BitNarrow_Bench / report /HEADLINE.md
AmareshHebbar's picture
bench results
34defc2 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
3.22 kB

BitNarrow bench

Training free removal of over refusal from 4 bit LLMs, tested on held out prompts that were never used to build or tune the edit.

Qwen2.5 7B Instruct

  • Over refusal on safe prompts: 26.8% to 18.5% (change -8.3 pts, 95% CI [-10.9, -5.7] pts, McNemar p = 6.7e-10, n = 750)
  • Refusal on harmful prompts: 94.0% to 90.5% (change -3.5 pts, 95% CI [-6.0, -1.0] pts, n = 400)
  • Capability change with 95% CI: arc_challenge -0.2 pts [-1.8, +1.2], gsm8k -3.5 pts [-6.8, -0.2], hellaswag -0.4 pts [-1.4, +0.6], mmlu +0.1 pts [-0.4, +0.5]
  • Patch size: 206 MB (only the edited tensors, loads onto the stock base model)
  • Labels from: judge1 (2300 of 2300 judged by judge 1)
suite n base refusal edited refusal change, 95% CI
xstest_safe 250 13.2% [9.6, 18.0] 11.6% [8.2, 16.2] -1.6 pts [-5.2, 1.6]
orbench_hard 500 33.6% [29.6, 37.9] 22.0% [18.6, 25.8] -11.6 pts [-15.0, -8.2]
harmbench 200 93.5% [89.2, 96.2] 87.0% [81.6, 91.0] -6.5 pts [-11.0, -2.0]
xstest_unsafe 200 94.5% [90.4, 96.9] 94.0% [89.8, 96.5] -0.5 pts [-2.5, 1.5]
task n base edited change, 95% CI
arc_challenge 500 52.6% 52.4% -0.2 pts [-1.8, +1.2]
gsm8k 400 78.2% 74.8% -3.5 pts [-6.8, -0.2]
hellaswag 500 67.8% 67.4% -0.4 pts [-1.4, +0.6]
mmlu 2280 72.4% 72.5% +0.1 pts [-0.4, +0.5]
detector agreement n agreement Cohen kappa
judge1 vs judge2 120 79.2% 0.576
judge1 vs keyword 2300 73.6% 0.451
judge2 vs keyword 120 61.7% 0.307
system base 4 bit edited 4 bit
tokens per second 379.6 384.21
peak VRAM 7,616 MB 7,616 MB
memory footprint 5,443 MB 5,597 MB

Edit chosen on the dev split only: strength 1.0, layer 19, band 15..22.

Method

  • The refusal direction is built from 128 OR Bench hard prompts against 128 Alpaca instructions.
  • Edit strength is picked on a separate dev split (100 OR Bench hard, 100 AdvBench). Test prompts are never seen before the final run.
  • Test sets: XSTest safe, a held out OR Bench hard slice, HarmBench standard and XSTest unsafe. A normalized text check proves zero overlap with the fit and dev prompts.
  • Both models load in bitsandbytes nf4. Generation is greedy, so anyone can reproduce the exact outputs.
  • Refusal labels come from an LLM judge (COMPLY, PARTIAL or REFUSE). PARTIAL counts as refusal. A second judge from another model family and a keyword detector are reported for agreement.
  • Capability uses lm evaluation harness with per item scores, so every change has a paired bootstrap CI.
  • Outputs on harmful prompts are not published as text. Their SHA256 hashes are, so a rerun can be matched byte for byte.

Verify

python -c "from huggingface_hub import snapshot_download as s; s('AmareshHebbar/BitNarrow_Bench', repo_type='dataset', local_dir='bench/results')"
python bench/verify.py

verify.py checks every file hash against manifest.json and recomputes every number on this page from the raw JSONL.

Manifest root: 09ce517bf876368f5220da0701679ab03df0a0eb67679c55103b0b0acbdead4d