Datasets:
[Verification] Eligibility and Status of Existing OSC-01665 Provisional Submission
Hello OSC organizers,
I would like to request clarification regarding the verification eligibility and current status of one of my existing submissions.
Submission details
- Entrant:
LYJ37Fii - Material:
OSC-01665(Cu2I6Ni2) - C2DB UID:
2CuNiI3-1 - Provisional score:
26.444 - Current status:
provisional(verified=false) - Method:
OSC-baseline (published A_d)
This entry uses the published baseline pairing value rather than an independently validated many-body solver. I want to be transparent about this distinction and avoid claiming it as an original Gold Track method.
I have independently reproduced the canonical DFT band filling and Fermi-level DOS for this material within an absolute tolerance of 1e-4. I have also performed preliminary 6×6 VMC calculations, but optimization convergence and equivalence with the production pairing observable have not yet been established.
Could you please clarify three points?
- Are submissions based on the published baseline eligible for promotion from provisional to verified, and can such submissions qualify for the Grand Prize?
- Is this specific submission awaiting verification, or is it missing a requirement that prevents verification?
- If additional independent calculations or a reproducibility package are required, can they be associated with this existing submission without creating a duplicate entry?
I have separately requested the exact pairing-operator and target-state specifications in Discussion #58, so I am not repeating those technical questions here.
My goal is to follow the official verification procedure correctly while preserving the existing submission and avoiding unnecessary duplicate entries.
Thank you for your guidance.
Thank you for the transparent write-up. Your OSC-01665 entry is on record as provisional. We will answer the three eligibility points in this thread together with the track rules in #61.