Dagaidagai's picture
Update blending-noise benchmark results
a0f77eb verified
|
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
61.2 kB
---
tags:
- seismic
- blending-noise
- deblending
- unet
- resunet
- dncnn
- attention-unet
- pytorch
library_name: pytorch
---
# Blending Noise Suppression Benchmark
This task performs supervised deblending on paired common-receiver gathers.
## Task
The model directly learns a mapping from pseudo-deblended input to the cleaner forwarding reference:
```python
denoised = model(pseudo_deblended_input)
```
This is a paired regression task, not a synthetic noise injection task.
## Dataset
Current paired SEG-Y inputs:
- input: `/root/Desktop/data/T02_pseudo_deblended_common_receiver_mod.sgy`
- target: `/root/Desktop/data/T02_forwarding_acoustic_common_receiver.sgy`
Logical volume shape:
- `(386, 270, 2000)`
- 386 common-receiver gathers
- 270 traces per common-receiver gather
- 2000 time samples per trace
Split policy:
- sequential receiver-gather split
- train: 300
- val: 43
- test: 43
## Models
- `unet`
- `res_unet`
- `dncnn`
- `atten_unet`
All model definitions are loaded from `model/blending_noise_suppression/`.
## Preprocessing
- paired loading with shape consistency check
- shared normalization statistics for input and target
- overlapping 2D patches of size `128 x 256`
- overlap ratio `0.5`
## Scripts
Training:
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/train_denoise_unet.sh`
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/train_denoise_res_unet.sh`
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/train_denoise_dncnn.sh`
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/train_denoise_atten_unet.sh`
Each training script now runs a fixed three-seed sweep:
- seeds: `42`, `43`, `44`
- run names: `<experiment.name>_<dataset_id>_<noise_tag>_seed<seed>`
For the current input file `T02_pseudo_deblended_common_receiver_mod.sgy`, this becomes `..._T02_mod_seed<seed>`.
- checkpoints: `/root/Desktop/data/results/blending_noise_suppression/<model>/<run_name>/checkpoints/`
Inference:
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/inference_denoise_unet.sh`
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/inference_denoise_res_unet.sh`
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/inference_denoise_dncnn.sh`
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/inference_denoise_atten_unet.sh`
Each inference script matches the same three seeds, writes per-seed outputs to:
- `/root/Desktop/data/results/blending_noise_suppression/<model>/<run_name>/inference`
and also saves a cross-seed aggregate summary to:
- `/root/Desktop/data/results/blending_noise_suppression/<model>/<experiment.name>_<dataset_id>_<noise_tag>_seed_stats/metrics_summary_mean_std.json`
Run all:
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/run_all_blending_models.sh`
## Upload
Dataset upload helpers in this folder are:
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/upload_dataset_to_hf.sh`
This uploads:
- `input/T02_pseudo_deblended_common_receiver_mod.sgy`
- `target/T02_forwarding_acoustic_common_receiver.sgy`
- `assets/deblending/*.png` from `scripts/blending_noise_suppression/assets/`
- generated dataset card `README.md`
The current shell wrappers follow the same style as the random-noise uploader:
- edit the fixed options directly inside the `.sh` file
- then run the shell script
Model upload helper in this folder:
- `bash scripts/blending_noise_suppression/upload_blending_model_to_hf.sh`
This uploads:
- `models/<model>/<dataset_variant>_seed<seed>/best.pt`
- `models/<model>/<dataset_variant>_seed<seed>/config.yaml`
- generated model card `README.md`
## Outputs
Each inference directory contains:
- `metrics_per_gather.csv`
- `metrics_per_sample.csv`
- `metrics_summary.json`
- `visualizations/`
- optional `npy/`
Inference defaults aligned with the random-noise workflow:
- `n_viz_gathers: 5`
- `save_npy: false`
- per-model inference `batch_size` matches the corresponding training config
Metrics are reported for:
- input vs target
- denoised vs target
- delta = denoised minus input
For naming consistency with the random-noise workflow:
- `metrics_summary.json` uses `input`, `denoised`, and `delta`
- the file also keeps a backward-compatible `restored` alias
- `metrics_per_sample.csv` provides a generic sample-level view, while `metrics_per_gather.csv` keeps the correct gather-specific naming
<!-- AUTO_RESULTS_BEGIN -->
## Results
Mean +- std over available seeds, computed from `*_seed_stats/metrics_summary_mean_std.json`.
Metrics are reported on common-receiver gathers in the normalized domain.
### Dataset Variant `T02_comp`
| Method | Parameters (M) | SNR | PSNR | SSIM | MAE | MSE | RMSE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_NE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_SNR | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_NE | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_SNR | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_NE | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_SNR | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_NE | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_SNR | FB_FRE_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_HIGH_SNR | FB_FRE_LOW_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_LOW_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_LOW_NE | FB_FRE_LOW_SNR | FB_FRE_MID_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_MID_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_MID_NE | FB_FRE_MID_SNR | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_SNR |
|---|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|
| Input | - | 1.1666+-0.0000 | 24.1733+-0.0000 | 0.6475+-0.0000 | 0.020175+-0.000000 | 0.003923+-0.000000 | 0.062252+-0.000000 | 2.424931+-0.000000 | -7.5937+-0.0000 | 0.354534+-0.000000 | 9.0088+-0.0000 | 41.080699+-0.000000 | -32.1112+-0.0000 | 13.037582+-0.000000 | -22.1041+-0.0000 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.873002+-0.000000 | 1.1802+-0.0000 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.898679+-0.000000 | 0.9282+-0.0000 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.871390+-0.000000 | 1.1961+-0.0000 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.900242+-0.000000 | 0.9140+-0.0000 |
| UNet | 7.76 | 13.7153+-0.0285 | 36.7220+-0.0286 | 0.9659+-0.0011 | 0.005862+-0.000223 | 0.000217+-0.000001 | 0.014654+-0.000046 | 0.548360+-0.013994 | 5.2264+-0.2239 | 0.187143+-0.000813 | 14.5646+-0.0368 | 2.023152+-0.118065 | -6.0304+-0.5009 | 1.022692+-0.006941 | -0.1832+-0.0606 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.191022+-0.000523 | 14.3887+-0.0221 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.310998+-0.004445 | 10.1490+-0.1246 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.195605+-0.001797 | 14.1894+-0.0790 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.354464+-0.016425 | 9.0312+-0.3973 |
| DnCNN | 0.56 | 15.9093+-0.0329 | 38.9159+-0.0329 | 0.9747+-0.0005 | 0.004189+-0.000073 | 0.000131+-0.000001 | 0.011382+-0.000043 | 0.398803+-0.003495 | 7.9922+-0.0759 | 0.143179+-0.001064 | 16.8937+-0.0645 | 1.973087+-0.099471 | -5.8083+-0.4441 | 0.804399+-0.021533 | 1.9187+-0.2312 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.149839+-0.001259 | 16.5090+-0.0723 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.312591+-0.005099 | 10.1085+-0.1418 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.143503+-0.000822 | 16.8827+-0.0485 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.337944+-0.004222 | 9.4342+-0.1109 |
| ResUNet | 8.11 | 13.0502+-0.0999 | 36.0568+-0.0999 | 0.9630+-0.0007 | 0.005982+-0.000151 | 0.000253+-0.000006 | 0.015824+-0.000182 | 0.580493+-0.004514 | 4.7277+-0.0675 | 0.202740+-0.001825 | 13.8691+-0.0791 | 2.196548+-0.210000 | -6.7265+-0.8433 | 0.993230+-0.044053 | 0.0782+-0.3850 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.203625+-0.003579 | 13.8350+-0.1530 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.323164+-0.002858 | 9.8146+-0.0767 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.215460+-0.001770 | 13.3486+-0.0718 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.331564+-0.004233 | 9.6056+-0.1129 |
| Attention UNet | 7.85 | 13.4453+-0.1919 | 36.4519+-0.1918 | 0.9651+-0.0010 | 0.005995+-0.000201 | 0.000230+-0.000010 | 0.015111+-0.000333 | 0.550504+-0.008220 | 5.1888+-0.1297 | 0.194943+-0.004859 | 14.2127+-0.2146 | 1.883427+-0.132940 | -5.4135+-0.5909 | 0.968391+-0.028346 | 0.2907+-0.2566 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.196462+-0.003245 | 14.1463+-0.1433 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.317140+-0.003001 | 9.9775+-0.0823 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.200722+-0.003868 | 13.9657+-0.1676 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.376004+-0.009141 | 8.5124+-0.2100 |
### Dataset Variant `T02_mod`
| Method | Parameters (M) | SNR | PSNR | SSIM | MAE | MSE | RMSE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_NE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_SNR | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_NE | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_SNR | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_NE | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_SNR | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_NE | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_SNR | FB_FRE_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_HIGH_SNR | FB_FRE_LOW_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_LOW_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_LOW_NE | FB_FRE_LOW_SNR | FB_FRE_MID_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_MID_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_MID_NE | FB_FRE_MID_SNR | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_SNR |
|---|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|
| Input | - | 3.3315+-0.0000 | 26.6881+-0.0000 | 0.7654+-0.0000 | 0.012160+-0.000000 | 0.002216+-0.000000 | 0.046691+-0.000000 | 1.812672+-0.000000 | -5.0296+-0.0000 | 0.291407+-0.000000 | 10.7119+-0.0000 | 32.195003+-0.000000 | -30.0783+-0.0000 | 10.154543+-0.000000 | -19.9091+-0.0000 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.683361+-0.000000 | 3.3090+-0.0000 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.695802+-0.000000 | 3.1510+-0.0000 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.678645+-0.000000 | 3.3687+-0.0000 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.689609+-0.000000 | 3.2288+-0.0000 |
| UNet | 7.76 | 14.7039+-0.2431 | 38.0605+-0.2431 | 0.9748+-0.0005 | 0.004650+-0.000281 | 0.000164+-0.000009 | 0.012648+-0.000360 | 0.473852+-0.018317 | 6.5041+-0.3309 | 0.167761+-0.005444 | 15.5276+-0.2822 | 2.123491+-0.119411 | -6.5083+-0.4739 | 0.907897+-0.009668 | 0.8630+-0.0887 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.168928+-0.004161 | 15.4765+-0.2150 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.270377+-0.001948 | 11.3674+-0.0602 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.177198+-0.010899 | 15.0684+-0.5435 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.314485+-0.026862 | 10.0991+-0.7195 |
| DnCNN | 0.56 | 17.4002+-0.0460 | 40.7567+-0.0460 | 0.9847+-0.0002 | 0.002816+-0.000052 | 0.000088+-0.000001 | 0.009280+-0.000054 | 0.317468+-0.002446 | 9.9740+-0.0672 | 0.123480+-0.000698 | 18.1918+-0.0488 | 1.908495+-0.075431 | -5.5801+-0.3437 | 0.699431+-0.018116 | 3.1511+-0.2222 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.127505+-0.000947 | 17.9398+-0.0564 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.268126+-0.002124 | 11.4418+-0.0681 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.119451+-0.000877 | 18.4804+-0.0641 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.295901+-0.003349 | 10.5996+-0.0971 |
| ResUNet | 8.11 | 14.1138+-0.0794 | 37.4704+-0.0794 | 0.9749+-0.0005 | 0.004629+-0.000126 | 0.000187+-0.000004 | 0.013524+-0.000125 | 0.486774+-0.004043 | 6.2610+-0.0725 | 0.181058+-0.001342 | 14.8585+-0.0644 | 2.130174+-0.187739 | -6.5089+-0.7907 | 0.872875+-0.023638 | 1.2102+-0.2271 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.180487+-0.003511 | 14.8949+-0.1682 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.270266+-0.001293 | 11.3680+-0.0415 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.192449+-0.001287 | 14.3336+-0.0586 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.290352+-0.006327 | 10.7610+-0.1905 |
| Attention UNet | 7.85 | 14.5616+-0.1395 | 37.9182+-0.1395 | 0.9749+-0.0004 | 0.004868+-0.000111 | 0.000168+-0.000005 | 0.012843+-0.000208 | 0.455199+-0.003818 | 6.8466+-0.0745 | 0.172010+-0.003499 | 15.3022+-0.1770 | 2.171944+-0.038920 | -6.7162+-0.1614 | 0.884095+-0.010330 | 1.1019+-0.0963 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.174245+-0.003430 | 15.1990+-0.1717 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.270073+-0.005210 | 11.3789+-0.1665 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.176185+-0.003015 | 15.0971+-0.1458 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.334154+-0.012100 | 9.5456+-0.3116 |
### Dataset Variant `T02_simp`
| Method | Parameters (M) | SNR | PSNR | SSIM | MAE | MSE | RMSE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_NE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_SNR | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_NE | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_SNR | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_NE | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_SNR | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_NE | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_SNR | FB_FRE_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_HIGH_SNR | FB_FRE_LOW_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_LOW_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_LOW_NE | FB_FRE_LOW_SNR | FB_FRE_MID_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_MID_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_MID_NE | FB_FRE_MID_SNR | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_SNR |
|---|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|:---:|
| Input | - | 6.6896+-0.0000 | 29.5209+-0.0000 | 0.8797+-0.0000 | 0.006035+-0.000000 | 0.001162+-0.000000 | 0.033769+-0.000000 | 1.359040+-0.000000 | -2.5295+-0.0000 | 0.218058+-0.000000 | 13.2445+-0.0000 | 18.050747+-0.000000 | -24.8266+-0.0000 | 5.957535+-0.000000 | -15.2400+-0.0000 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.465783+-0.000000 | 6.6411+-0.0000 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.478424+-0.000000 | 6.4075+-0.0000 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.461325+-0.000000 | 6.7222+-0.0000 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.470025+-0.000000 | 6.5676+-0.0000 |
| UNet | 7.76 | 17.0387+-0.2113 | 39.8701+-0.2112 | 0.9844+-0.0008 | 0.003486+-0.000332 | 0.000108+-0.000005 | 0.010272+-0.000247 | 0.365571+-0.003555 | 8.7478+-0.0849 | 0.127483+-0.003382 | 17.9170+-0.2360 | 1.415779+-0.097544 | -2.9125+-0.5822 | 0.652592+-0.002307 | 3.7166+-0.0316 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.124367+-0.002468 | 18.1415+-0.1829 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.215077+-0.010455 | 13.3626+-0.4145 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.133467+-0.001234 | 17.5222+-0.0794 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.251275+-0.022851 | 12.0500+-0.7735 |
| DnCNN | 0.56 | 20.4091+-0.0326 | 43.2404+-0.0326 | 0.9925+-0.0000 | 0.001532+-0.000031 | 0.000049+-0.000000 | 0.006957+-0.000029 | 0.222201+-0.001296 | 13.0774+-0.0526 | 0.088844+-0.000339 | 21.0477+-0.0335 | 0.898625+-0.021335 | 1.0318+-0.2143 | 0.406727+-0.002426 | 7.8283+-0.0523 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.086655+-0.000918 | 21.2753+-0.0958 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.188400+-0.003696 | 14.5150+-0.1741 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.086650+-0.000717 | 21.2743+-0.0735 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.202190+-0.000115 | 13.8956+-0.0046 |
| ResUNet | 8.11 | 16.5535+-0.1634 | 39.3848+-0.1634 | 0.9847+-0.0004 | 0.003306+-0.000134 | 0.000121+-0.000004 | 0.010861+-0.000203 | 0.382057+-0.009326 | 8.3679+-0.2092 | 0.136025+-0.002203 | 17.3502+-0.1454 | 1.356662+-0.063744 | -2.5668+-0.3877 | 0.618934+-0.018298 | 4.1788+-0.2558 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.131448+-0.003584 | 17.6564+-0.2426 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.211059+-0.001684 | 13.5171+-0.0696 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.144846+-0.002013 | 16.8097+-0.1269 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.222782+-0.007011 | 13.0636+-0.2739 |
| Attention UNet | 7.85 | 16.6680+-0.1592 | 39.4993+-0.1592 | 0.9831+-0.0005 | 0.003818+-0.000183 | 0.000117+-0.000004 | 0.010712+-0.000193 | 0.345422+-0.001738 | 9.2426+-0.0445 | 0.132686+-0.002938 | 17.5634+-0.1929 | 1.558382+-0.103877 | -3.7426+-0.5584 | 0.655009+-0.031865 | 3.7075+-0.4077 | 0.243824+-0.000000 | 28.75-41.8 | 0.129747+-0.002258 | 17.7680+-0.1561 | 0.023417+-0.000000 | 7-15.7 | 0.227748+-0.006546 | 12.8649+-0.2507 | 0.619438+-0.000000 | 15.7-28.75 | 0.136028+-0.000966 | 17.3499+-0.0621 | 0.006539+-0.000000 | 41.8-50.5 | 0.282750+-0.011078 | 10.9940+-0.3458 |
<!-- AUTO_RESULTS_DATA_BEGIN
{
"groups": {
"T02_simp": {
"input": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 1.35904,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": -2.529481,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.218058,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 13.244479,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 18.050747,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -24.82658,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 5.957535,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": -15.239973,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.465783,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 6.641073,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.478424,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 6.407515,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.461325,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 6.722218,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.470025,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 6.567561,
"std": 0.0
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.006035,
"std": 0.0
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.001162,
"std": 0.0
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 29.5209,
"std": 0.0
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.033769,
"std": 0.0
},
"snr": {
"mean": 6.6896,
"std": 0.0
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.8797,
"std": 0.0
}
},
"models": {
"unet": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.365571,
"std": 0.003555
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 8.747818,
"std": 0.08495
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.127483,
"std": 0.003382
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 17.916975,
"std": 0.236017
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 1.415779,
"std": 0.097544
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -2.912453,
"std": 0.582235
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.652592,
"std": 0.002307
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 3.716558,
"std": 0.031631
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.124367,
"std": 0.002468
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 18.141498,
"std": 0.182943
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.215077,
"std": 0.010455
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 13.362596,
"std": 0.414527
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.133467,
"std": 0.001234
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 17.522163,
"std": 0.079389
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.251275,
"std": 0.022851
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 12.049957,
"std": 0.773504
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.003486,
"std": 0.000332
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.000108,
"std": 5e-06
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 39.870067,
"std": 0.211213
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.010272,
"std": 0.000247
},
"snr": {
"mean": 17.038733,
"std": 0.211252
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.984367,
"std": 0.000793
}
},
"dncnn": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.222201,
"std": 0.001296
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 13.077423,
"std": 0.052612
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.088844,
"std": 0.000339
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 21.047728,
"std": 0.033486
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 0.898625,
"std": 0.021335
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": 1.031813,
"std": 0.214304
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.406727,
"std": 0.002426
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 7.828294,
"std": 0.052318
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.086655,
"std": 0.000918
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 21.275269,
"std": 0.095841
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.1884,
"std": 0.003696
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 14.51495,
"std": 0.174066
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.08665,
"std": 0.000717
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 21.274315,
"std": 0.073501
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.20219,
"std": 0.000115
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 13.895631,
"std": 0.004649
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.001532,
"std": 3.1e-05
},
"mse": {
"mean": 4.9e-05,
"std": 0.0
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 43.240433,
"std": 0.032581
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.006957,
"std": 2.9e-05
},
"snr": {
"mean": 20.409133,
"std": 0.032581
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.992467,
"std": 4.7e-05
}
},
"res_unet": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.382057,
"std": 0.009326
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 8.367912,
"std": 0.209189
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.136025,
"std": 0.002203
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 17.350155,
"std": 0.145372
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 1.356662,
"std": 0.063744
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -2.566785,
"std": 0.387671
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.618934,
"std": 0.018298
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 4.178846,
"std": 0.255754
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.131448,
"std": 0.003584
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 17.656395,
"std": 0.242572
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.211059,
"std": 0.001684
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 13.517144,
"std": 0.069615
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.144846,
"std": 0.002013
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 16.809731,
"std": 0.126925
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.222782,
"std": 0.007011
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 13.063601,
"std": 0.273914
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.003306,
"std": 0.000134
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.000121,
"std": 4e-06
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 39.384833,
"std": 0.163355
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.010861,
"std": 0.000203
},
"snr": {
"mean": 16.553467,
"std": 0.163361
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.984733,
"std": 0.000386
}
},
"atten_unet": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.345422,
"std": 0.001738
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 9.242622,
"std": 0.044542
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.132686,
"std": 0.002938
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 17.563374,
"std": 0.192941
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 1.558382,
"std": 0.103877
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -3.742594,
"std": 0.558392
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.655009,
"std": 0.031865
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 3.707478,
"std": 0.407706
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.129747,
"std": 0.002258
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 17.767984,
"std": 0.156131
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.227748,
"std": 0.006546
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 12.864948,
"std": 0.25067
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.136028,
"std": 0.000966
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 17.349868,
"std": 0.062088
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.28275,
"std": 0.011078
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 10.994049,
"std": 0.34579
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.003818,
"std": 0.000183
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.000117,
"std": 4e-06
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 39.4993,
"std": 0.159204
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.010712,
"std": 0.000193
},
"snr": {
"mean": 16.668,
"std": 0.159204
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.983133,
"std": 0.000499
}
}
}
},
"T02_comp": {
"input": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 2.424931,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": -7.593718,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.354534,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 9.008758,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 41.080699,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -32.111217,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 13.037582,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": -22.104066,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.873002,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 1.180197,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.898679,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 0.928245,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.87139,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 1.196139,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.900242,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 0.914014,
"std": 0.0
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.020175,
"std": 0.0
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.003923,
"std": 0.0
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 24.1733,
"std": 0.0
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.062252,
"std": 0.0
},
"snr": {
"mean": 1.1666,
"std": 0.0
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.6475,
"std": 0.0
}
},
"models": {
"unet": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.54836,
"std": 0.013994
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 5.226406,
"std": 0.223899
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.187143,
"std": 0.000813
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 14.564615,
"std": 0.036803
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 2.023152,
"std": 0.118065
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -6.030359,
"std": 0.500864
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 1.022692,
"std": 0.006941
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": -0.183214,
"std": 0.060633
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.191022,
"std": 0.000523
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 14.388735,
"std": 0.022121
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.310998,
"std": 0.004445
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 10.14902,
"std": 0.124587
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.195605,
"std": 0.001797
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 14.189351,
"std": 0.078959
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.354464,
"std": 0.016425
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 9.031165,
"std": 0.397263
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.005862,
"std": 0.000223
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.000217,
"std": 1e-06
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 36.722,
"std": 0.028583
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.014654,
"std": 4.6e-05
},
"snr": {
"mean": 13.715333,
"std": 0.028543
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.965867,
"std": 0.001096
}
},
"dncnn": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.398803,
"std": 0.003495
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 7.992174,
"std": 0.075868
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.143179,
"std": 0.001064
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 16.893717,
"std": 0.064534
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 1.973087,
"std": 0.099471
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -5.808303,
"std": 0.444088
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.804399,
"std": 0.021533
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 1.918662,
"std": 0.231168
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.149839,
"std": 0.001259
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 16.509007,
"std": 0.072336
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.312591,
"std": 0.005099
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 10.10851,
"std": 0.141768
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.143503,
"std": 0.000822
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 16.882654,
"std": 0.048469
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.337944,
"std": 0.004222
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 9.43421,
"std": 0.110889
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.004189,
"std": 7.3e-05
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.000131,
"std": 1e-06
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 38.915933,
"std": 0.032873
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.011382,
"std": 4.3e-05
},
"snr": {
"mean": 15.9093,
"std": 0.032888
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.974733,
"std": 0.000499
}
},
"res_unet": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.580493,
"std": 0.004514
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 4.727709,
"std": 0.067466
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.20274,
"std": 0.001825
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 13.86909,
"std": 0.079081
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 2.196548,
"std": 0.21
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -6.726541,
"std": 0.843273
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.99323,
"std": 0.044053
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 0.078229,
"std": 0.384972
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.203625,
"std": 0.003579
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 13.834959,
"std": 0.152958
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.323164,
"std": 0.002858
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 9.814647,
"std": 0.076709
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.21546,
"std": 0.00177
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 13.348618,
"std": 0.071846
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.331564,
"std": 0.004233
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 9.605575,
"std": 0.112871
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.005982,
"std": 0.000151
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.000253,
"std": 6e-06
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 36.056767,
"std": 0.099906
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.015824,
"std": 0.000182
},
"snr": {
"mean": 13.050167,
"std": 0.099906
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.963,
"std": 0.000712
}
},
"atten_unet": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.550504,
"std": 0.00822
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 5.188796,
"std": 0.129652
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.194943,
"std": 0.004859
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 14.212691,
"std": 0.21462
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 1.883427,
"std": 0.13294
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -5.41349,
"std": 0.590894
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.968391,
"std": 0.028346
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 0.290734,
"std": 0.256606
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.196462,
"std": 0.003245
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 14.14625,
"std": 0.143305
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.31714,
"std": 0.003001
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 9.977495,
"std": 0.082288
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.200722,
"std": 0.003868
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 13.965692,
"std": 0.16761
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.376004,
"std": 0.009141
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 8.512386,
"std": 0.210015
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.005995,
"std": 0.000201
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.00023,
"std": 1e-05
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 36.451933,
"std": 0.191846
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.015111,
"std": 0.000333
},
"snr": {
"mean": 13.445267,
"std": 0.191879
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.965133,
"std": 0.000988
}
}
}
},
"T02_mod": {
"input": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 1.812672,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": -5.029633,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.291407,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 10.711863,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 32.195003,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -30.078277,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 10.154543,
"std": 0.0
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": -19.909064,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.683361,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 3.309024,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.695802,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 3.151009,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.678645,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 3.36867,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.689609,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 3.228774,
"std": 0.0
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.01216,
"std": 0.0
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.002216,
"std": 0.0
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 26.6881,
"std": 0.0
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.046691,
"std": 0.0
},
"snr": {
"mean": 3.3315,
"std": 0.0
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.7654,
"std": 0.0
}
},
"models": {
"unet": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.473852,
"std": 0.018317
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 6.504145,
"std": 0.330883
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.167761,
"std": 0.005444
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 15.527641,
"std": 0.282178
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 2.123491,
"std": 0.119411
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -6.508345,
"std": 0.473904
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.907897,
"std": 0.009668
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 0.862995,
"std": 0.088737
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.168928,
"std": 0.004161
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 15.476525,
"std": 0.21498
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.270377,
"std": 0.001948
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 11.367376,
"std": 0.060239
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.177198,
"std": 0.010899
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 15.068369,
"std": 0.543453
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.314485,
"std": 0.026862
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 10.099075,
"std": 0.7195
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.00465,
"std": 0.000281
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.000164,
"std": 9e-06
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 38.0605,
"std": 0.243101
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.012648,
"std": 0.00036
},
"snr": {
"mean": 14.703933,
"std": 0.243086
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.974833,
"std": 0.000544
}
},
"dncnn": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.317468,
"std": 0.002446
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 9.97396,
"std": 0.067157
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.12348,
"std": 0.000698
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 18.191807,
"std": 0.048781
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 1.908495,
"std": 0.075431
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -5.580064,
"std": 0.343691
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.699431,
"std": 0.018116
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 3.151053,
"std": 0.22222
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.127505,
"std": 0.000947
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 17.939769,
"std": 0.056444
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.268126,
"std": 0.002124
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 11.4418,
"std": 0.068135
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.119451,
"std": 0.000877
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 18.48035,
"std": 0.064124
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.295901,
"std": 0.003349
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 10.599602,
"std": 0.097134
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.002816,
"std": 5.2e-05
},
"mse": {
"mean": 8.8e-05,
"std": 1e-06
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 40.756733,
"std": 0.046005
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.00928,
"std": 5.4e-05
},
"snr": {
"mean": 17.4002,
"std": 0.045971
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.984733,
"std": 0.000249
}
},
"res_unet": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.486774,
"std": 0.004043
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 6.261013,
"std": 0.072467
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.181058,
"std": 0.001342
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 14.858492,
"std": 0.064411
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 2.130174,
"std": 0.187739
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -6.508905,
"std": 0.790704
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.872875,
"std": 0.023638
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 1.210248,
"std": 0.227055
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.180487,
"std": 0.003511
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 14.894911,
"std": 0.168242
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.270266,
"std": 0.001293
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 11.367955,
"std": 0.041544
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.192449,
"std": 0.001287
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 14.333623,
"std": 0.058559
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.290352,
"std": 0.006327
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 10.761013,
"std": 0.190515
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.004629,
"std": 0.000126
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.000187,
"std": 4e-06
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 37.4704,
"std": 0.079422
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.013524,
"std": 0.000125
},
"snr": {
"mean": 14.1138,
"std": 0.079422
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.974867,
"std": 0.000478
}
},
"atten_unet": {
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_ne": {
"mean": 0.455199,
"std": 0.003818
},
"eb_wse_medium_40_70_snr": {
"mean": 6.846589,
"std": 0.074503
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_ne": {
"mean": 0.17201,
"std": 0.003499
},
"eb_wse_strong_70_100_snr": {
"mean": 15.302219,
"std": 0.176979
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_ne": {
"mean": 2.171944,
"std": 0.03892
},
"eb_wse_very_weak_5_20_snr": {
"mean": -6.716188,
"std": 0.161394
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_ne": {
"mean": 0.884095,
"std": 0.01033
},
"eb_wse_weak_20_40_snr": {
"mean": 1.101884,
"std": 0.096279
},
"fb_fre_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.243824,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_high_frequency_range_hz": [
28.75,
41.8
],
"fb_fre_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.174245,
"std": 0.00343
},
"fb_fre_high_snr": {
"mean": 15.199046,
"std": 0.171722
},
"fb_fre_low_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.023417,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_low_frequency_range_hz": [
7.0,
15.7
],
"fb_fre_low_ne": {
"mean": 0.270073,
"std": 0.00521
},
"fb_fre_low_snr": {
"mean": 11.37886,
"std": 0.166497
},
"fb_fre_mid_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.619438,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_mid_frequency_range_hz": [
15.7,
28.75
],
"fb_fre_mid_ne": {
"mean": 0.176185,
"std": 0.003015
},
"fb_fre_mid_snr": {
"mean": 15.097063,
"std": 0.145822
},
"fb_fre_very_high_energy_ratio": {
"mean": 0.006539,
"std": 0.0
},
"fb_fre_very_high_frequency_range_hz": [
41.8,
50.5
],
"fb_fre_very_high_ne": {
"mean": 0.334154,
"std": 0.0121
},
"fb_fre_very_high_snr": {
"mean": 9.545639,
"std": 0.311643
},
"mae": {
"mean": 0.004868,
"std": 0.000111
},
"mse": {
"mean": 0.000168,
"std": 5e-06
},
"psnr": {
"mean": 37.9182,
"std": 0.139451
},
"rmse": {
"mean": 0.012843,
"std": 0.000208
},
"snr": {
"mean": 14.561633,
"std": 0.139496
},
"ssim": {
"mean": 0.974933,
"std": 0.000386
}
}
}
}
},
"num_params": {
"unet": 7760000,
"dncnn": 560000,
"res_unet": 8110000,
"atten_unet": 7850000
}
}
AUTO_RESULTS_DATA_END -->
<!-- AUTO_RESULTS_END -->