review
stringlengths
5
16.6k
score
stringclasses
5 values
area
stringclasses
12 values
text
stringlengths
31
5.65k
This paper combines the machine learning technique within the traditional column generation method for solving combinatorial optimization problems. Specifically, the authors propose to use machine learning algorithms to predict high quality columns that belong to an optimal integer solution. Here the machine learning m...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This paper combines the machine learning technique within the traditional column generation method for solving combinatorial optimization problems. Specifically, the authors propose to use machine learning algorithms to predict high quality columns that belong to an optimal integer solution. Here the machine le...
This paper presented a new prompt learning approach for vision-language models, namely PLOT. The main idea of this paper is to learn multiple prompts per class and use optimal transport to match them with visual features of images. The whole optimization process contains inner and outer loops to optimize the matching a...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper presented a new prompt learning approach for vision-language models, namely PLOT. The main idea of this paper is to learn multiple prompts per class and use optimal transport to match them with visual features of images. The whole optimization process contains inner and outer loops to optimize the ma...
This article introduces wide graph neural networks (WGNNs). The structure of WGNNs is inspired by an analysis of oversmoothing in linear GNNs. Experiments are presented in which WGNNs achieve SOTA in several benchmark tasks, especially in the setting of heterphilic graphs. Strengths: In my view, the main strengths of ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This article introduces wide graph neural networks (WGNNs). The structure of WGNNs is inspired by an analysis of oversmoothing in linear GNNs. Experiments are presented in which WGNNs achieve SOTA in several benchmark tasks, especially in the setting of heterphilic graphs. Strengths: In my view, the main stren...
This paper focuses on the prediction of protein thermostability and the design of more thermostable proteins. After introducing a new benchmark to train and assess thermostability prediction models, authors describe a contrastive-learning framework to impart protein structure information on representations learned by l...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: This paper focuses on the prediction of protein thermostability and the design of more thermostable proteins. After introducing a new benchmark to train and assess thermostability prediction models, authors describe a contrastive-learning framework to impart protein structure information on representations lear...
This paper studies two methods (modeling label noise and semi-supervised methods) for handling datasets with noisy labels, and the causal structure strongly influences which of the methods perform better. The paper additionally proposes a method for finding the causal structure. The paper studies an interesting problem...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This paper studies two methods (modeling label noise and semi-supervised methods) for handling datasets with noisy labels, and the causal structure strongly influences which of the methods perform better. The paper additionally proposes a method for finding the causal structure. The paper studies an interesting...
This paper provides an empirical study of representational harms in pre-trained language models. The authors consider safety scores derived from a Mann-Whitney U-test, and compute such safety scores across a range of different models and marginalized demographics, finding that PTLMs have a tendency to show representati...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper provides an empirical study of representational harms in pre-trained language models. The authors consider safety scores derived from a Mann-Whitney U-test, and compute such safety scores across a range of different models and marginalized demographics, finding that PTLMs have a tendency to show repr...
This paper studies the machine learning problems with OOD data (that is, out-of-distribution data). The paper models OOD data by introducing a new variable called spurious attribute, of which the conditional distribution is different across training and testing data. The paper proposes to use CSV (conditional spurious ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper studies the machine learning problems with OOD data (that is, out-of-distribution data). The paper models OOD data by introducing a new variable called spurious attribute, of which the conditional distribution is different across training and testing data. The paper proposes to use CSV (conditional s...
This paper proposes a method for continual learning in text-image modeling. They propose a formulation that uses a historical and main neural networks whose parameters are used interchangeably between the two networks during parameter optimization as a weighed average. In experiments, the authors compare favorably agai...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes a method for continual learning in text-image modeling. They propose a formulation that uses a historical and main neural networks whose parameters are used interchangeably between the two networks during parameter optimization as a weighed average. In experiments, the authors compare favora...
Based on the finding of Non Robust Features (NRF) in the previous work (Ilyas et al., 2019), this paper tries to explain the phenomenon of Catastrophic Overfitting (CO) in FGSM-based adversarial training. It categorizes NRFs into different types and tried to design experiments to show that the two commonly observed ph...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: Based on the finding of Non Robust Features (NRF) in the previous work (Ilyas et al., 2019), this paper tries to explain the phenomenon of Catastrophic Overfitting (CO) in FGSM-based adversarial training. It categorizes NRFs into different types and tried to design experiments to show that the two commonly obs...
The authors study approximation and learning of functions from Besov spaces by transformer networks. The results show that transformer networks can avoid curse of dimensionality. Almost minimax optimal rates are presented. Transformer networks are not well understood theoretically. This paper provides some interesting...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The authors study approximation and learning of functions from Besov spaces by transformer networks. The results show that transformer networks can avoid curse of dimensionality. Almost minimax optimal rates are presented. Transformer networks are not well understood theoretically. This paper provides some int...
The paper proposes approach that enables simple hyperparameter search in scenarios where either label information is delayed or when the training on full dataset is too costly. The paper proses to use an auxiliary neural network to predict missing labels and a method to search for probable dataset to select a subset o...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes approach that enables simple hyperparameter search in scenarios where either label information is delayed or when the training on full dataset is too costly. The paper proses to use an auxiliary neural network to predict missing labels and a method to search for probable dataset to select a ...
This work strives to learn a visual-textual embedding space from weakly label image-text pairs from the internet. In a typical contrastive learning with cosine-similarity, the noise in training data prevents the deep network to produce a solution with alignment-uniformity, and the network achieves a suboptimal system ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This work strives to learn a visual-textual embedding space from weakly label image-text pairs from the internet. In a typical contrastive learning with cosine-similarity, the noise in training data prevents the deep network to produce a solution with alignment-uniformity, and the network achieves a suboptimal...
The paper proposes a method to improve indoor localization based on combination of RSSI and accelerometer data from waerable device. The localization data is used to produce features that serve as inputs for a classification model aiming to recognize when patients with Parkinson disease are off their medication. The an...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: The paper proposes a method to improve indoor localization based on combination of RSSI and accelerometer data from waerable device. The localization data is used to produce features that serve as inputs for a classification model aiming to recognize when patients with Parkinson disease are off their medication...
The paper uses a mixture of encoder-decoder transformers for code understanding and generation tasks. It in addition uses multiple pretraining objectives to train the mixture. The following pretraining objectives are standard and have been explored in previous works -- in particular (1) span denoising, (2) causal langu...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper uses a mixture of encoder-decoder transformers for code understanding and generation tasks. It in addition uses multiple pretraining objectives to train the mixture. The following pretraining objectives are standard and have been explored in previous works -- in particular (1) span denoising, (2) caus...
The paper proposes a version of LISTA where the update parameters can be made specific to each data sample even when the sensing matrix is not the same among samples. The paper then also proposes a variational method to dictionary learning to be integrated with the former approach. The paper considers a novel setting ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes a version of LISTA where the update parameters can be made specific to each data sample even when the sensing matrix is not the same among samples. The paper then also proposes a variational method to dictionary learning to be integrated with the former approach. The paper considers a novel ...
This paper proposes a new method for searching for optimal perturbation radii for adversarial training, which is shown to be more efficient than existing works. Strength - Well written. - Propose an efficient approach for searching for adaptive perturbation radii for each data point. It has better performance thant ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This paper proposes a new method for searching for optimal perturbation radii for adversarial training, which is shown to be more efficient than existing works. Strength - Well written. - Propose an efficient approach for searching for adaptive perturbation radii for each data point. It has better performanc...
This paper advocates a hybrid approach between inherent interpretability and post-hoc explainability for predictive models trained on image data. The aim is to blur the line between post hoc explanations of a Black-Box and constructing interpretable models, aiming to keep the high performance and flexibility of blackbo...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper advocates a hybrid approach between inherent interpretability and post-hoc explainability for predictive models trained on image data. The aim is to blur the line between post hoc explanations of a Black-Box and constructing interpretable models, aiming to keep the high performance and flexibility of...
The paper explores the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs). They carry out a comprehensive evaluation of 46 reasoning tasks to show that language models perform fairly well on single step reasoning problems, but suffer at multi-step reasoning problems. To that end, the paper proposes a new algorithm ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: The paper explores the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs). They carry out a comprehensive evaluation of 46 reasoning tasks to show that language models perform fairly well on single step reasoning problems, but suffer at multi-step reasoning problems. To that end, the paper proposes a new al...
The paper studies the task of learning continuous dynamical systems from data using a hybrid (machine learning + PDE solvers) approach and compares the performance to purely data-driven methods. In particular, authors consider a regularly occurring in practice setting where only a partial knowledge of the governing equ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: The paper studies the task of learning continuous dynamical systems from data using a hybrid (machine learning + PDE solvers) approach and compares the performance to purely data-driven methods. In particular, authors consider a regularly occurring in practice setting where only a partial knowledge of the gover...
The authors try to prove that the performance of graph convolutions placed in different combinations among the layers of a neural network is mutually similar for all combinations of the placement. ## Strength The analysis is comprehensive. ## Weaknesses 1. The assumption of the analysis is over-simplified. 2. Some cla...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: The authors try to prove that the performance of graph convolutions placed in different combinations among the layers of a neural network is mutually similar for all combinations of the placement. ## Strength The analysis is comprehensive. ## Weaknesses 1. The assumption of the analysis is over-simplified. 2. ...
This paper combines two rendering modules for synthesizing novel views and novel poses of human bodies from sparse multi-view images. The first one is a body representation based on neural radiance fields and SMPL, extracting pixel-to-image features from each view, and attaching features to SMPL vertices. In this way,...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper combines two rendering modules for synthesizing novel views and novel poses of human bodies from sparse multi-view images. The first one is a body representation based on neural radiance fields and SMPL, extracting pixel-to-image features from each view, and attaching features to SMPL vertices. In t...
* This paper explores the mechanism behind the generative adversarial imitation learning, which provide an important conclusion that instability is caused by deterministic policies, rather than GANs. * It provides some existing methods relieve exploding gradients, but at the expense of “non-confidence”, and ST-GAIL ha...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: * This paper explores the mechanism behind the generative adversarial imitation learning, which provide an important conclusion that instability is caused by deterministic policies, rather than GANs. * It provides some existing methods relieve exploding gradients, but at the expense of “non-confidence”, and ST...
The paper focuses on set-level self-supervised learning (SLSSL) and proposes a new method for this problem with the same name SLSSL. In order to eliminate the bad effects of corrupted labels, SLSSL augments a minibatch by corrupting labels and obtains a augmented model. Then SLSSL enforces the consistency between outpu...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper focuses on set-level self-supervised learning (SLSSL) and proposes a new method for this problem with the same name SLSSL. In order to eliminate the bad effects of corrupted labels, SLSSL augments a minibatch by corrupting labels and obtains a augmented model. Then SLSSL enforces the consistency betwe...
This paper modifies two aspects of the FID model (retrieval-augmented text generation) in section 3: (1) the authors truncate the passages to speed up the model (2) they modify the explainability component by using a ranking task. Results on KILT show a substantial improvement over the FID model. Strengths: simple mod...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper modifies two aspects of the FID model (retrieval-augmented text generation) in section 3: (1) the authors truncate the passages to speed up the model (2) they modify the explainability component by using a ranking task. Results on KILT show a substantial improvement over the FID model. Strengths: si...
This paper formulates a problem of decentralized online bandit optimization on directed graphs, in which the graph structure dictates the order of the players and how players observe the actions of other players. Moreover, all players can observe a joint bandit reward, which is a linear combination of the reward of eac...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper formulates a problem of decentralized online bandit optimization on directed graphs, in which the graph structure dictates the order of the players and how players observe the actions of other players. Moreover, all players can observe a joint bandit reward, which is a linear combination of the rewar...
This paper presents a novel method to generate 3D assets from text descriptions. The proposed method utilizes a pretrained diffusion model to generate a denoised 2D image from text and noisy input. The noisy input is rendered with a NerF model and known noise. The NerF model is trained by minimizing the noise residual ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Generative models
Review: This paper presents a novel method to generate 3D assets from text descriptions. The proposed method utilizes a pretrained diffusion model to generate a denoised 2D image from text and noisy input. The noisy input is rendered with a NerF model and known noise. The NerF model is trained by minimizing the noise r...
The paper describes multiple tricks to push the performance and of the self-supervised Barlow Twins step in a block-wise setting. Most prominently, it is reported than a block-wise training of a ResNet architecture with Barlow twins leads to a high top-1 accuracy of a down-stream classifier (70+% which is one percent a...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: The paper describes multiple tricks to push the performance and of the self-supervised Barlow Twins step in a block-wise setting. Most prominently, it is reported than a block-wise training of a ResNet architecture with Barlow twins leads to a high top-1 accuracy of a down-stream classifier (70+% which is one p...
The paper considers achieving the zero knowledge fair decision tree learning algorithms to guarantee confidentiality both the model and training data. An extension to ensembles of trees is also proposed. Strength: 1. The idea of considering confidential proof of fairness for training is interesting. 2. They design an...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: The paper considers achieving the zero knowledge fair decision tree learning algorithms to guarantee confidentiality both the model and training data. An extension to ensembles of trees is also proposed. Strength: 1. The idea of considering confidential proof of fairness for training is interesting. 2. They d...
Two unbiased stochastic proximal solvers for learning graph equilibrium models are proposed. They are inspired by the stochastic proximal gradient descent method and its variance reduction variant (called USP and USP-VR solver). Both provide considerable computational speed-ups in comparison with the original solvers. ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: Two unbiased stochastic proximal solvers for learning graph equilibrium models are proposed. They are inspired by the stochastic proximal gradient descent method and its variance reduction variant (called USP and USP-VR solver). Both provide considerable computational speed-ups in comparison with the original s...
The authors address the problem of federated learning in the scenario where clients have differently defined label sets (assuming a super set of labels and a subset with and without partial overlap), but without requiring cross-client data relabeling. Further they consider also the setting where only a small portion of...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The authors address the problem of federated learning in the scenario where clients have differently defined label sets (assuming a super set of labels and a subset with and without partial overlap), but without requiring cross-client data relabeling. Further they consider also the setting where only a small po...
This paper studies the edge of stability phenomenon. They propose to incorporate the cubic term in the convergence analysis and show that there is a self-stabilization property caused by this cubic term for general nonconvex optimization problems. Moreover, they show that GD is inherently regularizing the sharpness, i....
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper studies the edge of stability phenomenon. They propose to incorporate the cubic term in the convergence analysis and show that there is a self-stabilization property caused by this cubic term for general nonconvex optimization problems. Moreover, they show that GD is inherently regularizing the sharp...
This paper investigates bit-flip trojan attacks on text models with syntactic triggers. Several ideas are proposed for improving the effectiveness of these trojans. In experiments, this increases attack success rate (ASR) while having less of an effect on clean accuracy compared to baselines. Ablations confirm that mod...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper investigates bit-flip trojan attacks on text models with syntactic triggers. Several ideas are proposed for improving the effectiveness of these trojans. In experiments, this increases attack success rate (ASR) while having less of an effect on clean accuracy compared to baselines. Ablations confirm ...
This paper tries to fix bias in VideoQA models through causally approaches. The authors noticed that VideoQA models tend to just learn the dataset statistics ("How many ..." --> "2") and look to rectify that by forcing the model to answer questions that don't make sense for the input in order to disrupt the spurious co...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper tries to fix bias in VideoQA models through causally approaches. The authors noticed that VideoQA models tend to just learn the dataset statistics ("How many ..." --> "2") and look to rectify that by forcing the model to answer questions that don't make sense for the input in order to disrupt the spu...
This paper studies offline policy interval evaluation for discounted MDPs where the goal is to generate an interval that contains the ground truth with high probability. Specifically, this paper shows that, without the coverage and realizability, there exists a lower bound of the asymptotic bias. Then the paper propose...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper studies offline policy interval evaluation for discounted MDPs where the goal is to generate an interval that contains the ground truth with high probability. Specifically, this paper shows that, without the coverage and realizability, there exists a lower bound of the asymptotic bias. Then the paper...
This paper argues the existing drawback of OOD learning algorithms is because of lacking sufficient domains. The authors provide a hardness result that all learning algorithms require at least $poly (1/\epsilon)$ number of training domains to achieve an $\epsilon$ excess error. ### Strength - The authors provide theor...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This paper argues the existing drawback of OOD learning algorithms is because of lacking sufficient domains. The authors provide a hardness result that all learning algorithms require at least $poly (1/\epsilon)$ number of training domains to achieve an $\epsilon$ excess error. ### Strength - The authors provi...
This paper proposes a local model for boundary detection. At the core of the method, it assumes a local Gaussian Markov model in the feature space, where the features can be jointly learnt or derived from a neural network. The model uses a contrastive learning scheme to optimize features and pixel location connectivity...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Neuroscience and Cognitive Science (e.g., neural coding, brain-computer interfaces)
Review: This paper proposes a local model for boundary detection. At the core of the method, it assumes a local Gaussian Markov model in the feature space, where the features can be jointly learnt or derived from a neural network. The model uses a contrastive learning scheme to optimize features and pixel location conn...
This paper studies the task of detecting a planted community structure with small clusters (e.g. a planted clique) inside a graph with heterogeneous degrees. More precisely, the authors consider a random graph model such that $$ P(i \sim j) = \theta_i \theta_j P_{\pi(i), \pi(j)} $$ where $\theta$ models the degree het...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper studies the task of detecting a planted community structure with small clusters (e.g. a planted clique) inside a graph with heterogeneous degrees. More precisely, the authors consider a random graph model such that $$ P(i \sim j) = \theta_i \theta_j P_{\pi(i), \pi(j)} $$ where $\theta$ models the de...
This paper proposes to improve diffusion probabilistic models by considering multivariate diffusions. The motivation inherits previous probabilistic modeling methods that use auxiliary variables. By augmenting the diffusion space, it enables mixing between data dimensions and auxiliary dimensions, leading to better-ali...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Probabilistic Methods (eg, variational inference, causal inference, Gaussian processes)
Review: This paper proposes to improve diffusion probabilistic models by considering multivariate diffusions. The motivation inherits previous probabilistic modeling methods that use auxiliary variables. By augmenting the diffusion space, it enables mixing between data dimensions and auxiliary dimensions, leading to be...
The submission manifests several tricks in order to potentially improve the original MAE's recipe. The tricks include: 1) addition dropout in the attention layers; 2) a study on the normalization targets; and 3) intermediate mask tokens. The results are slightly improved with the authors' own implementation. Strengths:...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The submission manifests several tricks in order to potentially improve the original MAE's recipe. The tricks include: 1) addition dropout in the attention layers; 2) a study on the normalization targets; and 3) intermediate mask tokens. The results are slightly improved with the authors' own implementation. St...
The authors propose learning embedding in augmentation subspaces via masking, which specifies which dimensions are relevant for which augmentation. In the loss function, the mask is applied to the embeddings before comparison. Also, the loss function includes a L1 norm term that encourages masks to be sparse (with f...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: The authors propose learning embedding in augmentation subspaces via masking, which specifies which dimensions are relevant for which augmentation. In the loss function, the mask is applied to the embeddings before comparison. Also, the loss function includes a L1 norm term that encourages masks to be sparse...
This paper aims to reinforce the research about memory-dependence in decision making, especially reinforcement learning (RL). The core contribution is the introduction of a new task(environment) set, a kind of Maze with first-person image as observation. To get more rewards, the agent needs to "remember" (or "understan...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper aims to reinforce the research about memory-dependence in decision making, especially reinforcement learning (RL). The core contribution is the introduction of a new task(environment) set, a kind of Maze with first-person image as observation. To get more rewards, the agent needs to "remember" (or "u...
This paper studies the number of simplices contained in triangulations of all polytopes generated by ReLU networks. From the theoretical viewpoint, the authors prove upper (Theorem 1) and lower (Theorem 2) bounds on the maximal number of simplices. This implies that the average number of faces in a polytope grows only ...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper studies the number of simplices contained in triangulations of all polytopes generated by ReLU networks. From the theoretical viewpoint, the authors prove upper (Theorem 1) and lower (Theorem 2) bounds on the maximal number of simplices. This implies that the average number of faces in a polytope gro...
This paper proposes the M-L2O algorithm, as a substitute for the L2O algorithm, and then provides theoretical analysis and numerical experiments of the M-L2O algorithm. Strength: 1. The theoretical analysis looks solid 2. The numerical experiments corroborate the theoretical results. Weakness: 1. The L2O part problem ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This paper proposes the M-L2O algorithm, as a substitute for the L2O algorithm, and then provides theoretical analysis and numerical experiments of the M-L2O algorithm. Strength: 1. The theoretical analysis looks solid 2. The numerical experiments corroborate the theoretical results. Weakness: 1. The L2O part ...
This paper focuses on the deep metric learning field. The motivation of this paper is that Current pair-based and proxy-based methods harm the generalization ability as shrink the distance between positive pairs. As a result, it adopts the structure of normalizing flow as the deep metric layer and calculates the determ...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper focuses on the deep metric learning field. The motivation of this paper is that Current pair-based and proxy-based methods harm the generalization ability as shrink the distance between positive pairs. As a result, it adopts the structure of normalizing flow as the deep metric layer and calculates th...
The paper proposes an approach to train offline reinforcement learning methods with a mix of data belonging to the target environment or task of interest (e.g., a game) and data belonging to different, but related environments/tasks (e.g., different games). In particular, the paper proposes to use a small set of labele...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper proposes an approach to train offline reinforcement learning methods with a mix of data belonging to the target environment or task of interest (e.g., a game) and data belonging to different, but related environments/tasks (e.g., different games). In particular, the paper proposes to use a small set o...
The paper proposes a framework that accounts for observed confounding in treatment effect estimation via (i) balanced representation learning of treatment groups and (ii) adversarial propensity score learning. Experimental results on synthetic and semi-synthetic data sets demonstrate improved treatment effect estimatio...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: The paper proposes a framework that accounts for observed confounding in treatment effect estimation via (i) balanced representation learning of treatment groups and (ii) adversarial propensity score learning. Experimental results on synthetic and semi-synthetic data sets demonstrate improved treatment effect e...
The paper focuses on bilinear pooling in fine-grained image classification tasks. Bilinear pooling (that generates second-order features) is an effective method to capture details of fine-grained classes and achieves better performance than first-order features. Because bilinear features are high in dimension, many bil...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper focuses on bilinear pooling in fine-grained image classification tasks. Bilinear pooling (that generates second-order features) is an effective method to capture details of fine-grained classes and achieves better performance than first-order features. Because bilinear features are high in dimension, ...
The paper focuses on co-coercive variational inequalities and proposes a quantized generalized extra-gradient (Q-GenX) for solving these problems in multi-GPU settings where multiple processors/workers/clients have access to local stochastic dual vectors. In terms of theory, the paper proves $O(1/T)$ convergence of Q-G...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: The paper focuses on co-coercive variational inequalities and proposes a quantized generalized extra-gradient (Q-GenX) for solving these problems in multi-GPU settings where multiple processors/workers/clients have access to local stochastic dual vectors. In terms of theory, the paper proves $O(1/T)$ convergenc...
This paper introduces a new notion called the semirobustness of subnetworks. Then, the authors state how subnetwork semirobustness can be extended for the semirobustness of a bigger subnetwork under some condition that relates to the semirobust subnetwork and the rest part. Further theoretical analysis and empirical ve...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper introduces a new notion called the semirobustness of subnetworks. Then, the authors state how subnetwork semirobustness can be extended for the semirobustness of a bigger subnetwork under some condition that relates to the semirobust subnetwork and the rest part. Further theoretical analysis and empi...
This paper proposed an active learning approach for deep anomaly detection where a k-means++ based diversified querying strategy is adopted to ensure that the queries cover both the normal data and the anomalies well and two losses for queried and unqueried samples are designed to prevent neither the queried nor the un...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This paper proposed an active learning approach for deep anomaly detection where a k-means++ based diversified querying strategy is adopted to ensure that the queries cover both the normal data and the anomalies well and two losses for queried and unqueried samples are designed to prevent neither the queried no...
This paper proposes a new method to evaluate the perception results in autonomous vehicles based on its influences on the following planning module. With theoretical guarantees, the impact of the perception error can be decomposed into two orthogonal complements that are planning-critical and planning-invariant. Experi...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper proposes a new method to evaluate the perception results in autonomous vehicles based on its influences on the following planning module. With theoretical guarantees, the impact of the perception error can be decomposed into two orthogonal complements that are planning-critical and planning-invariant...
This paper proposes to use composition operators (product, mixture, negation) to modify the distribution for data generation. To do so, the authors proposed an energy-based parameterization of diffusion models. HMC (Hamiltonian Monte Carlo) is used for sampling rather than the reverse diffusion method. A simple illustr...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Generative models
Review: This paper proposes to use composition operators (product, mixture, negation) to modify the distribution for data generation. To do so, the authors proposed an energy-based parameterization of diffusion models. HMC (Hamiltonian Monte Carlo) is used for sampling rather than the reverse diffusion method. A simple...
This paper studies the benefits and limitations of dynamic benchmarking from a theoretical view. For the model where data collection and model fitting alternate sequentially, the authors show the model performance improves initially but can stall after only three rounds for the commonly used path dynamic benchmarking. ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper studies the benefits and limitations of dynamic benchmarking from a theoretical view. For the model where data collection and model fitting alternate sequentially, the authors show the model performance improves initially but can stall after only three rounds for the commonly used path dynamic benchm...
This paper considers the problem of finding $L_2$ heavy hitters in the sliding window model with differential privacy. If we relax either the privacy or the sliding window requirement, there were efficient algorithms but not with both. It gives an efficient algorithm for this problem with polylog space. I would consi...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper considers the problem of finding $L_2$ heavy hitters in the sliding window model with differential privacy. If we relax either the privacy or the sliding window requirement, there were efficient algorithms but not with both. It gives an efficient algorithm for this problem with polylog space. I wou...
The paper revisits the LTH and DLTH by relaxing the weight regularization in the early training stage, which tries to adopt early stopping instead to realize a better pre-trained weight initialization. Two sparse network training methods, termed as UniLTH and UniDLTH, were designed and developed through a nonlinear inc...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper revisits the LTH and DLTH by relaxing the weight regularization in the early training stage, which tries to adopt early stopping instead to realize a better pre-trained weight initialization. Two sparse network training methods, termed as UniLTH and UniDLTH, were designed and developed through a nonli...
Active learning is widely used for selecting data efficiently for machine learning models. Performance of existing methods is largely dictated by the quality of uncertainty estimates of the model which may make it challenging to scale up to large batches. The authors propose a technique known as Batch Balance based on...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: Active learning is widely used for selecting data efficiently for machine learning models. Performance of existing methods is largely dictated by the quality of uncertainty estimates of the model which may make it challenging to scale up to large batches. The authors propose a technique known as Batch Balance ...
This work explores how circuit motifs observed in biology can be built into artificial neural networks and finds they improve performance vs standard ANNs. Strengths - Viewing circuit motifs as computational building blocks is an interesting and important research direction with relevance for both AI and neuroscience....
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This work explores how circuit motifs observed in biology can be built into artificial neural networks and finds they improve performance vs standard ANNs. Strengths - Viewing circuit motifs as computational building blocks is an interesting and important research direction with relevance for both AI and neuro...
This paper presents an empirical study trying to explain the differences in speed of convergence of different layers of a neural network. To that end, the authors propose to measure the speed of convergence by tracking the rate of change in distance to the optimum of different layers within a time span. They argue that...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper presents an empirical study trying to explain the differences in speed of convergence of different layers of a neural network. To that end, the authors propose to measure the speed of convergence by tracking the rate of change in distance to the optimum of different layers within a time span. They ar...
This work provides a large-scale empirical study of the scaling properties of multitask/multilingual neural machine translation models. The work examined the dependence of the scaling law parameters on the task weights and demonstrated that the scaling exponent and the irreducible loss are independent of the task weigh...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This work provides a large-scale empirical study of the scaling properties of multitask/multilingual neural machine translation models. The work examined the dependence of the scaling law parameters on the task weights and demonstrated that the scaling exponent and the irreducible loss are independent of the ta...
This paper design and conduct a series of robustness tests to quantify the behavioral differences between contrastive learning and supervised learning to downstream and pre-training data distribution changes, and conclude that contrastive learning is more robust than supervised learning under downstream corruptions. Th...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This paper design and conduct a series of robustness tests to quantify the behavioral differences between contrastive learning and supervised learning to downstream and pre-training data distribution changes, and conclude that contrastive learning is more robust than supervised learning under downstream corrupt...
The authors consider the problem of unlearning. The aim is to do more efficiently than retraining from scratch. The authors propose to construct a prefix-sum-like tree during learning/training to keep intermediate results. These results can then be queried to construct a model that will look like the one without a cert...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: The authors consider the problem of unlearning. The aim is to do more efficiently than retraining from scratch. The authors propose to construct a prefix-sum-like tree during learning/training to keep intermediate results. These results can then be queried to construct a model that will look like the one withou...
The paper investigates methods for including known constaints into neural ODEs. It presents new approaches based on projection and ODE augmentation, which are compared and evaluated on two k-step-ahead prediction tasks. The results show some benefits of including such constraints, in particular in the low-data regime. ...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: The paper investigates methods for including known constaints into neural ODEs. It presents new approaches based on projection and ODE augmentation, which are compared and evaluated on two k-step-ahead prediction tasks. The results show some benefits of including such constraints, in particular in the low-data ...
Based on the strongly adaptive regret framework of Daniely et al., this paper proposes a strongly adaptive version of AdaGrad. The novelty seems to lie in an improved regret bound of SAOL, the meta algorithm of Daniely et al., which is similar to the regret bound of AdaGrad. ***Strength*** The idea is novel, simple, an...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Optimization (eg, convex and non-convex optimization)
Review: Based on the strongly adaptive regret framework of Daniely et al., this paper proposes a strongly adaptive version of AdaGrad. The novelty seems to lie in an improved regret bound of SAOL, the meta algorithm of Daniely et al., which is similar to the regret bound of AdaGrad. ***Strength*** The idea is novel, si...
This paper proposes a hierarchical ViT, by analyzing the effective design in Swin compared with the plain ViT. The model contains a hierarchical patch embedding with only MLP used in early stages, using transformer blocks with global attention in the 14x14 stage, and removing the last stage. Experiments on ImageNet, CO...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This paper proposes a hierarchical ViT, by analyzing the effective design in Swin compared with the plain ViT. The model contains a hierarchical patch embedding with only MLP used in early stages, using transformer blocks with global attention in the 14x14 stage, and removing the last stage. Experiments on Imag...
This paper aims to design reward functions for training TOD agents through reinforcement learning, inspired by Learning-to-Rank (LTR) methods. The authors demonstrate that their RewardNet and RewardMLE methods achieve strong improved performance on MultiWOZ 2.0 compared to SOTA methods for training TOD agents. Strength...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper aims to design reward functions for training TOD agents through reinforcement learning, inspired by Learning-to-Rank (LTR) methods. The authors demonstrate that their RewardNet and RewardMLE methods achieve strong improved performance on MultiWOZ 2.0 compared to SOTA methods for training TOD agents. ...
This paper provides sample complexity upper bound and lower bound for learning high uniform accuracy ReLU networks. It shows that any learning algorithm recovers neural networks to achieve high uniform accuracy needs intractably many samples (exponentially depending on the input dimension, network width and network dep...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper provides sample complexity upper bound and lower bound for learning high uniform accuracy ReLU networks. It shows that any learning algorithm recovers neural networks to achieve high uniform accuracy needs intractably many samples (exponentially depending on the input dimension, network width and net...
The paper provides a method to infer various meta-data features of datasets such as typical/atypical data points, noisy labels, noisy and out-of-distribution data points. *Strengths*: 1. The paper proposes, to the best of my knowledge, the first method which jointly infers multiple meta-data features of a dataset. 2....
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: The paper provides a method to infer various meta-data features of datasets such as typical/atypical data points, noisy labels, noisy and out-of-distribution data points. *Strengths*: 1. The paper proposes, to the best of my knowledge, the first method which jointly infers multiple meta-data features of a data...
The paper reviews the information reported around human subjects experiments in articles focused on artificial intelligence published at ICLR, at NeurIPS, and in Springer Nature. The authors identity papers that use crowdsourced labor (specifically papers that meet three criteria that they define), and on this set of w...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: The paper reviews the information reported around human subjects experiments in articles focused on artificial intelligence published at ICLR, at NeurIPS, and in Springer Nature. The authors identity papers that use crowdsourced labor (specifically papers that meet three criteria that they define), and on this ...
This paper proposes ProtoPNets, a method to debug models at the concept level. Strengths - The paper makes good progress on debugging models using concepts. The authors write well: this makes it quite straightforward to see how this paper varies from existing work. The contributions are thus clear. - The layperson vali...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper proposes ProtoPNets, a method to debug models at the concept level. Strengths - The paper makes good progress on debugging models using concepts. The authors write well: this makes it quite straightforward to see how this paper varies from existing work. The contributions are thus clear. - The layper...
This paper proposes score-based transport modeling (SBTM), a particle-based method to solve the Fokker-Planck equation. This is based on the transport map approach (TE) where the key challenge is to estimate the score of the distribution at the current time. Such a challenge is resolved by learning the score with neura...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: This paper proposes score-based transport modeling (SBTM), a particle-based method to solve the Fokker-Planck equation. This is based on the transport map approach (TE) where the key challenge is to estimate the score of the distribution at the current time. Such a challenge is resolved by learning the score wi...
This paper argues that the languages that emerge between networks are straightforwardly compositional with variations. The paper introduces a variation-based framework and new measures to analyze regularity in mappings and exhibit compositional structure, which is clearly shown in experiments. It shows that an emerge...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper argues that the languages that emerge between networks are straightforwardly compositional with variations. The paper introduces a variation-based framework and new measures to analyze regularity in mappings and exhibit compositional structure, which is clearly shown in experiments. It shows that a...
This work targets studying end-to-end learning for fitness activity recognition. A new fully annotated video dataset of fitness activities is established to evaluate different action recognition methods. And they show that end-to-end learning could perform similarly to SoTA action recognition pipelines based on pose ...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This work targets studying end-to-end learning for fitness activity recognition. A new fully annotated video dataset of fitness activities is established to evaluate different action recognition methods. And they show that end-to-end learning could perform similarly to SoTA action recognition pipelines based ...
This paper addresses the issue of PINNs overfitting at the boundary of the domain. Since numerical differentiation based methods require points outside the boundary of the domain to work well, the authors propose a simple and efficient solution which constraints the value of the function outside the boundary (external ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: This paper addresses the issue of PINNs overfitting at the boundary of the domain. Since numerical differentiation based methods require points outside the boundary of the domain to work well, the authors propose a simple and efficient solution which constraints the value of the function outside the boundary (e...
The paper studies value function approximation in reinforcement learning and proposes to include gradient-free evolutionary training steps when fitting the value function to data from the replay buffer. In particular, after a certain number of training steps the critics weights are perturbed with zero-mean Gaussian noi...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper studies value function approximation in reinforcement learning and proposes to include gradient-free evolutionary training steps when fitting the value function to data from the replay buffer. In particular, after a certain number of training steps the critics weights are perturbed with zero-mean Gaus...
This paper rigorously defined as well as thoroughly established simplicity bias for one hidden layer neural networks, as a function of a low dimensional projection of the inputs. The authors theoretically proved that the network primarily depends on only the linearly separable subspace when the data is linearly separab...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper rigorously defined as well as thoroughly established simplicity bias for one hidden layer neural networks, as a function of a low dimensional projection of the inputs. The authors theoretically proved that the network primarily depends on only the linearly separable subspace when the data is linearly...
The paper proposes an algorithm for solving safety-constrained decision problems with unknown dynamics that are also partially observable, which is one of the most difficult type of decision problems. The approach is to learn a safety-constrained POMDP model that has latent state, and also includes a safety critic. All...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper proposes an algorithm for solving safety-constrained decision problems with unknown dynamics that are also partially observable, which is one of the most difficult type of decision problems. The approach is to learn a safety-constrained POMDP model that has latent state, and also includes a safety cri...
This paper proposes an in-processing based method to design a fair classifier for the metric difference of conditional accuracy (DCA). First, the authors show that empirical DCA can be approximated by the root of empirical group variance. This suggests using the root of empirical group variance as a regularizer in the ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper proposes an in-processing based method to design a fair classifier for the metric difference of conditional accuracy (DCA). First, the authors show that empirical DCA can be approximated by the root of empirical group variance. This suggests using the root of empirical group variance as a regularizer...
This paper proposes a new benchmark for task-free continual learning. They claim that there is a large gap between how task-free continual learning is defined and how it is evaluated, so they. propose an algorithm to reorder any labeled dataset into a simulated task-free continual learning stream for benchmarking. Str...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This paper proposes a new benchmark for task-free continual learning. They claim that there is a large gap between how task-free continual learning is defined and how it is evaluated, so they. propose an algorithm to reorder any labeled dataset into a simulated task-free continual learning stream for benchmarki...
This paper handles the model selection problem in the context of unsupervised domain adaptation. In classical domain adaptation literature, model selection is a hard problem because of the lack of labeled target data. In recent years, several linear aggregation methods have been proposed yet they lack theoretical guara...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper handles the model selection problem in the context of unsupervised domain adaptation. In classical domain adaptation literature, model selection is a hard problem because of the lack of labeled target data. In recent years, several linear aggregation methods have been proposed yet they lack theoretic...
In this paper, the authors proposed a robust DCRRNN model to predict streamflow dynamics by using climate drivers (e.g. air temperature, wind speed and etc. ). The experimental results already demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed model, which can capture the dynamic change of streamflow from 2015 to 2022. Mean...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: In this paper, the authors proposed a robust DCRRNN model to predict streamflow dynamics by using climate drivers (e.g. air temperature, wind speed and etc. ). The experimental results already demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed model, which can capture the dynamic change of streamflow from 2015 to 20...
This article shows that exponential moving averages have several weaknesses, namely momentum and Lookahead optimizers. The authors then propose modifications corresponding to these weaknesses and propose a framework, Admeta, to analyze optimizers. Theoretical results are provided to show the convergence and the reasons...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Optimization (eg, convex and non-convex optimization)
Review: This article shows that exponential moving averages have several weaknesses, namely momentum and Lookahead optimizers. The authors then propose modifications corresponding to these weaknesses and propose a framework, Admeta, to analyze optimizers. Theoretical results are provided to show the convergence and the...
This paper proposes Low-Rank Graph Neural Network (LWGNN), which enhances GNNs by utilizing low-rank approximation to recover the underlying fully-connected matrix Z. In the matrix Z, a positive Z[i,j] means that node j and node i belong to the same class, and a larger value of Z[i,j] means that node j has more influen...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes Low-Rank Graph Neural Network (LWGNN), which enhances GNNs by utilizing low-rank approximation to recover the underlying fully-connected matrix Z. In the matrix Z, a positive Z[i,j] means that node j and node i belong to the same class, and a larger value of Z[i,j] means that node j has more...
The authors present an alternative paradigm to prompting: context distillation. The idea is that the model, instead of utilizing examples and specific prompts just for predicting without learning anything from these, tries to internalize this information. The authors propose a teacher-student architecture, where both s...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The authors present an alternative paradigm to prompting: context distillation. The idea is that the model, instead of utilizing examples and specific prompts just for predicting without learning anything from these, tries to internalize this information. The authors propose a teacher-student architecture, wher...
This paper presents a novel plug-and-play strategy for training large transformer models, which leverages sparse MoEs in a dropout-like manner to scale transformers to better performance in their full capacity without collapse. The method is simple, and the experiments are thorough. Pros - SMoE-Dropout demonstrates an ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper presents a novel plug-and-play strategy for training large transformer models, which leverages sparse MoEs in a dropout-like manner to scale transformers to better performance in their full capacity without collapse. The method is simple, and the experiments are thorough. Pros - SMoE-Dropout demonstr...
This paper proposes a new method for initializing GNN, by utilizing the trained weights from MLP. The method can lead to much faster convergence. Strength: - The proposed method has a strong empirical performance. Weakness: - The paper lacks technical novelty. There is no theoretical analysis of the findings. - The ...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes a new method for initializing GNN, by utilizing the trained weights from MLP. The method can lead to much faster convergence. Strength: - The proposed method has a strong empirical performance. Weakness: - The paper lacks technical novelty. There is no theoretical analysis of the findings....
This paper proposes Proxy approximated meta-node Contrastive (PamC) for contrastive representation learning on graphs. PamC is motivated by the computational burden of vanilla contrastive loss (i.e., InfoNCE), and to deal with this problem, it proposes a meta-node based approximation technique which proxies all negativ...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This paper proposes Proxy approximated meta-node Contrastive (PamC) for contrastive representation learning on graphs. PamC is motivated by the computational burden of vanilla contrastive loss (i.e., InfoNCE), and to deal with this problem, it proposes a meta-node based approximation technique which proxies all...
The authors propose a multimodal VAE, which includes an intermediate set representation. This fixed-size representation of every modality is then used for the mapping to the variational approximation. The authors show the performance of their proposed method on a computer vision study, a label-image dataset, and a ro...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The authors propose a multimodal VAE, which includes an intermediate set representation. This fixed-size representation of every modality is then used for the mapping to the variational approximation. The authors show the performance of their proposed method on a computer vision study, a label-image dataset, ...
The paper introduces a method to infer meaningful groupings of characters in a text. It is based on Slot attention method developed in the visual domain to obtain slots (vector representations), corresponding to meaningful parts of an image (objects). The paper adapts this method to work on a sequence of characters. Th...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper introduces a method to infer meaningful groupings of characters in a text. It is based on Slot attention method developed in the visual domain to obtain slots (vector representations), corresponding to meaningful parts of an image (objects). The paper adapts this method to work on a sequence of charac...
This paper proposes a Neural ODE model that implements a filtering approach for time series. In contrast to previous works, this approach relies on mapping the observations on a linear hidden process. The linearity of the underlying ODE allows fast integration and enforcing several desirable properties such as consist...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes a Neural ODE model that implements a filtering approach for time series. In contrast to previous works, this approach relies on mapping the observations on a linear hidden process. The linearity of the underlying ODE allows fast integration and enforcing several desirable properties such as ...
This work analyzes the effect of model accuracy on reward inference accuracy when fitted to human behavior. Specifically, it shows it is possible that a small model error leads to a very large error in inferring the reward. However, this scenario is unlikely. The authors backed their claims with simulations and real hu...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This work analyzes the effect of model accuracy on reward inference accuracy when fitted to human behavior. Specifically, it shows it is possible that a small model error leads to a very large error in inferring the reward. However, this scenario is unlikely. The authors backed their claims with simulations and...
This paper proposes a backdoor attack using features from the target class. Existing backdoor attacks usually use some pattern that does not relate to the target label, which could be identified by defense methods. This paper leverages the benign features from the target class as the trigger pattern to inject backdoor ...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes a backdoor attack using features from the target class. Existing backdoor attacks usually use some pattern that does not relate to the target label, which could be identified by defense methods. This paper leverages the benign features from the target class as the trigger pattern to inject b...
The authors present an energy-guided score model formulation for the task of equivariantly generating molecules. This work builds upon lots of recent references on SDE score matching models, equivariant networks (EGNNs) and specifically the work of Hoogeboom et al (2022), EDM. The main contribution of the paper is the ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: The authors present an energy-guided score model formulation for the task of equivariantly generating molecules. This work builds upon lots of recent references on SDE score matching models, equivariant networks (EGNNs) and specifically the work of Hoogeboom et al (2022), EDM. The main contribution of the paper...
The paper proposes DIFFUSER, a denoising diffusion model for text generative tasks. It treats text generation as a Markov chain of Levenshtein edit steps to denoise from the initial text. An editing step is modeled as an editing process in existing work (Reid & Neubig). The contribution of the paper is mainly 1) usin...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: The paper proposes DIFFUSER, a denoising diffusion model for text generative tasks. It treats text generation as a Markov chain of Levenshtein edit steps to denoise from the initial text. An editing step is modeled as an editing process in existing work (Reid & Neubig). The contribution of the paper is mainly...
This work analyzes the occurrence of spurious correlations in learning reward functions from preferences in the commonly used Bradley-Terry model. The authors show that picking up such correlations can have a drastic effect on the performance of an RL agent that is trained using the learned reward. In their empirical a...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This work analyzes the occurrence of spurious correlations in learning reward functions from preferences in the commonly used Bradley-Terry model. The authors show that picking up such correlations can have a drastic effect on the performance of an RL agent that is trained using the learned reward. In their emp...
The paper proposes an alternative learning objective for a continuous normalizing flow. Instead of standard maximum likelihood training, which requires backpropagating through the ODE solver, authors define a continuous sequence of intermediate densities between $p_0$ and $p_1$, and train the dynamics of the continuous...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Generative models
Review: The paper proposes an alternative learning objective for a continuous normalizing flow. Instead of standard maximum likelihood training, which requires backpropagating through the ODE solver, authors define a continuous sequence of intermediate densities between $p_0$ and $p_1$, and train the dynamics of the co...
This paper mainly tackles open-domain question answering. It uses Google search to obtain web information to prompt large-scale language model for answer generation. Strength: 1. This paper utilizes web-scale information through google search for downstream tasks like open-domain QA. 2. It proposes 4 methods to rerank ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper mainly tackles open-domain question answering. It uses Google search to obtain web information to prompt large-scale language model for answer generation. Strength: 1. This paper utilizes web-scale information through google search for downstream tasks like open-domain QA. 2. It proposes 4 methods to...
This work proposes a direct constraint optimization method to solve optimal transport maps using the original Monge's formulation. Three differential algorithms are studied: the Langrangian multiplier method, the augmented Lagrangian method, and the alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM). The proposed meth...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This work proposes a direct constraint optimization method to solve optimal transport maps using the original Monge's formulation. Three differential algorithms are studied: the Langrangian multiplier method, the augmented Lagrangian method, and the alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM). The propo...
This paper presents a method for continual Reinforcement Learning (learning on a sequence of related tasks) using a continuous subspace of policies. The proposed approach is quite inspired by the work of Gaya et al., 2021 in that solutions to new tasks, where possible, are parametrically represented as a convex combina...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper presents a method for continual Reinforcement Learning (learning on a sequence of related tasks) using a continuous subspace of policies. The proposed approach is quite inspired by the work of Gaya et al., 2021 in that solutions to new tasks, where possible, are parametrically represented as a convex...
This paper conducts a large-scale extensive empirical study to practically investigate whether insights in the computation theory can predict the out-of-distribution generalization limits for neural networks. It uses more than 10 thousand models and 15 tasks to evaluate the performance of program induction neural netw...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper conducts a large-scale extensive empirical study to practically investigate whether insights in the computation theory can predict the out-of-distribution generalization limits for neural networks. It uses more than 10 thousand models and 15 tasks to evaluate the performance of program induction neu...
This paper studies behavior of NTK on fine-tuning MLM models. Supposedly, pre-trained model is no longer iid random in parameters but still it can achieve good performance on CV tasks per previous literature. In this paper, authors extended the studies to NLP models with both regular fine-tuning and prompt-based learni...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper studies behavior of NTK on fine-tuning MLM models. Supposedly, pre-trained model is no longer iid random in parameters but still it can achieve good performance on CV tasks per previous literature. In this paper, authors extended the studies to NLP models with both regular fine-tuning and prompt-base...