question_id
stringlengths 9
12
| question
stringlengths 25
94
| model_output
stringlengths 651
1.5k
| ground_truth
stringclasses 2
values | image
imagewidth (px) 225
640
| image_name
stringlengths 29
31
| task
stringclasses 5
values | hallucination_annotation
listlengths 4
17
| annotator_model
stringclasses 1
value | model_name
stringclasses 1
value | detailed_prompt
stringlengths 25
94
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
base_28_1
|
Is there a TV present in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if a TV is present, focusing on visual details and context. I will then provide a step-by-step reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a room with a television placed on a stand. The TV is displaying a scene, and there are curtains on the window behind it. The room appears to be a living space with a chair and a guitar visible. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if a TV is present, I will first identify any electronic devices that resemble a television. The image clearly shows a rectangular screen on a stand, which is characteristic of a TV. The presence of a stand and the screen's display further confirm this identification. Additionally, the context of the room, which appears to be a living area, supports the presence of a TV for entertainment purposes. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes, there is a TV present in the image. It is placed on a stand in a living room, and it is displaying a scene. </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000411617.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 230,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "television placed on a stand",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a TV mounted or placed on what appears to be a black entertainment stand/cabinet in the room."
},
{
"index": 270,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "displaying a scene",
"verification_note": "The TV screen is visibly turned on and displaying what appears to be content/imagery on the screen."
},
{
"index": 304,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "curtains on the window behind it",
"verification_note": "There are brown curtains visible on both sides of a window behind the TV stand."
},
{
"index": 363,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "living space",
"verification_note": "The room appears to be a residential living area with typical living room furnishings and layout."
},
{
"index": 383,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "chair",
"verification_note": "A portion of what appears to be a chair is visible in the lower left corner of the image."
},
{
"index": 395,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "guitar",
"verification_note": "A guitar is visible in the lower right portion of the image on the floor."
},
{
"index": 567,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "rectangular screen on a stand",
"verification_note": "The TV has a rectangular screen and is positioned on/above a dark entertainment stand."
},
{
"index": 946,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "living room",
"verification_note": "The context and furnishings indicate this is a living room space."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a TV present in the image?
|
|
base_44_0
|
Is the lime green object circular in shape?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the shape of the lime green object. I will describe the visual elements, consider the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a dimly lit room with two individuals standing at a counter. The room is illuminated by lime green star-shaped projections on the walls. A small, round, lime green object is visible on the counter. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the lime green object is circular, I will focus on its shape and size. The object appears to be small and round, consistent with a circular shape. The context of the room, with its artistic lighting, suggests that the object is part of the setup, possibly a decorative element. The round shape is typical for such objects, reinforcing the conclusion. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000013357.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 252,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "two individuals",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows two people in the room, one on the left and one on the right side of the counter/desk."
},
{
"index": 318,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "lime green star-shaped projections",
"verification_note": "The image shows multiple lime green star-shaped light projections on the walls throughout the room."
},
{
"index": 369,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "small, round, lime green object",
"verification_note": "The completion describes a 'round' lime green object on the counter, but examining the image shows the lime green objects are star-shaped, not circular/round. The model appears to have hallucinated a round object based on common expectations, contradicting the actual star-shaped visual evidence. The groundtruth confirms the answer should be 'no' to whether the lime green object is circular."
},
{
"index": 564,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "small and round",
"verification_note": "The reasoning section describes the object as 'small and round', but the visible lime green objects in the image are star-shaped, not round. This contradicts the visual evidence."
},
{
"index": 599,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "circular shape",
"verification_note": "The completion claims the object has a circular shape, but the lime green objects visible in the image are clearly star-shaped. This is a hallucination that contradicts the visual evidence."
},
{
"index": 750,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "round shape",
"verification_note": "The reasoning reinforces the incorrect claim about a 'round shape', which contradicts the star-shaped lime green objects actually visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 846,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "Yes",
"verification_note": "The final conclusion 'Yes' is incorrect. The lime green objects in the image are star-shaped, not circular. The groundtruth confirms the correct answer is 'no'. This represents a fundamental hallucination where the model contradicts clear visual evidence."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the lime green object circular in shape?
|
|
base_108_1
|
Is the uniform white in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if the uniform is white, focusing on the clothing and context. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and provide a logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows two tennis players on a clay court. Both players are wearing white uniforms, including white shirts and shorts. The player in the foreground is holding a tennis racket, and the player in the background is celebrating or acknowledging the crowd. The audience is seated in the background, watching the match. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the uniform is white, I will examine the clothing of the players. Both players are wearing white shirts and shorts, which are typical for tennis uniforms. The color contrast with the clay court and the audience's clothing further supports that the uniforms are indeed white. The context of a tennis match and the typical attire for such events also suggest that the uniforms are white. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000017534.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 264,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "two tennis players",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows two tennis players on the court, matching the completion's description."
},
{
"index": 288,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "clay court",
"verification_note": "The orange/red-brown surface visible in the image is characteristic of a clay tennis court."
},
{
"index": 325,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white uniforms",
"verification_note": "Both players are wearing white clothing (shirts and shorts), which directly answers the instruction's question about uniform color."
},
{
"index": 351,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white shirts",
"verification_note": "Both players are visibly wearing white shirts in the image."
},
{
"index": 368,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "shorts",
"verification_note": "Both players are wearing shorts as part of their tennis attire."
},
{
"index": 380,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "player in the foreground is holding a tennis racket",
"verification_note": "The player in the foreground is clearly holding a tennis racket in their hand."
},
{
"index": 441,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "player in the background is celebrating or acknowledging the crowd",
"verification_note": "The player in the background appears to have their arm raised, consistent with celebrating or acknowledging the crowd."
},
{
"index": 513,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "audience is seated in the background",
"verification_note": "The image shows spectators seated in the stands behind the court."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the uniform white in the image?
|
|
base_121_1
|
Is there a pizza in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a pizza present. I will describe the visual elements, consider the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a dining table with various dishes. There is a plate with a piece of lettuce and what appears to be shrimp or a similar dish. In the background, there is a round dish with a red crust and melted cheese, resembling a pizza. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a pizza in the image, I will first identify the characteristics of a pizza, such as a round shape, crust, and toppings like cheese and pepperoni. The round dish in the background has a red crust and melted cheese, which are typical features of a pizza. The presence of these elements suggests that the dish is indeed a pizza. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes, there is a pizza in the image. </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000470545.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 225,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "dining table",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a dining table with various dishes and plates on it."
},
{
"index": 270,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "plate with a piece of lettuce",
"verification_note": "In the foreground, there is a white plate with a large piece of lettuce visible."
},
{
"index": 323,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "shrimp",
"verification_note": "The plate in the foreground contains what appears to be shrimp on top of the lettuce."
},
{
"index": 379,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "round dish",
"verification_note": "There is a round dish visible in the background/middle area of the table."
},
{
"index": 397,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "red crust",
"verification_note": "The pizza crust appears to be a typical golden/tan color, not red. The model may be confusing the red tomato sauce/toppings with the crust color based on common pizza descriptions."
},
{
"index": 411,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "melted cheese",
"verification_note": "The round dish in the background clearly shows melted cheese, which is characteristic of a pizza."
},
{
"index": 439,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "pizza",
"verification_note": "There is clearly a pizza visible in the image on a round plate in the middle/background area of the table, with cheese and toppings visible."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a pizza in the image?
|
|
base_149_0
|
Are there 3 people in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the number of people present, focusing on identifying human figures and their activities. I will then provide a detailed description, context analysis, and reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a beach scene with four individuals riding horses along the shoreline. The background includes trees and a cloudy sky, suggesting a leisurely or recreational activity. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there are three people in the image, I will count the visible human figures. The image depicts four individuals on horseback. Each person is clearly identifiable as a separate individual, indicating that there are indeed four people present. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000124562.jpg
|
counting
|
[
{
"index": 296,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "four individuals",
"verification_note": "The instruction asks 'Are there 3 people in the image?' and the groundtruth answer is 'no'. The image shows 5 people riding horses on the beach (visible as distinct riders), not 4. The completion claims 'four individuals' which conflicts with both the actual count in the image (5) and creates a Vision-Text Conflict as it contradicts the premise of the question asking about 3 people."
},
{
"index": 279,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "beach scene",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a beach setting with sand and ocean waves visible in the background."
},
{
"index": 320,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "horses",
"verification_note": "Multiple horses are clearly visible in the image with riders on them along the shoreline."
},
{
"index": 337,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "shoreline",
"verification_note": "The people are riding horses along the beach shoreline, visible where the sand meets the water."
},
{
"index": 372,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "trees",
"verification_note": "Trees are visible in the background on both sides of the image."
},
{
"index": 384,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "cloudy sky",
"verification_note": "The sky in the image shows clouds, consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 495,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "three people",
"verification_note": "The completion is determining if there are 'three people' based on the instruction's question. However, the image actually shows 5 people on horseback, and the groundtruth confirms the answer is 'no' to 3 people. The reasoning section contradicts itself by first mentioning 'three people' then counting 'four individuals'."
},
{
"index": 706,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "four people",
"verification_note": "The completion claims there are 'four people' in the image, but visual inspection reveals 5 distinct riders on horses. This is a miscount of the actual visual content, creating a Vision-Text Conflict with what's actually shown in the image."
},
{
"index": 754,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "Yes",
"verification_note": "The conclusion answers 'Yes' to the question 'Are there 3 people in the image?' However, the groundtruth is 'no' and the image shows 5 people, not 3. This is incorrect and represents a Vision-Text Conflict as the visual evidence contradicts the affirmative answer."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Are there 3 people in the image?
|
|
base_166_1
|
Are there exactly two dining tables in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the number of dining tables present. I will describe the visual elements, consider the context, and logically reason through the evidence to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a dining setting with a wooden table. On the table, there is a glass of red wine, a bowl with a spoon, a piece of pizza topped with prosciutto, and a salt shaker. The background includes a person wearing a purple shirt, and there are additional glasses and a bottle of wine. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there are exactly two dining tables, I will first identify the number of tables visible in the image. The image clearly shows one wooden table with various items on it, including food and drinks. There is no indication of a second table in the visible area of the image. The presence of a person and additional items on the table suggests a single dining setup. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000355325.jpg
|
counting
|
[
{
"index": 688,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "one wooden table",
"verification_note": "The completion states there is 'one wooden table' visible in the image. However, the groundtruth confirms there are exactly two dining tables in the image. The VLM has failed to identify the second table, contradicting both the visual evidence and the correct answer to the instruction's question about whether there are exactly two dining tables."
},
{
"index": 310,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "glass of red wine",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a glass containing red wine in the foreground, matching this description."
},
{
"index": 331,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bowl with a spoon",
"verification_note": "A white/light-colored bowl with a spoon is visible in the background of the image on the table."
},
{
"index": 352,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "piece of pizza topped with prosciutto",
"verification_note": "The image shows pizza on a wooden board with what appears to be prosciutto (Italian cured ham) on top, along with other toppings."
},
{
"index": 397,
"label": "Insufficient Information",
"span": "salt shaker",
"verification_note": "While there appears to be a small cylindrical object that could be a salt shaker on the table, the image quality and angle make it difficult to definitively confirm this is a salt shaker versus another small container."
},
{
"index": 436,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "person wearing a purple shirt",
"verification_note": "In the background, there is a person wearing what appears to be a purple/violet colored shirt."
},
{
"index": 481,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "additional glasses",
"verification_note": "Multiple glasses are visible in the image beyond the main wine glass, including what appears to be water glasses."
},
{
"index": 506,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bottle of wine",
"verification_note": "A wine bottle (appears to be purple/violet in color) is visible in the background of the image."
},
{
"index": 767,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "no indication of a second table",
"verification_note": "This claim directly contradicts the groundtruth answer which confirms there are exactly two dining tables in the image. The VLM has failed to identify the second table that must be present in the image."
},
{
"index": 903,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "single dining setup",
"verification_note": "The conclusion that this is a 'single dining setup' contradicts the groundtruth which confirms there are exactly two dining tables. This represents a failure to correctly count the tables in the image."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Are there exactly two dining tables in the image?
|
|
base_208_1
|
Are the walls red in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image by examining the visual elements, focusing on the color of the walls. I will then apply logical reasoning to determine if the walls are red, ensuring that the conclusion matches the standard answer. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a kitchen with a red wall. There is a countertop with jars, a sink, and a window. The lighting is warm, and the overall atmosphere is cozy. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the walls are red, I will focus on the color of the wall visible in the image. The wall appears to be painted in a shade that is distinctly red. The lighting and shadows do not alter the perception of the wall's color. The presence of other kitchen elements like the countertop and jars further confirms the setting, which supports the conclusion that the walls are indeed red. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes, the walls in the image are red. </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000465327.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 274,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "kitchen",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a kitchen setting with cabinets, countertop, sink, and cooking appliances visible."
},
{
"index": 289,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "red wall",
"verification_note": "The image shows a distinctly red wall in the kitchen area, which is clearly visible in the background."
},
{
"index": 310,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "countertop",
"verification_note": "A dark countertop is visible in the image with various items placed on it."
},
{
"index": 326,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "jars",
"verification_note": "Glass jars are visible on the countertop in the foreground of the image."
},
{
"index": 334,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sink",
"verification_note": "A sink fixture can be seen on the countertop in the image."
},
{
"index": 346,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "window",
"verification_note": "A window is visible in the image, mounted in or near the red wall area."
},
{
"index": 370,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "warm",
"verification_note": "The lighting in the image creates a warm ambiance with yellowish tones from the overhead lights."
},
{
"index": 406,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "cozy",
"verification_note": "The overall atmosphere can reasonably be described as cozy given the warm lighting and kitchen setting."
},
{
"index": 466,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "red",
"verification_note": "The wall color is clearly red/reddish in the image, which directly answers the instruction question about whether the walls are red."
},
{
"index": 857,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Yes, the walls in the image are red.",
"verification_note": "This conclusion is accurate and matches both the visual evidence in the image and the groundtruth answer. The walls are indeed red."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Are the walls red in the image?
|
|
base_236_0
|
Is there a smartphone in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if a smartphone is present, following the structured format provided. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows two horses standing on a grassy field. The horse on the left is light brown, while the horse on the right is dark brown with a white stripe on its face. The background includes more grass and a distant view of another horse. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if a smartphone is in the image, I will examine the visible objects and their characteristics. The primary objects in the image are the two horses, which are clearly visible and occupy most of the frame. There are no small, rectangular objects typically associated with smartphones visible in the image. The focus is entirely on the horses and the surrounding field, with no indication of any human-made objects like a smartphone. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000063516.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 253,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "two horses",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows two horses in the foreground - one light-colored and one dark-colored. This is accurate."
},
{
"index": 278,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "grassy field",
"verification_note": "The horses are standing on a field with grass visible throughout the image. This description is accurate."
},
{
"index": 317,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "light brown",
"verification_note": "The horse on the left is indeed light brown/tan in color, matching the description."
},
{
"index": 362,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "dark brown",
"verification_note": "The horse on the right is dark brown/black in color, which aligns with the description."
},
{
"index": 380,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white stripe on its face",
"verification_note": "The dark horse on the right clearly has a prominent white stripe/blaze running down its face, which is visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 463,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "another horse",
"verification_note": "In the background/distance of the image, there appears to be at least one additional horse visible, supporting this claim."
},
{
"index": 973,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly states 'No' in response to whether there is a smartphone in the image. The image shows only horses in a field with no visible smartphone, matching the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a smartphone in the image?
|
|
base_277_0
|
Is there a towel in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a towel present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a bathroom with a white bathtub, a window with blinds, a small shelf, a toilet, and a sink. The walls are tiled, and there is a showerhead above the bathtub. The lighting is dim, and the colors are primarily white and gray. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a towel in the image, I will examine the areas where towels are typically placed, such as the towel rack or on the floor. The image shows a bathroom with a bathtub and a window, but there is no visible towel rack or towel on the floor. The lighting is dim, which might make it difficult to spot a towel, but there are no indications of a towel's presence. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000507893.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 240,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white bathtub",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a white bathtub in the bathroom."
},
{
"index": 257,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "window with blinds",
"verification_note": "The image shows a window with horizontal blinds above the bathtub."
},
{
"index": 279,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "small shelf",
"verification_note": "There appears to be a small shelf or ledge visible on the tiled wall in the shower area."
},
{
"index": 294,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "toilet",
"verification_note": "A toilet is visible in the lower right portion of the image."
},
{
"index": 308,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sink",
"verification_note": "A sink is visible on the right side of the image, mounted on a white vanity."
},
{
"index": 328,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "tiled",
"verification_note": "The walls are clearly tiled with white tiles and a dark border stripe."
},
{
"index": 350,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "showerhead",
"verification_note": "A showerhead fixture is visible mounted on the wall above the bathtub."
},
{
"index": 396,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "dim",
"verification_note": "The lighting in the image is indeed dim, with low ambient light levels."
},
{
"index": 430,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white and gray",
"verification_note": "The primary colors in the bathroom are white (tiles, fixtures) and gray/dark tones (walls, border tiles)."
},
{
"index": 878,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion that there is no towel is correct and matches the groundtruth. No towel is visible in the image."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a towel in the image?
|
|
base_346_0
|
Is there a microwave present in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if a microwave is present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a small kitchen with yellow walls. There is a refrigerator on the right, a stove with a pot on it, and a sink with a window above it. Various kitchen items are visible, including bottles on a shelf and a dish rack. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if a microwave is present, I will examine the kitchen layout and visible appliances. The refrigerator and stove are clearly visible, but there is no visible microwave on the counter or on the wall. The space is compact, and typically, a microwave would be placed on the counter or mounted on the wall. The absence of a microwave-like appliance or structure in the visible area suggests that it is not present. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000088192.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 241,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "yellow walls",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows the kitchen has yellow/cream-colored walls, which matches the description."
},
{
"index": 266,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "refrigerator on the right",
"verification_note": "A white refrigerator is clearly visible on the right side of the kitchen in the image."
},
{
"index": 295,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "stove with a pot on it",
"verification_note": "A stove is visible on the left side of the image with what appears to be a pot or pan on it."
},
{
"index": 325,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sink with a window above it",
"verification_note": "A sink is visible in the center area beneath a window in the image."
},
{
"index": 399,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bottles on a shelf",
"verification_note": "Bottles can be seen on shelving/counter areas in the kitchen."
},
{
"index": 424,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "dish rack",
"verification_note": "A dish rack or drying rack is visible near the sink area in the image."
},
{
"index": 618,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no visible microwave on the counter or on the wall",
"verification_note": "After examining the visible areas of the kitchen, there is no microwave apparent on counters or wall-mounted. This observation is consistent with the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
},
{
"index": 909,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion that there is no microwave present matches the groundtruth answer and is supported by the visual evidence in the image."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a microwave present in the image?
|
|
base_388_0
|
Is the road made of gravel in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if the road is made of gravel. I will describe the visual elements, consider the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a rural road with a gravel surface. There are horses grazing near the road, and a stone structure is visible in the background. The road is bordered by grass and rocks, and the sky is clear. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the road is made of gravel, I will examine the surface texture and color. The road appears to have a coarse, uneven texture typical of gravel. The color is consistent with that of gravel, which is usually light and speckled. The presence of horses and the rural setting suggest a natural, unpaved road, which is commonly gravel. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000038919.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 245,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "gravel surface",
"verification_note": "The image shows a paved asphalt road with white line markings, not a gravel surface. The groundtruth confirms 'no' to the question about gravel. The completion incorrectly identifies the road as gravel, contradicting both the visual evidence and the groundtruth answer."
},
{
"index": 271,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "horses grazing near the road",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows horses (appearing to be ponies or small horses) standing on grass near the road, consistent with this description."
},
{
"index": 307,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "stone structure",
"verification_note": "There is a visible stone structure/ruins in the background on the hillside, which matches this description."
},
{
"index": 365,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bordered by grass and rocks",
"verification_note": "The road is indeed bordered by grass on one side and there are visible rocks/boulders near the roadside, consistent with the image."
},
{
"index": 409,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "clear",
"verification_note": "The sky in the image appears to be clear and blue with minimal cloud coverage."
},
{
"index": 557,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "coarse, uneven texture typical of gravel",
"verification_note": "The road surface appears smooth and paved (asphalt), not coarse and uneven. This description contradicts the visual evidence showing a paved road with clear white line markings."
},
{
"index": 661,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "light and speckled",
"verification_note": "The road appears to be dark gray/black asphalt, not light and speckled as gravel would be. This contradicts the actual appearance of the road surface in the image."
},
{
"index": 736,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "natural, unpaved road",
"verification_note": "The road is clearly paved with asphalt and has white line markings, indicating it is not unpaved. This directly contradicts the visual evidence."
},
{
"index": 812,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "Yes",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'Yes' (that the road is made of gravel) contradicts both the visual evidence showing a paved asphalt road and the groundtruth answer of 'no'. This is a clear hallucination where the model incorrectly identified the road surface material."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the road made of gravel in the image?
|
|
base_391_0
|
Is there a fork in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a fork present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a table covered with a white cloth, displaying various desserts. There are cakes, a fruit tart, and other sweet treats. Several utensils are visible on the table, including forks. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a fork in the image, I will first identify the objects on the table. The presence of desserts suggests the use of utensils for serving. Upon examining the table, I notice utensils placed alongside the desserts. Specifically, I see a fork positioned near the desserts, indicating its use for serving. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000365123.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 223,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "table covered with a white cloth",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a table covered with a white tablecloth."
},
{
"index": 268,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "various desserts",
"verification_note": "The image shows multiple desserts including cakes and other sweet treats on the table."
},
{
"index": 296,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "cakes",
"verification_note": "Multiple cakes are visible on the table in the image."
},
{
"index": 305,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "fruit tart",
"verification_note": "There appears to be a dessert with fruit topping (red fruits/strawberries) that could be described as a fruit tart."
},
{
"index": 394,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "forks",
"verification_note": "The completion claims there are forks visible on the table. However, the groundtruth explicitly states 'no' to the question 'Is there a fork in the image?' While there are some utensils visible (what appear to be serving utensils/knives), the presence of forks contradicts the groundtruth answer. This represents a conflict between what the model claims to see and what is actually in the image."
},
{
"index": 681,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "a fork positioned near the desserts",
"verification_note": "The completion specifically claims to see a fork positioned near the desserts. This directly contradicts the groundtruth answer of 'no' to whether there is a fork in the image. The model has hallucinated the presence of a fork, likely due to the context of desserts typically being served with forks."
},
{
"index": 777,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "Yes",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'Yes' contradicts the groundtruth answer of 'no'. The model incorrectly concluded that there is a fork in the image when the groundtruth confirms there is not."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a fork in the image?
|
|
base_407_1
|
Are there eight bowls in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the number of bowls present. I will describe the visual elements, consider the context, and use logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a group of people gathered around a picnic table outdoors. On the table, there are various items including bowls, containers, utensils, and food. The bowls are of different colors and sizes, and they are placed among other items. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the number of bowls, I will count each distinct bowl visible in the image. I will focus on identifying objects that are clearly bowls based on their shape and size. I will ensure that I do not count any items that are not bowls. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No. </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000341546.jpg
|
counting
|
[
{
"index": 225,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a group of people gathered around a picnic table outdoors",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows multiple people standing around an outdoor picnic table, which matches this description."
},
{
"index": 332,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bowls",
"verification_note": "Multiple bowls of various colors and sizes are visible on the picnic table in the image."
},
{
"index": 339,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "containers",
"verification_note": "Various containers including what appear to be storage containers and bottles are visible on the table."
},
{
"index": 351,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "utensils",
"verification_note": "Utensils such as forks and other eating implements are visible on and around the table."
},
{
"index": 365,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "food",
"verification_note": "Food items are visible in various bowls and containers on the table."
},
{
"index": 388,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "different colors and sizes",
"verification_note": "The bowls visible include green, blue, red, white, and other colors, and they vary in size from small to large."
},
{
"index": 748,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The completion concludes 'No' when asked if there are eight bowls in the image. However, counting the visible bowls on the table reveals approximately 8+ bowl-like objects (green bowls, blue bowls, red bowls, white bowls, etc.). The groundtruth confirms 'yes' there are eight bowls. The model appears to have miscounted, resulting in a conclusion that contradicts the actual visual evidence in the image."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Are there eight bowls in the image?
|
|
base_470_0
|
Is the pizza oval in shape in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the shape of the pizza, focusing on its outline and comparing it to typical shapes. I will then provide a detailed description, context analysis, and reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a pizza on a wooden cutting board. The pizza has a white sauce base with visible toppings such as mushrooms and cheese. The shape of the pizza appears to be irregular, with a slightly elongated form. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the shape of the pizza, I will examine its outline. The pizza's edges are not perfectly circular, indicating an irregular shape. The elongation suggests it is not round but rather oval. Comparing this with typical pizza shapes, an oval shape is characterized by a longer axis than the shorter one, which aligns with the observed characteristics. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000118118.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 284,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "wooden cutting board",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows the pizza is placed on a wooden cutting board, which matches the description in the completion."
},
{
"index": 322,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white sauce base",
"verification_note": "The pizza appears to have a white/cream-colored sauce base rather than traditional red tomato sauce, which is visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 369,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "mushrooms",
"verification_note": "Visible mushroom toppings can be seen scattered across the pizza surface in the image."
},
{
"index": 383,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "cheese",
"verification_note": "The pizza clearly has melted cheese visible across its surface in the image."
},
{
"index": 428,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "irregular",
"verification_note": "The pizza's shape is indeed irregular, not a perfect circle, which is accurate based on the visual evidence."
},
{
"index": 446,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "slightly elongated form",
"verification_note": "The pizza does appear to have a somewhat elongated shape rather than being perfectly circular."
},
{
"index": 582,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "not perfectly circular",
"verification_note": "This observation is correct - the pizza's outline is not a perfect circle as visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 688,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "oval",
"verification_note": "While the pizza is irregular and not perfectly circular, it is more round/circular than oval. The completion concludes 'Yes' to the question 'Is the pizza oval in shape?', but the groundtruth is 'no'. The pizza's shape, while irregular, is predominantly round rather than oval. This represents a vision-prior conflict where the model may be over-interpreting slight irregularities as an oval shape."
},
{
"index": 881,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "Yes",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'Yes' contradicts both the groundtruth answer 'no' and the actual visual evidence. While the pizza has an irregular shape, it is fundamentally round/circular rather than oval. The model has incorrectly concluded the pizza is oval-shaped, which conflicts with what is actually shown in the image."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the pizza oval in shape in the image?
|
|
base_475_1
|
Is there a kite to the right of the person in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the presence of a kite to the right of the person. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a person standing indoors, holding a large, triangular object that resembles a kite. The object is yellow with blue and red stripes. There are umbrellas in the background, and the setting appears to be a room with wooden flooring. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a kite to the right of the person, I will examine the image for any objects resembling a kite. The large, triangular object the person is holding is the primary focus. Since the question asks about a kite to the right of the person, I will look for any additional kite-like objects in that area. The image does not show any other kite-like objects to the right of the person. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000426700.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 264,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "indoors",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows an indoor setting with visible doors, walls, and wooden flooring."
},
{
"index": 290,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "triangular object",
"verification_note": "The large kite visible in the image has a triangular shape."
},
{
"index": 345,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "yellow",
"verification_note": "The kite appears to be primarily yellow/cream colored."
},
{
"index": 357,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "blue and red stripes",
"verification_note": "The kite has visible blue and red striping patterns on it."
},
{
"index": 389,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "umbrellas in the background",
"verification_note": "There are umbrellas visible in the background to the left of the person."
},
{
"index": 460,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "wooden flooring",
"verification_note": "The floor in the image is clearly wooden."
},
{
"index": 832,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "does not show any other kite-like objects to the right of the person",
"verification_note": "This is a critical hallucination. Looking at the image, the large triangular kite is positioned to the RIGHT of the person (from viewer's perspective). The person is on the left side of the frame, and the kite extends to their right side. The model's conclusion contradicts what is visually evident in the image, leading to an incorrect 'No' answer when the groundtruth is 'yes'."
},
{
"index": 929,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' contradicts the visual evidence. The kite is clearly positioned to the right of the person in the image, and the groundtruth confirms 'yes'. This represents a Vision-Prior Conflict where the model failed to correctly identify the spatial relationship between the person and the kite."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a kite to the right of the person in the image?
|
|
base_512_1
|
Is there a person in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image by describing its contents, focusing on identifying the presence of a person. Then, I will logically reason through the evidence to determine if there is a person in the image. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a person sitting on the ground in a natural setting. The person is wearing a purple garment and has a basket next to them. The background includes greenery and some scattered items. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a person in the image, I will examine the visible elements. The presence of a seated figure in a natural setting, along with a basket and clothing, suggests human activity. The posture and attire are consistent with a person engaged in an outdoor activity. These observations collectively indicate the presence of a person. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes, there is a person in the image. The person is sitting on the ground in a natural setting, wearing a purple garment, and holding a basket. The background includes greenery and some scattered items. </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000115455.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 252,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "person sitting on the ground",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a person in a seated position on the ground in an outdoor setting."
},
{
"index": 286,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "natural setting",
"verification_note": "The image shows an outdoor environment with greenery, plants, and natural ground, confirming this is a natural setting."
},
{
"index": 327,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "purple garment",
"verification_note": "The person in the image is visibly wearing purple-colored clothing on their upper body."
},
{
"index": 352,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "basket",
"verification_note": "A woven basket is clearly visible next to the person in the image."
},
{
"index": 397,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "greenery",
"verification_note": "The background and surrounding area show green plants and vegetation."
},
{
"index": 415,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "scattered items",
"verification_note": "Various items can be seen scattered around the person on the ground, including what appears to be plant material and other objects."
},
{
"index": 559,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "seated figure",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a person in a seated position."
},
{
"index": 720,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "outdoor activity",
"verification_note": "The person appears to be engaged in some form of outdoor activity, likely related to gathering or processing plants, as evidenced by the setting and surrounding materials."
},
{
"index": 957,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "holding a basket",
"verification_note": "While the basket is next to the person and they appear to be working with it, the person is holding something (appears to be a tool or implement) rather than actively holding the basket at the moment the photo was taken. However, the general claim of interaction with the basket in this context is reasonable given the scene."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a person in the image?
|
|
base_521_0
|
Is there a console located to the left of the dog in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a console located to the left of the dog. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use evidence-based reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a room with a desk and a computer monitor displaying a game. A black dog is sitting on a person's lap, who is seated in a chair. The desk has various items, including a trash can, a box, and some electronics. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a console to the left of the dog, I will examine the area on the desk to the left of the dog. The desk has a computer monitor and other items, but there is no visible console, such as a gaming console, in that specific area. The focus is on identifying any console-like device to the left of the dog. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No, there is no console located to the left of the dog in the image. </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000482242.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 244,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a room with a desk and a computer monitor displaying a game",
"verification_note": "The image shows a room with a desk that has a computer monitor. The monitor appears to be displaying some content, consistent with this description."
},
{
"index": 307,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "black dog",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a black dog sitting on the person's lap."
},
{
"index": 320,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sitting on a person's lap",
"verification_note": "The black dog is visibly sitting on the lap of a person seated in a chair."
},
{
"index": 354,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "seated in a chair",
"verification_note": "The person is clearly seated in a chair with the dog on their lap."
},
{
"index": 413,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "trash can",
"verification_note": "A white cylindrical object that appears to be a trash can is visible on the floor near the desk."
},
{
"index": 424,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a box",
"verification_note": "There appears to be box-like items on and around the desk area."
},
{
"index": 440,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "electronics",
"verification_note": "The desk has various electronic items including a computer monitor, speakers, and other electronic devices."
},
{
"index": 611,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "computer monitor",
"verification_note": "A CRT computer monitor is clearly visible on the desk displaying content."
},
{
"index": 830,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No, there is no console located to the left of the dog in the image.",
"verification_note": "Examining the area to the left of the dog (which would be toward the desk), there is no visible gaming console. The desk contains a monitor, speakers, and various items, but no identifiable console. This conclusion matches the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a console located to the left of the dog in the image?
|
|
base_537_0
|
Is the bench top made of aluminum in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the material of the bench top by examining its visual characteristics and context. I will then provide a detailed description, context analysis, and evidence-based reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a small bird perched on a white wooden bench. The bench appears to be made of wood, with visible grain patterns and a weathered, painted surface. The background is blurred, focusing attention on the bird and the bench. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the bench top is made of aluminum, I will consider the visual characteristics of the bench. Aluminum typically has a smooth, metallic appearance and does not show grain patterns like wood. The bench in the image has a textured, wooden appearance with visible grain patterns, indicating it is not aluminum. Additionally, the weathered and painted look is consistent with wood rather than aluminum, which is not commonly painted in this manner. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000358254.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 287,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "small bird",
"verification_note": "The image shows a bird that appears to be small in size, perched on the bench. This description is consistent with the visual content."
},
{
"index": 311,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white wooden bench",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a bench that is white in color and appears to be made of wood with visible grain patterns and weathered paint, consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 363,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "wood",
"verification_note": "The bench material appears to be wood based on visible grain patterns, texture, and weathered painted surface visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 374,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "visible grain patterns",
"verification_note": "The image shows clear wood grain patterns on the bench surface, particularly visible on the horizontal slats."
},
{
"index": 403,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "weathered, painted surface",
"verification_note": "The bench surface shows signs of weathering with peeling or worn paint, consistent with this description."
},
{
"index": 435,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "background is blurred",
"verification_note": "The background in the image is indeed blurred with a bokeh effect, focusing attention on the bird and bench in the foreground."
},
{
"index": 636,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Aluminum typically has a smooth, metallic appearance",
"verification_note": "This is accurate factual knowledge about aluminum's typical visual characteristics."
},
{
"index": 693,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "does not show grain patterns like wood",
"verification_note": "This is correct factual knowledge - aluminum does not have natural grain patterns like wood does."
},
{
"index": 762,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "textured, wooden appearance with visible grain patterns",
"verification_note": "The bench in the image clearly shows wood texture and grain patterns, supporting this description."
},
{
"index": 836,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "not aluminum",
"verification_note": "Based on the visual evidence (grain patterns, weathered paint, wood texture), the bench is clearly not made of aluminum. This conclusion is supported by the image content."
},
{
"index": 1014,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly answers the instruction's question about whether the bench top is made of aluminum. The visual evidence shows wood grain and weathered paint, confirming the bench is not aluminum. This matches the groundtruth answer 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the bench top made of aluminum in the image?
|
|
base_614_0
|
Is there a mountain visible in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if a mountain is visible, focusing on the details and context provided. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a group of children gathered around a table covered with a plaid tablecloth. On the table, there is a cake designed to look like a mountain, complete with red icing resembling lava and blue icing resembling water. The cake is decorated with various candies and edible items. The children are standing around the table, seemingly observing or interacting with the cake. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if a mountain is visible in the image, I will focus on the cake's design. The cake is shaped to resemble a mountain, with red icing representing lava and blue icing representing water. This design is intended to mimic a mountainous landscape. The presence of these elements suggests that the cake is meant to represent a mountain. Therefore, based on the cake's design and the context provided, it can be concluded that a mountain is indeed visible in the image. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000043029.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 255,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a group of children gathered around a table covered with a plaid tablecloth",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows multiple children standing around a table with a plaid/checkered tablecloth pattern."
},
{
"index": 355,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a cake designed to look like a mountain",
"verification_note": "The cake on the table has a mountain-like shape with peaked structures and decorative elements suggesting a mountainous landscape."
},
{
"index": 410,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "red icing resembling lava",
"verification_note": "The cake features red/pink icing that appears to flow down the mountain structure, resembling lava."
},
{
"index": 440,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "blue icing resembling water",
"verification_note": "There is blue icing visible on the cake that could represent water at the base of the mountain structure."
},
{
"index": 496,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "various candies and edible items",
"verification_note": "The cake is decorated with what appear to be various candies and edible decorations scattered across its surface."
},
{
"index": 1081,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "a mountain is indeed visible in the image",
"verification_note": "This is a critical hallucination. The instruction asks if a mountain is visible in the image, and the groundtruth answer is 'no'. While there is a cake DESIGNED to look like a mountain, there is no actual mountain visible in the image. The model conflates a cake representation with an actual mountain, contradicting the correct answer. The model's prior knowledge about mountain features led it to accept the cake's mountain-like design as fulfilling the requirement of 'a mountain being visible', when the question clearly seeks an actual mountain in the scene."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a mountain visible in the image?
|
|
base_624_0
|
Is there a snowboard in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a snowboard present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows two individuals skiing on a snowy slope. They are wearing winter clothing and are positioned on skis, moving down the mountain. There are ski lifts and snow-covered trees in the background, indicating a ski resort setting. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a snowboard in the image, I will focus on the equipment used by the individuals. Both individuals are clearly using skis, as evidenced by their stance and the presence of ski poles. There are no visible signs of a snowboard, such as a single wide board or bindings attached to boots. The context of a ski resort and the presence of ski lifts further supports the use of skis rather than snowboards. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No, there is no snowboard in the image. The two people are skiing on a snowy slope, and they are wearing winter clothing. </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000129071.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 226,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "two individuals skiing",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows two people on skis moving across a snowy slope, consistent with the description of skiing activity."
},
{
"index": 254,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "snowy slope",
"verification_note": "The image shows a snow-covered mountain slope where the individuals are skiing."
},
{
"index": 284,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "winter clothing",
"verification_note": "Both individuals are wearing dark winter jackets and appropriate cold-weather gear for skiing."
},
{
"index": 322,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "skis",
"verification_note": "Both individuals are clearly positioned on skis, with visible ski equipment beneath their feet."
},
{
"index": 364,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "ski lifts",
"verification_note": "A ski lift structure is clearly visible on the left side of the image."
},
{
"index": 378,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "snow-covered trees",
"verification_note": "Trees covered with snow are visible in the background and on the right side of the image."
},
{
"index": 429,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "ski resort setting",
"verification_note": "The presence of ski lifts, groomed slopes, and infrastructure indicates this is a ski resort."
},
{
"index": 669,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "ski poles",
"verification_note": "The skiers appear to be using ski poles as part of their equipment, which is standard for skiing."
},
{
"index": 937,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no snowboard",
"verification_note": "The completion correctly identifies that there is no snowboard in the image, matching the groundtruth answer of 'no'. Both individuals are on skis, not snowboards."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a snowboard in the image?
|
|
base_703_0
|
Is there a computer to the right of the refrigerator in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a computer to the right of the refrigerator. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows an open refrigerator in a kitchen setting. Inside the fridge, there are various food items and containers. To the right of the refrigerator, there is a stove with pots and pans on it. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a computer to the right of the refrigerator, I will examine the area to the right of the fridge. The image shows a stove with cooking utensils, but no visible computer or electronic device. The presence of kitchen appliances suggests a cooking or food preparation area, which is unlikely to have a computer. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000366510.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 243,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "open refrigerator",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a refrigerator with its doors open, revealing the interior contents."
},
{
"index": 266,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "kitchen setting",
"verification_note": "The image shows a kitchen environment with typical kitchen appliances including a refrigerator and stove."
},
{
"index": 312,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "various food items and containers",
"verification_note": "Inside the refrigerator, multiple food items and containers are visible on the shelves."
},
{
"index": 392,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "stove with pots and pans on it",
"verification_note": "To the right of the refrigerator, there is a white stove/range visible with what appears to be cookware on top."
},
{
"index": 621,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no visible computer or electronic device",
"verification_note": "The area to the right of the refrigerator shows only a stove with cooking equipment; no computer or similar electronic device is visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 679,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "kitchen appliances",
"verification_note": "The image shows typical kitchen appliances including the refrigerator and stove."
},
{
"index": 709,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "cooking or food preparation area",
"verification_note": "The visible stove and refrigerator indicate this is indeed a cooking/food preparation area."
},
{
"index": 808,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' correctly answers the instruction question about whether there is a computer to the right of the refrigerator, which aligns with the groundtruth and the visual evidence."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a computer to the right of the refrigerator in the image?
|
|
base_722_1
|
Is there a sheep in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a sheep present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a grassy hillside with three white animals that resemble sheep. The animals are positioned on a slope with green grass and some scattered trees. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a sheep in the image, I will first identify the animals present. The animals are white and fluffy, which are typical characteristics of sheep. The setting is a grassy hillside, a common environment for sheep. The presence of multiple animals with similar characteristics further supports the conclusion that these are sheep. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000167901.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 224,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "grassy hillside",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a hillside with grass, confirming this description of the terrain."
},
{
"index": 245,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "three white animals",
"verification_note": "The image shows three white animals on the hillside, matching this count and color description."
},
{
"index": 279,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sheep",
"verification_note": "The animals in the image are clearly sheep based on their fluffy white wool, body shape, and hillside grazing context."
},
{
"index": 318,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "slope",
"verification_note": "The terrain in the image is clearly sloped/inclined, confirming this description."
},
{
"index": 329,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "green grass",
"verification_note": "The image shows green grass covering the hillside where the sheep are located."
},
{
"index": 350,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "scattered trees",
"verification_note": "The image shows several trees scattered across the hillside landscape."
},
{
"index": 497,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white and fluffy",
"verification_note": "The animals in the image display white, fluffy wool characteristic of sheep."
},
{
"index": 641,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "multiple animals",
"verification_note": "The image contains three animals, confirming the presence of multiple animals."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a sheep in the image?
|
|
base_743_0
|
Are there 3 pizzas in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the number of pizzas present, focusing on visual evidence and logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a table with a pizza on a plate in the center. There are also several water bottles, a map, and a person holding a camera. The pizza appears to be the main focus on the table. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there are three pizzas in the image, I will first identify the number of distinct pizza items visible. The image clearly shows one pizza on a plate in the center of the table. There are no additional pizzas visible in the image. The presence of other items like water bottles and a map does not contribute to the count of pizzas. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000264155.jpg
|
counting
|
[
{
"index": 532,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "one pizza on a plate",
"verification_note": "The image shows one pizza on a plate in the center of the table, which matches the completion's description. This count is accurate and answers the instruction's question about whether there are 3 pizzas (there is only 1)."
},
{
"index": 667,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "water bottles",
"verification_note": "Multiple water bottles are clearly visible on the table in the image, matching the completion's description."
},
{
"index": 685,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a map",
"verification_note": "There appears to be a map or similar document visible on the table in the image, supporting this claim."
},
{
"index": 285,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a person holding a camera",
"verification_note": "A person holding a camera is visible in the upper left portion of the image, matching the completion's description."
},
{
"index": 762,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' correctly answers the instruction's question 'Are there 3 pizzas in the image?' The image shows only one pizza, not three, which aligns with the groundtruth answer 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Are there 3 pizzas in the image?
|
|
base_776_0
|
Is the chair made of metal in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if the chair is made of metal by examining visual details and context clues. I will then provide a structured response following the specified format. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows two people sitting at a table outdoors. The table is set with plates, cups, and cutlery. The chairs appear to be wooden, with a natural finish. The setting is a garden or park with other tables and chairs visible in the background. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the chair is made of metal, I will focus on the visible characteristics of the chairs. The chairs have a wooden appearance, with a natural finish that suggests they are made of wood rather than metal. The texture and color are consistent with wood, and there are no visible metal components such as metallic frames or metal legs. The outdoor setting and garden-like environment further suggest that the chairs are likely made of wood, which is commonly used in such settings for durability and aesthetic purposes. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000213530.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 237,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "two people",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows two people sitting at the table in the foreground."
},
{
"index": 248,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sitting at a table",
"verification_note": "Both individuals are visibly seated at a table with place settings."
},
{
"index": 267,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "outdoors",
"verification_note": "The setting is clearly outdoors with grass, trees, and natural lighting visible."
},
{
"index": 299,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "plates",
"verification_note": "Plates with food are visible on the table in front of both people."
},
{
"index": 307,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "cups",
"verification_note": "Coffee cups and saucers are visible on the table."
},
{
"index": 317,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "cutlery",
"verification_note": "Utensils/cutlery can be seen on the table as part of the place settings."
},
{
"index": 350,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "wooden",
"verification_note": "The chairs visible in the image have a wooden appearance with natural wood finish and grain texture."
},
{
"index": 365,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "natural finish",
"verification_note": "The chairs show a natural wood finish rather than painted or heavily treated surfaces."
},
{
"index": 398,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "garden or park",
"verification_note": "The outdoor setting with grass, trees, and multiple dining tables suggests a garden or park environment."
},
{
"index": 418,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "other tables and chairs visible in the background",
"verification_note": "Multiple tables with red tablecloths and wooden chairs are clearly visible in the background of the image."
},
{
"index": 614,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "wooden appearance",
"verification_note": "The chairs exhibit characteristics consistent with wooden construction including grain patterns and natural coloring."
},
{
"index": 640,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "natural finish",
"verification_note": "The finish on the chairs appears to be natural wood treatment rather than painted or metallic."
},
{
"index": 686,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "wood rather than metal",
"verification_note": "The visual characteristics (texture, color, grain) are consistent with wood construction, not metal. This correctly answers the instruction's question."
},
{
"index": 772,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no visible metal components such as metallic frames or metal legs",
"verification_note": "The chairs appear to be entirely wooden construction without visible metal frame elements or metal legs."
},
{
"index": 1050,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly answers that the chair is not made of metal, which aligns with both the visual evidence showing wooden chairs and the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the chair made of metal in the image?
|
|
base_799_0
|
Is the cement green in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is any green cement present. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use evidence-based reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a double-decker electric hybrid bus inside a large, industrial-looking building. The bus is predominantly white with green leaf designs on the side. There is a stroller on the ground near the bus. The ceiling is high with exposed beams and skylights, suggesting a warehouse or maintenance facility. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the cement is green, I will examine the visible surfaces in the image. The ground appears to be a typical concrete or cement surface, which is usually gray or beige. There is no indication of green coloring on the cement. The focus of the image is on the bus and the surrounding environment, which does not suggest any green cement. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000494957.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 230,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "double-decker electric hybrid bus",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a double-decker bus with 'Electric Hybrid Bus' text visible on its side, confirming this description is accurate."
},
{
"index": 273,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "large, industrial-looking building",
"verification_note": "The setting shows an indoor space with exposed beams, high ceiling with metal framework, and industrial lighting, consistent with a warehouse or exhibition hall."
},
{
"index": 320,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "predominantly white",
"verification_note": "The bus body is primarily white in color as shown in the image."
},
{
"index": 345,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "green leaf designs",
"verification_note": "The bus displays green leaf graphics/designs on its white body, clearly visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 388,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "stroller",
"verification_note": "A stroller/pushchair is visible on the ground near the front of the bus."
},
{
"index": 440,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "high with exposed beams and skylights",
"verification_note": "The ceiling structure shows exposed metal beams and lighting fixtures consistent with an industrial building, though the specific presence of skylights is difficult to definitively confirm from this angle."
},
{
"index": 492,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "warehouse or maintenance facility",
"verification_note": "The industrial setting with exposed infrastructure is consistent with either a warehouse, maintenance facility, or exhibition space - this is a reasonable characterization."
},
{
"index": 665,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "typical concrete or cement surface",
"verification_note": "The floor appears to be a standard concrete/cement surface as commonly found in industrial buildings."
},
{
"index": 718,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "gray or beige",
"verification_note": "The cement floor appears to be in the typical gray/beige color range of concrete, not green."
},
{
"index": 927,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly answers that the cement is not green - the floor appears to be standard gray concrete, matching the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the cement green in the image?
|
|
base_831_1
|
Is there a glass in front of the manikin in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a glass in front of the manikin. I will describe the visual elements, consider the context, and logically reason through the evidence to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a display area with two manikins. One manikin is seated, and the other is standing. The manikin on the right is wearing a black outfit. The display area appears to be enclosed by glass, as indicated by reflections and transparency. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a glass in front of the manikin, I will examine the reflections and transparency in the image. The presence of reflections and the way light interacts with the display area suggest that it is enclosed by glass. This is a common setup in retail displays to showcase products or manikins. The reflections and the way the manikin is positioned further support the conclusion that the display is indeed enclosed by glass. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000094092.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 275,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "two manikins",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows multiple manikins in the display - at least two are visible wearing black outfits, confirming the count of two or more manikins."
},
{
"index": 304,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "seated",
"verification_note": "There are manikins in seated positions visible in the display, particularly on the left side of the image."
},
{
"index": 329,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "standing",
"verification_note": "There are standing manikins visible in the display, particularly the one on the right side wearing black."
},
{
"index": 343,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "manikin on the right",
"verification_note": "There is clearly a manikin positioned on the right side of the display area."
},
{
"index": 377,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "black outfit",
"verification_note": "The manikin on the right is indeed wearing a black outfit, which is clearly visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 422,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "enclosed by glass",
"verification_note": "The display area shows clear evidence of glass enclosure - visible reflections, transparency, and the viewing perspective of a person looking at the display from outside supports this observation."
},
{
"index": 457,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "reflections",
"verification_note": "There are visible reflections in the image that indicate the presence of glass, such as light reflections on the transparent surface."
},
{
"index": 773,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "retail displays",
"verification_note": "The setup with manikins, glass enclosure, lighting, and professional presentation is consistent with retail display environments."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a glass in front of the manikin in the image?
|
|
base_952_1
|
Are there exactly two wine glasses in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the presence of wine glasses, focusing on identifying and counting them. I will then provide a detailed description, context analysis, and reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a cluttered kitchen counter with various items. There is a laptop with a sticker on the lid, a box of lasagna, a jar of sauce, a carton of milk, and several other items scattered around. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there are exactly two wine glasses in the image, I will first identify any objects that resemble wine glasses. Upon examining the image, I notice a clear glass with a design on it, which could be a wine glass. However, I do not see a second wine glass. The presence of only one wine glass-like object leads to the conclusion that there are not exactly two wine glasses in the image. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000410256.jpg
|
counting
|
[
{
"index": 262,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "cluttered kitchen counter",
"verification_note": "The image shows a counter with various items scattered on it, which can reasonably be described as cluttered. The setting appears to be a kitchen or similar domestic space."
},
{
"index": 319,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "laptop with a sticker on the lid",
"verification_note": "There is clearly a laptop in the image with a blue sticker (appears to say 'threadless') on the lid/base area."
},
{
"index": 355,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "box of lasagna",
"verification_note": "There is a red/orange box visible to the left of the laptop that appears to be a lasagna box based on its appearance and packaging."
},
{
"index": 373,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "jar of sauce",
"verification_note": "There is a jar with red contents visible to the right of the laptop that appears to be a sauce jar."
},
{
"index": 389,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "carton of milk",
"verification_note": "The completion identifies a carton of milk, but examining the image carefully, the blue and white containers appear to be Brita water filter packaging/products, not milk cartons. This is a misidentification of objects in the image."
},
{
"index": 635,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "clear glass with a design on it",
"verification_note": "There are clear glass containers visible in the image that have designs or patterns on them."
},
{
"index": 761,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "one wine glass-like object",
"verification_note": "The completion concludes there is only one wine glass in the image, but according to the groundtruth, there are exactly two wine glasses present. The model failed to identify both wine glasses, leading to an incorrect count that contradicts the visual evidence."
},
{
"index": 897,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' directly contradicts the groundtruth answer 'yes'. The image contains exactly two wine glasses, but the model incorrectly concluded there are not exactly two, resulting in a vision-based hallucination where the model failed to accurately count the wine glasses present in the image."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Are there exactly two wine glasses in the image?
|
|
base_1051_0
|
Is there a giraffe behind the trees in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a giraffe behind the trees. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a dirt road leading into a landscape with hills and sparse vegetation. A giraffe is walking on the road, and there are trees and bushes in the background. The sky is cloudy, and the scene appears to be in a natural, open environment. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a giraffe behind the trees, I will first identify the position of the giraffe in the image. The giraffe is clearly visible on the road, with its long neck and legs. I will then examine the background, focusing on the area behind the trees and bushes. The trees and bushes are sparse, and there is no indication of another giraffe or any obstruction that would suggest a giraffe is hidden behind them. The open nature of the landscape and the visibility of the giraffe on the road further support the conclusion that there is no giraffe behind the trees. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000462553.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 235,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "dirt road",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows an unpaved dirt road in the foreground where the giraffe is walking."
},
{
"index": 275,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "hills",
"verification_note": "The background of the image shows elevated terrain/hills with vegetation."
},
{
"index": 285,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sparse vegetation",
"verification_note": "The image shows scattered trees and bushes with open areas, characteristic of sparse vegetation in a savanna-like environment."
},
{
"index": 306,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "giraffe is walking on the road",
"verification_note": "A giraffe is clearly visible standing/walking on the dirt road in the center of the image."
},
{
"index": 352,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "trees and bushes in the background",
"verification_note": "Trees and bushes are visible both in the middle ground and background of the image."
},
{
"index": 399,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "cloudy",
"verification_note": "The sky in the image shows extensive cloud cover."
},
{
"index": 440,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "natural, open environment",
"verification_note": "The scene depicts an open natural landscape with characteristic savanna features."
},
{
"index": 612,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "giraffe is clearly visible on the road",
"verification_note": "The giraffe is prominently positioned on the road and easily visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 661,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "long neck and legs",
"verification_note": "The giraffe's distinctive long neck and legs are clearly visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 771,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "trees and bushes are sparse",
"verification_note": "The vegetation shown is scattered with open spaces between plants, confirming sparse distribution."
},
{
"index": 813,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no indication of another giraffe",
"verification_note": "Visual inspection of the image shows only one giraffe visible on the road; no additional giraffes are visible behind trees or elsewhere in the image."
},
{
"index": 1041,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no giraffe behind the trees",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly matches the groundtruth answer 'no' - there is no giraffe visible behind the trees in the image, only the one giraffe on the road."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a giraffe behind the trees in the image?
|
|
base_1071_0
|
Is there a truck in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a truck present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a yellow school bus on a red bridge. The background features a cityscape with buildings and a prominent tower. The scene is set during the day with clear visibility. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a truck in the image, I will first identify all vehicles present. The primary vehicle visible is a yellow school bus. I will then look for any other vehicles, such as trucks, by examining the bridge and surrounding areas. Since the image primarily focuses on the school bus and there are no other vehicles visible, I conclude that there is no truck present. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000130352.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 224,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "yellow school bus",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a yellow school bus on the bridge, matching this description exactly."
},
{
"index": 247,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "red bridge",
"verification_note": "The bridge structure visible in the image is clearly red/orange in color, consistent with this description."
},
{
"index": 285,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "cityscape with buildings",
"verification_note": "The background of the image shows an urban landscape with multiple buildings visible across the cityscape."
},
{
"index": 316,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "prominent tower",
"verification_note": "A tower structure is visible on a hill in the background of the image, appearing as a prominent landmark."
},
{
"index": 350,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "during the day",
"verification_note": "The image shows clear daylight conditions with good visibility, confirming this temporal description."
},
{
"index": 370,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "clear visibility",
"verification_note": "The image shows good visibility with the cityscape, buildings, and tower clearly visible in the background."
},
{
"index": 777,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no truck present",
"verification_note": "After examining the visible vehicles in the image, only a yellow school bus is present on the bridge. No truck is visible, which is consistent with the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a truck in the image?
|
|
base_1101_0
|
Are the street signs blue in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the color of the street signs, focusing on visual details and context. I will then apply logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a highway overpass with green street signs. The signs are in Chinese and include directions and distances. The overpass is lined with plants, and there is a streetlight nearby. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the color of the street signs, I will examine the visual elements of the image. The signs are prominently displayed against the overpass and are clearly visible. The color of the signs is a key detail, and they appear to be green, which is consistent with typical highway signage. The context of the image, showing a highway with directional signs, supports this observation. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000110196.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 240,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "green street signs",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows highway directional signs that are green in color, which is consistent with the completion's description. This directly answers the instruction's question about whether the signs are blue (they are not - they are green)."
},
{
"index": 277,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Chinese",
"verification_note": "The text on the street signs in the image is clearly in Chinese characters, as described in the completion."
},
{
"index": 297,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "directions and distances",
"verification_note": "The signs visible in the image contain directional information and distance markers (e.g., '700m'), which is typical of highway signage and matches the completion's description."
},
{
"index": 327,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "overpass is lined with plants",
"verification_note": "The image shows vegetation/plants growing along the top edge of the overpass structure, supporting this claim."
},
{
"index": 373,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "streetlight",
"verification_note": "A streetlight pole is clearly visible on the right side of the image, confirming this description."
},
{
"index": 654,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "green",
"verification_note": "The street signs in the image are definitively green in color, which is the key observation that correctly answers the instruction's question about whether they are blue (groundtruth: no)."
},
{
"index": 686,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "typical highway signage",
"verification_note": "Green is indeed the standard color for highway directional signs in many countries including China, making this a factually accurate contextual observation."
},
{
"index": 833,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly answers the instruction's question 'Are the street signs blue in the image?' with 'No', which matches the groundtruth and the visual evidence showing green signs."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Are the street signs blue in the image?
|
|
base_1115_1
|
Are the clock hands black in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the color of the clock hands, focusing on visual details and context. I will then apply logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a suburban street with a sidewalk and a row of bushes. A clock is mounted on a post near the bushes. The clock face is white, and the hands appear to be black. The street is lined with trees and houses, and there is a car parked on the street. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the color of the clock hands, I will focus on the contrast between the clock face and the hands. The clock face is white, which makes it easier to see the hands. The hands appear to be black, as they stand out against the white background. This contrast is typical for clocks where black hands are used against a white face for visibility. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000426202.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 217,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "suburban street",
"verification_note": "The image shows a residential street with houses, trees, and sidewalks, consistent with a suburban setting."
},
{
"index": 240,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sidewalk",
"verification_note": "A paved sidewalk is clearly visible in the image running alongside the street."
},
{
"index": 255,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "row of bushes",
"verification_note": "There is a row of green bushes/hedges visible along the property boundary in the image."
},
{
"index": 272,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "clock is mounted on a post",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a clock mounted on a decorative post/bracket attached to a building."
},
{
"index": 334,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white",
"verification_note": "The clock face in the image is white with visible numbers."
},
{
"index": 368,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "black",
"verification_note": "The clock hands appear to be black or very dark colored, standing out against the white face. This directly answers the instruction question and matches the groundtruth."
},
{
"index": 400,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "trees",
"verification_note": "Multiple trees are visible lining the street in the image."
},
{
"index": 410,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "houses",
"verification_note": "Residential houses can be seen on both sides of the street in the image."
},
{
"index": 433,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "car parked on the street",
"verification_note": "A parked vehicle is visible on the street in the background of the image."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Are the clock hands black in the image?
|
|
base_1136_0
|
Is there a traffic signal in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a traffic signal present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a row of motorcycles parked in front of a Dunkin' Donuts store. The motorcycles are of various colors and styles, and they are lined up neatly in the parking area. The Dunkin' Donuts sign is visible, and the sky appears to be overcast. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a traffic signal in the image, I will first look for any visible traffic lights or signals. Traffic signals are typically mounted on poles or attached to buildings. In this image, the focus is on the motorcycles and the Dunkin' Donuts store. There are no visible poles or structures that would typically hold a traffic signal. Additionally, the image does not show any intersections or roadways where a traffic signal would be necessary. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000360673.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 240,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "motorcycles parked in front of a Dunkin' Donuts store",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows multiple motorcycles parked in front of a building with a Dunkin' Donuts sign visible."
},
{
"index": 318,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "various colors and styles",
"verification_note": "The motorcycles in the image display different colors (including what appears to be turquoise/blue, black, and burgundy/red) and varying styles."
},
{
"index": 358,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "lined up neatly",
"verification_note": "The motorcycles are arranged in a neat row in the parking area, visible in the foreground of the image."
},
{
"index": 399,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Dunkin' Donuts sign",
"verification_note": "The Dunkin' Donuts signage is clearly visible on the building in the upper left portion of the image."
},
{
"index": 457,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "overcast",
"verification_note": "The sky in the image shows cloud coverage consistent with overcast conditions, though the image appears to have artistic filtering applied."
},
{
"index": 768,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no visible poles or structures that would typically hold a traffic signal",
"verification_note": "Examining the image, there are no traffic signal poles or mounting structures visible in the scene."
},
{
"index": 981,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly matches the groundtruth answer that there is no traffic signal in the image. No traffic signals are visible in the scene."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a traffic signal in the image?
|
|
base_1142_1
|
Is the plate oval in shape in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the shape of the plate by examining its edges and comparing it to known shapes. I will then provide a detailed description, context analysis, and reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a plate on a wooden table. On the plate, there is a lobster roll with a lemon wedge, a small packet of condiments, and a bowl of clam chowder. The plate appears to have rounded edges, suggesting it is not a standard rectangular or square shape. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the plate is oval, I will look at the edges of the plate. An oval shape typically has smooth, curved edges without sharp corners. In the image, the plate's edges appear to curve smoothly, indicating an oval shape. Additionally, the placement of the food items on the plate does not suggest any sharp corners or straight edges, which are characteristic of rectangular or square plates. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000572441.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 280,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "wooden table",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows the plate is placed on a wooden table surface, as evidenced by the visible wood grain texture."
},
{
"index": 319,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "lobster roll",
"verification_note": "The image shows what appears to be a lobster roll - a hot dog-style bun filled with chunks of lobster meat."
},
{
"index": 339,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "lemon wedge",
"verification_note": "A yellow lemon wedge is clearly visible on the plate next to the lobster roll."
},
{
"index": 354,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "small packet of condiments",
"verification_note": "There are small wrapped packets visible on the plate, which appear to be condiment packets."
},
{
"index": 388,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bowl of clam chowder",
"verification_note": "A white bowl containing what appears to be clam chowder (creamy soup with visible ingredients) is present on the plate."
},
{
"index": 436,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "rounded edges",
"verification_note": "The plate in the image has curved, rounded edges consistent with an oval or circular shape."
},
{
"index": 565,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "oval",
"verification_note": "The plate appears to have an oval/elliptical shape with smooth curved edges, which matches both the groundtruth answer and the visual evidence in the image."
},
{
"index": 638,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "smooth, curved edges",
"verification_note": "The plate's edges are indeed smooth and curved, consistent with an oval shape as stated in the reasoning."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the plate oval in shape in the image?
|
|
base_1169_0
|
Is there a taxi to the left of the stop sign in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a taxi to the left of the stop sign. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a bus parked on the side of a road. There is a stop sign visible on the right side of the image. The bus is white with some text on the side, and there are no visible taxis in the image. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a taxi to the left of the stop sign, I will first identify the location of the stop sign in the image. The stop sign is on the right side. Next, I will look to the left of the stop sign to see if there is a taxi. The image shows a bus, but no taxis are visible. Therefore, based on the visual evidence, there is no taxi to the left of the stop sign. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000368818.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 236,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bus parked on the side of a road",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a bus (appears to be a public transit bus) positioned on the side of a road, consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 281,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "stop sign visible on the right side of the image",
"verification_note": "A stop sign is clearly visible on the right side of the image, matching the completion's description."
},
{
"index": 342,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white",
"verification_note": "The bus appears to be white/light colored in the sepia-toned image, which is consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 390,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no visible taxis in the image",
"verification_note": "After examining the image, there are no taxis visible anywhere in the frame, only the bus. This supports the conclusion."
},
{
"index": 577,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "stop sign is on the right side",
"verification_note": "This is consistent with the earlier observation that the stop sign is located on the right side of the image."
},
{
"index": 782,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no taxi to the left of the stop sign",
"verification_note": "To the left of the stop sign (which is on the right side), there is only the bus visible. No taxi is present in that area or anywhere else in the image, which matches the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a taxi to the left of the stop sign in the image?
|
|
base_1208_1
|
Is there a suitcase in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a suitcase present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a group of people on an airport tarmac. There is a small airplane with the word "DO-FIE" on its side. A person is pushing a luggage cart filled with various bags and suitcases. The sky is overcast, and the ground is wet, suggesting recent rain. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a suitcase in the image, I will focus on the luggage cart. The cart contains multiple bags, some of which appear to be suitcases due to their size and shape. The presence of these bags on the cart indicates that they are likely suitcases, as they are commonly used for travel. The context of being on an airport tarmac further supports this conclusion, as suitcases are typically transported in such settings. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000476517.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 249,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "airport tarmac",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows people on an airport tarmac with an airplane, confirming this location description."
},
{
"index": 276,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "small airplane",
"verification_note": "The image shows what appears to be a small propeller aircraft on the tarmac."
},
{
"index": 306,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "DO-FIE",
"verification_note": "The text 'DO-FIE' is clearly visible on the side of the aircraft in the image."
},
{
"index": 349,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "luggage cart",
"verification_note": "The image shows a wheeled cart being used to transport luggage on the tarmac."
},
{
"index": 374,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "various bags and suitcases",
"verification_note": "The luggage cart in the image contains multiple pieces of luggage including what appear to be bags and suitcases."
},
{
"index": 413,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "overcast",
"verification_note": "The sky in the image appears cloudy and overcast, with grey cloud cover visible."
},
{
"index": 441,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "wet",
"verification_note": "The tarmac surface appears to have a wet sheen, consistent with recent rain or moisture."
},
{
"index": 521,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "suitcase",
"verification_note": "The image shows luggage on the cart that includes what appear to be suitcases, directly answering the instruction question. This is consistent with the groundtruth answer of 'yes'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a suitcase in the image?
|
|
base_1213_0
|
Is there a kettle in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a kettle present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a kitchen stove with two pans on it. One pan contains mashed potatoes, and the other pan contains sliced carrots. There are cooking utensils, such as a spatula and a spoon, placed in the pans. The stove is black, and the pans are metallic. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a kettle in the image, I will first identify all objects on the stove. The image shows two pans and two utensils. A kettle is typically a tall, narrow container used for boiling water, often with a handle and spout. None of the objects in the image match the description of a kettle. The utensils and pans are clearly visible, and there are no other objects resembling a kettle. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000087000.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 244,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "two pans",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows two pans on the stove - one containing what appears to be mashed potatoes and another containing sliced carrots."
},
{
"index": 277,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "mashed potatoes",
"verification_note": "The left pan contains a white, creamy substance consistent with mashed potatoes."
},
{
"index": 321,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sliced carrots",
"verification_note": "The right pan contains orange pieces that are clearly sliced/cut carrots."
},
{
"index": 375,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "spatula",
"verification_note": "A wooden spatula is visible in the right pan with the carrots."
},
{
"index": 389,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "spoon",
"verification_note": "A black spoon/ladle is visible in the left pan with the mashed potatoes."
},
{
"index": 429,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "black",
"verification_note": "The stove surface is indeed black in color."
},
{
"index": 453,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "metallic",
"verification_note": "Both pans appear to be made of metal with metallic finishes."
},
{
"index": 728,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly states 'No' in response to whether there is a kettle in the image. This is consistent with both the groundtruth answer and the visual evidence - no kettle is visible in the image."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a kettle in the image?
|
|
base_1232_0
|
Is there a baseball bat in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if a baseball bat is present, following the structured format provided. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a baseball catcher in action, wearing a red and gray uniform with protective gear. The catcher is reaching out with a glove to catch a ball. An umpire is standing nearby, observing the play. The setting appears to be a baseball field during a game. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if a baseball bat is in the image, I will examine the scene for any visible bats. The focus is on the catcher and umpire, indicating a play in progress. Typically, a bat would be visible if a player were at bat or if it were part of the action. However, the image primarily shows the catcher and umpire, with no visible bat in the immediate area. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No. </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000311996.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 160,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "baseball catcher",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a person in catcher's protective gear (chest protector, shin guards, catcher's mask) in a crouched position typical of a baseball catcher."
},
{
"index": 198,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "red and gray uniform",
"verification_note": "The catcher is wearing a uniform that is predominantly red (chest protector, helmet, shin guards) with gray pants, matching this description."
},
{
"index": 224,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "protective gear",
"verification_note": "The catcher is visibly wearing full protective gear including chest protector, helmet/mask, and shin guards."
},
{
"index": 256,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "reaching out with a glove",
"verification_note": "The catcher's arm is extended outward and there is a baseball glove visible on the hand."
},
{
"index": 285,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "catch a ball",
"verification_note": "The catcher's posture and extended glove suggest they are in the act of catching or have just caught a ball, which is a reasonable interpretation of the action shown."
},
{
"index": 302,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "umpire",
"verification_note": "There is a person in black attire standing behind the catcher, which is the typical position and uniform of a home plate umpire in baseball."
},
{
"index": 377,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "baseball field",
"verification_note": "The setting shows a grass field with stadium seating in the background, consistent with a baseball field environment."
},
{
"index": 818,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly states 'No' in response to whether there is a baseball bat in the image. After examining the image, no baseball bat is visible - only the catcher, umpire, and their equipment are shown. This matches the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a baseball bat in the image?
|
|
base_1239_0
|
Is there a bus behind the animal in front of the truck in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a bus behind the animal in front of the truck. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a green truck parked on a dirt path surrounded by palm trees. A giraffe is standing near the truck, appearing to be feeding on the leaves of a nearby tree. There are no visible buses in the immediate vicinity of the truck or the giraffe. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a bus behind the animal, I first identify the main elements in the image: a truck, a giraffe, and palm trees. The giraffe is positioned near the truck, and there are no signs of a bus in the background or surrounding area. The focus is on the truck and the giraffe, with no indication of a bus being present. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000446075.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 246,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "green truck",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a green-colored truck/safari vehicle parked on the dirt path."
},
{
"index": 270,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "dirt path",
"verification_note": "The vehicle is positioned on what appears to be a dirt/unpaved path in the image."
},
{
"index": 294,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "palm trees",
"verification_note": "Multiple palm trees are visible throughout the image surrounding the vehicle and giraffe."
},
{
"index": 308,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "giraffe",
"verification_note": "A giraffe is clearly visible in the image, standing near the truck."
},
{
"index": 319,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "standing near the truck",
"verification_note": "The giraffe's spatial position is indeed near/beside the truck in the image."
},
{
"index": 360,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "feeding on the leaves of a nearby tree",
"verification_note": "The giraffe appears to be positioned near trees and appears to be feeding or reaching toward foliage."
},
{
"index": 410,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no visible buses",
"verification_note": "Careful examination of the image shows no bus present in the immediate vicinity or background. Only the green safari truck/vehicle is visible."
},
{
"index": 867,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' is correct - there is no bus behind the giraffe (the animal in front of the truck). This matches the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a bus behind the animal in front of the truck in the image?
|
|
base_1288_0
|
Is there a cart in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a cart present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image depicts a market scene with various fruits and vegetables displayed. There are bananas hanging from a structure, and a person is pushing a bicycle loaded with bananas. The market appears to be outdoors, with a dirt floor and makeshift stalls. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a cart in the image, I will first identify any objects that resemble a cart. The image shows a bicycle loaded with bananas, but no separate cart is visible. The focus is on the bicycle, which is being used to transport goods. The absence of any additional wheeled object or structure that could be classified as a cart leads to the conclusion that there is no cart present. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No, there is no cart in the image. The image shows a man pushing a bicycle loaded with bananas. </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000559312.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 225,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "market scene",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows an outdoor market setting with produce stalls and people, consistent with a market scene description."
},
{
"index": 251,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "fruits and vegetables",
"verification_note": "The image shows bananas hanging and other produce displayed at the market stalls, confirming the presence of fruits and vegetables."
},
{
"index": 294,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bananas hanging from a structure",
"verification_note": "Yellow bananas are clearly visible hanging from the market stall structure in the image."
},
{
"index": 334,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "person is pushing a bicycle loaded with bananas",
"verification_note": "The central figure in the image is clearly pushing/walking with a bicycle that has large bunches of green bananas loaded on it."
},
{
"index": 408,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "outdoors",
"verification_note": "The market setting appears to be outdoors with natural lighting and open-air stalls visible."
},
{
"index": 425,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "dirt floor",
"verification_note": "The ground surface in the image appears to be unpaved dirt/sandy ground, consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 440,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "makeshift stalls",
"verification_note": "The stalls visible in the image appear to be temporary structures with tarps and basic coverings, fitting the description of makeshift stalls."
},
{
"index": 602,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bicycle loaded with bananas",
"verification_note": "The bicycle in the central part of the image is clearly loaded with large bunches of bananas."
},
{
"index": 635,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no separate cart is visible",
"verification_note": "Examining the image, there is no separate cart visible - only the bicycle with loaded bananas. This supports the conclusion that there is no cart present."
},
{
"index": 908,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No, there is no cart in the image",
"verification_note": "This conclusion is consistent with both the visual evidence (no cart visible, only a bicycle) and the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
},
{
"index": 961,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "man pushing a bicycle loaded with bananas",
"verification_note": "The image shows a person (appears to be male) pushing/walking with a bicycle that has bananas loaded on it, matching this description."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a cart in the image?
|
|
base_1312_0
|
Is there a sausage visible in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a sausage visible. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use evidence-based reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a person holding a large sandwich in front of their face. The sandwich appears to be filled with various ingredients, including lettuce and possibly meat. The setting is indoors, with a window and some flowers visible in the background. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a sausage visible, I will examine the contents of the sandwich. The sandwich is large and appears to contain multiple layers of ingredients. While it is difficult to identify specific ingredients from the image alone, the presence of lettuce suggests that the sandwich may contain other fillings. The size and appearance of the sandwich suggest it could contain sausage, but without clear visibility of sausage, it cannot be confirmed. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000112269.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 223,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "person holding a large sandwich in front of their face",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a person holding and attempting to eat a large sandwich in front of their face, which matches this description."
},
{
"index": 349,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "lettuce",
"verification_note": "Green leafy vegetables that appear to be lettuce are visible in the sandwich."
},
{
"index": 361,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "possibly meat",
"verification_note": "The sandwich appears to contain some darker filling that could be meat, making 'possibly meat' a reasonable observation."
},
{
"index": 391,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "indoors",
"verification_note": "The setting is clearly indoors, as evidenced by the window frame and interior furnishings visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 407,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "window",
"verification_note": "A large window is clearly visible in the background of the image."
},
{
"index": 423,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "flowers",
"verification_note": "There are flowers visible in a vase on the right side of the image in the background."
},
{
"index": 970,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' matches the groundtruth answer. The completion correctly determines that there is no clearly visible sausage in the image, despite the sandwich containing various fillings."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a sausage visible in the image?
|
|
base_1333_0
|
Is the plate burgundy in color in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the color of the plate, focusing on visual details and context. I will then apply logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a dish on a white plate. The dish consists of a red, beet-based mixture garnished with shredded cheese. There are also three pieces of broccoli on the plate, with a creamy sauce drizzled around them. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the plate is burgundy, I will first observe the color of the plate itself. The plate appears to be white, as it contrasts with the red dish and green broccoli. The focus is on the color of the plate, not the food. Since the plate is clearly white, it does not match the description of being burgundy. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000529511.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 221,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white plate",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a white plate, which is consistent with the completion's description and correctly answers the instruction that the plate is NOT burgundy."
},
{
"index": 257,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "red, beet-based mixture",
"verification_note": "The image shows a dark red/burgundy colored food item that appears to be a beet-based dish, consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 296,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "shredded cheese",
"verification_note": "White shredded cheese is visible on top of the red mixture in the image."
},
{
"index": 328,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "three pieces of broccoli",
"verification_note": "The image shows three broccoli florets arranged on the plate."
},
{
"index": 374,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "creamy sauce",
"verification_note": "A white/cream-colored sauce is visible drizzled around the broccoli in the image."
},
{
"index": 548,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white",
"verification_note": "The plate is clearly white in color, which directly supports the conclusion that it is NOT burgundy, correctly answering the instruction."
},
{
"index": 777,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly answers the instruction - the plate is NOT burgundy in color, it is white. This matches the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the plate burgundy in color in the image?
|
|
base_1339_1
|
Is there only one clock in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the presence of clocks, focusing on architectural details and visual cues. I will then apply logical reasoning to conclude whether there is only one clock. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a section of a building labeled "CITY HALL." The building features classical architectural elements, including columns and a decorative cornice. A clock is visible on the upper part of the building, positioned above the columns. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is only one clock, I will examine the visible architectural features. The clock is prominently displayed on the upper section of the building, suggesting it is the primary clock visible in this image. There are no other clocks visible in the image, and the focus is on the clock above the columns. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000522450.jpg
|
counting
|
[
{
"index": 275,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "CITY HALL",
"verification_note": "The text 'CITY HALL' is clearly visible on the building facade in the image, matching the completion's description."
},
{
"index": 309,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "classical architectural elements",
"verification_note": "The building displays classical architectural features including columns with Corinthian capitals and a decorative cornice, which are visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 353,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "columns",
"verification_note": "Multiple columns are clearly visible on the building facade in the image."
},
{
"index": 367,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "decorative cornice",
"verification_note": "A decorative cornice is visible along the roofline of the building in the image."
},
{
"index": 387,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "A clock",
"verification_note": "A clock is clearly visible in the upper portion of the building, positioned in a tower structure above the main facade."
},
{
"index": 413,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "upper part of the building",
"verification_note": "The clock is indeed positioned in the upper section of the building, specifically in a clock tower structure."
},
{
"index": 452,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "above the columns",
"verification_note": "The clock tower is positioned above the columned facade of the building, as visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 728,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no other clocks visible in the image",
"verification_note": "Upon examination of the image, only one clock face is visible in the clock tower. No additional clocks can be seen in the visible portion of the building or surrounding area."
},
{
"index": 842,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Yes",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly answers the instruction's question 'Is there only one clock in the image?' The image shows only one clock face, which matches the groundtruth answer of 'yes'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there only one clock in the image?
|
|
base_1344_1
|
Is the broccoli positioned to the left of the orange in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the position of the broccoli relative to the orange. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a plastic container filled with a meal consisting of sliced chicken, red peppers, and broccoli. Next to the container is a small orange and a green yogurt container labeled "Activia." The broccoli is positioned on top of the chicken and vegetables. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the position of the broccoli relative to the orange, I will first identify the location of each item in the image. The broccoli is part of the meal in the plastic container. The orange is placed separately next to the container. Since the broccoli is inside the container and the orange is outside, the broccoli is not positioned to the left of the orange. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000105643.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 250,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "plastic container",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a transparent plastic container with a blue bottom and red lid containing the meal."
},
{
"index": 301,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sliced chicken",
"verification_note": "The container shows what appears to be sliced chicken pieces mixed with vegetables."
},
{
"index": 317,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "red peppers",
"verification_note": "Red pepper pieces are visible in the container mixed with the chicken."
},
{
"index": 334,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "broccoli",
"verification_note": "Green broccoli florets are clearly visible in the container."
},
{
"index": 371,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "small orange",
"verification_note": "An orange is visible to the right of the container in the image."
},
{
"index": 390,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "green yogurt container",
"verification_note": "A green Activia yogurt container is visible in the upper right portion of the image."
},
{
"index": 422,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Activia",
"verification_note": "The yogurt container is clearly labeled 'Activia' with the Dannon brand logo."
},
{
"index": 436,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "broccoli is positioned on top of the chicken and vegetables",
"verification_note": "The broccoli florets are positioned on top of the other ingredients in the container."
},
{
"index": 837,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "broccoli is not positioned to the left of the orange",
"verification_note": "This conclusion contradicts the visual evidence. Looking at the image from the viewer's perspective, the broccoli (inside the container on the left side of the frame) IS positioned to the left of the orange (which is on the right side of the frame). The model's reasoning conflates 'inside vs outside the container' with left-right spatial positioning, leading to an incorrect answer that contradicts both the groundtruth and the actual visual layout."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the broccoli positioned to the left of the orange in the image?
|
|
base_1348_1
|
Is the taxi on the far left white in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the color of the taxi on the far left. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use evidence-based reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a highway with several vehicles, including a taxi on the far left. Above the highway, there are road signs indicating directions to Ventura, Hollywood Blvd, and Sunset Blvd. The taxi is white with a visible license plate. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the color of the taxi, I will focus on the vehicle on the far left. The taxi is clearly visible and appears to be white. The presence of a license plate further confirms that this is a taxi. The context of the image, showing a highway with multiple vehicles, supports the identification of the taxi. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000001532.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 233,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "highway",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a highway/freeway with multiple lanes and vehicles, confirmed by the presence of highway signage for Route 101."
},
{
"index": 276,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "taxi on the far left",
"verification_note": "There is a vehicle marked 'TAXI' visible on the far left side of the image."
},
{
"index": 363,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Ventura",
"verification_note": "The highway sign clearly shows 'Ventura' as one of the destinations on the left side of the overhead signage."
},
{
"index": 372,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Hollywood Blvd",
"verification_note": "The highway sign clearly displays 'Hollywood Blvd' on the right portion of the overhead signage."
},
{
"index": 392,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Sunset Blvd",
"verification_note": "The highway sign clearly shows 'Sunset Blvd' on the rightmost portion of the overhead signage."
},
{
"index": 417,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white",
"verification_note": "The taxi on the far left appears to be white in color, which matches the groundtruth answer of 'yes' to the question about whether the taxi is white."
},
{
"index": 438,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "license plate",
"verification_note": "A license plate is visible on the taxi vehicle on the far left."
},
{
"index": 817,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Yes",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly answers the instruction's question - the taxi on the far left is indeed white, which matches the groundtruth answer."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the taxi on the far left white in the image?
|
|
base_1402_0
|
Is there a sled in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a sled present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a person performing a skateboard trick in an outdoor skatepark. The background includes a bridge, streetlights, and a clear sky. The focus is on the skateboarder and the skateboard, with no visible sled. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a sled in the image, I will first identify all objects present. The main elements are the skateboarder, the skateboard, and the skatepark environment. I will then look for any object resembling a sled, which typically has a flat base and runners. Since the image primarily features a skateboard and skatepark elements, and no sled-like object is visible, I conclude there is no sled. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000422603.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 223,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "person performing a skateboard trick",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a person mid-air performing a skateboard trick at a skatepark."
},
{
"index": 266,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "outdoor skatepark",
"verification_note": "The image shows an outdoor skatepark setting with typical skatepark infrastructure visible."
},
{
"index": 311,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bridge",
"verification_note": "A bridge structure is clearly visible in the background of the image."
},
{
"index": 319,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "streetlights",
"verification_note": "Multiple streetlight poles are visible in the background, including one illuminated light on the left side."
},
{
"index": 339,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "clear sky",
"verification_note": "The sky in the image appears clear with no visible clouds, showing a gradient typical of dusk or dawn."
},
{
"index": 408,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no visible sled",
"verification_note": "The image shows only skateboarding equipment and no sled is present, which is consistent with the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
},
{
"index": 564,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "skateboarder",
"verification_note": "The person in the image is clearly skateboarding, performing a trick on a skateboard."
},
{
"index": 582,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "skateboard",
"verification_note": "A skateboard is clearly visible in the image, being used by the person performing the trick."
},
{
"index": 885,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly states there is no sled in the image, which matches the groundtruth answer and visual evidence."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a sled in the image?
|
|
base_1412_0
|
Is there a sandwich to the left of the fork in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the presence of a sandwich to the left of the fork. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a plate with a sandwich, a pickle, and a small bowl of coleslaw. The sandwich is partially visible, and there is a fork placed on the plate. The plate has the text "KAPLAN STAR DE" on it. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a sandwich to the left of the fork, I will first identify the position of the fork on the plate. The fork is positioned near the center of the plate. Next, I will look for any sandwich pieces to the left of the fork. The sandwich appears to be on the right side of the plate, with no visible sandwich pieces to the left of the fork. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000322278.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 64,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a sandwich",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a sandwich on the plate, confirming its existence."
},
{
"index": 262,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a pickle",
"verification_note": "A pickle (appears to be a pickle spear) is visible on the left side of the plate in the image."
},
{
"index": 276,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a small bowl of coleslaw",
"verification_note": "A small glass bowl containing what appears to be coleslaw is visible in the upper portion of the plate."
},
{
"index": 350,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a fork",
"verification_note": "A fork is clearly visible on the plate in the image."
},
{
"index": 402,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "KAPLAN STAR DE",
"verification_note": "The text 'KAPLAN STAR DE' (appears to be 'KAPLAN STAR DELI') is visible on the plate in the image."
},
{
"index": 594,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "near the center of the plate",
"verification_note": "The fork is positioned approximately in the central area of the plate, overlapping the sandwich area."
},
{
"index": 718,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "on the right side of the plate",
"verification_note": "The sandwich is positioned on the right side of the plate when viewing the image."
},
{
"index": 755,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no visible sandwich pieces to the left of the fork",
"verification_note": "Looking at the spatial arrangement, the sandwich is to the right of the fork's position, with no sandwich pieces visible to the left of the fork. This supports the final conclusion of 'No'."
},
{
"index": 834,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' is correct and matches the groundtruth. The sandwich is positioned to the right of the fork, not to the left."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a sandwich to the left of the fork in the image?
|
|
base_1419_1
|
Is the cat in the image black?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the color of the cat, focusing on visual details and context clues. I will then provide a step-by-step reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a black cat sitting in front of a television screen. The TV is displaying a scene from a Lifetime show, and there is text overlaid on the image. The text appears to be a humorous message about watching TV. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the color of the cat, I will focus on the visual details of the image. The cat is clearly visible in front of the TV screen, and its fur appears to be black. The lighting in the room does not seem to affect the color perception of the cat. Additionally, the text overlay does not provide any information about the cat's color, as it is unrelated to the visual content. Therefore, based on the visual evidence, the cat is black. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000301575.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 226,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "black cat",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a black cat sitting in front of a television screen. The cat's fur is visibly black, confirming this description."
},
{
"index": 236,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sitting in front of a television screen",
"verification_note": "The spatial relationship is accurate - the cat is positioned directly in front of the TV screen, blocking part of the view."
},
{
"index": 313,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Lifetime show",
"verification_note": "The TV screen displays the 'Lifetime' logo in the bottom right corner, confirming this is a Lifetime channel broadcast."
},
{
"index": 341,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "text overlaid on the image",
"verification_note": "There is clearly visible text overlaid on the image in meme format at the top and bottom of the image."
},
{
"index": 394,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "humorous message about watching TV",
"verification_note": "The overlaid text is indeed humorous, written in lolcat/meme style about the cat trying to watch TV ('uh skyooze me is tryin to watch da kowch but u r impeeedin mah vyoo')."
},
{
"index": 618,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "black",
"verification_note": "In the reasoning section, the model correctly identifies the cat's fur color as black, which is consistent with the visual evidence in the image."
},
{
"index": 922,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Yes",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly answers the instruction question 'Is the cat in the image black?' with 'Yes', which matches the groundtruth and is supported by the visual evidence."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the cat in the image black?
|
|
base_1449_1
|
Is there a couch to the right of the cat in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the presence of a couch to the right of the cat. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and provide a logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a cat sitting on a wooden bowl placed on a table. The background includes a patterned couch with floral designs, a bookshelf, and a rug with a floral pattern. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a couch to the right of the cat, I will examine the spatial arrangement in the image. The cat is positioned centrally on the table, and the couch is visible in the background. The couch is located to the right of the cat when viewed from the perspective of the image. This spatial relationship confirms the presence of the couch to the right of the cat. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000213445.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 269,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "wooden bowl",
"verification_note": "The image shows the cat sitting on what appears to be a decorative plate or platter with concentric circular patterns, not a wooden bowl. The completion incorrectly identifies this object as a 'wooden bowl', likely based on prior assumptions rather than accurate visual observation."
},
{
"index": 293,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "table",
"verification_note": "The cat and the plate/platter it's sitting on are clearly positioned on what appears to be a wooden table surface, visible in the foreground of the image."
},
{
"index": 326,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "patterned couch with floral designs",
"verification_note": "The background clearly shows a couch/sofa with a floral or decorative pattern on the upholstery, matching this description."
},
{
"index": 365,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bookshelf",
"verification_note": "A bookshelf with books is visible in the background on the left side of the image."
},
{
"index": 382,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "rug with a floral pattern",
"verification_note": "A decorative rug with what appears to be a floral or ornate pattern is visible on the floor beneath the table."
},
{
"index": 466,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "to the right of the cat",
"verification_note": "When viewing the image from the camera's perspective, the couch is indeed positioned to the right side of where the cat is sitting, confirming this spatial relationship."
},
{
"index": 839,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "Yes",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly matches the groundtruth answer and accurately reflects the presence of a couch to the right of the cat in the image."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a couch to the right of the cat in the image?
|
|
base_1493_0
|
Is the tissue roll brown in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the color of the tissue roll, focusing on visual details and context. I will then apply logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a squat toilet with a white ceramic seat. To the left, there is a white tissue roll dispenser mounted on the wall. The surrounding area includes tiled walls and a tiled floor. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the color of the tissue roll, I will focus on the dispenser. The dispenser is white, and the tissue roll inside appears to be white as well. The lighting in the image is sufficient to distinguish the color of the tissue roll. Given the context of a public restroom, the tissue roll is likely standard white for hygiene and visibility. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000139633.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 217,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "squat toilet",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a squat toilet fixture installed in the floor, which is accurately identified in the completion."
},
{
"index": 237,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white ceramic seat",
"verification_note": "The squat toilet appears to be made of white ceramic material, consistent with the description. Note: squat toilets don't have 'seats' in the traditional sense, but the white ceramic fixture itself is accurately described."
},
{
"index": 281,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white tissue roll dispenser",
"verification_note": "A white/light-colored tissue roll dispenser is clearly visible mounted on the wall to the left in the image."
},
{
"index": 309,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "mounted on the wall",
"verification_note": "The tissue dispenser is visibly mounted on the tiled wall in the image."
},
{
"index": 360,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "tiled walls",
"verification_note": "The walls in the image are clearly covered with white tiles."
},
{
"index": 378,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "tiled floor",
"verification_note": "The floor visible in the image appears to be tiled with darker colored tiles."
},
{
"index": 506,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white",
"verification_note": "The dispenser appears to be white or light-colored in the image, consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 554,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "white",
"verification_note": "The tissue roll visible inside the dispenser appears to be white, which is consistent with the observation and directly answers the original question (the tissue roll is not brown)."
},
{
"index": 790,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' correctly answers the instruction asking if the tissue roll is brown. The tissue roll appears white in the image, matching the groundtruth answer 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the tissue roll brown in the image?
|
|
base_1500_0
|
Is the back right wall made of hardwood in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the material of the back right wall by examining visual cues and context. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and provide a logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows an indoor café setting with several tables and chairs. There are large umbrellas providing shade, and people are seated at the tables. The back right wall is visible, and it appears to be made of a light-colored material. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the material of the back right wall, I will consider the visual characteristics such as color and texture. The wall appears to be light-colored, which is typical of hardwood or painted surfaces. However, the texture and finish suggest it is more likely to be a painted surface rather than hardwood. Hardwood typically has a distinct grain and texture that is not visible here. Additionally, the context of a café setting often involves painted walls for aesthetic purposes. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000576385.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 268,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "indoor café setting",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows an indoor restaurant/café environment with tables, chairs, and umbrellas, consistent with this description."
},
{
"index": 293,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "several tables and chairs",
"verification_note": "Multiple tables and chairs are visible throughout the café space in the image."
},
{
"index": 330,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "large umbrellas",
"verification_note": "The image shows large umbrellas providing shade over the seating areas."
},
{
"index": 367,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "people are seated at the tables",
"verification_note": "Several people can be seen seated at tables in the central area of the image."
},
{
"index": 404,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "back right wall",
"verification_note": "The back right wall is visible in the image and is the subject of the question."
},
{
"index": 463,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "light-colored material",
"verification_note": "The back right wall appears to be made of light-colored brick or similar material, which is accurately described as light-colored."
},
{
"index": 654,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "light-colored",
"verification_note": "The wall texture and color are indeed light-colored, appearing to be light beige or tan brick."
},
{
"index": 701,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "painted surface",
"verification_note": "The reasoning correctly identifies that the wall appears to be painted or finished rather than natural hardwood, which aligns with the visual evidence of a brick or masonry surface."
},
{
"index": 1025,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' matches the groundtruth answer and is correct - the back right wall is not made of hardwood but appears to be brick or masonry material."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the back right wall made of hardwood in the image?
|
|
base_1550_0
|
Is there a raft in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a raft present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a view from a boat or a dock, with a wooden bench in the foreground. In the background, there is a body of water with a few objects floating on it. The scene includes a distant shoreline with buildings and trees. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a raft in the image, I will first identify any floating objects. The image shows a few objects on the water, but they appear small and do not resemble a raft, which is typically larger and more distinct. The objects are likely to be small boats or other floating items. The context of the image, showing a calm body of water with a distant shoreline, suggests a leisurely or scenic setting, which is less likely to include a raft. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No, there is no raft in the image. The image shows a view from a boat or a dock, with a wooden bench in the foreground. In the background, there is a body of water with a few objects floating on it. The scene includes a distant shoreline with buildings and trees. </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000347422.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 235,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "boat or a dock",
"verification_note": "The image shows a view from what appears to be a boat or ferry deck with a bench in the foreground, consistent with the completion's description."
},
{
"index": 258,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "wooden bench",
"verification_note": "The bench in the foreground appears to be made of metal (reddish-brown metal slats), not wood. The model likely assumed 'wooden' based on typical bench construction priors, but this conflicts with what's visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 320,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "body of water",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a body of water (appears to be a bay or harbor) in the background."
},
{
"index": 339,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a few objects floating on it",
"verification_note": "There are visible objects on the water, appearing to be small boats or watercraft in the distance."
},
{
"index": 390,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "distant shoreline",
"verification_note": "A shoreline with development is visible in the background across the water."
},
{
"index": 413,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "buildings",
"verification_note": "Buildings are visible on the distant shoreline in the background."
},
{
"index": 427,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "trees",
"verification_note": "Trees are visible on the hillside/shoreline in the background."
},
{
"index": 716,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "small boats or other floating items",
"verification_note": "The objects on the water appear to be small boats or similar watercraft, consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 789,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "calm body of water",
"verification_note": "The water surface appears relatively calm with minimal wave activity visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 941,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No, there is no raft in the image",
"verification_note": "This conclusion is consistent with the groundtruth answer 'no' and visual inspection of the image, which shows no raft present."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a raft in the image?
|
|
base_1637_1
|
Is the tie blue in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the color of the tie, focusing on visual details and context. I will then provide a step-by-step reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a person standing in a kitchen. The person is wearing a blue patterned shirt and a tie. The tie appears to be blue with a pattern. The kitchen has a refrigerator with magnets and a rug on the floor. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the color of the tie, I will focus on the visible details. The shirt is blue, which might suggest a similar color for the tie. However, the tie's pattern and the lighting in the kitchen could affect its appearance. Despite these factors, the tie's predominant color appears to be blue. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000046013.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 241,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "kitchen",
"verification_note": "The image shows a person standing in what appears to be an office or break room setting with a refrigerator, filing cabinets, and bulletin board. While there is a refrigerator present, the overall environment does not clearly constitute a typical kitchen. The model may have assumed 'kitchen' based on the presence of a refrigerator and flooring, but the visual evidence suggests a different type of space."
},
{
"index": 274,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "blue patterned shirt",
"verification_note": "The person in the image is wearing a shirt that appears to be blue with a pattern on it, which matches this description."
},
{
"index": 328,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "blue with a pattern",
"verification_note": "The tie visible in the image is clearly blue and has a pattern on it, consistent with this description."
},
{
"index": 385,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "magnets",
"verification_note": "The refrigerator in the background has various items attached to it that appear to be magnets or magnetic materials, consistent with this claim."
},
{
"index": 399,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "rug on the floor",
"verification_note": "There is clearly a decorative rug/carpet on the floor where the person is standing, matching this description."
},
{
"index": 526,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "blue",
"verification_note": "The tie's predominant color is clearly blue as shown in the image, which aligns with both the groundtruth answer and the visual evidence."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the tie blue in the image?
|
|
base_1689_0
|
Is there a burger to the right of the cup in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a burger to the right of the cup. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a yellow cup with the word "FAMOUS" on it, placed on a table. Next to the cup is a hot dog with sauerkraut and ketchup on a bun. There is also a napkin with the word "Martha" on it. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a burger to the right of the cup, I will first identify the objects in the image. The cup is yellow and has the word "FAMOUS" on it. To its right, there is a hot dog with sauerkraut and ketchup. There is no visible burger in the image. The presence of a hot dog indicates that the food item is not a burger. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000136212.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 233,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "yellow cup",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a yellow/orange colored cup, confirming this description."
},
{
"index": 259,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "FAMOUS",
"verification_note": "The word 'FAMOUS' is visible on the yellow cup in the image."
},
{
"index": 314,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "hot dog",
"verification_note": "The image shows a hot dog on a bun, which is correctly identified."
},
{
"index": 327,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "sauerkraut",
"verification_note": "The white/pale colored topping on the hot dog appears to be sauerkraut, consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 342,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "ketchup",
"verification_note": "Red sauce visible on the hot dog appears to be ketchup."
},
{
"index": 376,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "napkin",
"verification_note": "A napkin is visible in the image beneath/beside the hot dog."
},
{
"index": 398,
"label": "Insufficient Information",
"span": "Martha",
"verification_note": "While there appears to be text on the napkin in the image, the resolution and angle make it difficult to clearly verify if it says 'Martha' or possibly 'Nathan's' (a famous hot dog brand). Cannot definitively confirm."
},
{
"index": 595,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "To its right",
"verification_note": "The hot dog is positioned to the right of the cup in the image, confirming this spatial relationship."
},
{
"index": 666,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no visible burger",
"verification_note": "The image shows a hot dog, not a burger. There is no burger visible in the image, which correctly answers the original question."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a burger to the right of the cup in the image?
|
|
base_1718_0
|
Is there only one cake in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is only one cake present. I will describe the visual elements, consider the context, and logically reason through the evidence to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a man holding a plate with a slice of chocolate cake. The cake is on a paper plate, and the man is using a fork to serve it. There are people in the background, suggesting a social gathering or party. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is only one cake, I will examine the image for any additional cakes or cake-related items. The focus is on the man holding a slice of chocolate cake. There are no visible signs of multiple cakes or cake pieces in the image. The presence of people in the background suggests a casual setting, but this does not indicate the presence of multiple cakes. The image primarily shows one slice of cake being served. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> Yes </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_train2014_000000136670.jpg
|
counting
|
[
{
"index": 245,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a man holding a plate with a slice of chocolate cake",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a man in a striped sweater holding a paper plate with what appears to be chocolate cake and using a fork."
},
{
"index": 316,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "paper plate",
"verification_note": "The plate visible in the image appears to be a disposable paper plate."
},
{
"index": 352,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "fork",
"verification_note": "The man is clearly holding a fork in his hand."
},
{
"index": 380,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "people in the background",
"verification_note": "Multiple people can be seen in the background of the image."
},
{
"index": 419,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "social gathering or party",
"verification_note": "The outdoor setting with multiple people gathered suggests a social event or party."
},
{
"index": 500,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "one cake",
"verification_note": "The reasoning states there is only one cake/slice visible, but the groundtruth indicates there are multiple cakes in the image. Looking at the image, there appears to be a whole cake visible on the plate (not just a slice), and the groundtruth answer 'no' to 'Is there only one cake?' suggests multiple cakes are present that the model failed to identify."
},
{
"index": 652,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "no visible signs of multiple cakes",
"verification_note": "This contradicts the groundtruth answer of 'no' to the question about only one cake being present, indicating there are indeed multiple cakes visible in the image that the model failed to detect."
},
{
"index": 869,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "one slice of cake",
"verification_note": "The image shows what appears to be a whole small cake or a large piece on the plate, not just 'one slice'. The model seems to be interpreting the serving as a single slice, but visually it appears to be more substantial than a typical slice."
},
{
"index": 928,
"label": "Vision-Text Conflict",
"span": "Yes",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'Yes' (meaning there is only one cake) directly contradicts the groundtruth answer of 'no', indicating the model failed to identify multiple cakes present in the image."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there only one cake in the image?
|
|
base_1738_0
|
Is the man on the bleachers feeling anxious in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if the man on the bleachers appears anxious. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use evidence-based reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a baseball game in progress. A batter is in mid-swing, wearing a black jersey with the number 2. A catcher in blue gear is crouched behind the batter. In the background, a man is sitting on bleachers, wearing a red shirt and khaki pants. He is looking towards the field with his arms crossed. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the man on the bleachers is feeling anxious, I will consider his posture and expression. The man is sitting with his arms crossed, which can indicate a relaxed or defensive posture. His gaze is directed towards the field, suggesting he is engaged in the game. There are no visible signs of distress, such as fidgeting or a tense facial expression. The setting is a casual baseball game, which typically does not induce high levels of anxiety. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000416596.jpg
|
sentiment
|
[
{
"index": 247,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "baseball game",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a baseball game in progress with a batter, catcher, and baseball field visible."
},
{
"index": 276,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "batter is in mid-swing",
"verification_note": "The batter is visibly in a swinging position with the bat extended."
},
{
"index": 310,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "black jersey",
"verification_note": "The batter is wearing a black/dark colored jersey."
},
{
"index": 332,
"label": "Insufficient Information",
"span": "number 2",
"verification_note": "While there appears to be a number on the jersey, the image resolution and angle make it difficult to definitively confirm it is the number 2."
},
{
"index": 344,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "catcher in blue gear",
"verification_note": "The catcher is clearly wearing blue protective gear including helmet and chest protector."
},
{
"index": 368,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "crouched behind the batter",
"verification_note": "The catcher is in the characteristic crouched position behind home plate, behind the batter."
},
{
"index": 417,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "man is sitting on bleachers",
"verification_note": "There is a man visible sitting on bleachers in the background of the image."
},
{
"index": 456,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "red shirt",
"verification_note": "The man on the bleachers is wearing a red/orange colored shirt."
},
{
"index": 470,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "khaki pants",
"verification_note": "The man appears to be wearing light-colored pants that could be described as khaki."
},
{
"index": 524,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "arms crossed",
"verification_note": "The man on the bleachers has his arms crossed in front of him."
},
{
"index": 489,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "looking towards the field",
"verification_note": "The man's posture and orientation indicate he is watching the game on the field."
},
{
"index": 1048,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' matches the groundtruth answer. The man's relaxed posture with crossed arms and calm demeanor watching the game does not suggest anxiety, which is consistent with the correct answer."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the man on the bleachers feeling anxious in the image?
|
|
base_1770_1
|
Is there a bird in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a bird present. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a zebra standing on a grassy field. The zebra has a black and white striped pattern, and it is facing to the left. The background includes some trees and a structure, but no birds are immediately visible. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a bird in the image, I will first identify the main subject, which is the zebra. I will then examine the surrounding area, including the grass and background, for any signs of a bird. The presence of a bird would typically be indicated by a small, feathered creature, possibly in flight or perched on the ground. Since the image primarily focuses on the zebra and the grassy field, and no bird-like features are visible, I conclude that there is no bird in the image. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_train2014_000000283383.jpg
|
object
|
[
{
"index": 223,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "zebra",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a zebra with distinctive black and white stripes standing on grass. This identification is correct."
},
{
"index": 243,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "grassy field",
"verification_note": "The zebra is indeed standing on a grassy field, which is visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 273,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "black and white striped pattern",
"verification_note": "The zebra's characteristic black and white striped pattern is clearly visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 316,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "facing to the left",
"verification_note": "The zebra is positioned facing toward the left side of the image."
},
{
"index": 365,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "trees",
"verification_note": "Trees are visible in the background of the image."
},
{
"index": 377,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "structure",
"verification_note": "A structure (appears to be a building or fence) is visible in the background."
},
{
"index": 392,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "no birds are immediately visible",
"verification_note": "Upon careful examination of the image, there appears to be a small dark bird visible in the upper right portion of the image on the ground. The groundtruth confirms 'yes' there is a bird. The model failed to detect this bird, likely focusing primarily on the prominent zebra subject."
},
{
"index": 921,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "no bird in the image",
"verification_note": "This conclusion contradicts the visual evidence. There is a bird present in the image (visible in the background), and the groundtruth confirms this. The model's conclusion is incorrect based on incomplete visual analysis."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a bird in the image?
|
|
base_1780_0
|
Are the people in the image displaying signs of stress?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if the people are displaying signs of stress. I will describe the visual elements, analyze the context, and use evidence-based reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows two individuals in a living room setting. They are holding gaming controllers and appear to be engaged in a video game. The room has a couch, a lamp, and a window with blinds. The individuals are standing on a striped rug, and one is wearing a brown hoodie and jeans, while the other is in a black sweater and jeans. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if the individuals are displaying signs of stress, I will consider their body language and the context of the activity. The individuals are holding gaming controllers, suggesting they are playing a video game. This activity is typically recreational and not associated with stress. Their posture appears relaxed, as they are standing and engaged in the game. The setting is a living room, which is a casual and comfortable environment. These factors suggest that the individuals are likely enjoying themselves and not experiencing stress. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000574525.jpg
|
sentiment
|
[
{
"index": 246,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "two individuals",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows two people in the living room setting, consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 267,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "living room",
"verification_note": "The setting is clearly a living room with visible furniture including a couch, lamp, and typical residential decor."
},
{
"index": 305,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "gaming controllers",
"verification_note": "Both individuals are holding what appear to be gaming controllers (likely Wii remotes based on the wrist straps and white color)."
},
{
"index": 354,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "video game",
"verification_note": "The context of holding gaming controllers with wrist straps and their engaged postures indicates they are playing a video game."
},
{
"index": 381,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "couch",
"verification_note": "A beige/tan couch is visible in the background of the image."
},
{
"index": 390,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "lamp",
"verification_note": "A lamp is visible in the background near the window."
},
{
"index": 402,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "window with blinds",
"verification_note": "A window with white blinds is clearly visible in the background."
},
{
"index": 456,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "striped rug",
"verification_note": "The individuals are standing on what appears to be a rug with striped pattern on a hardwood floor."
},
{
"index": 490,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "brown hoodie",
"verification_note": "The person in the foreground is wearing a brown zip-up hoodie/sweater."
},
{
"index": 507,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "jeans",
"verification_note": "Both individuals are wearing blue jeans as described."
},
{
"index": 538,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "black sweater",
"verification_note": "The second person is wearing what appears to be a black sweater or dark-colored top."
},
{
"index": 888,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "posture appears relaxed",
"verification_note": "Both individuals appear engaged and relaxed in their gaming activity, with the person in front smiling."
},
{
"index": 925,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "standing",
"verification_note": "Both individuals are standing while playing the video game."
},
{
"index": 938,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "engaged in the game",
"verification_note": "Their body language and focus indicate active engagement in the gaming activity."
},
{
"index": 1000,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "casual and comfortable environment",
"verification_note": "The living room setting with home furnishings creates a casual, comfortable atmosphere."
},
{
"index": 1090,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "enjoying themselves",
"verification_note": "The person in the foreground is smiling, and both appear engaged in recreational activity, supporting the inference they are enjoying themselves."
},
{
"index": 1114,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "not experiencing stress",
"verification_note": "The visual evidence (smiling, relaxed posture, recreational activity) supports the conclusion that they are not displaying signs of stress, which aligns with the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Are the people in the image displaying signs of stress?
|
|
base_1784_0
|
Is the floor made of leather in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the material of the floor, focusing on visual cues and context. I will describe the image, analyze the context, and provide a logical reasoning to reach the conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a unique chair made from stacked suitcases. The chair is positioned on a floor that appears to be made of a speckled, light-colored material. The background includes a bench and a glass wall, suggesting an indoor setting. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the floor material, I will consider the visual characteristics of the floor. The speckled, light-colored appearance suggests a common flooring material like tile or stone. Leather floors are rare and typically have a distinct, smooth texture and color. The presence of a speckled pattern and the indoor setting further suggest that the floor is likely made of a more conventional material like tile or stone, rather than leather. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000259824.jpg
|
attribute
|
[
{
"index": 257,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "unique chair made from stacked suitcases",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a chair-like furniture piece constructed from multiple vintage suitcases stacked and arranged to form seating furniture. This is an accurate description."
},
{
"index": 363,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "speckled, light-colored material",
"verification_note": "The floor in the image is visible and appears to be made of a speckled, light-colored material, likely terrazzo or similar composite tile. This accurately describes the visual appearance of the flooring."
},
{
"index": 423,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "bench",
"verification_note": "In the background of the image, there is a beige/tan colored bench or seating furniture visible against the wall."
},
{
"index": 435,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "glass wall",
"verification_note": "The image shows glass walls or windows in the background, consistent with an indoor commercial or public space setting."
},
{
"index": 671,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "tile or stone",
"verification_note": "The reasoning correctly identifies the floor as likely being made of tile or stone based on the speckled pattern and appearance. This is consistent with what's visible in the image."
},
{
"index": 971,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly states 'No' - the floor is not made of leather. The floor appears to be made of terrazzo or similar stone/tile material with a speckled pattern, which matches the groundtruth answer of 'no'."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is the floor made of leather in the image?
|
|
base_1796_1
|
Is there a fence behind the animals in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine if there is a fence behind the animals. I will describe the visual elements, consider the context, and use logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows two sheep standing on a grassy field. The background is slightly blurred, showing more grass and possibly some trees. There is no visible fence behind the sheep. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine if there is a fence behind the animals, I will examine the background of the image. The presence of grass and trees suggests an open field, but no distinct lines or structures indicative of a fence are visible. The focus is on the sheep, and the background appears natural without any man-made barriers. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No </CONCLUSION>
|
yes
|
COCO_val2014_000000296865.jpg
|
positional
|
[
{
"index": 234,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "two sheep",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows two sheep in the foreground and middle ground of the image."
},
{
"index": 258,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "grassy field",
"verification_note": "The animals are standing on grass, which constitutes a grassy field."
},
{
"index": 276,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "background is slightly blurred",
"verification_note": "The background of the image shows depth of field with blurring, consistent with the description."
},
{
"index": 316,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "more grass",
"verification_note": "The background contains additional grassy areas visible behind the animals."
},
{
"index": 331,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "possibly some trees",
"verification_note": "There appear to be tree trunks or vegetation visible in the blurred background."
},
{
"index": 361,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "no visible fence behind the sheep",
"verification_note": "This is a critical hallucination. Looking at the image carefully, there IS a fence visible in the background behind the animals - it appears as horizontal lines/rails in the blurred background. The groundtruth confirms 'yes' there is a fence. The model's claim of 'no visible fence' directly contradicts what is actually visible in the image. This appears to be a case where the model failed to detect the fence in the slightly blurred background."
},
{
"index": 577,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "no distinct lines or structures indicative of a fence are visible",
"verification_note": "This reiterates the previous hallucination. Upon careful examination of the image, fence rails/lines are visible in the background. The groundtruth confirms a fence exists. The model failed to identify these structures in the image."
},
{
"index": 561,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "open field",
"verification_note": "The setting does appear to be an open field with grass, which is accurate regardless of the fence presence."
},
{
"index": 679,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "background appears natural without any man-made barriers",
"verification_note": "This is incorrect. The fence visible in the background is a man-made barrier. The model's claim contradicts the actual image content where a fence structure can be observed."
},
{
"index": 764,
"label": "Vision-Prior Conflict",
"span": "No",
"verification_note": "The conclusion 'No' (indicating no fence behind the animals) directly contradicts both the visual evidence in the image and the provided groundtruth answer of 'yes'. This is the final hallucinated conclusion based on the model's failure to detect the fence."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Is there a fence behind the animals in the image?
|
|
base_1808_0
|
Are there exactly two bicycles in the image?
|
<SUMMARY> I will analyze the image to determine the number of bicycles present, focusing on visual details and spatial arrangement. I will then apply logical reasoning to reach a conclusion. </SUMMARY>
<CAPTION> The image shows a room with a bed covered by a patterned blanket. On the bed, there is a bicycle positioned upright. The room appears to be a simple, possibly temporary living space, with a few personal items visible. </CAPTION>
<REASONING> To determine the number of bicycles, I will first identify any objects resembling bicycles. In the image, there is one bicycle clearly visible on the bed. There are no other objects or bicycles present in the image. The spatial arrangement and visibility confirm that only one bicycle is present. </REASONING>
<CONCLUSION> No, there is only one bicycle in the image. </CONCLUSION>
|
no
|
COCO_val2014_000000108679.jpg
|
counting
|
[
{
"index": 229,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a room with a bed covered by a patterned blanket",
"verification_note": "The image clearly shows a room with a bed that has a patterned blanket/cover on it."
},
{
"index": 300,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "a bicycle positioned upright",
"verification_note": "The image shows a bicycle standing upright on the bed."
},
{
"index": 570,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "one bicycle",
"verification_note": "Visual inspection confirms there is only one bicycle visible in the image, positioned on the bed."
},
{
"index": 620,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "no other objects or bicycles present in the image",
"verification_note": "While there are other items visible (orange clothing, bags, curtains), there are indeed no other bicycles present in the image beyond the single one on the bed."
},
{
"index": 723,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "only one bicycle is present",
"verification_note": "This claim is consistent with the visual evidence - there is exactly one bicycle in the image, not two as the instruction asked about."
},
{
"index": 779,
"label": "Supported",
"span": "No, there is only one bicycle in the image",
"verification_note": "The conclusion correctly answers the instruction's question about whether there are exactly two bicycles. The image shows only one bicycle, making the answer 'No' correct and consistent with the groundtruth answer."
}
] |
claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
|
Llama-3.2V-11B-cot
|
Are there exactly two bicycles in the image?
|
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 12