review
stringlengths
5
16.6k
score
stringclasses
5 values
area
stringclasses
12 values
text
stringlengths
31
5.65k
This paper describes the typeAs of biases that can appear in automatic text summarization and presents an initial study of such biases using two corpuses: a synthetically generated one and the CNN/Daily mail corpus. The paper selects a few types of biases that can be analyzed automatically and proposes metrics (or pro...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper describes the typeAs of biases that can appear in automatic text summarization and presents an initial study of such biases using two corpuses: a synthetically generated one and the CNN/Daily mail corpus. The paper selects a few types of biases that can be analyzed automatically and proposes metrics...
The submission "When to Trust Aggregated Gradients: Addressing Negative Client Sampling in Federated Learning" describes a re-weighting strategy that can be applied during the optimization of ML models in federated learning. Given the full gradient norm over the entire dataset at some point in training, this strategy r...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The submission "When to Trust Aggregated Gradients: Addressing Negative Client Sampling in Federated Learning" describes a re-weighting strategy that can be applied during the optimization of ML models in federated learning. Given the full gradient norm over the entire dataset at some point in training, this st...
This paper proposed a RAIN to infer interactions among agents. It learns the attentive weight and unknown system dynamics, which is also helpful to predict future trajectories. The author(s) verified that RAIN can infer the system dynamic parameters and interaction graphs, and can outperform baseline discrete models. ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposed a RAIN to infer interactions among agents. It learns the attentive weight and unknown system dynamics, which is also helpful to predict future trajectories. The author(s) verified that RAIN can infer the system dynamic parameters and interaction graphs, and can outperform baseline discrete m...
The paper is concerned with accurately estimating the logging policy in off-policy learning when it is unknown or unavailable. Specifically, the paper derives an uncertainty-aware inverse propensity score algorithm called UIPS that is more accurate for rarely-taken actions, and provides theoretical and empirical argume...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper is concerned with accurately estimating the logging policy in off-policy learning when it is unknown or unavailable. Specifically, the paper derives an uncertainty-aware inverse propensity score algorithm called UIPS that is more accurate for rarely-taken actions, and provides theoretical and empirica...
The authors propose group reweighting algorithms for achieving group fairness. +: The performance of the algorithm seems to be better than the state of the arts. The paper writing is clear. -: The technical novelty seems limited. The difference between this work and the previous work [Agarwal et al., 2018] seems v...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: The authors propose group reweighting algorithms for achieving group fairness. +: The performance of the algorithm seems to be better than the state of the arts. The paper writing is clear. -: The technical novelty seems limited. The difference between this work and the previous work [Agarwal et al., 2018]...
This paper analyzes hindsight experience replay (HER) through divergence minimization with energy based models. With this analysis, it presents an approach that combines HER with behavioral cloning (BC) by only imitating actions in the dataset if they move the agent a certain amount towards the goal. The paper conclud...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper analyzes hindsight experience replay (HER) through divergence minimization with energy based models. With this analysis, it presents an approach that combines HER with behavioral cloning (BC) by only imitating actions in the dataset if they move the agent a certain amount towards the goal. The paper...
The paper proposes a novel model of data, and shows that under the proposed model, a model can only succeed if it performs feature learning. Specifically, the primary data model proposed in the paper involves a set of concepts, each with an equal number of vocabularies. There is an $R$ number of categories (or classes)...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: The paper proposes a novel model of data, and shows that under the proposed model, a model can only succeed if it performs feature learning. Specifically, the primary data model proposed in the paper involves a set of concepts, each with an equal number of vocabularies. There is an $R$ number of categories (or ...
1. The motivation is to tackle the accuracy-fairness tradeoffs of fair representation learning (FRL), indicating the need of providing provable upper bounds on unfairness of downstream classifiers. 2. They propose Fairness with Restricted Encoders (FARE), the first FRL method with provable fairness guarantees. They res...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: 1. The motivation is to tackle the accuracy-fairness tradeoffs of fair representation learning (FRL), indicating the need of providing provable upper bounds on unfairness of downstream classifiers. 2. They propose Fairness with Restricted Encoders (FARE), the first FRL method with provable fairness guarantees. ...
The authors introduces a new framework for OOD detection by defining more broadly the in-distribution (ID) samples using the notion of texture and semantic. Based on this definition, they create new benchmark scenarios. Finally, they propose a new method which perform well on both old and new benchmarks. Strength: - a ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: The authors introduces a new framework for OOD detection by defining more broadly the in-distribution (ID) samples using the notion of texture and semantic. Based on this definition, they create new benchmark scenarios. Finally, they propose a new method which perform well on both old and new benchmarks. Streng...
This paper presents a GNN design that directly aggregates the multi-hop neighbors by assigning the node features based on the different hop numbers. The explicit node coloring augments the message passing process and thus enables the model to differentiate some non-isomorphic subgraphs that a regular 1-WL will fail to ...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper presents a GNN design that directly aggregates the multi-hop neighbors by assigning the node features based on the different hop numbers. The explicit node coloring augments the message passing process and thus enables the model to differentiate some non-isomorphic subgraphs that a regular 1-WL will ...
Cascading ensembling of certifiably adversarially robust classifiers, which has been used by previous works, is shown to be unsound, which is demonstrated by theoretical proof as as well as experimental results on real test set data. Strengths: - The theoretical introduction and methodology are clearly presented and a...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: Cascading ensembling of certifiably adversarially robust classifiers, which has been used by previous works, is shown to be unsound, which is demonstrated by theoretical proof as as well as experimental results on real test set data. Strengths: - The theoretical introduction and methodology are clearly present...
This paper presents an image generation model called fast weight painters (FPA), applying the technique of fast weight programmer. The proposed method treats the generated image as the generated weight matrix. 1. This work seems to be one of the first attempts to apply fast weight programmer method to image generation...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper presents an image generation model called fast weight painters (FPA), applying the technique of fast weight programmer. The proposed method treats the generated image as the generated weight matrix. 1. This work seems to be one of the first attempts to apply fast weight programmer method to image ge...
Summary: Authors propose an active learning pipeline that incorporates domain knowledge into the pipeline for more efficient active learning & yielding models more consistent with known domain rules. Specifically, the model employs first-order-logic (FOL) based encoding to employ domain rules to inform examples to be s...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: Summary: Authors propose an active learning pipeline that incorporates domain knowledge into the pipeline for more efficient active learning & yielding models more consistent with known domain rules. Specifically, the model employs first-order-logic (FOL) based encoding to employ domain rules to inform examples...
This paper seeks to investigate the worst-case performance of neural network models in the low-data regime with respect to data sample index choice. Studying this problem is motivated by wanting to investigate neural network’s tendency to rely on spurious correlations for classification. The authors propose a method ca...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper seeks to investigate the worst-case performance of neural network models in the low-data regime with respect to data sample index choice. Studying this problem is motivated by wanting to investigate neural network’s tendency to rely on spurious correlations for classification. The authors propose a m...
This paper proposes an algorithm to optimally compress a model while preserving performance and improving inference speed. The algorithm achieves compression by modelling the weights as quantized latent representations sampled from a Gaussian prior which are further optimized using an entropy penalty. In order to ensur...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper proposes an algorithm to optimally compress a model while preserving performance and improving inference speed. The algorithm achieves compression by modelling the weights as quantized latent representations sampled from a Gaussian prior which are further optimized using an entropy penalty. In order ...
This paper investigates a multi-agent backdoor attack scenario, where multiple attackers attempt to backdoor a victim model simultaneously. Backdoor attacks, where an attacker poisons a model during training to successfully achieve targeted misclassification, are a major concern to train-time robustness. A consistent b...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper investigates a multi-agent backdoor attack scenario, where multiple attackers attempt to backdoor a victim model simultaneously. Backdoor attacks, where an attacker poisons a model during training to successfully achieve targeted misclassification, are a major concern to train-time robustness. A cons...
The paper proposes a learnable data augmentation procedure for speeding up reinforcement learning from pixels. In particular in applies a transformation to the input images, which is parameterized by a Gaussain distribution. The proposed method combines three main components: 1. Standard Q-learning approach with data ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper proposes a learnable data augmentation procedure for speeding up reinforcement learning from pixels. In particular in applies a transformation to the input images, which is parameterized by a Gaussain distribution. The proposed method combines three main components: 1. Standard Q-learning approach wi...
Long-range spatial information can be passed with a low computational cost through pooling and unpooling operations. On an irregular mesh, there is a challenge of how to select pivot nodes and assign non-pivot nodes to a pivot node for pooling so that all assignments are at most 2 hops away. Previous methods have used ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: Long-range spatial information can be passed with a low computational cost through pooling and unpooling operations. On an irregular mesh, there is a challenge of how to select pivot nodes and assign non-pivot nodes to a pivot node for pooling so that all assignments are at most 2 hops away. Previous methods ha...
This paper presents a unified framework for simultaneously detoxifying and debiasing language models. They consider protected groups as well as toxicity as an attribute of the generated text which can be controlled during the decoding time during an attribute classifier. Authors propose to use an embedding representati...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper presents a unified framework for simultaneously detoxifying and debiasing language models. They consider protected groups as well as toxicity as an attribute of the generated text which can be controlled during the decoding time during an attribute classifier. Authors propose to use an embedding repr...
This paper describes a method for characterizing the amount of added toxicity in a multilingual machine translation system’s output. The toxicity detection method is a list-based approach that is unchanged from an earlier publication (NLLB Team et al 2022, cited prominently and repeatedly). The main contributions here ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper describes a method for characterizing the amount of added toxicity in a multilingual machine translation system’s output. The toxicity detection method is a list-based approach that is unchanged from an earlier publication (NLLB Team et al 2022, cited prominently and repeatedly). The main contributio...
This paper follows-up on recent work around "chain-of-thought" (CoT) prompting, where the expected output of the model is not only the desired output, but also rationales that would reflect reasoning steps that a human would use to solve that same problem. The additional insight of this paper is that this process can ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper follows-up on recent work around "chain-of-thought" (CoT) prompting, where the expected output of the model is not only the desired output, but also rationales that would reflect reasoning steps that a human would use to solve that same problem. The additional insight of this paper is that this proc...
This paper proposes federated composite optimization, i.e., the nonconvex minimization of sum_i f_i + h in a federated setting. Here, f_i is smooth, h is not smooth but proximable. Note that the f_i are not assumed to be equal to each other (heterogeneous data). The Forward Backward Envelope (FBE) of f_i + h is a func...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Optimization (eg, convex and non-convex optimization)
Review: This paper proposes federated composite optimization, i.e., the nonconvex minimization of sum_i f_i + h in a federated setting. Here, f_i is smooth, h is not smooth but proximable. Note that the f_i are not assumed to be equal to each other (heterogeneous data). The Forward Backward Envelope (FBE) of f_i + h i...
This paper conducts a rigorous analysis on the fundamental properties of the policy induced value functions in multi-objective reinforcement learning (MORL). Based on the analysis, the authors further distinguish and consolidate three existing definitions of Pareto optimal policies and identify issues of training polic...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper conducts a rigorous analysis on the fundamental properties of the policy induced value functions in multi-objective reinforcement learning (MORL). Based on the analysis, the authors further distinguish and consolidate three existing definitions of Pareto optimal policies and identify issues of traini...
This paper considers the risk measure instead of the classically expected return in the offline RL setting. This paper shows that under some assumptions it is equivalent to minimize a risk measure in the latent space and in the natural space. A practical approach is proposed to use CVaR as the objective function. Stren...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper considers the risk measure instead of the classically expected return in the offline RL setting. This paper shows that under some assumptions it is equivalent to minimize a risk measure in the latent space and in the natural space. A practical approach is proposed to use CVaR as the objective functio...
The paper proposes a new loss function for time-series called TILDE-Q, which has 3 components. Each loss component is invariant to different distortions, including amplitude shifting, phase shifting, and uniform amplification. The paper starts with formal definitions of common time-series distortions and then designs 3...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes a new loss function for time-series called TILDE-Q, which has 3 components. Each loss component is invariant to different distortions, including amplitude shifting, phase shifting, and uniform amplification. The paper starts with formal definitions of common time-series distortions and then d...
This paper presents a method for learning solutions to PDE that are guaranteed to satisfy the constraints. This is done in eq. (5) by learning a basis for the solutions and finding the best linear combination of them. This results in the overall learning objective in eq. (8) that learns the basis that best-minimizes th...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: This paper presents a method for learning solutions to PDE that are guaranteed to satisfy the constraints. This is done in eq. (5) by learning a basis for the solutions and finding the best linear combination of them. This results in the overall learning objective in eq. (8) that learns the basis that best-mini...
- The paper addresses the problem of model extraction attacks (i.e., learning a surrogate model to mimic a black-box classifier under a budgeted query constraint) - The main contributions of the paper is two-fold: 1. formally posing model extraction as a bi-level optimization problem, thereby unifying some work ar...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: - The paper addresses the problem of model extraction attacks (i.e., learning a surrogate model to mimic a black-box classifier under a budgeted query constraint) - The main contributions of the paper is two-fold: 1. formally posing model extraction as a bi-level optimization problem, thereby unifying some...
This paper discusses the challenge of "relay generalization", where a policy trained with RL is evaluated when starting from initial states observed under an independently trained policy. Relay generalization is intended to measure the out-of-distribution generalization error, by testing how well the policy performs s...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper discusses the challenge of "relay generalization", where a policy trained with RL is evaluated when starting from initial states observed under an independently trained policy. Relay generalization is intended to measure the out-of-distribution generalization error, by testing how well the policy pe...
The paper proposes to divide computational graph of the neural network into the fixed path and float path and then shows the improvement of robust accuracy is mainly gained from correcting the vulnerability floating neurons. Specifically, the neural network graph is first divided into several activation regions and thu...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes to divide computational graph of the neural network into the fixed path and float path and then shows the improvement of robust accuracy is mainly gained from correcting the vulnerability floating neurons. Specifically, the neural network graph is first divided into several activation regions...
The paper proposes an interesting supervised learning setting for causal discovery. Firstly, it creates synthetic training data ( observational and international data ) with various simulators and settings. And then it designs a neural network that outputs the causal graphs. Based on such a supervised learning manner, ...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes an interesting supervised learning setting for causal discovery. Firstly, it creates synthetic training data ( observational and international data ) with various simulators and settings. And then it designs a neural network that outputs the causal graphs. Based on such a supervised learning ...
In this paper, the authors proposed a method for subset selection, which is useful for applications such as active learning. Specifically, in the proposed method, when constructing the subset, data is selected by importance sampling, where the sampling probability relates to the model's entropy. In the subset, the sele...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: In this paper, the authors proposed a method for subset selection, which is useful for applications such as active learning. Specifically, in the proposed method, when constructing the subset, data is selected by importance sampling, where the sampling probability relates to the model's entropy. In the subset, ...
This work studies a relatively new problem in self-supervised learning, which is called sustainable self-supervised learning. Based on a pretrained SSL model (or partially trained with certain epochs), the authors want to further improve it with the proposed target-enhanced conditional mask-reconstruction. The authors ...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This work studies a relatively new problem in self-supervised learning, which is called sustainable self-supervised learning. Based on a pretrained SSL model (or partially trained with certain epochs), the authors want to further improve it with the proposed target-enhanced conditional mask-reconstruction. The ...
The core questions in the paper are 1) What is the geometry of representations learned by contrastive learning with data augmentation? 2) What are the determinants of good generalization in downstream tasks? Strengths: A set of intuitive descriptors "manifold graph metrics" is proposed and evidence is presented tha...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: The core questions in the paper are 1) What is the geometry of representations learned by contrastive learning with data augmentation? 2) What are the determinants of good generalization in downstream tasks? Strengths: A set of intuitive descriptors "manifold graph metrics" is proposed and evidence is prese...
In this paper, the authors describe a hierarchical strategy for storing large batches of GNN training data in multiple levels of memory in a single system. By partitioning the storage of GNN training data between the extremely large out-of-core disk, smaller but faster CPU DRAM main memory, and much more limited but fa...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: In this paper, the authors describe a hierarchical strategy for storing large batches of GNN training data in multiple levels of memory in a single system. By partitioning the storage of GNN training data between the extremely large out-of-core disk, smaller but faster CPU DRAM main memory, and much more limite...
Summary: This paper provides some explanations for regularization in self-supervised learning algorithms and, to some extent, other phenomena beyond self-supervised learning. Its analysis is reasonable and comprehensive. However, this analysis does not yield very useful insights into the improvement of self-supervised...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: Summary: This paper provides some explanations for regularization in self-supervised learning algorithms and, to some extent, other phenomena beyond self-supervised learning. Its analysis is reasonable and comprehensive. However, this analysis does not yield very useful insights into the improvement of self-su...
This paper points out an issue in a recent theoretical result that motivates the adversarial training algorithm. The authors construct counter examples and provide explanations about the issue they identify, and then further propose a Danskin's Descent Direction for training robust neural networks. Strengths: The cla...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Optimization (eg, convex and non-convex optimization)
Review: This paper points out an issue in a recent theoretical result that motivates the adversarial training algorithm. The authors construct counter examples and provide explanations about the issue they identify, and then further propose a Danskin's Descent Direction for training robust neural networks. Strengths: ...
This paper explores the active learning problem under OOD data scenarios and incorporates AL and OOD objectives within a multi-objective optimization framework to balance their conflict. Specifically, they propose a Monte-Carlo Pareto optimization mechanism to enable efficient Pareto optimization, which selects optimal...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This paper explores the active learning problem under OOD data scenarios and incorporates AL and OOD objectives within a multi-objective optimization framework to balance their conflict. Specifically, they propose a Monte-Carlo Pareto optimization mechanism to enable efficient Pareto optimization, which selects...
This paper proposes an unsupervised keypoint discovery method, especially for videos. To this end, authors propose to build an entropy layer to measure the information, and a deep learning model to predict keypoint. The model is learned in an unsupervised manner, by maximizing the information in a single frame and acro...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: This paper proposes an unsupervised keypoint discovery method, especially for videos. To this end, authors propose to build an entropy layer to measure the information, and a deep learning model to predict keypoint. The model is learned in an unsupervised manner, by maximizing the information in a single frame ...
This paper proposes a method for 3D shape part segmentation. It learns an image-conditioned NeRF together with a semantic field. The method enables novel view (2D image) part segmentation and 3D point cloud part segmentation. The authors evaluate the proposed method on the PartNet dataset and show some real-world demos...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper proposes a method for 3D shape part segmentation. It learns an image-conditioned NeRF together with a semantic field. The method enables novel view (2D image) part segmentation and 3D point cloud part segmentation. The authors evaluate the proposed method on the PartNet dataset and show some real-wor...
Summary: - The paper proposed out-of-distribution (OOD) evaluation sets for the COIN and Breakfast dataset, together referred to as the new GAIN benchmark. To formulate the novel OOD evaluation sets, the authors ensured that the training set and the OOD evaluation set share the same set of steps, but different sets of ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: Summary: - The paper proposed out-of-distribution (OOD) evaluation sets for the COIN and Breakfast dataset, together referred to as the new GAIN benchmark. To formulate the novel OOD evaluation sets, the authors ensured that the training set and the OOD evaluation set share the same set of steps, but different ...
This paper presents a functional perspective for out-of-distribution (OOD) detection. The layer-wise features from a deep neural network are considered a trajectory. The class-wise centroids of the trajectories are computed from the training samples. Given a test trajectory, the similarity with respect to the centroid...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper presents a functional perspective for out-of-distribution (OOD) detection. The layer-wise features from a deep neural network are considered a trajectory. The class-wise centroids of the trajectories are computed from the training samples. Given a test trajectory, the similarity with respect to the ...
As most NAS algorithms search for well-performing architectures from scratch given the target dataset, this paper follows the existing line of transferring information across different datasets to accelerate the search process. Specifically, this paper follows (Lee et al., 2021) to learn the representation of datasets ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: As most NAS algorithms search for well-performing architectures from scratch given the target dataset, this paper follows the existing line of transferring information across different datasets to accelerate the search process. Specifically, this paper follows (Lee et al., 2021) to learn the representation of d...
The paper proposes to use auto-diff to compute the gradients of the Non-Equilibrium Green Function (NEGF) to solve the quantum transport problem. Numerical differentiation methods are more expensive and can result in numerical errors that could lead to wrong estimations of the physical properties of the system. Moreove...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: The paper proposes to use auto-diff to compute the gradients of the Non-Equilibrium Green Function (NEGF) to solve the quantum transport problem. Numerical differentiation methods are more expensive and can result in numerical errors that could lead to wrong estimations of the physical properties of the system....
This paper asks the question of why neural systems often develop a factorized or disentangled representation, i.e. a representation which aligns its variables/latent units with a meaningful factorization of the underlying problem structure. The authors use a combination of theory and simulations to show that biological...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Neuroscience and Cognitive Science (e.g., neural coding, brain-computer interfaces)
Review: This paper asks the question of why neural systems often develop a factorized or disentangled representation, i.e. a representation which aligns its variables/latent units with a meaningful factorization of the underlying problem structure. The authors use a combination of theory and simulations to show that bi...
This paper proposed a new learning scheme in Federated Learning that communicates knowledge between clients in the form of meta knowledge generated by dataset condensation. In this case, the global model aggregation in the cloud is replaced with a "meta training" process in the cloud using the combined meta knowledge f...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This paper proposed a new learning scheme in Federated Learning that communicates knowledge between clients in the form of meta knowledge generated by dataset condensation. In this case, the global model aggregation in the cloud is replaced with a "meta training" process in the cloud using the combined meta kno...
The authors propose a new inverse reinforcement learning algorithm that's able to provably meet the performance of an expert demonstrator in the presence of uncontrolled confounders, when certain conditions are met (i.e., does the agent have the causal structure of the data generating process right?). Strengths: The su...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Probabilistic Methods (eg, variational inference, causal inference, Gaussian processes)
Review: The authors propose a new inverse reinforcement learning algorithm that's able to provably meet the performance of an expert demonstrator in the presence of uncontrolled confounders, when certain conditions are met (i.e., does the agent have the causal structure of the data generating process right?). Strengths...
The paper proposes a test time adaptation (TTA) method named TAST where a trainable projector is added at test time on top of the feature extractor and optimised via information from the top nearest neighbors. ### Strengths S1: The method uses "pseudo-label distributions for test data using the nearest neighbor inform...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes a test time adaptation (TTA) method named TAST where a trainable projector is added at test time on top of the feature extractor and optimised via information from the top nearest neighbors. ### Strengths S1: The method uses "pseudo-label distributions for test data using the nearest neighbo...
The submission considers score-based generative models with SDEs, but for discrete variables. The main challenge here is that the existing score-based methods do not apply to discrete variables since the log likelihood is not well defined. To deal with this issue, the authors use continuous-time discrete-state Markov p...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Generative models
Review: The submission considers score-based generative models with SDEs, but for discrete variables. The main challenge here is that the existing score-based methods do not apply to discrete variables since the log likelihood is not well defined. To deal with this issue, the authors use continuous-time discrete-state ...
This paper focuses on mid-point mixup (a variant of mixup) and provides theoretical analysis on the effect of using mid-point mixup on multi-view data. The theoretical result is specific to the setting of the 2-layer convolutional networks and the datasets where samples at each class have 2 features. Under this setting...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper focuses on mid-point mixup (a variant of mixup) and provides theoretical analysis on the effect of using mid-point mixup on multi-view data. The theoretical result is specific to the setting of the 2-layer convolutional networks and the datasets where samples at each class have 2 features. Under this...
This work proposes a multi-objective optimization approach capable of dealing with objectives that converge at different rates. The authors then claim that three problems within the realm of generating adversarial examples can be cast as multi-objective optimization and apply the proposed Task Aware Multi-objective opt...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This work proposes a multi-objective optimization approach capable of dealing with objectives that converge at different rates. The authors then claim that three problems within the realm of generating adversarial examples can be cast as multi-objective optimization and apply the proposed Task Aware Multi-objec...
This paper provides an efficient approach on how to integrate scalar quantization, product quantization and random pruning into existing secure aggregation algorithms. The paper makes extensive experiments to show that the proposed method can reach a good balance between communication efficiency and accuracy. Strength...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper provides an efficient approach on how to integrate scalar quantization, product quantization and random pruning into existing secure aggregation algorithms. The paper makes extensive experiments to show that the proposed method can reach a good balance between communication efficiency and accuracy. ...
The paper augments standard neural networks with recurrent, parametrizable "activation functions". They show that randomly initialized networks with frozen weights can be trained with some degree of success by simply optimizing the parameters of these "activation functions". The results are competitive with normal, wei...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper augments standard neural networks with recurrent, parametrizable "activation functions". They show that randomly initialized networks with frozen weights can be trained with some degree of success by simply optimizing the parameters of these "activation functions". The results are competitive with nor...
This paper considers a federated learning problem with multiple heterogeneous clients, where each client’s data distribution is a distinct mixture of predefined domain distributions. It is assumed that the domains of the data samples are known. The goal is to federatively learn a model that can perform well in every do...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper considers a federated learning problem with multiple heterogeneous clients, where each client’s data distribution is a distinct mixture of predefined domain distributions. It is assumed that the domains of the data samples are known. The goal is to federatively learn a model that can perform well in ...
In this paper, the authors proposed an energy-based sampling adaptations method for domain generalization. In their method, they adapt the unseen target sample to source-domains at test time. A category latent variable is used to sample update. They show the effectiveness in several classification tasks. Strength: 1. ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Probabilistic Methods (eg, variational inference, causal inference, Gaussian processes)
Review: In this paper, the authors proposed an energy-based sampling adaptations method for domain generalization. In their method, they adapt the unseen target sample to source-domains at test time. A category latent variable is used to sample update. They show the effectiveness in several classification tasks. Streng...
This paper studied the deployment efficient reinforcement learning in linear MDP. The authors proposed new algorithms with improved sample complexity bound than previous papers as well as the near-optimal deployment complexity. # Strength The sample complexity to state of the art, to my knowledge. The algorithm also s...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper studied the deployment efficient reinforcement learning in linear MDP. The authors proposed new algorithms with improved sample complexity bound than previous papers as well as the near-optimal deployment complexity. # Strength The sample complexity to state of the art, to my knowledge. The algorith...
This paper conducted an empirical study on the effectiveness of the pre-training of a backbone for the task of 3D human pose and shape estimation (3DHPSE). In the experiments, the authors compared different pretraining strategies, including purely unlabeled self-supervised pre-training, 2D annotation-based pre-training...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper conducted an empirical study on the effectiveness of the pre-training of a backbone for the task of 3D human pose and shape estimation (3DHPSE). In the experiments, the authors compared different pretraining strategies, including purely unlabeled self-supervised pre-training, 2D annotation-based pre-...
Multiobjective (MO) RL has many applications with the thresholding algorithm often used. The authors point out a deficiency of such algorithms and propose a PG based approach. They also conduct a numerical study comparing their algorithm with benchmark algorithms. Strengths: The idea of using PG for MO-RL. The examp...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: Multiobjective (MO) RL has many applications with the thresholding algorithm often used. The authors point out a deficiency of such algorithms and propose a PG based approach. They also conduct a numerical study comparing their algorithm with benchmark algorithms. Strengths: The idea of using PG for MO-RL. T...
This paper extends the problem of bandit in matching markets from a 1-to-1 matching to many to one matching. Many to one matching are an important family with rich applications in domains like crowd-sourcing and pool ride-share. They extend the setting of optimal regret in the case of unique stable matching for the 1-t...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper extends the problem of bandit in matching markets from a 1-to-1 matching to many to one matching. Many to one matching are an important family with rich applications in domains like crowd-sourcing and pool ride-share. They extend the setting of optimal regret in the case of unique stable matching for...
This paper studies the effects of GPT3 on generalization, bias, uncertainty, and knowledge discovery. Strengths - The four facets considered are important and timely given the popularity and impact of GPT3. - The paper is coherent and thorough. Weaknesses - It is hard to follow the conclusions. It would be a useful e...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: This paper studies the effects of GPT3 on generalization, bias, uncertainty, and knowledge discovery. Strengths - The four facets considered are important and timely given the popularity and impact of GPT3. - The paper is coherent and thorough. Weaknesses - It is hard to follow the conclusions. It would be a ...
The authors propose "relay-evaluation", a method for evaluating the generalization performance of RL agents. Specifically, it forces the agent under test to start from the state s\_0, which is sampled from the trajectory generated by stranger agents. A sharp degradation of performance is observed under relay-evaluation...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The authors propose "relay-evaluation", a method for evaluating the generalization performance of RL agents. Specifically, it forces the agent under test to start from the state s\_0, which is sampled from the trajectory generated by stranger agents. A sharp degradation of performance is observed under relay-ev...
In this work the authors attack in models in the following adversarial threat model: * Problem considered: CIFAR-10 image classification task * Attacker threat model: can modify each training image by up to $\epsilon=8/255$ in $\ell_\inf$ norm * Attacker goal: minimize clean test accuracy on models trained on this dat...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: In this work the authors attack in models in the following adversarial threat model: * Problem considered: CIFAR-10 image classification task * Attacker threat model: can modify each training image by up to $\epsilon=8/255$ in $\ell_\inf$ norm * Attacker goal: minimize clean test accuracy on models trained on ...
Through of a set of "machine psychophysics" experiments, the authors probe on the image inversion effects comparing faces and other objects with a family of neural networks that are "classical", and other that incorporate both foveation + log-polar mapping to simulate visual processes up to V1. Authors find that their ...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Neuroscience and Cognitive Science (e.g., neural coding, brain-computer interfaces)
Review: Through of a set of "machine psychophysics" experiments, the authors probe on the image inversion effects comparing faces and other objects with a family of neural networks that are "classical", and other that incorporate both foveation + log-polar mapping to simulate visual processes up to V1. Authors find tha...
The paper proposes a weight shared training framework for FL that trains a family of model variants (DNN models), cost-efficiently in a federated fashion. The paper also proposes a heuristic that trains the upper and lower bounds in the model family by optimizing both bounds and load balancing their distribution over t...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes a weight shared training framework for FL that trains a family of model variants (DNN models), cost-efficiently in a federated fashion. The paper also proposes a heuristic that trains the upper and lower bounds in the model family by optimizing both bounds and load balancing their distributio...
This paper focuses on the zero-shot task generalization setting and proposes to learn to generate the instruction conditioned on the input and label. During inference, labels can be predicted by checking which label is the most likely to generate the given instruction. The authors also incorporate unlikelihood training...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper focuses on the zero-shot task generalization setting and proposes to learn to generate the instruction conditioned on the input and label. During inference, labels can be predicted by checking which label is the most likely to generate the given instruction. The authors also incorporate unlikelihood ...
In this paper, the authors propose the first coreset construction algorithm for RBFNNs, i.e., a small weighted subset which approximates the loss of the input data on any radial basis function network. This is achieved by constructing coresets for radial basis and Laplacian loss functions. The coreset is then used to d...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: In this paper, the authors propose the first coreset construction algorithm for RBFNNs, i.e., a small weighted subset which approximates the loss of the input data on any radial basis function network. This is achieved by constructing coresets for radial basis and Laplacian loss functions. The coreset is then u...
The work extends the CAV approach for concept-based explainability to deal with concepts that cannot be expressed as linear combinations of input (or latent) features. PROs - The work addresses a clear limitation of the CAV approach, that severely affects its practical applicability. - The derivation is sound _ Th...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: The work extends the CAV approach for concept-based explainability to deal with concepts that cannot be expressed as linear combinations of input (or latent) features. PROs - The work addresses a clear limitation of the CAV approach, that severely affects its practical applicability. - The derivation is sou...
The paper proposes a framework for human-agent collaboration in MOBA games. The framework consists in two main parts: i) a protocol of commands that human and agents use to communicate with each other, and that can be expressed as a tuple of "what" the sender asks the receiver to do, for "how long" has to be done, and ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper proposes a framework for human-agent collaboration in MOBA games. The framework consists in two main parts: i) a protocol of commands that human and agents use to communicate with each other, and that can be expressed as a tuple of "what" the sender asks the receiver to do, for "how long" has to be do...
This paper presents a technique to preserve physical conservation laws in neural network based dynamical systems. The authors propose to solve two tasks concurrently: (i) learning variables that remain constant for a given trajectory, and (ii) a dynamics function that respects the constant variables and that fits input...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Machine Learning for Sciences (eg biology, physics, health sciences, social sciences, climate/sustainability )
Review: This paper presents a technique to preserve physical conservation laws in neural network based dynamical systems. The authors propose to solve two tasks concurrently: (i) learning variables that remain constant for a given trajectory, and (ii) a dynamics function that respects the constant variables and that fi...
This paper proposes a higher order Brownian Motion Controller (BMC) for BrGANs to stabilize GANs' training process. Starting with the prototypical case of Dirac-GANs, the authors design a BMC and propose Dirac-BrGANs that retrieve exactly the same but reachable optimal equilibrium regardless of GANs' framework. The aut...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Generative models
Review: This paper proposes a higher order Brownian Motion Controller (BMC) for BrGANs to stabilize GANs' training process. Starting with the prototypical case of Dirac-GANs, the authors design a BMC and propose Dirac-BrGANs that retrieve exactly the same but reachable optimal equilibrium regardless of GANs' framework....
Hi, I'm currently on a medical leave and won't be able to perform ICRL review duties. sorry for the late notice. Hi, I'm currently on a medical leave and won't be able to perform ICRL review duties. sorry for the late notice. Hi, I'm currently on a medical leave and won't be able to perform ICRL review duties. sorry fo...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: Hi, I'm currently on a medical leave and won't be able to perform ICRL review duties. sorry for the late notice. Hi, I'm currently on a medical leave and won't be able to perform ICRL review duties. sorry for the late notice. Hi, I'm currently on a medical leave and won't be able to perform ICRL review duties. ...
The paper establishes minimax object function for perceptron algorithm, and treat it as a minimax optimization problem. For this problem, faster convergence rate (than perceptron) can be obtained. Strength. The minimax formulation is an interesting view of what perceptron tries to optimize, although it is fairly strai...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: The paper establishes minimax object function for perceptron algorithm, and treat it as a minimax optimization problem. For this problem, faster convergence rate (than perceptron) can be obtained. Strength. The minimax formulation is an interesting view of what perceptron tries to optimize, although it is fair...
The paper considers the problem of repeated first-priced auctions with budget constraints, a new model that did not capture attention before. Two scenarios of full feedback and censored feedback are analyzed. For full feedback, the proposed algorithm has a regret of $\tilde{O}(\sqrt{T})$. For censored feedback, the pr...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: The paper considers the problem of repeated first-priced auctions with budget constraints, a new model that did not capture attention before. Two scenarios of full feedback and censored feedback are analyzed. For full feedback, the proposed algorithm has a regret of $\tilde{O}(\sqrt{T})$. For censored feedback,...
The paper presents a new way to pre-train VLMs (vision-language-models) using both text generation and image generation as the VLPs (pre-training objectives). They then ablate the objectives on their model (and show that each objective’s inductive bias is actually helping) and the datasets used for training (smaller m...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper presents a new way to pre-train VLMs (vision-language-models) using both text generation and image generation as the VLPs (pre-training objectives). They then ablate the objectives on their model (and show that each objective’s inductive bias is actually helping) and the datasets used for training (s...
This paper provides a finite-time analysis of Actor-Critic (A-C) methods for reinforcement learning. First, the paper provides an upper bound to the error of the critic update due to function approximation and sample estimates. Then, it provides an upper bound to the error of the actor update due to approximating the g...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper provides a finite-time analysis of Actor-Critic (A-C) methods for reinforcement learning. First, the paper provides an upper bound to the error of the critic update due to function approximation and sample estimates. Then, it provides an upper bound to the error of the actor update due to approximati...
It is known that methods that store examples in memory have positive results for the Continual Learning problem, specifically in Class Incremental Learning. Instead of saving examples from previous tasks, some works recommended storing model checkpoints to retain the information. The authors of this paper point out tha...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: It is known that methods that store examples in memory have positive results for the Continual Learning problem, specifically in Class Incremental Learning. Instead of saving examples from previous tasks, some works recommended storing model checkpoints to retain the information. The authors of this paper point...
This paper presents a novel method (AQuaMaM) for 3D quaternion orientation estimation from potentially ambiguous 2D images. It employs a Transformer architecture to learn sequences of quaternion parameters representing distributions over the SO(3) group of 3D rotations, treating them as language tokens. The proposed ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper presents a novel method (AQuaMaM) for 3D quaternion orientation estimation from potentially ambiguous 2D images. It employs a Transformer architecture to learn sequences of quaternion parameters representing distributions over the SO(3) group of 3D rotations, treating them as language tokens. The p...
This paper conducts a deep, detailed study using the FID score for evaluating the quality of generative models. This paper reveals that imagenet pretrained model feature-based metric can be biased, leading to low generation quality with high FID score if the generator aligns the histograms of Top-N classifications be- ...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Generative models
Review: This paper conducts a deep, detailed study using the FID score for evaluating the quality of generative models. This paper reveals that imagenet pretrained model feature-based metric can be biased, leading to low generation quality with high FID score if the generator aligns the histograms of Top-N classificati...
The Higher-Order Gradient approach is of great value to the field of MAS, as it can be used in many important areas such as the theory of mind. The authors review the existing work and further propose Hierarchical Reasoning to facilitate the collaboration of team agents, noting that their approach is highly extensible ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The Higher-Order Gradient approach is of great value to the field of MAS, as it can be used in many important areas such as the theory of mind. The authors review the existing work and further propose Hierarchical Reasoning to facilitate the collaboration of team agents, noting that their approach is highly ext...
This paper explores how plateau occur in the loss curves of neural networks. Specifically, it shows that a significantly different last-layer bias may result in a long plateau in the loss and error curves. It also analyzes how gradient dynamics generates such bias gap during training with a simplified classification mo...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Theory (eg, control theory, learning theory, algorithmic game theory)
Review: This paper explores how plateau occur in the loss curves of neural networks. Specifically, it shows that a significantly different last-layer bias may result in a long plateau in the loss and error curves. It also analyzes how gradient dynamics generates such bias gap during training with a simplified classific...
The paper proposes a method to augment label-discriminative data in PLM few-shot learning setting. The main idea is to improve the PLM-generator by introducing a label-discriminative loss in a meta-learning framework. The improved PLM-generator is then used to generate augmentation data to finetune a classification PLM...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: The paper proposes a method to augment label-discriminative data in PLM few-shot learning setting. The main idea is to improve the PLM-generator by introducing a label-discriminative loss in a meta-learning framework. The improved PLM-generator is then used to generate augmentation data to finetune a classifica...
The paper focuses on multi-modal multi-task learning. They customize Mixture-of-Experts into the transformer layer to do efficient MTL. They achieve good performance on the HighMMT dataset. My major concern with the paper is the technical novelty. I will illustrate the issue from three aspects: 1. Using MoE to do mult...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: The paper focuses on multi-modal multi-task learning. They customize Mixture-of-Experts into the transformer layer to do efficient MTL. They achieve good performance on the HighMMT dataset. My major concern with the paper is the technical novelty. I will illustrate the issue from three aspects: 1. Using MoE to...
The paper describes to learn a model for category-level object pose estimation. The proposed approach relies on a dataset of RGB-D images of a certain category of objects, e.g. mugs or bottles, with a template mesh of an object belonging to the category. The method does not require any pose annotation to train, however...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: The paper describes to learn a model for category-level object pose estimation. The proposed approach relies on a dataset of RGB-D images of a certain category of objects, e.g. mugs or bottles, with a template mesh of an object belonging to the category. The method does not require any pose annotation to train,...
The paper formulates the problem of spatial arrangement of objects as minimizing the energy function over the configurations of the object graph. The graph is constructed by parsing the language instruction and utilizing visual language grounding. The graph energy function is composed of predicates parameterized as neu...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper formulates the problem of spatial arrangement of objects as minimizing the energy function over the configurations of the object graph. The graph is constructed by parsing the language instruction and utilizing visual language grounding. The graph energy function is composed of predicates parameterize...
The paper presents an approach based on using reinforcement learning for learning dynamics models in simulated robotics benchmark. A method based on SAC for learning multi-step models is implemented and compared to traditional supervised learning in terms of long-term accuracy in the predictions. Strength: - The proble...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: The paper presents an approach based on using reinforcement learning for learning dynamics models in simulated robotics benchmark. A method based on SAC for learning multi-step models is implemented and compared to traditional supervised learning in terms of long-term accuracy in the predictions. Strength: - Th...
This paper presents algorithms for offline RL combined with linear function approximation. They consider both MDP and Markov games scenarios. They combine two techniques: reference-advantage decomposition and variance-reweighted ridge regression which have been previously used in offline RL literature. The authors the...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper presents algorithms for offline RL combined with linear function approximation. They consider both MDP and Markov games scenarios. They combine two techniques: reference-advantage decomposition and variance-reweighted ridge regression which have been previously used in offline RL literature. The aut...
The paper tackles three major issues with CLIP-like models: openness, extensibility and stability. The paper argues that CLIP-like models are difficult to evaluate since they are unconstrained in terms of the vocabulary use. Therefore the paper proposes to use an incremental evaluation perspective, called extensibility...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper tackles three major issues with CLIP-like models: openness, extensibility and stability. The paper argues that CLIP-like models are difficult to evaluate since they are unconstrained in terms of the vocabulary use. Therefore the paper proposes to use an incremental evaluation perspective, called exten...
Note I have reviewed an earlier version of this paper for last year's conference. I have copied some of the notes from my earlier review but I have read the new version carefully and made sure that I only copied parts that hasn't changed in the new version. Overall, the earlier paper and the current version overlap qui...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Unsupervised and Self-supervised learning
Review: Note I have reviewed an earlier version of this paper for last year's conference. I have copied some of the notes from my earlier review but I have read the new version carefully and made sure that I only copied parts that hasn't changed in the new version. Overall, the earlier paper and the current version ove...
This paper focuses on multi-task pretraining via supervised data in NLG area. They collected 77 NLG datasets and applied different variants of multi-task pretraining on top. The pretrained models are evaluated on both seen and unseen tasks, comparing to the prior STOAs and BART finetune baselines. Strengths: - A coll...
Recommendation: 5: marginally below the acceptance threshold
Area: Applications (eg, speech processing, computer vision, NLP)
Review: This paper focuses on multi-task pretraining via supervised data in NLG area. They collected 77 NLG datasets and applied different variants of multi-task pretraining on top. The pretrained models are evaluated on both seen and unseen tasks, comparing to the prior STOAs and BART finetune baselines. Strengths: ...
After reviewing the limitations of the current RCSL methods in capturing reward stochasticity, this paper has proposed a new Learning algorithm DoC that solves the control problem in a stochastic environment by separating what is controllable from what is not. The former is formulated as the actions at hand at each tim...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: After reviewing the limitations of the current RCSL methods in capturing reward stochasticity, this paper has proposed a new Learning algorithm DoC that solves the control problem in a stochastic environment by separating what is controllable from what is not. The former is formulated as the actions at hand at ...
This paper is about learning linear maps for dimensionality reduction that are based on count sketch. Existing works either use randomized sketches or learn the values in a count sketch matrix (with the positions drawn randomly). This paper develops on such methods by proposing to learn both the positions and the value...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Optimization (eg, convex and non-convex optimization)
Review: This paper is about learning linear maps for dimensionality reduction that are based on count sketch. Existing works either use randomized sketches or learn the values in a count sketch matrix (with the positions drawn randomly). This paper develops on such methods by proposing to learn both the positions and t...
The paper proposes a method for learning fully-grown binary decision trees with axis-aligned splits by gradient descent. For that, it first describes a formulation for determining a point route through the tree (based on an integer formulation of logical-ands and logical-ors) given the set of decision splits, and its o...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: The paper proposes a method for learning fully-grown binary decision trees with axis-aligned splits by gradient descent. For that, it first describes a formulation for determining a point route through the tree (based on an integer formulation of logical-ands and logical-ors) given the set of decision splits, a...
In this paper, the authors proposed OTOv2, which is a follow-up work of OTOv1. OTOv2 makes structured pruning more automatic, generic and user-friendly by addressing several problems in OTOv1. Specifically, they proposed an algorithm to automatically find Zero-Invariant Group for arbitrary DNNs and an optimizater to ad...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: In this paper, the authors proposed OTOv2, which is a follow-up work of OTOv1. OTOv2 makes structured pruning more automatic, generic and user-friendly by addressing several problems in OTOv1. Specifically, they proposed an algorithm to automatically find Zero-Invariant Group for arbitrary DNNs and an optimizat...
The paper studies upper bounds on the performance of membership inference (MI) attacks on models trained with the subsampled Gaussian mechanism to ensure differential privacy. In this paper, the authors derive bounds on the advantage of an adversary mounting the MI attack.They also perform some experiments to illustrat...
Recommendation: 3: reject, not good enough
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: The paper studies upper bounds on the performance of membership inference (MI) attacks on models trained with the subsampled Gaussian mechanism to ensure differential privacy. In this paper, the authors derive bounds on the advantage of an adversary mounting the MI attack.They also perform some experiments to i...
This work enables kernel regression with the so-called neural tangent kernel to work with significantly larger datasets compared to before (order of million datapoints) by building on top of the framework of [1] for Gaussian processes. The key difference to [1] stems from the difference of computational costs to obtain...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: General Machine Learning
Review: This work enables kernel regression with the so-called neural tangent kernel to work with significantly larger datasets compared to before (order of million datapoints) by building on top of the framework of [1] for Gaussian processes. The key difference to [1] stems from the difference of computational costs t...
In this paper, the authors propose an algorithm for mitigating unintended bias without requiring access to the sensitive attribute. The intuition is similar to some recent works, which assume that the errors of a model provide a noisy proxy for the sensitive attribute (e.g. minorities would have a disproportionately la...
Recommendation: 8: accept, good paper
Area: Social Aspects of Machine Learning (eg, AI safety, fairness, privacy, interpretability, human-AI interaction, ethics)
Review: In this paper, the authors propose an algorithm for mitigating unintended bias without requiring access to the sensitive attribute. The intuition is similar to some recent works, which assume that the errors of a model provide a noisy proxy for the sensitive attribute (e.g. minorities would have a disproportion...
This paper studies goal-conditioned RL, in particular the graph-based approach, where we build a graph of subgoals to improve overall performance. Compared to previous methods, this paper introduces two improvements: 1) an additional loss term to make subgoal policies compatible with end goal policies, and 2) at execut...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Reinforcement Learning (eg, decision and control, planning, hierarchical RL, robotics)
Review: This paper studies goal-conditioned RL, in particular the graph-based approach, where we build a graph of subgoals to improve overall performance. Compared to previous methods, this paper introduces two improvements: 1) an additional loss term to make subgoal policies compatible with end goal policies, and 2) a...
This paper addresses image manipulation through text. The proposed method is based on an existing method (Mao et al., 2019) proposed for Visual Question Answering (VQA) with a neuro-symbolic approach. The proposed method leverages VQA annotations and shows better accuracy than comparative methods with weakly supervised...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: This paper addresses image manipulation through text. The proposed method is based on an existing method (Mao et al., 2019) proposed for Visual Question Answering (VQA) with a neuro-symbolic approach. The proposed method leverages VQA annotations and shows better accuracy than comparative methods with weakly su...
The manuscript introduces a new statistic metric to analyze the local trajectory of SGD methods like SGDm and various adaptive methods. The paper argues the positive correlation between the uniformity of diagonal Hessian and fast convergence, and that adaptive methods such as Adam bias the trajectories towards regions ...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Optimization (eg, convex and non-convex optimization)
Review: The manuscript introduces a new statistic metric to analyze the local trajectory of SGD methods like SGDm and various adaptive methods. The paper argues the positive correlation between the uniformity of diagonal Hessian and fast convergence, and that adaptive methods such as Adam bias the trajectories towards ...
The paper proposes a new approach to apply transformers to Long Sequence Data, called SKTFormer. The approach combines a CUR matrix approximation technique, a Fourier-convolution based smoother, and a convolution stem to avoid over-smoothing. The authors apply their method to a number of problems, showing promising per...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Deep Learning and representational learning
Review: The paper proposes a new approach to apply transformers to Long Sequence Data, called SKTFormer. The approach combines a CUR matrix approximation technique, a Fourier-convolution based smoother, and a convolution stem to avoid over-smoothing. The authors apply their method to a number of problems, showing promi...
The paper proposes a Transformer-based module for visual reasoning, the Guided Attention Module (GAMR). The model is instantiated with three components: an encoder module, a controller module, and a relational module. The encoder module uses CNN and TCN to extract image features. A guided attention module uses multi-he...
Recommendation: 6: marginally above the acceptance threshold
Area: Neuroscience and Cognitive Science (e.g., neural coding, brain-computer interfaces)
Review: The paper proposes a Transformer-based module for visual reasoning, the Guided Attention Module (GAMR). The model is instantiated with three components: an encoder module, a controller module, and a relational module. The encoder module uses CNN and TCN to extract image features. A guided attention module uses ...