Brownight's picture
add DGP.md
0e47b20 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
6.52 kB

Instrumental-variables data-generating processes

Each table describes 500 independent units from one simulated study. The observed variables are baseline covariates X, a binary instrument Z, a binary treatment D and an outcome Y. Holding the study's family and parameter draw fixed, the target is the population local average treatment effect:

LATE=E[Y(1)−Y(0)∣D(1)>D(0)]. \mathrm{LATE}=\mathbb E[Y(1)-Y(0)\mid D(1)>D(0)].

Every design satisfies exclusion (Z affects Y only through D), monotonicity (D(1) ≥ D(0)) and independence of Z given X. The nuisance functions used by the reference methods are the instrument propensity e(x) = P(Z=1 | x), the treatment means mD(x,z) = P(D=1 | x, Z=z) and the outcome means mY(x,z) = E[Y | x, Z=z]; all three families give them in closed form, and the LATE equals E[mY(x,1) − mY(x,0)] / E[mD(x,1) − mD(x,0)].

How the splits were generated

Released split Tables Family and parameter sampling
Historical adapter training 20,000 Draw one of the three families with equal probability, then its parameters from the prior below, then 500 context rows and 64 query rows. Root seed 20261116, split id 0.
Historical validation 1,000 Same prior, root seed 20261116, split id 1.
Starter train / dev / test 48 / 16 / 32 Fresh draws from the same prior with seed 20261119 and split ids 0 / 1 / 2; 500 rows per table.
Pooled evaluation 2,000 Draw each family with probability 1/3, then its parameters, then its 500 rows. Seed 20261117.

All randomness comes from numpy.random.SeedSequence([seed, split_id, table_index]), so every table can be regenerated from its indices with the generator shipped in the starter kit (iv_data.py, reference/). Evaluation draws one table per parameter draw; each table contributes one estimate and one interval.

Family Observed covariates Outcome Training tables Validation tables Evaluation tables
ding 0 binary 6,756 317 665
qiu 2, 5, 10 or 20 continuous 6,547 333 658
kennedy2020 1 binary 6,697 350 677

Designs and parameter priors

U(a, b) is a continuous uniform distribution; alternatives in a set have equal probability; parameters are drawn once per table. The ranges are ours, chosen to cover a broad band of instrument strengths and effect sizes; they are not the settings used in the source papers.

Binary instrument with a latent binary confounder (ding)

Source design — Ding, VanderWeele and Robins (2017), Instrumental variables as bias amplifiers with general outcome and confounding, Biometrika 104(2), Table 1 (doi); generator copied verbatim from the Arena registry file iv-ding-2017-binary-bias-v1.py. No covariates: X has zero columns.

Z∼Bernoulli(pz),U∼Bernoulli(pu),D∣Z,U∼Bernoulli(pZ,U),Y∣D,U∼Bernoulli(rD,U), \begin{aligned} Z&\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(p_z), & U&\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(p_u),\\ D\mid Z,U&\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(p_{Z,U}), & Y\mid D,U&\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(r_{D,U}), \end{aligned}

with monotonicity p₁,ᵤ ≥ p₀,ᵤ. Draw order per unit: Z, U, D, Y.

Parameter Prior
p_z, p_u U(0.2, 0.8) each
p₀,ᵤ for u ∈ {0, 1} U(0.05, 0.60) each
p₁,ᵤ p₀,ᵤ + (1 − p₀,ᵤ) f_u, f_u ~ U(0.1, 0.8)
r_{d,u}, four entries U(0.005, 0.995) each

Nuisances are constants: e = p_z, mD(z) = Σ_u P(U=u) p_{z,u}, mY(z) = Σ_u P(U=u) [(1 − p_{z,u}) r_{0,u} + p_{z,u} r_{1,u}]. LATE = Σ_u P(U=u)(p₁,ᵤ − p₀,ᵤ)(r₁,ᵤ − r₀,ᵤ) / Σ_u P(U=u)(p₁,ᵤ − p₀,ᵤ).

Principal strata with Poisson outcome shifts (qiu)

Source design — Qiu, Tao and Zhou (2021), Inference of heterogeneous treatment effects using observational data with high-dimensional covariates, JRSS-B 83(5), Section 6 DGP2 without interaction (doi); generator copied verbatim from the Arena registry file iv-qiu-2021-principal-stratum-poisson-v1.py.

x1∼N(0,σ0),xj=ρ xj−1+σ0(1−ρ2) εj (j≥2),t=∑j=1pxj/j2,Z∼Bernoulli(L(t)),D0=1[t−ζ+ε0≥0],D1=D0∨1[t+ζ+ε1≥0],D=DZ,Y=α0D+2t+ε+K11D0+K00(1−D1),K11∼Poisson(λ11),K00∼Poisson(λ00), \begin{aligned} x_1&\sim N(0,\sigma_0), & x_j&=\rho\,x_{j-1}+\sqrt{\sigma_0(1-\rho^2)}\,\varepsilon_j\ (j\ge 2), & t&=\sum_{j=1}^{p} x_j/j^2,\\ Z&\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(L(t)), & D_0&=\mathbf 1[t-\zeta+\varepsilon_0\ge 0], & D_1&=D_0\vee\mathbf 1[t+\zeta+\varepsilon_1\ge 0],\quad D=D_Z,\\ Y&=\alpha_0 D+2t+\varepsilon+K_{11}D_0+K_{00}(1-D_1), & K_{11}&\sim\mathrm{Poisson}(\lambda_{11}), & K_{00}&\sim\mathrm{Poisson}(\lambda_{00}), \end{aligned}

with L the logistic function and ε, ε₀, ε₁, ε_j independent standard normal.

Parameter Prior
p {2, 5, 10, 20}
σ₀ U(0.25, 1)
ρ U(0, 0.7)
ζ U(0.3, 1.5)
α₀ U(−2, 2)
λ₁₁, λ₀₀ U(0, 1.5) each

Nuisances: e(x) = L(t), mD(x,0) = Φ(t − ζ), mD(x,1) = a + (1 − a)Φ(t + ζ) with a = Φ(t − ζ), mY(x,z) = 2t + λ₁₁ a + λ₀₀ (1 − a)(1 − Φ(t + ζ)) + α₀ mD(x,z). LATE = α₀.

Sharp-instrument design with a latent complier type (kennedy2020)

Source design — Kennedy, Balakrishnan and G'Sell (2020), Sharp instruments for classifying compliers and generalizing causal effects, Annals of Statistics 48(4), Section 6.1 and Appendices E and I (arXiv).

X∼N(0,1),C∣X∼Bernoulli(Φ(b0+b1X)),Z∣X∼Bernoulli(L(X)),D=CZ+(1−C)A∗, A∗∼Bernoulli(1/2),Ya∼Bernoulli(0.5+(a−0.5)β),Y=YD. \begin{aligned} X&\sim N(0,1), & C\mid X&\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(\Phi(b_0+b_1X)), & Z\mid X&\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(L(X)),\\ D&=CZ+(1-C)A^*,\ A^*\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(1/2), & Y^a&\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(0.5+(a-0.5)\beta), & Y&=Y^D. \end{aligned}

C is the latent complier indicator. (b₀, b₁) are solved from the complier strength μ = E[Φ(b₀ + b₁X)], fixed at 0.3, and the sharpness ψ of the paper (b₁ from a 400-point ψ table, b₀ = Φ⁻¹(μ)·√(1 + b₁²)).

Parameter Prior
μ 0.3 (fixed)
ψ U(0.2, 0.8)
β U(−0.4, 0.4)

Nuisances with γ(x) = Φ(b₀ + b₁x): e(x) = L(x), mD(x,0) = (1 − γ)/2, mD(x,1) = γ + (1 − γ)/2, mY(x,z) = 0.5 − β/2 + β mD(x,z). LATE = β.

Notes

  • About 1% of tables have a very weak instrument (first-stage difference below 0.05); they are kept and dominate the RMSE of any estimator.
  • In the Kennedy design e(x) runs from about 0.04 to 0.96 over the observed range of X; learners whose propensity estimates reach exactly 0 or 1 (for example untrimmed random forests) fail on it unless the propensity is clipped.
  • The Ding tables have no covariates, so their nuisances are constants and the LATE reduces to the Wald ratio.
  • Everything is simulated from the equations above; no real data is involved.