Q
stringlengths
27
2.03k
A
stringlengths
4
2.98k
Result
stringclasses
3 values
Example 6.3 Let \( F = {\mathbb{F}}_{p} \) . A generator for \( {F}^{ * } \) is often called a primitive root modulo \( p \) . For example,2 is a primitive root modulo 5 . Moreover,2 is not a primitive root modulo 7, while 3 is a primitive root modulo 7 . In general, it is not easy to find a primitive root modulo \( p ...
Null
No
Corollary 6.4 If \( K/F \) is an extension of finite fields, then \( K \) is a simple extension of \( F \) .
Proof. By the previous corollary, the group \( {K}^{ * } \) is cyclic. Let \( \alpha \) be a generator of the cyclic group \( {K}^{ * } \) . Every nonzero element of \( K \) is a power of \( \alpha \) , so \( K = F\left( \alpha \right) \) . Therefore, \( K \) is a simple extension of \( F \) .
Yes
Theorem 6.5 Let \( F \) be a finite field with \( \operatorname{char}\left( F\right) = p \), and set \( \left| F\right| = {p}^{n} \) . Then \( F \) is the splitting field of the separable polynomial \( {x}^{{p}^{n}} - x \) over \( {\mathbb{F}}_{p} \) . Thus, \( F/{\mathbb{F}}_{p} \) is Galois. Furthermore, if \( \sigma...
Proof. Let \( \left| F\right| = {p}^{n} \), so \( \left| {F}^{ * }\right| = {p}^{n} - 1 \) . By Lagrange’s theorem, if \( a \in {F}^{ * } \) , then \( {a}^{{p}^{n} - 1} = 1 \) . Multiplying by \( a \) gives \( {a}^{{p}^{n}} = a \) . This equation also holds for \( a = 0 \) . Therefore, the elements of \( F \) are roots...
Yes
Corollary 6.6 Any two finite fields of the same size are isomorphic.
Proof. The proof of Theorem 6.5 shows that any two fields of order \( {p}^{n} \) are splitting fields over \( {\mathbb{F}}_{p} \) of \( {x}^{{p}^{n}} - x \), so the corollary follows from the isomorphic extension theorem.
Yes
Corollary 6.7 If \( K/F \) is an extension of finite fields, then \( K/F \) is Galois with a cyclic Galois group. Moreover, if \( \operatorname{char}\left( F\right) = p \) and \( \left| F\right| = {p}^{n} \), then \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \) is generated by the automorphism \( \tau \) defined by \( \tau...
Proof. Say \( \left\lbrack {K : {\mathbb{F}}_{p}}\right\rbrack = m \) . Then \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/{\mathbb{F}}_{p}}\right) \) is a cyclic group of order \( m \) by Theorem 6.5, so the order of the Frobenius automorphism \( \sigma \) of \( K \) is \( m \) . The group \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \)...
Yes
Theorem 6.8 Let \( N \) be an algebraic closure of \( {\mathbb{F}}_{p} \) . For any positive integer \( n \), there is a unique subfield of \( N \) of order \( {p}^{n} \) . If \( K \) and \( L \) are subfields of \( N \) of orders \( {p}^{m} \) and \( {p}^{n} \), respectively, then \( K \subseteq L \) if and only if \(...
Proof. Let \( n \) be a positive integer. The set of roots in \( N \) of the polynomial \( {x}^{{p}^{n}} - x \) has \( {p}^{n} \) elements and is a field. Thus, there is a subfield of \( N \) of order \( {p}^{n} \) . Since any two fields of order \( {p}^{n} \) in \( N \) are splitting fields of \( {x}^{{p}^{n}} - x \) ...
Yes
Corollary 6.9 Let \( F \) be a finite field, and let \( f\left( x\right) \) be a monic irreducible polynomial over \( F \) of degree \( n \) . 1. If \( a \) is a root of \( f \) in some extension field of \( F \), then \( F\left( a\right) \) is a splitting field for \( f \) over \( F \) . Consequently, if \( K \) is a ...
Proof. Let \( K \) be a splitting field of \( f \) over \( F \) . If \( a \in K \) is a root of \( f\left( x\right) \) , then \( F\left( a\right) \) is an \( n \) -dimensional extension of \( F \) inside \( K \) . By Theorem 6.5, \( F\left( a\right) \) is a Galois extension of \( F \) ; hence, \( f\left( x\right) = \mi...
Yes
Example 6.10 Let \( F = {\mathbb{F}}_{2} \) and \( K = F\left( \alpha \right) \), where \( \alpha \) is a root of \( f\left( x\right) = \) \( {x}^{3} + {x}^{2} + 1 \) . This polynomial has no roots in \( F \), as a quick calculation shows, so it is irreducible over \( F \) and \( \left\lbrack {K : F}\right\rbrack = 3 \...
Null
No
Example 6.11 Let \( F = {\mathbb{F}}_{2} \) and \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{4} + x + 1 \) . By the derivative test, we see that \( f \) has no repeated roots. The polynomial \( f \) is irreducible over \( f \), since \( f \) has no roots in \( F \) and is not divisible by the unique irreducible quadratic \( {x}^{2} + x ...
Null
No
Example 6.12 Let \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{2} + 1 \) . If \( p \) is an odd prime, then we show that \( f \) is reducible over \( F = {\mathbb{F}}_{p} \) if and only if \( p \equiv 1\left( {\;\operatorname{mod}\;4}\right) \) .
To prove this, if \( a \in F \) is a root of \( {x}^{2} + 1 \), then \( {a}^{2} = - 1 \), so \( a \) has order 4 in \( {F}^{ * } \) . By Lagrange’s theorem,4 divides \( \left| {F}^{ * }\right| = p - 1 \), so \( p \equiv 1\left( {\;\operatorname{mod}\;4}\right) \) . Conversely, if \( p \equiv 1\left( {\;\operatorname{mo...
Yes
Proposition 6.14 Let \( n \) be a positive integer. Then \( {x}^{{p}^{n}} - x \) factors over \( {\mathbb{F}}_{p} \) into the product of all monic irreducible polynomials over \( {\mathbb{F}}_{p} \) of degree a divisor of \( n \) .
Proof. Let \( F \) be a field of order \( {p}^{n} \) . Then \( F \) is the splitting field of \( {x}^{{p}^{n}} - x \) over \( {\mathbb{F}}_{p} \) by Theorem 6.5. Recall that \( F \) is exactly the set of roots of \( {x}^{{p}^{n}} - x \) . Let \( a \in F \), and set \( m = \left\lbrack {{\mathbb{F}}_{p}\left( a\right) :...
Yes
The monic irreducible polynomials of degree 5 over \( {\mathbb{F}}_{2} \) can be determined by factoring \( {x}^{{2}^{5}} - x \), which we see factors as
\[ {x}^{{2}^{5}} - x = x\left( {x + 1}\right) \left( {{x}^{5} + {x}^{3} + 1}\right) \left( {{x}^{5} + {x}^{2} + 1}\right) \times \left( {{x}^{5} + {x}^{4} + {x}^{3} + x + 1}\right) \left( {{x}^{5} + {x}^{4} + {x}^{2} + x + 1}\right) \times \left( {{x}^{5} + {x}^{4} + {x}^{3} + {x}^{2} + 1}\right) \left( {{x}^{5} + {x}^...
Yes
Proposition 7.2 Suppose that \( \operatorname{char}\left( F\right) \) does not divide \( n \), and let \( K \) be a splitting field of \( {x}^{n} - 1 \) over \( F \) . Then \( K/F \) is Galois, \( K = F\left( \omega \right) \) is generated by any primitive nth root of unity \( \omega \) , and \( \mathrm{{Gal}}\left( {K...
Proof. Since \( \operatorname{char}\left( F\right) \) does not divide \( n \), the derivative test shows that \( {x}^{n} - 1 \) is a separable polynomial over \( F \) . Therefore, \( K \) is both normal and separable over \( F \) ; hence, \( K \) is Galois over \( F \) . Let \( \omega \in K \) be a primitive \( n \) th...
Yes
The structure of \( F \) determines the degree \( \left\lbrack {F\left( \omega \right) : F}\right\rbrack \) or, equivalently, the size of \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {F\left( \omega \right) /F}\right) \) . For instance, let \( \omega = {e}^{{2\pi i}/8} \) be a primitive eighth root of unity in \( \mathbb{C} \) . Then \...
Null
No
Let \( F = {\mathbb{F}}_{2} \) . If \( \omega \) is a primitive third root of unity over \( F \) , then \( \omega \) is a root of \( {x}^{3} - 1 = \left( {x - 1}\right) \left( {{x}^{2} + x + 1}\right) \) . Since \( \omega \neq 1 \) and \( {x}^{2} + x + 1 \) is irreducible over \( F \), we have \( \left\lbrack {F\left( ...
Null
No
Lemma 7.6 Let \( n \) be any positive integer. Then \( {x}^{n} - 1 = \mathop{\prod }\limits_{{d \mid n}}{\Psi }_{d}\left( x\right) \) . Moreover, \( {\Psi }_{n}\left( x\right) \in \mathbb{Z}\left\lbrack x\right\rbrack \) .
Proof. We know that \( {x}^{n} - 1 = \prod \left( {x - \omega }\right) \), where \( \omega \) ranges over the set of all \( n \) th roots of unity. If \( d \) is the order of \( \omega \) in \( {\mathbb{C}}^{ * } \), then \( d \) divides \( n \), and \( \omega \) is a primitive \( d \) th root of unity. Gathering all t...
Yes
Corollary 7.8 If \( K \) is a splitting field of \( {x}^{n} - 1 \) over \( \mathbb{Q} \), then \( \left\lbrack {K : \mathbb{Q}}\right\rbrack = \) \( \phi \left( n\right) \) and \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/\mathbb{Q}}\right) \cong {\left( \mathbb{Z}/n\mathbb{Z}\right) }^{ * } \) . Moreover, if \( \omega \) is a primi...
Proof. The first part of the corollary follows immediately from Proposition 7.2 and Theorem 7.7. The description of \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/\mathbb{Q}}\right) \) is a consequence of the proof of Proposition 7.2.
No
Example 7.9 Let \( K = {\mathbb{Q}}_{7} \), and let \( \omega \) be a primitive seventh root of unity in \( \mathbb{C} \). By Corollary 7.8, \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/\mathbb{Q}}\right) \cong {\left( \mathbb{Z}/7\mathbb{Z}\right) }^{ * } \), which is a cyclic group of order 6. The Galois group of \( K/\mathbb{Q} \...
\[ \text{(id),}\left\langle {\sigma }_{3}^{3}\right\rangle ,\left\langle {\sigma }_{3}^{2}\right\rangle ,\left\langle {\sigma }_{3}\right\rangle \] whose orders are \( 1,2,3 \), and 6, respectively. Let us find the corresponding intermediate fields. If \( L = \mathcal{F}\left( {\sigma }_{3}^{3}\right) = \mathcal{F}\lef...
Yes
Example 7.10 Let \( K = {\mathbb{Q}}_{8} \), and let \( \omega = \exp \left( {{2\pi i}/8}\right) = \left( {1 + i}\right) /\sqrt{2} \) . The Galois group of \( K/\mathbb{Q} \) is \( \left\{ {{\sigma }_{1},{\sigma }_{3},{\sigma }_{5},{\sigma }_{7}}\right\} \), and note that each of the three nonidentity automorphisms of ...
Null
No
Example 8.2 Let \( F \) be any field, and let \( K = F\left( \sqrt{d}\right) \) for some \( d \in F - {F}^{2} \) . A convenient basis for \( K \) is \( \{ 1,\sqrt{d}\} \) . If \( \alpha = a + b\sqrt{d} \) with \( a, b \in F \), we determine the norm and trace of \( \alpha \) .
The linear transformation \( {L}_{\alpha } \) is equal to \( a{L}_{1} + b{L}_{\sqrt{d}} \), so we first need to find the matrix representations for \( {L}_{1} \) and \( {L}_{\sqrt{d}} \) . The identity transformation \( {L}_{1} \) has matrix \( \left( \begin{array}{ll} 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 \end{array}\right) \) . For \( {L}_...
Yes
Example 8.3 Let \( F = \mathbb{Q} \) and \( K = \mathbb{Q}\left( \sqrt[3]{2}\right) \) . We will determine the norm and trace of \( \sqrt[3]{2} \) . An \( F \) -basis for \( K \) is \( \{ 1,\sqrt[3]{2},\sqrt[3]{4}\} \) . We can check that \( {L}_{\sqrt[3]{2}}\left( 1\right) = \sqrt[3]{2},{L}_{\sqrt[3]{2}}\left( \sqrt[3...
\[ \left( \begin{array}{lll} 0 & 0 & 2 \\ 1 & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 & 0 \end{array}\right) ,\] so \( {N}_{K/F}\left( \sqrt[3]{2}\right) = 2 \) and \( {T}_{K/F}\left( \sqrt[3]{2}\right) = 0 \) .
Yes
Example 8.4 Let \( F \) be a field of characteristic \( p > 0 \), and let \( K/F \) be a purely inseparable extension of degree \( p \) . Say \( K = F\left( \alpha \right) \) with \( {\alpha }^{p} = \) \( a \in F \) . For instance, we could take \( K \) to be the rational function field \( k\left( x\right) \) over a fi...
Null
No
Lemma 8.5 Let \( K \) be a finite extension of \( F \) with \( n = \left\lbrack {K : F}\right\rbrack \) .\n\n1. If \( a \in K \), then \( {N}_{K/F}\left( a\right) \) and \( {T}_{K/F}\left( a\right) \) lie in \( F \) .\n\n2. The trace map \( {T}_{K/F} \) is an \( F \) -linear transformation.\n\n3. If \( \alpha \in F \),...
Proof. These properties all follow immediately from the definitions and properties of the determinant and trace functions.
No
Proposition 8.6 Let \( K \) be an extension of \( F \) with \( \left\lbrack {K : F}\right\rbrack = n \) . If \( a \in K \) and \( p\left( x\right) = {x}^{m} + {\alpha }_{m - 1}{x}^{m - 1} + \cdots + {\alpha }_{1}x + {\alpha }_{0} \) is the minimal polynomial of a over \( F \), then \( {N}_{K/F}\left( a\right) = {\left(...
Proof. Let \( \varphi : K \rightarrow {\operatorname{End}}_{F}\left( K\right) \) be the map \( \varphi \left( a\right) = {L}_{a} \) . It is easy to see that \( {L}_{a + b} = {L}_{a} + {L}_{b} \) and \( {L}_{ab} = {L}_{a} \circ {L}_{b} \), so \( \varphi \) is a ring homomorphism. Also, if \( \alpha \in F \) and \( a \in...
Yes
If \( F \) is any field and if \( K = F\left( \sqrt{d}\right) \) for some \( d \in F - {F}^{2} \), then a short calculation shows that the minimal polynomial of \( a + b\sqrt{d} \) is \( {x}^{2} - {2ax} + \left( {{a}^{2} - {b}^{2}d}\right) \).
Proposition 8.6 yields \( {N}_{K/F}\left( {a + b\sqrt{d}}\right) = {a}^{2} - {b}^{2}d \) and \( {T}_{K/F}\left( {a + b\sqrt{d}}\right) = {2a} \), as we had obtained before.
No
Example 8.8 If \( K \) is a purely inseparable extension of \( F \) of characteristic \( p \), then the minimal polynomial of any element of \( K \) is of the form \( {x}^{{p}^{n}} - a \) . From this, it follows that the trace of any element is zero.
Null
No
Lemma 8.9 Let \( K \) be a finite extension of \( F \), and let \( S \) be the separable closure of \( F \) in \( K \). Then \( \left\lbrack {S : F}\right\rbrack \) is equal to the number of \( F \)-homomorphisms from \( K \) to an algebraic closure of \( F \).
Proof. Let \( M \) be an algebraic closure of \( F \). We may assume that \( K \subseteq M \). If \( S \) is the separable closure of \( F \) in \( K \), then \( S = F\left( a\right) \) for some \( a \) by the primitive element theorem. If \( r = \left\lbrack {S : F}\right\rbrack \), then there are \( r \) distinct roo...
Yes
Lemma 8.10 Let \( K \) be a finite dimensional, purely inseparable extension of \( F \). If \( a \in K \), then \( {a}^{\left\lbrack K : F\right\rbrack } \in F \). More generally, if \( N \) is a finite dimensional, Galois extension of \( F \) and if \( a \in {NK} \), then \( {a}^{\left\lbrack K : F\right\rbrack } \in ...
Proof. Let \( K \) be purely inseparable over \( F \), and let \( n = \left\lbrack {K : F}\right\rbrack \). If \( a \in K \), then \( {a}^{\left\lbrack F\left( a\right) : F\right\rbrack } \in F \) by Lemma 4.16. Since \( \left\lbrack {F\left( a\right) : F}\right\rbrack \) divides \( n = \left\lbrack {K : F}\right\rbrac...
Yes
Lemma 8.11 Suppose that \( F \subseteq L \subseteq K \) are fields with \( \left\lbrack {K : F}\right\rbrack < \infty \) . Then \( {\left\lbrack K : F\right\rbrack }_{i} = {\left\lbrack K : L\right\rbrack }_{i} \cdot {\left\lbrack L : F\right\rbrack }_{i}.
Proof. Let \( {S}_{1} \) be the separable closure of \( F \) in \( L \), let \( {S}_{2} \) be the separable closure of \( L \) in \( K \), and let \( S \) be the separable closure of \( F \) in \( K \) . Since any element of \( K \) that is separable over \( F \) is also separable over \( L \), we see that \( S \subset...
Yes
Corollary 8.13 If \( K/F \) is Galois with Galois group \( G \), then for all \( a \in K \) , \[ {N}_{K/F}\left( a\right) = \mathop{\prod }\limits_{{\sigma \in G}}\sigma \left( a\right) \;\text{ and }\;{T}_{K/F}\left( a\right) = \mathop{\sum }\limits_{{\sigma \in G}}\sigma \left( a\right) . \]
Example 8.14 Let \( F \) be a field of characteristic not 2, and let \( K = F\left( \sqrt{d}\right) \) for some \( d \in F - {F}^{2} \) . Then \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) = \{ \mathrm{{id}},\sigma \} \), where \( \sigma \left( \sqrt{d}\right) = - \sqrt{d} \) . Therefore, \[ {N}_{K/F}\left( {a + b\sqrt{d}}\...
No
Example 8.14 Let \( F \) be a field of characteristic not 2, and let \( K = F\\left( \\sqrt{d}\\right) \) for some \( d \\in F - {F}^{2} \) . Then \( \\operatorname{Gal}\\left( {K/F}\\right) = \\{ \\mathrm{id},\\sigma \\} \), where \( \\sigma \\left( \\sqrt{d}\\right) = - \\sqrt{d} \) .
Therefore,\n\n\\[ \n{N}_{K/F}\\left( {a + b\\sqrt{d}}\\right) = \\left( {a + b\\sqrt{d}}\\right) \\left( {a - b\\sqrt{d}}\\right) = {a}^{2} - {b}^{2}d, \n\\]\n\n\\[ \n{T}_{K/F}\\left( {a + b\\sqrt{d}}\\right) = \\left( {a + b\\sqrt{d}}\\right) + \\left( {a - b\\sqrt{d}}\\right) = {2a}. \n\\]
No
Example 8.15 Suppose that \( F \) is a field containing a primitive \( n \) th root of unity \( \omega \), and let \( K \) be an extension of \( F \) of degree \( n \) with \( K = F\left( \alpha \right) \) and \( {\alpha }^{n} = a \in F \) . By the isomorphism extension theorem, there is an automorphism of \( K \) with...
\[ {N}_{K/F}\left( \alpha \right) = {\alpha \sigma }\left( \alpha \right) \cdots {\sigma }^{n - 1}\left( \alpha \right) = \alpha \cdot {\omega \alpha }\cdots {\omega }^{n - 1}\alpha \] \[ = {\omega }^{n\left( {n - 1}\right) /2}{\alpha }^{n} = {\left( -1\right) }^{n}a. \] If \( n \) is odd, then \( n\left( {n - 1}\right...
Yes
Theorem 8.16 If \( F \subseteq L \subseteq K \) are fields with \( \left\lbrack {K : F}\right\rbrack < \infty \), then\n\n\[ \n{N}_{K/F} = {N}_{L/F} \circ {N}_{K/L}\;\text{ and }\;{T}_{K/F} = {T}_{L/F} \circ {T}_{K/L};\n\]\n\nthat is, \( {N}_{K/F}\left( a\right) = {N}_{L/F}\left( {{N}_{K/L}\left( a\right) }\right) \) a...
Proof. Let \( M \) be an algebraic closure of \( F \), let \( {\sigma }_{1},\ldots ,{\sigma }_{r} \) be the distinct \( F \) -homomorphisms of \( L \) to \( M \), and let \( {\tau }_{1},\ldots ,{\tau }_{s} \) be the distinct \( L \) - homomorphisms of \( K \) to \( M \) . By the isomorphism extension theorem, we can ex...
Yes
Corollary 8.17 A finite extension \( K/F \) is separable if and only if \( {T}_{K/F} \) is not the zero map; that is, \( K/F \) is separable if and only if there is an \( a \in K \) with \( {T}_{K/F}\left( a\right) \neq 0 \) .
Proof. Suppose that \( K/F \) is not separable. Then \( \operatorname{char}\left( F\right) = p > 0 \) . Let \( S \) be the separable closure of \( F \) in \( K \) . Then \( S \neq K \) and \( K/S \) is a purely inseparable extension. Moreover, \( \left\lbrack {K : S}\right\rbrack = {p}^{t} \) for some \( t \geq 1 \) by...
Yes
Let \( F \) be a field of characteristic not 2, and let \( a \in {F}^{ * } - {F}^{*2} \). If \( K = F\\left( \\sqrt{a}\\right) \), then \( \\operatorname{Gal}\\left( {K/F}\\right) = \\{ \\mathrm{{id}},\\sigma \\} \) where \( \\sigma \\left( \\sqrt{a}\\right) = - \\sqrt{a} \). Thus, \( \\operatorname{Gal}\\left( {K/F}\\...
Null
No
Let \( \omega \) be a primitive fifth root of unity in \( \mathbb{C} \), let \( F = \mathbb{Q}\left( \omega \right) \) , and let \( K = F\left( \sqrt[5]{2}\right) \) . Then \( K \) is the splitting field of \( {x}^{5} - 2 \) over \( F \), so \( K \) is Galois over \( F \) . Also, \( \left\lbrack {F : \mathbb{Q}}\right\...
Let \( \alpha = \sqrt[5]{2} \) . The roots of \( \min \left( {F,\alpha }\right) \) are \( \alpha ,{\omega \alpha },{\omega }^{2}\alpha ,{\omega }^{3}\alpha \), and \( {\omega }^{4}\alpha \) . By the isomorphism extension theorem, there is a \( \sigma \in \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \) with \( \sigma \left( \a...
Yes
Lemma 9.4 Let \( F \) be a field containing a primitive nth root of unity \( \omega \) , let \( K/F \) be a cyclic extension of degree \( n \), and let \( \sigma \) be a generator of \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \) . Then there is an \( a \in K \) with \( \omega = \sigma \left( a\right) /a \) .
Proof. The automorphism \( \sigma \) is an \( F \) -linear transformation of \( K \) . We wish to find an \( a \in K \) with \( \sigma \left( a\right) = {\omega a} \) ; that is, we want to show that \( \omega \) is an eigenvalue for \( \sigma \) . To do this, we show that \( \omega \) is a root of the characteristic po...
Yes
Theorem 9.5 Let \( F \) be a field containing a primitive nth root of unity, and let \( K/F \) be a cyclic Galois extension of degree \( n \) . Then there is an \( a \in K \) with \( K = F\left( a\right) \) and \( {a}^{n} = b \in F \) ; that is, \( K = F\left( \sqrt[n]{b}\right) \) .
Proof. By the lemma, there is an \( a \) with \( \sigma \left( a\right) = {\omega a} \) . Therefore, \( {\sigma }^{i}\left( a\right) = {\omega }^{i}a \) , so \( a \) is fixed by \( {\sigma }^{i} \) only when \( n \) divides \( i \) . Since the order of \( \sigma \) is \( n \), we see that \( a \) is fixed only by id, s...
Yes
Corollary 9.7 Let \( K/F \) be a cyclic extension of degree \( n \), and suppose that \( F \) contains a primitive nth root of unity. If \( K = F\left( \sqrt[n]{a}\right) \) with \( a \in F \), then any intermediate field of \( K/F \) is of the form \( F\left( \sqrt[m]{a}\right) \) for some divisor \( m \) of \( n \).
Proof. Let \( \sigma \) be a generator for \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \). Then any subgroup of \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \) is of the form \( \left\langle {\sigma }^{t}\right\rangle \) for some divisor \( t \) of \( n \). By the fundamental theorem, the intermediate fields are the fixed fie...
Yes
Theorem 9.8 Let \( \operatorname{char}\left( F\right) = p \), and let \( K/F \) be a cyclic Galois extension of degree \( p \) . Then \( K = F\left( \alpha \right) \) with \( {\alpha }^{p} - \alpha - a = 0 \) for some \( a \in F \) ; that is, \( K = F\left( {{\wp }^{-1}\left( a\right) }\right) \) .
Proof. Let \( \sigma \) be a generator of \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \), and let \( T \) be the linear transformation \( T = \sigma - \mathrm{{id}} \) . The kernel of \( T \) is\n\n\[ \ker \left( T\right) = \{ b \in K : \sigma \left( b\right) = b\} \]\n\n\[ = F\text{.} \]\n\nAlso, \( {T}^{p} = {\left( \si...
Yes
Theorem 9.9 Let \( F \) be a field of characteristic \( p \), and let \( a \in F - {\wp }^{-1}\left( F\right) \) . Then \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{p} - x - a \) is irreducible over \( F \), and the splitting field of \( f \) over \( F \) is a cyclic Galois extension of \( F \) of degree \( p \) .
Proof. Let \( K \) be the splitting field of \( f \) over \( F \) . If \( \alpha \) is a root of \( f \), it is easy to check that \( \alpha + 1 \) is also a root of \( f \) . Hence, the \( p \) roots of \( f \) are \( \alpha ,\alpha + 1,\ldots ,\alpha + p - 1 \) . Therefore, \( K = F\left( \alpha \right) \) . The assu...
Yes
Example 9.10 Let \( F = {\mathbb{F}}_{p}\left( x\right) \) be the rational function field in one variable over \( {\mathbb{F}}_{p} \). We claim that \( x \notin {\wp }^{-1}\left( F\right) \), so the extension \( F\left( {{\wp }^{-1}\left( x\right) }\right) \) is a cyclic extension of \( F \) of degree \( p \). To prove...
To prove this, suppose instead that \( x \in {\wp }^{-1}\left( F\right) \), so \( x = {a}^{p} - a \) for some \( a \in F \). We can write \( a = f/g \) with \( f, g \in {\mathbb{F}}_{p}\left\lbrack x\right\rbrack \) relatively prime. Then \( x = {f}^{p}/{g}^{p} - f/g \), or \( {g}^{p}x = {f}^{p} - f{g}^{p - 1} \). Solv...
Yes
Proposition 10.1 Let \( K \) be a Galois extension of \( F \) with Galois group \( G \) , and let \( f : G \rightarrow {K}^{ * } \) be a crossed homomorphism. Then there is an \( a \in K \) with \( f\left( \tau \right) = \tau \left( a\right) /a \) for all \( \sigma \in G \) .
\( \\textbf{Proof. The Dedekind independence lemma shows that }\\mathop{\\sum }\\limits_{{\\sigma \\in G}}f\\left( \\sigma \\right) \\sigma \\left( c\\right) \\neq 0 \\) for some \( c \\in K \\), since each \( f\\left( \\sigma \\right) \\neq 0 \\) . Let \( b = \\mathop{\\sum }\\limits_{{\\sigma \\in G}}f\\left( \\sigma...
Yes
Theorem 10.2 (Hilbert Theorem 90) Let \( K/F \) be a cyclic Galois extension, and let \( \sigma \) be a generator of \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \). If \( u \in K \), then \( {N}_{K/F}\left( u\right) = 1 \) if and only if \( u = \sigma \left( a\right) /a \) for some \( a \in K \).
Proof. One direction is easy. If \( u = \sigma \left( a\right) /a \), then \( {N}_{K/F}\left( {\sigma \left( a\right) }\right) = {N}_{K/F}\left( a\right) \), so \( N\left( u\right) = 1 \). Conversely, if \( {N}_{K/F}\left( u\right) = 1 \), then define \( f : G \rightarrow {K}^{ * } \) by \( f\left( \mathrm{{id}}\right)...
Yes
Proposition 10.3 Let \( K/F \) be a Galois extension with Galois group \( G \) , and let \( g : G \rightarrow K \) be a 1-cocycle. Then there is an \( a \in K \) with \( g\left( \tau \right) = \) \( \tau \left( a\right) - a \) for all \( \tau \in G \) .
Proof. Since \( K/F \) is separable, the trace map \( {T}_{K/F} \) is not the zero map. Thus, there is a \( c \in K \) with \( {T}_{K/F}\left( c\right) \neq 0 \) . If \( \alpha = {T}_{K/F}\left( c\right) \), then \( \alpha \in {F}^{ * } \) and \( {T}_{K/F}\left( {{\alpha }^{-1}c}\right) = 1 \) . By replacing \( c \) wi...
Yes
Theorem 10.5 (Additive Hilbert Theorem 90) Let \( K \) be a cyclic Galois extension of \( F \), and let \( \sigma \) be a generator of \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \) . If \( u \in K \) , then \( {T}_{K/F}\left( u\right) = 0 \) if and only if \( u = \sigma \left( a\right) - a \) for some \( a \in K \) .
Proof. If \( u = \sigma \left( a\right) - a \), then \( {T}_{K/F}\left( u\right) = 0 \) . Conversely, suppose that \( {T}_{K/F}\left( u\right) = 0 \) . Let \( n = \left\lbrack {K : F}\right\rbrack \), and define \( g : G \rightarrow K \) by \( g\left( \mathrm{{id}}\right) = 0, g\left( \sigma \right) = \) \( u \), and f...
Yes
Theorem 10.5 (Additive Hilbert Theorem 90) Let \( K \) be a cyclic Galois extension of \( F \), and let \( \sigma \) be a generator of \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \) . If \( u \in K \) , then \( {T}_{K/F}\left( u\right) = 0 \) if and only if \( u = \sigma \left( a\right) - a \) for some \( a \in K \) .
Proof. If \( u = \sigma \left( a\right) - a \), then \( {T}_{K/F}\left( u\right) = 0 \) . Conversely, suppose that \( {T}_{K/F}\left( u\right) = 0 \) . Let \( n = \left\lbrack {K : F}\right\rbrack \), and define \( g : G \rightarrow K \) by \( g\left( \mathrm{{id}}\right) = 0, g\left( \sigma \right) = \) \( u \), and f...
Yes
Example 10.6 Let \( E = {S}_{3} \). If \( M = \langle \left( {123}\right) \rangle \), then \( M \) is isomorphic to \( \mathbb{Z}/3\mathbb{Z} \) and \( M \) is an Abelian normal subgroup of \( E \). The quotient group \( E/M \) is isomorphic to \( \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z} \). Therefore, \( {S}_{3} \) is a group extension...
Null
No
Example 10.7 Let \( E = {D}_{n} \), the dihedral group. One description of \( E \) is by generators and relations. The group \( E \) is generated by elements \( \sigma \) and \( \tau \) satisfying \( {\tau }^{n} = {\sigma }^{2} = e \) and \( {\sigma \tau \sigma } = {\tau }^{-1} \) . Let \( M = \langle \sigma \rangle \)...
Null
No
Let \( M \) and \( G \) be groups, and let \( \varphi : G \rightarrow \operatorname{End}\left( M\right) \) be a group homomorphism. If \( E \) is the semidirect product \( M{ \times }_{\varphi }G \), then \( {M}^{\prime } = \{ \left( {m, e}\right) : m \in M\} \) is a normal subgroup of \( E \) isomorphic to \( M \), an...
Null
No
Let \( {Q}_{8} \) be the quaternion group. Then \( {Q}_{8} = \) \( \{ \pm 1, \pm i, \pm j, \pm k\} \), and the operation on \( {Q}_{8} \) is given by the relations \( {i}^{2} = \) \( {j}^{2} = {k}^{2} = - 1 \) and \( {ij} = k = - {ji} \) . We show that \( {Q}_{8} \) is a group extension of \( M = \langle i\rangle \) by...
First note that \( M \) is an Abelian normal subgroup of \( {Q}_{8} \) and that \( {Q}_{8}/M \cong \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z} \) . Therefore, \( {Q}_{8} \) is a group extension of \( M \) by \( \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z} \) . We use 1 and \( j \) as coset representatives of \( M \) in \( {Q}_{8} \) . Our cocycle \( f \) that r...
Yes
Example 10.11 Let \( \mathbb{H} \) be Hamilton’s quaternions. The ring \( \mathbb{H} \) consists of all symbols \( a + {bi} + {cj} + {dk} \) with \( a, b, c, d \in \mathbb{R} \), and multiplication is given by the relations \( {i}^{2} = {j}^{2} = {k}^{2} = - 1 \) and \( {ij} = k = - {ji} \) . This was the first example...
\[ {x}_{\sigma }\left( {a + {bi}}\right) {x}_{\sigma }^{-1} = j\left( {a + {bi}}\right) {j}^{-1} = a - {bi} = \sigma \left( {a + {bi}}\right) . \] The cocycle \( f \) associated to this algebra is given by \[ f\left( {\mathrm{{id}},\mathrm{{id}}}\right) = {x}_{\mathrm{{id}}}{x}_{\mathrm{{id}}}{x}_{\mathrm{{id}}}^{-1} =...
Yes
Example 10.12 Let \( K/F \) be a Galois extension of degree \( n \) with Galois group \( G \), and consider the crossed product \( A = \left( {K/F, G,1}\right) \), where 1 represents the trivial cocycle. We will show that \( A \cong {M}_{n}\left( F\right) \), the ring of \( n \times n \) matrices over \( F \) .
First, note that \( A = { \oplus }_{\sigma \in G}K{x}_{\sigma } \), where multiplication on \( A \) is determined by the relations \( {x}_{\sigma }{x}_{\tau } = {x}_{\sigma \tau } \) and \( {x}_{\sigma }a = \sigma \left( a\right) {x}_{\sigma } \) for \( a \in K \) . If \( f = \sum {a}_{\sigma }{x}_{\sigma } \in A \), t...
Yes
If \( F \) is a field that contains a primitive \( n \) th root of unity, and if \( K/F \) is a cyclic extension of degree \( n \), then \( K/F \) is an \( n \) -Kummer extension. If \( F \) also contains a primitive \( m \) th root of unity for some \( m \) that is a multiple of \( n \), then \( K/F \) is also an \( m...
Null
No
Let \( K = \mathbb{Q}\left( {\sqrt{2},\sqrt{3}}\right) \). The field \( K \) is the splitting field of \( \left( {{x}^{2} - 2}\right) \left( {{x}^{2} - 3}\right) \) over \( \mathbb{Q} \), so \( K \) is a Galois extension of \( \mathbb{Q} \). A short calculation shows that \( \left\lbrack {K : \mathbb{Q}}\right\rbrack =...
\[ \text{id} : \sqrt{2} \rightarrow \sqrt{2},\;\sqrt{3} \rightarrow \sqrt{3}\text{,} \] \[ \sigma : \sqrt{2} \rightarrow - \sqrt{2},\;\sqrt{3} \rightarrow \sqrt{3} \] \[ \tau : \sqrt{2} \rightarrow \sqrt{2},\;\sqrt{3} \rightarrow - \sqrt{3} \] \[ {\sigma \tau } : \sqrt{2} \rightarrow - \sqrt{2},\;\sqrt{3} \rightarro...
Yes
If \( K = \mathbb{Q}\left( {\sqrt{{a}_{1}},\ldots ,\sqrt{{a}_{r}}}\right) \) for some \( {a}_{i} \in \mathbb{Q} \), then \( K/\mathbb{Q} \) is a 2-Kummer extension by Theorem 11.4. The degree of \( K/F \) is no larger than \( {2}^{r} \), but it may be less depending on the choice of the \( {a}_{i} \) .
Null
No
Example 11.6 Let \( F = \mathbb{Q}\left( i\right) \), where \( i = \sqrt{-1} \), and let \( K = F\left( {\sqrt[4]{12},\sqrt[4]{3}}\right) \) . Since \( i \) is a primitive fourth root of unity, \( K/F \) is a 4-Kummer extension. The degree of \( K/F \) is 8, not 16, since \( K = F\left( {\sqrt{2},\sqrt[4]{3}}\right) \)...
Null
No
Lemma 11.8 Let \( B : G \times H \rightarrow C \) be a bilinear pairing. If \( h \in H \), let \( {B}_{h} : G \rightarrow C \) be defined by \( {B}_{h}\left( g\right) = B\left( {g, h}\right) \) . Then the map \( \varphi : h \mapsto {B}_{h} \) is a group homomorphism from \( H \) to \( \hom \left( {G, C}\right) \) . If ...
Proof. The property \( B\left( {g,{h}_{1}{h}_{2}}\right) = B\left( {g,{h}_{1}}\right) B\left( {g,{h}_{2}}\right) \) translates to \( {B}_{{h}_{1}{h}_{2}} = \) \( {B}_{{h}_{1}}{B}_{{h}_{2}} \) . Thus, \( \varphi \left( {{h}_{1}{h}_{2}}\right) = \varphi \left( {h}_{1}\right) \varphi \left( {h}_{2}\right) \), so \( \varph...
Yes
Proposition 11.9 Let \( K \) be an \( n \) -Kummer extension of \( F \), and let \( B \) : \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \times \operatorname{kum}\left( {K/F}\right) \rightarrow \mu \left( F\right) \) be the associated Kummer pairing. Then \( B \) is nondegenerate. Consequently, \( \operatorname{kum}\left( {...
Proof. First, we show that \( B \) is a bilinear pairing. Let \( \sigma ,\tau \in \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \) and \( \alpha {F}^{ * } \in \operatorname{kum}\left( {K/F}\right) \) . Then\n\n\[ B\left( {{\sigma \tau },\alpha {F}^{ * }}\right) = \frac{{\sigma \tau }\left( \alpha \right) }{\alpha } = \frac{\si...
Yes
Proposition 11.10 Let \( K/F \) be an \( n \) -Kummer extension. Then there is an injective group homomorphism \( f : \operatorname{kum}\left( {K/F}\right) \rightarrow {F}^{ * }/{F}^{*n} \), given by \( f\left( {\alpha {F}^{ * }}\right) = {\alpha }^{n}{F}^{*n} \) . The image of \( f \) is then a finite subgroup of \( {...
Proof. It is easy to see that \( f \) is well defined and that \( f \) preserves multiplication. For injectivity, let \( \alpha {F}^{ * } \in \ker \left( f\right) \) . Then \( {\alpha }^{n} \in {F}^{*n} \), so \( {\alpha }^{n} = {a}^{n} \) for some \( a \in F \) . Hence, \( \alpha /a \) is an \( n \) th root of unity, ...
Yes
Example 11.11 Let \( F = \mathbb{C}\left( {x, y, z}\right) \) be the rational function field in three variables over \( \mathbb{C} \), and let \( K = F\left( {\sqrt[4]{xyz},\sqrt[4]{{y}^{2}z},\sqrt[4]{x{z}^{2}}}\right) \) . Then \( K/F \) is a 4- Kummer extension. The image of \( \operatorname{kum}\left( {K/F}\right) \...
The subgroup \( \langle a, b\rangle \) of \( {F}^{ * }/{F}^{*4} \) generated by \( a \) and \( b \) has order 16, since the 16 elements \( {a}^{i}{b}^{j} \) with \( 1 \leq i, j \leq 4 \) are all distinct. To see this, suppose that \( {a}^{i}{b}^{j} = {a}^{k}{b}^{l} \) . Then there is an \( h \in {F}^{ * } \) with\n\n\[...
Yes
Lemma 12.3 Let \( F \) be a field with \( \operatorname{char}\left( F\right) \neq 2 \), let \( f\left( x\right) \in F\left\lbrack x\right\rbrack \) be an irreducible, separable polynomial, and let \( K \) be the splitting field of \( f\left( x\right) \) over \( F \) . If \( \Delta \) is defined as in Definition 12.2, t...
Proof. Before we prove this, we note that the proof we give is the same as the typical proof that every permutation of \( {S}_{n} \) is either even or odd. In fact, the proof of this result about \( {S}_{n} \) is really about discriminants. It is easy to see that each \( \sigma \in G = \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\ri...
Yes
Corollary 12.4 Let \( F, K \), and \( f \) be as in Lemma 12.3, and let \( G = \) \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \) . Then \( G \subseteq {A}_{n} \) if and only if \( \operatorname{disc}\left( f\right) \in {F}^{2} \) . Under the correspondence of the fundamental theorem, the field \( F\left( \Delta \right) \s...
Proof. This follows from the lemma, since \( G \subseteq {A}_{n} \) if and only if each \( \sigma \in G \) is even, and this occurs if and only if \( \sigma \left( \Delta \right) = \Delta \) . Therefore, \( G \subseteq {A}_{n} \) if and only if \( \operatorname{disc}\left( f\right) \in {F}^{2} \) .
Yes
If \( K \) is a field and \( {\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n} \in K \), then the determinant of the Vandermonde matrix \( V\left( {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n}}\right) \) is \( \mathop{\prod }\limits_{{i < j}}\left( {{\alpha }_{j} - {\alpha }_{i}}\right) \).
Let \( A = V\left( {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n}}\right) \) . That \( \det \left( A\right) = \mathop{\prod }\limits_{{i < j}}\left( {{\alpha }_{j} - {\alpha }_{i}}\right) \) is a moderately standard fact from linear algebra. For those who have not seen this, we give a proof. Note that if \( {\alpha }_{i} = {\alp...
Yes
Proposition 12.6 (Newton’s Identities) Let \( f\left( x\right) = {a}_{0} + {a}_{1}x + \cdots + \) \( {a}_{n - 1}{x}^{n - 1} + {x}^{n} \) be a monic polynomial over \( F \) with roots \( {\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n} \) . If \( {t}_{i} = \mathop{\sum }\limits_{j}{\alpha }_{j}^{i}, \) then\n\n\[ \left. \begin{matri...
Proof. An alternative way of stating Newton's identities is to use the elementary symmetric functions \( {s}_{i} \) in the \( {a}_{i} \), instead of the \( {a}_{i} \) . Since \( {s}_{i} = \) \( {\left( -1\right) }^{i}{a}_{n - i} \), Newton’s identities can also be written as\n\n\[ {t}_{m} - {s}_{1}{t}_{m - 1} + {s}_{2}...
Yes
Example 12.7 Let \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{2} + {bx} + c \) . Then \( {t}_{0} = 2 \) . Also, Newton’s identities yield \( {t}_{1} + b = 0 \), so \( {t}_{1} = - b \) . For \( {t}_{2} \), we have \( {t}_{2} + b{t}_{1} + {2c} = 0 \), so \( {t}_{2} = - b{t}_{1} - {2c} = {b}^{2} - {2c} \) .
Therefore,\n\n\[\n\operatorname{disc}\left( f\right) = \left| \begin{matrix} 2 & - b \\ - b & {b}^{2} - {2c} \end{matrix}\right| = 2\left( {{b}^{2} - {2c}}\right) - {b}^{2} = {b}^{2} - {4c}\n\]\n\nthe usual discriminant of a monic quadratic.
Yes
Example 12.8 Let \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{3} + {px} + q \) . Then \( {a}_{0} = q,{a}_{1} = p \), and \( {a}_{2} = 0 \) , so by Newton's identities we get\n\n\[ \n{t}_{1} = 0 \]\n\n\[ \n{t}_{2} = - {2p} \]\n\n\[ \n{t}_{3} = - {3q} \]\n\n\[ \n{t}_{4} = 2{p}^{2} \]\n\nTherefore\n\n\[ \n\operatorname{disc}\left( f\right)...
Null
No
Proposition 12.9 Let \( L = F\left( \alpha \right) \) be a field extension of \( F \) . If \( f\left( x\right) = \) \( \min \left( {F,\alpha }\right) \), then \( \operatorname{disc}\left( f\right) = {\left( -1\right) }^{n\left( {n - 1}\right) /2}{N}_{L/F}\left( {{f}^{\prime }\left( \alpha \right) }\right) \), where \( ...
Proof. Let \( K \) be a splitting field for \( f \) over \( F \), and write \( f\left( x\right) = (x - \) \( \left. {\alpha }_{1}\right) \cdots \left( {x - {\alpha }_{n}}\right) \in K\left\lbrack x\right\rbrack \) . Set \( \alpha = {\alpha }_{1} \) . Then a short calculation shows that \( {f}^{\prime }\left( {\alpha }_...
Yes
Example 12.10 Let \( p \) be an odd prime, and let \( \omega \) be a primitive \( p \) th root of unity in \( \mathbb{C} \) . We use the previous result to determine \( \operatorname{disc}\left( \omega \right) \) . Let \( K = \) \( \mathbb{Q}\left( \omega \right) \), the \( p \) th cyclotomic extension of \( \mathbb{Q}...
First,\n\n\[ \n{f}^{\prime }\left( x\right) = \frac{p{x}^{p - 1}\left( {x - 1}\right) - \left( {{x}^{p} - 1}\right) }{{\left( x - 1\right) }^{2}} \n\]\n\nso \( {f}^{\prime }\left( \omega \right) = p{\omega }^{p - 1}/\left( {\omega - 1}\right) \) . We claim that \( {N}_{K/\mathbb{Q}}\left( \omega \right) = 1 \) and \( {...
Yes
Lemma 12.12 Let \( K \) be a separable field extension of \( F \) of degree \( n \), and let \( {\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n} \in K \) . Then \( \operatorname{disc}\left( {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n}}\right) = \det \left( {{\operatorname{Tr}}_{K/F}\left( {{\alpha }_{i}{\alpha }_{j}}\right) }\right) \) . C...
Proof. Let \( {\sigma }_{1},\ldots ,{\sigma }_{n} \) be the distinct \( F \) -homomorphisms from \( K \) to an algebraic closure of \( F \) . If \( A = \left( {{\sigma }_{i}\left( {\alpha }_{j}\right) }\right) \), then the discriminant of the \( n \) - tuple \( {\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n} \) is the determinant ...
Yes
Proposition 12.13 Let \( K \) be a separable field extension of \( F \) of degree \( n \) , and let \( {\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n} \in K \) . Then \( \operatorname{disc}\left( {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n}}\right) = 0 \) if and only if \( {\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n} \) are linearly dependent over...
Proof. Suppose that the \( {\alpha }_{i} \) are linearly dependent over \( F \) . Then one of the \( {\alpha }_{i} \) is an \( F \) -linear combination of the others. If \( {\alpha }_{i} = \mathop{\sum }\limits_{{k \neq i}}{a}_{k}{\alpha }_{k} \) with \( {a}_{j} \in F \), then\n\n\[ \n{\operatorname{Tr}}_{K/F}\left( {{...
Yes
Proposition 12.14 Let \( \left\{ {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{n}}\right\} \) and \( \left\{ {{\beta }_{1},\ldots ,{\beta }_{n}}\right\} \) be two \( F \) -bases for \( K \) . Let \( A = \left( {a}_{ij}\right) \) be the \( n \times n \) transition matrix between the two bases; that \( {is},\;{\beta }_{j} = \mathop{...
Proof. Since \( {\beta }_{j} = \mathop{\sum }\limits_{k}{a}_{kj}{\alpha }_{k} \), we have \( {\sigma }_{i}\left( {\beta }_{j}\right) = \mathop{\sum }\limits_{k}{a}_{kj}{\sigma }_{i}\left( {\alpha }_{k}\right) \) . In terms of matrices, this says that\n\n\[ \left( {{\sigma }_{i}\left( {\beta }_{j}\right) }\right) = {\le...
Yes
In this example, we show that the discriminant of a polynomial is equal to the discriminant of an appropriate field extension. Suppose that \( K = F\left( \alpha \right) \) is an extension of \( F \) of degree \( n \) . Then \( 1,\alpha \) , \( {\alpha }^{2},\ldots ,{\alpha }^{n - 1} \) is a basis for \( K \) . We calc...
We have \( \operatorname{disc}\left( {K/F}\right) = \det {\left( {\sigma }_{i}\left( {\alpha }^{j - 1}\right) \right) }^{2} \) . Consequently, if \( {\alpha }_{i} = {\sigma }_{i}\left( \alpha \right) \) , then\n\n\[ \operatorname{disc}\left( {K/F}\right) = \det {\left( \begin{matrix} 1 & {\sigma }_{1}\left( \alpha \rig...
Yes
Example 12.16 Let \( K = \mathbb{Q}\left( \sqrt{-1}\right) \). If \( i = \sqrt{-1} \), then using the basis \( 1, i \) of \( K/\mathbb{Q} \), we get
\[ \operatorname{disc}\left( {\mathbb{Q}\left( i\right) /\mathbb{Q}}\right) = \det {\left( \begin{matrix} 1 & i \\ 1 & - i \end{matrix}\right) }^{2} = {\left( -2i\right) }^{2} = - 4. \]
Yes
We now show that the discriminant of a field extension is the discriminant of the trace form. Let \( K \) be a finite separable extension of \( F \) . Let \( B : K \times K \rightarrow F \) be defined by \( B\left( {a, b}\right) = {T}_{K/F}\left( {ab}\right) \) . Then \( B \) is a bilinear form because the trace is lin...
But, by Lemma 12.12, this is the discriminant of \( K/F \) . Therefore, the previous notions of discriminant are special cases of the notion of discriminant of a bilinear form.
No
Theorem 13.1 Let \( f\left( x\right) \in F\left\lbrack x\right\rbrack \) be an irreducible, separable polynomial of degree 3 over \( F \), and let \( K \) be the splitting field of \( f \) over \( F \) . If \( D \) is the discriminant of \( f \), then \( \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \cong {S}_{3} \) if and onl...
Proof. Let \( G = \operatorname{Gal}\left( {K/F}\right) \) . By Corollary \( {12.4}, G \subseteq {A}_{3} \) if and only if \( D \in {F}^{2} \) . But \( G \cong {S}_{3} \) or \( G \cong {A}_{3} \), so \( G \cong {S}_{3} \) if and only if \( D \) is a square in \( F \) .
Yes
The polynomial \( {x}^{3} - {3x} + 1 \in \mathbb{Q}\left\lbrack x\right\rbrack \) has discriminant \( {81} = \) \( {9}^{2} \), and it is irreducible over \( \mathbb{Q} \) by an application of the rational root test. Thus, the Galois group of its splitting field over \( \mathbb{Q} \) is \( {A}_{3} \) .
Null
No
Consider \( {x}^{3} - {3x} + 1 \) . Then \( \Gamma = - D/{108} = - {81}/{108} = \) \( - 3/4 \) . We have \( p = - 3 \) and \( q = 1 \) . Then \( A = - 1/2 + i\sqrt{3}/2 \) and \( B = - 1/2 - i\sqrt{3}/2 \), so \( A = \exp \left( {{2\pi i}/3}\right) \) and \( B = \exp \left( {-{2\pi i}/3}\right) \) . We can then set \( ...
Suppose that the polynomial \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{3} + {px} + q \) has real coefficients. If \( \Gamma > 0 \), then \( D < 0 \), so \( D \) is not a square in \( F \) . We can then take the real cube roots of \( A \) and \( B \) for \( u \) and \( v \) . Furthermore, if \( \omega = \left( {-1 + i\sqrt{3}}\right) /...
Yes
Theorem 13.4 With the notation above, let \( m = \left\lbrack {L : F}\right\rbrack \) . 1. \( G \cong {S}_{4} \) if and only if \( r\left( x\right) \) is irreducible over \( F \) and \( D \notin {F}^{2} \), if and only if \( m = 6 \) .
Proof. We first point out a couple of things. First, \( \left\lbrack {K : L}\right\rbrack \leq 4 \), since \( K = L\left( {\alpha }_{1}\right) \) . This equality follows from the fundamental theorem, since only the identity automorphism fixes \( L\left( {\alpha }_{1}\right) \) . Second, \( r\left( x\right) \) is irredu...
Yes
Example 13.5 Let \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{4} + {x}^{3} + {x}^{2} + x + 1 \) . Then \( a = b = c = d = 1 \) , so \( {s}_{1} = {s}_{3} = - 1 \) and \( {s}_{2} = {s}_{4} = 1 \) . Also,\n\n\[ r\left( x\right) = {x}_{3} - {x}_{2} - {3x} + 2 = \left( {x - 2}\right) \left( {{x}^{2} + x - 1}\right) . \]
Set \( {\beta }_{1} = 2 \) . Then \( u = \sqrt{5} \) . Also,\n\n\[ {v}^{2} = \frac{1}{4}{\left( -1 + u\right) }^{2} - 2\left( {2 + {u}^{-1}\left( {-2 + 2}\right) }\right) \]\n\n\[ = \frac{1}{4}\left( {{u}^{2} - {2u} + 1}\right) - 4 = - \frac{5 + u}{2}. \]\n\nThus, \( v = \frac{i}{2}\sqrt{{10} - 2\sqrt{5}} \) . In addit...
Yes
Example 13.6 Let \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{4} - 4{x}^{3} + 4{x}^{2} + 6 \) . This polynomial is irreducible by the Eisenstein criterion. Now,\n\n\[ r\left( x\right) = {x}^{3} - 4{x}^{2} - {24x} = x\left( {{x}^{2} - {4x} - {24}}\right) ,\] \n\nso \( L = \mathbb{Q}\left( \sqrt{7}\right) \) . Take \( {\beta }_{1} = 0 \) ...
Null
No
Example 13.7 Let \( p \) be a prime, and let \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{4} + {px} + p \) . Then \( r\left( x\right) = {x}^{3} - {4px} - {p}^{2} \) . To test for roots of \( r\left( x\right) \) in \( \mathbb{Q} \), we only need to check \( \pm 1, \pm p, \pm {p}^{2} \) . We see that \( \pm 1 \) and \( \pm {p}^{2} \) are ...
Null
No
Example 13.8 Let \( l \in \mathbb{Q} \), and let \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{4} - l \) . Then the resolvent of \( f \) is \( r\left( x\right) = {x}^{3} + {4lx} = x\left( {{x}^{2} + {4l}}\right) \) . If \( - l \) is not a square in \( \mathbb{Q} \), then \( r\left( x\right) \) has exactly one root in \( \mathbb{Q} \) . M...
Null
No
Theorem 14.1 (Lindemann-Weierstrauss) Let \( {\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{m} \) be distinct algebraic numbers. Then the exponentials \( {e}^{{\alpha }_{1}},\ldots ,{e}^{{\alpha }_{m}} \) are linearly independent over \( \mathbb{Q} \) .
Proof of the theorem. Suppose that there are \( {a}_{j} \in \mathbb{Q} \) with\n\n\[ \mathop{\sum }\limits_{{j = 1}}^{m}{a}_{j}{e}^{{\alpha }_{j}} = 0 \]\n\nBy multiplying by a suitable integer, we may assume that each \( {a}_{j} \in \mathbb{Z} \) . Moreover, by eliminating terms if necessary, we may also assume that e...
Yes
Corollary 14.2 The numbers \( \pi \) and \( e \) are transcendental over \( \mathbb{Q} \) .
Proof of the corollary. Suppose that \( e \) is algebraic over \( \mathbb{Q} \) . Then there are rationals \( {r}_{i} \) with \( \mathop{\sum }\limits_{{i = 0}}^{n}{r}_{i}{e}^{i} = 0 \) . This means that the numbers \( {e}^{0} \) , \( {e}^{1},\ldots ,{e}^{n - 1} \) are linearly dependent over \( \mathbb{Q} \) . By choo...
Yes
Lemma 15.1 Let \( K \) be a subfield of \( \mathbb{R} \) .\n\n1. The intersection of two lines in \( K \) is either empty or is a point in the plane of \( K \) .\n\n2. The intersection of a line and a circle in \( K \) is either empty or consists of one or two points in the plane of \( K\left( \sqrt{u}\right) \) for so...
Proof. The first statement is an easy calculation. For the remaining two statements, it suffices to prove statement 2, since if \( {x}^{2} + {y}^{2} + {ax} + {by} + c = 0 \) and \( {x}^{2} + {y}^{2} + {a}^{\prime }x + {b}^{\prime }y + {c}^{\prime } = 0 \) are the equations of circles \( C \) and \( {C}^{\prime } \) , r...
Yes
Theorem 15.2 A real number \( c \) is constructible if and only if there is a tower of fields \( \mathbb{Q} = {K}_{0} \subseteq {K}_{1} \subseteq \cdots \subseteq {K}_{r} \) such that \( c \in {K}_{r} \) and \( \left\lbrack {{K}_{i + 1} : }\right. \) \( \left. {K}_{i}\right\rbrack \leq 2 \) for each \( i \) . Therefore...
Proof. If \( c \) is constructible, then the point \( \left( {c,0}\right) \) can be obtained from a finite sequence of constructions starting from the plane of \( \mathbb{Q} \) . We then obtain a finite sequence of points, each an intersection of constructible lines and circles, ending at \( \left( {c,0}\right) \) . By...
Yes
Theorem 15.3 It is impossible to trisect a \( {60}^{ \circ } \) angle by ruler and compass construction.
Proof. As noted above, a \( {60}^{ \circ } \) angle can be constructed. If a \( {60}^{ \circ } \) angle can be trisected, then it is possible to construct the number \( \alpha = \cos {20}^{ \circ } \) . However, the triple angle formula \( \cos {3\theta } = 4{\cos }^{3}\theta - 3\cos \theta \) gives \( 4{\alpha }^{3} -...
Yes
Theorem 15.4 It is impossible to double a cube of length 1 by ruler and compass construction.
Proof. The length of a side of a cube of volume 2 is \( \sqrt[3]{2} \) . The minimal polynomial of \( \sqrt[3]{2} \) over \( \mathbb{Q} \) is \( {x}^{3} - 2 \) . Thus, \( \left\lbrack {\mathbb{Q}\left( \sqrt[3]{2}\right) : \mathbb{Q}}\right\rbrack = 3 \) is not a power of 2, so \( \sqrt[3]{2} \) is not constructible.
Yes
Theorem 15.5 It is impossible to square a circle of radius 1.
Proof. We are asking whether we can construct a square of area \( \pi \) . To do so requires us to construct a line segment of length \( \sqrt{\pi } \), which is impossible since \( \sqrt{\pi } \) is transcendental over \( \mathbb{Q} \) by the Lindemann-Weierstrauss theorem; hence, \( \sqrt{\pi } \) is not algebraic of...
Yes
Theorem 15.6 A regular \( n \) -gon is constructible if and only if \( \phi \left( n\right) \) is a power of \( 2 \) .
Proof. We point out that a regular \( n \) -gon is constructible if and only if the central angles \( {2\pi }/n \) are constructible, and this occurs if and only if \( \cos \left( {{2\pi }/n}\right) \) is a constructible number. Let \( \omega = {e}^{{2\pi i}/n} = \cos \left( {{2\pi }/n}\right) + \) \( i\sin \left( {{2\...
Yes
Lemma 16.6 Let \( K \) be an \( n \)-radical extension of \( F \), and let \( N \) be the normal closure of \( K/F \). Then \( N \) is an \( n \)-radical extension of \( F \).
Proof. Let \( K = F\left( {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{r}}\right) \) with \( {\alpha }_{i}^{n} \in F\left( {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{i - 1}}\right) \). We argue by induction on \( r \). If \( r = 1 \), then \( K = F\left( \alpha \right) \) with \( {\alpha }^{n} = a \in F \). Then \( N = F\left( {{\beta }_{...
Yes
Example 16.4 If \( K = \mathbb{Q}\left( \sqrt[4]{2}\right) \), then \( K \) is both a 4-radical extension and a 2-radical extension of \( \mathbb{Q} \).
The second statement is true by considering the tower\n\n\[\n\mathbb{Q} \subseteq \mathbb{Q}\left( \sqrt{2}\right) \subseteq \mathbb{Q}\left( \sqrt{2}\right) \left( \sqrt{\sqrt{2}}\right) = \mathbb{Q}\left( \sqrt[4]{2}\right)\n\]
No
Lemma 16.6 Let \( K \) be an \( n \) -radical extension of \( F \), and let \( N \) be the normal closure of \( K/F \) . Then \( N \) is an \( n \) -radical extension of \( F \) .
Proof. Let \( K = F\left( {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{r}}\right) \) with \( {\alpha }_{i}^{n} \in F\left( {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{i - 1}}\right) \) . We argue by induction on \( r \) . If \( r = 1 \), then \( K = F\left( \alpha \right) \) with \( {\alpha }^{n} = a \in F \) . Then \( N = F\left( {{\beta ...
Yes
Lemma 16.6 Let \( K \) be an \( n \) -radical extension of \( F \), and let \( N \) be the normal closure of \( K/F \) . Then \( N \) is an \( n \) -radical extension of \( F \) .
Proof. Let \( K = F\left( {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{r}}\right) \) with \( {\alpha }_{i}^{n} \in F\left( {{\alpha }_{1},\ldots ,{\alpha }_{i - 1}}\right) \) . We argue by induction on \( r \) . If \( r = 1 \), then \( K = F\left( \alpha \right) \) with \( {\alpha }^{n} = a \in F \) . Then \( N = F\left( {{\beta ...
Yes
Proposition 16.8 Let \( G \) be a group and \( N \) be a normal subgroup of \( G \) . Then \( G \) is solvable if and only if \( N \) and \( G/N \) are solvable.
Null
No
Proposition 16.9 If \( n \geq 5 \), then \( {S}_{n} \) is not solvable.
Null
No
Corollary 16.11 Let \( f\left( x\right) \) be the general \( n \) th degree polynomial over a field of characteristic 0 . If \( n \geq 5 \), then \( f \) is not solvable by radicals.
Example 16.12 Let \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{5} - {4x} + 2 \in \mathbb{Q}\left\lbrack x\right\rbrack \) . By graphing techniques of calculus, we see that this polynomial has exactly two nonreal roots, as indicated in the graph below.\n\n![a19d421a-26e3-4457-9540-b27494dac6ed_168_0.jpg](images/a19d421a-26e3-4457-9540-b2...
No
Example 16.12 Let \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{5} - {4x} + 2 \in \mathbb{Q}\left\lbrack x\right\rbrack \) . By graphing techniques of calculus, we see that this polynomial has exactly two nonreal roots, as indicated in the graph below.
Furthermore, \( f \) is irreducible over \( \mathbb{Q} \) by the Eisenstein criterion. Let \( K \) be the splitting field of \( f \) over \( \mathbb{Q} \) . Then \( \left\lbrack {K : \mathbb{Q}}\right\rbrack \) is a multiple of 5, since any root of \( f \) generates a field of dimension 5 over \( \mathbb{Q} \) . Let \(...
Yes
Let \( f\left( x\right) = {x}^{3} - {3x} + 1 \in \mathbb{Q}\left\lbrack x\right\rbrack \), and let \( K \) be the splitting field of \( f \) over \( \mathbb{Q} \). We show that \( f \) is solvable by radicals but that \( K \) is not a radical extension of \( \mathbb{Q} \).
Since \( f \) has no roots in \( \mathbb{Q} \) and \( \deg \left( f\right) = 3 \), the polynomial \( f \) is irreducible over \( \mathbb{Q} \). The discriminant of \( f \) is \( {81} = {9}^{2} \), so the Galois group of \( K/\mathbb{Q} \) is \( {A}_{3} \) and \( \left\lbrack {K : \mathbb{Q}}\right\rbrack = 3 \), by Cor...
Yes