Intial commit

prompts.py

@@ -40,6 +40,11 @@ Use the following guidelines:
 In each of the review points, make sure to be specific and detailed. Make specific references to Figures and Tables in the paper to support your points.
 
 Provide the review in the review format, and make sure to follow the acceptance criteria.
+
+First, within the tags <thoughts>...</thoughts>, think about what to write in the review, focusing on potential positive and negative points to make.
+Reason through which ones are the most reasonable and most important to include.
+
+Then, within the tags <output>...</output>, write the review in the review format.
 """
 
 combine_prompt = """Your job is to act as a meta-reviewer for a TMLR paper review.
@@ -56,6 +61,10 @@ Group together the points from each subsection according to the review format: `
 
 Here are all the reviews:
 ```{all_reviews_string}```
+
+First, within the tags <thoughts>...</thoughts>, think through which points are the strongest and fairest, and how to best present them in the review with clarity.
+
+Then, within the tags <output>...</output>, write the review in the review format.
 """
 
 defend_prompt = """
@@ -95,7 +104,7 @@ Here is the rebuttal of the review:
 ```{defended_paper}```
 
 Before producing the modified review, think step by step within the tags <thinking>...</thinking>.
-Then, produce the modified review in the tags, with all the sections filled out and necessary context: <review>...</review>.
+Then, produce the modified review in the tags, with all the sections filled out and necessary context: <output>...</output>.
 """
 
 
@@ -150,4 +159,7 @@ Review: ```{review}```
 Please keep the original Markdown tags, like bold (two asterisks) or linebreak. 
 After parsing the importance, remove the original importance tag. 
 Shorten the Impact Concerns to a single sentence only.
+
+First, within the tags <thoughts>...</thoughts>, think through ways to make the review sound more human-like.
+Then, within the tags <output>...</output>, write the review in the review format.
 """