data/processed/RQ1/RadarCharts/Comparison_Powerful_vs_Lightweight.md

GPT-5 vs GPT-4o-mini (Powerful vs Lightweight)

Overall Summary (Averaged Across All Project Series)

Metric	GPT-5	GPT-4o-mini	Diff (A-B)
exact_match	0.29	0.31	-0.02
any_order_match	0.35	0.64	-0.28
precision	0.94	0.85	+0.09
recall	0.90	0.95	-0.05
retry_rate	0.10	0.10	-0.01
average_score	0.55	0.67	-0.13
pass_rate	0.60	0.59	+0.00

---

exact_match

Project Series	GPT-5	GPT-4o-mini	Diff (A-B)
BookWriter	0.00	0.00	+0.00
EmailResponder	0.01	0.43	-0.43
GameBuilder	1.00	0.88	+0.12
LandingPageGenerator	0.29	0.04	+0.26
MarkdownValidator	1.00	0.97	+0.03
RecruitmentAssistant	0.00	0.00	+0.00
SQLAssistant	0.00	0.00	+0.00
SocialMediaManager	0.02	0.12	-0.11

any_order_match

Project Series	GPT-5	GPT-4o-mini	Diff (A-B)
BookWriter	0.00	0.00	+0.00
EmailResponder	0.01	0.47	-0.47
GameBuilder	1.00	1.00	+0.00
LandingPageGenerator	0.42	0.98	-0.56
MarkdownValidator	1.00	1.00	+0.00
RecruitmentAssistant	0.00	0.70	-0.70
SQLAssistant	0.01	0.22	-0.21
SocialMediaManager	0.37	0.71	-0.34

precision

Project Series	GPT-5	GPT-4o-mini	Diff (A-B)
BookWriter	0.97	0.85	+0.12
EmailResponder	1.00	0.99	+0.01
GameBuilder	1.00	0.96	+0.04
LandingPageGenerator	0.86	0.78	+0.08
MarkdownValidator	1.00	0.99	+0.01
RecruitmentAssistant	0.98	0.76	+0.22
SQLAssistant	0.82	0.77	+0.05
SocialMediaManager	0.86	0.72	+0.14

recall

Project Series	GPT-5	GPT-4o-mini	Diff (A-B)
BookWriter	0.77	0.83	-0.06
EmailResponder	0.83	0.91	-0.08
GameBuilder	1.00	1.00	+0.00
LandingPageGenerator	0.97	1.00	-0.03
MarkdownValidator	1.00	1.00	+0.00
RecruitmentAssistant	0.90	0.98	-0.08
SQLAssistant	0.86	0.94	-0.08
SocialMediaManager	0.88	0.97	-0.10

retry_rate

Project Series	GPT-5	GPT-4o-mini	Diff (A-B)
BookWriter	0.00	0.00	+0.00
EmailResponder	0.00	0.00	+0.00
GameBuilder	0.00	0.00	+0.00
LandingPageGenerator	0.00	0.00	+0.00
MarkdownValidator	0.00	0.00	+0.00
RecruitmentAssistant	0.00	0.00	+0.00
SQLAssistant	0.44	0.37	+0.07
SocialMediaManager	0.34	0.47	-0.13

average_score

Project Series	GPT-5	GPT-4o-mini	Diff (A-B)
LandingPageGenerator	0.47	0.67	-0.20
MarkdownValidator	0.71	0.82	-0.11
SQLAssistant	0.45	0.52	-0.07

pass_rate

Project Series	GPT-5	GPT-4o-mini	Diff (A-B)
BookWriter	1.00	1.00	+0.00
EmailResponder	0.00	0.00	+0.00
GameBuilder	0.00	0.00	+0.00
RecruitmentAssistant	1.00	1.00	+0.00
SocialMediaManager	0.98	0.96	+0.02