exp011 s1: fused-data multiband 2-seed (payoff, monolith edge, surgical lesions all replicate)
f8dff9a verified | # exp011a_fused_multiband β the multiband mechanism on REAL DATA | |
| # (+ the segmentation blob-target cache) β CANDIDATE s0; s1 running | |
| **Questions.** (1) Does real fused data (multi-entity photos, natural | |
| captions) change the band economics that uniform synthetic data couldn't pay | |
| for? (2) Build the segmentation blob targets for the HIGH-band blobbing role | |
| (loss design held for review β new mechanism, pacing law). | |
| **Design.** qwen-deepfashion-fused, 4352 rows (dataset audit gates enforced; | |
| all rows passed), caption_joycaption at nl77, same certified beds as exp008 | |
| (multiband3 vs mono48, uniform eps objective, 3000 steps, pure Adam wd=0). | |
| **Results** (`results.json`): | |
| | arm | overall val | band0 (LOW) | band1 (MID) | band2 (HIGH) | | |
| |---|---|---|---|---| | |
| | frozen | 0.142435 | 0.293931 | 0.071764 | 0.010422 | | |
| | multiband3 | 0.135215 (β5.1%) | 0.280633 | 0.066728 | **0.009562** | | |
| | monolith r48 | **0.134184 (β5.8%)** | **0.278893** | **0.065772** | 0.009564 | | |
| Lesions: 3/3 surgical, with LARGER asymmetries than synthetic (band0 own | |
| 0.0130 vs 0.000062 cross β 200Γ). | |
| **Findings (candidate, s0).** | |
| 1. **Real data pays adapters 2β3Γ more** than synthetic (β5.1/β5.8% vs | |
| β2.2/β2.4% in exp008) β the richer distribution has more for small | |
| adapters to learn. | |
| 2. **The structural story replicates on real data**: surgical band | |
| specialists, monolith edge persists under a uniform objective, HIGH-band | |
| own-band win reappears at a hair (0.009562 vs 0.009564). | |
| 3. **Blob targets: built, verified, cached** β after a schema lesson: the | |
| first rasterizer pass returned 100% EMPTY (fused_json polygons are FLAT | |
| [x1,y1,...] lists in a declared `coord_space`, not the assumed pair-list | |
| NORM_0_1000; the emptiness counter caught it β silent-zero discipline). | |
| Corrected rasterizer: 100% non-empty, mean occupancy 0.293, coord_space | |
| norm_0_1000 confirmed on every row. `fix_blob_targets.py` in-package. | |
| **Next.** The blob LOSS (how coarse occupancy couples to the HIGH band's | |
| x0-estimate) goes to the 8am design review with targets ready. s1 | |
| replication of this bed lands ~07:30Z. | |
| **Caveats.** s0; 4352 rows single dataset; blob maps unused in this | |
| training (uniform objective by design). Cost β 2.9 GPU-h incl. cache. | |
| --- | |
| ## SEED-1 REPLICATION (2026-07-18, `results_s1.json`) β 2-SEED ON REAL DATA | |
| mb3 0.135245/0.135215, mono 0.134221/0.134184 β the 2-3x real-data payoff, | |
| the monolith edge, and 3/3 surgical lesions (band0 own 0.01292/0.01296 vs | |
| cross 0.00007) all replicate near-exactly. The fused-data multiband story | |
| is seed-robust. | |