What Does It Cost to Force-Close a Lightning Channel? Evidence from 974,000 Channel Closes, 2018-2026
Paper • 2611.16311 • Published
date large_stringlengths 8 8 | channels int64 4.86k 50.9k | nodes int64 2.32k 13.1k | cap_btc float64 746 5.84k | fresh14_share float64 0 0.98 | epoch large_stringclasses 3
values | status large_stringclasses 3
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
20230508 | 42,321 | 8,335 | 3,957.041222 | 0.966612 | A | ok |
20230808 | 42,318 | 8,702 | 3,610.647962 | 0.957418 | A | ok |
20230810 | 42,394 | 8,715 | 3,628.350519 | 0.956598 | A | ok |
20231020 | 44,565 | 8,537 | 4,675.005125 | 0.963963 | A | ok |
20231022 | 44,006 | 8,499 | 4,620.827511 | 0.961732 | A | ok |
20231023 | 43,900 | 8,493 | 4,540.112296 | 0.96082 | A | ok |
20231030 | 43,890 | 8,403 | 4,597.794574 | 0.95753 | A | ok |
20231101 | 43,856 | 8,393 | 4,625.510625 | 0.959709 | A | ok |
20231102 | 43,924 | 8,399 | 4,639.760335 | 0.960067 | A | ok |
20231103 | 43,934 | 8,398 | 4,643.791488 | 0.960054 | A | ok |
20231106 | 43,977 | 8,404 | 4,656.775149 | 0.961184 | A | ok |
20231107 | 43,970 | 8,411 | 4,639.873861 | 0.962156 | A | ok |
20231108 | 43,970 | 8,422 | 4,644.720995 | 0.961906 | A | ok |
20231109 | 43,920 | 8,428 | 4,617.924868 | 0.962204 | A | ok |
20231111 | 43,896 | 8,428 | 4,630.36338 | 0.960908 | A | ok |
20231113 | 43,867 | 8,437 | 4,636.993514 | 0.963047 | A | ok |
20231114 | 43,835 | 8,434 | 4,637.883941 | 0.961059 | A | ok |
20231115 | 43,781 | 8,430 | 4,648.316219 | 0.962084 | A | ok |
20231116 | 43,771 | 8,432 | 4,650.65143 | 0.960659 | A | ok |
20231117 | 43,738 | 8,439 | 4,638.712323 | 0.959555 | A | ok |
20231121 | 43,706 | 8,459 | 4,685.866075 | 0.959205 | A | ok |
20231122 | 43,703 | 8,462 | 4,689.96853 | 0.957097 | A | ok |
20231125 | 43,646 | 8,450 | 4,688.395721 | 0.949228 | A | ok |
20231126 | 43,640 | 8,445 | 4,688.344826 | 0.945555 | A | ok |
20231127 | 43,625 | 8,440 | 4,687.892094 | 0.939484 | A | ok |
20231130 | 43,017 | 8,440 | 4,458.38772 | 0.926936 | A | ok |
20231204 | 42,981 | 8,443 | 4,453.01401 | 0.930876 | A | ok |
20231205 | 42,771 | 8,418 | 4,443.55942 | 0.925393 | A | ok |
20231208 | 42,724 | 8,422 | 4,448.463567 | 0.937506 | A | ok |
20231210 | 42,655 | 8,421 | 4,465.949159 | 0.944883 | A | ok |
20231211 | 42,635 | 8,433 | 4,444.255831 | 0.947578 | A | ok |
20231212 | 42,623 | 8,448 | 4,430.583938 | 0.949487 | A | ok |
20231213 | 42,643 | 8,452 | 4,434.141618 | 0.950379 | A | ok |
20231215 | 42,645 | 8,459 | 4,443.431535 | 0.952327 | A | ok |
20231217 | 42,559 | 8,460 | 4,429.07935 | 0.954064 | A | ok |
20231219 | 42,564 | 8,474 | 4,427.518516 | 0.953623 | A | ok |
20231220 | 42,575 | 8,485 | 4,420.221961 | 0.952813 | A | ok |
20231221 | 42,549 | 8,474 | 4,427.000905 | 0.951186 | A | ok |
20231223 | 42,512 | 8,487 | 4,384.922135 | 0.950273 | A | ok |
20231225 | 42,507 | 8,485 | 4,385.259897 | 0.950808 | A | ok |
20231227 | 42,539 | 8,495 | 4,396.600268 | 0.949388 | A | ok |
20231228 | 42,484 | 8,504 | 4,429.779891 | 0.948922 | A | ok |
20231231 | 42,393 | 8,517 | 4,410.082041 | 0.9461 | A | ok |
20240102 | 42,200 | 8,530 | 4,369.095896 | 0.948081 | A | ok |
20240103 | 42,156 | 8,562 | 4,377.819122 | 0.948643 | A | ok |
20240104 | 42,135 | 8,563 | 4,393.877311 | 0.947455 | A | ok |
20240105 | 42,159 | 8,582 | 4,400.213149 | 0.949121 | A | ok |
20240106 | 42,095 | 8,568 | 4,406.298764 | 0.949305 | A | ok |
20240108 | 42,129 | 8,569 | 4,436.102357 | 0.949607 | A | ok |
20240109 | 42,102 | 8,563 | 4,462.899997 | 0.949955 | A | ok |
20240110 | 42,137 | 8,570 | 4,459.564202 | 0.950803 | A | ok |
20240111 | 41,841 | 8,573 | 4,239.76648 | 0.952582 | A | ok |
20240112 | 41,836 | 8,571 | 4,237.156649 | 0.951884 | A | ok |
20240113 | 41,764 | 8,552 | 4,232.022549 | 0.951513 | A | ok |
20240114 | 41,769 | 8,561 | 4,238.657783 | 0.951902 | A | ok |
20240115 | 41,768 | 8,560 | 4,240.386643 | 0.949938 | A | ok |
20240117 | 41,745 | 8,573 | 4,291.979717 | 0.95106 | A | ok |
20240118 | 41,686 | 8,580 | 4,287.030063 | 0.951782 | A | ok |
20240119 | 41,696 | 8,583 | 4,300.537652 | 0.950955 | A | ok |
20240122 | 41,776 | 8,602 | 4,333.069216 | 0.950689 | A | ok |
20240123 | 41,695 | 8,608 | 4,286.223706 | 0.950042 | A | ok |
20240124 | 41,688 | 8,609 | 4,283.39938 | 0.949818 | A | ok |
20240125 | 41,623 | 8,607 | 4,285.238142 | 0.949715 | A | ok |
20240126 | 41,605 | 8,616 | 4,305.948681 | 0.949501 | A | ok |
20240127 | 41,637 | 8,623 | 4,303.231054 | 0.949636 | A | ok |
20240129 | 41,761 | 8,641 | 4,336.615655 | 0.948373 | A | ok |
20240131 | 41,800 | 8,642 | 4,369.787437 | 0.947392 | A | ok |
20240201 | 41,823 | 8,645 | 4,390.286008 | 0.947899 | A | ok |
20240203 | 41,617 | 8,647 | 4,392.939111 | 0.946416 | A | ok |
20240204 | 41,595 | 8,647 | 4,389.253634 | 0.944633 | A | ok |
20240205 | 41,585 | 8,644 | 4,389.073309 | 0.942335 | A | ok |
20240207 | 41,580 | 8,641 | 4,388.960309 | 0.936003 | A | ok |
20240211 | 41,580 | 8,641 | 4,388.960309 | 0.91746 | A | ok |
20240212 | 40,014 | 8,376 | 4,216.513534 | 0.930224 | A | ok |
20240213 | 40,028 | 8,360 | 4,233.881396 | 0.932123 | A | ok |
20240214 | 40,039 | 8,363 | 4,241.456556 | 0.931242 | A | ok |
20240215 | 39,916 | 8,347 | 4,264.707287 | 0.931957 | A | ok |
20240219 | 39,273 | 8,245 | 4,129.439646 | 0.939577 | A | ok |
20240220 | 39,216 | 8,241 | 4,131.669238 | 0.943926 | A | ok |
20240222 | 39,233 | 8,237 | 4,182.586479 | 0.949609 | A | ok |
20240223 | 39,174 | 8,246 | 4,089.199242 | 0.950733 | A | ok |
20240224 | 39,225 | 8,247 | 4,071.715946 | 0.952913 | A | ok |
20240226 | 39,048 | 8,204 | 4,082.33939 | 0.955721 | A | ok |
20240227 | 39,088 | 8,210 | 4,098.118958 | 0.954897 | A | ok |
20240229 | 38,971 | 8,226 | 4,027.281702 | 0.955736 | A | ok |
20240304 | 39,049 | 8,243 | 4,066.564518 | 0.955594 | A | ok |
20240305 | 38,974 | 8,243 | 4,069.701309 | 0.955688 | A | ok |
20240306 | 38,907 | 8,238 | 4,059.831265 | 0.955047 | A | ok |
20240311 | 38,660 | 8,205 | 4,045.2192 | 0.95507 | A | ok |
20240312 | 38,587 | 8,196 | 4,068.817789 | 0.955166 | A | ok |
20240313 | 38,365 | 8,159 | 4,065.04136 | 0.954985 | A | ok |
20240315 | 38,244 | 8,151 | 4,090.542835 | 0.95432 | A | ok |
20240316 | 38,232 | 8,148 | 4,090.285592 | 0.951664 | A | ok |
20240317 | 38,223 | 8,142 | 4,090.094112 | 0.949062 | A | ok |
20240318 | 38,223 | 8,142 | 4,090.094112 | 0.946132 | A | ok |
20240319 | 38,223 | 8,142 | 4,090.094112 | 0.942731 | A | ok |
20240320 | 38,223 | 8,142 | 4,090.094112 | 0.939461 | A | ok |
20240321 | 38,223 | 8,142 | 4,090.094112 | 0.93483 | A | ok |
20240324 | 37,728 | 8,074 | 4,044.797015 | 0.927295 | A | ok |
20240325 | 37,709 | 8,068 | 4,049.030626 | 0.925588 | A | ok |
describegraph), 2023–2026
Open daily Parquet snapshots of the public Bitcoin Lightning Network gossip graph captured from our LND node (describegraph), curated by Bitcoin Data Labs (501(c)(3)).
bitcoindatalabs.org/research.html · Live Dashboard: lightning.bitcoindatalabs.orgzenodo.org/communities/bitcoindatalabs · Dataset DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24292148BitcoindataLabs/ln-gossip-daily10.5281/zenodo.24285334): github.com/bitcoindatalabs/bitcoindatalabs-mcp (uvx bitcoindatalabs-mcp)LN_PARQUET_DIR):arXiv:2610.20952): github.com/bitcoindatalabs/ln-client-diversityarXiv:2610.30350): github.com/bitcoindatalabs/ln-upgrade-dynamicsarXiv:2611.16311): github.com/bitcoindatalabs/ln-force-close-costs20230508 through 20261115 (847 quality-checked ok days included; 899 total raw captures documented in _quality.parquet / quality.parquet: 847 ok, 51 partial, 1 stale).arXiv:2610.20952, arXiv:2610.30350, and arXiv:2611.16311: Our research series truncates snapshots at fixed cutoffs (DATA_CUTOFF = "20261004" for Papers 1–2: 805 ok days; 2026-10 block 974,041 for Paper 3). Using any companion repo, extract the Zenodo yearly archives into one gossip_daily/ directory alongside _quality.parquet and run:export LN_PARQUET_DIR=/path/to/parquet_root # containing gossip_daily/{nodes,policies,_quality.parquet}
python src/01_client_census.py
Our gossip vantage node was replaced in mid-2024, which changes baseline channel and node visibility. Compare levels strictly within an epoch (or filter epoch == 'B' in quality.parquet for a homogeneous post-replacement panel):
| Epoch / Window | Dates | ok Days |
Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Epoch A | 2023-05-08 – 2024-04-27 |
132 | Prior vantage node (~37–44k channels, ~8.0–8.6k nodes with channels). |
gap (partial, excluded) |
2024-05-07 – 2024-06-30 |
0 (51 partial) | Partial captures (4.9k–8.8k channels, except 2024-06-10). Exact vantage jump occurred 2024-06-20 -> 2024-06-21 (44,025 -> 50,867 channels; 12,254 -> 13,037 nodes). |
| Epoch B | 2024-07-01 – 20261115 |
715 | Post-replacement vantage point (~41k median channels in 2024–early 2026; ~26.5k channels by Nov 2026). Includes documented missing "wallet locked" periods (2024-07-24–2024-08-05, 2025-03-27–2025-05-18) and 1 stale day (2024-08-06, excluded). |
describegraph).bitcoindatalabs.org), published security analyses should remain aggregates only (no naming, ranking, or labeling of individual nodes by software vulnerability or exploit exposure)."Source: Bitcoin Data Labs (bitcoindatalabs.org)".SELECT count(*), sum(capacity) / 2e8 AS total_cap_btc
FROM read_parquet('hf://datasets/BitcoindataLabs/ln-gossip-daily/data/policies/year=2026/date=20261004.parquet');
huggingface_hub + pandas)
from huggingface_hub import hf_hub_download
import pandas as pd
quality = pd.read_parquet(
hf_hub_download("BitcoindataLabs/ln-gossip-daily", "data/quality.parquet", repo_type="dataset")
)
epoch_b_dates = quality.query("epoch == 'B' and status == 'ok'")["date"].tolist()
bitcoindatalabs-mcp)
Need aggregate paper metrics, fee-spike close ratios, release-lag statistics, or weekly PlebRank centrality without scanning all 5.7 GiB locally? Run our MIT-licensed MCP server in Claude, Cursor, or VS Code (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24285334):
{
"mcpServers": {
"bitcoindatalabs-mcp": {
"command": "uvx",
"args": ["bitcoindatalabs-mcp"]
}
}
}
@misc{kumar2026lngossipdaily,
author = {Kumar, Saurabh},
title = {Lightning Network Daily Gossip Snapshots (describegraph), 2023--2026},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
publisher = {Zenodo},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.24292148},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24292148}
}
@misc{kumar2026clientdiversity,
author = {Kumar, Saurabh},
title = {Does Client Diversity Protect the Lightning Network? Evidence from the 2026 Core Lightning Shutdown},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
eprint = {2610.20952},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
primaryClass = {cs.CR},
doi = {10.48550/arXiv.2610.20952},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.20952}
}
@misc{kumar2026upgradedynamics,
author = {Kumar, Saurabh},
title = {Who Patches the Lightning Network? Evidence from Release Lines in Gossip, 2023--2026},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
eprint = {2610.30350},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
primaryClass = {cs.CR},
doi = {10.48550/arXiv.2610.30350},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.30350}
}
@misc{kumar2026forceclosecosts,
author = {Kumar, Saurabh},
title = {What Does It Cost to Force-Close a Lightning Channel? Evidence from 974,000 Channel Closes, 2018--2026},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
eprint = {2611.16311},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
primaryClass = {cs.CR},
doi = {10.48550/arXiv.2611.16311},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.16311}
}