parser_ratio — measure the SG-parser effect (gpt-4o-mini vs GPT-5.4) on GED
Purpose: all published CEDI rows had their transcripts parsed into unique_sg with
gpt-4o-mini. The Gemini-2.5-Pro SVG-500 run was parsed with a different model, so its
GED / GED_hal / GED_cov are not directly comparable. Re-parsing this fixed sample with
GPT-5.4 lets us measure the parser-induced ratio and correct for it.
Input
sample60_parsed_gpt4omini.json — 60 SVG-500 images (24 COCO / 12 VG / 24 ADE20K),
drawn from the Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct v19 run (GPT-4o examiner backbone).
Each entry has:
image_idsg— ground-truth scene graph (do not modify)conversations— merged transcript, ~25 turns/image, each withquestion/responseunique_sg_gpt4omini— the existing gpt-4o-mini parse (reference; do not modify)dist_score_gpt4omini— GED under that parse (mean over the 60 = 122.90)
What to run
Re-parse the same conversations with GPT-5.4 using the identical parser prompt
and post-processing. Everything except the model must stay the same:
- Prompt:
PROMPT.txt(verbatim;{question}is substituted with one turn's fullresponsestring — the batch parser passes the whole response as a single unit, not sentence-split). - System message:
"From the given sentence, your task is to extract meaningful triplets formed as <subject, predicate, object>." - Post-processing:
refine_output()ingrader/sg/llm_parser.py— drops non-physical words, keeps<s, p, o>,<o, is, attr>and bare<o>; triples are serialized as"( a , b , c )"and de-duplicated into a set. - Temperature / decoding: whatever the standard
LLMChatdefault is; keep it consistent.
Do NOT recompute GED — that step is LLM-free and will be run on our side.
Expected output
sample60_parsed_gpt54.json: same 60 entries, same image_id order, each adding
unique_sg_gpt54 (list of "( a , b , c )" strings). Keeping the other fields is fine.
Where to put it
Upload to this HF dataset under parser_ratio/sample60_parsed_gpt54.json.
We will then compute GED / GED_hal / GED_cov under both parses on the same 60 images and report the parser ratio (gpt-4o-mini ÷ GPT-5.4) alongside the already-measured examiner backbone ratio.