{ "selected": "c11", "frozen_before_test": true, "utc": "2026-11-18T17:24:09Z", "chosen_patch_sha256": "38b9bb6891edfe0064c76faf057e94f33ed7f77a8e08fb7088db7a53efc41d59", "reasoning": [ "Only c11 passed all six pre-registered gates on validation.", "c11: pooled B exact 209/256 vs base 171 (+38); matched random-position control 172 and same-column random-direction control 172.", "Greedy B 52 vs base 45; array exact 98 vs 73 with 0 lost base-correct array answers; A lost 1 (s2 count formatting), C/S/F lost 0; F_balanced 48 vs 45.", "Passage PPL -0.034% relative; KL first-token 0.459 (lowest of all candidates), KL passage 0.00154 (highest among candidates but tiny).", "Ranking is identical whether KL tie-break uses passage KL or first-token KL (only one passing candidate). Note: the KL variant for tie-breaking was fixed after c01-c09 results were seen; it did not affect the outcome.", "10 of 11 rejected candidates failed G5 (lost >=1 base-correct array answer), several also G3 (A/C losses); c09 failed G1/G2 (fences increased to 117)." ], "edits": [ { "param": "model.layers.12.feed_forward.w2.weight", "cols": [ 4731, 7264, 7919 ], "kind": "scale", "alpha": null, "scale": 0.5, "dir": "u" }, { "param": "model.layers.13.feed_forward.w2.weight", "cols": [ 488, 5186, 6715 ], "kind": "scale", "alpha": null, "scale": 0.5, "dir": "u" }, { "param": "model.layers.14.feed_forward.w2.weight", "cols": [ 3659 ], "kind": "scale", "alpha": null, "scale": 0.5, "dir": "u" }, { "param": "model.layers.15.feed_forward.w2.weight", "cols": [ 99, 532, 660, 926, 2017, 2439, 3263, 3682, 5191 ], "kind": "scale", "alpha": null, "scale": 0.5, "dir": "u" } ], "changed_scalars": 32768, "pct_unique": 0.0027998686686602605 }