emolero's picture
Add 89 missing ORAN specs (R003/R004) parsed via Datalab Marker (accurate); update manifest + STATUS
71af7ca verified
|
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
71.3 kB

--- O-RAN Work Group 6****Application Service Descriptor specification

Copyright © 2024 by the O-RAN ALLIANCE e.V.

The copying or incorporation into any other work of part or all of the material available in this specification in any form without the prior written permission of O-RAN ALLIANCE e.V. is prohibited, save that you may print or download extracts of the material of this specification for your personal use, or copy the material of this specification for the purpose of sending to individual third parties for their information provided that you acknowledge O-RAN ALLIANCE as the source of the material and that you inform the third party that these conditions apply to them and that they must comply with them.

O-RAN ALLIANCE e.V., Buschkauler Weg 27, 53347 Alfter, Germany

Register of Associations, Bonn VR 11238, VAT ID DE321720189

--- Contents

List of figures ..... 3
List of tables ..... 3
Foreword..... 4
Modal verbs terminology ..... 4
1 Scope ..... 5
2 References ..... 5
2.1 Normative references ..... 5
2.2 Informative references ..... 5
3 Definition of terms, symbols and abbreviations ..... 5
3.1 Terms ..... 5
3.2 Symbols..... 6
3.3 Abbreviations ..... 6
4 Objective ..... 6
5 Conventions..... 6
6 Application Service Descriptor information elements ..... 7
6.1 Overview ..... 7
6.2 Application Service Descriptor Information Element ..... 8
6.3 Deployment Item (DeploymentItem) Information Element ..... 9
6.4 External connection point (ExtCpd) Information Element ..... 10
6.5 NetworkInterfaceRealizationRequirements Information Element ..... 10
6.6 ExtCpdParamMappings Information Element..... 13
6.7 EnhancedClusterCapabilities Information Element..... 14
Annex (informative): Change History ..... 16

--- List of figures

Figure 6.1-1: DeploymentDescriptor with ASD representation ..... 8
------------------------------------------------------------------ ---

--- List of tables

Table 6.2-1: ASD Information Model ..... 8
Table 6.3-1: DeploymentItem IE ..... 9
Table 6.4-1: ExtCpd IE ..... 10
Table 6.5-1 NetworkInterfaceRealizationRequirements IE..... 10
Table 6.6-1: ExtCpdParamMappings IE..... 13
Table 6.7-1: EnhancedClusterCapabilities IE..... 14

--- Foreword

This Technical Specification (TS) has been produced by WG6 of the O-RAN Alliance.

The content of the present document is subject to continuing work within O-RAN and may change following formal O-RAN approval. Should the O-RAN Alliance modify the contents of the present document, it will be re-released by O-RAN with an identifying change of version date and an increase in version number as follows:

version xx.yy.zz

where:

  • xx: the first digit-group is incremented for all changes of substance, i.e. technical enhancements, corrections, updates, etc. (the initial approved document will have xx=01). Always 2 digits with leading zero if needed.
  • yy: the second digit-group is incremented when editorial only changes have been incorporated in the document. Always 2 digits with leading zero if needed.
  • zz: the third digit-group included only in working versions of the document indicating incremental changes during the editing process. External versions never include the third digit-group. Always 2 digits with leading zero if needed.

--- Modal verbs terminology

In the present document "shall", "shall not", "should", "should not", "may", "need not", "will", "will not", "can" and "cannot" are to be interpreted as described in clause 3.2 of the O-RAN Drafting Rules (Verbal forms for the expression of provisions).

"must" and "must not" are NOT allowed in O-RAN deliverables except when used in direct citation.

--- 1 Scope

The present document specifies the structure and format of the Application Service Descriptor (ASD).

--- 2 References

2.1 Normative references

References are either specific (identified by date of publication and/or edition number or version number) or non-specific. For specific references, only the cited version applies. For non-specific references, the latest version of the referenced document (including any amendments) applies.

NOTE: While any hyperlinks included in this clause were valid at the time of publication, O-RAN cannot guarantee their long-term validity.

The following referenced documents are necessary for the application of the present document.

2.2 Informative references

References are either specific (identified by date of publication and/or edition number or version number) or non-specific. For specific references, only the cited version applies. For non-specific references, the latest version of the referenced document (including any amendments) applies.

NOTE: While any hyperlinks included in this clause were valid at the time of publication, O-RAN cannot guarantee their long-term validity.

The following referenced documents are not necessary for the application of the present document, but they assist the user with regard to a particular subject area.

--- 3 Definition of terms, symbols and abbreviations

3.1 Terms

For the purposes of the present document, the terms given in [2] apply.

3.2 Symbols

Void.

3.3 Abbreviations

For the purposes of the present document, the following abbreviations apply:

ASD Application Service Descriptor
CNI Container Network Interface
DC Data Center
DPDK Data Plane Development Kit
GARP Gratuitous ARP (Address Resolution Protocol)
GPU Graphics Processing Unit
IPAM IP Address Management
K8s Kubernetes
LAG Link Aggregation Group
LI Lawful Interception
MAC Media Access Control
NAD Network Attachment Definition
NF Network Function
NW Network
OAM Operations, Administration and Management
O-RAN Open Radio Access Network
OVS Open vSwitch
PCIe Peripheral Component Interconnect Express
PF Physical Function
SMO Service Management and Orchestration
SR-IOV Single Root I/O Virtualization
URI Uniform Resource Identifier
UUID Universally Unique Identifier
VLAN Virtual Local Area Network
VF Virtual Function
vNIC virtual Network Interface Card
VPN Virtual Private Network
VPP Vector Packet Processing

--- 4 Objective

The present document delivers a specification of the information elements and attributes applicable to the ASD.

--- 5 Conventions

The attributes of the ASD information elements are described in the tables provided in section 6.2. Each table has 5 columns, with the following significance:

  • The "Attribute" column provides the attribute name.
  • The "Qualifier" column indicates whether the support of the attribute is mandatory, optional or conditional from the SMO perspective.
  • The "Cardinality" column contains the minimum and maximum cardinality of this information element (e.g., 1, 0 ... N, 1 ... N). A cardinality range starting with 0 indicates that the attribute need not always be included and 1 indicates that the attribute needs to be always included.
  • The "Type" column provides information on the type of the attribute values. It can be the name of an Information Element. If a cell in the "Type" is marked as "Not specified", which indicates that the specification of the type is left to the data model.
  • The "Description" provides a brief explanatory description, additional constraints, and examples.

6 Application Service Descriptor information elements

6.1 Overview

The Application Service Descriptor (ASD) contains data that describes an application and that is used by the SMO as input for the deployment of the application workload.

The ASD is a complementary descriptor to the cloud-native deployment artifacts. Hence, it contains design-time information provided by the application vendor that is not described/available in the cloud native artifacts. Such complementary information in the ASD can include specific infrastructure capabilities requirements for the deployment of the application software workload, constraints on the Kernel type needed, additional networking requirements needed beyond primary connectivity described in the cloud native artifacts, any special CNI (Container Network Interfaces), etc [i.1].

ASD can support an application workload deployment on OS container infrastructures, and it is applicable to O-RAN NF Deployments, xApps, and rApps.

Figure 6.1-1 illustrates the representation of O-RAN OAM Application Packaging Model as depicted in version 10.00 of [i.2] and shows how the Application Service Descriptor is positioned within the Application Package Model.

Figure 6.1-1: DeploymentDescriptor with ASD representation. The diagram shows a hierarchical structure of artifacts. On the left, a vertical flow shows 'ASD (DeploymentDescriptor)' having 'ASD DeploymentItem (DeploymentItem)', which has a 'Helm Chart (CloudNative DescriptorFile)', which may have a 'DockerImage (ExecutableImage)'. These are grouped in a dashed box labeled 'Deployment related artifacts'. On the right, a more complex graph shows 'AppPackage' at the top, which has 'DeploymentDescriptor' and 'MLModelDescriptor'. 'DeploymentDescriptor' has 'DeploymentItem', which has 'CloudNativeDescriptorFile' and 'ExecutableImage'. 'MLModelDescriptor' has 'ComponentDescriptor', which has 'ManagementDescriptor'. 'ManagementDescriptor' has 'SecurityDescriptor', 'AlarmDictionary', 'ConfigurationModel', 'AccountingDictionary', and 'PerformanceDictionary'. 'ComponentDescriptor' also has 'PTEDescriptor'.

Figure 6.1-1: DeploymentDescriptor with ASD representation. The diagram shows a hierarchical structure of artifacts. On the left, a vertical flow shows 'ASD (DeploymentDescriptor)' having 'ASD DeploymentItem (DeploymentItem)', which has a 'Helm Chart (CloudNative DescriptorFile)', which may have a 'DockerImage (ExecutableImage)'. These are grouped in a dashed box labeled 'Deployment related artifacts'. On the right, a more complex graph shows 'AppPackage' at the top, which has 'DeploymentDescriptor' and 'MLModelDescriptor'. 'DeploymentDescriptor' has 'DeploymentItem', which has 'CloudNativeDescriptorFile' and 'ExecutableImage'. 'MLModelDescriptor' has 'ComponentDescriptor', which has 'ManagementDescriptor'. 'ManagementDescriptor' has 'SecurityDescriptor', 'AlarmDictionary', 'ConfigurationModel', 'AccountingDictionary', and 'PerformanceDictionary'. 'ComponentDescriptor' also has 'PTEDescriptor'.

Figure 6.1-1: DeploymentDescriptor with ASD representation

6.2 Application Service Descriptor Information Element

For the O-RAN NF Deployments the Application Service Descriptor (ASD) is a main top level descriptor template which consists of the attributes described in Table 6.2-1 below.

Table 6.2-1: ASD Information Model

Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Type Description
asdId M 1 String Identifier of this ASD information element. This attribute shall be globally unique. The format will be defined in the data model specification phase.
asdVersion M 1 String Identifies the version of the ASD
asdSchemaVersion M 1 String Specifies the version of the ASD's schema. See note 1.
asdProvider M 1 String Provider of the application and of the ASD.
asdApplicationName M 1 String Name to identify the application. Invariant for the application lifetime.
asdApplicationVersion M 1 String Specifies the version of the application. See note 2.
Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Type Description
asdApplicationInfoName M 0..1 String Human readable name for the application. Can change during the ASD lifetime.
asdInfoDescription M 0..1 String Human readable description of the application. Can change during the ASD lifetime.
asdExtCpd M 0..N ExtCpd Describes the externally exposed connection points of the application.
enhancedClusterCapabilities M 0..1 EnhancedClusterCapabilities A list of expected capabilities of the target deployment cluster to aid placement of the application on a suitable cluster.
deploymentItem M 1..N DeploymentItem Cloud native deployment artifacts associated with the application.
asdInvariantId M 1 String Identifier of this descriptor in a version independent manner. This attribute is invariant across versions of ASD. It is in UUID format as specified in RFC 4122
NOTE 1: Version changes when a change is made to any one of the ASD attributes.
NOTE 2: Version changes when software or ASD values changes

6.3 Deployment Item (DeploymentItem) Information Element

The deploymentItem defined in O-RAN Operations and Maintenance Architecture [i.2] is realized by the DeploymentItem IE which has the DeploymentItem structure described in Table 6.3-1 below.

The DeploymentItem IE describes the type of cloud native artifact, its order of deployment in case multiple cloud native artifacts are employed with the same ASD, and the list of parameters that can be parameterized in this cloud native deployment artifact at deployment time.

Table 6.3-1: DeploymentItem IE

Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Type Description
deploymentItemId M 1 String The identifier of this deployment item
artifactType M 1 String Specifies the artifact type. One of following values can be chosen: "helm_chart", "helmfile", "crd", "terraform".
artifactId M 1 String Unique reference to a deployment item (cloud native deployment artifact). It can be a URI or file path.
deploymentOrder M 0..1 Integer Specifies the deployment order of the deployment item. A lower value specifies that the deployment item belongs to an earlier deployment stage, i.e., needs to be installed prior to a deployment item with higher deploymentOrder values. If not specified, the deployment of the deployment item can be done in arbitrary order and decided by the SMO.
lifecycleParameter M 0..N String The list of parameters that can be overridden at deployment time (e.g., the list of parameters in the values.yaml which can be overridden at deployment time)

6.4 External connection point (ExtCpd) Information Element

The ExtCpd IE describes endpoints exposed by the application to enable orchestrators to string together or optimally place linked applications.

Table 6.4-1: ExtCpd IE

Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Content Description
id M 1 String The identifier of this ExtCpdData
description M 1 String Describes the service exposed.
virtualLinkRequirement M 1 String Refers in an abstract way to the network that the ExtCpd shall be exposed for (for example, OAM, EndUser, backhaul, LI, etc). The intent is to enable a network operator to identify which extCpd was designed to be connected to which VPN.
networkInterfaceRealizationRequirements M 0..1 NetworkInterfaceRealizationRequirements Details container implementation specific requirements on the NetworkAttachmentDefinition. See notes 1 and 2.
inputParamMappings M 0..1 ExtCpd.ParamMappings Information on what parameters are required to be provided to the deployment tools for the asdExtCpd instance.
resourceMapping M 0..1 String Resource name for the cloud native resource manifest, as specified in the cloud native descriptor declaring the network interface (e.g., in the helm chart, for the: service, ingress or pod resource). Enables, together with knowledge on namespace, the SMO to lookup the runtime data related to the extCpd.
NOTE 1: Applies only for ExtCpd representing secondary network interfaces in a POD.
NOTE 2: Several ExtCpd may refer to same additional network interface requirements.

6.5 NetworkInterfaceRealizationRequirements Information Element

The NetworkInterfaceRealizationRequirements IE describes details related to secondary networks that attach the OS containers to the logical or physical networks.

Table 6.5-1 NetworkInterfaceRealizationRequirements IE

Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Content Description
trunkMode M 0..1 Boolean

Specifies whether the interface is capable of carrying traffic for multiple VLANs.

If not present or set to false: this interface shall connect to single network.

If set to true: the network interface shall be a trunk interface (connects to multiple VLANs).

Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Content Description
ipam M 0..1 Enum

Specifies which mode is used for the IP address assignment.

Values:

  • "infraProvided": the CNI specifies how IPAM is done and assigns the IP address to the pod interface.
  • "orchestrated": the IP address to be assigned to the pod interface is expected from the orchestration function as input parameter to the deployment request.
  • "userManaged": the IP address is provided directly to the application via an external management entity.

Default value is "infraProvided".

interfaceType M 0..1 Enum

Specifies the type of network interface. Different types of interfaces are supported by different CNIs.

Values:

  • "kernel.netdev": Linux kernel or vSwitch based. It is supported by CNIs™ like: OVS, MACVLAN, IPVLAN, BRIDGE, PTP, etc.
  • "direct.userspace": Provides direct access to network PCIe, typically an SR-IOV VF, but could also be a PF. Uses application specific driver contained in the image. The device is bound to a driver by the cloud provider which supports user space control by the application (e.g. vfio_pci, igb_uio). It is supported by the following CNIs™: SRIOV, HOST-DEVICE.
  • "direct.kerneldriver": Similar to direct.userspace but device is bound to a kernel driver by the cloud provider and can be consumed in the same way as a kernel netdev. It is supported by the following CNIs™: SRIOV, HOST-DEVICE.
  • "direct.bond": Based on the BOND CNI™. Requires the existence of a mated pair of direct kernel network attachments prior to the creation of the bond. Thus, when this interface type is indicated, three attachments definitions to the secondary container cluster network are expected: two providing the direct
Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Content Description

kerneldriver functionality and one with the BOND CNI™

  • "userspace": Based on the userspace CNI™ requires infrastructure to support a DPDK-OVS or VPP based vSwitch.

Default value is "kernel.netdev".

interfaceOption M 0..N Enum

vNIC configurations the network interface is verified to work with.

This attribute is applicable for interfaces of type "userspace".

Values:

  • "virtio"
  • "memif"
interfaceRedundancy M 0..1 Enum

Method required from the infrastructure to provide redundancy for the interface.

Values:
"infraProvided", "left", "right",
"activeActiveBond", "activePassiveBond",
"activePassive13"

  • "infraProvided": The application sees one vNIC, but the infrastructure provides redundant access to the network via both switch planes. For interface of type kernel.netdev the redundancy is provided by the vSwitch or Linux bonding. For interfaces of type direct, it requires that the physical NIC is connected to both switch planes (a.k.a. smartNIC). Thus, it imposes hardware requirements on the infrastructure. For interface of type userspace redundancy handled by a DPDK-OVS or VPP vSwitch
  • "left" and "right": indicates a vNIC connected non-redundantly to the network via one specific (left or right) switchplane. Redundancy is implemented by having two external connection points, indicating different values (left/right) in the descriptor.

For the the following values, the infrastructure provides for a single external connection point a mated vNIC pair in the Pod, one connecting to the network via left switchplane and the other connecting to the network via the right switchplane, and with the application using them together as a redundant

Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Content Description

network interface using a particular redundancy method that need to be accomodated in the node infrastructure:

  • • "activeActiveBond": Requires a static multi-chassis LAG in active-active mode from the infrastructure. Typically corresponds to bonding mode-2 "balance-xor"
  • • "activePassiveBond": The interfaces are bonded in active-passive mode in the application with move of bond MAC address. No specific requirements on DC fabric. Typically corresponds to bonding mode-1 "active-backup"
  • • "activePassive13": Application moves its IP address by attaching it to one of the two MACs by use of GARP messages.

6.6 ExtCpdParamMappings Information Element

The ExtCpdParamMappings IE describes required information on what parameters to be provided to the deployment tools for the ExtCpd instance.

Table 6.6-1: ExtCpdParamMappings IE

Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Content Description
loadbalancerIP M 0..1 String When present, this attribute specifies the name of the deployment artifact input parameter through which the SMO can configure the loadbalancerIP parameter of the K8s service or ingress controller that the ExtCpd represents. See note 2.
externalIPs M 0..1 String When present, this attribute specifies the name of the deployment artifact input parameter through which the SMO can configure the externalIPs parameter of the K8s service or ingress controller, or the pod network interface annotation, that the ExtCpd represents. The param name and provided IP address(es) value will be passed to the deployment tool when deploying the DeploymentArtifacts. See note 2.
nadName M 0..N String These attributes specify, for an ExtCpd representing a secondary network interface, the name(s) of the deployment artifact input parameter(s) through which the SMO can provide the names of the network attachment definitions (NADs) the SMO has created as base for the network interface the ExtCpd represents.
It is expected that the NADs themselves have been created prior to the deployment of the deployment artifacts. See notes 1, 2, and 3.
nadNamespace M 0..1 String Specifies, for an ExtCpd representing a secondary network interface, the name of the deployment artifact input parameter through which the SMO can provide the namespace where the NADs are located.
Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Content Description
Attribute may be omitted if the namespace is same as the application namespace. See note 2.

NOTE 1: When the ExtCpd represent a networkRedundant/mated pair of sriov interfaces, there are references to 2 or 3 related NADs needed to be passed, while for other interface types only one NAD reference is needed to be passed.

NOTE 2: The format of the Content strings is specific for each different orchestration templating technology used (Helm, Teraform, etc.). Currently only a format for use with Helm charts is suggested: "<helmchartname>:[<subchartname>.] 0 ... N[<parentparamname>.] 0 ... N<paramname>". Whether the optional parts of the format are present depends on how the parameter is declared in the helm chart. An example is: "chartName:subChart1.subChart2.subChart3.Parent1.Parent2.Parent3.parameter".

NOTE 3: A direct attached (passthrough) network interface, such as an sriov interface, attaches to a network via only one of the two switch planes in the infrastructure.

When using a direct attached network interface one therefore commonly in a pod uses a mated pair of sriov network attachments, where each interface attaches same network but via different switchplane.

The application uses the mated pair of network interfaces as a single logical “swith-path-redundant” network interface – and this is represented by a single ExtCpd.

Also, there is a case where a third “bond” attachment interface is used in the pod, bonding the two direct interfaces so that the application does not need to handle the redundancy issues – application just uses the bond interface.

In this case all three attachments are together making up a logical “switch-path-redundant” network interface represented by a single ExtCpd. When three NADs are used in the ExtCpd the NAD implementing the bond attachment interface is provided through the parameter indicated in the third place in the nadNames attribute.

6.7 EnhancedClusterCapabilities Information Element

The EnhancedClusterCapabilities IE describes information which is used to aid placement of the application service on a suitable cluster.

Table 6.7-1: EnhancedClusterCapabilities IE

Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Content Description
minKernelVersion M 1 String Describes the minimal required Kernel version, e.g., 4.15.0. Coded as displayed by linux command uname -r
requiredKernelModule M 0..N String Required kernel modules are coded as listed by linux lsmod command, e.g., ip6_tables, cryptd, nf_nat etc.
conflictingKernelModule M 0..N String Kernel modules, which shall not be present in the target environment. The kernel modules are coded as listed by linux lsmod command, e.g., ip6_tables, cryptd, nf_nat etc. Example: Linux kernel SCTP module, which may conflict with use of proprietary user space SCTP stack provided by the application.
requiredCustomResource M 0..N Structure (inlined)

List of the required custom resource types in the target environment, identifying each by the "kind" and "apiVersion" field in the K8S resource manifests and in the application. The list shall include those custom resource types which are not delivered with the application.

Example:
requiredCustomResources:
- {kind: "Redis", apiVersion: "kubedb.com/v1alpha1"}

>kind M 1 String Kind of the custom resource
Attribute Qualifier Cardinality Content Description
>apiVersion M 0..1 String apiVersion of the custom resource. If not indicated, any apiVersion of the custom resource is valid.
clusterLabel M 0..N String

This attribute indicates the required O-Cloud Node Cluster capabilities.

These can indicate special infrastructure capabilities (e.g., NW acceleration, GPU compute, etc.). The intent of these O-Cloud Node Cluster capabilities is to serve as a set of values that can support the SMO in application placement decisions. See note 1.

clusterLabel follow the Kubernetes label key-value-nomenclature [1] .

This attribute should use the standardized values for the O-RAN O-Cloud Node Cluster capabilities, the existing values for node features [i.3], and any new capabilities identified in O-RAN specifications. The attribute supports also extensions for non standardized values. See note 2.

requiredPlugin M 0..N Structure (inlined) A list of the names and versions of the required K8s plugin (e.g., multus v3.8)
>requiredPluginName M 1 String The names of the required K8s plugin (e.g., multus)
>requiredPluginVersion M 0..1 String The version of the required plugin (e.g., 3.8). If not indicated, any version of the plugin is valid.

NOTE 1: The SMO uses the set of standardized capabilities to identify O-Cloud Node cluster capabilities required in the DeploymentDescriptors and to match them to the capabilities available in the O-Cloud.

NOTE 2: References to standandardized values for the O-RAN O-Cloud Node Cluster capabilities and/or new capabilities identified in O-RAN specifications will be added in future versions of the present document.

Annex (informative): Change History

Date Revision Description
2023.04.17 00.00.01 Initial TS skeleton
00.00.02 Editor's notes with references to clauses in O-RAN.WG6.AppLCM-Deployment-R003-v01.00 for content, and informative document reference added.
2023.08.23 00.00.03 Implemented CRs:
NOK-2023.06.07-WG6-CR-ASD_conventions (NOK-0054 rev 1)
NOK-2023.06.07-WG6-CR-ASD_overview-02 (NOK-0055 rev 2)
2023.09.07 00.00.04 Implemented CRs:
NOK-2023.06.07-WG6-CR-ASD_application_service_descriptor_clauses-v05 (NOK-0056 rev 5)
ERI-2023.06.14-WG6-CR-0015-NetworkInterfaceRealizationRequirements-v03 (ERI-0015 rev 3)
2023.10.27 00.00.05 Implemented CRs:
ERI-2023.09.26-WG6-CR-0019-ASD-corrections-v04
ERI-2023.10.04-WG6-CR-0020-ASD-empty-clauses-and-cleanup-v02
2023.11.07 00.00.06 Copyright changed to 2024
2023.11.15 00.00.07 Addresses comments from Thinh at
November 2023 WG Approval Comment Wiki - Cloudification and Orchestration Workgroup - Confluence (atlassian.net)

Implements three changes from ERI-2023.09.26-WG6-CR-0019-ASD-corrections-v04 that were missed when implementing the CR in v.00.00.05.
2023.11.21 00.00.08 Addresses comments from Joan at
November 2023 WG Approval Comment Wiki - Cloudification and Orchestration Workgroup - Confluence (atlassian.net)
2023.11.21 00.00.09 Final resolution of Joan's comments according to agreement in WG6 meeting on 2023.11.21.
November 2023 WG Approval Comment Wiki - Cloudification and Orchestration Workgroup - Confluence (atlassian.net)
01.00 Final version 01.00