (clinical["stage"] != "NA")
& clinical["age"].notna()
)
# --- glossary ---------------------------------------------------------------
def _glossary_md() -> str:
hi = schema.MSI_SENSOR_HIGH
lo = schema.MSI_SENSOR_LOW
return (
"- **TCGA** β€” The Cancer Genome Atlas: a large public dataset of tumour genetics.\n"
"- **Adenocarcinoma** β€” cancer of gland-forming cells (the usual colorectal type).\n"
"- **COAD** β€” Colon Adenocarcinoma (cancer of the colon).\n"
"- **READ** β€” Rectum Adenocarcinoma (cancer of the rectum).\n"
"- **MACR** β€” Mucinous Adenocarcinoma of the Colon and Rectum: a mucinous tissue "
"SUBTYPE that can be colon or rectum (so this field is tumour TYPE, not pure "
"anatomical site).\n"
"- **MSI** β€” Microsatellite Instability: instability in short repeating DNA "
"stretches, caused by a failed DNA \"spell-checker\" (mismatch repair).\n"
"- **MSI-H (MSI-High)** β€” many unstable microsatellites; broken repair; high "
"mutation load.\n"
"- **MSS (Microsatellite Stable)** β€” repair working; a clean, stable genome.\n"
"- **MSI-Indeterminate** β€” between the thresholds; not clearly classifiable.\n"
"- **NA** β€” no MSI value available.\n"
f"- **MSIsensor score** β€” a computed measure of how many microsatellites differ "
f"between the tumour and the patient's own normal DNA; higher = more unstable. "
f"This viewer's labels use: **β‰₯ {hi} β†’ MSI-H**, **< {lo} β†’ MSS**, "
f"**between {lo} and {hi} β†’ Indeterminate** (thresholds read from the data layer).\n"
"- **TMB** β€” Tumour Mutational Burden: roughly, the number of mutations in the "
"tumour. MSI-H tumours have high TMB (the key sanity check).\n"
"- **Stage** β€” how far the cancer has spread (I–IV).\n"
"- **RSEM** β€” the method used to turn raw RNA-sequencing reads into the "
"per-gene expression numbers shown here. The values are relative (good "
"for comparing across patients), not absolute counts.\n"
"\n"
"**Biology you'll meet in later steps**\n"
"- **MMR (mismatch repair)** β€” the DNA spell-checker; genes MLH1, MSH2, MSH6, "
"PMS2. dMMR = broken, pMMR = working.\n"
"- **CD8A, GZMA, PRF1** β€” markers that \"killer\" T-cells are attacking the "
"tumour.\n"
"- **PD-L1 / CD274** β€” a \"shield\" protein tumours use to switch off the "
"immune attack.\n"
"- **Checkpoint inhibitor (anti-PD-1)** β€” a drug that removes the shield so "
"the immune system can attack.\n"
)
# --- main -------------------------------------------------------------------
_EXPANDER_CSS = """
<style>
/* Streamlit 1.58 expander testids verified against compiled bundle:
stExpander (container) / stExpanderDetails (body) / stExpanderIcon (chevron).
We do NOT style stExpanderIcon β€” keep the native chevron visible. */
[data-testid="stExpander"] {
margin-top: 0.4rem;
}
[data-testid="stExpander"] details {
border: 1px solid #ECEAE4;
border-radius: 8px;
background-color: #FCFBF8;
}
[data-testid="stExpander"] summary {
color: #5A6670;
font-size: 0.9rem;
font-weight: 500;
}
</style>
"""
def main() -> None:
st.markdown(_EXPANDER_CSS, unsafe_allow_html=True)
st.title("OncoDSL β€” TCGA CRC sanity viewer")
st.caption(
f"Source: cBioPortal study `{schema.STUDY}` "
f"(TCGA Colorectal Adenocarcinoma, PanCancer Atlas)."
)
# Glossary sits ABOVE the tabs so it's available everywhere.
with st.expander("Glossary β€” plain-language key", expanded=False):
st.markdown(_glossary_md())
clinical = load_clinical()
expr_loaded = load_expression_shape_and_sample()
if clinical is None or expr_loaded is None:
st.error(
"Processed data not found. Run from the repo root:\n\n"
"```\n"
"python -m data_pipeline.download\n"
"python -m data_pipeline.build\n"
"```"
)
return
tab_dataset, tab_h1, tab_h2 = st.tabs(
["Dataset", "Hypothesis 1", "Hypothesis 2"]
)
with tab_dataset:
_section_dataset(clinical, expr_loaded)
with tab_h1:
_section_h1_intro()
st.divider()
_section_dsl()
st.divider()
_section_h1_walkthrough()
st.divider()
_section_h1()
st.divider()
_section_airgap_demo()
with tab_h2:
_section_h2()
def _section_dataset(clinical: pd.DataFrame, expr_loaded) -> None:
(n_genes, n_expr_samples), expr_sample = expr_loaded
# ----- Panel 1: dataset overview -----
st.header("1. Dataset overview")
st.caption(
"How big the cohort is, and how many samples are usable for downstream analysis."
)
n_total = len(clinical)
n_coad = int((clinical["site"] == "COAD").sum())
n_read = int((clinical["site"] == "READ").sum())
n_macr = int((clinical["site"] == "MACR").sum())
usable = usable_mask(clinical)
n_usable = int(usable.sum())
c1, c2, c3, c4, c5 = st.columns(5)
c1.metric("Total samples", n_total)
c2.metric(
"COAD", n_coad,
help="Colon Adenocarcinoma β€” cancer of the colon.",
)
c3.metric(
"READ", n_read,
help="Rectum Adenocarcinoma β€” cancer of the rectum.",
)
c4.metric(
"MACR", n_macr,
help="Mucinous Adenocarcinoma of the Colon and Rectum β€” a mucinous tissue "
"subtype that can be colon or rectum.",
)
c5.metric(
"Usable cohort", n_usable,
help="Samples with an MSI label in {MSI-H, MSS} AND expression AND non-missing "
"stage AND non-missing age β€” the rows downstream analysis can use.",
)
st.caption(
f"Genes in expression matrix: **{n_genes}** Β· expression samples: "
f"**{n_expr_samples}** Β· MSI label derived from MSIsensor "
f"(β‰₯{schema.MSI_SENSOR_HIGH} β†’ MSI-H, <{schema.MSI_SENSOR_LOW} β†’ MSS, "
"between β†’ Indeterminate β€” cBioPortal does not ship a clean MSI-H/MSS column)."
)
with st.expander("How to read this", expanded=False):
st.markdown(
"- This is the whole colorectal cohort (colon + rectum + a mucinous "
"subtype), pooled on purpose β€” more data helps when samples are scarce.\n"
"- READ (155) is the rectal slice; we hold rectum back for validation later.\n"
"- MACR are mucinous tumours that can be colon or rectum, so they're "
"counted separately."
)
st.divider()
# ----- Panel 2: MSI counts -----
st.header("2. MSI status counts")
st.caption(
"How many have a broken DNA spell-checker (MSI-H) vs a working one (MSS)."
)
overall = (
clinical["msi_status"]
.value_counts()
.reindex(theme.MSI_ORDER, fill_value=0)
.rename_axis("msi_status")
.reset_index(name="count")
)
by_site = (
clinical.groupby(["site", "msi_status"]).size().reset_index(name="count")
)
left, right = st.columns(2)
with left:
st.subheader("Overall")
st.altair_chart(
alt.Chart(overall)
.mark_bar()
.encode(
x=alt.X("msi_status:N", sort=theme.MSI_ORDER, title="MSI status"),
y=alt.Y("count:Q", title="samples"),
color=alt.Color(
"msi_status:N",
sort=theme.MSI_ORDER,
scale=theme.msi_color_scale(),
legend=None,
),
tooltip=["msi_status", "count"],
)
.properties(height=CHART_HEIGHT),
width="stretch",
)
with right:
st.subheader("By tumour type")
st.caption(
"COAD = colon, READ = rectum, MACR = mucinous subtype (colon or rectum)."
)
st.altair_chart(
alt.Chart(by_site)
.mark_bar()
.encode(
x=alt.X("site:N", title="tumour type"),
y=alt.Y("count:Q", stack="zero", title="samples"),
color=alt.Color(
"msi_status:N",
sort=theme.MSI_ORDER,
scale=theme.msi_color_scale(),
legend=alt.Legend(title="MSI status", orient="right"),
),
order=alt.Order(
"msi_status_order:Q", sort="ascending",
),
tooltip=["site", "msi_status", "count"],
)
.transform_calculate(
msi_status_order=(
"indexof(['" + "','".join(theme.MSI_ORDER) + "'], datum.msi_status)"
)
)
.properties(height=CHART_HEIGHT),
width="stretch",
)
with st.expander("How to read this", expanded=False):
thresholds = (
f"β‰₯ {schema.MSI_SENSOR_HIGH} β†’ MSI-H, < {schema.MSI_SENSOR_LOW} β†’ MSS, "
f"between β†’ Indeterminate"
)
st.markdown(
"- All these are colorectal cancers. MSI-H vs MSS is a subtype, not "
"cancer-vs-no-cancer.\n"
"- MSS (the majority, ~85%) = the MMR \"spell-checker\" is working: "
"stable repeats, relatively few mutations β€” still cancer, driven by "
"other routes.\n"
"- MSI-H = spell-checker broken: unstable repeats, many mutations.\n"
"- These labels come from the MSIsensor score (instability measured "
"directly in the DNA repeats), NOT from the MMR genes' expression β€” "
"that independence is what makes a later rediscovery meaningful.\n"
f"- The labels are our interpretation of that score: **{thresholds}** "
"(thresholds read from the data layer)."
)
st.divider()
# ----- Panel 2Β½: the biology in one picture -----
_section_biology_picture()
st.divider()
# ----- Panel 3: TMB vs MSI β€” the load-bearing sanity check -----
st.header("3. TMB vs MSI (sanity check)")
st.caption(
"Broken-repair (MSI-H) tumours should carry far more mutations β€” they should "
"sit to the right."
)
tmb_df = clinical.loc[
clinical["msi_status"].isin(["MSI-H", "MSS"]) & clinical["tmb"].notna(),
["msi_status", "tmb"],
].copy()
# TMB is heavy-tailed; log1p the x axis so the MSI-H tail is readable.
tmb_df["tmb_log1p"] = np.log1p(tmb_df["tmb"])
hist = (
alt.Chart(tmb_df)
.mark_bar(opacity=0.85)
.encode(
x=alt.X(
"tmb_log1p:Q",
bin=alt.Bin(maxbins=40),
title="log1p(TMB nonsynonymous)",
),
y=alt.Y("count():Q", stack=None, title="samples"),
color=alt.Color(
"msi_status:N",
sort=theme.MSI_ORDER,
scale=theme.msi_color_scale(include_na=False),
legend=alt.Legend(title="MSI status", orient="right"),
),
tooltip=["msi_status", "count()"],
)
.properties(height=CHART_HEIGHT)
)
st.altair_chart(hist, width="stretch")
medians = tmb_df.groupby("msi_status")["tmb"].median().to_dict()
st.caption(
f"Median TMB (nonsynonymous) β€” MSI-H: **{medians.get('MSI-H', float('nan')):.2f}**, "
f"MSS: **{medians.get('MSS', float('nan')):.2f}**. "
"If MSI-H median isn't markedly higher than MSS, something is wrong upstream."
)
with st.expander("How to read this", expanded=False):
st.markdown(
"- The x-axis is a log mutation count; to translate back, "
"mutations β‰ˆ e^x βˆ’ 1.\n"
"- MSI-H tumours sit to the right (hypermutated); MSS to the left "
"(quiet) β€” that clean separation is the sanity check that data, "
"labels and counts are wired up correctly.\n"
"- Minor exception: a few MSS tumours with a broken POLE polymerase "
"are also hypermutated."
)
st.divider()
# ----- Panel 4: stage / age / missing -----
st.header("4. Stage, age, and missing-field counts")
st.caption(
"Stage = how far the cancer has spread (I–IV); age at diagnosis; and where "
"fields are missing across the cohort. Bars are split by MSI status so we "
"can eyeball confounding."
)
# Restrict to MSI-H vs MSS only for the confounder views.
h_vs_s = clinical[clinical["msi_status"].isin(["MSI-H", "MSS"])].copy()
left, mid, right = st.columns([1, 1, 1])
with left:
st.subheader("Stage β€” proportion MSI-H")
stage_order = ["I", "II", "III", "IV", "NA"]
grouped = h_vs_s.groupby("stage")["msi_status"]
stage_df = pd.DataFrame({
"stage": list(grouped.groups.keys()),
"n": grouped.size().values,
"n_msi_h": grouped.apply(lambda s: int((s == "MSI-H").sum())).values,
})
stage_df["pct_msi_h"] = stage_df["n_msi_h"] / stage_df["n"]
stage_df = (
stage_df.set_index("stage")
.reindex(stage_order)
.reset_index()
.fillna({"n": 0, "n_msi_h": 0, "pct_msi_h": 0})
)
st.altair_chart(
alt.Chart(stage_df)
.mark_bar(color=theme.MSI_COLORS["MSI-H"])
.encode(
x=alt.X("stage:N", sort=stage_order, title="stage"),
y=alt.Y(
"pct_msi_h:Q",
title="% MSI-H",
axis=alt.Axis(format="%"),
scale=alt.Scale(domain=[0, 1]),
),
tooltip=[
alt.Tooltip("stage:N"),
alt.Tooltip("n:Q", title="n (MSI-H + MSS)"),
alt.Tooltip("n_msi_h:Q", title="n MSI-H"),
alt.Tooltip("pct_msi_h:Q", title="% MSI-H", format=".1%"),
],
)
.properties(height=CHART_HEIGHT),
width="stretch",
)
with mid:
st.subheader("Age β€” MSI-H vs MSS (density)")
age_df = h_vs_s.loc[h_vs_s["age"].notna(), ["age", "msi_status"]]
age_min = float(age_df["age"].min())
age_max = float(age_df["age"].max())
st.altair_chart(
alt.Chart(age_df)
.transform_density(
"age",
as_=["age", "density"],
groupby=["msi_status"],
extent=[age_min, age_max],
steps=80,
)
.mark_area(opacity=0.8)
.encode(
x=alt.X("age:Q", title="age at diagnosis"),
y=alt.Y("density:Q", title="density", stack=None),
color=alt.Color(
"msi_status:N",
sort=theme.MSI_ORDER,
scale=theme.msi_color_scale(include_na=False),
legend=alt.Legend(title="MSI status", orient="right"),
),
tooltip=[
alt.Tooltip("msi_status:N"),
alt.Tooltip("age:Q", format=".1f"),
alt.Tooltip("density:Q", format=".3f"),
],
)
.properties(height=CHART_HEIGHT),
width="stretch",
)
with right:
st.subheader("Missing per field")
st.caption(
"For each field, how many samples lack a value β€” this is what trims the "
"full cohort down to the usable set. Small numbers here are normal."
)
missing = pd.DataFrame(
{
"field": [
"msi_status (NA)",
"msi_status (Indeterm.)",
"tmb",
"age",
"stage (NA)",
"sex (blank)",
"os_event",
"os_months",
"no expression",
],
"missing": [
int((clinical["msi_status"] == "NA").sum()),
int((clinical["msi_status"] == "MSI-Indeterminate").sum()),
int(clinical["tmb"].isna().sum()),
int(clinical["age"].isna().sum()),
int((clinical["stage"] == "NA").sum()),
int(clinical["sex"].isna().sum()
+ (clinical["sex"].astype(str) == "").sum()),
int(clinical["os_event"].isna().sum()),
int(clinical["os_months"].isna().sum()),
int((~clinical["has_expression"]).sum()),
],
}
)
st.dataframe(missing, hide_index=True, width="stretch")
with st.expander("How to read this", expanded=False):
st.markdown(
"**Stage and age**\n"
"- Stage and age are the background factors (\"confounders\") the "
"Effect operator will hold constant.\n"
"- If MSI-H differs from MSS here (e.g. older or earlier-stage), "
"that's real confounding β€” which is exactly why we adjust for it "
"rather than trust raw correlations.\n"
"\n"
"**Missing per field**\n"
"- This is a data-quality check, not a problem β€” these are small "
"counts against the full cohort.\n"
"- **msi_status (NA)** = no MSIsensor score, so no MSI label; "
"**(Indeterm.)** = score fell between the thresholds, so it can't "
"be called MSI-H or MSS.\n"
"- **tmb** = missing mutation-burden value. This only affects the "
"TMB chart; the MSI label does not depend on TMB.\n"
"- **age / stage (NA) / sex (blank)** = missing clinical fields.\n"
"- **os_event / os_months** = survival fields (os = overall "
"survival; event = whether the patient died; months = length of "
"follow-up). Used in later steps, not now.\n"
"- **no expression** = the sample has no RNA-expression data.\n"
"- The \"usable cohort\" keeps only samples that have everything "
"the core task needs: a clear MSI label (MSI-H or MSS), expression "
"data, and the confounders (stage and age). The missing values "
"above are mostly what got dropped to reach that usable count."
)
st.divider()
# ----- Panel 5: expression sanity (small table, NOT a heatmap) -----
st.header("5. Expression matrix sanity")
st.caption(
"A small slice of the gene-by-sample expression matrix β€” enough to confirm "
"the numbers look reasonable, not a full heatmap."
)
st.write(f"Shape: **{n_genes} genes Γ— {n_expr_samples} samples** (RSEM).")
st.write(
"First 20 genes Γ— 10 samples (raw values), and per-gene summary stats "
"across those 10 samples:"
)
st.dataframe(expr_sample, width="stretch")
st.dataframe(
expr_sample.T.describe().T[["count", "mean", "std", "min", "50%", "max"]],
width="stretch",
)
with st.expander("How to read this", expanded=False):
st.markdown(
"**Raw values table**\n"
"- This is a tiny corner of the full gene-expression matrix the engine "
"will later search β€” shown only to confirm it loaded.\n"
"- Rows = genes (Hugo_Symbol). Columns = patients (TCGA-… barcodes, one "
"tumour each). Each cell = how active that gene is in that tumour (a "
"relative RNA-expression value): higher = more active, 0 = effectively off.\n"
"- Many zeros are normal β€” in any tumour a large fraction of genes are "
"simply switched off (pseudogenes and tissue-specific genes especially). "
"The well-known genes (MLH1, CD8A…) sit elsewhere in the matrix.\n"
"- The number isn't meaningful on its own; what matters is how it "
"differs across patients.\n"
"\n"
"**Per-gene summary stats table**\n"
"- Summarises each gene across the sample columns shown.\n"
"- count = samples with a value; mean = average; std = how much it "
"varies; min / max = range; 50% = median.\n"
"- A gene that barely varies (std β‰ˆ 0) can't help tell patients apart; "
"the signal lives in genes that differ across patients.\n"
"- These stats cover only the small peek shown here β€” illustrative, not "
"the full-cohort numbers."
)
# --- Dataset tab: biology in one picture -----------------------------------
# Two parallel stories side-by-side. MSI-H (warm) sits on top: broken
# spell-checker -> MMR genes off, mutations pile up, immune system attracted.
# MSS (cool) below: working spell-checker, few mutations, immune-cold; with
# a "note"-shaped reminder that MSS is still cancer, just driven by other
# mechanisms.
_BIOLOGY_DOT = """\
digraph biology {
rankdir=LR;
bgcolor="transparent";
nodesep=0.45;
ranksep=0.9;
splines=spline;
fontname="Helvetica";
node [shape=box, style="rounded,filled", penwidth=1.1,
fontname="Helvetica", fontcolor="#23303A", fontsize=12,
margin="0.22,0.14", color="#3A6B7E", fillcolor="#F4F2EE"];
edge [color="#C2CACF", penwidth=1.3, arrowsize=0.7,
fontname="Helvetica", fontsize=11, fontcolor="#5A6670"];
msih [label="MSI-H\\nbroken spell-checker (dMMR)",
fillcolor="#FBEFE2", color="#BC6B2E"];
msih_mmr [label="MMR genes LOW\\nMLH1 Β· MSH2 Β· MSH6 Β· PMS2"];
msih_mut [label="mutations pile up\\n→ neoantigens"];
msih_imm [label="immune markers HIGH\\nCD8A Β· GZMA Β· PRF1"];
msih -> msih_mmr [label="switched off"];
msih -> msih_mut;
msih_mut -> msih_imm [label="immune-hot"];
mss [label="MSS\\nworking spell-checker",
fillcolor="#EAF0F2", color="#3A6B7E"];
mss_mmr [label="MMR genes normal / HIGH"];
mss_mut [label="few mutations\\n(stable genome)"];
mss_imm [label="immune markers LOW"];
mss_other [label="cancer driven by OTHER\\nmechanisms (not broken MMR)",
shape=note, fillcolor="#EFEFEA", color="#9AA0A6"];
mss -> mss_mmr [label="active"];
mss -> mss_mut;
mss_mut -> mss_imm [label="immune-cold"];
mss -> mss_other;
}
"""
def _section_biology_picture() -> None:
st.header("The biology in one picture")
st.caption(
"The whole story: the spell-checker's state drives both the MMR-gene "
"activity we measure and (via mutations) the immune response."
)
st.graphviz_chart(_BIOLOGY_DOT, width="stretch")
st.caption(
"MMR-gene activity is our readout of the spell-checker β€” low activity "
"β‰ˆ broken."
)
# --- Hypothesis 1 tab -------------------------------------------------------
_H1_INTRO_MD = (
"**Hypothesis 1 β€” Verification.** Before trusting the system to discover "
"anything, we check the tooling on a known answer. We hand it the established "
"MSI genes (we don't make it find them) and confirm the operators reproduce "
"the textbook biology: MSI-H tumours have low MMR-gene activity and high "
"immune activity, the MMR→immune link survives adjusting for stage and age, "
"and the two scores tell MSI-H from MSS apart. A strong result here isn't "
"a discovery β€” it's calibration. The blind discovery (Hypothesis 2) comes "
"next."
)
def _section_h1_intro() -> None:
st.markdown(_H1_INTRO_MD)
# --- DSL panel --------------------------------------------------------------
_DSL_NOUNS = [
("Cohort", "a set of patients with their data"),
("Matrix", "patients Γ— genes"),
("Vector", "one number per patient (a score)"),
("FeatureSet", "a chosen set of genes"),
("Scalar", "a single number"),
("Outcome", "the thing predicted (e.g. MSI status)"),
]
_DSL_VERBS = [
("Load", "read the cohort (expression + clinical + labels) into one shape"),
("Select", "pick a subset of the matrix's columns by their labels"),
("Reduce", "collapse the chosen columns to one score per patient (mean)"),
("Split", "partition the cohort by a per-patient predicate"),
("Associate", "observed correlation between two per-patient series"),
("Effect", "partial correlation after holding the listed confounders constant"),
("Search", "rank features by an objective and return the top-k (placeholder)"),
("Fit / Apply", "logistic regression to MSI-H vs MSS; Apply gives probabilities"),
]
_H1_PROGRAM_CODE = """\
mmr_score = Reduce(Select(M, MMR), "mean")
immune_score = Reduce(Select(M, IMMUNE), "mean")
effect = Effect(mmr_score, immune_score, adjust={stage, age})
fit = Fit((mmr_score, immune_score), msi_h_label)
"""
# Composition diagram. Operator nodes are stone-filled; the two SCORE nodes
# (MMR score, immune score) are cream "meta-concepts"; the two OUTPUT nodes
# (Effect, Fit) are cool-tinted to mark them as the program's results; the
# two "Given:" note-shaped nodes make explicit that we supply the gene panels
# in H1 (we don't make the system discover them).
_H1_DOT = """\
digraph H1 {
rankdir=LR;
bgcolor="transparent";
nodesep=0.5;
ranksep=1.0;
splines=spline;
fontname="Helvetica";
node [shape=box, style="rounded,filled", penwidth=1.2,
fontname="Helvetica", fontcolor="#23303A", fontsize=12,
margin="0.22,0.14", color="#3A6B7E", fillcolor="#F4F2EE"];
edge [color="#C2CACF", penwidth=1.3, arrowsize=0.7];
GivenMMR [label="Given: MLH1, MSH2, MSH6, PMS2",
shape=note, fillcolor="#EFEFEA", color="#9AA0A6"];
GivenIMM [label="Given: CD8A, GZMA, PRF1",
shape=note, fillcolor="#EFEFEA", color="#9AA0A6"];
M [label="Expression matrix"];
SelMMR [label="Select(MMR genes)"];
RedMMR [label="Reduce(mean)"];
MMR [label="MMR score", fillcolor="#FBEFE2", color="#BC6B2E"];
SelI [label="Select(immune genes)"];
RedI [label="Reduce(mean)"];
IMM [label="immune score", fillcolor="#FBEFE2", color="#BC6B2E"];
Eff [label="Effect(adjust: stage, age)",
fillcolor="#EAF0F2", color="#3A6B7E"];
Ft [label="Fit β†’ MSI-H probability",
fillcolor="#EAF0F2", color="#3A6B7E"];
GivenMMR -> SelMMR;
GivenIMM -> SelI;
M -> SelMMR -> RedMMR -> MMR;
M -> SelI -> RedI -> IMM;
MMR -> Eff;
IMM -> Eff;
MMR -> Ft;
IMM -> Ft;
}
"""
def _section_dsl() -> None:
st.header("The DSL")
st.caption(
"Two short labelled lists: the kinds of thing the engine works with, "
"and the operations it composes."
)
left, right = st.columns(2)
with left:
st.markdown(
"**Nouns β€” the kinds of thing**\n\n"
+ "\n".join(f"- **{n}** β€” {d}" for n, d in _DSL_NOUNS)
)
with right:
st.markdown(
"**Verbs β€” the operations**\n\n"
+ "\n".join(f"- **{v}** β€” {d}" for v, d in _DSL_VERBS)
)
st.markdown("&nbsp;") # gentle vertical breathing room
st.markdown(
"**The H1 program** β€” we supply the known genes and check the "
"operators reproduce the biology."
)
st.graphviz_chart(_H1_DOT, width="stretch")
st.markdown("**The H1 program β€” as a one-line composition**")
st.code(_H1_PROGRAM_CODE, language="python")
# --- H1 walkthrough: the operators on 6 real, held-out patients ------------
_WALKTHROUGH_N_PER_GROUP = 3
@st.cache_resource(show_spinner=False)
def _usable_cohort_for_walkthrough():
"""The same usable MSI-H-vs-MSS cohort the H1 program runs on (cached)."""
return usable_msi_cohort(Load("processed"))
@st.cache_data(show_spinner=False)
def _walkthrough_tables():
"""Build the three step tables for 3 MSI-H + 3 MSS held-out patients.
The patients are pulled from `res.fit.test_index` so their predicted
probabilities are genuinely out-of-sample (they were never seen during
fitting). Picking deterministically (the first 3 of each class in the
test set) keeps the panel stable across reloads.
"""
res = _h1_result()
cohort = _usable_cohort_for_walkthrough()
M = cohort.expression
status = res.msi_status
test_ids = list(res.fit.test_index)
msi_h = [s for s in test_ids if status.loc[s] == "MSI-H"][:_WALKTHROUGH_N_PER_GROUP]
mss = [s for s in test_ids if status.loc[s] == "MSS"][:_WALKTHROUGH_N_PER_GROUP]
chosen = msi_h + mss
mmr_vals = M.loc[chosen, MMR_GENES].round(1)
immune_vals = M.loc[chosen, IMMUNE_GENES].round(1)
mmr_score = res.mmr_score.loc[chosen].round(1)
immune_score = res.immune_score.loc[chosen].round(1)
step1 = pd.DataFrame(index=chosen)
step1.insert(0, "MSI", status.loc[chosen].values)
for g in MMR_GENES:
step1[g] = mmr_vals[g].values
step1["MMR score"] = mmr_score.values
for g in IMMUNE_GENES:
step1[g] = immune_vals[g].values
step1["Immune score"] = immune_score.values
step1.index.name = "patient"
step2 = pd.DataFrame(
{
"MSI": status.loc[chosen].values,
"MMR score": mmr_score.values,
"Immune score": immune_score.values,
},
index=chosen,
)
step2.index.name = "patient"
state6 = pd.DataFrame(
{"mmr_score": res.mmr_score.loc[chosen],
"immune_score": res.immune_score.loc[chosen]}
)
probs = Apply(res.fit, state6)
step3 = pd.DataFrame(
{
"MMR score": mmr_score.values,
"Immune score": immune_score.values,
"predicted MSI-H probability": probs.values.round(3),
"actual MSI status": status.loc[chosen].values,
},
index=chosen,
)
step3.index.name = "patient"
return step1, step2, step3
def _section_h1_walkthrough() -> None:
st.header("Working through the program on real patients")
st.markdown(
f"Here are {_WALKTHROUGH_N_PER_GROUP} MSI-H and "
f"{_WALKTHROUGH_N_PER_GROUP} MSS patients **from the held-out test "
"set** β€” the model never saw them during fitting. We follow the same "
"operators through, one step at a time."
)
res = _h1_result()
step1, step2, step3 = _walkthrough_tables()
st.subheader("Step 1 β€” Select + Reduce")
st.dataframe(step1, width="stretch")
st.markdown(
"**Select** pulls out these genes' values; **Reduce** averages them "
"into one score per patient. Notice the MSI-H patients tend to have a "
"lower MMR score and a higher immune score."
)
st.subheader("Step 2 β€” Effect")
st.dataframe(step2, width="stretch")
st.markdown(
f"**Effect** asks whether a lower MMR score actually drives a higher "
f"immune score β€” measured across ALL patients, holding stage and age "
f"constant. Here that adjusted correlation is "
f"**{res.effect.partial_corr:+.3f}**: close to zero, so the direct "
f"link between the two scores is weak."
)
st.subheader("Step 3 β€” Fit")
st.dataframe(step3, width="stretch")
st.markdown(
f"**Fit** learns to turn the two scores into a probability that a "
f"patient is MSI-H. Here are its predictions vs the truth for these "
f"held-out patients. Across all held-out patients it scores "
f"AUROC **{res.fit.auroc:.3f}**."
)
# --- H1 verification panel --------------------------------------------------
_AUROC_THRESHOLD = 0.75
_HOW_TO_READ_H1 = (
"- **Score distributions:** each curve is how a score is spread across "
"one group. We want MSI-H (amber) shifted LOW on MMR score and HIGH on "
"immune score vs MSS β€” broken repair plus an immune-hot tumour. Medians "
"are noted above each chart.\n"
" - The y-axis (density) is a smoothed, normalised histogram β€” how "
"common a score is within each group. Each curve's area sums to 1, so "
"the two groups can be compared fairly despite very different sizes "
"(MSS has far more patients than MSI-H). The number itself isn't "
"meaningful; what matters is where each curve peaks and how the shapes "
"differ.\n"
"- **Effect:** does a low MMR score drive a high immune score? "
"\"Unadjusted\" is the raw correlation; \"adjusted\" holds stage and age "
"constant. Both run βˆ’1 to +1; here both are small (near zero), so the "
"direct linear link between the two scores is weak β€” the subtype "
"separation comes through more than this single correlation.\n"
" - **Why βˆ’1 to +1:** Effect is a correlation, always between βˆ’1 and "
"+1. +1 = the two scores rise and fall together in perfect lockstep; "
"βˆ’1 = they move in perfect opposition (one up while the other goes "
"down); 0 = no linear relationship. Sign = direction, size = strength. "
"For this biology we'd expect a negative value (low MMR ↔ high immune); "
"near-zero here means that direct link is weak.\n"
"- **Fit:** we train on the two scores to predict MSI-H vs MSS, then test "
"on held-out patients. AUROC: 0.5 = chance, 1.0 = perfect. Raw accuracy "
"is hidden because always guessing \"MSS\" would already score ~86% on "
"this imbalanced cohort.\n"
" - **Why two metrics:** AUROC measures how well the scores SEPARATE "
"the two groups when ranked, at any threshold, robust to the size "
"imbalance β€” \"can the scores tell MSI-H from MSS at all?\" Balanced "
"accuracy is the average of how many MSI-H we correctly catch "
"(sensitivity) and how many MSS we correctly catch (specificity) at a "
"single yes/no cutoff β€” \"if forced to decide, how well on BOTH groups, "
"not just the majority?\" A high AUROC with a lower balanced accuracy "
"(as here) means the ranking separates well but the default cutoff "
"isn't tuned to call both classes evenly."
)
def _section_h1() -> None:
st.header("H1 verification")
res = _h1_result()
# --- (a) Conclusion block --------------------------------------------
a_pass = res.mmr_separates_correct_direction # MMR median lower in MSI-H
b_pass = res.immune_separates_correct_direction # immune median higher in MSI-H
c_pass = res.fit.auroc >= _AUROC_THRESHOLD
if a_pass and b_pass and c_pass:
st.success(
f"**Conclusion:** Hypothesis 1 is verified. The operators reproduce "
f"the known MSI biology β€” MSI-H tumours separate from MSS with "
f"AUROC **{res.fit.auroc:.3f}**, and the scores point the expected "
f"way (MMR lower, immune higher in MSI-H). The instrument is "
f"calibrated, so we can trust it for the blind discovery in "
f"Hypothesis 2. This is a tooling check, not a discovery β€” we were "
f"given the genes. Caveat: the direct MMR-score↔immune-score "
f"correlation is weak (adjusted **{res.effect.partial_corr:+.3f}**), "
f"so we rely on the overall subtype separation rather than that "
f"single link."
)
else:
lines = ["**Conclusion:** Hypothesis 1 is not fully verified β€”"]
if not a_pass:
lines.append(
f"- Check A failed: MMR median MSI-H "
f"**{res.mmr_median_msi_h:.1f}** vs MSS "
f"**{res.mmr_median_mss:.1f}** (expected MSI-H lower)."
)
if not b_pass:
lines.append(
f"- Check B failed: immune median MSI-H "
f"**{res.immune_median_msi_h:.1f}** vs MSS "
f"**{res.immune_median_mss:.1f}** (expected MSI-H higher)."
)
if not c_pass:
lines.append(
f"- Check C failed: held-out AUROC **{res.fit.auroc:.3f}** "
f"below the **{_AUROC_THRESHOLD:.2f}** threshold."
)
st.warning("\n".join(lines))
# --- (b) Score distributions -----------------------------------------
st.subheader("Score distributions, split by MSI status")
score_df = pd.concat([
pd.DataFrame({"score_name": "MMR score",
"value": res.mmr_score.values,
"msi_status": res.msi_status.values}),
pd.DataFrame({"score_name": "Immune score",
"value": res.immune_score.values,
"msi_status": res.msi_status.values}),
], ignore_index=True)
left, right = st.columns(2)
for col, score_name, summary in [
(left, "MMR score",
f"median MSI-H **{res.mmr_median_msi_h:.1f}** vs MSS **{res.mmr_median_mss:.1f}** "
f"({'lower in MSI-H βœ“' if res.mmr_separates_correct_direction else 'wrong direction'})"),
(right, "Immune score",
f"median MSI-H **{res.immune_median_msi_h:.1f}** vs MSS **{res.immune_median_mss:.1f}** "
f"({'higher in MSI-H βœ“' if res.immune_separates_correct_direction else 'wrong direction'})"),
]:
with col:
st.markdown(f"**{score_name}** β€” {summary}")
sub = score_df[score_df["score_name"] == score_name]
v_min = float(sub["value"].min())
v_max = float(sub["value"].max())
chart = (
alt.Chart(sub)
.transform_density(
"value",
as_=["value", "density"],
groupby=["msi_status"],
extent=[v_min, v_max],
steps=80,
)
.mark_area(opacity=0.8)
.encode(
x=alt.X("value:Q", title=score_name),
y=alt.Y("density:Q", title="density", stack=None),
color=alt.Color(
"msi_status:N",
sort=theme.MSI_ORDER,
scale=theme.msi_color_scale(include_na=False),
legend=alt.Legend(title="MSI status", orient="right"),
),
)
.properties(height=CHART_HEIGHT)
)
st.altair_chart(chart, width="stretch")
st.markdown(
"**Why this matters:** MSI-H tumours have a broken spell-checker, so "
"the MMR genes are less active (MMR score LOW) and the resulting "
"pile-up of mutations makes the tumour immune-hot (immune score "
"HIGH). MSS is the reverse β€” working repair, few mutations, "
"immune-cold. Seeing exactly that split here confirms our scores "
"capture the real biology; if they didn't, the tooling would be wrong."
)
# --- (c) Effect numbers ----------------------------------------------
st.markdown(
"*Step: does the MMR score causally relate to the immune score? "
"(a check on the mechanism)*"
)
st.subheader("Effect: MMR score β†’ immune score, adjusting for stage and age")
e = res.effect
e1, e2, e3 = st.columns(3)
e1.metric(
"Unadjusted pearson", f"{e.unadjusted:+.3f}",
help=(
"Plain correlation between the two scores across patients, from "
"βˆ’1 to +1. Near 0 = little linear association."
),
)
e2.metric(
"Adjusted partial corr.", f"{e.partial_corr:+.3f}",
help=(
"The same correlation after statistically holding stage and age "
"constant β€” what's left once those background factors are removed."
),
)
e3.metric(
"n used", e.n_used,
help="Patients with all required values (both scores + stage + age).",
)
st.caption(e.note)
# --- (d) Fit numbers -------------------------------------------------
st.markdown(
"*Step: can the two scores together predict MSI-H vs MSS? "
"(a check that the signal is usable)*"
)
st.subheader("Fit (MMR + immune score β†’ MSI-H) held-out performance")
f1, f2, f3, f4 = st.columns(4)
f1.metric(
"AUROC", f"{res.fit.auroc:.3f}",
help=(
"Area Under the ROC Curve: how well the model ranks an MSI-H "
"patient above an MSS one, from 0.5 (coin-flip) to 1.0 (perfect). "
"Robust to the MSI-H/MSS imbalance."
),
)
f2.metric(
"Balanced accuracy", f"{res.fit.balanced_acc:.3f}",
help=(
"Average of sensitivity (MSI-H correctly flagged) and specificity "
"(MSS correctly flagged); 0.5 = chance."
),
)
f3.metric(
"Train n", res.fit.n_train,
help="Patients used to fit the model.",
)
f4.metric(
"Test n", res.fit.n_test,
help="Held-out patients used to score it β€” never seen in training.",
)
_auroc_pct = round(res.fit.auroc * 100)
st.markdown(
f"**AUROC 0.5 = guessing, 1.0 = perfect.** "
f"**{res.fit.auroc:.3f}** means: take a random MSI-H patient and a "
f"random MSS patient β€” about **{_auroc_pct}%** of the time the model "
f"gives the MSI-H one the higher score."
)
# --- (e) How to read this -------------------------------------------
with st.expander("How to read this", expanded=False):
st.markdown(_HOW_TO_READ_H1)
# --- H2 preview: the airgap. Outside the H1 verification flow; sits at the
# bottom of the Hypothesis 1 tab as a setup for the next hypothesis. -----------
def _section_airgap_demo() -> None:
st.header("Preview β€” the airgap (setup for Hypothesis 2)")
st.markdown(
"This isn't part of Hypothesis 1 β€” here we used the known gene names "
"openly. It's a preview of the machinery that will make Hypothesis 2 "
"honest: the discovery engine is handed a matrix with gene names "
"hidden (opaque IDs), and only after it picks genes do we \"reveal\" "
"what they were β€” proving the next step rediscovered the biology "
"rather than recalling it."
)
demo = _airgap_demo()
if demo is None:
st.info("Processed expression matrix not found β€” skipping airgap demo.")
return
head, opaque_ids, revealed = demo
st.markdown("**Anonymised matrix head** (samples Γ— opaque feature IDs):")
st.dataframe(head, width="stretch")
st.markdown("**`reveal()` round-trip** β€” opaque ID β†’ real gene symbol:")
st.dataframe(
pd.DataFrame({"opaque_id": opaque_ids, "real_symbol": revealed}),
hide_index=True, width="stretch",
)
# --- Hypothesis 2 tab (reads from the FastAPI) -----------------------------
H2_API_BASE = os.getenv("H2_API_BASE", "http://localhost:8000")
_H2_AUROC_THRESHOLD = 0.75
_H2_P_THRESHOLD = 0.05
_H2_HYPOTHESIS_MD = (
"**Hypothesis 2 β€” Blind discovery.** Claim: if we hide the gene names "
"and show the engine only the numbers, it can rediscover the genes that "
"define the MSI subtype on its own β€” recovering the MMR spell-checker "
"genes (MLH1, MSH2, MSH6, PMS2) out of ~20,000, without being told them. "
"Confirmed if: (1) the program it finds separates MSI-H from MSS on "
"patients it never trained on (high AUROC), (2) that beats a chance "
"baseline (permutation test), and (3) when we reveal the genes, they "
"overlap the known MMR set. This is the real test β€” H1 only checked the "
"tooling on genes we supplied; here the engine finds them itself."
)
@st.cache_data(show_spinner=False, ttl=60)
def _h2_api_get(path: str):
r = requests.get(f"{H2_API_BASE}{path}", timeout=10)
r.raise_for_status()
return r.json()
def _h2_api_post_reveal(gene_ids: list[str]) -> list[str]:
r = requests.post(
f"{H2_API_BASE}/reveal",
json={"gene_ids": gene_ids},
timeout=10,
)
r.raise_for_status()
return r.json()["symbols"]
def _h2_card(num: int, title: str) -> "st.delta_generator.DeltaGenerator":
card = st.container(border=True)
card.caption(f"Step {num} of 5")
card.subheader(title)
return card
def _h2_program_dot(feature_sets: list[list[str]]) -> str:
"""Render a program (1 or 2 feature sets) as a graphviz DOT string."""
lines = [
"digraph p {",
' rankdir=LR;',
' bgcolor="transparent";',
' nodesep=0.5; ranksep=0.9; splines=spline;',
' fontname="Helvetica";',
' node [shape=box, style="rounded,filled", penwidth=1.2,',
' fontname="Helvetica", fontcolor="#23303A", fontsize=11,',
' margin="0.22,0.14", color="#3A6B7E", fillcolor="#F4F2EE"];',
' edge [color="#C2CACF", penwidth=1.3, arrowsize=0.7];',
' M [label="Expression matrix"];',
]
score_nodes: list[str] = []
for i, fs in enumerate(feature_sets, start=1):
head = ", ".join(fs[:3])
suffix = ", …" if len(fs) > 3 else ""
sel_label = f"Select({len(fs)} genes:\\n{head}{suffix})"
score_label = f"score {i}" if len(feature_sets) > 1 else "score"
lines += [
f' Sel{i} [label="{sel_label}"];',
f' Red{i} [label="Reduce(mean)"];',
f' Score{i} [label="{score_label}", fillcolor="#FBEFE2", color="#BC6B2E"];',
f" M -> Sel{i} -> Red{i} -> Score{i};",
]
score_nodes.append(f"Score{i}")
lines.append(
' Fit [label="Fit β†’ MSI-H probability", fillcolor="#EAF0F2", color="#3A6B7E"];'
)
for s in score_nodes:
lines.append(f" {s} -> Fit;")
lines.append("}")
return "\n".join(lines)
def _h2_show_api_error(exc: Exception) -> None:
st.error(
f"Cannot reach the H2 API at `{H2_API_BASE}`. To bring it up:\n\n"
"```bash\n"
"python -m scripts.run_h2 # run the engine once (~1-2 min)\n"
"uvicorn api.app:app --reload # then start the API\n"
"```\n\n"
f"Error: `{type(exc).__name__}: {exc}`"
)
def _section_h2() -> None:
try:
run_log = _h2_api_get("/run")
result = _h2_api_get("/result")
except Exception as exc:
_h2_show_api_error(exc)
return
_h2_step_hypothesis()
_h2_step_setup(run_log)
_h2_step_evolve(run_log)
_h2_step_result(result)
_h2_step_reveal_and_conclusion(result)
def _h2_step_hypothesis() -> None:
card = _h2_card(0, "The hypothesis")
with card:
_, mid, _ = st.columns([1, 6, 1])
with mid:
st.markdown(_H2_HYPOTHESIS_MD)
def _h2_step_setup(run_log: dict) -> None:
card = _h2_card(1, "The setup β€” why blind")
with card:
_, mid, _ = st.columns([1, 6, 1])
with mid:
run = run_log["run"]
st.markdown(
f"The cohort: **{run['n_train']} train + {run['n_test']} held-out "
f"test** patients across **{run['n_genes']:,}** anonymised "
f"feature IDs (dropped from {run.get('n_genes_input', run['n_genes']):,} "
f"to {run['n_genes']:,} after removing features with any missing "
f"value). The prefilter shortlists "
f"**{run['prefilter_N']:,}** features by |AUROC βˆ’ 0.5| computed "
"on the train split only; the GP composes within that shortlist."
)
demo = _airgap_demo()
if demo is not None:
head, _ids, _syms = demo
st.markdown("**Anonymised matrix head** (samples Γ— opaque feature IDs):")
st.dataframe(head, width="stretch")
with mid:
st.markdown(
"The genes are hidden behind meaningless IDs, and the objective "
"is computed only from MSI status β€” never from a gene name. So "
"whatever the engine finds, it found in the data, not by "
"recalling a name."
)
def _h2_step_evolve(run_log: dict) -> None:
card = _h2_card(2, "Watch it evolve")
with card:
_, mid, _ = st.columns([1, 6, 1])
with mid:
st.markdown(
"The engine starts with random small programs, scores each on "
"how well it separates MSI-H from MSS (on held-out folds), "
"keeps the best, then breeds and mutates them over generations, "
"discarding the weak β€” like selective breeding for programs."
)
generations = run_log["generations"]
max_gen = generations[-1]["generation"]
elitism = int(generations[0].get("elitism", 5))
gen = st.slider(
"Generation",
min_value=0,
max_value=max_gen,
value=max_gen,
step=1,
key="h2_evolve_gen",
)
# Fitness curve.
gens_df = pd.DataFrame({
"generation": [g["generation"] for g in generations],
"best": [g["best_fitness"] for g in generations],
"median": [g["median_fitness"] for g in generations],
})
long_df = gens_df.melt(
"generation", var_name="series", value_name="fitness",
)
fit_curve = (
alt.Chart(long_df)
.mark_line(point=True)
.encode(
x=alt.X("generation:Q", title="generation"),
y=alt.Y("fitness:Q", title="fitness (CV AUROC βˆ’ Ξ» Γ— n_genes)"),
color=alt.Color(
"series:N",
scale=alt.Scale(
domain=["best", "median"],
range=["#BC6B2E", "#6E7F8C"],
),
legend=alt.Legend(title=None, orient="top-right"),
),
tooltip=[
alt.Tooltip("generation:Q"),
alt.Tooltip("series:N"),
alt.Tooltip("fitness:Q", format=".3f"),
],
)
.properties(height=240)
)
rule = (
alt.Chart(pd.DataFrame({"generation": [gen]}))
.mark_rule(color="#BC6B2E", strokeDash=[4, 4])
.encode(x="generation:Q")
)
st.altair_chart(fit_curve + rule, width="stretch")
# Top-K candidates at the selected generation.
cand = generations[gen]["candidates"]
pop_df = pd.DataFrame([
{
"rank": i + 1,
"id": c["id"],
"n_genes": c["n_genes"],
"fitness": c["fitness"],
"first_ids": ", ".join(c["gene_ids"][:3])
+ ("…" if len(c["gene_ids"]) > 3 else ""),
}
for i, c in enumerate(cand)
])
pop_df["status"] = pop_df["rank"].apply(
lambda r: "survivor (elite)" if r <= elitism else "discarded"
)
pop_chart = (
alt.Chart(pop_df)
.mark_bar()
.encode(
y=alt.Y(
"id:N",
sort=alt.SortField("rank", order="ascending"),
title="candidate",
),
x=alt.X("fitness:Q", title="fitness"),
color=alt.Color(
"status:N",
scale=alt.Scale(
domain=["survivor (elite)", "discarded"],
range=["#3A6B7E", "#9AA0A6"],
),
legend=alt.Legend(title=None, orient="top"),
),
opacity=alt.condition(
f"datum.rank <= {elitism}",
alt.value(1.0),
alt.value(0.35),
),
tooltip=[
alt.Tooltip("rank:Q"),
alt.Tooltip("id:N"),
alt.Tooltip("n_genes:Q"),
alt.Tooltip("fitness:Q", format=".4f"),
alt.Tooltip("first_ids:N", title="first IDs"),
],
)
.properties(height=220)
)
st.markdown(
f"**Top {len(cand)} candidates at generation {gen}.** "
f"Top {elitism} (solid) survive as elites into the next generation; "
"the rest fade."
)
st.altair_chart(pop_chart, width="stretch")
best = cand[0]
st.markdown(
f"**Best of generation {gen}:** `{best['id']}` Β· "
f"fitness **{best['fitness']:.4f}** Β· {best['n_genes']} genes"
)
st.graphviz_chart(_h2_program_dot(best["feature_sets"]), width="stretch")
def _h2_step_result(result: dict) -> None:
card = _h2_card(3, "The result")
with card:
_, mid, _ = st.columns([1, 6, 1])
win = result["winning"]
base = result["baseline"]
with mid:
st.markdown(
f"The engine's pick after evolving: **{win['program_repr']}** β€” "
f"a {len(win['gene_ids'])}-gene program."
)
st.graphviz_chart(_h2_program_dot(win["feature_sets"]), width="stretch")
m1, m2, m3, m4 = st.columns(4)
m1.metric(
"Held-out AUROC", f"{win['holdout_auroc']:.3f}",
help=(
"Area Under the ROC Curve on the held-out test patients the "
"engine never trained on. 0.5 = chance, 1.0 = perfect."
),
)
m2.metric(
"Permutation p", f"{win['permutation_p']:.4f}",
help=(
"Fraction of label-shuffled null runs whose AUROC matched or "
"beat the real winner. Small = unlikely to be a fluke."
),
)
m3.metric(
"Baseline AUROC", f"{base['holdout_auroc']:.3f}",
help=(
"Deterministic top-k by univariate prefilter, then "
"Reduce(mean) + Fit. Internal sanity check the GP should match."
),
)
m4.metric(
"n_genes used", len(win["gene_ids"]),
help="Number of opaque feature IDs the winning program touches.",
)
with mid:
auroc_pct = round(win["holdout_auroc"] * 100)
st.markdown(
f"**AUROC 0.5 = guessing, 1.0 = perfect.** "
f"**{win['holdout_auroc']:.3f}** means it ranks a random MSI-H "
f"above a random MSS about **{auroc_pct}%** of the time."
)
st.markdown(
f"**Permutation p {win['permutation_p']:.4f}** β€” how often pure "
"chance matched this; small = unlikely a fluke."
)
_H2_REVEAL_KEY = "h2_revealed_symbols"
_H2_REVEAL_FOR_IDS_KEY = "h2_revealed_for_ids"
def _h2_step_reveal_and_conclusion(result: dict) -> None:
win = result["winning"]
winning_ids = list(win["gene_ids"])
card = _h2_card(4, "The reveal")
with card:
_, mid, _ = st.columns([1, 6, 1])
with mid:
st.markdown(
"We have not looked at any gene name yet. The button below "
"calls the only endpoint allowed to translate the opaque IDs "
"back β€” pressing it is the moment the airgap opens."
)
clicked = st.button("Reveal the genes", type="primary")
if clicked:
try:
symbols = _h2_api_post_reveal(winning_ids)
except Exception as exc:
_h2_show_api_error(exc)
return
st.session_state[_H2_REVEAL_KEY] = symbols
st.session_state[_H2_REVEAL_FOR_IDS_KEY] = winning_ids
revealed = st.session_state.get(_H2_REVEAL_KEY)
revealed_for = st.session_state.get(_H2_REVEAL_FOR_IDS_KEY)
if not revealed or revealed_for != winning_ids:
with mid:
st.info("Click **Reveal the genes** to open the airgap.")
return
mmr_set = set(MMR_GENES)
reveal_df = pd.DataFrame({
"opaque ID": winning_ids,
"real symbol": revealed,
"MMR": [s in mmr_set for s in revealed],
})
styled = reveal_df.style.apply(
lambda row: [
"background-color: #FBEFE2; color: #BC6B2E; font-weight: 600"
if row["MMR"] else "" for _ in row
],
axis=1,
).hide(axis="index")
st.dataframe(styled, width="stretch")
with mid:
st.markdown(
"Only now do we look at the names. These are the genes the "
"engine chose β€” blind. Any row highlighted in amber matches "
"the known MMR set."
)
recovered = [s for s in revealed if s in set(MMR_GENES)]
_h2_step_conclusion(result, recovered)
def _h2_step_conclusion(result: dict, recovered: list[str]) -> None:
card = _h2_card(5, "Conclusion")
with card:
_, mid, _ = st.columns([1, 6, 1])
with mid:
win = result["winning"]
auroc = float(win["holdout_auroc"])
p_val = float(win["permutation_p"])
k = len(recovered)
a_pass = auroc >= _H2_AUROC_THRESHOLD
b_pass = p_val < _H2_P_THRESHOLD
c_pass = k >= 1
if a_pass and b_pass and c_pass:
recovered_str = ", ".join(recovered) if recovered else "β€”"
st.success(
f"**Conclusion:** Hypothesis 2 is verified. Blind β€” with "
f"gene names hidden β€” the engine found a program "
f"separating MSI-H from MSS (held-out AUROC "
f"**{auroc:.3f}**, permutation p **{p_val:.4f}**), and on "
f"reveal it recovered **{k}** of the 4 MMR genes "
f"(**{recovered_str}**). It rediscovered the biology "
f"rather than recalling it. (Like H1, this is the "
f"mechanism, not drug response.)"
)
else:
lines = ["**Conclusion:** Hypothesis 2 is not fully verified β€”"]
if not a_pass:
lines.append(
f"- Check A failed: held-out AUROC **{auroc:.3f}** "
f"below the **{_H2_AUROC_THRESHOLD:.2f}** threshold."
)
if not b_pass:
lines.append(
f"- Check B failed: permutation p **{p_val:.4f}** "
f"not below **{_H2_P_THRESHOLD:.2f}**."
)
if not c_pass:
lines.append(
f"- Check C failed: **{k}** of the 4 MMR genes "
f"recovered (need at least 1)."
)
st.warning("\n".join(lines))
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()