{
  "stage": "C5-D final end-to-end benchmark",
  "profile": "QUICK_TRAIN",
  "n_val": 750,
  "old_system_available": false,
  "best_method": "raw_input",
  "summary_top": [
    {
      "method": "raw_input",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 5.760847321059961e-07,
      "log_l1": 0.0015785939913669912,
      "energy_rel": 0.0008914630922857516,
      "freq_l1": 1.9524815107918886e-05,
      "dir_l1": 1.4581698814633152e-05,
      "score": 4.337026900422606e-05,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.0001785319102258048,
      "wave_region_mse": 5.732576784662352e-07,
      "hs_abs": 0.00040660763043657883,
      "tp_abs": 0.15877104696881655,
      "dp_abs": 13.393333333333333,
      "dmean_abs": 0.024930716240589807,
      "etot_rel": 0.0008914630914256613
    },
    {
      "method": "raw_domain_smooth_proxy_NOT_OLD_SYSTEM",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 0.0007049834983578572,
      "log_l1": 0.1178919918636481,
      "energy_rel": 0.000891467068392861,
      "freq_l1": 0.003095058148726821,
      "dir_l1": 0.00016746634418571678,
      "score": 0.0032581963448483436,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.0005918542051634479,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.001201183067363066,
      "hs_abs": 0.0004066092554799701,
      "tp_abs": 0.34382602323125155,
      "dp_abs": 21.186666666666667,
      "dmean_abs": 0.024930666406770684,
      "etot_rel": 0.0008914670676206141
    },
    {
      "method": "quality_one",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 0.0026618690077448263,
      "log_l1": 0.17898931367198626,
      "energy_rel": 0.09770590741242631,
      "freq_l1": 0.004841188035284479,
      "dir_l1": 0.0013754632964652653,
      "score": 0.00831361101946094,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.000178213616471794,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.004522277299780398,
      "hs_abs": 0.04477427521268773,
      "tp_abs": 0.45266631094224047,
      "dp_abs": 26.786666666666665,
      "dmean_abs": 4.9132171062908805,
      "etot_rel": 0.09770590760534421
    },
    {
      "method": "comm_one",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 0.002712154464330524,
      "log_l1": 0.1793732144832611,
      "energy_rel": 0.1030767472087949,
      "freq_l1": 0.004912469367962331,
      "dir_l1": 0.0013896994083964576,
      "score": 0.00847757337714751,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.000168204496547105,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.0046129778177322195,
      "hs_abs": 0.04728585553109969,
      "tp_abs": 0.45152736383836395,
      "dp_abs": 25.666666666666668,
      "dmean_abs": 5.019588309324944,
      "etot_rel": 0.10307674748665707
    },
    {
      "method": "quality_one_zero",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 0.002791438645644424,
      "log_l1": 0.1963414568801721,
      "energy_rel": 0.08845041710638907,
      "freq_l1": 0.0053065549513945974,
      "dir_l1": 0.00162010637895825,
      "score": 0.008736613212529996,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.0001909826298590739,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.0047520081559972215,
      "hs_abs": 0.038679694298384325,
      "tp_abs": 0.4593838693684126,
      "dp_abs": 27.126666666666665,
      "dmean_abs": 5.453094466834529,
      "etot_rel": 0.08845041697603559
    },
    {
      "method": "comm_one_zero",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 0.002813078403046044,
      "log_l1": 0.19472480310002963,
      "energy_rel": 0.08882263190910453,
      "freq_l1": 0.005322492804999153,
      "dir_l1": 0.0016341505919893584,
      "score": 0.00875352564863001,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.00018106336634082253,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.0047913531753389785,
      "hs_abs": 0.03934545819161042,
      "tp_abs": 0.44720490141187447,
      "dp_abs": 27.033333333333335,
      "dmean_abs": 5.508573932943814,
      "etot_rel": 0.08882263186784085
    },
    {
      "method": "quality_one_shuf",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 0.0029208437087557587,
      "log_l1": 0.18583512475093206,
      "energy_rel": 0.10523826888871068,
      "freq_l1": 0.005231702979033192,
      "dir_l1": 0.0014950646460056304,
      "score": 0.00893430144326063,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.0001799460223054723,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.004970218836329877,
      "hs_abs": 0.04858071863997911,
      "tp_abs": 0.49137436160030756,
      "dp_abs": 26.733333333333334,
      "dmean_abs": 5.513645051218971,
      "etot_rel": 0.10523826902952721
    },
    {
      "method": "comm_one_shuf",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 0.002923051152184295,
      "log_l1": 0.18548589367667834,
      "energy_rel": 0.10979381540669904,
      "freq_l1": 0.005251729218599697,
      "dir_l1": 0.0015103733132127673,
      "score": 0.009011487662218006,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.00016724792281365807,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.0049801857577792055,
      "hs_abs": 0.050422417278065096,
      "tp_abs": 0.46463754595552487,
      "dp_abs": 26.08,
      "dmean_abs": 5.490441668989741,
      "etot_rel": 0.10979381537922586
    },
    {
      "method": "comm_cond",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 0.0029742713288093605,
      "log_l1": 0.25958668964107834,
      "energy_rel": 0.16033845103101338,
      "freq_l1": 0.0067131551389272015,
      "dir_l1": 0.002333398247913768,
      "score": 0.011427342230570464,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.0006529669554375536,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.00503529464515547,
      "hs_abs": 0.06105291515081222,
      "tp_abs": 0.5083003555496314,
      "dp_abs": 24.386666666666667,
      "dmean_abs": 7.004500021214966,
      "etot_rel": 0.1603384511472196
    },
    {
      "method": "quality_cond",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 0.002917997436753164,
      "log_l1": 0.26162350703279175,
      "energy_rel": 0.17156490335958854,
      "freq_l1": 0.006630020439624787,
      "dir_l1": 0.00231024579393367,
      "score": 0.011529021673892586,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.0007003396170534112,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.004932368936405206,
      "hs_abs": 0.06534036826951349,
      "tp_abs": 0.5079887759574057,
      "dp_abs": 24.606666666666666,
      "dmean_abs": 6.498347083574629,
      "etot_rel": 0.17156490346799794
    },
    {
      "method": "main_prior",
      "n": 750,
      "mse": 0.006757325881626457,
      "log_l1": 0.40188150133689243,
      "energy_rel": 0.2087290743092696,
      "freq_l1": 0.008430526329825322,
      "dir_l1": 0.0056553808203898374,
      "score": 0.019075369432844533,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.0015726637545750842,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.011521987029661734,
      "hs_abs": 0.09338137580168476,
      "tp_abs": 0.7583425403150007,
      "dp_abs": 30.206666666666667,
      "dmean_abs": 13.535790446000393,
      "etot_rel": 0.20872907414525999
    },
    {
      "method": "quality_ddim",
      "n": 48,
      "mse": 0.009828234920860268,
      "log_l1": 0.28501094443102676,
      "energy_rel": 0.45138067472726107,
      "freq_l1": 0.009203669692700108,
      "dir_l1": 0.003721391925258407,
      "score": 0.024170708748701142,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.000650036048379358,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.01706972152654392,
      "hs_abs": 0.2315283179762301,
      "tp_abs": 0.7937382924600356,
      "dp_abs": 33.4375,
      "dmean_abs": 10.036171692029393,
      "etot_rel": 0.4513806734670416
    },
    {
      "method": "comm_ddim",
      "n": 48,
      "mse": 0.009823481217608787,
      "log_l1": 0.2846377193927765,
      "energy_rel": 0.4540588989232977,
      "freq_l1": 0.00919937837170437,
      "dir_l1": 0.0036492138412237787,
      "score": 0.024182103224574047,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.0006447511797584108,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.017070834621942293,
      "hs_abs": 0.23303852760250388,
      "tp_abs": 0.8238559463185627,
      "dp_abs": 36.5625,
      "dmean_abs": 9.494866021708532,
      "etot_rel": 0.4540588979422451
    },
    {
      "method": "quality_ddim_zero",
      "n": 48,
      "mse": 0.010098906641360372,
      "log_l1": 0.30737476733823615,
      "energy_rel": 0.3940391852520406,
      "freq_l1": 0.010239176597679034,
      "dir_l1": 0.004393212133436464,
      "score": 0.024380006470746594,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.0006503563693816735,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.01755158949526958,
      "hs_abs": 0.20172670711448837,
      "tp_abs": 0.856774450273512,
      "dp_abs": 37.1875,
      "dmean_abs": 13.328594567883025,
      "etot_rel": 0.3940391894173811
    },
    {
      "method": "comm_ddim_zero",
      "n": 48,
      "mse": 0.010096782042334477,
      "log_l1": 0.30457384046167135,
      "energy_rel": 0.402607512815545,
      "freq_l1": 0.010193569964030758,
      "dir_l1": 0.004350535714668998,
      "score": 0.02444616423618572,
      "artifact_energy_ratio": 0.0006476265549887709,
      "wave_region_mse": 0.017555202144042898,
      "hs_abs": 0.20594921670346877,
      "tp_abs": 0.847558325812983,
      "dp_abs": 36.979166666666664,
      "dmean_abs": 12.285617867787982,
      "etot_rel": 0.40260751676399
    }
  ],
  "quality_one_step_mse": 0.0026618690077448263,
  "quality_one_shuffle_mse": 0.0029208437087557587,
  "quality_one_zero_mse": 0.002791438645644424,
  "comm_one_step_mse": 0.002712154464330524,
  "comm_one_shuffle_mse": 0.002923051152184295,
  "comm_one_zero_mse": 0.002813078403046044,
  "quality_direct_mse": 0.008437796198452512,
  "comm_direct_mse": 0.007756128980778158,
  "quality_one_artifact_ratio": 0.000178213616471794,
  "comm_one_artifact_ratio": 0.000168204496547105,
  "quality_gap_shuffle": 0.0002589747010109324,
  "quality_gap_zero": 0.00012956963789959768,
  "comm_gap_shuffle": 0.00021089668785377082,
  "comm_gap_zero": 0.00010092393871551997,
  "pass_causal_quality": true,
  "pass_causal_comm": true,
  "pass_artifact": true,
  "recommended_output": "quality_one",
  "freeze_ready": true
}