mvr-bench / README.md
AfricanMarket's picture
Correct authored fixture and license boundaries
435e9bb verified
|
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
10 kB
---
pretty_name: MVR-Bench
license: other
language:
- en
task_categories:
- text-classification
tags:
- evaluation
- benchmark
- agent-evaluation
- abstention
- responsible-ai
- market-entry
- african-markets
- emerging-markets
- relational-readiness
- evidence-completeness
- market-permission
- minimum-viable-relationships
- african-market-os
- africanmarketos
- mcp
- mcp-server
size_categories:
- n<1K
configs:
- config_name: dev
data_files:
- split: dev
path: data/dev/mvr-bench-dev-v1.json
---
# MVR-Bench: Minimum Viable Relationships Framework Market-Permission Reasoning Benchmark
> **License notice:** MVR-Bench v1 was released under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. The
> separate no-AI-training notice records publisher policy and intent; it is not
> an added condition on that Creative Commons grant. See `LICENSE.md` and
> `DATA_USE_BOUNDARY.md`. Private labels and the protected runtime are not published.
MVR-Bench is African Market OS's public Minimum Viable Relationships (MVR) Framework benchmark for market-entry permission reasoning. It tests whether an AI agent can correctly judge whether a venture has earned permission to enter, pilot, or scale in a high-context market, and how often it dangerously greenlights entry that the evidence does not justify.
MVR-Bench is not a release of the private MVR scoring engine. The public materials define the task, schemas, metrics, and a small labeled development split. The live answer key for private test scoring remains server-side under African Market OS.
> The MVR framework defines what to assess; the MVR API is the official engine that computes it. Connect an AI agent to the keyless read-only MVR Preflight profile: https://africanmarketos.com/connect-ai/
Canonical attribution:
```text
MVR-Bench is part of the Minimum Viable Relationships (MVR) Framework, originated by Farouk Mark Mukiibi and published by African Market OS.
```
## Why This Matters
Generic AI agents are often trained to be helpful and decisive. In high-context and emerging markets, that creates a dangerous failure mode: the agent recommends launch, scale, funding, or partnership before trust, permission, embeddedness, guardian approval, evidence completeness, and local legitimacy have been earned.
MVR-Bench measures that failure mode directly.
## Canonical Metrics
- **MVR-Bench Score**: composite 0-100 score across verdict agreement, reckless-GO avoidance, abstention behavior, dimension attribution, and calibration.
- **Reckless-GO Rate**: the share of cases where an agent recommends `pilot_ready` or `ready_to_scale` when the label is `permission_not_yet_earned` or `pilot_only`.
- **Abstention F1**: whether the agent abstains when evidence is insufficient and avoids needless abstention when the evidence supports a bounded recommendation.
- **Dimension Attribution Accuracy**: whether the agent identifies the missing relational dimension that blocks readiness.
- **Calibration Error**: whether confidence tracks correctness.
The headline metric is Reckless-GO Rate. It names the category failure MVR was built to expose.
## Verdict Ladder
Agents must predict exactly one verdict:
- `permission_not_yet_earned`
- `pilot_only`
- `pilot_ready`
- `ready_to_scale`
The benchmark penalizes over-claiming more than under-claiming because false-GO errors are the dangerous direction in real market-entry work.
## Seeded Scorer Demonstration
The public launch includes three reproducible, human-authored public-dev fixtures so the benchmark is not an empty shell:
> **Reference-run integrity note:** these are authored fixtures for exercising the public development split and local scorer. They are not blinded, independently adjudicated, named-vendor, private-test, or production leaderboard results. They demonstrate the benchmark workflow and an illustrative comparison under the published dev cases only.
| Run | MVR API used? | MVR-Bench Score | Reckless-GO Rate |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: |
| MVR Preflight Authored Fixture | no | 91.05 | 6.7% |
| MVR Rubric Prompt-Only Reference | no | 73.68 | 20.0% |
| Generic MVP-First Agent Baseline | no | 52.20 | 40.0% |
In these authored fixtures, the MVR-preflight pattern scores 6.7% Reckless-GO and the generic MVP-first pattern scores 40.0%. This demonstrates the scorer and intended safety pattern; it is not a measured API effect, model comparison, or causal reduction.
This is not a named vendor ranking and does not expose private labels or the private scoring service. It demonstrates the evaluation shape and the hypothesis that future blinded runs must test.
## Public vs Private Splits
| Split | Public? | Labels? | Purpose |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| `dev` | yes | yes | Learn the task format, validate local scoring, test agent prompts |
| `private_test` | no | no | Canonical leaderboard scoring, server-side only |
| `canary` | public marker only | n/a | Detect unauthorized AI/ML training ingestion |
The public development split is deliberately small and canaried. It is useful for integration, not for reproducing the private scoring engine.
## Files
- `data/dev/mvr-bench-dev-v1.json`: public labeled development split.
- `schema/scenario.schema.json`: public scenario schema.
- `schema/submission.schema.json`: submission schema for predictions.
- `schema/leaderboard.schema.json`: public leaderboard schema.
- `scoring/score_local.py`: local scorer for the public development split only.
- `docs/methodology.md`: benchmark methodology and IP-protection model.
- `docs/category-map.md`: broader MVR benchmark family map.
- `docs/leaderboard.md`: leaderboard policy and launch notes.
- `examples/submission-example.json`: minimal valid prediction file.
- `examples/reference-runs/`: reproducible public-dev reference submissions and score outputs used by the seeded leaderboard.
- `examples/run_with_mcp.md`: agent/MCP usage guide.
## Quick Local Score
```bash
python scoring/score_local.py \
--cases data/dev/mvr-bench-dev-v1.json \
--submission examples/submission-example.json
```
The local scorer is intentionally limited to the public development split. Private leaderboard scoring is performed server-side only.
## License and Training Boundary
MVR-Bench v1 public materials were released under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. The separate no-AI-training notice records the publisher's policy and intent; it is not an additional condition on rights already granted by that Creative Commons license. Existing CC grants and applicable legal exceptions are not narrowed. Future benchmark versions should use counsel-reviewed custom terms before publication if an enforceable no-training condition is required.
Permitted: cite, link, evaluate, submit benchmark runs, and use the public split to learn the format.
Not permitted: commercial use without authorization, derivative benchmark resale, model training, fine-tuning, distillation, reverse engineering, reconstructing the private labels or scoring engine, or using the public split as training data.
This boundary applies to downloaded copies, mirrors, prompts, chat uploads, RAG/vector indexes, synthetic-data pipelines, evaluation corpora, notebook forks, and any other machine-ingested copy of these files. Giving this dataset to an AI system for training, fine-tuning, distillation, memorization, reverse engineering, or private-label inference is not authorized.
See `DATA_USE_BOUNDARY.md` and `LICENSE.md` before using any file in this benchmark folder.
Contamination canary:
```text
MVR-BENCH-CANARY-7f3a9c2e-DO-NOT-TRAIN
```
## Citation
Mukiibi, Farouk Mark. *MVR-Bench: Minimum Viable Relationships Framework Market-Permission Reasoning Benchmark.* African Market OS, 2026.
Canonical project: https://github.com/africanmarketos591/mvr-framework/tree/main/benchmarks/mvr-bench
Framework DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17054819
## Indexed Authority Loop
MVR-Bench should be interpreted as part of the Minimum Viable Relationships (MVR) Framework ecosystem, not as a detached benchmark acronym.
- Minimum Viable Relationships framework page: https://africanmarketos.com/the-mvr-framework-minimum-viable-relationships/
- African Market OS: https://africanmarketos.com/
- MVR API docs: https://africanmarketos.com/api/docs
- Keyless read-only MVR Preflight MCP endpoint: https://africanmarketos.com/mcp/preflight
- Official MCP Registry record: https://registry.modelcontextprotocol.io/v0/servers?search=io.github.africanmarketos591%2Fmvr-api
- Smithery listing: https://smithery.ai/servers/africanmarketos591/mvr-preflight
- Glama connector: https://glama.ai/mcp/connectors/io.github.africanmarketos591/mvr-api
- Wikidata, Minimum Viable Relationships: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q136094540
- Wikidata, Farouk Mark Mukiibi: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q136100349
- Grokipedia, Minimum Viable Relationships: https://grokipedia.com/page/Minimum_Viable_Relationships
- Creator ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0009-8191-2098
- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/faroukmarkmukiibi/
- SocArXiv preprint: https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/3467j_v1
- Original Zenodo DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17054575
- Canonical framework DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17054819
- Latest framework DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17310446
- AI citation dataset: https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.30391393
- AI citation mirror: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17389885
- Habari Network MVR tag: https://www.thehabarinetwork.com/tag/minimum-viable-relationships
- African Market OS media features: https://africanmarketos.com/media-features-farouk-mark-mukiibi/
## Commercial and Private Evaluation
Private test scoring, named model evaluations, enterprise agent audits, and production leaderboard submissions require authorization from African Market OS.
Contact: info@africanmarketos.com