Random Noise Suppression AVO Benchmark
Deep-learning-based random-noise attenuation on pre-stack seismic shot gathers, using the clean seismic.segy AVO dataset and synthetic Gaussian / Poisson noise injection.
Task
Given a clean shot gather, the benchmark first injects synthetic random noise at a specified SNR, then trains a model to directly reconstruct the clean signal:
denoised = model(noisy_input)
This is a paired regression task with clean-target supervision. Most models directly predict the clean gather. The DDPM variant predicts diffusion noise during training and reconstructs the clean gather through reverse sampling at evaluation / inference time.
Dataset
- Source: Clean AVO seismic.segy data
- Current training volume:
seismic.segy - Geometry: 201 traces per shot, time sampling interval
dt = 2 ms - Split: Shot-level sequential
7:1:1- 801 training shots
- 100 validation shots
- 100 held-out test shots
Synthetic Noise Settings
- Noise kinds:
gaussian,poisson - Default sweep in training / inference scripts:
SNR = -5, 0, 5 dB - Noise injection: per-shot variance-controlled synthetic corruption
- Reproducibility: noise generation is seeded from
experiment.seed
Model Architectures
- UNet (
unet): classic encoder-decoder with skip connections. Base channels: 32, depth: 4. - ResUNet (
res_unet): U-Net with residual blocks. Base channels: 32, depth: 4. - DnCNN (
dncnn): residual denoising CNN with 17 layers and 64 feature channels. - Attention UNet (
atten_unet): U-Net with attention gates. Base channels: 32, depth: 4. - DDPM (
ddpm): standard conditional denoising diffusion probabilistic model with reverse sampling from Gaussian noise to the clean shot gather. - SCRN (
SCRN): Swin Transformer convolutional residual network adapted to the same random-noise benchmark pipeline.
Preprocessing
- Amplitude correction: spherical divergence correction is skipped by default
- Normalization:
max_abs, per-shot - Patching: overlapping 2D patches of size
128 x 256(trace x time) - Patch overlap:
50%
Training uses patched shot gathers. Inference reloads the raw volume, applies inference.shot_split, injects synthetic noise, runs patch-based reconstruction, and inverse-normalizes outputs for visualization.
Repository Structure
scripts/random_noise_suppression_avo/
|- train_denoise_unet.sh
|- train_denoise_res_unet.sh
|- train_denoise_dncnn.sh
|- train_denoise_atten_unet.sh
|- train_denoise_ddpm.sh
|- train_denoise_SCRN.sh
|- inference_denoise_unet.sh
|- inference_denoise_res_unet.sh
|- inference_denoise_dncnn.sh
|- inference_denoise_atten_unet.sh
|- inference_denoise_ddpm.sh
|- inference_denoise_SCRN.sh
`- run_all_random_noise_models.sh
configs/random_noise_suppression_avo/
|- denoise_unet.yaml
|- denoise_res_unet.yaml
|- denoise_dncnn.yaml
|- denoise_atten_unet.yaml
|- denoise_ddpm.yaml
`- denoise_SCRN.yaml
Each experiment directory is named by model, noise kind, SNR, and seed, for example:
random_noise_avo_unet_base_gaussian_snr5_seed42/
random_noise_avo_dncnn_base_poisson_snr0_seed43/
random_noise_avo_ddpm_base_gaussian_snrneg5_seed44/
Training Details
Shared benchmark defaults:
| Hyperparameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Loss | MSE |
| DDPM note | trains on diffusion-noise prediction and validates clean reconstruction after reverse sampling |
| Optimizer | AdamW (lr=1e-4, weight_decay=1e-5) |
| Scheduler | Cosine annealing (min_lr=1e-6) |
| Epochs | 200 |
| Gradient clipping | 1.0 |
| Seeds | 42, 43, 44 by default in shell sweeps |
| Batch size | 192 in current YAML defaults |
Usage
Train One Model Family
bash scripts/random_noise_suppression_avo/train_denoise_unet.sh
or
bash scripts/random_noise_suppression_avo/train_denoise_ddpm.sh
Each training shell script sweeps:
- noise kind
- SNR
- seed
by rewriting a temporary YAML config before calling torchrun.
Run Inference
bash scripts/random_noise_suppression_avo/inference_denoise_unet.sh
Inference outputs:
- per-shot metrics CSV
- summary JSON
- visualizations
- optional
.npyfiles - multi-seed mean/std aggregation JSON
Run All Model Families
bash scripts/random_noise_suppression_avo/run_all_random_noise_models.sh
Current total-run script executes:
unetdncnnres_unetatten_unetddpm
Each model is trained first, then its inference sweep is launched immediately after training finishes.
Inference Outputs
For each experiment, the inference directory typically contains:
inference/
|- inference.log
|- metrics_per_shot.csv
|- metrics_summary.json
|- visualizations/
`- npy/ # only when save_npy=true
Metrics
The benchmark reports:
snrpsnrssimmaemsermse
for three groups:
- noisy: noisy input vs clean target
- denoised: model prediction vs clean target
- delta:
denoised - noisy
Metrics are computed in the normalized domain. Saved visualization outputs are inverse-normalized back to the original amplitude domain.
Notes
- This benchmark injects synthetic random noise once per experiment before patch extraction; it is not an epoch-wise dynamic noise augmentation setup.
- Shot-level inference uses the held-out test shot defined by
inference.shot_split. - Batch size and patch size may need adjustment for memory-heavy models such as DnCNN and DDPM.
References
- Ronneberger et al., U-Net: Convolutional Networks for Biomedical Image Segmentation, MICCAI 2015
- He et al., Deep Residual Learning for Image Recognition, CVPR 2016
- Zhang et al., Beyond a Gaussian Denoiser: Residual Learning of Deep CNN for Image Denoising, IEEE TIP 2017
- Ho et al., Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models, NeurIPS 2020
- Song et al., Denoising Diffusion Implicit Models, ICLR 2021
- Oktay et al., Attention U-Net: Learning Where to Look for the Pancreas, MIDL 2018
- Gao et al., Swin Transformer for simultaneous denoising and interpolation of seismic data, Computers and Geosciences 2024
- SEG C3 Velocity Model: https://wiki.seg.org/wiki/C3
Results
Mean +- std over available seeds, computed from *_seed_stats/metrics_summary_mean_std.json.
Metrics are reported in the normalized domain. Raw (noisy) is the synthetic noisy input before denoising.
Gaussian Noise
SNR -5 dB
| Method | Parameters (M) | SNR | PSNR | SSIM | MAE | MSE | RMSE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_NE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_SNR | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_NE | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_SNR | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_NE | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_SNR | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_NE | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_SNR | FB_FRE_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_HIGH_SNR | FB_FRE_LOW_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_LOW_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_LOW_NE | FB_FRE_LOW_SNR | FB_FRE_MID_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_MID_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_MID_NE | FB_FRE_MID_SNR | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_SNR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raw (noisy) | - | -5.0000+-0.0015 | 28.4184+-0.0015 | 0.6663+-0.0002 | 0.030315+-0.000008 | 0.001448+-0.000001 | 0.037994+-0.000007 | 30.056404+-0.003195 | -29.5408+-0.0009 | 0.974550+-0.000441 | 0.2240+-0.0039 | 217.468024+-0.075775 | -46.7401+-0.0030 | 100.131537+-0.019746 | -39.9965+-0.0018 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 1.841567+-0.000122 | -5.2710+-0.0006 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 1.150310+-0.000255 | -1.2055+-0.0019 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 1.147630+-0.000330 | -1.1892+-0.0025 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 18.962028+-0.014011 | -25.2465+-0.0056 |
| UNet | 7.76 | 8.9440+-0.0034 | 42.3624+-0.0034 | 0.9807+-0.0000 | 0.004273+-0.000002 | 0.000058+-0.000000 | 0.007623+-0.000003 | 2.416080+-0.000817 | -7.6466+-0.0029 | 0.338792+-0.000149 | 9.4048+-0.0037 | 15.867472+-0.007823 | -23.9986+-0.0043 | 7.376587+-0.006652 | -17.3406+-0.0071 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 0.371155+-0.000550 | 8.6215+-0.0129 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 0.350323+-0.000279 | 9.1190+-0.0065 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 0.308464+-0.000132 | 10.2247+-0.0039 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 1.857709+-0.001298 | -5.2139+-0.0053 |
SNR 0 dB
| Method | Parameters (M) | SNR | PSNR | SSIM | MAE | MSE | RMSE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_NE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_SNR | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_NE | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_SNR | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_NE | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_SNR | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_NE | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_SNR | FB_FRE_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_HIGH_SNR | FB_FRE_LOW_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_LOW_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_LOW_NE | FB_FRE_LOW_SNR | FB_FRE_MID_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_MID_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_MID_NE | FB_FRE_MID_SNR | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_SNR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raw (noisy) | - | 0.0000+-0.0015 | 33.4184+-0.0015 | 0.8644+-0.0001 | 0.017047+-0.000004 | 0.000458+-0.000000 | 0.021365+-0.000004 | 16.901958+-0.001796 | -24.5408+-0.0009 | 0.548030+-0.000248 | 5.2240+-0.0039 | 122.291257+-0.042611 | -41.7401+-0.0030 | 56.308101+-0.011104 | -34.9965+-0.0018 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 1.035589+-0.000068 | -0.2710+-0.0006 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 0.646867+-0.000144 | 3.7945+-0.0019 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 0.645360+-0.000186 | 3.8108+-0.0025 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 10.663132+-0.007879 | -20.2465+-0.0056 |
| UNet | 7.76 | 10.5129+-0.0048 | 43.9313+-0.0048 | 0.9847+-0.0000 | 0.003534+-0.000002 | 0.000040+-0.000000 | 0.006361+-0.000003 | 1.862257+-0.001138 | -5.3904+-0.0051 | 0.285767+-0.000168 | 10.8867+-0.0049 | 11.745703+-0.009011 | -21.3908+-0.0068 | 5.497729+-0.002016 | -14.7914+-0.0029 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 0.295392+-0.000340 | 10.6085+-0.0097 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 0.298379+-0.000381 | 10.5175+-0.0108 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 0.250014+-0.000159 | 12.0534+-0.0055 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 1.658566+-0.001730 | -4.2297+-0.0092 |
SNR 5 dB
| Method | Parameters (M) | SNR | PSNR | SSIM | MAE | MSE | RMSE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_NE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_SNR | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_NE | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_SNR | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_NE | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_SNR | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_NE | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_SNR | FB_FRE_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_HIGH_SNR | FB_FRE_LOW_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_LOW_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_LOW_NE | FB_FRE_LOW_SNR | FB_FRE_MID_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_MID_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_MID_NE | FB_FRE_MID_SNR | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_SNR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raw (noisy) | - | 5.0000+-0.0015 | 38.4184+-0.0015 | 0.9528+-0.0000 | 0.009587+-0.000002 | 0.000145+-0.000000 | 0.012015+-0.000002 | 9.504669+-0.001010 | -19.5408+-0.0009 | 0.308180+-0.000139 | 10.2240+-0.0039 | 68.769427+-0.023962 | -36.7401+-0.0030 | 31.664372+-0.006244 | -29.9965+-0.0018 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 0.582355+-0.000039 | 4.7290+-0.0006 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 0.363760+-0.000081 | 8.7945+-0.0019 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 0.362912+-0.000104 | 8.8108+-0.0025 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 5.996320+-0.004431 | -15.2465+-0.0056 |
| UNet | 7.76 | 12.7151+-0.0046 | 46.1335+-0.0046 | 0.9911+-0.0000 | 0.002776+-0.000001 | 0.000024+-0.000000 | 0.004937+-0.000003 | 1.481680+-0.000344 | -3.4066+-0.0018 | 0.221581+-0.000125 | 13.0955+-0.0048 | 9.064477+-0.003318 | -19.1393+-0.0034 | 4.239337+-0.001748 | -12.5320+-0.0035 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 0.239064+-0.000116 | 12.4555+-0.0039 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 0.215258+-0.000339 | 13.3532+-0.0133 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 0.191701+-0.000072 | 14.3603+-0.0033 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 1.533126+-0.002486 | -3.5443+-0.0129 |
Poisson Noise
SNR -5 dB
| Method | Parameters (M) | SNR | PSNR | SSIM | MAE | MSE | RMSE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_NE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_SNR | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_NE | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_SNR | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_NE | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_SNR | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_NE | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_SNR | FB_FRE_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_HIGH_SNR | FB_FRE_LOW_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_LOW_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_LOW_NE | FB_FRE_LOW_SNR | FB_FRE_MID_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_MID_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_MID_NE | FB_FRE_MID_SNR | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_SNR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raw (noisy) | - | -4.9986+-0.0015 | 28.4198+-0.0015 | 0.6663+-0.0001 | 0.030308+-0.000004 | 0.001447+-0.000000 | 0.037988+-0.000007 | 30.055742+-0.008101 | -29.5406+-0.0024 | 0.974447+-0.000121 | 0.2249+-0.0011 | 217.357200+-0.102979 | -46.7357+-0.0040 | 100.096922+-0.017429 | -39.9936+-0.0012 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 1.841246+-0.000500 | -5.2697+-0.0024 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 1.149769+-0.000100 | -1.2014+-0.0009 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 1.147469+-0.000565 | -1.1882+-0.0043 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 18.965560+-0.004406 | -25.2484+-0.0018 |
| UNet | 7.76 | 8.9857+-0.0031 | 42.4041+-0.0031 | 0.9808+-0.0000 | 0.004256+-0.000000 | 0.000058+-0.000000 | 0.007587+-0.000003 | 2.415076+-0.002099 | -7.6446+-0.0074 | 0.337022+-0.000162 | 9.4499+-0.0042 | 15.838296+-0.020752 | -23.9837+-0.0112 | 7.364007+-0.012769 | -17.3268+-0.0150 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 0.369695+-0.000207 | 8.6562+-0.0048 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 0.346966+-0.000291 | 9.2024+-0.0073 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 0.307719+-0.000289 | 10.2453+-0.0085 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 1.854940+-0.000681 | -5.2019+-0.0030 |
SNR 0 dB
| Method | Parameters (M) | SNR | PSNR | SSIM | MAE | MSE | RMSE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_NE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_SNR | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_NE | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_SNR | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_NE | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_SNR | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_NE | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_SNR | FB_FRE_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_HIGH_SNR | FB_FRE_LOW_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_LOW_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_LOW_NE | FB_FRE_LOW_SNR | FB_FRE_MID_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_MID_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_MID_NE | FB_FRE_MID_SNR | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_SNR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raw (noisy) | - | 0.0023+-0.0012 | 33.4206+-0.0012 | 0.8645+-0.0000 | 0.017041+-0.000002 | 0.000458+-0.000000 | 0.021360+-0.000003 | 16.897970+-0.004420 | -24.5386+-0.0022 | 0.548122+-0.000078 | 5.2225+-0.0012 | 122.192401+-0.050008 | -41.7331+-0.0035 | 56.272479+-0.003774 | -34.9910+-0.0005 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 1.035247+-0.000049 | -0.2683+-0.0004 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 0.646679+-0.000100 | 3.7971+-0.0014 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 0.645245+-0.000461 | 3.8120+-0.0062 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 10.666173+-0.001591 | -20.2493+-0.0019 |
| UNet | 7.76 | 10.2685+-0.0045 | 43.6869+-0.0045 | 0.9836+-0.0000 | 0.003591+-0.000001 | 0.000043+-0.000000 | 0.006543+-0.000003 | 1.889969+-0.000705 | -5.5192+-0.0033 | 0.294167+-0.000159 | 10.6331+-0.0049 | 11.981634+-0.005965 | -21.5637+-0.0042 | 5.589865+-0.005678 | -14.9357+-0.0088 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 0.302042+-0.000172 | 10.4159+-0.0051 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 0.306526+-0.000292 | 10.2817+-0.0086 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 0.251918+-0.000122 | 11.9870+-0.0046 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 1.700620+-0.001753 | -4.4417+-0.0097 |
SNR 5 dB
| Method | Parameters (M) | SNR | PSNR | SSIM | MAE | MSE | RMSE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_NE | EB_WSE_MEDIUM_40_70_SNR | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_NE | EB_WSE_STRONG_70_100_SNR | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_NE | EB_WSE_VERY_WEAK_5_20_SNR | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_NE | EB_WSE_WEAK_20_40_SNR | FB_FRE_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_HIGH_SNR | FB_FRE_LOW_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_LOW_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_LOW_NE | FB_FRE_LOW_SNR | FB_FRE_MID_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_MID_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_MID_NE | FB_FRE_MID_SNR | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_ENERGY_RATIO | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_FREQUENCY_RANGE_HZ | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_NE | FB_FRE_VERY_HIGH_SNR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raw (noisy) | - | 5.0013+-0.0005 | 38.4197+-0.0005 | 0.9528+-0.0000 | 0.009585+-0.000001 | 0.000145+-0.000000 | 0.012013+-0.000001 | 9.502945+-0.000967 | -19.5391+-0.0007 | 0.308110+-0.000111 | 10.2259+-0.0031 | 68.744539+-0.029754 | -36.7371+-0.0038 | 31.665301+-0.014444 | -29.9967+-0.0040 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 0.582273+-0.000219 | 4.7300+-0.0031 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 0.363669+-0.000022 | 8.7967+-0.0007 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 0.362916+-0.000190 | 8.8104+-0.0045 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 5.996074+-0.000881 | -15.2461+-0.0005 |
| UNet | 7.76 | 12.6735+-0.0009 | 46.0919+-0.0009 | 0.9909+-0.0000 | 0.002779+-0.000000 | 0.000025+-0.000000 | 0.004961+-0.000001 | 1.481825+-0.000701 | -3.4074+-0.0040 | 0.222778+-0.000029 | 13.0481+-0.0011 | 9.008784+-0.003577 | -19.0862+-0.0034 | 4.219501+-0.002957 | -12.4921+-0.0066 | 0.168114+-0.000000 | 48.3333-73.5333 | 0.239523+-0.000217 | 12.4398+-0.0074 | 0.283209+-0.000000 | 6.3333-23.1333 | 0.216420+-0.000178 | 13.3066+-0.0068 | 0.425271+-0.000000 | 23.1333-48.3333 | 0.191949+-0.000036 | 14.3481+-0.0016 | 0.001317+-0.000000 | 73.5333-90.3333 | 1.547839+-0.002906 | -3.6236+-0.0174 |