coneml-348m-gamma / eval /README.md
RandomMountainMan's picture
Add eval audit package (battery, scorers, raw Gamma+Qwen artifacts)
556961e verified
|
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
7.38 kB

ConeML 348M Gamma Evaluation Package

This folder contains the local artifacts behind the Gamma model-card numbers. It is meant to make the release claims auditable without publishing training data or private infrastructure details.

Gamma Artifacts

File What it validates
artifacts/gamma/humaneval164_fullctx.json HumanEval full-context run: 22/164, pass@1 13.4%, truncation 4.9%.
artifacts/gamma/gsm8k1319_fullctx.json GSM8K full test run: 35/1319, exact-match 2.65%, truncation 1.7%.
artifacts/gamma/internal_coverage_418.json Internal 418-item capability battery: 219/418 with per-bucket breakdown and raw generations.
artifacts/gamma/epistemic_32.json Epistemic 32-item battery: 23/32 (abstention 10/10, contradiction 4/6, false premise 5/10, sycophancy 4/6) with raw generations.
artifacts/gamma/heldout_transitive_probe.json Held-out transitive-binding probe with generated rows, examples, N=128 per depth for Gamma. Includes a non-name entity control suite.

Checkpoint identifiers inside the artifacts are scrubbed to the release name (coneml-348m-gamma); all scores, rows, and generations are exactly as run against the released checkpoint.

Qwen Local Reference Artifacts

These are local reference runs, not a fully reproducible public Qwen baseline. They are included so the reader can see the exact saved outputs behind the card's local comparison table.

File What it contains
artifacts/qwen/qwen25_05b_ollama_full418.json Qwen qwen2.5:0.5b on the full 418-item internal battery.
artifacts/qwen/qwen25_05b_ollama_objective.json Qwen objective-only subset.
artifacts/qwen/qwen25_05b_ollama_epistemic.json Qwen epistemic subset.
artifacts/qwen/qwen25_05b_ollama_transitive.json Qwen transitive-binding summary by depth.

Recoverable Qwen run details:

  • Model tag in saved artifact: qwen2.5:0.5b
  • Runtime path: Ollama /api/chat
  • Prompt shape for FULL418: one user message containing the internal prompt
  • Explicit system prompt in harness: none
  • FULL418 decoding options: temperature=0, repeat_penalty=1.15, num_predict=2048
  • Transitive decoding options: temperature=0, num_predict=16
  • Scoring: same functional scorers as the Gamma internal battery
  • Raw generations: saved in the JSON files above

Missing Qwen baseline details:

  • Ollama version
  • Model digest
  • GGUF source and quantization level
  • Server-side chat template
  • Upstream checkpoint revision
  • Any server default context settings not captured by /api/chat request body

Because these details were not captured, the Qwen numbers should be read as a local reference run, not as a public leaderboard-quality baseline. A cleaner public comparison would rerun Qwen/Qwen2.5-0.5B-Instruct through Transformers with a pinned revision and tokenizer.apply_chat_template(...).

Battery And Scripts

File Purpose
batteries/coverage_all_418.jsonl Internal 418-item battery definition used by the coverage runs.
scripts/eval_coverage.py Gamma internal coverage evaluator.
scripts/eval_api_full.py Ollama/API evaluator for a chat model on the same 418-item battery.
scripts/heldout_transitive_probe.py Gamma held-out transitive-binding evaluator.
scripts/qwen_transitive_probe.py Ollama/API transitive-binding evaluator.

The copied API scripts use http://127.0.0.1:11434 as a scrubbed default host. The original private endpoint is not published.

Headline Results

Public benchmarks for Gamma:

  • HumanEval: 22/164 = 13.4%
  • GSM8K: 35/1319 = 2.65%

Internal FULL418 comparison, all 15 categories, sorted by Gamma-minus-Qwen delta:

Category (scorer) Gamma Qwen local reference Ξ”
Algorithms/data-structures (code_exec) 11/20 1/20 +10
Code full-program (code_exec) 9/20 0/20 +9
Code-write (code_exec) 13/40 10/40 +3
Math-computation (math_exact) 17/56 14/56 +3
Factual (factual_terms) 24/30 24/30 0
Relational-binding (factual_terms) 27/30 28/30 βˆ’1
Instruction (bleed) 23/30 25/30 βˆ’2
Explanation (rubric) 17/20 20/20 βˆ’3
Narrative (rubric) 26/30 29/30 βˆ’3
Math word-problem (math_exact) 1/42 5/42 βˆ’4
Reasoning-decomposition (factual_terms) 23/30 28/30 βˆ’5
Data/SQL (sql_shape) 6/15 12/15 βˆ’6
Math-explanation (rubric) 8/20 14/20 βˆ’6
Systems/devops (rubric) 4/15 12/15 βˆ’8
Reasoning-everyday (factual_terms) 10/20 19/20 βˆ’9
Overall 219/418 241/418 βˆ’22

The split follows the scorer type. Machine-verified aggregate β€” the four categories scored by code execution or exact numeric match: Gamma 50/136 (37%) vs Qwen 25/136 (18%), a 2.0Γ— margin. Qwen's overall lead comes from the rubric/keyword-scored breadth categories (everyday reasoning, systems/devops, SQL shape, explanation, narrative, instruction) plus word problems. Both facts are real; neither cancels the other.

The local code-slice numbers are prompt-surface-sensitive. The Qwen artifact's generations on the full-program and algorithms slices frequently reproduce the signature and docstring without an implementation body (15/20 full-program failures are IndentationError: expected an indented block after function definition), with wrong-algorithm and name/signature-mismatch failures making up most of the rest. This does not contradict Qwen's stronger published public HumanEval performance; it is evidence about this battery under this harness, scored identically for both models.

Epistemic internal probe:

Metric Gamma Qwen local reference
Epistemic total 23/32 17/32
Abstention 10/10 2/10
Contradiction 4/6 1/6
False premise 5/10 8/10
Sycophancy 4/6 6/6

Binding Denominators

Gamma chat-surface held-out name probes use N=128 at each depth:

Suite Depth 1 Depth 2 Depth 3 Depth 4 Depth 5
Held-out names, trained query surface 125/128 127/128 118/128 110/128 94/128
Held-out names, unseen query phrasing 127/128 120/128 111/128 90/128 69/128
Older-relation held-out names 118/128 116/128 108/128 88/128 76/128
Non-name entity control (colored cards) 77/128 73/128 69/128 57/128 50/128

Chance is 1/(depth+1): the answer is one of the chain's depth+1 items. The non-name control suite is included in the Gamma artifact (the Qwen artifact covers only the three name suites) and is reported on the card as a limitation: binding strength is name-based, and the entity control runs 39–60% β€” above chance at every depth, well below the name suites. The Qwen artifact stores rounded percentages without per-row counts; Gamma's cells are exact counts.

Privacy And IP Boundary

Included:

  • Eval task definitions for the 418 battery
  • Eval scripts and scorer logic
  • Public benchmark raw outputs
  • Internal battery raw outputs
  • Local Qwen reference outputs

Not included:

  • SFT training rows
  • Pretraining corpus files
  • Private service hostnames or IPs
  • API tokens or credentials
  • Full corpus mixture internals beyond the release-card training-budget disclosure