Discovery proposal: Cr2Se2 (OSC-01198) — Cr in the unmeasured magnetic-chalcogenide cell of the p4/nmm M2X2 family; downfold request

#77
by PhD-Shin - opened

Discovery track proposal — Cr2Se2 (2CrSe-1, OSC-01198). This is a downfold request, not a rank claim.

This material is in candidates.csv but not in active_challenge.csv, so it cannot be submitted through the Space. Submitting as a PR per the README.

Why this material: the same unsampled cell, with the transition metal that has the strongest record in it. Fixing the layer group and stoichiometry of the current top two anchors (p4/nmm, 2:2 TM:anion) and splitting the active members by anion type and magnetism gives:

anion magnetic n nef range t range (eV)
chalcogenide No 9 0.461 – 1.419 0.128 – 0.259
halide No 2 0.447 – 0.552 0.216 – 0.241
halide Yes 3 2.391 – 4.081 0.022 – 0.053
chalcogenide Yes 0 — —

magnetic = Yes raises nef by 4–7x at fixed layer group and stoichiometry, through a 4–10x reduction in t. This is consistent with the published pipeline using a non-spin-polarized pw.x SCF: in a magnetic material the suppressed exchange splitting leaves a narrow, partly filled d manifold pinned at E_F. The chalcogenide × magnetic cell is empty, so this material cannot be reached by regression over the published table — which is why it is worth measuring.

Why Cr. Cr is the transition metal with the strongest measured record for this mechanism in your own table: five of the top ten active entries are magnetic Cr compounds — 2CrISe-1 45.297, 2BrCrTe-1 40.333, 2CrFSe-1 37.618, 2ClCrTe-1 36.887, 1NCr2F2-1 34.173. Cr with a Se ligand already reaches nef 3.1949 (2CrISe-1). 2CrSe-1 is the only C2DB Cr2Se2 2:2 polymorph, so there is no structure- or active-band-selection ambiguity of the kind the README flags for multi-band metals.

Flags. e_hull 0.143, gap_pbe 0.0, is_metal True, magnetic Yes, sc_relevance 0.67, layer_group p4/nmm, 4 atoms. On e_hull: 0.143 is not a disqualifier in this slot — the current first and second anchors (2BrFe-1, 2FeI-1) sit at 0.282 and 0.211. No Cr2Se2 polymorph appears in active_challenge.csv. Source: C2DB, CC-BY-4.0.

On the claimed numbers — these are a floor, not an estimate. I cannot predict this material and I am not pretending to. nef = 0.7403 is the minimum nef among the active p4/nmm M2Se2 members (2ScSe-2), all non-magnetic, and A_d = 0.03844 is the lowest value on the dome plateau (Ne = 36, delta = 0); together they give 8.538. The real value should exceed this floor because the magnetic column is systematically higher, but I have no basis for quantifying it, and I make no claim that this material beats the current top anchor (55.375). Please downfold it with the published pipeline and replace these claimed values with the real ones. No rescaling or empirical fitting to the published reference scores was done.

Reproducible from the published data alone: active_challenge.csv, candidates.csv, scoring_meta.json, pipeline/downfold.py.

Correction to the number I posted in this PR. The "lower bound" I wrote was not a lower bound.

I wrote 8.538 here and called it a conservative floor. The computed canonical value, under the protocol of #58, is:

quantity value
N(E_F) 1.05493
n_band 1.6001
delta 0.6111
A_d 0.00262
canonical score 0.829

The actual value is about ten times lower than the figure I presented as a floor. n_band = 1.6001 puts this id far down the overdoped side of the dome, where A_d is small.

The error was mine and it was methodological: I had correctly back-derived the scoring formula, but I had no way to compute its input nef, and I filled that gap with a regression point estimate and then described the estimate as a bound. An unmeasured bound is not a bound. I now reproduce the canonical protocol directly, so I can state computed numbers instead; the agreement evidence is in my comment on #74.

0.829 does not belong anywhere near the board, and I am not asking for anything here other than that the record show the computed value rather than mine. I understand that ranking is decided by your own downfold (#5, #46).

FINAL_Bench org

Thank you for setting the record straight with the computed value. The record for OSC-01198 will show the canonical result once it is run.

Ready to merge
This branch is ready to get merged automatically.

Sign up or log in to comment