CallOpeningDetX / annotation_guide.md
SRK-CobuildX's picture
CallOpeningDetX v0.1
0dff23d verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
10.4 kB

Call opening annotation guide v0.2

You label the opening of a customer-service call from a speaker-labelled transcript. You report what the institution side communicated, with exact quotes as evidence. You do not judge whether a policy is met.

Each call is given as numbered turns t0, t1, … with a speaker role (Agent, Customer, or IVR for an automated recording) and a metadata line. The transcript is speech-recognised: expect fillers, repeats, misspellings and names written as heard.

1. Who counts

  • Only Agent and IVR turns can provide identification or a notice.
  • A customer introducing themselves, naming the bank, or asking "Are you recording?" never counts.
  • Trust the speaker labels. If a turn looks mislabelled, label as given and say so in notes.

2. The opening window

opening_end_turn = the index of the Agent turn that answers the customer's first statement of their reason for calling. That turn is part of the opening (disclosures in it count).

  • Greetings, identification, notices, asking the customer's name, "how can I help" all come before it.
  • The reason counts as stated at the customer's first explicit request or problem ("I want to close my account", "my card was declined"), not a hint or small talk ("today is my last day as a customer", "I have a question"). The answer is the first Agent turn that responds to the request itself ("Yeah, absolutely", "Sure, I can help with that", "Let me look into that"). A bare backchannel ("OK.", "Mhm", "Wow!") or an Agent turn about something else (spelling the customer's name, asking them to repeat) is not the answer; keep looking.
  • If the customer states no reason in the turns shown, use the last Agent turn shown and add a note.
  • Fields are labelled only from turns up to and including opening_end_turn. Identification or a notice that first appears later goes into late_mentions, not into the labels.

3. Fields

agent_identification: present | absent | unclear

  • present: the agent gives their own first name, full name, or agent / employee number. "This is Amanda", "my name is Jean", "I'm Agnes", "Hi, Dani Brooks, with Intellibank", "you're speaking to Carlie", "my agent number is eight two five seven one four".
  • unclear: an attempt that cannot be made out ("this is, uh, with Intellibank", a name cut off).
  • absent: none of the above. A department name ("this is customer service") is not identification.

institution_identification: present | absent | unclear

  • present: the institution is named, even misspelled by speech recognition ("Intellibank", "Intellabank", "Intel Bank", "Rivertown Insurance").
  • unclear: only a generic noun ("thank you for calling bank", "the bank", "customer service") or an unintelligible name.
  • absent: no institution mentioned by the agent or IVR.
  • The institution named inside a product name ("Intellibank Business Total Checking") counts as present.
  • If the metadata line says an automated notice naming the institution was played, that counts as present; quote nothing (evidence turn -1).

recording_notice: definite_recording | possible_recording | monitoring_only | none | unclear

  • definite_recording: the call is recorded. "This call is being recorded", "we are on a recorded line", "I will be assisting you on this recorded call", "recorded and monitored", "this call will be recorded".
  • possible_recording: recording is only possible. "may be recorded", "may be monitored or recorded", "calls are sometimes recorded", "some calls are recorded".
  • monitoring_only: monitored / listened to, no mention of recording. "This call may be monitored for quality". Monitoring never implies recording.
  • none: no notice, or a negation ("this call is not recorded"; keep the negation as evidence with polarity negated).
  • unclear: contradicting or garbled statements about recording.
  • More than one notice: the strongest wins (definite_recording > possible_recording > monitoring_only).
  • Not recording notices (label none unless there is a real notice too; quote them as polarity distractor only when they could confuse a reader): "I'm recording your address", "let me record your info", "I see a record of your call", "for the record, my name is", "your records", "on a secure line", a customer asking "do you record this?".

recording_purpose: list of quality, training, security, other, not_stated, unclear

Only when recording_notice is definite_recording, possible_recording or monitoring_only; otherwise [].

  • quality: quality assurance, quality purposes, customer satisfaction, customer service purposes, to improve our service.
  • training: training, coaching.
  • security: security, for your protection, fraud prevention, verification.
  • other: any other stated purpose: compliance, regulatory, legal, record keeping, dispute resolution.
  • not_stated: a notice with no purpose. Never combine not_stated with another value.
  • unclear: a purpose phrase that cannot be made out.
  • "secure line", "secured line", "secure call" are never a purpose (they describe the line, not why the call is recorded): "this call is being recorded on a secure line" → ["not_stated"].
  • "quality and training" → ["quality", "training"]. "for your security and customer satisfaction" → ["security", "quality"]. "on a secure line" is not a purpose.
  • The purpose must be stated for the recording or monitoring within the opening window.

opening_coverage: complete | incomplete | unknown

  • complete: metadata says starts at call start: yes.
  • incomplete: metadata says no, or (metadata not given) the text plainly starts in the middle of the call: the first turns continue a conversation already under way (an account being looked up, a reply to a question we never saw) with no greeting.
  • unknown: metadata not given and the text could be the start of the call (for example it starts with a greeting).
  • When coverage is incomplete, a field you would otherwise label absent / none is labelled unclear instead: not observed is not confirmed absence.

4. Evidence

For every field value other than absent, none, not_stated and coverage, give at least one evidence item: {"field", "value", "polarity", "turn", "quote"}.

  • turn is the turn index (-1 for metadata); quote is copied exactly from that turn (same spelling, same case, no added or removed characters), as short as possible while still carrying the meaning: "This is Amanda", "Intellibank", "this call is being recorded", "for quality assurance purposes".
  • polarity: asserted (normal), negated ("is not recorded"), distractor (looks like a notice but is not).
  • For recording_purpose, one item per purpose value.
  • For unclear values, quote the garbled part.

late_mentions: items {"field", "value", "turn", "quote"} for identification or notices after opening_end_turn.

5. Output

Reply with one JSON object: {"rows": [ … ]}, one item per call, in the order given:

{"id": "<call id>", "opening_end_turn": 2,
 "agent_identification": "present", "institution_identification": "present",
 "recording_notice": "definite_recording", "recording_purpose": ["security", "quality"],
 "opening_coverage": "complete",
 "evidence": [{"field": "agent_identification", "value": "present", "polarity": "asserted", "turn": 0, "quote": "My name is Sandra"}],
 "late_mentions": [], "notes": ""}

notes: empty, or one short sentence about anything doubtful.

6. Worked examples

  1. t0 Agent: Good morning, Intellibank. This is Amanda, how may I help you? t1 Customer: I need my balance. t2 Agent: Yeah, absolutely. → end 2; agent present ("This is Amanda"); institution present ("Intellibank"); notice none; purpose []; coverage complete.
  2. t0 Agent: Thank you for calling Intellibank. My name is Jean, and I will be assisting you on this recorded call. → agent present; institution present; definite_recording ("this recorded call"); purpose ["not_stated"].
  3. t0 Agent: …My name is Sandra and I'll be assisting you on a recorded call for your security and customer satisfaction. → definite_recording; purpose ["security", "quality"] (quotes "for your security", "customer satisfaction").
  4. t0 Agent: Thank you for calling Intellibank. My name is Casey. t1 Customer: I want to open a savings account. t2 Agent: I can help with that. Just to let you know we are on a recorded line on a secure line, and my agent number is eight two five. → end 2; definite_recording ("we are on a recorded line"); purpose ["not_stated"] ("secure line" is not a purpose).
  5. t0 Customer: Ring, ring. t1 Agent: Good afternoon. Thank you for calling bank. This is Ron Smit. → agent present ("This is Ron Smit"); institution unclear ("calling bank").
  6. t0 Agent: Hello, thanks for calling Rivertown insurance customer service. How may I help you? → agent absent; institution present ("Rivertown insurance").
  7. … t3 Agent: yes I do see there's a record of a call here → notice none; optional distractor evidence ("there's a record of a call").
  8. t2 Agent: Thanks for calling Northgate Bank, this is Ravi. t3 Customer: Are you recording this? t4 Agent: No, this call is not recorded. (t4 answers the customer's first reason) → notice none, evidence polarity negated ("this call is not recorded").
  9. t0 Agent: This call may be monitored for quality purposes. Thank you for calling Westfield Bank. → monitoring_only; purpose ["quality"].
  10. t0 Agent: Calls may be recorded or monitored for training. Thank you for calling Kaveri Credit Union, my name is Anil. → possible_recording; purpose ["training"].
  11. Metadata starts at call start: no; t0 Agent: …so I'll go ahead and pull up that account for you. → coverage incomplete; agent / institution / notice unclear (not observed is not absent).
  12. t0 Agent: Thank you for calling Intellibank. How can I help? t1 Customer: My card was declined. t2 Agent: I can look into that. … t10 Agent: just so you know this call is recorded, I'm Lavinia. → end 2; agent absent; notice none; late_mentions for both.