AINativeBench / data /processed /RQ2 /ECDFs /Per_Project_Model_Comparison.md
王子睿
restructure + add files
f080257
|
Raw
History Blame
17.9 kB

Per-Project Model Performance Comparison

This document compares model performance within each of the 21 projects.

Each project shows:

  • Model statistics (mean)
  • Relative performance compared to the fastest model

All Projects Combined (Summary Across All Projects, by Model)

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
GPT-5 45.52
GPT-4o-mini 69.33
DeepSeek-V3-1 191.58
DeepSeek-R1 589.60
Gemini-2.5-flash 175.03
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 110.57
Qwen3-235b 307.27

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (45.52s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
GPT-5 45.52 +0.0%
GPT-4o-mini 69.33 +52.3%
DeepSeek-V3-1 191.58 +320.8%
DeepSeek-R1 589.60 +1195.1%
Gemini-2.5-flash 175.03 +284.5%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 110.57 +142.9%
Qwen3-235b 307.27 +574.9%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (589.60s mean, +1195.1% slower than baseline GPT-5)


BookWriter-A2A: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 961.15
DeepSeek-V3-1 443.80
GPT-4o-mini 101.15
GPT-5 193.58
Gemini-2.5-flash 240.55
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 133.91
Qwen3-235b 458.96

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-4o-mini (101.15s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 961.15 +850.2%
DeepSeek-V3-1 443.80 +338.8%
GPT-4o-mini 101.15 +0.0%
GPT-5 193.58 +91.4%
Gemini-2.5-flash 240.55 +137.8%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 133.91 +32.4%
Qwen3-235b 458.96 +353.7%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (961.15s mean, +850.2% slower than baseline GPT-4o-mini)


BookWriter-H_A2A: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 829.76
DeepSeek-V3-1 295.61
GPT-4o-mini 101.57
GPT-5 111.41
Gemini-2.5-flash 172.33
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 81.73
Qwen3-235b 256.93

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking (81.73s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 829.76 +915.2%
DeepSeek-V3-1 295.61 +261.7%
GPT-4o-mini 101.57 +24.3%
GPT-5 111.41 +36.3%
Gemini-2.5-flash 172.33 +110.8%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 81.73 +0.0%
Qwen3-235b 256.93 +214.4%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (829.76s mean, +915.2% slower than baseline Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking)


BookWriter-MCP: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 960.29
DeepSeek-V3-1 395.67
GPT-4o-mini 112.23
GPT-5 140.17
Gemini-2.5-flash 183.47
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 115.47
Qwen3-235b 442.38

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-4o-mini (112.23s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 960.29 +755.7%
DeepSeek-V3-1 395.67 +252.6%
GPT-4o-mini 112.23 +0.0%
GPT-5 140.17 +24.9%
Gemini-2.5-flash 183.47 +63.5%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 115.47 +2.9%
Qwen3-235b 442.38 +294.2%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (960.29s mean, +755.7% slower than baseline GPT-4o-mini)


EmailResponder: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 233.49
DeepSeek-V3-1 47.23
GPT-4o-mini 17.90
GPT-5 9.41
Gemini-2.5-flash 180.03
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 217.85
Qwen3-235b 37.41

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (9.41s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 233.49 +2380.4%
DeepSeek-V3-1 47.23 +401.8%
GPT-4o-mini 17.90 +90.1%
GPT-5 9.41 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 180.03 +1812.6%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 217.85 +2214.3%
Qwen3-235b 37.41 +297.4%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (233.49s mean, +2380.4% slower than baseline GPT-5)


EmailResponder-MCP: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 141.80
DeepSeek-V3-1 44.42
GPT-4o-mini 18.15
GPT-5 8.25
Gemini-2.5-flash 115.85
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 151.00
Qwen3-235b 38.30

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (8.25s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 141.80 +1618.6%
DeepSeek-V3-1 44.42 +438.4%
GPT-4o-mini 18.15 +119.9%
GPT-5 8.25 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 115.85 +1304.1%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 151.00 +1730.1%
Qwen3-235b 38.30 +364.2%

Slowest model: Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking (151.00s mean, +1730.1% slower than baseline GPT-5)


GameBuilder: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 914.94
DeepSeek-V3-1 518.26
GPT-4o-mini 94.49
GPT-5 45.35
Gemini-2.5-flash 163.51
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 169.19
Qwen3-235b 317.52

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (45.35s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 914.94 +1917.5%
DeepSeek-V3-1 518.26 +1042.8%
GPT-4o-mini 94.49 +108.4%
GPT-5 45.35 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 163.51 +260.6%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 169.19 +273.1%
Qwen3-235b 317.52 +600.1%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (914.94s mean, +1917.5% slower than baseline GPT-5)


GameBuilder-MCP: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 827.60
DeepSeek-V3-1 516.71
GPT-4o-mini 136.40
GPT-5 43.16
Gemini-2.5-flash 185.74
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 120.75
Qwen3-235b 316.86

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (43.16s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 827.60 +1817.7%
DeepSeek-V3-1 516.71 +1097.3%
GPT-4o-mini 136.40 +216.1%
GPT-5 43.16 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 185.74 +330.4%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 120.75 +179.8%
Qwen3-235b 316.86 +634.2%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (827.60s mean, +1817.7% slower than baseline GPT-5)


LandingPageGenerator-A2A: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 302.33
DeepSeek-V3-1 215.52
GPT-4o-mini 44.98
GPT-5 23.26
Gemini-2.5-flash 76.95
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 98.14
Qwen3-235b 208.99

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (23.26s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 302.33 +1199.6%
DeepSeek-V3-1 215.52 +826.5%
GPT-4o-mini 44.98 +93.3%
GPT-5 23.26 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 76.95 +230.8%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 98.14 +321.9%
Qwen3-235b 208.99 +798.4%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (302.33s mean, +1199.6% slower than baseline GPT-5)


LandingPageGenerator-H_A2A: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 283.59
DeepSeek-V3-1 234.43
GPT-4o-mini 41.31
GPT-5 30.31
Gemini-2.5-flash 73.92
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 47.47
Qwen3-235b 196.56

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (30.31s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 283.59 +835.7%
DeepSeek-V3-1 234.43 +673.5%
GPT-4o-mini 41.31 +36.3%
GPT-5 30.31 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 73.92 +143.9%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 47.47 +56.6%
Qwen3-235b 196.56 +548.5%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (283.59s mean, +835.7% slower than baseline GPT-5)


LandingPageGenerator-MCP: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 274.53
DeepSeek-V3-1 135.84
GPT-4o-mini 55.93
GPT-5 23.98
Gemini-2.5-flash 91.42
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 97.29
Qwen3-235b 92.07

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (23.98s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 274.53 +1044.7%
DeepSeek-V3-1 135.84 +466.4%
GPT-4o-mini 55.93 +133.2%
GPT-5 23.98 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 91.42 +281.2%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 97.29 +305.7%
Qwen3-235b 92.07 +283.9%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (274.53s mean, +1044.7% slower than baseline GPT-5)


MarkdownValidator: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 147.98
DeepSeek-V3-1 10.29
GPT-4o-mini 8.47
GPT-5 7.32
Gemini-2.5-flash 554.35
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 132.33
Qwen3-235b 9.54

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (7.32s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 147.98 +1922.0%
DeepSeek-V3-1 10.29 +40.6%
GPT-4o-mini 8.47 +15.8%
GPT-5 7.32 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 554.35 +7474.7%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 132.33 +1708.2%
Qwen3-235b 9.54 +30.3%

Slowest model: Gemini-2.5-flash (554.35s mean, +7474.7% slower than baseline GPT-5)


MarkdownValidator-MCP: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 129.20
DeepSeek-V3-1 10.69
GPT-4o-mini 3.58
GPT-5 2.98
Gemini-2.5-flash 457.36
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 168.14
Qwen3-235b 10.49

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (2.98s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 129.20 +4229.5%
DeepSeek-V3-1 10.69 +258.3%
GPT-4o-mini 3.58 +19.9%
GPT-5 2.98 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 457.36 +15225.7%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 168.14 +5534.3%
Qwen3-235b 10.49 +251.5%

Slowest model: Gemini-2.5-flash (457.36s mean, +15225.7% slower than baseline GPT-5)


RecruitmentAssistant-A2A: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 922.16
DeepSeek-V3-1 312.32
GPT-4o-mini 178.62
GPT-5 67.32
Gemini-2.5-flash 357.79
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 195.19
Qwen3-235b 1476.89

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (67.32s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 922.16 +1269.9%
DeepSeek-V3-1 312.32 +364.0%
GPT-4o-mini 178.62 +165.3%
GPT-5 67.32 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 357.79 +431.5%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 195.19 +190.0%
Qwen3-235b 1476.89 +2094.0%

Slowest model: Qwen3-235b (1476.89s mean, +2094.0% slower than baseline GPT-5)


RecruitmentAssistant-H_A2A: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 774.66
DeepSeek-V3-1 245.49
GPT-4o-mini 144.28
GPT-5 52.98
Gemini-2.5-flash 127.63
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 94.40
Qwen3-235b 973.11

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (52.98s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 774.66 +1362.1%
DeepSeek-V3-1 245.49 +363.3%
GPT-4o-mini 144.28 +172.3%
GPT-5 52.98 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 127.63 +140.9%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 94.40 +78.2%
Qwen3-235b 973.11 +1736.6%

Slowest model: Qwen3-235b (973.11s mean, +1736.6% slower than baseline GPT-5)


RecruitmentAssistant-MCP: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 839.96
DeepSeek-V3-1 339.42
GPT-4o-mini 129.31
GPT-5 59.50
Gemini-2.5-flash 201.33
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 163.09
Qwen3-235b 1381.73

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (59.50s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 839.96 +1311.7%
DeepSeek-V3-1 339.42 +470.4%
GPT-4o-mini 129.31 +117.3%
GPT-5 59.50 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 201.33 +238.4%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 163.09 +174.1%
Qwen3-235b 1381.73 +2222.2%

Slowest model: Qwen3-235b (1381.73s mean, +2222.2% slower than baseline GPT-5)


SQLAssistant-A2A: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 1130.69
DeepSeek-V3-1 161.80
GPT-4o-mini 33.96
GPT-5 21.10
Gemini-2.5-flash 151.07
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 68.41
Qwen3-235b 82.32

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (21.10s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 1130.69 +5258.1%
DeepSeek-V3-1 161.80 +666.7%
GPT-4o-mini 33.96 +60.9%
GPT-5 21.10 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 151.07 +615.9%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 68.41 +224.2%
Qwen3-235b 82.32 +290.1%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (1130.69s mean, +5258.1% slower than baseline GPT-5)


SQLAssistant-H_A2A: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 898.25
DeepSeek-V3-1 68.15
GPT-4o-mini 29.00
GPT-5 28.21
Gemini-2.5-flash 83.10
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 54.03
Qwen3-235b 69.68

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (28.21s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 898.25 +3083.7%
DeepSeek-V3-1 68.15 +141.6%
GPT-4o-mini 29.00 +2.8%
GPT-5 28.21 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 83.10 +194.5%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 54.03 +91.5%
Qwen3-235b 69.68 +147.0%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (898.25s mean, +3083.7% slower than baseline GPT-5)


SQLAssistant-MCP: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 941.69
DeepSeek-V3-1 112.55
GPT-4o-mini 48.84
GPT-5 26.09
Gemini-2.5-flash 104.38
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 46.95
Qwen3-235b 89.03

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (26.09s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 941.69 +3509.9%
DeepSeek-V3-1 112.55 +331.5%
GPT-4o-mini 48.84 +87.2%
GPT-5 26.09 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 104.38 +300.1%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 46.95 +80.0%
Qwen3-235b 89.03 +241.3%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (941.69s mean, +3509.9% slower than baseline GPT-5)


SocialMediaManager-A2A: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 557.94
DeepSeek-V3-1 158.60
GPT-4o-mini 87.89
GPT-5 41.51
Gemini-2.5-flash 65.45
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 40.70
Qwen3-235b 135.01

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking (40.70s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 557.94 +1271.0%
DeepSeek-V3-1 158.60 +289.7%
GPT-4o-mini 87.89 +116.0%
GPT-5 41.51 +2.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 65.45 +60.8%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 40.70 +0.0%
Qwen3-235b 135.01 +231.8%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (557.94s mean, +1271.0% slower than baseline Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking)


SocialMediaManager-H_A2A: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 427.00
DeepSeek-V3-1 111.56
GPT-4o-mini 46.16
GPT-5 27.98
Gemini-2.5-flash 65.04
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 29.03
Qwen3-235b 102.98

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): GPT-5 (27.98s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 427.00 +1426.0%
DeepSeek-V3-1 111.56 +298.7%
GPT-4o-mini 46.16 +65.0%
GPT-5 27.98 +0.0%
Gemini-2.5-flash 65.04 +132.4%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 29.03 +3.7%
Qwen3-235b 102.98 +268.0%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (427.00s mean, +1426.0% slower than baseline GPT-5)


SocialMediaManager-MCP: Model Comparison

Model Statistics Summary

Model Mean (s)
DeepSeek-R1 735.24
DeepSeek-V3-1 219.42
GPT-4o-mini 144.00
GPT-5 39.59
Gemini-2.5-flash 59.94
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 38.63
Qwen3-235b 126.60

Relative Performance (vs. Fastest Model)

Baseline (fastest): Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking (38.63s mean)

Model Mean (s) Slowdown vs Baseline
DeepSeek-R1 735.24 +1803.3%
DeepSeek-V3-1 219.42 +468.0%
GPT-4o-mini 144.00 +272.8%
GPT-5 39.59 +2.5%
Gemini-2.5-flash 59.94 +55.2%
Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking 38.63 +0.0%
Qwen3-235b 126.60 +227.7%

Slowest model: DeepSeek-R1 (735.24s mean, +1803.3% slower than baseline Gemini-2.5-flash-nothinking)