Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet Duplicate
id
string
split
string
language
string
domain
string
pool_id
string
tier
string
intended_tier
string
subtype
string
answerable
bool
answer_format
string
question
string
question_gloss_en
string
expected_answer
string
expected_answer_gloss_en
string
requirements
list
evidence
list
evidence_bundles
list
oracle_docs
list
integration_operation
string
wording
string
source_block
string
source_family
string
information_need_id
string
notes
string
revision
int64
content_hash
string
doc_scope
string
accepted_alternatives
string
necessity_audit
string
absence_audit
string
paraphrase_of
string
provenance
string
exposure
string
review
string
descriptive
string
V2-dev-BOOK-en-AB-001
dev
en
BOOK
BOOK-en
null
T3
null
false
abstain
How much was the stage fare from Newport to New Bedford that was paid for Frederick Douglass, and how does it compare with what Franklin paid the boatmen on his way to Philadelphia?
null
The amount of Douglass's stage fare is not given: he says only that he could not pay and that Nathan Johnson advanced the money. (Franklin gave the boatmen about a shilling in copper.) The comparison cannot be made.
null
[]
[]
[]
[]
null
ordinary
BOOK-en-DEV-AUTOBIO
franklin_autobiography+douglass_narrative
IN-dev-BOOK-en-AB-001
Half-answerable trap: Franklin's side exists, Douglass's amount does not.
1
cb9b56a84f257a590f704d8133e9a65cc7e54289a7b198447fc72700e8486165
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": []}
{}
null
{"missing_obligation": "The amount of the Newport-New Bedford stage fare in Douglass's Narrative.", "search_variants": ["fare", "stage", "New Bedford", "Newport", "dollar", "cents", "advanced the money", "Ruggles"], "inspected_locations": ["K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en chapter XI (p1_b208-b221) and appendix", "...
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:35:00+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 0, "n_regions": 0, "n_docs": 0, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-en-T1-001
dev
en
BOOK
BOOK-en
T1
T1
T1_fact
true
explanation
In his lectures on the candle, how does Faraday explain why a burning candle forms a hollow cup of liquid fuel at its top instead of melting down its sides?
null
The heat of the flame drives an ascending current of air that plays evenly on all sides of the candle and keeps the outside edge cool; the inside melts from the flame but the cooled rim does not, so a cup forms.
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "An upward air current produced by the candle's heat cools the outer sides/edge of the fuel.", "subject": "candle", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"cause of the cup\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\":...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en", "doc_title": "The Chemical History of a Candle", "unit_id": "K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en::p1_b47", "quote": "As the air comes to the candle it moves upwards by the force of the curr...
[ [ "E1" ] ]
[ "K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en" ]
null
paraphrase
BOOK-en-DEV-SCIENCE-PAMPHLET
faraday_candle
IN-dev-BOOK-en-T1-001
null
1
703730957a4a757bfbb9b5040fabaad42c9faddb887dbe21f11573737f37b602
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en"]}
{}
null
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:35:00+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en": "452b9e8f84b6f7c28c9abafa4e6037c937003ae9c32528658d921290223e2539"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 1, "n_regions": 1, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 376, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-en-T1-002
dev
en
BOOK
BOOK-en
T1
T1
T1_table_cell
true
single
In Common Sense, what does Paine give as the cost of building a 70-gun ship of war, with masts, sails and rigging?
null
£17,785 sterling (Mr. Burchett's figure, including masts, yards, sails, rigging and eight months' boatswain's and carpenter's stores).
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "A 70-gun ship costs £17,785.", "subject": "ship of 70 guns", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"building and fitting cost\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null, \"population\": null, \"unit\": null, ...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.gutenberg-147_paine_common-sense.en", "doc_title": "Common Sense", "unit_id": "K.gutenberg-147_paine_common-sense.en::p001_t1#table.0", "quote": "| 70 | | = | 17,785", "start": 75322, "end": 75341, "text_sha256": "e366339be205966031fe2fc5661ef2ceb6ab34135ff...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3" ] ]
[ "K.gutenberg-147_paine_common-sense.en" ]
null
ordinary
BOOK-en-DEV-SCIENCE-PAMPHLET
paine_common-sense
IN-dev-BOOK-en-T1-002
Table row; E3 is the caption directly above the table that says what the figures are.
1
a40c2e05aa084747ac55dcb6106c98f0435ae621331ac65760d61c4764057026
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.gutenberg-147_paine_common-sense.en"]}
{}
null
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:35:00+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.gutenberg-147_paine_common-sense.en": "e366339be205966031fe2fc5661ef2ceb6ab34135ff5dcaa1d50c7d91daf6ac4"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 3, "n_regions": 1, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 366, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-en-T1-003
dev
en
BOOK
BOOK-en
T1
T1
T1_fact
true
single
Who chose the surname 'Douglass' for Frederick Douglass after his escape, and what book suggested it?
null
Nathan Johnson, his host in New Bedford, who had just been reading 'The Lady of the Lake'.
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Mr. (Nathan) Johnson chose the name.", "subject": "Frederick Douglass", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"person who chose the surname\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": \"New Bedford\", \"version\": null, \"population\...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en", "doc_title": "Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave", "unit_id": "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en::p1_b220", "quote": "I gave Mr. Johnson the privilege of choosing me a name, but told him he must not ta...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3" ] ]
[ "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en" ]
null
ordinary
BOOK-en-DEV-AUTOBIO
douglass_narrative
IN-dev-BOOK-en-T1-003
E3 supplies Johnson's first name, one paragraph earlier in the same passage.
1
3b017d3f70f2c816de14515f68991094394af0ca51038a17f75a7479a48b1f1d
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en"]}
{}
null
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:35:00+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en": "520b09b4134df57b6c6a6c4ad6dfb70d9abee0575d4d342b8f9432b14f4a1a86"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 3, "n_regions": 1, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 1634, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-en-T2-001
dev
en
BOOK
BOOK-en
T2
T2
T2_definition_bridge
true
explanation
Of the virtues in Franklin's plan for moral perfection, which one did he find hardest to acquire? Give its number and precept in his list, and his reasons for the difficulty.
null
Order, number 3: 'Let all your things have their places; let each part of your business have its time.' It gave him the most trouble because a master who must receive people of business at their own hours cannot keep to a fixed schedule, and because he had not been used to keeping places for things and papers; his very...
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Order was the hardest.", "subject": "Franklin's virtues", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"hardest virtue\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null, \"population\": null, \"unit\": null, \"condition\":...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en", "doc_title": "Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin", "unit_id": "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en::p1_b376", "quote": "3. Order.", "start": 187016, "end": 187025, "text_sha256": "aa6417fffec6d939ed9eab0fe...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3", "E4" ] ]
[ "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en" ]
resolve the virtue named in the later confession against its definition in the numbered list
paraphrase
BOOK-en-DEV-AUTOBIO
franklin_autobiography
IN-dev-BOOK-en-T2-001
null
1
9c0e4de4de26cd040d2a0b650a86d323e341dd6572410488f83db530714fecb2
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["numbered list of the thirteen virtues (p1_b376-b377)", "later account of his progress (p1_b422)"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "E1+E2", "obligation_lost": "R2, R3: the number and precept are only in the list"}, {"removed": "E3+E4", "obligation_lost": "R1, R4: which virtue was hardest and why is only in t...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:35:00+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en": "aa6417fffec6d939ed9eab0fefae9a82d498f1109bf780aa922dfe1243fa1761"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 4, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 8906, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-en-T2-002
dev
en
BOOK
BOOK-en
T2
T2
T2_bounded_synthesis
true
explanation
How did Frederick Douglass learn to read in Baltimore? Who first taught him, what reasons did Mr. Auld give for stopping the lessons, and how did Douglass finish learning?
null
Mrs. Auld first taught him the alphabet and to spell words of three or four letters. Mr. Auld stopped it, saying it was unlawful as well as unsafe to teach a slave to read, and that learning would 'forever unfit him to be a slave' and make him unmanageable and discontented. Douglass then made teachers of the white boys...
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Mrs. Auld taught him the A, B, C and to spell words of three or four letters.", "subject": "Frederick Douglass", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"first teacher\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en", "doc_title": "Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave", "unit_id": "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en::p1_b110", "quote": "Very soon after I went to live with Mr. and Mrs. Auld, she very kindly commenced to...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3", "E4", "E5" ] ]
[ "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en" ]
bounded synthesis across chapter VI (start and stop of the lessons) and chapter VII (how he completed learning)
ordinary
BOOK-en-DEV-AUTOBIO
douglass_narrative
IN-dev-BOOK-en-T2-002
Revised after independent review: chapter VII alone answered the first version (who taught / that it stopped / how he finished).
2
3d4e2de6a3b165d2b6ef238f051441884dbfdf68c7ebceba91148ddde7ca7052
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["chapter VI (p1_b110)", "chapter VII (p1_b116)"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "E1+E2+E5", "obligation_lost": "R2: Mr. Auld's stated reasons (unlawful, unsafe, 'unfit him to be a slave') are only in chapter VI"}, {"removed": "E3+E4", "obligation_lost": "R3: the street-boy lessons and the bread appear only ...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T13:02:45+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en": "520b09b4134df57b6c6a6c4ad6dfb70d9abee0575d4d342b8f9432b14f4a1a86"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 5, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 9014, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-en-T2-003
dev
en
BOOK
BOOK-en
T2
T2
T2_bounded_synthesis
true
explanation
Faraday shows the audience two products of a burning candle, water and carbonic acid. How does he make the water visible, and how does he show that the air from the candle contains carbonic acid?
null
Water: he burns the candle under a dish holding ice and salt, and a drop of condensed water hangs from the dish (he tests water with potassium). The other product, carbonic acid, is shown by pouring clear lime-water into a jar that has collected the air from the candle: the lime-water turns milky, forming chalk.
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Water is condensed from the flame on a dish cooled with ice and salt, where a drop hangs.", "subject": "candle", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"how water is shown\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\":...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en", "doc_title": "The Chemical History of a Candle", "unit_id": "K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en::p1_b93", "quote": "I am now going to take away the candle which has been burning beneath th...
[ [ "E1", "E2" ] ]
[ "K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en" ]
bounded synthesis of two demonstrations in different lectures (III and V)
paraphrase
BOOK-en-DEV-SCIENCE-PAMPHLET
faraday_candle
IN-dev-BOOK-en-T2-003
Revised after independent review: the first version's 'the other product' was unbound (soot/carbon is also a product).
2
7bb5f33db922adbe1de2f2b57b2f3b32aef1918c2a79277e8571aaf82318376d
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["Lecture III: water from the combustion (p1_b93)", "Lecture V: carbonic acid (p1_b203)"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "E1", "obligation_lost": "R1: the water demonstration is lost"}, {"removed": "E2", "obligation_lost": "R2: the lime-water test is lost"}], "single_region_complete": false, "single_document...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T13:02:45+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en": "452b9e8f84b6f7c28c9abafa4e6037c937003ae9c32528658d921290223e2539"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 2, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 78499, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-en-T3-001
dev
en
BOOK
BOOK-en
T3
T3
T3_cross_doc_bridge
true
explanation
Benjamin Franklin's father made candles in Boston from one particular material. According to Faraday's candle lectures, what is that material made from, and how can it be turned into stearin?
null
Franklin's father was a tallow-chandler, so the material is tallow. Faraday says it is suet, the fat of the ox (Russian tallow). To make stearin it is boiled with quick-lime into a soap, the soap is decomposed with sulphuric acid (leaving stearic acid and giving glycerin), and the oil is pressed out.
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Franklin's father was a tallow-chandler (tallow candles).", "subject": "Josiah Franklin", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"trade / candle material\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null, \"populatio...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en", "doc_title": "Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin", "unit_id": "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en::p1_b82", "quote": "At ten years old I was taken home to assist my father in his business, which was that of a tallow-...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3", "E4" ] ]
[ "K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en", "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en" ]
bridge: Franklin's Autobiography identifies the material (tallow); Faraday describes it and its conversion
paraphrase
BOOK-en-DEV-SCIENCE-PAMPHLET
franklin_autobiography+faraday_candle
IN-dev-BOOK-en-T3-001
null
1
127d947e26afca965f11a451c37e909752a41b658abe209f86d28492fdc15213
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical-history-of-a-candle.en", "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["Franklin, Autobiography", "Faraday, Chemical History of a Candle"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "Franklin", "obligation_lost": "R1: without it the material is not identified (Faraday also covers wax, spermaceti, paraffin)"}, {"removed": "Faraday", "obligation_lost": "R2, R3: Franklin says nothing about w...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:35:00+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en": "aa6417fffec6d939ed9eab0fefae9a82d498f1109bf780aa922dfe1243fa1761", "K.gutenberg-14474_faraday_chemical...
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 4, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 2, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-en-T3-002
dev
en
BOOK
BOOK-en
T3
T3
T3_cross_subject
true
comparison
Benjamin Franklin and Frederick Douglass both taught themselves to write. What did each use as a model, and how did each practise?
null
Franklin used essays from an odd volume of the Spectator: he noted short hints of each sentence, later rewrote the papers from the hints without the book, and compared his version with the original to correct his faults (he also turned tales into verse and back). Douglass copied the letters that ship carpenters chalked...
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Franklin's model was the Spectator.", "subject": "Benjamin Franklin", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"writing model\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null, \"population\": null, \"unit\": null, \"c...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en", "doc_title": "Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin", "unit_id": "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en::p1_b133", "quote": "About this time I met with an odd volume of the Spectator.", "start": 47041, "end": 47099...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3", "E4", "E5", "E6" ] ]
[ "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en", "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en" ]
cross-subject comparison of two self-education methods (non-numeric)
ordinary
BOOK-en-DEV-AUTOBIO
franklin_autobiography+douglass_narrative
IN-dev-BOOK-en-T3-002
null
1
6c25e99936d6462737b5f4f3ea2c2224a82548fac7e4a80969f3e90ef0670c07
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en", "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["Franklin, Autobiography", "Douglass, Narrative"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "Franklin", "obligation_lost": "R1, R2: Douglass's book says nothing of Franklin"}, {"removed": "Douglass", "obligation_lost": "R3, R4: Franklin's book says nothing of Douglass"}], "single_region_complete": false, "single_docum...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:35:00+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en": "aa6417fffec6d939ed9eab0fefae9a82d498f1109bf780aa922dfe1243fa1761", "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative....
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 6, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 2, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-en-T3-003
dev
en
BOOK
BOOK-en
T3
T3
T3_cross_subject
true
comparison
How old was Benjamin Franklin when he was bound as an apprentice to his brother, and how old was Frederick Douglass when he was sent from Colonel Lloyd's plantation to Baltimore? Which of them was younger at that turning point?
null
Franklin signed his indentures at twelve; Douglass was probably between seven and eight when he left for Baltimore. Douglass was younger, by about four to five years.
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Franklin was twelve when he signed the indentures.", "subject": "Benjamin Franklin", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"age when bound apprentice to his brother\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null,...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en", "doc_title": "Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin", "unit_id": "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en::p1_b129", "quote": "signed the indentures when I was yet but twelve years old", "start": 43122, "end": 43179,...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3" ] ]
[ "K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en", "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en" ]
cross-subject numeric comparison
paraphrase
BOOK-en-DEV-AUTOBIO
franklin_autobiography+douglass_narrative
IN-dev-BOOK-en-T3-003
null
1
0cecfeb4222c076c9de117435ca1b370cc4089b220c98f2b5c52438d06b828b2
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en", "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["Franklin, Autobiography", "Douglass, Narrative"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "Franklin", "obligation_lost": "R1, R3: Franklin's age at the indentures is only in his book"}, {"removed": "Douglass", "obligation_lost": "R2, R3: Douglass's age at the move is only in his book"}], "single_region_complete": fa...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:35:00+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.gutenberg-20203_franklin_autobiography.en": "aa6417fffec6d939ed9eab0fefae9a82d498f1109bf780aa922dfe1243fa1761", "K.gutenberg-23_douglass_narrative....
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 3, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 2, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-fa-AB-001
dev
fa
BOOK
BOOK-fa
null
T1
null
false
abstain
غیاث‌الدین کیخسرو، پادشاه سلجوقی روم، در چه سالی با شاهزادهٔ گرجی ازدواج کرد؟
In what year did Ghiyath al-Din Kaykhusraw, the Seljuk sultan of Rum, marry the Georgian princess?
در کتاب‌های این مجموعه سال این ازدواج نیامده است؛ تنها گفته شده که کیخسرو در سال ۶۳۴ هجری به جای پدرش به پادشاهی رسید و دختر پادشاه گرجی را به زنی گرفت.
The books in this collection do not give the year of the marriage; they only say he succeeded his father in 634 AH and married the Georgian king's daughter.
[]
[]
[]
[]
null
ordinary
BOOK-fa-DEV-KASRAVI-SHORT
kasravi_shir-o-khorshid
IN-dev-BOOK-fa-AB-001
Trap: the accession year 634 AH is next to the marriage statement.
2
1f3aaa1fe905205ed5de6c06959e8fee2c71c3b9d4c42fb44b4c6f6e92d2305c
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": []}
{}
null
{"missing_obligation": "The year of Kaykhusraw II's marriage to the Georgian princess.", "search_variants": ["کیخسرو", "گرجی", "گرجستان", "ازدواج", "بزنی گرفت", "634", "ابن عبری"], "inspected_locations": ["K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa (all units, incl. footnote p1_b82 quoting Ibn al-Ibri)", "all BOOK-fa unit...
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:34:59+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 0, "n_regions": 0, "n_docs": 0, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-fa-T1-001
dev
fa
BOOK
BOOK-fa
T1
T1
T1_fact
true
explanation
شاه طهماسب صفوی روی سکه‌های مسی‌اش خورشید را بر پشت چه جانوری نشاند، و چرا شیر را برنگزید؟
On his copper coins, on the back of which animal did Shah Tahmasp place the sun, and why not the lion?
بر پشت بره. او می‌پنداشت نقش شیر و خورشید صورت طالع پادشاه است و چون طالع خودش برج حمل (بره) بود، خورشید را بر پشت بره نشاند.
On a ram (lamb). He believed the lion-and-sun depicted the king's horoscope, and his own sign was Aries, so he put the sun on a ram.
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Tahmasp put the sun on the back of a ram (lamb) on his copper coins.", "subject": "Shah Tahmasp I", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"animal under the sun on copper coins\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"versi...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa", "doc_title": "تاریخچه شیر و خورشید", "unit_id": "K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa::p1_b95", "quote": "ولی چنانکه گفتیم این پادشاه می‌پنداشته که شیر و خورشید صورت طالع پادشاهی است و چون طالع خود او برج حمل (بره) بوده از این...
[ [ "E1" ], [ "E2" ] ]
[ "K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa" ]
null
paraphrase
BOOK-fa-DEV-KASRAVI-SHORT
kasravi_shir-o-khorshid
IN-dev-BOOK-fa-T1-001
Two restatements in the same book (part 2 and part 3); each alone suffices, so T1.
2
d5e6f41fcc555fae9e1cdd75aa101adb0a081c425a37cda993c21b7244a15f1a
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa"]}
{}
null
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:34:59+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa": "c48336f01b77a0c59023046bb34cd481f1c400dab016fe1036ac692edda8aa5d"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 2, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 8593, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-fa-T1-002
dev
fa
BOOK
BOOK-fa
T1
T1
T1_list_local
true
list
به نوشتهٔ کسروی، زبان آذری هنوز در کدام جاهای آذربایجان میان بومیان رواج دارد؟
According to Kasravi, in which places of Azarbaijan is Azari still in use among the natives?
کسروی چهار جا را می‌شناسد که آذری هنوز در آنها میان بومیان گفته می‌شود: هرزند و گلین‌قیه (از پیرامون مرند)، زنوز، حسنو (در قره‌داغ) و خلخال. او همچنین شنیده است که در لیقوان و پیرامون آن نیز تا شصت‌وهفتاد سال پیش آذری را می‌شناختند و در برخی خاندان‌ها به آن سخن می‌گفتند، ولی سپس از میان رفته است.
Kasravi knows of four places where Azari is still spoken among the natives: Harzand and Galin-Qayeh (near Marand), Zonuz, Hasanu (in Qaradagh) and Khalkhal. He has also heard that in Liqvan and its surroundings Azari was known until sixty or seventy years ago and spoken in some families, but has since disappeared.
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Harzand and Galin-Qayeh (near Marand).", "subject": "Azari language", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"surviving locations\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null, \"population\": null, \"unit\": nul...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa", "doc_title": "آذری یا زبان باستان آذربایجان", "unit_id": "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa::p1_b153", "quote": "هنوز در چند جا میان خود بومیان سخن گفته میشود و آنچه ما میدانیم یکی از آنجاها هرزند و گلین قیه (از پیرامونهای مرند)، و دیگری زنوز ...
[ [ "E1", "E2" ] ]
[ "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa" ]
null
ordinary
BOOK-fa-DEV-KASRAVI-SHORT
kasravi_azari
IN-dev-BOOK-fa-T1-002
Revised on the researcher's review: the answer now says these are the places Kasravi knows of (not that there are only four) and includes Liqvan, where Azari was known 60-70 years earlier but has since vanished. Both come from the same paragraph (p1_b153), so the question stays T1.
4
8ad025d3034f4b494798f93e569e0ddbc6eff267a03313e64ac577af084fce36
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa"]}
{}
null
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:34:59+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa": "e49538490f69c4a86113129a5b5bb12518dff2ea30623461acb8a7b52ecbdff1"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 2, "n_regions": 1, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 172, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-fa-T1-003
dev
fa
BOOK
BOOK-fa
T1
T1
T1_fact
true
single
شاپور یکم ساسانی پس از آنکه در خراسان یک پادشاه «تورانی» را شکست داد و کشت، در محل همان جنگ چه شهری ساخت؟ این شهر امروز چه نام دارد؟
After Shapur I defeated and killed a 'Turanian' king in Khorasan, what city did he found at the battle site, and what is it called today?
شهر استوار نیوشاهپور (یعنی «شاپور خوب») را ساخت که همان نیشابور امروزی است؛ این شهر مرکز ولایت ابرشهر شد.
The fortified city of Nev-Shahpuhr ('good Shapur'), today's Nishapur; it became the seat of the province of Abarshahr.
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Shapur founded Nev-Shahpuhr (Niv-Shahpur).", "subject": "Shapur I", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"city founded at the battle site\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": \"Khorasan\", \"version\": null, \"population\": n...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa", "doc_title": "ایران در زمان ساسانیان", "unit_id": "K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa::p1_b642", "quote": "شاهپور در خراسان یک پادشاه «تورانی» پهلیزگ نام را مغلوب و مقتول کرد و در محلی که جنگ رخ داده بود، شهر مستحکم نیوش...
[ [ "E1" ] ]
[ "K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa" ]
null
paraphrase
BOOK-fa-DEV-ANCIENT
christensen_iran-sasanian
IN-dev-BOOK-fa-T1-003
null
1
9b4bcc45bdf2ce8f98d8811f99588d0fb72ade241c10e9d4b288a8df62984547
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa"]}
{}
null
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:34:59+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa": "123d1ae12cb38df89cf36639f6915a3576981656e5ff5178378cc48d01034ee3"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 1, "n_regions": 1, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 200, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-fa-T2-001
dev
fa
BOOK
BOOK-fa
T2
T2
T2_bounded_synthesis
true
explanation
نقش شیر و خورشید از زمان ناصرالدین‌شاه شکل ثابتی پیدا کرد. در این شکل، شیر چه ویژگی‌هایی دارد و چرا شیرِ نقش‌های پیش از آن یال نداشت؟
From Naser al-Din Shah's time the lion-and-sun got a fixed form. What are the lion's features in it, and why did the lion in earlier images have no mane?
شیر ایستاده است، رویش به سمت چپ و برگشته به بیرون، دمش برافراشته و گردنش یال‌دار است و شمشیر به دست دارد. شیرِ نقش‌های قدیمی بی‌یال بود چون شیرهای ایران، چه نر و چه ماده، یال ندارند؛ شیر یال‌دار از زمان ناصرالدین‌شاه و از روی نقش‌های اروپایی آمده است.
Standing, facing left and turned outward, tail raised, maned, holding a sword. The lion in older images was maneless because Iranian lions (male and female) have no mane; the maned lion since Naser al-Din Shah is copied from European images.
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "In the fixed form the lion stands, faces left (turned outward), tail raised, with a mane.", "subject": "official lion-and-sun", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"features of the lion\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": {\"value\": \"Nase...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa", "doc_title": "تاریخچه شیر و خورشید", "unit_id": "K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa::p1_b124", "quote": "آن شمشیر را که به تنهایی نشانی بوده بدست شیر داده‌اند", "start": 31721, "end": 31774, "text_sha256": "c4833...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3" ] ]
[ "K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa" ]
bounded synthesis: the fixed form (part 3 body) + the reason for the mane (footnote at the end of the book)
ordinary
BOOK-fa-DEV-KASRAVI-SHORT
kasravi_shir-o-khorshid
IN-dev-BOOK-fa-T2-001
null
2
ea57996d315534622165bba381bf6a076d0464d50948ae6f039f51e153ad2feb
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa"]}
{}
{"regions": ["part 3 body, p1_b124 (fixed form since Naser al-Din Shah)", "end footnotes, p1_b154 (maneless Iranian lions)"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "E1+E2", "obligation_lost": "R1, R2: the lion's posture, direction, tail and sword are lost"}, {"removed": "E3", "obligation_lost": "R3: the reason earlier lions had...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:34:59+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa": "c48336f01b77a0c59023046bb34cd481f1c400dab016fe1036ac692edda8aa5d"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 3, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 4992, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-fa-T2-002
dev
fa
BOOK
BOOK-fa
T2
T2
T2_comparison_derivation
true
comparison
به روایت خود رومیان، از بنای شهر رم تا بیرون راندن آخرین پادشاهش چند سال گذشت؟ این پادشاه چندمین پادشاه رم بود؟
By the Romans' own tradition, how many years passed from Rome's founding to the expulsion of its last king, and which number king was he?
۲۴۳ سال: رم به اعتقاد رومیان در ۷۵۳ پیش از میلاد ساخته شد و تارکن مغرور در ۵۱۰ پیش از میلاد بیرون رانده شد. او هفتمین و آخرین پادشاه رم بود.
243 years: founded 753 BC by Roman belief, Tarquin the Proud expelled in 510 BC. He was the seventh and last king.
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Rome was founded in 753 BC by Roman belief.", "subject": "Rome", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"founding year\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null, \"population\": null, \"unit\": null, \"condit...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.wikisource_foroughi_ancient-rome.fa", "doc_title": "تاریخ مختصر دولت قدیم روم", "unit_id": "K.wikisource_foroughi_ancient-rome.fa::p1_b42", "quote": "اعتقاد رومیها این بوده که شهر ایشان هفتصد و پنجاه و سه سال قبل از میلاد مسیح علیه‌السلام بنا شده", "start": 13524, ...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3" ], [ "E1", "E4", "E3" ] ]
[ "K.wikisource_foroughi_ancient-rome.fa" ]
compare and derive: founding year (start of chapter 2) and expulsion year (end of chapter 2 / chapter 3) -> duration
paraphrase
BOOK-fa-DEV-ANCIENT
foroughi_ancient-rome
IN-dev-BOOK-fa-T2-002
null
2
78163896b78dfdfd18b6fe5b3383a82a9a334a4455df1993345ca7852cb28279
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.wikisource_foroughi_ancient-rome.fa"]}
{}
{"regions": ["chapter 2 opening, p1_b42 (founding 753 BC)", "chapter 2 end, p1_b53-b54 (seventh king, 510 BC) or chapter 3, p1_b67 (510 BC)"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "E1", "obligation_lost": "R3: the start year is missing, duration cannot be derived"}, {"removed": "E2/E4", "obligation_lost": "R3: the end year is ...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:34:59+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.wikisource_foroughi_ancient-rome.fa": "b94110214ff9d12bc81c1370844310bc6c7f8370b80f075f237ca6269a5c1ce0"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 4, "n_regions": 3, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 13886, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-fa-T2-003
dev
fa
BOOK
BOOK-fa
T2
T2
T2_comparison_derivation
true
explanation
به نوشتهٔ کسروی، از پیروزی طغرل‌بیک و برادرانش بر سلطان مسعود غزنوی تا لشکرکشی طغرل به آذربایجان چند سال گذشت؟ فرمانروای آذربایجان در برابر او چه کرد؟
Per Kasravi, how many years passed between Tughril and his brothers' victory over Sultan Mas'ud of Ghazna and Tughril's entry into Azarbaijan? What did Azarbaijan's ruler do?
۱۵ سال (از ۴۳۱ تا ۴۴۶ هجری). امیر وهسودان و پسرش مملان فرمان‌بردار شدند و پرداخت باج را پذیرفتند و طغرل آنان را از فرمانروایی برکنار نکرد.
15 years (431 to 446 AH). Emir Vahsudan and his son Mamlan submitted and agreed to pay tribute, and Tughril did not remove them from power.
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Tughril and his brothers defeated Mas'ud in 431 AH.", "subject": "Tughril Beg", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"year of victory over Mas'ud\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null, \"population\": n...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa", "doc_title": "آذری یا زبان باستان آذربایجان", "unit_id": "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa::p1_b75", "quote": "چون طغرل بیک و برادرانش در سال 431 سلطان مسعود را شکستند و بر خراسان دست یافته بنیاد فرمانروایی گزاردند", "start": 20309, "...
[ [ "E1", "E2" ] ]
[ "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa" ]
compare and derive: two dated events in different subsections of part 2
ordinary
BOOK-fa-DEV-KASRAVI-SHORT
kasravi_azari
IN-dev-BOOK-fa-T2-003
null
2
29ded9e37b5fbf9736dfd63f4f6eb184b21f6405e62f04c3af5f2405e1433c69
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa"]}
{}
{"regions": ["part 2, subsection 'the Seljuk era or the time of Turkish migration' (p1_b75)", "part 2, subsection 'Azarbaijan in the Seljuk era' (p1_b89)"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "E1", "obligation_lost": "R3: the start year (431) is missing"}, {"removed": "E2", "obligation_lost": "R3, R4: the entry year and the ...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:34:59+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa": "e49538490f69c4a86113129a5b5bb12518dff2ea30623461acb8a7b52ecbdff1"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 2, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 5463, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-fa-T3-001
dev
fa
BOOK
BOOK-fa
T3
T3
T3_bounded_aggregation
true
single
امپراتور رومی‌ای که به دست شاپور یکم ساسانی اسیر شد، چند سال پس از به تخت نشستن گرفتار شد؟
How many years after becoming emperor was the Roman emperor captured by Shapur I taken prisoner?
۹ سال: والرین (والریانوس) در سال ۲۵۱ میلادی به امپراتوری رسید و در سال ۲۶۰ به دست ایرانیان اسیر شد.
9 years: Valerian became emperor in 251 AD and was captured by the Persians in 260.
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Valerian became emperor in 251 AD.", "subject": "Valerian", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"year of accession\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null, \"population\": null, \"unit\": null, \"conditi...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.wikisource_foroughi_ancient-rome.fa", "doc_title": "تاریخ مختصر دولت قدیم روم", "unit_id": "K.wikisource_foroughi_ancient-rome.fa::p1_b667", "quote": "یک نفر از اعضاء سنا را که پیرمردی متمول بود موسوم به والرین با پسرش که گالین نام داشت بامپراطوری برداشتند (سنه 251).",...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3" ] ]
[ "K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa", "K.wikisource_foroughi_ancient-rome.fa" ]
cross-document derivation: accession year (Foroughi, Rome) and capture year (Christensen, Sasanians)
paraphrase
BOOK-fa-DEV-ANCIENT
foroughi_ancient-rome+christensen_iran-sasanian
IN-dev-BOOK-fa-T3-001
The text says 251 (modern sources say 253); the answer follows the text. Name differs between books: والرین vs والریانوس.
2
afb7bf79a2a5327ac7854b492207943fd2a0e625df4d789445ee6d8a37f859b0
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa", "K.wikisource_foroughi_ancient-rome.fa"]}
{}
{"regions": ["Foroughi, Ancient Rome", "Christensen, Iran under the Sasanians"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "Foroughi", "obligation_lost": "R1: the accession year is given only there (Christensen gives no accession date)"}, {"removed": "Christensen", "obligation_lost": "R2: the capture year is given only there (Forou...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:34:59+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.wikisource_foroughi_ancient-rome.fa": "b94110214ff9d12bc81c1370844310bc6c7f8370b80f075f237ca6269a5c1ce0", "K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.f...
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 3, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 2, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-fa-T3-002
dev
fa
BOOK
BOOK-fa
T3
T3
T3_cross_doc_bridge
true
explanation
در روزگار شاپور دوم ساسانی، ایالتی را به‌ویژه «کشور مغان» می‌شمردند. نام این ایالت از نام چه کسی گرفته شده و او چه کرده بود؟
Under Shapur II one province was counted above all as 'the land of the Magi'. After whom is it named, and what had he done?
آن ایالت آتروپاتن، یعنی آذربایجان است. نامش از «آتورپات» می‌آید، مردی از بومیان که وقتی اسکندر به ایران آمد برخاست، آنجا را از افتادن به دست یونانیان نگه داشت و در آن فرمانروایی بنیاد نهاد؛ از این رو سرزمین را «آتورپاتکان» خواندند.
Atropatene, i.e. Azarbaijan. It is named after Atropat, a native who rose when Alexander invaded, kept the land from the Greeks and founded a rule there; hence 'Aturpatakan'.
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "The province is Atropatene, i.e. Azarbaijan.", "subject": "land of the Magi (Shapur II era)", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"identity of the province\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": {\"value\": \"reign of Shapur II\", \"kind\": \"...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa", "doc_title": "ایران در زمان ساسانیان", "unit_id": "K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa::p1_b349", "quote": "حتی در زمان شاپور دوم کشور ماد و خصوصا ایالت آتروپاتن (آذربایجان) را کشور مغان می‌شمردند.", "start": 156366, ...
[ [ "E1", "E2" ], [ "E1", "E3" ] ]
[ "K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa", "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa" ]
bridge: Christensen identifies the province from its description; Kasravi's Azari explains its name
paraphrase
BOOK-fa-DEV-KASRAVI-SHORT
christensen_iran-sasanian+kasravi_azari
IN-dev-BOOK-fa-T3-002
null
2
8459656b13fb1404bf0daac02965681fa639a11bc61e3fd5868d182871d797ba
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa", "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa"]}
{}
{"regions": ["Christensen, Iran under the Sasanians", "Kasravi, Azari"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "Christensen", "obligation_lost": "R1: nothing else in the pool calls a province 'the land of the Magi' under Shapur II"}, {"removed": "Azari", "obligation_lost": "R2, R3: Christensen does not explain the name's origin...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:34:59+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.wikisource_christensen_iran-sasanian.fa": "123d1ae12cb38df89cf36639f6915a3576981656e5ff5178378cc48d01034ee3", "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa": "e49...
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 3, "n_regions": 3, "n_docs": 2, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-BOOK-fa-T3-003
dev
fa
BOOK
BOOK-fa
T3
T3
T3_bounded_aggregation
true
explanation
شاه اسماعیل صفوی به چه زبانی شعر می‌گفت و به گمان کسروی چرا نقش شیر و خورشید را به کار نبرد؟
In what language did Shah Ismail write poetry, and why, in Kasravi's guess, did he not use the lion-and-sun?
به ترکی شعر می‌گفت و دیوانش در دست است. نقش شیر و خورشید را به کار نبرد چون، به گمان کسروی، شیر و خورشید را صورت طالع پادشاه می‌پنداشتند و طالع اسماعیل برج عقرب بود و نمی‌خواست خورشید را بر پشت کژدم بنشاند.
Turkish (his diwan survives). He avoided the lion-and-sun because the emblem was thought to be the king's horoscope and his sign was Scorpio: he did not want the sun on a scorpion.
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Shah Ismail wrote poetry in Turkish (his diwan survives).", "subject": "Shah Ismail I", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"language of his poetry\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": null, \"population\"...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa", "doc_title": "آذری یا زبان باستان آذربایجان", "unit_id": "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa::p1_b111", "quote": "خود آن شاه بترکی شعرهایی میسروده که دیوانش در دست است.", "start": 33159, "end": 33213, "text_sha256": "e49538490f69c4a...
[ [ "E1", "E2" ] ]
[ "K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa", "K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa" ]
aggregation about one subject across two books by the same author
ordinary
BOOK-fa-DEV-KASRAVI-SHORT
kasravi_azari+kasravi_shir-o-khorshid
IN-dev-BOOK-fa-T3-003
null
2
9221aaa5e1737ffbf295dd4ff8867be80c16da4fdcd451622211e0b1e8ae34f7
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa", "K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa"]}
{}
{"regions": ["Kasravi, Azari", "Kasravi, History of the Lion and Sun"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "Azari", "obligation_lost": "R1: Shir-o-Khorshid says nothing about Ismail's poetry or language"}, {"removed": "Shir-o-Khorshid", "obligation_lost": "R2: Azari says nothing about the emblem or Ismail's horoscope"}], "si...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-book-author", "writer": "claude-book-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:34:59+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"K.wikisource_kasravi_azari.fa": "e49538490f69c4a86113129a5b5bb12518dff2ea30623461acb8a7b52ecbdff1", "K.wikisource_kasravi_shir-o-khorshid.fa": "c4833...
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 3, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 2, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-en-AB-001
dev
en
LAW
LAW-en
null
T1
null
false
abstain
Under section 54 of the Modern Slavery Act 2015, what is the minimum annual turnover, in pounds, above which a commercial organisation must publish a slavery and human trafficking statement?
null
The Act does not give a figure. Section 54(2)(b) applies the duty to organisations whose total turnover is not less than an amount prescribed by regulations made by the Secretary of State, and s.54(3) leaves the calculation of turnover to regulations; no amount appears in the Act.
null
[]
[]
[]
[]
null
ordinary
LAW-en-DEV-UKCRIME
modern-slavery-act
IN-dev-LAW-en-AB-001
Plausible trap: the widely cited GBP 36 million comes from secondary legislation, which is not in the pool.
1
ab7f59e3c9f493a7042707d827ca89ca57e61aca2613a0a0b2baf935abba828b
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": []}
{}
null
{"missing_obligation": "A monetary turnover threshold for the s.54 statement duty stated in the Act.", "search_variants": ["turnover", "£", "million", "36", "prescribed by regulations", "minimum turnover"], "inspected_locations": ["L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en s.54 (all subsections), s.58 (regulations), Schedu...
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:15:21+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 0, "n_regions": 0, "n_docs": 0, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-en-T1-001
dev
en
LAW
LAW-en
T1
T1
T1_fact
true
single
A company that must produce a slavery and human trafficking statement has no website. What must it do when someone asks in writing for the statement, and how quickly?
null
It must give a copy of the statement to anyone who asks for one in writing, before the end of the 30-day period beginning with the day the request is received (Modern Slavery Act 2015, s.54(8)).
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "It must provide a copy of the statement to the person making the written request.", "subject": "Modern Slavery Act 2015, s.54(8)", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"duty of an organisation without a website\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"ti...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en", "doc_title": "Modern Slavery Act 2015", "unit_id": "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en::p1_b986", "quote": "If the organisation does not have a website, it must provide a copy of the slavery and human trafficking statement to an...
[ [ "E1" ] ]
[ "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en" ]
null
paraphrase
LAW-en-DEV-UKCRIME
modern-slavery-act
IN-dev-LAW-en-T1-001
Trap: s.54(7) is the website case (publish and link from the homepage).
1
5862235e1e963d38bb0a219a95f28b838b09506c177bb5008214a2787d2b2dbd
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en"]}
{}
null
null
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:15:21+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en": "9079e987ef6c3653c39e7ac9906a4641598d748250891ddeaffde3a137999d54"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 1, "n_regions": 1, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 273, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-en-T1-002
dev
en
LAW
LAW-en
T1
T1
T1_fact
true
single
Under the Data Governance Act, how long does a competent public sector body have to decide on a request to re-use protected public-sector data, and can that period be extended?
null
It must adopt a decision within two months of receiving the request, unless national law sets shorter limits. For exceptionally extensive and complex requests the two months may be extended by up to 30 days, and the applicant must be told as soon as possible, with reasons (Art. 9(1)).
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "The decision must be taken within two months of receipt of the request.", "subject": "Data Governance Act, Art. 9(1)", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"deadline to decide on a re-use request\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"p...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en", "doc_title": "Regulation (EU) 2022/868 (Data Governance Act)", "unit_id": "L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en::p1_b197", "quote": "Unless shorter time limits have been established in accordance with national law, the c...
[ [ "E1", "E2" ] ]
[ "L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en" ]
null
ordinary
LAW-en-DEV-EUDATA
data-governance-act
IN-dev-LAW-en-T1-002
E1 and E2 are consecutive sub-paragraphs of Art. 9(1): one local region.
1
a793aca2601edb45c9afa5ba0bc09afed985ccff469cad026f257b55f7ad8bff
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en"]}
{}
null
null
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:15:21+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en": "c40670fef949ee7f6e12151acea0a0f8c976308b5e1caab7e4f347d82d01fe4c"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 2, "n_regions": 1, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 461, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-en-T1-003
dev
en
LAW
LAW-en
T1
T1
T1_list_local
true
list
Whose consent is needed before a prosecution under the Bribery Act 2010 can be brought in England and Wales?
null
Proceedings may be instituted only by or with the consent of the Director of Public Prosecutions or the Director of the Serious Fraud Office (s.10(1)).
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "The Director of Public Prosecutions can consent.", "subject": "Bribery Act 2010, s.10(1)", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"who may consent to prosecution in England and Wales\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": \"Engla...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "doc_title": "Bribery Act 2010", "unit_id": "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en::p1_b125", "quote": "(1) No proceedings for an offence under this Act may be instituted in England and Wales except by or with the consent of—", "start": 1252...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3" ] ]
[ "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en" ]
null
paraphrase
LAW-en-DEV-UKCRIME
bribery-act
IN-dev-LAW-en-T1-003
Trap: s.10(2) lists the Northern Ireland DPP and the SFO Director for Northern Ireland.
1
30646c64a7193185ef5c518a59aac5a0b8b1aee67fabfaa1b5e18927ad81b3c8
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en"]}
{}
null
null
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:15:21+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en": "2de4c6347d40d5c7aeadea1483033eb4958f7cd3b63e1156ac68e5cd08d8cf61"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 3, "n_regions": 1, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 211, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-en-T2-001
dev
en
LAW
LAW-en
T2
T2
T2_definition_bridge
true
explanation
A British citizen living in France pays an official of a French ministry to win a government contract; everything happens in France. Does the Bribery Act 2010 reach this, and under which offence?
null
Yes. The official holds an administrative position of a country outside the UK, so he is a foreign public official, and paying him to obtain business is the offence of bribing a foreign public official (s.6). Although no part of it happened in the UK, s.12(2)-(3) still applies because the briber has a close connection ...
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "The conduct is the s.6 offence of bribing a foreign public official.", "subject": "Bribery Act 2010, s.6", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"offence committed\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\": \"Brib...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "doc_title": "Bribery Act 2010", "unit_id": "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en::p1_b67", "quote": "(1) A person (“P”) who bribes a foreign public official (“F”) is guilty of an offence if P's intention is to influence F in F's capacity as a ...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3", "E4", "E5", "E6", "E7", "E8", "E9" ] ]
[ "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en" ]
resolve definitions and apply (foreign public official; close connection) to a territorial rule
paraphrase
LAW-en-DEV-UKCRIME
bribery-act
IN-dev-LAW-en-T2-001
null
2
dc83017d7be402100843feeb49112170dd04f95e986e19d23b58ce11fbc2c29c
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["s.6 (bribery of foreign public officials)", "s.12 (territorial application)"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "E1-E4 (s.6)", "obligation_lost": "R1: without s.6 there is no offence matching payment to a foreign official for business"}, {"removed": "E5-E9 (s.12)", "obligation_lost": "R4: without s.12 an act ...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:15:21+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en": "2de4c6347d40d5c7aeadea1483033eb4958f7cd3b63e1156ac68e5cd08d8cf61"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 9, "n_regions": 6, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 11361, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-en-T2-002
dev
en
LAW
LAW-en
T2
T2
T2_rule_exception
true
explanation
A business customer asks in March 2026 to move from its cloud provider to another provider under the EU Data Act. What is the longest notice period the contract may impose before switching starts, how long may the transition itself last, and may the provider charge for the switch?
null
The contract's maximum notice period for starting the switch may not exceed two months (Art. 25(2)(d)); the switch must then be completed within a mandatory maximum transitional period of 30 calendar days (Art. 25(2)(a)). In March 2026 the provider may still charge, but only reduced switching charges, which may not exc...
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "The notice period for initiating switching may not exceed two months.", "subject": "Data Act, Art. 25(2)(d)", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"maximum notice period\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": null, \"version\":...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "L.eurlex-32023R2854_data-act.en", "doc_title": "Regulation (EU) 2023/2854 (Data Act)", "unit_id": "L.eurlex-32023R2854_data-act.en::p1_b458", "quote": "(d) a maximum notice period for initiation of the switching process, which shall not exceed two months;", "start": ...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3", "E4" ] ]
[ "L.eurlex-32023R2854_data-act.en" ]
bounded synthesis of contract terms (Art. 25) with the dated charging rule (Art. 29)
paraphrase
LAW-en-DEV-EUDATA
data-act
IN-dev-LAW-en-T2-002
Trap: Art. 25(4) allows an alternative transitional period of up to seven months only where 30 days is technically unfeasible.
2
92fbcc272cac4ef7f919687f7c0dc23f39ebee8f7b77967a98a51929a6aaa075
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["L.eurlex-32023R2854_data-act.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["Art. 25 (contractual terms concerning switching)", "Art. 29 (gradual withdrawal of switching charges)"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "E1+E2 (Art. 25)", "obligation_lost": "R1, R2: notice and transition limits appear only in Art. 25"}, {"removed": "E3+E4 (Art. 29)", "obligation_lost": "R3, R4: the chargin...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:15:21+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"L.eurlex-32023R2854_data-act.en": "493b57e43c844eb4179eea100135860568aefdf5ceb3dabb6dfa87fab5a18fa1"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 5, "n_regions": 5, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 6936, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-en-T2-003
dev
en
LAW
LAW-en
T2
T2
T2_rule_exception
true
explanation
A medical research foundation runs on a not-for-profit basis but is legally controlled by a for-profit pharmaceutical group. Can it be registered as a recognised data altruism organisation under the Data Governance Act? And for an entity that does qualify and has supplied all the required information, how long does the...
null
No. Besides operating on a not-for-profit basis, the entity must be legally independent from any entity that operates on a for-profit basis (Art. 18(c)); a foundation controlled by a for-profit group fails that test. A qualifying entity that has submitted all the necessary information must be entered in the public nati...
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "The entity must operate on a not-for-profit basis and be legally independent from any for-profit entity.", "subject": "Data Governance Act, Art. 18(c)", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"independence requirement for registration\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", ...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en", "doc_title": "Regulation (EU) 2022/868 (Data Governance Act)", "unit_id": "L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en::p1_b280", "quote": "In order to qualify for registration in a public national register of recognised data a...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3" ] ]
[ "L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en" ]
rule + condition (eligibility requirement of Art. 18, procedure of Art. 19)
paraphrase
LAW-en-DEV-EUDATA
data-governance-act
IN-dev-LAW-en-T2-003
null
1
2687661571ab8c88b8c3b7932cb49b24ab065b2b6aa5a492bf7486308aee4fcb
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["Art. 18 (general requirements for registration)", "Art. 19 (registration procedure)"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "E1+E2 (Art. 18)", "obligation_lost": "R2: the legal-independence requirement is only in Art. 18(c)"}, {"removed": "E3 (Art. 19)", "obligation_lost": "R3, R4: the 12-week deadline and EU-wid...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:15:21+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en": "c40670fef949ee7f6e12151acea0a0f8c976308b5e1caab7e4f347d82d01fe4c"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 3, "n_regions": 3, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 4189, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-en-T3-001
dev
en
LAW
LAW-en
T3
T3
T3_cross_subject
true
comparison
The Data Governance Act and the Data Act both define a 'data holder'. How do the two definitions differ on whether a natural person can be a data holder, and on what the status is based?
null
Under the Data Governance Act a data holder is a legal person (including public sector bodies and international organisations) or a natural person who is not a data subject with respect to the data in question, and the status rests on having the right to grant access to or share personal or non-personal data (Art. 2(8)...
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "DGA: a natural person is a data holder only if not a data subject with respect to the data.", "subject": "Data Governance Act, Art. 2(8)", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"can a natural person be a data holder\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en", "doc_title": "Regulation (EU) 2022/868 (Data Governance Act)", "unit_id": "L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en::p1_b102", "quote": "(8) ‘data holder’ means a legal person, including public sector bodies and internationa...
[ [ "E1", "E2" ] ]
[ "L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en", "L.eurlex-32023R2854_data-act.en" ]
cross-subject comparison of two definitions of the same term
ordinary
LAW-en-DEV-EUDATA
data-governance-act+data-act
IN-dev-LAW-en-T3-001
null
1
576ad04511f89d0b869c148a1c34f1741d00c95bb62812518e5f7ab8fb27ac04
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en", "L.eurlex-32023R2854_data-act.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en", "L.eurlex-32023R2854_data-act.en"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en", "obligation_lost": "R1, R2: the DGA definition is only in DGA Art. 2(8)"}, {"removed": "L.eurlex-32023R2854_data-act.en", "obligation_lost": "R3, R4: ...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:15:21+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"L.eurlex-32022R0868_data-governance-act.en": "c40670fef949ee7f6e12151acea0a0f8c976308b5e1caab7e4f347d82d01fe4c", "L.eurlex-32023R2854_data-act.en": "49...
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 2, "n_regions": 2, "n_docs": 2, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-en-T3-002
dev
en
LAW
LAW-en
T3
T3
T3_cross_subject
true
comparison
A UK company can get into trouble under the Bribery Act 2010 for failing to stop a bribe paid on its behalf, and under the Modern Slavery Act 2015 for not producing a slavery and human trafficking statement. Is each of these a criminal offence, and how is each enforced or punished?
null
Bribery Act: yes, failure of a commercial organisation to prevent bribery is a criminal offence (s.7), punishable on conviction on indictment by a fine (s.11(3)); the organisation has a defence if it had adequate procedures to prevent bribery (s.7(2)). Modern Slavery Act: no offence is created; the statement duties are...
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Failure to prevent bribery is a criminal offence of the organisation.", "subject": "Bribery Act 2010, s.7", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"is failure to prevent bribery an offence\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": null, \"place\": n...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "doc_title": "Bribery Act 2010", "unit_id": "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en::p1_b99", "quote": "(1) A relevant commercial organisation (“C”) is guilty of an offence under this section if a person (“A”) associated with C bribes another per...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E4", "E5" ] ]
[ "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en" ]
cross-subject comparison of corporate compliance regimes in two Acts
paraphrase
LAW-en-DEV-UKCRIME
bribery-act+modern-slavery-act
IN-dev-LAW-en-T3-002
null
1
84ec4a2b9e1025d69c46febf5ab7f8c11a55e642b8f49377ef8191d3a89ddcc8
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "obligation_lost": "R1, R2: the s.7 offence and its fine are only in the Bribery Act"}, {"removed": "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en", "obligation_lost": "R3: the...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:15:21+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en": "2de4c6347d40d5c7aeadea1483033eb4958f7cd3b63e1156ac68e5cd08d8cf61", "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en": "9079e987...
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 5, "n_regions": 5, "n_docs": 2, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-en-T3-003
dev
en
LAW
LAW-en
T3
T3
T3_cross_subject
true
comparison
For an individual convicted on indictment, which carries the heavier maximum prison sentence: bribing a foreign public official under the Bribery Act 2010, or human trafficking under the Modern Slavery Act 2015?
null
Human trafficking. Bribing a foreign public official (s.6) carries up to 10 years' imprisonment, a fine or both on indictment (Bribery Act s.11(1)(b)); human trafficking (s.2) carries imprisonment for life on indictment (Modern Slavery Act s.5(1)(a)).
null
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "Bribery of a foreign public official: maximum 10 years on indictment.", "subject": "Bribery Act 2010, s.11(1)(b)", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"maximum prison term on indictment for an individual\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints": "{\"time\": ...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "doc_title": "Bribery Act 2010", "unit_id": "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en::p1_b148", "quote": "(1) An individual guilty of an offence under section 1, 2 or 6 is liable—", "start": 15466, "end": 15539, "text_sha256": "2de4c63...
[ [ "E1", "E2", "E3", "E4", "E5" ] ]
[ "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en" ]
cross-subject comparison of maximum penalties
ordinary
LAW-en-DEV-UKCRIME
bribery-act+modern-slavery-act
IN-dev-LAW-en-T3-003
Trap: MSA s.4 (committing an offence with intent to traffick) carries 10 years unless by kidnapping/false imprisonment.
1
d72d6a0db823be2afdf11b3706ec259619bb7d2982164a808507af9df9a5280d
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en"]}
{}
{"regions": ["L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en"], "removal_test": [{"removed": "L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en", "obligation_lost": "R1, R3: the 10-year maximum is only in Bribery Act s.11"}, {"removed": "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en", "obligation_lost": "R2, R3: the life...
null
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:15:21+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"L.ukpga-2010-23_bribery-act.en": "2de4c6347d40d5c7aeadea1483033eb4958f7cd3b63e1156ac68e5cd08d8cf61", "L.ukpga-2015-30_modern-slavery-act.en": "9079e987...
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 5, "n_regions": 5, "n_docs": 2, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-fa-AB-001
dev
fa
LAW
LAW-fa
null
T1
null
false
abstain
طبق قانون مطبوعات ۱۳۶۴، نشریه‌ای که نام صاحب امتیاز و مدیر مسئول را در شماره‌هایش چاپ نکند به چند ریال جزای نقدی محکوم می‌شود؟
Under the 1364 Press Law, what fine in rials applies to a periodical that does not print the names of its licence holder and managing editor in its issues?
در قوانین این مجموعه مبلغی برای جزای نقدیِ این تخلف طبق قانون مطبوعات ۱۳۶۴ نیامده است. این قانون درج نام صاحب امتیاز و مدیر مسئول را الزامی می‌کند و انتشار بدون آن‌ها را ممنوع می‌داند، اما مبلغی برای جزای نقدی تعیین نمی‌کند؛ بنابراین نمی‌توان رقمی ذکر کرد.
The laws in this collection give no rial fine for this offence under the 1364 Press Law. It requires the names and forbids publishing without them, but states no fine amount, so no figure can be given.
[]
[]
[]
[]
null
ordinary
LAW-fa-DEV-PRESS
press-law
IN-dev-LAW-fa-AB-001
Plausible trap: the 1334 bill does fix a rial fine; the 1364 law contains no rial amounts at all.
3
e526f2baa85740ea37aa0912b5a37633687522aaa870cff33393cbb7a6f2fb7a
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": []}
{}
null
{"missing_obligation": "A rial fine, in the 1364 Press Law, for omitting the licence holder's and managing editor's names.", "search_variants": ["ریال", "جزای نقدی", "جریمه", "غرامت", "صاحب امتیاز و مدیر مسئول", "نام صاحب امتیاز"], "inspected_locations": ["L.wikisource_press-law-1364.fa all 36 articles (esp. Arts. 7, 1...
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:09:00+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 0, "n_regions": 0, "n_docs": 0, "span_envelope_chars": null, "flags": []}
V2-dev-LAW-fa-T1-001
dev
fa
LAW
LAW-fa
T1
T1
T1_fact
true
single
طبق قانون تأمین اجتماعی، کارفرمایی که حق بیمه را در موعد مقرر نپردازد، علاوه بر خود حق بیمه، برای هر روز تأخیر چه مبلغی باید بپردازد؟
Under the Social Security Act, apart from the premium itself, what must an employer who misses the payment deadline pay for each day of delay?
برای هر روز تأخیر، نیم در هزارِ مبلغ عقب‌افتاده به‌عنوان خسارت تأخیر (ماده ۹۸). این خسارت نیز به روش مقرر در ماده ۵۰ وصول می‌شود.
An amount equal to half per thousand (0.05%) of the overdue sum for each day of delay, as delay damages (Art. 98), collected under Art. 50.
[ { "id": "R1", "proposition": "The late-payment damages are half per thousand of the overdue amount for each day of delay.", "subject": "Social Security Act 1354, Art. 98", "aspect": "{\"label\": \"daily delay damages on unpaid premiums\", \"type\": \"property\", \"object\": null}", "constraints"...
[ { "id": "E1", "doc_id": "L.wikisource_social-security-1354.fa", "doc_title": "قانون تأمین اجتماعی", "unit_id": "L.wikisource_social-security-1354.fa::p1_b408", "quote": "کارفرمایانی که در موعد مقرر در این قانون حق بیمه موضوع قانون را پرداخت ننمایند علاوه بر تأدیه حق بیمه به پرداخت مبلغی معادل‌نی...
[ [ "E1" ] ]
[ "L.wikisource_social-security-1354.fa" ]
null
ordinary
LAW-fa-DEV-SOCSEC
social-security
IN-dev-LAW-fa-T1-001
Trap: Art. 46 sets a floor of 12% a year for damages when an instalment plan is granted (different rule); Direct Taxes 1345 Art. 167 also contains 'نیم در هزار' (a levy for guild councils, unrelated).
2
0c12be85ba127f051c1bea0dd4386b167836a01b007158d7eb2bf1a0cfb4fad9
{"primary": "pool", "oracle_docs": ["L.wikisource_social-security-1354.fa"]}
{}
null
null
null
{"curator": "claude-law-author", "writer": "claude-law-author", "reviewer": null, "created": "2026-09-25T12:09:00+03:30", "legacy_parent_id": null, "source_versions": {"L.wikisource_social-security-1354.fa": "dcb006c5f958e59264917e5b3593c34ad705853fb337d6f42621c8868a003fb7"}}
{"fact_exposure": "none", "source_exposure": "indexed_only", "matches": []}
{"agent_verdict": null, "agent_notes": null, "user_verdict": null, "user_rating": null, "user_tags": [], "user_note": null, "reviewed_hash": null, "reviewed_at": null}
{"n_evidence": 1, "n_regions": 1, "n_docs": 1, "span_envelope_chars": 202, "flags": []}
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

AnyRAG benchmark

Status: public release of the benchmark of the AnyRAG study (project page; paper in preparation). The per-question results of the study are in a separate dataset, ArashNasr/anyrag-results.

156 questions (60 dev, 96 test) for retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) over natural Persian and English documents: company reports, non-fiction books and statutes. Every question has atomic answer requirements, gold evidence with exact quotes and character offsets into the frozen source text, and one or more complete evidence bundles. The benchmark was built for the paper What Reaches the Reader: A Comparison of Retrieval-Augmented Generation Setups in Persian and English (Arash Nasr Esfahani, University of Tehran).

The documents themselves are not included. corpus_manifest/ lists every document with its title, edition, source URL, landing page and file hash, so the six search pools can be rebuilt from their origins (see Rebuilding the corpus).

Composition

Six search pools, one per genre and language. Each split has the same number of questions per tier in every pool, plus one unanswerable question per pool, for which a correct answer is an abstention.

Pool Docs Characters Sources Dev Test
RPT-fa (reports) 97 4.76 M annual and activity reports of 42 Iranian companies 10 16
RPT-en (reports) 15 16.64 M annual or integrated reports of 11 international companies 10 16
BOOK-fa (non-fiction) 9 5.70 M modern Persian prose transcribed on Wikisource (e.g. Kasravi, Pirnia, Bahar) 10 16
BOOK-en (non-fiction) 11 6.26 M Project Gutenberg non-fiction (e.g. Darwin, Mill, Tocqueville, Douglass) 10 16
LAW-fa (statutes) 13 1.18 M Iranian statutes from Wikisource transcriptions (Civil Code, Commercial Codes, Direct Taxes Acts and others) 10 16
LAW-en (statutes) 10 3.52 M EU regulations (GDPR, DSA, AI Act and others) and UK Acts 10 16
Total 155 38.06 M 60 96
Split T1 T2 T3 Unanswerable Total Persian / English
dev 18 18 18 6 60 30 / 30
test 30 30 30 6 96 48 / 48

The two languages are not translations of each other: they use different documents, so a difference between the Persian and the English half mixes the effect of the language with the effect of the sources.

Tiers

The tier of a question is the least widely spread evidence that suffices to answer it, judged against the whole frozen pool (including restatements and answers that can be derived), not by character distance.

Tier Meaning Subtypes
T1 Local fact: one coherent passage, list or table region gives the answer and its binding labels T1_fact, T1_list_local, T1_table_cell
T2 Within-document integration: one document suffices, but no single region does; a named integration operation is needed T2_definition_bridge, T2_rule_exception, T2_comparison_derivation, T2_bounded_synthesis
T3 Cross-document integration: every sufficient evidence bundle spans at least two documents T3_cross_time_version, T3_cross_subject, T3_cross_doc_bridge, T3_bounded_aggregation
(null) Unanswerable: tier is null, intended_tier records the attempted task, answer_format is abstain -

Files

Path What
data/dev.jsonl, data/test.jsonl the 60 dev and 96 test questions in a viewer-friendly form (the default config)
data/decisive_spans_dev.jsonl decisive spans of the 60 dev questions (the decisive_spans config)
questions/{rpt,book,law}_{dev,test}.jsonl the frozen question files, verbatim, one JSON object per line (question-v2 schema); their SHA-256 hashes are in FROZEN_questions.json
questions/*_review_decisions.jsonl, questions/AUTHORING_LOG.md the source-review verdicts (accept / fix / reject) and the authoring log
decisive_spans/ decisive spans for the dev questions (verbatim) and their summary
corpus_manifest/manifest.csv report pools: company, title (Persian and English), year, format, pages, source URL, landing URL, SHA-256 and notes, including reports that were looked for but not downloaded
corpus_manifest/manifest_v2.csv, sources_v2.json, FROZEN_v2.json book and law pools: title, edition, source and landing URLs, reuse basis, conversion notes, SHA-256 of the original and converted files and of the extracted text
corpus_manifest/FROZEN_reports.json SHA-256 of the extracted text of the report pools
run_format/test_v2judge_all.jsonl the 96 test questions in the run format the study's harness and report scripts read (derived from questions/*_test.jsonl; each record cites the source file hash)
SCHEMA.json JSON Schema of a question record
DESIGN.md the design document (tier rules, quotas, authoring and review pipeline) agreed before authoring

data/*.jsonl and questions/*.jsonl hold the same records. In data/, the fields whose structure varies from record to record are stored as JSON-encoded strings so the dataset viewer and datasets can load them: the requirement fields value, aspect and constraints, and the top-level fields doc_scope, accepted_alternatives, necessity_audit, absence_audit, paraphrase_of, provenance, exposure, review and descriptive (decode them with json.loads). split is dev in data/ and dev_open in the verbatim files, and oracle_docs is copied out of doc_scope. For exact reproduction use the verbatim files in questions/.

from datasets import load_dataset
import json

ds = load_dataset("ArashNasr/anyrag-benchmark")            # splits: dev, test
q = ds["test"][0]
print(q["id"], q["tier"], q["question"])
for r in q["requirements"]:
    print(r["id"], r["proposition"], json.loads(r["value"]))
for e in q["evidence"]:
    print(e["doc_id"], e["unit_id"], e["start"], e["end"], e["quote"])

Fields

The full definition is SCHEMA.json. A pipeline under evaluation should see only id, question, language, pool_id and (for the shared answer prompt) answer_format; everything else is for the evaluator.

Field Meaning
id e.g. V2-test-RPT-fa-T1-001; AB in place of the tier marks an unanswerable question
split, language (fa/en), domain (RPT/BOOK/LAW), pool_id split, language, genre and the search pool (the whole pool is the primary search scope)
tier, intended_tier, subtype tier (null for unanswerable), the attempted tier, the subtype
question, question_gloss_en the question in its language; an English gloss for Persian questions (a review aid, never given to a pipeline)
expected_answer, expected_answer_gloss_en the reference answer, stating every required requirement; English gloss for Persian
answer_format, answerable shared answer contract (single, list, comparison, series, explanation, abstain); whether the question has an answer in the pool
requirements[] atomic answer obligations: id, proposition, subject, aspect, constraints (time, place, version, population, unit, condition, definition), typed value with unit, value_type and comparator, required (operands that only support a derived result are optional) and kind
evidence[] every piece of source text the answer rests on, including binding labels: doc_id, doc_title, unit_id, quote (short, exact), start/end (code-point offsets into the frozen extracted text), text_sha256, role, region, supports (requirement ids)
evidence_bundles each bundle is a complete, sufficient set of evidence ids; alternative bundles are interchangeable
accepted_alternatives requirement id to accepted alternative answers (e.g. other units)
integration_operation, necessity_audit T2/T3: the named operation and the removal test that shows each region is needed
absence_audit unanswerable questions: the missing obligation, the search variants and the locations inspected
source_block, source_family, information_need_id allocation units: a source block lies entirely in one split; dev and test share no evidence document, source block or information need
wording ordinary or paraphrase (about half of each)
provenance the agent roles that drafted the record, creation time and the SHA-256 of each source document version
exposure whether the fact or source had appeared in earlier, unrelated question sets
review review slots bound to content_hash (not populated in the released records; see the construction notes below)
content_hash SHA-256 over question, expected answer, answer format, requirements, evidence and bundles (canonical JSON)
descriptive verifier statistics (number of evidence items, regions, documents, span envelope), never used as tier gates

Decisive spans (dev only): for each dev question and requirement, the minimal sentence-level part of a gold quote that holds the value of the requirement (spans[] with doc_id, unit_id, offsets and the short text), matched after Persian and Arabic letter and digit folding. There are 158 spans over the 54 answerable dev questions (median 113 characters, at most 390). They were used for development diagnostics only.

How the questions were built

The author designed the benchmark and its construction procedure. The questions were built in six steps, four automated and two by people:

  1. A curator agent (Claude Opus 5.5) chose information needs in the frozen pools and wrote the requirements, quotes, bundles and audits, without seeing any method output.
  2. A question-writer agent wrote the question and the expected answer from that specification, about half in ordinary wording and half paraphrased. The saved provenance records the same agent identifier for both roles on all 156 questions, so the intended separation of the two roles cannot be shown.
  3. A mechanical verifier checked the schema, that every quote equals the frozen text at its offsets, and that a bundle supports every requirement, and flagged copied spans, answer leakage and near-duplicates.
  4. A separate source-review agent (Claude Opus 5.5) checked answers, tiers (by the removal test) and necessity against the full pool. First-round outcomes (accept / fix / reject) over the 52 questions of each genre were 37 / 11 / 4 for reports, 42 / 8 / 2 for books and 43 / 6 / 3 for laws; fixes were applied and replacements re-reviewed (questions/*_review_decisions.jsonl).
  5. A native Persian speaker reviewed the Persian wording (141 findings over the three Persian sets, applied with a change log).
  6. The author spot-checked 32 of the 156 questions in an interface that showed the question, the expected answer, the requirements and the marked evidence: 31 were accepted and 1 was fixed.

Limits. The benchmark was drafted and source-checked by language-model agents, and only a sample was checked by a person. No independent annotator validated answerability, tiers or gold evidence. Some English book and statute questions can be answered from memory. Some report sources had been used in earlier, unrelated question sets, so for reports the test evaluates new questions but not unseen documents. Development documents act as distractors for test questions, and the two splits share the searchable pools. Many test questions share source material: the 90 answerable test questions fall into 20 groups that share a source, so confidence intervals should resample whole groups.

Rebuilding the corpus

The report, book and law documents are not redistributed. The books (Project Gutenberg, Wikisource) and statutes (EUR-Lex, legislation.gov.uk, Iranian statute transcriptions on Wikisource) are public, and the company reports are published by the companies themselves.

  1. Download each document listed in corpus_manifest/manifest.csv (reports) and corpus_manifest/manifest_v2.csv (books and laws) from its source_url (or landing_url) and check its sha256. Rows without a local file were looked for but not used.
  2. Convert and extract the text with the study's conversion and extraction scripts (code/corpus_build/ and code/tools/extract/ in the AnyRAG code release; see the project page for its availability). The conversion notes in manifest_v2.csv and sources_v2.json describe what was removed from each book and statute file.
  3. Compare the extracted text with the hashes in FROZEN_v2.json and FROZEN_reports.json. When they match, the unit_id, start and end of every evidence item point at the exact quote, and its text_sha256 can be checked.

Web pages and report files can change or disappear; when a file no longer matches its hash, the gold offsets for that document may not hold.

Intended use

  • Evaluating retrieval and evidence selection for RAG in Persian and English: whether a complete evidence bundle reaches the candidate list and the reader's evidence pack, at a fixed evidence budget.
  • Evaluating answers against atomic requirements (with an LLM or human judge) and abstention on unanswerable questions.
  • Development work on the dev split.

The test split has already been used. The 96 test questions were the one-shot test of the paper, and all of the paper's post hoc analyses were run on the same test set, so it is no longer an unseen test. Use it for comparison with the paper's numbers, and tune only on dev. With 90 answerable test questions only differences of about 11 answers are detectable.

This is a small research benchmark, not a measure of general RAG quality. The questions were drafted by language models and checked mostly by language models (see the limits above).

Licence

The annotations (questions, answers, requirements, evidence records, bundles, decisive spans and the manifest) are released under CC BY 4.0 (see LICENSE-DATA). The source documents are not part of this licence and keep their own terms (public domain, official legislation, or the publishing company's terms); the short gold quotations are included for research purposes.

Citation

@misc{nasresfahani2026evidence,
  title  = {What Reaches the Reader: A Comparison of Retrieval-Augmented Generation Setups in Persian and English},
  author = {Nasr Esfahani, Arash},
  year   = {2026},
  note   = {In preparation. University of Tehran. Project page: https://arashnasresfahani.github.io/AnyRAG/}
}

Links

Downloads last month
49